id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13348v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13348v1 | Textual Unlearning Gives a False Sense of Unlearning | 2024-06-19T08:51:54 | 2024-06-19T08:51:54 | Jiacheng Du, Zhibo Wang, Kui Ren | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are susceptible to "memorizing" training data,
including a large amount of private or copyright-protected content. To
safeguard the right to be forgotten (RTBF), machine unlearning has emerged as a
promising method for LMs to efficiently "forget" sensitive training content and
mitigate knowledge leakage risks. However, despite its good intentions, could
the unlearning mechanism be counterproductive? In this paper, we propose the
Textual Unlearning Leakage Attack (TULA), where an adversary can infer
information about the unlearned data only by accessing the models before and
after unlearning. Furthermore, we present variants of TULA in both black-box
and white-box scenarios. Through various experimental results, we critically
demonstrate that machine unlearning amplifies the risk of knowledge leakage
from LMs. Specifically, TULA can increase an adversary's ability to infer
membership information about the unlearned data by more than 20% in black-box
scenario. Moreover, TULA can even reconstruct the unlearned data directly with
more than 60% accuracy with white-box access. Our work is the first to reveal
that machine unlearning in LMs can inversely create greater knowledge risks and
inspire the development of more secure unlearning mechanisms. | [
0.0097773951,
0.0861885324,
-0.0106837489,
0.0611350201,
-0.0341058746,
0.0077192388,
0.0345085189,
0.0165038928,
0.007077523,
-0.0182925425,
-0.0359075367,
-0.0024361445,
0.0142356614,
0.0084679425,
0.0410807207,
0.0429157056,
0.0194088016,
-0.0228391029,
0.0066744778,
-0.0425019339,
0.0108000478,
-0.0062764473,
0.0062340992,
-0.0354501009,
0.0022215752,
-0.0283952244,
-0.0414706729,
-0.0303162057,
-0.0209818594,
0.000684132,
0.0101110628,
0.0470647477,
0.0155719426,
0.0790537,
0.000002095,
-0.0281038545,
-0.0858165473,
0.0258227177,
-0.0566172749,
0.0715926439,
0.0032168978,
0.0004997673,
0.004589281,
0.0238485858,
-0.0329783224,
0.0191343538,
0.0106361983,
0.0428562351,
0.0464897603,
0.1008811593,
-0.0099910414,
0.0152267106,
0.0019141615,
-0.0422066599,
0.0173407923,
-0.058449842,
0.0091463085,
-0.0532505289,
-0.0701956302,
0.0042557972,
0.0142908096,
0.0431657732,
0.0012147507,
0.0256726444,
-0.0457404479,
0.031607721,
-0.0241138004,
0.0191529114,
-0.0040003886,
0.0262934174,
0.0003634648,
-0.0299325734,
0.0258589964,
0.0218942128,
0.0267602708,
0.0290202182,
-0.0023872391,
0.0446832143,
-0.0230717883,
-0.0015645718,
-0.0256075803,
-0.0393407568,
0.0792502612,
-0.0111462548,
0.0190117024,
0.0398446992,
0.0057397066,
-0.0102933431,
-0.0109125879,
-0.0674577281,
0.0380864963,
-0.0490324348,
0.0232329611,
0.0064404057,
0.050116282,
0.0364788435,
-0.060917493,
-0.0267631598,
0.0269159433,
-0.0557617843,
0.0489703231,
-0.0090760943,
-0.0096318349,
0.0570916012,
-0.0347180106,
0.0270368587,
-0.010354151,
0.0387937017,
0.0028657427,
0.015322363,
-0.0144600412,
-0.0412723757,
0.025282098,
0.0665666014,
0.0472263992,
0.0283864904,
-0.0004271553,
0.0130631942,
-0.0289031621,
0.0520113334,
-0.0419769287,
-0.0056218556,
-0.0139931468,
-0.0199825894,
-0.0254058223,
-0.0184709188,
0.0222632624,
0.0012415618,
-0.0179368537,
-0.0699582845,
-0.0431475975,
-0.0280253887,
-0.0294269193,
0.0109223286,
-0.0009850918,
0.1009058803,
0.0003264684,
-0.0355354846,
-0.0810658708,
-0.0776120052,
0.0141597316,
-0.0248089619,
0.0209501144,
-0.0620825738,
-0.0095707942,
-0.0112081841,
-0.0218100939,
-0.0814963356,
0.0007719537,
0.0006509349,
-0.0589193925,
0.0447446443,
0.0084848283,
-0.022415068,
-0.0023337866,
0.0176680628,
-0.0234457999,
0.0284954831,
-0.0251966324,
0.0367468446,
0.0501652658,
-0.007077117,
0.0694189668,
0.0393374339,
0.0654892549,
0.01173684,
-0.0158409625,
0.0007710411,
0.0620031953,
-0.061531309,
-0.0008620406,
0.0407544784,
0.0007752798,
-0.0469998829,
0.0895685405,
0.0200359207,
-0.0573606491,
0.0532436185,
-0.0436567813,
-0.0080985203,
0.0061679943,
0.0328237116,
-0.0553023219,
-0.0087349163,
-0.099758558,
-0.0220525414,
0.0049795401,
-0.0091195079,
-0.0169685539,
-0.0069456929,
0.0224336479,
-0.0634624958,
0.0397545621,
0.0133628258,
0.021067366,
0.0659975782,
0.0022902652,
0.0925357863,
0.0437858962,
-0.0623547435,
0.0012824713,
-0.0388074517,
0.0049344208,
0.0222279057,
0.0586655177,
-0.0426167697,
0.0294077434,
-0.0201173462,
-0.0087247938,
-0.0178562161,
0.0220939312,
0.0160502382,
0.0537585169,
-0.0263821594,
-0.0227226932,
-0.0259663854,
0.032735493,
0.0056630634,
0.0005944874,
-0.0192179363,
0.0261305999,
-0.0431636162,
-0.027996026,
0.0148847885,
-0.0301654134,
-0.0405151509,
0.0109972842,
0.0051367772,
-0.0022864314,
0.0246312171,
-0.0329143256,
0.0201577507,
0.0524107255,
0.0179889873,
-0.0196666978,
-0.0380195715,
-0.0222569145,
0.0080690756,
0.0097928923,
-0.0294363219,
0.0230967384,
0.0754006356,
-0.0158907212,
-0.0045373538,
0.0382223129,
-0.0070489827,
0.0507929437,
-0.0050558434,
0.0332394168,
-0.0473445579,
0.0054204054,
-0.0123639889,
0.0544591583,
-0.0384066366,
0.0059309918,
-0.0302635264,
-0.0314923525,
-0.0017365775,
-0.0270453021,
-0.0560138635,
-0.0030164961,
-0.0149059957,
0.0250619221,
-0.0065746442,
-0.0290212762,
-0.0121775037,
-0.0128630893,
-0.0068568098,
-0.0310388021,
-0.0152661214,
0.0384274647,
0.0119342292,
-0.0028855014,
-0.0290385708,
-0.0459461883,
-0.0236255769,
-0.0300342366,
-0.0464801751,
0.0137147466,
0.0140883271,
-0.0160838347,
0.0111396927,
0.0021406,
-0.008982636,
0.0189386588,
0.0657649338,
-0.0283517726,
0.0075612701,
-0.0011110296,
0.0708279312,
-0.0284562856,
0.034918718,
-0.0171002932,
-0.0014920203,
-0.0145951211,
-0.0063840114,
-0.0467866473,
0.0391193889,
0.0148564801,
0.0344365127,
0.0499851182,
0.022805281,
-0.021843601,
-0.009748131,
-0.0137785552,
-0.0673810542,
-0.046489995,
0.0022074406,
0.0229569431,
0.0140008498,
0.0407760665,
-0.0181285758,
0.0061289677,
0.0298586003,
-0.0051760464,
-0.0210139044,
-0.0301874466,
-0.0301318523,
-0.016409548,
0.003746602,
-0.0082057025,
-0.0930913538,
0.0364914797,
-0.0403215401,
0.0296277404,
-0.0318825096,
-0.0180017613,
0.0070302128,
0.0570037402,
-0.0025205733,
0.0365194418,
0.0521720462,
-0.0244183242,
-0.0346217863,
-0.0044481321,
0.0597426668,
-0.0603878684,
-0.0044521838,
-0.0117929969,
-0.0384682454,
0.0055754613,
-0.0154064028,
-0.037626449,
-0.032645423,
-0.0002707082,
-0.0127651952,
-0.0116738556,
-0.0212507993,
-0.0094460286,
-0.0817125589,
0.0683343261,
-0.0043868925,
-0.0001592991,
0.0120576248,
-0.0202507675,
0.0444965437,
0.0003292112,
-0.071622856,
-0.0121796578,
-0.0307337213,
-0.0099443169,
0.0951558724,
0.0417253673,
0.0249396842,
0.0379685909,
-0.013588544,
-0.001638856,
-0.0048759389,
-0.0249746572,
0.0433074608,
-0.0107156197,
-0.0286609419,
-0.0025053578,
0.0663256049,
0.0035291165,
-0.0541828871,
-0.0133618526,
0.0315955803,
0.0145281823,
-0.0093150474,
-0.0125094755,
-0.0903472826,
0.0092055779,
0.0254242141,
0.0710594282,
-0.0111991055,
-0.0344761945,
-0.017360786,
-0.0853916183,
-0.0366977341,
0.0429039933,
-0.0151241422,
-0.0310763884,
-0.0296835806,
-0.0368692093,
0.0088134008,
0.0068010432,
-0.0032591994,
0.0039597433,
0.0157405529,
0.0117295189,
-0.0408549495,
-0.0351632088,
0.0279864445,
-0.029098114,
0.0253024343,
0.0309402533,
-0.0126612484,
-0.0426625423,
-0.0388773493,
0.0025160366,
0.0034245811,
-0.0032849952,
0.0145836184,
0.0573198162,
-0.0072444407,
-0.0157366451,
0.0181567557,
0.0753451064,
0.0187503081,
-0.0186213087,
0.0324408598,
0.0502929315,
0.0188072622,
-0.0106228851,
0.016169088,
-0.0502117202,
0.0165179409,
0.0513910912,
-0.0040473039,
-0.0156184966,
-0.0089219436,
-0.0405798368,
0.0395020284,
0.0120340623,
-0.0034263958,
0.0290556513,
-0.0006061504,
-0.0299143735,
-0.0439169668,
0.0004390842,
-0.0333103761,
0.0201224703,
0.0409180038,
0.0368356854,
0.0390221775,
-0.0160911866,
-0.0540869124,
-0.0291532706,
-0.071833171,
0.0106587233,
-0.0179423224,
-0.0252896771,
-0.0121249026,
-0.0037375477,
-0.008827161,
-0.0217905007,
-0.0947398618,
-0.0780551583,
0.0208967142,
0.0413326621,
0.018139448,
0.0447292291,
-0.0020390626,
-0.054933358,
0.1053347811,
0.025798073,
-0.0443574972,
0.0211178623,
0.0471979566,
-0.0253256969,
0.0080038551,
0.0443054363,
-0.0546363629,
-0.0396162532,
0.0699495301,
-0.0600704402,
-0.0213883109,
0.0210847221,
0.0013776589,
0.0381070711,
0.0344847329,
0.0348175913,
0.0455311276,
-0.0016883983,
0.0565864109,
0.0239445549,
-0.0268386919,
-0.0010909807,
0.0114014121,
0.0544253141,
0.0127665335,
0.0438764691,
-0.028971957,
0.0478947908,
0.0207152199,
-0.00533971,
-0.0238041282,
0.0800544471,
0.0148985498,
0.0475748517,
0.0090572536,
-0.0035350919,
0.0474120229,
-0.0215469263,
0.0381748378,
-0.015822947,
0.0499382503,
0.0030154688,
-0.0092178388,
-0.0315783843,
0.0049993116,
-0.0294510256,
-0.0566354282,
-0.0175094754,
0.0183728803,
0.0176736005,
-0.0214541145,
-0.0342404209,
-0.0073029115,
0.0165605303,
-0.0349223092,
-0.0093561877,
-0.028234506,
-0.0563355424,
0.0038314501,
0.0040144874,
-0.0318348482,
0.0963082686,
0.098099038,
-0.0145296324,
0.0655824095,
-0.0169723928,
-0.0165357776,
-0.0274458937,
-0.015011779,
0.0422459394,
0.0179610569,
-0.0301446281,
-0.0341479927,
-0.0184912533,
-0.0650535822,
0.013125713,
-0.0133297304,
0.047670003,
-0.0029489479,
-0.0079704812,
0.0583757013,
-0.0058751386,
0.0348992981,
-0.093168214,
0.032150574,
0.036210157,
-0.0168528296,
-0.0065494226,
-5.725734535e-33,
0.0254577231,
-0.0076812357,
-0.0562969185,
0.0603319407,
0.0590583608,
0.0312824771,
0.0128748827,
-0.0009668033,
-0.0323376656,
-0.0275805239,
-0.0301145352,
0.0045789233,
-0.002774111,
0.0261149555,
-0.0249124113,
-0.0370857753,
0.0072281067,
-0.0253600571,
-0.0420056619,
0.0197267681,
0.0890126005,
0.047155343,
0.0534765944,
-0.0873399004,
0.034328118,
-0.0430189781,
-0.0445626192,
0.0178809818,
-0.0382884443,
0.0372172408,
-0.0142523106,
-0.0000639552,
-0.004720273,
-0.0034238365,
-0.0164045487,
0.0133033991,
-0.0198422,
0.0054809023,
-0.0109653836,
0.0041109207,
0.0235206522,
-0.0311867744,
0.0215730369,
-0.0294366144,
0.030830102,
-0.004081002,
-0.0140990671,
0.0084139723,
-0.0495865382,
-0.0193389095,
0.0248486642,
0.0059713153,
-0.0374905877,
-0.0133380722,
0.0625574142,
0.0001302592,
0.022742074,
-0.0439071842,
-0.1042073891,
0.0408520065,
0.0424930863,
0.0190679599,
0.0415729545,
0.0113119455,
0.0082076378,
0.0859778374,
0.0522124432,
0.0164714083,
0.0177847147,
-0.0005564237,
0.0073401877,
0.0172866657,
0.0203419216,
0.0208930448,
0.0498418473,
-0.054343868,
-0.0126904761,
-0.0082372921,
-0.0219671447,
0.0184231028,
0.0459060669,
0.0224549454,
-0.0376741141,
-0.0248136185,
-0.0652905554,
-0.0216658227,
-0.0566427819,
-0.0022832223,
0.0003104886,
0.0232178625,
-0.0366163142,
-0.0224400479,
-0.0173964053,
-0.0328258947,
-0.0114730764,
0.054593619,
0.0143149905,
-0.0074040117,
-0.0203493685,
-0.0158723593,
-0.0469148941,
-0.0000297567,
0.0023519516,
-0.0509782135,
0.0200757328,
0.0101774363,
0.0640031174,
0.0507360734,
-0.0617749095,
-0.0141452067,
-0.0231707506,
0.0197976325,
0.0643086433,
-0.0048994226,
0.030772483,
-0.0104763014,
-0.0127946986,
-0.0226446819,
0.0479224995,
0.022715671,
-0.0598058961,
0.0378405005,
-0.0316367634,
-0.0218919422,
-0.0005538341,
-0.0227406081,
0.0237202123,
0.0597048402,
0.0820008069,
-0.0123223132,
0.0253537558,
-0.0116824321,
2.831e-7,
0.0048211962,
-0.0268082395,
0.00959739,
-0.0165491886,
0.0417131335,
0.0782769024,
-0.0491644479,
0.0683695301,
-0.0036465172,
-0.0032309063,
-0.0350665264,
-0.0106301522,
0.0479368381,
0.0257471371,
-0.0713298097,
-0.0006914367,
-0.0740326047,
-0.0198736135,
-0.0443352833,
-0.0221440867,
0.0108622173,
0.0854815692,
0.0513798408,
-0.0347397551,
-0.0231090672,
-0.0588603355,
0.0207710024,
-0.0239838064,
-0.0095159663,
-0.0300038308,
0.0429481268,
0.0702313408,
-0.010330623,
-0.0061245062,
-0.0403994657,
0.0087567205,
-0.0404235758,
0.0473505519,
0.0671252683,
-0.0332888477,
-0.0208441727,
-0.0054394659,
-0.0205921698,
0.0011385449,
0.0675684661,
0.0260429699,
-0.0380039141,
-0.0261191893,
-0.0137015712,
-0.0422639698,
0.0313838571,
0.0189651996,
-0.0097199073,
0.0364391096,
-0.0270668436,
0.0123648252,
0.0038923568,
-0.081086807,
-0.0454638377,
-0.024653757,
-0.0240925569,
-0.0158930626,
0.0083217509,
0.0032210641,
0.0037163475,
-0.0547936857,
0.0704705194,
2.296048116e-34,
-0.0270168353,
-0.0701155663,
-0.0222203564,
0.0492902398,
0.0120924534,
-0.0308706816,
0.0407674983,
0.0215394814,
-0.0050543509,
-0.0358319879,
-0.0049368702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13342v1 | ZeroDL: Zero-shot Distribution Learning for Text Clustering via Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T08:48:05 | 2024-06-19T08:48:05 | Hwiyeol Jo, Hyunwoo Lee, Taiwoo Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have brought
significant progress in solving NLP tasks. Notably, in-context learning (ICL)
is the key enabling mechanism for LLMs to understand specific tasks and
grasping nuances. In this paper, we propose a simple yet effective method to
contextualize a task toward a specific LLM, by (1) observing how a given LLM
describes (all or a part of) target datasets, i.e., open-ended zero-shot
inference, and (2) aggregating the open-ended inference results by the LLM, and
(3) finally incorporate the aggregated meta-information for the actual task. We
show the effectiveness of this approach in text clustering tasks, and also
highlight the importance of the contextualization through examples of the above
procedure. | [
-0.0125771929,
0.0040435093,
0.0080787754,
0.0434955955,
-0.027331613,
0.0257757381,
0.0149082122,
-0.0057435166,
-0.01241701,
-0.0539284758,
-0.0272890031,
0.009492618,
-0.014493919,
-0.0034789783,
0.0194300599,
-0.0327193029,
-0.0140204402,
0.0030694108,
-0.0093393428,
0.0122543667,
0.0156726781,
0.0228494145,
0.0224659815,
0.0157092754,
0.0097980602,
-0.026177343,
0.0019009382,
0.0090230945,
0.022627892,
-0.0093429405,
-0.047826495,
0.0163128786,
0.0637976155,
0.0295587424,
0.0000019583,
-0.0463767052,
-0.0502767116,
-0.0037986988,
-0.0254133921,
-0.0126661295,
0.0825804994,
-0.0677302107,
0.0024672216,
-0.0045975153,
0.0071095959,
-0.0214171298,
0.0448330678,
0.0494278781,
0.0179666523,
0.0581156984,
-0.0314957649,
-0.0269644689,
-0.0019185271,
-0.0328692533,
0.0257343482,
-0.0495573357,
0.056368947,
0.0083111646,
0.0038259863,
0.0458883755,
-0.0212912429,
0.0202144142,
0.0096489862,
0.0115159927,
-0.0118753556,
0.0598492883,
-0.0547695607,
0.0019411101,
0.0215428639,
0.0807926282,
0.0053746584,
-0.0333325267,
0.0167472921,
0.0025468376,
-0.0156266969,
0.0255540758,
-0.0845029205,
0.0497280844,
0.0047674789,
0.0458548516,
0.0058095204,
0.0284258258,
0.0556284338,
0.0068592089,
-0.0477623753,
0.0714299232,
-0.0131168971,
0.0157770067,
-0.0344829634,
-0.0174176749,
-0.060109362,
-0.0367392153,
-0.039374765,
0.037807323,
0.0193371922,
0.0306359604,
-0.0192051996,
-0.0212032218,
0.0247008055,
-0.0327878222,
-0.0035770785,
0.0019549213,
0.015837023,
0.0966298431,
0.00659444,
-0.0225589946,
-0.005044261,
-0.0288879536,
-0.0532201938,
-0.0554654412,
-0.0509234667,
0.002844661,
0.0014737773,
0.023393251,
-0.0240306947,
0.0029315592,
-0.014235815,
0.0463487543,
-0.0119400397,
0.0159122348,
-0.018194396,
-0.0062726345,
-0.0163777769,
-0.0395088084,
0.0305750817,
0.0337702893,
-0.0502803177,
0.0354948975,
-0.0383079834,
0.0081014968,
-0.0188150592,
0.0542549081,
0.0287331473,
-0.0452331267,
-0.0206131209,
0.0398748443,
0.0178300496,
-0.0326303467,
-0.052221749,
-0.0134719536,
-0.0295995399,
-0.0523400046,
-0.0489444733,
-0.0868262574,
0.0054302439,
0.0104723275,
0.0064764344,
-0.011419449,
-0.0190833826,
0.0151506448,
-0.0402123593,
0.0708723739,
-0.0015844475,
-0.0033927241,
0.0248300657,
-0.0084143775,
-0.0071779201,
0.0955738351,
-0.0173356179,
0.006743392,
0.037359938,
0.0142913042,
0.0043422957,
0.0268435944,
0.0378978252,
0.0603414997,
-0.0335333161,
0.0033326624,
0.0328000933,
-0.0092088142,
0.0285311844,
-0.0125451125,
-0.0716944262,
-0.0011842547,
0.0145730069,
0.091414541,
0.0142918248,
-0.0262937341,
0.0047598267,
0.0096149547,
-0.0378672704,
-0.0193142798,
-0.0205708463,
0.0004243734,
-0.0640747845,
-0.0001908966,
0.0495386869,
0.0058223833,
-0.0592898391,
-0.0274152812,
-0.0224539693,
-0.0113843018,
-0.0139050316,
0.0192799866,
0.0825633556,
-0.0027416837,
0.0052717528,
0.0018403454,
0.0491426401,
-0.0125398487,
0.0261367764,
-0.0062534404,
0.0421466082,
0.0142894788,
0.0443794541,
-0.0775962919,
-0.0058816285,
-0.0026622969,
0.044729393,
-0.003230433,
-0.0504600741,
-0.0415736958,
0.0037196409,
-0.0463696718,
-0.0353701673,
0.0006147628,
0.0297259465,
-0.0076820995,
-0.011071655,
-0.0014648323,
0.0131621119,
-0.0645168424,
0.0313024335,
0.0154271359,
-0.028684346,
-0.0233994201,
0.0494724885,
-0.004849236,
-0.006537396,
0.0080699734,
-0.0176687278,
-0.0203840956,
0.0376458243,
-0.009752606,
-0.0147424787,
-0.0252432209,
0.0004109589,
-0.06354931,
0.0210231636,
-0.0201406907,
-0.0084929746,
-0.0638397709,
-0.0505756773,
-0.0328019336,
0.0363701507,
0.0382167362,
0.079199791,
-0.027407499,
0.0198927522,
-0.0091869142,
-0.0127021521,
-0.0679249242,
0.0926451832,
0.0045460821,
0.0166536514,
0.0186254177,
0.0053675217,
-0.0090478184,
-0.0154961655,
-0.0267360359,
-0.0196974911,
0.010371577,
0.0351129808,
0.0200878866,
-0.0299178399,
-0.0272339489,
-0.0067515238,
-0.0988791808,
0.0278469585,
-0.0333304778,
-0.0189589784,
0.039370887,
0.0100097097,
-0.0097510964,
-0.0213058013,
-0.008630326,
-0.021382099,
-0.0076961974,
-0.0062000835,
0.0396248884,
0.0052381763,
0.0009418202,
-0.0310068801,
-0.0179718845,
-0.0268455762,
0.0953067392,
-0.0101994323,
-0.010498994,
-0.0086785741,
0.047502283,
-0.0212552436,
-0.015384838,
-0.0363478474,
0.0437419377,
-0.0296479594,
-0.0550231449,
0.0208841991,
0.0629229173,
-0.0103583252,
0.0240747835,
0.0202348456,
-0.011123145,
-0.0430027172,
-0.0232530721,
-0.032004714,
-0.0014599155,
-0.0100911092,
-0.0066744057,
0.0268616173,
0.0416824557,
0.0201121476,
-0.0348505452,
-0.0417829268,
0.0171043221,
-0.0294740796,
0.006297336,
-0.0755617023,
0.0225955453,
0.0464707352,
0.0167072807,
-0.0441981666,
-0.0494468361,
0.0398569852,
-0.0283186659,
0.02542907,
-0.0100792106,
-0.0384995937,
-0.0781811625,
0.0416887067,
0.0020672868,
0.0126704508,
0.0161399171,
0.0040837177,
0.0052355779,
-0.009057736,
0.0000422944,
0.0352535546,
0.0743770376,
-0.0263494346,
0.0377604663,
-0.0021324996,
0.001097434,
-0.0116345901,
-0.0432244763,
-0.0157480314,
0.0238943696,
-0.0099410331,
0.0037219573,
-0.0837912783,
0.0318243168,
0.0487694256,
0.0165792424,
-0.0135152871,
-0.0310027488,
-0.0064405152,
0.0395106263,
0.0514650159,
-0.0669251531,
-0.0288804341,
-0.0342242569,
-0.0040590558,
0.068286255,
0.0391248465,
0.0258535463,
-0.0165761039,
0.0002749276,
0.0058988463,
-0.02657439,
0.0008377479,
-0.0030070846,
0.0169720557,
0.0167471115,
-0.0137583828,
0.1295146793,
0.0473005064,
-0.0976106748,
-0.009179241,
-0.0053111631,
0.0195805039,
0.0314795524,
0.0043969722,
-0.0588991605,
-0.0322693661,
-0.0159858651,
-0.0034716292,
0.020172175,
-0.0527321622,
-0.0019274649,
-0.1093258932,
0.0408359282,
0.0211367402,
-0.0697575957,
-0.0228845589,
-0.0809077099,
0.0397015586,
-0.0483610705,
-0.0146663841,
-0.0079479683,
-0.0156345852,
-0.0108251292,
0.0176776666,
0.0074791471,
-0.0497859344,
0.0115428707,
-0.0458229259,
0.0360321142,
0.0377770662,
0.0202469882,
0.01531169,
0.0455132201,
0.004607039,
-0.0518612899,
-0.0350290649,
-0.0147510516,
0.053476233,
-0.0457476191,
0.0309403148,
-0.0022455617,
0.0651070178,
-0.0507588834,
-0.0308361761,
0.0338749774,
0.0720384568,
0.0021686491,
0.012978795,
-0.0214150958,
-0.0333186463,
0.0054931203,
0.0633522496,
-0.0068891374,
-0.0103764031,
0.0394140743,
-0.0239121411,
-0.0246910006,
0.0356615521,
0.0004844138,
0.0080532907,
-0.0256838314,
-0.0186024308,
-0.0413720645,
0.0001099017,
0.0579150282,
0.0544405542,
-0.0147829568,
0.0340305641,
-0.0013929941,
-0.0615964942,
-0.0359407254,
0.0286480542,
-0.0609361492,
0.012332743,
-0.0274864286,
0.0091304909,
0.0762783512,
-0.0330613963,
-0.0155302724,
-0.0056065954,
-0.0758676007,
-0.0658847317,
-0.0647266135,
-0.01625387,
0.0108124847,
0.0594280809,
-0.031763196,
-0.0814463124,
0.0917706192,
0.0556725301,
-0.003925371,
-0.001598438,
-0.0204080306,
0.0229269676,
0.0196039136,
0.0434486791,
-0.0319758095,
0.0464059897,
0.0045297486,
-0.0201442521,
-0.102972284,
0.0004964284,
-0.003749358,
-0.0208756011,
0.0596259125,
0.0125445127,
-0.0376404822,
-0.0239541475,
-0.0289891977,
-0.0296992436,
-0.0606936179,
0.0195550229,
-0.002593559,
0.0368430018,
-0.0330406241,
-0.0222668909,
0.0543534756,
-0.0074329437,
0.0334092565,
-0.042862162,
0.0098157702,
0.0585897416,
-0.0038260971,
-0.0106083974,
0.021681428,
0.0016865354,
-0.0241570584,
-0.0082421526,
0.0362575352,
-0.0114446403,
0.0174585748,
0.0313903578,
0.0310174841,
-0.0705917701,
0.0226438995,
-0.0668638721,
0.0295378342,
-0.0052785506,
0.0174885094,
0.0441218019,
-0.0429602861,
0.0205335859,
0.0007828267,
-0.0234688781,
-0.0260268915,
0.0269585475,
0.0179545581,
-0.0280560013,
0.0155109521,
0.0489999391,
-0.0255380869,
0.0403244011,
0.0928936973,
-0.0026855585,
0.036840111,
0.0011855017,
-0.0240534246,
-0.0216129869,
0.0235475693,
0.030039655,
0.0475756861,
-0.0024696707,
0.0271341801,
-0.0497733019,
-0.0606660545,
0.0450883731,
-0.0282332171,
-0.0247322917,
0.0098635769,
0.0263787042,
0.0544893034,
0.0208771788,
0.0160209406,
-0.0444489121,
-0.0049570999,
0.0203981251,
-0.0226678476,
-0.0102466652,
-6.36825387e-33,
-0.0057613403,
-0.0701456964,
0.0090812994,
-0.0236004032,
-0.005957691,
0.0280097965,
-0.0104415687,
-0.0150747634,
0.0045424714,
-0.0022784092,
-0.0037720515,
0.0170754492,
-0.003757481,
0.0355782509,
-0.0200989265,
0.0135992924,
0.0094164638,
0.0355251729,
-0.0093082273,
0.03643471,
0.0489710197,
0.0090965256,
0.0250949729,
-0.0087064281,
0.022662608,
-0.0092154481,
0.014378693,
0.0245496091,
0.0525000803,
0.0410861745,
-0.0197227504,
0.0370592736,
0.0446979403,
-0.0128889037,
-0.0091653876,
0.0061180736,
-0.04639237,
-0.0252755154,
0.0075196815,
-0.0346401744,
0.0147139803,
-0.0103294179,
0.0235321429,
0.0080057057,
0.0420612805,
-0.03360755,
0.0605355501,
-0.0082907015,
-0.0648838431,
-0.0066388291,
-0.0384180062,
0.066897288,
-0.0347261503,
-0.0161673874,
0.037420027,
0.0231246185,
0.0208368804,
0.0876810104,
-0.0566868968,
0.0335038789,
-0.0192424934,
0.0134544084,
0.0470162332,
0.0523022115,
0.0293229129,
0.0492344275,
-0.0239561256,
0.0054481346,
-0.0766508132,
-0.0105869453,
0.0379887037,
0.0238306914,
-0.0291848388,
0.0808668584,
0.0067947814,
0.0324684195,
-0.0714863837,
0.0626415908,
-0.0015618562,
-0.0147848092,
0.034169022,
0.0554326549,
-0.051548928,
-0.0522740036,
-0.0486438796,
-0.0490515418,
-0.0352716409,
0.0107973255,
-0.0111422548,
0.0029011038,
-0.0458503254,
0.0123718241,
0.0323647782,
-0.0355699472,
-0.0231352653,
0.0299465153,
0.0227662046,
0.0346818902,
-0.0038159504,
0.0092362305,
-0.0655693486,
-0.024292618,
0.0199657585,
0.0049082581,
-0.0110406866,
-0.0018086508,
0.0479112417,
-0.0238590762,
-0.0386550725,
-0.019771181,
-0.0059919711,
-0.0184253417,
-0.0210171454,
0.0431030616,
0.0156537052,
0.0379231758,
0.0157908183,
0.0601679161,
0.0544793718,
-0.0332260542,
0.0457150824,
0.0296272207,
-0.0457668342,
-0.0508581139,
-0.0130182728,
-0.0132080689,
0.0028381362,
0.000735473,
0.0804197639,
-0.0643756092,
-0.0320698731,
-0.0070857159,
2.61e-7,
0.0573599413,
0.036090292,
0.0184156056,
0.0075146602,
0.0243042354,
0.0552975461,
-0.0306823459,
-0.0046440978,
0.0218845345,
-0.0108061442,
0.0354118086,
0.0470358171,
0.0152602363,
0.0352796391,
-0.0619855635,
0.0377956927,
-0.0156208314,
0.0016195851,
-0.0420257933,
-0.0198807977,
-0.0018319929,
0.1154836044,
0.0353027843,
0.0102693876,
0.0287451018,
-0.049956765,
0.0488603972,
-0.0252735298,
-0.0247368179,
0.0340040624,
-0.0463522486,
-0.0018364885,
0.0003440862,
0.0234022588,
0.0259222947,
0.020775998,
0.0003945151,
0.0563294366,
-0.0240195394,
-0.0194860511,
0.0151603213,
-0.0020896308,
0.0032637252,
-0.0387051553,
0.1043430492,
-0.0737068281,
-0.0304157138,
0.0037901695,
-0.0067424676,
-0.0015134895,
0.0059688566,
0.0103033725,
-0.0352745354,
0.0449431874,
0.0143788271,
-0.0025607427,
-0.0166553818,
-0.0704106465,
0.0032272963,
0.0115320776,
-0.0480281785,
-0.0340423211,
0.0280409344,
-0.035602238,
0.0102500217,
-0.0556899272,
0.0659630597,
2.591005592e-34,
0.0327021107,
0.0163682364,
-0.0375726745,
-0.0070832972,
0.0136678936,
-0.0161604956,
-0.0772425756,
-0.0101150051,
0.0299534015,
-0.1170093492,
0.0097385244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13340v1 | SD-Eval: A Benchmark Dataset for Spoken Dialogue Understanding Beyond Words | 2024-06-19T08:46:29 | 2024-06-19T08:46:29 | Junyi Ao, Yuancheng Wang, Xiaohai Tian, Dekun Chen, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Yuxuan Wang, Haizhou Li, Zhizheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech encompasses a wealth of information, including but not limited to
content, paralinguistic, and environmental information. This comprehensive
nature of speech significantly impacts communication and is crucial for
human-computer interaction. Chat-Oriented Large Language Models (LLMs), known
for their general-purpose assistance capabilities, have evolved to handle
multi-modal inputs, including speech. Although these models can be adept at
recognizing and analyzing speech, they often fall short of generating
appropriate responses. We argue that this is due to the lack of principles on
task definition and model development, which requires open-source datasets and
metrics suitable for model evaluation. To bridge the gap, we present SD-Eval, a
benchmark dataset aimed at multidimensional evaluation of spoken dialogue
understanding and generation. SD-Eval focuses on paralinguistic and
environmental information and includes 7,303 utterances, amounting to 8.76
hours of speech data. The data is aggregated from eight public datasets,
representing four perspectives: emotion, accent, age, and background sound. To
assess the SD-Eval benchmark dataset, we implement three different models and
construct a training set following a similar process as SD-Eval. The training
set contains 1,052.72 hours of speech data and 724.4k utterances. We also
conduct a comprehensive evaluation using objective evaluation methods (e.g.
BLEU and ROUGE), subjective evaluations and LLM-based metrics for the generated
responses. Models conditioned with paralinguistic and environmental information
outperform their counterparts in both objective and subjective measures.
Moreover, experiments demonstrate LLM-based metrics show a higher correlation
with human evaluation compared to traditional metrics. We open-source SD-Eval
at https://github.com/amphionspace/SD-Eval. | [
0.0175087769,
0.074008435,
0.0038350981,
0.0284828823,
-0.0197497029,
0.011881981,
0.0257266555,
-0.0293850359,
-0.0005419744,
-0.0502325185,
-0.0869381279,
-0.0493272878,
0.025695201,
0.049031578,
0.0231247209,
-0.0503346734,
0.0353359431,
-0.0314384103,
0.0156456959,
0.0230204575,
0.0098050069,
0.0229228195,
-0.0312239397,
0.0541981347,
-0.0078073214,
-0.0108582135,
-0.0292295478,
0.0334571786,
0.0063689286,
-0.0092323981,
0.0031109126,
0.030073151,
0.044491116,
0.0202296637,
0.0000019388,
-0.0477368683,
0.0232265741,
-0.0435255058,
-0.0444976985,
0.0077735111,
0.0503110439,
-0.0000299381,
0.0064604394,
0.0246745627,
-0.039664045,
-0.0195348933,
0.0327621885,
0.0364435315,
0.0715044811,
0.0672326162,
-0.0029642223,
-0.0110041099,
0.0014594852,
-0.0181770679,
-0.0034231283,
-0.0351581126,
0.0199786555,
0.0140382322,
0.0059237862,
-0.0314605162,
0.0087244082,
0.0250694584,
0.0052596317,
-0.0210638344,
0.0320231095,
0.0015423248,
-0.0427772328,
-0.0502487607,
-0.0317797326,
0.1342937797,
0.031921301,
0.0100291539,
-0.0001999034,
0.0083584227,
0.000543356,
-0.0479150414,
-0.0561264269,
0.0010341415,
0.0180016924,
0.0025594512,
-0.0456424206,
0.0444581583,
-0.0062068659,
0.0193674937,
0.014013215,
0.0389711037,
-0.0095527247,
-0.0134477401,
-0.0074055744,
-0.0220296104,
-0.016819844,
-0.0343354084,
0.0119682867,
0.0219018627,
-0.0562004186,
0.0173459947,
-0.0460478999,
-0.0057747811,
0.0024476002,
-0.0390862077,
0.026438009,
0.0316041596,
-0.0404610224,
0.0177022386,
0.0022593415,
0.0850224718,
0.0067148651,
-0.0146436691,
-0.0188851301,
0.0027001288,
-0.0397093855,
0.0182274766,
-0.022670323,
-0.0068894699,
-0.0607206002,
-0.0444879979,
-0.0345705375,
0.0128029017,
-0.0269831754,
0.0108391382,
0.0271592941,
0.0309277307,
-0.0310744643,
0.01242333,
-0.0044079642,
0.0181129389,
-0.0193431638,
0.0554394871,
0.0342309251,
-0.105041936,
-0.0110859247,
0.0429427214,
0.0304812789,
-0.0153375128,
0.003866409,
0.0661600083,
-0.0060253823,
-0.0192470513,
-0.0156816822,
-0.0467304923,
-0.053009972,
-0.0859488621,
-0.0149838626,
-0.0383219607,
0.0440783687,
-0.0115843527,
-0.0179038364,
-0.0183792263,
0.0106749767,
-0.0114507563,
-0.0124911638,
0.029124137,
0.001210126,
0.0305835567,
0.017505154,
0.0265124366,
-0.0069675744,
0.0449323729,
0.0309119131,
0.0164165404,
0.0283047054,
-0.0112392772,
-0.0069022393,
0.045004528,
0.0212277044,
-0.0072780745,
-0.0017468847,
0.028927112,
-0.0358145609,
0.0573755875,
0.0393597633,
0.0355493985,
-0.0495785251,
-0.0383461192,
0.0756355599,
0.0150044886,
-0.019110525,
0.016110111,
0.0266300682,
0.0634907559,
0.0175055712,
-0.0192500725,
-0.0222934615,
0.0103942612,
-0.0135826115,
-0.0005521796,
0.0369633436,
0.0346243195,
-0.0397162884,
-0.0363161378,
0.0112853926,
0.0006225571,
0.0063582901,
0.0231377371,
0.0313301086,
0.0108387303,
-0.0420242958,
0.0520168468,
0.0004413674,
-0.0656306744,
-0.0064412188,
-0.0397059768,
0.0317996219,
0.0549887531,
0.0350618921,
-0.0052699652,
-0.0505683124,
-0.040720176,
0.0363383591,
0.031618759,
0.0294739455,
-0.018678112,
0.0817972496,
-0.0669845119,
-0.0117242141,
-0.0252204556,
-0.0048922258,
0.0426683016,
0.0033749659,
-0.0247171409,
0.0206096396,
-0.0187466443,
0.0104087386,
0.0093401521,
-0.0150495572,
-0.0232720263,
0.0128135374,
-0.0149791716,
0.0478577428,
0.0449398719,
-0.032227654,
-0.0033051944,
0.0271380059,
-0.0156632494,
0.0084272297,
0.04528201,
-0.0678735226,
-0.041955404,
0.0410926566,
-0.0293417349,
-0.0164974257,
0.0565831736,
-0.0265170708,
-0.0733609125,
0.0668250173,
-0.0283065066,
0.0016438524,
-0.0524498895,
0.0097121093,
0.0114271175,
0.0479805805,
0.013295074,
0.0235834233,
0.0113134105,
0.0030530747,
0.0470767915,
0.0505977198,
0.0148272747,
-0.0571172275,
-0.0161018968,
-0.0034558065,
-0.0463113151,
0.0226952843,
-0.0012926847,
0.0230170228,
-0.070716612,
-0.0236847904,
-0.1345523,
0.0144617185,
-0.0129338279,
0.0077619562,
0.0268287119,
-0.0056570172,
-0.0179973114,
-0.0143749565,
-0.0588309579,
-0.0020787332,
0.048512429,
-0.0254861061,
-0.0095418748,
-0.0003474475,
-0.0210619047,
-0.0422277376,
0.0341811329,
0.0337259807,
0.0248673838,
-0.0088123623,
0.0172927435,
-0.0097922264,
0.0210062824,
-0.0327750035,
0.02963553,
-0.0086237006,
-0.0658119768,
0.0011500699,
0.0091728829,
0.023979051,
0.0410705358,
0.0249070618,
0.0168042835,
0.0019556214,
-0.0532843918,
-0.0535311736,
0.0209531132,
-0.0092051243,
0.0178898498,
-0.0289452411,
-0.0124801416,
-0.020840127,
0.0462290831,
0.0240343586,
0.0364453718,
-0.037188217,
0.0097155096,
0.0180338398,
-0.0575331673,
-0.0430350751,
-0.0064388141,
-0.0556363426,
0.0416001268,
-0.0354208574,
-0.0362418965,
0.0442515239,
-0.0723538026,
-0.0622031391,
-0.0387397595,
-0.0250687264,
-0.023514986,
0.056251511,
-0.0441288352,
0.0118636256,
0.0077992417,
-0.0035522885,
-0.0267437473,
-0.0027106928,
-0.0095995143,
-0.0405450016,
0.0246682148,
-0.0559049509,
-0.0149896741,
0.0047630873,
-0.0244772471,
-0.0540446304,
-0.0521115251,
-0.0256619882,
-0.0021734242,
0.0130902827,
-0.0196100194,
-0.0088534178,
0.026857337,
0.0179328769,
0.0084567945,
-0.0279318858,
0.0057431068,
-0.0199190397,
0.0396041311,
0.0614068061,
0.0531303622,
0.0001502083,
-0.0213132538,
0.0587526113,
0.0273275077,
0.0484029427,
0.0096773589,
-0.0348762274,
0.0321196094,
0.0245019309,
0.0473016202,
-0.0049078199,
0.0186202936,
0.0682820305,
-0.0307016149,
-0.0083999475,
0.1329929382,
0.0030810439,
-0.0046312786,
-0.0018165734,
-0.0145086441,
0.03937722,
0.0211050268,
-0.0018930797,
-0.0556574687,
-0.0461858399,
0.0230022725,
0.0228990614,
-0.021362301,
-0.0152968522,
-0.0243156571,
-0.0878806412,
0.05830805,
0.0065533058,
-0.070824571,
-0.0197824147,
-0.0110816136,
0.0045560645,
-0.0265703872,
0.0497767814,
-0.0140016638,
0.0066633248,
-0.0306747835,
0.0360763371,
-0.0288227797,
-0.0527643226,
0.0605539717,
-0.0058460869,
0.0792021304,
0.034516979,
0.0797255337,
0.0244875289,
-0.0191013012,
0.0274233911,
0.0145090716,
-0.011659259,
0.0125149796,
0.0384390354,
0.0066077518,
-0.0170388333,
-0.0261392668,
0.0697379038,
-0.042719394,
0.0004278991,
0.0232998915,
0.0187195968,
-0.0464023687,
0.0210544504,
0.0019189729,
0.0618899316,
0.0401962623,
0.0885890946,
0.0651705787,
-0.0236908495,
-0.0410232954,
0.0221083034,
0.0001080105,
-0.0396612622,
0.0037188104,
0.0212249588,
0.0067167804,
-0.0225903895,
-0.0731439441,
-0.0342920609,
0.0025403034,
0.0369564481,
-0.0125271957,
-0.0265880134,
-0.0124732517,
0.018633578,
-0.022480078,
0.0553949811,
-0.0063338191,
0.036017172,
-0.0283324514,
-0.0005743007,
0.0205817986,
-0.0571582392,
-0.0212699082,
0.0522280931,
-0.0886001959,
-0.0643575788,
-0.0052235201,
0.0282705035,
0.0282751024,
0.0524045303,
-0.0104245208,
-0.0401274338,
0.0048051253,
-0.0162752476,
-0.0543300919,
-0.0025615399,
0.0473552458,
0.0261130612,
-0.020686375,
0.0330958068,
-0.0324207097,
0.0543934517,
-0.0192886274,
-0.0021516846,
-0.025398273,
-0.0664590001,
-0.0175861828,
0.0293564983,
0.0450695716,
0.0147168692,
-0.0194704495,
-0.0232126955,
-0.003406221,
-0.0185780767,
0.0065606521,
-0.086233288,
-0.0145424986,
0.0221504811,
-0.0027481408,
-0.0109106116,
-0.0107466774,
-0.0287944525,
0.0228305068,
-0.0325801857,
0.0268828236,
-0.0007486063,
-0.0003176149,
0.0117390063,
-0.0018358417,
-0.0318906903,
0.0169370975,
-0.0085107759,
0.0061112074,
0.0199363306,
0.0787370726,
-0.0015378223,
-0.0197559353,
0.0376033373,
0.0239005741,
-0.0514597185,
-0.0311906077,
-0.0017631829,
0.0505979434,
0.0340862833,
0.011166974,
0.1011729464,
-0.0029014624,
0.0283551272,
-0.0457005575,
0.0828706548,
-0.023068618,
-0.0299565103,
0.0386689268,
0.0120144747,
-0.0413015336,
0.01222168,
0.0648394302,
0.0039366581,
0.0293169878,
-0.0071349586,
0.0212436952,
-0.0573809482,
-0.0426024981,
0.0193374567,
0.0133924801,
0.0004927898,
0.0015198685,
-0.0379158892,
-0.0500667356,
-0.0260334909,
0.022243429,
0.0131006166,
-0.0281731989,
0.048855938,
0.0502281934,
-0.0274531748,
-0.0031557672,
-0.0347510614,
-0.0308017731,
-0.0377834812,
-0.0089431116,
-0.0108505171,
-6.26801065e-33,
-0.0302020051,
-0.0020278648,
0.0209624097,
-0.0046686884,
-0.0474568233,
-0.0011842416,
-0.0551991016,
0.0001543028,
-0.0216939729,
-0.0066856989,
0.0107174329,
0.0157124344,
0.0062885405,
0.0438600369,
-0.0300357305,
-0.0259526595,
0.0437680706,
-0.0240371004,
-0.014588994,
0.0548151545,
0.0500816852,
0.0248909798,
0.0215419494,
-0.0708899051,
0.0154136959,
-0.0134657351,
-0.031361334,
0.0123136565,
0.0212758575,
0.0482809544,
-0.0225570239,
0.037350703,
0.0090373363,
-0.0368802622,
-0.042017024,
0.047409445,
-0.0540607423,
-0.004892583,
0.0204783659,
0.042156212,
-0.0354191698,
0.0129974717,
0.0073904907,
0.0287451949,
-0.0113768466,
-0.0044506118,
0.0136103928,
-0.0278711393,
0.0023308294,
-0.0201298948,
-0.0276565403,
0.039555151,
-0.0504200198,
-0.0824114382,
0.0115779387,
0.1220726892,
-0.023963958,
-0.0134126553,
-0.0170096215,
0.0318049714,
-0.0078504356,
-0.0216959696,
0.0687859431,
0.0370260626,
0.0105096409,
0.0783339366,
0.0313128978,
-0.0151630268,
-0.0059393742,
-0.031263262,
0.0177410953,
0.0862864256,
-0.0111631993,
0.0623144694,
-0.0237829201,
-0.0017576201,
-0.043433357,
0.0280239023,
0.0493241251,
0.0086656101,
0.0309701134,
0.0010145369,
-0.0129385861,
-0.0024076069,
-0.0538225695,
0.0034857257,
-0.034093041,
-0.0063463934,
0.05897329,
0.0053456682,
0.0005738486,
-0.0409639105,
0.0615718402,
-0.047989808,
0.0286759827,
0.0343578383,
-0.0453724712,
-0.0003922606,
0.0013603159,
0.0276407991,
-0.0535239317,
-0.0266945362,
0.071577765,
0.0384417512,
0.0265080854,
-0.0186065733,
-0.0239347052,
0.0137706613,
-0.0188751966,
-0.0004230246,
-0.0523254313,
0.0645478144,
-0.042104017,
0.0234351493,
0.0330568403,
-0.0183204226,
-0.0405912027,
0.0525152199,
-0.0389310829,
0.0208531003,
-0.0120547423,
-0.0678897202,
0.0079106558,
0.0256276075,
-0.0554891229,
0.0006461134,
-0.0096164718,
-0.0918177813,
0.0257930793,
-0.0101393368,
-0.0080360733,
0.0107944533,
2.701e-7,
-0.034381818,
0.0207987875,
0.0307659991,
0.0217600241,
0.0335087925,
0.0484296158,
-0.0286679529,
0.0332468636,
0.0064492901,
-0.0069946605,
0.0139628919,
0.0092237554,
0.1092682779,
-0.0113992896,
-0.0901816413,
-0.0431500934,
-0.095748432,
-0.008868576,
-0.0105000995,
-0.0229046363,
0.0716248676,
0.0670480505,
-0.0352437273,
-0.0116191246,
0.0164270345,
-0.0175060406,
0.0477189384,
-0.060630355,
-0.0195305366,
0.0091939829,
0.0561451279,
-0.0013887667,
0.0001377192,
0.0070261182,
-0.00001823,
0.0131509528,
-0.0013320784,
0.1058933362,
0.0305105727,
-0.0652940124,
0.0103733661,
0.0277109221,
-0.0094094947,
-0.0626031384,
0.057626754,
-0.0310709719,
-0.0429161265,
-0.0488224477,
-0.0242667738,
-0.0122989547,
-0.0019938136,
-0.0178829096,
0.0035654614,
0.0249479022,
0.0029071751,
-0.0629312173,
-0.0026623993,
-0.0532548353,
-0.012959579,
0.009709334,
-0.0878883153,
-0.0429268293,
-0.0384495333,
-0.0061767721,
0.0193407387,
-0.0275595356,
-0.01909969,
2.082066818e-34,
0.0225108005,
-0.0249207076,
0.0058680801,
-0.0049623144,
0.0391722433,
-0.0402570516,
-0.0020514382,
0.0014790499,
0.0329122953,
-0.0536178425,
0.0141844209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13337v1 | Medical Spoken Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-19T08:39:09 | 2024-06-19T08:39:09 | Khai Le-Duc | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Spoken Named Entity Recognition (NER) aims to extracting named entities from
speech and categorizing them into types like person, location, organization,
etc. In this work, we present VietMed-NER - the first spoken NER dataset in the
medical domain. To our best knowledge, our real-world dataset is the largest
spoken NER dataset in the world in terms of the number of entity types,
featuring 18 distinct types. Secondly, we present baseline results using
various state-of-the-art pre-trained models: encoder-only and
sequence-to-sequence. We found that pre-trained multilingual models XLM-R
outperformed all monolingual models on both reference text and ASR output. Also
in general, encoders perform better than sequence-to-sequence models for the
NER task. By simply translating, the transcript is applicable not just to
Vietnamese but to other languages as well. All code, data and models are made
publicly available here: https://github.com/leduckhai/MultiMed | [
0.0130893188,
0.0496998727,
0.0435643122,
0.0244405977,
0.0427063033,
0.0391044281,
-0.004923597,
0.0241346676,
-0.0035204326,
-0.0120325349,
-0.0588438734,
-0.064103283,
0.0548627339,
0.0256203432,
0.0264133774,
-0.0577726103,
0.0167889744,
-0.0294033065,
0.0150601836,
0.0264939107,
-0.0363901556,
0.0139815789,
-0.0431984253,
0.0404307023,
0.0449890643,
0.0458058603,
-0.022030212,
0.008617321,
0.0567496158,
-0.0819798633,
-0.018054964,
0.0220141616,
-0.0194763448,
-0.0072874343,
0.0000018443,
-0.0270234011,
-0.0275958627,
0.0099588372,
-0.0622067787,
-0.0516634509,
-0.0127845248,
-0.0686617866,
-0.0149765629,
0.0081473291,
0.0097257458,
-0.0756090656,
0.0132124927,
0.0543913022,
0.0126890298,
0.0861668512,
-0.0116313864,
0.0064487639,
0.0284592751,
-0.0422657207,
0.0036754529,
-0.0071190093,
0.0284337122,
-0.0400671959,
-0.0004278752,
0.0170672256,
0.0048530223,
0.0191125367,
-0.0330066085,
0.0670913234,
0.0044243834,
0.0307142939,
-0.0415437669,
-0.0022643011,
0.0085819485,
0.0868283063,
-0.0323596671,
0.0306130387,
0.0642517656,
-0.0043990728,
-0.0447004177,
-0.0548406169,
0.0037560791,
0.0005633131,
-0.0381009951,
0.005922555,
0.0300402604,
0.0357307717,
0.0337635428,
-0.0144933034,
0.0002950954,
-0.0390218347,
-0.0041629453,
-0.0195125733,
0.0281990618,
-0.0054184701,
0.0005061126,
-0.0146633778,
0.0428881645,
0.0364683717,
-0.0100684669,
0.0127042606,
-0.0215781163,
0.0028255875,
0.0259098019,
-0.078180261,
-0.0185722429,
0.0164476875,
-0.0170711838,
0.0198958796,
-0.0348755568,
0.0378006026,
-0.0272966605,
0.0363352224,
0.0118146157,
-0.0123067526,
-0.0265777931,
0.0123684937,
-0.0166123006,
0.0493433028,
-0.0434900224,
0.0047035869,
-0.067067951,
-0.0290271938,
0.0201786198,
0.0206791684,
0.0358978398,
0.0153038511,
-0.0246557053,
-0.0053915656,
-0.0081935069,
0.0270357206,
0.0337300487,
0.0212822594,
-0.0298640467,
-0.0561044775,
0.0024815605,
0.0074434169,
0.0430217236,
-0.0061109378,
0.0410830341,
0.0721212402,
0.0257145911,
-0.0717515051,
-0.0192312635,
-0.0099938828,
0.0108652636,
-0.0432929508,
0.0239870735,
-0.0316069201,
0.0581681095,
0.0135419471,
0.0209038462,
-0.0503264144,
0.0374687053,
-0.0227564257,
-0.0627138242,
0.0891781598,
-0.0375267491,
-0.0019480125,
0.0283207875,
0.0269284137,
0.042958796,
0.010501991,
0.0452009551,
-0.0477312952,
0.0001672198,
-0.01890314,
0.0187203251,
0.031753961,
0.0101581095,
-0.04168332,
0.0332362801,
0.008465345,
-0.0204576347,
0.0505464338,
0.0140872234,
0.0519079417,
-0.0074205738,
-0.0063729067,
-0.0150959212,
0.0398749709,
0.003906759,
-0.030416429,
0.0154975271,
-0.0326248854,
0.0229203757,
-0.0341837741,
-0.0161846057,
-0.0017310387,
0.0176490024,
0.0136308372,
0.0187176708,
0.0299566593,
-0.0474807993,
-0.0004402148,
-0.0055848123,
-0.0264254864,
-0.0343532674,
-0.0033685931,
0.0321642086,
0.007347764,
-0.0743994713,
0.0731298402,
0.0392411314,
-0.0062834695,
0.0174370501,
-0.0331364721,
-0.0190403033,
0.0317424238,
0.0266423505,
-0.0471729413,
-0.0426426716,
-0.0441233441,
-0.0438127853,
0.0348446406,
-0.0236100256,
0.0057435585,
0.087547265,
-0.048598703,
0.0112910522,
0.0476452783,
0.0239691306,
0.047062628,
0.0161591638,
0.0788195059,
0.0084507046,
0.0116978167,
-0.0228082631,
0.022453187,
-0.0652164146,
-0.038774021,
0.0307871662,
0.0183744971,
0.0634023175,
0.0628561601,
-0.0169692468,
-0.0084376577,
0.032982152,
-0.0299201496,
0.0057307836,
0.0095539363,
-0.0301454496,
-0.0818450451,
-0.0233265981,
-0.0243346337,
-0.001119349,
-0.0074435831,
-0.0239525586,
-0.0430965535,
-0.0703315064,
0.0394370221,
0.0340220705,
-0.0260847099,
0.0541275628,
0.0562262274,
0.0417106114,
0.0170955118,
0.0031530804,
-0.0462452844,
0.0210087486,
0.0633323193,
-0.018159112,
-0.0117710764,
-0.0372013152,
-0.0256429017,
0.050479576,
0.0135352332,
-0.0005519363,
-0.016168952,
0.0265895501,
-0.00603949,
-0.0185985044,
-0.0790808946,
-0.0026348538,
-0.0084521715,
0.0417038426,
-0.0000420944,
0.0273253135,
-0.0044217156,
-0.0438887849,
-0.0179606248,
-0.016486017,
0.0231003761,
-0.0099955928,
0.0002986599,
0.0285341293,
0.0120638348,
-0.0102944383,
0.0250886194,
-0.0269747358,
-0.0073950016,
-0.0135614574,
-0.0792449117,
-0.0394405387,
0.0159494318,
-0.0228273254,
-0.034476772,
-0.0167434942,
-0.005055388,
-0.0240914896,
0.0299385041,
-0.0004596864,
0.0372092351,
-0.0093619665,
0.0376773924,
-0.0424551666,
-0.0087885894,
-0.0024420167,
0.013465751,
-0.0088796169,
0.0259479955,
-0.0270236284,
-0.0402426571,
0.0027347193,
0.093527481,
0.00133718,
0.0566759482,
-0.0145765087,
-0.0534383692,
-0.0000101192,
-0.0072590774,
-0.0218809098,
0.0176923275,
-0.0392324217,
0.0005631349,
0.0034545062,
-0.0076492154,
0.0572896227,
-0.0711782351,
-0.030096747,
-0.0166080333,
-0.0346614458,
-0.0610216446,
0.0289975684,
0.0168083981,
0.0098413844,
0.0111338776,
-0.0993449315,
0.0319412835,
0.0657356232,
-0.0409575477,
-0.0734038353,
0.010096211,
0.0238901246,
-0.0285021048,
-0.0294461232,
-0.0213223174,
-0.043751996,
0.024370417,
-0.0510706119,
0.0334948413,
-0.0098914951,
0.0057473993,
-0.0298883058,
0.0767837018,
-0.0258150622,
0.0637045801,
0.0302614477,
0.0253667273,
-0.0274363812,
0.0682398975,
0.0085031725,
0.0089467335,
-0.0349323936,
-0.0211542957,
0.002527605,
0.0166755151,
-0.0432099514,
0.0074173328,
0.0282161012,
-0.0019811532,
0.0080792969,
-0.0034774861,
0.0047759209,
-0.0021521866,
0.0365223847,
-0.039514713,
0.0211030934,
0.1061735228,
-0.0008084554,
-0.0293471292,
-0.0123782847,
0.0196086857,
-0.0183638651,
-0.003432282,
0.0007904675,
-0.0617531277,
-0.048410669,
0.028423775,
-0.0060126116,
0.0056806095,
-0.0481004305,
0.0035600127,
-0.0667361841,
-0.0009235549,
-0.0029690461,
-0.0916461125,
-0.0396384299,
-0.053105928,
-0.0364393294,
-0.0414534546,
0.0133348918,
-0.0212879423,
-0.0179264378,
-0.0288973339,
0.0221735314,
-0.0428704247,
-0.0616777688,
0.0288233459,
-0.0292705521,
0.058605127,
0.0432212204,
0.0222909823,
-0.0168406833,
-0.0105267242,
0.0070594493,
0.0077977241,
-0.0270496644,
-0.00292847,
0.0611991696,
-0.043884892,
-0.012298001,
-0.0096744886,
0.040289361,
-0.0432907529,
-0.0235295147,
0.0046297219,
0.0328603387,
-0.0127498833,
-0.0117585314,
-0.0068696695,
0.0016779579,
0.0194084421,
0.0510003939,
-0.0213376973,
0.0019334835,
0.0007753425,
-0.0001366428,
0.0258734729,
0.017645305,
-0.0445734896,
0.0237235501,
-0.03135572,
-0.0521741509,
-0.036466524,
-0.0281133577,
0.0313752107,
0.0095964409,
0.0206898898,
0.0060543488,
0.0502375513,
0.034451995,
-0.0498704873,
0.042012617,
-0.0008347108,
0.0032189176,
-0.0911705717,
-0.0462292396,
0.0489060804,
0.0185207445,
-0.0135664074,
0.00865635,
-0.0353939906,
-0.0208538268,
-0.0117835812,
0.0350119248,
0.0097113876,
0.0351108573,
0.0222402401,
0.0294118002,
0.0591441356,
0.0258745477,
-0.0634488836,
-0.014816951,
0.0174682941,
0.0246520638,
-0.0536152944,
0.0166869909,
0.017325107,
0.0015980984,
0.0062217424,
0.0095925247,
-0.0358594246,
-0.0728658363,
-0.0250300281,
0.0147502013,
0.0832876787,
-0.0254959427,
-0.0248659644,
-0.0603512675,
0.0394883975,
0.0066641136,
0.0640088916,
-0.0241353642,
-0.0383798853,
0.0345384218,
-0.0004472077,
-0.0204931851,
0.0296475869,
-0.0233176146,
-0.056201756,
0.003385555,
0.0489819869,
0.0119030494,
0.0503103361,
0.0490112752,
-0.008958729,
-0.0121211149,
0.0607786886,
0.0300117787,
0.0367167741,
-0.0240057074,
0.026679581,
-0.0294471532,
0.0421583802,
0.0227447804,
0.0319979265,
-0.0064209034,
-0.0152100641,
-0.0592700057,
0.0492740832,
0.021236632,
0.0120547377,
0.0434538722,
0.0096644452,
0.0214822218,
-0.0253475234,
0.053611435,
-0.0861136094,
0.0110743269,
0.0382715128,
0.0021940966,
-0.031138856,
0.0230618976,
0.0725778192,
0.0293607451,
0.0311243478,
0.0426995531,
-0.0134676741,
-0.0285332892,
-0.0157832354,
0.0302536767,
-0.0143123157,
-0.0607011653,
0.00545156,
-0.0053005405,
-0.0559668951,
0.0534574501,
-0.0338313319,
-0.0230891611,
0.0068995198,
0.0077860197,
-0.024494553,
0.0063132402,
-0.00688812,
-0.0161918644,
0.0112666991,
-0.0426915474,
-0.0161013901,
0.0529736206,
-5.665524245e-33,
-0.049508024,
-0.0138243809,
0.0296896249,
-0.0244903583,
-0.0087752044,
0.0510094687,
-0.0204720236,
0.0307550263,
0.0263797119,
-0.0433997773,
-0.0158274472,
-0.0238656495,
0.0339155681,
0.0379094034,
-0.0038121685,
-0.0469244011,
0.044077117,
0.0527178943,
-0.0197976343,
0.0076541808,
0.0068830797,
0.0722319633,
0.0983390883,
-0.0726282522,
-0.0093219141,
0.0173621234,
0.0396317244,
-0.0219168197,
0.0288882256,
0.0486478247,
-0.0596168637,
-0.0089323483,
0.0110752964,
-0.052865047,
0.0087851789,
0.0020734593,
-0.1642269194,
0.0510505326,
-0.0386214964,
0.0664442927,
-0.0462508574,
-0.0441906415,
-0.002980123,
0.0042166798,
0.009412528,
-0.0112339454,
0.019276768,
-0.0412297286,
0.0095364312,
-0.003185367,
-0.0107345721,
0.0622987524,
-0.0016317028,
0.0330683887,
0.0382122621,
0.0232311413,
-0.0232237317,
0.0009788777,
-0.0944336727,
-0.0122422623,
0.0275282227,
0.0047965758,
-0.0031188484,
0.0126418108,
-0.0322215259,
0.0252944585,
0.0382928997,
-0.0637343451,
-0.0252933744,
0.0224139336,
-0.0290452074,
0.0439466313,
-0.0078208586,
0.0403627641,
0.0257182512,
-0.0443168133,
-0.0705982894,
0.0372945555,
-0.0454679206,
0.0089455359,
0.0082382504,
-0.0273173973,
-0.0335252956,
0.0182569269,
-0.0068105804,
-0.0464420654,
-0.0074573676,
-0.0237363148,
0.040586967,
0.0532876551,
-0.0141101545,
0.049031008,
0.0724289939,
-0.0182905681,
-0.0219035707,
-0.003050348,
0.0308826491,
-0.0181433223,
-0.0700528845,
0.0322264805,
-0.0794418082,
-0.0604633577,
0.0444579571,
-0.0305913333,
0.0432173833,
-0.0095892036,
0.0214890875,
-0.012212473,
-0.0772695243,
-0.0031936397,
0.0208243094,
0.0295235123,
-0.0265724864,
0.0770645738,
0.0087685324,
-0.0129888896,
0.0042730821,
0.054762587,
-0.0190413054,
-0.0107439477,
-0.0421404094,
-0.0070366468,
0.035539858,
0.0142711308,
-0.039785143,
0.0065580159,
-0.0313042067,
-0.0006704357,
0.0263755005,
-0.0369840935,
0.0112512512,
-0.0137700941,
2.489e-7,
0.0104091875,
-0.0086565176,
0.0422492661,
-0.0433875918,
-0.0094774393,
0.0028180582,
0.0012639161,
0.0453484841,
-0.0208402779,
-0.0096494062,
0.0060661878,
-0.0214229114,
0.0504101478,
0.0221521091,
-0.1115275547,
-0.0494814664,
-0.0657593533,
0.0042135417,
-0.029665757,
-0.0234967712,
-0.0102068689,
0.1074131131,
-0.050527893,
-0.0145333027,
-0.0160672516,
0.0223207492,
0.0462126099,
-0.0045166421,
0.0222051237,
0.0380018614,
-0.0184795056,
0.031476412,
-0.0152812628,
-0.000610372,
-0.0260534957,
0.0011433007,
0.0351080634,
0.1135520041,
-0.0236344561,
-0.0192295257,
0.0027828948,
0.0225576479,
-0.0110761551,
0.003650022,
0.0642755926,
-0.0213947725,
-0.0487521514,
0.0181143321,
-0.0138552478,
0.0210927743,
0.0589214638,
0.0111720059,
0.0036437479,
0.0437853336,
0.0629037842,
-0.0242782496,
-0.0386681408,
-0.0568184443,
0.0003443937,
0.0236815009,
-0.0092965551,
-0.0025313713,
0.0327496156,
-0.0239966009,
-0.0024443229,
-0.0451433919,
0.0190954804,
2.042636789e-34,
-0.0004827674,
0.0229710266,
-0.0268786699,
0.0357728861,
0.0236630552,
-0.0723107383,
-0.021274738,
-0.0022452113,
-0.0209247563,
-0.0305410866,
-0.0131896455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13332v1 | How effective is Multi-source pivoting for Translation of Low Resource Indian Languages? | 2024-06-19T08:31:52 | 2024-06-19T08:31:52 | Pranav Gaikwad, Meet Doshi, Raj Dabre, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) between linguistically dissimilar languages is
challenging, especially due to the scarcity of parallel corpora. Prior works
suggest that pivoting through a high-resource language can help translation
into a related low-resource language. However, existing works tend to discard
the source sentence when pivoting. Taking the case of English to Indian
language MT, this paper explores the 'multi-source translation' approach with
pivoting, using both source and pivot sentences to improve translation. We
conducted extensive experiments with various multi-source techniques for
translating English to Konkani, Manipuri, Sanskrit, and Bodo, using Hindi,
Marathi, and Bengali as pivot languages. We find that multi-source pivoting
yields marginal improvements over the state-of-the-art, contrary to previous
claims, but these improvements can be enhanced with synthetic target language
data. We believe multi-source pivoting is a promising direction for
Low-resource translation. | [
0.0133877844,
-0.0232980698,
0.0004718331,
0.0258627441,
-0.085281074,
0.0096556097,
0.0069506411,
0.0046536503,
-0.074176304,
-0.0186423939,
-0.0272675492,
0.0085580247,
0.0592102222,
-0.0221090615,
0.0141208814,
-0.069127962,
0.0235746279,
0.007811842,
-0.0125898421,
0.0248141252,
0.0087428186,
0.0645376369,
-0.0325979106,
0.0112529723,
-0.020030871,
-0.0247843098,
0.0424138121,
0.0586384274,
0.0413645394,
0.0046123909,
-0.042071119,
0.026980795,
0.0050163814,
0.0347498357,
0.0000015913,
-0.0272881798,
-0.0653922409,
-0.0095499214,
0.0287000556,
-0.0167046171,
0.064930737,
-0.0751031116,
0.023945028,
0.0464050025,
0.003148363,
0.0044619329,
0.0512890555,
0.0075061186,
0.0455668345,
0.0980322212,
-0.0369700454,
-0.0725454465,
-0.002627332,
-0.0059217336,
-0.0335897915,
-0.0084782746,
-0.0632069558,
-0.0150897969,
-0.0226135198,
-0.0040800851,
-0.0078320438,
0.0273717716,
-0.01139923,
-0.0289866589,
-0.0152104842,
-0.002306029,
-0.055390574,
-0.0223113373,
0.0589066297,
0.0563455001,
-0.0966841578,
-0.0114429835,
-0.0109197181,
-0.0107526369,
0.0055489079,
-0.0175208766,
-0.0608486831,
0.0305900387,
-0.0376193225,
0.0285595171,
0.0250882693,
0.0304726306,
-0.0152410679,
-0.0339476541,
-0.0001929465,
-0.0461068749,
0.0159471091,
-0.0170062594,
-0.0029101206,
0.0146167586,
0.0570243225,
0.0302342828,
0.0291531775,
-0.0336108878,
-0.0023752202,
0.0360334925,
-0.0285097249,
-0.0435183942,
-0.0010682094,
-0.0443061329,
0.0015230955,
0.0612075292,
-0.0215091594,
-0.0053217886,
0.0003028004,
0.0212416332,
-0.0314423852,
0.0032811342,
-0.0745933428,
-0.0100293495,
0.0017020524,
0.0121088503,
-0.0352636725,
-0.0278339889,
-0.1008209735,
0.0158827472,
-0.0629550219,
0.0115895579,
0.048571717,
-0.0479746684,
0.0136207342,
-0.0439075157,
-0.0393525995,
-0.0321941264,
0.048817724,
0.0998927429,
-0.0184567031,
-0.000835059,
0.0029379842,
-0.0944023877,
-0.0199049786,
0.0515282638,
-0.0047667418,
-0.0464094691,
-0.0493996292,
0.0605567023,
-0.0294596516,
-0.0140115265,
-0.072528176,
0.0314512514,
-0.0175919328,
-0.0360282511,
-0.0067351763,
-0.0585419126,
0.0874407664,
0.0409877077,
0.0371523015,
0.0046812571,
-0.005400911,
0.0130382376,
-0.0729266033,
0.0566560104,
-0.0025655457,
0.0276884809,
0.0340493433,
-0.0097230133,
0.0392066389,
0.0655199289,
0.0273349807,
0.0104515394,
0.0399250723,
-0.0238282159,
-0.0023128253,
0.0299549457,
-0.0062471181,
0.005631885,
-0.0113439308,
0.0270452742,
-0.0141245192,
0.0346175283,
-0.0019370465,
0.0262645427,
-0.0162365921,
0.073990792,
0.0219388846,
0.0278209373,
0.0106981713,
0.0457477495,
0.0231256895,
0.0156931113,
0.0034397226,
0.0305026993,
-0.0000977853,
0.0185509995,
0.0254451707,
-0.013008344,
0.0689881369,
0.034869723,
-0.0154825374,
0.0198903996,
-0.0072522992,
-0.0488625467,
-0.0442582332,
-0.013301,
0.0358250514,
0.0041558375,
-0.0571634471,
0.0282896329,
0.0202033985,
-0.0667941794,
0.0172086991,
0.0181134902,
-0.0394378863,
0.0193849318,
-0.0129363192,
0.0095229512,
-0.0130556887,
0.0073108338,
0.0075913975,
0.0340678804,
0.043367628,
0.0000065075,
0.0119359586,
-0.0432321131,
0.0204454586,
0.0461820327,
-0.0302044861,
0.0494706556,
-0.0510333367,
0.0121120494,
0.0257896874,
-0.0017638621,
-0.0179360136,
0.0176258441,
0.0244950932,
0.0527014695,
0.0243549272,
0.0085673286,
0.0373367146,
0.0042629256,
0.011404234,
0.0092886519,
0.0303648785,
-0.0162806995,
0.0033808011,
0.0826160759,
0.0253181942,
-0.0473877266,
-0.0040548993,
-0.0858402476,
0.0012433132,
-0.0109656937,
-0.0075347098,
-0.0788889378,
-0.0124597671,
0.009812668,
-0.0071131382,
0.0123421606,
0.0655819103,
-0.0144869918,
-0.0022966093,
-0.0495753139,
0.0376943797,
0.0418592952,
0.0087876804,
-0.0170753729,
-0.0491604246,
0.0596861057,
-0.0672128201,
0.0498551205,
0.0398978032,
0.0453151986,
-0.0026714916,
0.0229818728,
0.0007389221,
-0.0719623789,
-0.0247925203,
-0.0766162947,
-0.0022000198,
0.0206525177,
0.0241135806,
0.0060948473,
0.0476236977,
0.0084938826,
-0.005231692,
0.0001998575,
-0.0249756034,
0.0504222363,
0.0288964678,
0.0296989717,
-0.0093253059,
0.0351960361,
-0.0001046524,
-0.008917952,
0.0264585316,
0.0423283502,
0.016478125,
-0.026592005,
-0.0510129966,
0.0009163731,
0.0100295953,
-0.0458815098,
0.0184463505,
-0.017870564,
-0.0108479224,
-0.0043877,
0.04611196,
-0.0076998495,
-0.0085770041,
-0.0486020856,
0.007863529,
-0.022873573,
-0.0153896613,
-0.0223637093,
0.0323958099,
-0.013957737,
-0.0328081623,
-0.0720228702,
0.0406004265,
-0.0309976321,
0.01640011,
0.0058483789,
-0.0506303199,
-0.0453429185,
-0.0245411657,
0.0332120359,
-0.0073223533,
0.0360835865,
0.0146704381,
0.0580207296,
-0.0042836475,
-0.0161462948,
0.0316328518,
-0.0186193082,
-0.0263132043,
-0.0803899318,
0.0209227595,
-0.0367710032,
0.0161306094,
-0.0605500974,
-0.0007813619,
-0.0555815026,
0.0074254628,
-0.0328828245,
0.0271495394,
0.0153277125,
0.0069305263,
0.0497899428,
-0.0856172964,
0.0370562002,
-0.0626705661,
-0.0183982626,
-0.0136818876,
-0.0610634498,
0.0241581108,
-0.028686272,
0.027954286,
-0.0109732719,
-0.0400181003,
0.052920837,
0.0223974306,
0.0092264647,
-0.009951706,
-0.003643129,
0.0397018716,
0.0251924731,
0.016561754,
-0.0164266862,
-0.0301417857,
0.0186466724,
0.0152881797,
-0.0176795553,
0.063521713,
-0.0288506467,
0.0305869412,
-0.0201544762,
0.0299117826,
0.0049268319,
-0.0422664322,
-0.0298459977,
0.0001777193,
0.0270187799,
-0.0013752277,
0.0861923918,
0.0357502513,
-0.0238410551,
-0.0353539549,
-0.0691692606,
-0.0082495259,
-0.0242248196,
0.0503563695,
-0.0369366296,
0.0086892005,
-0.0021481877,
0.0286943149,
0.0457770005,
0.0234505441,
-0.0367372893,
-0.1193585098,
0.0036088154,
0.0070610899,
-0.0828575119,
-0.0853808597,
-0.0305537377,
-0.0532721095,
-0.0393635519,
0.0151888365,
0.0284308847,
-0.0223240033,
-0.0193604883,
0.0106965099,
0.0101146363,
-0.001550958,
-0.0616819412,
-0.0071761766,
-0.0331628732,
0.0118261641,
0.0252950341,
-0.0378148146,
-0.0172190201,
0.0143803991,
-0.0373666622,
-0.0232662838,
-0.0203183014,
0.0360608585,
-0.0107351895,
-0.0025405714,
0.0524965674,
-0.0059113936,
-0.045482602,
-0.0160252191,
0.0246409774,
0.0195540525,
0.0202812571,
-0.0013106684,
0.0312761441,
-0.0197573733,
0.0241408721,
0.0108048571,
0.012206018,
-0.024601087,
0.0373152755,
-0.0158506352,
-0.0130529879,
-0.0342117772,
-0.0017324935,
0.026800802,
-0.1099058017,
-0.0519102588,
-0.0511678942,
-0.04522698,
0.0304843094,
0.0897944868,
0.0187536422,
0.0470742993,
-0.0003869443,
0.0313529,
0.0096351346,
-0.0260299463,
-0.0193710569,
0.0173888598,
-0.031842526,
0.0134447673,
0.0351368189,
0.0313365683,
0.0032201295,
-0.0084915385,
0.0097539714,
-0.0483225249,
-0.0323896185,
0.0005936222,
0.0232041311,
-0.0030227487,
-0.0179469399,
-0.0032541626,
-0.0283628516,
0.0150513137,
-0.0479904562,
-0.0188399069,
0.0239566807,
0.0023784956,
-0.0064334567,
0.0506105982,
-0.0342693441,
0.0130262505,
-0.0516694561,
0.0300515052,
-0.0458626188,
-0.0069590425,
0.0333557986,
0.0252221227,
0.0178029127,
-0.0822988674,
-0.0282820463,
0.0116005437,
0.0186296999,
-0.0138318921,
-0.0382868759,
-0.0274506565,
-0.0066691511,
0.0840521976,
0.0008829021,
0.0193536766,
-0.0174344778,
-0.0438730195,
-0.0324378945,
0.0046181669,
0.0122891869,
0.0192671139,
0.0842370167,
0.018369697,
0.0105103869,
-0.0208642203,
-0.0215023924,
-0.0281509906,
-0.0003711851,
-0.0230066087,
0.0106358649,
0.0175620653,
0.0320040546,
0.0307537112,
0.0254301503,
0.0418681987,
0.028086625,
0.0064894981,
0.0288987365,
0.0559903681,
0.0072760419,
0.1297833174,
0.0204212833,
-0.0149857579,
0.0062983958,
0.054891225,
0.012769877,
-0.002300604,
-0.0237830654,
-0.0167629849,
-0.0121205077,
-0.0149489082,
0.0697400272,
-0.0295121558,
-0.0391159207,
0.0070445552,
-0.0143892141,
-0.0294822287,
-0.0269622076,
-0.0534764864,
-0.0388790965,
0.040504951,
0.0012878154,
-0.0654241666,
-0.0218185745,
0.0117998766,
-0.0103002749,
0.056571234,
-0.0184657089,
-0.0037528472,
0.0861260593,
0.0325800739,
0.0338124558,
-0.0183449686,
0.0172965769,
-0.0125295576,
-0.0378033556,
-0.011126955,
-5.094080442e-33,
-0.0459929109,
-0.0050864499,
-0.0205867626,
-0.0057976064,
-0.0084721679,
-0.0418289788,
0.0036110368,
-0.0116215665,
0.0039986852,
-0.0033890463,
-0.0369555056,
0.0074189939,
0.0445328541,
-0.0214776322,
0.0499050803,
0.0428213142,
0.0133484183,
0.0157277025,
-0.0398557186,
-0.0018675935,
0.0498398244,
0.0182745308,
0.0726956278,
-0.0559716485,
0.0317629576,
-0.0727895722,
-0.0181317404,
0.046619311,
0.0147703877,
-0.0277211834,
0.0296318904,
-0.0020508205,
0.0296179894,
-0.0421334244,
-0.0064134225,
0.0084612211,
-0.0647817627,
0.0397374555,
0.0654776767,
0.0656639263,
0.0062608509,
-0.0427368097,
0.0288113579,
-0.0189841036,
0.0344625823,
0.0193215832,
0.0072654653,
-0.0279476158,
-0.0531985871,
-0.0029693926,
-0.0630965754,
0.0307510793,
-0.0181844737,
-0.0101652313,
-0.0035667166,
0.1018028259,
0.0010810893,
-0.0591833219,
0.0068938318,
0.0260837674,
-0.0224601571,
0.038150318,
0.0523275696,
-0.0123050371,
-0.0567197725,
-0.0314915478,
0.020303648,
-0.0578982383,
0.0447249971,
0.0168739613,
-0.0282380916,
0.0179845821,
0.0032697984,
0.0379714072,
0.0288891718,
-0.0677749664,
-0.0351105295,
0.0301116463,
-0.0053626532,
0.0255647451,
-0.002013345,
0.0220655482,
-0.0168423075,
-0.0734393895,
0.0515254326,
-0.0550285503,
-0.0098512014,
-0.0076243277,
0.0250307601,
0.0105020786,
-0.0033180274,
0.080176875,
0.0620902292,
-0.0007157827,
0.0315910839,
0.0389045291,
-0.0388724245,
0.0414174832,
-0.0335547999,
0.0182726942,
-0.019441545,
-0.079045698,
0.0144577017,
0.0470143333,
0.0150871808,
-0.0109834168,
0.048181057,
-0.0034750437,
-0.0545761436,
0.0039665648,
-0.0094370972,
0.0150364265,
-0.0297575686,
0.0225550979,
-0.0271383766,
-0.0033226535,
-0.0122172963,
-0.0257124901,
0.0256044399,
-0.0042297943,
-0.0144171696,
0.0259831045,
0.0224684123,
-0.0046832301,
-0.0318457596,
0.0346023291,
-0.000628331,
-0.0016333484,
0.0537463762,
-0.0116100563,
-0.0384671353,
0.0002553422,
2.409e-7,
0.033378575,
0.041295141,
0.0271970816,
-0.0298215691,
-0.0393601246,
-0.0121058803,
-0.0463713519,
0.0080539212,
0.0208532047,
0.10506396,
0.032145001,
-0.0023094499,
0.0850506648,
0.0596611425,
-0.0881716684,
-0.0512520559,
-0.0418298244,
0.0013085271,
-0.0480510667,
-0.0009596445,
-0.0235116556,
0.0664941519,
0.00382521,
-0.0136338146,
-0.0320837907,
-0.0331385359,
0.0477766767,
-0.0102466671,
-0.0123213194,
0.0060941931,
-0.004453578,
-0.0078830542,
-0.0834659934,
-0.0146137644,
0.0029118464,
0.0184979141,
0.0840209424,
0.0691492036,
0.0071113613,
0.0047690556,
0.0404059254,
0.0098548643,
-0.0266021695,
0.0079506263,
0.0001511161,
0.0024762345,
-0.0046936786,
0.0198689513,
-0.0051749651,
0.0480854139,
0.0224869382,
0.0102893552,
-0.0293987393,
0.0118059246,
0.0363629684,
-0.0542771704,
-0.0456539504,
-0.02375089,
-0.0671607405,
0.0288746841,
0.0035542122,
-0.0488795415,
0.0172779709,
-0.0242008939,
0.0436582603,
0.0096934736,
0.0049225762,
1.614140859e-34,
0.0703301653,
0.0030956252,
0.0068776817,
-0.008031697,
0.0228093807,
-0.0414386019,
0.0172845181,
0.0228062961,
-0.01615059,
-0.041961126,
-0.0289307795
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13331v1 | Improving Zero-shot LLM Re-Ranker with Risk Minimization | 2024-06-19T08:29:54 | 2024-06-19T08:29:54 | Xiaowei Yuan, Zhao Yang, Yequan Wang, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) system, advanced Large Language
Models (LLMs) have emerged as effective Query Likelihood Models (QLMs) in an
unsupervised way, which re-rank documents based on the probability of
generating the query given the content of a document. However, directly
prompting LLMs to approximate QLMs inherently is biased, where the estimated
distribution might diverge from the actual document-specific distribution. In
this study, we introduce a novel framework, $\mathrm{UR^3}$, which leverages
Bayesian decision theory to both quantify and mitigate this estimation bias.
Specifically, $\mathrm{UR^3}$ reformulates the problem as maximizing the
probability of document generation, thereby harmonizing the optimization of
query and document generation probabilities under a unified risk minimization
objective. Our empirical results indicate that $\mathrm{UR^3}$ significantly
enhances re-ranking, particularly in improving the Top-1 accuracy. It benefits
the QA tasks by achieving higher accuracy with fewer input documents. | [
0.0280101188,
0.0408655219,
0.0354385674,
-0.0161234811,
-0.00095718,
-0.0001502861,
-0.0168334376,
-0.0097634187,
-0.0159021951,
-0.0741328895,
-0.0122033963,
-0.0247258246,
-0.0151900882,
-0.0187026672,
0.0276267417,
0.0174453687,
0.0279198214,
-0.0449099094,
0.0135184377,
-0.01437103,
-0.0231726617,
0.008025581,
0.0162331685,
0.0072500641,
0.0354903676,
0.0315866321,
-0.0118622705,
0.0684087574,
0.0040066387,
-0.0196685586,
-0.0049411231,
0.0361244977,
0.015048041,
0.0560424998,
0.0000017673,
-0.0830719545,
-0.0634106994,
-0.0050416482,
-0.0220853947,
-0.0067499569,
0.0323302299,
0.0198360216,
-0.0005527462,
0.038089864,
-0.0234135166,
0.0332804769,
0.0157189853,
0.0396687128,
-0.0030847683,
0.0619006269,
0.0071829841,
0.0041119256,
0.0272603054,
-0.0548991561,
0.0866397768,
-0.0696057975,
0.0140232434,
0.0227172691,
0.0236671176,
0.0407354496,
0.0041430634,
0.0101642851,
-0.0202112608,
-0.0298543908,
0.0353502259,
0.0230325293,
-0.046857547,
0.018177269,
0.0149429459,
0.0339836553,
-0.0208005719,
-0.0190773308,
0.0162983779,
0.0070706932,
0.016526008,
0.0427249894,
-0.0830065757,
0.0398471244,
-0.0059613371,
0.0123135811,
0.0196031537,
-0.0050845668,
0.0310511887,
0.0451589376,
-0.0223593768,
0.0702570304,
0.0250887033,
-0.0205656085,
-0.0000536097,
0.0107604191,
0.0158575922,
-0.0101267854,
-0.0013898577,
0.0198467392,
-0.0280549023,
0.0279637333,
-0.0146187693,
-0.0214552041,
0.0461363792,
-0.0419612452,
0.023213204,
-0.0080055911,
0.0305508729,
0.0648791194,
-0.0158905294,
0.0048693065,
0.0124948537,
-0.0315730646,
-0.0244357157,
0.0182711743,
-0.0032467465,
-0.0370421447,
-0.005888511,
0.0197813772,
-0.0184040815,
-0.0184447952,
-0.057225965,
0.0381113626,
0.0316660702,
-0.0126386909,
0.0228159502,
0.058355093,
-0.0975939482,
0.0005536878,
-0.0188664589,
0.0114866067,
0.0277510714,
0.0050601629,
0.0004166902,
-0.0365870744,
0.0157916192,
0.0161833465,
0.0181797426,
-0.026031265,
0.0022421964,
-0.0011732655,
-0.0132062593,
-0.0271221455,
-0.0227988195,
-0.0438682847,
-0.0006197573,
-0.0198814645,
0.0008630774,
-0.067378059,
-0.0035956816,
0.003527574,
0.002682663,
-0.0228942297,
0.0172753334,
0.0183122419,
-0.0385736898,
0.0087786615,
0.0425819047,
0.015044787,
0.0494196638,
0.0121580977,
0.0150328642,
0.0358189866,
0.0008146386,
0.0510858148,
0.0525262654,
0.0203183834,
0.0225964095,
0.0156517699,
0.0148011073,
0.0567788221,
-0.0120498836,
-0.0010759442,
-0.0281420946,
0.028442286,
0.0519694909,
0.0164824352,
-0.0381025113,
-0.0067360327,
0.0357293263,
-0.0197477136,
0.0421905294,
-0.0268091802,
0.0289767068,
0.0038772442,
-0.0403917283,
0.0005632991,
-0.009618138,
0.0195605904,
-0.0292874053,
0.0268263873,
0.078548722,
0.0259182863,
-0.0281778406,
-0.0103676505,
0.0041436371,
0.0037474704,
-0.0676935986,
-0.0153304739,
0.0687242299,
0.0286598932,
-0.0217158627,
0.0085467463,
-0.0026367847,
-0.0277761519,
0.0363188498,
-0.0483999699,
0.0178571679,
0.0467095301,
0.0942907929,
-0.0413985178,
-0.0015478089,
-0.0011129313,
-0.034910012,
-0.0098548857,
-0.0091606732,
-0.0036198536,
-0.0154550234,
-0.0439574644,
-0.0597793423,
-0.0116478521,
0.0174864121,
0.042993784,
-0.0056967158,
0.0229824483,
0.0492184795,
-0.0804743394,
-0.0436700769,
-0.0007538493,
-0.0393055491,
-0.0708480626,
0.0527176522,
-0.0304267723,
0.009856618,
-0.0087965736,
-0.0253545232,
0.0416441783,
0.0389956981,
0.0114066424,
-0.0396746323,
-0.0162078142,
0.0346052274,
-0.0108986041,
0.020667702,
-0.0286884829,
0.0393986776,
0.0082082916,
-0.0422470607,
-0.0398132019,
0.0028464035,
-0.0215064771,
0.0062474539,
-0.0552670993,
0.0279670805,
0.024234768,
0.0043518054,
-0.0637245029,
0.0685946941,
-0.0092211263,
0.0306775365,
0.04822395,
-0.00755321,
-0.0162159484,
-0.0670864731,
0.0018993248,
-0.0015192293,
0.0065220422,
0.0328491367,
0.0677685365,
0.0194462501,
-0.0184741933,
-0.0075024669,
-0.0814872682,
0.0174152292,
-0.0142266387,
0.0030193888,
-0.0195701141,
0.0314773209,
-0.0192634519,
-0.0145113831,
-0.0393541045,
-0.0428869687,
0.0129165445,
0.0313185565,
-0.0084642256,
0.0015966708,
0.0150511144,
-0.0082546454,
-0.0271168072,
0.0281692799,
0.0442955568,
0.02726545,
0.0327923223,
-0.0483547747,
0.079102248,
-0.058062274,
-0.0120228697,
-0.0236194301,
0.0260241404,
-0.0277529266,
-0.0520404465,
0.0466352403,
0.0363302641,
0.0246765278,
-0.0125955548,
0.0532663949,
0.0081379516,
-0.06895978,
-0.0250511747,
-0.0631750599,
-0.0247362796,
0.0160836931,
-0.0481230654,
0.011862319,
-0.0166134089,
-0.0024784543,
-0.0224957541,
0.0022002289,
0.036413528,
0.0102112591,
-0.036211513,
-0.08036834,
-0.0029342442,
0.0157337878,
0.0484363772,
0.0082794176,
-0.0713549852,
0.0406225733,
-0.0055218912,
0.0472681932,
-0.0461888313,
0.0205774233,
-0.045262292,
-0.0083317971,
0.0169937871,
0.0247950498,
-0.0505532548,
0.0034479694,
-0.0445721895,
0.044174064,
0.0375528969,
-0.0471605062,
0.002038223,
-0.0251343362,
0.0332036652,
-0.0116025582,
-0.0445933342,
-0.0210641976,
-0.0245269369,
0.0321327969,
-0.0026114981,
-0.0064162253,
-0.016964335,
-0.0344821066,
0.0116210319,
0.0398251191,
0.0379874036,
-0.0576375462,
-0.0374738872,
0.0116449185,
0.0725340024,
0.0650980249,
-0.0614908747,
0.0314705893,
-0.0256821029,
-0.0070005544,
0.0464767404,
0.0877008364,
0.0022992485,
0.0145135941,
-0.0140725551,
0.0443654209,
-0.0134591032,
-0.0300115664,
0.0308205206,
-0.0514716655,
0.0053169825,
-0.0389250964,
0.0651766583,
0.0285660792,
-0.0455255136,
-0.0073536104,
-0.0463774092,
0.0487544574,
0.0085927583,
0.0590664707,
-0.0542977825,
0.0110315699,
0.002139566,
0.0785299465,
-0.0216658469,
-0.0227723625,
0.0065913633,
-0.1446509063,
0.0851462036,
0.0029160182,
0.0363590494,
0.0055288104,
-0.0522044264,
0.0007005691,
-0.0076804855,
-0.0157477893,
0.0476913378,
-0.0201650336,
0.0169763789,
0.03220658,
0.0308795925,
-0.0692777559,
-0.0398061052,
-0.0228132084,
-0.0175261963,
0.0481403358,
0.0055728871,
0.0085455561,
-0.0035629538,
0.0036389024,
-0.0153680174,
0.0130246757,
0.0020310951,
0.0011994417,
-0.0192080736,
0.0473238379,
-0.0168532655,
0.0254375171,
0.0032108075,
0.0135067338,
-0.0270622615,
0.0447097123,
-0.0700106546,
0.0190684292,
-0.0409013443,
-0.033230532,
0.0101555428,
0.0395560712,
-0.0067657153,
-0.0065131881,
-0.0216251835,
-0.0384818465,
0.0506025776,
-0.0240036808,
0.0335865282,
0.0220245682,
-0.0478535704,
-0.0574876219,
-0.0868896917,
0.0044555864,
-0.0130718956,
0.0385881439,
-0.003701177,
0.0381193273,
-0.0452344492,
-0.0262190867,
-0.0395088904,
-0.0233850293,
-0.0169157144,
-0.0064637777,
-0.0292636342,
0.0094435308,
0.0661361516,
-0.0708607808,
-0.0371159129,
-0.0240846574,
-0.0358777232,
-0.0617921054,
-0.0316970088,
0.0651905388,
0.0315232761,
0.0190526862,
-0.0120034115,
-0.0676763356,
0.0405989625,
0.0832169652,
0.0106041618,
0.024602633,
-0.0246938653,
0.0102179358,
-0.0350293405,
-0.0062965611,
-0.0899359807,
0.0072276145,
-0.0257629286,
0.037459787,
0.0069834515,
-0.0431075357,
-0.0052005528,
0.026186578,
0.0294365808,
-0.0553210191,
0.0281580761,
-0.0309804454,
0.0245965868,
-0.0394183025,
-0.010377341,
-0.0118999658,
0.0451850817,
0.0493960306,
0.0111939032,
0.0025156629,
0.0448435247,
-0.029046556,
0.0575686209,
-0.0681596249,
-0.053019084,
0.0159739275,
-0.0258061979,
0.0229994599,
-0.0354819037,
0.0076950677,
0.0307095144,
0.0298418198,
0.0544452257,
-0.0200449415,
0.02858009,
0.01947405,
-0.0083828792,
-0.0229814667,
0.0056630429,
-0.086105369,
-0.0480967462,
-0.0536699966,
-0.0180303399,
0.0435421765,
0.0159990583,
0.0586221069,
-0.033522822,
-0.0109248497,
-0.0294272993,
-0.0018439963,
0.059494786,
-0.0253387541,
0.0055674617,
0.0295777079,
0.00210857,
0.0683559105,
0.0968263,
0.0440033153,
0.0042571011,
-0.0419889614,
-0.0612484515,
-0.0060975263,
-0.021785982,
0.0317102447,
0.030070236,
-0.0004901118,
-0.0259862784,
-0.0454909652,
-0.0239085983,
0.0029945145,
0.0067695514,
0.0014885087,
-0.042474661,
0.0509977005,
0.0896228626,
-0.0245591886,
0.0296772663,
-0.0842435211,
-0.0186519492,
-0.0764108449,
-0.0320231654,
0.0194796957,
-6.217715655e-33,
0.0144177657,
-0.072315231,
-0.0145777222,
-0.0478424914,
0.00401452,
0.0051604151,
0.0082748719,
-0.0471625663,
0.0507552922,
-0.0288406778,
-0.0052894959,
0.0131661929,
0.0079673128,
0.0330538116,
0.0148359314,
0.0293979906,
0.019277215,
-0.0011371323,
-0.0559016913,
0.0499548763,
0.0613357872,
0.0315100737,
-0.0007684901,
-0.010953893,
-0.0169079546,
-0.0192334484,
-0.0162479375,
0.0052139885,
0.0289220735,
0.0617003217,
0.0048229932,
0.034671165,
0.0340067893,
-0.0478454977,
0.007203348,
-0.0127476342,
-0.0133997248,
-0.0080999862,
-0.024588747,
-0.0553478338,
0.0016265102,
-0.0020608818,
0.0006715757,
0.0147871245,
-0.0297115762,
-0.0013746877,
0.0402132608,
-0.006259582,
-0.0769766495,
-0.1112135202,
-0.0182259995,
0.02685716,
-0.0090810768,
-0.0030957577,
0.0036262826,
0.059318956,
-0.0065574748,
0.0572032593,
-0.0264587905,
0.0488151461,
-0.0079851281,
0.0529206395,
0.0681369752,
0.0323163234,
-0.0184230134,
0.0413559265,
0.0051740091,
-0.0087375641,
0.0099589126,
-0.0369011946,
-0.0027934203,
0.0221080109,
-0.0190458912,
0.055061426,
0.0346742496,
0.0273097958,
-0.0772409514,
0.1074787006,
0.0124618988,
0.0235446151,
0.0609482415,
0.0378404707,
-0.0461410135,
-0.045898445,
-0.031695541,
-0.0012502049,
-0.024331009,
-0.0116962781,
0.0351909809,
0.0404192358,
-0.0481506214,
-0.0254187323,
0.0605275705,
0.0055693523,
-0.0370010063,
0.0413406044,
-0.0188016482,
0.0013043174,
-0.0380241908,
0.0236033462,
-0.027214773,
-0.0075488985,
0.0429934151,
-0.0103732282,
-0.030944068,
0.0101570506,
0.0114635797,
0.0296759438,
-0.0337525643,
0.0107371984,
-0.0083064297,
0.0186048504,
-0.0112322615,
0.0436759815,
0.007750751,
0.0037380231,
0.0100961467,
0.0467288345,
0.0561904386,
0.0287510008,
0.0244645197,
-0.0393498205,
-0.0015001581,
-0.0260877889,
-0.0196188409,
0.0460055172,
0.0056450088,
0.0336667895,
0.0456247479,
-0.0521311425,
-0.029079318,
0.0310644768,
2.714e-7,
0.0456436127,
0.0293641072,
-0.0038445042,
0.0092105633,
0.0379611365,
0.0259618983,
0.0009261205,
0.0409536026,
0.0546395816,
0.00811351,
0.0309438612,
-0.0263424441,
0.0288165417,
-0.0039214962,
-0.0858567283,
-0.0196629334,
-0.087796919,
-0.0122143114,
-0.0489419289,
-0.0687718093,
0.0089505212,
0.0683138818,
-0.0488143116,
-0.0490298979,
-0.0032662083,
-0.0396956392,
0.0658786595,
0.0047747185,
-0.0374870449,
0.0237042177,
0.0752273574,
0.0021262995,
-0.0018271731,
-0.0325840265,
-0.0344462357,
0.0151269706,
0.0204017255,
0.0274587926,
-0.0025214416,
-0.0168236382,
0.0250380915,
0.0144671276,
0.0255730506,
-0.0580859035,
0.0539115742,
-0.0100644799,
-0.0046971058,
-0.0081230626,
-0.0518384166,
-0.0227359943,
0.0035640514,
-0.0566629842,
-0.0264905617,
0.0150806503,
-0.024594184,
0.03691395,
-0.0050733681,
-0.0401230268,
0.0051244325,
-0.0112866713,
-0.0275431611,
-0.0699916482,
-0.0066003208,
-0.010347289,
-0.0256238431,
-0.0885789022,
0.0091654016,
2.617427353e-34,
0.0610452816,
0.0000612694,
-0.0148214204,
-0.0113319801,
0.029328566,
0.0018421586,
-0.0503903888,
0.040588446,
0.0148908207,
-0.0885602981,
-0.0436349995
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13282v1 | Understanding the RoPE Extensions of Long-Context LLMs: An Attention Perspective | 2024-06-19T07:23:33 | 2024-06-19T07:23:33 | Meizhi Zhong, Chen Zhang, Yikun Lei, Xikai Liu, Yan Gao, Yao Hu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enabling LLMs to handle lengthy context is currently a research hotspot. Most
LLMs are built upon rotary position embedding (RoPE), a popular position
encoding method. Therefore, a prominent path is to extrapolate the RoPE trained
on comparably short texts to far longer texts. A heavy bunch of efforts have
been dedicated to boosting the extrapolation via extending the formulations of
the RoPE, however, few of them have attempted to showcase their inner workings
comprehensively. In this paper, we are driven to offer a straightforward yet
in-depth understanding of RoPE extensions from an attention perspective and on
two benchmarking tasks. A broad array of experiments reveals several valuable
findings: 1) Maintaining attention patterns to those at the pretrained length
improves extrapolation; 2) Large attention uncertainty leads to retrieval
errors; 3) Using longer continual pretraining lengths for RoPE extensions could
reduce attention uncertainty and significantly enhance extrapolation. | [
0.0255086832,
-0.0173537973,
0.0087862201,
0.0495724082,
-0.0092140529,
-0.0008149873,
-0.0230199881,
0.0211772453,
-0.0304896738,
-0.0292232614,
-0.0318005383,
-0.0122621255,
0.0218893159,
-0.0342966281,
0.0386692397,
-0.055755198,
0.0331988931,
-0.0089937057,
-0.0147835556,
0.0210052282,
-0.0055652559,
-0.0318777226,
0.0418554954,
0.0209771842,
-0.0079734186,
0.013915617,
-0.0588491932,
0.0356053598,
0.0650321916,
-0.0328689255,
-0.0106720114,
-0.0085732331,
0.0716193914,
0.0012094011,
0.0000017124,
-0.0232199542,
-0.0108119501,
-0.010614736,
-0.0056256582,
0.0030445054,
-0.0003909807,
-0.0248731468,
0.0328977294,
-0.0063304426,
-0.0112526538,
0.0140801091,
0.0203952268,
0.015227221,
0.0213021655,
0.0880046859,
-0.0164380707,
-0.0119971866,
0.0128247635,
-0.0655139163,
0.0895440578,
-0.0637838095,
0.0380431302,
-0.0020985238,
0.0279458035,
0.0795149431,
-0.0413780026,
0.025481455,
0.0545720905,
0.0313618071,
0.0037821068,
0.050919462,
0.0082359528,
0.0237190854,
-0.0204873569,
0.0625114143,
-0.044210434,
0.0016311439,
-0.0328664891,
0.0035344991,
0.0355358794,
-0.0131286616,
-0.0609076507,
0.0197979398,
0.0092089828,
-0.0019838545,
-0.0282326639,
0.0325124413,
0.0133751146,
-0.0151727051,
-0.0525088534,
0.0444797575,
-0.0223645605,
-0.0676567629,
-0.0243307743,
0.0081824055,
-0.0108457236,
-0.0156121794,
0.0540171713,
0.0709377602,
0.0326737389,
0.030779006,
-0.030629009,
0.0074870316,
0.0153819881,
-0.0315413922,
0.0317324996,
0.0571637526,
-0.0103439754,
0.0639115348,
-0.0583287403,
0.0597774871,
-0.044177901,
0.0303834137,
-0.0505970567,
0.0305950437,
-0.0039844862,
0.0059236526,
-0.0461361483,
0.0032714186,
-0.0186772663,
-0.0497650579,
-0.0011894918,
0.0523441136,
0.0472157933,
0.0227201749,
-0.0177769475,
0.0103686946,
-0.0351599082,
-0.0370249338,
-0.0115466025,
0.0206320584,
-0.0424974449,
0.0199452136,
0.0241067745,
0.0065188338,
-0.0491799861,
0.0307633467,
-0.0000797612,
-0.0331428312,
-0.0068931147,
0.0484319553,
0.0091174785,
-0.0483519062,
-0.02713174,
-0.0043069357,
-0.058944229,
-0.0399043635,
0.0329082459,
-0.0468200408,
0.0410247073,
0.0002024079,
0.0016188929,
0.0159751959,
0.0249135215,
0.036086306,
-0.0369843841,
0.0435285941,
0.0057509313,
-0.0100956019,
-0.0190720912,
0.0333811454,
0.0098209316,
0.0577716455,
0.0329783522,
0.079053767,
0.0273815431,
0.0398416929,
-0.0049685282,
0.0142908515,
0.003111026,
0.000732309,
-0.0123432195,
0.0209139399,
-0.0097898627,
0.0459378548,
0.0243244041,
0.0081747128,
-0.0509331934,
-0.0317301825,
0.04606013,
0.0850766897,
0.0502670109,
0.0006101472,
0.0455943011,
-0.0229936447,
-0.0109467115,
0.0438509621,
-0.063759163,
0.0488306917,
0.0326623991,
0.0400294177,
0.037826471,
0.0049507422,
-0.0202568173,
-0.0432169512,
-0.035001453,
-0.0032816879,
-0.0051084571,
-0.0218394697,
0.023726631,
-0.0193165187,
-0.038899865,
0.0443044044,
-0.0081519252,
-0.0269603375,
-0.009450376,
0.0016401387,
-0.0351849645,
0.0743503422,
0.0116505083,
-0.0575329475,
-0.0650253445,
-0.0265530273,
0.0207222328,
0.037169151,
-0.0079568848,
0.0225920789,
0.0162346102,
-0.0370701104,
-0.0622894242,
-0.0116215926,
-0.0116416682,
0.0223747231,
0.0531768985,
0.0431242101,
0.0387711339,
-0.0405718721,
0.0141886128,
0.0214357115,
-0.0307488181,
-0.0262364671,
-0.0473896638,
0.0149893053,
0.0064070444,
0.0194703527,
0.0238250308,
0.0100903213,
0.0729502589,
-0.037785504,
0.0354753211,
-0.0260068607,
-0.0955534354,
-0.0603632368,
0.0440580137,
-0.0533612743,
-0.0331916623,
0.0013839636,
-0.0252850987,
-0.0212816354,
-0.020487342,
-0.0331464,
0.0451439321,
-0.0000646826,
0.0098432973,
0.0267535057,
0.0105821909,
-0.0639648288,
0.0456381738,
-0.0402820073,
0.0348774828,
0.033966396,
0.0063477899,
-0.0027880352,
-0.0514396988,
-0.0217029974,
-0.0081368471,
0.0073737395,
0.0004789049,
-0.0101228366,
-0.006623629,
-0.0567290746,
-0.0559000932,
-0.0570511594,
-0.0064904764,
-0.0357334502,
0.0221345332,
0.0139426123,
-0.0131099075,
-0.0220776591,
-0.0312300045,
-0.0328559987,
0.0086818952,
-0.0542788655,
0.0180856679,
0.0230757166,
0.0015523197,
-0.0077253203,
-0.0332923904,
-0.0111558102,
0.0058193919,
0.0611345358,
-0.0079918858,
-0.0456728935,
-0.0935280472,
0.0398143306,
-0.0200211089,
-0.0165221579,
-0.036379993,
-0.017794691,
0.0133118611,
-0.0573483519,
0.0441743843,
0.0917874351,
-0.0011079916,
0.0225438941,
0.0613434538,
0.0109179914,
-0.0627241731,
0.0393468663,
-0.0530097112,
0.0006524225,
-0.0610729083,
0.0099506211,
-0.005527765,
0.021816479,
-0.0362707749,
0.0091969799,
-0.0361452512,
-0.0212940555,
0.0520009436,
-0.0108809825,
-0.008250352,
0.0157237109,
-0.0406109765,
0.0265271012,
-0.0323318541,
-0.0561201386,
0.0361841843,
-0.0132009033,
-0.0237215068,
0.0050703548,
0.0055697164,
-0.0460800529,
0.0651223734,
0.0309718382,
0.006370564,
-0.0420161821,
-0.0172938555,
-0.0343002863,
0.0385263562,
-0.0362851322,
-0.0142998183,
0.0594602711,
0.040909864,
-0.0003120725,
-0.032349661,
-0.018349532,
-0.0450432189,
-0.004765695,
0.0106025459,
-0.0217074901,
-0.0013620177,
-0.0234815832,
-0.0236219838,
0.006995128,
0.0471678488,
0.0310553238,
-0.0153250908,
-0.0034013027,
-0.0457516946,
0.0299558435,
-0.0044819727,
0.0326033048,
-0.0031025277,
-0.0418563485,
-0.0088580111,
0.0649539828,
-0.0179172643,
-0.0296132229,
-0.0240763295,
0.0111254212,
0.0201706029,
-0.0425498784,
0.0069797607,
0.0182911437,
0.0322751217,
-0.0707678571,
-0.025063917,
0.0788773075,
0.03029898,
-0.0748519227,
-0.0193456747,
-0.0259235352,
0.0579076484,
0.0310724732,
0.0376152359,
-0.0473865457,
-0.0072000395,
0.0185842533,
-0.0043039829,
0.0568566211,
0.0035630704,
-0.0255036596,
-0.0883405134,
0.0142987734,
0.0276779272,
-0.0285819229,
-0.0489091575,
-0.0152105931,
0.0041450961,
0.0706529468,
0.0117245754,
0.0467106812,
-0.029454682,
-0.0121962884,
0.0013657103,
-0.0398490801,
-0.0143504869,
-0.0247291066,
-0.0182944946,
-0.0149564678,
0.0284944419,
0.0118145561,
0.0080512408,
-0.0438372046,
0.0277226083,
-0.0064451187,
0.0387003794,
0.000144251,
0.0489650331,
-0.0386935025,
0.0053836405,
0.0149244694,
-0.0149620473,
-0.0321497582,
-0.0187440161,
-0.005133843,
0.0934609398,
-0.0194817111,
0.0277292747,
-0.0203644037,
0.0099710459,
-0.0255766958,
0.0520918369,
0.0604270175,
-0.0136624621,
-0.0335129239,
-0.0499376357,
-0.0095338505,
-0.0230384301,
-0.0217567626,
0.028495457,
-0.0135282623,
0.0253150929,
-0.0438383445,
-0.0696544498,
0.0158032123,
0.0512788482,
-0.0041550505,
0.0137266861,
-0.0279233698,
-0.0291476436,
-0.0607493334,
0.0169462077,
-0.0103154061,
0.0105384262,
-0.0121621275,
0.0625490174,
0.0150547968,
-0.0235392805,
0.0194581244,
-0.0262217075,
-0.0968617946,
-0.0551353097,
-0.0043683928,
0.0417288467,
0.0219373871,
0.0891472399,
-0.0000142603,
0.0066975462,
0.0490387194,
0.0194198191,
-0.0158180892,
0.0568353459,
0.0482265577,
0.0757456943,
0.0151325529,
0.0237483419,
-0.0634628609,
-0.0105357394,
0.0030185631,
0.017722277,
-0.0505449697,
-0.0639937967,
-0.0086157545,
-0.0238877106,
0.042739667,
-0.0007701297,
0.0025946361,
0.0199308638,
0.0627662539,
-0.0310255084,
0.0051923338,
-0.0333814844,
-0.0224049035,
0.0254103336,
-0.0260662641,
0.01918214,
0.0349931531,
0.0197373107,
0.0032619231,
-0.0299419891,
0.036378257,
-0.017941175,
-0.0147868749,
0.0098349117,
0.0452702902,
-0.0516148508,
-0.0111388816,
-0.0219235476,
0.0599028133,
0.0060837017,
0.0248396453,
0.0187773407,
-0.021212291,
-0.0433001369,
0.0421999246,
-0.1198203191,
-0.021496946,
-0.0048850742,
0.0157625731,
0.0459802374,
-0.0168641284,
0.0327924229,
0.0154807409,
-0.0129628545,
-0.0000033977,
0.0092482399,
-0.0277538057,
-0.0090310676,
0.0208814647,
0.0205279253,
0.0042242007,
0.0189157333,
0.0284775663,
0.015419797,
-0.0008089885,
0.0249202885,
-0.0103399521,
-0.0172000248,
-0.0319031216,
0.0402914248,
0.0206530765,
0.0076354267,
-0.0202354956,
-0.0213648956,
-0.0469529778,
0.0422212295,
-0.0002152433,
-0.0315608121,
-0.0085015595,
0.0213810634,
0.0285640098,
-0.0148255704,
0.0112688923,
0.0058303243,
-0.024740601,
0.0105924755,
-0.0380267501,
-0.004120301,
-5.56650354e-33,
-0.0293089133,
-0.0346809067,
0.0335326642,
-0.0334327891,
-0.0742514431,
0.027870696,
-0.0113622388,
-0.0118871257,
0.0090260478,
-0.0060954988,
-0.0235865433,
-0.0086672753,
0.0216035675,
0.0073880563,
-0.0337125435,
-0.0202414691,
-0.0013209941,
0.0247858223,
0.0105221448,
-0.017544914,
0.0462449454,
0.0604546592,
0.0697520971,
-0.040236827,
0.0399271213,
0.0153555879,
0.0012665302,
0.0080192098,
-0.0035017212,
0.0665182099,
-0.0299347918,
-0.0163646135,
0.0222572312,
-0.0301799458,
-0.0555918328,
0.051792793,
-0.0732694194,
-0.0491882861,
-0.0223838799,
0.0094591416,
-0.0500156544,
-0.0392403938,
0.0879937932,
-0.0088010542,
-0.0008205494,
-0.0456374288,
0.0248092338,
-0.0396094583,
-0.072978735,
0.0067134011,
-0.0209460072,
-0.0034571234,
0.023009859,
0.0033400585,
0.0304151122,
0.0482719094,
0.0189885534,
0.0443413556,
-0.0645037889,
-0.0203012116,
-0.0117123043,
0.06729009,
0.023100527,
0.0222034976,
0.0003442703,
0.0460609235,
-0.0004175902,
-0.0065102926,
-0.0482717417,
-0.0570045374,
-0.0034984329,
0.0479277074,
0.0337975249,
-0.0001785908,
0.0525180735,
0.0326895975,
-0.0625436679,
0.0053658448,
-0.0294469576,
0.0714440346,
0.017901333,
0.0294919573,
-0.0412021354,
-0.0097053479,
0.0056934673,
0.0085940612,
-0.0096845692,
-0.0499320179,
0.0482532717,
0.0542783067,
0.0177917406,
0.0052821012,
0.0676344857,
-0.0225641131,
0.0150719509,
0.002186524,
-0.003328999,
0.0398649722,
0.0207187571,
0.0165831447,
-0.0324531272,
-0.0014672435,
0.0082436809,
-0.0003384015,
-0.0043557202,
-0.0279665329,
0.0626578405,
0.0051027378,
-0.0692215562,
-0.0186934639,
-0.0422191583,
-0.0263041705,
-0.007966713,
-0.0081912028,
0.0641469434,
-0.0310979318,
-0.0082814386,
0.1110869721,
0.0118547101,
-0.0151483025,
0.0108792726,
-0.0321214758,
0.0157365147,
0.040281903,
-0.0152004836,
0.0064519523,
-0.0222297292,
0.0360503308,
0.0046254061,
-0.0686405227,
-0.0000899422,
0.0336469747,
2.536e-7,
0.0508049242,
0.021874046,
0.086436145,
0.006718141,
0.0364467464,
-0.0174099021,
-0.0258518886,
0.0361384228,
-0.0061067287,
-0.0312448591,
0.0214361995,
0.0596799664,
0.0215719901,
-0.0055866786,
-0.0949948281,
-0.0376047269,
-0.0383917019,
-0.0110469619,
-0.0255807973,
-0.0172030553,
0.0574720018,
0.083265081,
-0.0068438272,
0.0432638638,
-0.0035844736,
-0.0713745654,
0.0787498578,
-0.0622728132,
0.0141119491,
-0.0213844981,
0.0322311819,
0.0163937267,
-0.0280161612,
-0.0491967015,
0.0087419124,
0.0281127412,
0.0066298773,
0.0792341828,
-0.0030286668,
-0.0410248153,
-0.0013368404,
-0.0085171917,
0.0006783193,
-0.0334058106,
0.0390901528,
-0.0766776428,
0.0198482331,
0.0075034024,
-0.033566501,
0.001696915,
0.0081470134,
0.0251337271,
0.0295577701,
-0.023158757,
0.0035338644,
-0.0026639192,
-0.0217145104,
-0.1418691427,
-0.0455603413,
0.0094506508,
-0.0757468939,
-0.0090812994,
-0.0586115867,
0.0092396317,
0.056300845,
-0.0644732714,
-0.0614773929,
2.360431227e-34,
0.0103333825,
-0.0365463533,
0.0237527639,
0.0534376092,
-0.0085989172,
-0.0315348208,
0.0022777382,
0.0020789239,
0.0594139919,
-0.0745555311,
-0.0324312262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13274v1 | In-Context Learning on a Budget: A Case Study in Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | Uri Berger, Tal Baumel, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few shot in-context learning (ICL) typically assumes access to large
annotated training sets. However, in many real world scenarios, such as domain
adaptation, there is only a limited budget to annotate a small number of
samples, with the goal of maximizing downstream performance. We study various
methods for selecting samples to annotate within a predefined budget,
specifically focusing on the named entity recognition (NER) task, which has
real-world applications, is expensive to annotate, and is relatively less
studied in ICL setups. Across different models and datasets, we find that a
relatively small pool of annotated samples can achieve results comparable to
using the entire training set. Moreover, we discover that random selection of
samples for annotation yields surprisingly good performance. Finally, we
observe that a diverse annotation pool is correlated with improved performance.
We hope that future work adopts our realistic paradigm which takes annotation
budget into account. | [
0.0090245577,
0.0141004249,
0.0129263848,
0.0105826324,
-0.0088640563,
0.0606844462,
0.0597032271,
0.0127063422,
-0.0112796556,
-0.054116834,
-0.0315443724,
0.0067338194,
-0.0163545534,
-0.0448669344,
0.0168755259,
-0.0486403741,
0.0089063207,
-0.0177467037,
0.0092149116,
0.0327433087,
-0.0270522144,
-0.0183765162,
-0.0183541663,
0.0180543922,
0.0134253353,
-0.0051851892,
-0.0078943148,
0.0409765393,
0.0438260883,
-0.0707753748,
-0.0094396239,
0.0353623815,
0.0083724232,
0.0239495132,
0.0000019516,
-0.0742091388,
-0.0533667542,
0.0268835481,
-0.0620643049,
0.0003291824,
0.0434228368,
0.0000343335,
0.0173535347,
0.0024113117,
-0.0130625069,
-0.034114372,
0.0619958043,
0.0358461179,
0.0081185149,
0.0691481605,
-0.0112653421,
-0.0026398355,
-0.0270291008,
-0.066097334,
-0.0090161888,
-0.0831798613,
0.0318166316,
-0.030417027,
-0.0057127737,
0.0028952265,
-0.0263346601,
-0.0082834903,
-0.0083682192,
0.008731625,
0.0476303995,
0.0541448556,
-0.0589871407,
0.0221068244,
0.0100310268,
0.052228719,
-0.0144706443,
0.0102893077,
0.016849272,
-0.0494438708,
0.0177341383,
-0.0345110372,
-0.0438226275,
-0.0203668587,
-0.0217742492,
0.0067087179,
-0.0235692114,
0.0359366089,
0.0293754078,
0.0005107777,
0.008565289,
-0.0404425636,
-0.0164825059,
-0.0107173333,
0.0126259839,
0.0473338328,
-0.0609039739,
-0.0486798026,
-0.0513026528,
-0.0049324799,
-0.0007071582,
0.0308716558,
-0.0670425817,
-0.0094675366,
-0.0088130366,
-0.024985075,
0.0507358238,
0.0075946678,
0.0240697525,
0.0833468437,
-0.0107234754,
-0.0311778393,
-0.0099867424,
0.0042594341,
-0.0023367987,
-0.0117005892,
-0.0811517835,
0.0381650589,
-0.0567217134,
0.0396771766,
-0.0277710613,
0.0072268024,
-0.0528447665,
0.0148299476,
-0.008398247,
-0.0074246014,
-0.0228724312,
-0.0212002695,
-0.0214978456,
0.0307021011,
0.0295725092,
0.0215444751,
-0.0081017176,
0.0109624593,
0.0206463039,
-0.0612668917,
-0.020797072,
-0.0077225664,
0.0274071172,
-0.0610225275,
0.020491505,
0.0740338713,
0.0372920968,
-0.1173695624,
-0.0607182235,
0.0102828899,
0.0024606057,
-0.0315842517,
0.0033782811,
-0.0307978448,
0.008577792,
0.0107631898,
0.0307391733,
-0.0446882807,
-0.0051097963,
-0.0010853773,
-0.0380159579,
0.068004258,
-0.0127741741,
-0.0419189595,
0.0226382483,
-0.0198953878,
-0.0046766228,
0.0849529058,
0.0319814458,
-0.0203987025,
0.0296313819,
0.0101437876,
0.0005324266,
0.0242031552,
0.0424617641,
0.0126440004,
0.0189968608,
0.0183030963,
0.0043746652,
0.0038242713,
0.0373360552,
-0.0363664553,
-0.0389156006,
-0.0073802234,
0.0248485673,
0.0434638374,
0.0265641455,
-0.0493402779,
-0.0068529849,
-0.0107118385,
0.003837802,
-0.0537006706,
-0.0404744111,
0.0755856484,
-0.0053188107,
-0.006944234,
0.0253340527,
-0.0016166205,
-0.040902283,
-0.0161976814,
-0.0097916089,
0.0110759335,
-0.0379815884,
0.019923117,
0.072541602,
0.0180911515,
-0.0079041068,
0.0341199823,
0.0507863946,
0.0173684377,
-0.0228076912,
-0.0050134938,
-0.0108595341,
0.0399171114,
0.0126433782,
-0.0388940312,
-0.0201814007,
-0.0689611211,
0.05199847,
0.0434367098,
0.0208451841,
-0.0180701092,
0.0479122736,
-0.0294822454,
-0.0342903957,
0.0020983159,
0.0231673587,
0.0200926457,
0.0272995047,
0.0238967836,
-0.0078966692,
-0.0477638729,
-0.016238166,
0.0477670804,
-0.0401405282,
-0.0529751554,
0.029672727,
0.0291660633,
0.0593405105,
0.0142305354,
-0.0283636022,
-0.026093794,
-0.0118130222,
-0.0378898084,
0.0072949836,
-0.0160151981,
0.0087058619,
-0.0486186258,
-0.0109385094,
-0.0322847217,
0.0024176808,
-0.0367061123,
-0.0629132837,
-0.0268941782,
-0.0172374304,
-0.0334786996,
0.0318009295,
-0.0228487439,
-0.021877544,
-0.0029458841,
0.0190406181,
-0.0586318858,
0.0560376458,
0.0110252565,
-0.0146535188,
0.0198179595,
0.0254141428,
0.0050832862,
-0.0490917079,
-0.0200711377,
-0.0364715569,
0.0043139034,
-0.0193906762,
0.0129468041,
0.0062607815,
-0.037750341,
0.0281544402,
-0.0721101686,
-0.0080403863,
-0.0218106098,
0.0235727299,
-0.0074331495,
0.0254106484,
-0.0134486593,
-0.050628908,
0.0234742351,
0.0019324381,
-0.0552681535,
0.050654009,
0.0323816612,
0.0151086142,
0.0141355516,
-0.0014751499,
-0.0061473465,
0.0046203081,
0.0581788681,
0.0307198763,
-0.0743979961,
-0.0543885827,
0.0368355736,
0.0091590071,
0.0012186999,
0.0042374311,
0.0492666177,
-0.0132916104,
0.035361141,
-0.0481713489,
0.0605172813,
-0.0171620641,
0.0306019969,
-0.0009460723,
0.0349545367,
-0.0368357189,
0.0265444126,
0.0034182402,
0.0189604834,
-0.0155300619,
-0.0020728873,
0.0177846942,
0.0514606498,
-0.0568433441,
0.0089799231,
-0.051598262,
0.0407994911,
-0.0241719969,
-0.0226695742,
-0.0463582128,
0.0402791053,
-0.0019765429,
0.0400952846,
-0.0103254039,
-0.0163714942,
0.0458980389,
0.0189171471,
0.0021653976,
-0.0402632281,
0.0004631628,
-0.0338287763,
0.0261542518,
-0.0061976891,
-0.0011202155,
0.0455380008,
-0.0169252213,
-0.0207255594,
0.0229976568,
0.0420780592,
0.0136964722,
0.0591139346,
0.0085397977,
0.0641255975,
-0.0504148118,
-0.0518183894,
-0.0278826132,
-0.0339199044,
-0.0615822785,
0.00469566,
-0.03897921,
0.0072742049,
-0.0277540218,
0.0178259127,
0.005975653,
0.0991294384,
0.0175284538,
-0.0328723751,
-0.0082406094,
0.0317452922,
0.0096499287,
0.004494437,
0.0184617061,
-0.0154820476,
0.0187829416,
0.0365892462,
0.0222970378,
-0.0034959305,
-0.0150059201,
0.0095714359,
0.0031019072,
-0.0409912691,
-0.0063872901,
0.0198926851,
0.0407948419,
-0.0235193949,
-0.0510171056,
0.0746337622,
-0.0079604993,
-0.0517414883,
-0.0099134054,
0.019479217,
0.0046314811,
0.0409667939,
0.0237091389,
-0.0809273124,
-0.0672851726,
0.0174676273,
0.0388820618,
0.0063448893,
-0.0745604113,
-0.0070258421,
-0.1352405101,
0.0507336557,
-0.0169084463,
-0.0896933153,
0.0261685941,
-0.0730843022,
0.0328395404,
-0.0634531453,
-0.0067081996,
-0.0166886337,
-0.0139555009,
-0.0043513509,
0.0545130447,
0.0254669748,
-0.0774054229,
-0.0045672213,
-0.0410457924,
0.0366861336,
0.0519976951,
-0.0022983227,
-0.0021020384,
0.0184945073,
0.0414119549,
-0.0360495634,
0.0169704519,
-0.0217310041,
0.1099248156,
-0.0022125104,
-0.0347696058,
0.0199793968,
0.0164840966,
-0.0310794879,
-0.0312070958,
0.0317108929,
0.0348358564,
-0.012265373,
0.047075171,
-0.0127127022,
-0.050341513,
0.0295696929,
0.0617121346,
0.0214300565,
-0.0583396666,
-0.0049559874,
0.0218811687,
-0.0269660559,
-0.0586900935,
0.0241719764,
0.0083578108,
-0.0459236465,
-0.0518510714,
-0.052153863,
-0.0331156552,
0.033862114,
0.097696431,
-0.0156943761,
0.0041635782,
0.0030367081,
0.0466722958,
-0.0580572858,
0.018326601,
-0.0551196933,
-0.002126788,
-0.0197415724,
-0.0161787365,
0.0295468625,
-0.0170441102,
-0.0532184727,
0.0121315662,
-0.0844962895,
-0.044023037,
0.0072569768,
0.0382888168,
0.0212066285,
0.076342456,
0.0001161528,
-0.0153274378,
0.0605740882,
0.0573621616,
0.0099209398,
0.030216882,
0.0271371659,
0.0102978786,
-0.0415083729,
0.0196557213,
-0.0453803502,
0.0255841035,
0.0664924085,
0.0005982856,
-0.046738781,
0.014173775,
-0.0106904423,
-0.0169964805,
0.0560767986,
-0.0269766916,
-0.0357010812,
-0.0107147545,
0.0374721251,
0.0440447107,
0.0078694746,
-0.0243115574,
-0.0439751334,
-0.0062249172,
-0.0111475885,
-0.0275156125,
0.0532752946,
0.0204907972,
0.0401060171,
-0.0366114937,
-0.0101039577,
0.0363257155,
0.0183467735,
-0.0056346036,
-0.000666367,
-0.0080324654,
0.0421026535,
0.041608192,
0.0462219752,
-0.0244872551,
0.0121770967,
0.0316356868,
0.0531237908,
-0.013706618,
0.0005596138,
-0.0574161075,
0.0449656583,
-0.0400432348,
0.0643209219,
0.0448435061,
-0.0358404629,
0.0425068103,
-0.0177127495,
-0.0074900626,
-0.0138483141,
0.0005637911,
-0.0010600295,
-0.0133360727,
-0.0062041329,
0.0355207324,
-0.0014404303,
0.0156300496,
0.0801915154,
0.0188386478,
0.0402888171,
0.0057668653,
0.0232599694,
-0.053714294,
0.0054482887,
-0.0026415752,
0.0280577093,
0.0080287643,
0.0248137936,
-0.0551052056,
-0.0293570608,
0.0299545843,
-0.0659891143,
-0.0135918325,
0.0238570385,
0.0290723834,
0.0041787471,
0.0049629635,
-0.0209175944,
-0.0051032188,
-0.0157913528,
0.0042653284,
-0.0118201077,
0.0033062971,
-5.933492876e-33,
-0.0390448906,
-0.0061012986,
0.009417207,
0.0198689308,
0.0356120877,
0.0053429315,
-0.0166134052,
-0.0080710901,
-0.0065197321,
-0.0272884928,
-0.0250285715,
-0.0095456289,
0.0393016376,
0.029901363,
0.0222581513,
-0.0365228504,
0.0765927434,
0.0035994891,
-0.0227087867,
0.0251968857,
0.0326271169,
0.0376425944,
0.0564135201,
-0.0619039647,
-0.0041112523,
0.0153845353,
-0.0132928286,
-0.0094177267,
0.0537959039,
0.0490195006,
0.0003396715,
0.0029895871,
0.0190600604,
-0.0796307474,
-0.0175291989,
-0.0184410997,
-0.1336181015,
-0.0084053362,
-0.0423777662,
0.0468403213,
0.0148535566,
-0.0336812623,
0.01957158,
-0.00896315,
0.013737171,
-0.02781149,
0.0347070843,
-0.0498675071,
-0.0305338763,
-0.0453636795,
-0.0523402691,
0.0506543703,
0.002291976,
0.027714977,
0.0168473572,
-0.0072178924,
0.0019693719,
0.0252206307,
-0.0646164864,
-0.0260874722,
-0.0001527961,
0.0065745534,
0.0094278138,
0.0385497101,
-0.0000062841,
0.0530364811,
0.0358128957,
0.0174851865,
0.0352343172,
-0.0369641706,
0.0234217383,
0.0055051614,
-0.0045809611,
0.1043142602,
0.0770187229,
-0.0060465639,
-0.1113960445,
0.0042776428,
0.0103410129,
-0.0036191535,
0.0268806629,
0.0036670426,
-0.0529635996,
-0.0017296766,
-0.0085625714,
-0.0484810174,
-0.027819328,
0.001049535,
0.0383338816,
0.049211923,
-0.0539046191,
0.0575089194,
0.0521046817,
-0.0153275877,
-0.051099129,
0.0069976561,
0.0504565127,
0.019143004,
0.006214858,
-0.0304828323,
-0.0457506068,
-0.0306946374,
0.0023220247,
0.0207804181,
0.0385106988,
-0.0420791544,
0.1237753108,
0.0015216365,
-0.0767179579,
-0.0254300181,
-0.0138030266,
0.0579406619,
-0.0057142675,
0.0488797985,
0.0258530732,
0.004834882,
-0.0181126241,
0.0271829851,
0.0336338766,
-0.0525294282,
0.0225033425,
0.0168606024,
-0.0173336249,
-0.0103124725,
-0.0125252586,
-0.0113979848,
0.034855783,
0.0088508977,
0.0250415839,
-0.067302227,
-0.0091718556,
0.0012934285,
2.653e-7,
0.0048123184,
0.0293847676,
-0.0035033943,
-0.0529642142,
0.0294481274,
0.0273822974,
-0.0070568398,
0.0385931693,
-0.0063933884,
-0.0030786414,
-0.0000255473,
-0.0223915428,
0.0244376902,
0.0297958218,
-0.0836935192,
-0.0037671183,
-0.0125241363,
0.0340775177,
-0.0168942064,
-0.0079823043,
-0.0452511944,
0.0910743997,
0.0418239348,
-0.0348701775,
0.0157037675,
-0.058061868,
0.0549020395,
-0.0307016131,
0.0450840667,
-0.0130990809,
-0.0260158312,
0.0868288353,
-0.010281329,
0.0526618659,
-0.0239932239,
0.0304047372,
0.0161519572,
0.0473129898,
-0.0136025324,
-0.0007504824,
-0.0237721801,
0.0258675851,
0.0196072217,
0.0062691285,
0.0576334931,
-0.102082096,
-0.0156966224,
-0.0512679182,
-0.0071855737,
-0.0195013564,
0.0102716759,
0.04878534,
0.0245688409,
0.0144074205,
0.0145692034,
-0.0096292077,
-0.0246160179,
-0.0583553426,
0.0204249173,
0.0210557934,
-0.0032315082,
-0.0251722466,
-0.0296476688,
0.0140162883,
0.0352158323,
-0.046632871,
-0.0237920582,
2.121201826e-34,
0.002034459,
-0.004969113,
0.0060640192,
0.0395679548,
-0.0708562285,
-0.0021003033,
-0.0388419926,
-0.0353062451,
0.0401830934,
-0.0482154451,
0.0287968963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13275v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13275v2 | Enhancing Automated Audio Captioning via Large Language Models with Optimized Audio Encoding | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | 2024-06-25T08:07:36 | Jizhong Liu, Gang Li, Junbo Zhang, Heinrich Dinkel, Yongqing Wang, Zhiyong Yan, Yujun Wang, Bin Wang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Automated audio captioning (AAC) is an audio-to-text task to describe audio
contents in natural language. Recently, the advancements in large language
models (LLMs), with improvements in training approaches for audio encoders,
have opened up possibilities for improving AAC. Thus, we explore enhancing AAC
from three aspects: 1) a pre-trained audio encoder via consistent ensemble
distillation (CED) is used to improve the effectivity of acoustic tokens, with
a querying transformer (Q-Former) bridging the modality gap to LLM and compress
acoustic tokens; 2) we investigate the advantages of using a Llama 2 with 7B
parameters as the decoder; 3) another pre-trained LLM corrects text errors
caused by insufficient training data and annotation ambiguities. Both the audio
encoder and text decoder are optimized by low-rank adaptation (LoRA).
Experiments show that each of these enhancements is effective. Our method
obtains a 33.0 SPIDEr-FL score, outperforming the winner of DCASE 2023 Task 6A. | [
0.0059948619,
0.0696921721,
-0.0078595057,
0.0211810768,
0.0385919474,
0.0011724499,
0.0052681142,
-0.0312912129,
-0.0710790679,
-0.0472388268,
-0.0525941737,
-0.0022943129,
0.0100409035,
0.0291879568,
0.0085055586,
-0.0574841239,
0.0168065224,
-0.0871622264,
0.0103650587,
-0.0305561163,
-0.0335002877,
0.0038728868,
-0.0248484462,
0.0316753127,
0.0295150038,
0.0209867191,
-0.0009275971,
0.0278562829,
-0.0035816818,
-0.03694297,
-0.0444909893,
0.0499947481,
0.0847492442,
0.0092231007,
0.0000018575,
-0.0353403166,
-0.0054952744,
0.0029236835,
-0.0219327863,
0.01026244,
0.0133252274,
-0.0117480429,
-0.0057836948,
0.050658837,
0.0242519993,
-0.0410858616,
0.0567243099,
0.0303718038,
0.0727230906,
0.0587758161,
0.0002151126,
-0.0784472972,
0.0220975466,
-0.0315629914,
-0.0154617839,
-0.0345357619,
0.0098817665,
0.0478608161,
0.0195665266,
0.0085338326,
-0.0356135294,
0.046335794,
-0.0241232477,
-0.0161427092,
0.0176858772,
0.0340497121,
-0.0558434948,
-0.0339551046,
-0.0107408082,
0.0949297175,
0.0450435802,
0.0046892148,
-0.030396251,
0.044152353,
-0.0212050863,
-0.0410058461,
-0.0627057403,
0.0407523252,
0.0498367362,
0.0189158097,
-0.015939815,
0.0521836951,
0.0367874093,
-0.0104824957,
-0.024594998,
-0.0062193326,
0.0112149594,
-0.0159552209,
0.0051546055,
-0.0277603436,
-0.0437193029,
-0.0257653799,
0.0360661969,
0.0118245305,
-0.0188536029,
-0.0168646704,
-0.0219891891,
-0.0413539819,
-0.0227698628,
0.0047893072,
0.0135453576,
0.0412350222,
-0.0470872484,
0.0540378727,
-0.0140295476,
0.0649484843,
0.0177339334,
0.0145974876,
-0.0443560891,
-0.0094493125,
-0.0376996771,
-0.0004733526,
-0.0429516733,
0.0397393107,
-0.0479149632,
-0.0333201997,
-0.0262807608,
-0.0223570541,
-0.016949892,
0.0239686724,
0.0174872577,
0.0160314441,
-0.0395265184,
-0.0022158914,
0.0034343218,
0.0502669364,
0.0119339032,
0.0662009791,
-0.0259241983,
-0.0288339723,
-0.0275615267,
0.020056095,
0.0353860036,
-0.0085996361,
0.0311927311,
0.0616199337,
-0.0168342292,
-0.0312115736,
0.0228466485,
0.0329975449,
-0.0389609672,
-0.0346132554,
-0.0277066659,
-0.0480696522,
0.0741477013,
-0.0063358047,
0.0127794929,
-0.026614666,
0.0123086357,
0.0078911018,
0.0253460556,
0.0913739726,
-0.0029326789,
0.0460402519,
0.0474079661,
0.0104807764,
0.0085511087,
0.0826119632,
0.0831457749,
0.024129618,
0.0167829357,
-0.0484279022,
0.0017254491,
0.0380579159,
-0.00749875,
0.0113089783,
-0.0172408931,
-0.0157259144,
-0.011732663,
0.0302740708,
0.0724522918,
0.0696917623,
-0.0154433036,
-0.002393763,
0.0719423518,
0.0227307472,
0.0096034659,
0.0185422078,
0.0082269525,
-0.0023122055,
-0.0002811613,
-0.0232787915,
-0.0163368378,
0.0476991683,
0.0292372629,
0.013394556,
0.0696892142,
0.0450039692,
-0.008633214,
-0.0198246688,
-0.0148545718,
-0.0180786736,
-0.0222631358,
0.025498569,
0.0159125477,
0.0042973594,
-0.0591838881,
0.0553557314,
0.0011260511,
-0.0574530065,
0.0296017472,
-0.0538412556,
0.011592933,
0.0385512151,
0.0375683345,
-0.0269287564,
-0.0022991041,
-0.0618778877,
-0.0045255735,
0.0334193185,
0.0033412795,
-0.0178391412,
0.0278437044,
-0.0507009104,
-0.0222692154,
-0.0099492874,
0.0001739605,
0.012341015,
-0.0215386935,
0.0237182789,
0.0255108457,
-0.0569720119,
-0.0333185047,
-0.0087327464,
0.0359113142,
-0.0634340793,
0.0264845695,
0.0131340474,
0.0482011437,
0.0435629822,
-0.0473568365,
0.000366539,
0.0394134708,
-0.0556376502,
-0.0279440377,
0.0323081575,
-0.0747307837,
-0.0568040535,
0.0310836043,
-0.0239912271,
0.0358763337,
0.031973999,
-0.01845726,
-0.0685590729,
0.0135202277,
-0.040119715,
0.0148222223,
-0.0257210806,
0.0352820307,
-0.0064181802,
0.0314899944,
0.0052668187,
0.0158187747,
0.026768947,
-0.0518689677,
0.0157490112,
-0.008338334,
-0.0135457655,
-0.0251416042,
-0.053458795,
0.0750934556,
0.0110833142,
0.0245079063,
-0.0004629216,
-0.0060558873,
-0.0069582984,
-0.0364693888,
-0.0747430995,
0.0207922459,
-0.0287122577,
0.0139008928,
0.0119367586,
0.0027043957,
0.0147025203,
-0.0096367728,
-0.0114757977,
-0.0654060915,
0.0050364537,
-0.0015007395,
-0.0304973908,
0.0221983381,
-0.0639640912,
-0.0130945025,
0.0145523986,
0.0255765636,
0.005227258,
-0.0341025926,
-0.0158742033,
-0.0204916615,
0.0225673355,
0.0040511475,
-0.0040541338,
-0.0122064864,
-0.0125504173,
-0.04331306,
0.0170951784,
0.0176286325,
0.0111466432,
-0.000675599,
0.0361758955,
0.0802040845,
0.0187593736,
-0.023276452,
0.0263740644,
0.0093439436,
-0.0394851379,
-0.0313413143,
-0.0151318526,
-0.0158943925,
0.0463008545,
0.0261354297,
0.0193410404,
-0.0383616015,
-0.022994874,
-0.0336419158,
-0.0374771655,
-0.047914885,
-0.0641821772,
-0.0327473767,
0.0159854684,
-0.0176157393,
-0.0347155854,
0.0502495952,
-0.0679753944,
-0.0606089979,
-0.0673272982,
-0.0287525728,
-0.0401853137,
0.0524819046,
-0.0306415297,
0.0278366376,
-0.0090155229,
-0.0530886836,
-0.0115029132,
-0.0104472525,
0.0063300524,
-0.061397586,
0.061262887,
-0.0269541312,
-0.0085204411,
-0.0272850711,
-0.0445546992,
-0.0078506302,
-0.0217623729,
-0.023330994,
0.0340433866,
-0.0033645025,
0.0000511511,
-0.0466061011,
0.0591672324,
0.0324648321,
0.0369786061,
-0.0369303338,
0.0301769525,
-0.0368881039,
0.0619955063,
0.0183008984,
0.0545712262,
-0.0302741136,
-0.0176593754,
0.0748129264,
-0.0139212012,
0.0282554235,
-0.0059750504,
-0.0262458492,
0.0240703952,
0.0429668613,
0.0111435037,
-0.0188286621,
0.0221812092,
0.0515749753,
-0.0332267545,
0.0088686859,
0.119456552,
0.0193625949,
-0.0075362334,
-0.0078927763,
0.007398529,
0.0257699136,
0.0223295614,
-0.0000362781,
-0.0355760902,
-0.0375941135,
0.0331963822,
0.0599624291,
0.0536188371,
0.0368559361,
-0.0101330215,
-0.0854003504,
0.0529338196,
0.026585998,
-0.0610895492,
-0.0733286887,
-0.0513284765,
-0.0210201126,
-0.0193849076,
0.0628115833,
-0.0030571925,
-0.0246260799,
0.0016449298,
0.0370663106,
-0.0081085432,
-0.0637505949,
0.0040093949,
-0.0383400805,
0.0931928754,
0.0883737355,
0.0358214788,
-0.0534430817,
0.0019670695,
-0.0268812906,
-0.021223167,
-0.0070576253,
0.0296076611,
0.0246466324,
-0.0014274451,
0.0004810167,
0.0544952713,
0.0145212086,
-0.0139702074,
-0.0074731954,
0.0106147528,
0.0424450077,
0.0055326233,
0.0032594807,
0.0103030344,
0.0426087826,
-0.0214758273,
0.0896537602,
0.0348980576,
-0.0017687011,
0.0273775533,
-0.0015915905,
-0.0039687054,
-0.067550309,
0.0234248117,
0.0024031422,
-0.0121023171,
-0.0156824421,
-0.0587494038,
0.0119640026,
0.0303654205,
-0.0017940231,
0.0381076932,
0.0079012513,
-0.0048274812,
0.0344105512,
-0.0223605447,
0.032748457,
-0.0267035067,
0.0226913802,
-0.0347623751,
-0.0179070439,
0.0728454515,
-0.0437661931,
-0.0206292756,
0.0267823562,
-0.0639102533,
-0.0255049579,
-0.0165487826,
0.013483868,
0.0146001531,
0.0443778001,
0.0189906042,
-0.043196626,
0.0354371667,
0.0295078773,
-0.0078455172,
0.0530101247,
0.0164886396,
-0.006773578,
-0.0262745656,
0.0257753953,
-0.0690881908,
0.0321557149,
-0.0357406028,
0.0663766861,
0.0181703214,
-0.0588069186,
0.0141108409,
0.0235505793,
0.0116278948,
-0.0110074151,
-0.0048362473,
-0.0303552691,
0.0529442318,
-0.0023451967,
0.0038120088,
-0.0373397246,
0.0143508827,
0.0439028591,
0.0337469019,
-0.0161825791,
0.0347318761,
-0.0019614752,
-0.0072413846,
-0.0160952434,
0.0655663684,
0.0219277274,
-0.0573951341,
0.027382331,
0.0169190243,
-0.0223490223,
-0.0107318964,
0.0476105697,
0.0226973742,
-0.0223644823,
-0.0052598636,
-0.0252374914,
-0.0027822175,
-0.0232543238,
0.0554307774,
-0.0159799326,
-0.0138821229,
-0.0325120389,
0.0445199423,
0.0511156581,
0.0125419535,
0.0585808009,
0.0205772091,
0.009709524,
-0.0104170693,
0.0024898192,
-0.0262138452,
-0.0117076263,
0.0693208575,
-0.0027288934,
0.0062424541,
0.0383817218,
0.0457681678,
-0.0259212721,
0.0495871715,
-0.0225953162,
0.0157187935,
-0.0130752372,
-0.0222279467,
-0.0329636298,
0.01505333,
-0.0106404079,
-0.0102130659,
0.0166340359,
-0.0613816604,
0.0113155888,
-0.0508654341,
-0.0081818989,
-0.0358713903,
0.0234855507,
0.0123101035,
-0.0163869821,
-0.0260688476,
0.0062619951,
-0.0638534725,
-0.0048346929,
0.0006586933,
-0.0013444418,
-5.775451334e-33,
-0.0617269725,
0.0110925725,
-0.0144419502,
-0.0508257486,
-0.0447148904,
-0.0161308236,
-0.0392128974,
-0.0136009846,
0.0091513209,
-0.0107883951,
0.0047597196,
-0.0069278129,
0.0285489969,
0.0158697739,
-0.0052784607,
-0.0181422774,
0.1040581912,
-0.0298347473,
-0.0282423217,
0.0368057936,
0.0121178869,
0.0072888369,
-0.0079102674,
-0.0586411245,
-0.033656355,
0.002045518,
-0.0456806868,
-0.006068496,
0.0368648544,
0.0458605662,
-0.0072944062,
0.0538062602,
-0.0149614271,
-0.0368498303,
-0.0183763094,
0.0123773031,
-0.0787643418,
0.0208663829,
0.0381334499,
0.0419166647,
0.0528551228,
-0.0389524922,
0.0305109192,
0.0038367009,
-0.0329626501,
0.0008796849,
0.0190141909,
-0.0173115842,
-0.0054982933,
-0.0631684363,
-0.0448549129,
-0.0128675001,
-0.0401204191,
-0.0520839728,
0.0476582609,
0.0562913306,
-0.007192736,
0.019967936,
-0.0367807783,
0.0430961847,
0.0363304168,
0.0253513325,
0.0727990568,
0.042462226,
-0.0387339927,
0.0247660484,
0.0023789587,
-0.0698458403,
-0.0207561702,
-0.0035911382,
0.0027778659,
0.0373770185,
0.0107445801,
0.0100011118,
0.0278654043,
0.0039435816,
-0.0220366977,
0.021673087,
-0.0683079064,
0.0190253053,
0.0348013565,
0.0578884892,
-0.0220242832,
-0.0022948126,
-0.1005163044,
0.0208981503,
-0.0295418669,
-0.0287833475,
0.0563220456,
0.0015335297,
-0.0218784921,
-0.0172040761,
0.045898553,
-0.0457952991,
0.0076480936,
-0.0055720797,
-0.0388268307,
0.0298402831,
-0.0152677214,
0.0003424264,
-0.0035560953,
-0.0135251703,
0.1140926406,
-0.0120831179,
0.0292386077,
-0.0184828453,
0.003744704,
0.060993515,
-0.0700048134,
0.0067165559,
0.002187693,
-0.0202298537,
-0.0094457706,
0.0525101013,
-0.0089901956,
0.0252203848,
-0.0246768501,
0.0144134983,
-0.0217428412,
0.0385459624,
-0.0338024609,
-0.0291023646,
-0.0214325022,
0.0256673023,
-0.0368869528,
0.0508712307,
0.0141919022,
-0.0298038702,
0.0059447326,
-0.0522309244,
-0.044375062,
0.0062820083,
2.721e-7,
0.0023017048,
0.0365051143,
0.0110042142,
-0.043129947,
0.0232796408,
0.0104714576,
-0.0458957255,
0.0197117813,
0.0309904385,
-0.0188673399,
0.0395159647,
0.0203445219,
0.0586127974,
0.0178035237,
-0.1017878801,
0.0027684744,
-0.0610410385,
0.0013818443,
-0.0446446203,
-0.0483068265,
0.0577297956,
0.1209761649,
-0.0408141203,
-0.0357719176,
-0.0125163216,
-0.0651332587,
0.0290945899,
-0.0195099171,
-0.0016196425,
-0.0039525707,
0.0078346441,
0.0050143856,
-0.0330854096,
0.0100321565,
-0.0402834341,
0.0485370085,
0.0277192313,
0.074450478,
0.0158248693,
-0.0389506482,
-0.0354025438,
0.0844395235,
-0.0086181993,
-0.0255839378,
0.0831258446,
-0.0257615317,
-0.0322042815,
-0.022856975,
-0.0548668504,
-0.0029892139,
0.0002402417,
-0.0402954444,
0.0285885558,
-0.0098781791,
0.025880361,
0.0168665182,
-0.0459336527,
-0.0561049879,
0.0144495666,
0.0044917096,
-0.0571429357,
-0.0632518828,
-0.0288002249,
-0.0468183681,
-0.005108234,
-0.0339865759,
0.0077650137,
2.387167755e-34,
0.0451863371,
-0.0629972667,
0.0092915641,
0.0138910161,
0.0184162408,
-0.0014705984,
-0.0201606173,
-0.0164502878,
-0.0292573366,
-0.0873605013,
-0.0150076216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13269v1 | Investigating Low-Cost LLM Annotation for~Spoken Dialogue Understanding Datasets | 2024-06-19T06:59:57 | 2024-06-19T06:59:57 | Lucas Druart, Valentin Vielzeuf, Yannick Estève | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.SP | In spoken Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems, the choice of the semantic
representation describing the users' requests is key to a smooth interaction.
Indeed, the system uses this representation to reason over a database and its
domain knowledge to choose its next action. The dialogue course thus depends on
the information provided by this semantic representation. While textual
datasets provide fine-grained semantic representations, spoken dialogue
datasets fall behind. This paper provides insights into automatic enhancement
of spoken dialogue datasets' semantic representations. Our contributions are
three fold: (1) assess the relevance of Large Language Model fine-tuning, (2)
evaluate the knowledge captured by the produced annotations and (3) highlight
semi-automatic annotation implications. | [
0.0194034353,
-0.0198885184,
-0.0197627321,
0.0977299511,
-0.0076550385,
0.0297897793,
-0.0190570951,
-0.0258098319,
0.011935072,
-0.0965162218,
-0.0564136207,
-0.0019402481,
-0.0026714522,
0.0055519021,
0.0096010342,
-0.0723102391,
0.0452616028,
-0.045673836,
0.0040071676,
0.0225555841,
0.0074179713,
0.0067331907,
-0.049502477,
0.0494329594,
0.0082282377,
-0.0203084201,
-0.0361467637,
0.0257274918,
-0.0194992106,
-0.0009357802,
-0.0249009356,
0.0357110277,
0.0377173945,
0.0400121734,
0.0000015895,
-0.0798165202,
0.0007058912,
-0.0249443464,
-0.0710981786,
0.0040011588,
-0.0072140838,
0.0271670967,
-0.0012529021,
0.0051580481,
-0.0322716013,
0.0153907211,
0.03144335,
0.0520370901,
0.0783481151,
0.0654265136,
0.0006712599,
-0.0036513763,
-0.0144521436,
0.0013365884,
0.0361320153,
-0.0498789847,
0.0075189727,
0.069880791,
0.0055209044,
-0.0022905283,
0.0049278708,
0.0133412182,
-0.0397849418,
-0.0395015888,
-0.0170613676,
-0.014850012,
-0.065473035,
-0.0069720806,
-0.0158531982,
0.0817932785,
0.0668662041,
0.0237303134,
-0.0085188933,
0.0049987859,
-0.0058559729,
-0.0353663377,
-0.059665639,
-0.0294530075,
-0.006092425,
0.0258238744,
0.002088492,
0.0025467037,
0.006037137,
0.0012532,
-0.0220810659,
0.0669820234,
-0.0373299159,
-0.0061936295,
-0.0182505529,
-0.0280196685,
-0.0303475559,
-0.0581867322,
-0.0121149477,
0.0314935781,
-0.0472089462,
0.043263346,
-0.0335686207,
0.0247218516,
0.0232483409,
-0.0365069248,
0.0303646754,
0.0598988049,
-0.0385538191,
0.068049334,
0.0106557002,
0.0369867831,
-0.0030285392,
0.004637633,
-0.021600455,
-0.0229014773,
-0.063367568,
0.0138348341,
-0.0489504784,
0.0153670022,
-0.0449292026,
0.0004348491,
-0.0183114205,
0.0619249828,
0.0080717048,
0.0407272317,
0.0280114524,
-0.0194715671,
-0.024385564,
0.0102808159,
-0.0487583503,
0.0183742009,
0.0033375858,
0.0445916243,
0.0005340285,
-0.0591193736,
-0.0061473045,
0.0127951661,
0.0247334652,
-0.0192312822,
-0.0256350655,
0.0762875304,
0.0148816714,
-0.0365869887,
-0.0293034632,
-0.0332102925,
-0.0138222501,
-0.0277982783,
-0.0430150442,
-0.0201424956,
0.0259050746,
0.0090124551,
-0.0248948559,
-0.0084526017,
0.0112639097,
0.0033088143,
-0.0112621142,
0.0924254283,
-0.0577309914,
0.0260478929,
0.0336499251,
0.0052921162,
-0.0420674831,
0.0781062394,
0.0510018878,
-0.0064938571,
0.0540971309,
-0.0148417195,
-0.0437383689,
0.0439716391,
-0.014803756,
0.0048158877,
0.0122923739,
0.0461452119,
-0.022282958,
0.0222348478,
0.0196331739,
0.0208340306,
-0.0397361219,
0.009024187,
0.0453584269,
0.0844601169,
0.0135299135,
-0.0225876365,
0.0121193137,
0.0454014316,
0.0221093688,
0.0203671493,
-0.0232671928,
0.0076826653,
-0.0028463784,
-0.0096365772,
0.0389843322,
-0.0244019441,
-0.0242030714,
-0.0534681194,
-0.0360349528,
0.0070020934,
0.0016693115,
0.0291088969,
0.0304478984,
0.0181667972,
-0.0261287633,
0.0711783096,
0.0191329159,
-0.0428356193,
-0.0237909555,
-0.0480988584,
0.0123802982,
0.078258194,
0.0348314084,
-0.0580690466,
-0.0801686645,
-0.0375298634,
0.0478448458,
0.0270382203,
0.0413842425,
-0.0500591658,
0.0292081181,
-0.0593490712,
-0.0332197137,
-0.0063913488,
0.0079620965,
0.0073894337,
-0.0279190764,
-0.062243171,
0.0065069632,
-0.0404620804,
-0.0071996506,
0.0091532804,
0.0144788567,
-0.0147996424,
0.0092715947,
0.0212501846,
0.0577478781,
0.0509730466,
0.0055744736,
-0.0230307132,
0.0287577976,
0.0024123259,
0.0433484577,
0.0298524071,
-0.0198822264,
-0.0386799201,
0.0477413647,
0.0256322939,
-0.0361335129,
-0.0137470243,
-0.0542468987,
-0.0591470376,
-0.011676562,
-0.0375963748,
0.0327726789,
-0.0662307069,
0.0055514807,
0.016573634,
0.0156589802,
-0.0289630238,
0.0151200937,
0.0184541475,
0.0047104377,
0.059400402,
0.0143419113,
0.0646881983,
-0.0533502288,
-0.0089125335,
0.0098627536,
-0.0044262898,
0.0060116551,
-0.0061845598,
0.0062557869,
-0.0552317575,
-0.0082469936,
-0.0900284275,
0.0113829784,
-0.0255885255,
0.0228838008,
0.0193939731,
0.0165111944,
-0.0014690799,
-0.033942081,
-0.0260125529,
-0.0053201979,
0.0321164727,
-0.0135360407,
0.0377469994,
0.0172125529,
-0.0520278253,
-0.0520682223,
0.0492143407,
0.00637209,
-0.0128002092,
-0.0071797352,
-0.0251779482,
-0.072370708,
0.0269253757,
-0.0228122659,
0.0301244482,
-0.0258981511,
-0.0266347583,
0.0190063883,
0.0174780563,
0.0036107989,
0.0366003364,
-0.0035496471,
0.0317221805,
0.0223685615,
-0.0306191165,
-0.0690453723,
0.0352454931,
0.0167601984,
-0.0033716988,
-0.0681429133,
-0.0070523927,
0.0049518272,
0.05344427,
0.0010726552,
0.018542368,
-0.0314575545,
-0.0312894136,
0.0101326574,
-0.0020180736,
-0.0264639873,
-0.0027246941,
-0.0442547537,
0.0547826737,
-0.0115468893,
-0.0236030929,
0.0588313453,
-0.0771027282,
-0.0300585348,
-0.0366741233,
-0.0356627107,
-0.0528998971,
0.080619581,
-0.0358949229,
-0.0021599231,
0.0062509896,
-0.0610160157,
-0.0293046497,
0.005675598,
0.0289919134,
-0.0312504694,
0.0848160237,
-0.0356772244,
0.0052742106,
-0.0196786467,
-0.0014024472,
-0.0409427099,
-0.001946193,
-0.0482385829,
0.0101524945,
-0.0086358013,
-0.0014840913,
0.0110340565,
0.0266242214,
-0.0083177984,
0.0253052507,
0.0086792083,
-0.0008794705,
-0.0446344204,
0.0193676781,
0.0309696794,
0.0615348667,
-0.0344556458,
0.0414445512,
0.070468694,
0.0195955783,
0.021706732,
-0.0331208184,
-0.0174050983,
0.0008356598,
0.0519323312,
-0.0355512686,
-0.0344280861,
0.0143067725,
0.0617546849,
-0.0484892279,
-0.0110571207,
0.1331517696,
0.0098183015,
-0.0062035248,
0.0017231682,
-0.0450841114,
0.0305208974,
0.0399839282,
-0.0036171007,
-0.1134795174,
-0.0534790494,
0.0035949724,
0.0305564422,
0.0186926778,
-0.0419284217,
-0.0228979718,
-0.0571953543,
0.0396274291,
-0.0189672392,
-0.0225033984,
0.0078058252,
-0.0382370763,
0.0237360038,
-0.0139514469,
0.0566523075,
-0.0114886919,
0.017656628,
-0.0251718946,
0.0383934975,
-0.0240210295,
-0.035130769,
0.0409791656,
-0.0132547338,
0.0795750916,
0.0487328805,
0.0607117228,
0.0306856483,
0.0031951044,
0.045768626,
0.0188182369,
0.0158185642,
-0.0051076286,
0.0478101857,
-0.017983878,
-0.0108740395,
0.0148502775,
0.0306297541,
-0.0253966767,
-0.0172779988,
0.0218854621,
0.0573154241,
-0.0869614258,
0.0819059089,
0.0117490999,
0.0187965427,
0.018586183,
0.0939229205,
0.0581549332,
-0.0127857113,
0.0149198752,
-0.0351393372,
-0.0287741255,
-0.0332287028,
-0.003677336,
0.0109173246,
-0.0228940248,
0.0047782995,
-0.0434549227,
-0.0403747447,
0.053874813,
0.0095682349,
0.0031363529,
0.0482511669,
-0.0170488209,
0.0321099721,
-0.0077812914,
0.031318076,
-0.0410711169,
-0.0030893264,
-0.0404075906,
-0.0410555564,
0.0651765913,
-0.0394947678,
-0.0115884608,
0.0207942612,
-0.0798158795,
-0.0549234785,
-0.0382668003,
0.0257265735,
0.0276572052,
0.0597955771,
0.002565477,
-0.0490405224,
-0.0395042747,
-0.0065544802,
-0.0318173841,
-0.0330806524,
0.025988413,
0.0667334944,
-0.0155569697,
0.0633622706,
-0.069235228,
0.0066294326,
-0.0409806557,
0.0349215157,
-0.0464813896,
-0.1078254431,
0.0067724823,
0.0361035988,
0.0777316839,
0.0144643756,
-0.0172213409,
-0.0204089545,
0.0561475307,
-0.0243322216,
-0.0295560807,
-0.0580394529,
0.0243571848,
-0.0228410121,
-0.0680460408,
-0.0136923399,
-0.0057807043,
-0.0511101335,
0.0485363789,
-0.0280577689,
0.039415013,
0.0345674865,
-0.0248079114,
0.0093427887,
-0.0097772703,
-0.0175923519,
0.0047168154,
0.0354643837,
-0.0014496484,
0.0179573335,
0.07815516,
-0.0033892577,
-0.0122668976,
0.0125324912,
0.0327675939,
-0.0440997854,
-0.0484152772,
0.0179090127,
0.0177655928,
0.0425166786,
-0.0027640634,
0.0602731891,
-0.0056344341,
0.0180655159,
-0.0014403127,
0.083492063,
-0.0087223565,
-0.0237820726,
0.0534160994,
0.0162043218,
-0.0410400517,
0.023704255,
0.0574445836,
-0.0083287451,
0.0375708081,
-0.006808511,
-0.0062129833,
-0.0622356385,
-0.0531169027,
0.0150571354,
0.052311711,
-0.0081965886,
-0.0263029411,
-0.0298146214,
-0.0466959663,
-0.0053041913,
-0.0178265683,
-0.0234871656,
-0.0106532341,
0.0453205369,
0.0225569736,
-0.0204154029,
-0.0009485035,
-0.019675428,
-0.0493553244,
-0.0236088913,
-0.0009687701,
-0.0103046754,
-4.931617204e-33,
-0.0470337048,
-0.0221478995,
0.0267301649,
0.0450778343,
-0.0085615553,
-0.0180670209,
-0.0224416554,
-0.0073759924,
-0.034713205,
-0.0216845721,
-0.0157834962,
0.0226204377,
0.017924048,
0.022857165,
-0.0263973325,
-0.0403550901,
0.0503558777,
-0.0046972707,
-0.0115021132,
0.0107219545,
0.0468266159,
0.0015195516,
0.0446188524,
-0.0649732202,
0.0584283806,
0.0105259912,
-0.0043784548,
0.0387563519,
0.0356227048,
0.070034571,
-0.0051779724,
0.0580141321,
0.0208420213,
-0.0357564315,
-0.039357502,
0.0056204814,
-0.0593377277,
-0.0078215888,
0.0633752421,
0.0342085846,
-0.0011325282,
-0.0066264835,
0.0143815102,
0.0063414136,
-0.0079684984,
0.0110245971,
0.0189524721,
-0.0479386374,
-0.0211519282,
0.0024898774,
-0.0177090541,
0.0402799137,
-0.0418761782,
-0.0621772818,
0.0429450236,
0.043492727,
0.0368049704,
-0.0379872583,
-0.0143923108,
0.0168502871,
-0.0000968687,
0.005653902,
0.0719478205,
0.029553581,
-0.0002155455,
0.0593067743,
0.0207489412,
0.0069106272,
0.0156007726,
-0.0245056003,
-0.0114199715,
0.0445734896,
-0.0416923054,
0.0251580942,
-0.0569491275,
0.015096833,
-0.037472479,
0.0425900593,
0.0122325951,
0.0109483423,
0.0006645164,
0.0327313133,
-0.0156296529,
-0.0005861012,
-0.0526670553,
0.0178832542,
-0.0093835425,
-0.0244100429,
0.0384468101,
-0.0196576621,
0.0038679482,
0.0030814174,
0.0464373603,
-0.0348473601,
-0.010578814,
0.0296701659,
-0.0220692884,
0.0025749316,
-0.0237986259,
-0.0096398322,
-0.0097969063,
-0.049952168,
0.0488158427,
0.0071387938,
0.038175758,
-0.0067092241,
0.0238937363,
-0.0077014044,
-0.0297798105,
0.0019863767,
-0.0351383761,
0.0155279888,
-0.0724966601,
0.044381164,
0.0267971698,
-0.0192809496,
-0.0226846095,
0.0822975188,
-0.0020922618,
-0.0388768911,
-0.0070345337,
-0.0152677083,
0.0037124406,
0.0018669509,
-0.0317424983,
-0.0083264513,
0.0163065307,
-0.0161190964,
0.0074008633,
-0.0053460975,
0.0105170757,
-0.019176269,
2.255e-7,
0.0360127315,
0.0433012061,
0.0255766325,
0.020547349,
0.0108067784,
0.0395525657,
-0.0119761825,
0.0056454265,
0.0299638323,
-0.0488799401,
0.0392600708,
0.0071479315,
0.0350739583,
0.0018822413,
-0.118846491,
-0.0539684407,
-0.0412394032,
-0.0179638602,
-0.0258620605,
0.015080086,
0.0736184344,
0.0693483129,
-0.0099705802,
0.0120019978,
-0.0238446221,
-0.0425344817,
0.0141383968,
-0.0850011706,
-0.0006547721,
0.0440113768,
0.0592547245,
0.0171356183,
-0.007525281,
0.0117909797,
-0.0028359736,
0.0446342528,
-0.0016516243,
0.0782755613,
-0.015524772,
-0.0634423494,
-0.0425088517,
-0.0246942136,
0.0157224443,
-0.0174797028,
0.0502392314,
-0.0310698058,
-0.0461791083,
-0.0117707895,
0.0055425693,
-0.0272735208,
-0.0200965516,
-0.000960479,
0.0236950442,
0.0139401136,
0.0034343433,
-0.0253334753,
-0.008411292,
-0.0657159835,
0.0018840043,
0.011081662,
-0.0615783446,
-0.0541278683,
-0.0217061788,
-0.0091579547,
0.021861501,
-0.0567464642,
-0.0132289883,
1.747442721e-34,
0.0091360845,
-0.0102562811,
0.0193857048,
0.0547693595,
0.0397204794,
-0.0136919348,
0.0169186108,
0.0232970342,
0.0481154136,
-0.0670974851,
-0.0113045126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13261v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13261v2 | BeHonest: Benchmarking Honesty of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T06:46:59 | 2024-07-01T15:18:07 | Steffi Chern, Zhulin Hu, Yuqing Yang, Ethan Chern, Yuan Guo, Jiahe Jin, Binjie Wang, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous works on Large Language Models (LLMs) have mainly focused on
evaluating their helpfulness or harmlessness. However, honesty, another crucial
alignment criterion, has received relatively less attention. Dishonest
behaviors in LLMs, such as spreading misinformation and defrauding users,
eroding user trust, and causing real-world harm, present severe risks that
intensify as these models approach superintelligence levels. Enhancing honesty
in LLMs addresses critical deficiencies and helps uncover latent capabilities
that are not readily expressed. This underscores the urgent need for reliable
methods and benchmarks to effectively ensure and evaluate the honesty of LLMs.
In this paper, we introduce BeHonest, a pioneering benchmark specifically
designed to assess honesty in LLMs comprehensively. BeHonest evaluates three
essential aspects of honesty: awareness of knowledge boundaries, avoidance of
deceit, and consistency in responses. Building on this foundation, we designed
10 scenarios to evaluate and analyze 9 popular LLMs on the market, including
both closed-source and open-source models from different model families with
varied model sizes. Our findings indicate that there is still significant room
for improvement in the honesty of LLMs. We also encourage the AI community to
prioritize honesty alignment in LLMs. Our benchmark and code can be found at:
\url{https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/BeHonest}. | [
0.0573753268,
0.1026637852,
-0.0480843335,
0.0789367259,
-0.0824158639,
-0.0270072501,
0.0058050072,
0.0056779762,
0.0295506138,
0.0010790235,
-0.0426048003,
-0.0184489172,
0.015084099,
0.0548191778,
0.0069441297,
0.0176946595,
0.0505071878,
-0.0135499556,
0.0373249054,
-0.0174057577,
0.0279569961,
0.0168393105,
0.010101405,
0.0368611477,
-0.0258801337,
-0.0104124965,
-0.0009554882,
-0.0199856479,
0.0086456761,
0.0001841322,
0.0124937929,
0.0434544086,
-0.0159394164,
0.0842814147,
0.0000020848,
-0.0543694086,
-0.0192005895,
0.006044168,
-0.0453317724,
0.0481464341,
0.0355088077,
-0.0344858356,
0.0090384083,
0.0097998511,
-0.0598887056,
0.0588765964,
0.0535467975,
0.0322080739,
0.0727209672,
0.0817662925,
0.0033172695,
0.0306367502,
0.0519848503,
-0.0136900283,
-0.008663238,
-0.0472989902,
0.0289705377,
-0.0210966598,
-0.0524981394,
0.0161848292,
0.0174323227,
0.0271532331,
0.0161736459,
-0.0373374596,
-0.0193044227,
0.0026121321,
-0.0404248945,
-0.0436022803,
-0.0161307957,
0.0462272093,
0.014286547,
-0.0255353432,
-0.0067989221,
-0.0150634302,
-0.0106567647,
0.0139428237,
-0.0020488773,
0.0253914297,
-0.0236061327,
-0.0075422074,
0.0106924931,
0.0166258477,
0.0619347692,
0.0277696457,
0.0344929397,
0.0862766132,
0.0041971537,
-0.038378831,
0.0191144776,
-0.0310227238,
-0.0041877963,
-0.0749431923,
-0.01633057,
0.0220372435,
-0.0455067307,
0.0241846088,
-0.0301941764,
0.0271032173,
0.0641854107,
-0.0473485701,
0.0328844711,
0.0210606027,
0.0192332417,
0.0218752977,
0.026061561,
0.0810849816,
0.0014716289,
0.0336511694,
-0.0203167908,
-0.0142348278,
0.0179170948,
-0.0062995632,
-0.0105607472,
0.0118634468,
0.000014766,
0.0125533715,
-0.036981713,
0.0079603745,
-0.0680927262,
0.0490901992,
0.0084944163,
-0.008678874,
-0.0123518296,
-0.0235226844,
-0.0222613215,
0.0097503569,
-0.045485273,
0.0227988865,
0.0054413206,
-0.063883692,
-0.002466779,
0.0117531009,
-0.0644279495,
-0.0279915109,
-0.0052139503,
0.0664150342,
0.0153663848,
-0.018586399,
-0.0323147699,
-0.024172578,
-0.0313557908,
-0.0867580697,
-0.0254128166,
-0.0513965115,
0.0378835537,
-0.0100529762,
-0.0280406922,
-0.0741380677,
0.0055128075,
0.0073112743,
-0.0439588688,
0.0357459188,
-0.0293534473,
0.0281674266,
0.0093846219,
0.0326001607,
-0.0629490763,
0.0447992869,
0.0149949193,
0.0474053025,
0.0759159178,
-0.0155434068,
0.0230965856,
0.0464115925,
0.0207433868,
0.0520097241,
0.0095114317,
0.0245236754,
0.0093927579,
0.025148537,
0.0114147952,
0.08686997,
-0.003334898,
-0.0514428951,
0.1067735404,
0.0040385276,
-0.0321379825,
0.0041865613,
0.0213524643,
0.0188615695,
0.0108516635,
0.0112271998,
-0.0766669512,
-0.0037150725,
-0.0550751686,
-0.0018132875,
0.0191308688,
0.0283942632,
0.006304529,
-0.019476559,
-0.0345141478,
-0.0215911977,
0.0355396047,
0.0340430774,
-0.0106555568,
-0.0289659072,
-0.0235456359,
0.0457873866,
0.0399045087,
-0.0376635492,
-0.0137250638,
-0.0747029409,
0.0386709422,
0.0532524362,
0.0368175507,
0.0070972294,
0.0134569369,
-0.0304957218,
0.0015930235,
0.0438854471,
0.0379495807,
-0.0109228939,
0.0154467775,
-0.0095156627,
-0.0036508655,
-0.0190871041,
0.0299570989,
0.0141125629,
0.0217579082,
0.0125361485,
-0.0077658789,
-0.0566188432,
-0.0125071444,
0.0330608115,
-0.0461338982,
0.0056951512,
-0.0284537431,
0.0051412284,
0.0313930511,
0.0009045054,
-0.0294710547,
0.0036661814,
0.0344634205,
0.0021868921,
-0.0045795077,
-0.0329296365,
-0.0109029245,
0.0444215238,
0.0456785187,
-0.0238961242,
-0.0062847305,
0.0541375056,
-0.0157638025,
0.0143480292,
-0.0092842346,
-0.027186498,
0.031805288,
-0.0337502211,
0.0345873386,
-0.0664127842,
0.0041690269,
-0.0129768644,
0.0407120138,
-0.0632031113,
0.0313867591,
-0.0012007351,
-0.0331567638,
0.0049514705,
0.0117210494,
-0.0249143355,
0.0128372135,
-0.000856569,
0.0379382372,
0.0701123849,
0.0409007221,
-0.0187288858,
-0.0501111522,
-0.1051657796,
-0.0182769522,
-0.0181350429,
0.0015870924,
0.0294638984,
-0.0174574628,
-0.002388756,
0.0462639034,
-0.032303486,
0.0021625201,
0.0106909489,
0.0215670299,
0.0229822956,
-0.0089200512,
-0.0425782874,
-0.0351734608,
0.0139674181,
-0.0178882014,
0.0258632302,
-0.0123805366,
-0.0089758746,
-0.0348923169,
-0.0021633042,
-0.0517174117,
0.0106296698,
-0.0349111222,
-0.0673415065,
0.0162763335,
0.032030195,
-0.0217499342,
0.0484430306,
0.0518298633,
0.0285147037,
0.057296358,
0.0265585762,
-0.0676449686,
-0.0176665671,
0.0046231137,
-0.0335282795,
-0.05265259,
-0.0847936422,
0.0301362518,
0.0535607152,
0.0132393939,
-0.0061336081,
-0.0219411142,
0.023414081,
-0.0341499262,
-0.0669098645,
0.02202674,
-0.0528303608,
-0.017895896,
0.0353981815,
-0.0102822594,
-0.0832809806,
0.0816051215,
-0.0487629548,
0.0349422209,
0.0151216593,
-0.0106891906,
-0.006503358,
0.0574066341,
-0.018300442,
0.050667651,
0.0289726108,
0.0156144649,
-0.0353987664,
-0.0207042284,
0.0539003089,
-0.0401005745,
0.0331910402,
-0.0452575311,
0.0099787256,
0.0214722995,
-0.0547958277,
-0.0656186417,
-0.091236636,
-0.0105945198,
-0.00154492,
0.0291417707,
-0.0427884273,
-0.0578357503,
-0.0444040298,
0.0299949758,
-0.0098403841,
-0.0122086909,
0.0019037075,
0.0048325867,
-0.0347052626,
0.068665348,
-0.0131225483,
0.0667491481,
-0.0173933487,
0.0118642729,
0.0578471199,
-0.01377529,
0.0390454531,
0.0091974335,
-0.0223952346,
0.0171188638,
-0.0107224267,
0.0127376048,
0.0350391082,
0.0351675861,
-0.0205214024,
-0.0217803288,
0.0970630348,
0.0120512722,
-0.0221204869,
0.0270907842,
-0.0164847672,
0.0229823068,
0.0205023903,
-0.0022315749,
-0.0871389657,
-0.0100892074,
0.007731318,
0.00176569,
-0.030465398,
-0.052139841,
-0.020060502,
-0.1116915569,
0.0109855235,
0.0178236905,
-0.0383480228,
-0.0303179659,
-0.0356686935,
-0.0334080569,
-0.0048831245,
0.0634838343,
0.0053596068,
0.0170830209,
-0.0454201698,
-0.0240978524,
-0.0255673788,
-0.0179379657,
0.0455211513,
-0.0352830961,
0.0788551867,
0.0525039695,
0.027870046,
-0.0251862425,
-0.0599534586,
-0.0060653202,
0.0344045833,
-0.0293995347,
0.0202825293,
0.0428288691,
-0.0131864296,
0.0108656092,
0.004991814,
0.0000582681,
0.0045045135,
0.0078312028,
0.0343020149,
0.0283681527,
0.0032480056,
-0.0574156903,
-0.0022943069,
-0.0077322898,
0.0519961417,
0.086450085,
0.0008393328,
-0.0213880986,
-0.0072826585,
-0.0376819149,
-0.0183948576,
-0.0007284294,
-0.0275601298,
0.048785083,
0.0313836299,
0.0061733089,
-0.0685179606,
-0.0345289931,
-0.0327953883,
-0.0256305858,
0.0407904014,
-0.0187614411,
0.0140790157,
-0.0220987443,
-0.0182884205,
-0.0104127731,
-0.0450327918,
0.0574276149,
-0.0516384207,
0.0315306187,
-0.0101536466,
-0.0111733247,
0.021775851,
0.0274868011,
-0.0557116084,
-0.071698755,
0.034756057,
0.0639403462,
0.0245638303,
0.0423688851,
-0.0274001639,
-0.0252986979,
0.0236158874,
0.0010457874,
-0.0708711967,
0.0318176486,
0.0449825004,
-0.004666456,
0.0209259577,
0.0504497811,
-0.0554860868,
-0.0223711636,
0.015435338,
0.0149494903,
-0.025023587,
-0.0480886474,
0.0359426104,
0.0475615822,
0.0149888378,
-0.0142400684,
0.0284068193,
-0.0162503421,
-0.0132024856,
-0.0278103612,
-0.0292141773,
-0.015732076,
-0.0000370959,
0.0424279869,
0.0167610906,
0.0177801531,
0.0065116873,
-0.0365289263,
0.0016831511,
-0.0197627097,
-0.0138152586,
-0.0217179228,
0.0285321362,
0.0238347035,
0.009787051,
-0.0438260585,
0.0409822203,
-0.0111027956,
0.0575632565,
0.008979911,
0.0407962836,
0.0115881599,
-0.0197103675,
0.007376641,
0.0339336842,
-0.0224986169,
-0.0351824388,
0.0107132001,
0.0330577046,
0.0281107929,
0.0303685609,
0.0501266085,
-0.0204503518,
0.0010880727,
-0.028967429,
0.0040129046,
0.0002463441,
-0.0678486302,
0.0144487722,
0.0069797193,
-0.0402514935,
0.0277292095,
0.0517387949,
-0.0211046953,
0.0320398472,
-0.0122386934,
-0.0143449511,
-0.0202560183,
-0.0388316214,
0.0005021471,
0.0208358672,
-0.0352137275,
-0.0359113403,
-0.0808940604,
-0.0680358708,
0.0028455814,
0.0169618614,
0.0060166731,
-0.0106980586,
-0.0159350336,
0.07790602,
0.0157001559,
0.0208449792,
-0.0740781277,
-0.0273526367,
-0.0098631177,
-0.01133887,
-0.0368387029,
-6.471522518e-33,
0.0239965841,
-0.0437271744,
-0.0060380865,
-0.0280297603,
-0.0169535894,
0.0251352079,
-0.0082126278,
0.0155757442,
-0.0870549157,
0.0152693735,
-0.0134603381,
0.0078366622,
0.0014532839,
-0.0152472081,
-0.0152330361,
0.0026285001,
0.020138843,
0.00333459,
-0.0469294973,
0.0013710565,
0.0220763255,
-0.0345142074,
0.0477607846,
-0.0696424395,
0.0748896673,
-0.0183837358,
-0.0569453165,
0.061518468,
-0.061983671,
0.0610835142,
-0.0026197641,
0.0558633283,
0.0091905966,
-0.0007014742,
0.0178734418,
-0.0235569011,
0.017407978,
-0.0173874069,
0.0728761181,
-0.0082870917,
-0.0314063057,
-0.0358841009,
0.0341891758,
-0.0345294997,
-0.0468839146,
-0.0230776351,
0.0045347684,
0.0103087062,
-0.0214412417,
0.0064886878,
-0.0587379672,
-0.0072767315,
-0.0272789653,
-0.0093280217,
-0.0329257585,
0.0319141559,
0.0108057139,
0.0058312099,
-0.0768997818,
0.0188818034,
0.0080170473,
-0.0073378007,
0.0817075595,
-0.0420124941,
0.0068315268,
0.0924879536,
0.0237438437,
0.0298549738,
0.0041682664,
-0.0137508791,
0.0247603972,
0.0461742058,
0.0580893122,
0.0841621235,
-0.0203235801,
-0.0533077456,
-0.0531185567,
0.0105793308,
0.044113528,
0.0196462851,
0.0245262086,
-0.0160795003,
-0.0773826092,
-0.0149230817,
-0.0421833619,
-0.0022039013,
-0.0388123952,
-0.0280634332,
0.0449589267,
-0.0061432123,
-0.0090008676,
-0.0300462004,
0.0287892614,
-0.0663504899,
-0.0046019703,
0.0350141376,
-0.01589448,
-0.0119175576,
0.0142069273,
0.0630154014,
-0.0354632176,
-0.0043915464,
-0.0300184134,
-0.0003210899,
0.0349996313,
0.0049489262,
0.0475802757,
0.0035700502,
-0.0248945802,
0.0198439658,
-0.0359672941,
0.0323498696,
0.0107665733,
-0.0434192605,
0.0279762689,
-0.0163269304,
-0.0354634523,
0.0236567482,
0.0192024484,
-0.0014905948,
-0.0545698889,
0.0314492844,
0.0042148582,
0.0181731768,
-0.0155276461,
0.0020473483,
-0.0268412959,
0.0279683489,
0.0299114846,
-0.0218853317,
-0.01589166,
-0.0144100292,
2.785e-7,
-0.0146960532,
0.0285980906,
-0.0042116065,
0.060160473,
-0.0125080505,
0.0672480613,
-0.022880327,
0.0411053188,
-0.0299860388,
-0.0302764773,
-0.0208337102,
0.0143137779,
0.0648892298,
0.0571682677,
-0.0453591645,
0.0313758738,
-0.0843672156,
-0.042815093,
-0.0574939959,
-0.007521804,
0.020510979,
0.0609623492,
0.0354233421,
-0.0069258655,
-0.0118643558,
-0.0588526614,
0.0254119392,
-0.0358087905,
-0.0287465341,
0.0240059309,
0.0253343303,
-0.009049071,
0.0182400346,
0.0127985533,
-0.0052059991,
0.013095187,
-0.0446361117,
0.0686199218,
-0.0213540569,
-0.0436194539,
-0.0223040767,
-0.0633837655,
0.0129976012,
-0.0828666687,
0.0500507951,
0.0096518109,
-0.0311486516,
-0.0689314231,
-0.0047237352,
-0.0274862628,
0.0474884659,
-0.0376284495,
-0.0226887409,
0.0314161181,
0.0052914131,
0.0084275985,
-0.0105814775,
-0.0071467655,
-0.0298189204,
-0.0094771469,
-0.0101892017,
-0.0741096139,
-0.002854723,
0.0281643048,
0.0059114946,
-0.0539870262,
0.0643466935,
2.342186958e-34,
0.0141867921,
-0.0431386381,
0.0252732448,
0.0263634976,
0.0838113576,
0.026267197,
-0.0097265001,
0.0187230594,
-0.0092886984,
-0.0126038529,
-0.009175064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13250v1 | LangTopo: Aligning Language Descriptions of Graphs with Tokenized Topological Modeling | 2024-06-19T06:20:22 | 2024-06-19T06:20:22 | Zhong Guan, Hongke Zhao, Likang Wu, Ming He, Jianpin Fan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have been widely researched in the
field of graph machine learning due to their outstanding abilities in language
comprehension and learning. However, the significant gap between natural
language tasks and topological structure modeling poses a nonnegligible
challenge. Specifically, since natural language descriptions are not sufficient
for LLMs to understand and process graph-structured data, fine-tuned LLMs
perform even worse than some traditional GNN models on graph tasks, lacking
inherent modeling capabilities for graph structures. Existing research overly
emphasizes LLMs' understanding of semantic information captured by external
models, while inadequately exploring graph topological structure modeling,
thereby overlooking the genuine capabilities that LLMs lack. Consequently, in
this paper, we introduce a new framework, LangTopo, which aligns graph
structure modeling with natural language understanding at the token level.
LangTopo quantifies the graph structure modeling capabilities of GNNs and LLMs
by constructing a codebook for the graph modality and performs consistency
maximization. This process aligns the text description of LLM with the
topological modeling of GNN, allowing LLM to learn the ability of GNN to
capture graph structures, enabling LLM to handle graph-structured data
independently. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method on
multiple datasets. | [
0.0112926448,
0.0461200774,
-0.0089018196,
0.0388785973,
-0.044860784,
-0.0005744729,
-0.0168871153,
-0.0015927739,
0.0484332144,
-0.026701929,
-0.0267015118,
-0.01483355,
0.0042578173,
0.0806462467,
0.0347212031,
-0.0033116217,
0.0089158649,
-0.0193782412,
0.0004452977,
-0.0186775997,
-0.0118848765,
0.0591729768,
0.0529178418,
0.032960698,
-0.0083361678,
-0.0138972402,
-0.0263117645,
0.0328138843,
-0.0455989167,
-0.0437682346,
-0.0166240837,
0.0200269911,
0.0369595066,
0.0294165071,
0.0000018067,
-0.0055361767,
-0.0174657796,
0.0140493447,
0.0163093656,
0.0016488344,
0.0260668844,
-0.0717129782,
0.0473696701,
-0.0214152392,
-0.0245892461,
-0.0162770581,
0.0724486038,
0.028876489,
0.0343999751,
0.0487965196,
-0.0245710984,
-0.0243146885,
0.0259034801,
-0.0154500166,
-0.0097798025,
-0.0233665202,
0.0394921005,
0.0432609245,
0.0206874758,
-0.0084305881,
-0.0592748299,
0.0193373524,
-0.0011412213,
-0.0086846519,
0.0507187285,
0.0326054208,
-0.0103671253,
0.0132538192,
-0.0055867541,
0.1192886382,
-0.0191824809,
-0.0427271314,
0.0332427733,
-0.0129672233,
-0.0322367214,
0.0324636362,
-0.0439808331,
-0.0208296813,
-0.0125035448,
0.02652606,
-0.0180911981,
-0.0530981235,
0.0921135098,
-0.0032680982,
-0.035516344,
0.1003826931,
-0.0198422316,
0.0103366831,
-0.0077619199,
-0.0211774074,
-0.0327031054,
-0.0390639268,
0.0155080492,
0.0230228454,
-0.0204895791,
0.0159223005,
0.0040378002,
0.0295126829,
0.0025156469,
-0.004873578,
0.0252647102,
-0.0128291659,
-0.0222213306,
0.0410109982,
-0.0179326143,
0.0388890617,
-0.0449486151,
0.0750045404,
-0.0546010919,
-0.0321311764,
-0.052192729,
0.0008920673,
-0.0430141836,
0.029315114,
-0.0009133872,
-0.057172928,
-0.0122414827,
0.0587701052,
-0.022748068,
0.0055702506,
0.0008080329,
0.005200698,
-0.0084669823,
-0.0073695933,
0.0093271788,
0.0004267806,
0.0002144886,
0.0069276546,
-0.0404926799,
-0.0031234194,
0.0037016645,
0.0345912017,
0.0467456169,
-0.0304925106,
0.0042258068,
0.0845138431,
0.0687233955,
0.0004560629,
0.0024512392,
-0.0181193873,
-0.0182092208,
-0.0548399724,
0.0360384881,
-0.0884009302,
0.0475906059,
0.036598973,
-0.0176545102,
-0.0566134378,
0.0160956085,
-0.0105557796,
-0.0459241606,
0.0739784613,
-0.050322935,
0.0159423258,
-0.0169636197,
-0.0452663824,
-0.0178692881,
0.0179474745,
0.0182280466,
0.0267985314,
0.024185,
0.0067129,
-0.0476518795,
0.0348496735,
0.0367158167,
-0.0118103446,
-0.0296573397,
0.0238434225,
0.0022031644,
0.019688921,
-0.0054235472,
0.090199858,
-0.0162809789,
-0.0519950129,
0.0228275135,
0.0603198409,
0.0112611707,
0.0223156679,
0.0338091999,
0.0341791734,
-0.0092194006,
0.0041810232,
-0.0656845197,
0.0072231684,
0.0155220078,
0.0395110212,
-0.0184922088,
-0.0260224938,
-0.0001355691,
-0.0193464551,
-0.0375178717,
-0.0351121575,
0.098280862,
-0.0029921534,
0.0683027282,
-0.0017340905,
-0.0354475379,
0.025300581,
0.0292573869,
0.0059212055,
0.0053850664,
0.0041140821,
-0.0215584449,
0.0700105801,
0.0209820587,
-0.028860487,
-0.0322983265,
0.0015365991,
0.0082949605,
-0.0219523758,
0.0231569503,
-0.0267442521,
-0.0098420409,
-0.0315962806,
-0.0422206707,
-0.0470513217,
-0.0141471932,
0.0301657431,
0.0013250207,
-0.0259744003,
-0.0142002562,
-0.0923108384,
-0.0801667199,
0.0229339097,
0.0356252454,
0.0335147716,
-0.0029178713,
-0.0110677611,
0.0095642405,
0.03772901,
0.0118855229,
0.0110728918,
0.0269051194,
0.0012826276,
-0.0026791124,
-0.0058391327,
-0.0341547206,
-0.0174172502,
0.0775834695,
-0.0192705095,
-0.0499063171,
0.019693438,
-0.0587500483,
-0.0310440958,
0.0444698334,
-0.0808244869,
0.0326864272,
-0.0049200091,
-0.0360846743,
-0.0028817516,
0.0120776696,
-0.0010604342,
0.0421502776,
0.0166288037,
0.0196821298,
0.0160193052,
0.0232934784,
-0.0024175206,
-0.0377095975,
-0.0255234297,
0.0216989685,
0.0043989709,
0.0156674124,
0.0291795619,
0.0071451361,
-0.0162919965,
0.0186733436,
-0.0953655839,
-0.0272819344,
-0.0052491268,
0.0037990338,
0.0171152111,
-0.0114559941,
0.0166317821,
-0.0174048804,
-0.052488897,
0.009048176,
-0.0053461562,
-0.0043152994,
0.0568933673,
-0.0254794024,
-0.0522423759,
-0.0164063536,
-0.0567030273,
-0.0567341931,
0.0877345502,
0.0337592177,
-0.0747812763,
-0.0072836624,
0.0184699483,
-0.0489095971,
0.0168243758,
-0.0137125794,
0.0233507678,
-0.0003544534,
-0.003520519,
0.0306813959,
0.0256707612,
-0.0306851454,
0.03606157,
0.0650183037,
0.0055593611,
-0.0141839022,
-0.0176956579,
-0.0502061956,
0.0170657448,
-0.0170072224,
-0.0325479023,
-0.0079350099,
0.013774639,
0.0049468596,
-0.0085329693,
-0.0196243245,
-0.0028875987,
-0.0318481363,
0.0443955399,
-0.0272306893,
-0.0277478043,
0.0195924863,
0.0185939614,
-0.0466415025,
-0.029824188,
0.0950045958,
-0.021869421,
-0.0048266938,
0.0362208486,
-0.0214465782,
-0.0829311758,
0.0842064992,
0.0615940467,
0.0276628509,
0.0141135929,
-0.0482198782,
-0.0369664058,
-0.0037954426,
0.0061074686,
-0.0144354654,
0.0286212191,
-0.0094260778,
0.0348408893,
0.0181301329,
-0.0170900878,
0.0055900747,
0.0227086358,
-0.0364135951,
0.0522974841,
0.0001238482,
-0.0543631129,
0.0274247099,
0.0184664205,
-0.0254972111,
0.0042459918,
-0.0284032002,
0.0203470401,
-0.044498682,
0.0312647633,
0.0359158032,
-0.0257529486,
-0.0164878573,
-0.0251880493,
-0.0282508917,
0.0231490359,
-0.0229566991,
0.0312135015,
-0.0386784934,
0.0155712385,
0.0091831237,
0.0109248199,
-0.0152962264,
-0.016916994,
0.0385980532,
-0.0264540724,
-0.0105774859,
0.0651737973,
0.0202921201,
-0.0116475103,
0.006943244,
-0.002892622,
0.0191327985,
0.0293599535,
0.0070209,
-0.0770777315,
0.0117153991,
-0.0168765653,
0.0135118626,
0.0479347929,
-0.0360097587,
-0.0063580382,
-0.0660267323,
0.0093298536,
0.0325507596,
-0.0611556061,
-0.0531881973,
-0.0648135319,
-0.02513103,
-0.0113865342,
0.0164132304,
-0.0338133946,
-0.0135182887,
-0.0089392969,
0.004152,
-0.0392428413,
-0.0133962622,
0.045128677,
-0.027548993,
0.0254460834,
-0.0204947051,
0.0499139503,
0.0044568675,
0.0041751456,
0.0647135675,
0.0804802999,
-0.017637115,
-0.0217766892,
0.0131111862,
0.0091878232,
-0.0021502476,
-0.0143216047,
0.0329887979,
-0.0563089885,
-0.0274153724,
-0.0670538992,
0.0788652375,
0.0046700072,
-0.0332581513,
0.0033946459,
-0.0070732986,
-0.0152057633,
0.0145573495,
0.061175894,
0.0032204902,
-0.0653383061,
-0.0599621646,
0.0281532761,
-0.0636541918,
-0.0549858809,
0.0198213905,
-0.010606573,
0.01162575,
-0.0154433567,
-0.0039221295,
0.0256396979,
-0.0388807021,
0.0094369166,
0.0109847719,
0.0447119996,
-0.0693580657,
-0.0872737393,
0.0355281495,
-0.0313697122,
0.033810284,
0.0206508208,
-0.0334339775,
0.0354610421,
0.0115974853,
-0.0231099352,
0.0221227929,
-0.0563797355,
-0.0752176791,
-0.0220504124,
-0.0098522939,
0.0113421418,
0.0550615564,
-0.0134734167,
-0.0207981076,
-0.0069250842,
0.040235199,
-0.0299327318,
-0.0249885675,
0.0170725472,
0.0161427967,
-0.0062274807,
0.0366347544,
-0.0754681751,
0.0104070799,
0.0388282575,
0.0303636976,
-0.0358116403,
0.0041442583,
0.0187286753,
0.065854609,
0.032884717,
0.027521329,
0.0009993028,
-0.0550186448,
-0.0489009693,
-0.0158546753,
-0.0401141271,
0.0028175474,
-0.01434197,
0.017408805,
-0.0118243657,
-0.0015922065,
-0.049437955,
0.0238082409,
0.0479345657,
-0.020137025,
-0.0136819417,
0.0061917147,
-0.038276583,
0.058035586,
0.0114553329,
-0.031209264,
0.0245575719,
-0.0154281324,
0.0056384639,
-0.0125849778,
-0.0399892852,
0.0304873884,
-0.014680285,
-0.0496379361,
0.0102817044,
-0.0245629344,
-0.0251604486,
-0.0276994798,
0.0198149811,
0.0407159068,
0.0269422196,
0.0306185111,
-0.0097877868,
-0.0120261488,
-0.0281818565,
0.0704262182,
0.0010478125,
-0.0678761825,
0.0594666414,
0.0263461508,
-0.002308531,
0.0049311034,
0.0311381761,
0.0925736651,
0.0044407812,
-0.0042122635,
-0.0329018012,
-0.0222304501,
0.0143180247,
-0.0284228586,
0.0354028046,
-0.0219005086,
0.0119181527,
-0.0467742644,
-0.1015862525,
0.0612285845,
0.0132716345,
0.0164031684,
0.0113485754,
0.0160778854,
0.0319814533,
0.0263353996,
-0.020943841,
-0.0263377763,
0.0529232286,
0.0455793664,
-0.0341241434,
-0.0260169655,
-6.053795907e-33,
-0.0025898842,
-0.1076330021,
0.0171627235,
0.0165798143,
-0.0312494189,
0.0260630604,
-0.047528144,
-0.0061029987,
-0.0210615098,
0.0147277359,
0.0083226701,
0.0145890228,
-0.0111257285,
0.0236213431,
-0.0409619175,
-0.0134898024,
0.0060025156,
-0.0030933234,
0.0058375588,
0.0243228041,
0.0229291767,
0.0278853793,
0.0364185795,
-0.0940668955,
0.0423728637,
-0.0228041764,
0.0310288463,
0.0105119562,
0.0402932055,
0.0241568238,
-0.0225076061,
0.044965487,
0.0387431085,
0.028183816,
-0.0026710508,
0.0055265715,
-0.0657503158,
-0.0158748832,
0.0235091597,
0.0243297443,
-0.031380862,
-0.0440322869,
0.0820386559,
0.0027513816,
0.0205160826,
-0.0403119214,
0.0594657473,
0.0132228592,
-0.0473887734,
0.0322449394,
-0.0486788899,
0.0425527394,
-0.0138674881,
0.0132921143,
0.0291516986,
-0.0157742705,
0.0212678369,
0.0225326419,
-0.0530990101,
0.0267492887,
-0.0502428263,
0.0008047276,
0.0256912578,
0.0242020134,
0.0272467695,
0.0488924086,
0.0154936947,
0.0006141545,
-0.039459642,
0.0308851879,
0.0363380089,
0.0816219151,
0.0036520977,
-0.0202565044,
-0.0458106361,
0.0013325569,
-0.1010460779,
-0.0363061279,
-0.0243601725,
0.0073944191,
-0.0017652246,
0.0238814447,
0.0136913881,
-0.0494157337,
-0.0183547027,
-0.0736535937,
-0.0293805301,
-0.0045278692,
-0.0173324849,
-0.043091815,
-0.0387505628,
0.0403915681,
-0.0289713554,
-0.0904818103,
-0.0446357727,
0.0609842427,
-0.0119171748,
0.0576539896,
-0.0056210798,
0.0478397273,
-0.0533516333,
-0.0451701134,
-0.0348473974,
0.0003462831,
0.0339303501,
0.0076517435,
0.0515086316,
0.0315543935,
-0.0139980139,
-0.0071039293,
-0.0439743772,
-0.0604206808,
-0.0549225658,
-0.0247489028,
0.0604026839,
0.0555437766,
0.0081636487,
0.0668035746,
0.0464489385,
0.0246986952,
-0.0069848606,
0.0152059896,
-0.0070459386,
0.0512059666,
-0.0192697551,
-0.0274463929,
-0.0130645912,
0.0238481648,
0.057822112,
-0.0310227256,
-0.0262498576,
-0.0039134412,
2.58e-7,
0.0743118301,
0.0614613444,
0.0726836994,
0.0517747551,
0.0151399421,
0.0002935556,
-0.0176823679,
0.0325021371,
-0.0199891664,
-0.0294654202,
0.0348377302,
0.0556486845,
-0.039506603,
0.0256815925,
-0.0676749125,
0.0885293558,
-0.1089290604,
-0.0154795032,
-0.0333855748,
0.0355868563,
0.0312216058,
0.0621930696,
0.0091839209,
0.0051834504,
-0.0377698317,
-0.0663646385,
0.0506493449,
-0.0274846125,
0.0054316646,
0.0218852405,
-0.0094842445,
-0.0146790035,
-0.0193286855,
-0.0038217495,
0.0218055006,
0.0325226188,
0.0554388836,
0.0417484902,
-0.0258158688,
-0.0019734467,
-0.0046290052,
-0.0399249382,
-0.0064501939,
-0.0447864607,
0.0583488718,
-0.063902393,
-0.0489048399,
-0.0397412516,
-0.0010471757,
0.0003686736,
0.0145536177,
-0.0063294931,
-0.0255157314,
0.0528143831,
0.0160213225,
-0.0292757098,
0.034461759,
-0.0523747616,
-0.0056429342,
0.0035257707,
-0.0174634792,
0.0004248423,
-0.0084597012,
0.0280887969,
0.0230638254,
-0.0006136255,
0.0228750128,
2.16828864e-34,
0.0369835347,
-0.0155700324,
-0.0261276066,
0.0103123803,
0.0353473201,
-0.0502123013,
0.0152362613,
0.0280949716,
-0.0065389583,
-0.0837989748,
-0.0184988156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13249v1 | R^2AG: Incorporating Retrieval Information into Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T06:19:48 | 2024-06-19T06:19:48 | Fuda Ye, Shuangyin Li, Yongqi Zhang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) has been applied in many scenarios to
augment large language models (LLMs) with external documents provided by
retrievers. However, a semantic gap exists between LLMs and retrievers due to
differences in their training objectives and architectures. This misalignment
forces LLMs to passively accept the documents provided by the retrievers,
leading to incomprehension in the generation process, where the LLMs are
burdened with the task of distinguishing these documents using their inherent
knowledge. This paper proposes R$^2$AG, a novel enhanced RAG framework to fill
this gap by incorporating Retrieval information into Retrieval Augmented
Generation. Specifically, R$^2$AG utilizes the nuanced features from the
retrievers and employs a R$^2$-Former to capture retrieval information. Then, a
retrieval-aware prompting strategy is designed to integrate retrieval
information into LLMs' generation. Notably, R$^2$AG suits low-source scenarios
where LLMs and retrievers are frozen. Extensive experiments across five
datasets validate the effectiveness, robustness, and efficiency of R$^2$AG. Our
analysis reveals that retrieval information serves as an anchor to aid LLMs in
the generation process, thereby filling the semantic gap. | [
0.074044086,
0.052812811,
0.0047589652,
0.0196971055,
-0.0329769589,
-0.0008846148,
-0.036138542,
-0.0074946713,
0.0018172337,
-0.0665063933,
-0.0296415798,
-0.030877158,
-0.0270781014,
-0.0026437037,
-0.0048797159,
-0.0236765388,
0.0678269118,
-0.0163632017,
-0.0099678095,
0.0265203249,
0.0001387315,
0.0535774268,
0.0210470948,
0.0254678745,
-0.0419454016,
0.0231736321,
-0.0033037285,
0.0455326363,
0.0073251538,
-0.026824154,
0.0139152296,
0.0402604789,
0.0389347002,
0.0374514945,
0.0000020516,
-0.0440105796,
-0.0327447727,
0.0103918184,
-0.0357148424,
-0.0111390185,
0.075437367,
0.0211344473,
0.0254532415,
0.0160996169,
-0.0209300257,
-0.0292811282,
0.0197914205,
0.0740163922,
0.0324437469,
0.0699081868,
-0.0042613214,
-0.007412008,
0.0205570683,
-0.0403478928,
0.0489373989,
-0.0447908863,
0.015054265,
0.0017380628,
0.050854817,
0.0602780506,
0.0213105287,
0.0597723797,
0.0082069915,
-0.0121316873,
0.0046411138,
0.0296863262,
-0.0598057173,
-0.0165643878,
-0.029208133,
0.0426943526,
0.0523314066,
-0.0047916742,
0.0091853486,
0.0049332334,
0.0069844723,
0.0356629565,
-0.0191966332,
0.0114283049,
-0.0315289199,
0.0194719564,
-0.00428223,
-0.007211172,
0.0264102798,
0.0342824459,
-0.0283915326,
0.0359457731,
0.0245277062,
-0.0367087536,
-0.0061951834,
0.0284109805,
0.0067981393,
-0.0104089305,
-0.0199642275,
0.0227438249,
-0.0297306757,
0.0377575718,
-0.0444449522,
-0.0381985344,
0.0318412334,
0.0178950429,
0.0622224808,
0.0113299312,
-0.0581355542,
0.028072739,
-0.0603100918,
0.0287494604,
-0.0317394137,
-0.0082443096,
-0.0610743538,
-0.005808054,
-0.038718652,
-0.0251477938,
-0.0632045269,
0.0314622149,
-0.0434894897,
-0.051410947,
-0.0062843049,
0.0529529713,
0.0136181563,
-0.0016461824,
-0.0201567486,
0.0288047679,
-0.0571758747,
0.000666724,
-0.039638076,
0.0124895619,
-0.0024542289,
0.0041379165,
0.0484301597,
-0.081578657,
0.0025722235,
0.0057398272,
0.0312802903,
-0.0206733402,
-0.0082982527,
0.0323903486,
-0.0309551898,
-0.0408997051,
-0.0480658896,
-0.0501066931,
0.01073125,
-0.0529599339,
0.0016741659,
-0.0411148593,
0.0268777218,
-0.0034866014,
-0.0150654782,
-0.0268786456,
0.0177833345,
0.0465235747,
-0.0361951292,
0.0293604769,
-0.0298759919,
0.0254828278,
0.0366760418,
-0.0013298285,
0.0144068841,
0.065163061,
-0.0105630299,
0.0192272048,
0.0343266986,
0.0249500945,
-0.0014454988,
0.0125427851,
0.0318566449,
0.0264915656,
-0.0320589319,
0.0050875852,
-0.0100662112,
0.0038873425,
0.0321246125,
0.0680946559,
-0.0419287197,
0.0162210353,
0.0251127165,
0.0267467927,
0.0194860585,
0.0147963436,
0.0695946366,
0.0343443751,
-0.0301889442,
0.0278449226,
-0.0145338094,
0.0317160673,
-0.051951319,
0.0314644352,
0.0306083597,
0.0260879174,
-0.0487665311,
-0.0216335692,
-0.0123522077,
-0.0022128143,
0.0129089328,
0.0120006222,
0.0378332548,
0.05615687,
-0.0404625162,
0.0263137128,
-0.0135499826,
-0.0551745631,
0.0272099189,
-0.0667253137,
0.0521862581,
0.0721271783,
0.0785921589,
0.0036011471,
-0.0148332361,
0.00361018,
-0.0002632425,
0.0433474258,
0.0473346263,
-0.0008551677,
-0.0093118995,
-0.0708996803,
-0.0543924123,
-0.0111355241,
0.0075093512,
0.0290849712,
0.0300338604,
-0.0084170392,
0.0753048211,
0.0070844786,
-0.02965937,
0.0342158452,
-0.0342621356,
-0.0190602671,
0.0103159277,
-0.0055557569,
0.0036400105,
0.0061148489,
-0.0153487846,
0.0256537609,
0.0364054851,
-0.0098727755,
-0.0113541475,
0.0011505062,
-0.0351554602,
-0.019812407,
-0.0215190761,
0.0613978989,
0.0232248269,
-0.0029999975,
-0.0324802212,
-0.0230013616,
0.0134244049,
-0.0317150578,
0.0339730717,
-0.0910733938,
-0.001399424,
0.0648528859,
0.0067073721,
-0.0382240675,
0.0507650226,
-0.0030825674,
0.0050923042,
0.0184404179,
0.0226331595,
0.0161348376,
-0.0618791357,
-0.0177372769,
-0.0092095397,
-0.0077621313,
0.0381290875,
0.0550279915,
0.017098641,
-0.0538553782,
-0.0368746519,
-0.049686294,
-0.0112815462,
-0.0250540003,
-0.0056142863,
-0.0020857186,
0.0372660756,
-0.0054530413,
-0.0306409523,
-0.0169481132,
-0.0240698662,
0.0413785502,
0.0393408425,
-0.0031520289,
0.0502036847,
0.0062672142,
-0.0297552776,
-0.0063624047,
0.0316558145,
0.014000169,
0.0076147681,
0.001099276,
-0.073182255,
0.0182574838,
-0.0679584295,
0.0196709055,
-0.0243202709,
0.0014197052,
0.0173758511,
-0.0700073987,
0.050267309,
0.0209090691,
0.0227319766,
-0.0032943129,
0.0322498046,
-0.0117665362,
-0.0909713879,
0.0215723217,
-0.0465310067,
-0.0573645942,
-0.0147276502,
-0.0190656446,
0.0234303307,
-0.0027548845,
0.0094182165,
0.0036364421,
-0.0325399004,
-0.0217196997,
-0.0009377546,
-0.0438202098,
-0.0482450053,
-0.0392917655,
-0.0199145712,
0.0391334593,
-0.0324534178,
-0.0518148616,
0.0791944191,
-0.0425915681,
-0.0269885734,
-0.0579025,
0.0032250369,
-0.0317608826,
0.053713616,
-0.0220621023,
0.0297892895,
-0.043433819,
-0.0182690471,
-0.0305426251,
-0.0167736374,
-0.0132015925,
-0.0568755418,
0.0511063263,
-0.0151945082,
0.0304787122,
0.0101146679,
-0.0249131657,
-0.0664684027,
-0.0270382743,
0.0272262488,
0.000452188,
-0.0335712358,
-0.0198176112,
-0.0536627993,
-0.012735053,
0.0481023006,
0.0597449839,
-0.0183566511,
-0.0268798359,
-0.0136640407,
0.0435814783,
0.0893690735,
0.0124459295,
-0.0435990393,
-0.0251990966,
0.0051658312,
0.0263203159,
0.0264769103,
-0.0463592149,
-0.0021008379,
-0.0047452799,
0.0512893535,
0.0202059504,
0.0007042361,
0.0273765903,
0.0165492594,
-0.0380035527,
-0.0439644717,
0.0629580691,
0.0265652947,
-0.0202011112,
-0.0330073014,
-0.0387067944,
0.0651096702,
0.0316406265,
0.0533751771,
-0.0613504462,
-0.0132609168,
0.0079600904,
0.0360330343,
-0.0019197634,
0.0071457596,
-0.0263837278,
-0.1340464056,
0.0670552626,
0.0068035033,
-0.0170952994,
-0.0063237171,
-0.0127706435,
0.0103402203,
0.0422734506,
0.0057343487,
0.0409088396,
-0.0415398553,
-0.0068573346,
0.0224371329,
0.036759004,
-0.0426225476,
-0.0502317511,
-0.0159291569,
-0.0063235424,
0.0988584086,
-0.0010394278,
0.0303270407,
-0.0505212359,
0.0153647419,
-0.0373589396,
0.0389579944,
-0.0342085473,
0.0473388545,
-0.0244933572,
0.0064915339,
-0.0382417999,
0.0015158056,
0.0210218169,
-0.0040158834,
-0.0289096292,
0.0548669845,
-0.0395762138,
0.00182458,
-0.0471167341,
-0.011053442,
0.033841297,
0.0711998641,
0.0300012045,
-0.0028436966,
-0.0048070657,
0.0081335213,
0.0200917237,
-0.0302982163,
0.0110461442,
0.042695757,
-0.0321390517,
-0.0106624346,
-0.0673675686,
-0.052798178,
-0.0044837673,
0.0117794489,
-0.0057484163,
0.0288044587,
-0.0500071943,
-0.0198030621,
-0.070006676,
0.0352567583,
-0.0408664569,
-0.0154354358,
-0.0347449221,
-0.0347861461,
0.0407745466,
-0.0641269162,
-0.0123340869,
0.03403062,
-0.0125038428,
-0.0451741107,
-0.0217581447,
0.0337388478,
0.0260846354,
0.0558867566,
-0.0083317161,
-0.0234857704,
0.061309997,
0.0608152337,
-0.0483834669,
0.0134233618,
-0.0039080535,
-0.0038626667,
-0.0318255238,
0.0298965909,
-0.0829540864,
0.0259900205,
-0.0221038479,
0.0629218146,
0.0098047657,
-0.0334934518,
0.0303847976,
0.0426161699,
0.0368559211,
-0.0066063963,
0.0357162803,
-0.0554959141,
0.0054968894,
-0.0205437671,
-0.0164861567,
-0.0513148643,
0.0375970714,
0.0294716433,
-0.0157577097,
0.0192723684,
0.0086205732,
-0.0001501559,
0.0970640406,
-0.0259563979,
-0.0292783286,
0.0054355925,
0.034957163,
0.0399902835,
0.0179523639,
-0.0408120267,
0.0217185654,
0.0032130908,
0.0377704129,
-0.0416740887,
0.0835247859,
0.0287485253,
-0.0132060125,
-0.0271858033,
0.0194170941,
-0.0483212657,
-0.055288069,
-0.0300052557,
0.0051234504,
0.0031752817,
-0.0008980427,
0.0720805377,
-0.0356243923,
-0.004714577,
-0.0349132866,
0.021118816,
0.0054524327,
-0.0753841624,
0.0298457965,
0.0198600031,
-0.0169551484,
0.0301330872,
0.028407529,
-0.0495096557,
0.0433057994,
-0.0718937814,
-0.0058039119,
-0.0424491093,
-0.0303269997,
0.0301718134,
0.0016234682,
-0.0308761131,
0.0052026571,
-0.0250144023,
-0.057816159,
-0.0166202951,
0.0013420951,
-0.0276332386,
-0.0220272448,
0.0347427391,
0.0729420334,
-0.0065451213,
-0.0303460155,
-0.059581209,
-0.0013704418,
-0.0747008771,
-0.029528277,
-0.035128925,
-6.865122108e-33,
-0.0410132781,
-0.0086612292,
0.0358661972,
-0.0666330755,
-0.0256656408,
0.0149274068,
-0.035920389,
-0.0215490628,
-0.0049630706,
-0.0262879264,
-0.0093018468,
-0.0217896663,
0.019352017,
0.0241596419,
-0.0113953408,
0.0063301548,
0.066588074,
0.0032706889,
-0.0178466141,
0.05689786,
0.0885683149,
0.0377627648,
0.0102043962,
-0.0579320304,
0.0073641557,
-0.0370129757,
-0.0066414936,
0.0095035927,
-0.0110329464,
0.0879394636,
-0.0235415474,
0.0294063948,
0.0195920747,
0.0027846312,
-0.0188175868,
0.0301908106,
-0.0912884697,
-0.0177811272,
0.0150461728,
-0.0214873366,
-0.0437458269,
-0.0131869456,
0.0137954243,
-0.0509506725,
-0.0057970546,
0.0229731277,
0.0182561036,
-0.0064527788,
-0.0260193311,
-0.0256075971,
-0.0616875328,
0.0106061529,
0.0427962691,
-0.014370352,
0.0166129787,
0.0576818548,
0.006271902,
0.0186948664,
-0.0392096192,
0.0121184764,
-0.025248494,
0.0585875697,
0.04519004,
0.0459046997,
-0.0255084932,
0.0596684925,
0.0048617069,
-0.0311360694,
-0.0038411978,
-0.045433905,
0.0369772874,
0.0476243645,
-0.0256400164,
0.040259514,
0.0220845267,
-0.0299659688,
-0.0120054698,
0.0406771451,
0.0030869984,
0.0675431564,
0.0534144454,
-0.0122306384,
-0.0390100889,
-0.0029877431,
-0.0367319919,
0.0175191313,
-0.0523124225,
-0.0466214679,
0.0809999853,
0.0844098255,
0.0046912394,
-0.0088462131,
0.0578515716,
0.0135755744,
0.0043326188,
0.0455864072,
-0.041869428,
-0.0107736411,
-0.0368121751,
0.0041823485,
-0.0263359901,
-0.0634211078,
0.0769946054,
-0.0181417484,
-0.0375532471,
0.0122336205,
0.0185707398,
0.0352424122,
-0.0514198691,
0.0367016271,
-0.0302390903,
0.0695167854,
-0.0250139385,
-0.0199696608,
0.0362987332,
0.0172947571,
-0.0258554537,
0.0521706045,
0.0066416357,
0.0150812333,
-0.0298297759,
-0.0349708721,
0.0247605443,
0.0177058429,
-0.0136898803,
0.0555606894,
-0.0270026717,
0.0067537166,
0.0362293348,
-0.0067472747,
0.0002012249,
0.0545684434,
2.896e-7,
0.0062964628,
0.0040988149,
0.0511437543,
-0.0007662958,
-0.0236349851,
-0.0029007865,
-0.0219228771,
0.0196338892,
0.0458151437,
0.0135497618,
-0.0027743948,
0.0064712898,
0.0668587536,
0.0099224905,
-0.0878791884,
0.0086364606,
-0.0747199059,
-0.0115908813,
-0.0499330871,
-0.0128612835,
0.0642130673,
0.0579463765,
-0.0182681885,
-0.0211413894,
-0.0116527742,
-0.0744349957,
0.0701313615,
-0.0189312566,
-0.0127941957,
0.0067674476,
0.080393672,
0.0399277806,
0.01036363,
-0.0414764583,
0.0023797809,
0.0237311386,
-0.0171638373,
0.038440045,
0.0118646063,
-0.0537913404,
-0.0052677682,
0.0251191836,
-0.0150211575,
-0.0323742405,
0.0323667191,
-0.0261994805,
0.0077602756,
-0.0064423531,
-0.0419802591,
-0.0012719269,
-0.0231642276,
-0.0399335288,
-0.0244264528,
0.0173316859,
0.0184413455,
0.0072559314,
-0.0255120303,
-0.0859936252,
0.0059257457,
0.0129137542,
-0.0404795259,
-0.0344730876,
-0.0591786467,
0.0319285505,
-0.0267580487,
-0.0378898196,
0.0023389815,
2.693732089e-34,
0.049461171,
0.0021534436,
-0.0033557869,
0.0177055299,
0.0374366753,
0.0149258105,
-0.0201060809,
0.050264813,
-0.00833009,
-0.1062081158,
-0.0218512155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13246v1 | GSR-BENCH: A Benchmark for Grounded Spatial Reasoning Evaluation via Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-19T06:15:26 | 2024-06-19T06:15:26 | Navid Rajabi, Jana Kosecka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | The ability to understand and reason about spatial relationships between
objects in images is an important component of visual reasoning. This skill
rests on the ability to recognize and localize objects of interest and
determine their spatial relation. Early vision and language models (VLMs) have
been shown to struggle to recognize spatial relations. We extend the previously
released What'sUp dataset and propose a novel comprehensive evaluation for
spatial relationship understanding that highlights the strengths and weaknesses
of 27 different models. In addition to the VLMs evaluated in What'sUp, our
extensive evaluation encompasses 3 classes of Multimodal LLMs (MLLMs) that vary
in their parameter sizes (ranging from 7B to 110B), training/instruction-tuning
methods, and visual resolution to benchmark their performances and scrutinize
the scaling laws in this task. | [
0.0234475452,
0.0489687659,
-0.0013736244,
0.0826121569,
-0.0434162319,
0.0389620587,
0.0325650275,
-0.0321865305,
-0.0029693863,
-0.0464904755,
-0.0427017361,
-0.0140628116,
0.0279018246,
0.0120322127,
0.0152901169,
-0.0655093864,
0.0079666581,
-0.0336521044,
-0.0566814579,
0.0074461466,
-0.014085033,
0.0141521106,
-0.0351882838,
0.0458738916,
-0.0469327085,
0.0049883141,
-0.002694045,
0.0029324426,
0.0272204336,
-0.0653745979,
-0.0265315641,
0.0125267021,
0.0804000199,
-0.0333712809,
0.0000018589,
-0.0169641841,
0.0291017108,
-0.0082460428,
0.017063776,
-0.0247658733,
-0.0313815214,
-0.0333387107,
0.0258340351,
-0.0129805263,
-0.0275371112,
-0.0102920104,
0.050361082,
0.0391623899,
0.0429228432,
0.0245401729,
-0.0109481988,
-0.0700789019,
0.0114724981,
-0.0132730389,
0.0575020052,
-0.0158701278,
-0.0033933066,
0.0346711092,
0.0122354878,
0.0195712075,
-0.0528403781,
0.010067692,
0.0489429496,
0.0055088219,
0.0053903819,
0.0494013317,
-0.0179064255,
-0.0230991542,
-0.0034238591,
0.0672549754,
-0.0144843739,
-0.0153759364,
-0.0175269227,
-0.0002498247,
-0.0097379331,
0.0090129264,
-0.0488765314,
0.0351853669,
-0.0124206236,
0.0354172289,
-0.0589913912,
0.0047704945,
0.0150372498,
0.0152367279,
-0.0179333314,
0.0598168783,
0.0016077054,
0.0335035734,
0.0007188014,
0.0017537968,
-0.0106837656,
-0.034882199,
-0.0046243165,
0.058234863,
-0.005651867,
0.0074884971,
-0.0059048678,
0.0634373873,
-0.0220519081,
-0.0324258804,
0.0447963551,
0.02629322,
-0.0425801575,
0.0778731033,
-0.0746249408,
0.0534585342,
-0.0293752812,
0.0723943636,
0.0115982248,
0.003520262,
-0.0184448734,
0.0166367088,
-0.0056073363,
0.0054114237,
-0.0464191586,
-0.0450195782,
0.005666283,
0.0084932568,
-0.0230120197,
0.015447014,
-0.0122873718,
0.0383667499,
0.0278962031,
-0.0270240046,
-0.0325066037,
0.013914546,
-0.0248070117,
0.0367319174,
-0.0472962856,
-0.0352680013,
-0.0208998434,
0.0472711585,
0.0082957326,
-0.0367481783,
-0.0047602048,
0.0675932914,
-0.0098085534,
-0.0537722856,
-0.0328332111,
-0.0136858579,
-0.0014581832,
-0.0746579692,
0.0626293793,
-0.0615615733,
-0.0122303469,
-0.007692731,
-0.0327837169,
-0.0286207795,
0.0231712963,
-0.0056039104,
-0.0413173661,
0.070381172,
0.002300709,
0.0141906328,
0.0073314756,
0.0149486186,
0.0269376654,
0.056806419,
0.0529848486,
0.0565556139,
-0.0183357242,
0.019087242,
-0.0040257848,
0.0027764703,
-0.000783899,
0.0173261762,
-0.0892218053,
0.0023100011,
-0.0252057388,
0.0379577056,
0.0096380189,
0.0311505292,
-0.009561643,
-0.0376690179,
0.0511272065,
0.0709675476,
-0.0153660141,
-0.0239852984,
0.0272877105,
-0.0135935657,
-0.0127218403,
-0.0152400807,
-0.0752517805,
0.0851706862,
-0.0080068726,
-0.0258139297,
-0.0042071929,
0.0551087819,
-0.0341470614,
-0.0291950405,
-0.0679266602,
0.0053197667,
-0.0166585278,
0.0148519399,
0.0630680993,
0.0042116814,
-0.0211802255,
0.0522459,
-0.0047112028,
-0.0048604566,
-0.0059817624,
-0.0145580433,
0.0136249382,
0.003330427,
0.0113526089,
0.0003211587,
-0.033476118,
-0.0105500566,
0.0669061691,
0.0485358015,
0.0014713744,
0.0250150673,
0.035983406,
-0.0372684933,
-0.0777034611,
-0.0198080931,
0.0105788149,
0.0015934731,
0.0506906323,
-0.0179916918,
0.0191222951,
-0.0811622292,
0.0522283055,
0.0356104784,
0.0399777032,
0.0204692036,
-0.0628060326,
0.0215675533,
-0.0082012136,
-0.0346807279,
0.0072383438,
-0.0183053743,
0.0172670856,
-0.0083297668,
0.0323398635,
0.0360821038,
-0.051622469,
-0.0274064466,
0.0217543654,
-0.0551439449,
-0.0305826124,
0.0261719842,
-0.0466983728,
0.0115961703,
0.0287814643,
0.0041791676,
-0.0079153255,
-0.0339286998,
-0.0086912159,
0.0222849622,
0.0179852452,
-0.0432355069,
0.061363101,
-0.0629009008,
0.0080107488,
-0.0140335737,
0.0149998646,
0.0432582237,
-0.0158769619,
0.0317341276,
-0.0194688104,
-0.0067287604,
0.0061919075,
-0.053223107,
0.0348505639,
-0.0390564501,
0.0006911395,
-0.0251915436,
-0.0256415065,
0.000858975,
-0.0047711353,
-0.0134168146,
-0.0615703724,
-0.0022376832,
-0.060444165,
0.0077712969,
0.018796742,
-0.0092988582,
0.0223078728,
0.0372315459,
-0.0369144119,
0.0016396022,
-0.0047327075,
0.0182056408,
-0.0118618999,
0.0806541219,
0.0414061844,
-0.0151520493,
-0.0084293764,
-0.0142937917,
-0.0514718518,
0.0154947191,
-0.0116946856,
0.0005005743,
0.0616085269,
-0.0519960076,
0.0070575089,
0.0639976412,
-0.0166020524,
0.0450299606,
0.0364370942,
-0.0152407847,
-0.0523617677,
-0.020083636,
0.0030775906,
-0.0166704264,
-0.0025601017,
0.0042018564,
-0.0546735637,
0.0458636545,
-0.0201381948,
-0.0150795123,
-0.0416955426,
0.0353716947,
0.0175987333,
-0.0268436149,
-0.0715524033,
0.031574022,
0.015527715,
0.0494019948,
-0.0648398846,
-0.0665227249,
0.0050667259,
-0.0481820926,
0.0079852901,
0.0118499836,
0.0093845716,
-0.0253867935,
0.0938367993,
0.0356384479,
0.0193937067,
-0.0579047315,
-0.0185008999,
-0.0254518855,
-0.0268158857,
-0.0147993406,
0.0409558862,
0.0382232256,
-0.0944495574,
0.0282968041,
-0.0246764645,
-0.0124006392,
-0.0307996292,
0.0120882047,
-0.0506990068,
0.0036861764,
-0.0716644377,
0.0028264718,
-0.0086105186,
0.0501548164,
0.0403502621,
0.0200411081,
-0.0177983548,
-0.0206408091,
-0.0178689938,
0.0237424504,
0.0281166285,
0.0655463636,
-0.0162571352,
-0.0544365458,
-0.0310202222,
0.0366211012,
-0.0354115106,
-0.0193398055,
-0.0862411633,
0.0882541463,
0.0175551809,
0.052923087,
0.0168264993,
0.020997189,
0.0864520743,
-0.0536033697,
-0.034221001,
0.0382607803,
0.0340174511,
0.0110657336,
-0.0065073734,
-0.023320416,
0.0116648208,
0.0579896644,
-0.0152342403,
-0.0326915942,
-0.0529649518,
0.0079684891,
-0.0539083779,
0.0820630267,
-0.0320242755,
-0.0053486945,
-0.0718851089,
0.0600122623,
-0.0011626226,
-0.093611449,
-0.058282271,
0.0135244448,
-0.012484937,
0.0250010472,
-0.0235722009,
-0.0268546809,
-0.0037340058,
0.0104956152,
0.0120197767,
0.0107624494,
0.0009906495,
0.0178700723,
-0.0548407808,
0.0069974922,
0.0038508472,
0.0065694493,
0.0290202051,
-0.0910948589,
0.0375309698,
0.0729353279,
0.042664282,
-0.0317542329,
0.0313133821,
0.0023396832,
-0.0369690545,
-0.0007227281,
0.0136050163,
-0.0298998691,
-0.0355985127,
-0.0319917537,
0.0706271082,
-0.0411898643,
0.006264247,
-0.0396355428,
0.0466958135,
-0.0278028436,
0.0379720256,
0.0479683578,
0.0272283927,
-0.0578717329,
-0.010286523,
-0.0139146801,
-0.0374039076,
-0.0167814977,
0.025593508,
0.0157698411,
0.036183022,
-0.021511022,
-0.0046736808,
0.044979699,
0.049840048,
-0.0066816173,
-0.0499821082,
-0.0342580713,
0.0027861351,
-0.060229104,
0.0980218872,
-0.0181706138,
0.0225169677,
-0.0173973609,
0.0258486159,
0.023656914,
-0.0585399456,
-0.0147445304,
-0.0091098538,
-0.0956617221,
-0.0204121079,
-0.0564865358,
0.064589493,
0.0217685271,
0.0224503074,
0.0178438388,
-0.0176210161,
-0.0066361399,
0.0418439843,
0.0086522009,
0.0461370498,
-0.009429628,
-0.0050635743,
0.0006719687,
-0.0049347389,
-0.0252899975,
0.0311463717,
0.0367222503,
0.0207977965,
-0.0264089592,
0.0054377904,
-0.0311334673,
-0.0311719012,
0.0733368546,
-0.0025236055,
-0.0084385201,
-0.0403452627,
0.0314748548,
-0.007744215,
0.0504326746,
-0.0625576377,
0.0246047527,
0.0094592012,
0.0528828166,
0.0068244562,
-0.0339122489,
0.032207597,
0.0575730577,
0.011792263,
-0.0099191274,
0.0210925043,
-0.0342797562,
-0.0040862584,
0.0378469899,
-0.0289550927,
0.0177366715,
-0.0389307849,
0.0436850488,
0.0251263641,
0.0346737579,
0.019308012,
-0.0062473724,
-0.0272908174,
0.0280925501,
-0.0393340066,
-0.0559290685,
-0.0151676675,
0.029122632,
0.0763170272,
-0.0021904854,
-0.0132727074,
-0.0011347581,
-0.0001528541,
0.0244235378,
0.0575894453,
0.0119676013,
-0.0437927507,
0.0484352857,
0.0300623756,
-0.0001297262,
-0.0161627103,
0.0248897132,
0.0059261806,
0.0294034872,
-0.0092327287,
0.0210886057,
-0.0170967504,
-0.0494904108,
0.0274486728,
0.0278937034,
0.0122280177,
0.0506194569,
-0.0343848728,
-0.0618027151,
-0.0405864418,
0.0689916611,
-0.009737975,
0.0369026549,
0.0279224999,
0.0285884887,
0.0123362672,
-0.0365231149,
0.0061246231,
-0.0189767033,
0.0136842085,
0.011670691,
0.0248540677,
-6.032969086e-33,
-0.0335992463,
-0.060588304,
0.0694315359,
-0.0251334179,
0.0119600119,
0.0256116595,
-0.0402694121,
-0.0059628026,
-0.0494035147,
0.0068862909,
0.0202980153,
-0.0116143832,
-0.0011188139,
0.0307935067,
-0.0009090827,
-0.0016204995,
-0.0019504173,
0.0155313779,
0.0138618937,
-0.0331283771,
0.033036083,
0.0050243917,
0.0701208636,
-0.0521630272,
-0.0386503451,
0.0566325113,
-0.0375643447,
0.0529741459,
-0.0542293936,
0.0525047034,
-0.029157849,
-0.0264957324,
0.0251833312,
-0.0211653244,
-0.0432488173,
-0.0243925918,
-0.0697518587,
-0.0365302265,
0.0052135959,
0.0259164348,
-0.0748299658,
0.0144235361,
0.0446461774,
-0.005923769,
0.014236304,
-0.0408174768,
0.0397516862,
-0.0215393659,
-0.0251239017,
0.0455127582,
-0.012895315,
0.0055307448,
-0.0061759301,
-0.0135292755,
0.0298396572,
-0.0250976514,
0.0158640034,
0.0560597889,
-0.0350822955,
0.0039022963,
0.0092177512,
-0.0009280566,
0.0709917247,
0.048166953,
0.0005909317,
0.1017215252,
0.0166543722,
-0.0524393208,
-0.042653989,
-0.0272380002,
0.0542242303,
0.0807392597,
0.0355714597,
0.0369775072,
0.005414566,
0.0460032932,
-0.0676159486,
0.0232551005,
-0.0314720571,
0.0790792406,
-0.0055388408,
0.008674196,
0.0173797309,
0.0056211925,
-0.0175975282,
-0.003863856,
-0.0484633073,
0.0040280516,
0.0524955988,
-0.0023100404,
0.0294508021,
0.0304771848,
0.0487795286,
-0.0334412456,
-0.0230936464,
0.0046729059,
0.013415711,
0.0151321068,
0.0206296109,
0.0250970945,
-0.0387387723,
-0.011900777,
0.0298295543,
-0.0069178208,
0.0158415101,
0.0110090971,
0.0241570361,
-0.0013587332,
-0.0277791545,
-0.0220774952,
-0.0584250391,
-0.0207676012,
0.0130012482,
0.0139303431,
0.0376364551,
-0.0149977952,
-0.0408335477,
0.0597527437,
-0.0342125855,
-0.0197327025,
-0.0009141143,
-0.0316465497,
-0.0369267724,
0.0635875314,
-0.0028027643,
0.0031812878,
-0.0533091426,
-0.0583277382,
0.0580817126,
-0.0647030696,
-0.021507388,
0.0476124175,
2.598e-7,
0.0264832135,
0.0292899981,
0.0236264374,
0.0017186122,
-0.0168439001,
0.0296496525,
-0.0304366816,
0.0087399194,
-0.0220729169,
-0.0415846258,
-0.0172887743,
0.0880251378,
0.0434295647,
0.0024763276,
-0.0232948195,
0.0507329442,
-0.0314602107,
-0.0255440734,
-0.0545895919,
-0.0141282519,
0.0364264995,
0.009430903,
-0.0071569779,
-0.006750071,
0.0182457101,
-0.0249108505,
0.0316279419,
-0.0574160405,
0.0378570557,
-0.0313843936,
0.0382152572,
-0.0255828667,
-0.0085474206,
0.0086394409,
0.0209462177,
-0.0354844742,
0.0263309199,
0.0293825064,
-0.0280441865,
-0.0426474772,
-0.010479277,
-0.0113685913,
-0.0234260205,
-0.084103547,
0.0792605579,
-0.0630452409,
0.0061228685,
0.0243091956,
-0.0067055179,
-0.0297434963,
0.0127297761,
0.0096869925,
-0.0136256795,
-0.0317535847,
0.0159557667,
-0.0249452516,
-0.023923317,
-0.0968789533,
-0.012539872,
0.0152054206,
-0.0301859323,
-0.0035167993,
-0.0324027911,
-0.0215366334,
0.0519345887,
0.0200966131,
-0.1048801839,
1.723921929e-34,
-0.0044711502,
0.0073671853,
0.0130302515,
-0.0104190772,
0.0207606331,
-0.0148602426,
-0.0588300601,
0.0057653547,
-0.0231219903,
-0.0316291079,
0.02446674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13236v1 | Data Contamination Can Cross Language Barriers | 2024-06-19T05:53:27 | 2024-06-19T05:53:27 | Feng Yao, Yufan Zhuang, Zihao Sun, Sunan Xu, Animesh Kumar, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The opacity in developing large language models (LLMs) is raising growing
concerns about the potential contamination of public benchmarks in the
pre-training data. Existing contamination detection methods are typically based
on the text overlap between training and evaluation data, which can be too
superficial to reflect deeper forms of contamination. In this paper, we first
present a cross-lingual form of contamination that inflates LLMs' performance
while evading current detection methods, deliberately injected by overfitting
LLMs on the translated versions of benchmark test sets. Then, we propose
generalization-based approaches to unmask such deeply concealed contamination.
Specifically, we examine the LLM's performance change after modifying the
original benchmark by replacing the false answer choices with correct ones from
other questions. Contaminated models can hardly generalize to such easier
situations, where the false choices can be \emph{not even wrong}, as all
choices are correct in their memorization. Experimental results demonstrate
that cross-lingual contamination can easily fool existing detection methods,
but not ours. In addition, we discuss the potential utilization of
cross-lingual contamination in interpreting LLMs' working mechanisms and in
post-training LLMs for enhanced multilingual capabilities. The code and dataset
we use can be obtained from \url{https://github.com/ShangDataLab/Deep-Contam}. | [
0.018890867,
0.0836329237,
-0.0356767923,
0.0729759932,
-0.032586135,
0.0130231511,
0.0074301641,
-0.0019799159,
-0.0037327402,
-0.0223766137,
-0.0260613859,
-0.038226109,
0.0215321761,
0.0107025728,
0.0357096605,
-0.0046889922,
0.0822261646,
-0.0271476004,
-0.045219779,
-0.0385223553,
-0.005736982,
-0.0211897437,
0.0422958434,
0.0087142279,
0.013678709,
-0.0126124928,
-0.0013939395,
-0.0288979188,
-0.0031117352,
-0.0214213673,
0.0000224055,
0.0500981919,
-0.0015994492,
0.0794221163,
0.00000218,
-0.0326703377,
-0.0217954312,
-0.0040211277,
-0.0061804671,
0.0592287257,
0.008381159,
-0.0241301805,
0.0054879719,
0.0192678031,
-0.0300658308,
-0.0409264974,
0.0294024441,
0.0118748527,
0.0517121777,
0.064604871,
0.0060165757,
0.033680696,
0.0217406787,
-0.0200999789,
0.0208728351,
-0.0397228301,
0.0298553333,
0.0058907429,
-0.0178545788,
-0.0019113267,
-0.0445289686,
0.0422359705,
0.0404485203,
0.0435718596,
-0.0526228249,
0.0031167911,
-0.0392977186,
-0.0204562787,
0.0055773384,
0.0855309591,
-0.0385349654,
-0.0162479337,
-0.0092018442,
-0.0172210038,
-0.0159295313,
0.001608256,
-0.0254917145,
0.0213144403,
0.0054535223,
0.0101861926,
-0.0047553726,
-0.0254126005,
0.0527824126,
0.0062825326,
-0.0364083685,
0.0837231204,
0.0305582993,
-0.0422784574,
0.0085702296,
0.0102213556,
-0.0089544123,
-0.0676333159,
0.019985022,
0.004218,
-0.0254446119,
0.0407228842,
-0.0244877245,
-0.0558703989,
0.0522376485,
-0.0388093255,
0.0149706202,
0.0337154083,
-0.0656954497,
0.0319595486,
-0.0373762436,
0.0880783796,
-0.0331052206,
0.0484271534,
-0.0595421791,
-0.0254833046,
0.0291712601,
-0.0115327081,
-0.0123551674,
0.0177568998,
-0.0134213101,
0.0145687778,
-0.0509507172,
0.010052369,
-0.0575050302,
0.0323030613,
-0.037001837,
-0.0174164157,
-0.0274528954,
0.0075630234,
-0.0230128858,
0.0202293675,
-0.0373632088,
0.0162732732,
-0.0047079967,
-0.0834953636,
-0.0120835481,
-0.0024368246,
-0.0167806055,
-0.0370497406,
0.0290091764,
0.0633239597,
-0.0016687718,
-0.0131696342,
-0.000999904,
-0.0236563142,
-0.0116752582,
-0.0504184552,
0.0110330274,
-0.0728745982,
0.0495810956,
0.0016144917,
0.0211110208,
-0.0486511365,
-0.001304822,
0.0526754148,
-0.0297229122,
0.0621801428,
-0.0083201211,
0.0060676001,
-4.311e-7,
0.0165624283,
-0.0060963989,
0.0825828016,
0.0143325627,
0.0045845252,
0.0580856167,
-0.0345210694,
0.0087241763,
0.0623052716,
0.0327583738,
0.0280385576,
-0.0112152901,
0.0163652077,
0.0634167045,
0.0145464055,
0.0264166985,
0.0402104966,
-0.0190305207,
-0.0360996313,
0.0426443815,
0.019228356,
-0.0284722075,
0.0089507587,
0.014158166,
-0.0128314961,
0.0086062821,
0.0739629194,
-0.0437847078,
-0.0426490791,
-0.0293521918,
-0.0043373038,
0.017017914,
0.0461279042,
-0.0273295492,
-0.0345418006,
-0.0197849777,
-0.0167098753,
0.0332085155,
0.0384320803,
0.0653909147,
0.0099850297,
-0.0436149202,
0.0259754881,
0.0275128987,
-0.0485533103,
0.0260216873,
-0.0448676944,
0.0301279612,
0.0301122852,
0.0347154588,
-0.02487031,
0.0089400988,
0.0002430375,
0.0068700244,
0.0058892472,
0.0572662652,
-0.0124118514,
0.0316095315,
-0.0483495519,
-0.0219908953,
-0.0235847812,
0.0089092636,
0.0461265184,
0.0125553058,
0.0106785111,
0.0373595133,
-0.0408059731,
-0.0321637988,
0.0422216505,
-0.0305920765,
-0.0181874335,
0.0131190997,
0.0004665932,
0.0191886257,
0.0013733397,
-0.00063933,
0.0016424244,
0.036283385,
-0.0158359781,
-0.0050444668,
-0.0186956581,
-0.0482451618,
-0.0078562601,
0.0341886841,
-0.041031789,
-0.0346460976,
0.0769515634,
-0.0401976071,
-0.04312215,
-0.003539192,
0.0103785684,
0.0216631833,
-0.0267299488,
0.0432225838,
-0.0298865195,
0.0280728526,
-0.0321198404,
0.0566301048,
-0.0125627993,
0.0656838939,
0.0172688458,
-0.0068110223,
0.0495106317,
-0.0418288037,
-0.0636714771,
0.0373675749,
-0.0189283453,
0.0216009859,
0.0296962168,
-0.0027148705,
-0.0518475734,
0.0207718872,
-0.0872276649,
0.0280191973,
-0.0187651236,
-0.0071614045,
0.0095364703,
0.0027317551,
-0.0083704172,
-0.0112318387,
-0.0504942648,
-0.0098899808,
0.0281952508,
0.063279748,
0.0002988179,
-0.0065200385,
0.0322606675,
-0.0181786902,
-0.0263601523,
-0.0255776662,
0.0449099839,
-0.0308592115,
0.0001480085,
-0.0572586209,
0.0319365524,
-0.0474429429,
0.0281206295,
-0.0246407557,
-0.0241323207,
0.0051354831,
0.0007312981,
0.0013999185,
0.0589104891,
-0.0301883724,
-0.0260847621,
0.077196233,
-0.0089038266,
-0.073813282,
0.0086492673,
0.0055981064,
-0.0518832467,
-0.0118458429,
-0.0703544617,
-0.0087377885,
0.0649490431,
0.0078523606,
-0.035103444,
-0.0430353023,
0.0077730799,
-0.0656069443,
-0.0323165879,
-0.0515142307,
-0.0003520332,
-0.0062758466,
0.0545146354,
-0.0211070701,
-0.0561362766,
0.067207478,
-0.02499431,
0.0023744458,
-0.0542796254,
0.0190754291,
-0.0380860344,
0.0415557288,
0.0031968346,
0.0233610906,
0.0027324543,
-0.0195343494,
-0.057774853,
-0.0010135495,
0.0041406932,
-0.058991652,
0.0408794433,
-0.0346437506,
-0.0251061283,
-0.0169447511,
-0.0466007292,
-0.0496314801,
-0.0320445634,
-0.0053452831,
-0.0143860979,
0.01446681,
0.0190885328,
-0.0091290623,
-0.0218382329,
0.017679546,
0.0392337181,
-0.0017060407,
0.0305145718,
-0.0282858629,
0.0106863566,
0.0358356908,
-0.0289723631,
0.0419438519,
-0.0623697564,
-0.0076318681,
0.0556775406,
0.043840006,
0.006748212,
-0.0028765709,
0.0055521498,
0.0472047031,
0.007552559,
-0.0304786488,
0.0060718604,
0.0332507752,
-0.074131228,
0.0029686424,
0.0772061944,
0.0221080333,
-0.0191393569,
0.0109305652,
-0.0082844393,
0.0145792067,
0.0259772595,
0.0163263343,
-0.1278043985,
-0.0041098818,
0.0240981784,
-0.0085100885,
-0.0268214773,
-0.0085772797,
-0.0206963215,
-0.1572633982,
-0.0030567949,
0.01549167,
-0.0708522052,
-0.0047542984,
-0.055051811,
-0.0263113789,
-0.0056110877,
0.060648147,
-0.0071442695,
0.0189970825,
-0.0042700646,
-0.0144435521,
-0.0127670933,
-0.0789099261,
0.0196777284,
-0.0142661752,
0.0408638865,
0.0294592269,
0.0197505094,
-0.0296771452,
-0.0248829499,
0.0634731725,
-0.0389180258,
-0.0241289437,
-0.0223109499,
0.0451260246,
0.0250925701,
-0.0316413827,
0.0265289042,
-0.0116257155,
-0.0059878752,
0.0043495419,
0.0299885217,
0.0792172551,
0.0175914653,
-0.0339370184,
0.0094646588,
-0.0192644577,
0.0070299124,
0.0791338757,
0.0038707303,
-0.0482842363,
-0.0180689059,
-0.0443027429,
0.0002604506,
-0.0277312864,
0.0091012819,
0.0446394645,
-0.0161049161,
-0.0130336406,
-0.0487178788,
-0.0541393682,
0.0214567557,
0.0092252363,
0.0363810696,
0.033200074,
-0.0324019305,
-0.0169783141,
-0.0237896778,
0.0595107488,
-0.0513226725,
0.0472058766,
-0.043955747,
0.0120497905,
-0.0189820845,
0.0004579926,
-0.0142548149,
0.0438523553,
-0.0939849988,
-0.0884323344,
0.00484786,
0.0406145006,
0.0278556645,
0.0425196774,
0.0032484005,
-0.0607478209,
0.0247681383,
-0.0192310363,
-0.0257456638,
0.0162558407,
0.0427220091,
-0.0391679667,
0.0071368925,
0.0280318093,
-0.0435498469,
-0.0175679624,
0.0388603508,
0.0290856212,
-0.040176414,
0.0108930366,
0.0308731943,
0.0312519111,
0.0536260568,
0.0024650937,
-0.0043506557,
-0.034814138,
0.0314696915,
-0.0376485661,
-0.0282796137,
-0.021341471,
-0.0013361289,
0.0365623198,
-0.0073007778,
0.0089276545,
0.0122201098,
-0.017381046,
0.0405619703,
-0.0515698828,
0.0096270004,
0.0510418341,
0.0289515611,
0.059791714,
0.0114002274,
-0.0170674436,
0.0300346483,
0.0173439346,
0.0537889488,
-0.0045424551,
0.0333418809,
0.0006818055,
-0.004110327,
-0.0107145365,
-0.0198868159,
-0.0620070435,
-0.0339717641,
-0.0013923426,
0.0266638324,
0.0364986286,
-0.0167297237,
0.0296347011,
0.008369064,
-0.0215774179,
-0.0290424284,
-0.0156999547,
0.0031824205,
-0.0323658772,
0.0424276404,
0.0016559762,
-0.0248118844,
0.0326030441,
0.1022350937,
0.0187539794,
0.0463798679,
-0.0323564038,
0.0043913266,
-0.0196918435,
-0.0036014463,
0.0521539301,
0.041768875,
-0.0567324162,
-0.024820447,
-0.0381328538,
-0.1025453955,
0.0024519991,
0.0117216865,
0.009238489,
-0.0057465392,
-0.0181734823,
0.087389268,
-0.0077468632,
0.0008578656,
-0.0530872047,
0.0245339517,
0.0049700649,
-0.0190905184,
-0.0086397789,
-6.66105188e-33,
0.003076104,
-0.0112695731,
0.0078892363,
-0.0232048854,
0.0107273487,
0.0493624471,
-0.0193055142,
0.0003565022,
-0.04288451,
-0.004169073,
-0.0147456564,
0.0077696792,
0.0143375434,
0.0127882687,
-0.0112030441,
-0.0170117151,
0.0416392833,
0.0263543185,
-0.0419783928,
0.0017022415,
0.0269140452,
0.0162652638,
0.0605615489,
-0.061852742,
0.055275891,
-0.0207562242,
-0.0160284452,
0.0213790815,
-0.0407878906,
0.0641468391,
-0.0155046061,
0.0741178021,
0.0202168208,
-0.0226454977,
-0.0373098925,
0.0056007439,
-0.0622363761,
-0.0237303115,
0.040673025,
0.0385881998,
-0.0200697538,
-0.0326376259,
0.0445729084,
-0.0357328579,
-0.0174179859,
0.0094771208,
0.0157755353,
-0.0316241607,
-0.0531979837,
-0.0047854576,
-0.0262804218,
0.0163921528,
0.0129052037,
0.0231472626,
0.0201628152,
0.090172708,
0.0071011707,
0.0282073822,
-0.0711240098,
0.0242468733,
0.0488339029,
0.0070397472,
0.0838691667,
0.0360884443,
0.0168824717,
0.0579092987,
0.0352996141,
0.0316010416,
0.049349077,
-0.0332587026,
0.0463434197,
-0.0050022546,
0.0685767829,
0.0622257665,
0.0553415604,
-0.0318246707,
-0.0860865265,
0.0068334993,
-0.005080712,
0.0026821515,
0.0213388652,
0.0073038847,
-0.0397316441,
-0.0349972434,
-0.0751958415,
0.0008957539,
-0.0506030172,
-0.0182087552,
0.0474316776,
0.0071592326,
-0.0289059337,
0.0056478507,
0.0335307494,
-0.0342384093,
-0.0161829479,
0.0156689696,
-0.0076235593,
0.0030393093,
0.0079885358,
0.0678325668,
-0.0313093588,
-0.0298841856,
-0.0314149782,
-0.0266358852,
0.0423771143,
0.0251660235,
0.0495280139,
-0.0023291225,
-0.0675988048,
0.0073400089,
-0.0450825058,
-0.0023098784,
0.0158450436,
0.0003504642,
0.0540940203,
-0.0001456372,
0.0039627901,
0.0381955691,
0.0555260181,
0.0229702499,
-0.0552835688,
-0.0098428624,
0.007299508,
0.0270306077,
-0.0085447766,
-0.0344356447,
-0.0142388269,
0.032397747,
0.0615488701,
-0.0448797643,
-0.0128141101,
0.0023743443,
2.784e-7,
0.0263234191,
0.0283919759,
-0.0120153865,
0.0138036339,
-0.0027438516,
0.0229013413,
-0.0482274368,
0.0118171414,
0.0144380648,
-0.0079891467,
-0.0140888421,
0.0050908807,
0.059626963,
0.0509387366,
-0.0739078075,
0.0058909967,
-0.0318079218,
-0.0053298543,
-0.065280579,
0.0198817011,
0.0050710719,
0.1011363044,
0.0024295042,
-0.0192750692,
-0.0079807136,
-0.0681507364,
0.0603624806,
-0.0461322069,
-0.0427283607,
0.0225665644,
0.032787174,
0.0488118865,
0.018705532,
0.0390887372,
-0.0186197776,
0.0065234485,
0.047223784,
0.0351438485,
0.0123710698,
-0.0175426863,
-0.0197599344,
-0.0526875332,
-0.0322457813,
-0.0882634744,
0.0895726457,
-0.0159893893,
-0.0202000178,
-0.0588195883,
-0.0082125645,
-0.0422833413,
0.0672718436,
-0.0243800469,
-0.0194777101,
0.0088964039,
0.0192208588,
0.0041526291,
-0.0231556352,
-0.0374964364,
-0.0260546096,
0.0029579222,
-0.0362387486,
-0.0526749566,
-0.0342704542,
-0.0148975737,
-0.0130164726,
-0.0596586503,
0.0289580617,
2.902810979e-34,
0.0621838123,
-0.0416063257,
0.0231268536,
-0.0216702186,
0.0451036468,
-0.0254468117,
-0.0123045919,
0.009289911,
-0.005811472,
-0.0586925708,
-0.0071268869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13232v1 | Towards Robust Evaluation: A Comprehensive Taxonomy of Datasets and Metrics for Open Domain Question Answering in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T05:43:02 | 2024-06-19T05:43:02 | Akchay Srivastava, Atif Memon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Open Domain Question Answering (ODQA) within natural language processing
involves building systems that answer factual questions using large-scale
knowledge corpora. Recent advances stem from the confluence of several factors,
such as large-scale training datasets, deep learning techniques, and the rise
of large language models. High-quality datasets are used to train models on
realistic scenarios and enable the evaluation of the system on potentially
unseen data. Standardized metrics facilitate comparisons between different ODQA
systems, allowing researchers to objectively track advancements in the field.
Our study presents a thorough examination of the current landscape of ODQA
benchmarking by reviewing 52 datasets and 20 evaluation techniques across
textual and multimodal modalities. We introduce a novel taxonomy for ODQA
datasets that incorporates both the modality and difficulty of the question
types. Additionally, we present a structured organization of ODQA evaluation
metrics along with a critical analysis of their inherent trade-offs. Our study
aims to empower researchers by providing a framework for the robust evaluation
of modern question-answering systems. We conclude by identifying the current
challenges and outlining promising avenues for future research and development. | [
0.0381640233,
0.052602604,
0.0039732112,
0.0382576138,
-0.0299821347,
0.0117046069,
0.001913102,
-0.0087205619,
-0.0044804881,
-0.0529943816,
-0.0399675816,
-0.0483299606,
-0.0200715382,
0.044669684,
-0.0093670366,
-0.010731888,
0.0432150997,
-0.0095348908,
-0.0210952312,
0.0127615398,
0.006615906,
0.0182269718,
-0.0058767041,
0.0593441166,
0.0138055393,
-0.0313238278,
0.0046783867,
-0.0080991536,
0.0130090434,
-0.0175392982,
0.0237058476,
0.0239813775,
0.0298844781,
0.0362713337,
0.0000015583,
-0.0656097755,
0.0073896362,
0.0075627062,
-0.046560429,
-0.0179641768,
0.0056592003,
-0.0045405841,
0.0541240983,
0.0237052161,
-0.0478645787,
-0.0315444507,
0.061800614,
0.0152135855,
0.0709104463,
0.0178768393,
0.0194104388,
-0.0274005253,
0.0100686792,
0.0134695629,
-0.0381292067,
-0.0587110929,
0.0125938449,
0.0146129671,
0.0097172102,
0.0178327356,
-0.0130856559,
0.0152846407,
0.0484091453,
0.0131221125,
-0.0099563068,
-0.0075105834,
-0.0464348197,
-0.0012392495,
0.0107022086,
0.1473073512,
0.0354274996,
0.0041564698,
-0.0408463776,
-0.0017178361,
-0.0073067928,
0.015337226,
-0.0539872609,
0.0258607157,
0.0083674956,
-0.006924836,
-0.041519165,
0.0467276983,
0.0079823714,
0.0414713919,
-0.0082330229,
0.0560966246,
-0.0033715339,
-0.0219572149,
0.0417576581,
-0.0179059971,
-0.0705193803,
-0.0436217748,
-0.0124561107,
0.0651085153,
-0.0090438388,
0.0108273597,
-0.0366395749,
-0.0337711461,
0.0451250933,
-0.0525677726,
0.033505626,
0.0101320762,
-0.0475355089,
0.0747661814,
-0.0046517872,
0.0565453619,
-0.0364313163,
0.0057951207,
-0.0413733758,
-0.0569122508,
-0.0361235924,
-0.0062133409,
-0.0350379571,
0.0164612178,
-0.041081354,
-0.0262976587,
-0.020818796,
0.0212388262,
-0.0039901035,
-0.0112610338,
0.0057682414,
0.0633674487,
0.0145515818,
0.0061689797,
-0.0750416294,
0.0427364372,
-0.0668692514,
0.0309587382,
-0.0012870736,
-0.0646416023,
-0.0124237398,
0.0147750918,
0.0100423601,
-0.0291884895,
0.0048673828,
0.0852739513,
0.0211657993,
-0.0075857802,
-0.0112656057,
-0.0517255515,
-0.001957278,
-0.0571306832,
-0.002270805,
-0.0735066906,
0.0099247219,
0.0152159389,
-0.0260164458,
-0.0351094455,
0.0086782929,
0.0499929078,
-0.0008155093,
0.0647947118,
-0.0080943825,
-0.029370673,
0.0423889868,
0.0140143903,
0.0091362549,
0.0695446432,
0.0068464982,
-0.0148057081,
0.0834686831,
0.0241527651,
0.02504378,
0.0387539119,
0.0148709137,
0.0132362098,
0.0220225267,
0.090248391,
0.0145541262,
0.043761529,
-0.0081816027,
0.0416927077,
-0.012536034,
-0.0803802311,
0.0380206108,
0.0352055281,
0.0050138934,
0.0111018922,
0.0335315093,
-0.010035634,
0.0407781266,
-0.0096213771,
-0.0025955329,
0.0240897667,
-0.0206945967,
-0.0078860242,
0.0166173447,
0.015763063,
-0.0288332719,
-0.0607125275,
-0.0198506098,
-0.0055130185,
-0.008020591,
0.0251937378,
0.0476959869,
0.0192681719,
-0.0308039133,
0.0325835012,
-0.000421126,
-0.0072703199,
-0.0038927863,
-0.0422560312,
0.0338976979,
0.0006493148,
0.0474151485,
-0.0697190389,
-0.0203076079,
-0.0204795897,
0.0367771275,
0.0305585694,
0.0178158358,
-0.0141768232,
0.0360601731,
-0.0250582602,
-0.0164409615,
-0.0279243123,
-0.0112590836,
-0.0101810358,
0.039812047,
0.0168802142,
0.0009047522,
-0.0696516857,
-0.0087292595,
0.0250853039,
0.0025442576,
-0.0418920107,
0.027561076,
-0.0051607243,
0.0170776825,
0.0266796891,
-0.0222418476,
0.0166934766,
0.0424930118,
-0.0133107584,
-0.0389548689,
-0.0292671658,
-0.0338622704,
0.0088860122,
0.0209476054,
-0.0395340957,
-0.0338827111,
0.0842206702,
-0.0536289811,
-0.0132830748,
-0.0084211864,
-0.0422108695,
-0.0273948181,
-0.0617002174,
-0.0459751189,
-0.0036363134,
0.035937354,
-0.0483371466,
0.0666771531,
-0.0112293866,
0.0221593678,
0.0067091733,
0.0221146587,
0.0536694303,
-0.0114420028,
-0.0269136298,
-0.0070196125,
-0.0213110521,
0.0257729311,
0.0139037212,
0.0060437974,
-0.0743010119,
0.0142291049,
-0.0847056359,
0.0231533572,
-0.0347823165,
0.031925872,
0.0344875455,
0.0005429369,
0.0060691754,
-0.0169917699,
-0.0460006408,
-0.0040671402,
0.0418628566,
0.015533871,
0.0645864233,
0.0243410096,
0.0169472117,
-0.0159376618,
-0.0242643543,
0.0009132575,
0.0990149975,
-0.0177126862,
0.0462796763,
-0.0223323312,
-0.0075419322,
-0.0670991838,
0.0366471,
0.0117846066,
-0.011445527,
0.0129540879,
0.014315322,
0.0059562721,
0.0344563052,
0.0008548513,
0.0001324929,
0.0235368032,
0.0127965342,
-0.0199310239,
-0.0043615294,
-0.0235079303,
-0.0503652282,
-0.0089578433,
-0.0070022633,
-0.0013459275,
0.005502807,
-0.0100614056,
-0.0235656518,
-0.0079832617,
0.0275574885,
-0.0193439294,
-0.024712041,
-0.0664313734,
0.0102345049,
-0.0020766051,
0.0520167015,
-0.0150371306,
-0.0295443349,
0.0647788495,
0.0011353353,
0.0034134306,
-0.0460247807,
-0.0099395839,
-0.0768094286,
0.0875597745,
-0.0329407267,
0.0040523089,
0.0248010494,
0.0111284452,
-0.0330823883,
-0.0162064191,
-0.0081355916,
-0.0487180799,
0.0443263836,
-0.0330023095,
0.009168434,
-0.0154589582,
-0.0220034178,
-0.0466460325,
-0.0596168824,
-0.035260912,
0.0337043405,
-0.0246821512,
-0.0109640434,
-0.0122172087,
0.0036249114,
-0.0045605609,
0.0008281386,
-0.0115882866,
-0.0027710621,
-0.0148246912,
0.1109168753,
0.0744120404,
0.0810108483,
0.0330780596,
0.0065248609,
0.038330663,
0.062556915,
0.0159299634,
-0.0206195768,
-0.0296011921,
-0.0003364352,
0.001432214,
-0.0220159031,
0.0111161619,
0.0186065994,
0.0449057333,
-0.0420960262,
-0.0229307991,
0.1041130051,
0.0413333625,
0.0137982154,
-0.0049099443,
-0.018031178,
0.0085569136,
0.0155407544,
0.0021638563,
-0.0934724435,
-0.0613968112,
-0.0454431809,
0.0265776068,
-0.0085701738,
-0.0406276025,
-0.0042278343,
-0.1183478534,
0.0065717306,
-0.0557398647,
-0.0630394295,
-0.0406719409,
-0.0430584364,
0.0102593377,
-0.0198779609,
0.0216329079,
-0.0190911666,
0.0106118033,
-0.0012235785,
0.0069276369,
0.0058351681,
-0.017893048,
0.0825122967,
-0.0626322329,
0.0199760068,
0.0522279851,
0.0135471281,
-0.0067817853,
-0.0269355811,
-0.0038287516,
-0.0593549088,
-0.0162908081,
0.0186226293,
0.0477099381,
0.0046994821,
-0.0174865536,
-0.0459479131,
0.0302066188,
-0.0378734991,
0.0130732451,
0.0212619659,
0.0837017968,
-0.0127655081,
0.0209197961,
-0.0321657397,
0.0043314951,
-0.0048329677,
0.0669389442,
0.0171912462,
-0.0314052217,
-0.0419792868,
-0.0109984754,
-0.0190538876,
-0.0407097265,
-0.0339047052,
0.0155583061,
0.0341555886,
0.043901749,
-0.0834029093,
-0.0371363945,
0.0411875769,
0.0069458866,
-0.0408630781,
-0.0182023551,
-0.0124063408,
0.0371684246,
-0.0539738946,
0.05374562,
-0.0101053733,
0.0305505842,
-0.0454358272,
0.0171652362,
0.0257042665,
-0.0164199341,
-0.0484708622,
0.0557560883,
-0.0798907951,
-0.010993951,
-0.0166948289,
0.014236371,
0.0164082889,
-0.0338807032,
-0.0215433203,
-0.0746293515,
0.0258386713,
0.0257720836,
-0.0306021422,
-0.0150446724,
0.0367861316,
0.014584098,
-0.0001967281,
0.0389125794,
-0.0660870969,
-0.020135656,
-0.013321328,
0.0180932637,
-0.001404781,
-0.0476160757,
0.0267960131,
-0.0053921915,
0.0081691993,
0.0300810952,
-0.043696586,
0.0038098108,
0.0114637539,
-0.0039445986,
-0.0317389779,
-0.0397373699,
0.0363912098,
0.027339533,
-0.005333168,
-0.0130228093,
0.036524605,
-0.0096636005,
0.0480119996,
-0.0510537215,
0.0089627607,
0.0702869669,
0.001246976,
-0.0324345529,
-0.0034527024,
-0.0420072004,
-0.0093398467,
-0.0224285778,
0.0470420159,
0.0037976671,
0.0588227399,
0.0162652303,
-0.0005693032,
0.0095351562,
0.0288008116,
-0.074838154,
-0.0249939039,
-0.0149476733,
0.0457852706,
0.0372213908,
0.0132558262,
-0.0011457568,
0.0064219376,
-0.0393096656,
-0.0155917555,
-0.0223964676,
-0.0036339818,
-0.0119362287,
0.0514836013,
0.0356520265,
-0.0056648157,
0.033183109,
0.0658852756,
0.0208568145,
0.0347240455,
0.0129409041,
-0.0127802705,
-0.0063081528,
-0.0120104188,
-0.0013904212,
0.0158264246,
0.0170306265,
0.0205306169,
-0.056268014,
-0.0543611236,
0.008598798,
0.0146195916,
-0.0165666118,
0.0059271744,
0.0599068478,
0.0363330618,
0.0317236744,
-0.0218870733,
-0.033634223,
0.0230249371,
-0.0354273841,
-0.0109221805,
-0.0168235768,
-5.566865004e-33,
0.0171958022,
-0.0399322025,
0.0014321075,
-0.0637689233,
-0.0311135221,
0.0248267036,
0.0123772072,
-0.002551792,
-0.0497215465,
0.0149894496,
0.0031036129,
0.0073688482,
-0.0063899625,
0.0429025665,
-0.0339307003,
-0.0653246269,
-0.0261567086,
-0.0490098186,
-0.0290985294,
0.0113174701,
0.034635704,
0.0032697846,
0.0338637643,
-0.0237160269,
0.0414608568,
-0.0145283649,
-0.0016053941,
0.0370159298,
-0.0028082666,
0.1015298143,
-0.0308237411,
0.0733859912,
0.0291620642,
-0.0568852611,
0.01825523,
0.04383054,
-0.0849131942,
-0.0256946031,
0.0076739253,
0.0013914877,
-0.089638181,
0.0238121599,
0.0090033216,
0.0182286166,
0.011002467,
-0.0339595601,
0.0300758556,
-0.0278036464,
0.0305685103,
-0.0221399851,
-0.0046523865,
0.0304252729,
-0.0221753102,
-0.0397648439,
-0.0390695557,
0.0652483031,
-0.0100002922,
0.0178502817,
-0.0385440998,
-0.0187662356,
-0.0026885744,
0.0077032153,
0.0533493906,
0.0095049441,
-0.0100118462,
0.0327798389,
-0.0134624289,
-0.0146528194,
-0.0560845956,
-0.0108232331,
-0.0284753591,
0.033123076,
0.0854235739,
0.0931009576,
0.0350102894,
0.0610901266,
-0.1071247384,
0.0376269892,
-0.0427851863,
0.0280429665,
0.0005100644,
-0.0371417925,
-0.0040908172,
0.0134469289,
-0.0826346949,
0.0561340004,
-0.0411955342,
0.0067061009,
0.0455025807,
-0.0393001139,
-0.0247024503,
-0.0082592526,
0.0358403139,
-0.0634524375,
0.0239197221,
0.0505506136,
0.0069811894,
0.0319331884,
0.04456947,
0.0454777554,
-0.0162317008,
0.0504494272,
0.0441994332,
-0.0067508933,
0.0095934188,
-0.0221715048,
0.005210707,
0.0107689966,
-0.0340543836,
0.0169133618,
-0.0333319306,
0.0203390643,
-0.0410322323,
0.0388362147,
0.0140580721,
0.0128192967,
-0.0288776308,
0.0459793098,
0.0087757101,
0.0290454868,
-0.0408674739,
-0.0418636799,
0.0214210078,
-0.008265648,
-0.0370881185,
0.0219599064,
-0.0285620186,
-0.0074694129,
-0.0363461077,
-0.0569937266,
0.0026283462,
0.0406068452,
2.153e-7,
0.0733323768,
-0.0038573444,
0.0263656992,
0.057004977,
0.0032781607,
0.0274728201,
0.0342000574,
0.0515402779,
-0.0105817607,
-0.0396088883,
-0.006380565,
0.027590327,
0.0237982646,
0.0368567258,
-0.0423420817,
-0.020010313,
-0.054272335,
-0.0181319583,
-0.0350920372,
-0.012327644,
0.0793138891,
0.093023248,
-0.000716879,
-0.0174494274,
-0.0251361467,
-0.0619695783,
0.0469509885,
0.0063049258,
0.0175984204,
-0.024044292,
0.0321662575,
0.0105464784,
0.0319884792,
0.0178935416,
0.0099076778,
-0.0000964171,
0.0534078889,
0.0284026656,
0.0284386482,
-0.0708939955,
-0.0335299969,
-0.0429262072,
0.0012043822,
-0.0570811704,
0.1037681326,
-0.0332761854,
-0.0408448838,
-0.0168229248,
-0.0139026968,
-0.019247381,
0.0547436029,
-0.0307184868,
-0.0040912544,
0.0180901214,
0.0183976535,
-0.0130145112,
0.0130290706,
-0.065253295,
-0.009523157,
-0.0111589972,
-0.0335405096,
-0.0443199761,
-0.0165970214,
-0.0253288038,
0.0210574195,
-0.0409234501,
-0.0032386819,
1.696826095e-34,
0.02672318,
0.0047239722,
0.0131890774,
0.0031508578,
0.0214299839,
-0.0030909639,
0.0095506227,
-0.0552762002,
0.0458846577,
-0.0955238789,
0.0151866022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13230v1 | Enhancing Language Model Factuality via Activation-Based Confidence Calibration and Guided Decoding | 2024-06-19T05:33:34 | 2024-06-19T05:33:34 | Xin Liu, Farima Fatahi Bayat, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Calibrating language models (LMs) aligns their generation confidence with the
actual likelihood of answer correctness, which can inform users about LMs'
reliability and mitigate hallucinated content. However, prior calibration
methods, such as self-consistency-based and logit-based approaches, are either
limited in inference-time efficiency or fall short of providing informative
signals. Moreover, simply filtering out low-confidence responses reduces the
LM's helpfulness when the answers are correct. Therefore, effectively using
calibration techniques to enhance an LM's factuality remains an unsolved
challenge. In this paper, we first propose an activation-based calibration
method, ActCab, which trains a linear layer on top of the LM's last-layer
activations that can better capture the representations of knowledge. Built on
top of ActCab, we further propose CoDec, a confidence-guided decoding strategy
to elicit truthful answers with high confidence from LMs. By evaluating on five
popular QA benchmarks, ActCab achieves superior calibration performance than
all competitive baselines, e.g., by reducing the average expected calibration
error (ECE) score by up to 39%. Further experiments on CoDec show consistent
improvements in several LMs' factuality on challenging QA datasets, such as
TruthfulQA, highlighting the value of confidence signals in enhancing
factuality. | [
0.0339763835,
0.0811768621,
-0.0224808902,
0.0543456264,
-0.0200861208,
-0.000763324,
-0.0154952183,
-0.03894528,
-0.0042921458,
-0.0241447426,
-0.0075754337,
-0.0379184559,
0.0106237428,
0.0367337093,
-0.01747353,
0.0210741237,
0.0388355069,
-0.0118454061,
0.0317548104,
-0.0215962678,
0.0017534081,
0.0035534627,
-0.0292698517,
0.0386993065,
-0.0138881719,
-0.0357110538,
0.0163445845,
0.0026706313,
0.0021709884,
-0.0315379426,
0.0511670671,
0.0629328564,
-0.0049759648,
0.0387740172,
0.0000021534,
-0.0259556286,
-0.0003752467,
-0.0217276514,
-0.074525699,
0.0357371047,
-0.0078348257,
-0.0078294119,
0.0132395476,
0.0345168859,
-0.0655004159,
0.0233900361,
0.0483915731,
0.0159428883,
0.053509362,
0.0538562275,
0.008832817,
-0.0159653686,
0.0565726981,
0.0132142929,
0.0095980857,
-0.0359208472,
-0.0056102909,
0.0676401109,
-0.0524397455,
0.0139842397,
-0.0013921006,
0.0599636659,
0.0426111035,
-0.0288567115,
0.0264902692,
0.039079953,
-0.0209169742,
-0.0130037051,
-0.0147289103,
0.0531272218,
0.0274992269,
-0.0487053916,
-0.0473108999,
-0.0302728713,
0.0022623006,
-0.0227928087,
-0.013754392,
0.0107123135,
0.0014264988,
0.0389966406,
0.0064357067,
0.0220269915,
0.0385677405,
0.0080866767,
0.0232058037,
0.0870511383,
-0.0103044286,
-0.0334751122,
-0.0279750526,
0.0290400442,
0.0222923476,
-0.0358522646,
0.0296064857,
0.0373872966,
0.0002416264,
0.0401460305,
-0.0356154889,
0.0096532507,
0.0298937485,
-0.045950491,
0.0042928346,
0.0465378687,
-0.0293396842,
0.034760043,
-0.0290344562,
0.0671152174,
0.0083327349,
0.0314895511,
-0.0344870873,
-0.0098803714,
-0.0291537791,
-0.0168583635,
-0.0091075143,
0.0086582694,
0.0044930512,
0.022494955,
-0.0631882772,
0.0020676209,
-0.0035070695,
0.0156537928,
-0.0226390865,
0.0299481284,
-0.0350199938,
-0.0269052889,
-0.0566407219,
0.0789336637,
-0.0194345545,
0.0315218419,
0.0167814605,
-0.1137525067,
-0.0144176343,
0.006680815,
-0.018827742,
0.0038493986,
0.013123394,
-0.0318276212,
-0.0086315246,
-0.035437841,
-0.0407603122,
-0.0278237201,
-0.0330275968,
-0.0517487563,
-0.0336620323,
-0.0655769929,
0.0264238324,
0.0148981232,
-0.0085607432,
-0.0438576974,
0.0151635446,
0.0171267707,
-0.0201454293,
0.0759168789,
-0.0159648526,
0.0036869571,
0.0356164575,
0.0077032237,
-0.0109256404,
0.0746053755,
0.0577874109,
0.0197550897,
0.0472935662,
0.0088042868,
0.0476870425,
0.0016693235,
0.0298641846,
-0.0179265924,
0.0004018508,
0.0133499168,
-0.0330170542,
0.0162975546,
0.0368454456,
0.0401337706,
-0.0438657738,
-0.0114899753,
0.1030389592,
-0.0104830442,
0.0006321836,
-0.0128174201,
-0.0162180737,
-0.0059657651,
0.042153351,
-0.0016863446,
-0.0606676899,
0.046635475,
-0.0467205718,
0.0174076371,
0.0256289523,
0.0236095525,
-0.0055997632,
-0.0744572803,
-0.0245563909,
-0.020358175,
0.03051842,
0.0407926254,
0.0120625803,
-0.0045790174,
-0.0302055404,
0.0557360835,
0.0151086794,
-0.0252887085,
0.0163504705,
-0.054906819,
0.0347633138,
0.0137918731,
0.0352716371,
0.0193478204,
-0.0168455057,
-0.0039295512,
0.0071965219,
0.0436054431,
0.0706877485,
-0.0042922734,
0.0004617669,
-0.0665762201,
-0.0192795321,
-0.0076911272,
0.0156849213,
-0.0012720641,
0.02610269,
0.0173578374,
0.0046339724,
-0.0281187352,
-0.0307271127,
0.0258351862,
0.0055376659,
-0.0548440106,
0.0115595311,
-0.0177554544,
0.0063437009,
0.020860875,
-0.0123828333,
0.0313080996,
0.0039194566,
-0.0040158639,
-0.0288142972,
-0.0070935553,
-0.0559454747,
-0.0117182378,
0.0596664511,
-0.0093785794,
-0.0379946381,
0.0375410058,
-0.0198510662,
-0.0194816049,
-0.0035270152,
-0.0382817127,
-0.0037269508,
-0.0720981061,
0.0023055947,
-0.0132376486,
0.0112832496,
-0.0502345897,
0.0535936989,
-0.0233551338,
0.0019686839,
0.0094421888,
-0.0086159352,
0.0339473076,
-0.0141551876,
-0.0118280491,
0.0023533863,
-0.0007534586,
0.0369898155,
0.0356062055,
-0.0191618614,
-0.0334148593,
-0.0057780696,
-0.0662580207,
-0.006413958,
-0.0298519116,
0.0061101657,
0.0225432795,
-0.0047538369,
0.0100468127,
-0.014785042,
-0.0833021626,
0.0030947903,
0.0088080829,
0.0222734697,
0.0173742604,
-0.0210907739,
0.0080407038,
-0.0366430394,
-0.0007683357,
-0.0328228772,
0.0174824148,
0.0270602722,
0.0075586005,
-0.0604350381,
-0.0232810136,
-0.0351356156,
0.0139283091,
-0.0012369315,
-0.0358499661,
0.0214816444,
0.0342119969,
-0.0387819521,
0.0537447482,
0.021521518,
-0.0203733407,
0.0746861994,
0.0433802083,
-0.059790045,
0.0213780999,
-0.0293082707,
-0.0403488427,
-0.0380069949,
-0.0726323053,
0.0043883459,
0.062813364,
0.0586161949,
0.0087596346,
-0.0700354502,
-0.0082945973,
-0.0224335827,
-0.048669152,
-0.0058552921,
-0.0056409189,
-0.0201331433,
0.0533006154,
-0.0210256409,
-0.0514864773,
0.0985467061,
-0.0484183282,
0.0049424851,
-0.0460403338,
-0.006255229,
-0.0053479355,
0.010336386,
-0.0011009288,
0.0167057961,
0.0281876232,
-0.0043756058,
-0.0362162925,
-0.0313176997,
0.0309048891,
-0.0887803286,
0.0264299288,
-0.0459541418,
-0.0019000674,
0.0157245751,
-0.0314902402,
-0.078970097,
-0.0227721855,
-0.0341654271,
0.0033987549,
-0.0057267225,
-0.0033351621,
-0.0182615556,
-0.0205405299,
0.0117297741,
0.0321366973,
-0.0481366254,
-0.0054317317,
-0.0011918051,
0.0370175689,
0.0939082652,
0.0511648841,
0.0796977207,
-0.0057180808,
0.0230759718,
0.0768316463,
-0.0257874094,
0.0407091342,
-0.0283763874,
-0.0230685622,
0.0363097377,
-0.0024210941,
0.0019810179,
0.0423088074,
0.0789013803,
-0.033269465,
-0.0453043245,
0.1330330074,
0.0339166857,
-0.0425006114,
-0.0022974829,
-0.0331113227,
0.0074543371,
0.0107506104,
0.0216218308,
-0.0909325778,
-0.0167240407,
-0.0156439915,
0.0463751256,
-0.0078259427,
-0.0009765985,
0.0006634616,
-0.0967859626,
0.0310424417,
0.0094633177,
0.0040576747,
-0.0778021738,
-0.0414568149,
-0.0139942244,
0.0082471902,
0.0633589178,
0.0339457951,
0.0510844588,
0.0218769647,
0.0317457914,
-0.0449432768,
-0.0449132361,
0.017140599,
-0.0235912576,
0.1036424488,
0.064843066,
0.0089419382,
-0.0000265759,
-0.056946829,
-0.0124229277,
-0.0344048478,
-0.0207219999,
0.0145929074,
0.0407258011,
-0.014227991,
0.0000215702,
-0.0069283056,
0.0223486628,
-0.0216325261,
-0.0118267443,
-0.0089384429,
0.0522296093,
-0.0111123333,
-0.0000427581,
-0.0346420594,
0.0039890697,
0.0068063107,
0.0857280865,
0.0401934646,
-0.0348664708,
-0.0075917412,
-0.052818276,
0.0245155655,
-0.0515396036,
-0.0404357538,
0.0713889226,
0.0468902923,
-0.0091062961,
-0.0600952953,
-0.0513973497,
-0.0004989199,
-0.0196614172,
-0.0302023403,
-0.0006021762,
0.0344185047,
-0.0131112896,
-0.0336818062,
-0.0042940783,
-0.0664665103,
0.0274011977,
-0.0264107957,
0.0318994522,
0.0017609996,
-0.0347236805,
0.0089098038,
0.0073264749,
-0.0919156671,
-0.07316342,
-0.0006713496,
0.038005475,
0.0190763343,
0.0424974672,
-0.0356968045,
-0.0709113702,
0.0331920013,
0.0215129759,
-0.0394754447,
0.0070162383,
0.0200505555,
-0.0015423845,
-0.0088895634,
0.0405665897,
-0.0314783193,
-0.0061493572,
0.0097714644,
0.0757087544,
-0.0474228151,
-0.0605078451,
0.0688130036,
0.0001585966,
0.0407536924,
0.0088243317,
0.005570496,
-0.0012368214,
0.0244539622,
-0.0247726031,
-0.0168122482,
-0.0049420544,
-0.0102089541,
0.0387309529,
-0.035494566,
-0.0061904537,
-0.0699597672,
-0.044661209,
0.0348957703,
-0.0329897143,
-0.0185860787,
0.0154044321,
0.0272940639,
0.0070357285,
-0.0361554734,
-0.0519548953,
0.0145719303,
-0.0074154572,
0.0533448979,
0.0296522398,
0.0391591117,
0.003193283,
-0.0190007258,
-0.0040220791,
-0.0216427781,
-0.0679124221,
-0.0122768609,
-0.0213876758,
-0.0036564288,
0.0410207622,
0.0205972511,
0.0387936085,
-0.0338471904,
-0.005442162,
-0.006886438,
-0.0088004991,
0.0280954689,
-0.0137822693,
0.0494509302,
0.0050318763,
-0.0088977991,
-0.0056776837,
0.0554778501,
-0.0188979935,
0.0376945771,
-0.0279141217,
-0.0267822519,
-0.0135838836,
-0.0318434052,
-0.0314425752,
0.0428218506,
-0.0574264452,
0.0205533076,
-0.0413424671,
-0.0654987842,
0.0402394757,
0.0495099351,
0.0092974696,
-0.0341743603,
-0.004716529,
0.0593988597,
-0.0100376625,
-0.0587971099,
-0.0624317005,
0.0312912352,
-0.0062643965,
0.0172548164,
-0.0450195894,
-6.891958644e-33,
-0.0001928831,
-0.0205807779,
0.0109201083,
0.0089798616,
0.0207416564,
0.034023013,
-0.0081451433,
0.0368296541,
-0.0573203079,
0.0223153252,
-0.0140868062,
0.0304561611,
0.0212769061,
0.0374040976,
0.0036001732,
-0.0186209027,
0.0310089532,
-0.0212131776,
-0.0501478352,
-0.0003571947,
-0.0105657261,
-0.0080712698,
0.0749716163,
-0.1044425741,
0.0649227202,
0.0014522591,
-0.0156674273,
0.0283002909,
-0.0319999829,
0.078827031,
-0.0252636671,
0.0619479194,
0.0181306712,
-0.0254256427,
0.0133898454,
-0.031619262,
-0.0673385412,
-0.032216873,
0.0419073254,
0.0439096689,
-0.034848325,
-0.0111891693,
0.0289797243,
-0.0236753281,
-0.0352934748,
-0.0160774682,
0.0124819493,
-0.0453507453,
-0.0078795888,
-0.0413075238,
-0.0128387986,
0.00758004,
0.0130971046,
-0.009277883,
-0.007035878,
0.0615900904,
-0.0108426865,
0.0183921363,
-0.1035492793,
0.0079935109,
0.0223255921,
0.0235455371,
0.0764494538,
0.0208129752,
-0.0199650098,
0.0523109101,
0.016077375,
-0.0007359468,
-0.0489692651,
0.0004347633,
0.0390857086,
-0.0211494789,
0.0695262328,
0.0762157589,
0.0387479737,
-0.0149700893,
-0.0682337061,
0.0222138856,
0.0511823632,
0.0105573172,
0.0400926806,
0.0120741036,
-0.0802275315,
-0.0122808339,
-0.0619347021,
0.0016178532,
-0.0433499701,
-0.0267997216,
0.0259445664,
0.0135118477,
-0.0353623219,
-0.0136088906,
0.0183442011,
-0.0499259867,
-0.0353378505,
0.0088822264,
0.0218312573,
0.0077092205,
-0.0050837011,
0.0419275761,
-0.0409752391,
0.042663008,
-0.0168995038,
-0.0194464698,
0.0025577422,
0.0200589262,
0.0196284838,
-0.0003592718,
-0.0374562927,
0.0101183783,
-0.0217186268,
0.0026921425,
0.0314057283,
-0.0070656268,
0.0159523059,
0.013138677,
-0.0311325211,
0.0123733487,
-0.0126602855,
0.0339745842,
-0.0416422002,
-0.0397269465,
0.017815778,
0.0390650705,
-0.048187837,
-0.0234794822,
-0.0341052786,
-0.0042052018,
-0.0142440442,
-0.0588941202,
-0.014589767,
0.011025439,
2.764e-7,
0.044266969,
0.0347229354,
0.008641514,
0.0531510003,
0.0042956723,
0.0381466448,
0.0073838243,
0.0136820395,
0.05959877,
-0.0855779722,
-0.0258717444,
0.0273915231,
0.0362243727,
0.0471387841,
-0.0444876999,
-0.0205145571,
-0.0267184004,
0.0274125673,
0.0020019179,
-0.0001593981,
0.0550298467,
0.0828819498,
0.0061322618,
-0.0118230442,
-0.0016091038,
-0.0216767192,
0.0578622483,
0.0056937523,
-0.0201806277,
0.0356196314,
0.0795396939,
0.0109363273,
0.0117918178,
0.0245807394,
-0.0083867507,
0.005209316,
-0.0274067838,
0.0489067584,
-0.0043571885,
-0.0556887202,
-0.054242447,
-0.0172271784,
0.0167107992,
-0.0670340806,
0.0667416379,
-0.0197135769,
-0.0065695848,
-0.0531247891,
-0.0435208157,
-0.0136434427,
0.050900735,
-0.0050922241,
-0.0468500853,
0.0042750677,
0.0293551795,
0.0319341086,
-0.0258337148,
-0.0344413966,
-0.0631478429,
-0.0043095532,
-0.0095202839,
-0.0317551382,
-0.0068639461,
-0.0159455035,
0.0070308,
-0.0676347315,
0.0478671528,
2.601469558e-34,
0.0263203457,
-0.0114826309,
0.0440331772,
0.0393431112,
0.0407586955,
0.0184304882,
0.0155117782,
0.0081458027,
0.0439912155,
-0.0752038881,
-0.0160374865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13229v1 | Probing the Emergence of Cross-lingual Alignment during LLM Training | 2024-06-19T05:31:59 | 2024-06-19T05:31:59 | Hetong Wang, Pasquale Minervini, Edoardo M. Ponti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve remarkable levels of
zero-shot cross-lingual transfer performance. We speculate that this is
predicated on their ability to align languages without explicit supervision
from parallel sentences. While representations of translationally equivalent
sentences in different languages are known to be similar after convergence,
however, it remains unclear how such cross-lingual alignment emerges during
pre-training of LLMs. Our study leverages intrinsic probing techniques, which
identify which subsets of neurons encode linguistic features, to correlate the
degree of cross-lingual neuron overlap with the zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer performance for a given model. In particular, we rely on checkpoints
of BLOOM, a multilingual autoregressive LLM, across different training steps
and model scales. We observe a high correlation between neuron overlap and
downstream performance, which supports our hypothesis on the conditions leading
to effective cross-lingual transfer. Interestingly, we also detect a
degradation of both implicit alignment and multilingual abilities in certain
phases of the pre-training process, providing new insights into the
multilingual pretraining dynamics. | [
-0.0464869142,
0.0114724515,
-0.0264482796,
0.0790827125,
-0.0414254256,
0.0263166521,
0.0273046382,
-0.0389809012,
-0.0265247952,
0.0207970608,
-0.0715129077,
-0.0475036725,
0.0317445472,
-0.0204259269,
0.0204551127,
0.0323802605,
0.0928752497,
-0.0369120203,
-0.0616752319,
-0.020247519,
0.0030834621,
0.0040457216,
-0.0059444821,
0.0041089398,
0.0171119943,
-0.0348741785,
-0.014495424,
-0.0122762714,
0.0281410161,
-0.0014063384,
-0.0430064052,
0.049499698,
0.0112426057,
0.0728137493,
0.0000017325,
-0.0602017231,
0.0120560471,
-0.0045040278,
0.0060762349,
0.0266781729,
0.0100388462,
-0.0589015298,
-0.0103765568,
-0.0276753977,
-0.0075678071,
0.0030860712,
0.0723751411,
0.0283717215,
0.0177312456,
0.0605975538,
-0.0000076838,
-0.0266821906,
0.0077380193,
-0.0430105217,
-0.0106108813,
-0.0541204549,
0.0203720033,
-0.0233719945,
-0.0677178353,
-0.0128351366,
-0.0540178381,
0.0420182236,
0.0237550717,
0.0123318741,
-0.0286911633,
0.0284533706,
0.0124346567,
-0.0371800326,
0.0053668967,
0.0333977342,
-0.0642990842,
-0.030339757,
-0.0299105458,
-0.0184902586,
-0.0031243637,
-0.0434251316,
-0.0703297853,
0.0078143012,
0.0337989815,
0.0494703874,
0.0370492339,
-0.0312875025,
0.0719059557,
-0.0183494277,
-0.034482047,
0.0247987434,
0.0447581038,
-0.0201033372,
0.0158530492,
0.0526819304,
0.0549698658,
-0.0442421697,
-0.0182590429,
0.009244917,
-0.0235885419,
0.0179036576,
-0.0183314402,
0.0017069968,
0.0063376059,
-0.0084918514,
0.0726412311,
0.0738231987,
-0.030082278,
0.037868496,
-0.0572042875,
0.0466635264,
-0.0340784341,
0.0285669677,
-0.0190698747,
-0.0135908406,
-0.0252003204,
-0.0182826072,
0.0195955243,
-0.0144169135,
-0.0085678129,
-0.0165514834,
-0.0400770903,
0.0186146889,
0.0135887824,
-0.0275578201,
-0.0191386621,
-0.0398796871,
-0.0600246303,
0.0212874152,
-0.0186618511,
0.0883633494,
-0.0290898234,
0.0075444058,
0.0093598962,
-0.0317775942,
-0.0575267747,
0.023561785,
-0.0121357394,
-0.0685929358,
-0.0063998266,
0.053417854,
-0.0646625161,
-0.0232009441,
-0.0609701835,
0.0276091043,
-0.00415421,
-0.0369397923,
0.0489806384,
-0.0435879193,
0.0830861628,
0.0141393729,
0.0053243176,
-0.0016649279,
-0.0110721933,
-0.0109251169,
-0.0008997104,
0.0357581563,
0.0024687464,
0.0086885896,
-0.0019608911,
-0.0329068601,
0.0319333188,
0.0766039342,
-0.0118687656,
-0.0178331658,
0.0187655296,
-0.0104497746,
-0.0487768166,
0.073478274,
0.0369662791,
0.0230292697,
-0.0478012003,
-0.0316255838,
0.0545875765,
0.0527986027,
0.0675414801,
-0.0263813082,
-0.0235089231,
0.0074570454,
0.0407212228,
0.0609448515,
0.0169930421,
0.0373243727,
0.0533597395,
-0.0518267453,
-0.0060287337,
0.0534426086,
-0.0327331163,
0.0428748801,
0.0074915467,
0.0153265465,
0.0237062927,
0.0806887969,
-0.0325195752,
0.0057206918,
-0.0013219763,
-0.0000715075,
-0.0108903674,
-0.0278073959,
0.0446968339,
0.0017736286,
-0.0127834175,
0.0654881522,
0.0459624007,
-0.0184249599,
0.0271494687,
-0.0193325635,
-0.0054031685,
0.0039970493,
-0.0270372927,
-0.0137501266,
-0.0186905656,
0.0123977615,
0.0242607836,
0.0717911199,
0.047213383,
0.0352878086,
0.0618509389,
-0.0428976752,
-0.0057574515,
-0.048597984,
-0.0107828761,
0.0469275825,
-0.0227253754,
0.0244951863,
-0.0052704038,
-0.0086355284,
-0.0456414372,
0.0329592824,
-0.0902671814,
-0.0002958468,
0.0096457917,
0.00847199,
0.0106338505,
0.0024027773,
-0.0139251165,
0.0067974655,
0.0168661792,
-0.0502357297,
0.0111521306,
0.0417510606,
-0.0483702905,
-0.0280584712,
0.0514153726,
0.0124959489,
-0.0072258809,
-0.0254227594,
-0.0127807865,
-0.0563231595,
0.0103862444,
0.0191105623,
0.0503111631,
-0.0289553031,
0.0337942168,
-0.0241001416,
0.0554948635,
-0.0177698489,
0.0306692589,
0.0294107925,
0.0213926211,
-0.0026142143,
-0.021377502,
0.043899741,
-0.0212213341,
-0.0211643353,
0.0515095964,
-0.0122486604,
0.0063124383,
0.0129791219,
-0.0063274316,
-0.016518021,
-0.0107663153,
-0.0709096119,
0.0259268004,
0.0067912694,
0.0384937264,
0.030621862,
-0.0202643722,
0.0018053402,
0.0147023033,
-0.0413519479,
0.016465554,
0.0167748779,
0.0287063159,
0.0447820127,
-0.0084563615,
-0.0051622004,
-0.0515680611,
-0.0356428623,
-0.0091297179,
0.0671700612,
-0.0114762429,
-0.0226079933,
-0.0566464216,
0.0131898262,
-0.0433584377,
-0.0234886315,
0.0004742366,
-0.053796012,
0.0188661478,
0.0033450034,
0.0114439894,
0.0491379052,
-0.0216874816,
-0.0060772067,
0.0509779155,
-0.0397140719,
-0.0374232344,
-0.0180547554,
-0.0065507838,
-0.0089754397,
-0.0874004811,
0.0052100816,
-0.026680259,
0.1134652719,
-0.0126005681,
-0.0268456917,
-0.0523744226,
-0.0345831625,
-0.0175140705,
-0.0202863868,
-0.0407988355,
0.0273505151,
-0.0255143475,
0.0571183898,
-0.0409332551,
-0.0208120756,
0.0382110775,
-0.043254111,
-0.0085007269,
-0.0289134495,
-0.0165972002,
-0.0219386593,
0.0379584394,
0.0061955121,
0.0378242657,
-0.0128688635,
-0.0376057252,
-0.0635412708,
0.0170718357,
0.0058157793,
0.0047756233,
0.0236435812,
-0.0056561767,
-0.0111631276,
-0.0006664871,
-0.0261593033,
-0.0139900269,
-0.0130502563,
-0.0061805672,
0.0198127199,
0.0091341035,
-0.0168605223,
-0.047335133,
-0.0424858928,
0.0566885918,
0.0334006473,
-0.0335536189,
0.0226506125,
-0.0384463295,
0.0112657854,
0.0234593377,
0.0167847052,
0.035653092,
-0.0802674741,
0.0203979611,
0.0019468339,
-0.0112488689,
0.0315889418,
-0.0404540487,
0.0055534868,
0.0253261253,
-0.0306600444,
-0.0223621596,
-0.036348287,
0.043007616,
-0.0197366234,
-0.0109340586,
0.0489438288,
0.0008847436,
-0.0453512818,
0.012490727,
-0.0524626635,
0.0214795191,
0.0436625257,
0.0417776257,
-0.0728837028,
-0.0164854471,
0.0196364708,
-0.0389576033,
0.0287008397,
0.0188455917,
-0.0054668337,
-0.1385797113,
-0.0304883532,
0.0308872685,
-0.0976601616,
0.0170866009,
0.0064742174,
-0.0272787567,
0.0130878845,
0.086930491,
-0.0211302824,
-0.0015125206,
-0.0170259122,
-0.0045158323,
0.0710579753,
-0.0525236763,
0.0031282632,
-0.0587173551,
0.0589102842,
0.0543648861,
0.0194092412,
-0.0255096331,
-0.016089594,
0.0895994753,
-0.0094745606,
0.0250105783,
0.0115060769,
0.0054123383,
0.027925102,
-0.0260087438,
0.0131825693,
-0.0016136559,
-0.0056244838,
-0.0213015471,
-0.0141272638,
0.0784002244,
0.0358485915,
-0.0331584029,
0.0527956896,
0.0105414344,
-0.028116677,
0.0555956326,
0.0346332379,
-0.0325154588,
-0.0014620647,
0.0001027561,
0.0113181584,
-0.030928215,
-0.0445715673,
0.0529352613,
-0.0364624225,
-0.0297476761,
-0.04194941,
-0.0407614373,
-0.0041714022,
0.0198286269,
0.0470051467,
0.0112382518,
-0.0460040979,
-0.0706792474,
-0.0018140248,
0.0546528324,
-0.0148230512,
0.0054089925,
-0.0743569061,
0.0262157992,
-0.0191813894,
-0.0468391292,
-0.0000084759,
0.0089819683,
-0.0877559781,
-0.0847847015,
-0.0025484688,
0.0302419122,
0.0113481833,
0.0404935591,
0.0021597473,
-0.0464031249,
0.0508893579,
0.031002285,
0.0000913505,
0.0444522873,
0.0168280676,
-0.0218640584,
-0.0066563278,
0.0406907313,
-0.0058574234,
-0.0117571941,
0.0245941058,
0.0484990589,
0.0117385332,
-0.0234415047,
-0.0031521455,
0.0108384611,
0.0362030268,
-0.0138804531,
-0.0133847315,
-0.040881712,
0.0172753744,
-0.0001844695,
0.012460703,
-0.0050276401,
-0.082181178,
0.0599102825,
-0.0098229209,
0.0355577767,
0.0445940718,
0.0209324025,
-0.0101480475,
-0.0165910199,
-0.0592553653,
-0.0134246154,
0.0171925798,
-0.0052525965,
0.0366899855,
0.0016422279,
0.0368386023,
-0.0027220219,
0.0370012894,
-0.0288986508,
0.0212213937,
0.0200489163,
0.0436871648,
-0.0380464047,
0.0027552703,
-0.0505359657,
-0.0167765133,
0.0269755051,
-0.0184406247,
0.0862568766,
-0.039724499,
0.1126199737,
0.010236932,
-0.023390729,
-0.0059233345,
0.0278025158,
-0.0433953814,
-0.0062022805,
0.031536907,
-0.0048575788,
0.0035935517,
-0.0163642634,
0.0299435146,
-0.0179536436,
0.0154794799,
-0.0172382668,
0.012269428,
0.0171001181,
-0.0165395718,
0.0453016348,
-0.0316593274,
-0.0431408994,
-0.0359102301,
-0.0232648663,
-0.0561855286,
0.0097746672,
0.0267461967,
-0.0261222646,
-0.0046302811,
-0.0178230535,
0.0697308406,
-0.0159403123,
-0.0053566247,
0.0028385581,
-0.0047869631,
0.0389071517,
-0.0154317971,
0.0165650416,
-6.249841181e-33,
-0.0397990756,
0.0208763443,
0.0252687093,
-0.0244410262,
-0.0364591405,
-0.0015905164,
-0.0283703525,
0.0041950438,
-0.0078947814,
0.0240635797,
-0.0014544997,
-0.0094061848,
0.0121301441,
0.0181428976,
0.0386843793,
-0.0069960342,
0.0255464688,
-0.0174408555,
-0.0123815769,
-0.0003050104,
0.054139711,
0.040484529,
0.0977064893,
0.0023796456,
0.0203574114,
0.0121681467,
0.0175372288,
0.0323965065,
-0.0330816992,
0.0295192562,
-0.021629991,
-0.0000349763,
0.0291353147,
-0.0333235897,
-0.0277018249,
-0.0139009943,
-0.0474122241,
-0.0471671484,
0.0689404681,
0.010962395,
-0.0121409763,
-0.0332796425,
0.0335082822,
-0.0423615128,
0.0109241214,
-0.0507990941,
0.0168153942,
-0.0139612937,
-0.0259203017,
0.0191015732,
-0.1151927337,
-0.0118298158,
-0.00052291,
0.0244421232,
0.0393991284,
0.0320215896,
-0.001958899,
0.0299172755,
-0.059876252,
-0.0146680344,
-0.0240483712,
0.0708441213,
0.0972518474,
0.0307000987,
0.0237257928,
0.0685028583,
0.0603220053,
-0.0082705989,
0.0340179875,
0.0002012354,
0.0576531962,
0.0072677261,
-0.0001677838,
0.0521711335,
0.028060751,
0.0306407511,
-0.0809057951,
-0.0090983128,
0.0259121358,
0.0022129833,
0.0028202594,
0.0069231912,
0.0476134568,
-0.0223079417,
-0.03330658,
-0.0604169369,
-0.0276333299,
-0.0356496125,
0.0169364717,
-0.0226416457,
0.0078074341,
-0.0070128399,
0.070957683,
-0.0104004322,
-0.028336063,
0.0114875697,
-0.039708063,
0.012295302,
-0.0039672852,
0.0338297673,
-0.0573861971,
-0.0686097369,
-0.0454061814,
-0.0073975278,
0.0465755127,
0.0199541431,
0.0531123206,
-0.0126020266,
-0.0251454972,
0.0209157858,
-0.0580249429,
-0.0114700496,
0.0185899846,
0.0302468929,
0.044153966,
0.001392404,
-0.0150016341,
0.0559760891,
0.0427958481,
0.0084112845,
-0.0081574004,
-0.0110094761,
0.0239799134,
0.0617060326,
-0.0167244691,
0.0003336264,
-0.0527673066,
0.0277236626,
0.0480308272,
-0.0545057543,
-0.0305027664,
0.0335551053,
2.595e-7,
0.0388658345,
0.0184754655,
0.0236143116,
0.0210787039,
0.0131788887,
0.0135603938,
-0.0758527815,
0.0195833668,
0.006310679,
-0.0236630458,
-0.0123186912,
0.0408663526,
0.069431439,
0.0356886946,
-0.0426701792,
-0.019654762,
-0.0592487752,
0.0488452762,
-0.0668678135,
-0.010872378,
-0.0390317589,
0.0651782751,
-0.0181059651,
-0.0144528523,
0.034178365,
-0.0423767529,
0.0836993679,
-0.0234718267,
-0.0232201815,
0.0109589659,
-0.0286028516,
-0.0336432271,
-0.0138368802,
-0.0005148865,
-0.0233488176,
0.0590480492,
-0.0214181878,
0.0389445126,
-0.0052685379,
-0.0191820133,
-0.0021995015,
0.0236013681,
-0.0364062339,
-0.0604014248,
0.0496453419,
-0.0502367504,
-0.0329929292,
-0.0410391949,
0.0086935069,
-0.013553842,
0.0706129968,
-0.0457969494,
-0.0066419723,
0.030772455,
0.0381208025,
0.0233824607,
-0.0552062616,
-0.014717103,
-0.0374776497,
0.0174614098,
-0.0418070033,
-0.0047456925,
-0.0548504516,
-0.0087936725,
0.0152618317,
-0.0359441377,
-0.0006417286,
2.087355395e-34,
0.0027424402,
-0.0111476043,
0.0548163019,
0.0024227162,
0.0255683176,
-0.0271031223,
-0.0163434781,
0.0250393525,
-0.0368763916,
-0.0465887934,
-0.0088876784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13219v1 | MC-MKE: A Fine-Grained Multimodal Knowledge Editing Benchmark Emphasizing Modality Consistency | 2024-06-19T05:15:21 | 2024-06-19T05:15:21 | Junzhe Zhang, Huixuan Zhang, Xunjian Yin, Baizhou Huang, Xu Zhang, Xinyu Hu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) are prone to non-factual or outdated
knowledge issues, which can manifest as misreading and misrecognition errors
due to the complexity of multimodal knowledge. Previous benchmarks have not
systematically analyzed the performance of editing methods in correcting these
two error types. To better represent and correct these errors, we decompose
multimodal knowledge into its visual and textual components. Different error
types correspond to different editing formats, which edits distinct part of the
multimodal knowledge. We present MC-MKE, a fine-grained Multimodal Knowledge
Editing benchmark emphasizing Modality Consistency. Our benchmark facilitates
independent correction of misreading and misrecognition errors by editing the
corresponding knowledge component. We evaluate three multimodal knowledge
editing methods on MC-MKE, revealing their limitations, particularly in terms
of modality consistency. Our work highlights the challenges posed by multimodal
knowledge editing and motivates further research in developing effective
techniques for this task. | [
0.0387260057,
0.0292802006,
-0.0185004435,
0.0462724976,
-0.0450217277,
-0.0092323646,
0.0167538486,
-0.0036464566,
-0.032122124,
-0.0935940221,
-0.0581699423,
-0.0135211144,
0.0521679744,
-0.0033717251,
0.0238294285,
-0.0870601833,
0.0591843538,
-0.0225099027,
-0.0313785598,
0.0074606636,
0.0388632864,
-0.0127123622,
-0.0422173962,
0.0216204021,
-0.0477085933,
-0.0539390668,
-0.0222892854,
0.0278079528,
-0.000090961,
-0.0063937437,
-0.0106023094,
0.0567033961,
0.0193783063,
0.021815991,
0.0000020812,
-0.0399086662,
-0.0023875989,
-0.000998374,
0.0195151269,
0.0374205373,
0.030564053,
-0.0489992127,
-0.0029710843,
-0.0367647372,
0.0185258072,
-0.0110609084,
0.0709007382,
0.0422604196,
0.0786982775,
0.0429177508,
-0.0052999207,
0.0198190305,
0.0074284808,
0.0083852001,
0.0095820623,
-0.0232626423,
0.0285246242,
0.0672894344,
-0.0499948561,
-0.0069525642,
-0.0538224131,
0.0632172152,
-0.0203151908,
-0.0277003068,
-0.0044124327,
-0.0084728869,
0.0187630411,
-0.0130756395,
-0.0138168391,
0.0682159662,
0.027371252,
0.0068130256,
-0.0157760866,
-0.003139911,
0.0142921312,
0.0497329123,
-0.0418027528,
0.0082754707,
-0.01255704,
-0.0190008003,
-0.0680455416,
-0.0695187896,
0.0311376508,
-0.0014073491,
0.019133579,
0.016187435,
0.0398296304,
-0.0274619218,
-0.044044707,
-0.0372570269,
-0.0361888073,
-0.0646026954,
-0.009877624,
0.0064918296,
-0.0020872361,
-0.00114582,
-0.061085131,
-0.0336460136,
0.0038090739,
-0.0368766189,
0.0640720874,
0.0288815703,
-0.0451879762,
0.0599269159,
0.005654261,
0.0221553855,
0.0051243845,
0.0035019156,
0.0055240612,
0.0079218624,
-0.0501742363,
-0.0046859593,
-0.0354222953,
-0.0229331553,
-0.0492675789,
-0.0012839512,
-0.0303926375,
0.0216085427,
-0.0401076153,
0.0528626479,
-0.034093108,
-0.0230827667,
-0.0136544816,
-0.0190641358,
-0.0364277773,
0.0859329328,
0.0007253216,
0.0187449008,
-0.0124432817,
-0.0314430632,
0.0357269049,
0.0250963457,
0.0092288796,
-0.0360323787,
-0.0242890716,
0.063733086,
-0.0523312427,
-0.0028077918,
-0.0376886241,
-0.0681042075,
-0.0381581001,
-0.0400836281,
0.0098040923,
-0.0461526662,
0.0464013219,
-0.027346313,
-0.0179693904,
-0.024696067,
-0.0150588602,
-0.0122303003,
-0.0301896445,
0.0987634063,
-0.0320333056,
0.023351552,
0.0629529953,
0.0342920311,
-0.0342734978,
0.0574580207,
0.0302271992,
-0.0213232301,
0.0770009309,
-0.0066360808,
0.0030855197,
0.0641964301,
-0.0155271264,
-0.0079309093,
-0.0332626924,
-0.0119412374,
-0.0016111884,
0.0624750257,
0.0332886279,
0.0303982794,
-0.0354034416,
-0.0161308665,
0.1165790111,
-0.036278829,
0.024744194,
-0.0036558493,
0.0086929472,
-0.0302072093,
0.037811067,
0.0139694707,
-0.0494924262,
0.0449915938,
-0.0440351665,
0.0271110572,
0.0184535626,
0.0200359356,
-0.0038575493,
0.0040418212,
-0.0136721442,
0.0204793438,
0.0008175832,
-0.0268870406,
0.0309543367,
0.0086311074,
-0.0238777269,
0.0457060449,
0.0045689931,
-0.0237861592,
0.0184796453,
-0.0071602715,
-0.0141804619,
0.0590099767,
0.0536656193,
-0.0335139632,
-0.0604022555,
-0.0177721679,
0.0105516631,
0.0119347638,
0.0602262691,
-0.0292844381,
-0.0021085411,
-0.0419274718,
-0.0326144807,
-0.0237752032,
0.0265172869,
-0.0268962216,
0.0136486962,
-0.0017434669,
0.001495015,
-0.0652915463,
0.0428076126,
-0.0038627747,
0.0268270187,
0.0369135365,
-0.0676515177,
0.020596372,
0.0070181745,
-0.0112871677,
-0.0326402001,
-0.0175118651,
-0.0340202563,
0.0143471528,
-0.0047680615,
0.0462928154,
-0.0281011146,
-0.0350012034,
0.0677403286,
-0.0469615273,
-0.056169387,
0.0197160244,
-0.0126368804,
-0.0004291622,
-0.001437497,
-0.0122715328,
0.014907226,
-0.0358005464,
0.0136820991,
0.0094054127,
-0.0360010564,
0.0049535176,
0.026489865,
-0.0295121837,
-0.0107786087,
-0.0041551464,
-0.0133517459,
-0.0094866315,
-0.0084597711,
-0.028042702,
0.0415348597,
0.0226656236,
0.0171273574,
-0.0177874994,
-0.0402645543,
-0.0441079661,
-0.0065431087,
-0.1301187724,
-0.0398267023,
-0.0074518151,
-0.0136370137,
0.0332948603,
0.0123646446,
-0.0078120907,
-0.0223203227,
0.0247498956,
0.0584994256,
-0.0171576962,
0.0501343943,
0.0338849053,
0.0186245739,
0.0363522619,
-0.0290340129,
0.0141112208,
0.0042567383,
0.0706082508,
-0.0034957915,
-0.0040471735,
-0.0370010436,
-0.0034246044,
-0.0704181939,
0.0269705094,
-0.0081476904,
-0.0101021146,
0.0067134043,
0.0002496417,
0.0951879546,
-0.0089424681,
0.0021665262,
0.0134965731,
0.0582654998,
-0.0758475587,
-0.0135500757,
0.0049002408,
0.0375746712,
-0.0184806194,
-0.0211865027,
-0.0410030186,
-0.0039859177,
0.062365599,
0.0286186598,
-0.0090364926,
-0.0236706398,
0.0294564068,
0.0028277556,
-0.044719547,
-0.0647435561,
0.0042376183,
0.0112727461,
0.0218050461,
-0.0605418682,
-0.0259428471,
0.049031496,
-0.0515295267,
0.0216612183,
0.0368634462,
0.033656083,
0.0136112403,
0.0712484121,
-0.0162418019,
0.048343353,
-0.0176928677,
0.010917847,
-0.0670430958,
-0.0281309318,
0.0870739371,
-0.0055590486,
0.0835635066,
-0.1033883318,
0.0090378234,
-0.0044660429,
0.0052826391,
0.005967163,
-0.0138969263,
-0.0104872342,
-0.0196802262,
-0.0071230871,
-0.0291925762,
-0.0190425292,
0.0063392203,
0.0643425658,
0.0256909896,
0.0175100677,
-0.0292704459,
-0.0158029422,
0.0161770694,
0.0403675623,
0.0560367629,
-0.017925458,
-0.058610104,
-0.0052161422,
0.0586169399,
-0.0096801268,
-0.0366069153,
-0.0410472602,
-0.0010218149,
-0.0108152796,
-0.0301064067,
-0.0166206788,
0.0057081194,
0.0940681919,
-0.0492851511,
0.0315696374,
0.0719759762,
0.0122272931,
-0.0332752466,
0.0007956878,
-0.0061682095,
-0.0024165686,
0.0314942971,
0.0072790091,
-0.0958516598,
-0.0529559627,
0.033295583,
0.0029925825,
0.0109469155,
-0.0526085868,
-0.0159303118,
-0.0650550798,
0.0343694389,
-0.0000518583,
-0.0433458053,
-0.0644291714,
-0.0047442308,
0.0240206327,
0.017206965,
0.0317409448,
0.0366960131,
-0.0094094044,
-0.0121568162,
-0.0276664458,
0.0020080721,
-0.0551973023,
-0.0082433457,
-0.0475497209,
0.0539820679,
-0.0048022484,
-0.0047857151,
0.0152191184,
-0.0207212456,
0.0371893458,
0.0438970067,
0.0260523222,
-0.0180459768,
0.0235664975,
-0.0187208764,
-0.0080770263,
-0.0208820887,
-0.0114773382,
0.0532672144,
-0.0474031381,
0.0198285189,
0.0882342309,
-0.0187002923,
0.0196592137,
-0.0020341056,
-0.003363579,
-0.0141683966,
0.0402520336,
0.0358923934,
-0.0162491146,
0.0024995862,
-0.0286396034,
0.0059504667,
-0.004475812,
0.0091599328,
0.0041378941,
-0.0296395589,
0.0481354445,
-0.067698963,
-0.0437078439,
0.0283296462,
0.0245645605,
0.0250958893,
-0.0077564111,
0.0003357492,
-0.0140456688,
-0.0515986569,
0.0182213783,
-0.0350629911,
0.020751169,
-0.023254158,
0.0246015731,
-0.0244780537,
-0.0387355089,
0.0086198496,
-0.0041443845,
-0.052083455,
-0.0386708677,
-0.0233712923,
0.044618547,
0.0133860065,
0.0344262198,
0.0383033194,
-0.0887958184,
-0.0048756744,
0.0224310253,
-0.0003824593,
0.052122172,
-0.0045520435,
0.0027143378,
-0.0168759301,
0.0250604674,
-0.0447808057,
-0.0295782667,
0.0139589692,
0.0601137355,
-0.0024922795,
-0.0238969922,
0.0027885819,
0.0194841363,
0.0068750475,
-0.0048639053,
-0.0005359621,
-0.0447576344,
0.008678155,
-0.0131988823,
-0.0392296612,
-0.0273101479,
0.021082662,
-0.0030100776,
0.0064847069,
0.0049542007,
0.0326870456,
0.0206579063,
0.0174522977,
-0.0259687938,
0.0124251237,
0.0238041356,
-0.0169736762,
0.0260069128,
0.0303669088,
-0.0059127617,
0.0400339216,
-0.0250313822,
0.0030502204,
-0.0211504828,
0.1029598936,
0.0283403546,
-0.0390342027,
-0.0539945774,
0.0224193465,
0.0041951449,
0.0119866654,
-0.0005125737,
0.0502815247,
0.0775137395,
0.025380766,
0.0560321584,
-0.0475232974,
-0.0419660471,
-0.0233209636,
0.0602851659,
0.0142121986,
-0.0061676847,
0.0347545408,
0.0129130967,
0.0157650951,
0.0323398598,
0.0565493405,
-0.0558177494,
0.0916677713,
-0.0376523845,
-0.0454947427,
-0.0502124652,
-0.0196435805,
0.0302834529,
0.0176657438,
-0.0439210497,
-0.0149270743,
-0.0658839345,
-0.0473461002,
0.0094794957,
0.0342414193,
-0.0163250212,
0.0298378561,
0.0106339948,
0.0625341162,
0.0194230061,
-0.0242922548,
-0.0210987534,
0.0075391186,
0.0067397198,
0.034207467,
0.0056022867,
-6.033118226e-33,
-0.0193752609,
-0.020144172,
0.0399293564,
-0.0432449207,
-0.0441188961,
0.014437126,
-0.0226218328,
0.0282781459,
0.0253297463,
0.0216361117,
0.0322599933,
-0.0198200606,
-0.0169913359,
0.0045451415,
0.0089900224,
0.0245342311,
0.0596507043,
0.0163489543,
-0.0443960354,
-0.0375564545,
0.029661227,
0.0260205641,
0.0576471761,
-0.0358030759,
0.0527758114,
0.045823399,
-0.0243830644,
0.0320057459,
-0.0354285873,
0.0596723109,
-0.0310117584,
0.0296615902,
0.0232480764,
0.0055491566,
-0.0330479778,
-0.0391989909,
-0.0405422859,
0.0043385243,
0.0251024719,
0.0650332123,
-0.0504143946,
-0.0055481861,
0.0636567697,
-0.0139717385,
-0.0072854329,
-0.0438799188,
0.0344816558,
-0.0164674595,
0.0157824997,
0.0187174082,
-0.0491007082,
0.0224080402,
-0.0056901854,
-0.0187601224,
0.0060891872,
0.0085912701,
0.0576484352,
-0.0245874431,
-0.1062315479,
0.0112352483,
-0.0041247527,
0.0171813909,
0.087497592,
0.0068628066,
0.0018902505,
0.0586546101,
0.0215899255,
0.0096054142,
-0.0205384903,
0.0417779125,
0.0243232362,
0.0326715522,
-0.0097129205,
0.114848651,
-0.0057820827,
0.014405339,
-0.0100641558,
-0.0004392135,
-0.0701273903,
0.0311419368,
-0.0035884301,
0.0470996238,
0.0048287534,
0.0115167992,
-0.0793875679,
0.0151538998,
-0.0589712784,
-0.0026794279,
0.0364740677,
0.0095052458,
0.0041433354,
0.0178515706,
0.0467891358,
0.0028938898,
-0.0369507372,
-0.0374535546,
-0.0247611571,
0.093136251,
-0.0076551363,
-0.0103184581,
0.0024272616,
0.0127432821,
0.0477833785,
-0.0237141717,
0.0165528934,
0.0139247673,
0.0175083596,
0.048301585,
-0.0561698042,
0.0124584083,
-0.0148343034,
-0.0101803308,
-0.0098116705,
-0.0477471761,
0.0327857845,
-0.0234837607,
-0.0625216141,
-0.0031078842,
0.0524067618,
0.0141451983,
-0.0140884342,
-0.0177705549,
-0.0326108597,
0.0124032777,
-0.0086180642,
0.0371273458,
-0.0242212303,
-0.0656813011,
0.0117089869,
-0.0339161083,
-0.0122112129,
0.0224914458,
2.702e-7,
0.0393104814,
0.070182845,
0.014031644,
-0.0217375476,
0.0550148264,
0.0628536791,
-0.0552498847,
0.0026282261,
-0.0245108102,
-0.0356546566,
-0.0006073492,
0.0214897487,
0.0172179528,
0.0280177537,
0.0105479918,
-0.022179231,
0.020727938,
0.0004357618,
-0.0279496834,
0.0080141788,
0.0561783761,
-0.0187726282,
0.0088616554,
-0.0288341977,
0.0211752821,
-0.0452158675,
0.0936777294,
-0.0219008345,
-0.0370353088,
-0.0072951424,
0.0601109527,
0.0058663781,
0.0188300498,
0.0386190228,
-0.0000767455,
-0.0884212777,
0.0306445714,
0.0369422138,
-0.0239774678,
0.0351831913,
-0.0290890001,
0.0305577125,
-0.0556459762,
-0.040416386,
0.0516866334,
-0.0167170279,
-0.0082410872,
-0.0328923576,
-0.0338418335,
0.0007080704,
-0.0065652346,
-0.0192479733,
-0.0378090665,
0.0286149494,
0.0212283917,
0.0424101986,
-0.0658156872,
-0.0289321113,
-0.0341833532,
0.0207942817,
-0.0259777717,
-0.0562822036,
-0.0393836088,
-0.0693741888,
0.0366279557,
-0.0898502097,
-0.0426847562,
2.108205956e-34,
0.0034223569,
0.0055762697,
0.0246903449,
-0.0349189527,
0.0423415042,
-0.0381137617,
-0.0212199111,
-0.0166305881,
-0.0282535739,
-0.0483894609,
-0.0267555695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13217v1 | Bridging Law and Data: Augmenting Reasoning via a Semi-Structured Dataset with IRAC methodology | 2024-06-19T04:59:09 | 2024-06-19T04:59:09 | Xiaoxi Kang, Lizhen Qu, Lay-Ki Soon, Zhuang Li, Adnan Trakic | cs.CL | cs.CL | The effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) in legal reasoning is often
limited due to the unique legal terminologies and the necessity for highly
specialized knowledge. These limitations highlight the need for high-quality
data tailored for complex legal reasoning tasks. This paper introduces
LEGALSEMI, a benchmark specifically curated for legal scenario analysis.
LEGALSEMI comprises 54 legal scenarios, each rigorously annotated by legal
experts, based on the comprehensive IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion)
framework. In addition, LEGALSEMI is accompanied by a structured knowledge
graph (SKG). A series of experiments were conducted to assess the usefulness of
LEGALSEMI for IRAC analysis. The experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of incorporating the SKG for issue identification, rule
retrieval, application and conclusion generation using four different LLMs.
LEGALSEMI will be publicly available upon acceptance of this paper. | [
0.0589249209,
0.0167244542,
-0.0043613967,
0.0235920902,
-0.0987881646,
0.0196444001,
0.0194864571,
0.02048802,
0.0227670576,
-0.0600248389,
0.0475340411,
0.0135137793,
-0.0391242355,
0.0134078013,
-0.0072693825,
0.0017940975,
0.0154120196,
-0.0093159592,
0.0907925665,
0.0129380925,
0.025856901,
0.0344239883,
0.0031426759,
-0.0016519744,
-0.0471944995,
-0.0117135271,
-0.0054208315,
0.0309793726,
-0.0059424997,
-0.0524910688,
-0.0029928361,
0.0483650379,
0.0401177965,
0.0145645514,
0.0000020385,
-0.0695003346,
-0.0146757569,
-0.0150329145,
-0.0308438502,
0.0093304338,
-0.0045147068,
-0.0299031511,
-0.0065602395,
-0.0208880138,
-0.0494737923,
0.022138685,
-0.0114261657,
0.0284442455,
0.0295164399,
0.0856629759,
-0.0250921361,
-0.0688863471,
0.0222825147,
-0.0122685414,
-0.0091512688,
-0.0150862094,
0.0453406237,
0.057188075,
0.0412723683,
-0.0148529802,
0.0616744719,
0.015467396,
0.032945063,
-0.0499016047,
-0.0403336994,
-0.0072843297,
-0.0531758405,
0.0270785764,
0.0080412189,
0.040574763,
0.0713642836,
-0.0371851064,
-0.0183822215,
-0.0151040712,
0.0392289385,
0.0632518977,
-0.0358628705,
0.0544612557,
-0.0489167236,
0.0307145361,
0.0280099716,
0.020357687,
0.017244149,
0.0189971495,
-0.0397871695,
0.1185339689,
-0.0234377049,
-0.0291569531,
-0.0077396058,
-0.0308976118,
0.0001777012,
-0.0667000115,
0.0276674386,
0.0594638884,
-0.0163890906,
0.0474255309,
0.0021460832,
-0.0020403087,
0.0645063445,
-0.0957684591,
0.0031643757,
0.003611404,
0.0146056553,
0.0811940953,
-0.0234989841,
-0.0135914804,
-0.0240125302,
0.009019807,
0.0032651264,
-0.0237482972,
-0.0607834011,
-0.019798452,
-0.0194353517,
0.0632427633,
-0.0757296681,
0.0161827188,
0.0048470469,
0.0149436425,
-0.0207886714,
0.0302272197,
0.0194101594,
-0.0022675097,
0.0064441813,
-0.0326684713,
-0.0729197413,
-0.0718313456,
-0.0508729815,
0.0658548027,
-0.0079425406,
-0.0124660768,
0.025963217,
-0.0137766022,
0.0056199562,
-0.0137624806,
-0.0039308495,
0.0938543454,
0.0248886328,
-0.0009876994,
-0.0770442188,
-0.1026084051,
-0.0115449224,
-0.0713056475,
-0.0064361049,
-0.0851781517,
0.0292680059,
-0.0144494446,
-0.0314022899,
-0.0571988225,
0.0218404569,
0.0340135247,
-0.008368128,
0.0323460624,
-0.0570526458,
0.0007384873,
-0.0343135968,
0.0309779122,
0.062485408,
0.0200284142,
-0.0110868551,
-0.0129694166,
0.0229368396,
0.0121848425,
-0.012282379,
0.0158003792,
-0.0034552915,
0.035352692,
-0.0168213565,
0.0592943542,
-0.0296987034,
0.0142333182,
-0.028263133,
0.0227059089,
-0.0094458973,
-0.0257471371,
0.0195601042,
0.0424512029,
0.0122428024,
0.0511864647,
0.0066924659,
0.0096275257,
0.0162388198,
-0.0033158346,
-0.0146432286,
0.0047537582,
-0.0171035808,
-0.0050893361,
-0.0504514426,
-0.0033191631,
-0.0305563882,
-0.0445511714,
-0.0290286466,
0.030932121,
-0.0242015906,
-0.0106494427,
0.0268974677,
0.0146744568,
0.0131304255,
0.0347521566,
0.0107507547,
-0.0348193459,
-0.0580689944,
-0.0154746966,
0.004406746,
0.0501772687,
0.0678719878,
-0.0455891304,
-0.062990427,
-0.0038510591,
0.0042657387,
0.0269373916,
0.0157275125,
-0.006373757,
-0.0400743224,
-0.0178802051,
-0.0252994113,
0.0102099162,
0.0100151636,
0.0027045475,
0.0131759262,
-0.0025142233,
0.0070822798,
-0.0557084456,
0.0133628687,
0.0320383608,
-0.0199147016,
-0.004863305,
0.0061207525,
-0.0459246077,
0.0368766077,
0.0354663432,
-0.0040598162,
0.0200132225,
0.0399873219,
-0.0024555279,
-0.0128867785,
0.0264233928,
0.0028073387,
-0.0131071443,
0.0747825205,
-0.0449380875,
0.0010528791,
-0.0327673741,
-0.0332341492,
-0.0179824643,
-0.0448451564,
0.0131302625,
0.0121385437,
-0.0373608023,
-0.0078031006,
-0.0000188766,
-0.0208553784,
-0.0035919789,
0.04513897,
-0.0031545872,
-0.0097046681,
0.0245971307,
-0.0151615748,
0.051885888,
0.0071383351,
0.0045963698,
-0.0264515057,
-0.0418903083,
0.005932231,
0.0093334168,
-0.0019618466,
-0.0341731012,
0.011920345,
-0.0582140833,
0.0251687411,
-0.0041650711,
-0.0038261705,
0.0032491558,
-0.0465791337,
-0.0305582676,
-0.0094810985,
-0.0168394819,
-0.0246297549,
-0.0251522046,
-0.0028413455,
0.0013235698,
-0.0001632998,
-0.0437371917,
0.0160256438,
-0.0281616375,
-0.0394811258,
0.0411586575,
0.0498888232,
-0.0111264829,
-0.0156513527,
0.0841503665,
-0.0443555973,
0.0020442272,
-0.0237065051,
0.0232814234,
-0.0102670146,
0.0045337887,
-0.000865881,
-0.0312784091,
-0.0023898301,
0.001954251,
0.0286841225,
-0.0469376408,
-0.0500014946,
-0.0291717611,
0.0193420276,
0.0386493467,
-0.0438962951,
-0.023343483,
0.0024526918,
-0.0097102653,
0.0122442748,
0.0130823515,
-0.0191563666,
0.0161935557,
-0.0079265023,
0.0090389727,
-0.032657478,
-0.0378107354,
0.0033996813,
0.0635419488,
0.0307635665,
-0.033773832,
0.0766863227,
0.0112411575,
0.0626420975,
-0.0429106764,
-0.0126731023,
-0.0484472215,
0.0751558989,
0.0016436877,
-0.0039215446,
-0.0062817093,
0.0031744197,
0.0198469684,
-0.0413139574,
0.0663273633,
-0.0350854248,
0.0735461041,
-0.065775618,
0.0592574291,
-0.0011688058,
-0.0203649867,
-0.0146568147,
-0.0376960039,
0.0176765732,
0.0512369685,
0.0145219965,
0.0312865414,
0.0184519719,
0.0110573824,
-0.0132861342,
0.0080071725,
0.0188037492,
-0.0226790719,
-0.0252269842,
0.0272444282,
0.0052537168,
-0.0484943092,
0.0082190521,
0.0387887694,
0.036050193,
0.0204455778,
-0.0102230953,
-0.0168462731,
-0.0116509805,
0.0305407476,
-0.0111293541,
-0.0325642005,
0.0067519597,
0.0335237272,
-0.0086185653,
-0.076318346,
0.0144847408,
0.0758508444,
0.0422240868,
-0.022409644,
-0.0118276365,
-0.0271325931,
-0.0116260769,
0.0333311744,
0.025345074,
-0.135388121,
0.0389480777,
-0.0145225776,
-0.0392244756,
-0.0595273785,
-0.0668849126,
-0.0219149236,
-0.0661809146,
0.1102355272,
0.0267710164,
0.0038844077,
-0.0446579829,
-0.0236520283,
0.0011853452,
0.0066820881,
-0.0411216579,
0.0026083339,
-0.0094423862,
-0.0301148165,
0.0057656723,
-0.0570168085,
0.0020343596,
0.0334943347,
-0.0167138595,
0.0570388772,
-0.0057624318,
0.0180251524,
-0.0232222658,
0.0137686878,
0.0148068937,
0.0291349348,
0.0059915483,
0.0019945647,
0.0122005306,
0.0324209444,
0.027279662,
-0.0705886409,
0.0302577075,
-0.0224124696,
-0.0732709318,
0.0564671755,
0.0930451304,
-0.0691509545,
0.010069537,
-0.0256597605,
-0.0180233251,
0.0035031731,
0.0465367399,
0.0042176079,
0.030674018,
-0.0406317674,
-0.0219652541,
-0.0176610444,
-0.0519944578,
0.0074367663,
0.0119861737,
-0.0163441394,
0.000904602,
-0.00622768,
-0.0079714367,
0.0106692426,
0.0315846913,
0.0176516958,
0.0240147859,
0.0230950378,
-0.0251893941,
-0.0418130457,
0.0013189432,
-0.0529187173,
0.0164892506,
0.038877476,
0.031180935,
0.0036194662,
0.0149223562,
-0.0011868292,
-0.0016452662,
0.004670423,
-0.0306428615,
0.0118569136,
-0.0054339166,
0.0186504927,
0.0252915975,
-0.0064588855,
-0.0294298735,
0.0734969974,
0.0084131965,
-0.0258914977,
-0.0225603022,
0.0489087291,
0.0000476877,
-0.0047837305,
0.0114695923,
0.009527578,
0.0147787686,
0.01897805,
0.0390134342,
-0.0470102616,
-0.0229386874,
0.0467429049,
0.0649511442,
-0.0119846882,
0.0214809533,
-0.0504554287,
-0.0169526543,
0.0199726913,
-0.0460978337,
-0.0174325295,
-0.0124630947,
-0.0083553335,
0.0103325769,
-0.0451219827,
-0.0260229371,
0.0734866485,
-0.0255424622,
-0.0088015199,
-0.0247997306,
0.0221213605,
0.0466043875,
-0.0038041817,
0.0436045974,
-0.0608021282,
-0.0034622436,
0.0279868115,
-0.038452372,
0.0278893188,
-0.0064446223,
0.0668361112,
0.0180507116,
-0.0113272611,
-0.0245936476,
0.0065766685,
-0.0051176208,
-0.0318839438,
0.0069159209,
0.0544140749,
0.0430990718,
0.0279888138,
0.0021465288,
-0.036803361,
-0.0084020933,
0.0099464646,
0.027352931,
-0.0107175959,
-0.0390531756,
0.0621035546,
0.0394616462,
-0.0397936963,
0.0305618029,
0.024896808,
-0.0072477111,
0.0186445676,
-0.0229146611,
-0.0363481604,
-0.018432755,
-0.0401879214,
-0.0007813362,
0.0171659645,
-0.0128273079,
-0.0597158745,
-0.0914734676,
-0.0392746776,
-0.0451307595,
0.0237522963,
-0.0286125764,
0.0324113928,
0.0048690448,
0.0447189622,
0.0575956255,
-0.0412709229,
-0.0494060181,
0.006114027,
-0.0553898439,
-0.000797145,
-0.0181259401,
-5.816436414e-33,
-0.0249585137,
-0.0525284596,
0.041003868,
0.0024860285,
-0.0215609595,
-0.0175381601,
-0.0341628008,
-0.0076235146,
-0.0308901723,
0.0393594168,
0.0056324936,
0.0539273471,
0.0164020434,
-0.018265387,
-0.0031005729,
-0.0027645011,
-0.0145616131,
0.0022841031,
0.0186813306,
0.0113859484,
0.0117387325,
-0.0088905133,
0.0008264025,
-0.1169252098,
0.04485045,
0.0296152439,
-0.0037947246,
-0.0063995593,
-0.081267342,
0.0544230491,
-0.0144506227,
0.0440889336,
0.0392117277,
-0.0331237689,
-0.0025584449,
0.0292173829,
-0.039370086,
0.0004913185,
0.034707725,
-0.0304832235,
0.005221664,
-0.0503556542,
0.0263712294,
0.0108964071,
-0.0061338954,
-0.0159465894,
0.0213099718,
-0.053786356,
-0.0401462875,
-0.0659491122,
-0.0805098563,
0.0658758506,
-0.0284259655,
0.0411004573,
0.0182026364,
0.0132790431,
0.00701317,
0.0034949156,
-0.0524200648,
0.0121014751,
-0.0193468649,
-0.0414925329,
0.0585354827,
-0.0719613656,
-0.0005546201,
0.0568085127,
-0.0219150279,
0.0080378121,
-0.0361210629,
-0.0030293402,
-0.0180738959,
0.1193662509,
0.0157733671,
0.025064569,
-0.0235197302,
-0.0126206363,
-0.085565567,
-0.0256553236,
0.0082671028,
0.0322682895,
0.0375589468,
-0.0062690396,
-0.0525958017,
-0.0369443856,
-0.0113364113,
-0.0034818491,
-0.0073575964,
-0.0272393115,
0.0278516077,
-0.0282427128,
0.0400592275,
0.0139749423,
-0.0008103008,
-0.0370972566,
-0.0000349882,
0.0594428666,
0.0125786718,
0.0051536006,
-0.0149256177,
0.0621632971,
-0.0341290347,
-0.0229659248,
0.0278421212,
-0.0582518838,
0.00654952,
-0.0007059226,
0.0613049679,
-0.0110098626,
-0.031960126,
-0.0191201176,
-0.024445409,
-0.0053859986,
0.0235678107,
0.0114475805,
0.0110415658,
0.0599458516,
0.0212271307,
0.0247577112,
0.0476404503,
-0.0303219259,
0.0010395674,
-0.0184789151,
-0.0226012915,
-0.0113769649,
0.0081381444,
0.007010859,
-0.0069947094,
0.0350121856,
0.0354594477,
0.0257917624,
0.0094493916,
0.0920251608,
2.745e-7,
0.0940658897,
0.0253125466,
-0.0116921887,
0.0412106961,
-0.0103396513,
0.0112466468,
-0.0001915163,
-0.0003227699,
0.0312138591,
-0.015720902,
0.0371604748,
0.014152254,
0.0137835145,
0.0871285871,
-0.0324702226,
-0.0260727704,
-0.0302540027,
-0.0673261136,
-0.0832185596,
0.0323204882,
0.0843893141,
0.0485561006,
0.0481207967,
0.0002084352,
-0.0124224033,
-0.0551252924,
0.01585689,
-0.0363753438,
-0.0349169374,
0.0180760771,
0.0601483397,
-0.0237330943,
-0.0055654775,
0.0818653256,
0.0166074727,
0.0359713361,
-0.0595766976,
0.0521995202,
0.0004301171,
0.0452566072,
-0.0159294475,
-0.0881289393,
0.0232528225,
-0.0511312075,
0.0732912347,
-0.0318567567,
-0.0250909869,
0.0015277632,
-0.0282012671,
-0.0429636501,
-0.0046235737,
0.0158696715,
0.0023621253,
-0.0334934406,
0.00573229,
-0.0134691903,
0.0015821289,
-0.057992097,
0.0136652663,
0.0761098191,
-0.0203796569,
0.005652443,
0.0045331437,
0.0050987736,
0.0483392589,
-0.0769227147,
0.0418405235,
2.382289683e-34,
0.0054043937,
0.0089630112,
-0.0122879054,
0.0540202409,
0.0439024642,
0.0180023871,
-0.0517720617,
0.0196129493,
-0.0227318332,
-0.070879139,
0.0250603016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13213v1 | Multi-Meta-RAG: Improving RAG for Multi-Hop Queries using Database Filtering with LLM-Extracted Metadata | 2024-06-19T04:53:48 | 2024-06-19T04:53:48 | Mykhailo Poliakov, Nadiya Shvai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | The retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) enables retrieval of relevant
information from an external knowledge source and allows large language models
(LLMs) to answer queries over previously unseen document collections. However,
it was demonstrated that traditional RAG applications perform poorly in
answering multi-hop questions, which require retrieving and reasoning over
multiple elements of supporting evidence. We introduce a new method called
Multi-Meta-RAG, which uses database filtering with LLM-extracted metadata to
improve the RAG selection of the relevant documents from various sources,
relevant to the question. While database filtering is specific to a set of
questions from a particular domain and format, we found out that Multi-Meta-RAG
greatly improves the results on the MultiHop-RAG benchmark. The code is
available at https://github.com/mxpoliakov/Multi-Meta-RAG. | [
0.0260162987,
0.0458529592,
-0.0151889585,
0.0098336479,
-0.0452113077,
-0.0121356901,
-0.0046127918,
0.0184338558,
-0.0162540041,
-0.0611289144,
-0.0307573043,
0.0067629409,
-0.0574041978,
-0.0299131889,
0.0206088256,
0.0124317696,
0.0586713031,
-0.0098607084,
-0.0328246355,
-0.0108934119,
-0.0085268235,
0.0460195616,
0.0104549713,
0.0024325664,
-0.0249999315,
0.000312578,
-0.0079032537,
0.00897393,
-0.009835124,
-0.0187134352,
-0.0042605237,
0.0269460212,
0.0081953146,
0.0365741663,
0.0000021113,
-0.0623339526,
-0.0597164445,
0.0185201652,
-0.0172048882,
-0.0179179199,
0.0327540785,
0.0657100603,
0.0173011422,
0.031850826,
-0.0407929197,
0.0092054252,
-0.0078885406,
0.0281948578,
0.025870122,
0.0619253851,
-0.0029674058,
-0.0291385055,
0.008942876,
-0.0207472518,
0.0927150995,
-0.0368131101,
0.0142431185,
0.0443761088,
0.1034802869,
0.0272338334,
0.026853865,
0.0205831956,
-0.0108217364,
-0.028892519,
-0.0210099276,
0.0106291668,
-0.0561851189,
0.0145257879,
0.0086009344,
0.0637889355,
0.048361484,
-0.0208838079,
0.0193553194,
0.0299778357,
0.009996701,
0.0986579508,
-0.061521519,
0.0072051245,
-0.035300862,
-0.0006130848,
0.0040107858,
-0.0162340812,
0.0470974706,
0.0349060483,
-0.0242933426,
0.1162856147,
0.0302480236,
-0.0147884153,
0.022046417,
0.0127843069,
-0.0003391296,
-0.0182165895,
0.0165820383,
0.0412606373,
-0.0383236967,
0.0178526454,
-0.0090293195,
-0.0342165641,
0.0718451366,
-0.0134649044,
-0.0284675062,
0.0235574804,
-0.0430306792,
0.071297735,
-0.0186482463,
-0.038442187,
-0.0506754518,
-0.0309800003,
-0.0389718376,
-0.0616895668,
-0.0679598004,
-0.0258597415,
-0.020131629,
0.0644739494,
-0.0788153857,
0.0014684353,
0.0001958078,
0.0301577486,
-0.0139297899,
-0.0304976217,
-0.0066193766,
-0.0049138935,
-0.0326010995,
-0.009674822,
-0.0377433561,
0.022681782,
-0.040453285,
0.013825113,
0.0330816358,
-0.0625688508,
0.0020568015,
0.0327184759,
0.032295797,
-0.0311548226,
0.033118926,
0.0501387566,
0.0041786721,
0.0063766907,
-0.0636954382,
-0.0812026113,
0.0105752973,
-0.0555103868,
0.0226695035,
-0.0636705756,
0.0345797054,
0.0010757545,
-0.0166917518,
-0.0053435946,
0.0048133903,
0.0428816192,
-0.0321502648,
0.0013484883,
-0.0229591243,
-0.001135965,
0.0564876236,
0.0185516421,
-0.0046289698,
0.0808695704,
-0.0457326807,
0.0186872389,
0.0544445254,
0.0346546955,
-0.0090599991,
0.0148234423,
0.0335143432,
0.0458277911,
-0.042482093,
0.040092133,
0.0281719696,
0.0022395339,
0.0145958299,
0.0397025906,
-0.0492238402,
0.0055605941,
-0.0268573873,
-0.0011663113,
0.0439946391,
-0.0247894879,
0.0455059037,
0.0158397034,
0.0071301796,
0.0129589243,
-0.0063024662,
0.0288766902,
-0.0490348935,
-0.0079433648,
0.0606512614,
0.04622823,
-0.0392334387,
-0.0094386013,
-0.0106677217,
0.0100082299,
-0.0745228454,
0.0155573338,
0.036052227,
-0.0033102105,
-0.0065861135,
0.0558036305,
0.0437942259,
-0.0250229873,
0.0244896412,
-0.0371539332,
0.0245724358,
0.0333909579,
0.0875094458,
-0.0696572512,
-0.0157116465,
-0.0122780371,
0.0252971128,
0.0157986078,
0.0475875549,
-0.0247885119,
-0.0106114149,
-0.0418104716,
-0.0547722131,
-0.0144331632,
0.0036226525,
0.0142634585,
0.0198651962,
0.0154979257,
0.0380380861,
-0.0613141358,
0.0175878704,
0.0306209177,
-0.0483378507,
-0.0208376907,
0.0299281217,
-0.0095128538,
0.0190762747,
0.0341218598,
-0.0167314392,
0.0318308063,
0.0572531521,
-0.0167951938,
-0.0194725432,
-0.0194274206,
0.0344043858,
-0.0277621485,
0.0406911783,
-0.0099436473,
0.0012929717,
-0.0227250364,
-0.020483898,
-0.0637899041,
-0.0424477644,
-0.008495817,
0.0184624381,
-0.077439487,
-0.0080032144,
0.0262889527,
0.0144623555,
-0.0524365753,
0.0461423509,
0.0045401561,
0.014554075,
0.0180312395,
-0.0055678906,
0.0282988995,
-0.0088675879,
0.0060281465,
0.0338600688,
-0.0193453059,
0.043767605,
0.0450420305,
-0.0011589786,
-0.0783595964,
-0.0191704743,
-0.0703918263,
0.0294833817,
-0.0183629561,
0.0136591755,
0.0022414459,
0.0376429558,
-0.0113956807,
-0.0020480077,
-0.0678365454,
-0.0071428935,
0.0238538571,
0.0196909159,
0.0122864256,
0.037804503,
0.0280711707,
-0.0168150757,
-0.0169445314,
-0.0076366668,
0.0520302653,
-0.0231391657,
0.0054372726,
-0.0146297477,
-0.0392833129,
-0.0629147366,
0.0147103406,
-0.0068679727,
0.0214391239,
0.0044421297,
-0.0764562115,
0.0373063572,
-0.0314609595,
0.0084207272,
-0.0483407751,
0.0559866354,
-0.0085567934,
-0.0704398006,
0.0215184819,
-0.0101904124,
0.0440668277,
0.0255142972,
-0.0150876921,
0.0296879672,
-0.0208875984,
-0.02758215,
-0.0282795951,
-0.0028886071,
0.0126818055,
0.0276277605,
-0.0295989253,
-0.0419470295,
-0.0208014287,
0.0350112766,
0.0579413176,
-0.0036690533,
-0.0302453656,
0.0579555109,
-0.018369928,
0.0129386438,
-0.0559291728,
0.028205011,
-0.0405404978,
0.0558578409,
-0.0251871981,
0.0385375246,
-0.0672668591,
-0.0014504519,
-0.0077252947,
-0.0326431803,
0.0316402689,
-0.0493661314,
0.0126769161,
-0.0338028818,
0.0539958328,
0.0059406264,
-0.0062390184,
-0.0370409079,
-0.0161851346,
0.0251210555,
0.0021901084,
-0.0498166978,
0.0372608453,
-0.0560924523,
-0.002190158,
0.0319042392,
0.0210788548,
-0.0379317813,
-0.0117263189,
0.0197950993,
0.0365360491,
0.057340607,
-0.0195693336,
-0.0031745983,
0.0062576057,
0.0145383654,
0.0558571666,
0.0341271199,
-0.0334371403,
0.0537533872,
0.0046033915,
0.0383389853,
-0.0299504604,
-0.0232027844,
0.0011920951,
-0.017693378,
-0.0515629984,
-0.0138909463,
0.0626656562,
0.071120277,
-0.0367168896,
-0.0179223418,
-0.0571071953,
0.0177570488,
0.0292621329,
0.0833806545,
-0.0817644298,
-0.0200029276,
0.0093381125,
0.0168396495,
-0.0008582554,
-0.0205684397,
-0.0141764302,
-0.1210420206,
0.0548281074,
-0.0143487826,
-0.0149724884,
0.0136364745,
-0.0590861477,
-0.0038018408,
0.0374691524,
0.0044670198,
0.0453822762,
-0.0114239976,
-0.0121599566,
0.0025786667,
0.0571022145,
-0.0357356742,
0.0173314624,
-0.0096640252,
-0.0114455093,
0.045998998,
0.0262684803,
0.0118226726,
-0.0459302701,
0.0682196766,
-0.0000915923,
0.0054563214,
-0.0418814011,
0.0496086478,
0.010421847,
0.0110638104,
-0.0059860633,
0.0136900758,
-0.0223077312,
-0.0142333163,
0.000185391,
0.0950283706,
-0.056221161,
0.0335345119,
-0.0633145273,
-0.0266739242,
0.019553069,
0.0718509704,
-0.0069142482,
-0.0094551649,
-0.0144672263,
0.0050944085,
-0.0306196194,
-0.0209703203,
0.0016874863,
0.0688668117,
-0.0315978564,
-0.0357947648,
-0.0648259893,
-0.040113315,
0.0126147429,
0.062883608,
-0.0166101623,
0.0640116334,
-0.0119628618,
-0.0107564069,
-0.0613559112,
0.0036730624,
-0.0516684875,
-0.0011970984,
-0.0087377187,
0.0075241807,
0.0745465755,
-0.0365526341,
-0.0121622887,
-0.0049889572,
-0.0271490738,
-0.0553361177,
-0.0051932759,
0.013763926,
0.0243082196,
0.0308487378,
-0.0309226178,
-0.024933666,
0.0249372926,
0.0377125926,
-0.0668145269,
-0.0408937782,
0.0093028564,
-0.035979446,
-0.0489021651,
0.0383235216,
-0.0858313739,
0.0372765251,
-0.0291917697,
0.0402338691,
0.0274366215,
0.0106838904,
0.0295953639,
0.0728368685,
0.0343661271,
0.0005468603,
-0.0030325083,
-0.0236197449,
0.0212703366,
-0.0521451198,
-0.042944517,
-0.002825595,
0.0538783781,
-0.0081977677,
-0.0644024312,
0.0200027209,
-0.0052746455,
-0.0266066287,
0.0539010279,
-0.0055822763,
0.0041210968,
-0.0379884355,
0.0279097073,
0.0296770465,
-0.0242027529,
-0.0284604635,
-0.0000460164,
0.0188618358,
0.0392483138,
-0.0652814656,
0.0180364847,
0.0244447608,
-0.0018799847,
-0.0071591111,
-0.0040450809,
-0.0886193812,
-0.0066708913,
-0.0154993609,
-0.0056587262,
0.0221599657,
-0.0031162046,
0.0363883376,
-0.0009573613,
-0.0353523977,
-0.0227552447,
0.0117335003,
0.0463137925,
-0.0130630899,
0.0233550072,
0.0384331606,
-0.0329771154,
0.0480495244,
0.0772954151,
-0.0420266986,
0.0331973732,
-0.0100691887,
-0.0378653705,
-0.0502502546,
-0.061970979,
-0.0254502315,
0.0414918587,
-0.0351860188,
0.0194444899,
-0.0475574099,
-0.0104143275,
-0.0254417993,
0.0075269444,
-0.0272866115,
-0.003452935,
0.0403769985,
0.0950554311,
0.0394849405,
-0.0039071888,
-0.0591086075,
0.0279004555,
-0.0684062317,
-0.0199081674,
0.0641578361,
-6.958477665e-33,
-0.0131975813,
-0.0366777182,
0.0542374142,
-0.0601255298,
-0.0151004922,
-0.0308124013,
-0.0281771552,
-0.0326102152,
-0.0361778103,
-0.0228433032,
-0.0184769742,
0.0291942079,
0.0145887416,
0.0210281927,
-0.0076431609,
0.0223823953,
0.02239912,
0.0192371774,
-0.0205676407,
0.0349964984,
0.0726105422,
0.0356079936,
0.0080284663,
-0.0067714471,
0.0032190513,
-0.0124311764,
-0.0057995995,
0.0161730759,
-0.016034618,
0.0742742568,
-0.0100117214,
0.0252660159,
0.0262273196,
-0.0472629182,
0.0013214285,
-0.0457139276,
-0.063205719,
-0.0355616137,
0.0090189856,
-0.0399765186,
-0.001944187,
-0.0394604988,
0.0139803458,
-0.0022074154,
0.0385548398,
0.0131429303,
0.0223956276,
-0.0296167824,
-0.0484446958,
-0.0492896326,
-0.0324629843,
0.0287383161,
0.0061318213,
0.0374530666,
0.0010210614,
0.0789515004,
0.0105457883,
0.0603369921,
-0.0178806372,
0.0401711129,
-0.044202853,
0.0406572558,
0.0248276182,
-0.0109251058,
0.0081443712,
0.0486551635,
-0.0189423077,
-0.0032332398,
0.0322979428,
-0.0053680944,
-0.0067942939,
0.0567185096,
-0.0046609933,
0.0609340444,
0.0497250631,
-0.0178185906,
-0.0960366577,
0.0725042894,
-0.0097467424,
0.0242617596,
0.0022320789,
-0.0058341715,
-0.0122931432,
-0.0128037399,
-0.0288109183,
0.0097411452,
-0.0436389074,
-0.0083676865,
0.0292034633,
0.0041881339,
-0.0214457884,
0.0196904931,
0.0339011215,
-0.0228899289,
-0.0175850801,
0.046775315,
-0.0766106024,
-0.0258844029,
-0.0247536395,
0.04009749,
0.0002728886,
-0.0223426912,
0.0271224063,
-0.0194225647,
-0.0092051458,
0.0335438028,
0.0341918617,
-0.008745498,
-0.0743353441,
0.0046437099,
-0.0407693014,
0.0476396196,
-0.0182962529,
-0.0226780679,
0.0228559393,
0.0412912853,
0.0231690798,
0.0363977924,
0.0364167579,
0.0031938867,
-0.0085646957,
-0.0443660393,
0.0140977995,
0.015264526,
-0.0121190753,
0.036765743,
-0.0060854964,
0.0111577297,
0.0614705086,
-0.0374989621,
-0.0170039274,
0.039199274,
2.933e-7,
0.0558241494,
0.0175416153,
0.0273911133,
0.017666528,
-0.0190287568,
-0.014945047,
-0.0295409597,
0.007823986,
0.0107163694,
-0.0092466213,
-0.0111133773,
0.019363381,
0.0479657203,
0.0617978312,
-0.0692635775,
-0.0263091382,
-0.0305847041,
-0.0415115952,
-0.056776382,
-0.0233365614,
0.0327380933,
0.0486810841,
-0.0166634507,
-0.0367116071,
-0.0259028561,
-0.0398492329,
0.0460982881,
-0.0157721918,
-0.0398978367,
0.0466685966,
0.0577624924,
-0.0104115671,
0.0092015285,
-0.0192134865,
-0.0416682661,
0.0376196653,
-0.0248521045,
0.0508188717,
-0.0007389775,
-0.036111623,
0.0173461884,
-0.0347710848,
0.0408588126,
-0.0015054304,
0.1000583917,
0.0402673036,
-0.0080461008,
-0.0080472007,
-0.0445125028,
-0.007063156,
0.0085524926,
-0.0385898761,
-0.0233960971,
0.0185593069,
0.0014594557,
-0.0021374549,
-0.0133146346,
-0.0694103613,
-0.0204331353,
0.032686647,
-0.0399714075,
-0.0514334515,
-0.0008681573,
-0.0236386955,
0.0017393905,
-0.0618940815,
0.0020345557,
2.889701003e-34,
0.0465362631,
0.021899879,
-0.015054618,
0.0049126591,
0.0485782549,
-0.0205548238,
-0.0772744268,
0.0057155658,
-0.0048686746,
-0.0985562354,
-0.0124754356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13195v1 | Learning Translations via Matrix Completion | 2024-06-19T04:03:19 | 2024-06-19T04:03:19 | Derry Wijaya, Brendan Callahan, John Hewitt, Jie Gao, Xiao Ling, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Bilingual Lexicon Induction is the task of learning word translations without
bilingual parallel corpora. We model this task as a matrix completion problem,
and present an effective and extendable framework for completing the matrix.
This method harnesses diverse bilingual and monolingual signals, each of which
may be incomplete or noisy. Our model achieves state-of-the-art performance for
both high and low resource languages. | [
0.0182662942,
0.0604584217,
-0.02341149,
0.0459020659,
-0.0403815955,
0.0283093955,
-0.0159422569,
-0.0195888877,
0.031080747,
0.0140920924,
0.0086153727,
-0.0253328234,
0.0504095592,
-0.0644423813,
0.0182916895,
-0.0168401003,
0.0407007746,
-0.0149668921,
-0.1145812422,
-0.0546102114,
-0.038182985,
0.0263742227,
-0.007512636,
0.001904302,
-0.0103406617,
0.0168448109,
0.0308110584,
-0.0046243155,
0.0106909806,
0.0490365662,
-0.057126753,
0.0074085337,
0.0029945509,
0.0350512452,
0.0000015688,
-0.0100648422,
-0.0311788563,
-0.0279023517,
0.0643191114,
-0.01688453,
0.045995269,
-0.0585258715,
0.0250269249,
0.0064572911,
-0.0217579622,
-0.0025048875,
0.0585849732,
-0.0072540538,
-0.0033675961,
-0.019005768,
-0.0223257132,
-0.0101467147,
-0.0041105459,
-0.0406413451,
-0.0156433787,
-0.0619769804,
-0.0099021494,
0.0168059096,
-0.0161467139,
-0.0039777257,
-0.0231990088,
0.0816903412,
0.0055258116,
0.0236609299,
-0.0047829123,
-0.0161631964,
0.0208695456,
-0.035719309,
0.0055672331,
0.0451076068,
-0.0260288753,
0.0010709703,
-0.001302233,
0.0306885336,
0.0101251826,
0.0310415681,
-0.0430828147,
0.0040159235,
0.0106270937,
0.0185660478,
0.0204302017,
-0.0191456508,
0.0352917686,
-0.0248954594,
-0.04518589,
0.0923641771,
0.0627295151,
-0.0262465496,
-0.0298683643,
0.050711818,
0.0735107586,
0.0163472202,
0.0215519276,
-0.0108671645,
-0.0136403125,
0.0447524525,
-0.0090605207,
-0.0756088719,
0.0026413822,
-0.0767794773,
-0.0009575895,
0.0559956729,
-0.044818677,
0.0639052838,
-0.0781308785,
-0.014625432,
-0.0680764914,
-0.0163023137,
-0.0824155435,
-0.0468867607,
-0.0009706297,
0.0510480739,
-0.0206357781,
0.0056720451,
-0.0379209518,
0.0000237366,
-0.0343036875,
0.0018377375,
-0.0003971869,
0.0305083543,
-0.007479704,
-0.0429130606,
-0.0620035715,
-0.0220317952,
0.0256729629,
0.0378482901,
-0.0111491848,
0.0081765028,
-0.0656947121,
-0.000649698,
-0.0536286235,
0.021298809,
0.0113615599,
-0.0422377735,
0.0102282073,
0.0801720545,
-0.0158588458,
-0.0551833324,
-0.0323712304,
0.009700832,
-0.0492936857,
-0.053826686,
-0.0248136744,
-0.0860533267,
0.091125764,
0.0287087075,
0.0397135727,
-0.0015851802,
0.0029639727,
-0.0179691128,
-0.0825057104,
0.0768092424,
-0.0273295101,
-0.0052045062,
0.0271964408,
-0.0432019904,
0.0515816025,
0.0785008147,
-0.0074742455,
0.0254946165,
0.055635944,
-0.0038315335,
-0.0305240303,
0.0693084374,
0.0309698656,
0.048871208,
-0.0627487525,
-0.0196007174,
0.0825978592,
0.0196260642,
0.0063276356,
0.0534658805,
-0.022828538,
0.032709565,
0.0324723832,
0.0205541309,
-0.0011203961,
0.0443910323,
0.0692928508,
-0.0363493003,
-0.0308814067,
0.0351893567,
0.0069667553,
0.008610216,
-0.0201167725,
0.0083913896,
0.034990333,
0.0449289009,
-0.0280661359,
-0.022371199,
0.0166304056,
-0.0601492003,
0.0742526799,
-0.002181076,
0.0807799622,
0.0473959185,
-0.0328031108,
0.0299722552,
0.021050632,
-0.058102902,
0.0741819292,
0.0308818184,
-0.0269197859,
0.0513131618,
0.0226256084,
0.0095092626,
0.0028085567,
-0.0212107319,
0.0049616601,
0.0081846183,
0.0252862219,
-0.0061953897,
0.0342297293,
-0.0566726215,
-0.0149256485,
0.0469894335,
-0.0072613568,
0.0135081392,
-0.0013041169,
0.0089589916,
0.0276926868,
-0.0426570177,
-0.0693422779,
0.0322453119,
-0.0368061848,
-0.0062309643,
0.0756094083,
0.0307633542,
0.0288773756,
0.0350937024,
0.0454680324,
-0.0247961562,
0.0232061408,
-0.0420056134,
-0.052780062,
0.0238299649,
-0.0021153158,
-0.0513048396,
0.0579726212,
-0.0268938877,
-0.0021787644,
0.0137883928,
-0.0148735633,
-0.0759487674,
0.0227701459,
-0.0451108105,
0.002328183,
-0.0282756221,
0.0266560167,
0.0039891829,
0.0094221709,
-0.0076886201,
0.0677568763,
-0.0255798735,
0.0345602073,
-0.013729902,
-0.0631858781,
0.0461619496,
-0.0390878431,
-0.0334269553,
0.0154945487,
0.032157205,
0.0306160823,
0.0377039909,
-0.0266635232,
0.0095426608,
-0.0406007506,
-0.0611685999,
0.0024669422,
-0.0063038361,
0.0042135483,
0.0081270207,
0.0294360183,
0.0425099283,
-0.0238084812,
-0.0084048333,
0.0309551172,
0.0193463322,
0.0242051445,
-0.0049932287,
0.0061478736,
-0.0343754254,
-0.0280036684,
-0.0388386138,
0.0388851501,
0.0396415442,
-0.0334771946,
-0.0475819372,
-0.032053262,
-0.0121473484,
-0.0177978892,
0.0394060686,
-0.0087629342,
-0.0297380034,
-0.0136740254,
-0.005963787,
0.0693222359,
-0.0067634303,
0.0083601605,
-0.0713981017,
0.0491586402,
-0.0257708356,
0.003551652,
0.0092316931,
-0.0530318767,
-0.0309229381,
-0.033268027,
-0.0190115739,
-0.0137258274,
0.0534678362,
0.0011773042,
-0.0412073843,
-0.0499252118,
-0.1094694659,
-0.0183470864,
0.0130194286,
-0.0568940379,
-0.0086565614,
-0.00842191,
0.04258544,
-0.0309504531,
-0.0475376993,
0.0496658981,
-0.047767248,
0.0078136437,
-0.0628187954,
0.0028438696,
-0.0448266529,
0.0150164999,
0.0155338226,
0.0455753468,
-0.1024470255,
-0.0192359388,
-0.0134890173,
0.0223788843,
0.0256792959,
-0.0117533356,
0.0509920418,
-0.0304571912,
0.005287806,
0.0036384491,
0.0047265715,
-0.0242510866,
-0.0040171696,
0.0161190946,
-0.0314877667,
0.0286372304,
-0.0114122331,
-0.0119635835,
-0.0181073807,
0.0440876819,
0.0368862078,
0.012583971,
0.0099313185,
-0.0163956527,
0.0022995784,
-0.0133245001,
-0.0174507163,
0.009617704,
-0.0480275713,
-0.0102024339,
-0.0092846984,
0.0198436324,
0.0127796261,
-0.0097923381,
-0.0134873223,
0.0613337792,
0.0119225318,
-0.0440138578,
-0.0231977087,
-0.0081933429,
0.0366118215,
0.0066742487,
0.0313156582,
0.0253551342,
-0.0760240331,
-0.0179982856,
0.0001674013,
-0.0192100145,
0.0496300757,
0.0213816892,
-0.1034064367,
0.0460948832,
-0.0000582471,
0.0250288155,
0.0517130755,
-0.0031928336,
-0.0275896266,
-0.0685738027,
-0.0118120834,
0.0529494621,
-0.0224682745,
-0.0479061827,
-0.0204036683,
-0.0176838599,
-0.0394999385,
0.0141290966,
0.0099124135,
0.0264359228,
-0.0294028651,
-0.0048046224,
0.0580483191,
-0.0455760472,
-0.0495157614,
-0.0421310142,
0.0018480256,
-0.0020599016,
0.0315893888,
-0.0467787907,
-0.028226614,
0.0066380948,
-0.0377190039,
-0.0591387413,
0.0128402887,
0.0187438,
0.0304383654,
-0.0146293091,
0.0148731396,
0.036487367,
-0.0497700162,
0.0053399219,
0.0023376425,
0.0627356172,
0.0072778217,
0.0408571139,
0.0348205902,
-0.0043648058,
0.0271858368,
0.0281036645,
0.0079490589,
-0.0472559892,
0.0799822658,
0.0282847025,
-0.0096738311,
-0.0373665728,
-0.0030744825,
-0.0061885552,
-0.0449983254,
-0.0106671229,
-0.060418088,
-0.0348028839,
0.029991053,
0.0511303246,
0.018427657,
0.043577455,
-0.0173077807,
-0.0455405749,
0.0091526276,
0.0070566121,
-0.0131050926,
0.0143162627,
0.0002648237,
-0.0086903106,
-0.0151417525,
-0.0439898297,
0.0148789808,
0.0294584632,
-0.070623897,
-0.0380518436,
0.00008691,
0.0612663738,
0.0188355874,
0.0272864737,
-0.0556139089,
-0.0201509073,
-0.0196856502,
0.0455902144,
-0.0271970369,
0.0127396286,
0.0200612303,
0.0099891862,
0.002558386,
0.051486522,
-0.0048962696,
0.0021108808,
0.0147923119,
0.0511393324,
-0.0270299558,
-0.0341457836,
0.0548005849,
-0.0244563036,
0.0135908751,
-0.0736229047,
0.0287892371,
-0.0444890931,
0.013920377,
-0.0422636047,
-0.0208653715,
-0.0283190664,
-0.0144888591,
0.0454360098,
-0.0129797645,
0.0163232442,
-0.0269467905,
0.0034486111,
0.0116061121,
-0.0009486152,
-0.0685107484,
-0.0211936552,
-0.0350548774,
0.033975102,
0.0454566367,
-0.0321697444,
0.0316429771,
-0.0087095667,
0.0160981715,
-0.0237818006,
0.0218085088,
0.0022732655,
0.0072293882,
-0.0358623043,
-0.0149327517,
0.0124133928,
-0.0635131523,
-0.0098816985,
0.0531791151,
0.0780929998,
-0.0163496267,
0.0695218444,
-0.0264762696,
-0.0334211513,
0.014323554,
0.0033393872,
0.0065705539,
-0.0234830137,
-0.0071794186,
-0.0135898087,
-0.0121130263,
0.0384595878,
0.070200868,
-0.0460130349,
0.0111294044,
-0.0441234596,
0.017786568,
-0.0093649086,
-0.0035176221,
-0.0208222531,
0.0300854668,
-0.0450416654,
-0.0014538938,
-0.0297974888,
-0.0611876622,
-0.0256281607,
0.0332412496,
-0.0092513813,
0.0061378847,
0.0130099664,
0.0943095013,
-0.0155482069,
0.0184309278,
-0.0638466403,
0.003507213,
0.0680792555,
-0.0339406393,
-0.0157009512,
-5.05849933e-33,
-0.0260013882,
-0.0145818554,
-0.0185858421,
-0.0103167081,
0.0384009741,
-0.0173572451,
0.0007981075,
0.0361534879,
0.0132212173,
-0.0001673574,
0.0292239711,
0.0205049496,
0.0128098596,
0.0087173237,
0.0458381549,
0.054770615,
0.0500179566,
0.0150918495,
0.0172576662,
0.0085911741,
0.0677492023,
0.0201163087,
0.0675852969,
-0.0739711523,
0.0445354171,
-0.0375904553,
-0.0151273292,
0.0341044776,
0.0280774031,
0.022970045,
-0.025260793,
0.0354196876,
0.0278942622,
-0.0106472606,
-0.0045764097,
-0.0432919897,
-0.0929253027,
0.0013722535,
0.0467475429,
0.024093397,
-0.0754732266,
-0.0303827245,
0.0428162105,
-0.0407505594,
-0.0086237444,
-0.0057346509,
0.0076054805,
-0.0423348509,
-0.0643832609,
0.0395381004,
-0.061719276,
0.0041970043,
0.0294908863,
0.0029071395,
0.0426539667,
0.0541162193,
-0.0080647245,
-0.0364012122,
-0.0601010136,
-0.004899485,
-0.0375874303,
0.0555019453,
0.0491022766,
-0.0122619914,
-0.0141175808,
-0.0081674736,
0.0447214246,
0.0247397553,
0.0396442153,
-0.0116691105,
-0.0096569443,
-0.0082647521,
0.0366194956,
0.0699898824,
-0.0034508014,
-0.0428750589,
-0.0253027156,
0.0196732897,
0.0073341914,
-0.0132979201,
0.0266287308,
-0.0157972723,
-0.0052062073,
-0.0180493537,
-0.0605254434,
-0.0333678201,
-0.0137331206,
-0.0337907784,
-0.0254056342,
0.0435137674,
-0.0346976481,
-0.0136526069,
0.0540689416,
-0.0115645304,
-0.0153754223,
0.0212332122,
0.0054634036,
0.0029209328,
-0.0042374302,
0.0401852839,
-0.0071560289,
-0.0533820465,
-0.044570066,
-0.0164908152,
-0.0098932656,
-0.0040990571,
0.0341819264,
0.0247809626,
-0.025895752,
0.0195847731,
-0.0505392961,
-0.0109933084,
-0.0145592075,
0.006957192,
0.0486789271,
0.003592368,
0.0019429534,
0.0732071027,
0.0374928489,
0.0183002129,
0.0055730115,
-0.0390505344,
0.0132916868,
0.0497724265,
-0.0141097186,
-0.0105099482,
-0.0349798463,
-0.0022636969,
0.0279036071,
-0.0307844579,
-0.0001147535,
-0.0058425176,
2.458e-7,
0.0353996605,
0.0047363946,
-0.0254580062,
0.0059142183,
0.0090480866,
-0.0206068866,
-0.0131849144,
0.0183353256,
-0.0141525958,
0.0131793171,
0.020748863,
-0.0149633233,
0.0624922439,
0.0340634137,
-0.0779740438,
-0.029306097,
-0.013569626,
0.0340752527,
-0.0561432615,
-0.0245536454,
0.0393623635,
0.0684754476,
0.0362065062,
-0.0000302277,
-0.0269547049,
-0.020578688,
0.1130920276,
-0.0064511988,
-0.0555070676,
-0.0085489014,
0.0497888923,
0.0212024413,
-0.0267661456,
0.0163747799,
-0.0216879342,
0.06438943,
0.0322084539,
0.0319374315,
0.0094663538,
0.0170569867,
0.0583720841,
-0.0453983285,
-0.0110298581,
-0.046290569,
0.0441866256,
-0.0212486256,
0.0286657922,
0.0152864866,
-0.0424354486,
0.0665162653,
0.0280120187,
-0.0137440581,
-0.03327021,
0.0070697241,
0.0663679317,
0.0295526329,
-0.0128737837,
-0.0447322801,
0.021793168,
0.0530122966,
-0.0408398248,
-0.0062594744,
0.0222645011,
-0.0015417659,
0.0000135026,
-0.019921327,
0.0211771857,
1.629141842e-34,
0.01052518,
-0.0074742888,
0.0359940454,
0.0047188532,
0.0033802809,
-0.0810557753,
-0.069988288,
0.0234846491,
0.0080658682,
-0.0574115105,
-0.0186907202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13193v1 | PRESTO: Progressive Pretraining Enhances Synthetic Chemistry Outcomes | 2024-06-19T03:59:46 | 2024-06-19T03:59:46 | He Cao, Yanjun Shao, Zhiyuan Liu, Zijing Liu, Xiangru Tang, Yuan Yao, Yu Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have seen growing adoption across
various scientific disciplines. These advancements encourage the investigation
of molecule-text modeling within synthetic chemistry, a field dedicated to
designing and conducting chemical reactions to synthesize new compounds with
desired properties and applications. Current approaches, however, often neglect
the critical role of multiple molecule graph interaction in understanding
chemical reactions, leading to suboptimal performance in synthetic chemistry
tasks. This study introduces PRESTO(Progressive Pretraining Enhances Synthetic
Chemistry Outcomes), a new framework that bridges the molecule-text modality
gap by integrating a comprehensive benchmark of pretraining strategies and
dataset configurations. It progressively improves multimodal LLMs through
cross-modal alignment and multi-graph understanding. Our extensive experiments
demonstrate that PRESTO offers competitive results in downstream synthetic
chemistry tasks. The code can be found at https://github.com/IDEA-XL/PRESTO. | [
0.0017116939,
0.0766751841,
0.0092814472,
0.0265165251,
-0.0105768396,
-0.0005407954,
0.0496922992,
0.0165033154,
0.0224848539,
-0.0297456328,
-0.0770770684,
-0.0428986177,
-0.0306823179,
0.0558013879,
0.0596055649,
0.0103932293,
0.0268852748,
-0.0615877584,
-0.0595979728,
-0.014341346,
0.0347010493,
0.0224587265,
-0.0235075112,
-0.0014896226,
-0.0094331475,
-0.0299853422,
0.0062165684,
0.0161886122,
0.0433543175,
-0.0313347243,
-0.0168403275,
0.0848400369,
0.0362260193,
0.0504159816,
0.0000016534,
-0.0716227815,
0.0010981205,
0.0249306038,
-0.0023450619,
0.0049167229,
0.0594257973,
-0.0198083539,
-0.0003907745,
-0.0179524422,
-0.0316829421,
0.0104502896,
0.0707761422,
0.0027702735,
0.0287306402,
0.0414725207,
-0.0120649394,
-0.008598295,
0.0327030048,
-0.004002376,
0.0693588108,
0.013836897,
0.0431677438,
0.0181722157,
-0.0009269566,
-0.0116245225,
-0.0137028713,
0.038116172,
-0.0096957153,
-0.0371884406,
0.0102283573,
-0.0068300925,
0.0046458277,
-0.0532561466,
-0.0145232631,
0.1056970134,
0.0021223235,
-0.0179118719,
-0.070898287,
0.0002172599,
-0.0587233305,
0.0256977845,
-0.0571705699,
-0.0061105192,
0.0029536346,
0.0102689434,
-0.0155843077,
-0.0441623181,
0.0249920953,
0.0112752486,
0.0169721264,
0.0224109869,
0.0277049523,
-0.0181630608,
0.0134605998,
0.0088746166,
-0.0413634479,
0.003395461,
0.0104909213,
-0.0048538209,
-0.0108438451,
0.0126149328,
0.0012775598,
-0.0325223356,
0.0243884139,
-0.0413787141,
0.0651819855,
0.0195260756,
-0.0039829412,
0.0139438156,
-0.0367280692,
0.0224493239,
-0.0302053615,
0.0194638129,
-0.0412133969,
0.0116883954,
-0.0439129733,
-0.0079912925,
-0.0213615894,
-0.003773849,
-0.0491111875,
-0.0202110745,
-0.0503515862,
0.0364729129,
0.026815258,
-0.0124897994,
0.0280491021,
0.0132395448,
-0.0312253479,
0.0002450269,
-0.0076577561,
0.0460203923,
0.0231311973,
0.0277350359,
-0.0213635657,
-0.0501013696,
-0.0429099984,
0.020308001,
-0.021885097,
-0.0443388745,
0.0089427447,
0.0939247757,
-0.0224143881,
0.0052852379,
0.01266017,
-0.0575156584,
0.0270487778,
-0.0464652106,
0.0499243923,
-0.0435702726,
0.0741986632,
0.0484453887,
0.0094189253,
-0.0477368049,
0.0070704301,
-0.0175696332,
-0.0029503664,
0.1236615255,
-0.0118018501,
-0.0497028418,
-0.001328054,
0.0098122032,
0.024968341,
0.0354205258,
0.019414315,
-0.0017472893,
-0.0138754547,
-0.0154848322,
-0.0043283864,
0.0351658016,
0.014903402,
-0.0120081427,
-0.0303022768,
-0.0064189369,
0.0295537151,
0.085884884,
0.0521313474,
-0.017597327,
-0.0346214138,
-0.0050233561,
0.0583477765,
0.0169940051,
0.068398498,
0.0252426323,
0.0399983823,
-0.0065902979,
0.0013610992,
-0.019908607,
-0.0461518951,
0.0520060994,
-0.0394581929,
-0.0075570643,
0.0444583669,
0.0589961931,
0.0018077428,
0.0000471418,
-0.0056350087,
-0.0081428839,
-0.0208330546,
-0.0331393406,
0.0490917638,
-0.0451504178,
-0.1044601724,
0.0320656337,
0.0528890826,
-0.0448764414,
-0.0085441219,
-0.0129381055,
-0.0100572789,
0.0774659365,
0.055609908,
-0.0595734529,
-0.0439903885,
0.0233654492,
-0.0196118634,
0.0343391635,
0.0258473996,
-0.0043756394,
0.035424117,
-0.0131555386,
-0.0427575074,
-0.0587818362,
-0.0176483262,
-0.0220484361,
0.0024406638,
-0.0246331356,
-0.0228868425,
-0.0447291844,
0.0029598053,
0.0207785349,
-0.012181242,
-0.025693031,
-0.0342322625,
-0.0324960947,
0.0259626452,
0.0094545241,
-0.0160322338,
0.0229992662,
0.0436920635,
-0.0472257622,
0.0285463855,
-0.0206957143,
-0.0063344459,
-0.0721958876,
0.0492601544,
-0.0318076909,
0.0029891946,
0.0017766516,
-0.0250752587,
-0.0230523683,
0.0485007688,
0.0353381857,
-0.0054593817,
-0.0243561361,
0.0032033967,
0.0002507184,
0.0699772537,
-0.0337869599,
0.0096977502,
0.0097389976,
0.0241914392,
-0.0127082113,
0.0417088307,
0.0225605834,
-0.0093710311,
0.013183591,
0.016546946,
0.0610679239,
0.0378827304,
0.0171093345,
-0.0067802975,
-0.0311961956,
-0.012533959,
-0.0618943833,
-0.0220941175,
-0.0010386533,
0.0141201364,
0.0407435745,
-0.0297588296,
-0.0083257463,
0.0113014355,
0.0141327474,
-0.0193642862,
-0.0301896986,
0.0085835112,
0.0342260562,
-0.0147936726,
-0.0566945635,
-0.0534999967,
-0.0401417091,
-0.0309862178,
0.0800554454,
0.0107407449,
-0.0427994952,
-0.0151699185,
-0.0104396371,
0.0017636394,
0.0210912414,
0.0102372263,
-0.0013037575,
0.0216839295,
0.000859649,
0.0611077845,
0.0018470049,
-0.0114783961,
0.0166233201,
0.0815955251,
-0.0031275162,
-0.0139685282,
-0.0161246378,
0.0003244942,
-0.0112532498,
0.0078430157,
-0.0278560407,
-0.0160310268,
0.071956262,
-0.0186950751,
0.0176887866,
-0.0039379788,
0.0145037593,
0.0121243838,
-0.0462463498,
-0.0374534316,
0.0139163015,
0.0041855299,
-0.0062815757,
0.0036595524,
-0.0761024728,
0.0640826598,
-0.0367268585,
-0.0102768419,
-0.0583056882,
0.0249177068,
0.0225807186,
0.0059224241,
0.013299631,
0.0266773049,
-0.0022431505,
0.0119341714,
-0.0320818871,
-0.0131745823,
0.0509592257,
0.0028274085,
0.0301069692,
-0.0529636182,
0.0332982354,
-0.020361729,
-0.0169385802,
-0.0042242017,
-0.0266013164,
-0.0068296962,
0.0236803666,
0.0266473461,
-0.0336907841,
-0.0051165186,
0.0305288155,
0.0489578992,
-0.0201182812,
-0.0184595585,
-0.0059971376,
-0.0333084539,
0.0341589265,
0.0078921318,
-0.041737821,
0.0092429481,
-0.0561947823,
0.0409997366,
0.0235959999,
0.0293278676,
-0.0121022444,
-0.0446023419,
0.0283059645,
0.0193413906,
0.0303906519,
-0.0016324595,
0.0048403423,
0.0167372767,
-0.0274230912,
-0.0058622584,
0.0605810061,
0.0137287322,
-0.0258967653,
0.0126053682,
0.0225851983,
0.0168485697,
-0.0070837121,
0.0421664901,
-0.0991506949,
-0.0360605828,
-0.0434281267,
0.0044201505,
0.0060440251,
-0.0026904915,
-0.0167589933,
-0.0532094389,
0.0467085727,
0.0310928077,
-0.0747219473,
-0.00924931,
-0.0613298789,
-0.033936657,
0.0065836278,
0.0210187063,
0.0333153829,
-0.0176630821,
-0.04333096,
0.0139272567,
0.00830983,
-0.0643624738,
-0.0055683022,
-0.0042316834,
-0.0251281932,
0.027948387,
0.0045938496,
0.0209994838,
0.009000456,
0.060627766,
0.0209631622,
0.0323158428,
-0.021241473,
0.0212049298,
0.0375755355,
-0.0012528634,
-0.0243636891,
0.0207394622,
-0.0439099036,
-0.0719302744,
-0.0597441159,
0.1002453491,
-0.0272503495,
0.0032095651,
-0.0403240956,
0.0263905358,
-0.0067681824,
0.0211206954,
0.0144499317,
-0.0246070437,
-0.0803823397,
-0.0281225014,
0.0181458741,
-0.0624990538,
-0.0133439591,
-0.0226295292,
-0.0339025296,
0.0092749372,
0.0048682466,
-0.0135352705,
0.0345673189,
0.0130110448,
-0.036437612,
0.0060956869,
-0.0220042467,
-0.0379733182,
-0.0423216298,
0.0820077881,
-0.0122081619,
0.0202804469,
-0.0412790775,
-0.0637792945,
0.0355652012,
-0.0258944035,
0.0061273123,
0.0584344417,
-0.073472783,
-0.0469732247,
-0.0281858463,
0.0141868582,
0.0268229339,
0.0406480171,
0.0129567664,
-0.0634831563,
0.0533657819,
0.0634269789,
0.0173608717,
0.0122769373,
0.0075824768,
0.007932188,
-0.0214042328,
-0.0172303095,
-0.0123982802,
0.0243226159,
0.0236588996,
0.0282538868,
0.0274805389,
-0.0397051163,
0.0219471417,
0.0415695086,
0.0594240502,
-0.0045210109,
0.0145469652,
-0.0572542101,
-0.0226528402,
0.0118845236,
0.0093649328,
-0.035520371,
-0.0227921978,
0.0305503719,
-0.02617543,
0.0012568884,
0.0061785807,
-0.0402680077,
0.0187448431,
-0.0447668806,
0.0382025056,
0.0148573583,
-0.0020227965,
0.1061183512,
-0.0065340083,
-0.0077257808,
0.0191648547,
-0.0498922132,
0.0038090635,
-0.0280342642,
0.0218565762,
0.0009033293,
0.0583297424,
-0.0388337858,
0.0374313071,
0.0021261575,
-0.0255502854,
-0.0951013193,
0.0471390523,
0.0895406604,
0.011404641,
0.0749286786,
-0.010323206,
-0.024172388,
-0.0201799609,
0.0652065426,
-0.0078644622,
-0.0014568766,
0.070175074,
0.0063693095,
-0.0046186992,
-0.005533882,
0.0894203782,
-0.0000297752,
0.0501139797,
-0.0089719687,
-0.0317256711,
-0.0216691401,
-0.0535971448,
0.0022087723,
-0.0094702831,
-0.0140239503,
-0.0254164897,
-0.0442467444,
-0.0454995111,
0.0292779859,
0.0317033567,
-0.060488224,
0.0182424709,
0.0559287518,
0.0746169463,
-0.0130059943,
-0.0474695489,
0.0033167056,
0.0111635858,
0.037784297,
-0.0516678616,
-0.002212899,
-5.404153811e-33,
-0.0113223447,
0.0019284887,
0.0169552974,
-0.0155005911,
-0.0466339886,
-0.0204099324,
-0.0863597244,
-0.0233154427,
0.0463610552,
0.0559051558,
0.0281694662,
-0.0411734283,
0.0116633167,
-0.0350319892,
-0.0050733029,
0.0297996402,
0.011958275,
0.006919445,
-0.0150149669,
0.0365719013,
0.0516264476,
0.0560816638,
0.0557632335,
-0.0246692263,
-0.0130360015,
0.0275538992,
-0.0187919084,
-0.0121236332,
-0.0625264421,
0.0589448623,
-0.0483603701,
0.0837273002,
-0.0078576859,
-0.0187594574,
-0.0504397266,
0.0055347462,
-0.0007808222,
0.0115033453,
0.0459171236,
-0.0012894451,
-0.0252170023,
-0.0138996206,
0.0336058512,
0.0143559687,
-0.0425769575,
-0.0134399328,
0.027441103,
-0.0088849701,
0.0016340816,
-0.0354918167,
-0.0951755047,
0.0031995613,
0.0170750059,
-0.0005686313,
-0.0047681998,
0.0245605931,
0.0182100683,
0.0125716925,
-0.0162221827,
0.0648590326,
-0.0098449476,
0.0190733895,
0.0819150656,
0.055607751,
0.0087330136,
0.0426278599,
0.0193796493,
-0.003374828,
0.028362399,
0.0302054007,
0.0339836031,
0.0472847,
0.0264111944,
0.0530839041,
0.0024850667,
0.0410280339,
-0.1055364013,
-0.0131412279,
-0.0493354723,
-0.0114903525,
0.014457603,
0.0562238768,
0.0564689003,
-0.0588030666,
-0.0530389883,
0.0494876131,
-0.0303237718,
-0.0075761075,
-0.0208923183,
-0.0398657471,
-0.0341461897,
-0.0030406932,
0.0401163958,
-0.0256949924,
-0.0356174409,
0.0355890654,
-0.0446087457,
0.0707591325,
-0.0208231173,
0.0126675004,
-0.0453177206,
-0.0613310225,
0.0367153548,
-0.0557938702,
0.0276602786,
-0.0175800882,
-0.0285891071,
0.0448559187,
-0.0177854225,
-0.0108958939,
-0.087904647,
-0.0188081283,
0.0499248207,
-0.0012860569,
0.0184817892,
0.0013029019,
-0.0191372074,
0.0465547554,
0.0074201534,
-0.0021714931,
0.0326861516,
-0.0007238237,
0.0013568447,
0.066517815,
-0.0530979931,
0.0251270775,
-0.0558714345,
-0.0379345901,
0.0503887944,
-0.0877075419,
-0.0284769796,
-0.0024225037,
2.503e-7,
0.0814351365,
0.0315699615,
0.0468893945,
-0.0258313026,
-0.0009415084,
0.0168316346,
-0.0026786991,
0.046625752,
-0.0202126186,
-0.0189607814,
0.0105542289,
0.0183079336,
0.0283953268,
0.024049297,
0.0112274773,
0.0122044943,
-0.0447884053,
-0.0081855999,
-0.0877662301,
-0.0052984636,
-0.0139145274,
0.0447707511,
-0.019798236,
-0.0363712758,
0.0125488983,
-0.0118782856,
0.0626917928,
-0.0512263812,
-0.0354578756,
0.054480616,
-0.0184852276,
-0.0800155327,
0.0040437691,
0.0577938296,
-0.0264714751,
-0.0289794765,
0.0211250558,
0.0351460353,
-0.0294944588,
-0.0213333163,
0.0266745165,
-0.0123647628,
-0.0003352015,
-0.0164649226,
0.0019663638,
-0.045816388,
-0.0182289016,
0.0040713134,
-0.0271140579,
-0.0212588068,
0.0293516312,
-0.0415528007,
0.0243554991,
0.0468421243,
0.0011504545,
0.0209320933,
-0.0202338658,
-0.0194119737,
-0.0550258458,
0.0230517536,
-0.0585020334,
-0.0344902575,
-0.0449344702,
-0.0241618957,
0.0266394895,
-0.0093691209,
-0.022243008,
2.276077339e-34,
0.0575185902,
-0.0091538746,
0.0282549206,
-0.0041171028,
0.0629447699,
-0.0310237873,
0.0152213853,
0.0306275897,
-0.0093877828,
-0.1046069041,
-0.0181081239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13188v1 | Synthetic Context Generation for Question Generation | 2024-06-19T03:37:52 | 2024-06-19T03:37:52 | Naiming Liu, Zichao Wang, Richard Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs), QG remains a
challenging problem due to its complicated process, open-ended nature, and the
diverse settings in which question generation occurs. A common approach to
address these challenges involves fine-tuning smaller, custom models using
datasets containing background context, question, and answer. However,
obtaining suitable domain-specific datasets with appropriate context is often
more difficult than acquiring question-answer pairs. In this paper, we
investigate training QG models using synthetic contexts generated by LLMs from
readily available question-answer pairs. We conduct a comprehensive study to
answer critical research questions related to the performance of models trained
on synthetic contexts and their potential impact on QG research and
applications. Our empirical results reveal: 1) contexts are essential for QG
tasks, even if they are synthetic; 2) fine-tuning smaller language models has
the capability of achieving better performances as compared to prompting larger
language models; and 3) synthetic context and real context could achieve
comparable performances. These findings highlight the effectiveness of
synthetic contexts in QG and paves the way for future advancements in the
field. | [
0.0435321853,
0.0247987602,
-0.008888972,
0.0391198955,
-0.0191264302,
-0.0015449935,
0.0244232956,
-0.0215584468,
-0.0142964926,
-0.0574009903,
-0.0064702798,
-0.0574536026,
-0.0334674641,
0.0385853052,
0.0336705223,
-0.0100008612,
0.0274405386,
-0.0128481342,
-0.0353431515,
0.0200364981,
0.0002833882,
0.0208167247,
-0.0043633324,
0.0449700616,
-0.0078129908,
-0.0200015027,
-0.0414954238,
0.0367807597,
0.0138346339,
-0.0399386734,
0.0247220565,
0.0529287048,
0.0297524929,
0.0125402901,
0.0000017264,
-0.046316769,
-0.0058310614,
-0.0231228881,
-0.0147702172,
-0.0259792805,
0.0044621797,
0.0384826511,
0.0156663973,
0.0459744409,
-0.0850582048,
-0.0030718732,
0.0127702104,
0.0327385105,
0.0672045201,
0.0539404601,
-0.0142969852,
-0.0233592205,
-0.0055851131,
-0.0256921165,
0.0550356507,
-0.0460151918,
0.0051232981,
0.0437145606,
0.0245812908,
0.02199159,
-0.0037388674,
0.0128677171,
0.0461299531,
-0.0194913577,
0.001900395,
0.0231557768,
-0.0232917443,
-0.0064547262,
-0.0045706681,
0.1159382835,
0.0203893073,
-0.0156247942,
-0.0008261261,
0.0021360659,
0.0483478978,
-0.0033662319,
-0.0419299155,
0.0377199911,
-0.0298087634,
-0.0146030951,
0.036488384,
0.0004930779,
0.005648436,
0.0031227288,
-0.0232334491,
0.0245934147,
0.0341435224,
-0.0119062597,
-0.0528912172,
0.0016618334,
-0.0698753744,
-0.0717349127,
-0.0108318152,
0.0354969352,
-0.0486028604,
0.0445503592,
-0.0660314485,
0.0009594624,
0.0145001095,
0.0198859517,
-0.0035069489,
0.0365578458,
0.0146781448,
0.017727403,
0.0005460577,
0.0357934013,
-0.0084491679,
-0.018263163,
-0.0772098601,
-0.0109514436,
-0.0274882969,
-0.0232548509,
-0.0518932156,
0.0210567806,
-0.1063630208,
-0.0379447527,
-0.0276470855,
0.0534504317,
0.0421664715,
-0.0079996455,
0.0312431175,
0.0273833871,
-0.0675706714,
0.0022158572,
-0.0049454207,
-0.0266401824,
-0.0657150075,
0.0191670954,
0.0694465414,
-0.0790167376,
0.0154539896,
0.0164720863,
0.0362203307,
-0.0282055624,
-0.0367185995,
0.0285610538,
0.0120304339,
-0.0158558432,
-0.0223308392,
-0.0666597858,
-0.0271397904,
-0.0347927175,
-0.0245541167,
-0.0586288497,
0.0236412529,
0.0146223279,
-0.0196052566,
0.0273385122,
0.0325679816,
0.0444726869,
0.0257107727,
0.0565087833,
-0.018052211,
0.0045799371,
0.0510933548,
0.0218656473,
0.0321039185,
0.0602388494,
0.0240787826,
-0.0014219135,
0.0265389979,
0.0006980679,
-0.0104476502,
0.0156315099,
0.0181851704,
-0.0082861371,
-0.0164682325,
0.0334280841,
0.0176500827,
0.0469433516,
-0.018558085,
0.0540229231,
-0.0294390153,
-0.0013571582,
0.038811259,
0.0303223841,
0.0278918315,
0.0103777573,
0.0764849633,
0.014239708,
-0.0100176865,
0.0144991614,
-0.0241824836,
0.0092817107,
-0.0051261904,
0.0259349402,
0.0071201157,
0.0239542723,
-0.0217863657,
-0.0330157578,
0.0126220034,
0.0206093192,
-0.0133769978,
0.0100438939,
0.0018998273,
0.0541186854,
-0.0512584969,
0.0314273722,
-0.0035503139,
-0.0597005822,
0.012643707,
-0.0285776071,
0.0549857654,
0.0145397624,
0.0648487136,
-0.0089574615,
-0.0471956469,
-0.0157272238,
0.0098337149,
0.033052735,
0.0587516613,
-0.0320244543,
-0.0082786009,
-0.0257915258,
-0.0063685095,
-0.0549756549,
0.0075020879,
0.0046297275,
0.0353711993,
0.0159848556,
0.021807665,
-0.0307459626,
0.0052062352,
0.0296489298,
-0.0636530966,
-0.0436180793,
0.0276153684,
-0.018645769,
-0.0159563217,
0.0204589944,
0.0075778128,
0.0313602425,
0.0341648385,
-0.0534402207,
-0.00644007,
0.0389275104,
-0.0886321589,
-0.0914355665,
0.0180597994,
-0.0191459581,
0.0204075798,
-0.008142367,
-0.0352554694,
-0.0409843661,
-0.0139039,
-0.0049088425,
0.026188219,
-0.0678812489,
-0.0050513339,
0.0270730518,
-0.0030652829,
-0.069893159,
0.069903329,
0.010968633,
0.0045082336,
0.0350376517,
0.0686115772,
0.0136157861,
-0.0267542806,
0.022843523,
-0.0046890825,
-0.0347208157,
0.0176120084,
0.0232823789,
0.0257969927,
-0.0967544466,
-0.0238896124,
-0.0895045102,
0.0448303111,
-0.0329299383,
0.0132320253,
0.0766753629,
0.028201703,
-0.0236417111,
-0.013495326,
-0.0943759978,
-0.0034899563,
0.0361761525,
-0.0053043268,
0.043120563,
0.0314467773,
0.0472958907,
-0.0320677012,
0.0014684917,
-0.0033969842,
0.0397822782,
0.0383661501,
0.0326772965,
-0.0705268458,
0.0389618464,
-0.0299514513,
-0.0095941611,
-0.0000549382,
-0.0145259351,
0.0335812755,
-0.0352130905,
0.0572994836,
0.0371622033,
0.0217776727,
0.012403843,
0.0157740954,
0.0055690901,
-0.0331642553,
0.0139853964,
-0.0321558043,
-0.0103551745,
-0.0165913198,
-0.0375561118,
0.0161785055,
0.0510769822,
0.0222600959,
-0.0012933066,
-0.0426733792,
0.0815732777,
-0.0080833491,
-0.0211583897,
-0.0553309023,
0.0009838825,
-0.0190245192,
0.0667793304,
-0.0253747795,
-0.019387912,
0.0336578079,
-0.0042438651,
0.0009714682,
-0.0529369563,
0.0035609468,
-0.044536531,
0.062372826,
-0.0058230413,
0.0305991378,
0.0071194801,
-0.0284245256,
-0.0836776644,
0.0074913222,
0.007623652,
-0.0400534868,
0.0243081413,
-0.0567104071,
0.0008547675,
-0.0033959614,
-0.0389992632,
-0.0869923234,
-0.035546124,
-0.0037010002,
-0.0246490594,
0.0083918814,
-0.0092174402,
0.0368022434,
0.0178580508,
-0.0153540969,
0.0446564928,
-0.0329450779,
-0.0205921661,
-0.0287902579,
0.1315359324,
0.099086538,
0.0266936664,
0.0264081769,
-0.022539543,
0.0738885105,
0.0430400483,
0.0358362608,
0.0334053673,
0.0217389949,
-0.0015234078,
-0.0075620315,
-0.0107773338,
-0.0102993669,
0.0364755057,
0.0801456794,
-0.0396261327,
-0.063644208,
0.0996443704,
0.0563261099,
-0.0178000722,
-0.0097568715,
-0.0261797383,
0.0392742641,
0.0325348265,
0.0236446448,
-0.1102718562,
-0.0343690179,
-0.022605665,
-0.0040586079,
-0.0001251758,
-0.0414072908,
-0.0204037391,
-0.1327705085,
0.0281493664,
-0.0029082247,
-0.0765168443,
-0.0132381674,
0.0146168731,
-0.0012279697,
0.0309832413,
0.0193705726,
0.0183514617,
-0.0149949891,
0.0259925388,
0.0152230095,
0.0205608364,
-0.0460217334,
-0.0042829923,
-0.0315671265,
0.029555222,
0.0431689695,
0.0173962824,
0.0351804942,
-0.0004968445,
0.0087673236,
-0.0647561327,
0.0116185648,
-0.00635124,
0.0145569323,
0.0050490121,
-0.0106443018,
-0.0211322643,
0.0510955825,
-0.0493394583,
-0.0096660908,
0.0533910468,
0.0344407223,
-0.0257876068,
-0.0229601655,
-0.0125966314,
0.0222416092,
0.0319413953,
0.0749286935,
0.0708458573,
-0.0619563013,
-0.0196852628,
-0.0322737843,
0.0193271581,
-0.0861991271,
-0.0012248721,
0.0025180858,
0.0328948721,
0.035816811,
-0.119842425,
-0.0419722721,
0.0404864959,
0.0274681561,
0.0038731101,
0.0153393671,
-0.0185946263,
-0.0154099651,
-0.0460220538,
0.0215397011,
-0.0238403175,
-0.0073716962,
-0.0359960273,
-0.0069281165,
0.0424038805,
-0.057642065,
-0.0090266578,
0.0060855243,
-0.0874443725,
-0.0515972413,
-0.0011097464,
0.0244864691,
0.0160694476,
0.0416536033,
-0.0245406702,
0.0006356078,
0.0001538118,
0.0248357132,
-0.0205457248,
-0.0044369954,
-0.0199601538,
0.0280701965,
-0.015784299,
0.0271975864,
-0.0442274846,
0.0019358869,
-0.0018214565,
0.0746679604,
-0.0600710995,
-0.042467922,
0.0463467836,
-0.0181591343,
-0.0104834344,
-0.0190749001,
-0.0011482732,
-0.0247659683,
0.0114677008,
-0.0434096456,
-0.0142839449,
-0.0594892763,
0.0182831064,
-0.0015606454,
-0.021797955,
0.0177780278,
-0.027946841,
-0.0539967455,
0.0516152941,
-0.0196922366,
-0.0142834196,
0.0055050999,
0.0334711708,
0.0477118939,
-0.010659528,
-0.0251183528,
-0.0073375986,
0.0047294749,
0.0607434846,
-0.0023093054,
0.0887285694,
0.0111864032,
-0.0333994366,
0.0250222813,
0.0231567658,
-0.0647815466,
-0.0366503187,
-0.0137664257,
0.0170337074,
0.042096898,
0.0161050595,
-0.0115119005,
-0.0062203659,
-0.0147110857,
0.0014080185,
0.0556561239,
0.0347909853,
-0.0387410857,
0.042762775,
0.0243855026,
-0.0242626835,
0.0122262212,
0.0544357784,
0.0144583406,
0.0397374742,
0.0131063452,
0.0353651494,
-0.0581700541,
0.0020448898,
0.004941599,
0.0165346917,
-0.0030292142,
0.0444328971,
-0.0545125604,
-0.0675016567,
-0.018399572,
0.019384915,
-0.0160642751,
-0.0002142585,
0.0384741277,
0.0507986806,
-0.0152848903,
0.0027129804,
-0.0349436253,
0.0369840376,
-0.0649314746,
-0.0364196077,
-0.0108117014,
-5.791324549e-33,
-0.0148324799,
-0.0659139603,
0.0381549671,
-0.0485210232,
-0.0245879013,
-0.0088500604,
-0.0473665297,
0.0028632586,
-0.0003146701,
-0.0227633193,
-0.0232640021,
0.0213180594,
-0.0069231531,
0.0363669991,
-0.0216860976,
-0.0479806289,
0.034953706,
-0.0222097058,
0.0031211602,
0.0718167573,
0.0111785037,
0.0188753493,
0.0101211695,
-0.0092489775,
0.0127020115,
-0.0560327284,
0.0012344661,
0.0369651467,
-0.0110493582,
0.0643560588,
-0.0305466373,
0.0149205299,
0.0290664043,
-0.0157330222,
0.0088906446,
0.0600860938,
-0.0323410034,
-0.0378225148,
0.0017195705,
-0.0221044552,
-0.0746052861,
-0.044056125,
-0.0037970967,
-0.0264117345,
0.0358838886,
0.0188367665,
0.0191765577,
-0.0201642103,
-0.0161965042,
-0.0483470708,
-0.0404540561,
0.0026806169,
0.0044889231,
-0.0133577185,
-0.0467602275,
0.0894013122,
0.0114766499,
0.0128386663,
0.0090919221,
0.0224452261,
0.0206693318,
-0.0024623368,
0.0395636819,
0.0478793979,
-0.0076806881,
0.0358795077,
0.0104514435,
-0.0002010555,
-0.0038849302,
0.0039052407,
-0.0267065018,
0.0236707386,
0.0430462994,
0.0921959504,
0.0501476116,
0.0211283229,
-0.0588364229,
0.0393686295,
-0.011462111,
-0.0386071838,
0.0060984534,
-0.0523761623,
0.0089189922,
0.0097134942,
-0.0482519045,
0.0162183214,
-0.0322291516,
-0.0095255207,
0.0666991025,
0.0005475949,
-0.0368469134,
-0.0300871227,
0.0388766527,
-0.0349748842,
0.0155832507,
0.015217267,
-0.0180376414,
0.0035908998,
-0.0207171235,
0.0403482914,
-0.0248559006,
0.0179778337,
0.0350572988,
0.0113954581,
-0.0020743434,
0.0403359644,
0.0053235712,
-0.0266517401,
-0.035133373,
0.0158354212,
-0.0375598408,
0.0676254928,
-0.0312042851,
-0.006177933,
0.0054458007,
0.0207009949,
-0.0207706299,
0.0307347365,
0.0358197205,
-0.0055084093,
-0.0245321095,
-0.0298231337,
-0.0084977997,
0.0416419953,
-0.0231547579,
0.0062864674,
-0.0255615655,
0.0429234244,
0.0397890657,
-0.0417336337,
-0.0213796496,
0.0082015917,
2.364e-7,
0.0391148999,
0.0131663037,
0.028114425,
0.0172295514,
0.0053069461,
0.0126705077,
0.0335880592,
0.0133144548,
0.0308166817,
0.0040989001,
0.0143439639,
0.0216854662,
0.0233161487,
0.0064494931,
-0.1010698974,
0.0023005621,
-0.066168718,
0.0120444112,
-0.059924148,
0.002044207,
0.0790261477,
0.0795025527,
-0.0387771726,
-0.0146007603,
0.0053453278,
-0.021613745,
0.0477015153,
-0.0249399431,
-0.0169938151,
0.0465688258,
-0.0026665716,
0.0283270385,
0.0122263925,
-0.0130525492,
-0.0173898079,
-0.0012922611,
-0.0025730643,
0.0267370827,
0.0418599099,
-0.0441558585,
-0.0091909049,
-0.0147632454,
0.0305919629,
-0.0708336532,
0.0561090037,
-0.075213179,
0.0028722668,
-0.0234873481,
-0.014438523,
-0.0292487647,
0.0017597813,
-0.0406845137,
-0.0225972068,
-0.0122373402,
0.0178539585,
-0.0020245118,
0.0175198074,
-0.0447806306,
-0.0228428692,
0.0102458494,
-0.025455296,
-0.039624311,
-0.0425720103,
-0.0125802225,
-0.0100805778,
-0.0286427066,
0.0109634595,
2.044923952e-34,
0.0200162828,
0.0069071115,
0.0200677458,
0.0331799984,
0.028012393,
-0.0273566619,
-0.011115212,
-0.0181957558,
0.0342594385,
-0.0997328982,
-0.0236922093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13185v1 | Learnable In-Context Vector for Visual Question Answering | 2024-06-19T03:33:45 | 2024-06-19T03:33:45 | Yingzhe Peng, Chenduo Hao, Xu Yang, Jiawei Peng, Xinting Hu, Xin Geng | cs.CL | cs.CL | As language models continue to scale, Large Language Models (LLMs) have
exhibited emerging capabilities in In-Context Learning (ICL), enabling them to
solve language tasks by prefixing a few in-context demonstrations (ICDs) as
context. Inspired by these advancements, researchers have extended these
techniques to develop Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) with ICL capabilities.
However, applying ICL usually faces two major challenges: 1) using more ICDs
will largely increase the inference time and 2) the performance is sensitive to
the selection of ICDs. These challenges are further exacerbated in LMMs due to
the integration of multiple data types and the combinational complexity of
multimodal ICDs. Recently, to address these challenges, some NLP studies
introduce non-learnable In-Context Vectors (ICVs) which extract useful task
information from ICDs into a single vector and then insert it into the LLM to
help solve the corresponding task. However, although useful in simple NLP
tasks, these non-learnable methods fail to handle complex multimodal tasks like
Visual Question Answering (VQA). In this study, we propose \textbf{Learnable
ICV} (L-ICV) to distill essential task information from demonstrations,
improving ICL performance in LMMs. Experiments show that L-ICV can
significantly reduce computational costs while enhancing accuracy in VQA tasks
compared to traditional ICL and other non-learnable ICV methods. | [
0.0083177164,
0.0401404984,
0.0080046672,
0.0794054568,
-0.021074703,
-0.0059264665,
0.0295828357,
0.0125865526,
-0.0132639669,
-0.0777418837,
-0.0378626324,
-0.0404963456,
-0.0127784908,
-0.001807663,
0.0515610836,
-0.054927472,
0.0243735667,
-0.0564651117,
-0.0171826091,
-0.0066643613,
0.0219263285,
-0.0031281223,
-0.0200220961,
0.0207017604,
-0.0351202041,
-0.0439771824,
-0.0187450573,
0.0160455424,
0.0172591135,
-0.0394872688,
0.0043047075,
0.0310865026,
0.0852779821,
-0.0261636507,
0.0000018999,
-0.0008171995,
0.0197302978,
0.0023526386,
-0.0047985362,
-0.0069926623,
0.0085567776,
-0.0280961748,
0.0233399887,
-0.0066840672,
-0.042898275,
0.000015989,
0.0256544426,
0.0378120318,
0.0591091141,
0.0595957525,
0.0042154356,
-0.0020185632,
0.0126671717,
-0.005359727,
0.0278244782,
-0.0594846718,
-0.0011091403,
0.0298856422,
0.0216310881,
0.0071449471,
-0.08627446,
0.0631185099,
0.0389279425,
0.0208710153,
-0.0203728434,
0.0561967418,
-0.0187634248,
-0.0047964691,
-0.0303779095,
0.0808456242,
-0.0202046297,
0.0131348427,
-0.0173937455,
0.0037245792,
-0.0056388592,
0.0085853366,
-0.0782513097,
0.0445464961,
-0.0113364393,
0.013693531,
-0.0223815311,
0.0185049661,
0.0012085118,
0.0094195623,
0.0181021225,
0.0009075343,
-0.0098806489,
0.0140243135,
-0.0054719998,
-0.0080583515,
-0.0724487901,
-0.052631557,
-0.062078584,
0.0471531972,
-0.0464149117,
0.0283923242,
-0.0350820944,
-0.0227154549,
-0.0081618493,
-0.0288915541,
0.0632973015,
0.0018197418,
-0.025788622,
0.056436196,
-0.0099312663,
0.0463192202,
-0.0394931175,
0.0349178873,
-0.0366131924,
-0.0371131077,
-0.0174858533,
-0.0013640651,
-0.0430090018,
0.0199248027,
-0.0465853997,
-0.0644718558,
0.009370652,
0.0406594798,
-0.0447290689,
-0.0177265424,
-0.0189889353,
0.0272135213,
-0.0292162728,
0.0154156629,
-0.036760211,
0.0419185795,
-0.045555409,
0.0149683226,
-0.0105812121,
-0.0465526171,
-0.0141361402,
0.0314801559,
0.0156436916,
-0.0448575467,
0.0208760556,
0.0593943223,
-0.0521864593,
-0.067097418,
-0.0099783996,
-0.0063187685,
0.0023475045,
-0.0586884879,
0.0572877228,
-0.0835006759,
0.0488579795,
-0.0159316044,
0.0051557701,
-0.0288687218,
0.0128255114,
0.0431507975,
-0.0126610026,
0.0961504206,
0.0328967422,
0.0091088414,
0.0129891131,
0.0065748338,
-0.0220510308,
0.0794204026,
0.0100880284,
-0.0106277019,
0.065259248,
0.0062971627,
0.0547523201,
0.0378174856,
0.035938032,
0.0387159735,
-0.0446224585,
0.0398571566,
0.0111698322,
0.014364914,
0.0626310334,
0.0326417796,
-0.0321036614,
-0.0309174154,
0.060057532,
0.0248322636,
0.0009196959,
-0.0524115376,
0.0384940021,
0.0043165297,
0.0202215873,
-0.0141267702,
-0.0720293373,
0.0617183931,
-0.0223370772,
0.003926619,
0.0239717327,
0.0143621275,
-0.0459412783,
-0.0339901336,
-0.0072384831,
-0.006819291,
0.0184790418,
0.0499811172,
0.0327285342,
0.0228155777,
-0.0340217464,
-0.0149243856,
0.0033021218,
0.0008689905,
-0.0205625817,
-0.0175764672,
0.0474485196,
0.0234389883,
0.0439599454,
-0.0079306858,
-0.0148866698,
-0.0009433691,
0.0687696263,
0.0355837978,
-0.0226080101,
-0.0293947924,
0.0348026305,
-0.03265284,
-0.0178425647,
-0.0315066315,
0.0094502196,
-0.016944157,
0.051891569,
-0.0215052925,
-0.0202311333,
-0.0431626886,
0.032262221,
0.0256700702,
0.0007698099,
-0.0154073909,
-0.0328023881,
0.0138333794,
0.0248838682,
-0.0211710036,
0.0013173464,
-0.0151807116,
0.0389606506,
-0.0400330499,
0.0064448607,
0.0050226809,
-0.0432665683,
-0.1066305712,
0.0134402448,
-0.0496043898,
-0.0238638334,
0.0092481561,
-0.0598602407,
0.0084317503,
-0.016942624,
-0.036156673,
0.0108486153,
-0.0405202694,
-0.0371515267,
0.0639256611,
-0.0004279527,
-0.0241712593,
0.0611364208,
-0.0333359577,
-0.0005848969,
0.0537525974,
0.0450793952,
-0.0163990464,
-0.0404952653,
-0.0127958134,
0.016805457,
0.004719249,
0.0298473872,
-0.0238869656,
0.033387024,
-0.0342956521,
0.0070848665,
-0.1183645427,
0.001022594,
-0.0243094824,
-0.0337338895,
0.0032026898,
-0.0004411957,
0.0103406869,
-0.0285721719,
-0.0497702472,
-0.0174426269,
0.0187970139,
0.0285770223,
0.0311309081,
0.0331835188,
0.0007592653,
-0.0075106113,
-0.0074375728,
0.0247014351,
0.1078749746,
-0.0466487184,
0.0164212082,
-0.0056020352,
-0.024996154,
-0.0315250754,
0.0696842298,
-0.040377114,
0.0090211369,
0.0199160445,
0.0001916303,
0.0417346247,
0.0675785914,
0.0189509727,
0.0449197255,
-0.0058139008,
-0.0253523607,
-0.0478582457,
0.0332454778,
0.0088073043,
-0.0297774188,
-0.0066077262,
-0.0048889918,
-0.021538645,
0.0225154124,
-0.0276672803,
-0.0108434232,
-0.0437908359,
0.041574508,
0.0220219586,
-0.0473272428,
-0.0652234778,
0.0146744717,
-0.0152584203,
0.0058967727,
-0.0259038024,
-0.0704933852,
0.019436188,
-0.0305603575,
-0.0243351385,
-0.0050445804,
-0.0012550204,
-0.0432607979,
0.0820425153,
0.0104434351,
0.0170993954,
-0.0538573228,
0.0058632051,
-0.0539761297,
-0.005052174,
-0.0074522402,
-0.018737359,
0.067402333,
-0.0591752976,
0.0318733007,
-0.0151156923,
-0.032135766,
-0.0613542981,
-0.0168582629,
0.0007017851,
0.0060780323,
-0.0563255474,
0.0062125009,
0.0151604107,
0.0025990398,
0.039187178,
-0.0016485464,
-0.0126809301,
0.004154366,
-0.0216387846,
0.056908451,
0.0558665358,
0.0793416128,
-0.0468320325,
-0.0367586277,
-0.0153370863,
0.0544912182,
0.0647684783,
-0.0387881324,
-0.0351411514,
0.0294358358,
0.0117325308,
0.0379593261,
-0.0142879002,
0.0441165864,
0.060643401,
-0.0569468699,
-0.0049146642,
0.0579578057,
0.0016165702,
-0.0245553069,
0.0034416672,
0.041060999,
-0.0124787036,
0.0365161821,
0.0377941579,
-0.0755641088,
-0.0612204187,
-0.0098163513,
0.009756431,
0.0067872219,
0.0076724296,
-0.0335903801,
-0.11005795,
0.0493149422,
-0.0023113182,
-0.0707048401,
-0.0579422452,
0.0024675659,
-0.0070572412,
0.0190234389,
0.0277143028,
0.0144115957,
-0.0120626846,
0.0170986522,
0.0017150118,
0.0066092391,
-0.057678964,
0.025554182,
-0.0343568362,
0.0202087238,
0.0180836637,
-0.0039424002,
-0.0074736788,
-0.0585097671,
0.036745593,
-0.0362327397,
-0.0024977739,
-0.0308567956,
0.0443788841,
-0.0427134149,
-0.041256588,
0.0037685968,
0.0571903139,
0.0099555319,
-0.051503621,
-0.0215331595,
0.0659833699,
0.0010265613,
-0.0060620522,
-0.039951548,
-0.0167006832,
0.0105099026,
0.0570581816,
0.015995821,
-0.0569324717,
-0.0220115874,
-0.0059353979,
-0.0277364831,
-0.0290094428,
-0.0066241091,
0.0121818846,
0.0184019916,
0.0209415462,
-0.0711659193,
-0.0300800316,
0.0528216772,
0.1030614004,
-0.0430082083,
0.0107712783,
-0.0382483862,
0.0209981836,
-0.0636422113,
0.0818977952,
-0.0361258723,
0.0383928493,
-0.0489128381,
0.0010998675,
0.0090873726,
-0.0359155461,
-0.034444347,
0.045080103,
-0.0710017458,
-0.0041679023,
-0.0513078235,
0.059091147,
0.0066242749,
0.0606109835,
0.0375505947,
-0.016310079,
0.0474494472,
0.0281303432,
0.0267431252,
0.0429206155,
0.0147479903,
0.0191784799,
0.0099998182,
0.0169685129,
-0.0394871421,
-0.0214550216,
0.0094829928,
0.0518927127,
-0.0233336315,
0.0055037141,
0.0263613015,
0.0078155873,
0.0187274907,
-0.0040889215,
-0.0023997456,
-0.0153603908,
0.0105189737,
0.0169117209,
-0.0299928747,
-0.0867578313,
0.0088450536,
-0.0109825619,
0.0145964604,
0.0007776744,
-0.0051411893,
0.027889058,
0.0073917974,
-0.0206710789,
0.0043867026,
0.0381028093,
-0.0293689072,
-0.0035200885,
0.0326385088,
-0.0083779804,
0.002377969,
-0.0287301671,
0.0401546173,
0.0033483377,
0.0836499259,
0.0480451621,
-0.0475500114,
-0.0509297512,
0.0265620053,
-0.0135241039,
0.0054409546,
-0.0372908153,
0.0541287363,
0.0487918854,
0.0107099572,
-0.0178673938,
-0.0003894159,
-0.0125870183,
-0.0007117029,
0.0170519277,
0.0102309817,
-0.0539835282,
0.110658519,
0.0389430486,
0.0215881504,
-0.0092192525,
0.0760499984,
-0.0138599807,
0.0374008566,
-0.0266656931,
0.0371896215,
-0.0402629189,
-0.0103695681,
0.0655480921,
0.031339366,
0.0185170416,
0.0352172889,
-0.0284630284,
-0.0621723719,
0.0044974792,
0.0308993999,
-0.0596740283,
-0.001676627,
0.0488498285,
0.0323222168,
0.0427500084,
-0.04166108,
-0.0359145999,
-0.0204471555,
0.0175424125,
-0.005225352,
0.011209921,
-5.855314788e-33,
-0.0407787077,
-0.0415256731,
0.0579116382,
-0.011627499,
-0.0336631872,
0.0320378207,
-0.0111907776,
0.0038695049,
-0.0115873665,
-0.0241644308,
-0.0068660784,
-0.0279062074,
-0.0063413233,
0.0476454943,
-0.0088753719,
-0.0268041249,
-0.0077182441,
-0.0003359763,
-0.0185190383,
-0.0088293217,
-0.0000514951,
0.0078642052,
0.0419283733,
-0.0541796312,
0.0193255842,
-0.001240938,
-0.0330513455,
0.0639317408,
-0.024588719,
0.062962167,
-0.034633372,
0.0159638859,
0.030950604,
-0.0349223055,
-0.0250514131,
0.0315522403,
-0.0661564991,
0.0027141559,
0.0478549227,
0.037642248,
-0.11535763,
0.0123779662,
0.0472017117,
-0.0109875407,
0.0241334885,
-0.0223354492,
0.0097466437,
-0.0186090674,
-0.0007892181,
-0.0029536583,
-0.0290918276,
0.0072468421,
0.0157233831,
-0.0451259911,
0.013037595,
0.0391610786,
0.0073224427,
0.0197400823,
-0.0549754575,
-0.0089004785,
-0.0250342116,
0.0125088226,
0.0837566257,
0.052453354,
0.0013152303,
0.0466909707,
0.0079975445,
-0.0414134935,
-0.015773708,
-0.033581689,
0.0370352678,
0.0639111474,
0.0349423066,
0.0628300682,
0.0332760327,
0.0523135066,
-0.0203348454,
0.0239776075,
-0.002411752,
0.0308114048,
-0.0140827652,
0.0115969144,
-0.0065156943,
-0.0131540056,
-0.0421622284,
0.0187694654,
-0.0169701818,
-0.0050101867,
0.0646328107,
0.04510919,
-0.009912516,
0.0464062393,
0.073649697,
-0.0510936715,
-0.0260503236,
0.0246775169,
-0.0080486275,
0.0657766685,
0.0113512212,
0.0073837759,
-0.0188224185,
-0.0155252619,
0.0400314331,
-0.0460649729,
-0.0196574815,
0.0017264499,
0.0281206891,
0.0442561805,
-0.05351099,
-0.0183646325,
-0.0347836204,
0.0235766582,
-0.0184966587,
0.0123493718,
0.0301935747,
-0.0002012537,
-0.0553099997,
0.0160340499,
-0.0115629118,
-0.059122283,
-0.0226467084,
-0.0368160903,
-0.0316123776,
0.005074088,
-0.0210188031,
0.0236507561,
-0.0222229641,
0.0033912959,
-0.0209505428,
-0.0573485233,
-0.0018485349,
0.0667853951,
2.514e-7,
0.0501749441,
0.0127450693,
-0.0070005199,
0.0390447713,
0.0311410092,
0.0387639925,
-0.0319790803,
0.0266322587,
-0.0049605272,
-0.0395952426,
0.0112178894,
0.0662869364,
0.0300898086,
0.0278624333,
-0.0086178677,
-0.008252372,
-0.0123842424,
-0.0129821161,
-0.0404870883,
-0.0040740841,
0.0189072099,
0.0751490369,
-0.0063786018,
-0.0084860818,
0.0272416696,
-0.0547917485,
0.0785087645,
-0.0224001314,
-0.0085509559,
-0.0279207043,
-0.0202744789,
0.0138275381,
0.0276181698,
0.0377563462,
0.0049689421,
0.0086305784,
0.0418261029,
0.0393930376,
-0.0046951789,
-0.0453852564,
-0.0218036845,
0.0162256584,
-0.0227251053,
-0.0358915366,
0.1005444601,
-0.0576501861,
-0.0071438942,
-0.0320094302,
-0.0266138855,
-0.0233978108,
-0.0033507566,
0.0047080084,
-0.0422607958,
0.0284073688,
0.039191138,
-0.0330879875,
-0.0320050977,
-0.0840029195,
-0.0232801959,
0.0089101577,
-0.075889051,
-0.0192244295,
-0.0475296415,
0.0234461389,
0.0108018499,
-0.0367476642,
-0.0802639574,
1.987074706e-34,
0.0287743211,
-0.0065891589,
0.0098213404,
0.0363701843,
-0.0111523084,
-0.0180968381,
-0.0277392324,
-0.0067482539,
0.0191056542,
-0.0378508642,
-0.0213310998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13184v1 | Locating and Extracting Relational Concepts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T03:29:51 | 2024-06-19T03:29:51 | Zijian Wang, Britney White, Chang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relational concepts are indeed foundational to the structure of knowledge
representation, as they facilitate the association between various entity
concepts, allowing us to express and comprehend complex world knowledge. By
expressing relational concepts in natural language prompts, people can
effortlessly interact with large language models (LLMs) and recall desired
factual knowledge. However, the process of knowledge recall lacks
interpretability, and representations of relational concepts within LLMs remain
unknown to us. In this paper, we identify hidden states that can express entity
and relational concepts through causal mediation analysis in fact recall
processes. Our finding reveals that at the last token position of the input
prompt, there are hidden states that solely express the causal effects of
relational concepts. Based on this finding, we assume that these hidden states
can be treated as relational representations and we can successfully extract
them from LLMs. The experimental results demonstrate high credibility of the
relational representations: they can be flexibly transplanted into other fact
recall processes, and can also be used as robust entity connectors. Moreover,
we also show that the relational representations exhibit significant potential
for controllable fact recall through relation rewriting. | [
0.0351041071,
-0.0095453868,
-0.045046445,
0.0523510836,
-0.0270401537,
-0.0132412631,
-0.0103913583,
0.028728649,
0.0357702449,
-0.0570774674,
-0.0181062687,
-0.0221135579,
0.0234999303,
0.0144545296,
0.0173600577,
-0.0870672911,
0.0632279441,
-0.0142914448,
0.0299060885,
0.0109688649,
-0.0201110858,
-0.003790902,
-0.0188561231,
0.0192465801,
-0.0568445437,
-0.0078576757,
-0.0032737316,
-0.0216261242,
0.0042460179,
-0.0404649824,
-0.0515000597,
0.0358044244,
0.0246412288,
-0.0219136067,
0.0000021964,
-0.0785172209,
-0.0193390325,
-0.0336670242,
-0.0623683259,
0.0070935916,
-0.0438205972,
0.019789774,
0.0158727989,
-0.039207574,
-0.0259504188,
-0.0006481339,
0.0442854501,
0.0525183305,
0.0051573971,
0.0393650569,
-0.0205913689,
-0.0144174192,
0.0090538729,
0.0105566271,
0.050946489,
0.0028274988,
0.0389720686,
0.0231621526,
-0.0160153937,
0.0398621671,
-0.0155448327,
0.003864117,
0.0273960773,
0.0117918821,
0.0413389839,
0.0391647778,
0.0510690734,
-0.0150706572,
0.0390534885,
0.0636121184,
0.0909590945,
-0.009362177,
0.0124400165,
0.0169224944,
0.0362671688,
0.0907942057,
-0.0386831462,
0.0056522014,
-0.0252378546,
-0.0114649879,
-0.0115937488,
-0.0097394157,
0.0466555171,
0.0190067012,
-0.0294583756,
0.0738822296,
0.0176133495,
-0.0281356424,
-0.0327478312,
-0.0163020641,
-0.0039037629,
-0.0674641207,
0.0147462012,
0.0392200872,
-0.0341465212,
0.0444185324,
-0.0260420833,
0.0324476659,
0.005622148,
-0.0529627092,
-0.0035534492,
0.0485146642,
-0.0094057713,
0.0641232952,
-0.0630266964,
0.069574289,
-0.0269598346,
-0.0025840621,
0.0181764793,
0.0352519266,
-0.0537721403,
-0.0482670218,
-0.0020278648,
0.0444091484,
-0.0137940533,
0.0100215282,
-0.0070093903,
0.0215266533,
-0.0213285536,
0.0287395697,
-0.0547454171,
0.0045467885,
0.0102524115,
-0.0169554353,
-0.1041867658,
0.0441049039,
-0.0608301312,
0.0114070689,
-0.0156425331,
-0.0461441316,
-0.0129325241,
-0.0283797309,
0.0062145251,
-0.0202168021,
-0.0430438928,
0.0579070821,
0.0051132697,
-0.0231459085,
-0.0690419227,
-0.0768982619,
0.0324096531,
-0.0246501956,
0.0035321407,
-0.0309698153,
0.0145522933,
0.0394978784,
-0.0039441977,
-0.0716239661,
0.0449644327,
0.0189901404,
-0.0487356409,
0.0433347933,
-0.0024739024,
0.0120765679,
0.0105628222,
0.0458976217,
0.0010906695,
0.0199005399,
0.0430954732,
0.0219750851,
0.0031418132,
0.0092272302,
-0.0230955854,
-0.0127642117,
0.0214220881,
-0.0219752528,
-0.0355915315,
0.009668435,
0.0283387732,
0.0131445723,
0.0310460161,
0.0212480854,
-0.0170503743,
0.0087247062,
0.0884095579,
0.010107209,
-0.0203881301,
0.0321528278,
0.0291501246,
-0.0382802263,
0.0209762864,
0.0281359088,
-0.0735756829,
0.0454458781,
-0.026118448,
0.0056623528,
-0.0208584424,
0.0142888846,
-0.0030657498,
-0.0183113329,
-0.0055058668,
0.0267789587,
-0.0270290468,
0.0106782643,
0.0435303859,
0.0154249538,
-0.0147963185,
0.1061615422,
0.0416141525,
-0.0220468342,
0.038769342,
-0.0317508504,
0.026469402,
0.0749541596,
0.0265280642,
-0.0511491224,
0.0003218926,
-0.0158512257,
-0.0039387383,
0.017714683,
0.0306796469,
-0.0006629006,
-0.0272152722,
-0.0026475475,
-0.0071908911,
0.0128033357,
0.0150616094,
0.0189863257,
0.0105185499,
-0.0002546653,
0.0038844771,
-0.0055039763,
0.0444895029,
0.0234699473,
0.0154824378,
-0.0345562696,
-0.0546501018,
0.0592886545,
-0.0073859831,
0.0330320708,
0.0236068331,
0.0306376703,
0.0358626954,
-0.0162780229,
-0.0294008199,
0.0021044442,
-0.0797795504,
0.0073857456,
-0.0131036956,
0.0183768384,
-0.003282215,
-0.0439748839,
0.0327577777,
-0.0546159074,
0.0186732318,
-0.020214282,
0.0833048001,
0.0193087477,
0.0017374537,
0.0248021521,
-0.033594165,
-0.0323580354,
0.1115275547,
0.0001977961,
0.0033418958,
0.0105394656,
-0.0174580831,
-0.0125677316,
-0.0215288512,
0.0326713398,
0.0171370693,
-0.0124942753,
-0.0210376568,
0.0151414806,
-0.0662170202,
-0.0617341027,
-0.0101830661,
-0.0362738371,
0.0076781092,
0.009429656,
0.0090902774,
0.028864257,
-0.0077818134,
-0.0075426446,
-0.0129578533,
-0.0014973506,
-0.0015436533,
-0.0333837755,
0.0449596271,
0.0211817846,
0.0033637651,
-0.0147409746,
-0.0050669266,
0.0190508943,
-0.0478071161,
0.053450834,
0.0282588862,
-0.0415895581,
-0.0471843332,
0.0443520918,
-0.0285420679,
-0.032375209,
-0.0091220299,
0.0051527279,
0.0220081266,
0.0146651659,
0.0683082268,
0.0557304472,
-0.0119395107,
0.0819425657,
0.0526897907,
-0.0391907431,
-0.0504672155,
-0.0023206542,
-0.0241000541,
0.0350512452,
-0.0024397119,
-0.0307773128,
-0.0299784727,
0.0527738892,
0.0416264459,
0.013499883,
-0.0357766561,
0.0300327297,
-0.0244153589,
-0.0131893056,
-0.0540116355,
-0.0556122288,
-0.0273547415,
0.0228922237,
-0.0297014993,
-0.0220139325,
0.0228640866,
-0.0063853771,
0.0084999669,
0.0343599431,
0.0245393831,
0.0010155129,
0.0892063081,
-0.0142769367,
0.0216376223,
0.0294568725,
-0.0620747879,
-0.0542773046,
0.0027997647,
0.035618633,
-0.0259764865,
0.0266223047,
-0.0524726957,
0.0143098747,
0.0198176894,
0.0060244976,
-0.0780297667,
0.0167283583,
-0.0403328501,
0.0102106426,
0.0011124398,
-0.0192208942,
-0.0032165835,
0.013979651,
0.0780060217,
-0.0169895943,
-0.0019026812,
-0.0154492306,
-0.0226668492,
0.0004275919,
0.0422764681,
-0.00145154,
0.0395439155,
0.0021673699,
0.0210698545,
0.0296235587,
-0.024667928,
-0.0506695993,
0.0065240772,
-0.0022900319,
-0.0039299973,
-0.0680693388,
-0.0212935228,
0.0241632015,
0.0325862952,
-0.0758570954,
-0.0104122451,
0.1048215255,
0.0383868851,
-0.0284527596,
0.0152970897,
-0.0014787546,
0.0205892008,
0.0446533002,
-0.0133288717,
-0.0926674977,
0.010783392,
0.0194033999,
-0.0670940951,
-0.0330432877,
-0.0631436557,
-0.0149653917,
-0.1038601473,
-0.025219962,
-0.0187207572,
-0.0307263285,
-0.0316814482,
-0.0394185558,
0.0131008308,
0.0509997942,
0.0067870645,
0.0054127071,
-0.0156861823,
0.001259184,
-0.0083200485,
0.0317554027,
-0.0013983822,
0.0098094959,
-0.0003240717,
0.0506018624,
0.021962164,
0.0255037155,
-0.0023856298,
-0.028537659,
-0.0081367763,
0.0109542757,
0.0461082235,
-0.0150091024,
0.0342764854,
0.0053146658,
0.0007102973,
-0.0560333654,
0.0135980668,
-0.0017251882,
-0.0622573271,
0.0022345502,
0.0893553272,
-0.0172751583,
-0.0073011946,
0.0262090024,
-0.02236766,
0.0014562772,
0.0838639364,
0.0244791191,
-0.0182955991,
0.0191082284,
-0.0103951693,
0.0385932624,
0.0501425974,
-0.0473786294,
-0.0138453934,
0.0040884763,
0.0224509295,
-0.0931184664,
-0.0392610915,
0.0478813164,
0.0258105099,
0.0427598692,
0.0144431535,
0.0421403497,
-0.0123823341,
-0.012097883,
0.0350830741,
-0.0544299521,
0.0205427222,
0.007735095,
-0.0237432402,
-0.0075693675,
-0.0459831916,
-0.0013856785,
-0.0714797899,
-0.0211487785,
-0.0229491312,
0.0104380799,
0.0402952433,
0.0298114233,
0.0221385527,
0.0152091533,
-0.0454730578,
0.0038666918,
0.0226691328,
-0.0763514191,
0.001041902,
-0.0012893758,
0.0266951695,
-0.0090066185,
0.0438574068,
-0.0446679704,
-0.0339532755,
0.0071438914,
0.0490923859,
-0.0251086429,
-0.0346340425,
0.04819851,
0.0041702338,
0.0490019582,
0.0168376993,
0.0310543962,
-0.0483518466,
0.0008482612,
-0.05345897,
-0.0001005753,
0.0038590066,
0.0365381278,
0.0051146438,
0.0389076658,
0.0009070287,
-0.0879128501,
0.0218741298,
0.0112578077,
0.0341915786,
-0.0275103357,
0.0290031638,
-0.0019224174,
0.0306384098,
0.0296711419,
-0.0035314991,
0.0477617793,
-0.0096083069,
0.0247924849,
-0.0206890889,
0.1242955774,
0.0235240441,
-0.0324718542,
-0.0820398033,
-0.038101647,
-0.0443121269,
-0.0111756613,
0.0513911098,
0.0421216898,
0.07301265,
-0.0364135802,
0.0057153734,
-0.0477635376,
0.0045468211,
0.0228190068,
0.0151767898,
0.0245533269,
-0.0327725075,
0.0229133777,
0.044928696,
-0.0178525932,
0.0283943806,
0.0512728207,
-0.0450918376,
0.0644287542,
0.0032813787,
-0.0214513782,
-0.0152413677,
-0.0337435454,
0.016104484,
0.0011435527,
-0.047257565,
-0.0009754761,
-0.1129911691,
-0.0505752191,
0.0087347785,
-0.0259051882,
-0.0128600681,
-0.0549772158,
0.0353642143,
0.0158490576,
0.0069019222,
-0.0590472855,
-0.0172334891,
0.0462999307,
-0.0316272601,
0.0060823937,
-0.0396811776,
-6.780872958e-33,
-0.0464018919,
-0.0526884459,
0.0039799619,
-0.0052432502,
-0.0272266921,
0.0162454993,
-0.0494916774,
0.0198601261,
-0.0239734035,
0.0396505259,
-0.025911957,
-0.0092186835,
0.0121307513,
-0.0291714035,
-0.0051182993,
-0.038207978,
0.0451144129,
0.030629389,
-0.0232920237,
0.0103293294,
0.0722699389,
0.0251073483,
0.0335302614,
-0.0667169988,
0.0547221489,
-0.0071580061,
0.0107178865,
0.0296952594,
-0.0306145828,
0.0395613238,
-0.0329125188,
0.0333982073,
0.0178023223,
-0.0546524152,
-0.0057504405,
0.0683388487,
-0.0616572425,
-0.0643758401,
0.0810791627,
-0.0056014052,
-0.0292211194,
-0.0577888452,
0.0236267522,
-0.0275631268,
0.0168179758,
0.0063763703,
0.0412165262,
-0.0112567712,
-0.0301266108,
-0.0273793656,
-0.0635928512,
-0.02057999,
-0.002186808,
0.0069102636,
-0.0096611986,
-0.031379614,
0.0153918648,
-0.0340197124,
-0.0507249348,
-0.0139159439,
-0.0233436972,
0.0086529693,
0.0364012271,
0.0619637482,
0.0209893268,
0.0822914839,
-0.0280929245,
0.0390872806,
-0.0480961427,
0.0189939607,
-0.0008158803,
0.0270742364,
0.0048614433,
0.0434034541,
-0.0039455122,
-0.0204305649,
-0.0412109345,
-0.0428428091,
-0.0037397125,
0.0412746668,
0.0001696454,
0.0076541924,
-0.0262932647,
-0.0154434405,
-0.0587431453,
0.0135003543,
-0.0420739353,
-0.0579855964,
0.0383826084,
-0.0255768634,
-0.011787001,
-0.0333747044,
0.0027266534,
-0.004565882,
-0.0429726094,
0.0133818062,
0.0083483867,
0.0098612364,
-0.0107191149,
-0.0293468069,
-0.0346075371,
-0.0003515493,
-0.0081149172,
-0.0125554912,
0.028506659,
0.0585375167,
-0.0053338944,
-0.0075162593,
-0.0385035947,
-0.0210057888,
-0.0468993597,
-0.0421351269,
-0.0085808244,
-0.0681221634,
0.0599130094,
0.0456481911,
-0.0158868413,
0.0208599139,
0.0544827059,
0.0126327872,
-0.0339213945,
0.0293982308,
-0.0469706357,
0.0203644186,
-0.0096909106,
-0.0210628677,
-0.0329137407,
0.0542585105,
0.0363737866,
-0.0467247404,
-0.0039418023,
-0.0371495485,
2.987e-7,
0.0008439118,
0.0631107539,
0.0110385176,
0.0393436775,
0.0082753617,
0.0310880747,
0.0362767093,
0.0087505486,
0.0400694199,
-0.0604026206,
-0.0085675837,
0.0207896605,
-0.008311416,
0.0104308529,
-0.1077398211,
-0.0023555704,
-0.012250307,
-0.0211140066,
-0.0322759226,
0.0054938039,
0.085151054,
0.0184704028,
0.0574458577,
0.0260355044,
-0.0371008702,
-0.0348976366,
0.0408584177,
-0.0602343082,
0.017704716,
-0.0103205228,
0.0200384539,
-0.0062131672,
-0.0008607189,
0.0575770177,
0.0142702861,
0.0000244637,
-0.0130920261,
0.0519846268,
0.0165460072,
-0.0016653267,
-0.0476279035,
-0.0261597,
0.0067866589,
-0.0545696802,
0.0429897867,
-0.0597232208,
0.0014742056,
0.069300659,
-0.0058170948,
-0.0196926277,
-0.0158925857,
0.0396627523,
-0.0008149798,
-0.0003631201,
-0.034697637,
0.0329912864,
0.0021417385,
-0.0333918221,
-0.0319394581,
0.0156933703,
0.004968985,
-0.0510243028,
-0.0305022299,
-0.023322491,
-0.0075810072,
-0.0371108428,
-0.020110352,
2.580024363e-34,
-0.0575420037,
-0.0114494236,
0.0439751782,
0.0461616479,
0.04142024,
-0.027636826,
-0.0447003096,
0.0462346599,
0.0419881232,
-0.0826374888,
0.000674005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13173v2 | Biomedical Visual Instruction Tuning with Clinician Preference Alignment | 2024-06-19T03:07:33 | 2024-06-30T01:22:09 | Hejie Cui, Lingjun Mao, Xin Liang, Jieyu Zhang, Hui Ren, Quanzheng Li, Xiang Li, Carl Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, 68T45, 68T37, 68T05, 68T07, 68T09,, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.10 | Recent advancements in multimodal foundation models have showcased impressive
capabilities in understanding and reasoning with visual and textual
information. Adapting these foundation models trained for general usage to
specialized domains like biomedicine requires large-scale domain-specific
instruction datasets. While existing works have explored curating such datasets
automatically, the resultant datasets are not explicitly aligned with domain
expertise. In this work, we propose a data-centric framework, Biomedical Visual
Instruction Tuning with Clinician Preference Alignment (BioMed-VITAL), that
incorporates clinician preferences into both stages of generating and selecting
instruction data for tuning biomedical multimodal foundation models. First,
during the generation stage, we prompt the GPT-4V generator with a diverse set
of clinician-selected demonstrations for preference-aligned data candidate
generation. Then, during the selection phase, we train a separate selection
model, which explicitly distills clinician and policy-guided model preferences
into a rating function to select high-quality data for medical instruction
tuning. Results show that the model tuned with the instruction-following data
from our method demonstrates a significant improvement in open visual chat
(18.5% relatively) and medical VQA (win rate up to 81.73%). Our
instruction-following data and models are available at BioMed-VITAL.github.io. | [
0.0425810292,
0.0612646379,
0.001382195,
-0.0110716186,
-0.0260877647,
0.0236299112,
0.0244024005,
0.0258092266,
-0.012232108,
-0.0090662269,
-0.0493932888,
-0.0729453117,
0.0139110899,
0.0438470021,
0.0332702622,
-0.099531725,
0.0447841808,
0.050228402,
-0.0168089606,
0.0188206024,
0.0171394292,
0.0118517773,
-0.0565950051,
0.0458437763,
0.0087996386,
-0.0366558284,
-0.0011542804,
0.0341969393,
0.0252026506,
-0.0715733841,
0.0145429596,
0.0724133477,
0.0085175373,
-0.0509819426,
0.0000023438,
-0.0375136957,
-0.009522872,
0.0085338466,
-0.0035070002,
-0.015762683,
0.0596100241,
-0.0144914798,
0.0005204134,
0.0036733623,
-0.0307757985,
-0.0114611257,
0.0639654472,
0.0005128685,
0.0512361601,
0.0304166228,
0.0043497109,
0.0280461889,
-0.0035763786,
-0.0159217343,
0.0228647888,
-0.01431535,
-0.0129665174,
0.040558245,
0.0413077287,
0.019937126,
-0.0446380451,
0.0338045806,
-0.0000312885,
0.0218650531,
0.0518829077,
0.0387669876,
-0.0107664699,
-0.0292764455,
-0.0467619635,
0.0891695395,
0.0305018853,
0.033255022,
0.0094068339,
-0.0146951023,
-0.001633199,
0.0232328903,
-0.0764288604,
-0.0058802352,
-0.0334567949,
-0.0091537461,
-0.0318038948,
-0.0082636392,
0.0064249579,
0.001727634,
0.0387522019,
-0.0414631478,
0.0068609598,
0.0209942088,
0.0074566747,
-0.0018982961,
-0.0474551469,
-0.0434558094,
0.0025837522,
0.0193358399,
-0.0550239719,
0.0023141054,
-0.0344711356,
0.0022360014,
0.0290751047,
-0.0005369578,
0.0651881769,
0.0380399227,
-0.0441384241,
0.0262853969,
0.0293181092,
0.0045525008,
-0.0519819781,
0.0652405396,
-0.0104429023,
0.0593679473,
-0.0587840378,
0.005738318,
0.0031622543,
-0.0148251466,
-0.0353239961,
-0.0041269204,
-0.0687152147,
0.0102696968,
-0.0113666328,
-0.0063350876,
0.0201341249,
0.0509387217,
-0.0532866716,
0.0357138477,
-0.0616465583,
0.0401203632,
0.0020164242,
-0.0034208575,
-0.00264234,
-0.0417078137,
0.0059192632,
0.0110102221,
-0.0135342162,
-0.0198332872,
0.0075676469,
0.0893189237,
-0.0131981354,
0.0057470137,
0.0037833019,
-0.0402113907,
-0.0068515651,
-0.0216435902,
0.0563929677,
-0.0335059613,
0.0222810619,
0.0132787414,
0.0350952409,
-0.0294634514,
-0.0009541844,
0.0339696556,
-0.0053181057,
0.0651198253,
-0.0090885237,
-0.0063330685,
0.0074382266,
0.0272791442,
-0.0295313951,
0.0369099006,
-0.0021524709,
-0.0218105428,
0.0066001699,
-0.0506107956,
-0.0110210134,
-0.0042323451,
0.0247196723,
-0.017144816,
-0.01325294,
0.0045687244,
0.0152614014,
0.0809839442,
-0.0195727572,
0.0138176475,
-0.052508574,
-0.0239122715,
0.0288362484,
0.0166340619,
0.0626384392,
-0.0369787738,
0.0154407797,
-0.0080221649,
0.0074051223,
-0.0006051706,
-0.0383403823,
0.0685366765,
0.0168025624,
-0.0122322459,
-0.0173592735,
0.0285762511,
-0.0396254733,
-0.0450859442,
-0.0031914439,
-0.0102114975,
-0.009494015,
0.0025878407,
0.0376170948,
-0.0294688251,
-0.0528995395,
0.0059189829,
0.0551208444,
-0.0383090749,
-0.0104336506,
-0.0536140651,
-0.0286224559,
0.0877565145,
0.0639543533,
-0.0047408398,
-0.0799803063,
-0.0331229903,
0.0460556224,
-0.0002971024,
0.0653673336,
-0.0313490853,
0.0364319645,
-0.0494387187,
-0.0657868013,
-0.0140468646,
0.009508335,
0.0058364081,
0.0058872229,
-0.0126516139,
-0.0485644676,
-0.0195425265,
-0.0110265873,
0.0485275686,
-0.0446786061,
0.0005813545,
-0.0070875189,
-0.0018176172,
0.0513463579,
0.0119784931,
0.0084891776,
0.0015911894,
0.0064647589,
0.0240126811,
0.0522045232,
-0.0078899367,
-0.0349293463,
-0.0260010157,
-0.0025093823,
-0.0553721115,
0.0023203234,
-0.0203041825,
-0.0457525477,
-0.0032344572,
-0.0147997485,
-0.0382991806,
-0.0101499902,
0.0028529947,
0.01210781,
0.0237305555,
-0.0383004583,
-0.0450560562,
0.0069032232,
-0.0192071758,
-0.00859279,
0.0550865792,
-0.0006017227,
0.019463677,
-0.0686894134,
0.0171923917,
0.0037489405,
-0.0179089699,
0.0054235673,
-0.000317582,
0.0371944346,
-0.0365407765,
0.0079173259,
-0.1154192388,
0.0019463975,
0.0270630438,
-0.0279843546,
0.0400699899,
-0.0028271298,
-0.0091831665,
-0.0159279481,
-0.0182346348,
0.0090000564,
0.0067440933,
0.0051031969,
0.033534158,
0.0446468405,
0.0039122403,
-0.0410162173,
0.0031835269,
-0.0298955422,
0.0011311121,
0.0226234905,
0.0252986439,
0.0112627232,
-0.0249095131,
-0.0356378816,
0.0089566987,
-0.0109565929,
-0.0282522812,
0.0502630882,
0.0097543234,
-0.0343767181,
0.0682384744,
-0.0015046587,
0.0485456586,
0.0373358727,
-0.0095029073,
-0.0593085885,
0.0098246178,
-0.050930351,
-0.0143120326,
0.0141081968,
-0.0343034118,
-0.0013818778,
0.0582006052,
0.0044884072,
0.0308851656,
-0.0637091771,
0.0253373981,
0.0236601364,
0.0247758217,
-0.0387740359,
0.0469996966,
-0.0237706024,
0.0238381252,
-0.0370332971,
-0.0630730838,
0.1073223874,
0.0184950903,
0.0491902977,
-0.0694506988,
0.010376811,
-0.019997729,
-0.013299589,
-0.0159059204,
0.0295269284,
0.0127349747,
0.0131513989,
-0.0654499978,
0.0358446613,
0.0404055305,
-0.0378859155,
0.0311251916,
-0.060131494,
-0.0107504539,
-0.0032220399,
-0.0276272465,
-0.0397832729,
0.0101306122,
0.0140892696,
-0.0373932049,
0.0259488225,
0.0109972097,
-0.0600057989,
-0.0074982811,
-0.0056030117,
0.0347539186,
-0.0054501356,
-0.0114476578,
-0.0079737874,
-0.0192535669,
0.0269107781,
-0.0026936317,
-0.0615575984,
-0.0594403371,
0.0070438953,
0.0579556897,
-0.0030468479,
-0.0232682545,
-0.0238185655,
0.0366062745,
0.0122355958,
0.0232505351,
0.0076723304,
0.0357534736,
0.0737575367,
-0.0198792387,
0.0317872241,
0.0640213564,
0.007130852,
-0.0507451594,
0.0054172641,
0.0234686621,
-0.0025332461,
-0.005847971,
0.0275900513,
-0.0948010758,
-0.050708998,
-0.0455203168,
0.0830005184,
-0.0119103417,
-0.0113712074,
-0.0100791855,
-0.0318979956,
0.0629053786,
0.0176065452,
-0.0460958406,
-0.016931612,
-0.0347008072,
0.0357211381,
-0.0487007983,
-0.0137720089,
-0.0098134931,
-0.032291241,
0.0003784401,
0.0254585464,
0.0315783881,
-0.1106685624,
0.016552778,
-0.0051194555,
0.0297863856,
0.0628895313,
0.0120988972,
0.0283326544,
-0.0397830196,
-0.0076836911,
0.0382502265,
0.0248478279,
-0.0424068794,
0.1172269285,
-0.0122055877,
0.0214741528,
-0.0509803593,
0.0633592978,
0.0310525429,
-0.0123232473,
-0.013301935,
0.0573897362,
-0.0361874104,
0.0080750948,
-0.0719622001,
0.0389830023,
0.0466972031,
0.0260706693,
0.0056605963,
-0.0450019166,
0.0028172904,
-0.0042518503,
0.060781464,
-0.0326223373,
-0.031377364,
0.0065786378,
-0.056166254,
-0.0033126627,
-0.0531649776,
-0.0137395523,
0.0396292843,
0.0452162959,
0.0022760651,
-0.0264385156,
-0.0021662402,
0.0164017677,
-0.0466560833,
0.0921322778,
0.0316557921,
0.010930662,
-0.0967655703,
-0.0923311114,
0.0263903178,
-0.057241872,
-0.0070308428,
0.0470053256,
0.0293126199,
-0.0157168414,
-0.0472990125,
0.0976237878,
0.0227795392,
0.0428988002,
0.0314695053,
-0.0035935517,
0.0112785939,
0.0719271228,
-0.0110765742,
-0.0248847473,
-0.0091251777,
-0.0239273664,
-0.0295142829,
-0.0354806334,
-0.0021503589,
0.0403079726,
0.0047380859,
0.017454667,
0.0074439254,
0.0154605201,
0.0314428955,
0.0060482086,
0.0705744848,
-0.0436468832,
-0.0130297719,
-0.0300441179,
-0.0086852815,
-0.0145889632,
0.0375161618,
-0.041492898,
0.003548926,
0.0092632901,
-0.0373431407,
-0.0021584446,
-0.0099287909,
-0.044381775,
-0.0162593778,
-0.0811135322,
0.0332893655,
0.0175506379,
0.0027273367,
0.0297140386,
0.0154962614,
0.0040214714,
-0.0086651715,
-0.0188915189,
0.0177765898,
0.0091367094,
0.1104532555,
0.0224572551,
0.0231581517,
0.0283756163,
0.0506298169,
-0.0271737762,
-0.0428573303,
-0.0590174794,
0.0193716288,
0.0204754304,
-0.0021815361,
-0.0128200818,
-0.0249239579,
0.0065606143,
-0.0288485959,
0.0518109053,
-0.0342384763,
0.0189513545,
0.0524345338,
0.006852271,
0.0382937528,
-0.0488794334,
0.0695109069,
0.0047375103,
0.0634853989,
-0.0285889711,
-0.0323874429,
-0.061175745,
-0.0083711417,
0.0811360776,
0.036070805,
-0.0321482196,
0.0429622531,
-0.0555431172,
-0.0322433971,
-0.0033017411,
-0.0018267285,
-0.0236713029,
-0.0262445621,
0.0961185023,
0.0200497787,
-0.0251203254,
-0.039760828,
-0.000395893,
0.0299541205,
-0.0284758955,
-0.0368636027,
-0.0013420362,
-5.965684156e-33,
-0.0013268163,
-0.0272092577,
0.0482169017,
-0.0027621633,
0.0018635606,
0.0020903102,
-0.0307296198,
-0.0018791385,
-0.027845839,
0.0204273704,
0.0307522528,
-0.0279689208,
-0.0072882692,
0.035420049,
0.0070915129,
-0.0137680378,
0.0270328894,
-0.0246239025,
-0.0365979634,
0.0381616317,
-0.0114817228,
0.0023012466,
0.0524091721,
-0.1046986431,
-0.0309005678,
0.0321949944,
0.0044810958,
-0.0146116344,
-0.0251728781,
0.0689067394,
-0.0101338616,
0.020306034,
0.0192906149,
-0.0102412011,
-0.0239365585,
-0.0236236975,
-0.0351111852,
-0.0354160853,
0.0084423432,
-0.0185312852,
-0.0964931101,
-0.0088217165,
0.0349900946,
-0.0171071663,
-0.0561135486,
-0.0548676476,
0.0350872949,
-0.0158611014,
-0.0077927751,
0.0218668189,
-0.0331549942,
0.039265722,
-0.0157215241,
-0.0635567084,
-0.0227097031,
0.0535053313,
0.0014833257,
0.0383970067,
-0.0070480099,
0.0655895844,
0.0487725921,
-0.0082123941,
0.0449417569,
0.0038588238,
0.026055228,
0.0399134606,
0.0113823395,
-0.0258405097,
-0.0157587826,
-0.0059316135,
-0.0123590017,
0.0793656409,
0.027336318,
0.0305292699,
0.0186053514,
-0.0052591786,
-0.0702140182,
0.0522570014,
-0.062430419,
0.0268131495,
-0.0003833441,
-0.0185574088,
-0.0515070148,
-0.0287352987,
-0.0043252725,
-0.0421891436,
-0.0116343359,
-0.0462109707,
0.0672328547,
-0.0107947607,
-0.0198327918,
0.0115894182,
0.0197306424,
-0.0146694211,
-0.0210412852,
-0.0047985008,
0.0132022751,
0.0516856015,
-0.0174412373,
-0.0341847725,
-0.0574401207,
-0.0245917961,
0.063745454,
-0.0324856341,
0.048343502,
0.0305967573,
-0.0211194679,
-0.0153103638,
-0.011026592,
-0.0044974531,
-0.0127359647,
-0.0130579527,
0.0132092759,
-0.0037056461,
0.0505405478,
0.0226511117,
-0.0310498755,
0.0771639049,
-0.0187912863,
-0.0190984067,
-0.0676819235,
-0.0975601375,
-0.0208969079,
0.0390164293,
-0.015595641,
0.0152924946,
-0.0490393713,
-0.0268278625,
-0.0158274788,
-0.0452347584,
-0.0197655819,
0.0076627526,
2.95e-7,
0.0564459823,
0.058824569,
-0.0053792177,
-0.0218952745,
0.0125965439,
0.0156679805,
-0.025967529,
0.0032913403,
0.025754286,
-0.0565519668,
0.0226860344,
0.0310652647,
0.0231183264,
0.0059657558,
-0.0292088799,
-0.0260636751,
-0.0095008444,
-0.0022691328,
-0.019514,
-0.0259645041,
0.0533027202,
0.0167009626,
-0.0328054577,
-0.0266021434,
0.048051022,
0.0516562611,
0.0614394732,
-0.0397350788,
0.0139426794,
0.0333297811,
0.0043333704,
-0.015829809,
0.0023216489,
0.0416173153,
-0.0296783336,
-0.0479903147,
-0.0038875344,
0.0784179643,
-0.0647047535,
0.0134937307,
0.0257479809,
0.0270874184,
-0.0124995038,
-0.0195719562,
0.0183636341,
-0.062239714,
-0.0196870361,
0.0201061461,
-0.0282815881,
-0.0108141489,
0.0739318952,
-0.0380579643,
-0.0214711055,
0.0195412152,
0.0156326182,
0.0240616444,
-0.0529111922,
-0.0293725263,
0.004492179,
0.0297008567,
-0.0446314029,
-0.051098574,
0.0144865494,
-0.0239664,
-0.0110181849,
-0.0298767909,
-0.0400355011,
2.565118084e-34,
0.0263310485,
-0.005152212,
0.068144381,
-0.0185511075,
0.0240260344,
-0.009191988,
0.0157229044,
0.0242529213,
0.0479098707,
-0.038063284,
-0.0273170546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13170v1 | Amphista: Accelerate LLM Inference with Bi-directional Multiple Drafting Heads in a Non-autoregressive Style | 2024-06-19T02:53:39 | 2024-06-19T02:53:39 | Zeping Li, Xinlong Yang, Ziheng Gao, Ji Liu, Zhuang Liu, Dong Li, Jinzhang Peng, Lu Tian, Emad Barsoum | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently use autoregressive decoding, which
lacks parallelism in inference and results in significantly slow inference
speeds, especially when hardware parallel accelerators and memory bandwidth are
not fully utilized. In this work, we propose Amphista, a speculative decoding
algorithm that adheres to a non-autoregressive decoding paradigm. Owing to the
increased parallelism, our method demonstrates higher efficiency in inference
compared to autoregressive methods. Specifically, Amphista models an
Auto-embedding Block capable of parallel inference, incorporating
bi-directional attention to enable interaction between different drafting
heads. Additionally, Amphista implements Staged Adaptation Layers to facilitate
the transition of semantic information from the base model's autoregressive
inference to the drafting heads' non-autoregressive speculation, thereby
achieving paradigm transformation and feature fusion. We conduct a series of
experiments on a suite of Vicuna models using MT-Bench and Spec-Bench. For the
Vicuna 33B model, Amphista achieves up to 2.75$\times$ and 1.40$\times$
wall-clock acceleration compared to vanilla autoregressive decoding and Medusa,
respectively, while preserving lossless generation quality. | [
-0.0027176954,
0.0611352324,
-0.011187885,
0.0560469776,
-0.0203035232,
0.0297933593,
-0.0038194079,
-0.0213525277,
-0.0425357074,
-0.0250106752,
-0.0088726338,
-0.0888800099,
0.0046126763,
0.0095598763,
0.0071433713,
-0.0253231768,
0.0250540245,
-0.0584194474,
-0.0075556501,
-0.014296365,
-0.0233714301,
0.0144395838,
0.0052372161,
0.0528497994,
0.0169602707,
-0.012840311,
-0.0356770679,
0.0115313437,
0.0001939273,
-0.0195388794,
-0.0475960635,
0.0634836778,
0.0272052158,
0.055501733,
0.0000024649,
-0.0237875078,
-0.0201079976,
0.0092821857,
-0.0201994181,
0.002224657,
0.0349025764,
-0.0397856981,
-0.0439568907,
-0.00886421,
-0.0243202765,
-0.0347014368,
0.0631952733,
-0.0339533463,
0.0406347997,
0.0502290688,
-0.0001301308,
-0.0517849773,
0.0212207362,
-0.053344015,
-0.0361352116,
-0.0490034968,
0.001202474,
-0.0270724874,
-0.0262700561,
-0.0137753282,
-0.0202333182,
0.0540664978,
0.0266176295,
-0.0005626794,
0.0082616387,
0.0345938243,
0.0180781204,
-0.0204188935,
0.0007313133,
0.0502073355,
0.0230655596,
-0.0482497588,
-0.0126871578,
-0.0020329854,
-0.0181680378,
-0.0212861244,
-0.0447848588,
0.0407646112,
-0.0305863917,
0.0178549998,
0.0722231492,
0.0131307999,
0.0409031846,
-0.0289940219,
-0.0168404188,
0.0502577089,
0.0330392197,
0.0001893225,
-0.037388429,
0.0221743342,
-0.0068478347,
-0.0444574133,
0.0077498886,
0.0174195953,
0.0173547938,
0.0110377781,
-0.0465055667,
-0.0604030713,
-0.0095334053,
-0.0503416918,
0.0776843131,
0.0831565335,
-0.0326608308,
0.0347657278,
-0.0320334285,
-0.0373289809,
-0.048513189,
-0.0157030448,
-0.0650741979,
0.0143017694,
0.0323345065,
-0.0247150045,
-0.0345895849,
0.0009805198,
-0.0569081381,
-0.0206401981,
-0.0165273398,
0.0346508063,
0.0137108034,
-0.0122207273,
0.0141602578,
-0.0010756372,
-0.0386829786,
-0.0166184884,
0.0090692332,
0.0214652568,
-0.0126640638,
0.0000653092,
-0.0084582521,
-0.0730734393,
-0.0529524684,
0.0102234147,
-0.0245187078,
-0.0220186692,
-0.0186873861,
0.1075447798,
-0.020022504,
0.0088224476,
-0.0441247076,
-0.0258366913,
0.0139247747,
-0.062064603,
0.0444818214,
-0.0561520644,
0.0479134656,
0.0345627107,
-0.0046890876,
-0.0095729725,
0.002857381,
-0.0002148095,
-0.0100783538,
0.0727680698,
-0.0256696455,
-0.0123876641,
0.0194042027,
0.0241855308,
-0.0244694166,
0.1245769113,
0.0258291289,
0.0442937799,
-0.0250387415,
0.0209133942,
-0.0297743604,
0.0625867024,
0.0378756225,
0.0163742211,
-0.0387599766,
-0.0148771442,
0.0143109439,
0.0137999179,
0.0891816765,
0.0118669905,
-0.0451651663,
-0.0321383402,
0.0287283938,
0.0308096502,
0.0312707573,
0.0466994122,
0.0765463188,
-0.0204367973,
0.0142617421,
0.0182000976,
-0.0285832547,
0.0633446276,
-0.029401945,
0.0406686291,
0.0342387706,
0.0532752313,
-0.0106460629,
-0.0360611491,
-0.002564752,
0.0211520828,
-0.0445824526,
-0.0029960962,
0.0514020696,
0.0196299031,
-0.0696118101,
0.0405222438,
0.0363402404,
-0.0436400101,
-0.0437131189,
-0.0530944541,
0.0314193144,
0.0730636716,
0.0401600227,
0.0050802105,
-0.0195351373,
0.0108959358,
-0.0160555337,
0.0537150241,
0.0165062621,
0.006753176,
0.0134144137,
-0.0473585948,
-0.0112273879,
0.0154061373,
0.0302227475,
0.0754194483,
-0.0131787332,
-0.0114894547,
0.010377598,
-0.015288379,
0.0194289591,
0.0074267546,
-0.0289912708,
-0.0013125611,
-0.0186467525,
0.0032020763,
0.0145617519,
-0.008039536,
-0.0196755119,
0.0288582947,
0.0320726857,
-0.0758112818,
-0.0026171068,
0.0599369705,
-0.0757480934,
-0.0633257627,
0.0140981358,
-0.0044406825,
-0.0032166867,
-0.0168084521,
0.0053327819,
-0.0431165174,
0.0296346769,
-0.0247925185,
0.0978671461,
-0.055634968,
0.03947936,
0.0417178795,
0.0342476927,
-0.0060472013,
0.0793764293,
-0.0477087535,
-0.0173071753,
0.0643057227,
0.009961037,
-0.0021867987,
-0.0261123236,
-0.0101365261,
0.0387954153,
0.0129206497,
-0.0141412383,
-0.0496849567,
-0.0237678122,
-0.0030757855,
-0.0024486387,
-0.0673822612,
-0.0084794518,
-0.0430365279,
0.036920283,
0.0122448308,
0.0186913274,
-0.0114489906,
-0.0147764338,
0.0085039027,
-0.0002250984,
-0.0309656188,
0.0306247286,
-0.0040322794,
-0.0137089221,
-0.0184014998,
-0.0113421101,
-0.0416076221,
-0.0085816253,
0.0510327145,
-0.0119586969,
-0.0196929984,
-0.0617029294,
0.0037414448,
-0.0108178146,
0.0143239293,
-0.0136328964,
-0.0195341613,
0.0011227905,
-0.0659201816,
0.0398946069,
0.0479416251,
-0.0206232946,
0.02593733,
0.0439390503,
-0.0173417609,
-0.0191457067,
0.0216206573,
0.0175308343,
0.0279155057,
-0.0024646677,
-0.0206474699,
-0.0302694626,
0.0840620622,
0.015607195,
0.00770663,
-0.0623548552,
0.0025457249,
0.0134013323,
-0.0421805568,
0.022255186,
-0.003477175,
-0.0067879311,
0.0412388742,
-0.0130434837,
-0.0579903387,
0.072298184,
-0.0742940009,
-0.0235569309,
-0.003414352,
0.0317144357,
-0.0429838784,
0.0623988621,
0.0140143838,
0.0149046667,
-0.0174660739,
-0.032269273,
-0.0045614205,
0.0672139302,
0.0415945761,
-0.0348145477,
0.0333687961,
-0.039787177,
0.0268735718,
-0.0443209484,
-0.0095270509,
-0.0251374245,
0.003570457,
-0.043127019,
-0.0001797596,
0.0314338803,
-0.0219900236,
-0.003015463,
0.0481140427,
-0.0490049645,
0.0454114452,
-0.0076228823,
0.0076569631,
-0.0216847099,
0.0516644605,
0.049182985,
-0.0050898772,
0.0074130795,
-0.0505182371,
0.0689398348,
0.0554556549,
0.0133786239,
0.0272927266,
-0.0578911416,
0.0277091675,
0.0541585125,
0.0043921978,
-0.027885044,
0.0192569345,
0.0323743001,
-0.0795658454,
-0.000758806,
0.0837929025,
0.0135160098,
-0.0500894971,
-0.0212645754,
-0.0104791922,
0.0700238496,
0.0020995734,
0.0193511248,
-0.0954378322,
-0.0396702066,
0.0394108631,
0.0106092058,
0.0246349499,
-0.0102977147,
-0.0333519094,
-0.0980679914,
0.0712956712,
0.0204579476,
-0.0046227681,
0.0242007133,
-0.026068883,
-0.0126366867,
0.0125390803,
0.0035631112,
0.0371955857,
-0.0109094707,
0.0181758013,
-0.004431285,
-0.0323943533,
0.0033459687,
-0.0164384488,
0.008645148,
0.0556748807,
0.0639336482,
0.0061656572,
0.0198806841,
-0.0229608826,
0.0105194449,
-0.0249523539,
0.0136748757,
-0.0474440046,
0.0518155023,
0.0008897422,
-0.0005055484,
0.005603598,
0.0098756682,
-0.005807335,
0.0051395581,
-0.0349500366,
0.0438519716,
-0.0231476128,
-0.0206171572,
-0.0415916741,
0.0209057834,
-0.0331142619,
0.0659759194,
0.0444855131,
-0.0091373669,
-0.0536244996,
-0.0625047013,
-0.0171265658,
-0.0691077262,
-0.0094670858,
-0.0023140251,
0.0657381192,
-0.0545189902,
-0.0265166964,
-0.0183079056,
0.0150887929,
0.0350609645,
-0.006817658,
0.0340018384,
-0.0132772075,
-0.0230821669,
-0.0837369561,
0.0033295054,
-0.014533625,
0.02398335,
-0.0283734668,
0.0083807968,
0.0515266135,
-0.0402496383,
-0.0134512316,
0.0517910235,
-0.1174099296,
-0.0833059922,
-0.0117350426,
0.02975595,
0.0247038808,
0.0537071489,
-0.0392091982,
-0.0360524952,
0.0470865555,
0.0101896375,
-0.0375930034,
0.0418029688,
0.0089125885,
0.0015159623,
-0.0138698174,
0.0503430106,
0.0140310153,
-0.0075933686,
-0.0155780222,
0.0303273015,
-0.0000733425,
-0.0461370833,
0.0068349615,
-0.0109209269,
-0.0099722892,
-0.0233720746,
-0.010801333,
-0.0101409387,
0.0440636948,
-0.0222859289,
-0.0039184541,
-0.0477171838,
0.0196348112,
0.021375047,
-0.0454951189,
-0.0080828611,
0.0111459466,
0.0467697904,
0.0096498942,
-0.0334617347,
0.027495835,
-0.001181706,
0.0224798787,
0.0204127617,
-0.0192438345,
-0.0109099001,
0.0027142258,
-0.0288132913,
0.0564488135,
-0.0398277082,
0.0234282445,
0.0144491885,
-0.0023840282,
-0.0050986758,
0.0425313525,
-0.0630307347,
-0.0693474635,
-0.0431314483,
0.01946822,
0.0667473525,
0.0017277406,
0.0943406075,
-0.0149187902,
-0.0003895522,
0.0132451691,
0.0232288223,
-0.0149901435,
-0.0244318135,
0.0418719389,
0.0078311944,
-0.0169503745,
-0.0100243082,
0.0508245341,
0.0180756617,
0.0439734347,
0.0014642343,
0.0134672374,
-0.0331039391,
-0.0677718148,
0.0082534626,
0.0281411558,
-0.0144078471,
-0.0065966095,
-0.0391197838,
-0.0638352334,
0.0153586669,
0.0105507979,
-0.0411699712,
-0.0272110291,
0.0009386554,
0.0300803948,
0.0090315863,
-0.0673775896,
-0.0117535172,
0.0227931216,
0.0355210081,
-0.0006146777,
0.009202702,
-7.309240771e-33,
-0.0542456508,
-0.0034257611,
0.037255086,
-0.0275628902,
-0.0478223525,
-0.0170746334,
-0.0396528654,
-0.0152448919,
-0.0050981077,
-0.0118670464,
-0.0173016805,
0.0299028344,
0.0186979696,
0.0019865562,
0.0119039789,
0.0107306689,
0.0619129613,
0.0130252186,
-0.018348936,
0.0124300681,
0.0129845152,
0.0577858984,
0.0391192585,
-0.016686108,
-0.0106013566,
-0.0226760898,
-0.0112139694,
-0.0117909294,
-0.0367332064,
0.0236615799,
-0.0475203879,
-0.0130242296,
-0.0015365188,
-0.0247166045,
-0.0290639866,
-0.0194313284,
-0.1028065607,
0.0014237042,
0.0308013335,
0.0277025346,
-0.011002508,
-0.0313442834,
0.0118100038,
0.05184035,
0.0118241226,
-0.0519936606,
-0.0012993774,
-0.0369742624,
-0.0270115938,
-0.0056989705,
-0.0659459308,
0.0475720316,
0.0057316846,
0.0043401588,
0.0915060937,
0.0052468525,
0.0079717878,
-0.0018269041,
-0.0927813053,
0.0084306523,
-0.0129255578,
0.0592637509,
0.0785758719,
0.0249907207,
-0.0175332651,
0.026925724,
0.0449286252,
-0.0304397643,
-0.0452583991,
0.0021783421,
0.0192435272,
0.039576374,
-0.0253703184,
-0.0051594684,
0.0482320301,
0.021724442,
-0.0184022617,
0.0182645805,
0.0405133255,
0.0253234357,
0.0467487536,
0.033617042,
-0.0284837317,
-0.0447976701,
-0.0489491522,
-0.034130726,
-0.0407789275,
-0.0180953369,
0.0305619016,
0.0151298763,
-0.0018647235,
-0.0138204526,
0.041668728,
-0.0327390283,
0.0179938953,
0.0349404626,
-0.013659223,
0.0285560358,
-0.0120321,
0.0403967872,
0.0014195297,
0.0135242511,
-0.003196077,
0.0005685787,
0.0034585907,
0.0041316664,
0.0075014452,
0.0249147005,
-0.0678164214,
-0.0114325732,
-0.0516468883,
-0.0080912495,
0.0262438115,
0.0233645868,
0.0391052328,
-0.009560152,
0.0004131549,
0.0283370819,
-0.0025704133,
0.0643402562,
-0.0506616794,
-0.0026222756,
-0.0079290271,
0.023131948,
-0.0185085386,
0.0310917329,
-0.0299781486,
0.0178473722,
0.0386291631,
-0.0847355202,
-0.0345093347,
0.0555628017,
3.125e-7,
0.0473435,
0.0073152352,
0.0522034653,
0.0264864974,
0.0100925714,
0.0185654182,
-0.0337950438,
0.0110298935,
0.0489520989,
-0.0004693751,
0.0066612172,
0.0530795529,
0.0675186291,
0.0277045611,
-0.0625139028,
0.010853352,
-0.0384552777,
-0.002533549,
-0.0343722254,
-0.0625071675,
0.0090541253,
0.07852038,
-0.0437971875,
-0.022031473,
0.0508876704,
0.0095089562,
0.071852982,
0.0091428598,
-0.0062908218,
0.0112170549,
-0.0141616305,
-0.0066626747,
-0.0374845117,
-0.0134768812,
-0.0162100233,
0.004341553,
-0.0273097642,
0.0347850174,
-0.0050128666,
-0.0035758521,
0.0283566974,
-0.003488929,
-0.0128455348,
-0.0130718974,
0.0614906326,
-0.0010835978,
-0.0187188312,
-0.0421302542,
-0.0098051066,
0.0069835065,
-0.0139461551,
0.0177920125,
0.03640664,
0.0297129247,
0.0319933072,
-0.0243269596,
-0.0219402835,
-0.0704622865,
-0.0628999919,
-0.0055633262,
-0.0764954537,
-0.0443214104,
-0.0648260191,
0.0310716536,
0.0394307785,
-0.094509773,
-0.0102956314,
3.489584009e-34,
0.0454868227,
-0.0049308692,
0.0157023948,
0.0866194218,
0.01656029,
-0.0273229238,
0.0541021563,
0.015929807,
-0.0073093171,
-0.0955564305,
-0.0484164543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13167v1 | QRMeM: Unleash the Length Limitation through Question then Reflection Memory Mechanism | 2024-06-19T02:46:18 | 2024-06-19T02:46:18 | Bo Wang, Heyan Huang, Yixin Cao, Jiahao Ying, Wei Tang, Chong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have made notable advancements in natural
language processing, they continue to struggle with processing extensive text.
Memory mechanism offers a flexible solution for managing long contexts,
utilizing techniques such as compression, summarization, and structuring to
facilitate nuanced and efficient handling of large volumes of text. However,
existing techniques face challenges with static knowledge integration, leading
to insufficient adaptation to task-specific needs and missing
multi-segmentation relationships, which hinders the dynamic reorganization and
logical combination of relevant segments during the response process. To
address these issues, we introduce a novel strategy, Question then Reflection
Memory Mechanism (QRMeM), incorporating a dual-structured memory pool. This
pool synergizes static textual content with structured graph guidance,
fostering a reflective trial-and-error approach for navigating and identifying
relevant segments. Our evaluation across multiple-choice questions (MCQ) and
multi-document question answering (Multi-doc QA) benchmarks showcases QRMeM
enhanced performance compared to existing approaches. | [
0.0468304865,
-0.0079281311,
-0.0168404281,
0.0123929977,
-0.0261484906,
-0.0119107859,
-0.0399756059,
-0.0201546904,
-0.0070465226,
-0.0617946796,
-0.0135860629,
-0.0170323122,
-0.0184729062,
0.0064729583,
0.015241148,
-0.053585317,
0.0596474744,
-0.0299046542,
-0.0115764001,
-0.0057093021,
0.023793444,
-0.0019029165,
0.0282629151,
-0.0051837871,
0.0114339786,
-0.0399192981,
-0.0466415472,
0.0151336957,
-0.0186167751,
-0.0364276022,
-0.0168571472,
0.0268011373,
0.0147124128,
0.018710956,
0.0000021225,
-0.0463207327,
-0.032617189,
0.0065624686,
-0.0246318597,
0.0250645112,
0.0341245122,
0.0239941217,
0.036483869,
0.0140319327,
-0.0053278496,
-0.0023109152,
0.0059072226,
0.0114070671,
0.0784177259,
0.0410749465,
0.0026002827,
-0.0166813824,
0.0145362746,
0.0026703768,
0.0087745162,
-0.050112281,
0.0167021751,
0.0091496585,
0.0261627734,
0.0413507707,
-0.0473850965,
0.00642415,
0.0267671421,
0.005710626,
0.0093510048,
0.0441089086,
-0.0334869325,
0.0134572471,
-0.00071292,
0.0925461352,
0.0285588019,
-0.003363892,
0.0073932502,
0.0061593698,
0.0117159905,
0.0154919187,
-0.0776640996,
0.0161587708,
-0.0298971906,
-0.0239997189,
-0.027550282,
-0.0197204538,
0.0041850149,
0.007587146,
-0.0309185367,
0.0230972227,
0.0195888504,
-0.0239181742,
0.0093683815,
0.0076857745,
-0.0111856889,
-0.0372641385,
0.0118468199,
0.0746930614,
-0.0191892311,
0.0398230664,
-0.0555574894,
-0.0726102889,
0.051999554,
-0.0430060178,
0.0059364541,
0.0254819077,
-0.0089860549,
0.0547565073,
-0.0454269424,
0.031970147,
-0.0344286487,
0.0299344156,
-0.080166094,
-0.0493363328,
-0.0516736843,
-0.0289763231,
-0.0423238054,
0.0810669959,
-0.0329124294,
-0.0527544953,
-0.0169362091,
0.0627879277,
0.0308097303,
-0.0112705035,
-0.0014534192,
0.0290679093,
0.0002402962,
0.0085904924,
-0.0460436717,
0.0428428501,
-0.0567970723,
-0.0300900079,
-0.0011449124,
0.0246076621,
-0.018289499,
0.0145923998,
0.0128082046,
-0.0316239521,
0.0117109558,
0.0480283238,
-0.0208583958,
-0.0260761995,
-0.0113513349,
-0.0341666564,
-0.0106895473,
-0.0507894084,
0.0357940868,
-0.0705710351,
0.0261986889,
0.0204089824,
-0.0173957571,
0.0482967421,
0.0139323166,
0.0455051735,
-0.0612147711,
0.0408773609,
0.0292144082,
-0.022252325,
0.0411732271,
0.0232769214,
0.0328234248,
0.0717472509,
0.0126903038,
-0.0148584191,
0.0373587608,
-0.0023062928,
-0.0403977707,
-0.0006612379,
0.0335689075,
-0.0041742926,
-0.0306099746,
0.0567888804,
-0.0039772247,
0.0101599777,
0.0194199327,
0.0562309064,
-0.0190248601,
-0.0630081594,
0.0029884588,
0.0689412951,
-0.0190296751,
0.0315254629,
-0.0115628308,
0.0228053872,
0.0235955697,
0.0260121189,
-0.0138582326,
0.048823297,
-0.0165805165,
0.0306852181,
0.0435119905,
0.03570766,
-0.018743027,
-0.0152770169,
-0.0328310095,
0.0137616722,
0.0334453396,
0.015847126,
0.0244729556,
0.0017503239,
-0.0445865355,
0.0787803307,
-0.013792091,
-0.0236948133,
-0.0007985138,
-0.0382035784,
0.0433447547,
0.0514400713,
0.0582787357,
-0.0619136468,
-0.0682402253,
0.0258824881,
0.0016967448,
0.027467031,
0.0351317823,
-0.0123523818,
-0.0011618101,
-0.0484970771,
-0.0103959003,
-0.0431061387,
-0.0122834509,
0.0203320496,
0.049502898,
-0.0056608925,
-0.00304723,
-0.0314432159,
0.0291758887,
0.0193557702,
0.0304730646,
-0.022221867,
0.000023681,
-0.0301687159,
-0.0012601262,
0.0086720176,
-0.0009134567,
0.0290897321,
0.0460068695,
-0.0237328429,
-0.0335016809,
-0.015215205,
-0.0870948881,
-0.058482293,
0.024019951,
-0.019352328,
-0.0160363,
0.0234537628,
-0.0392241329,
-0.0583666973,
-0.0007872019,
-0.05077333,
0.0277071726,
-0.0235125516,
-0.0145055028,
0.0260052662,
0.0019518351,
-0.039042335,
0.0793356672,
-0.0051852693,
0.0096065979,
0.0154328421,
0.0229247119,
-0.0098388596,
-0.0108870342,
-0.007713642,
-0.0009363217,
0.000481297,
0.0081689404,
-0.0012306678,
-0.0124945603,
-0.0838823617,
-0.003737106,
-0.091779463,
0.0244421866,
-0.0113078943,
0.0166578759,
0.0389379151,
0.0250391141,
0.0098265177,
-0.0236895755,
-0.0527166724,
0.0262223259,
0.0231214426,
0.0409833863,
0.0201359503,
0.0178760905,
0.0420200601,
-0.01787154,
-0.034102343,
-0.0288651176,
0.0638568923,
-0.0179389939,
-0.0026552938,
-0.026089428,
0.0042667794,
-0.0255511273,
0.0089569986,
0.0024726344,
0.0034113887,
-0.0112809427,
-0.0423701108,
0.0847406313,
0.052807983,
0.0008143524,
-0.0100580128,
0.0612585284,
-0.022826381,
-0.0379343741,
0.0329616368,
-0.0189678315,
0.0121331019,
-0.0088201445,
-0.0037792712,
-0.0077242032,
0.0457450636,
-0.005106051,
-0.0183565747,
-0.0072143711,
0.0042810855,
-0.0035664102,
0.0163353737,
-0.0442637466,
-0.0558756068,
-0.0093073528,
-0.0045260894,
-0.0362244621,
0.0082236249,
0.0607195534,
-0.0198528748,
-0.0144791957,
-0.0806487873,
0.0057988055,
-0.0699306056,
0.0849047154,
0.0083985543,
-0.0001175142,
0.0154716345,
-0.016898863,
-0.0414392874,
-0.0237789508,
-0.0052822214,
-0.0198508445,
0.0531857796,
-0.034516532,
0.0153032942,
-0.0268766265,
-0.0088942237,
-0.0224462859,
-0.0167066678,
0.0060719829,
0.0292256847,
0.0221414529,
-0.0052541741,
0.0044855522,
0.004447822,
0.0262059793,
0.0291305352,
-0.0282126907,
-0.0065431832,
-0.0201229844,
0.0875253528,
0.0635956675,
0.0554257371,
0.0446041748,
-0.0208646972,
0.0406167321,
0.093580693,
0.0866971537,
-0.0444385111,
0.0351294614,
-0.0278469622,
0.0124899773,
-0.0593338646,
0.0041784504,
-0.004061576,
0.049044501,
-0.0949392766,
-0.0426605977,
0.0880161896,
0.0614551678,
-0.052070573,
-0.028214395,
-0.0505313538,
0.0316443257,
0.0393790416,
0.0637301803,
-0.0564837158,
-0.0227325819,
-0.0007401949,
0.002318996,
0.0158500914,
-0.0344489291,
-0.0147940386,
-0.1049892679,
-0.0051829754,
-0.014106689,
-0.053230539,
0.0432251506,
-0.0227569323,
-0.0243909415,
0.0643069446,
-0.0171433575,
-0.0063380525,
-0.0239153393,
-0.0194292516,
0.0023256682,
-0.035605222,
0.0626915768,
0.0386124514,
-0.0102774249,
-0.0375876427,
0.0176938567,
0.0148460455,
0.0152844712,
0.0188531969,
0.0679048896,
-0.0697057694,
0.0082297837,
-0.0306515526,
0.0464337207,
-0.0134314355,
0.0297252666,
-0.0335472971,
0.0011070753,
-0.0189514607,
-0.0104604913,
0.0244678333,
0.0800090879,
0.0021516888,
0.0052585891,
-0.0352176316,
-0.0030983076,
-0.0593550727,
0.0678337812,
0.0354702882,
0.0019342512,
-0.0780888721,
-0.0115385111,
-0.0036463125,
-0.0666672438,
-0.0179081485,
0.0214195028,
-0.0087816827,
0.0653998554,
-0.0594497919,
-0.0457045101,
0.0387523547,
0.027465608,
-0.0305690672,
0.0093456982,
0.0085910326,
-0.0182441548,
-0.0698124766,
0.0105250115,
-0.0344925672,
-0.0077663944,
-0.0116134761,
-0.0030343167,
0.002562782,
0.0088802734,
-0.0161251538,
0.0132254856,
-0.0796763822,
-0.0479347706,
-0.0154600646,
0.0270908363,
0.0153793003,
0.0527010858,
-0.0148863411,
-0.0113067245,
0.0386248529,
-0.0244881548,
-0.055561088,
0.033571098,
-0.0118874554,
0.0143851638,
-0.0031400763,
0.0182538833,
-0.0709209517,
-0.0137311062,
-0.0188253541,
0.0545435548,
-0.0193222854,
-0.0370397568,
0.0082556186,
-0.0023411021,
-0.0109611982,
0.0443098247,
0.0253293291,
-0.001333315,
0.0561945848,
-0.0346529409,
-0.0177338794,
0.0000513971,
0.0144692371,
0.0055579846,
-0.0390601866,
-0.0029732443,
0.0113462703,
0.01513578,
0.0652898774,
-0.0235560052,
-0.0102238292,
0.0306098517,
-0.0544137657,
0.0131069673,
0.002119275,
-0.0299829897,
-0.0307734348,
-0.003637987,
0.0484766439,
-0.0252311416,
0.0584574491,
0.0178871229,
-0.027643526,
-0.027914824,
0.0083665596,
-0.0954393446,
-0.0479109995,
0.0019214062,
0.0353588201,
0.004921095,
-0.0080959806,
0.0106070535,
0.0053595565,
-0.0310879294,
0.0031001971,
-0.0048890794,
-0.0019280154,
-0.04705837,
0.038993746,
0.0521255918,
-0.0011934827,
0.0000435843,
0.0588331446,
0.0125177009,
0.0152441235,
0.0265022963,
-0.0310966577,
-0.0301073771,
-0.0417412333,
-0.0196310487,
0.0473652519,
-0.0061885891,
0.0042990861,
-0.0836562514,
-0.0563555248,
0.0174203161,
-0.0012971524,
0.0157919005,
-0.0397138521,
0.0345901921,
0.0542471595,
0.0559746772,
-0.0455096364,
-0.0200542919,
0.0563741103,
-0.041878745,
-0.0124145085,
0.0238348302,
-6.462330887e-33,
-0.0432888903,
-0.045998577,
0.0364213511,
-0.0491468087,
-0.0428090915,
0.0329455398,
-0.0286169723,
-0.0175264999,
0.0028304257,
-0.0276448168,
-0.0177314114,
0.0161913615,
-0.0050150654,
0.0372224636,
-0.0193794258,
-0.0245322213,
0.0310780555,
-0.0113357212,
-0.0242750179,
0.0378213115,
0.049253393,
0.0365855061,
0.0114284456,
0.0402560085,
0.0035572483,
0.0073670917,
0.0683037862,
0.0168748368,
-0.0000929812,
0.0864607692,
-0.0184273906,
0.0090016592,
0.0405572318,
-0.0350069851,
-0.0176234152,
0.0754124746,
-0.1230443418,
-0.0525450706,
0.0221972857,
0.0017227239,
-0.0657395497,
-0.0318534933,
0.0258139521,
0.0064071822,
0.0908482075,
-0.0491916239,
0.0326825939,
0.0012562677,
-0.0470689796,
-0.0454890914,
-0.0372636579,
0.0178051237,
-0.0051768227,
0.0173261501,
-0.0304913949,
0.0185712799,
0.0122678038,
0.0514002368,
-0.0557594113,
-0.0427344814,
-0.0459099002,
0.0329109766,
0.0208806228,
0.0459865928,
0.0013878301,
0.0456858203,
-0.0196531042,
0.0045280801,
-0.0362811275,
0.0172977224,
0.0138957938,
0.0057819276,
0.037633758,
0.0056758355,
0.055540178,
0.0425685942,
-0.0679290146,
0.0207733698,
0.0169758108,
0.0391393304,
0.0098783402,
0.0148838582,
0.0025565454,
-0.0106274635,
-0.035155803,
0.0732282102,
-0.052123636,
-0.0021907126,
0.0380907394,
-0.0043167002,
-0.0416655876,
0.0014319665,
0.0414513089,
-0.0231061075,
-0.0005256084,
0.0323338956,
0.0092136078,
0.0401111878,
0.0018556428,
0.0550964214,
-0.0344163999,
0.0356434807,
0.0142472722,
-0.0355703048,
-0.0270296987,
0.0249898508,
0.0080717457,
-0.001836417,
-0.070347026,
0.0084169712,
-0.0293424148,
-0.0032445944,
-0.0402916633,
0.0280449111,
0.035982646,
0.063701801,
0.005563492,
0.06226293,
0.024704529,
0.0022616729,
-0.0334134959,
-0.0208229814,
-0.0001750458,
0.0193576384,
0.0104941539,
0.0006134512,
-0.0172959156,
0.0101841809,
0.0157024413,
-0.0792163461,
0.0084041478,
0.0596065558,
2.762e-7,
0.0575042479,
0.036814902,
0.0525688939,
0.007898801,
0.0019563006,
-0.0015004376,
0.0122367293,
0.023486536,
0.0166175906,
-0.0238611754,
-0.0045358604,
0.057206165,
0.0034428888,
0.0550098717,
-0.1135593355,
-0.0019356975,
-0.0389755145,
-0.02892638,
-0.0503030606,
-0.0201733168,
0.0507672988,
0.0830612183,
-0.0145000322,
0.0023785119,
-0.0481877588,
-0.0557275265,
0.0577500314,
0.0254816413,
-0.0073848343,
0.0129133789,
0.0093418416,
-0.0183203705,
-0.0154391639,
0.0165890157,
0.0045238677,
0.0176925212,
-0.0209415387,
0.0585018918,
0.0207233857,
-0.0742629617,
0.0087012378,
-0.0409173034,
0.0220020711,
-0.0115512544,
0.0691813156,
-0.0395259783,
-0.0035863924,
-0.0026973325,
-0.0150537118,
-0.0108512212,
-0.0085511943,
0.0206673853,
-0.0044690622,
0.0386698246,
-0.0193275474,
-0.0342367366,
0.0377250612,
-0.1044579744,
-0.0227036942,
0.0178798307,
-0.0415692441,
-0.0232681073,
-0.0482705086,
-0.0249526631,
0.0248271283,
-0.066013366,
-0.0345631391,
3.04462473e-34,
0.0355903916,
-0.0166831315,
0.0020182759,
0.0566859655,
0.0219318904,
-0.0280970503,
-0.0232408401,
0.00947065,
0.0391466804,
-0.118278712,
-0.0215872265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13163v1 | LLMatDesign: Autonomous Materials Discovery with Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T02:35:02 | 2024-06-19T02:35:02 | Shuyi Jia, Chao Zhang, Victor Fung | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI, cs.CL | Discovering new materials can have significant scientific and technological
implications but remains a challenging problem today due to the enormity of the
chemical space. Recent advances in machine learning have enabled data-driven
methods to rapidly screen or generate promising materials, but these methods
still depend heavily on very large quantities of training data and often lack
the flexibility and chemical understanding often desired in materials
discovery. We introduce LLMatDesign, a novel language-based framework for
interpretable materials design powered by large language models (LLMs).
LLMatDesign utilizes LLM agents to translate human instructions, apply
modifications to materials, and evaluate outcomes using provided tools. By
incorporating self-reflection on its previous decisions, LLMatDesign adapts
rapidly to new tasks and conditions in a zero-shot manner. A systematic
evaluation of LLMatDesign on several materials design tasks, in silico,
validates LLMatDesign's effectiveness in developing new materials with
user-defined target properties in the small data regime. Our framework
demonstrates the remarkable potential of autonomous LLM-guided materials
discovery in the computational setting and towards self-driving laboratories in
the future. | [
-0.0040153326,
0.0802695453,
-0.0295662172,
0.033169169,
-0.0241407771,
-0.0290575288,
0.0129904998,
0.0172832645,
0.0362841561,
0.0105284071,
-0.0414162092,
0.0450549014,
-0.0704646185,
0.0584105067,
-0.0037166486,
0.0152647961,
0.028042892,
-0.0619237125,
0.0121791987,
-0.0181702934,
-0.0188116189,
-0.0386944786,
-0.011282241,
0.0177525952,
0.0103573343,
0.0003869222,
-0.0488131829,
-0.0033520011,
0.0035678856,
-0.0226552747,
-0.0025436247,
0.0533470772,
0.0196337216,
0.0396914445,
0.0000022957,
-0.057883516,
0.0135423532,
0.0486770868,
-0.008496589,
-0.0075273532,
0.0436337851,
-0.0570613444,
-0.042723421,
-0.015079841,
-0.0325825252,
0.0248942953,
0.0482395217,
0.0061488762,
-0.0042243339,
-0.0122550437,
0.0040925406,
-0.0008985473,
0.0180798005,
0.0115532652,
0.0607190952,
-0.0194262154,
0.0045745904,
0.0294468347,
0.0732078701,
0.0247499961,
0.0068749264,
0.0421290398,
-0.0073845368,
-0.0463461466,
0.0511878543,
0.0010207944,
-0.0311957896,
-0.024087077,
0.0014214233,
0.0809392706,
0.0169114042,
-0.0329317786,
-0.0442979634,
-0.0296883918,
-0.0447313674,
0.0266845208,
-0.0299540907,
0.0055595133,
0.024108775,
0.0025576279,
0.0064273663,
-0.0013965727,
0.0316974297,
0.0278832801,
-0.0248364769,
0.0856460929,
-0.0119491164,
0.0008757037,
-0.0077531375,
0.0064944555,
0.017036153,
0.009708819,
-0.0013019687,
0.017948864,
-0.0199662074,
-0.0012581468,
0.021612389,
0.0017869829,
0.0467808656,
-0.0443639979,
0.0621866919,
0.0306768492,
0.0019600701,
0.04579667,
-0.0670684204,
0.0116944257,
-0.0142046791,
0.0057957042,
-0.0695986897,
-0.0147339506,
-0.0298371259,
-0.0194930919,
-0.0252495408,
-0.0139854187,
-0.0366464928,
-0.0192302335,
0.00696307,
0.0777493715,
-0.0073254989,
0.0090917815,
-0.0273620747,
-0.0050753863,
-0.0196720231,
-0.0136438878,
-0.023797432,
-0.0022441954,
-0.0112073626,
0.0165261216,
-0.0070713153,
-0.0086597987,
-0.0331061855,
0.0208230577,
-0.0120112142,
0.0250545982,
0.0102725923,
0.1479993016,
-0.0092127509,
-0.0223301928,
0.0028151278,
-0.054962527,
0.0406046808,
-0.0219893605,
0.0222720224,
-0.0216134097,
0.0299416427,
0.0478416719,
-0.0132012032,
-0.0856184065,
0.0063440641,
-0.0387395807,
0.0249135513,
0.0902004689,
-0.0084631769,
-0.0348284803,
0.0147706317,
-0.0014817748,
0.0059111533,
0.0338979401,
0.0145019153,
0.0780426934,
-0.0163495243,
0.0000824876,
0.0024040716,
0.0125427675,
-0.0139541393,
-0.023301892,
-0.0301827714,
-0.0236053541,
0.0274014678,
0.0636197627,
-0.0068495916,
-0.0199746899,
0.0035601212,
-0.0003124482,
0.0580651946,
0.0364667661,
0.0171608627,
0.0545547232,
0.0090145748,
0.0305523034,
0.0175201315,
-0.0712484196,
-0.0052913222,
0.0658065379,
-0.0368019864,
-0.0376227312,
0.0143670775,
0.0196580682,
-0.0007090436,
-0.0579197966,
-0.0179596599,
-0.0244426988,
0.0360540114,
-0.0232097507,
0.067186892,
-0.0188865066,
-0.0443570465,
0.0111965192,
0.0229344871,
-0.0496305041,
-0.0528755933,
-0.0337240621,
0.0580013469,
0.1037070602,
0.0321047455,
-0.0640168786,
-0.0393203534,
0.0409581661,
0.0053909346,
0.016762631,
-0.013753037,
-0.013516292,
0.0166556351,
-0.0026135168,
-0.0305904616,
-0.0446194597,
0.0205168258,
0.010713581,
-0.0382419936,
-0.0396513194,
-0.01735962,
-0.024341695,
-0.0592493117,
0.0418014526,
-0.0311207604,
-0.048138164,
0.0787936971,
-0.0086597688,
0.0266113561,
0.0160960704,
0.048617743,
0.0014085344,
0.0931565315,
-0.0613800809,
-0.0297302976,
-0.0302592777,
0.0252308883,
-0.0085702548,
0.0062675918,
-0.0406106934,
0.0414369106,
-0.0235693119,
-0.0295440014,
-0.0093041593,
0.0721451715,
0.0056159575,
-0.0192050021,
-0.0067920559,
-0.0103273094,
-0.0140466448,
0.0510516427,
-0.0510046519,
0.0203379616,
0.0229907818,
-0.0266217459,
0.0063644303,
0.0429420061,
0.025366148,
-0.0140744997,
0.021627415,
0.0055697598,
0.0321999565,
0.0371174589,
0.0303723682,
-0.0080080638,
0.0012329273,
-0.0263788868,
0.0283612888,
-0.0001620403,
0.0004463561,
-0.0152950939,
0.0229162257,
-0.0270410087,
-0.0010677237,
-0.029580839,
0.0568224266,
0.0268655661,
-0.0358506851,
-0.066426076,
0.0653039739,
0.0092061041,
-0.0641136914,
-0.0234071538,
-0.0460360199,
-0.0378180146,
0.0333324336,
0.0315060839,
0.0442713127,
-0.0733385682,
0.0220203865,
0.0413973704,
0.0236362033,
-0.0124752047,
-0.0382895879,
0.0165643618,
-0.0344426781,
-0.021782048,
0.0467847176,
-0.0314271897,
0.0637412518,
0.0747604743,
-0.0027336264,
-0.0133790663,
-0.0089641474,
-0.0167618152,
0.0214700829,
0.0629191101,
-0.0108252792,
0.0298398342,
0.0345329084,
-0.0525508709,
0.0026717812,
-0.0214523263,
0.0528544597,
0.0159051884,
-0.0729034096,
0.0045144837,
0.0283246692,
0.030922126,
0.020928191,
0.0475027077,
-0.0563433096,
0.0826288834,
-0.0190953836,
0.0048002931,
-0.0483114682,
-0.0588561147,
-0.0130800093,
0.0288202297,
-0.0044439645,
0.0094867675,
0.0106928358,
0.0396342911,
0.0176655129,
-0.0132517135,
0.0173466224,
-0.0045443103,
0.005328387,
-0.0663563311,
0.0244263392,
0.0328392051,
-0.0589072779,
-0.0318622217,
0.0193966441,
0.0025694142,
0.0450270697,
-0.0075606275,
-0.030885417,
-0.0471918769,
0.0258809384,
0.0518964045,
-0.0108519485,
-0.0155924559,
0.0054086559,
-0.0667610839,
-0.0137865366,
-0.0148736835,
-0.0153645584,
0.0294609312,
0.0095805479,
0.0618372336,
0.0435900129,
0.0194130521,
-0.0273116082,
-0.0901951641,
0.0298948754,
0.0212112404,
0.026897829,
0.0035393331,
-0.0043886122,
0.0070389709,
-0.0342882313,
-0.0247297715,
0.0296056364,
0.0183057617,
-0.0442922376,
0.0267078709,
-0.0071333093,
-0.0233201329,
-0.0140646026,
0.0386951752,
-0.0645522401,
-0.0360435136,
-0.0155561194,
0.0290723983,
-0.0211452767,
-0.0109507032,
-0.0106525403,
-0.041762542,
0.0539937578,
-0.0141837196,
-0.0638070256,
-0.021697728,
-0.0772700384,
-0.011305932,
-0.025608046,
0.0103683518,
0.0642495081,
-0.0213736817,
-0.0188193619,
-0.0104155336,
-0.0306929033,
-0.0764209181,
0.0219521131,
0.0247150287,
-0.0135354325,
0.047684662,
0.0207214337,
-0.0351325385,
-0.0077505144,
0.0222314317,
0.0122153293,
0.021712793,
-0.0752138942,
-0.0061864774,
0.0480941385,
-0.0285394304,
-0.0024330134,
0.0608211681,
-0.0310149845,
-0.0518874899,
-0.0175261609,
0.1012066901,
-0.0392558798,
0.020052623,
-0.052899342,
-0.0472649857,
0.0413177907,
0.0459864624,
-0.032434497,
-0.0602530576,
-0.0884646624,
-0.0267684273,
-0.0056691412,
-0.0235124398,
-0.0277030058,
-0.0246815514,
-0.0296933074,
0.008291686,
-0.0056910217,
-0.0080745108,
0.0183671191,
-0.0088163204,
-0.0179480333,
-0.0107844071,
-0.0166285355,
0.0024578089,
-0.0615350865,
0.007928961,
0.0038512675,
0.0164172631,
-0.0318567976,
-0.054513786,
0.0417012721,
-0.0622829795,
-0.0031974637,
0.0452911071,
-0.0167181492,
-0.0420458578,
0.0176223833,
0.0564386249,
0.0199906565,
0.01256599,
-0.0293647703,
-0.079404749,
0.072605744,
0.0388011746,
-0.0275804754,
-0.0076190918,
0.0043362067,
0.0076865121,
-0.0264323074,
-0.0185957383,
-0.0096926969,
0.0469772182,
0.0015538096,
0.0096638761,
-0.0096842209,
-0.0630615875,
0.0255962349,
0.0321643241,
0.0267315879,
0.015914375,
0.0405134112,
-0.0201943293,
-0.0051406776,
0.0420482829,
0.0253498461,
-0.0521531478,
0.0107885394,
0.0438471027,
-0.0500215441,
0.0173728801,
-0.0412291214,
-0.0080875391,
0.0136999842,
-0.0205686353,
0.0794869438,
-0.0108133443,
0.0441847816,
0.0677195936,
0.0242046546,
0.0072988342,
0.0451535806,
-0.0493109189,
0.0625585094,
-0.024852002,
0.0456745774,
0.0212214123,
0.057838317,
-0.054465849,
0.0642940328,
-0.0345960334,
-0.1062749103,
-0.0424431525,
0.0203514248,
0.0308085568,
0.0267947279,
0.0327151306,
-0.0345128812,
-0.0187768098,
-0.0191387478,
0.0485176258,
-0.0023610438,
-0.0168858655,
0.0097841015,
0.0219364185,
-0.0010229072,
-0.0677452832,
0.0488263629,
0.0329472311,
-0.0135209281,
-0.0344286226,
-0.0282987133,
-0.0294595044,
-0.0196613148,
-0.0071193692,
-0.0231867749,
-0.0253287926,
-0.0365696624,
-0.0189492013,
-0.0187807009,
-0.0047790315,
0.0602209084,
-0.0370590463,
-0.0365595929,
0.0272010975,
0.1012388691,
0.0016139125,
-0.0586797558,
-0.0102379909,
-0.0167158209,
0.0086660339,
-0.0195191223,
-0.0043541724,
-6.176566741e-33,
0.0094162542,
0.0100055467,
0.0030111012,
0.0234142691,
0.0369760767,
-0.0545525476,
-0.0810832679,
-0.0029846353,
0.0395166762,
0.0612675287,
-0.0050149979,
-0.0247169286,
0.0138299391,
-0.0186471343,
0.0750953853,
0.0343213268,
0.0069019399,
0.0406657681,
-0.0122879883,
0.0158491898,
0.0267200936,
0.0248754099,
0.0160512365,
-0.0498465635,
-0.0036004239,
0.0406760946,
0.0214282684,
-0.0311608817,
-0.0626067519,
0.0624870174,
-0.0555362552,
0.0437690206,
-0.0292873066,
-0.0086510377,
-0.0492693186,
-0.0068010157,
-0.0578903556,
-0.0329712704,
-0.0270196069,
0.0076415497,
-0.0246124789,
-0.0146277668,
-0.0017485636,
-0.0060498705,
-0.0913411155,
0.0208176672,
0.0180952232,
-0.0442071185,
0.0405822545,
0.018282868,
-0.0888540149,
-0.0082587404,
0.0200950373,
0.0058308383,
0.0428750254,
-0.0191204678,
-0.0279195625,
-0.0274325944,
-0.0331380665,
0.0599260256,
0.0116924904,
-0.0133060031,
0.0456289984,
0.0494352132,
0.0012468114,
-0.0117253643,
0.0502681509,
0.0440514311,
0.0298526064,
0.0080114873,
0.0176397022,
0.0699955374,
0.0675092414,
0.0310699474,
-0.0067112441,
0.0213271175,
-0.1039395556,
-0.0074230232,
0.0109288925,
0.0206673183,
0.052866742,
0.065311484,
0.0272993818,
-0.043375507,
-0.0186090469,
0.026466528,
0.0178287271,
-0.0255034119,
-0.0292206518,
0.0006064279,
-0.0801077858,
-0.046200566,
0.0158985611,
-0.0512961335,
-0.0108182877,
0.0325074941,
-0.0228851717,
-0.0060402462,
-0.0206985492,
-0.0075919628,
-0.0857121721,
-0.0253831875,
-0.0328602716,
-0.0048391968,
0.0277483426,
-0.0007889946,
-0.0521867983,
0.0461390205,
0.0011197156,
0.0113074603,
-0.0671051666,
-0.0356270485,
0.0390187465,
-0.0166570451,
0.0011421227,
-0.0117818872,
-0.0074657383,
-0.0016039945,
-0.011213596,
0.0057794568,
0.0046591708,
0.0286962073,
-0.0082083838,
0.0038579684,
-0.0455287173,
-0.0388460234,
-0.073515065,
0.0198215786,
0.0533862524,
-0.0630416572,
0.0126478355,
0.0246715266,
3.058e-7,
0.0505705327,
0.0513922125,
0.0011309064,
0.0211013649,
-0.0067068418,
0.0505272783,
-0.0170173496,
-0.0067367544,
-0.0030652322,
-0.0080358395,
0.0385785177,
0.0525293499,
0.0180216599,
-0.0179248154,
-0.0479253456,
0.0231541824,
0.0281213839,
-0.0084628565,
-0.0660135895,
0.0049567996,
-0.0087277545,
0.0351809338,
0.01524188,
-0.0402397029,
0.0124925431,
-0.030713357,
0.0095712179,
-0.0594615415,
0.0505180396,
0.0615575612,
-0.0152798379,
-0.0409489833,
-0.0329567045,
0.0467710271,
0.0052934829,
-0.0057890452,
-0.0207822081,
0.0398699678,
-0.0040677902,
0.0096531259,
0.0236423165,
-0.0197014865,
0.0297537092,
-0.0013200009,
0.0159690809,
-0.0197945535,
-0.0360245071,
0.0130042033,
0.0355291441,
-0.0232143439,
-0.0069115977,
-0.0255029071,
0.0300421137,
-0.0075843334,
-0.0246451832,
0.0342274606,
0.003875623,
-0.0324232318,
-0.0109530445,
0.002402022,
-0.0554700941,
0.0107831676,
-0.0450221747,
-0.0050107753,
0.0145039028,
-0.0169945993,
0.0316173024,
2.795109064e-34,
0.0615109541,
-0.0064677172,
0.0063806209,
0.0496840924,
0.0413762406,
0.0046008239,
-0.0249757562,
0.0299697705,
0.0334130935,
-0.0735159516,
0.000375812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13161v1 | APPL: A Prompt Programming Language for Harmonious Integration of Programs and Large Language Model Prompts | 2024-06-19T02:29:59 | 2024-06-19T02:29:59 | Honghua Dong, Qidong Su, Yubo Gao, Zhaoyu Li, Yangjun Ruan, Gennady Pekhimenko, Chris J. Maddison, Xujie Si | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become increasingly capable of handling
diverse tasks with the aid of well-crafted prompts and integration of external
tools, but as task complexity rises, the workflow involving LLMs can be
complicated and thus challenging to implement and maintain. To address this
challenge, we propose APPL, A Prompt Programming Language that acts as a bridge
between computer programs and LLMs, allowing seamless embedding of prompts into
Python functions, and vice versa. APPL provides an intuitive and Python-native
syntax, an efficient parallelized runtime with asynchronous semantics, and a
tracing module supporting effective failure diagnosis and replaying without
extra costs. We demonstrate that APPL programs are intuitive, concise, and
efficient through three representative scenarios: Chain-of-Thought with
self-consistency (CoT-SC), ReAct tool use agent, and multi-agent chat.
Experiments on three parallelizable workflows further show that APPL can
effectively parallelize independent LLM calls, with a significant speedup ratio
that almost matches the estimation. | [
-0.0082133589,
0.0245557595,
-0.0175573342,
0.0130665768,
-0.0544156022,
0.0176528823,
0.008286613,
-0.0049336548,
0.0560752377,
-0.0150495367,
0.0081185224,
0.0138373161,
0.0158231501,
0.0474362485,
0.0139944581,
-0.0182808638,
0.0572826639,
-0.0542996377,
-0.0027946511,
-0.0063414369,
-0.021453226,
0.0389402881,
-0.0086093592,
0.0315040462,
-0.0046232743,
-0.0450959466,
-0.037689101,
0.0112490933,
-0.0079765748,
0.0048402725,
-0.0253419969,
0.0256832726,
0.0148695726,
0.072145097,
0.0000022762,
-0.0916167572,
-0.0089046629,
0.0184800401,
-0.0477138609,
0.02296062,
0.0240757968,
-0.0082234088,
-0.0382774808,
0.0400619395,
-0.0013730513,
-0.0065920381,
0.0664465651,
-0.0643169358,
0.0807702467,
0.0240537021,
0.0095434701,
0.0625156239,
0.0106195584,
0.027880732,
-0.0423806608,
-0.0232186839,
0.0185904633,
-0.0206277501,
0.0525603071,
-0.0184300914,
0.0442157425,
0.0232661217,
0.0307204165,
-0.0581165142,
-0.0291535165,
0.0196108576,
0.0248973295,
-0.055957824,
-0.041464828,
0.0055093658,
-0.0126828533,
-0.0325042643,
-0.0150147788,
-0.0052623809,
-0.0126220798,
0.0163594019,
-0.0623681024,
0.06814491,
-0.0012196002,
-0.010581906,
0.0554934703,
-0.0432566293,
0.0089410264,
-0.020802727,
-0.0151962405,
0.0792997852,
0.0488300696,
-0.0044321925,
-0.0583519116,
0.0109545104,
0.0261156373,
-0.0785569698,
0.0168290138,
0.0411691293,
-0.1079002321,
0.0160430428,
-0.0050138924,
-0.0248068999,
0.0591761768,
-0.0349793807,
0.0106639983,
0.0392931402,
-0.0621936433,
0.0516881347,
0.0281521101,
0.0509536974,
0.0270635877,
-0.0151039017,
0.0123075265,
-0.0153112207,
-0.0082375165,
-0.002194037,
-0.0528818481,
0.002332618,
-0.0029237473,
0.018164875,
0.0205447022,
0.092801474,
-0.0207701307,
0.0930011272,
-0.0183237977,
-0.0709464997,
-0.008229835,
0.0011602538,
-0.0117498897,
0.0504390113,
-0.0098863561,
-0.0500572883,
0.0020160337,
-0.0529196709,
-0.0194126628,
0.0070211366,
-0.0196582265,
-0.0096126571,
0.0010035833,
0.0665703863,
0.0132340956,
0.0331315883,
0.0023331684,
-0.0295625441,
0.0373514444,
-0.0580443591,
-0.0497572683,
-0.1017550156,
0.0117703304,
0.0507596545,
0.0054346342,
-0.0407786481,
-0.023420509,
0.0035529314,
0.021919081,
0.0379700847,
-0.0600238107,
0.0078822942,
0.0119840875,
0.0188222099,
0.0159415491,
0.0418495871,
-0.0237573106,
0.0071220482,
0.0404773727,
-0.0233093034,
0.0161254518,
0.037129052,
-0.0340689458,
0.0425755084,
-0.0186207797,
0.0127342083,
0.0682006776,
0.0224984698,
-0.039602302,
0.0315103941,
0.039037481,
0.011410065,
0.0144038768,
0.0187826194,
-0.0434544198,
-0.0183482207,
0.0388742499,
0.0508629382,
-0.0108689424,
0.0050412584,
-0.0526867025,
0.031689126,
-0.0078925835,
0.017405577,
0.000291234,
0.0800958648,
-0.0047430955,
-0.023788875,
-0.0278600343,
-0.0008814671,
-0.0273020845,
0.0121451998,
0.0589164011,
-0.0129740341,
-0.0395573601,
0.0284328312,
0.0160868932,
-0.0295345988,
-0.0385322198,
-0.0503540337,
0.0522481091,
0.0969040394,
0.0619807616,
-0.0322565064,
-0.0352841765,
-0.025979232,
0.0065035382,
0.0251517128,
0.0237407051,
-0.0100026382,
-0.0142456926,
0.0004383105,
-0.0127031412,
-0.0060547031,
0.0099305417,
0.0403079651,
-0.0091570392,
-0.0160107613,
-0.020817345,
0.0443850495,
-0.0174497981,
0.0140221501,
-0.0076268539,
-0.0383349359,
-0.0459177159,
0.0224490091,
-0.0152825154,
0.0074496157,
-0.0139485914,
-0.0095157288,
0.0454680733,
0.0317136012,
-0.0006843643,
-0.0165263601,
-0.0394958258,
0.0050866161,
0.0496166162,
0.0688197911,
-0.0397704653,
0.0263017435,
-0.0409731455,
-0.0307386704,
0.0359075032,
0.0084590577,
0.0361710005,
0.0111203399,
0.0565341748,
-0.008926074,
-0.0016572165,
-0.0163049661,
-0.030555591,
0.0426095687,
0.0023946471,
0.0289324615,
0.0406462848,
0.0338616595,
-0.0122292098,
-0.0493856072,
0.0542209037,
0.0016342502,
0.0435690321,
0.005647175,
0.0391806178,
-0.0052421093,
0.0031875556,
-0.0897279307,
0.0308762006,
-0.0265299063,
0.0052497298,
0.0221990794,
0.0466014072,
-0.0297202021,
-0.0233582556,
0.0199447572,
0.0321115442,
0.0307292473,
0.0299477205,
0.0206891336,
0.0015957799,
-0.0870243162,
-0.0025300628,
-0.0217908882,
-0.0090209646,
0.0382554121,
0.0115169063,
-0.0585235916,
-0.0967084989,
0.014104099,
-0.012828622,
0.018189773,
-0.0014955851,
-0.0136971483,
0.0172161795,
-0.0479923263,
0.0451645702,
-0.0041291607,
-0.0639856383,
0.0028270353,
0.0815622136,
-0.0176013056,
-0.0667198896,
-0.005077024,
0.0056583919,
-0.0480321087,
0.0494544804,
-0.0119377784,
-0.0026791908,
0.0648716092,
-0.0198956262,
-0.0238758121,
0.0205857139,
0.0024451248,
0.0107960254,
0.0154205309,
-0.0211697537,
-0.0591641292,
-0.004873781,
0.0449024364,
0.0267123226,
-0.1106468216,
0.0738316402,
-0.0593251437,
-0.0455916896,
-0.0279988628,
-0.100064978,
-0.0431489609,
0.1058520675,
-0.0025504134,
-0.0244773254,
0.0160237383,
-0.0495382361,
-0.0000775508,
0.0257164575,
0.0083293766,
-0.000274612,
0.0265319012,
-0.0627674535,
0.0128351105,
-0.0268153604,
-0.0145113394,
-0.0163874906,
0.0211802907,
-0.0663503334,
-0.0090594906,
-0.0231909081,
-0.0196515694,
0.0269121826,
0.0097806053,
0.042403236,
0.044046104,
0.024488993,
-0.0097795706,
-0.0146954814,
-0.0464496613,
-0.0444152765,
-0.0181905739,
-0.0095028188,
-0.01027143,
0.0787809789,
0.032906469,
0.0263452325,
-0.0114953984,
-0.0290881488,
-0.0428587198,
0.0532608591,
-0.0322511345,
-0.0249190461,
0.0354826227,
0.0066692834,
-0.0875207037,
-0.0236989148,
0.0878114626,
0.0212758873,
-0.0525296479,
-0.0008695205,
-0.0664253235,
0.0244860314,
0.0307884011,
0.0636544675,
-0.1082918718,
0.0023971251,
0.0206727982,
0.0073830346,
0.0013959128,
0.0247354861,
-0.0121121844,
-0.0605403185,
0.0521948226,
-0.0000563528,
-0.0032502534,
-0.0122011751,
-0.0468514115,
0.0021957979,
0.0324853212,
0.0325172991,
0.0375520252,
0.0069485744,
-0.0026304384,
-0.0174307134,
-0.0191586483,
0.0161132328,
0.0098446682,
-0.0181053057,
0.0598565489,
0.0327999778,
0.0033580519,
0.0051351739,
-0.0001250845,
0.0607457645,
0.0348124169,
-0.0353369489,
-0.0481735095,
-0.0282508973,
0.0465422235,
-0.0282657277,
-0.003003008,
-0.0370501988,
-0.0418688394,
-0.0382188112,
0.0178849623,
0.0835158974,
-0.029982863,
0.0001979017,
0.0102993827,
-0.0249448456,
0.0357546695,
0.047672905,
0.0090420414,
-0.0103779091,
-0.0476034284,
-0.0316478387,
-0.0606048368,
0.0017524862,
-0.0098967124,
0.0064446637,
0.0091403704,
-0.0248791613,
-0.017043246,
-0.0027879842,
0.0777662694,
0.0060502575,
0.0089965966,
0.0087533882,
-0.030139925,
0.009137217,
-0.0378230698,
0.0161886774,
-0.0322755761,
0.0520073473,
-0.0533555672,
-0.0223808251,
-0.0211245213,
-0.0069991313,
-0.0116219586,
0.0409748666,
-0.0619901791,
-0.0447607487,
0.0295059029,
0.0440013483,
0.023441501,
0.0044311243,
-0.0285199657,
-0.0359908342,
-0.0450587161,
0.0396849066,
-0.071371071,
-0.0032080885,
-0.0093200291,
0.0250335522,
0.0185625162,
-0.0077183577,
-0.0477832556,
-0.0461027548,
-0.0327430628,
-0.0022937856,
-0.0050657932,
-0.0801931471,
0.0016017621,
0.0808976069,
-0.0266512353,
-0.0073737074,
-0.0228293277,
-0.0084302621,
0.0192902386,
-0.0098528741,
-0.0134516358,
-0.0526764169,
0.026131697,
-0.0506639332,
-0.0502790548,
0.058359392,
-0.0248376504,
-0.0153520806,
0.0204661321,
-0.033146318,
0.0441154465,
-0.0515808389,
0.0140548758,
0.0819538906,
0.0237131156,
-0.0214769691,
0.0241654497,
0.0308496505,
0.039953541,
-0.0360695124,
0.0361250676,
0.0072981571,
-0.0117038563,
0.0191213023,
0.021599235,
-0.0345309973,
-0.1077647507,
0.0398971662,
0.0624408945,
0.0541265197,
0.0357280709,
0.0628440008,
-0.0518857986,
0.0042445166,
-0.0356310718,
0.0411349982,
0.0165135507,
-0.0114513943,
-0.0047328114,
0.0253367946,
-0.0049379137,
-0.0098473877,
0.0272926558,
-0.0382692963,
0.0040378757,
0.0147374962,
-0.0381925516,
-0.0476328023,
-0.0048116189,
0.0078705046,
0.0141602466,
-0.0402274914,
-0.0351805538,
-0.0547986254,
-0.0332620591,
-0.0416308008,
0.0406754501,
-0.0372419767,
-0.0424375199,
0.0121804615,
0.0528634228,
0.0454801917,
0.0322765559,
0.0050149146,
0.0613613836,
0.014159427,
-0.0423162878,
0.0198794119,
-5.728195727e-33,
-0.0421731956,
-0.0550340563,
0.0418227054,
0.0199432559,
-0.0001008163,
-0.0046288981,
-0.0669073761,
0.0046987869,
0.0372610241,
-0.0065434384,
0.0104323821,
-0.0066349842,
0.0252260081,
-0.03409563,
0.0128412778,
0.0342112668,
0.0226730481,
0.0560564958,
-0.0110749602,
0.0228719488,
0.0497772805,
0.0124565484,
0.0333652198,
-0.0371480808,
0.0172478985,
-0.0133349178,
0.0238717981,
0.0265192054,
-0.0232876707,
0.0259095915,
0.0082736146,
0.0446783341,
-0.0097473664,
-0.0660233051,
-0.0296696536,
0.0361381397,
-0.0106321182,
-0.0241822377,
0.0338633209,
0.01581976,
-0.0407362804,
-0.0096174246,
0.001644978,
-0.001938291,
0.023880152,
0.0435734987,
-0.0024255712,
0.0303836651,
-0.0305971149,
0.0572398342,
-0.0503510535,
0.0094566755,
-0.0186460987,
-0.0093578845,
0.0302645862,
-0.0046265204,
0.0094193593,
0.0026583883,
0.0000021478,
0.003380819,
-0.0003661585,
0.0194633771,
0.0683107525,
-0.0053847544,
-0.0309542194,
0.0016171999,
0.0364872403,
0.0182015318,
-0.0128515838,
0.0287421811,
-0.0196564775,
0.0039304611,
0.0283558909,
-0.0051802415,
-0.0663141012,
-0.007477046,
-0.0186116304,
0.0227032676,
0.0997252762,
-0.0107217673,
-0.0043061371,
0.0059412513,
-0.0082886564,
-0.0446669459,
-0.0287543256,
0.034492854,
-0.0291083027,
-0.0190444626,
-0.005270564,
-0.0369440727,
0.0005982809,
-0.007816717,
0.0387141854,
0.0215325058,
-0.0134616373,
-0.0117323911,
-0.0311184339,
0.0207440592,
-0.0024412591,
0.0349833556,
0.0149333533,
0.0268455725,
-0.0623461679,
-0.0106234215,
0.0496160686,
0.0319860838,
-0.0308254976,
0.0398746729,
-0.0558110178,
0.0306945313,
-0.0697195455,
0.0282303281,
-0.0199250448,
-0.0076871677,
0.0245363005,
-0.0183075927,
0.0173517093,
0.0497830771,
0.0124373883,
-0.0750999674,
-0.0324070416,
0.0395822264,
-0.0146756703,
-0.0491866991,
-0.0491149612,
-0.0134303952,
-0.0581580475,
0.0430104658,
0.0557343774,
-0.0003888005,
-0.0139206136,
-0.0179491844,
3.068e-7,
0.0033190653,
0.0517925657,
0.0355926007,
0.0640892163,
0.0178228132,
0.0248738565,
-0.0302673969,
-0.0023891132,
0.0294533968,
-0.0065796138,
-0.042579852,
0.0024281202,
0.047364343,
0.037971694,
-0.0752963871,
0.0098124482,
-0.057629101,
0.0260183476,
-0.0783353895,
0.0072532459,
0.0246052537,
0.0221609659,
0.0390871279,
-0.0233252048,
0.0164059028,
-0.0206389818,
-0.0391895361,
-0.0291026272,
-0.0081471801,
0.0142884357,
-0.0354571119,
0.0042741122,
0.0193748921,
0.0372471586,
-0.0000789699,
-0.0467027314,
-0.037682455,
0.0522548929,
0.0184056759,
0.0340462439,
0.0304789562,
-0.0362833403,
0.0044734827,
-0.0838014036,
0.0136815701,
-0.0006272003,
-0.0214386452,
-0.0389814824,
0.0212979503,
-0.0413850285,
-0.004604728,
0.0048199003,
0.0071527315,
0.053882245,
-0.0228895973,
-0.0230580624,
-0.0300544351,
-0.011308087,
-0.0466671027,
0.0035653953,
-0.0317420512,
-0.0765415356,
-0.0410925858,
-0.0281628612,
-0.0051026358,
-0.0402365699,
-0.0016678601,
3.402961096e-34,
0.0404013917,
-0.0014766519,
0.0364530534,
0.0410351828,
0.000725978,
-0.00349297,
-0.0198167842,
0.0300237481,
0.0379314013,
-0.0433566011,
-0.0409021266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13152v1 | Analyzing Diversity in Healthcare LLM Research: A Scientometric Perspective | 2024-06-19T02:00:51 | 2024-06-19T02:00:51 | David Restrepo, Chenwei Wu, Constanza Vásquez-Venegas, João Matos, Jack Gallifant, Luis Filipe | cs.CL | cs.CL | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) in healthcare has demonstrated
substantial potential for enhancing clinical decision-making, administrative
efficiency, and patient outcomes. However, the underrepresentation of diverse
groups in the development and application of these models can perpetuate
biases, leading to inequitable healthcare delivery. This paper presents a
comprehensive scientometric analysis of LLM research for healthcare, including
data from January 1, 2021, to June 16, 2024. By analyzing metadata from PubMed
and Dimensions, including author affiliations, countries, and funding sources,
we assess the diversity of contributors to LLM research. Our findings highlight
significant gender and geographic disparities, with a predominance of male
authors and contributions primarily from high-income countries (HICs). We
introduce a novel journal diversity index based on Gini impurity to measure the
inclusiveness of scientific publications. Our results underscore the necessity
for greater representation in order to ensure the equitable application of LLMs
in healthcare. We propose actionable strategies to enhance diversity and
inclusivity in artificial intelligence research, with the ultimate goal of
fostering a more inclusive and equitable future in healthcare innovation. | [
0.0408011004,
0.1152012125,
-0.0265228488,
-0.051298745,
0.0042199823,
0.0274286345,
0.0840425566,
0.0154044041,
0.0070164688,
-0.0058432668,
0.0028668689,
-0.0359380022,
0.0464192964,
0.0678246617,
0.0312006418,
-0.0125742359,
0.015933603,
0.0379291773,
0.0487477221,
-0.0361438133,
-0.0455543697,
0.0164891165,
-0.0096118692,
0.0822020322,
0.0518942811,
0.0060915104,
0.0604849197,
-0.0167264473,
0.004908537,
-0.0628760532,
0.0118678398,
0.0376361497,
-0.0304357279,
0.0251597427,
0.0000021225,
-0.0745536163,
-0.0186866969,
0.0681097135,
-0.0193577968,
-0.0432157852,
0.0080789784,
-0.0631752834,
-0.0302260015,
0.0148563329,
-0.0380481109,
-0.0067491918,
0.0446673408,
-0.0059330706,
-0.0501260199,
0.0115971733,
0.0052709398,
0.0147650382,
0.027794268,
-0.0478417091,
0.0110738091,
0.0202017203,
0.0256249346,
-0.0194968078,
0.0279327836,
-0.0193712488,
0.0031558219,
0.056879133,
-0.0008128273,
0.0234648418,
0.0262620468,
0.0795443803,
-0.0097362027,
-0.0180846155,
0.0196067113,
0.0055893194,
0.0633624643,
0.0238083322,
0.036001306,
0.0114709781,
0.003126391,
0.0384442322,
-0.052534204,
0.0376895592,
-0.0113857295,
-0.0235170498,
0.0116636623,
0.0148794604,
0.0304608122,
0.0283639394,
-0.0133607332,
0.0644820407,
0.0089474963,
-0.0382826477,
0.0252988823,
0.0015944795,
0.0064381962,
-0.0052306,
-0.0039891815,
0.006223252,
-0.0463138856,
-0.0072134095,
0.0540216267,
-0.0504298508,
0.1112162173,
-0.0494030267,
-0.0088165188,
-0.0009274254,
0.0278443173,
0.0133629404,
0.0360057987,
-0.0199649073,
-0.0142884785,
0.0337674879,
-0.0338121839,
0.0144766485,
-0.0250940416,
-0.0097453427,
0.0505068228,
-0.0167869162,
-0.0197179783,
0.0263199285,
-0.0972393379,
-0.0264781788,
-0.0585811064,
-0.0176304281,
-0.0007750715,
0.0446583964,
-0.0335881561,
0.0134122968,
-0.0026275101,
0.0175645016,
-0.0178595893,
0.0400079265,
-0.0556157939,
-0.0383402407,
0.0325445123,
0.0216332264,
-0.0029265902,
-0.0185179543,
0.0219713226,
0.0106546758,
0.0282273814,
-0.0458015911,
0.0413342379,
-0.0007098404,
-0.029371487,
-0.033673387,
0.0615593009,
-0.0744292289,
0.0463062115,
0.021221118,
0.0249937717,
-0.0791989118,
-0.0174878426,
-0.0153986681,
-0.0575696081,
0.00830271,
-0.064464733,
0.0010703481,
0.0632889271,
0.0283510145,
-0.0070593441,
0.0304395445,
0.0228864681,
-0.0741627961,
0.0172880739,
-0.0035116447,
-0.0114427628,
-0.0026604198,
0.0087339859,
0.0423797555,
0.0271949135,
0.0127344029,
0.0041925861,
0.0524981059,
-0.0168689992,
0.0231112596,
0.0086785993,
0.0085248556,
0.0249209013,
0.1066750884,
0.0035257994,
0.0485013947,
-0.0117678521,
-0.0661473647,
-0.0205369499,
-0.0614511557,
0.0029034643,
-0.0078482497,
0.0211735126,
-0.0203621108,
0.0439420342,
0.0392734259,
-0.0232777689,
-0.029885266,
-0.0184025075,
0.006704987,
0.0157675054,
-0.0319906175,
0.0226813611,
-0.0527663082,
0.0504296944,
0.0373220854,
0.0377326272,
-0.0409107432,
-0.0331946388,
-0.0230407305,
0.0027980732,
0.0377862751,
0.0151583664,
-0.0404267572,
0.0113712437,
-0.0181422941,
-0.0195202399,
0.0447642058,
-0.0164087862,
0.0381316505,
-0.0141888075,
-0.002271496,
-0.0299521033,
0.0531121306,
0.0102421818,
0.0247267764,
0.0292269681,
0.0907412246,
-0.0605148673,
-0.0274814442,
-0.0355580747,
0.0329566635,
-0.0728819296,
0.0422131419,
0.0141524803,
-0.0364391506,
0.0480606817,
0.0353787243,
-0.0282676965,
0.0308187976,
-0.0034185848,
-0.0479758866,
-0.0223372336,
-0.0014410596,
0.0152984224,
0.0467494689,
0.0113454284,
-0.0686350465,
0.0053858799,
-0.021832766,
0.0034402085,
0.0080356477,
0.0411105864,
0.0062707104,
-0.0241668597,
0.0271352455,
0.0020667315,
-0.01050648,
0.0264098011,
-0.0256936047,
-0.0137039283,
-0.0733292028,
0.0246663261,
0.0149311172,
-0.0823943689,
0.0111955795,
-0.0006768702,
-0.0240411814,
0.0380332172,
-0.0012322878,
0.0196441058,
0.0197603423,
0.0354563259,
0.0049266042,
-0.0039052011,
-0.0657050982,
-0.0300010834,
0.0533515699,
-0.0279025808,
-0.0372083522,
0.0012081033,
-0.0024073781,
0.0218670908,
0.0042268094,
-0.0573762991,
0.0492392629,
0.018972205,
0.0041997782,
0.014666941,
-0.0116158286,
-0.030862147,
-0.0309112221,
-0.024806397,
0.0299257636,
0.0374319889,
-0.0017842242,
0.0352174938,
-0.0368147939,
-0.0341851301,
-0.0209548939,
-0.023489302,
-0.0199260339,
0.0254546888,
0.0319044925,
-0.0211975202,
0.0081312796,
-0.0172217991,
0.018463226,
0.0626444221,
0.0194750167,
0.0159408804,
0.0032832418,
0.00305382,
0.0333488882,
0.0483111404,
-0.0865585729,
0.0341933891,
0.0299657658,
-0.0045792377,
-0.0010709638,
-0.0158670358,
0.0149304001,
-0.0677896291,
-0.0512175113,
-0.0476717502,
0.0018289085,
-0.029029021,
0.078007713,
0.0049882317,
-0.0451130308,
0.0116085,
-0.0003199203,
0.0556965545,
-0.0913576186,
-0.0193225052,
-0.0521740168,
-0.0158478282,
-0.0316614211,
0.0037165242,
0.0085224556,
0.007657947,
-0.0469570644,
-0.0177225731,
-0.0380465463,
-0.042647589,
0.0620355085,
-0.0294714849,
0.0126732439,
-0.0130158626,
-0.0315375961,
-0.0208855141,
-0.0142480917,
0.0000270877,
0.0226581786,
0.0892852098,
-0.0317396671,
-0.0743391663,
0.0269940011,
0.0584632121,
0.0602848791,
0.0049832538,
-0.0185571406,
0.0089067547,
-0.0665575862,
0.0261163451,
0.0134963235,
0.0514205135,
-0.0214762148,
0.0007450935,
0.0330794714,
-0.0154878926,
0.0389210358,
0.0210391078,
0.0061192368,
0.0180182066,
-0.0319322199,
-0.0166464429,
-0.0088533992,
0.0138158584,
0.0013044131,
0.019611109,
0.0784699395,
-0.0165224597,
-0.1001150683,
0.0202684049,
-0.0766447634,
-0.0038981428,
-0.0001770443,
0.0090024211,
-0.0809375048,
0.0479588173,
-0.0107351737,
0.0273697786,
-0.0605230294,
-0.0329749174,
-0.0065521193,
-0.036708694,
0.0319482759,
-0.0049777441,
-0.0567372479,
-0.0183271915,
-0.0106924362,
0.0088875005,
0.0239400435,
0.0216309205,
-0.0424554385,
0.0119676692,
0.0056560496,
-0.0094294818,
-0.1123010442,
-0.0615280047,
0.0283915289,
-0.0314156637,
0.0291535687,
0.0364003666,
0.0278997757,
-0.0634419993,
0.0193582103,
-0.0090166628,
0.0120882243,
-0.0176423099,
-0.0251120571,
0.0522220694,
0.0033310447,
0.0094916746,
-0.049653504,
-0.0067771552,
-0.0219659619,
-0.0061881556,
0.0285584703,
0.045118764,
-0.0174092669,
-0.0046963776,
-0.0764092728,
0.0144572463,
0.0016684061,
0.0246022977,
0.0011773156,
-0.0109171597,
0.0120122023,
-0.0163813513,
0.0438725911,
0.0502927266,
-0.0083899163,
0.0245332494,
-0.0068976921,
-0.0418350063,
0.0004158922,
-0.0389582776,
0.0022840078,
-0.0342005976,
0.0191023089,
0.0269651953,
0.0566903427,
-0.0278219283,
-0.0105306664,
0.0038869765,
0.0145678325,
0.0487994179,
-0.0059894724,
-0.058020018,
-0.0044020354,
0.0116943354,
-0.0208712071,
-0.015467993,
0.0569938198,
0.0088006761,
0.0107647292,
0.0425595827,
0.0252819527,
-0.0260481425,
0.0029065958,
-0.0238620043,
0.0377197675,
0.0607066974,
-0.0056643407,
0.0055807712,
-0.0215482451,
0.0094579794,
-0.0073159775,
-0.0190711375,
-0.0267800502,
0.0063127563,
0.012068972,
0.0184565727,
-0.0265976358,
-0.0424515791,
-0.0199739076,
-0.0078111053,
-0.0062034768,
-0.066879645,
0.0021719381,
0.0009694429,
-0.0263138525,
-0.0254381914,
0.042777773,
-0.0247541685,
-0.0436424054,
0.0262889042,
0.0115706371,
-0.0112374118,
0.0430022739,
-0.026599234,
-0.0321127884,
-0.0783709064,
0.0934651941,
-0.0184687898,
0.0420743525,
0.0127715152,
-0.009751861,
0.0052440562,
-0.0056794183,
-0.0572178178,
0.0248487704,
0.022422336,
0.02804083,
-0.0074097198,
-0.0155168623,
-0.0182474274,
0.0590229891,
-0.068055898,
-0.0717789531,
0.0245421566,
0.0187286623,
0.0278472044,
0.0342041478,
0.0384357274,
-0.0023950734,
0.006510233,
-0.0412287004,
0.0039372174,
-0.0249722172,
0.0555645041,
0.0175660159,
-0.0084244059,
-0.0156926513,
-0.0431801043,
0.0969795957,
0.0377298966,
-0.0020265346,
-0.0361436345,
-0.0207283814,
0.0183336455,
-0.0512993187,
-0.0030886033,
0.0112189483,
-0.0539792441,
0.0243568886,
-0.0813750848,
-0.01771608,
0.0231122375,
-0.0411939733,
-0.0055466481,
-0.0433250181,
-0.0224922895,
0.0359635912,
-0.0024343976,
-0.0470689572,
0.0010642057,
0.0287892111,
-0.0817339197,
-0.0368810147,
0.0523525588,
-6.184301494e-33,
0.0281099975,
-0.0595970303,
0.0021367741,
-0.0552873872,
-0.0237202328,
0.0579725727,
-0.0276053846,
0.0036758143,
-0.0229466725,
0.0380634293,
-0.0345784463,
0.0158372223,
-0.0099660074,
0.0348020345,
0.0607716441,
0.0136859575,
-0.0038291418,
0.0300888158,
-0.0118797729,
0.0060088751,
-0.067005001,
0.0125990296,
0.0256889667,
-0.0685621351,
0.0486262403,
0.0069521209,
0.0461719818,
-0.0016679869,
-0.0009999874,
0.0523268394,
-0.0187686644,
0.0313662067,
0.0362367369,
-0.0718727484,
0.0179357547,
-0.0047167442,
-0.0087834932,
0.0039151497,
0.0121247107,
-0.0163158849,
0.012156724,
-0.0336739197,
0.0424578562,
0.0467773862,
-0.0811240673,
-0.0367407724,
0.0591195263,
-0.0345313549,
-0.0048549841,
-0.0619624853,
-0.023810463,
0.0331922583,
-0.0467579104,
0.056293156,
-0.049586378,
-0.0165037438,
-0.0370865948,
0.0369159505,
-0.0325196981,
-0.0054268753,
0.0206950512,
-0.0075327838,
0.0225028284,
-0.0276907906,
-0.0142108165,
0.0380991548,
0.0224967133,
0.0207534451,
-0.0486975573,
-0.0385146551,
-0.0065195351,
-0.016648706,
0.0491843745,
0.055884365,
0.0081853019,
-0.0191027541,
-0.0783109367,
0.0279507004,
-0.0374499001,
0.0405880623,
0.0678783953,
-0.0176709369,
-0.0634851456,
-0.0426571816,
0.01815648,
-0.0409004726,
0.0191246923,
-0.022839196,
0.0087263044,
-0.0202571042,
-0.0064635659,
0.0374046862,
0.0493895039,
-0.040165849,
-0.0328480043,
0.0179251172,
0.0522476733,
0.0050987173,
-0.0032419437,
0.0011390585,
-0.0862688571,
0.0134168789,
-0.0260056052,
0.0432968736,
0.0519755557,
0.0149680935,
-0.0011881626,
-0.0429529808,
-0.037058048,
-0.02451244,
0.0333106257,
-0.0038392092,
0.0236801617,
0.0356420092,
0.0027425857,
0.0326627865,
0.0381721593,
0.0256080832,
0.050809864,
0.030746147,
-0.0423660241,
-0.0128788445,
-0.0433357246,
0.0110395774,
-0.0527208783,
-0.0032413893,
-0.0329089276,
0.0395114943,
0.0405505374,
-0.0406862088,
-0.0105331428,
-0.0745465457,
2.905e-7,
0.0805171803,
0.0153165907,
-0.0442643091,
-0.0456325039,
0.0387754776,
0.0104417633,
0.0119027514,
0.0112589477,
0.0077063488,
0.0003305774,
0.0299801305,
0.0268378463,
0.0162029974,
0.0126650995,
-0.0275922827,
0.007933015,
-0.1164716855,
0.0068364283,
-0.046744585,
0.0101965992,
-0.0447839685,
0.0240886491,
-0.0263991617,
-0.0228754003,
-0.0349137187,
0.0059514078,
-0.0024584732,
-0.0661255717,
0.032889314,
0.0408715717,
0.003921574,
-0.0121792778,
0.0417407304,
0.0191863254,
-0.0047682356,
0.0184470098,
0.0055049425,
0.0192713663,
-0.0464980677,
0.0628658906,
0.0581961349,
-0.0017446054,
0.0112401638,
-0.0700081661,
0.02408465,
0.0078681447,
-0.0714428276,
-0.0631002486,
0.0005234866,
-0.0144170448,
0.1198422238,
-0.016640855,
-0.021185426,
0.0276499633,
0.023891313,
-0.004891044,
-0.0018413174,
-0.0022032473,
0.0045794309,
0.0061741793,
-0.0251336433,
-0.060419891,
0.0163496807,
0.0070920982,
-0.0070131398,
-0.0127978241,
0.0410417579,
2.633673741e-34,
0.027830936,
0.0075686886,
0.0031301556,
0.0331413262,
0.0365571752,
-0.003262646,
-0.0099655148,
0.0085963113,
-0.0031196293,
-0.0084531838,
-0.0027867923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13144v1 | DialSim: A Real-Time Simulator for Evaluating Long-Term Dialogue Understanding of Conversational Agents | 2024-06-19T01:37:10 | 2024-06-19T01:37:10 | Jiho Kim, Woosog Chay, Hyeonji Hwang, Daeun Kyung, Hyunseung Chung, Eunbyeol Cho, Yohan Jo, Edward Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced the capabilities of conversational agents, making them applicable to
various fields (e.g., education). Despite their progress, the evaluation of the
agents often overlooks the complexities of real-world conversations, such as
real-time interactions, multi-party dialogues, and extended contextual
dependencies. To bridge this gap, we introduce DialSim, a real-time dialogue
simulator. In this simulator, an agent is assigned the role of a character from
popular TV shows, requiring it to respond to spontaneous questions using past
dialogue information and to distinguish between known and unknown information.
Key features of DialSim include evaluating the agent's ability to respond
within a reasonable time limit, handling long-term multi-party dialogues, and
managing adversarial settings (e.g., swap character names) to challenge the
agent's reliance on pre-trained knowledge. We utilized this simulator to
evaluate the latest conversational agents and analyze their limitations. Our
experiments highlight both the strengths and weaknesses of these agents,
providing valuable insights for future improvements in the field of
conversational AI. DialSim is available at
https://github.com/jiho283/Simulator. | [
0.0557189323,
0.0439249687,
-0.0333189256,
0.0325075425,
-0.0182697084,
0.0020544026,
0.0336336158,
-0.0115892543,
0.0228800382,
-0.0264031943,
-0.0161133613,
-0.0351345316,
-0.0269030128,
0.0566741563,
-0.0043310905,
-0.0587688535,
0.0418040082,
-0.0545659922,
0.0518897697,
-0.0002747524,
0.0138332807,
-0.0080156112,
-0.0418042243,
0.0371826403,
-0.0109189162,
-0.0369230583,
-0.0595506653,
-0.0263579879,
0.0097521162,
-0.0158715509,
0.017997114,
0.0579819158,
0.0432366207,
0.0332296118,
0.0000020061,
-0.0404181145,
0.0216443818,
-0.0408607014,
-0.0547686331,
0.0203816481,
0.0405973867,
0.0314974412,
-0.0102608558,
0.008426236,
-0.0613459498,
0.0155803394,
0.0116643328,
0.0409553722,
0.0712445453,
0.0632335097,
-0.0029606384,
-0.0114196995,
0.0037989975,
-0.0231889933,
-0.0058044707,
-0.1024855226,
0.0073782383,
0.0165099632,
0.0344371125,
-0.0123366043,
-0.0145592149,
0.0246741045,
0.032385163,
-0.0511987098,
-0.013018677,
0.0346897207,
-0.041621495,
-0.0169207118,
-0.0211148076,
0.1044405177,
0.0175262038,
0.0076419832,
-0.0028016102,
0.0064239446,
0.014920976,
-0.0298833121,
-0.0387455486,
-0.0113866366,
0.0029930957,
-0.0228653941,
-0.0367310867,
0.0222356655,
-0.0129899094,
0.0005611512,
-0.01166235,
0.0289623011,
0.0105238184,
-0.0112535832,
-0.0322996266,
-0.0166710541,
0.0326040126,
-0.1032742783,
0.0019604315,
0.0744593218,
-0.0862827525,
0.0345238224,
-0.0466397144,
0.0215182696,
0.0199113712,
-0.0608246475,
-0.0249117259,
0.0378930308,
-0.0040470767,
0.0398928709,
0.0308847744,
0.0640041679,
0.0193650723,
0.0103402985,
0.0079399431,
0.0191651285,
-0.0355447605,
-0.024666436,
-0.0427448936,
0.0030730935,
-0.0355059057,
-0.0399490558,
0.0026950198,
0.046252504,
-0.0191418212,
0.0563707016,
-0.0398211069,
0.0162807684,
-0.0233341288,
0.0103753097,
-0.0717284307,
0.0261962879,
-0.049367018,
-0.0017292255,
0.0125645557,
-0.079574272,
-0.0161945242,
0.0142113827,
-0.0158887729,
-0.0013332933,
-0.0023223069,
0.0688672587,
-0.0263496749,
-0.0323592946,
0.0154805025,
0.0088494606,
-0.0327097848,
-0.0842566192,
-0.004833532,
-0.0264939796,
0.025805939,
-0.0124158608,
-0.0188047551,
-0.031548135,
0.0284605529,
0.0045128884,
0.0112100691,
0.073510319,
0.0397367589,
0.0068056062,
0.0391120017,
0.0393386707,
-0.0189064965,
0.0494382083,
0.0314832963,
0.0129994657,
0.0367945284,
-0.0128832869,
0.0557069033,
0.0357552134,
0.011362033,
0.0102780759,
-0.0053445767,
0.0427058712,
-0.0029265168,
0.0619596653,
0.0042035021,
0.0299113337,
-0.0241688583,
-0.0277310237,
0.061787419,
0.0304549094,
-0.0228365306,
0.0105984239,
0.0364032537,
0.059018828,
0.0437832959,
0.0152048757,
-0.0481240004,
0.0364321172,
0.0123893144,
-0.0135205127,
-0.0271057636,
0.0235398114,
-0.0271278825,
-0.0227829311,
0.0463593528,
-0.0043552043,
0.0310345106,
0.0192817617,
0.0142153651,
-0.0053614983,
-0.0639723986,
0.0226145927,
0.0041483636,
-0.0394372083,
-0.0330167376,
-0.0618575551,
0.0417914279,
0.1042722985,
0.0555227697,
-0.0302369501,
-0.064724423,
-0.0163802095,
0.0151878037,
0.0441216864,
0.0362991467,
-0.0258025508,
0.0425375625,
-0.0347557291,
0.0229099672,
-0.0288030989,
-0.0007288677,
0.0801608711,
0.0054925405,
0.0188667998,
-0.0160271768,
0.0216723792,
0.0108135138,
0.015715437,
-0.0652425438,
-0.021728443,
-0.0408414565,
0.0000913742,
0.0177920684,
-0.0183274746,
-0.0185496379,
-0.0271935854,
0.0300464407,
0.0072945282,
-0.0034802402,
0.0403299369,
-0.0729849711,
-0.0388822481,
0.0407793112,
-0.0123354727,
-0.0560367294,
0.0388929844,
-0.0108892033,
-0.0343775451,
0.0392491147,
-0.0189839918,
0.0299584772,
-0.0394068286,
0.0284129865,
-0.0045215595,
0.0391034186,
-0.0214606375,
0.0311208051,
0.0290951803,
-0.0209556445,
0.0467201695,
0.0654317141,
-0.0097971354,
-0.0668578371,
0.0070359064,
0.0387304649,
-0.0013265982,
-0.0017426308,
0.0031524925,
-0.0067056622,
-0.0655626878,
-0.0429748073,
-0.091077961,
0.0083988681,
0.001668906,
-0.0289751105,
-0.007287425,
0.0021281592,
-0.0297254696,
-0.016109731,
-0.0464072227,
0.0261223167,
0.0317719057,
-0.0356020294,
0.0276832469,
0.0092105558,
-0.0503290333,
-0.0474166311,
0.0429351106,
0.0035780722,
0.0230261087,
0.0077211368,
0.0029750667,
0.0082329037,
-0.0068099834,
-0.0097979642,
0.0695460886,
-0.0341792181,
-0.0546074919,
0.0276713613,
0.0051200087,
0.0135657573,
0.04451124,
0.0539879501,
0.0410386287,
0.0146035459,
-0.0705059469,
-0.052723486,
0.0686076134,
0.0072140219,
-0.0185117796,
-0.0773947835,
0.00344583,
-0.0300751943,
0.063638337,
-0.0127052376,
0.0304697845,
-0.028155731,
0.0304741189,
0.0384532027,
-0.0684906766,
-0.0059154476,
-0.0212146342,
-0.0495174341,
0.0073352903,
-0.0223697573,
0.0133020617,
0.0729258955,
-0.0458036959,
-0.0397682227,
-0.0367402509,
0.0003928154,
-0.0100990636,
0.0935877413,
-0.0136052258,
-0.0029040142,
0.0048907883,
-0.0275638606,
-0.0289845821,
-0.0097332168,
0.0052683568,
-0.0367388725,
0.0325515047,
-0.0423208624,
0.0044418033,
0.0064104302,
0.0122943688,
-0.0779767707,
-0.0405032001,
-0.051305484,
-0.0107239764,
0.0026935146,
-0.026763605,
-0.042969875,
0.0142911337,
0.0030891888,
0.0181926377,
-0.0135997571,
0.0050727408,
-0.020685114,
0.0116801709,
0.048597455,
0.0290657599,
-0.0155449789,
-0.019280076,
0.1290208101,
0.04244297,
0.0225405991,
0.0077316109,
-0.0374365076,
-0.0243074354,
-0.0043258434,
-0.0061146538,
0.0213135555,
0.0085247429,
0.0467628837,
-0.0661286488,
-0.0280747656,
0.1257174164,
0.0157762431,
-0.0360386707,
0.0127368663,
-0.0378056318,
0.0000505465,
0.0031825299,
0.0372187793,
-0.0771183893,
-0.0241608582,
0.0112653654,
0.0073795496,
-0.0196315516,
-0.0565322973,
-0.0153668215,
-0.1042470783,
0.0265498757,
-0.0133577092,
-0.0409188084,
0.0195287615,
0.003603461,
0.0046399683,
0.0073912824,
0.0477912501,
0.0018073524,
0.0312756039,
-0.0219249632,
-0.0175228585,
-0.0117654586,
0.0094494903,
0.0769837648,
-0.0154248886,
0.1040696874,
0.040348269,
0.0666807666,
0.008459433,
0.0038272841,
-0.0019594654,
0.0189767517,
-0.0057388614,
0.034305919,
0.0394546315,
-0.0378268324,
-0.0072072633,
-0.0181381423,
0.0220800657,
-0.001996604,
-0.0134500097,
0.0625310168,
0.0156975389,
-0.0547005124,
-0.0152782388,
-0.0202563442,
0.0475095436,
0.06108303,
0.0686568916,
0.0323284902,
-0.0508514941,
-0.0377036855,
-0.0003641843,
-0.0142625235,
-0.0475955196,
-0.0135756982,
-0.0149137611,
0.0143438168,
-0.0056352071,
-0.0311972704,
-0.0714401975,
0.0331909098,
0.0063472395,
-0.0140470471,
-0.0242519472,
-0.002268834,
0.0327072814,
0.0184423048,
-0.0052040205,
-0.0286586694,
0.037975885,
-0.0185580086,
-0.0241597928,
0.0465703346,
-0.0436925106,
-0.0176091008,
0.0234324113,
-0.0825895965,
-0.0439198352,
0.0255526528,
0.0512372516,
0.0288302898,
0.0690895915,
-0.0408426635,
-0.0039374032,
-0.0059141899,
-0.0063135833,
-0.0512517951,
0.0286971163,
0.0136944083,
0.0253228936,
-0.0046763434,
0.0272464491,
-0.0198721569,
0.0424768664,
-0.0390509441,
0.007750534,
-0.0772760883,
-0.0786532834,
-0.00189033,
0.0078731813,
0.0173445269,
0.0330781117,
-0.0259977747,
-0.0134754367,
0.0281389095,
-0.051731132,
-0.0014211995,
-0.0311026759,
-0.0256931186,
-0.0063105272,
-0.0046935873,
0.0433636717,
-0.0387690142,
-0.0473897755,
0.0000508053,
0.0324469879,
0.0030661556,
0.0450718626,
0.0021816855,
0.0083585083,
-0.0009851117,
-0.0088325497,
0.0362150893,
0.0142635675,
0.0466915593,
0.0239134952,
0.0860832632,
0.0090797665,
-0.0445892811,
0.0513949916,
0.0292767342,
-0.0761207491,
-0.0583606996,
0.0121231005,
0.0716329366,
0.0066839731,
0.0286427885,
0.0189413242,
-0.0348724909,
0.0306054763,
-0.0021490778,
0.0115526067,
0.0011872392,
-0.0595671535,
0.0194282178,
0.0249510277,
-0.0147685679,
0.0394525155,
0.0501327701,
0.0134860165,
0.0550985336,
0.0134945912,
0.0273685623,
-0.0569107197,
-0.0307677649,
0.0052684234,
0.0139819197,
-0.0108594187,
0.012834237,
-0.0517485924,
-0.031806048,
-0.0000144144,
0.0148251057,
-0.0181152392,
-0.0373991653,
0.0007409398,
0.0340016671,
0.0087533472,
0.0171557963,
-0.025748102,
0.0354479961,
-0.0298722479,
-0.0331073925,
-0.0006830223,
-5.749469236e-33,
-0.0606286041,
-0.0404097326,
0.0377684012,
-0.0182062853,
-0.0666483268,
-0.0059388462,
-0.0758231133,
-0.0081570297,
-0.0244428366,
-0.005709474,
-0.025711963,
0.0412339233,
-0.0004249757,
0.0264927503,
-0.02651917,
-0.0614350438,
0.0367316268,
0.0174842943,
-0.0273726135,
0.0433048308,
0.0319063328,
0.0165217388,
-0.0055962969,
-0.0536685847,
0.0160631295,
-0.0352406241,
-0.0207335558,
0.0223610252,
-0.0075311325,
0.0566646978,
-0.0293089896,
0.0020262219,
-0.0042481432,
-0.0414172933,
0.003704261,
0.0414200649,
-0.043657776,
-0.0131748402,
0.0018291557,
0.0192352477,
-0.0255083721,
-0.0318330713,
-0.0052165878,
0.0036114249,
0.0029390324,
0.0090748221,
0.0171771664,
-0.0211505219,
0.0120749203,
0.0464211665,
-0.083702296,
0.0118618729,
-0.0518677868,
-0.0740567446,
-0.0187475998,
0.0481263213,
0.0109828226,
-0.0384267345,
-0.0349310301,
0.0156563073,
0.0149603393,
-0.0241800882,
0.0463475287,
0.035901282,
0.014694849,
0.0850730836,
0.0670249835,
0.0100466087,
-0.0416219756,
-0.0471151657,
0.0140068568,
0.0318145268,
0.0191223994,
0.0622496679,
-0.0331672505,
-0.0276802927,
-0.017266674,
0.0160081275,
0.0563849993,
0.0463874936,
0.0173643641,
0.0104272198,
-0.0328450873,
0.0023707405,
-0.0318104848,
0.0035998721,
0.0000494527,
-0.0536635295,
0.0451485068,
0.0048572933,
-0.012699008,
-0.0264755134,
0.0324445851,
-0.0377868377,
0.0330130421,
0.0086667165,
-0.0082528265,
0.0049153771,
-0.0082122851,
0.0449797213,
-0.0240354389,
0.0069357702,
0.0588408411,
0.0019786495,
0.0244325027,
0.0355258361,
-0.0204312727,
0.0247862246,
-0.0097420504,
-0.0218014866,
-0.0150362551,
0.054967422,
-0.0012399835,
0.036670316,
-0.0041862591,
-0.0135641564,
-0.0347176865,
0.0371369533,
-0.0101349177,
-0.0171692315,
-0.0347156413,
-0.033832062,
0.0147582097,
0.0047461567,
-0.0614472181,
-0.0096392622,
-0.0558084808,
-0.009626234,
0.0155101446,
-0.0739390403,
0.0086079296,
-0.0252098665,
2.691e-7,
-0.0297871567,
0.0370376334,
0.0412610248,
-0.0022079791,
0.0335287526,
0.0452066027,
-0.018823212,
0.0506461523,
0.0133059481,
-0.0333731845,
0.0163401645,
0.0472559445,
0.0515296236,
0.0300914571,
-0.0737634003,
-0.0463079959,
-0.0547151752,
-0.0219863951,
-0.0484141111,
-0.0179167166,
0.0448359475,
0.0641425028,
0.0241682436,
0.0051271901,
0.0047701765,
-0.0513013229,
0.0264992788,
-0.0262115914,
-0.0315324552,
0.0188705679,
0.0161564946,
-0.0075575528,
-0.0052996692,
0.0246989671,
0.019774409,
0.0157572832,
-0.0245629121,
0.0695474446,
-0.019537691,
-0.0505198762,
-0.016345365,
0.0005772334,
0.0021673869,
-0.0411579832,
0.0685780793,
-0.0399568267,
-0.0347651877,
-0.0291526411,
-0.0327560902,
-0.0235440545,
-0.0261641666,
0.0038339144,
-0.0125112031,
0.0087018162,
-0.0203497764,
-0.0207998473,
0.02642202,
-0.066963084,
0.0009050382,
-0.0260746181,
-0.0531898588,
-0.0585844778,
-0.0337090455,
-0.0290120468,
0.0463377312,
-0.0390299596,
0.0319128148,
1.92851167e-34,
0.0404529646,
0.0315420665,
-0.0172342397,
0.0580754168,
0.0408272706,
0.0066489279,
0.0450095199,
0.0088004461,
0.0511225685,
-0.0713465288,
-0.0241580736
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13138v1 | Large Language Models are Biased Because They Are Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T01:08:03 | 2024-06-19T01:08:03 | Philip Resnik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper's primary goal is to provoke thoughtful discussion about the
relationship between bias and fundamental properties of large language models.
We do this by seeking to convince the reader that harmful biases are an
inevitable consequence arising from the design of any large language model as
LLMs are currently formulated. To the extent that this is true, it suggests
that the problem of harmful bias cannot be properly addressed without a serious
reconsideration of AI driven by LLMs, going back to the foundational
assumptions underlying their design. | [
0.0200172681,
0.0621045157,
-0.0410715081,
0.0655670539,
-0.0402895287,
0.017058406,
0.0267463755,
0.0162895937,
0.0287852045,
-0.0569932424,
-0.0422467366,
-0.0299108922,
0.0003813641,
0.0074270358,
0.022201214,
-0.037637379,
0.0271172151,
-0.0379821658,
0.0320080109,
-0.0469412915,
-0.0081158392,
-0.0100607974,
0.0267667361,
0.020263046,
-0.0037725947,
0.0150849102,
0.0365954041,
-0.0076829884,
-0.0331500806,
0.0032324996,
-0.0312140491,
-0.0106470101,
0.0001044113,
0.0333202854,
0.0000017272,
-0.0611345954,
0.019624006,
-0.0093732076,
-0.0297971591,
0.0048107663,
0.0507932156,
0.0010031037,
-0.0142725827,
0.0114709437,
-0.0267822426,
0.0138422232,
0.0542778857,
0.0231956486,
0.0089225862,
0.0846627653,
0.0098019261,
-0.0477746353,
0.0139435129,
-0.0177960545,
0.0166452266,
-0.0494459495,
0.0546282753,
-0.0126824994,
0.017069824,
-0.0073452601,
-0.0334952027,
0.0266904458,
0.0129207047,
0.0040373774,
-0.015211598,
0.0260746107,
-0.0081724487,
-0.0255134962,
-0.0027188957,
0.0465308726,
-0.0270827357,
-0.0200346354,
0.0078692837,
-0.0164676327,
0.0274222344,
-0.0136885624,
-0.039078299,
0.0879653171,
0.0138050197,
0.0238125212,
0.0656820387,
-0.0016780691,
0.0584259816,
0.0350718759,
-0.0515356027,
0.0798943117,
0.0308357906,
-0.0251455903,
0.002274124,
0.0464722738,
0.0358479172,
-0.0703066438,
-0.0337952822,
0.0315665305,
-0.0394111462,
0.0433868207,
-0.0187127963,
0.0476235449,
0.0021278891,
-0.0557934195,
0.0388049409,
0.0052919011,
-0.0119755026,
0.0223644599,
-0.0158695728,
0.0076481882,
-0.0298787169,
0.0131860897,
-0.0382679366,
-0.0127355587,
0.0263995863,
-0.0026245648,
-0.0049685156,
0.0281771254,
0.0016555417,
0.0217326507,
-0.0159581359,
0.0287180357,
-0.0193465278,
0.0246472675,
-0.0002580196,
-0.0192546807,
-0.0186589323,
-0.036441382,
-0.0339853875,
0.0156038785,
-0.0097995363,
0.041866459,
-0.0417158008,
-0.0943989232,
0.0147011001,
0.0358865745,
-0.0277313311,
-0.0534799285,
-0.0020868888,
0.1201846227,
0.0404480696,
-0.030698657,
-0.0454043299,
-0.0101087242,
-0.0155469952,
-0.0605131239,
-0.0127892299,
-0.0366011299,
0.0044727502,
0.0247916896,
0.0086952141,
-0.0568414591,
-0.0159714185,
-0.0082283551,
-0.0753774717,
0.0416041687,
-0.0262856632,
0.0194106475,
0.0318437926,
-0.0022913504,
0.0131199146,
0.081634365,
0.0510608219,
0.0279272776,
0.0295507219,
-0.0065900371,
0.0343212709,
0.0592309572,
-0.0274666268,
0.0213049278,
-0.0563353859,
0.0058358931,
-0.0327907577,
0.0260572322,
0.0267644059,
0.088112779,
-0.0030102103,
0.0175082367,
0.0711242631,
0.0161449108,
0.015907431,
0.0289183073,
0.0184327457,
-0.0376597866,
-0.0061066877,
0.0295593888,
-0.0598421916,
0.0117886364,
-0.0278032105,
-0.0118711432,
-0.0060685151,
0.0269136745,
-0.0304016732,
-0.0460893624,
-0.019647371,
-0.0101253251,
-0.0093652317,
0.0247649532,
0.0381499715,
-0.0220107101,
0.0007621722,
0.0692612976,
0.0325378813,
-0.0181981605,
0.0241432395,
-0.0882636085,
0.023886105,
0.0221542791,
0.0110834166,
-0.0305354912,
-0.0107204672,
0.0075534866,
-0.0040036994,
0.0652691051,
0.0765293464,
-0.0155745223,
-0.0146970861,
-0.0495712049,
-0.0097557008,
0.0062957085,
0.0301589817,
0.0161596686,
-0.0223691445,
0.0286828484,
-0.0136363851,
-0.0392899588,
-0.062041454,
0.0325954743,
-0.0108843734,
-0.0521229655,
-0.0207427666,
-0.0015320202,
0.0265740585,
0.0103107253,
-0.0448970795,
0.0115848202,
0.0124911703,
-0.0263063647,
-0.0001311214,
-0.0228704028,
-0.0102393935,
0.0300324205,
0.0516257882,
-0.0404670238,
-0.0033703658,
0.0070872214,
-0.0287187118,
-0.0072602252,
0.0461969823,
-0.035134498,
0.0689456016,
0.0099448618,
0.0541335866,
-0.0582292676,
0.0002732495,
-0.0626390055,
0.0484976582,
-0.0086761052,
-0.0058721476,
0.0263555236,
-0.0012234738,
0.0279474966,
-0.0338306613,
-0.0251579564,
0.0554841757,
0.0336048678,
0.0331728719,
0.0570328832,
-0.0081753246,
-0.008029459,
-0.0655778348,
-0.0257534645,
-0.0256465059,
-0.0123037659,
-0.0144118844,
-0.0058977478,
0.0054289708,
-0.0193050392,
0.0084333736,
-0.0393534601,
0.0013371619,
0.0226538293,
0.0325574242,
0.0398142673,
-0.0034573148,
-0.0489697829,
-0.0346103534,
-0.0035842112,
-0.0108578391,
0.0173617341,
0.0120763816,
-0.0290380642,
-0.1084289625,
0.0487289801,
-0.0181830581,
0.0084449155,
0.0050105695,
-0.005120032,
0.0156806614,
-0.0183896478,
-0.0113028195,
0.0904468819,
-0.0035834375,
0.0388590619,
0.0882247835,
0.005211236,
-0.0570821911,
-0.0209910441,
0.000691615,
-0.0490054525,
-0.0554864816,
-0.0474297367,
0.0112492535,
0.0515065305,
0.0032866795,
-0.0118314903,
-0.0200638827,
0.0592572019,
-0.0476438217,
-0.0456576422,
0.0319208428,
-0.0365229733,
-0.0299769975,
0.0375210121,
-0.0207561124,
-0.0778450221,
0.0252586566,
-0.006040215,
0.0341881812,
-0.0235317498,
-0.0109900646,
-0.0710571259,
0.0332024805,
0.0043452964,
0.0309250411,
-0.010348849,
-0.0252934098,
-0.0698498487,
-0.0248946641,
-0.0058063674,
-0.0177899562,
0.0651027709,
-0.0464117862,
0.0253726225,
-0.0188319925,
-0.0551494695,
-0.0446941964,
-0.0164771695,
-0.0637908131,
-0.0003341168,
0.0163837336,
-0.0146856969,
-0.0415622406,
-0.0281092152,
0.0325478986,
-0.0159924794,
-0.0012757932,
0.0056166635,
-0.0021107404,
-0.0116050942,
0.0473090895,
-0.0108391298,
0.0652472451,
-0.0222993698,
0.0232705064,
0.0216785464,
0.0125351949,
0.0477884524,
-0.0206584223,
0.0023908368,
0.0553666428,
-0.0531670749,
-0.0340588614,
0.0168048665,
0.0388688557,
-0.0224482156,
0.0098262941,
0.120929651,
-0.0086226063,
-0.051527448,
0.0356278345,
0.0116435625,
-0.0112600839,
0.0396386459,
0.0117032453,
-0.0868237615,
0.0019595828,
0.012640127,
-0.0103464443,
-0.0319898725,
-0.0312608927,
-0.0264357049,
-0.1164063737,
0.0299407188,
0.033204142,
0.0036467109,
-0.0342112929,
-0.0027301081,
-0.0142965773,
-0.0238219257,
0.0647202134,
0.0114578092,
-0.0146009075,
-0.025152633,
0.0194155201,
-0.0196577348,
-0.0400445014,
-0.0202654973,
-0.0565523803,
0.0806382522,
0.0498437472,
0.0436091088,
-0.061807368,
-0.0018045707,
0.0706656203,
0.0134527571,
-0.0055517307,
-0.0112723392,
0.016179705,
-0.0060942839,
-0.0343976878,
-0.0107216844,
0.0016959445,
-0.002775365,
0.0339396335,
0.0217867736,
0.0580884293,
-0.0430850312,
-0.0744786263,
-0.0078767138,
-0.057838209,
-0.0034788421,
0.0686907619,
0.0050919838,
-0.0583458357,
-0.0122280708,
-0.06244554,
-0.0461818837,
0.040895965,
-0.0707537234,
0.0351156071,
-0.0042860569,
-0.0076546026,
-0.0349287502,
-0.041417703,
0.0045071654,
0.0185045581,
0.0516905226,
0.0157968458,
-0.0155723738,
-0.0273372419,
0.0332729444,
0.0025816599,
-0.0583189353,
0.0203541126,
-0.0434551686,
0.0041798605,
0.0187595673,
-0.0402830802,
0.0194815006,
-0.0120605249,
-0.053246513,
-0.0803106353,
0.0245657992,
0.0431146063,
0.0342106782,
0.0245214738,
-0.0084796697,
-0.1000700071,
0.0664122328,
0.0191361178,
-0.0026384506,
0.0474075936,
0.0065701739,
0.0038513425,
0.0167804975,
0.0610073283,
-0.0656670332,
0.0122519853,
0.0557715148,
0.0085723437,
-0.0483979844,
-0.0544221438,
0.0012620082,
0.0389975496,
0.0135979261,
-0.0310024042,
0.0522177443,
-0.0124871628,
0.0030772032,
-0.0293710921,
-0.0342769809,
-0.0067062364,
0.0002257829,
0.0279781725,
0.0427670479,
-0.036825031,
-0.0192642212,
-0.0231673252,
0.0080957571,
-0.0097931102,
0.0658074319,
-0.0129286079,
0.0300742332,
0.0484258421,
0.0189472791,
-0.0149084898,
0.0738925412,
-0.0214990396,
0.060477268,
0.0436594039,
0.0041254563,
0.0322453603,
0.0081794215,
-0.0341878086,
0.0142670451,
-0.0668614209,
-0.1015407592,
0.0307760891,
0.0321587324,
0.067155391,
-0.0252428018,
0.0479969122,
-0.0303635951,
0.0037196341,
-0.0075338343,
-0.034372326,
0.0436597243,
-0.0246795379,
0.0269904565,
-0.0040089972,
-0.0413118526,
0.0186215341,
0.0507390164,
0.0095126722,
0.0736978576,
-0.0223306976,
0.0040951176,
-0.0259835813,
-0.0449004695,
0.002838888,
-0.0305139516,
-0.0191247035,
-0.0170855578,
-0.0749186128,
-0.0694224164,
0.0078128763,
0.0042257588,
0.0190242957,
-0.0448216759,
-0.0124566052,
0.0334451273,
0.0036271291,
0.002312371,
-0.0313338339,
-0.0085941907,
-0.0247088987,
-0.0174404923,
-0.0015999316,
-5.661771112e-33,
-0.0019452457,
-0.0141612524,
0.0192705486,
-0.0042270538,
-0.0048123379,
-0.0066053574,
-0.0020944634,
0.0257432796,
-0.070724763,
0.0076293512,
-0.0182169341,
0.0000428002,
0.0116574243,
-0.0145205688,
0.0358538069,
-0.0111159617,
0.0363431498,
-0.0051028691,
-0.0006751638,
-0.0147669762,
-0.0226001311,
-0.0105116535,
0.0352303609,
-0.0572480299,
0.0378452316,
0.0006726352,
-0.0233806837,
0.0265492238,
-0.0099348715,
0.0292304419,
-0.022370005,
0.0637655333,
0.016573308,
-0.0155938948,
-0.0139852008,
0.0109686498,
0.0366700925,
-0.0232574251,
0.0412548929,
0.0447971262,
0.0454393364,
-0.0602598153,
0.0441091731,
-0.0013586339,
-0.0894628093,
0.0218180679,
0.0103101153,
-0.0424888059,
-0.0041860025,
0.0208990835,
-0.0640396103,
0.0273917913,
0.0090427501,
0.041098956,
0.0039828918,
-0.0532831252,
-0.0009984078,
0.026670415,
-0.0094680069,
0.0211825594,
0.0332108811,
0.0156043451,
0.0634516776,
0.0201312453,
-0.0014417886,
0.0657388046,
0.0856739357,
0.0466872603,
-0.0288153458,
-0.0393725745,
-0.0015349225,
0.0181034133,
0.0245890208,
0.0471250825,
-0.0069502164,
0.0182308797,
-0.0692528561,
-0.014028281,
0.0259925108,
0.0404473916,
0.0217937678,
0.0060921917,
-0.0729065984,
-0.0466959439,
-0.037515711,
-0.053030666,
-0.0281875283,
-0.003942484,
0.0207943805,
0.002232831,
0.0338952094,
-0.0085304733,
0.0287001077,
-0.0761695728,
-0.0325182118,
0.002924853,
-0.0058558579,
-0.007279072,
-0.0042220899,
0.0076462934,
-0.0587979481,
-0.0374157056,
-0.0442691781,
0.0139426542,
0.0084233452,
0.0315996818,
-0.0120717688,
0.0284969863,
-0.0497607291,
-0.0106750345,
-0.0410305448,
-0.0200831685,
0.0620447099,
0.0143854236,
0.047602348,
-0.0193215013,
0.0185702778,
0.0280394685,
0.017261399,
-0.0112057813,
0.0018867636,
0.0178039297,
-0.0081085162,
0.0375567973,
-0.0565732755,
-0.0083380248,
-0.0104883183,
0.0657754615,
0.0420988016,
-0.0708981305,
-0.0182918124,
-0.0366579741,
2.444e-7,
0.0279332772,
0.0522329807,
0.0093958806,
0.0469724201,
0.0088923872,
0.022766443,
-0.0178362392,
0.0368782319,
-0.0254761223,
0.0190949403,
-0.0034662238,
0.0374708436,
0.0264316164,
0.0078283083,
-0.0770442337,
0.0335253701,
-0.0435192399,
0.0307832137,
-0.060154587,
0.0025221156,
0.0067208009,
0.0856814682,
0.0136892591,
-0.0249984227,
-0.0315170996,
-0.0561090074,
0.0244806837,
-0.0477758683,
0.0220573749,
0.0530741215,
0.0456080213,
0.0227781255,
-0.0001984582,
0.0049463841,
0.0298915263,
0.0271770917,
-0.0172635522,
0.0467099734,
-0.0177823547,
0.0054654507,
-0.0098035736,
-0.057622727,
-0.0135314008,
-0.0420342684,
0.0681383237,
0.0207586102,
-0.0373410955,
-0.065205507,
0.0204591583,
-0.0087519316,
0.0165061485,
-0.0160667486,
-0.0106438585,
0.0068728873,
0.0212847646,
-0.0168683976,
0.0076748035,
-0.0674802512,
-0.0275546238,
-0.0073111667,
-0.0283890236,
-0.0828692317,
0.0066355513,
0.0598074831,
0.0250215847,
-0.015255061,
0.0242646895,
1.78817957e-34,
0.0271869898,
-0.0320633836,
0.0337947793,
0.0282268003,
0.024696026,
0.0274664219,
-0.040315073,
0.0040360759,
0.0328961238,
-0.0719239786,
-0.0031149562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13133v1 | PathoLM: Identifying pathogenicity from the DNA sequence through the Genome Foundation Model | 2024-06-19T00:53:48 | 2024-06-19T00:53:48 | Sajib Acharjee Dip, Uddip Acharjee Shuvo, Tran Chau, Haoqiu Song, Petra Choi, Xuan Wang, Liqing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.GN | Pathogen identification is pivotal in diagnosing, treating, and preventing
diseases, crucial for controlling infections and safeguarding public health.
Traditional alignment-based methods, though widely used, are computationally
intense and reliant on extensive reference databases, often failing to detect
novel pathogens due to their low sensitivity and specificity. Similarly,
conventional machine learning techniques, while promising, require large
annotated datasets and extensive feature engineering and are prone to
overfitting. Addressing these challenges, we introduce PathoLM, a cutting-edge
pathogen language model optimized for the identification of pathogenicity in
bacterial and viral sequences. Leveraging the strengths of pre-trained DNA
models such as the Nucleotide Transformer, PathoLM requires minimal data for
fine-tuning, thereby enhancing pathogen detection capabilities. It effectively
captures a broader genomic context, significantly improving the identification
of novel and divergent pathogens. We developed a comprehensive data set
comprising approximately 30 species of viruses and bacteria, including ESKAPEE
pathogens, seven notably virulent bacterial strains resistant to antibiotics.
Additionally, we curated a species classification dataset centered specifically
on the ESKAPEE group. In comparative assessments, PathoLM dramatically
outperforms existing models like DciPatho, demonstrating robust zero-shot and
few-shot capabilities. Furthermore, we expanded PathoLM-Sp for ESKAPEE species
classification, where it showed superior performance compared to other advanced
deep learning methods, despite the complexities of the task. | [
-0.0143755944,
0.0763914436,
-0.0167424958,
-0.0256717093,
0.0106293354,
-0.0033984953,
0.0235823244,
-0.0040822118,
-0.0029332398,
-0.001704334,
-0.0096053993,
-0.0002592009,
0.0588980168,
0.0720636547,
0.0493360721,
0.0088633196,
0.0596223213,
-0.0009737985,
0.0140759554,
0.0344731063,
-0.0304065254,
-0.0134505229,
0.0011524664,
0.0303875227,
-0.0123975128,
-0.0018277863,
-0.0109487902,
0.0209227391,
0.0876891166,
-0.0654263869,
0.0233129933,
0.018348014,
-0.0113406535,
0.0343025774,
0.0000022446,
0.0041802283,
-0.0215336587,
-0.0320432968,
-0.0263629258,
0.0018709005,
-0.0175096579,
-0.0445282161,
0.019278815,
-0.0105376756,
-0.0289675985,
-0.0417502448,
0.11549218,
0.0327674635,
0.0245396737,
0.1057437435,
0.0112721678,
-0.0412544683,
0.0293940399,
-0.0186941382,
-0.0024823586,
0.0036537116,
0.0482919179,
-0.0110588912,
-0.0006963729,
-0.0166490823,
-0.0185316168,
0.0309627708,
0.0037775193,
-0.0349691659,
-0.0064173751,
0.0083243977,
-0.0088748233,
-0.0317294262,
0.0449587367,
0.0995963588,
-0.0711291283,
-0.0582922623,
-0.0136629781,
-0.0186617747,
-0.0285360999,
-0.0218811631,
-0.0100749219,
0.0124034379,
-0.0135917533,
0.0522847846,
0.001809777,
0.0146232238,
0.0792261064,
-0.037965592,
0.0129126003,
0.0700094476,
-0.0520059578,
0.0059097004,
-0.0523963645,
-0.0329430625,
-0.0476539843,
-0.0523409583,
0.0159344282,
0.0547881573,
-0.0846821219,
-0.042469807,
0.0046521006,
-0.0630308315,
0.0953717232,
-0.0302295573,
0.0171528701,
-0.0020116505,
-0.0227215905,
0.0076230629,
-0.0069760252,
-0.0135109462,
-0.0186585914,
0.0298809409,
0.0173008554,
-0.0128924642,
-0.0423495956,
0.0122148478,
0.040777646,
-0.0262928288,
-0.001921593,
0.0329400748,
-0.0748899207,
-0.06881506,
0.0019401722,
-0.0181577764,
0.0081408182,
0.0094381198,
-0.0096140336,
0.0632510856,
0.0483691134,
0.0631296933,
0.0085696718,
-0.0116618015,
-0.0003953584,
-0.048423443,
-0.0374366045,
-0.0090542017,
-0.0061203837,
-0.0007365045,
0.0481468104,
0.071436435,
0.0248612463,
-0.0528975278,
0.0038825457,
0.0173643585,
-0.0488422327,
-0.0120534068,
-0.0955334976,
-0.0358549245,
0.0451084934,
0.0246130023,
0.002375155,
-0.0381689183,
0.0107495571,
-0.023563901,
-0.0621196441,
0.0554472394,
-0.0321922079,
-0.0153769748,
0.0372404642,
0.0018281947,
-0.0044581043,
-0.0008030804,
-0.0055535198,
0.0070856395,
-0.0115416273,
-0.0216980744,
0.0138387624,
0.019475136,
-0.0087486599,
-0.0380617231,
0.0155464197,
-0.0025674291,
0.0278507881,
0.0481180586,
0.0055688666,
0.0168590732,
0.0380570367,
-0.0397301652,
0.0395097099,
0.0352881141,
-0.0032012905,
0.0017253462,
0.0592833571,
0.0490892977,
-0.0341878049,
-0.0553148985,
-0.0157749914,
0.0163857266,
-0.0221306179,
0.0075014997,
-0.0115199955,
0.0339038409,
0.0030631076,
-0.0174882207,
-0.0554183647,
0.001022225,
-0.0279135462,
-0.0192745011,
0.013542559,
-0.0112455767,
-0.0416115262,
0.0232676324,
0.0437386669,
-0.0606164709,
0.0032302046,
-0.0431153588,
0.0551743656,
0.0534214936,
-0.0066058794,
-0.017969219,
-0.0776602775,
-0.0118342992,
-0.0517435782,
-0.0024326034,
0.0191733353,
-0.0047345404,
0.0227288231,
-0.0147329187,
-0.0030216998,
-0.006394574,
0.0313908681,
0.0204775184,
0.005472288,
-0.0080723343,
0.0411652811,
-0.0186498836,
-0.0328021981,
0.023669431,
-0.0276319366,
-0.035440933,
0.0306074843,
0.0341351405,
0.0770944878,
0.023709096,
-0.0083550205,
0.0217136983,
0.033264026,
-0.035732355,
0.0035995587,
-0.0080375727,
0.0246796198,
-0.0161417443,
-0.0058815633,
0.000173375,
-0.0352264941,
0.0363045372,
-0.0145949693,
-0.0161872376,
0.0011251481,
-0.0244205333,
-0.0074197124,
-0.017079968,
-0.0032839281,
0.0131645519,
0.0211287178,
0.0058366554,
0.0234806705,
0.0096331127,
-0.0405271016,
0.017322056,
-0.0404899418,
0.0063439179,
-0.0229290854,
-0.0061160163,
-0.0415758267,
0.0153568778,
-0.0417921618,
-0.0422352366,
-0.0105365533,
-0.0024772068,
0.0570876636,
-0.0988661051,
0.0134387361,
0.0182732027,
0.0023533416,
-0.0128434282,
-0.0061991126,
-0.0106911492,
-0.0136163468,
-0.010391905,
-0.0040798625,
0.0098555256,
-0.0248235725,
0.0394863039,
-0.0048472346,
-0.0494578481,
-0.0690967739,
-0.0054933773,
-0.0764970109,
0.0559078008,
0.0145712672,
-0.0354900882,
0.0111620827,
-0.035343986,
-0.0345324688,
-0.0183275305,
-0.0099204425,
-0.0417286307,
-0.0447855443,
-0.0324359387,
-0.0586654693,
0.02484967,
-0.0501743145,
0.0188029557,
0.041860655,
0.0369916931,
-0.0230879486,
0.0242465809,
-0.029114943,
0.0028701071,
0.0363332294,
0.0008337191,
-0.003764445,
0.0573905595,
-0.019342104,
-0.0115075,
-0.0374597199,
0.0118995942,
0.0246441811,
-0.0097606396,
0.000695803,
-0.0003970402,
0.0056552319,
0.0166231003,
-0.0173495188,
-0.0603932105,
0.0425755084,
-0.0337782055,
0.0077958745,
-0.0179340634,
-0.0132984314,
-0.0340205133,
-0.0300270934,
0.006563291,
0.0272257812,
0.0311457925,
-0.0543860197,
0.0407642648,
0.0338230506,
-0.0131463399,
-0.0582996197,
0.014792175,
-0.0249851122,
-0.0007664266,
0.0172527861,
0.0013100841,
0.0013910391,
0.038455829,
-0.0279040541,
0.0154461274,
0.0213762261,
-0.0238983613,
-0.0412588678,
0.0565607138,
0.0038645111,
0.020903185,
0.0048684399,
0.0186949931,
0.0238995217,
0.0175431333,
0.0272628795,
-0.0493977256,
0.0404834747,
0.0074392883,
0.042187199,
0.0128440093,
-0.0231603049,
0.047666274,
-0.029844176,
0.0171494689,
-0.0009924835,
0.000985791,
-0.0418543406,
0.0355381705,
0.0490815192,
-0.0317454673,
-0.0104221972,
0.0852752104,
0.0185920242,
-0.0032561573,
0.040506959,
-0.0292701889,
-0.0087841004,
-0.0252106935,
0.0132069634,
-0.0928216726,
-0.0512845442,
0.0095363911,
-0.0184681099,
-0.0077737831,
-0.0887767673,
0.0099907471,
-0.0305932369,
-0.0109030977,
0.0399468206,
-0.0334116928,
-0.022583399,
-0.0699306503,
-0.0495350957,
-0.0512762666,
0.011591061,
0.0176145583,
0.040072795,
0.0109783057,
-0.0313376114,
0.0156778283,
-0.0580051057,
0.0417758226,
-0.0543059409,
-0.0040415684,
0.0572318099,
-0.0045934967,
-0.0079715261,
0.0121659655,
-0.0110028228,
0.0309054125,
0.0279233642,
-0.027688019,
0.0662417039,
0.0021029804,
-0.0293849967,
-0.0131621137,
0.003611638,
-0.0545873232,
-0.0090522859,
0.0160457455,
0.1022327691,
0.0136399614,
-0.0020854608,
-0.0411904193,
-0.0516453683,
-0.0138875991,
0.0449071415,
0.0169071946,
-0.0072742244,
-0.0218486656,
0.0280358214,
0.0284949429,
-0.0321601555,
-0.0577361323,
0.0165565014,
-0.0129681928,
-0.0592214912,
-0.0329183117,
0.0072137793,
0.0418744385,
-0.0337923691,
0.0313596129,
-0.0156987272,
0.0032275796,
-0.0247821491,
-0.0965947062,
0.0282311384,
0.0445976444,
0.0175340138,
-0.072359398,
-0.0509286262,
0.0745601952,
0.0599068552,
0.0251119565,
0.0547270887,
-0.0141731808,
-0.0827955827,
-0.0400557928,
0.0487890132,
0.0116252946,
-0.0531704463,
0.0426949859,
0.008874773,
0.0544356219,
0.0237986054,
0.0010006704,
-0.0353640765,
-0.0034585246,
-0.0670476407,
-0.0343802124,
0.0174099524,
-0.0211587306,
0.0033380564,
0.0101694912,
0.0277105272,
-0.0264132749,
0.02830109,
0.0273099039,
-0.0049799038,
0.1089582667,
-0.0130631663,
-0.0648165792,
-0.0256696325,
-0.0322628543,
0.0543798059,
0.0249758046,
0.0001064707,
-0.0033286624,
0.0132886264,
0.0196432322,
-0.0265287403,
0.0388574265,
0.0187346637,
-0.0116566801,
-0.0498748645,
0.0404160693,
0.0421216823,
-0.0074866312,
0.0457896814,
-0.0174192693,
0.0167471487,
0.0373413637,
-0.0144902198,
-0.0315986499,
0.0206239782,
-0.0179790445,
-0.0183579978,
0.0770391747,
-0.0255886819,
0.0505592972,
-0.0007578438,
0.0150886318,
-0.0299027693,
0.0494814999,
0.0424710996,
-0.0334227942,
0.0646637902,
0.0076996312,
-0.005305049,
-0.0576005727,
0.0753152296,
-0.0514862463,
-0.0298061594,
0.0260595679,
0.0092219915,
-0.0887528881,
-0.04089275,
0.0482241325,
0.0043275473,
0.0616210625,
0.0214371588,
0.0083047692,
-0.0274907332,
-0.0040159067,
0.0408763401,
0.004962618,
-0.0321964398,
0.0339175686,
-0.0283082556,
-0.0416296721,
0.0488924459,
-0.0519554205,
0.0081283059,
0.0376800336,
-0.028328374,
0.013005333,
0.0274328068,
-0.0504091233,
-0.0208549146,
0.0191295948,
-0.0340419337,
-0.0296037327,
0.0078769242,
-5.691280796e-33,
0.0023191615,
-0.0213196035,
0.0078686187,
0.0028038195,
0.0414145589,
0.0477589183,
-0.0535328016,
-0.0119077303,
-0.0365788192,
0.0084886989,
0.0125614563,
-0.0176728982,
-0.0159943588,
0.004445015,
0.0327039361,
0.0175813083,
0.0414400436,
0.0240823422,
-0.0448963456,
-0.0031109683,
0.0487435758,
0.0109186191,
0.0593800917,
-0.0202900395,
-0.0519776791,
0.0032345299,
0.0467195623,
-0.0219402499,
-0.0475536473,
0.0240624286,
0.0186491236,
0.0309180338,
-0.0160725117,
-0.0568513796,
-0.0261394009,
-0.0001552859,
-0.0398374014,
0.0493973196,
-0.0481481664,
0.0048740082,
0.0140148671,
-0.0524377003,
0.031784229,
-0.001177777,
-0.0205967799,
-0.0106554683,
0.0417174287,
-0.0487759933,
0.0032990098,
-0.0659641922,
-0.0250712279,
0.0524946488,
0.0130833061,
0.0121153016,
0.0325816758,
-0.0172340255,
-0.014287903,
0.040555492,
0.0045700511,
0.0318623371,
0.0642946213,
0.0205099341,
0.0762217492,
0.0049073622,
-0.026029855,
0.0401535854,
0.0190237444,
-0.1140679196,
0.0315280668,
0.0743661299,
-0.0169787966,
0.0784699619,
0.0127847362,
0.0140979374,
0.0022692715,
-0.0558004752,
-0.0954527259,
0.0502369553,
-0.0253980514,
0.017146904,
-0.0276944302,
-0.0018067928,
0.0114874691,
0.0086492691,
-0.0046002399,
-0.0536263548,
-0.017621791,
-0.0080144862,
0.052875299,
-0.0412777476,
-0.0260754637,
0.0458841361,
-0.0036354654,
-0.0019876005,
-0.0113468235,
0.0626538694,
0.0462372452,
-0.0001190782,
-0.0134738218,
0.0425799936,
-0.0446477868,
-0.0141030047,
0.0225267131,
-0.0610677078,
0.0625546649,
0.0240544192,
0.0520624556,
-0.0015308616,
-0.0110508539,
0.0056231762,
0.0059585106,
0.0221635699,
-0.0434814468,
0.1061710417,
0.0266961269,
-0.0377642401,
0.0227801334,
0.0505235493,
0.014275278,
0.0171762183,
0.0310811922,
0.0059434166,
-0.0180314109,
-0.0024613249,
-0.0304703433,
-0.0086890273,
0.0080699315,
0.016074704,
-0.0249952376,
-0.0855961889,
-0.0294344779,
0.006702275,
3.004e-7,
0.0764441267,
0.0612677336,
0.0200213119,
-0.01757841,
-0.0377914645,
0.0565251298,
-0.027174009,
0.02804433,
-0.0729490519,
-0.0440632254,
0.0052608117,
-0.0098524736,
-0.0170000996,
0.0145093445,
-0.0235789455,
0.0059116147,
-0.0804371014,
0.0610928424,
-0.0307338238,
-0.0058346717,
0.012139691,
0.1133808494,
0.0182492845,
-0.0360076204,
0.0906309709,
-0.0028738941,
0.01845048,
-0.0169393364,
-0.0012447593,
0.0322900154,
-0.0293120183,
-0.0349408761,
0.0167462304,
0.0195085686,
-0.0445391349,
0.0191638842,
-0.0119826533,
0.0572697408,
0.0048172465,
-0.0461104959,
-0.0137789007,
0.0354662649,
-0.0009251697,
-0.0737956464,
0.0492389165,
-0.0203771628,
-0.0375917368,
0.0343433432,
-0.0480504483,
0.0330968946,
0.0521892533,
0.0064740074,
0.0367685929,
0.0185173601,
0.0129787857,
-0.0194712058,
-0.0203158502,
-0.0463581197,
-0.0480922423,
-0.007844192,
-0.0438186228,
0.0091032833,
-0.0256159417,
-0.0127705242,
0.0023611065,
-0.0271301027,
0.0089134267,
2.733259694e-34,
0.0433931164,
-0.0542283058,
0.0041673761,
0.0332643762,
-0.0215487424,
-0.025058629,
-0.0083980989,
0.0056790845,
-0.0018932131,
-0.0153508848,
-0.0029170427
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13131v2 | When Parts are Greater Than Sums: Individual LLM Components Can Outperform Full Models | 2024-06-19T00:48:44 | 2024-06-24T15:13:13 | Ting-Yun Chang, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper studies in-context learning (ICL) by decomposing the output of
large language models into the individual contributions of attention heads and
MLPs (components). We observe curious components: good-performing ones that
individually do well on a classification task, even when the model performs
poorly; bad-performing ones that do much worse than chance; and label-biased
components that always predict the same label. We find that component
accuracies are well-correlated across different demonstration sets and
perturbations of prompt templates, even when the full-model accuracy varies
greatly. Based on our findings, we propose component reweighting, which learns
to linearly re-scale the component activations from a few labeled examples.
Given 24 labeled examples, our method improves by an average of 6.0% accuracy
points over 24-shot ICL across 8 tasks on Llama-2-7B. Overall, this paper both
enriches our understanding of ICL and provides a practical method for
improvement by examining model internals. | [
-0.0099763814,
0.008539021,
-0.003229799,
0.0646940693,
0.0021077723,
0.0208911672,
-0.0026652503,
0.0048208633,
0.0030076099,
-0.0535804406,
-0.0837111175,
-0.0443670154,
0.0259136483,
-0.0072965883,
0.0536604598,
-0.0491223671,
0.0284492355,
-0.0258078817,
-0.0241279975,
-0.0010644719,
0.0001770434,
-0.0166459642,
0.014170533,
0.0328699313,
0.0072243628,
-0.0237186905,
0.0227105115,
0.0186416842,
0.018516019,
-0.0270242095,
0.015525002,
0.0196266808,
0.0017909266,
0.0088548902,
0.0000019703,
-0.0513736866,
0.0330131426,
-0.045424141,
-0.0382342078,
0.0286608264,
0.0178126916,
-0.0024110379,
0.0001894216,
0.036972478,
-0.0164556783,
0.0060156244,
0.0330159664,
0.0300474782,
0.0329407975,
0.0713166147,
0.0099594267,
-0.0188948456,
0.0214933697,
-0.0462950058,
0.0412680805,
-0.0355221145,
0.0113073904,
-0.0422958955,
-0.0059848502,
-0.0035093497,
-0.0093051698,
0.0310058407,
0.0311740544,
0.0112768784,
0.0361133963,
0.0725204051,
0.0003984729,
0.0054944856,
-0.0109083205,
0.079850018,
-0.0274653062,
-0.0428858399,
-0.0179086886,
-0.02910956,
0.0380241647,
-0.029282121,
-0.0589754581,
0.0498608202,
0.0055605299,
0.048961848,
0.0519905053,
0.0097322315,
0.0549594276,
-0.0232049376,
-0.0307437219,
0.0605904981,
-0.0054351259,
-0.0420031659,
0.0128467986,
0.0087733343,
-0.0194490999,
-0.0575854108,
-0.0199665446,
0.03878114,
-0.0412931666,
0.0480578057,
-0.0563816093,
-0.0084762499,
0.0247029345,
-0.0451681949,
0.0429217964,
0.0504595563,
-0.0466188714,
0.0563163608,
-0.0206379816,
0.038315814,
-0.0295614973,
0.0313341729,
-0.0545786582,
-0.0119395768,
-0.0143630933,
-0.0048683234,
-0.017117722,
0.0248382427,
-0.0002958878,
-0.0057851123,
-0.0383029953,
0.0496553071,
-0.0099309999,
0.0087986225,
0.0205235984,
-0.0200615656,
-0.0373716466,
-0.0045700241,
-0.0088719772,
0.0239103194,
-0.0251136497,
0.0306686834,
0.0146702379,
-0.0572455339,
-0.0360792652,
0.0308010671,
-0.010417209,
-0.0116801718,
0.0150964726,
0.0565481037,
-0.0209710635,
-0.0694248676,
-0.0166444648,
-0.0153867286,
-0.0247675497,
-0.0645443574,
-0.0193033349,
-0.0728362873,
0.0186134707,
0.0146817146,
0.0119818766,
-0.0317724086,
0.0150295645,
0.03313547,
0.0009604255,
0.0482626632,
0.0290738456,
0.0065468317,
0.0380355418,
0.0126865255,
0.0008719646,
0.0783492401,
0.0051706121,
0.0152730811,
-0.0119520128,
0.0122596063,
0.00911838,
0.0517582893,
0.0464860648,
0.0242068339,
-0.0379241928,
-0.0006838361,
0.0486354865,
0.0204665605,
0.0590264127,
0.0174776316,
-0.032986965,
-0.0063954261,
0.0863359645,
0.0439821817,
0.0199155323,
-0.0412364155,
-0.0167219229,
-0.0253915638,
0.0133768618,
0.0014242078,
-0.104902789,
0.0282016136,
-0.0250330139,
0.0104724243,
0.0470912196,
-0.0070755775,
-0.034313947,
-0.0355538949,
-0.0281225182,
-0.014938076,
-0.032694608,
0.0351910554,
0.0280458499,
0.0241023581,
-0.0411678739,
0.058415629,
0.0589565337,
-0.0125993686,
-0.004852558,
-0.0442594066,
0.0381788649,
0.0229755472,
0.0165819395,
-0.0348515995,
-0.0221426357,
-0.0041919504,
0.0313314646,
0.0328608155,
-0.014988305,
-0.0068033058,
0.0206734166,
-0.0426175892,
0.0092300856,
-0.0295221359,
0.0253562275,
0.0341744609,
0.0073920614,
-0.0125599829,
-0.0068835258,
-0.0347730517,
0.0213815477,
0.05054814,
-0.0261801127,
-0.068449758,
0.0066676992,
0.0168497842,
0.0500244759,
-0.0204004943,
0.0235993583,
0.0069721644,
0.0435597114,
-0.0555891059,
0.0251455512,
0.0036102363,
-0.0658007711,
-0.074500747,
0.0264832415,
0.0103867725,
-0.0121198846,
-0.0168481767,
-0.0178413671,
-0.0465083718,
-0.0214126669,
-0.0540301874,
0.0378019772,
-0.0170112085,
0.019222375,
0.0026596638,
0.0477497876,
-0.0688717887,
0.0714644417,
-0.0347700045,
0.0109031424,
0.0477933064,
0.0235396177,
-0.0070011741,
-0.0388814844,
0.0080358461,
-0.0039497809,
0.0033045898,
-0.0227143299,
-0.0411632694,
0.0109141292,
-0.0403879173,
-0.02918805,
-0.0762434155,
-0.0076183337,
-0.0391938351,
0.0313131846,
0.0483078845,
0.0032343185,
-0.0015452164,
-0.0316657498,
-0.0068940171,
-0.0022053486,
0.0011248664,
0.0320422463,
0.0248713847,
0.0063434956,
-0.0123394988,
-0.0314161591,
-0.0043925811,
0.0055404739,
0.058483284,
-0.0319769904,
-0.0366870314,
-0.0907969698,
0.0370435715,
0.006401137,
0.0043272944,
-0.0272931717,
-0.0069529875,
0.0094650928,
-0.0075836149,
0.0490035377,
0.1126394719,
-0.0318012275,
0.0380972326,
0.0783552676,
0.0167740248,
-0.0757499263,
0.0079045827,
0.0152833983,
-0.0031454999,
-0.0378546752,
-0.0131437089,
0.0155981975,
0.0731466115,
0.0188275855,
0.0397036113,
-0.0353299305,
-0.0125894761,
0.001844756,
-0.026439121,
-0.0661584735,
-0.0032474189,
-0.0523730516,
0.0650291666,
-0.0049832286,
-0.0764290467,
0.0437181182,
-0.029497942,
-0.0206391718,
-0.0158729572,
-0.0370492972,
-0.0623242445,
0.0382823572,
0.0023884673,
0.0004446686,
-0.0045887479,
-0.0551897287,
-0.0580537468,
-0.0040381756,
-0.0256391671,
-0.0009606741,
0.0940947831,
-0.0186034031,
0.0085733607,
-0.0200084504,
-0.041764278,
-0.0562361144,
-0.0063721365,
-0.0295327194,
-0.0069960617,
-0.0288440511,
0.0118076103,
-0.0419492424,
-0.0109931175,
0.0409691669,
0.0375863276,
0.0039199414,
-0.0166171771,
-0.0130391698,
0.0319649093,
-0.0075096367,
0.0165179335,
0.0155942524,
-0.0651073307,
0.0009528461,
0.0455067642,
0.0526239835,
-0.0057974253,
-0.0133402683,
-0.014367098,
0.0520846583,
-0.0296290088,
-0.0181517806,
0.0646713525,
0.0535739809,
-0.0872846916,
-0.0236025881,
0.0892938748,
0.012699238,
-0.089144595,
-0.0024595179,
-0.0055876132,
0.0171880983,
0.0536073782,
0.026727844,
-0.057487946,
-0.0492158122,
0.0279036369,
0.0155649856,
0.0258800779,
0.0190104786,
0.0016998375,
-0.1226584017,
0.0417974032,
0.0131607354,
-0.0662174299,
-0.0451034717,
-0.0658150911,
0.0109354425,
0.00015328,
0.043114379,
0.0199662745,
-0.0277376659,
-0.021044068,
0.0090238396,
0.0030102672,
-0.0351037048,
0.0191138089,
-0.0047487216,
0.0460115485,
0.0359206162,
0.0103763035,
0.0001514688,
-0.0555853955,
0.0960821137,
-0.0757978186,
0.0264683161,
-0.0070792185,
0.0260758903,
-0.0000104835,
-0.005089141,
0.010612119,
0.0347984657,
-0.0467265211,
-0.0187151134,
0.0037703856,
0.064790763,
-0.019887818,
0.0146052511,
-0.0312103275,
-0.0338537432,
0.0102096833,
0.0691370815,
0.058077585,
-0.0366101265,
-0.0143078519,
-0.0303169191,
-0.0045051523,
0.019189164,
0.0135940751,
0.0202843696,
-0.0042573554,
-0.0038187406,
-0.0580541752,
-0.0344612002,
0.0191397574,
0.0362081788,
-0.0091769369,
0.0017440725,
-0.0372297652,
-0.0200206097,
-0.0033841741,
0.0377928168,
-0.0478031598,
0.0216006991,
-0.0855391845,
0.0145697976,
0.0330586582,
-0.0644498095,
-0.0052024373,
0.0064524957,
-0.0973378047,
-0.0662267283,
0.0092842001,
0.0370100588,
0.0166557916,
0.0627901405,
-0.0143363243,
-0.067242153,
0.0656056628,
0.0295290723,
-0.004966368,
0.0555377714,
0.006664569,
0.0127793122,
0.0063254354,
0.04145322,
-0.0715453252,
0.0200036541,
0.0420978479,
0.0002475764,
-0.0384675413,
-0.0394497104,
0.0091858665,
-0.0108057596,
0.0445602275,
-0.0170712732,
-0.0044718701,
-0.0074238838,
0.0444693901,
0.0238659102,
-0.0028038775,
0.0011087939,
-0.0213774778,
0.0235684756,
-0.0199477132,
0.0084753819,
0.0367521867,
0.0103426864,
0.0254570022,
-0.0250770394,
0.0100200782,
-0.0189964902,
-0.0037887516,
0.0070152497,
0.0224175584,
-0.0189072266,
0.0049436106,
-0.004574718,
0.0479603596,
0.0143879652,
0.0136083821,
0.006660447,
-0.005335412,
-0.0626237392,
0.0181422457,
-0.0828617066,
0.0036928456,
-0.0138978809,
0.0321786217,
0.0579161346,
-0.0037488067,
0.0223957654,
-0.0037244111,
-0.0112967221,
-0.0148067866,
0.0032429721,
-0.0229028277,
-0.0190089997,
0.054731492,
0.0238725208,
-0.0005187478,
0.0027989242,
0.0718156174,
-0.0019114069,
0.0427965485,
0.0247537438,
0.0477813371,
-0.0341992117,
-0.0087004919,
0.0115566952,
0.0657987744,
-0.0233590063,
0.0109152161,
-0.0261032954,
-0.0378085487,
0.017771598,
0.005135431,
-0.0179624949,
-0.0381573774,
0.0331963524,
0.0395741984,
0.0157342553,
0.0021300835,
0.0022159969,
-0.0227898173,
-0.0061862278,
-0.021179961,
0.0144148134,
-6.435735327e-33,
-0.0472186953,
-0.054057423,
0.0058216653,
0.0106893033,
0.0087347087,
0.0111739151,
-0.0406891368,
0.0154762669,
-0.0206025951,
-0.0160615854,
-0.0414693877,
0.0112873213,
0.0123205613,
0.0115688732,
0.020074632,
-0.0294816829,
0.0314307734,
0.0153768621,
-0.0429648869,
0.0124047631,
0.0281280242,
0.0237660222,
0.0742184222,
-0.0194647163,
0.0099783037,
-0.0241886191,
-0.0144915329,
0.0161694065,
-0.0432706997,
0.0543211512,
-0.0141411545,
0.0561865196,
0.0346512273,
-0.054604087,
-0.0326044858,
0.0220334213,
-0.0528036319,
-0.0287100021,
0.0266457014,
-0.0071065123,
-0.0268625114,
-0.0461081974,
0.0822180435,
0.0152183855,
-0.0079970611,
-0.0294403173,
0.0349303372,
-0.0151918614,
-0.0609141216,
-0.0207060706,
-0.0403805375,
0.0005592463,
0.0008858963,
-0.0092552239,
-0.004989027,
0.0055652508,
-0.0235299263,
0.081207186,
-0.0727226734,
-0.0151115777,
0.0039538331,
0.0588595606,
0.0487789921,
0.0575569756,
-0.0060029333,
0.0347152092,
0.0257515591,
0.0181034431,
-0.0150435818,
-0.079559043,
0.0350460634,
0.0249783825,
0.0219716132,
0.0508120321,
0.0562186576,
0.0220214687,
-0.0817677975,
0.0133407619,
0.0340967774,
0.0466963947,
0.0134619726,
0.0373549387,
-0.0299467277,
-0.0249663461,
-0.0351230279,
-0.0068353806,
-0.0461229011,
0.0017164939,
0.0505931899,
0.0285207387,
0.0214799866,
-0.0123906257,
0.0268193223,
-0.0192791298,
-0.0156756137,
0.0187996347,
0.0053771907,
0.0127423927,
0.0172471404,
-0.0034115121,
-0.0830713958,
-0.0085305832,
-0.0099016055,
0.0226986203,
0.0058832611,
0.0088839298,
0.0672439113,
0.0119271744,
-0.0880533233,
-0.0056371647,
-0.0246985443,
0.017960215,
-0.0059832814,
0.0601720773,
0.0623400956,
-0.0437466651,
-0.0059097484,
0.0492605194,
-0.0010299829,
-0.0348375887,
-0.0313866027,
-0.0088842772,
-0.031951759,
0.017138727,
-0.0395324342,
0.0061862376,
-0.0198038761,
0.0390883088,
0.0378516875,
-0.0170306433,
-0.0193536114,
0.0165862907,
2.684e-7,
0.0361182503,
0.0393470228,
-0.0316120237,
0.0343759656,
0.0272560194,
0.0404331982,
-0.0451236889,
0.039821621,
0.0321467556,
-0.0471227057,
-0.0141405016,
0.0118562086,
0.0471248366,
-0.0058917082,
-0.0928171799,
0.0309329722,
-0.066720508,
0.0266829785,
-0.0073764548,
-0.0427104905,
-0.0184571613,
0.1258876026,
0.0177166183,
-0.0311151575,
0.0152477063,
-0.0108987261,
0.0600463524,
-0.0483790115,
-0.0034257646,
-0.0119545311,
-0.002201105,
0.0301104914,
-0.0122902729,
0.0155020934,
-0.0115251085,
0.039807491,
-0.025290776,
0.0509230681,
-0.0070029516,
-0.0388879851,
-0.0067385756,
0.0135286562,
0.0230252557,
-0.0788671672,
0.0515555553,
-0.040672496,
-0.0104775056,
-0.0465681776,
0.0021311857,
-0.0326102376,
0.0513587445,
-0.004761362,
0.0233555902,
0.0110523291,
-0.0037723039,
-0.028476784,
-0.0436107144,
-0.096003823,
-0.080910407,
0.0021746121,
-0.0317490175,
-0.0319556147,
-0.0452105738,
0.004262771,
0.0388609879,
-0.0725015551,
-0.0213170275,
2.235015623e-34,
0.0130231148,
-0.0142559363,
0.0335861966,
0.0761801153,
-0.0336096026,
-0.0219218712,
-0.0242075287,
0.0090939794,
0.0348286256,
-0.0642411485,
0.0194953643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13124v1 | Learning to Generate Answers with Citations via Factual Consistency Models | 2024-06-19T00:40:19 | 2024-06-19T00:40:19 | Rami Aly, Zhiqiang Tang, Samson Tan, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate, impeding their
reliability in mission-critical situations. One approach to address this issue
is to provide citations to relevant sources alongside generated content,
enhancing the verifiability of generations. However, citing passages accurately
in answers remains a substantial challenge. This paper proposes a
weakly-supervised fine-tuning method leveraging factual consistency models
(FCMs). Our approach alternates between generating texts with citations and
supervised fine-tuning with FCM-filtered citation data. Focused learning is
integrated into the objective, directing the fine-tuning process to emphasise
the factual unit tokens, as measured by an FCM. Results on the ALCE few-shot
citation benchmark with various instruction-tuned LLMs demonstrate superior
performance compared to in-context learning, vanilla supervised fine-tuning,
and state-of-the-art methods, with an average improvement of $34.1$, $15.5$,
and $10.5$ citation F$_1$ points, respectively. Moreover, in a domain transfer
setting we show that the obtained citation generation ability robustly
transfers to unseen datasets. Notably, our citation improvements contribute to
the lowest factual error rate across baselines. | [
0.0540967807,
0.0147905499,
0.0284048039,
-0.0063817156,
-0.0277858209,
-0.0135360733,
0.0097737955,
-0.0136753833,
0.0001008834,
-0.082782954,
0.0372712836,
-0.0243837796,
-0.0208531544,
-0.0287453104,
0.0350791477,
0.0160984546,
0.0566919856,
-0.0093199145,
0.056054499,
-0.0028090507,
-0.010384988,
0.0334066376,
-0.0020109136,
0.0184815582,
-0.0034349978,
-0.0298991296,
0.0309337825,
0.0017187819,
0.0335643105,
-0.021082405,
0.04898303,
0.0523619018,
0.01331928,
0.0102295363,
0.0000020665,
-0.05509305,
0.0095762452,
0.0141794393,
-0.0351216607,
0.0383830592,
0.0351723768,
-0.0011896017,
0.02202994,
0.0196870621,
-0.0298844799,
0.0129571119,
0.0012555735,
0.0473083369,
0.1104259267,
0.0406584516,
0.0185475778,
-0.032962665,
0.0339344107,
-0.0252304431,
-0.001753369,
-0.0331680328,
0.0312611759,
0.0670576021,
-0.0042346241,
0.0619854853,
0.0382787026,
0.0319182873,
0.0023444777,
-0.008866081,
0.0651082471,
0.021604551,
-0.0358230174,
0.0275722388,
0.020343177,
0.0492261946,
0.0088421395,
-0.0432441086,
0.0221768431,
-0.0034964599,
-0.0130466316,
0.0214540716,
-0.0235894378,
0.0128008146,
-0.019905569,
-0.00992289,
0.0271911509,
-0.0287115704,
0.0137157356,
0.014360195,
-0.0100662373,
0.043192666,
0.0089183124,
-0.0289568081,
-0.0137959709,
-0.0086902985,
-0.0252958853,
-0.0519470647,
-0.0273616817,
0.0457714647,
-0.0242425222,
-0.0121087199,
-0.055000782,
0.026657315,
0.0443339944,
-0.0155632664,
0.0131128514,
-0.0087982491,
-0.0086730178,
0.0465561748,
-0.0638795719,
0.0286920555,
0.0001126782,
-0.0326416604,
0.0022055623,
-0.0182584636,
-0.0683188811,
0.0015608306,
-0.0000602649,
0.03411806,
-0.0220151376,
-0.015681738,
-0.066335097,
-0.0055260705,
-0.0210146401,
0.0285604894,
0.0021164794,
-0.0065172436,
-0.0553363934,
0.006560294,
-0.0304065943,
0.0070107738,
-0.0176687855,
0.0438428707,
-0.0067698541,
-0.0605575331,
-0.0041481052,
0.0067882068,
0.0083635198,
-0.0199509244,
0.0184925701,
0.0594990738,
-0.0222403519,
0.0130067319,
-0.0708614737,
-0.0593308322,
-0.0069422489,
-0.0766397789,
-0.0106005622,
-0.0846829936,
0.0027077412,
0.0265728142,
-0.0163695067,
-0.0690461397,
0.0364207625,
0.0402389355,
-0.0443481542,
0.0334094428,
0.0066222171,
0.0112522729,
0.0141074024,
-0.0240236335,
0.0511758141,
0.0384540297,
0.0404237732,
-0.0085377488,
0.0364835374,
0.0271517355,
0.0156697817,
-0.0028085348,
0.0400817841,
0.0478304774,
0.0271490775,
-0.0188910868,
-0.0188261736,
0.0146691529,
0.0192185398,
0.037564259,
-0.0116964253,
0.0173302833,
0.0581928864,
-0.022578055,
-0.0190335009,
0.0066428827,
0.0767802,
0.0157167185,
0.020069411,
0.008738827,
-0.0420307294,
0.018927291,
0.0255892444,
0.0172073115,
0.0643185303,
0.029926952,
-0.0286407229,
0.000079515,
-0.0159069132,
-0.0025857713,
-0.0569150262,
-0.0196321737,
0.0184870437,
0.0130877625,
-0.0659501627,
0.0868105218,
0.0221127383,
-0.019460069,
0.0242139343,
0.0045647877,
0.037285123,
0.0087754931,
0.045891311,
0.0021670284,
-0.011142401,
-0.0609162077,
0.0572349541,
0.0505611859,
0.0205157455,
-0.0060435333,
-0.0078843003,
-0.0334453136,
-0.0351828262,
-0.0247302894,
0.0109873433,
-0.0416553207,
0.0397819094,
0.0043501551,
0.0434573516,
-0.0787566602,
-0.0441098511,
0.0386572778,
-0.0264683999,
-0.0369661972,
-0.0132745523,
-0.0129981246,
0.0143995034,
0.0195918307,
-0.0434621722,
0.0127262836,
0.0052136062,
-0.0201907866,
0.0118865436,
-0.0123191951,
-0.0042050895,
0.045745872,
0.0515435562,
-0.0425146036,
-0.0059464569,
-0.0156440865,
-0.0550867841,
-0.0202899091,
-0.0103561599,
-0.0369939804,
-0.0412826389,
-0.0247172844,
0.0162114017,
0.0121214706,
0.0066774483,
-0.048609525,
0.0594652072,
0.0132103842,
0.0236904956,
0.0306805,
0.0047409888,
0.0386802889,
-0.0163321886,
0.0130356923,
-0.0445794389,
-0.0152788088,
0.0073519037,
0.0608015768,
-0.0050680912,
-0.0302566309,
-0.0041866885,
-0.0228843037,
0.0049597821,
-0.0024180596,
0.012271665,
0.0116302837,
-0.0219862964,
0.0133193601,
0.0177958421,
0.0007513943,
-0.0184644125,
0.0083114123,
0.0105664618,
0.0385619216,
-0.0033769652,
0.0400916189,
-0.0399391353,
0.0071030245,
-0.0173731633,
0.0279280003,
0.0308804698,
0.0322567374,
-0.0863092765,
0.0320367552,
-0.0498811454,
0.0021929559,
0.0053211288,
-0.0052265972,
0.02305522,
0.016756082,
0.0387997702,
0.0444799699,
0.0342987366,
-0.0160761327,
0.0190010387,
0.0077986312,
-0.0644124225,
-0.0011917601,
-0.0349288099,
-0.0373529606,
-0.0052064653,
-0.0335069112,
0.0091040218,
0.0176640823,
0.0157683231,
0.0010110941,
-0.0336562842,
0.0390882827,
-0.0129264612,
0.0007697293,
-0.0092131151,
0.0058024591,
-0.0167573001,
0.0156685263,
-0.0071020303,
-0.0063193301,
0.0641892031,
-0.0381667055,
0.0396628194,
-0.034057904,
0.0062774667,
-0.0209880769,
-0.0144460658,
0.0112511767,
-0.0076632113,
0.0415382124,
0.0327972956,
-0.0784056112,
0.0007516287,
0.0292572435,
-0.0305440575,
0.0505044721,
-0.0239460897,
0.0198519602,
-0.024823539,
-0.0142764002,
-0.0558053963,
-0.0473250709,
-0.0259607434,
0.0479886942,
-0.0132125551,
-0.011807113,
-0.0344608538,
-0.0208398458,
0.0808619782,
0.029894812,
-0.0308638085,
-0.0362476967,
-0.0513915308,
0.0421297103,
0.0883991942,
0.0030853883,
0.0394633561,
-0.022961989,
-0.0365257561,
0.0506235473,
0.0314851403,
0.024667196,
-0.0245592631,
-0.0617734082,
0.0154767158,
-0.0470326766,
0.0084875664,
0.0198934637,
0.0774925575,
-0.0343996249,
-0.03568995,
0.1017760634,
0.0216240212,
0.0148345856,
-0.0042479946,
-0.0084115742,
0.0203049406,
0.0372637399,
0.0321587175,
-0.0978623033,
-0.0296341926,
-0.0384975672,
0.0583790727,
0.004258052,
-0.0460885465,
-0.001831666,
-0.1492332816,
0.0341355875,
0.0057334043,
0.0060414588,
-0.0413221903,
-0.0631025359,
0.0285838749,
-0.0034126374,
-0.0269954056,
0.0317599699,
-0.0204346981,
0.0107701793,
0.0388606302,
0.0368334502,
-0.0623353757,
0.0144104678,
-0.0792350322,
0.0468852036,
0.0181875639,
0.0362777039,
0.0037273564,
-0.0302044451,
0.030744344,
-0.0697832406,
-0.015760459,
0.0095980791,
0.0167746469,
-0.006919588,
0.0139392707,
0.0097262915,
0.0526904278,
-0.0041395635,
-0.0402105115,
0.0312603228,
0.0760175064,
-0.0134929782,
-0.0055830637,
-0.0299016535,
0.0223128051,
0.0106388899,
0.0785175711,
0.0204791557,
-0.0250943135,
-0.0374821387,
-0.0204443187,
0.0430654064,
-0.0714086294,
-0.0386790223,
0.0093085254,
-0.0399248563,
0.0451751091,
-0.0827049389,
-0.0129160946,
-0.0202607848,
0.0067965197,
0.0262627527,
0.0180068146,
0.0286994819,
-0.0130722001,
-0.029839335,
0.0015341826,
-0.0674656555,
0.0196818151,
-0.0407299809,
0.0259387996,
0.0154919373,
-0.0210893955,
-0.0154761225,
0.0271310881,
-0.0045279623,
-0.0345531814,
0.0064115631,
0.0378649831,
0.0132992947,
0.0183376037,
-0.0230027139,
-0.0351179689,
0.0455045812,
0.0802821741,
-0.0261000041,
0.0358996429,
-0.0030981826,
-0.0430407487,
-0.0245347265,
0.0105608413,
-0.0597112738,
0.020840684,
-0.013308526,
0.0393625349,
0.000384206,
-0.0619584247,
0.0048898757,
0.0008976579,
0.0430367403,
-0.0155284358,
0.0026486125,
-0.0016551184,
0.0002820589,
0.0176682863,
-0.0193193555,
0.0045048646,
0.0248163361,
-0.0346199088,
0.0085947709,
0.0052128937,
0.0121232765,
-0.0273415502,
0.0934793949,
-0.0280391797,
-0.0244044755,
-0.02035423,
0.0478014164,
-0.025285041,
-0.0434679873,
-0.0402620137,
-0.0200539865,
-0.0089180712,
0.0464287549,
-0.0117674144,
0.0454941653,
0.0124694165,
0.0141023463,
-0.0124358926,
-0.0239199027,
-0.0695815906,
0.0217354614,
-0.0659724921,
-0.0544813834,
0.0540268496,
-0.0082809869,
0.0496956035,
-0.0500368252,
-0.0313819833,
-0.0311539862,
0.0176427551,
0.0081662014,
0.0226826165,
0.0117134433,
0.0243733581,
-0.0211036671,
0.0681831837,
0.0585458353,
0.0428364314,
0.0482353531,
-0.0238052681,
-0.0112413988,
-0.0387895703,
-0.0568989143,
-0.0837341994,
0.0106330086,
0.0301897433,
0.0147361308,
-0.0587525107,
-0.0478373766,
0.0384583659,
0.0181551985,
0.0009836882,
-0.0318763889,
0.0176448766,
0.0441924408,
-0.0188826881,
-0.0329784304,
-0.0750088245,
0.0499103852,
0.0095029995,
-0.0260925218,
-0.0314454362,
-6.576970973e-33,
-0.0180696938,
-0.0371370316,
0.0174284372,
-0.0144209443,
-0.0212942902,
0.009502341,
-0.0443862639,
-0.0335260145,
-0.0573687255,
0.0018470942,
0.0018510716,
-0.0116422027,
-0.007297955,
0.0309164729,
-0.0004959633,
0.0158525128,
0.0589554347,
0.0149568636,
-0.0391232036,
0.0436761156,
0.0750952959,
-0.0149204349,
0.0223937985,
-0.1134039164,
0.0233471263,
-0.0252061486,
-0.0322920345,
0.007608077,
0.007282027,
0.0695431456,
0.0061965217,
0.027346801,
0.005146645,
-0.0739807636,
0.0083448617,
-0.0189972855,
-0.0896618515,
-0.0003483171,
0.0363947824,
-0.0772034228,
-0.0141404839,
-0.0647495613,
0.0276618581,
-0.0177182369,
-0.0240237266,
-0.0397352912,
0.0617758892,
-0.0293430202,
-0.0215270668,
-0.0742716789,
-0.0826790482,
0.0252664462,
0.0285223965,
0.0196440611,
-0.0654957741,
0.0617072992,
-0.0114003774,
0.0605130754,
-0.0590949953,
0.0181153808,
0.0027661503,
0.0575377345,
0.0415492542,
-0.0080231633,
-0.0233639572,
0.0501276962,
-0.0398032963,
-0.0184926335,
0.0034934129,
-0.0548725314,
-0.0180357676,
0.058687184,
0.0669556707,
0.1292624027,
-0.0150364814,
0.0262794998,
-0.0851231664,
0.0201809593,
-0.0116525991,
0.0596366674,
0.0492439047,
-0.0333170891,
-0.000158348,
0.0067368723,
-0.0455498956,
0.0149450041,
-0.0214766879,
-0.0018321624,
0.0044235806,
0.0160884485,
-0.0580812804,
0.0263341479,
0.0610250905,
-0.0281670932,
-0.0208207015,
0.0592490621,
-0.0529030599,
0.0200274754,
0.006503209,
-0.0088455817,
-0.0788700208,
-0.017685065,
0.024613563,
-0.0108870585,
0.0237563383,
0.0393469334,
0.0345750749,
-0.0020726116,
-0.0409117565,
0.0038985817,
-0.0123973638,
0.0370757245,
-0.015532569,
-0.0443684384,
0.007799536,
0.0279801916,
0.0042391247,
0.0231394917,
0.0151841622,
-0.0144741852,
0.0271798931,
-0.0138811031,
0.0275495853,
0.0478400774,
-0.0210677125,
0.0274107717,
-0.0429341234,
0.066354543,
-0.0420773141,
-0.0663421452,
-0.0152428094,
0.0224158466,
2.75e-7,
0.0137015199,
0.0253455024,
-0.0054493737,
-0.0066314344,
0.0187310968,
0.0398601182,
0.022671558,
0.0255763158,
0.0264027212,
-0.021681536,
-0.0129710883,
0.0047558686,
0.0433208793,
0.0201134887,
-0.0611432008,
-0.0192842763,
-0.0629004017,
0.0008278051,
-0.0376494899,
-0.0144913141,
0.0169164725,
0.0461743623,
-0.0005136734,
-0.0070210374,
-0.0224984623,
-0.0359697267,
0.0686408579,
0.0267374124,
-0.0383969173,
0.0352200046,
0.0267166402,
0.0229825452,
0.0018147333,
0.0211290158,
-0.0536807142,
-0.0113508748,
0.01156097,
0.0651746988,
0.0360816158,
-0.0159374587,
-0.0103606898,
-0.0293267109,
0.0230750348,
-0.0510374308,
0.0517224334,
-0.0731709898,
0.000626885,
-0.0428032987,
-0.0719123036,
0.0304723717,
-0.0238366332,
0.0019376349,
-0.0259241052,
0.0098476177,
-0.0137061002,
0.052657146,
-0.0630286261,
-0.0131187271,
-0.0165246688,
0.0631585717,
-0.0249740202,
-0.0714769438,
0.0139173865,
-0.0366647318,
0.0185488798,
-0.0430011861,
0.0332199782,
2.591633288e-34,
0.0246419534,
-0.0150976619,
0.0169692487,
-0.015990667,
0.0292042568,
0.0221521165,
-0.0461671986,
0.030609047,
0.0321363732,
-0.0425032489,
0.0057545733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13121v1 | Can Long-Context Language Models Subsume Retrieval, RAG, SQL, and More? | 2024-06-19T00:28:58 | 2024-06-19T00:28:58 | Jinhyuk Lee, Anthony Chen, Zhuyun Dai, Dheeru Dua, Devendra Singh Sachan, Michael Boratko, Yi Luan, Sébastien M. R. Arnold, Vincent Perot, Siddharth Dalmia, Hexiang Hu, Xudong Lin, Panupong Pasupat, Aida Amini, Jeremy R. Cole, Sebastian Riedel, Iftekhar Naim, Ming-Wei Chang, Kelvin Guu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Long-context language models (LCLMs) have the potential to revolutionize our
approach to tasks traditionally reliant on external tools like retrieval
systems or databases. Leveraging LCLMs' ability to natively ingest and process
entire corpora of information offers numerous advantages. It enhances
user-friendliness by eliminating the need for specialized knowledge of tools,
provides robust end-to-end modeling that minimizes cascading errors in complex
pipelines, and allows for the application of sophisticated prompting techniques
across the entire system. To assess this paradigm shift, we introduce LOFT, a
benchmark of real-world tasks requiring context up to millions of tokens
designed to evaluate LCLMs' performance on in-context retrieval and reasoning.
Our findings reveal LCLMs' surprising ability to rival state-of-the-art
retrieval and RAG systems, despite never having been explicitly trained for
these tasks. However, LCLMs still face challenges in areas like compositional
reasoning that are required in SQL-like tasks. Notably, prompting strategies
significantly influence performance, emphasizing the need for continued
research as context lengths grow. Overall, LOFT provides a rigorous testing
ground for LCLMs, showcasing their potential to supplant existing paradigms and
tackle novel tasks as model capabilities scale. | [
0.0463522673,
0.0477472953,
-0.0043693283,
0.0339882039,
-0.0527810715,
0.0122505389,
0.0298130158,
-0.0295488387,
-0.0014533177,
-0.0574761704,
-0.0004702288,
-0.0661807358,
-0.0390320048,
0.040301986,
0.0178604089,
-0.0120357564,
0.0450366326,
-0.0328869633,
0.0076974994,
0.0244096741,
-0.0138377463,
0.0109246019,
0.0062345844,
0.0278239828,
-0.0511131398,
-0.0084502632,
-0.024020046,
0.0312538892,
-0.0299461372,
-0.0181409325,
0.0205746926,
0.048131384,
0.0596561432,
0.0301732291,
0.0000018056,
-0.0694134086,
-0.0346329287,
0.0003037892,
-0.0642406195,
-0.0314703733,
0.0568472259,
0.0078750933,
0.0027953135,
0.017534988,
-0.0454898551,
0.004535947,
0.0103291385,
0.0282005705,
0.0310225245,
0.0709936097,
-0.0099387821,
-0.0472302623,
-0.0062689451,
-0.0331087187,
0.0449082889,
-0.0580990463,
0.0201918185,
-0.0073242015,
0.0454812013,
0.0060630539,
-0.0037467233,
0.0446299873,
0.0434237756,
-0.0011781494,
-0.0129729901,
0.0230737273,
-0.0434062332,
0.0162830036,
0.004909154,
0.066508837,
0.0170073081,
-0.0251180567,
0.0016925137,
0.0349816829,
-0.0001454978,
-0.0395582728,
-0.0313017666,
0.0304711163,
-0.0251317117,
-0.0062924707,
0.0087314509,
-0.0033353365,
0.0320520066,
0.0051073632,
-0.0589401722,
0.0560874455,
0.00689852,
-0.0495038703,
0.0027986462,
-0.0202363152,
0.0116716651,
-0.0707567483,
0.0201459192,
0.0529652201,
-0.0739636347,
0.0232760049,
-0.015387632,
0.012390947,
0.0214525964,
0.0046534841,
-0.0114495195,
0.0460525341,
-0.0254126154,
0.1027984396,
-0.0500445515,
0.024214888,
0.0000825519,
0.0060897456,
-0.0306684524,
-0.0559964143,
-0.0595916621,
-0.0209679883,
-0.0622881837,
0.006331814,
-0.0903105065,
-0.0484727658,
-0.0085840886,
0.0362818055,
0.0026628349,
0.0433550887,
-0.0037189298,
0.0199330635,
-0.0212694872,
-0.0134017486,
-0.0245780591,
0.0010455705,
-0.0241653733,
0.0103612822,
0.0402716361,
-0.0576268844,
-0.022561131,
0.0119232601,
0.0026342212,
-0.0458270684,
0.0235247687,
0.063635841,
0.0127656795,
-0.0441938899,
-0.0506077819,
-0.0511503592,
-0.0243829172,
-0.0615985319,
-0.0103101674,
-0.0616470464,
0.0374893881,
0.0243046489,
-0.0196208898,
-0.012194803,
0.0011423882,
0.0279786065,
-0.0029977059,
0.0755576789,
0.0323058963,
-0.0013102352,
0.0039314437,
0.0166605003,
-0.0028688884,
0.0664220154,
-0.0067645735,
0.0491555184,
0.0296879299,
0.016109664,
0.0046631233,
0.0020420579,
0.0136643359,
0.0050409506,
-0.0497886837,
0.0612715967,
0.0154129323,
0.026568573,
0.0106902933,
0.0717929006,
-0.0091553265,
-0.0152331507,
0.0293642543,
0.0415658019,
0.0761921778,
-0.0261263121,
0.0848880783,
-0.0115249883,
-0.0404151604,
-0.0239518136,
-0.0827567652,
0.0173430089,
-0.0260016676,
0.0392682552,
0.028423477,
-0.0148368906,
-0.0363752954,
-0.0396536216,
-0.0239963643,
-0.009896745,
-0.0212966055,
0.0257917736,
0.0429311842,
0.0176048484,
-0.0296621639,
0.0257355645,
-0.0105395243,
-0.0327648222,
0.0034650913,
-0.0319542214,
0.0261837076,
0.1000257283,
0.0428123884,
-0.0446339361,
-0.0055225645,
-0.0170669816,
0.0346079655,
0.0163260177,
0.0208392758,
-0.0174712986,
0.0242363457,
-0.0141574508,
-0.014214525,
0.0016668357,
0.0063470146,
-0.0022207489,
0.0440354757,
0.0119163087,
0.0359055735,
-0.0381815843,
0.0037886447,
0.0257974695,
-0.0342417248,
-0.0266299918,
-0.0129168872,
0.024140954,
0.0101097608,
0.0158671755,
-0.0198547244,
0.045407813,
0.0457309186,
-0.0424122587,
-0.0506681874,
-0.0094611561,
-0.0603290647,
-0.0395276546,
0.0281650666,
0.0386680625,
-0.0102338269,
-0.0472880974,
-0.0226703528,
-0.0513270311,
0.0159062874,
-0.0082298853,
0.0514434017,
-0.0650286227,
-0.0080353953,
0.0236249398,
-0.0261029955,
-0.0495317243,
0.0679289177,
0.0030703612,
0.0250269584,
0.0203238856,
0.0228513367,
0.0044983858,
-0.0677965656,
-0.0375558361,
-0.0020209535,
-0.0064033307,
0.0116263293,
-0.0042979866,
-0.001250698,
-0.0483175181,
-0.0096035404,
-0.1205255389,
0.0184910763,
-0.0504181348,
-0.0027825776,
-0.0072393222,
0.0246510897,
-0.01800346,
-0.0207561795,
-0.0300432779,
-0.0304848086,
0.0134609006,
0.0565500259,
0.0269772746,
0.0308470707,
-0.0167009979,
-0.0382162333,
-0.0356535986,
-0.0353245549,
0.0546711348,
-0.0331018567,
-0.0085914517,
-0.020910291,
0.0077881259,
-0.0145969363,
0.0226919241,
-0.0165879615,
0.0286762509,
0.0094940104,
-0.0537722148,
0.0477605201,
0.0824937522,
-0.0009768112,
0.0127859721,
-0.01177797,
-0.0185621232,
-0.0492046177,
0.0392929316,
-0.0124655589,
-0.0161870401,
-0.0088771367,
0.027653899,
0.0037119216,
0.0082836961,
-0.0054746084,
-0.0097038941,
-0.0315245278,
0.0106404908,
0.0016209268,
-0.0001745464,
-0.0590887256,
-0.0155281955,
0.014727355,
0.051515732,
-0.032077428,
-0.0150059024,
0.0689756051,
-0.0332492851,
-0.0025823317,
-0.0105774142,
-0.0155589953,
-0.0605087131,
0.0836588889,
-0.0166620426,
0.0109393587,
-0.0502521135,
-0.046557501,
-0.0244374704,
-0.0170259364,
-0.0266665965,
-0.0328015573,
0.0613352209,
-0.0098522427,
0.0366786942,
-0.0049424884,
-0.0483287461,
-0.0426876545,
-0.0245666727,
-0.0256844871,
0.0367247947,
-0.0075009717,
0.0032459109,
0.0025900321,
0.0215706397,
0.0118261408,
0.0562496781,
0.0006068905,
-0.0170176681,
-0.0128730685,
-0.0063582556,
0.0244838037,
-0.0031470666,
0.0240760837,
-0.0094812876,
0.0284177382,
0.0367603861,
0.0670406446,
-0.0316593945,
-0.0206278525,
0.0141157387,
-0.0095737781,
-0.0213515759,
0.0085383914,
0.0118707884,
0.0307369493,
-0.0748603716,
-0.0378863327,
0.1017158031,
0.0209605936,
-0.0243532676,
-0.0077363737,
-0.0073555992,
0.0188211314,
0.03648597,
0.0330078378,
-0.1128940806,
-0.0608913526,
0.0279546287,
-0.0004460182,
0.0315456577,
-0.0418353938,
-0.0001387745,
-0.1081285477,
0.0345386006,
-0.0196850691,
-0.0508648604,
-0.0195966102,
-0.0297664721,
0.0002047474,
0.0012014948,
0.0288644489,
0.0667903796,
-0.0232600775,
-0.0147850551,
-0.0022210074,
0.0251361895,
-0.0379191823,
0.0532489903,
-0.0564306304,
0.0101828575,
0.0397868119,
-0.0237285309,
0.0416105576,
-0.0210342314,
0.0535197034,
-0.037939366,
0.0287289675,
0.0006540845,
0.0264867134,
-0.0403360426,
-0.0019977498,
0.0026153661,
0.0216740016,
-0.0713984221,
0.0009694536,
-0.0081882561,
0.0663791671,
-0.0150295096,
0.0229760353,
-0.0335443504,
-0.0104353325,
0.0403328277,
0.1007963493,
0.0207977202,
-0.0080482056,
-0.0748767704,
-0.0217134003,
-0.0417280197,
-0.0258639175,
0.028144747,
0.0116965296,
0.0137282964,
-0.0029552348,
-0.0402908251,
-0.043030303,
0.0442837849,
0.0763859004,
-0.0156089198,
0.0291765798,
-0.0332668088,
-0.0090019647,
-0.0879149884,
0.0281166378,
-0.0493087433,
0.0415566266,
-0.0388732813,
0.0452554338,
0.0182845406,
-0.0215051547,
-0.0271017738,
0.0065357955,
-0.0733200535,
-0.0420516133,
0.0112768728,
0.0130076539,
0.0273035858,
0.034137547,
-0.0341120139,
-0.0294183195,
0.0224780962,
0.0226187594,
-0.0418070257,
0.002788692,
0.0045041055,
0.0277561806,
0.0088451607,
0.0518970788,
-0.0708832592,
0.0092513198,
-0.0081618335,
0.0658412501,
0.014358284,
-0.0013598852,
0.0233276859,
-0.0037429621,
-0.0020937878,
0.0400027595,
-0.0213649757,
-0.0094516091,
0.0506340526,
-0.0369186588,
-0.0498145558,
-0.0082593253,
0.017760193,
0.0077426103,
-0.0026961353,
0.0241932031,
-0.0262752268,
0.0023650378,
0.065877296,
-0.0194589086,
-0.0155217899,
0.0393993556,
-0.0062269499,
0.0435150303,
-0.0057769418,
-0.0250902288,
0.0270496439,
-0.0109375799,
0.0583836101,
-0.0513520166,
0.0414313413,
0.0358718261,
-0.0051699579,
-0.0415978767,
0.0256847385,
-0.0800204799,
-0.0306750052,
0.0223315246,
0.0220110547,
0.0417449996,
-0.0319112316,
-0.0167018361,
-0.0103238923,
0.0033546784,
-0.0318733342,
0.0173747223,
0.0330905654,
-0.0442854241,
0.0150509262,
0.0542868748,
-0.0291859508,
0.023503786,
0.0423437506,
-0.0109358961,
0.0312737152,
0.002289728,
-0.0206265878,
-0.0304046478,
-0.0189219303,
0.018712353,
0.0486064404,
-0.0137196342,
-0.0072926958,
-0.0670347288,
-0.0631741062,
0.027793115,
0.0190531537,
-0.0251059122,
0.0050923764,
0.0316261761,
0.1149563491,
0.0560530499,
-0.0367759317,
-0.0320302583,
0.0053716865,
-0.0203952584,
-0.0351315849,
-0.028840078,
-5.917119342e-33,
-0.0211842544,
-0.0245891511,
0.0608475432,
-0.0331111401,
-0.0137883732,
0.0075075077,
-0.0351547934,
-0.0157748032,
-0.0257147532,
-0.0016416908,
-0.0474730618,
0.0392068848,
0.0198771935,
0.0441477261,
0.0219615176,
-0.028994333,
0.0272537973,
0.023033699,
0.0135759013,
0.0112055736,
0.0947486833,
0.0538649,
0.0029137824,
-0.0263523534,
0.0077507379,
0.0078934263,
0.032372646,
0.0663213357,
-0.0226463825,
0.0620000437,
-0.022795964,
0.0164737776,
0.0364814252,
-0.0248794556,
0.0006255967,
0.0200950596,
-0.1005439684,
0.0005869627,
0.0143015692,
-0.0308341701,
-0.0193078145,
-0.028776804,
0.0353714488,
-0.0237511955,
-0.0014079276,
0.0006903898,
-0.0061231805,
-0.0140669569,
-0.023534717,
-0.0395549312,
-0.0478765853,
0.0146925515,
0.0253314078,
-0.002422557,
-0.0027777415,
0.0281966627,
0.011068821,
0.0472909957,
-0.05913103,
-0.0013592566,
-0.067748107,
0.0375783816,
0.0517010018,
0.0064639719,
-0.0012628655,
0.0396420546,
0.010408151,
0.0059484681,
-0.0421832316,
-0.0103609022,
0.0147404792,
0.0683181584,
0.0070287711,
0.0240416005,
0.0307567362,
-0.0090714917,
-0.05603268,
-0.0025409041,
-0.0228174347,
0.0609353632,
0.0338585675,
0.0247836541,
-0.068469353,
-0.0260247234,
-0.0491499081,
0.012644656,
-0.043741826,
-0.0078475792,
0.0719604045,
0.0356889591,
0.0072337855,
-0.0073640565,
0.0508206077,
-0.0078717843,
-0.0189943556,
0.0329710804,
0.0005050797,
-0.0241811443,
-0.002362262,
0.0545687638,
-0.0369129628,
-0.0072144931,
0.0327527821,
0.0300899167,
-0.0196104459,
-0.000801363,
0.0454318821,
0.0244171899,
-0.0676183701,
-0.0100117642,
-0.0513837524,
0.049091287,
-0.046282243,
0.0275804512,
0.0431346968,
0.0438210182,
0.0107590491,
0.0597838312,
0.0061013671,
-0.0165938772,
-0.0329879746,
-0.0021248744,
0.0131023303,
-0.0008726963,
-0.0008819703,
0.0099101504,
-0.0127272075,
0.019392563,
0.0310709495,
-0.0329064056,
0.023564091,
0.0497551225,
2.496e-7,
0.0353240445,
0.0059318384,
0.0737138838,
0.0093922503,
0.0119595192,
0.0057257428,
-0.0140855974,
0.0106751211,
0.0050671799,
-0.0127887605,
-0.006763937,
0.0347210728,
0.0175608564,
0.0188182071,
-0.087554574,
-0.0052372757,
-0.0410769805,
-0.0334423669,
-0.0695621148,
-0.0049089477,
0.0790209472,
0.0881415755,
-0.0145727331,
-0.0184602104,
0.0104792956,
-0.0944644213,
0.0464357138,
-0.0100778649,
-0.0039803828,
-0.0047656731,
0.0071407002,
0.0078894012,
0.0259484481,
0.0058090924,
0.0224078186,
0.0276777931,
-0.0110731702,
0.0844230577,
0.0013499712,
-0.0538634025,
-0.0153077478,
-0.032077916,
-0.0116036525,
-0.0556396618,
0.0872613639,
-0.0452130139,
0.0140237147,
-0.0104638301,
-0.0078082778,
-0.0098175779,
-0.0090365671,
0.0234696735,
-0.015013556,
0.0093357526,
0.0238276273,
0.0136787407,
0.0091006085,
-0.1294441074,
-0.0121349832,
0.0149152335,
-0.0405422747,
0.0001136127,
-0.0206545424,
0.0215775296,
0.0136022652,
-0.0387046337,
-0.0376024246,
2.78295808e-34,
0.0533415899,
0.0186436586,
0.0197331831,
0.0037186835,
0.0544652194,
-0.0032715891,
-0.0531963781,
0.0151177133,
0.0043449788,
-0.0990756676,
-0.0405231528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13114v1 | Multi-Stage Balanced Distillation: Addressing Long-Tail Challenges in Sequence-Level Knowledge Distillation | 2024-06-19T00:01:14 | 2024-06-19T00:01:14 | Yuhang Zhou, Jing Zhu, Paiheng Xu, Xiaoyu Liu, Xiyao Wang, Danai Koutra, Wei Ai, Furong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced various natural
language processing tasks, but deploying them remains computationally
expensive. Knowledge distillation (KD) is a promising solution, enabling the
transfer of capabilities from larger teacher LLMs to more compact student
models. Particularly, sequence-level KD, which distills rationale-based
reasoning processes instead of merely final outcomes, shows great potential in
enhancing students' reasoning capabilities. However, current methods struggle
with sequence level KD under long-tailed data distributions, adversely
affecting generalization on sparsely represented domains. We introduce the
Multi-Stage Balanced Distillation (BalDistill) framework, which iteratively
balances training data within a fixed computational budget. By dynamically
selecting representative head domain examples and synthesizing tail domain
examples, BalDistill achieves state-of-the-art performance across diverse
long-tailed datasets, enhancing both the efficiency and efficacy of the
distilled models. | [
0.0216982011,
0.0510330573,
-0.0125757577,
0.0104120718,
-0.052081842,
0.0347297601,
-0.0209114235,
-0.0473377034,
-0.0199205857,
-0.0177310035,
0.0442187488,
-0.0353786573,
-0.0036318977,
0.0322938971,
-0.0088094287,
-0.0637541264,
0.0118304668,
-0.0502153486,
0.033893913,
0.006615811,
-0.0062816474,
0.0238081552,
-0.0247619003,
0.0347951762,
0.0534260161,
-0.0357963704,
-0.0264106914,
-0.0324269123,
0.0258572996,
-0.0128307622,
0.0061696698,
0.0718809664,
0.0495694317,
-0.0040697027,
0.0000022336,
-0.0515171438,
-0.004890542,
0.0020099713,
-0.047292579,
0.0133382268,
-0.022916995,
0.0330450125,
0.0345484838,
0.0119116344,
-0.0402393602,
0.0258981828,
0.0103916517,
0.0168541018,
0.0676788166,
0.0459037907,
0.0199519768,
-0.084866561,
0.0044957264,
-0.0220585205,
0.0091787856,
-0.0031784694,
0.0237185173,
0.0089322971,
0.0158453472,
-0.0305565186,
-0.0482558347,
0.016873125,
0.0327877551,
-0.0103205349,
-0.0430007316,
0.019456381,
-0.0452164151,
-0.0436511748,
0.0166132469,
0.0725145563,
-0.0206286535,
-0.0158332363,
0.0244970862,
-0.0015013163,
0.0131246885,
0.0015134386,
-0.0620296933,
0.0217029061,
-0.0098786345,
0.0363382027,
0.0055697691,
-0.0012528143,
0.0156602263,
0.0093619181,
-0.058183074,
0.0335694291,
-0.017019026,
-0.0128100915,
0.0223735757,
0.0066237804,
-0.083641544,
-0.0251289923,
0.0057807309,
0.0461969972,
0.0072510983,
0.0200648755,
-0.0219208524,
-0.0160423145,
0.0139628993,
0.0292318128,
0.0143315373,
0.0402533859,
0.0002294423,
0.0185538866,
-0.0036954009,
0.0303783771,
0.028896343,
0.0225736573,
-0.0103304721,
0.0089137591,
-0.0923061222,
-0.0066925366,
-0.0050453744,
0.0458417535,
-0.0729937255,
-0.0038758132,
-0.0251777507,
-0.0131484335,
-0.0324900337,
-0.030729901,
0.0480403751,
0.0412951298,
-0.0180022828,
0.0037895453,
-0.0422499329,
0.09045811,
-0.0486141145,
0.023567019,
0.0540957525,
-0.0159833841,
-0.0363580883,
-0.0101819402,
0.0220113974,
-0.0242151283,
-0.0075129038,
0.0511342697,
-0.0129280444,
-0.0328883342,
-0.0659166947,
-0.0473267846,
-0.0381070264,
-0.1065356955,
0.0101978946,
-0.0746975541,
0.0260786247,
0.0038805983,
0.0026645886,
-0.0656318069,
0.0309547391,
-0.011569269,
0.0012730514,
0.0489252321,
0.0290941093,
-0.0099377204,
-0.0288769063,
0.0460304618,
-0.0166105106,
0.091823265,
0.0210312661,
-0.0005852691,
0.0007197947,
-0.0279038176,
-0.0293281507,
-0.0208081789,
0.0359236896,
-0.006139555,
-0.0433324873,
-0.0016132015,
-0.0470199585,
0.0181716271,
0.0261479579,
0.033792913,
-0.0305451248,
0.0132732373,
0.0432845764,
0.0329086259,
0.0208376087,
-0.0309338626,
0.0282662734,
0.0105311526,
-0.0237146784,
0.066607438,
-0.0464032814,
-0.0000493136,
0.0042039691,
0.0244415812,
0.0169414803,
0.0631161109,
-0.0123349093,
-0.0637568235,
0.0091807805,
0.0159863885,
0.0086865164,
0.0325531028,
0.0553026535,
0.0432104394,
0.0028219447,
0.0513126254,
0.050584618,
-0.048001118,
0.0377651267,
-0.0384691432,
0.0161074065,
0.0328770615,
0.0257965252,
-0.0225376226,
-0.0322947539,
-0.0214464497,
0.0342988074,
0.0063157105,
-0.0038951109,
-0.0335264616,
0.0162084345,
-0.0499492362,
-0.0696504712,
0.0010052095,
0.0255963616,
-0.0224067885,
0.0243855957,
0.0017948899,
0.0381589122,
-0.092152983,
-0.0314090475,
0.0163170006,
-0.0555155948,
-0.0679333434,
-0.0292784236,
0.0246292371,
0.0325582698,
0.0118784234,
-0.0101623787,
0.0038025819,
0.045660764,
-0.043309968,
-0.0303211659,
-0.0538391918,
-0.0331267118,
-0.0854206309,
0.0575185791,
-0.0445706137,
-0.0063471422,
0.0200620331,
-0.0722056031,
-0.062586315,
0.0159748215,
0.0190486424,
0.0203863997,
-0.0179882832,
0.0460970178,
0.0225232374,
0.0296081118,
-0.0394842401,
0.0598864034,
-0.0243737828,
-0.0135582294,
-0.0268268771,
-0.0675402731,
-0.047682602,
0.0087676328,
-0.009127846,
0.0176055524,
-0.0229242686,
0.0049113901,
0.0183754358,
-0.0011864125,
-0.0351265557,
0.0096017988,
-0.0158227608,
0.0228829682,
-0.0337935127,
0.0221138466,
-0.0116345193,
0.02664648,
0.0119110374,
0.0128455432,
-0.0244428311,
-0.0368480943,
-0.0009805663,
0.0178170931,
0.0045252875,
0.0089620138,
-0.0173260421,
0.0040080836,
-0.0262522586,
-0.0187222771,
0.0475946926,
-0.0410713144,
0.0215967409,
-0.0048740967,
0.0363992453,
-0.0296497103,
0.0195498373,
-0.0031583724,
0.0091832587,
0.0165842902,
-0.0089774644,
0.0397339277,
0.0313784927,
-0.0004735275,
0.0158200823,
0.0633318946,
-0.0124200005,
-0.0615779944,
0.0257990863,
-0.0472464934,
0.0278311577,
-0.0245678294,
-0.0016319355,
-0.0145333176,
0.0842899531,
-0.0115895132,
-0.0265681259,
-0.0410055295,
0.0144215748,
0.0064759576,
-0.0035232089,
-0.0544383824,
0.0057173348,
-0.0094888331,
0.0459777638,
-0.0317673683,
-0.0245429762,
0.0966807604,
-0.0048050671,
0.0137883183,
-0.0523133911,
0.0022558775,
-0.0297751557,
0.062809445,
-0.0251118112,
-0.0290719569,
0.0287296996,
0.0109779099,
-0.0636517406,
-0.0201305375,
0.0199035611,
-0.0273149237,
0.0795716196,
-0.0928039178,
-0.0301249586,
-0.0027180417,
-0.0220936481,
-0.0439014733,
0.0056099324,
-0.0007431719,
0.0170703772,
0.007098482,
-0.0092194565,
-0.0414333157,
0.0114235133,
0.0241152272,
0.0437926352,
0.0010931236,
0.0076866499,
-0.0314087309,
0.0365905277,
0.0568262748,
0.0021993641,
0.0174833741,
-0.0137617597,
0.0519328415,
0.0479780696,
0.0420728065,
-0.0411438234,
0.0150295682,
0.004432498,
0.0323005095,
-0.040213,
-0.0059256819,
0.0373159312,
0.0432262383,
-0.0745488629,
-0.0062975707,
0.1019513756,
0.0215852018,
0.0157910641,
0.0108880708,
0.0452626161,
0.0920248777,
0.028834682,
-0.0147252167,
-0.0874639302,
-0.0613141246,
0.0150512438,
0.0339665636,
0.0071334844,
-0.040216431,
-0.0053856703,
-0.1132937595,
0.0278898384,
0.0165038258,
-0.00610808,
-0.037494272,
-0.0564308912,
-0.0156407151,
-0.0150117027,
0.0118220523,
0.0085853059,
-0.018704759,
0.0282396916,
0.056256894,
-0.0000494468,
-0.0752733201,
0.0154928481,
-0.0081457142,
-0.0179615039,
0.0333274156,
0.0347494818,
0.0326001905,
-0.0566380136,
-0.0064365859,
-0.0427512378,
-0.0008591051,
0.0065231384,
0.0284316503,
0.0252508409,
0.0133926235,
-0.004624492,
0.0778914914,
-0.0698374659,
-0.0199207608,
0.0392300412,
0.0949689373,
-0.015437237,
-0.0534537621,
-0.0481713526,
-0.0208671615,
0.0127240848,
0.0822314769,
0.0637046918,
-0.0288419984,
-0.0434865318,
-0.0149216894,
-0.0588134602,
-0.0340002812,
-0.0010897642,
-0.0059599117,
-0.001595741,
0.0105341021,
-0.0447128676,
-0.0093964282,
0.0385829993,
0.0422202535,
-0.0007731072,
0.013207715,
0.0201204289,
0.0095450487,
-0.0548867136,
0.0219600517,
-0.0126976511,
0.0068020131,
-0.0263869949,
0.0058334223,
-0.0329029076,
-0.0276602805,
-0.0525172725,
0.0409723632,
-0.0842368081,
-0.0833478644,
0.0153582664,
0.0152786318,
0.0273392126,
0.0697496757,
0.0141464723,
-0.0171312243,
0.0661811382,
0.0217593163,
0.0131238718,
-0.0194686688,
0.0257635638,
-0.0359834433,
0.0101921493,
0.0247328803,
0.0013354848,
0.0272859912,
0.0276980698,
0.0731815621,
-0.0191469025,
0.0161175393,
0.0175533369,
0.0169610083,
0.0957524702,
0.0139067685,
-0.0117348451,
-0.0312918536,
0.0183459278,
0.0207198691,
-0.01821924,
-0.032441508,
0.003243139,
0.0428971387,
0.0018006103,
0.0003366382,
0.0152056236,
0.022070488,
0.0035923873,
-0.0283278897,
0.0331874937,
0.0029911001,
-0.0188073125,
0.0601633303,
-0.0180340912,
0.0080443658,
0.0574265867,
-0.0054475432,
0.054702498,
0.0040926575,
0.0399510413,
0.022863064,
0.0697883591,
0.0240929201,
-0.0109676812,
-0.0837237537,
-0.029113939,
-0.0299709756,
-0.0175717454,
0.0251011979,
-0.0120781232,
0.030575525,
-0.0021548127,
-0.0076287165,
-0.0161870886,
0.0384090059,
-0.00970513,
0.0007983058,
-0.0060765804,
0.0415320545,
-0.0180249754,
-0.0144090652,
0.0879924893,
-0.0072255209,
0.0595125034,
-0.0149124702,
-0.0005972283,
-0.0178554971,
-0.0928584114,
0.0165454317,
0.0380933844,
0.0237530284,
-0.0024011084,
-0.0708450675,
-0.0837097839,
-0.0152101237,
-0.0289156474,
0.0118609052,
-0.0388419926,
0.0367325433,
0.0259372611,
-0.0472894311,
-0.0225023236,
-0.0212191585,
-0.0083274767,
-0.0225997977,
-0.0243707057,
-0.0183849279,
-6.633222052e-33,
0.0032705737,
0.0080172271,
0.0177408289,
-0.0067948834,
-0.0067546251,
-0.0028017326,
-0.0106429104,
-0.0136893261,
-0.0045672785,
0.0376022235,
0.0059269462,
0.0316239111,
0.0163284764,
0.0507157184,
0.012331306,
0.0197422374,
0.0649931431,
0.0284994356,
-0.0199894849,
0.0403435305,
0.0562325679,
0.0381637104,
0.0388982445,
-0.0177118592,
0.00742942,
0.0126636596,
0.0287603829,
0.0169848017,
-0.0433358513,
0.0206682868,
0.0051867533,
0.0645429194,
0.0004863652,
-0.0690136328,
-0.0356503353,
-0.0089077326,
-0.1069965139,
-0.0367432572,
0.0397201441,
-0.0436948873,
0.0002256353,
-0.0325707085,
0.0396858752,
0.0176574197,
0.0232356191,
-0.0431220829,
0.0293807872,
-0.0178626925,
-0.0221103355,
-0.0395561233,
-0.0524425432,
0.0268717967,
-0.0412852466,
-0.0403832085,
-0.0078612231,
0.0255544968,
0.0001416322,
0.0073834131,
-0.0495181046,
0.0289222617,
0.0657851696,
0.06070254,
0.0699974447,
0.0197473522,
-0.0244704671,
0.0589747094,
-0.0216727722,
-0.0186926555,
-0.02710074,
0.0090605142,
0.0341166668,
0.0661588237,
0.0046783192,
0.0197731815,
0.0899636969,
-0.0172144696,
-0.0688263327,
0.0136315702,
-0.007995938,
0.0373454243,
-0.0048505245,
-0.0000459928,
-0.0089983866,
-0.04022488,
-0.0665446669,
-0.0080312015,
-0.0130796591,
0.0163512304,
0.0330926739,
-0.0050602332,
-0.0501829349,
-0.0101558389,
0.0059764283,
-0.0384754241,
0.0118560977,
0.048573371,
0.0011687998,
-0.0347902514,
0.0145963151,
0.0064333887,
-0.0412460938,
-0.0204485022,
0.0298759118,
0.0087599214,
-0.0013314541,
0.0024248438,
0.053441532,
-0.0057075853,
-0.022779461,
-0.0108772181,
-0.0524146035,
0.0410013683,
0.0065666777,
0.0689240396,
0.0570362434,
0.0270706248,
-0.0219473224,
-0.0026445547,
0.0110253775,
-0.0435121767,
-0.0008311034,
0.0354232378,
0.0109222773,
0.0200778656,
0.000271866,
-0.0329457596,
-0.0057416647,
-0.0259351879,
0.0165277552,
-0.0403176844,
-0.0033432867,
0.0207731165,
2.932e-7,
0.0407039896,
-0.0026931267,
0.0227437504,
-0.0091704251,
-0.0084653497,
0.0046668849,
-0.0005742767,
-0.016877098,
0.0181205999,
-0.0634831637,
-0.01170542,
0.0562207736,
0.0465016216,
0.0275451951,
-0.0900051594,
-0.0497228429,
-0.0171909053,
-0.0360999405,
-0.038267184,
-0.0278530382,
0.0713013187,
0.0521656647,
0.0259101149,
-0.0356430635,
0.0240975879,
-0.0145596238,
-0.0016775621,
0.0342696495,
0.0546220131,
0.028882226,
-0.0041474137,
-0.0416643508,
0.0233666841,
0.0403197668,
-0.0311527736,
0.0229554512,
-0.0439702608,
0.0820164084,
0.0020348406,
-0.0116630662,
-0.0111801382,
0.0140537592,
0.0102576902,
-0.0278710201,
0.0696683079,
-0.0939803123,
-0.0268178955,
-0.0127693545,
-0.0465446711,
-0.0373926684,
0.0170903318,
0.0216622651,
0.0484420657,
0.0225871783,
-0.0157680772,
-0.0285750031,
-0.0146818999,
-0.0971372649,
-0.0158143491,
0.0154308872,
-0.0275910944,
-0.0408381522,
-0.0274571646,
-0.0587475225,
0.0084867347,
-0.0488421991,
-0.0115806255,
2.964624992e-34,
0.0316668488,
0.0094299791,
0.0136937173,
-0.012200336,
0.0289823376,
-0.0167208239,
-0.0544287339,
-0.0047558928,
0.0119781373,
-0.0523316152,
-0.0230802894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13106v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13106v3 | Accelerating Complex Disease Treatment through Network Medicine and GenAI: A Case Study on Drug Repurposing for Breast Cancer | 2024-06-18T23:40:00 | 2024-06-27T08:28:51 | Ahmed Abdeen Hamed, Tamer E. Fandy | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2; I.2.6 | The objective of this research is to introduce a network specialized in
predicting drugs that can be repurposed by investigating real-world evidence
sources, such as clinical trials and biomedical literature. Specifically, it
aims to generate drug combination therapies for complex diseases (e.g., cancer,
Alzheimer's). We present a multilayered network medicine approach, empowered by
a highly configured ChatGPT prompt engineering system, which is constructed on
the fly to extract drug mentions in clinical trials. Additionally, we introduce
a novel algorithm that connects real-world evidence with disease-specific
signaling pathways (e.g., KEGG database). This sheds light on the
repurposability of drugs if they are found to bind with one or more protein
constituents of a signaling pathway. To demonstrate, we instantiated the
framework for breast cancer and found that, out of 46 breast cancer signaling
pathways, the framework identified 38 pathways that were covered by at least
two drugs. This evidence signals the potential for combining those drugs.
Specifically, the most covered signaling pathway, ID hsa:2064, was covered by
108 drugs, some of which can be combined. Conversely, the signaling pathway ID
hsa:1499 was covered by only two drugs, indicating a significant gap for
further research. Our network medicine framework, empowered by GenAI, shows
promise in identifying drug combinations with a high degree of specificity,
knowing the exact signaling pathways and proteins that serve as targets. It is
noteworthy that ChatGPT successfully accelerated the process of identifying
drug mentions in clinical trials, though further investigations are required to
determine the relationships among the drug mentions. | [
0.019218808,
0.0600151159,
-0.0394447632,
-0.0068376861,
-0.0200718865,
-0.0125406738,
0.0278282557,
0.0348895527,
0.0669943392,
0.0157423336,
0.0125556663,
0.0347345546,
-0.0179460049,
0.1162898466,
0.0087288152,
0.010821566,
0.0211497527,
0.0413863882,
-0.008173435,
-0.0116067575,
-0.0102101229,
0.0008218821,
0.0078864908,
0.0372480154,
0.0075655105,
-0.0237962473,
0.0424778089,
-0.033394739,
0.0226615109,
-0.0287163612,
-0.0029377872,
-0.019464964,
-0.0544532724,
0.0326907225,
0.0000018561,
-0.0691606402,
-0.0371962339,
0.0246214084,
-0.0143358493,
-0.0163557027,
0.0374176651,
0.0100023076,
0.00166751,
-0.0197460223,
0.017225666,
0.0061011617,
0.023130117,
0.0543309189,
-0.0046560722,
0.0258997139,
-0.0050295284,
0.0152327586,
0.0736534223,
-0.0161432754,
0.0468327291,
-0.043511916,
0.0632417202,
-0.03141753,
0.0759175718,
-0.0227178242,
0.0300417803,
0.0478978716,
-0.0343559235,
-0.0249998402,
0.059891358,
0.026339164,
0.0387688801,
-0.0232218616,
-0.058825437,
0.0474326983,
-0.0055492944,
-0.0186163466,
0.0152371842,
-0.0006996716,
-0.0230658613,
0.0593995564,
-0.0186606273,
-0.0544743873,
-0.0580805875,
-0.0098457178,
-0.0087316819,
-0.024861671,
0.0342690907,
-0.0310482066,
0.018049892,
0.0278185084,
-0.0178447478,
0.034247525,
-0.0029890388,
-0.0380882919,
0.0191285685,
-0.0041347346,
0.0380339175,
-0.00701808,
-0.0272508841,
-0.0053940928,
0.0633406714,
-0.0089888163,
0.0707421154,
-0.0314492621,
-0.0004035484,
-0.0210157912,
0.000294356,
0.042545937,
-0.0299136564,
-0.0521345511,
-0.0736382455,
-0.0043363841,
-0.0453568771,
0.0328697674,
-0.0818939954,
-0.0150234373,
0.0001068532,
0.0533504114,
-0.0335955843,
-0.0373215526,
-0.0625871643,
0.051488854,
-0.0418222919,
0.0068880641,
0.0498730801,
0.0493173078,
0.0374675877,
0.016996311,
-0.0113374498,
-0.0105297957,
0.0096290112,
0.0176738948,
0.0024747739,
-0.0310209896,
0.0172650088,
-0.0382410921,
0.020621866,
0.0101256073,
0.0088608358,
0.1152941957,
-0.0087974314,
-0.0030612417,
0.0038107159,
-0.0640316829,
-0.0175636597,
-0.0458886065,
0.0120650604,
-0.0280202907,
0.0475391559,
-0.0145570086,
0.0207357053,
-0.000096791,
-0.0152943917,
-0.0372796692,
-0.0523007698,
0.0435539186,
-0.0104928305,
-0.0237695295,
0.0408969745,
0.0051206765,
-0.0577382222,
-0.0277706757,
-0.0037037302,
-0.0069386247,
0.0152756367,
0.0302875936,
0.0018834221,
0.0017589616,
0.0361893103,
-0.0299620181,
0.0589516237,
0.0156039856,
0.037331745,
0.0349668488,
-0.0866153687,
-0.0147647094,
-0.0271774922,
0.0110717639,
0.0165931135,
0.0406031422,
0.081573233,
0.0519733131,
-0.0010647476,
-0.0342037119,
-0.0147812823,
-0.0454916954,
-0.0221031271,
0.0156622268,
-0.0551942065,
0.028783584,
-0.0022504907,
0.0406741053,
0.0000339448,
-0.0161668267,
-0.0044802497,
-0.0254294313,
-0.0352274328,
-0.01837801,
0.0152920103,
-0.028641453,
-0.0229528919,
-0.0556547791,
0.0583647676,
0.0202164669,
-0.0240051243,
-0.0462687165,
-0.0252141356,
0.0721072853,
0.0571649186,
-0.034622509,
-0.0079552419,
0.0095740492,
-0.0347085744,
-0.0529277287,
-0.013293297,
-0.0165277608,
-0.0195914302,
0.0392684415,
0.0051934738,
0.0328774005,
0.0282230321,
0.0312237758,
-0.031870082,
-0.0047062291,
-0.0743324459,
-0.0321036205,
0.0158339757,
-0.0057199574,
-0.0275709312,
0.0043197656,
0.0136322305,
-0.0082664629,
0.0398671068,
0.0383161716,
0.0011547637,
0.0362181589,
0.0583564751,
-0.071258828,
-0.060367085,
-0.015308395,
0.0607193075,
-0.0040416964,
-0.0382313319,
-0.0515086316,
0.0265205521,
-0.0382875577,
-0.0514166206,
-0.0122816283,
0.0352484658,
0.0051937979,
0.0195976645,
0.0287964158,
-0.0158944242,
0.0073632733,
0.0047400012,
-0.0161377639,
0.0147446934,
0.0410424359,
-0.0554719493,
0.0302829463,
-0.0566162653,
0.0319210775,
-0.0007767545,
0.0398622639,
-0.0039339629,
0.0100563383,
0.0015812967,
-0.0068974714,
-0.0431966148,
-0.0087628979,
-0.0104136281,
-0.0168401133,
0.0067430693,
0.05527303,
0.0345045514,
-0.0097549828,
0.0105355363,
0.0022707402,
-0.031622909,
-0.0189070776,
0.0391485468,
-0.0086668367,
-0.0126853818,
0.0193067566,
0.0484007597,
-0.0764108971,
-0.0371251553,
-0.0351109356,
-0.0384358093,
0.0726334378,
0.0301170629,
-0.0647235736,
0.0010215621,
-0.0165417418,
-0.0258598402,
0.0056601027,
-0.0092966594,
0.0364710577,
-0.0062594325,
0.034555845,
-0.0141645949,
0.0045852773,
-0.0574257337,
-0.0104785888,
0.0297933947,
-0.0167032238,
0.0118995132,
-0.0174326878,
-0.0609956831,
-0.0405004323,
0.0595979691,
-0.0039942181,
0.0009493092,
0.0124699604,
0.0267591793,
-0.0202998053,
0.0020330362,
-0.0324266404,
-0.0034560086,
0.0063768714,
-0.0581256784,
-0.0236237291,
0.0008508186,
0.0274759997,
0.0104022631,
-0.0372180194,
0.1198866516,
0.0053279083,
0.0466746651,
-0.0709367692,
-0.0072607812,
-0.0182211101,
-0.0216518883,
0.0355996117,
0.025600601,
0.0565050021,
0.0456474908,
0.0277895983,
-0.0089982804,
0.0469996743,
-0.0082855718,
0.0287982058,
-0.0081620226,
0.0703075901,
0.0373235382,
-0.0361955352,
-0.038150046,
0.0767602175,
0.001120289,
-0.0056993058,
0.0504270829,
0.0086370762,
-0.0446610339,
0.0070622461,
-0.0414672196,
0.0094731357,
0.0133828176,
-0.0255048014,
0.0058584502,
-0.0229041614,
0.0058420021,
-0.1071767807,
-0.0138470279,
0.0294222068,
0.0834280774,
0.0271348562,
-0.0175738633,
-0.0161600336,
-0.0138170375,
0.0525996089,
-0.0344353504,
-0.0187581163,
-0.0102032823,
0.0288130045,
0.0021276847,
-0.0294579156,
0.010048748,
0.0149363959,
0.0373114161,
-0.0631379709,
0.0015391188,
0.0297251269,
-0.0599816926,
-0.0366868228,
0.0651256219,
-0.124419719,
-0.0101346616,
-0.0275227949,
-0.0025169221,
-0.0281221569,
-0.0229566097,
-0.0289175436,
-0.0044235205,
0.050801903,
0.0228757653,
-0.0410378762,
0.050165683,
-0.1000085771,
-0.0191179924,
-0.0427222848,
-0.0271004122,
-0.0143004889,
0.0104030697,
-0.0394866019,
-0.0336620435,
-0.0157791078,
-0.0716102049,
-0.0027532834,
0.0026944811,
0.0401500575,
-0.0259249136,
0.0165998582,
0.0294513032,
0.006171356,
-0.005296567,
0.0386799537,
0.0326576382,
-0.0147778392,
0.0990651473,
0.0275808088,
0.0241023693,
-0.091121316,
0.0521440692,
-0.0317957364,
-0.050734397,
-0.0303366985,
0.0911933109,
-0.0369280763,
-0.0191852152,
-0.0971863568,
-0.030245997,
0.0064163371,
0.0425481983,
-0.0123550463,
0.0126435347,
-0.0247455016,
0.0018896323,
0.0264018215,
-0.0161463767,
0.0158643257,
-0.0045495941,
-0.0745045617,
0.0238931943,
-0.0532942005,
0.0060178395,
0.0432562009,
0.0029408697,
0.0138823129,
0.0256543495,
0.035490647,
-0.0398989022,
-0.0234525334,
-0.0024440577,
0.060511034,
0.0160676837,
-0.0131825125,
-0.0653512776,
0.0372258648,
-0.0080368258,
-0.0070916815,
0.0360086113,
-0.0201743823,
-0.0308177546,
-0.0666719824,
0.0149944257,
0.0353433117,
0.0044863368,
-0.0057525164,
0.0232425909,
0.0617342815,
0.0475324467,
0.0158467293,
-0.0559571981,
-0.0516335703,
-0.0166895352,
-0.0294889733,
-0.0283513404,
-0.0362599865,
0.0675421283,
-0.0015854321,
-0.0129060196,
0.0184420645,
0.0364821143,
0.0673875511,
0.0246180296,
0.0473177284,
0.0100145331,
-0.0317753777,
-0.0458194986,
0.02270169,
-0.0091331312,
0.0381040014,
-0.0101975296,
-0.0103173843,
-0.0185907818,
-0.0235349573,
0.0440405346,
0.0051808627,
-0.0199769009,
-0.030569125,
-0.0594704449,
-0.0309977382,
0.0295302644,
0.0138075491,
0.0530131459,
-0.007803617,
0.0148413954,
-0.0063332506,
-0.0503226221,
-0.0060619144,
-0.0158111136,
0.0015661999,
0.0013092521,
0.0190401543,
-0.0479387827,
0.0346343443,
-0.0562006198,
-0.0701303184,
-0.0160036683,
0.0699987933,
0.07553453,
0.0301562827,
0.0637290999,
-0.021474611,
-0.0040109865,
-0.0474370942,
-0.0195232015,
-0.0091911415,
0.0474461429,
-0.0094775306,
0.0180279482,
0.0032884153,
-0.0569696687,
0.0554770641,
-0.0117083825,
0.0262487549,
-0.0353382528,
-0.0530516095,
-0.0300094653,
-0.0176933035,
0.0262353625,
0.036300905,
-0.053122066,
-0.0202711802,
-0.032253366,
-0.012092378,
0.0218687057,
0.0323354937,
-0.017920481,
0.0273524076,
-0.0076393248,
0.0096946871,
0.0461733527,
-0.0435911193,
-0.0021760894,
0.0043165209,
-0.0350270346,
-0.0503071174,
0.0091608735,
-5.596317015e-33,
0.0719281361,
-0.0211752951,
-0.0068700043,
0.0449277088,
0.034811344,
0.0308143422,
-0.0647955909,
-0.0230344571,
0.0631923527,
0.0682038292,
0.0094074635,
-0.02259399,
-0.0120567773,
0.0102945883,
-0.0284737907,
0.0074406825,
0.0189029891,
0.0396356024,
0.0125993099,
0.018994892,
0.0386088528,
0.0678113997,
-0.0423101746,
-0.0114223845,
0.0071111852,
0.0153184654,
0.0230373796,
0.0054374775,
-0.0363969803,
0.079813987,
-0.0090534883,
0.0512461364,
-0.0262925774,
-0.0262216646,
0.0028668281,
-0.0069989134,
-0.0591934621,
0.0144610079,
0.0105428267,
-0.0580896512,
-0.0065628956,
0.0213180557,
0.0168994218,
-0.0235544387,
-0.020459367,
-0.0049896166,
0.0445724949,
-0.0120865433,
-0.0488921441,
-0.0113267638,
-0.021800654,
0.0079568559,
-0.0021231305,
0.028917728,
-0.0466304049,
-0.0235427134,
-0.004024317,
-0.0017795397,
-0.0412939824,
0.0296041481,
-0.0109507432,
0.0046775676,
0.0145672718,
-0.0301301293,
0.0237085223,
0.0715789273,
0.000591136,
-0.0141047938,
0.0381054245,
-0.0081028491,
-0.0499548614,
0.0566276237,
0.013413772,
0.0023967316,
-0.0167589467,
-0.010282225,
-0.1076322868,
0.0175602809,
-0.0184035655,
-0.0125510776,
0.0110716056,
0.0257893484,
0.0138468565,
-0.0165280309,
0.0079969876,
0.00674927,
-0.0580228902,
-0.0183867682,
0.0123702949,
-0.0196349174,
-0.02999001,
0.0519534498,
0.0028833575,
-0.0564568751,
-0.0141268475,
0.0206070542,
0.0470522977,
0.0036665716,
-0.0217066631,
-0.0123091349,
-0.0133818956,
-0.0051478678,
-0.0037070066,
-0.0266768187,
0.0105673447,
0.0085718213,
0.0252067894,
-0.0301388223,
-0.0104218721,
0.0353397578,
-0.0412817821,
-0.0016614151,
0.0193302371,
-0.0219971761,
0.0243757647,
0.056928385,
0.0198456682,
0.0500003956,
0.0315256678,
0.0376734659,
-0.0388202667,
0.0488995351,
-0.0190052632,
-0.0078569753,
-0.081488803,
0.0012589297,
-0.0233172216,
0.0369095281,
0.0272251852,
-0.0570614971,
-0.0342659466,
0.0298931077,
2.823e-7,
0.0472908653,
0.0130840763,
0.0209777281,
-0.0169864204,
0.0612559207,
-0.0076346952,
-0.0268513542,
0.010592863,
-0.0141593786,
-0.0075065535,
0.0491117761,
-0.0204210728,
0.0212471709,
-0.0156067554,
-0.0246845987,
-0.0215750933,
-0.0260145422,
-0.0498415828,
-0.061768733,
-0.0166934524,
0.0364718325,
0.0083051352,
0.0536542945,
-0.0350569114,
0.0574623309,
-0.009571773,
-0.0118424892,
-0.0316740051,
0.0133971889,
0.0395703092,
-0.0172564946,
-0.0333323851,
-0.0220506247,
0.0483562201,
-0.011097189,
-0.0520499982,
-0.0522300936,
0.0140620014,
-0.0195331424,
0.0362202711,
0.0481492877,
-0.0203259028,
0.0325123258,
-0.0378806405,
0.0065366705,
-0.0526256859,
-0.0641274676,
0.0002537502,
0.0269142538,
-0.0521996953,
0.0760775134,
0.0063527725,
0.0119660981,
0.046569176,
-0.0137643488,
0.0740431994,
0.0117755728,
-0.0272007715,
0.0749722496,
0.0769813955,
-0.0329306908,
-0.0262397248,
-0.0004968641,
-0.0279105194,
0.0614586286,
-0.0573877878,
0.0129672782,
2.160280126e-34,
0.0554462336,
-0.0042946385,
0.0412831455,
0.0252510607,
0.0407191887,
-0.0269839782,
-0.0119041875,
-0.0196966808,
-0.019375883,
-0.075885199,
-0.0181802791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13094v1 | Exploring and Benchmarking the Planning Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T22:57:06 | 2024-06-18T22:57:06 | Bernd Bohnet, Azade Nova, Aaron T Parisi, Kevin Swersky, Katayoon Goshvadi, Hanjun Dai, Dale Schuurmans, Noah Fiedel, Hanie Sedghi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We seek to elevate the planning capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs)investigating four main directions. First, we construct a comprehensive
benchmark suite encompassing both classical planning domains and natural
language scenarios. This suite includes algorithms to generate instances with
varying levels of difficulty, allowing for rigorous and systematic evaluation
of LLM performance. Second, we investigate the use of in-context learning (ICL)
to enhance LLM planning, exploring the direct relationship between increased
context length and improved planning performance. Third, we demonstrate the
positive impact of fine-tuning LLMs on optimal planning paths, as well as the
effectiveness of incorporating model-driven search procedures. Finally, we
investigate the performance of the proposed methods in out-of-distribution
scenarios, assessing the ability to generalize to novel and unseen planning
challenges. | [
0.0622636713,
0.0483692773,
0.0014934399,
0.034385778,
-0.0621139221,
-0.0160856731,
-0.0091346605,
-0.0127321621,
-0.0103161307,
-0.0379686542,
0.0191380773,
-0.0259774514,
-0.034131255,
0.0244651064,
-0.0118169291,
-0.014207121,
0.0013442942,
-0.0739158764,
-0.019861171,
0.0241944417,
-0.0321922638,
0.0087077441,
0.0036131409,
0.0391569696,
-0.0219340138,
0.0234105457,
-0.0396604203,
0.0311882086,
-0.009376348,
-0.0612401962,
-0.0102402056,
0.0096291844,
0.0435532853,
0.0391880162,
0.0000021036,
-0.0511003807,
-0.0531862713,
-0.0201686099,
-0.0387703627,
0.0157928951,
0.045233991,
-0.0215811748,
-0.0062626195,
0.0338818841,
-0.0262659844,
0.0351803899,
0.0153168347,
0.0252773371,
0.0180411041,
0.0745023936,
-0.0135850655,
-0.0246548522,
-0.0235244278,
-0.0049631386,
-0.0197011996,
-0.0899046436,
0.0161675923,
0.0111766784,
0.0558062233,
0.0222030878,
-0.0137436418,
0.0321307778,
0.0120444214,
0.0033679944,
-0.0431095473,
0.0393386669,
-0.0375843234,
0.0073395744,
-0.0075648334,
0.0672114193,
-0.0276749134,
-0.0052745882,
0.0275964346,
-0.0277504809,
-0.0356214978,
-0.003802377,
-0.0344664641,
0.0164747052,
0.0019664501,
0.0147390533,
-0.0057369899,
-0.0100715961,
0.0501483232,
0.0150851207,
-0.0523719117,
0.0632067397,
0.0033650964,
-0.0335253924,
0.015160067,
-0.0381494053,
-0.0438433588,
-0.0481418744,
0.0169651881,
0.0541756786,
-0.088390097,
0.0375529826,
-0.0048582759,
0.0226889923,
-0.0011382372,
-0.0119492151,
0.0593706109,
0.0290864203,
0.0167248975,
0.065207541,
0.0126917781,
0.055235438,
-0.0303883702,
-0.0377082117,
-0.0411707833,
-0.0077687833,
-0.0590142496,
0.0049977368,
-0.0652757511,
-0.0024427548,
-0.079969421,
-0.0582539402,
0.0037286601,
0.0394607857,
0.0305080563,
0.0374898575,
0.0216992199,
-0.0017774659,
-0.0253713857,
-0.0501728915,
-0.0536354259,
-0.0275327601,
-0.0395194851,
-0.0107790465,
-0.0338902026,
-0.0071599688,
0.0152082583,
0.0122775715,
-0.0055068135,
-0.0210950021,
0.0009118547,
0.0866374746,
-0.0042371689,
-0.0310001709,
-0.0370503031,
-0.0294971466,
-0.0501225181,
-0.0520573594,
-0.0059862668,
-0.0560843535,
-0.0014671198,
0.0028626705,
-0.0122544039,
-0.0216463841,
0.0330546796,
-0.0067511895,
-0.018454371,
0.0477590784,
0.0371929556,
0.0476776585,
0.0124740815,
-0.0133690629,
0.0433096439,
0.115069285,
0.0273346156,
0.0513394065,
0.0042402344,
0.0655342266,
0.0290580317,
0.071798712,
-0.0081962142,
0.030781094,
-0.0203879811,
0.031157827,
0.0148127899,
0.0733056366,
-0.0071461215,
0.0095672952,
-0.0125130499,
0.0006406893,
0.0136899436,
0.0382108316,
0.0155680422,
-0.0065865861,
0.0594484545,
0.0371468104,
-0.0670307577,
-0.0619185567,
-0.0285975877,
-0.0177001562,
-0.0410852768,
0.0037006733,
-0.0174144246,
0.017777374,
-0.0106453421,
-0.034852799,
-0.0382557102,
-0.0048925248,
-0.0009765419,
0.0038734046,
0.0471940935,
0.0025155959,
-0.0875947699,
0.0242335144,
-0.0024746021,
0.0169739574,
-0.0035588106,
-0.036392536,
-0.0254682153,
0.0727362856,
0.0780402943,
-0.0572409555,
-0.0337409154,
0.0246894751,
0.0094511509,
0.0545168146,
0.0134614306,
-0.0229964983,
0.0189825352,
-0.057703916,
-0.0459660143,
-0.0139233815,
0.0011580661,
0.0142976716,
0.057767354,
0.0057662488,
0.0036579631,
-0.0370021947,
-0.021648556,
0.0473468713,
-0.061888475,
-0.0512362495,
-0.0058852597,
-0.0021222585,
0.0404675193,
-0.0226856563,
-0.0159417298,
0.0149621293,
0.0214324668,
-0.0211180542,
-0.0196701251,
-0.025445627,
-0.039551761,
-0.0262009986,
0.0299361311,
-0.0014327775,
0.0024293533,
-0.0246539153,
-0.0276192985,
-0.0162259191,
-0.0095491707,
-0.0350174308,
0.0649791285,
0.0034948392,
0.0521528237,
0.0067578987,
-0.0652652308,
-0.0610257648,
0.0539635532,
-0.0131797716,
-0.0350094587,
0.056854412,
0.0197915472,
0.0113382218,
-0.0271286089,
-0.0037408099,
0.0112895202,
-0.0023508009,
-0.0194338821,
0.0130840167,
0.0284000579,
-0.0345091484,
-0.0709244311,
-0.0952702314,
0.0175168477,
-0.0243576691,
-0.0279904101,
-0.0003381522,
0.0088499086,
-0.0166457705,
0.0114404019,
0.0007948617,
-0.0027045924,
-0.0111951111,
-0.0059812674,
-0.0018353832,
0.0530640595,
-0.0362723246,
-0.0430508554,
-0.0024195197,
-0.0054716864,
0.0219125263,
-0.00073441,
-0.013131965,
-0.0448576324,
0.0708815455,
-0.0246708412,
0.0239970256,
-0.0346610285,
-0.0144484062,
-0.0143065182,
-0.03521448,
0.0508129038,
0.0216681361,
-0.0025364612,
0.0344734043,
0.0679430068,
-0.046930708,
-0.0591072142,
0.0446519591,
-0.0504194982,
-0.0592093021,
-0.0854567289,
-0.026476169,
0.0411114022,
0.0414295681,
-0.0369105116,
0.0347074345,
-0.0576177686,
-0.0105624953,
-0.0137631251,
-0.0449291393,
-0.0116243595,
0.0007118802,
0.0188092645,
0.0783738717,
-0.0237312112,
-0.0305537172,
0.0274900701,
-0.0118174069,
0.0108305849,
-0.0489120968,
0.0073353825,
-0.0477291793,
0.0620082691,
0.0003461021,
0.0423578136,
-0.0168396328,
0.0030312864,
-0.019735191,
-0.0164695978,
-0.0101105291,
0.0106659643,
0.0377168804,
-0.0775972977,
0.027783215,
0.0252114162,
-0.0589162111,
-0.0421675444,
-0.0530921593,
-0.040273957,
0.0207947008,
0.0206720866,
-0.0301487818,
-0.0441081189,
0.0182723179,
0.0073791835,
0.063549906,
0.019305544,
-0.023092797,
-0.0308448076,
-0.0188290942,
0.0573449209,
0.0088042859,
0.0382071733,
-0.0010364668,
0.0217788722,
-0.0121776219,
0.0364081077,
-0.0260159709,
-0.0175865386,
0.008223447,
0.0095516751,
-0.0109064551,
-0.0199214909,
0.0745576769,
0.0384178832,
-0.0314969681,
-0.0538377762,
0.0798127949,
0.054087162,
-0.0228498783,
0.0073866234,
-0.0471090786,
0.0209805313,
0.0413974971,
0.046700947,
-0.022631567,
-0.0274311285,
0.0245877597,
-0.0072672502,
-0.0133273862,
-0.0529198609,
-0.011171408,
-0.1434277594,
0.0523706973,
-0.0018665856,
-0.0386904888,
0.0112602152,
-0.0288064219,
-0.0184608195,
-0.0006778181,
-0.0110101802,
-0.0073469905,
-0.0051218076,
-0.0298441947,
0.0027921922,
-0.0509018376,
-0.0420989878,
0.0104231844,
-0.0073810122,
0.0363069884,
0.0881685913,
0.0319876969,
0.0301582627,
0.0259663351,
0.0458470583,
0.0297317356,
0.0337827727,
-0.0332568996,
0.0062456816,
0.0245109163,
0.0216581542,
0.016315084,
0.0147612002,
-0.03687758,
-0.0424644239,
0.0557474829,
0.0819597915,
-0.0194149166,
0.0125055863,
-0.0183453634,
-0.0009330633,
0.0499766842,
0.0669064224,
-0.0182540826,
-0.0174861643,
-0.0442341752,
-0.0137128979,
-0.0263534263,
-0.0584752373,
-0.0116182519,
-0.0030528994,
0.0083865868,
0.0404894389,
-0.0426209606,
-0.0029671318,
0.058449164,
0.0608087629,
0.0364428237,
0.007293277,
0.0196325183,
0.0203295853,
-0.0155297052,
0.0018776228,
-0.0544048771,
0.026452437,
-0.0553631671,
0.0104074096,
0.0344975814,
-0.0186764672,
-0.0120070791,
0.0346523263,
-0.0517925061,
-0.0750448704,
0.0154894441,
0.0248835478,
0.0186146963,
0.0545398109,
-0.0085812584,
-0.0351426154,
0.0685123056,
-0.0067487834,
-0.0057932348,
0.0138264494,
0.0064677726,
0.0667466447,
0.0060098069,
0.0472233668,
-0.0371902585,
0.0115663242,
0.0252430439,
0.0581546463,
-0.0477747284,
-0.0058929971,
0.0057053082,
0.0099175982,
-0.0028302744,
-0.0321549214,
-0.0424327292,
-0.0008277942,
0.0249179136,
-0.0273076892,
-0.0390530713,
-0.0350254774,
0.0279663112,
0.0311122984,
-0.0162766892,
0.0272823628,
0.0390640348,
0.0050577475,
0.0244602337,
0.0219803657,
-0.0179517455,
0.0321945325,
-0.0320073552,
0.0737479627,
0.0029499934,
0.0229687486,
0.0216934532,
0.0006026466,
0.0451528542,
0.0068290341,
0.0432190299,
0.0186591633,
-0.0030270703,
-0.0700361058,
-0.0431707539,
-0.0197875686,
-0.0647977293,
-0.0085813636,
0.0512079336,
0.0539529435,
-0.0250209756,
0.0198973455,
-0.0655824617,
0.0014635521,
-0.0064855958,
-0.0112918392,
0.0156584159,
-0.0369861647,
0.0487576202,
0.0390934423,
-0.0311143547,
0.0146796154,
0.057811413,
0.0499502905,
0.0887320936,
0.0300280619,
-0.0129443146,
-0.0452465117,
-0.0299668685,
0.0271801576,
0.0432440415,
-0.0071408823,
0.0337535031,
-0.068432875,
-0.027474381,
-0.0000033083,
0.0061668223,
-0.0225781165,
-0.0219612531,
0.0571884587,
0.0579864755,
0.0085343458,
0.006046033,
-0.0302446838,
-0.0353268646,
-0.0088434042,
-0.041493427,
-0.0293523781,
-6.101934972e-33,
-0.0112625528,
-0.0545102544,
0.0795104951,
-0.0724132434,
0.0008585649,
0.0040327222,
-0.0415564775,
0.0224985182,
0.0173810311,
0.0038899353,
-0.0388562083,
0.0010764101,
0.0145740611,
0.0278798938,
0.0021076424,
0.0044887871,
0.0400585346,
-0.0008161085,
-0.0371321924,
0.0027172123,
0.0139529761,
-0.0008120911,
-0.0080002667,
-0.0341236405,
-0.056840498,
0.0144689484,
-0.0081650745,
0.0672024488,
0.019274395,
0.0576008148,
-0.0258432645,
-0.0069971574,
0.0105188182,
-0.0089418963,
-0.0254505537,
-0.0030696846,
-0.0026662743,
-0.0054529714,
0.0193292797,
-0.0243489817,
-0.0191767272,
-0.0322648734,
0.0026871343,
0.0115326038,
-0.0373439305,
0.0192011166,
0.005227847,
-0.0101506952,
-0.0234556496,
0.0033394755,
-0.0738293678,
0.0318709239,
-0.0254619718,
-0.0285090376,
0.0667456388,
0.010718924,
0.008159996,
0.0079624429,
0.0214019474,
0.0286935735,
-0.0214701686,
0.0373153389,
0.0777972937,
0.0388480127,
0.0000502981,
0.0545816272,
-0.0019757752,
0.0232447274,
-0.0074371994,
-0.0524470806,
0.0118935015,
0.0876988322,
-0.0193537418,
0.0619617067,
0.0045188824,
0.0377207622,
-0.0348432362,
0.003072737,
-0.0287785083,
0.0218052696,
0.0757601112,
0.0221314114,
-0.0512452014,
-0.0250076279,
-0.0655274689,
0.0277862661,
-0.0200363807,
0.0086423373,
0.0505941547,
0.0507151112,
0.001800151,
-0.0003157156,
0.0367255136,
-0.0229538158,
-0.0063347165,
0.0550044142,
-0.0199102294,
0.0136948721,
0.0028171504,
0.0487080887,
-0.0642599612,
-0.043892283,
-0.0065593314,
0.0017800709,
-0.0143558811,
-0.0050184438,
-0.0281764939,
0.0312073939,
-0.0651644766,
-0.0083038602,
-0.0392293185,
0.0095759835,
-0.0148441363,
0.0036353981,
0.0450126752,
-0.019696122,
-0.0174723156,
0.003338913,
0.0520974807,
-0.0812479481,
0.0267435554,
-0.0168616567,
-0.008075444,
0.0029125232,
-0.0223832075,
0.0055991807,
-0.0288879387,
-0.015090486,
0.0439111404,
-0.0312822722,
-0.0215930138,
0.0325095505,
2.776e-7,
0.0416020118,
0.0780512989,
0.0104552237,
0.0221668612,
0.0084974822,
0.0172768515,
0.0026846195,
-0.0421122611,
-0.0256579127,
0.0120016541,
0.0584161282,
0.0439284444,
0.0360965021,
0.0170979723,
-0.0768758282,
0.0340888947,
-0.0354620591,
-0.0036466273,
-0.1023265272,
-0.0294934213,
0.014415022,
0.0921738073,
-0.0147911813,
0.0010981312,
-0.0148599837,
-0.0627567843,
0.0410769284,
-0.0721375123,
-0.0011390273,
0.0238648299,
-0.0336240605,
0.0138637088,
-0.0024670074,
-0.0187365152,
0.0102768745,
0.0495755561,
-0.0011083803,
0.0937836841,
0.0217233393,
-0.0390706249,
0.0100363446,
-0.0249261893,
-0.0109575456,
-0.0401442498,
0.0502500013,
-0.046407003,
-0.0031436372,
-0.0240672026,
0.0364599489,
-0.0213895664,
-0.0299325846,
-0.0196196195,
0.0073800562,
0.0145165008,
0.0004311638,
-0.0009700668,
0.0092517277,
-0.0767558813,
0.0056922282,
0.0284423307,
-0.0432187282,
-0.0204185937,
-0.0635725036,
0.01840524,
0.0117420023,
-0.0318392739,
0.011650661,
2.79394459e-34,
0.0202932954,
0.0162684992,
-0.0081331478,
0.0329299159,
0.0373751819,
0.0274314042,
-0.0310250614,
0.0345157683,
0.0102973767,
-0.0888000578,
-0.0060968515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13092v1 | Multilingual Synopses of Movie Narratives: A Dataset for Story Understanding | 2024-06-18T22:44:50 | 2024-06-18T22:44:50 | Yidan Sun, Jianfei Yu, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Story video-text alignment, a core task in computational story understanding,
aims to align video clips with corresponding sentences in their descriptions.
However, progress on the task has been held back by the scarcity of manually
annotated video-text correspondence and the heavy concentration on English
narrations of Hollywood movies. To address these issues, in this paper, we
construct a large-scale multilingual video story dataset named Multilingual
Synopses of Movie Narratives (M-SYMON), containing 13,166 movie summary videos
from 7 languages, as well as manual annotation of fine-grained video-text
correspondences for 101.5 hours of video. Training on the human annotated data
from SyMoN outperforms the SOTA methods by 15.7 and 16.2 percentage points on
Clip Accuracy and Sentence IoU scores, respectively, demonstrating the
effectiveness of the annotations. As benchmarks for future research, we create
6 baseline approaches with different multilingual training strategies, compare
their performance in both intra-lingual and cross-lingual setups, exemplifying
the challenges of multilingual video-text alignment. | [
0.0191614293,
0.006554286,
-0.005491979,
0.0621471889,
-0.011978901,
-0.0062781163,
0.0023878035,
-0.0095114075,
-0.0443063341,
-0.0028927394,
-0.0103859976,
-0.0453159884,
0.0324553996,
0.0190266259,
-0.0152508263,
-0.0630128011,
0.0271246862,
0.0109168217,
0.0214335043,
0.0288007651,
0.0355819017,
0.0559295826,
-0.0118601341,
-0.0007988177,
-0.0434124321,
-0.0338773765,
0.0160402618,
0.0094551891,
0.0887565017,
-0.035561841,
-0.0036432992,
0.0005373223,
0.0630434826,
0.0070895874,
0.0000015367,
-0.0716186687,
0.0173318107,
-0.0174844936,
0.0168440714,
0.0290450659,
0.0165956598,
-0.0677468926,
0.017092688,
-0.0158910211,
-0.0067738486,
0.0391549245,
0.0559687316,
0.0090214871,
0.0169965737,
0.036053285,
-0.047742337,
-0.0626580641,
-0.0364160575,
-0.0186512619,
0.0088932617,
-0.0151684936,
-0.0169434436,
0.020461224,
0.0151532795,
-0.0420351475,
-0.0577197373,
0.0303054247,
-0.0140561787,
-0.0052924929,
-0.01927674,
0.024136195,
-0.060101632,
-0.0037094029,
-0.0171223897,
0.0809900165,
0.0216895342,
0.0233139209,
-0.0453461818,
-0.0099393176,
-0.0172869824,
-0.0085836696,
-0.0532925837,
0.0448094271,
0.0003518282,
0.0036604663,
0.0057441345,
0.0197179541,
0.0244641006,
-0.0473316871,
0.0643257722,
0.0017075522,
0.0281944089,
0.0046689846,
-0.0319188274,
-0.0200316422,
-0.0025424405,
-0.0472096652,
0.0181992669,
-0.0030066157,
0.0166375842,
0.0012017384,
-0.0580603741,
-0.0138727818,
-0.030626094,
-0.0817342997,
0.0191897918,
0.0379627421,
-0.0540200993,
0.0611933842,
0.0167546645,
0.0725385323,
0.0051254756,
0.0059772953,
-0.0228701141,
-0.0017604248,
-0.0420040563,
0.0285773966,
-0.0158125442,
-0.0061102444,
-0.0348116383,
-0.0108769694,
-0.0211031828,
-0.008358947,
-0.0067310529,
0.0345167518,
-0.0564842224,
-0.0008691699,
0.0102973133,
-0.0186368003,
-0.0452486351,
0.0563892461,
-0.0700723305,
0.0225830246,
-0.0416874811,
-0.0038781951,
-0.0337230675,
0.0146605195,
0.0077265943,
-0.040662244,
0.0517992787,
0.0237329472,
-0.0448727719,
-0.0108524989,
-0.0186272245,
0.0047171698,
-0.0348461345,
-0.0458034799,
-0.0579677597,
-0.0459072702,
0.107584618,
0.0036637341,
-0.0139196347,
-0.0346738771,
0.0141967097,
-0.013416945,
-0.0311168637,
0.0710179284,
-0.003026979,
0.0138861006,
-0.0138402013,
-0.0101834368,
0.0000888159,
0.0385470465,
0.0412166677,
0.0415917337,
0.0581187122,
0.0368175991,
0.0123323165,
0.0533692911,
-0.0481196418,
0.0270928815,
-0.0568420589,
0.0142286001,
0.0377490707,
0.0853196979,
0.031317208,
0.0255200937,
-0.0158237778,
-0.0269612912,
0.0633375496,
0.0643585771,
-0.0437347181,
-0.0269361548,
0.0519311242,
0.0296499878,
0.0077416203,
0.0253451038,
-0.011364039,
0.0536720939,
0.0664422587,
0.0173394717,
-0.0077290181,
0.0267533511,
-0.0478560627,
0.0071769198,
-0.0220455565,
-0.0237391442,
-0.0144818928,
-0.0095589226,
0.0264223795,
-0.0118247624,
-0.031320747,
0.0445290543,
0.032200776,
-0.024439171,
0.0548523851,
0.0517586879,
0.0112718232,
0.0948985517,
0.0251092222,
-0.0304880161,
-0.066515021,
-0.0284996461,
0.0139508257,
0.0232972372,
0.024535967,
-0.0414039418,
0.0576498359,
-0.0869279802,
0.004536646,
-0.0180972852,
0.0020164857,
0.050701838,
-0.0454008877,
0.0066018743,
-0.0290248916,
-0.0169600826,
-0.0645574853,
0.0491685495,
-0.0188505854,
0.0024326451,
-0.034028504,
0.0248206276,
0.0259138085,
0.0372587778,
-0.0336818546,
-0.0526194461,
0.0243069846,
-0.0208742097,
0.0389676876,
0.0848255381,
-0.0066788848,
-0.0474304706,
0.04029819,
-0.0654829592,
-0.032955531,
0.0299667288,
-0.0153888045,
-0.0505661145,
-0.0139968842,
-0.0188689213,
-0.0151233636,
-0.0297743753,
0.0099157989,
0.0046628155,
0.0328018516,
-0.0112707466,
0.0141825629,
0.0327420346,
0.0062898677,
-0.0060529602,
-0.0127964271,
0.0521966554,
-0.0321453512,
-0.0068623172,
-0.0073465523,
-0.0048611653,
-0.0097715138,
0.0528695174,
-0.0463764481,
-0.0170981195,
0.0055854111,
-0.0827867761,
0.0414793417,
-0.0020508235,
0.0264344309,
0.0323720686,
0.0087640146,
-0.0404071361,
-0.043692518,
-0.0230080336,
0.0016957277,
-0.0137017109,
-0.0272932108,
0.0344213396,
0.0468214862,
0.0019554473,
-0.0322124772,
0.015569835,
-0.0388235077,
0.037795417,
0.018573435,
-0.0548902042,
-0.016319694,
-0.0151649499,
0.0047216024,
0.0183413643,
-0.0298910793,
-0.0256022923,
-0.0123468367,
0.0665380359,
0.010789711,
0.0427975804,
0.0067666527,
-0.0172622595,
0.050749179,
-0.0155097358,
0.0024413536,
0.0292618126,
0.0341811143,
-0.0158719793,
-0.0645816922,
-0.0482997,
-0.0329464152,
0.0110799093,
0.008810116,
0.0603739358,
-0.0657987073,
-0.0267531779,
0.0303913914,
0.0355036408,
-0.001463994,
-0.0160121098,
-0.0174436495,
0.0684614629,
-0.0184720308,
-0.0058830311,
0.0339301191,
-0.0706676394,
-0.0345011987,
-0.0266860574,
-0.0050295289,
-0.03835788,
0.0881549865,
-0.010691205,
0.0594042465,
-0.0245276392,
-0.0307816491,
-0.0685207918,
-0.0064389207,
0.0683001429,
0.0159654934,
0.0077140233,
-0.0110290609,
0.0103464285,
-0.0138121741,
-0.0200518668,
-0.0347305611,
-0.0431862436,
-0.0617311224,
-0.0400470234,
-0.0136459321,
-0.0418650396,
-0.0419307314,
0.0232081115,
0.023991365,
0.051822491,
-0.0184874404,
0.0223023873,
-0.0003034195,
0.0448683202,
0.0807228237,
-0.0102674766,
-0.0217088014,
-0.0449619778,
0.0620622076,
0.0177938677,
-0.0157322027,
-0.0139494995,
-0.0028673531,
0.0002100201,
0.0358997993,
-0.0463617705,
0.0044621374,
-0.0211730134,
0.0495650433,
-0.0459880754,
0.0158904251,
0.0981213301,
0.0072998968,
-0.0556613542,
-0.0065167691,
-0.0119309211,
-0.0244776551,
0.0511807017,
0.0291677117,
-0.1163050383,
-0.0378622226,
-0.0301581156,
-0.0056217839,
0.0365196839,
-0.0243488736,
-0.0472534001,
-0.0658865497,
0.0412614867,
0.0226136427,
-0.040053118,
-0.0328301676,
0.001378107,
-0.0015949339,
-0.0428193398,
0.0040636263,
-0.0167233702,
-0.0142521346,
-0.0172487404,
-0.0255833119,
-0.0282708462,
-0.014964846,
0.0502045304,
-0.0622961745,
0.0341262706,
0.0365230404,
0.050328169,
-0.0355613902,
0.0101519562,
0.0110932831,
0.0214570649,
-0.0002954588,
0.0344134532,
0.069616437,
-0.0660926476,
-0.0149791725,
0.0115378331,
0.0492697209,
0.0218057632,
-0.0453961566,
0.0444594212,
0.0560327582,
0.0091170147,
0.0308493264,
-0.0129638165,
0.0331368186,
-0.0194826666,
0.0586721897,
-0.0156828128,
-0.0424168408,
0.0282955598,
0.0333512425,
-0.0011408672,
-0.0340649672,
0.0101612732,
0.0113628926,
-0.0376297347,
0.0008522593,
-0.0325381942,
-0.0652029514,
0.0299077015,
0.024839364,
0.0460378453,
0.0013607848,
-0.0047852299,
0.012592433,
-0.0728732795,
0.0511860847,
-0.0071972986,
0.0027537178,
0.0040344056,
0.027737027,
0.0048921653,
-0.0301499534,
-0.0010006177,
0.010689741,
-0.0512716956,
-0.0621533729,
-0.0338317826,
0.0069673313,
0.0146768894,
0.1150751561,
0.0167290661,
0.0045021554,
0.0059430967,
0.0069626132,
-0.0118798781,
0.0101015717,
-0.0230544787,
-0.0208249893,
-0.0389219597,
0.0247280523,
-0.0131437983,
-0.0057264706,
-0.0321021378,
0.028620448,
-0.0313334614,
-0.0217946284,
0.0174909029,
-0.0036705965,
0.0381656811,
-0.0749083385,
-0.0368431509,
-0.0760050565,
-0.023160791,
-0.0148804225,
-0.0146472119,
-0.0214305334,
-0.0204455014,
0.0231348388,
-0.0123113999,
-0.0390360802,
0.0096922005,
-0.045721408,
-0.0455529653,
-0.0283087343,
-0.0435657278,
0.0157833062,
-0.0323800556,
-0.0094039999,
0.0357136913,
0.0016993666,
0.0308980197,
-0.0188678335,
0.0593292713,
0.0078068045,
0.044727426,
0.0100292452,
0.0204787552,
0.0333555937,
0.0387690552,
0.0122049851,
0.0031018229,
-0.0317028016,
-0.0010843795,
0.0681655556,
-0.0790727958,
0.0343901291,
-0.0146117024,
0.0057324148,
-0.0031345615,
0.030120207,
-0.0438592099,
-0.0401960202,
0.0010578044,
-0.0008528918,
-0.0301833171,
0.054356914,
0.0594597496,
-0.0435056463,
0.0188937597,
0.0323963724,
-0.0303561632,
-0.0108903823,
-0.0040429742,
0.0043497914,
0.0142913135,
-0.0341159962,
-0.0286938772,
-0.0462616906,
-0.0332631133,
0.0274203084,
-0.006941386,
0.0033575224,
0.0299202837,
0.0158058386,
0.02254037,
-0.0005479209,
0.0136284279,
0.0001613973,
-0.0385738984,
-0.0381801352,
-0.0252366327,
-0.0217737183,
-4.665914706e-33,
-0.0352417231,
0.0182518084,
0.001147056,
0.0440414511,
-0.071645394,
0.0189237427,
0.0166845508,
0.0148451775,
-0.0231118761,
0.061039567,
0.0382780693,
0.0088436706,
0.0155807184,
0.0199250542,
0.0297312122,
-0.0182907041,
0.0314315148,
-0.0053036604,
-0.0651596412,
-0.0198456533,
0.0574615113,
0.0384974852,
0.088855803,
-0.0529423207,
-0.0080739791,
-0.041088108,
-0.0319723859,
0.0094306059,
0.0867185295,
0.0246817525,
0.0155234914,
0.0003445863,
0.0079491362,
-0.0046115564,
0.0089849196,
0.0006357863,
-0.0284019578,
0.0137835853,
0.0706704855,
0.0573795363,
0.0138363866,
-0.0326331221,
0.012467212,
-0.0408110321,
0.0034758549,
-0.0241749976,
0.0705320612,
-0.0370471254,
0.0691461936,
-0.0010073301,
-0.0943660438,
-0.0042336397,
-0.0514881946,
-0.0538956337,
0.0466595627,
0.0526400916,
0.036284443,
-0.0131907035,
-0.0624614358,
0.0070437975,
-0.0740563199,
0.0578981712,
0.0602640696,
0.0013859881,
-0.0333801471,
0.0721301362,
0.0190317035,
-0.0566556752,
-0.0181938149,
0.0302402936,
-0.0113779241,
-0.0122393575,
0.0170701537,
0.0553510189,
0.011437797,
0.0084429169,
-0.078451708,
0.0382504053,
-0.0165140275,
0.0215590429,
0.0150756286,
0.0213202629,
0.0084673399,
0.0128011536,
-0.0265719239,
-0.0403142348,
0.0073930412,
-0.0336604826,
-0.0142016718,
-0.0365386084,
0.0452142768,
0.0393838026,
0.0564155169,
-0.0229474679,
0.0444818512,
-0.0116846375,
-0.0549168773,
0.0442423299,
0.0173661187,
0.0535447486,
-0.0370954163,
0.002346975,
-0.0129976729,
0.0355409048,
0.0741701052,
0.0065546515,
0.0725072399,
0.0398030765,
-0.0230751187,
0.0082377484,
-0.0019800316,
-0.028037874,
-0.0687715039,
0.0008144824,
0.0244132616,
0.0533638783,
-0.0310080275,
0.0418051034,
0.0080046812,
-0.00548351,
-0.0043928977,
-0.0433110446,
-0.0067138001,
0.0180435758,
-0.0260662399,
0.0478317253,
-0.0021603392,
-0.0327899531,
0.0074307858,
-0.0466306917,
-0.011873696,
0.0323342234,
2.248e-7,
0.0022686527,
0.0100031784,
0.0484058745,
-0.007884494,
-0.0218072534,
0.0423078351,
-0.0114029692,
0.0510939062,
-0.0052361991,
-0.038175337,
0.056446664,
0.0173687227,
0.0215443652,
0.0000814489,
-0.0590032078,
-0.0199514925,
-0.0705795884,
-0.0294034034,
-0.0694397464,
0.0164659172,
0.0280133095,
0.0885783136,
0.0369366668,
0.0151823377,
-0.0078477627,
-0.04672442,
0.0710096732,
-0.0165198538,
-0.0714930892,
0.0252673943,
-0.0205677822,
-0.0165824722,
-0.0627662316,
0.015913317,
-0.0095744841,
0.0186963119,
0.0444285721,
0.0301227216,
-0.0551031716,
-0.0023268559,
-0.0293821935,
0.0281247068,
-0.0484288745,
-0.0312362574,
0.0189039111,
0.0087116882,
-0.0298674647,
-0.0383425727,
-0.0203936584,
0.0611745231,
0.015414671,
-0.0031849011,
-0.0012521537,
0.0499315225,
0.0477904193,
0.0108677689,
-0.0386978611,
-0.0613983795,
-0.0203073882,
0.0552915409,
0.0034176901,
0.0312570818,
-0.0016491882,
-0.0210108589,
0.0260350648,
-0.0527489558,
0.0072262674,
1.535876697e-34,
0.0086000878,
-0.0067851976,
0.0004075182,
-0.0111043965,
0.0128428219,
-0.0214214269,
-0.0215678029,
0.0087844497,
0.0051236786,
0.0010279341,
-0.0149904368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13069v2 | Evaluating $n$-Gram Novelty of Language Models Using Rusty-DAWG | 2024-06-18T21:31:19 | 2024-06-25T15:02:40 | William Merrill, Noah A. Smith, Yanai Elazar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How novel are texts generated by language models (LMs) relative to their
training corpora? In this work, we investigate the extent to which modern LMs
generate $n$-grams from their training data, evaluating both (i) the
probability LMs assign to complete training $n$-grams and (ii) $n$-novelty, the
proportion of $n$-grams generated by an LM that did not appear in the training
data (for arbitrarily large $n$). To enable arbitrary-length $n$-gram search
over a corpus in constant time, we develop Rusty-DAWG, a novel search tool
inspired by indexing of genomic data. We compare the novelty of LM-generated
text to human-written text and explore factors that affect generation novelty,
focusing on the Pythia models. We find that, for $n > 4$, LM-generated text is
less novel than human-written text, though it is more novel for smaller $n$.
Larger LMs and more constrained decoding strategies both decrease novelty.
Finally, we show that LMs complete $n$-grams with lower loss if they are more
frequent in the training data. Overall, our results reveal factors influencing
the novelty of LM-generated text, and we release Rusty-DAWG to facilitate
further pretraining data research. | [
0.0669630617,
0.0521243736,
-0.0162612237,
-0.0023055018,
-0.0418338366,
0.0128036644,
-0.0127190389,
0.0313716047,
-0.028101204,
-0.0261882395,
-0.0000386327,
-0.0700128078,
0.0104309237,
0.0428708009,
0.0467106141,
0.0070049227,
0.0458272472,
-0.012554788,
-0.0006404619,
0.0116946688,
-0.0293496344,
-0.0064887428,
0.0502922758,
0.026683988,
0.0085613122,
0.0202579591,
-0.0337837599,
0.0357986763,
-0.006774948,
-0.037052799,
-0.0081122471,
0.0791829228,
0.0016553804,
0.1233529598,
0.0000019004,
-0.0429874249,
-0.0183471497,
-0.0132105211,
-0.0280995406,
0.041455511,
0.080293417,
0.0290035903,
-0.0269705448,
0.0097269174,
-0.0267955456,
-0.0395664684,
0.041015286,
0.0224102288,
0.0018810661,
0.082161814,
-0.0074884226,
-0.0228766855,
0.0323761925,
-0.0467559732,
0.0360647961,
0.0064397519,
0.0100743566,
-0.022564834,
0.0190054718,
0.0065321717,
0.0099596772,
0.0544450581,
0.0043209628,
0.0072818426,
0.0003991993,
0.03996915,
0.009537071,
-0.029404778,
0.0102088973,
0.0251885355,
-0.0539230667,
-0.096402593,
0.0115475571,
0.0243582353,
0.0100505874,
0.0167182945,
-0.0329850689,
0.0326256827,
-0.0303041656,
0.0527254306,
0.055304423,
-0.0045565218,
0.0430722572,
-0.0051789801,
-0.0196947902,
0.0339597985,
0.0358851776,
-0.0480576642,
-0.025160633,
0.0295539293,
-0.01150571,
-0.012409213,
0.0116066607,
0.0009252537,
-0.0055396748,
0.0125169884,
-0.0299433563,
-0.0796566829,
0.0390850268,
-0.0878480449,
0.0397133902,
0.0120894965,
-0.0288812965,
0.0258891564,
-0.0132049592,
0.0228847507,
-0.0126705011,
-0.0109210173,
-0.0734743699,
-0.0271289237,
-0.055170361,
-0.0393211544,
-0.0406720117,
0.0052010575,
0.00549509,
-0.0197981689,
0.0007026712,
0.0278040934,
0.0529818162,
-0.0383431576,
-0.0112550016,
-0.0077932421,
-0.0463163629,
0.0120561067,
0.0027627733,
-0.0355020054,
-0.0035071219,
-0.0073362864,
-0.0054543144,
-0.1015028879,
-0.0223722011,
0.0143685676,
0.0201154277,
-0.0210008603,
0.0233449563,
-0.0024121967,
-0.0256303679,
-0.0496410318,
-0.0400828607,
0.0181816109,
-0.0187682379,
-0.0100717675,
0.0005890126,
-0.067090407,
-0.0035563901,
0.007298246,
0.0020311787,
-0.0373717248,
-0.0154255945,
0.0354370959,
-0.0526293181,
0.0037135195,
-0.0169356763,
0.0552691072,
0.0380806401,
-0.0181762315,
0.035133794,
0.061540518,
0.0034934997,
-0.0227233507,
0.0520890243,
-0.0317068547,
0.0164694749,
0.0526104979,
-0.0007433636,
0.0103301406,
0.0039702589,
-0.0195687115,
0.0268174112,
0.0242544133,
0.0374261551,
0.0416712537,
-0.0303438362,
-0.0354452245,
0.0617107227,
0.0998631567,
0.040776059,
0.0513160266,
0.020493282,
-0.0010677857,
0.0205828156,
0.0378241763,
0.0196224786,
-0.010693335,
-0.0492941067,
0.0073690913,
0.0067309728,
0.0412423089,
-0.0301616937,
-0.001780137,
-0.0120976567,
0.006558801,
0.0391153693,
-0.0597657561,
0.0427126177,
0.0260735452,
-0.034270227,
-0.0128874714,
0.0105004553,
-0.047024373,
-0.0000255362,
-0.0443711616,
0.0364581235,
0.0621715896,
0.0809114128,
0.0074384683,
0.0251195822,
0.0294950418,
-0.0421186388,
0.0527379327,
0.0226195566,
-0.0040249373,
0.0068101157,
-0.0415194556,
-0.0093279183,
-0.0087298751,
0.0331780277,
0.0454264544,
0.0153232832,
0.0257985219,
0.0030616964,
-0.0544492453,
-0.0238921121,
0.0395994633,
-0.0593033396,
0.0131056756,
-0.0042405622,
-0.0359552875,
-0.0159502365,
0.0098888306,
-0.0389706045,
0.0421642512,
0.0405821241,
-0.0421567783,
-0.0234416742,
-0.0013227849,
0.0105658229,
-0.0158344768,
0.0402049646,
-0.0428640358,
0.0186590888,
0.0378472693,
0.0254199822,
-0.0269518849,
0.0222649556,
-0.0502224118,
0.0721608102,
-0.0833406597,
0.039164748,
-0.0458669439,
0.0120554678,
-0.0442290716,
0.0847505853,
0.0015246875,
0.0418654867,
-0.0257633701,
-0.0628896579,
0.0236615986,
-0.0775362328,
-0.0374172814,
0.0240489952,
-0.0031131725,
0.022235617,
0.0220796466,
0.0078562517,
0.0111172227,
-0.0344945155,
-0.0790759474,
-0.0051618558,
-0.0348728374,
0.007146446,
0.0281307474,
0.0074919094,
-0.0253417175,
-0.0037378322,
-0.0302756447,
-0.0603479221,
0.0253912453,
0.0311820712,
0.0224250965,
0.0286489464,
-0.0124863246,
-0.0362656303,
-0.0291973427,
0.0277657732,
0.075826548,
0.0026642687,
-0.0537562631,
-0.0491175018,
0.0493295603,
-0.0093608517,
0.0077662398,
0.0102875084,
-0.0286992807,
0.0170176979,
-0.0301346797,
0.0389511324,
-0.0097288778,
0.0327206515,
0.0232973453,
0.0519990362,
0.0172789954,
-0.0521919988,
-0.0438512042,
-0.0447179861,
0.0056746239,
-0.0222300421,
-0.0365429372,
0.0474189445,
0.0717537999,
0.0077242763,
-0.0215582773,
-0.0595010892,
0.0262082797,
-0.0098571619,
-0.0177809801,
-0.0276395697,
-0.0296203867,
-0.0023654022,
0.0518084578,
-0.0272383448,
-0.0719393268,
0.0388088264,
-0.0310024098,
0.0012880269,
-0.0669516698,
-0.0154447537,
-0.0040228995,
0.0320916809,
-0.0040514944,
0.0269690081,
0.0281700008,
-0.0234609488,
-0.0097355265,
0.0854609832,
0.0136477957,
-0.0568554141,
0.0558127388,
-0.0156083135,
0.0127609065,
0.0282988604,
-0.0069190329,
-0.0288865827,
-0.0648160428,
0.0078763226,
-0.0360402316,
0.0553937405,
-0.0325009897,
0.0031719874,
0.0122400727,
0.0052343002,
0.0597831495,
-0.0037341812,
0.0074536232,
0.0181647185,
0.0435651615,
0.015033477,
-0.0153291496,
0.0149016958,
-0.0259152856,
0.0193697866,
0.0189532284,
-0.0028123767,
-0.0228642058,
0.0077166376,
0.0051126629,
0.0154577969,
0.0211245082,
-0.0658294931,
-0.0065005054,
-0.020267738,
-0.0195507295,
-0.0482675955,
0.0795871019,
0.0479639955,
-0.0339046419,
0.0119946087,
-0.0349044241,
0.0631955937,
0.0115848444,
0.0414008051,
-0.0457058102,
0.0064083519,
-0.0028300963,
0.017753426,
-0.0315768756,
-0.0249651074,
-0.0300183594,
-0.1214579269,
0.0213843174,
0.0374024361,
-0.0309436265,
-0.0041689971,
-0.0022359884,
-0.0485956892,
0.0072801923,
-0.0207225215,
0.0477034859,
0.0022265238,
0.0367443785,
0.0428360254,
-0.0071166563,
-0.1000398248,
-0.0453940891,
-0.0155004337,
0.0408231877,
0.0789787397,
0.0026001064,
-0.0326399729,
-0.0149556687,
0.0190807842,
-0.0009961968,
0.0226181932,
-0.0346979648,
0.0536905192,
0.0389897972,
-0.0139563102,
-0.0588728487,
0.0101410262,
-0.0161933023,
-0.0167513248,
-0.0458161347,
0.0513272546,
-0.0166612733,
-0.0383798517,
-0.016182743,
-0.0406942964,
0.0185452402,
0.1017388552,
0.0455218032,
-0.0671551675,
-0.0067210682,
-0.041112788,
0.0573215596,
-0.0494439527,
-0.0300894734,
0.0458846614,
0.0008204852,
-0.0423382446,
-0.1016011536,
-0.0054382463,
-0.0183145441,
0.0420818888,
0.0157904159,
0.0453705899,
-0.05205293,
-0.0492853113,
-0.0465418585,
-0.0035883056,
-0.0211973879,
-0.0319951549,
-0.0988495946,
-0.0286880806,
-0.0065444978,
-0.041069638,
-0.037724141,
0.0168700013,
-0.0791978613,
-0.0562306195,
0.0162701719,
-0.0501677319,
0.0375710316,
0.0054400903,
-0.0066978326,
-0.065260753,
0.054543715,
0.0195161495,
0.0145958317,
0.0463542789,
-0.0110890288,
-0.0284094214,
0.0024600108,
0.0232079476,
-0.0245212317,
-0.014948789,
-0.0015078672,
0.0421226732,
-0.0016364971,
-0.0160189308,
0.0396469571,
0.0345532,
0.0529455207,
-0.0184862297,
0.0146439699,
-0.0338637643,
-0.0122388899,
0.0252947565,
0.0119869309,
-0.0389671102,
-0.0176682826,
0.0632021502,
-0.0002270052,
-0.0310675465,
0.0467179976,
-0.0169015005,
0.0989504009,
-0.0641136616,
-0.0356360115,
0.0062052291,
0.0334811769,
0.0272752643,
0.0090945102,
0.0022116278,
0.0269788895,
-0.0406790003,
0.036574997,
-0.0160226375,
-0.0194429457,
0.0121972347,
-0.0137172006,
0.0010775052,
0.0160219595,
-0.0752193183,
-0.0194542352,
-0.0473627746,
-0.0072798501,
0.053871572,
-0.0108732497,
0.051934693,
-0.0369191766,
0.0040248157,
-0.065248996,
0.0059128348,
0.0335273854,
-0.0116955619,
-0.0121884234,
-0.0242982022,
-0.0493461564,
0.0135145979,
0.1181920916,
0.0038789406,
0.0693003237,
-0.0299791824,
-0.012008165,
-0.007400196,
0.0305656902,
0.0095143793,
0.0144817838,
-0.0225771721,
-0.0101398258,
-0.0541653931,
-0.032638751,
0.0143750552,
0.0098531805,
0.0255194306,
0.0083669322,
-0.0123919742,
0.0485169329,
-0.0338850468,
0.0390039273,
-0.0361489765,
0.0026202346,
0.0107990615,
-0.0339167193,
0.0117626172,
-6.402192596e-33,
0.0053225053,
-0.0005954162,
-0.038627822,
-0.0237889979,
0.0305427182,
0.0029739805,
-0.0424176976,
0.0144698778,
-0.0248860307,
0.0175631754,
-0.0092691835,
0.0080443062,
0.0088218404,
-0.0061835703,
-0.0064675459,
0.0241718143,
0.026328722,
-0.0066813091,
0.0019864526,
0.0068975175,
0.0474723428,
0.0493834987,
0.0655737668,
-0.0063738981,
-0.0014738195,
-0.0319281891,
-0.0125366319,
0.0027592797,
0.0103026042,
0.0514856689,
-0.0174596161,
0.0252548307,
0.0136390282,
-0.0338405482,
-0.0471925512,
0.0063219187,
-0.0268655904,
-0.0203703307,
-0.015570445,
-0.0149747608,
0.0434176512,
-0.0405517183,
-0.009444355,
-0.0167201217,
-0.0584420636,
0.0431787036,
0.0180750247,
-0.0357178859,
-0.0662733391,
-0.0229651332,
-0.0173243936,
0.0329481512,
0.016613882,
0.0002788887,
0.0210776404,
0.0162555221,
-0.0173618551,
0.0179135557,
-0.037363518,
0.0674275383,
0.0369176343,
0.0359259769,
0.026887171,
-0.0079322038,
0.0056131533,
0.0410030298,
0.0535088964,
-0.009446783,
-0.0074351016,
0.0162444729,
0.0565910265,
0.0054056682,
0.0138453906,
0.0183302909,
0.0613823235,
-0.0052824328,
-0.0437520817,
0.0438692831,
0.0045623323,
-0.0288235769,
0.0621629879,
0.0276725423,
-0.0746824369,
-0.0245297831,
-0.0284849256,
-0.0258674994,
-0.0181310065,
-0.0088216383,
0.0223413073,
0.0001582902,
-0.029508708,
-0.0253755003,
0.0438703783,
-0.023578763,
-0.0231049918,
0.0297976546,
-0.0559180155,
0.0245841295,
-0.0178926904,
0.016456645,
0.0061336756,
-0.0211456791,
0.0560570508,
0.0057487702,
0.0136194769,
-0.0139698004,
0.007790613,
0.0422023386,
-0.0934318304,
0.0011173757,
-0.0269188769,
-0.0030492903,
0.0339078195,
-0.0187102444,
0.0060602366,
-0.0244817119,
0.016234953,
0.0545483865,
0.0375329666,
0.0191159341,
-0.0246085282,
-0.0165891387,
0.002156808,
-0.0168229267,
-0.0015225871,
0.0293119047,
-0.0150283268,
-0.0066500884,
0.0748858601,
0.015352603,
0.0077431421,
0.0356497392,
2.646e-7,
0.0517638586,
0.0630721152,
0.0326414406,
-0.0180278551,
0.0396758094,
0.0304384753,
-0.0605266951,
0.0206066333,
-0.0138276042,
0.0086049223,
-0.0081458744,
-0.0173585583,
0.0505172648,
-0.0013848807,
-0.0651523694,
-0.0244632252,
-0.082972087,
0.0283976756,
-0.0414540619,
0.0127617829,
-0.0008688469,
0.0992263258,
-0.0006185945,
-0.0202672966,
0.0234660134,
-0.0851463601,
0.0653284565,
-0.0501505062,
0.0049411538,
0.0074023711,
0.0485032126,
0.0150829051,
0.0191386361,
0.0035548138,
-0.0355147272,
0.0206185468,
0.018786557,
0.0100075165,
0.0006625614,
-0.0049709454,
0.0407311842,
-0.0192213748,
-0.0298494995,
-0.0795203149,
0.0301138982,
0.0546296388,
-0.0272175409,
-0.0376556776,
0.0031979124,
0.0104062064,
0.0076764673,
-0.0283686724,
-0.0073728207,
0.0164903868,
0.025950538,
0.024162516,
-0.0349075496,
-0.0421166085,
-0.0384218171,
0.0063326028,
-0.0562587306,
-0.0241107512,
-0.0593292005,
0.0199212171,
0.0396782272,
-0.0658167452,
0.0312992409,
2.589668008e-34,
0.0417760722,
0.0001507777,
-0.0121525815,
0.0360135995,
0.0154147055,
-0.0014774437,
0.0420714468,
0.0361602567,
-0.0299133547,
-0.085897021,
-0.0085998112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13050v1 | Think-then-Act: A Dual-Angle Evaluated Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T20:51:34 | 2024-06-18T20:51:34 | Yige Shen, Hao Jiang, Hua Qu, Jihong Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their impressive capabilities, large language models (LLMs) often
face challenges such as temporal misalignment and generating hallucinatory
content. Enhancing LLMs with retrieval mechanisms to fetch relevant information
from external sources offers a promising solution. Inspired by the proverb
"Think twice before you act," we propose a dual-angle evaluated
retrieval-augmented generation framework \textit{Think-then-Act}. Unlike
previous approaches that indiscriminately rewrite queries or perform retrieval
regardless of necessity, or generate temporary responses before deciding on
additional retrieval, which increases model generation costs, our framework
employs a two-phase process: (i) assessing the input query for clarity and
completeness to determine if rewriting is necessary; and (ii) evaluating the
model's capability to answer the query and deciding if additional retrieval is
needed. Experimental results on five datasets show that the
\textit{Think-then-Act} framework significantly improves performance. Our
framework demonstrates notable improvements in accuracy and efficiency compared
to existing baselines and performs well in both English and non-English
contexts. Ablation studies validate the optimal model confidence threshold,
highlighting the resource optimization benefits of our approach. | [
0.0464560352,
0.0918550193,
-0.0223656539,
0.0213535018,
-0.0563298129,
-0.0096838549,
-0.0169152711,
-0.0054108077,
-0.0033584135,
-0.059079729,
-0.0012811766,
-0.084920831,
-0.0169546995,
0.0278741922,
0.0442064144,
-0.0199612528,
0.048217725,
-0.0060193292,
-0.0019699035,
0.0035029636,
0.0038110099,
0.0252424385,
-0.0092309173,
0.0486213528,
-0.0033392699,
0.0095132207,
-0.0176459979,
0.0375444964,
0.0029935411,
-0.0074560069,
0.0280045047,
0.0548236743,
-0.0019424858,
0.0696334541,
0.0000020477,
-0.0338345096,
-0.0330117829,
-0.0128867421,
0.0080348384,
0.0059505911,
0.0740357339,
0.0260515567,
0.0162325613,
0.0319277793,
-0.04341124,
0.0008732355,
0.039553389,
0.0160458963,
0.0419419035,
0.0774057731,
0.0042107091,
-0.0167255104,
0.0057251747,
-0.0166962966,
0.0380845852,
-0.008474716,
0.0113331918,
-0.0125886118,
0.0202049576,
0.01026526,
0.0087829698,
0.0739246309,
0.0276245438,
-0.0223129448,
0.0158005003,
0.0209246296,
-0.0708823055,
-0.013714008,
0.0048093335,
0.0439258702,
0.0089960545,
-0.0449105501,
-0.0027766281,
0.0004436896,
-0.0067760488,
0.0167058483,
-0.0509742424,
0.0074115824,
-0.0048335609,
0.014837143,
0.0134861553,
-0.0039182999,
0.0249528028,
0.0330396742,
-0.0599394478,
0.0586178452,
0.0324333571,
-0.0351031721,
-0.0185671542,
0.0179078802,
0.0065007596,
-0.0336673036,
0.0096688215,
0.0278065782,
-0.0381766446,
0.0390964448,
-0.0257223826,
-0.0424500629,
0.0310753658,
-0.0381564312,
0.0315177925,
0.0465353727,
-0.0111575313,
0.02821251,
-0.0141331321,
0.0398689844,
-0.0283754487,
0.0113150785,
-0.0827125385,
0.0057514147,
-0.0390184335,
-0.0309402235,
-0.0534533486,
0.0234887563,
-0.0426524132,
-0.0127983764,
-0.0357578546,
0.0223010182,
0.011621112,
-0.0388344973,
-0.0088569662,
0.0457247235,
-0.0273445677,
-0.018163681,
-0.0242314767,
0.0331554227,
0.0237248987,
-0.0053893621,
0.0248348378,
-0.0814712644,
-0.0208962671,
0.0128911249,
-0.0093186321,
-0.0238475539,
-0.028383486,
0.0242088176,
-0.0275440365,
-0.0279608797,
-0.0393892117,
-0.0533290282,
-0.0170768425,
-0.0497340225,
0.0027910387,
-0.0710420609,
0.0531816594,
0.0056424793,
-0.0315302163,
-0.0512665436,
0.0237427745,
0.059389662,
-0.0107305441,
0.0364817157,
0.0063864919,
0.0411213152,
0.0244968347,
0.0142452354,
0.0106453123,
0.0944264829,
0.0298357289,
0.0179714151,
0.025683213,
0.0238683075,
0.0085168136,
0.0494557656,
0.0477075018,
0.0064542103,
-0.057480704,
0.0316755213,
-0.0312370118,
0.0284909699,
0.0004175566,
0.061978329,
-0.0244596135,
0.0143564157,
0.0271979515,
-0.0052300496,
0.0180172883,
-0.0182673614,
0.0745218098,
0.0228139218,
-0.0202312339,
0.0049210843,
-0.0217129085,
0.0374156907,
-0.0326914005,
0.0275636483,
0.0477339178,
0.0385076068,
-0.0272002425,
-0.0336872153,
-0.0007616634,
0.0123025663,
-0.0027731366,
0.0337014571,
0.0308956597,
0.0262068398,
-0.0509401858,
0.0716146156,
0.0161727779,
-0.0604407042,
0.0232663807,
-0.050496839,
0.0071159662,
0.0798020139,
0.0990179405,
0.0083797034,
-0.0242737383,
0.0236148555,
-0.0052153594,
0.0427780561,
0.0474128202,
0.0027156617,
-0.015708806,
-0.0667425245,
-0.0221068487,
0.0098241586,
0.0061125606,
0.0115976827,
0.0287233163,
-0.0014027175,
0.06015772,
-0.0242613629,
-0.0163420234,
0.019892782,
-0.0415575579,
-0.0167258885,
-0.0031363254,
0.0004608829,
0.0142009677,
0.00562935,
-0.0012556466,
0.0509427153,
0.0164745152,
-0.025436487,
-0.0348248519,
-0.005738419,
-0.0579928383,
-0.043067921,
0.0282211006,
0.0271607563,
0.0118077304,
0.0069328244,
-0.0110405767,
-0.0524721295,
0.0187254958,
-0.0518434234,
0.0534403585,
-0.0812088251,
0.0159624796,
0.005724214,
0.0198189225,
-0.0608335994,
0.0679163933,
-0.0265095625,
0.0289866216,
0.0493622795,
-0.0080646081,
0.0038049931,
-0.0508049168,
-0.0406680591,
-0.0063852272,
-0.0041698734,
0.025538655,
0.0328675881,
0.0209967531,
-0.0617579184,
-0.0358605385,
-0.0789736062,
-0.0047782045,
-0.0332333334,
-0.0206053257,
0.0292432588,
0.0342868306,
-0.0232192818,
0.0101261465,
-0.0344717093,
-0.0364588164,
0.0378639922,
0.0502639525,
-0.0056897192,
0.0256771669,
-0.0351330936,
-0.0342424326,
-0.0096705975,
-0.0017984762,
0.0458462276,
-0.0191440489,
-0.0282359924,
-0.0422872007,
0.0558090247,
-0.0692007169,
0.0079238825,
0.0000102256,
-0.0166424941,
0.0058039362,
-0.0566890873,
0.0562599599,
0.0074191215,
0.0328501053,
-0.0292954259,
0.0576510765,
-0.0593072809,
-0.0758440793,
0.0207343735,
-0.0368530937,
-0.0367449857,
0.0036704605,
-0.066103451,
0.0167494882,
0.0281607602,
0.028733382,
-0.0150178801,
-0.0611687452,
0.0243255962,
-0.0334616601,
-0.0611394942,
-0.0467714369,
0.0046106065,
-0.0289916042,
0.066828005,
-0.0224750675,
-0.0391757637,
0.0814414993,
-0.0349248238,
-0.0046350947,
-0.0355875939,
0.0232771151,
-0.0257986169,
0.0548107401,
0.0051713395,
0.0273721125,
-0.0105498563,
-0.0152672548,
-0.0498042293,
-0.002265458,
-0.0011766147,
-0.079849571,
0.0467419401,
-0.0372159816,
0.0280817095,
0.0116895577,
-0.0206521824,
-0.0638182759,
-0.0471305847,
0.0035790983,
-0.0282803662,
0.0122065991,
-0.0023289702,
-0.0326012187,
0.0119214924,
0.0480594747,
0.0166779216,
-0.0386097059,
-0.0166036226,
0.0033377749,
0.0299382415,
0.0869355127,
-0.0061709038,
-0.0069556762,
-0.0087772487,
0.0193819441,
0.052879028,
0.0493558273,
-0.0315460488,
-0.0170197468,
-0.0225446783,
0.0366680995,
0.0182495397,
-0.0104141245,
0.0251238216,
0.0190257952,
-0.0416077562,
-0.0551333763,
0.1000622436,
0.0576931946,
-0.0339960903,
-0.0221026111,
-0.0402624011,
0.0609500892,
0.0154353669,
0.0387446657,
-0.0802475363,
-0.0024415085,
0.0206603222,
0.0456344001,
-0.0242700782,
-0.0136868516,
-0.0346400179,
-0.1411985457,
0.054514464,
0.0089959353,
0.0094781872,
-0.0022642193,
-0.0105237579,
0.0058670631,
0.016434418,
0.0067178872,
0.0671676099,
0.0070073074,
0.0153189907,
-0.0054308111,
0.0117234997,
-0.03980745,
0.0204903539,
0.0091324411,
0.0029897823,
0.0490514152,
0.0262326282,
0.0538083538,
-0.0546679422,
0.0059610326,
-0.0372307114,
0.0093782125,
-0.0188468508,
0.0227075014,
0.0336625166,
-0.0021007634,
-0.0179023482,
0.0004080416,
-0.0081178742,
-0.0172315035,
-0.0101884501,
0.0814955458,
-0.0396566428,
0.0368813127,
-0.0584079996,
0.0253710039,
0.0264809597,
0.0729138106,
0.0375831462,
-0.0218749754,
-0.0233500302,
-0.0028325464,
-0.0035512953,
-0.1049661487,
-0.0468689315,
0.0107559143,
0.0251738187,
0.0273902584,
-0.071532689,
-0.0425320938,
-0.0155036068,
0.0242432076,
0.0084326705,
0.0243146475,
-0.0015024517,
-0.0296644177,
-0.0436873622,
0.0115780784,
-0.0492398664,
0.010911854,
-0.00105777,
-0.0064640883,
0.0329012424,
-0.0262296293,
-0.0015509466,
0.0529409423,
-0.0469358563,
-0.0889558718,
-0.0126623102,
0.0373319872,
0.0278802868,
0.0325662531,
-0.0179408062,
-0.0254772808,
0.038699992,
0.0507200472,
-0.0499782339,
0.0102732182,
-0.0023316559,
0.0140434597,
-0.0077887536,
0.0422688164,
-0.0516427569,
-0.0141240545,
-0.0182296187,
0.0810134932,
0.0042967997,
-0.0235448796,
0.0534209087,
0.0456968136,
0.0248741116,
-0.0387620144,
0.0207397621,
-0.0270511676,
0.0191340744,
-0.0483318642,
-0.0345986299,
-0.0468125492,
0.0415468067,
0.0211981405,
-0.0227542538,
0.0007102198,
-0.0115296943,
-0.016675951,
0.0340204276,
-0.0174805187,
-0.0410958976,
-0.0249741264,
-0.0006288372,
0.052602984,
-0.0031540263,
-0.0186282881,
0.0170932952,
0.0011039497,
0.0300526936,
-0.0212797169,
0.0512528084,
0.0225350168,
-0.0098626893,
-0.0378487818,
0.0168647878,
-0.0602555797,
-0.0563403405,
-0.0314532928,
-0.016710395,
0.025518043,
-0.0068749879,
0.0680284649,
-0.0063608335,
-0.0124805681,
-0.0185838975,
0.020665627,
0.0329386517,
-0.0672974139,
0.004187895,
0.019473277,
-0.0141381482,
-0.0012539959,
0.0719689503,
-0.0403460935,
0.0265801121,
-0.0112818535,
-0.029622566,
-0.0358074158,
-0.0579380505,
-0.0341840237,
-0.0040755495,
-0.0368417688,
-0.0089603532,
-0.0582669936,
-0.0619501695,
0.0114954319,
0.0040818094,
-0.0135435369,
-0.0008701634,
0.0443061665,
0.0922712386,
0.0033985178,
-0.0062309024,
-0.0505842343,
0.0202885028,
-0.0320600532,
-0.0403328091,
-0.0454479828,
-6.83897544e-33,
-0.0269617029,
0.0061749443,
0.0547371358,
-0.0733505562,
-0.0379470699,
-0.0019797853,
-0.0589885861,
0.0135881538,
0.0040292805,
-0.0180792268,
-0.0160594843,
0.0038385533,
0.0168462936,
0.0351503231,
0.0128192501,
0.0056549176,
0.0196335297,
-0.0055400552,
-0.0255631041,
0.0362843648,
0.0745399296,
0.0312956683,
0.022135634,
-0.0351027027,
0.0008644832,
-0.0055653318,
-0.0074457643,
0.0326971635,
-0.0169442333,
0.0559245944,
-0.0112964381,
0.0496509783,
0.0130240535,
-0.0159959905,
-0.0389071442,
-0.0082822153,
-0.0311860777,
-0.0038781229,
0.0237166099,
-0.0072176442,
-0.0384950377,
-0.0181103349,
0.0230987668,
-0.0299747251,
-0.008544161,
0.0013413553,
0.008820843,
-0.0421541817,
-0.0098682158,
-0.0169105232,
-0.0527023785,
0.0142875146,
0.0068002082,
-0.0299614463,
-0.0089042373,
0.097632274,
0.0195070822,
0.0313485228,
-0.0523884632,
0.0248326939,
0.0090381419,
0.0675552115,
0.0643750504,
0.011296236,
0.0092480183,
0.0444162674,
0.011205392,
-0.0231411289,
-0.0288083311,
-0.0125199426,
0.0477985442,
0.0245399177,
0.0184495747,
0.0652544051,
0.0049215551,
-0.016472619,
-0.0353339091,
0.0308517292,
-0.0174936447,
0.0440807007,
0.0570487194,
0.0018212441,
-0.0479121618,
-0.0265689269,
-0.0262809992,
-0.0016723818,
-0.0529948361,
-0.0292460211,
0.0556555241,
0.0367513858,
-0.0172844026,
-0.0258265417,
0.0707731545,
-0.026571719,
0.0110085066,
0.036798019,
-0.05167735,
0.0013335228,
-0.0097325398,
0.0405483283,
-0.004508561,
-0.0025617613,
0.0434228778,
0.0106257275,
-0.0461512655,
0.0107560605,
0.0075141592,
0.0393818244,
-0.0443096533,
0.0069299056,
-0.0556447022,
0.0558848195,
-0.0335898809,
-0.0539633259,
0.0247096233,
0.0237735659,
-0.0253083147,
0.055710692,
0.0390936062,
0.0102662407,
-0.0249362327,
-0.0152298706,
0.0116150547,
0.0318692438,
-0.0224788357,
0.0293067116,
-0.0134237977,
0.0066707735,
0.0375198983,
-0.0484679863,
-0.0248514041,
0.0361117758,
2.864e-7,
0.0508473963,
0.0154290115,
0.015571571,
0.0488322191,
-0.0039723357,
0.0011363452,
-0.0109160002,
-0.0070432755,
0.0438959189,
-0.0051456518,
0.0089820707,
0.0209657922,
0.061238829,
0.0201782081,
-0.0894037485,
0.0045607146,
-0.0845016837,
-0.0179531872,
-0.047791604,
-0.0476898961,
0.0586193539,
0.077283971,
-0.0121430624,
-0.022453716,
-0.0190060884,
-0.0594447628,
0.0756849051,
-0.0066371895,
-0.0548293926,
0.0379004478,
0.0617714636,
0.0275151059,
0.0306380093,
-0.0352609605,
-0.0213535633,
0.013048158,
0.0018747664,
0.0105189905,
0.0378562771,
-0.0522693843,
0.001111459,
-0.0277259164,
-0.0024124689,
-0.0806128234,
0.052508343,
-0.0376454778,
0.012235757,
-0.0038894548,
-0.0292356517,
0.0250794832,
0.0304915737,
-0.0321587138,
-0.029855419,
0.0239206348,
0.0222631972,
0.0201886948,
-0.0065690735,
-0.0761843473,
-0.044377394,
0.0104212174,
-0.0448656902,
-0.0124474913,
-0.0305477455,
0.0060534189,
-0.0213172454,
-0.0635656491,
0.0058305399,
2.771384282e-34,
0.0463850759,
0.0070710904,
0.0021147446,
0.0082856519,
0.0348815583,
-0.0133526083,
-0.0042979214,
0.0229642056,
-0.0087553374,
-0.0905144215,
-0.0554775633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13035v2 | D2O: Dynamic Discriminative Operations for Efficient Generative Inference of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T20:01:51 | 2024-06-23T08:27:48 | Zhongwei Wan, Xinjian Wu, Yu Zhang, Yi Xin, Chaofan Tao, Zhihong Zhu, Xin Wang, Siqi Luo, Jing Xiong, Mi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Efficient inference in Large Language Models (LLMs) is impeded by the growing
memory demands of key-value (KV) caching, especially for longer sequences.
Traditional KV cache eviction strategies, which prioritize less critical
KV-pairs based on attention scores, often degrade generation quality, leading
to issues such as context loss or hallucinations. To address this, we introduce
Dynamic Discriminative Operations (D2O), a novel method that utilizes two-level
discriminative strategies to optimize KV cache size without fine-tuning, while
preserving essential context. Initially, by observing varying densities of
attention weights between shallow and deep layers, we use this insight to
determine which layers should avoid excessive eviction to minimize information
loss. Subsequently, for the eviction strategy in each layer, D2O innovatively
incorporates a compensation mechanism that maintains a similarity threshold to
re-discriminate the importance of previously discarded tokens, determining
whether they should be recalled and merged with similar tokens. Our approach
not only achieves significant memory savings and enhances inference throughput
by more than 3 times but also maintains high-quality long-text generation.
Extensive experiments across various benchmarks and LLM architectures have
demonstrated that D2O significantly enhances performance with a constrained KV
cache budget. | [
0.0341453739,
0.066456221,
0.0005828852,
0.0544421338,
-0.0146833947,
0.0271262079,
0.0134878987,
-0.0252689291,
0.0009703647,
-0.0349995345,
-0.0119520044,
-0.0725835115,
-0.0071179746,
0.0003245477,
0.0106756631,
-0.0149437794,
0.0434421301,
-0.0370593891,
0.0054187817,
0.0053005693,
-0.004213355,
0.0236738957,
0.0179569498,
0.0109057017,
0.0033967383,
-0.0145953735,
-0.0151378289,
0.0101751583,
0.009800734,
-0.0271556713,
0.0072465995,
0.0685068518,
0.00514994,
0.0353953019,
0.000002077,
-0.0126874801,
-0.0098897759,
-0.0221814197,
-0.0297065955,
0.0462570712,
0.0529439934,
0.0186088122,
-0.0013242647,
-0.0088250479,
0.0008443746,
-0.045749642,
0.0702699348,
0.0051438771,
0.0101440232,
0.0589447357,
0.0019531378,
-0.0236093942,
0.0175407007,
-0.0501978174,
0.0020669859,
-0.0587595403,
0.0269043893,
-0.0361286812,
-0.0634939596,
-0.0244885292,
-0.0036907948,
0.0459964871,
0.0372211002,
0.0045403852,
0.0194979534,
0.0746330172,
-0.0329974554,
-0.0248559602,
0.0172915366,
0.0621945933,
-0.027036164,
-0.0321273319,
0.0182160735,
-0.0122305099,
-0.0082539693,
-0.0342861302,
-0.0400786139,
0.0110553456,
-0.0075289989,
0.0260721091,
0.0427604914,
0.0142367249,
0.037231341,
0.0307938494,
-0.0304156411,
-0.0152270496,
0.0538656116,
-0.0003029029,
-0.0464094542,
-0.0042213136,
-0.0151000638,
-0.0714921728,
-0.0035715685,
0.0087441793,
-0.0030628194,
0.0318983607,
-0.0623297803,
-0.0201272052,
0.0267687123,
-0.0669113025,
0.0461891219,
0.0447858311,
-0.0067413235,
0.0158956945,
-0.0544968471,
0.0562944412,
-0.0396994054,
-0.0076926532,
-0.0290410072,
-0.0179324858,
0.0101930369,
-0.0149121415,
-0.0243303459,
0.027375821,
-0.013474049,
-0.0152880661,
-0.0581317395,
0.0253013447,
0.0074862973,
-0.0323286057,
-0.0069857608,
0.0224029571,
-0.0509920344,
0.0146450158,
0.0129514113,
0.0027734665,
-0.0502981544,
-0.00183795,
0.0232204311,
-0.0673685744,
-0.0381950215,
0.0304687992,
0.0329390652,
-0.0538325869,
-0.0114740599,
0.0851411149,
-0.0135283461,
-0.0365508832,
-0.0466807112,
-0.0239848029,
-0.0176782701,
-0.0765105858,
0.0307049807,
-0.0689833462,
0.0241485778,
-0.0118825743,
-0.0406588241,
-0.0263849925,
0.0206720438,
0.0474534631,
-0.0154879047,
0.0166378878,
0.0039970465,
-0.032783296,
0.0150580043,
-0.0015493309,
0.0117670791,
0.0765999407,
0.0303236842,
0.0571482889,
0.0139779663,
0.011925471,
-0.007971541,
0.0235386156,
0.0503937565,
0.0121392887,
-0.0400411226,
0.0001159974,
0.0152305868,
0.0247687306,
0.0726843327,
0.0594310425,
-0.0505593605,
-0.0276493691,
0.0372984298,
0.0365801416,
0.0248130914,
0.0329935104,
0.0555607714,
-0.0032636484,
-0.0249042846,
0.0219624341,
-0.0315907151,
0.050385654,
0.0207107142,
0.017660534,
0.0659584627,
0.054456275,
-0.0295177586,
-0.0302585792,
-0.0231990963,
0.0045337272,
0.0136148902,
0.0383204147,
0.0131334132,
0.0224906057,
-0.0401362069,
0.0995429009,
0.0394675545,
-0.0460531302,
-0.0157272108,
-0.0505042151,
0.032343559,
0.0851393193,
0.031266585,
0.0179886743,
-0.0371738672,
0.0484954678,
0.0297945943,
0.0346857347,
0.0202647187,
-0.0180221088,
0.0310341287,
-0.0765572563,
-0.0170891937,
-0.0268232878,
0.0087835826,
0.0203204434,
0.0670682117,
0.0099276938,
0.059360303,
-0.0236182511,
-0.0023772584,
0.028958803,
-0.0208713226,
-0.044818718,
0.0305427089,
-0.0012479733,
0.0044142702,
-0.0076226005,
0.0105475513,
0.0209952835,
0.0081653735,
-0.0535740852,
0.0004553044,
-0.005456876,
-0.090462938,
-0.0501501374,
0.0263885856,
0.0271763019,
0.0121590672,
-0.0157347415,
-0.0441317707,
-0.0222759843,
0.0536455549,
-0.0470574424,
0.0308924187,
-0.054911077,
-0.0011784427,
0.0161884148,
0.0582370237,
-0.0112074092,
0.1106623933,
-0.0347882211,
0.0038534009,
0.0371517055,
0.0427834094,
-0.0229440685,
-0.0311022829,
0.0249979198,
0.0115196034,
-0.0124061545,
-0.0088711772,
-0.0081002647,
-0.0235480536,
-0.0218610913,
-0.0143318698,
-0.0555085652,
0.0224028751,
-0.0278358608,
0.0266491827,
0.014608874,
0.0268751942,
0.0078654578,
0.00598482,
-0.0182800349,
-0.0148848807,
-0.0115055274,
0.03814568,
-0.0002005509,
-0.0150915179,
-0.0234896969,
-0.0226068236,
-0.0204598065,
0.0071647749,
0.0584570989,
-0.0221768301,
-0.0314743295,
-0.0131197283,
0.0393958278,
-0.0280938093,
0.0271463618,
-0.004888643,
-0.0162467752,
-0.0164673496,
-0.0236113444,
0.0691125095,
0.0465873666,
0.0201348066,
0.0090031363,
0.0203034729,
-0.0477682836,
-0.0346133709,
0.0113171041,
-0.0100765685,
0.0193577632,
-0.0146677429,
-0.0099686645,
-0.0298232827,
0.0952300727,
-0.0086665256,
-0.0191022865,
-0.0434052758,
-0.0117350826,
0.01060984,
-0.0058638938,
0.005677463,
-0.0002929216,
-0.017613994,
0.0150768487,
-0.0405987464,
-0.0382646844,
0.0761497393,
-0.054975573,
0.0053580482,
-0.0338360481,
0.0167880543,
-0.0272654165,
0.0575406663,
-0.0123710455,
0.0239874665,
-0.0092501389,
-0.0216345061,
-0.0312570371,
0.0275143478,
-0.0035631473,
-0.0414594598,
0.0507742465,
-0.0436449647,
0.0283314064,
-0.025639046,
-0.0286866613,
-0.0640177727,
0.0067335581,
-0.0213944428,
0.0159189142,
0.0265277289,
-0.0171992164,
-0.0166833494,
0.0044941902,
-0.0115084536,
0.0759005249,
-0.0024562955,
0.0295790099,
-0.0118257683,
0.0449385978,
0.0600830726,
-0.0036084428,
0.004612789,
-0.0392351486,
0.0111973807,
0.0845222846,
0.0291028228,
0.0206958633,
-0.0075383084,
-0.0064703044,
0.0294724368,
0.0024153821,
0.0054852935,
0.0232156422,
0.0348130502,
-0.0789971873,
-0.0394800603,
0.0921928361,
0.0012119991,
-0.0756872371,
0.0013298037,
0.0202894863,
0.0359344669,
0.0157205071,
0.0146922814,
-0.0875606611,
-0.0593410768,
0.0148668326,
0.0117106233,
-0.0048918459,
-0.0023557995,
-0.0154332919,
-0.119097732,
0.0144928582,
-0.0007467457,
-0.0218245797,
0.0039670579,
-0.0368954763,
-0.007047018,
0.0302931909,
-0.009860727,
0.0115464311,
0.0138385156,
-0.0222017206,
0.0056786044,
0.0228824466,
-0.0472684838,
0.0373882912,
-0.0242006052,
0.0014201353,
0.0560767725,
0.0203456804,
0.0609251149,
-0.0493646972,
0.040090017,
-0.0392912626,
-0.0177043416,
-0.0067299553,
0.0164048914,
-0.0255559161,
0.0092962356,
-0.0137017695,
0.0281264652,
-0.0132180126,
-0.0216769483,
-0.0154611431,
0.0435202047,
0.0084029557,
-0.0232856665,
-0.0118009178,
-0.0008906856,
-0.007605894,
0.0544103459,
0.066741854,
-0.0122862784,
-0.0494310856,
-0.0102061993,
0.0065988149,
-0.0886581615,
0.0025209906,
0.0132654132,
0.0160186458,
-0.0556875989,
-0.0588212386,
-0.0098533193,
-0.008798549,
0.015773518,
-0.0276498217,
0.0122014852,
-0.0158839561,
-0.0308578089,
-0.0784064457,
0.022336537,
-0.0527003556,
0.0060338997,
-0.0224226825,
-0.0196833611,
0.0153881218,
-0.0150333904,
-0.0197763853,
0.0555381067,
-0.1399942636,
-0.0758810192,
-0.0092107654,
0.0168078206,
0.0080635119,
0.0752823427,
-0.0011926892,
-0.0548507497,
0.0329028778,
0.0247557927,
-0.0108124251,
0.0148842279,
-0.0202020761,
-0.0108616892,
-0.006398119,
0.0425716117,
-0.0445906781,
0.024791114,
0.0343258008,
0.0416554734,
0.0103106024,
0.0019381145,
-0.0260844622,
-0.0266853701,
0.0046180887,
-0.0350056961,
-0.0006227835,
-0.0315364599,
0.0541467927,
0.0079479711,
-0.0113721415,
-0.0400648825,
0.0136079155,
0.0188240968,
-0.0144796884,
0.0156964157,
-0.0056587583,
0.0492280312,
0.0110671753,
-0.0208558589,
-0.0247052293,
0.0173054021,
0.0114024142,
0.0154447835,
-0.0178576801,
-0.045891203,
0.0180809908,
-0.0006246942,
0.0588563383,
-0.0573307499,
0.009083339,
0.006462723,
-0.0105860233,
-0.0377946161,
0.0002789902,
-0.0413687117,
-0.0237386953,
-0.053119164,
0.0060694776,
0.0682689622,
-0.0160533637,
0.0278464034,
-0.0019355125,
-0.0215289518,
-0.0143693825,
0.0080660488,
-0.0154990098,
-0.0579774827,
-0.0025609098,
0.0332101993,
-0.0115127163,
-0.0029371888,
0.0834672004,
0.0378398187,
0.0421985313,
-0.0284919161,
-0.0041008419,
-0.0246743541,
-0.0532785319,
-0.0099772308,
0.0218990017,
-0.0062841214,
-0.0015762625,
-0.0396342166,
-0.0757100359,
0.017861383,
-0.0351731442,
0.0051132357,
-0.0052502914,
0.0438550785,
0.0603054352,
-0.0036663178,
-0.0482129864,
-0.023430679,
0.0077671679,
-0.005519894,
-0.0256869197,
-0.0437659919,
-6.995628429e-33,
-0.0164909847,
-0.0150937531,
0.029783871,
-0.0445747711,
-0.0580816269,
0.022294132,
-0.0505218022,
-0.0472423509,
0.0030185466,
-0.0089418963,
0.0069203596,
0.0164506864,
0.0178840756,
0.0556557849,
-0.0297051761,
-0.0310886819,
0.0536214411,
0.017294962,
-0.0182869919,
0.0799079463,
0.0415337235,
0.0415582806,
0.051647719,
0.0109750042,
-0.0146185523,
-0.0113201942,
0.0420253538,
-0.0029717356,
-0.01308564,
0.0299449414,
-0.0625491366,
0.0095929559,
0.0214792006,
-0.032784339,
-0.0263755266,
0.0042533195,
-0.0919443965,
-0.0015330403,
0.0004273979,
-0.0041258289,
-0.0236345455,
-0.0691898242,
0.0313183405,
0.0404493921,
0.025628373,
-0.0291857198,
0.0082358625,
-0.0055591566,
-0.0626600459,
-0.0541628934,
-0.0724456832,
0.0481333472,
0.0250393245,
-0.0080045704,
0.0241611693,
0.004791996,
0.0114867613,
0.0492739715,
-0.0597002655,
-0.0051825522,
-0.00229542,
0.0785078257,
0.0632240176,
0.055665344,
0.0250082221,
0.0513747148,
0.0526124313,
-0.0113915671,
-0.0324534699,
0.0346005857,
0.0280212555,
0.0419649258,
0.0079093296,
0.0217311401,
0.0736921951,
-0.0039322902,
-0.0744433627,
-0.0401431359,
-0.019845305,
0.0285147261,
0.0687639117,
0.0038752379,
-0.0180224348,
-0.0464328714,
-0.0312151089,
0.0181085281,
-0.0510836728,
0.0071356255,
0.0235295054,
0.0588698648,
-0.0432526991,
-0.0299087185,
0.0483862534,
-0.0246368628,
0.0144550148,
0.0284000356,
0.0125667471,
0.0078011844,
-0.0027187816,
0.0313900188,
-0.016264623,
-0.0395394936,
0.0178394206,
-0.0160911418,
-0.0092031863,
0.0002245749,
0.0139099341,
0.0086784922,
-0.0368281379,
0.0095577901,
-0.0767474324,
0.0153554128,
-0.0107765794,
0.0729333535,
0.0247879755,
0.0128638921,
-0.0007236043,
0.0534549505,
0.0390249565,
0.0400120281,
0.0054638525,
-0.0159038715,
0.0096537517,
0.0493748933,
-0.0266479906,
0.0147477398,
-0.0598182864,
-0.014713347,
-0.0054728407,
-0.0724436939,
-0.0130125238,
0.0658930242,
2.83e-7,
0.0041868952,
0.0090752002,
0.0707366392,
-0.003283717,
0.010181007,
0.0047836173,
0.0573804975,
0.0059754648,
0.0113687264,
0.0041598529,
0.0036059574,
0.0387209058,
0.057200361,
0.0428135693,
-0.1024650112,
0.0307290293,
-0.086434342,
0.0191808976,
-0.051669836,
-0.0548299812,
-0.0011407017,
0.1108577922,
-0.0184291638,
-0.0210413113,
0.0486326329,
-0.029734483,
0.0616168417,
0.0356485955,
0.0272797309,
0.0261029508,
0.029553568,
0.0189122483,
-0.0082375128,
-0.0187107604,
-0.0188744832,
0.0127350781,
-0.0236835182,
0.0669258833,
0.0119731938,
-0.0662333742,
0.0107275089,
-0.0265002251,
-0.0092937024,
-0.036902599,
0.0838445723,
-0.0462582856,
-0.002229976,
-0.0489670411,
0.019875858,
-0.0043637417,
-0.0102769313,
-0.0095459903,
-0.0127353361,
0.0390781388,
0.00709002,
-0.0183642637,
-0.0160171352,
-0.1069620997,
-0.0374797732,
-0.0329825915,
-0.0832532123,
-0.0108661111,
-0.0673288852,
-0.0253081489,
0.0210188981,
-0.0304749403,
0.0229381509,
2.895643678e-34,
0.0305065699,
-0.0103568109,
-0.0294165928,
0.0427975357,
0.0283869673,
-0.0167084541,
-0.0031480554,
0.0169398859,
-0.0021661073,
-0.0744246095,
-0.0378874391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13009v1 | Detecting Errors through Ensembling Prompts (DEEP): An End-to-End LLM Framework for Detecting Factual Errors | 2024-06-18T18:59:37 | 2024-06-18T18:59:37 | Alex Chandler, Devesh Surve, Hui Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurate text summarization is one of the most common and important tasks
performed by Large Language Models, where the costs of human review for an
entire document may be high, but the costs of errors in summarization may be
even greater. We propose Detecting Errors through Ensembling Prompts (DEEP) -
an end-to-end large language model framework for detecting factual errors in
text summarization. Our framework uses a diverse set of LLM prompts to identify
factual inconsistencies, treating their outputs as binary features, which are
then fed into ensembling models. We then calibrate the ensembled models to
produce empirically accurate probabilities that a text is factually consistent
or free of hallucination. We demonstrate that prior models for detecting
factual errors in summaries perform significantly worse without optimizing the
thresholds on subsets of the evaluated dataset. Our framework achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) balanced accuracy on the AggreFact-XSUM FTSOTA,
TofuEval Summary-Level, and HaluEval Summarization benchmarks in detecting
factual errors within transformer-generated text summaries. It does so without
any fine-tuning of the language model or reliance on thresholding techniques
not available in practical settings. | [
0.0578647479,
0.020092573,
0.0352203622,
0.031554278,
-0.0103655746,
0.0315051116,
-0.0030637509,
-0.0142237674,
-0.0095750662,
-0.072557196,
0.0147366021,
-0.0653620064,
0.072485961,
0.0077627786,
0.0122353183,
-0.0311816633,
0.0571111813,
-0.028892573,
-0.035150677,
-0.010845162,
0.0116158146,
0.0109853623,
0.0083897104,
0.0355709642,
-0.0070434734,
-0.016218977,
-0.0086452169,
0.0130316485,
0.0379525758,
0.0261385944,
0.0134408083,
0.0539475568,
-0.0197914056,
0.0934227034,
0.0000018383,
-0.0540805683,
-0.0451195017,
-0.010624011,
-0.010536084,
0.0236829687,
0.0312984213,
-0.0220247544,
-0.0151831163,
0.033616025,
0.02517136,
0.003392118,
0.0129474876,
0.0730752349,
0.0803391188,
0.066900745,
0.015442933,
0.0014770838,
0.0218922663,
-0.0059525878,
-0.0339499637,
0.0032787852,
0.0258507729,
0.0035088046,
-0.035177689,
0.0084289238,
-0.0039194287,
0.010735685,
0.0004368832,
-0.037430238,
-0.0107929949,
-0.0066897306,
-0.0333779119,
-0.0165360421,
-0.0003059865,
0.0493295565,
0.0068335063,
-0.0306962151,
-0.0055560931,
0.0090919873,
0.0135813719,
0.0057130288,
-0.0105615631,
0.0707589909,
-0.0589068234,
0.04262916,
-0.0089495461,
-0.0258614253,
0.0136287222,
0.0392211229,
-0.0074009118,
0.0560172386,
0.0034634981,
-0.02341602,
-0.0325528234,
0.0393499099,
-0.011116785,
-0.0655825958,
0.0128146755,
0.0206656698,
-0.0450048484,
-0.0419671983,
-0.0679017827,
-0.0320706815,
0.0561925843,
-0.0365989357,
0.0084229,
-0.0286783092,
-0.0281366706,
0.0664071366,
-0.0160584245,
0.0559269153,
0.0527640246,
0.0188984722,
-0.0290574152,
-0.0243471973,
0.0050162766,
0.0031519847,
-0.0157118868,
0.0151399672,
-0.0685551316,
0.0143621061,
-0.045393575,
-0.0058466,
-0.0135262916,
0.057560239,
-0.0067315237,
-0.0007587739,
0.0009757382,
-0.0328512937,
-0.0316406861,
0.0137856305,
0.0261728466,
-0.0084368614,
0.0296412501,
-0.0421364792,
-0.0285890549,
0.0174363237,
-0.0130341947,
0.0150935566,
0.0032614765,
-0.0172895361,
-0.0197381154,
-0.0290376581,
-0.006456722,
-0.0388633832,
-0.0350233354,
-0.0326599553,
-0.0260797031,
-0.0826489851,
-0.0138045708,
-0.0193012599,
0.0175099075,
-0.0142234899,
0.0009267841,
0.0283531118,
-0.0376792587,
0.0420995019,
-0.0534964576,
0.0126378899,
0.034132909,
0.0049226098,
0.0085690813,
0.0321030244,
0.0239566527,
0.0312557258,
0.0593636781,
0.0388631523,
0.0424589999,
-0.0011876973,
-0.0198649094,
0.0291985087,
0.0097744893,
-0.0322859734,
-0.0129650803,
-0.0184013583,
0.047981184,
0.087554276,
-0.0208785739,
-0.0070400452,
0.0788834691,
0.0133875404,
-0.0110917017,
0.0051744333,
-0.0045321379,
0.0264944993,
0.0470058061,
0.037026763,
-0.044991836,
0.0130330436,
-0.0695850998,
0.0157175735,
0.0960189477,
0.052932404,
-0.008969306,
-0.052625224,
-0.0215259343,
0.0073364,
-0.0121960137,
-0.0250949059,
0.0242639147,
0.0083833318,
-0.0591541603,
0.0447137989,
-0.0004723241,
-0.0648798048,
0.0099575426,
-0.0415622778,
0.0185611714,
0.0770880729,
0.0728148818,
-0.0097320359,
0.0105351917,
-0.0338307694,
0.0109250601,
0.0610455088,
0.0380098261,
-0.0220166873,
-0.0130812135,
-0.0405600108,
-0.0294982195,
0.0084226243,
0.0453422405,
-0.0282626096,
-0.0027782437,
-0.0115714241,
0.0307586547,
-0.0126640666,
-0.0693664253,
0.0357630961,
0.0038306343,
-0.0157947037,
-0.0269714836,
-0.0259169526,
-0.0026770746,
0.0092953825,
-0.0452930406,
0.0069502858,
-0.0002521006,
0.0072140042,
-0.055834122,
-0.0342869796,
0.0095630419,
-0.0354221724,
0.0480252095,
-0.0388072878,
-0.0230868515,
0.0030670941,
-0.0683504641,
-0.0448829979,
-0.0418206118,
-0.0506275482,
-0.0287281461,
-0.0665688813,
0.0569683276,
0.0073262448,
0.0161141939,
-0.029609276,
0.0310349017,
-0.0151160648,
0.0253080949,
-0.0065370533,
-0.0599456057,
-0.0178814158,
-0.0272718277,
-0.03228008,
0.0131136253,
0.0135577181,
0.0471157841,
0.0395707935,
0.0023435352,
-0.0133675747,
-0.0437686816,
-0.1091363281,
-0.012990172,
-0.0405475274,
0.0030993912,
0.040672794,
0.0039058316,
-0.0135429213,
-0.0041995947,
0.0098950332,
-0.0531132668,
0.0485508628,
0.0150790997,
0.0481334254,
-0.0143352756,
0.0198487137,
-0.0463355295,
-0.0027862617,
-0.0135740312,
0.0402908698,
0.0141457031,
-0.0460802801,
-0.1008995846,
0.0349977985,
-0.0231701676,
-0.0104694553,
0.0100374632,
0.0029578046,
-0.0145991528,
0.0160992369,
0.04015233,
0.0306736417,
0.0531518348,
0.0063196789,
0.0388969854,
-0.0134434281,
-0.0226975698,
-0.010898971,
-0.0178185776,
-0.0022823471,
0.0089709731,
-0.0242992975,
0.0428444743,
0.0300954618,
-0.0020027414,
-0.0004879851,
-0.0031169264,
0.0298018567,
-0.0185258687,
0.000832343,
-0.0360414982,
-0.0414855853,
0.0004329116,
0.0557971224,
-0.053897813,
-0.0187914874,
0.0716241375,
-0.0446255803,
0.0319198258,
-0.0578191206,
0.0043191663,
-0.0343146101,
-0.0004603017,
0.0238737799,
0.0199328214,
-0.009253948,
-0.0025701339,
-0.0374919474,
-0.0152540077,
0.0513767153,
-0.0446108617,
0.1130819842,
-0.0610827766,
0.022149507,
-0.0119839814,
-0.0137277003,
-0.0217493065,
-0.049268119,
-0.0131242704,
0.0034328904,
-0.0116947955,
-0.0173937902,
-0.0932288617,
0.001810167,
0.0319413207,
0.0728645623,
-0.0199538115,
-0.0321478099,
-0.0178856328,
0.0312927701,
0.0535389371,
0.0206073187,
0.0840989575,
-0.0826179236,
0.0422220677,
0.0682333335,
0.0025955222,
0.0061455774,
0.0430926606,
-0.0472405292,
0.0204385128,
-0.0733112246,
-0.0234623943,
-0.0290675778,
0.0608144403,
-0.0477408618,
-0.002691458,
0.1093126461,
0.0241023824,
-0.0365387797,
-0.0191961825,
0.0115685957,
0.0061598946,
-0.00516085,
0.0021442601,
-0.0759711191,
-0.0177628044,
0.0373220928,
0.0360326879,
-0.0007299448,
-0.0257309731,
0.0043823114,
-0.097161226,
0.0437946506,
0.0324318483,
-0.0232468508,
-0.0686052442,
-0.0187718384,
0.0235833619,
-0.0050481823,
0.064058505,
0.0539334193,
-0.0240949318,
-0.0000297491,
0.0125796972,
-0.062628001,
-0.0461526513,
-0.0232206658,
-0.0358390883,
0.0213784147,
0.0584912896,
0.0072211465,
-0.0037404273,
0.016114464,
0.0416144058,
-0.0065460745,
-0.0337207466,
0.0123210913,
0.0921009183,
0.0046131746,
0.0281151719,
-0.0199239962,
0.0086425152,
-0.0125934174,
-0.0184095912,
-0.0100480886,
0.0169036444,
-0.016085811,
-0.0315580107,
-0.0246410873,
0.0256557092,
-0.0113123031,
0.0670878664,
0.0058209379,
0.0113850851,
-0.0581108779,
-0.0665041879,
0.0008447097,
-0.0266864616,
0.0106146177,
0.0261911135,
-0.0025281839,
-0.0015285125,
-0.079697527,
-0.0367616117,
0.0078000282,
-0.0362844244,
-0.0058045709,
-0.0266440157,
-0.018130511,
0.0048030154,
-0.0079829451,
-0.0028416114,
-0.0196277574,
0.0252607334,
-0.042514585,
0.031067891,
0.0426817872,
0.0071365172,
0.0005778684,
0.0173388515,
-0.0856139511,
-0.0463438481,
0.0109275952,
0.0109345149,
0.025470864,
0.0509987287,
-0.0105748316,
-0.0111949202,
0.0789261609,
0.0799137726,
0.0242734738,
0.0611627698,
-0.006453733,
0.0060451385,
-0.0298302043,
0.0068492852,
-0.0551254041,
0.0085858712,
-0.0340951942,
0.0408306196,
-0.0279986262,
-0.0773366839,
0.0168029293,
0.036392156,
0.0202088859,
-0.0162485782,
0.0253071785,
-0.0415713601,
0.0118503151,
0.0125435591,
-0.0302039366,
-0.0146670155,
0.0604306646,
-0.0135433963,
-0.0068335538,
-0.0052554323,
0.0773150772,
-0.0124384509,
0.0332089774,
-0.0172096994,
0.0000145578,
-0.0378388762,
0.0107325977,
-0.0128185265,
-0.0343335569,
-0.0307576638,
-0.019505702,
0.0051007872,
0.036064513,
0.0354746319,
0.0229774695,
0.0327275954,
0.0042292816,
-0.0218897779,
0.0250114314,
-0.075357087,
-0.0127388686,
-0.0926065072,
0.0337740257,
0.052973181,
0.0035681194,
0.0783253014,
-0.0300024506,
-0.0127420975,
-0.0400863737,
0.0109943785,
0.0548988581,
0.0147434445,
-0.0218530744,
0.0204301421,
0.0002330794,
0.0166522451,
0.0642719567,
-0.0296520256,
0.0282821767,
0.0055214623,
-0.0425982475,
-0.0296949819,
-0.0737967268,
-0.0502040125,
-0.0203824937,
-0.0011581175,
-0.0345197171,
-0.0633400604,
-0.0219714735,
0.0707089603,
0.056878373,
0.0363729708,
-0.0265223924,
-0.0060719009,
0.0383967347,
0.0166379176,
0.0291894078,
-0.0640708581,
-0.0186897926,
0.0224956647,
0.000085816,
-0.0212345887,
-5.788227856e-33,
-0.0360782035,
-0.038094528,
-0.0422862619,
0.0261859186,
-0.0198130719,
-0.0007206218,
-0.0332907252,
-0.0113793248,
0.0264948364,
0.0404942073,
-0.0057769469,
0.0443794094,
0.0147019671,
0.0226169713,
-0.0023508137,
0.0159220211,
0.0763831958,
0.0102792839,
-0.0486098342,
0.0172909442,
0.0515974164,
0.0017720172,
0.0460641198,
-0.0111649083,
0.0702520162,
-0.002475146,
-0.0572822057,
0.0246635117,
-0.0109833675,
0.0143875852,
0.0020440756,
0.0427989438,
0.0109558487,
-0.0238587763,
-0.0446158499,
-0.0178869497,
-0.070228599,
-0.0166271329,
0.0017879095,
-0.0081767542,
-0.0045000757,
-0.0072735338,
0.0398518518,
-0.0138183292,
-0.0229411423,
-0.0496139564,
0.0410085581,
-0.0535278618,
-0.0127087422,
-0.0721932799,
-0.0222150087,
0.0398477465,
0.0164069515,
0.0040941085,
-0.0311007053,
0.0387004837,
0.0117521435,
0.0168225542,
-0.079354465,
0.0164720435,
0.0592608638,
0.0279804673,
0.0242050625,
0.0091638407,
-0.0399785638,
0.1048856229,
-0.0000403925,
-0.0020660462,
-0.0680337995,
0.003935155,
-0.0068041417,
-0.0377573818,
0.0444454737,
0.0624912716,
0.0526337326,
0.0250811819,
-0.042500183,
0.0784010813,
-0.0272214916,
0.0229500011,
0.0291041918,
-0.0298635215,
-0.0131006446,
-0.0291906521,
-0.0407946669,
0.0247511361,
-0.0069714244,
0.0141682923,
-0.0151552316,
0.0220538974,
-0.0220220834,
-0.0294260364,
-0.0002447087,
-0.0520954654,
-0.0085582091,
-0.0112077836,
-0.0213927366,
-0.008545612,
0.0106570618,
0.004995903,
-0.001840569,
0.0093846759,
0.0112041924,
0.0213080347,
-0.0110449856,
0.0001435922,
0.0650930703,
0.0052235983,
-0.0860460028,
0.0457814336,
0.0214275271,
0.0517696142,
-0.0106157521,
0.0238382872,
0.0070517398,
-0.0240238402,
0.0036357073,
0.0158190709,
-0.0215687715,
0.025142394,
-0.0048525664,
0.0326943733,
-0.0030546,
0.0349533968,
-0.0143604521,
0.0125322174,
-0.0226328336,
-0.0240185224,
0.0279170237,
-0.0337632746,
0.0201703757,
0.0158123672,
2.471e-7,
0.0412060991,
0.0459278449,
0.0484456047,
-0.0364825241,
-0.0074531832,
0.0266150422,
-0.0211222358,
0.0204452369,
0.0161792934,
-0.0112430165,
0.0059784022,
0.0278158132,
0.0872731805,
0.0477221645,
-0.0791647434,
-0.0031625531,
-0.0716469884,
-0.0250648223,
-0.0217609089,
-0.0466532074,
0.0277093928,
0.0671398193,
-0.0049684118,
-0.0288304314,
-0.0009544422,
-0.0360325873,
0.0550707467,
-0.0085615478,
-0.0357944518,
0.0353285521,
0.090185307,
-0.0166308098,
0.0324692428,
0.0076968079,
-0.012808254,
-0.0320873819,
0.0246832613,
0.0249816347,
0.0097861392,
0.016491415,
-0.0380939879,
-0.0197151974,
0.0332001746,
-0.015561088,
0.0305602178,
-0.0157958921,
0.0243282784,
-0.0459933914,
-0.0366878621,
0.0046689888,
0.0388115384,
-0.0059410636,
-0.0461840145,
0.0380088054,
0.0005276593,
0.0208410304,
0.0150318136,
-0.0599272139,
-0.0265311915,
0.0194713399,
-0.0061944542,
-0.0710674152,
0.0224271361,
-0.0058700615,
-0.0141815897,
-0.0605904907,
0.0093972087,
2.694090937e-34,
0.1123680845,
-0.0215398688,
-0.022154754,
-0.0250234213,
0.0317421965,
-0.0064078108,
-0.0156772099,
-0.0119772367,
-0.0176120438,
-0.0532595627,
0.0043210015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12998v1 | Articulatory Encodec: Vocal Tract Kinematics as a Codec for Speech | 2024-06-18T18:38:17 | 2024-06-18T18:38:17 | Cheol Jun Cho, Peter Wu, Tejas S. Prabhune, Dhruv Agarwal, Gopala K. Anumanchipalli | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Vocal tract articulation is a natural, grounded control space of speech
production. The spatiotemporal coordination of articulators combined with the
vocal source shapes intelligible speech sounds to enable effective spoken
communication. Based on this physiological grounding of speech, we propose a
new framework of neural encoding-decoding of speech -- articulatory encodec.
The articulatory encodec comprises an articulatory analysis model that infers
articulatory features from speech audio, and an articulatory synthesis model
that synthesizes speech audio from articulatory features. The articulatory
features are kinematic traces of vocal tract articulators and source features,
which are intuitively interpretable and controllable, being the actual physical
interface of speech production. An additional speaker identity encoder is
jointly trained with the articulatory synthesizer to inform the voice texture
of individual speakers. By training on large-scale speech data, we achieve a
fully intelligible, high-quality articulatory synthesizer that generalizes to
unseen speakers. Furthermore, the speaker embedding is effectively disentangled
from articulations, which enables accent-perserving zero-shot voice conversion.
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of universal,
high-performance articulatory inference and synthesis, suggesting the proposed
framework as a powerful coding system of speech. | [
-0.0344191119,
0.1041427106,
0.013465344,
-0.0116179418,
0.0291294046,
-0.0140576651,
0.033214312,
-0.0028857484,
-0.0602037981,
0.0331680253,
-0.0673749596,
-0.0280842055,
0.0495996736,
0.0375367962,
0.0769052431,
-0.0419573635,
-0.0323560983,
-0.0288301837,
-0.0063146823,
-0.0207838807,
0.0042500948,
-0.0084990729,
-0.041122701,
0.032204736,
0.0083675254,
0.0262386911,
-0.0449433737,
0.0142047927,
0.0232215133,
0.0061543318,
-0.0358360671,
-0.0286086481,
0.0602595955,
0.0219720714,
0.0000017471,
0.0075488212,
0.0099368291,
0.0014771307,
-0.0804238692,
-0.0029971886,
0.0218887441,
0.0111423945,
-0.0218681861,
0.0193044133,
-0.0237308722,
-0.023115756,
0.0613058954,
-0.0246283412,
0.0644816831,
0.0375028215,
-0.0164459329,
-0.0362820178,
0.0359019376,
-0.0153711233,
-0.0541466996,
0.0440598577,
-0.0231536441,
-0.0537591875,
0.0039188596,
0.0131452177,
-0.0588631369,
0.0647876859,
0.0109351194,
0.0150092207,
0.0665952116,
0.0448711552,
-0.0042512948,
-0.0684506446,
0.0053496375,
0.0603035167,
0.0366489515,
0.0285353847,
0.0083575314,
0.0682170764,
0.0005900464,
-0.0181288645,
0.0050783558,
-0.001207603,
0.0280408878,
0.0231258515,
-0.0435391404,
0.0423095189,
0.0005054118,
-0.0508445725,
0.0026604061,
-0.0327062309,
-0.0032370202,
-0.0168559887,
0.0278532468,
-0.0198987704,
0.0037087351,
-0.0297019053,
0.0575800575,
0.0281390268,
0.0321977586,
-0.0254242681,
-0.0254285894,
-0.0511594638,
-0.0514263958,
-0.0153522305,
0.0188456289,
0.024820853,
-0.0138642564,
-0.0381603092,
-0.0364138968,
0.0429391265,
-0.0308593959,
-0.0047898623,
0.025872441,
-0.0065039606,
-0.0168127362,
-0.0330062322,
-0.0374538824,
0.0186009221,
-0.0165471844,
-0.0166123137,
-0.0013607505,
-0.0009810015,
-0.0768525228,
0.0154127805,
-0.0408335142,
0.056656912,
-0.0235800128,
-0.0058040023,
0.0052840565,
0.0180222858,
-0.0083063552,
0.0819477662,
-0.0123703359,
-0.0203091241,
-0.0261463951,
0.0313349664,
0.048257716,
0.0266717486,
0.0358575098,
0.0005468306,
0.0152790556,
0.0370760076,
0.0395308472,
-0.0225450844,
-0.0044516614,
0.0063695004,
0.0055091153,
-0.0688855425,
0.0297336616,
-0.0259732399,
-0.0024564944,
-0.0483432561,
-0.0102303121,
-0.0216189083,
0.0095354663,
0.0450397804,
-0.011649684,
0.0310167409,
0.0753391981,
-0.0070549557,
0.0110736834,
-0.0039214427,
0.0688675344,
-0.0086479541,
-0.0445695855,
-0.0352507904,
0.0116152819,
0.046290651,
0.069254145,
-0.0072360868,
-0.0364170745,
-0.0697185025,
-0.0214115288,
0.0568496659,
0.0595992096,
0.0238600913,
-0.0420155041,
-0.0499879941,
0.0636177883,
0.045134671,
0.0355328135,
-0.0022078634,
0.0322394185,
-0.0098072719,
-0.0150368232,
-0.0338712372,
0.0058146198,
0.040616557,
0.0171462093,
0.0091041597,
0.0082822647,
0.0215890389,
-0.0698458403,
-0.0035459138,
0.0424071662,
-0.0332474224,
0.0134118507,
0.001928883,
0.0382095687,
0.0215701796,
-0.0207612179,
0.0145078506,
-0.0441307127,
-0.0279710572,
0.0386256129,
-0.0033444713,
-0.0569393821,
-0.0027579649,
-0.0152178146,
0.005604316,
0.0003898824,
-0.0641636923,
0.009293424,
0.063603282,
-0.0702475756,
-0.0350731984,
0.0742145479,
-0.0385669507,
-0.0052477657,
0.0403468311,
-0.0099992165,
0.0229158383,
-0.0550449304,
0.0350682028,
-0.007574576,
0.0430232622,
0.0506433658,
-0.025057219,
-0.0688782856,
-0.0131144654,
0.0021286206,
0.0145333726,
0.0441370457,
0.0127293766,
-0.0506898873,
0.0026930228,
0.0123891952,
-0.0767865255,
-0.0234166794,
0.0397625975,
-0.0321178511,
-0.0301769394,
0.0231098477,
-0.0474114455,
0.0405069105,
-0.001611434,
0.0454888977,
-0.0987526476,
0.0565314516,
-0.0393340811,
0.0555903204,
-0.0055031045,
-0.0057450789,
0.0188541226,
-0.0105081983,
0.0327844396,
-0.0494505353,
0.0384736545,
-0.0317281224,
0.0213051271,
0.0389075354,
-0.012625224,
-0.0592352636,
-0.021419622,
0.0362106562,
0.013245522,
0.0197220389,
-0.0199973676,
-0.0092945909,
0.0263426341,
-0.0373313352,
-0.0997847766,
-0.002097046,
0.0262193959,
0.0055008973,
-0.0213437043,
0.0077831559,
0.0227436367,
-0.0272795372,
-0.0729730278,
-0.0187374037,
-0.0060405429,
-0.0181645602,
-0.0142141357,
0.0048667602,
-0.0349860117,
-0.006186415,
0.0151859429,
0.0198236946,
-0.0138292471,
-0.0169938393,
-0.0036839382,
-0.0278454963,
0.0040002475,
0.0277889203,
0.0292352494,
0.0092826905,
-0.0518772975,
-0.0079951314,
0.0039611273,
-0.0198597051,
0.0523266234,
-0.0170300249,
0.0057491688,
0.0220435038,
0.0030045733,
-0.0446148179,
-0.0003274199,
0.021587871,
0.0833558217,
-0.0353574194,
0.0335662253,
-0.0170771424,
0.025394896,
0.06934838,
0.0098343082,
-0.063306883,
-0.0132302362,
0.0133457156,
-0.0335972644,
-0.0043875952,
-0.0413559079,
-0.0111566214,
0.0208431017,
-0.0480440371,
-0.0139165353,
0.0445865989,
-0.027734274,
-0.0808887258,
0.0468191281,
-0.0206582844,
0.0206696298,
0.0087062884,
0.011361761,
0.0188861508,
-0.0190188345,
-0.0334826373,
-0.01675562,
0.0501366146,
-0.0098102465,
-0.0524313934,
0.0074581588,
-0.0370709486,
-0.0310937818,
-0.0207347311,
-0.0335268565,
-0.0120484615,
0.0264939498,
-0.0034994704,
0.0301026125,
-0.0344738103,
-0.0361271203,
0.0529490858,
0.008682183,
0.0337194465,
0.030888183,
0.0057951505,
0.0206524208,
-0.0134102013,
0.0170958173,
0.0090779876,
0.0688761175,
-0.0640302747,
-0.0085170073,
0.0530699342,
-0.0126238624,
0.0161711071,
0.0819660574,
-0.0399793386,
0.0205046274,
0.0122004412,
0.0612406172,
-0.0431352742,
-0.0285032876,
0.0217497181,
-0.0016058041,
0.0046566357,
0.0883238316,
-0.0291152466,
-0.0122590689,
-0.0097067645,
0.0412933491,
0.0365537666,
-0.0266637895,
-0.0068796366,
-0.0620243177,
0.0060156868,
0.0486228094,
0.0119954571,
0.0282949749,
0.0261483565,
0.0073304339,
-0.0631927997,
0.0328949094,
0.0522280186,
-0.0000426409,
-0.0696513951,
-0.0077821906,
0.0006144154,
-0.0060896836,
-0.0126504572,
0.0262461845,
0.035020873,
0.0089587932,
0.0392627083,
-0.0671854094,
-0.0258037783,
0.0089207422,
-0.0292391591,
0.1017957628,
0.0532870591,
0.0761917979,
-0.0213749837,
-0.03263909,
-0.0481264554,
0.0304742455,
-0.0153355151,
-0.0123764453,
0.0540764593,
0.049668029,
-0.0161980931,
0.0215582997,
0.0801959783,
-0.0307447463,
0.0401783697,
-0.0023631384,
0.0661503896,
-0.0388972387,
0.0289558563,
0.0000752958,
0.0101995971,
0.0011805716,
0.0541543141,
0.0217764471,
-0.0822108313,
-0.0258512888,
-0.0176027771,
0.0579753108,
-0.0174130406,
-0.0388739035,
0.0296525322,
0.026723275,
-0.0725580081,
-0.0613988824,
0.0184946135,
0.0092579145,
0.0732365772,
0.0402282402,
-0.0353574343,
0.0273745656,
-0.0316312015,
-0.0240453202,
-0.0444636084,
0.001841433,
0.0453651994,
0.0092148501,
-0.034730304,
0.0508944765,
-0.0357740633,
0.015528095,
0.0125881359,
0.0145026678,
-0.0659321621,
0.006494632,
-0.014762043,
0.0174947437,
0.0915777683,
-0.038131129,
-0.0258749593,
0.0788035244,
-0.0370565914,
-0.0309561845,
0.0688909888,
0.0743165165,
0.0036139153,
-0.0181221198,
0.002830365,
-0.0101939375,
0.0286459345,
-0.0420913026,
-0.0293900631,
-0.0304592215,
-0.0405535847,
-0.0114503615,
0.0019950422,
0.0113100978,
-0.0154897068,
0.0365781002,
-0.0375855863,
-0.0028068798,
-0.0099421879,
0.0864228383,
-0.0766489282,
-0.0250914693,
0.0529725179,
0.0383311138,
0.0031422533,
-0.0283332784,
0.0447805375,
0.0180110987,
0.0328968726,
0.0360268205,
-0.0050383015,
0.044611901,
-0.0139718289,
0.0492929816,
0.0172943119,
0.0462214835,
-0.0206097793,
0.0173967052,
-0.0007982834,
-0.0216144249,
0.0012866895,
-0.0142782284,
0.0162971821,
0.0206377413,
-0.039817743,
0.0287431814,
0.0113552297,
0.0036286116,
0.0043273452,
0.0257349107,
0.047316961,
0.0277783517,
0.0262477212,
0.0177185759,
0.0275057722,
-0.0727851763,
-0.0040914831,
0.0121926237,
-0.0051051974,
-0.0135819307,
-0.0014111565,
0.0084422193,
0.0096489945,
0.0415902324,
-0.0922149196,
0.0414160565,
-0.0181568358,
-0.0054122224,
-0.0032051383,
-0.0226236545,
0.0027891814,
0.0094468137,
0.0001258521,
-0.0438526049,
0.0309121534,
-0.0205575842,
-0.0007254882,
-0.0507463403,
0.0352824219,
-0.0429723896,
-0.0287081543,
0.0074395472,
0.0053233858,
-0.0473244712,
0.0201050807,
-0.0247048177,
-0.0247086249,
-4.987125149e-33,
-0.0578171872,
0.0176644772,
0.0163368247,
0.0479824804,
-0.0643402562,
-0.0089475177,
-0.0435793921,
-0.0159012787,
-0.0269859955,
0.003626578,
0.0069580553,
0.0232309178,
-0.0163151193,
0.0037700315,
0.0218672045,
0.0112882173,
0.0513848551,
-0.0431792326,
0.0477151386,
0.0317652561,
0.0805563554,
0.0203814656,
0.0324975997,
-0.0746996328,
-0.0497728996,
0.0309781507,
0.0059167482,
-0.0287845787,
0.0182471965,
-0.0331533477,
-0.0166102499,
0.0146268215,
-0.0163121689,
-0.026260484,
0.0059621516,
0.0165829305,
-0.0539929718,
-0.0360925868,
-0.0547859296,
0.0300533902,
-0.0334134549,
-0.0384056456,
0.0365628302,
-0.0087272385,
-0.023288209,
-0.0320725068,
0.0140863005,
-0.0365790613,
0.0057816841,
-0.0591229126,
-0.0095434114,
0.003670271,
-0.0140144136,
-0.0402926058,
0.0575066619,
0.0666602105,
-0.0319298729,
-0.0301162582,
-0.0560696609,
0.0300142989,
-0.0335429572,
0.018640222,
0.0301324632,
0.0403271168,
0.0475494154,
0.0332897119,
0.0410663895,
-0.0729554743,
-0.0235890243,
0.0571505353,
0.0438124463,
0.0700059831,
0.0297840163,
0.016149411,
0.003785179,
-0.0549924262,
0.0083849011,
-0.0063035307,
0.0110989725,
-0.0214533638,
-0.0223086141,
0.0524133667,
-0.0258340202,
-0.0187982488,
-0.0548337884,
-0.039959617,
0.0152649609,
-0.0271684993,
0.0199744385,
-0.0056467117,
0.0138775539,
-0.0075498275,
0.048024755,
-0.0272149537,
0.0192682575,
-0.0106405756,
-0.0197120849,
0.0210632943,
0.0231470671,
-0.0132064363,
0.0179281477,
-0.021680532,
0.0600138493,
0.056324631,
0.0664269179,
-0.0240816027,
-0.0308049694,
0.0596627519,
-0.0266340002,
-0.0408426449,
-0.0177423302,
0.0083244313,
0.0382413082,
-0.0248888377,
0.0306787752,
0.0301245041,
-0.0043302518,
0.0080268383,
-0.0391731374,
0.039451506,
-0.0071391254,
-0.0351803191,
-0.0229645949,
0.0117395837,
-0.0511110611,
0.0005575546,
0.0204859413,
-0.0456252098,
0.020973241,
-0.0542198718,
-0.0064648446,
-0.0031010439,
2.706e-7,
-0.0404486991,
-0.0436468571,
0.0640947744,
-0.0493675768,
0.062907055,
0.0144697018,
-0.0228136331,
0.0300142094,
-0.0049129389,
-0.1065419093,
-0.0056652082,
0.0253453162,
0.0736644045,
0.0117598716,
-0.04079739,
-0.0234634932,
-0.0480718128,
0.0004609991,
-0.0200205036,
-0.0068575041,
0.0106038656,
0.0521757044,
0.0015367981,
-0.0632963628,
0.071497038,
-0.0083347838,
0.0449862219,
0.0104653416,
0.0270804595,
-0.0546825938,
0.0155362086,
-0.0685932711,
-0.012205366,
0.0194709413,
-0.0167381819,
0.0349302813,
0.0041292231,
0.0513014272,
-0.0414516181,
-0.0270070471,
0.0105468193,
0.021970192,
-0.0591731742,
0.0430488102,
0.0380045362,
-0.0132613573,
-0.0478786156,
-0.0338968039,
-0.0263770074,
0.0066781212,
0.0113399988,
-0.0224436242,
0.0213374756,
-0.0189688392,
-0.0151558341,
-0.0305624343,
0.0253718141,
-0.0330608562,
-0.0213047452,
0.0066956161,
-0.1055782214,
-0.0031889474,
-0.0141113838,
-0.0216084309,
0.0061849393,
-0.0157445502,
-0.0273215733,
1.780983685e-34,
-0.0438940078,
-0.0253799316,
0.0591062047,
0.0342015848,
-0.0180789698,
-0.0313202664,
0.0021525992,
0.0310114082,
0.0462764874,
-0.0278846417,
-0.0479225181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12997v1 | Suitability of CCA for Generating Latent State/ Variables in Multi-View Textual Data | 2024-06-18T18:37:24 | 2024-06-18T18:37:24 | Akanksha Mehndiratta, Krishna Asawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The probabilistic interpretation of Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) for
learning low-dimensional real vectors, called as latent variables, has been
exploited immensely in various fields. This study takes a step further by
demonstrating the potential of CCA in discovering a latent state that captures
the contextual information within the textual data under a two-view setting.
The interpretation of CCA discussed in this study utilizes the multi-view
nature of textual data, i.e. the consecutive sentences in a document or turns
in a dyadic conversation, and has a strong theoretical foundation. Furthermore,
this study proposes a model using CCA to perform the Automatic Short Answer
Grading (ASAG) task. The empirical analysis confirms that the proposed model
delivers competitive results and can even beat various sophisticated supervised
techniques. The model is simple, linear, and adaptable and should be used as
the baseline especially when labeled training data is scarce or nonexistent. | [
0.0400442667,
0.0330128558,
-0.0214975365,
0.0272981562,
-0.0209411886,
0.0265969578,
-0.0024309114,
0.0035292853,
0.0085080098,
-0.0737047791,
0.0191160291,
-0.0537896678,
0.0104213227,
0.0112666599,
-0.0175102409,
-0.0393453091,
-0.0088213319,
0.0021377392,
0.0301837921,
-0.0213329028,
0.0127293011,
-0.0392569564,
-0.0062528462,
0.0156926848,
-0.0314677618,
-0.0397254787,
-0.007736037,
-0.0717465356,
0.0239292998,
0.0045893351,
-0.0152601795,
0.0633838773,
0.009704656,
-0.0481460392,
0.0000018489,
-0.0294875205,
-0.0149999913,
-0.0232212748,
0.0519071743,
-0.0005103768,
0.013103419,
0.0218082089,
0.0341974609,
0.0167783052,
-0.0738832802,
0.0179697014,
0.014468465,
0.0741943195,
0.0487743989,
0.0371877812,
-0.0075306329,
-0.0649357364,
-0.0181312412,
-0.0087934704,
-0.0027741084,
-0.0372420475,
0.0503345765,
0.0305776969,
-0.0148891481,
0.0131429313,
-0.0505003817,
0.0235556886,
-0.0231640525,
-0.0319514684,
-0.0146946898,
0.0335045345,
0.0109200533,
0.009391536,
0.02054107,
0.0952925757,
0.0387704559,
-0.0189112108,
0.0094779469,
-0.0080250958,
-0.0098209875,
0.0468005203,
-0.0340792313,
-0.0186225176,
-0.0351210199,
0.0486702137,
0.0199934244,
-0.001344142,
-0.026783837,
-0.0512475036,
-0.0009422289,
-0.0042571742,
0.0017440236,
-0.0279893354,
-0.0297398232,
0.0153252361,
-0.0104073742,
-0.0144742262,
0.0047864229,
0.0514090545,
0.0218484532,
0.0264215395,
0.0239986759,
-0.0694140568,
0.015105756,
-0.0758006573,
0.0025923892,
0.0024537139,
0.0050633838,
0.0274880957,
-0.0247280262,
0.0632011071,
0.0234060064,
-0.0034337887,
-0.0409952663,
0.0145404823,
-0.0412305109,
-0.0190924983,
0.0009329586,
0.0618922301,
0.0330935121,
0.015425344,
-0.0476529337,
-0.0188438743,
-0.0245312285,
0.0010509281,
0.0314642787,
0.0543060936,
0.018897498,
0.0812397674,
0.0057122544,
0.0206352863,
-0.0616788305,
0.0221210308,
-0.0546254888,
0.0202829558,
0.019241808,
0.0289104376,
0.048249159,
0.0127397524,
-0.0016147918,
0.0145716639,
-0.0103114042,
-0.0207773168,
0.033903271,
-0.0310131963,
-0.0813006163,
-0.0292623118,
-0.0045440332,
-0.0685489476,
0.0215565413,
0.0464114808,
0.0192626435,
0.0070724161,
0.0096256658,
0.023853384,
-0.0307128001,
0.0189258736,
0.0502640754,
0.0068825963,
0.0086962003,
0.013012453,
0.0629934818,
0.0301997997,
0.0551672354,
-0.0027960809,
0.0390272103,
-0.0212734826,
0.0712794662,
0.0066972366,
-0.0012701722,
-0.0372728519,
-0.0098571405,
0.0157080479,
0.0268427134,
-0.0247916728,
-0.0245325193,
0.0199644249,
0.01571385,
-0.030228572,
0.002099874,
0.0022516288,
0.0350847915,
-0.00544423,
0.0351514481,
-0.0173163228,
0.0474897288,
0.0504543446,
0.0178809147,
0.0027839718,
-0.0303322356,
-0.0177308992,
0.006952039,
-0.0077232779,
-0.0361530855,
-0.0464853868,
0.0073213559,
-0.0265084039,
-0.0448549688,
-0.0250988603,
0.0704395622,
-0.0453653149,
-0.0005987417,
-0.0351076573,
0.0121690631,
-0.0260078926,
0.0113335848,
-0.0188174099,
0.0291542467,
0.0216062851,
0.0588264354,
-0.030957751,
-0.0117522599,
0.0001464066,
0.0275681596,
-0.0471521392,
-0.0030630915,
-0.0409153141,
-0.026039483,
-0.0215606112,
-0.0256091859,
-0.0124397157,
0.0014077735,
0.0477074832,
-0.0380745195,
0.0275609102,
0.0149295637,
0.0209459066,
-0.0289225858,
0.018974958,
0.0555071607,
-0.0091175959,
0.0413276255,
0.0148302568,
0.019732587,
0.0530104637,
0.0176619627,
0.005249734,
0.070062615,
-0.03743352,
-0.0285745244,
0.0143211754,
-0.0655838102,
-0.0297706258,
-0.0056520035,
-0.0737854019,
0.0306976866,
0.0250502452,
-0.0063587916,
-0.0665993765,
0.0242239144,
-0.0227447078,
-0.0142882699,
0.0000539259,
-0.0009142817,
0.0056401449,
0.0002860254,
-0.0457254685,
0.0699341744,
0.0289072022,
0.0556409247,
0.0065070866,
-0.0087198922,
0.0604053736,
0.012677717,
-0.0180089343,
-0.0073850784,
0.005270204,
-0.0127847632,
0.0411216617,
-0.005030008,
-0.0038464076,
-0.0631192923,
-0.0736505836,
-0.0484738909,
-0.0120730186,
0.0091452114,
0.0327321887,
-0.0432971008,
0.0152487569,
0.0073295324,
-0.0804490969,
0.0492476784,
0.0408442542,
-0.0053730882,
0.0283518117,
0.0480710901,
-0.0292056762,
-0.0421790294,
0.0097334683,
-0.0527363606,
0.0447180457,
0.0766471997,
-0.0537021905,
-0.0274853632,
0.0515878834,
0.0108015705,
0.0373995602,
-0.038526196,
-0.0272132084,
0.0292865541,
-0.0247091502,
0.0658450425,
0.0175492968,
0.044111833,
0.0072462461,
0.0572868809,
-0.0293906629,
-0.0357270837,
0.0141533269,
-0.0517549179,
-0.0184303243,
-0.0504699275,
-0.0409981087,
-0.0418117456,
0.034660168,
0.0634870306,
-0.0315565057,
-0.0661086142,
0.0030333931,
-0.0105432989,
-0.0030232561,
-0.0612515993,
-0.0206285212,
-0.0217862576,
0.0155668231,
0.028958492,
-0.005999302,
0.0521718152,
-0.0253276229,
0.031120766,
-0.0186029784,
0.0311910752,
-0.0696900263,
0.0371417925,
0.017222289,
-0.0203342643,
-0.0592358112,
-0.0103690811,
-0.0076021906,
0.0227492377,
0.021293683,
-0.0401736163,
0.0103610251,
-0.0322086327,
-0.0082157208,
-0.0129602514,
-0.0179481655,
-0.0571743622,
-0.033120703,
0.0151247457,
-0.006393848,
0.0137189636,
0.0165524092,
-0.0125825852,
0.0261068214,
-0.0192700531,
-0.0161789637,
-0.0462032147,
0.004342793,
-0.0078390148,
0.0976204202,
0.0553974919,
-0.0080944551,
-0.0119676245,
-0.0143239424,
0.0315801129,
0.068794854,
0.0259488709,
0.0149813937,
0.0185084771,
-0.006894887,
-0.0076303645,
0.0076859603,
-0.0414000489,
0.0075530256,
-0.0230643768,
-0.0105642928,
-0.0215778574,
0.0809494779,
0.0435027629,
-0.1028086096,
-0.0191357229,
-0.0222115573,
-0.0429258235,
0.0259225033,
0.0189895574,
-0.0449403711,
-0.007762942,
-0.0646545291,
0.0315089449,
-0.0303550977,
-0.0505805425,
0.0009933341,
-0.0238195546,
-0.0195447151,
-0.0525802672,
-0.0258978046,
-0.0297658928,
-0.0833800361,
0.0140505647,
0.0031887365,
-0.0657150075,
-0.0031471846,
-0.0227052215,
0.0323310606,
0.0368162058,
-0.0257837754,
-0.0140039045,
0.0584531873,
0.0093700169,
0.0167455748,
0.0340358652,
0.0548221171,
-0.0319295712,
0.0084629469,
-0.0370263048,
-0.1105562076,
0.0172508974,
-0.00813682,
0.0354823545,
-0.0198579784,
0.0086810775,
-0.0116045214,
0.0426342413,
-0.015185561,
0.0048928927,
0.0613106601,
0.0714739934,
-0.0310060959,
-0.047452651,
-0.0188857019,
0.0216707271,
0.0133100385,
0.0735593811,
0.028927587,
-0.0485075638,
-0.0438067429,
-0.011878795,
0.0033506069,
0.0034158251,
-0.0084450357,
-0.0342050418,
0.0322264694,
-0.018058572,
-0.0858608261,
-0.0594408885,
0.0610339157,
0.0278455112,
0.0144098615,
0.0442610942,
-0.027875362,
0.0052183252,
-0.03658906,
-0.0301055051,
0.0019667102,
-0.0020245283,
-0.0486055985,
0.021879077,
0.0455298051,
-0.0590410456,
-0.0256775282,
-0.0126335202,
-0.070667617,
-0.0369894058,
0.0091906004,
0.0181106515,
0.008642829,
-0.0000170181,
-0.0028463569,
-0.0204054248,
0.0305899847,
0.0428818837,
-0.0237097051,
0.0196409374,
0.009553479,
0.0042824605,
0.0108466214,
0.00003666,
-0.0230065081,
0.0065788119,
0.0092942724,
0.0365783237,
-0.0346028209,
-0.0549567491,
0.0241765715,
0.0066171126,
0.0438601337,
0.0195042528,
-0.0126525695,
-0.0350160524,
0.0186035186,
-0.0563388579,
-0.0042033256,
0.0113009661,
0.0066494555,
-0.0403841361,
-0.0015260042,
-0.0487045497,
-0.0067973244,
-0.0417230725,
0.0249846131,
-0.0092229052,
0.020184204,
0.0523352101,
0.0026153033,
-0.0088872993,
-0.0243666712,
0.0057111126,
-0.0308722034,
0.0416039228,
0.00921968,
-0.005555877,
0.0647271052,
0.0183431208,
-0.0261944868,
-0.0244134683,
0.0020211374,
-0.0661735758,
0.0478753485,
-0.0361243114,
0.0370559245,
0.0146752363,
-0.0188326184,
0.0592881665,
-0.0432280004,
0.0341308862,
-0.0219387282,
0.0123324702,
0.045107089,
-0.0230306238,
0.075118579,
0.0060583893,
0.0192533918,
0.0220630541,
0.1118152291,
-0.0350106917,
0.0215149038,
-0.0455172323,
-0.0296074301,
-0.0395500697,
0.0059273541,
0.0426021293,
0.0039891326,
-0.003992517,
-0.0156304818,
-0.0550504327,
0.0066996282,
0.0299148429,
0.0169107858,
-0.0002556606,
0.0185111631,
0.0000441922,
0.0686722323,
0.0113947736,
0.0031545735,
-0.0918144137,
0.0160738844,
0.0233264193,
-0.0384660773,
-0.015478584,
-5.770995108e-33,
0.0079647005,
-0.0807697028,
-0.0002630031,
0.0893165842,
0.0233856309,
0.0165759046,
-0.0031805029,
0.0313014612,
-0.0112252366,
0.0129264267,
-0.0157890413,
-0.0046171243,
0.0065228757,
0.0046218126,
0.0564595275,
-0.0048719519,
-0.0192359928,
-0.0262618866,
0.0194262359,
0.0329802111,
0.0543963239,
-0.0131756226,
0.0465105101,
-0.0920070931,
0.0472296774,
-0.0150155574,
-0.0046276818,
-0.0188536625,
-0.0177831538,
0.0390511304,
-0.0293274708,
0.0394681022,
0.0605258495,
0.0135100465,
0.0348996446,
0.0177610125,
-0.0636528805,
-0.0616525002,
0.015851181,
-0.0055684745,
-0.0428273268,
-0.017374292,
-0.0149537837,
-0.0045704069,
-0.0073499866,
0.0505554564,
0.0873911157,
-0.0387289263,
0.0389903747,
-0.0527826324,
-0.022362642,
-0.0001162848,
-0.030611556,
0.036641594,
-0.001343744,
0.0985340178,
0.0016033638,
0.0404727161,
-0.0439220145,
0.069027856,
0.0242878385,
0.0289424825,
0.0260944273,
-0.0024020309,
-0.0156132719,
0.0424904749,
0.0107337311,
-0.0225366838,
-0.0477847308,
-0.0428151451,
-0.0043608081,
-0.0225853845,
0.0706194565,
0.0913352221,
0.011708973,
0.0103205396,
-0.1054394245,
0.0540645495,
0.0491681807,
0.0193041116,
0.0241293758,
-0.0682870224,
-0.0692246854,
-0.0244182069,
-0.0424108915,
0.0400987528,
-0.0420278795,
-0.0299028717,
0.0334925838,
-0.0065346253,
-0.0330644436,
-0.0158647131,
-0.0012266268,
-0.0387236923,
-0.0467044227,
0.045173645,
-0.0103471028,
0.0349821746,
0.0052402713,
-0.0289744716,
-0.0310722422,
-0.0119523089,
0.0417525247,
-0.0310459659,
0.0236972403,
-0.0250093825,
0.0253244005,
-0.0385656692,
-0.0334587507,
-0.0376517475,
0.0179852489,
-0.0282871239,
-0.0144639481,
-0.0576937497,
0.0102398973,
0.0091785472,
-0.0002690289,
0.0546365604,
0.0104796467,
0.0282449555,
0.0003165735,
-0.0666438714,
0.0552587658,
0.0098693464,
-0.0245569348,
-0.0084811784,
-0.0053207027,
0.0027028893,
-0.0006864722,
-0.0373442769,
0.0174452849,
0.0438232981,
2.487e-7,
0.065083243,
0.0481117032,
0.0180553645,
-0.0309426803,
0.0462152958,
0.0066501475,
-0.0163876154,
0.0098511185,
0.0321539119,
-0.0167018436,
0.0437880419,
-0.0106928628,
-0.0210317578,
0.0379411578,
-0.0578021705,
-0.0125909718,
0.0030628226,
-0.0613002293,
-0.0188779105,
-0.000052704,
0.1335359365,
0.0290062558,
0.003411751,
0.0172141232,
-0.051454585,
0.0211275145,
0.0535085239,
0.01145887,
-0.0065407809,
0.0135126552,
0.0321922787,
-0.0824582726,
0.0354432464,
0.0342857987,
0.0052496805,
0.0074321404,
0.0350083522,
0.0226544961,
0.01401552,
-0.0412351675,
0.0344781019,
0.0242231749,
-0.0022909427,
-0.0409497507,
0.110886313,
-0.0454883985,
-0.0242413376,
-0.0063818437,
-0.0357711986,
0.025793124,
0.0031461741,
0.0287821013,
0.016116336,
0.0210885145,
-0.0289805699,
-0.0172826722,
0.0275229402,
-0.0544926412,
0.0459539182,
-0.0158104952,
-0.037668623,
-0.0107528176,
-0.0076777842,
0.0032552569,
0.0466972068,
-0.0317635648,
0.0255840123,
2.093851149e-34,
0.0299279578,
-0.0283034649,
0.0026280766,
-0.0367102809,
-0.0221590027,
-0.0121945189,
-0.0578634106,
0.0206050295,
0.0197933856,
-0.1196328551,
-0.0427454747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12975v1 | SHIELD: Evaluation and Defense Strategies for Copyright Compliance in LLM Text Generation | 2024-06-18T18:00:03 | 2024-06-18T18:00:03 | Xiaoze Liu, Ting Sun, Tianyang Xu, Feijie Wu, Cunxiang Wang, Xiaoqian Wang, Jing Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed machine learning but raised
significant legal concerns due to their potential to produce text that
infringes on copyrights, resulting in several high-profile lawsuits. The legal
landscape is struggling to keep pace with these rapid advancements, with
ongoing debates about whether generated text might plagiarize copyrighted
materials. Current LLMs may infringe on copyrights or overly restrict
non-copyrighted texts, leading to these challenges: (i) the need for a
comprehensive evaluation benchmark to assess copyright compliance from multiple
aspects; (ii) evaluating robustness against safeguard bypassing attacks; and
(iii) developing effective defenses targeted against the generation of
copyrighted text. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a curated dataset to
evaluate methods, test attack strategies, and propose lightweight, real-time
defenses to prevent the generation of copyrighted text, ensuring the safe and
lawful use of LLMs. Our experiments demonstrate that current LLMs frequently
output copyrighted text, and that jailbreaking attacks can significantly
increase the volume of copyrighted output. Our proposed defense mechanisms
significantly reduce the volume of copyrighted text generated by LLMs by
effectively refusing malicious requests. Code is publicly available at
https://github.com/xz-liu/SHIELD | [
0.0266024061,
0.0702860951,
-0.0162297487,
0.06422849,
-0.0677568913,
-0.0032915685,
0.0508139916,
0.0224615932,
0.0293111596,
-0.0339502916,
0.0217208676,
-0.0041793878,
0.0085427342,
0.0187215358,
0.0372306667,
0.0441583022,
-0.0049327505,
-0.0114675313,
0.000531871,
-0.0260912515,
0.0038059331,
0.0299493074,
0.0201417636,
0.0236829035,
0.005831277,
-0.0217584558,
0.0032167181,
0.0250998661,
0.0165822152,
-0.0134359216,
0.0042240475,
0.0588118732,
-0.018283926,
0.0882406309,
0.0000018299,
-0.0636907816,
-0.0152122173,
0.0356999114,
0.0032449341,
0.0591225736,
0.0781373531,
-0.0138958106,
-0.0316839032,
0.0244353544,
-0.0280879121,
0.0562401451,
0.0090771532,
0.0197045319,
0.0731767565,
0.0618181527,
-0.0179582965,
-0.0207082797,
0.0436236635,
-0.0262097511,
0.0164929982,
-0.0106637711,
0.0078310138,
0.0164138768,
0.0262836423,
0.0070940685,
0.027719859,
0.0359881483,
0.0098544136,
-0.0175388176,
-0.0230776761,
0.0007831682,
-0.0468793437,
-0.0133315036,
-0.0049008061,
0.0442488417,
-0.020488048,
-0.0585615784,
0.0245046131,
-0.0114785563,
0.0315347202,
0.0201194379,
-0.0066199051,
0.0777576342,
-0.0019197366,
0.0166465696,
-0.0143658482,
-0.0228188932,
0.0347031802,
0.0215592105,
0.0189293977,
0.0055310512,
0.0282291248,
-0.0562734008,
0.0018557995,
-0.0196527243,
0.03089826,
-0.0654193237,
0.0315435119,
-0.0250516441,
0.0533309057,
-0.0028585352,
-0.0893106535,
-0.0720597506,
0.0405291989,
-0.0677543208,
0.0124757029,
0.0045193778,
-0.0026044121,
0.020028336,
-0.0565119125,
0.0100379083,
-0.031180175,
0.0466270484,
0.0576391593,
0.009443569,
0.001779502,
-0.0104638543,
-0.0065358067,
0.0482841432,
-0.0227971561,
-0.0026409456,
-0.0372462459,
0.0421163775,
-0.0134548144,
0.0511763245,
-0.0407560579,
0.0040271608,
0.0395548269,
0.0263022166,
0.0458417274,
-0.0608082153,
0.0274284426,
0.0142164035,
-0.007431699,
-0.0499691293,
0.0043009031,
0.0180586837,
-0.0296377838,
-0.0236645732,
0.0381878801,
0.1266383976,
0.0435376205,
-0.0171179771,
-0.0008486042,
-0.0685207322,
0.0001246835,
-0.026679961,
-0.009184069,
-0.0750809312,
-0.0186279658,
-0.0094538024,
-0.0055267802,
-0.0810323507,
0.0099273771,
0.032841932,
-0.0561081134,
0.0136519866,
-0.0021866516,
-0.0006504967,
-0.0076772096,
0.0089709349,
-0.000517136,
0.003604071,
0.0401755422,
0.0401667468,
0.0611174963,
-0.0088948477,
0.0390198305,
0.0691166371,
0.0297850519,
0.0561806709,
-0.0438081846,
-0.025104994,
0.0268999524,
-0.0272677634,
-0.0135700116,
0.0615629107,
0.0174680352,
-0.0382360741,
0.1093372777,
0.0833786279,
-0.0345151015,
0.0420081839,
-0.0018613416,
0.0104098152,
0.0233225748,
-0.0413555577,
-0.0444192924,
-0.005604072,
-0.0613211133,
-0.013297759,
-0.0193946641,
0.0423922054,
0.0369263329,
0.0255249273,
-0.0181506928,
-0.0192529242,
-0.0017488477,
-0.0084609315,
0.0135246404,
0.0164038651,
-0.0133663099,
0.054645583,
-0.0126321055,
-0.0629698858,
-0.0046073431,
-0.0589127056,
0.0269926395,
0.050218042,
0.093158558,
0.0191957057,
0.0534622967,
-0.0313225351,
-0.0265107229,
0.0423291437,
-0.0129935732,
0.0112432037,
0.0152833173,
-0.0238437187,
-0.0118642934,
-0.0325155221,
-0.0027886566,
-0.0145723158,
0.0306062661,
0.0153889069,
0.0437594913,
-0.0290146656,
-0.0587061793,
0.0206119232,
-0.0153845958,
-0.0177977253,
0.0010539057,
-0.0037620426,
0.0218447186,
0.0333285667,
-0.0519825332,
0.02549229,
0.0591415353,
0.006284269,
-0.0134976283,
0.0149232717,
0.0492968112,
0.0084446752,
0.0555411913,
-0.0319843516,
0.0294017866,
0.0423282124,
-0.0306565817,
0.0354031771,
0.0107224733,
-0.0372699127,
0.0148131484,
-0.0276178624,
0.0005258358,
-0.031234974,
0.0512965396,
-0.0171182882,
-0.0008066955,
-0.0097698485,
0.019236315,
0.0352083035,
-0.0151037937,
0.0461849011,
-0.0041923984,
-0.0478334501,
0.0088167526,
-0.0405373946,
0.0270732921,
-0.0085230088,
0.0307630189,
-0.0044855159,
-0.0116072772,
0.012227783,
-0.0044772872,
-0.0013152388,
0.0179499537,
0.0393271074,
-0.002997468,
-0.043479152,
-0.0046592951,
-0.0226738341,
-0.0813700333,
0.0106114941,
-0.0146650393,
0.0065513938,
-0.0517256409,
-0.0493701026,
0.0207928885,
0.0092996992,
-0.0006313961,
0.043892514,
0.0107013667,
-0.0152439401,
-0.0239289906,
0.0237451233,
-0.0241305158,
0.0010821901,
0.0181768797,
0.0024292551,
-0.0047017424,
-0.0234252047,
-0.0253789406,
0.0267070457,
0.03198722,
-0.0097384378,
0.0424305312,
0.0150179835,
-0.0308370907,
-0.0175121184,
0.0020368767,
-0.0354428031,
-0.0236592982,
-0.0670565888,
0.0259470046,
0.013204094,
0.029021576,
-0.0084532285,
-0.0195986871,
0.0260994919,
-0.010201348,
-0.0266288798,
-0.0112124588,
0.0107967919,
-0.0478077605,
-0.0014523696,
-0.010038428,
-0.0859957263,
0.0275864676,
-0.0876442492,
0.0191400237,
0.0007698693,
-0.0147225708,
-0.0089154271,
0.0495450199,
-0.0065711252,
0.0309941191,
-0.0011232252,
0.0100081824,
-0.0089999707,
0.0234121382,
0.0541775152,
-0.0405168198,
0.0095435986,
-0.0223135948,
-0.0130140493,
0.002821397,
0.0023690604,
-0.0252713375,
-0.0634470955,
0.0038429757,
-0.0073247259,
0.0254098903,
-0.0220001768,
0.0192855895,
-0.0300938636,
0.0455567874,
0.0166737232,
0.0074571255,
0.0072774454,
-0.0236005038,
0.0735390261,
0.0004138902,
-0.0402953997,
-0.0171930566,
-0.0048817438,
-0.0005031872,
0.055709701,
0.0172031876,
0.0268338528,
0.0065448983,
0.0081655867,
0.0111724604,
0.0254810117,
0.0274005011,
0.0441123918,
0.0363731273,
-0.008168227,
-0.0044543929,
0.060290236,
0.0152514325,
-0.0029239384,
0.006003045,
-0.0038854466,
0.0271028299,
0.008011668,
0.0132573238,
-0.0914570615,
0.0081895478,
0.0243666489,
0.0709694326,
-0.0314575769,
-0.0098768715,
-0.0151809957,
-0.098180227,
0.0486726277,
0.0189941674,
-0.0165413674,
-0.027659785,
-0.0374430008,
-0.0328317694,
0.0127488496,
-0.0523524769,
-0.0475436747,
0.0245013554,
-0.0085489647,
0.0191017091,
-0.010316384,
-0.0129775396,
0.0242123473,
-0.0346585587,
0.0213005468,
0.0807491615,
0.0115008652,
-0.0299663749,
-0.0302543398,
0.0210096892,
-0.0093636848,
-0.0409894846,
0.009235994,
0.0142180119,
0.0133316293,
-0.0017864006,
-0.014547077,
0.0571300387,
-0.0032973851,
-0.0653542057,
0.0299898852,
0.0547044352,
-0.0074021886,
-0.0195283499,
-0.0303166397,
-0.0013004767,
0.0225284211,
0.0588695109,
0.0365975872,
-0.0437996835,
-0.0362263806,
-0.0775892064,
-0.0184664745,
-0.0985675678,
-0.0389468856,
-0.0155170737,
-0.0242309943,
-0.0088212127,
-0.0528784804,
0.0023866899,
-0.0728847608,
-0.0029736196,
0.0460386686,
-0.0058694505,
0.0193432029,
-0.0251061916,
-0.0623837784,
-0.0464951433,
-0.0443834849,
0.0605952442,
-0.0411646962,
-0.0087444093,
-0.0128013641,
0.000494817,
-0.0247233417,
0.0362162925,
-0.1022317708,
-0.0654537082,
0.0205973443,
0.044708129,
0.0254620463,
-0.0034789965,
-0.0360350087,
-0.053269621,
0.1151553765,
0.085850887,
-0.0271556713,
0.0491549261,
0.0556397364,
-0.0388646796,
-0.0034685973,
0.0123848245,
-0.0526905544,
-0.0228591841,
0.0681192949,
-0.0277947225,
0.0006503763,
-0.0315939933,
-0.0023672828,
0.0731206536,
-0.0259831361,
-0.0540669449,
0.0241178926,
0.0114308763,
0.0246467516,
0.0021094449,
-0.0343191326,
-0.027537521,
0.0037640769,
0.0443718061,
-0.0407123901,
-0.0031671936,
0.0649349317,
0.0239355098,
0.0073786457,
-0.0194320939,
0.0417643189,
-0.0182947461,
0.038519688,
0.0485910028,
0.0045271665,
-0.0112866741,
0.0422783829,
-0.0425074808,
0.0132627012,
0.0009019584,
0.0227852128,
-0.0035301147,
0.0122776367,
0.0031509639,
0.0621801764,
-0.0521516241,
-0.0297921691,
-0.0459381416,
0.0471710078,
0.027413236,
0.0126250945,
0.0348494686,
-0.0515325256,
-0.0148545569,
-0.0375393108,
0.0204375777,
-0.0333997272,
-0.0600891225,
-0.0314379893,
-0.0191781763,
-0.0256407708,
0.0343667604,
0.0630257726,
0.0314353295,
0.0513278507,
0.0292613003,
-0.0390100814,
-0.0258757081,
-0.036541637,
0.0333814584,
-0.0281453207,
-0.0357087664,
-0.0332872607,
-0.0537862182,
-0.0924760401,
0.0065640314,
0.0265325867,
0.0450333133,
0.0011302434,
-0.0400968753,
0.0349236876,
-0.0088177556,
0.0138567258,
-0.0794719458,
0.0615818538,
-0.0132071851,
-0.0573744103,
-0.0036900996,
-4.969970279e-33,
0.0227629989,
-0.0330098569,
-0.0455407836,
0.0173772518,
0.014677777,
0.0081626074,
-0.0330871418,
-0.0351719633,
0.002748152,
-0.0324624851,
-0.0189500656,
-0.0058794329,
-0.0049625523,
0.0034758281,
-0.0161580518,
-0.0118825957,
-0.0129205473,
0.0025002859,
-0.0503782071,
0.0221336093,
0.027487997,
0.0001853994,
-0.0083537642,
-0.0782954842,
0.043029204,
-0.0484192297,
-0.0561875403,
-0.0320247672,
-0.0977879018,
0.0433153845,
-0.0014189441,
0.0155419316,
0.0086611928,
-0.0355100967,
-0.0180080421,
0.030095499,
0.0089898407,
0.018770216,
-0.0050547891,
0.0026756055,
0.0471969023,
-0.0409533009,
0.063689895,
-0.0110328766,
-0.031257011,
0.0076247957,
0.0174795073,
-0.0312557295,
-0.036985714,
-0.0644772798,
-0.0207258202,
0.0143278847,
-0.0443378985,
0.014145297,
0.0337666906,
0.0010055273,
0.0045922669,
0.0466803052,
-0.0578733757,
0.0418277495,
0.0251636505,
-0.0129850479,
0.0469621606,
-0.0028732629,
0.0290173776,
0.0430658944,
0.0046363482,
-0.0283515975,
0.0008339916,
0.0204112977,
0.0107626365,
0.054565914,
0.0585234165,
0.1048521101,
0.0455549136,
-0.035128776,
-0.0165530201,
0.0255894382,
-0.0282927267,
-0.0160986148,
0.0250306483,
-0.0148698688,
-0.0192592293,
0.0005525502,
-0.0348003767,
-0.0662586913,
-0.0182255376,
-0.0196881182,
0.0218078271,
0.0075545129,
-0.0300292242,
-0.0242019054,
0.0090576978,
-0.0812513232,
-0.0292209312,
0.0266647693,
-0.0577555783,
-0.0011761783,
-0.0004669142,
-0.0021657317,
-0.0297940988,
0.0004803168,
0.0127910441,
-0.039729204,
0.0411924459,
-0.0118908025,
0.0707437471,
0.046313636,
-0.0667399019,
0.0192714855,
-0.0305213928,
0.0340157673,
0.0356172062,
0.0319862701,
-0.0004448894,
-0.0112345712,
0.0182839502,
-0.0237416923,
-0.0025332586,
-0.0052325837,
-0.0271805953,
0.0239649396,
0.0018082019,
0.0095818434,
-0.0239761397,
0.0033582551,
-0.0080601079,
0.0553421937,
0.0634872019,
-0.0457372814,
-0.0176233016,
-0.0233253408,
2.567e-7,
0.0231944472,
-0.0066081225,
0.0399503894,
-0.0062291813,
0.0075677037,
0.0747607872,
-0.0268613789,
0.0707789585,
-0.0426902808,
0.0056763957,
-0.0256406106,
-0.0264858566,
0.0792929977,
0.0096384753,
-0.0694840103,
0.0102993529,
-0.0818742067,
0.0155165382,
-0.0641487762,
0.0192804504,
0.0606401265,
0.047928188,
0.0428853817,
-0.0487324595,
-0.0027718239,
-0.0798038095,
0.0161966663,
-0.0204705019,
0.004868086,
-0.0454220511,
0.0182638578,
-0.0000895534,
0.0121639362,
-0.0086791124,
-0.0548350476,
-0.0048853927,
-0.0408973023,
0.0491391756,
0.0406817161,
0.0046615442,
-0.0262332764,
-0.0604392327,
-0.008762219,
-0.0416144282,
0.0502240025,
0.0762257352,
0.0004027818,
-0.0245974679,
-0.0122396508,
-0.0554639287,
0.0115402061,
-0.0369244292,
0.0146292299,
-0.0284475274,
0.0008437107,
0.0148457158,
0.0040020016,
-0.0810991749,
-0.0313509479,
-0.0293298606,
-0.018356761,
-0.0186538119,
-0.0252808463,
0.0351435095,
0.0502380058,
-0.0320630893,
0.0500335582,
2.579334678e-34,
-0.0054422733,
-0.0566462129,
-0.0070172492,
0.0340794958,
0.0161627773,
-0.008122975,
0.0485348888,
0.0147565873,
-0.0419156998,
-0.0358066373,
0.0065455716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12845v1 | Interpretable Preferences via Multi-Objective Reward Modeling and Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-18T17:58:28 | 2024-06-18T17:58:28 | Haoxiang Wang, Wei Xiong, Tengyang Xie, Han Zhao, Tong Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as the primary
method for aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. The
RLHF process typically starts by training a reward model (RM) using human
preference data. Conventional RMs are trained on pairwise responses to the same
user request, with relative ratings indicating which response humans prefer.
The trained RM serves as a proxy for human preferences. However, due to the
black-box nature of RMs, their outputs lack interpretability, as humans cannot
intuitively understand why an RM thinks a response is good or not. As RMs act
as human preference proxies, we believe they should be human-interpretable to
ensure that their internal decision processes are consistent with human
preferences and to prevent reward hacking in LLM alignment. To build RMs with
interpretable preferences, we propose a two-stage approach: i) train an
Absolute-Rating Multi-Objective Reward Model (ArmoRM) with multi-dimensional
absolute-rating data, each dimension corresponding to a human-interpretable
objective (e.g., honesty, verbosity, safety); ii) employ a Mixture-of-Experts
(MoE) strategy with a gating network that automatically selects the most
suitable reward objectives based on the context. We efficiently trained an
ArmoRM with Llama-3 8B and a gating network consisting of a shallow MLP on top
of the ArmoRM. Our trained model, ArmoRM-Llama3-8B, obtains state-of-the-art
performance on RewardBench, a benchmark evaluating RMs for language modeling.
Notably, the performance of our model surpasses the LLM-as-a-judge method with
GPT-4 judges by a margin, and approaches the performance of the much larger
Nemotron-4 340B reward model. | [
0.0761539862,
0.0803510845,
-0.004849581,
0.0223003291,
-0.01738826,
-0.0082051372,
-0.0387786701,
-0.0066816309,
-0.0202742573,
0.0040868642,
-0.0985622332,
0.0015453513,
-0.0206664447,
-0.0043099676,
0.0087383986,
-0.0519974977,
0.0421735756,
-0.0210682433,
0.0234887321,
-0.017696226,
0.0476216972,
0.0196290314,
0.0230062418,
0.0491758026,
0.0102438508,
0.0224188305,
-0.0018628538,
-0.0177099556,
0.0203191135,
-0.0013635893,
0.0367469639,
0.0669701472,
0.0336891338,
0.0184541568,
0.0000023723,
-0.0261037648,
-0.0297817513,
-0.0156741906,
-0.0272343345,
-0.0148079144,
0.044637531,
0.0300854798,
0.0041012126,
0.0213085935,
-0.038590081,
0.0338626131,
0.0441891924,
0.0532272495,
0.0773579329,
0.0665202364,
0.0046399604,
-0.018265374,
0.0211317837,
-0.0408689938,
0.0257048048,
-0.0508344918,
-0.0071157678,
0.0031437976,
0.0069779097,
0.0336250477,
-0.0069133481,
0.004507754,
0.0190652609,
0.021258276,
0.0266574416,
0.0283879451,
0.0348858461,
-0.0069392608,
-0.027598409,
0.0747744441,
-0.0255270917,
0.0007174726,
-0.0041627744,
-0.0176071562,
0.013528483,
-0.0096829403,
0.0064109084,
0.000486743,
0.0101357391,
0.0449852832,
-0.0055624181,
0.0440115035,
0.0361825302,
0.056725245,
-0.0145254396,
0.0923541486,
-0.0300796404,
-0.0231735259,
0.0190163553,
0.0133677069,
-0.0281880666,
-0.0244193282,
0.0312479921,
-0.0042960849,
-0.0597032011,
0.0424931906,
-0.0251777098,
0.0142349629,
0.009778033,
-0.0292816069,
0.0494441912,
0.0452647917,
-0.0078708297,
0.0347610675,
0.0037054471,
0.0657434091,
-0.0100203957,
0.0287105013,
-0.0496678315,
0.0064308308,
-0.0542759411,
-0.0133552551,
0.0399573818,
0.0452167429,
-0.0257001389,
0.0093133617,
-0.0875620618,
-0.0009373333,
-0.0674875155,
0.0323365144,
0.013994623,
0.0438335128,
-0.0311592612,
-0.0067757498,
-0.0915176198,
0.0161639508,
-0.0388820805,
0.0425392836,
0.0190328117,
0.0012900063,
0.0215377491,
-0.0016554174,
-0.0225620437,
-0.0155511564,
0.0196949355,
0.0922104791,
-0.0196813215,
-0.0119569302,
0.0044602551,
-0.0397920422,
-0.0280761532,
-0.0443377532,
-0.0362401493,
-0.0545644201,
0.0593830906,
-0.0267426874,
-0.0189790372,
-0.0486082807,
0.0161944535,
0.0146955876,
-0.0375690944,
0.0596721061,
0.0107672447,
-0.0133212078,
-0.0112533113,
0.0254203714,
-0.0373050123,
0.0409112163,
0.0387352668,
0.0866532028,
0.0093594119,
0.0168776754,
0.0165182892,
0.0196985416,
0.0242066775,
-0.0025959641,
-0.014183634,
-0.0036324754,
-0.0393118933,
0.0613449067,
0.0667263269,
0.0537468307,
-0.0509564131,
-0.0374299549,
0.0970737338,
0.0178958699,
0.0108285202,
0.0269463956,
0.0071204156,
0.0362921618,
-0.0104253264,
0.0021075094,
-0.0492984056,
0.0507975966,
-0.0185622647,
-0.0247904919,
0.0407720022,
0.0000761238,
-0.0181906633,
-0.0592256449,
0.0348392837,
-0.0367874168,
-0.0120994868,
0.0432814285,
0.0452865213,
-0.0364527479,
-0.0531014465,
-0.0232111886,
0.0485708825,
-0.0148524083,
0.0186203383,
-0.0862854347,
0.0510053709,
0.1057549939,
0.0440142229,
-0.0216626711,
-0.0066047078,
-0.0479617827,
-0.0860745907,
0.0036803614,
0.0159509815,
-0.0190772489,
0.0053347158,
-0.0614787638,
-0.0260584392,
0.0104290992,
0.0092246663,
0.0689091235,
0.0095776301,
-0.0282620601,
-0.015912598,
0.0103698391,
-0.0361720845,
0.0323369801,
-0.0062033455,
-0.0030519539,
0.0278932005,
0.0052891597,
0.0671623349,
0.0088761672,
0.0215793271,
0.0052645868,
-0.0074181925,
-0.0011456471,
-0.0278588366,
-0.0146958437,
-0.0910190269,
-0.0171922725,
0.0092161419,
-0.0154224578,
0.0090484768,
0.0408367366,
-0.0233593304,
-0.0390020981,
-0.0170971639,
-0.0125418976,
0.0215484574,
-0.0525598042,
-0.0251804478,
0.0086104451,
0.0075220047,
-0.0644165501,
0.0368682742,
-0.0371278822,
-0.0064822789,
-0.0147770736,
-0.0410940014,
0.0040523871,
-0.027338855,
-0.0391159318,
-0.0073004756,
0.0096970927,
0.0672381073,
0.0252581928,
0.0240793303,
-0.03977089,
-0.0740134567,
-0.0561490655,
-0.0095772045,
0.0026775813,
0.0098008467,
0.0204218272,
-0.0136435349,
0.0216594655,
-0.0031338818,
-0.0595162697,
-0.0030940333,
0.0000488177,
-0.0039810147,
0.0186524484,
0.0175010376,
-0.0023938427,
-0.052347146,
-0.0081964284,
-0.0182810072,
0.0074648559,
-0.0278041679,
0.0315622315,
-0.0349243991,
0.0061482023,
-0.0368578658,
0.0167995133,
-0.0171994139,
-0.0413705558,
0.0168291517,
0.012255731,
0.0240564067,
0.0763114467,
0.01540324,
0.0458954237,
0.0465938449,
0.0248467084,
-0.090393737,
-0.0087041901,
-0.0404856056,
-0.0256523993,
-0.0203983635,
-0.0335102081,
0.0137433037,
0.064456068,
0.0180571936,
0.0095520783,
-0.0849702656,
0.0180465076,
-0.0113386977,
-0.0754663721,
-0.0498935767,
-0.0161389709,
-0.0222629402,
0.0620531477,
-0.0001862891,
-0.0414086357,
0.094183065,
0.0260722097,
0.0100908782,
-0.0250768811,
-0.014245443,
-0.0252621341,
-0.00062275,
-0.0270085335,
0.0343416035,
-0.0186791029,
-0.0172568914,
-0.0621386766,
-0.0645008162,
0.0463752039,
-0.0514744259,
0.0166247282,
-0.0308224168,
-0.0170379896,
0.0073814341,
-0.0673967302,
-0.0325042456,
-0.0484490283,
-0.0128124896,
0.0081170965,
0.0031376414,
-0.0050854129,
-0.0277681518,
-0.0022312633,
0.0235021003,
-0.0055652079,
-0.0477044433,
-0.0053803092,
-0.0108608278,
-0.0035216087,
0.0591297299,
0.0167861823,
0.0190092511,
-0.0519580394,
-0.0151171237,
0.0491563939,
0.0429636389,
-0.0181491841,
-0.0253839865,
0.0183826275,
0.0382691473,
0.0024246417,
-0.0192041472,
0.0279500261,
0.0329081789,
-0.0512375608,
0.0180144347,
0.0929114744,
0.0095648784,
-0.0766490027,
0.0158449989,
-0.0044744271,
0.0337591618,
-0.0083286967,
0.0638721436,
-0.0497898869,
-0.0198589154,
0.000019427,
0.0528175719,
-0.0296877883,
-0.0296785813,
-0.0023004357,
-0.0765332282,
0.0028605529,
-0.0057410784,
-0.0700084344,
0.0105698248,
-0.0020525984,
-0.0163065027,
-0.0469227843,
0.0150343226,
0.0039857007,
0.046276547,
-0.0032233382,
0.015985176,
0.0286951829,
-0.041839283,
0.0560601801,
-0.0266510937,
0.096825406,
0.0961150378,
0.0201432537,
-0.019119978,
-0.027567355,
-0.0020966677,
0.0258846655,
-0.0141964136,
-0.006563969,
0.0140413558,
-0.0400588326,
-0.0060322294,
-0.0484578311,
0.0403342135,
0.0141222719,
-0.0059175957,
-0.0159254149,
0.0586508885,
0.0007708372,
-0.0047411914,
-0.011965638,
-0.0041188579,
0.014530885,
0.0628581569,
-0.016866859,
-0.0966505781,
-0.0072114184,
-0.0324146003,
-0.0339118131,
-0.0197006762,
-0.0461550727,
0.0138966329,
0.0340137742,
-0.0224459302,
-0.0461308509,
-0.0326602645,
-0.018491365,
0.0160599612,
0.0194265265,
-0.0228194129,
0.0085332114,
0.0005757587,
0.0039820122,
0.0254882649,
-0.032609079,
0.0040768832,
-0.0693914592,
0.0077527366,
0.0360060334,
-0.0774700865,
-0.023511136,
-0.0351313315,
0.0189028606,
-0.0400828719,
-0.0132616777,
0.0956872553,
0.0200732313,
0.0374066867,
0.0005460959,
-0.0966277272,
0.0403169245,
0.0412007198,
-0.0699014589,
0.0069174501,
0.0561653487,
0.0604642034,
0.0039252681,
0.0342060477,
-0.0368397534,
0.0319781452,
0.0393887572,
-0.0047268756,
0.0026919332,
-0.0223033428,
0.0440482311,
-0.0190998279,
0.00274188,
-0.0129446108,
-0.0123353787,
-0.0609785765,
-0.0351806246,
0.0011199295,
-0.0120839514,
-0.0441865996,
-0.0189399142,
0.0417173281,
-0.0157393795,
-0.0153154936,
-0.0671799183,
-0.0025277522,
0.008995777,
-0.0319492891,
-0.0001022205,
0.018110618,
0.0031600597,
-0.0137671065,
0.0181358662,
-0.021618329,
-0.0102080833,
0.0122409668,
0.0464372747,
-0.0026612966,
0.0746090785,
0.0291988552,
-0.0200331453,
-0.0136731165,
0.0541729778,
-0.0235209707,
0.0014738177,
-0.0179420803,
0.0018707868,
0.0324032269,
0.0184319746,
0.0357131511,
-0.0323374383,
0.0118195219,
-0.0187337641,
0.0404203869,
-0.0358132869,
-0.0031320467,
0.0427304953,
0.0345006213,
-0.0050630951,
-0.0072006001,
0.045926109,
0.0009195561,
-0.0163820274,
-0.0355505385,
-0.0102455812,
-0.0552815013,
0.006922584,
0.0154441958,
0.0503135622,
-0.0449472852,
-0.0079515511,
-0.0456543714,
-0.0274285302,
-0.0591178872,
0.0320549756,
-0.0132183125,
-0.0273276493,
0.0409220383,
0.0414911322,
-0.0475916378,
0.0193796735,
-0.0684883595,
-0.0603933521,
0.0000385606,
-0.0128466627,
-0.0208198652,
-6.986950342e-33,
0.0000077151,
-0.0203292444,
0.0164651424,
-0.0237208661,
-0.0183332358,
-0.0112198731,
0.0060088448,
0.0192408264,
-0.0302194394,
-0.0077695888,
-0.0179158971,
-0.018866824,
-0.0027226112,
-0.0144430501,
0.012246253,
-0.003557282,
0.0365982465,
-0.015503861,
-0.0312577151,
0.0146768382,
0.0312221963,
0.0156900212,
0.0709468126,
-0.1129367575,
0.0496467464,
0.0546482839,
-0.0717744827,
0.0153994691,
-0.0355074443,
0.0745002478,
-0.017786853,
0.0425457135,
0.010877464,
-0.0499197394,
0.0041571036,
-0.0076419436,
-0.0506351478,
-0.0234193616,
0.0446533039,
-0.0234157816,
-0.0311688278,
-0.0316008069,
0.0583221205,
-0.019445803,
-0.0172543172,
0.0055456483,
0.0246842541,
-0.003395051,
-0.0180771034,
0.0207259879,
-0.0088634025,
0.0100639928,
-0.003204196,
-0.0251653735,
0.0211373921,
0.0261504501,
-0.0397310555,
0.0461879373,
-0.0166152772,
0.040555384,
-0.0058523291,
0.0267038159,
0.0587001666,
0.0290958099,
-0.0049541243,
0.0687444732,
0.0453283563,
0.0002531536,
0.0005767457,
-0.040433649,
0.0348900259,
0.0508085117,
0.0561892912,
0.0368220247,
0.0146731501,
-0.0346097723,
-0.0258779097,
0.0180417802,
0.0155268498,
0.0054748715,
0.0862289593,
0.0497547835,
-0.0746938288,
-0.0342909656,
-0.0334789306,
-0.0242530517,
-0.0506060831,
-0.0381043106,
0.0354498066,
0.0119566964,
-0.0248981602,
-0.0318129733,
0.0048683221,
-0.0532076694,
-0.0097182449,
-0.0050142705,
-0.0356215127,
0.0048185247,
0.0061761346,
0.0052679675,
-0.0845656022,
-0.0133265369,
-0.0132676633,
-0.0347844698,
-0.0057944767,
0.0260145031,
0.0286187362,
0.0267082695,
-0.0347327515,
0.0075026602,
-0.0344820172,
0.0068378127,
0.0033420131,
0.0096194204,
0.0434432402,
-0.0097038746,
-0.0283749793,
0.0510671884,
0.0071763052,
-0.0167320818,
-0.0305330418,
-0.0401555635,
0.0015505212,
0.0216250457,
-0.0328942947,
0.0045913453,
-0.007930018,
-0.0416529514,
0.0098573547,
-0.0024950737,
-0.014386043,
0.0176033452,
3.02e-7,
0.0026217387,
0.0474007688,
-0.0304241348,
-0.0043508955,
-0.0044196052,
0.0801831856,
0.0038929719,
0.0285549667,
0.011241057,
-0.0046672528,
0.0526904836,
0.0152355488,
0.051572144,
0.0000599409,
-0.0631196648,
-0.0008973946,
-0.0346673839,
0.018207645,
-0.0143253058,
0.0007211823,
0.080034554,
0.094882153,
0.0542526804,
0.0009262335,
0.0128639285,
0.0218571592,
0.0570645221,
-0.0668401122,
-0.0152366003,
-0.0031633324,
0.0548144579,
0.0027238776,
-0.0120043792,
0.0152331926,
0.0281728059,
0.015831504,
-0.0036658922,
0.0978247523,
-0.0177222006,
-0.056910485,
0.0165884998,
0.0216233935,
0.0024611168,
-0.0722025335,
0.0376978256,
-0.0231513958,
-0.0609251745,
-0.0344802588,
0.0237645842,
-0.0479026474,
0.0080562709,
-0.0370064527,
-0.012456215,
-0.0139333745,
0.0109814014,
0.0097889537,
-0.0192509275,
-0.0581133403,
0.0010371543,
0.002424293,
-0.0362254381,
-0.0424655378,
-0.0400614738,
0.0635982901,
-0.0057441206,
-0.0546155721,
-0.0002316417,
2.78689943e-34,
0.024249291,
-0.0306673497,
0.0209239703,
0.0357580334,
0.0362917632,
0.0563275516,
-0.0220954679,
0.0268753599,
0.0697922632,
-0.0316055082,
-0.0445745997
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12832v1 | LaMDA: Large Model Fine-Tuning via Spectrally Decomposed Low-Dimensional Adaptation | 2024-06-18T17:52:59 | 2024-06-18T17:52:59 | Seyedarmin Azizi, Souvik Kundu, Massoud Pedram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) has become the default approach to fine-tune large
language models (LLMs) due to its significant reduction in trainable
parameters. However, trainable parameter demand for LoRA increases with
increasing model embedding dimensions, leading to high compute costs.
Additionally, its backward updates require storing high-dimensional
intermediate activations and optimizer states, demanding high peak GPU memory.
In this paper, we introduce large model fine-tuning via spectrally decomposed
low-dimensional adaptation (LaMDA), a novel approach to fine-tuning large
language models, which leverages low-dimensional adaptation to achieve
significant reductions in trainable parameters and peak GPU memory footprint.
LaMDA freezes a first projection matrix (PMA) in the adaptation path while
introducing a low-dimensional trainable square matrix, resulting in substantial
reductions in trainable parameters and peak GPU memory usage. LaMDA gradually
freezes a second projection matrix (PMB) during the early fine-tuning stages,
reducing the compute cost associated with weight updates to enhance parameter
efficiency further. We also present an enhancement, LaMDA++, incorporating a
``lite-weight" adaptive rank allocation for the LoRA path via normalized
spectrum analysis of pre-trained model weights. We evaluate LaMDA/LaMDA++
across various tasks, including natural language understanding with the GLUE
benchmark, text summarization, natural language generation, and complex
reasoning on different LLMs. Results show that LaMDA matches or surpasses the
performance of existing alternatives while requiring up to 17.7x fewer
parameter updates and up to 1.32x lower peak GPU memory usage during
fine-tuning. Code will be publicly available. | [
0.0463934876,
0.0707667992,
-0.0007049323,
0.0533472598,
0.0233194865,
0.0226188302,
-0.0102559794,
-0.022982683,
-0.0263063014,
-0.0661696792,
-0.0541087091,
-0.0002453013,
0.0276151821,
0.0245326664,
0.013289975,
-0.0660209656,
0.0292447638,
-0.0621221438,
-0.0015806329,
0.0004760986,
0.0132658137,
0.0302073378,
0.0049068467,
0.0124641545,
0.0480697677,
-0.0090331677,
-0.0315354243,
-0.0042726221,
0.0363591351,
0.0086163199,
0.0101427007,
0.0602976196,
0.0498092137,
0.0296164621,
0.0000022807,
-0.0334395766,
-0.0224424563,
-0.0263293721,
0.0362310261,
0.0519197471,
0.0324562788,
-0.0116787562,
-0.0110694002,
0.0087921349,
-0.0209794007,
-0.0095189698,
0.0317424685,
0.014841727,
0.0569836609,
0.0676536188,
-0.0065103108,
-0.0414871164,
0.0204482488,
-0.0524099804,
-0.0426770709,
-0.0781558007,
0.0289952327,
-0.0045532854,
-0.0319073759,
-0.0400935523,
-0.0348212533,
-0.0014955098,
-0.0222302061,
-0.0035080796,
0.0063851895,
0.0150022767,
-0.0358533226,
-0.0152952122,
0.0035775818,
0.0861986801,
-0.0514919162,
-0.0090618059,
0.0314162001,
-0.0098502161,
-0.0040612244,
-0.0395882688,
-0.0287013445,
0.0251672603,
0.0451421589,
0.0138955666,
0.0058148047,
-0.0298819393,
0.0390455797,
0.0415361524,
-0.0376363508,
0.0315150432,
0.0403779671,
0.0036529084,
-0.0145595251,
-0.0322436914,
-0.0423197299,
-0.030737387,
0.0059384117,
0.0107338559,
-0.0318329819,
0.0018537788,
-0.0990085453,
-0.0596875511,
-0.0035798808,
-0.0220396277,
0.0833510756,
0.0510640889,
0.0488331728,
0.0531695522,
-0.0652891397,
0.0367553309,
0.0005207011,
0.0077172122,
-0.0505863577,
0.006496571,
0.0065396563,
0.0263736527,
-0.0294872485,
0.0338403583,
-0.0702248588,
-0.0379196554,
-0.0373440571,
0.0134226121,
-0.0018684095,
-0.0077884533,
-0.0217263531,
0.0214294102,
-0.0130429734,
-0.0057920502,
0.0145559497,
0.0441707447,
-0.0321121439,
0.0179292653,
0.0086428123,
-0.0262429174,
-0.0251076408,
0.0297329575,
0.0444941074,
-0.0160923246,
0.0534401834,
0.0347134285,
-0.0289323758,
-0.0629478619,
-0.0252208076,
-0.0017368486,
-0.0113357017,
-0.0887855291,
0.0161718223,
-0.0329051353,
0.0496108308,
0.0098518385,
0.0040793084,
-0.0398564003,
0.0111089684,
0.0217795298,
-0.0518807024,
0.0479556583,
-0.0243502911,
-0.0135149965,
0.0170822963,
0.0028712361,
0.0029610631,
0.0511146374,
0.0396491401,
0.0464984365,
-0.0118000871,
-0.0277224407,
-0.0498350486,
0.0097339479,
0.0196533538,
0.0190561526,
-0.0256657824,
0.0124383327,
-0.0207073186,
0.0193253458,
0.0622197948,
0.025360778,
-0.0233053174,
-0.0039518941,
0.0221778657,
0.0603838637,
0.0145174256,
0.0693785548,
-0.0122464811,
-0.0166077055,
-0.0070072524,
-0.0168667063,
-0.0431630053,
0.06044228,
-0.0555121712,
0.0045823972,
0.0546766296,
0.0782789961,
-0.0194495786,
-0.0218460262,
-0.0012547944,
0.0060214084,
0.0036216087,
0.0073778904,
0.0201971643,
-0.012194301,
-0.0318078212,
0.0683691129,
0.0513753518,
-0.0575395674,
-0.0154842436,
-0.0530848801,
0.0243626498,
0.0503287576,
0.0122266449,
-0.0228503291,
-0.0318272747,
-0.0073685683,
0.0482626446,
0.035620328,
0.0259248689,
0.0222813096,
-0.0040820027,
-0.0828765333,
-0.0011904873,
-0.0284900423,
0.0065247095,
0.0188454837,
0.0099421125,
0.0073063737,
0.0284805801,
-0.0115328664,
-0.0424505211,
0.0313759409,
-0.0250100978,
-0.0196861178,
0.0190525521,
-0.0184649453,
0.0108835818,
-0.0125550386,
-0.0058572707,
-0.0157947354,
0.0339784883,
-0.0350681655,
0.0115930606,
-0.0426446274,
-0.0686196759,
0.0004975897,
0.0309668183,
0.0167167913,
0.0274078641,
0.0536224917,
-0.0487278365,
-0.0512733571,
0.0704151616,
-0.0188303515,
-0.0332769193,
-0.03988057,
0.018450899,
-0.0034832382,
0.0618063658,
-0.0284520686,
0.0338685848,
-0.0170216393,
-0.0051361052,
0.0425632708,
0.0349844992,
0.0125850346,
-0.0039091213,
-0.0360171571,
0.0138376672,
-0.0094719902,
0.0545959212,
-0.0020202682,
0.0144815985,
-0.0083109075,
-0.0195599571,
-0.0402723029,
0.0443617962,
-0.0353393741,
0.0085995682,
0.0340369791,
0.0205956716,
0.0151691744,
-0.0117349401,
-0.0097569944,
0.0588622317,
-0.0038675552,
0.005005463,
-0.0131760854,
0.0004055505,
-0.0085747335,
-0.0561076216,
-0.0111815641,
0.0267531723,
0.0596700571,
-0.0428909883,
-0.0299796723,
-0.0530624092,
0.0221976973,
-0.0449728407,
0.0492482483,
-0.0143370526,
-0.0366575271,
-0.033241462,
-0.0207431372,
0.045862779,
0.0665652826,
0.010323693,
0.0073922444,
0.0755666271,
0.0228918567,
-0.0140408147,
0.0302268025,
-0.0000450247,
-0.0134719992,
-0.0258634482,
0.0029687176,
-0.0002590301,
0.0458765253,
-0.0101048118,
-0.0080983927,
-0.0526579432,
0.027087383,
-0.0000575969,
-0.033290036,
-0.0243961886,
0.0081533622,
-0.0258513298,
-0.013602308,
-0.01282633,
-0.0254060719,
0.0309503488,
-0.0376620777,
-0.0079071056,
-0.0558336452,
-0.046775531,
-0.0600084923,
0.0201546904,
-0.0120610818,
0.063772656,
-0.0617082156,
0.0146675436,
-0.0133491494,
-0.033066541,
0.0058986172,
-0.0093956999,
0.0509424917,
-0.0301617775,
0.0239578951,
-0.0722112879,
-0.0519115217,
-0.0024611012,
-0.0072311601,
-0.0300356541,
0.027087139,
0.0122976704,
-0.0499379709,
-0.0203811824,
0.0132122738,
0.0062463684,
0.081907317,
-0.0400821976,
0.0091884071,
-0.05636058,
0.0252269097,
0.0807183832,
0.0763641074,
0.0309915617,
-0.0116373943,
0.0154399276,
0.0475305952,
0.0016133973,
-0.0187174343,
-0.0564036183,
0.0355908461,
0.0217719451,
-0.008024917,
-0.0075245993,
0.0179903563,
0.0408509001,
-0.0511381924,
-0.0112617295,
0.0819949508,
0.0154321976,
-0.0598718524,
-0.0036695874,
0.007259646,
0.087584123,
0.0330633484,
0.0426845253,
-0.0363134407,
-0.0464163311,
0.0094742738,
0.0350911058,
0.0487045981,
-0.0199339017,
-0.0259239711,
-0.0755927563,
0.0129956305,
0.0370095447,
-0.0295290686,
-0.0370248556,
-0.0239900649,
0.0067986217,
0.0341955498,
0.0399740487,
0.0244822297,
-0.0171511639,
-0.0180678852,
0.0193572547,
-0.0055909632,
-0.0387791097,
0.0013027926,
-0.012465667,
0.0242422987,
0.0221373681,
0.0150057143,
0.0249314383,
-0.0340537019,
0.0374829881,
-0.0380755849,
0.0119110802,
-0.0191478096,
0.0261503346,
0.0259516351,
-0.0102300895,
-0.011431098,
0.0456537865,
-0.0380097777,
-0.0372288451,
-0.0114739975,
0.0835565254,
0.0085885003,
-0.042331893,
0.0111530563,
-0.0090866582,
-0.0414708219,
0.0643149316,
0.0343257561,
-0.0435725637,
-0.054370366,
-0.0180090647,
-0.0415509492,
-0.0561039634,
-0.0111603085,
-0.0286014006,
0.0157345552,
0.0317003019,
-0.0151801612,
0.0157190468,
0.03548434,
0.0231065415,
-0.0272615552,
-0.0009162918,
0.0196544863,
-0.0074775517,
-0.0492689125,
0.0325178131,
-0.0452334061,
-0.0175965689,
-0.0339401886,
-0.0051322835,
0.0455106348,
-0.0080128834,
-0.0079481946,
0.007261463,
-0.0857617334,
-0.0662011355,
-0.0102062253,
0.0175520014,
0.0163151007,
0.035730768,
0.0201756544,
-0.0894054919,
0.0041573006,
0.0220040567,
-0.0046582464,
0.0875218436,
-0.0059929183,
-0.029068673,
-0.0257019512,
0.0555402301,
-0.043572776,
-0.0059548933,
0.0281091798,
0.0519749746,
0.0369462445,
-0.0414946936,
-0.0205730647,
0.0253374949,
0.0075389356,
-0.0035942972,
-0.0240487643,
-0.0286005475,
0.0320228375,
-0.0073139789,
-0.0105528776,
-0.0209259614,
-0.0251494851,
0.018303141,
0.0047852956,
-0.031560313,
0.0122617045,
0.0677615553,
-0.0028877468,
-0.0517096706,
-0.0022807713,
-0.0121623194,
-0.0294546615,
0.0550767593,
-0.0022921285,
-0.0274447128,
0.0361966044,
-0.0056001311,
0.0223861113,
-0.0568225384,
0.0087973196,
0.0189888403,
-0.033826936,
-0.080203943,
0.0507006049,
-0.0272773299,
-0.0894232094,
-0.0411896072,
0.0105206026,
0.0607908033,
0.021338895,
0.0736919418,
0.0224625021,
-0.0296800118,
0.0015735425,
0.0032833202,
0.0122622009,
-0.0101709552,
0.0425610021,
0.006664135,
-0.0087072859,
0.0389317386,
0.05071491,
0.0392486863,
0.034168236,
-0.0124356551,
0.0296164993,
-0.0338624343,
-0.0382241793,
-0.0451611243,
0.0281572025,
-0.0213269442,
0.0007989976,
-0.0030926119,
-0.0567085147,
-0.0041156635,
-0.0361285582,
-0.0025923436,
-0.03961863,
0.0235706866,
0.0199575555,
-0.0060746595,
-0.0249772873,
-0.0042130295,
-0.0028101283,
-0.0028431644,
-0.0169213917,
0.0069463793,
-7.060448126e-33,
-0.0326522179,
0.0158763994,
0.0227070879,
0.0078940475,
-0.0030065572,
-0.044173874,
-0.0450541452,
0.0026491331,
-0.0012765554,
-0.0082544703,
-0.0100011015,
-0.0069922805,
-0.003271566,
0.0329628326,
-0.0194425788,
0.0184226017,
0.066546537,
-0.009953374,
-0.0206197128,
0.0492924899,
0.0196967199,
0.036879275,
0.0282595418,
-0.0285718553,
-0.0824489444,
0.0154671129,
-0.0321495384,
0.0064165518,
-0.0268297512,
0.0149732307,
-0.0589675233,
0.0391957983,
0.0176577158,
0.0159440786,
-0.0379945375,
-0.0116565218,
-0.0975568295,
-0.0008230075,
0.035171207,
-0.0004691979,
-0.0381415859,
-0.0406423621,
0.0390891656,
0.0542846471,
-0.0352236331,
-0.0279481318,
-0.0083874194,
-0.0301827881,
-0.0367180482,
-0.0155294957,
-0.059497375,
0.0229557101,
0.0064929887,
0.0137666501,
0.0347057357,
0.0000732312,
-0.0227528494,
0.0396145508,
-0.0842571184,
-0.0275677331,
0.0236946121,
0.0662361458,
0.0514377616,
0.0641124099,
-0.037768133,
0.0648328587,
0.0076858778,
0.0121665299,
0.0237189289,
0.0021419416,
0.0525505692,
0.0386779606,
0.0250999946,
0.0256685857,
0.0070297667,
-0.0004552493,
-0.0744404942,
-0.0194061156,
0.0114266519,
0.0193130877,
0.0540878363,
0.0362956524,
0.0136157898,
-0.0254930537,
-0.0534979887,
0.0278767198,
-0.0683517233,
0.0160816088,
0.0491766818,
0.0459611006,
-0.0472600572,
-0.0204904061,
0.0129735097,
-0.0278038271,
0.0232471954,
0.0144378152,
-0.0217995029,
0.0055775517,
0.0244786143,
0.0257614069,
-0.0334779024,
-0.0610497221,
0.0474358089,
-0.04089747,
0.0065177199,
-0.0210711118,
0.0374720469,
0.0494023412,
-0.0811146423,
0.0013982829,
-0.0137731088,
0.0276847873,
0.0325363204,
0.0919021741,
-0.0064483564,
0.0024863349,
0.0059276684,
0.0840781331,
0.0038806822,
0.0361600518,
-0.0007919839,
-0.0250915606,
0.0496469848,
0.0292618908,
-0.0381248742,
0.0192577094,
-0.028447805,
0.0038916131,
0.0295491479,
-0.0812188983,
-0.0230777599,
0.0132873952,
3.063e-7,
0.0094847241,
0.0501808822,
-0.0239228141,
-0.0363908596,
0.0225847661,
0.0300273951,
0.0112550249,
0.0318845585,
0.0363474004,
0.0151772415,
-0.0089390213,
0.0170785636,
0.0244415868,
-0.0201297533,
-0.061990343,
-0.0028976654,
-0.0627500638,
0.0336631797,
-0.044235751,
-0.0402494669,
0.0013933748,
0.1191723943,
-0.0218510646,
-0.0232009161,
0.0233207848,
-0.032777559,
0.0593131445,
-0.0080835531,
-0.004269043,
0.0093068639,
0.0293765906,
0.0277979169,
-0.0421670899,
-0.013436636,
-0.0020911181,
0.06532453,
-0.0425072983,
0.1005534604,
-0.0057832496,
0.0111332098,
0.0469095223,
0.0207693987,
0.0267685186,
-0.0485428348,
0.0742879361,
-0.0358361453,
-0.032849621,
-0.0552385636,
-0.0011576831,
-0.0127838077,
-0.0192878991,
-0.0350146666,
0.0078917313,
0.0216321647,
0.0094944891,
-0.0102892257,
-0.0238812212,
-0.1155075729,
-0.0048503056,
0.0230554752,
-0.0441951528,
-0.0279817469,
-0.0817177147,
-0.0073746177,
0.0493221059,
-0.061717093,
0.0210504625,
3.19261304e-34,
0.0376011655,
-0.0177430231,
0.0072438372,
-0.0170629378,
0.0474951528,
-0.0187895708,
-0.0139851682,
0.0084119579,
0.0095395995,
-0.1454045326,
-0.0284960587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12830v1 | What Are the Odds? Language Models Are Capable of Probabilistic Reasoning | 2024-06-18T17:51:24 | 2024-06-18T17:51:24 | Akshay Paruchuri, Jake Garrison, Shun Liao, John Hernandez, Jacob Sunshine, Tim Althoff, Xin Liu, Daniel McDuff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LM) are capable of remarkably complex linguistic tasks;
however, numerical reasoning is an area in which they frequently struggle. An
important but rarely evaluated form of reasoning is understanding probability
distributions. In this paper, we focus on evaluating the probabilistic
reasoning capabilities of LMs using idealized and real-world statistical
distributions. We perform a systematic evaluation of state-of-the-art LMs on
three tasks: estimating percentiles, drawing samples, and calculating
probabilities. We evaluate three ways to provide context to LMs 1) anchoring
examples from within a distribution or family of distributions, 2) real-world
context, 3) summary statistics on which to base a Normal approximation. Models
can make inferences about distributions, and can be further aided by the
incorporation of real-world context, example shots and simplified assumptions,
even if these assumptions are incorrect or misspecified. To conduct this work,
we developed a comprehensive benchmark distribution dataset with associated
question-answer pairs that we will release publicly. | [
0.0294490103,
0.0754650608,
-0.0049551828,
0.0463651195,
-0.053318616,
0.008083446,
-0.0340514369,
-0.0350883901,
-0.0395439789,
-0.0466052853,
0.0052595153,
-0.0583385266,
0.043074768,
0.0195350721,
0.0163269062,
-0.0579297543,
-0.0347601809,
-0.0267739613,
0.0529312007,
-0.0176314637,
0.0136192758,
0.0024997555,
-0.0154556017,
0.0176683459,
0.0170465615,
0.0162707865,
0.0315048881,
0.0250474308,
0.0172333643,
-0.0245284811,
0.0077044452,
0.0508865342,
0.0100041153,
-0.0138433874,
0.0000019956,
-0.0381599888,
0.0098198829,
-0.0300693177,
-0.006310462,
-0.0087418053,
0.0279635806,
-0.016684508,
-0.0279301982,
0.0288020782,
-0.0464451909,
0.015945375,
0.0438013077,
-0.0055795358,
0.0054287291,
0.0158664584,
-0.0010031568,
-0.0300963912,
-0.00143008,
-0.000045717,
0.0430022888,
-0.0361946523,
0.0077087092,
0.048399847,
-0.0047955033,
0.0124559347,
-0.0243217107,
0.0643837526,
0.0484078079,
-0.0133820167,
-0.0254225694,
0.0554838702,
-0.0580755398,
-0.0224054046,
0.0097595388,
0.0533763692,
-0.0216139648,
-0.0262415018,
-0.0244481843,
-0.0341996253,
-0.0121496525,
0.0315342173,
-0.0574078225,
0.0338543728,
-0.0018605667,
0.0467851795,
-0.0062296875,
0.0336118527,
0.0500441864,
-0.0045233858,
-0.0313447788,
0.1129638553,
0.0002798275,
0.0274507608,
-0.0082106413,
0.0033255061,
-0.0486803874,
-0.047751978,
0.0070964098,
0.0082873413,
0.0239046291,
0.0546338484,
0.0051711258,
-0.0093131363,
0.0286965091,
-0.0277620722,
0.0248951446,
0.0324673168,
-0.0121003902,
0.0593719073,
0.0246225838,
-0.0037842079,
0.0458934791,
0.0085315416,
-0.0161399785,
0.0002125434,
-0.0296145342,
-0.0063993428,
0.0253543202,
-0.0206469335,
-0.043726258,
-0.0226002391,
-0.0376241729,
0.021075774,
0.0073733763,
-0.0259247515,
0.0601699352,
0.0318195596,
-0.0235369075,
-0.0282005165,
-0.0613467731,
0.0023447084,
-0.0360097401,
0.017320333,
0.0067754039,
-0.0615153722,
0.0225699786,
0.0003018825,
-0.007980776,
-0.0316887163,
-0.008287142,
0.0146221593,
0.0160899479,
-0.0247811228,
0.0004027298,
-0.0133086592,
-0.0415638648,
-0.0245877597,
-0.0352736302,
-0.0868887678,
0.0134449312,
0.0413663685,
0.0083457874,
-0.0236546621,
0.0186510962,
0.0173726194,
-0.0477032252,
0.1126446649,
0.019298831,
0.0182249919,
0.0289230719,
0.0109253619,
0.0284923911,
0.0866053998,
0.0542000607,
-0.0233109742,
0.0400920399,
0.0092194714,
0.0198232345,
0.0367652737,
-0.0141881322,
-0.0100356657,
-0.0314361006,
0.0037691789,
-0.0419201218,
0.0148111163,
0.0344441198,
0.0255683418,
0.0011964525,
-0.0327251665,
0.077266477,
0.0807272345,
-0.0221851785,
-0.0620334893,
0.007146019,
-0.0000133778,
0.009709809,
-0.0209961534,
-0.0634504929,
0.0135660386,
0.0162034854,
0.0235974416,
0.0282766968,
0.0061938227,
0.0033150394,
-0.0565832332,
-0.0365135111,
-0.0171250906,
0.0029482278,
0.0159318633,
0.0532365851,
-0.0160813779,
0.0059207375,
0.0399508439,
0.0110167386,
-0.0207080171,
0.0113027375,
-0.0526777394,
0.0024130307,
0.0510865636,
0.0544926859,
-0.0239287782,
-0.0016062438,
0.0226607844,
0.0023622252,
0.0272214301,
0.0199734345,
0.0193342045,
0.00346494,
-0.0294794161,
-0.0136750443,
0.0088582244,
0.0288654044,
0.0096019628,
0.005525298,
-0.0107962321,
0.004689313,
-0.10306146,
0.0066235997,
0.0168382227,
-0.004876554,
0.0061279759,
0.0449243858,
-0.0302903447,
-0.0156045277,
-0.0242045317,
-0.002794242,
0.05868572,
-0.0057637086,
-0.0120036947,
-0.013737428,
-0.0009358169,
-0.0107444329,
-0.0179940797,
0.0450160764,
-0.0258159358,
0.0143366223,
0.0056909947,
-0.0334209055,
-0.0123174647,
0.0047347043,
-0.0222636573,
0.0551393516,
-0.042371057,
0.0196866132,
0.0073812171,
0.0242396109,
-0.0644320771,
0.073957853,
-0.0230300259,
0.0194926113,
-0.0191089883,
0.018275382,
0.0249668881,
-0.0546611473,
-0.0235540718,
-0.0296394993,
-0.0059866398,
0.0223254785,
0.0358381085,
-0.0293033496,
-0.0265090503,
0.0183998011,
-0.0625566989,
-0.0032392952,
-0.0087010609,
0.0379721895,
0.0074872123,
-6.677e-7,
-0.0406876467,
-0.0335449241,
-0.0112678101,
-0.0217639264,
0.0048348275,
0.0278022923,
0.0564974025,
-0.0116106914,
0.0085834153,
-0.0569101274,
-0.0277166627,
-0.0403748117,
0.042444434,
0.0256620422,
0.0285608433,
-0.0294027328,
0.025617484,
-0.0534530468,
0.0016969746,
-0.0060205976,
-0.0115485806,
0.0072465963,
-0.0284666847,
0.0608343519,
0.058641769,
0.0142468065,
0.0312411766,
0.0722112283,
-0.0225587115,
-0.0597044043,
-0.046208784,
-0.0425820164,
-0.0214641597,
-0.0338464193,
-0.0746377483,
-0.0432987064,
0.0531836599,
0.05431832,
-0.0153522892,
-0.0374464951,
0.074417077,
-0.0082158186,
-0.0010614856,
-0.0804273859,
0.0302878451,
-0.0112765301,
0.1014018953,
-0.002179472,
-0.0686356947,
0.0530045703,
-0.0222290326,
0.0338609405,
-0.0417457074,
-0.0029362408,
-0.0127864266,
0.069687292,
0.0300327428,
-0.0259234905,
0.0016539074,
-0.014689655,
-0.042013444,
0.0058111707,
0.0288273655,
-0.0309480671,
0.016120689,
-0.1006989926,
-0.0080810674,
0.0130437035,
-0.005573675,
-0.0219010245,
-0.0832571387,
-0.0475870259,
-0.0025313662,
-0.0250670537,
-0.0268075392,
-0.0159448013,
0.0427901298,
-0.0018574725,
0.0165658835,
-0.0334766954,
-0.0281773228,
-0.0184038542,
0.0490391403,
0.0743536502,
-0.020960018,
0.0290746409,
-0.0075838044,
-0.0207695197,
0.0316368975,
0.0428083427,
0.0704322904,
-0.0118115563,
-0.0248010103,
0.001899714,
0.006034221,
-0.0363214053,
0.0530381463,
0.02823833,
-0.0155199179,
-0.0105535854,
0.1334367245,
0.0504861809,
0.0000311427,
-0.0013260128,
-0.0058821621,
0.0049936804,
0.0056099463,
0.0311179981,
-0.0883837193,
-0.0084179277,
-0.0021635734,
0.0362140797,
-0.023636315,
-0.0257253665,
-0.0034607498,
-0.096057944,
0.0396601968,
-0.0075478409,
-0.0274957009,
-0.0329806022,
-0.0534639955,
0.0087852478,
-0.001194438,
-0.0001201328,
-0.0001040514,
0.0338913724,
0.0399674065,
0.0067160409,
-0.0452188663,
-0.0741665289,
0.0578739233,
-0.036135111,
0.0390478708,
0.0495018959,
0.0404163785,
0.0004291739,
-0.0034480691,
-0.0024043689,
-0.0486649051,
-0.0354081765,
0.0190717168,
0.0154729271,
0.022688698,
0.0058469707,
-0.0098124715,
0.0206284076,
-0.0791673437,
-0.011465149,
-0.008046994,
0.0766474232,
-0.0461135581,
-0.0449089408,
-0.0405183509,
0.0024562513,
0.0009109582,
0.0949569196,
0.0244655814,
-0.0027216005,
0.0016074401,
-0.0475681759,
-0.0006653466,
0.001315942,
-0.0100455806,
-0.0021172105,
0.0191770773,
-0.0615292974,
-0.0602475144,
-0.0192418005,
-0.0075112637,
-0.0004748044,
0.0016934664,
-0.0066986415,
-0.0003744198,
-0.0104555311,
-0.0375208557,
0.0165984835,
-0.0260180961,
0.0014047499,
-0.0087938579,
-0.0076980023,
0.048837062,
-0.0103070922,
-0.0593208484,
0.0110654375,
-0.0946632922,
-0.0529893674,
-0.0163936671,
0.0432096794,
0.031793043,
-0.0169644766,
-0.0129876975,
-0.0606821589,
0.0309106186,
0.0557392426,
0.0043144082,
-0.0120292297,
-0.0327464156,
0.017094573,
0.0214054137,
0.0129010705,
-0.0384116918,
0.0159018915,
0.0027114351,
0.0565263219,
-0.0612985082,
-0.0941362977,
0.00949784,
-0.0225389972,
0.0564883947,
-0.0089678224,
-0.0662463233,
0.0034533972,
-0.0100772884,
-0.0458812751,
-0.0213559326,
0.0099895634,
-0.0118718334,
0.0534931011,
0.0034175881,
-0.0493170172,
-0.0061537195,
-0.0240618549,
0.0482186601,
-0.0196840186,
-0.0239691176,
0.0642160699,
-0.0008703589,
0.0082789436,
-0.0452315994,
0.0218119975,
0.0021502234,
-0.011866211,
0.0705278888,
0.0277725384,
0.0225899722,
-0.0138160586,
-0.0417648666,
0.0001663627,
-0.0111274952,
-0.0767853558,
-0.0446307287,
0.0041291541,
0.0308507588,
0.0164560322,
-0.0054890891,
0.0068662888,
-0.0321126282,
0.0086537302,
-0.0236501563,
0.020562876,
0.0724164844,
-0.0076028067,
0.0714811161,
0.0291268826,
-0.0150339119,
-0.0035906921,
0.0571935475,
0.0230461061,
-0.0118321041,
-0.0089094285,
-0.0502839573,
0.0043575494,
-0.0082172463,
-0.0194613077,
0.0538757369,
-0.0041261669,
0.0354463607,
-0.0649579316,
-0.0869717374,
-0.0008694188,
0.0526805259,
-0.0227046106,
0.0033656575,
-0.0055866167,
0.0930553004,
-0.0170113482,
0.0124447262,
-0.0484365709,
0.015760418,
-0.0466062129,
0.0024211011,
-0.0456278659,
-6.505747771e-33,
0.0026830416,
-0.0527645871,
-0.0004445697,
-0.0079117566,
0.0381438509,
-0.0033568607,
-0.053942211,
0.015475397,
-0.0085645812,
0.0050140289,
-0.0137911448,
0.0370133892,
0.0306761004,
0.0369566083,
0.0185768511,
-0.0253499486,
-0.0403579548,
-0.0196708646,
-0.0207919069,
-0.0429132655,
0.037203595,
0.0241926927,
0.0437657647,
-0.050662417,
0.0740829557,
-0.0089790616,
0.0154162934,
0.045065593,
0.0298371464,
0.0348104127,
-0.0175173022,
0.0530985259,
0.0267796647,
-0.0360600576,
-0.0140691893,
0.0251007434,
-0.0312684588,
-0.0462202057,
0.0266645011,
0.0090964772,
-0.0185508467,
0.0152532784,
0.0447883271,
0.0090374742,
-0.0175242089,
-0.0326983817,
0.0722547993,
-0.0351802409,
-0.0072536217,
-0.0119679226,
-0.0165121723,
0.0422619656,
0.0051864991,
-0.0048880526,
-0.0029758078,
-0.0094817458,
0.0023397945,
0.0054986547,
-0.0104381591,
0.0351976305,
0.0140908798,
0.0325180255,
0.0996329635,
-0.0065611051,
0.0033893068,
0.053832978,
-0.0066204253,
-0.0269687977,
-0.0258959029,
-0.0246447306,
0.0472000241,
-0.0279454868,
0.0031549286,
0.0526927002,
0.0409699753,
0.0457324199,
-0.0453827754,
0.0476150066,
0.0664601699,
-0.0161560122,
0.0526031479,
0.0337989815,
-0.0641945824,
-0.0447032638,
-0.0426416285,
-0.0146002583,
-0.0238917787,
-0.0348673128,
0.0181021597,
-0.0338671245,
-0.0031064311,
-0.0032424766,
0.0048266207,
-0.0377228893,
-0.0638151243,
0.0079082167,
0.0422322713,
0.00093326,
-0.0165404901,
0.0440339632,
-0.0166781824,
0.0248482022,
-0.0060539478,
-0.0180607084,
-0.0149062164,
0.0157098901,
0.0010128071,
-0.0029950209,
-0.0543973148,
-0.0328187943,
-0.0286272783,
-0.0208537392,
-0.0180967078,
0.0684667304,
0.0049880589,
0.0377141237,
-0.0028937175,
0.011610399,
0.0105973147,
-0.0183397029,
-0.0079243761,
0.0308712553,
-0.0229269825,
-0.0102180932,
-0.0410582498,
-0.0300495401,
-0.0195188392,
-0.0156387351,
0.014590377,
-0.0333321318,
-0.0225390382,
0.01571518,
2.638e-7,
0.1590245515,
0.0370253026,
-0.0101470724,
0.0438897498,
0.0208603647,
0.0006918075,
-0.0110516632,
-0.0366185382,
0.0545177422,
-0.0389152877,
-0.0026822176,
0.0237248596,
0.0130780404,
0.0393255726,
-0.0750596821,
0.0167808235,
-0.0520354323,
0.0034116735,
-0.0122024473,
-0.0009853197,
0.0643472597,
0.1240117848,
0.0213344935,
-0.007054083,
-0.0067860452,
-0.0396004282,
0.0463195331,
-0.0332585312,
-0.0080422955,
0.048308827,
-0.0194049105,
0.0033018943,
0.018018689,
0.0522135012,
-0.0212828964,
-0.0201996211,
0.0284084212,
0.0733086839,
-0.0109164631,
-0.0313158892,
-0.0248306375,
-0.0157888029,
0.0278620962,
-0.0828128755,
0.0692935139,
-0.0453055091,
-0.0295985453,
0.0206555743,
-0.0139801726,
-0.0472348258,
0.0273571275,
-0.0256555509,
-0.0468601882,
-0.0323971212,
0.0206223056,
0.0143691059,
0.006235193,
-0.0674460009,
-0.0596987903,
0.0076946812,
-0.0402746126,
-0.0721984655,
-0.0173588395,
-0.0126819899,
0.0069922935,
-0.0380528569,
0.0017244044,
2.570979485e-34,
0.0247221999,
0.0584622473,
-0.0308587849,
0.004920837,
0.0379832685,
0.0205207393,
0.0347414128,
0.0220463742,
0.0421959497,
-0.0792226568,
-0.0199416447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12824v1 | From RAGs to rich parameters: Probing how language models utilize external knowledge over parametric information for factual queries | 2024-06-18T17:46:08 | 2024-06-18T17:46:08 | Hitesh Wadhwa, Rahul Seetharaman, Somyaa Aggarwal, Reshmi Ghosh, Samyadeep Basu, Soundararajan Srinivasan, Wenlong Zhao, Shreyas Chaudhari, Ehsan Aghazadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) enriches the ability of language models
to reason using external context to augment responses for a given user prompt.
This approach has risen in popularity due to practical applications in various
applications of language models in search, question/answering, and chat-bots.
However, the exact nature of how this approach works isn't clearly understood.
In this paper, we mechanistically examine the RAG pipeline to highlight that
language models take shortcut and have a strong bias towards utilizing only the
context information to answer the question, while relying minimally on their
parametric memory. We probe this mechanistic behavior in language models with:
(i) Causal Mediation Analysis to show that the parametric memory is minimally
utilized when answering a question and (ii) Attention Contributions and
Knockouts to show that the last token residual stream do not get enriched from
the subject token in the question, but gets enriched from other informative
tokens in the context. We find this pronounced shortcut behaviour true across
both LLaMa and Phi family of models. | [
0.0673073903,
0.010575667,
-0.0397223085,
0.0100498032,
-0.0133452602,
-0.0140236476,
-0.0264829062,
-0.0049930848,
-0.0027839015,
-0.0594290048,
-0.0395940393,
-0.0081070438,
-0.0134556536,
0.0181217995,
0.041597873,
-0.0366040319,
0.0511139445,
-0.0188676864,
-0.0015070074,
-0.000470137,
-0.0045691477,
0.0036951818,
0.0176646747,
0.0483193249,
-0.0005596108,
0.0106776999,
-0.023471199,
0.0132305715,
-0.0214538015,
0.0096072443,
0.0031086518,
0.0322096162,
-0.0126769496,
0.0284213033,
0.0000020241,
-0.0644895285,
0.0120731536,
-0.0202882625,
-0.0407296643,
0.0203087311,
0.0096716182,
0.0643642396,
0.0137485247,
0.0297643244,
-0.0339006558,
0.0138893537,
0.0561967082,
0.0416630916,
0.0409328341,
0.0575416237,
-0.0000466488,
-0.0059752576,
0.0171445068,
-0.0264642704,
0.0769193619,
-0.0298905876,
0.0013826358,
-0.0267030802,
0.034909565,
0.0414263345,
-0.0122403586,
0.0386963822,
0.0457851402,
-0.0211718492,
0.0166836977,
0.0374575965,
-0.0415971354,
-0.0204928685,
0.0229632799,
0.0523453802,
0.037226297,
-0.0506983064,
-0.0049950648,
0.0257066488,
0.0331302136,
0.0344101675,
-0.0754701048,
-0.0072705527,
-0.0097208312,
-0.0101698041,
0.014507547,
-0.0225110184,
0.0223191902,
0.0293090884,
-0.0111322617,
0.0764952153,
0.0238515977,
-0.0082397182,
-0.0580607019,
-0.0055792192,
-0.0084664235,
-0.06642057,
-0.0114433281,
0.0562354252,
-0.039461378,
0.0317402631,
-0.0112706805,
-0.0069557126,
0.043616984,
-0.0388969146,
-0.0325938947,
0.058520738,
-0.0489795655,
0.0331064425,
-0.0520771146,
0.0423608534,
-0.0386600271,
0.0337655023,
-0.0442290083,
-0.0261260271,
-0.0388146788,
-0.0579435639,
-0.0449453555,
0.0488818139,
-0.0176290628,
-0.0106405104,
-0.0182751771,
0.0615300946,
0.0207764134,
-0.0399837382,
-0.0166552402,
0.0338665843,
-0.0424836874,
0.0157772694,
-0.0663609579,
0.0221909806,
-0.0615781285,
0.0299063493,
0.0349802673,
-0.0911856368,
-0.0222241115,
0.0199836176,
0.0024194573,
-0.0311780926,
-0.0100722564,
0.0542916916,
-0.0121689616,
-0.038339477,
-0.0468369424,
-0.0554445088,
-0.019345155,
-0.0519037619,
0.0066070338,
-0.0644905269,
0.0301055815,
0.0441708863,
-0.0425507203,
-0.0049910867,
0.0135004828,
0.0575281382,
-0.0637698472,
0.040096689,
0.0085877441,
0.012496138,
0.035104163,
0.0213312171,
0.0110387364,
0.0742413253,
0.0121384226,
0.0436792001,
0.0281791426,
-0.0027352157,
-0.0075795073,
0.0064774705,
0.0345566049,
0.0082207657,
-0.031351082,
0.0405851863,
0.0046738642,
-0.0077384878,
0.0255520102,
0.0448702686,
-0.0401849523,
-0.0165636856,
0.0487021916,
0.0113422051,
0.02170958,
0.0050727138,
0.0462623872,
-0.0313164778,
0.0134366388,
0.0511082709,
-0.0523019508,
0.0473705046,
-0.041772604,
0.0001397031,
0.0590574071,
0.015383089,
-0.0471986607,
-0.0479255617,
0.0083827376,
0.0248050764,
-0.015434958,
0.0131307747,
0.0272700395,
0.0380122699,
-0.006278249,
0.0522445031,
0.0094406819,
-0.0431664698,
-0.0072236122,
-0.0637793094,
0.035194844,
0.0263882037,
0.0847041011,
-0.0173288714,
-0.0121990051,
0.0269742496,
0.0090887668,
0.0197584927,
0.0586768985,
0.0187744331,
-0.0054401844,
-0.0176914241,
-0.0023693808,
-0.0299873333,
0.0065120119,
0.0037540419,
0.0239342749,
-0.0018941213,
0.0248610955,
-0.0307379235,
0.0011984287,
0.008929695,
-0.0226584952,
-0.0336988308,
-0.0153530743,
0.0034994008,
0.0048687183,
0.005578177,
0.0155235473,
0.0540449917,
0.0229126923,
-0.0090511022,
-0.0204558894,
0.02172352,
-0.0396920703,
-0.0181000214,
0.0114364689,
0.0322111733,
0.0283452291,
0.0130148502,
0.0152640631,
-0.0616488606,
0.0414381213,
-0.0550489314,
0.094841212,
-0.0566432588,
0.0092674112,
0.0106485058,
0.0345388465,
-0.0335417613,
0.0773058683,
0.0000126874,
0.0078322906,
0.0222945549,
0.0433911756,
0.0057497853,
-0.0384069495,
0.0256549735,
0.0266435724,
-0.0109186955,
0.0139875719,
0.0583459437,
-0.0394432694,
-0.0788082629,
-0.0113096545,
-0.0779651403,
-0.0006030847,
-0.0246553104,
0.0108401794,
0.0355732627,
0.0300493408,
-0.0109093012,
-0.0291546676,
-0.053364899,
0.0022220558,
0.0246545542,
0.0624169558,
0.0276119467,
0.0292048752,
0.0173052829,
-0.0554169007,
-0.0139746899,
-0.0014057225,
0.0246331766,
0.0173644517,
-0.0089200744,
-0.0305651799,
0.0346330553,
-0.0619237348,
0.0150581431,
-0.0261204336,
-0.0334150642,
0.0162158739,
-0.0208566748,
0.0503803864,
0.0613370053,
0.0231228322,
0.021271307,
0.0254088063,
0.0010045153,
-0.0674120039,
0.0235680174,
-0.0335726999,
-0.0399862453,
0.0075672534,
-0.0320960321,
0.0144386338,
0.0472952276,
-0.0061796871,
-0.0110607361,
-0.0453078113,
0.0317900814,
0.0208077151,
-0.0445491411,
-0.0304247029,
-0.0144675151,
-0.0193004999,
0.0684291497,
-0.0320329554,
-0.0732777268,
0.0669806153,
-0.0284176394,
-0.0101120099,
-0.0255801957,
0.0179721806,
-0.0402512737,
0.042236656,
0.0009615639,
0.0281133205,
-0.0267622098,
-0.0315041728,
-0.0674988329,
-0.0205926783,
0.0138926143,
-0.0510080904,
0.0154672144,
-0.0050980407,
0.0228931326,
0.0104175797,
-0.0231832284,
-0.0709060207,
-0.0416124053,
0.0059382939,
0.0208845548,
-0.0241104439,
-0.0204709638,
-0.01703641,
-0.0030939474,
0.0583372787,
0.0201693401,
-0.0514067672,
-0.0156168947,
-0.029311318,
0.0323134065,
0.0813591555,
0.0039238599,
0.0414570346,
-0.0121200792,
0.0375659652,
0.0528317802,
0.0432571508,
-0.0286241248,
0.0249915142,
-0.0268183034,
0.0339749567,
-0.0161725711,
-0.029252978,
0.019825913,
0.0476726629,
-0.0380220488,
-0.0448687784,
0.0756267011,
0.0514837615,
-0.0466288291,
0.006830411,
-0.0514726676,
0.0574360788,
0.0495656282,
0.0495421141,
-0.0565429367,
-0.0163155254,
0.0155467587,
0.0238894168,
-0.048692666,
-0.0020456435,
-0.0247471649,
-0.1305731833,
0.0221780054,
-0.024391273,
-0.0511937514,
-0.0070201941,
-0.036706306,
0.0273222812,
0.0490231141,
0.0297982488,
0.0380460769,
-0.0093375053,
0.0028393758,
0.0035302853,
0.0516558588,
-0.0061326968,
-0.0095663704,
-0.0018646654,
0.0284505133,
0.0499894507,
0.0237308647,
0.0109846247,
-0.0192684568,
0.028765915,
-0.0118460255,
0.0361252762,
-0.0128183085,
0.050526645,
0.0156656317,
-0.0016149069,
-0.0243436843,
0.0191156957,
-0.0263649821,
-0.0130423503,
-0.0191184431,
0.0358629823,
-0.0481795371,
0.0116986362,
-0.021497475,
-0.0006160389,
-0.0159803536,
0.0641681626,
0.0457486957,
-0.0160995759,
-0.0318504311,
-0.033747457,
-0.0067124763,
0.0039209644,
-0.0475678109,
-0.0123645244,
0.0061878678,
-0.0295028519,
-0.0906811133,
-0.0476686843,
0.008046424,
0.0176507719,
-0.0236429591,
0.0302697606,
-0.0583889671,
-0.0271332953,
-0.0091847852,
0.0452833101,
-0.0481646471,
-0.0059499787,
-0.0363002531,
-0.009151415,
0.0223873947,
-0.0905987248,
0.0038986534,
0.0061500734,
-0.0519002452,
-0.0551911034,
-0.002286748,
0.0506125018,
0.0337813161,
0.00856899,
-0.0286717042,
-0.0462332182,
-0.0071184859,
0.0330898203,
-0.0427945293,
0.0252673253,
-0.0078271795,
0.0140260737,
-0.0125150234,
0.0451933295,
-0.0699948668,
0.0007196685,
0.0086395517,
0.0427064523,
0.0071338927,
-0.0324977003,
0.0559351258,
0.0243425872,
0.023930151,
0.0217366405,
0.0071671414,
-0.0025442468,
0.0243448913,
-0.0474117398,
-0.0014534547,
-0.0069806143,
0.010309252,
-0.0307890549,
0.0165156405,
0.0163112562,
-0.0426926911,
-0.0276888646,
0.0683022067,
-0.0274786297,
-0.0320885777,
-0.0007132414,
-0.0113095967,
0.0170482937,
0.0133519834,
-0.007345052,
0.0157071725,
0.0120155159,
0.0541964918,
-0.0367837399,
0.0663241968,
0.0114844516,
-0.0263888109,
-0.0215072557,
0.0219436456,
-0.1173858866,
-0.067811057,
0.0221948959,
0.029352691,
0.0261986051,
-0.0431989096,
0.0374877043,
-0.0164124407,
-0.0004399949,
-0.0139348069,
0.0014835432,
0.0295588039,
-0.0396872163,
0.0118401879,
0.0250341147,
-0.0237987973,
0.0062716305,
0.0592905059,
-0.0041849855,
0.055299446,
-0.0442650542,
-0.0170215555,
-0.0064665424,
-0.0428359918,
0.0024010893,
0.0487265661,
-0.0181936435,
0.0105134035,
-0.0779285803,
-0.069653675,
-0.0438144207,
-0.0285025742,
-0.0202241987,
-0.0395574085,
0.0421999805,
0.0907342508,
0.0128719294,
-0.0336530022,
-0.0527553521,
0.0427444577,
-0.0701864734,
0.0161921568,
-0.0118450234,
-7.081413803e-33,
-0.0227669012,
-0.0282388553,
0.0315276757,
-0.0300568193,
-0.0118875084,
0.0009261623,
-0.0468465276,
-0.0080176657,
-0.0585461743,
-0.0285671949,
-0.0521974824,
0.0289635677,
0.0098387469,
0.0093582245,
-0.0006320903,
-0.0354213007,
0.0237854812,
0.0041924729,
-0.0613203198,
0.0511662513,
0.0767309517,
-0.008365755,
0.0219091307,
-0.012290854,
0.0195511151,
-0.0136001436,
0.0198362451,
0.0501966476,
-0.0320230648,
0.0830006525,
0.0041456632,
0.0564258583,
0.0329122208,
-0.0456402749,
-0.0040274439,
0.0460249484,
-0.0591867343,
-0.0551027171,
0.0638605729,
-0.0214675665,
-0.0665560663,
-0.0661959276,
0.0394930877,
-0.0274135806,
0.0207549483,
0.0256149638,
0.0267609451,
-0.0124330707,
-0.018325394,
0.0103904195,
-0.0532969944,
-0.0030709286,
0.0127696944,
-0.0287582055,
-0.0394548923,
0.0703623146,
-0.003015012,
0.0459006652,
-0.0021333075,
0.030921096,
-0.0207507089,
0.0641944557,
0.0693100244,
0.040366102,
0.0136878695,
0.0368326604,
0.0068429993,
0.0399852246,
-0.0297019258,
-0.0201332755,
0.0161923505,
0.0297881085,
0.0216034222,
0.0080687413,
0.0109156752,
-0.0176979546,
-0.0374022163,
0.0011316295,
0.0341814458,
0.0629382581,
0.0122004589,
-0.0160880033,
-0.0292971469,
-0.0121563235,
-0.0594094545,
0.0063751023,
-0.0565018952,
-0.0314781033,
0.0399476588,
0.0297493022,
-0.0001709524,
-0.0418189168,
0.0274446085,
-0.021861501,
0.0190605428,
0.0428253002,
-0.0358258896,
0.0013606308,
-0.0002396949,
0.0275055766,
-0.026657993,
0.0227937177,
0.0234277509,
-0.020466134,
-0.0167775955,
0.0426189974,
0.0120228948,
0.0146189732,
-0.0409038104,
-0.0016502956,
-0.0674233511,
0.0376568735,
-0.0338213369,
-0.0415535755,
0.0410449691,
0.0369812176,
-0.0106553584,
0.0389142074,
0.0415060706,
0.0210705996,
-0.0539831892,
-0.0309100822,
-0.0222073868,
0.0103585524,
-0.0318738446,
0.0197599884,
-0.0363537557,
0.0572258085,
0.0164640453,
-0.0539696813,
-0.0247834288,
0.0095037576,
2.862e-7,
0.0388328098,
0.0298471227,
0.0275185574,
0.0299107786,
0.0221525505,
0.0115642697,
0.0187597368,
0.0192624405,
0.0543875806,
-0.0160468929,
-0.0238567665,
0.0323745795,
0.0251853894,
0.0011364579,
-0.0845968202,
-0.0127569484,
-0.0804928541,
-0.0211608037,
-0.0173978414,
-0.0339920707,
0.0544165671,
0.0779409334,
-0.0099117057,
-0.0152410595,
-0.0316372775,
-0.0722947568,
0.0529057495,
-0.0006285221,
-0.0102904141,
0.0309455004,
0.0471264832,
0.0210234802,
0.0365009494,
0.0040457929,
-0.0034250405,
0.0319885612,
0.0052400203,
0.0403754599,
0.0091169756,
-0.0853288174,
-0.0234031063,
-0.011678014,
0.0235457327,
-0.0756556392,
0.0977146849,
-0.0101775927,
-0.017964052,
-0.0331089348,
0.0070817722,
0.0130377281,
0.0053072101,
-0.0173662584,
-0.0267008431,
0.0206833351,
-0.0017971208,
0.0128216799,
0.014001349,
-0.0730756074,
-0.0622038282,
-0.0261400118,
-0.0371639505,
-0.0708005577,
-0.0631091595,
-0.0005390799,
-0.0079889419,
-0.048952058,
-0.0134033738,
2.729824817e-34,
0.0230227318,
0.0040115323,
0.0221311823,
0.0248072539,
0.0291391872,
-0.0137556335,
-0.0030346746,
0.0288412143,
0.048988387,
-0.0922454074,
-0.0203970615
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12822v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12822v1 | Is It Good Data for Multilingual Instruction Tuning or Just Bad Multilingual Evaluation for Large Language Models? | 2024-06-18T17:43:47 | 2024-06-18T17:43:47 | Pinzhen Chen, Simon Yu, Zhicheng Guo, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models, particularly multilingual ones, are designed, claimed,
and expected to cater to native speakers of varied languages. We hypothesise
that the current practices of fine-tuning and evaluating these models may
mismatch this intention owing to a heavy reliance on translation, which can
introduce translation artefacts and defects. It remains unknown whether the
nature of the instruction data has an impact on the model output; on the other
hand, it remains questionable whether translated test sets can capture such
nuances. Due to the often coupled practices of using translated data in both
stages, such imperfections could have been overlooked. This work investigates
these issues by using controlled native or translated data during instruction
tuning and evaluation stages and observing model results. Experiments on eight
base models and eight different benchmarks reveal that native or generation
benchmarks display a notable difference between native and translated
instruction data especially when model performance is high, whereas other types
of test sets cannot. Finally, we demonstrate that regularization is beneficial
to bridging this gap on structured but not generative tasks. | [
-0.0113075748,
0.0759761408,
-0.0390805304,
0.0516568907,
-0.032435026,
0.0175845642,
0.0658416376,
-0.0056683882,
-0.0465916283,
-0.0242731702,
-0.0598106347,
-0.0753011927,
0.0205462072,
-0.0038337873,
0.0452415384,
-0.0387145057,
0.0530165546,
-0.0439391509,
-0.0385274664,
-0.0019465679,
-0.0123429568,
0.0072148191,
0.013323131,
0.0441219918,
0.0000082519,
-0.0011920679,
0.0157983322,
0.0278586037,
0.0095651355,
-0.0098919962,
0.0005739435,
0.061152447,
-0.0035333554,
0.0492764078,
0.0000020188,
-0.033555638,
0.0359309167,
-0.0124315098,
-0.0062301252,
0.0484992005,
0.044539392,
-0.0511482954,
-0.0231285281,
-0.0015862022,
-0.0038108195,
-0.0246125497,
0.0357347652,
-0.0146279316,
-0.0015416824,
0.0719574541,
0.0015768065,
-0.0138674919,
-0.0086743264,
-0.0201690532,
-0.0056206635,
-0.0202473905,
-0.0026246652,
0.0232233815,
0.0052979183,
-0.0042318329,
-0.0563955046,
0.0266756546,
0.0376060233,
0.0221755691,
-0.0408001654,
0.0041226544,
0.0030808225,
-0.031547945,
-0.0073555401,
0.0455603376,
-0.0266426075,
-0.0084841652,
-0.0309611838,
-0.0154384542,
-0.0157154631,
-0.0148230009,
0.0032982482,
0.0403720252,
0.0053918608,
-0.0020168533,
0.0410390422,
-0.0457259901,
0.0318609923,
-0.0302781556,
-0.0169556402,
0.0419859402,
0.0397870615,
-0.0521997251,
0.0050540385,
0.0370944925,
0.00187617,
-0.0475098938,
-0.0119842244,
-0.0008891248,
-0.0334767774,
0.0284362268,
-0.0339240097,
-0.0441300534,
0.006848067,
-0.0448011495,
0.0660608634,
0.0592632964,
-0.0226604212,
-0.0002489252,
-0.0091370987,
0.0712594837,
0.0070411437,
0.0647337362,
-0.0649015903,
0.0100158844,
-0.019635655,
0.0192019027,
-0.0176031627,
-0.0259136185,
-0.0419115052,
0.0214641355,
-0.0253153127,
0.0050150272,
0.0025724869,
-0.0139411669,
-0.0004450903,
-0.0489804335,
-0.0690822154,
0.0180308893,
-0.0044010547,
0.0382306017,
-0.066161409,
0.0041959044,
0.003868588,
-0.0728527606,
0.0162380394,
0.0113329412,
-0.0243437719,
-0.039772924,
0.0116724884,
0.0378295444,
-0.0174880493,
-0.0148617513,
-0.0190384854,
-0.00850977,
-0.0271203928,
-0.1030892283,
0.0135942306,
-0.0527499877,
0.0557517409,
0.024369901,
0.0219915994,
-0.0468017347,
-0.023721043,
0.0024072984,
-0.007612444,
-0.0039314907,
0.0219938196,
0.0140748918,
-0.009722095,
-0.0003978244,
0.0387478545,
0.0971170738,
0.0286130533,
-0.0271669663,
0.0316308774,
-0.0359984189,
-0.0439748988,
0.0783844069,
0.0224743858,
0.0414486602,
-0.0318010263,
-0.0071261162,
0.0328418761,
0.0239613522,
0.0455106124,
0.034745317,
-0.0274104066,
0.0093884589,
0.0174362883,
0.0160239339,
-0.0062588602,
0.0076140598,
0.0835063457,
-0.0029937536,
0.0260516461,
0.0648814812,
-0.0182854924,
-0.0211583972,
-0.0116914948,
-0.0018787924,
-0.0133167477,
0.0499716178,
-0.0376446471,
-0.0239633806,
-0.0147989066,
-0.0106036616,
0.0150796846,
0.0110413339,
0.0557095706,
-0.0104302857,
-0.0179351997,
0.0131792771,
0.0524885431,
-0.0328215174,
0.0180272311,
-0.0493873395,
-0.0046825553,
0.0485343188,
0.0070981206,
0.0432633869,
-0.0553374887,
0.0252617374,
0.0000412603,
0.0554763749,
0.0841841102,
-0.0160949938,
0.0374043249,
-0.0416254252,
-0.0330320187,
-0.0253208485,
0.0176710393,
0.0634580031,
-0.0111648086,
0.0015081175,
0.0089475084,
-0.0409889668,
-0.0745754167,
0.0379460864,
-0.0792823657,
-0.019184323,
-0.0135817444,
0.0035232878,
-0.000836911,
0.0150510278,
-0.0042753755,
-0.0134665109,
0.0048426092,
-0.017888885,
0.0419881828,
0.0182644539,
-0.068880789,
-0.0247759223,
0.0143348901,
-0.002609354,
-0.0096912282,
0.0128142396,
-0.0199701004,
-0.0545425564,
0.0247512646,
-0.007189387,
0.0093198577,
-0.0184208266,
0.0175833646,
-0.0478088856,
0.022790188,
-0.0308794957,
0.0239369217,
-0.0059717279,
0.0531087331,
0.0288758706,
-0.001215615,
0.036201667,
-0.0364280865,
-0.0438823439,
0.0344338976,
-0.0097229928,
0.0112755699,
0.0388846844,
0.0606342256,
-0.0359748565,
0.0015768424,
-0.066309683,
0.0134280184,
-0.0375940576,
0.0457103103,
0.0290462058,
0.0048301709,
-0.0143197309,
-0.0035748002,
-0.034511596,
-0.0374723412,
0.0263734404,
0.0285294652,
-0.0132094827,
0.0216848925,
-0.0087678814,
-0.0310734808,
-0.0349223316,
0.0054644109,
0.0252539702,
-0.0024183406,
0.0321411826,
-0.0591991618,
0.0375122763,
-0.0313625559,
0.0140229044,
0.0110675087,
-0.0542041399,
0.0350562893,
0.0282355919,
0.0828740597,
0.0655624196,
-0.0594877079,
0.0267785769,
0.0324776396,
0.0113473469,
-0.0660664961,
0.0132962782,
0.0030994068,
-0.0498054028,
-0.0725082606,
-0.0719996244,
-0.0267268457,
0.1013501734,
0.0145785632,
-0.0094157998,
-0.0770741999,
0.0020026383,
-0.0796617717,
-0.0379595719,
-0.0242556967,
0.0349567123,
0.0018817051,
0.0378475897,
-0.0389169566,
-0.048728589,
0.0830780193,
-0.0216986258,
-0.0160224047,
-0.0496047027,
0.0164865237,
-0.0259631313,
0.0142218638,
0.0100382427,
0.0135197267,
-0.0507388115,
0.0068758982,
-0.0521549843,
0.0228302572,
0.0149002979,
0.0050452058,
0.0345081687,
-0.0525906421,
-0.0355625302,
-0.0077655064,
-0.0359455459,
-0.0208382588,
0.0222360156,
0.0084472802,
0.0125943776,
0.0680999309,
-0.0054274155,
-0.0313929468,
-0.0165100973,
0.032878574,
0.0297674742,
-0.0326407701,
0.0312760547,
-0.0173104554,
-0.0244375095,
0.0117944395,
-0.0225675292,
-0.0013917695,
-0.0808271542,
0.0222007204,
-0.0072427285,
0.0273421519,
-0.0144853229,
-0.0200692844,
0.0129373316,
0.0383682027,
-0.0010823358,
-0.0245579816,
0.0258233994,
0.0863053575,
-0.0649348944,
-0.030959066,
0.0826421753,
0.02901306,
-0.0228056684,
0.0174357761,
-0.0265849065,
0.0403396375,
0.0255258828,
0.0450863577,
-0.0691113696,
0.0171713959,
-0.0102084735,
0.0180745423,
0.0065413066,
0.021702189,
0.0090503367,
-0.1162112206,
0.0030948939,
0.0219505429,
-0.0773106292,
-0.0092385197,
-0.0277092773,
-0.0174401551,
-0.007423324,
0.0796340182,
0.0078829117,
-0.0089964503,
-0.0065773539,
0.0406254902,
0.0115214633,
-0.0922841206,
0.0487942547,
-0.0378528014,
0.0409110934,
0.0421337672,
0.0170446001,
0.0050492873,
-0.0475613624,
0.0429496467,
0.0115798116,
0.015131685,
-0.0063818218,
0.0024456216,
0.0479418263,
-0.026759414,
0.0158677939,
-0.017730372,
-0.0111762136,
0.0116307763,
-0.0153634129,
0.0479449145,
0.0037515759,
-0.0264059175,
0.0014074169,
-0.0218108166,
-0.0042004618,
0.0360270739,
0.036992982,
-0.067428641,
-0.0276242644,
-0.0474246182,
-0.0253211297,
-0.1006690115,
-0.0300617162,
0.0648727417,
-0.0398487486,
-0.0211203452,
-0.036788892,
-0.0823054984,
0.0230219383,
0.014936571,
0.0221500732,
-0.0308409911,
-0.0334016047,
-0.0291076265,
0.0198807791,
0.0593598224,
-0.019666506,
0.0239334386,
-0.0838520825,
-0.0731247962,
-0.0201557726,
-0.0039653815,
-0.0061265822,
0.0122456066,
-0.0820978954,
-0.0605582818,
-0.0019451543,
0.0590208992,
0.0071505615,
0.0401447229,
0.0087003019,
-0.0421088152,
-0.0202561393,
-0.0368748754,
-0.0112545323,
0.0221657585,
0.0347189531,
-0.0403826535,
-0.0255984012,
0.030518597,
-0.0233412515,
0.0423167981,
0.0371273942,
0.0452436693,
0.029271923,
-0.0252798516,
0.0096769622,
0.037521854,
0.0330177806,
-0.05473933,
-0.0416705981,
-0.0363578163,
0.0091160256,
-0.0352447033,
0.0140678678,
-0.0157395694,
-0.0299464315,
0.0228962693,
0.0171076357,
-0.008674765,
-0.0031927421,
-0.0149899116,
0.0360937305,
-0.0503515564,
0.0349384956,
0.0243486036,
0.0149774533,
0.025562292,
0.0575715005,
-0.0123027191,
0.0355892591,
-0.0022731472,
0.0482666567,
-0.0256763864,
0.0464116186,
-0.0121549638,
0.0376878083,
0.0099898288,
-0.0036696114,
-0.0022375819,
-0.001314931,
-0.0317069329,
-0.0236457735,
0.0476776212,
-0.0138843879,
0.0861846954,
-0.0000614252,
-0.0014597608,
-0.031324558,
0.0149853071,
-0.0094898278,
-0.0589348748,
0.0070962212,
-0.0057250615,
-0.002227162,
-0.0171771143,
0.0770956427,
0.029270472,
0.0579778366,
-0.0319912471,
0.0499151163,
-0.0247440785,
-0.007689096,
0.0208792612,
-0.0098355236,
-0.0334239416,
0.0109205097,
-0.0420888886,
-0.0767553225,
-0.0278603137,
0.0449177362,
0.0267824139,
0.0142633896,
0.0164485984,
0.0513388924,
-0.0536105447,
-0.0051264698,
-0.0514919832,
-0.0225871522,
0.0043383106,
-0.0101260711,
0.0029225354,
-6.285650412e-33,
-0.0329068378,
0.0192790348,
0.0335823745,
-0.0316915996,
0.0212898217,
-0.020019386,
-0.0302078221,
0.015795134,
-0.0104082394,
0.0058296616,
0.0018558137,
-0.0237259474,
0.0137023004,
0.0247244202,
0.0311301015,
0.0155016063,
0.0440475494,
-0.0191191323,
-0.0126698455,
0.0195431951,
0.0312494971,
0.0002194502,
0.1219276935,
-0.0282050353,
0.049075909,
-0.01566354,
0.0029054144,
-0.0167814959,
-0.0452784821,
0.0691348463,
-0.0062135779,
0.0586695448,
0.0210040845,
-0.0264310725,
-0.0376422219,
-0.0468991026,
-0.0338359103,
-0.033895243,
0.0308212824,
0.0462871715,
-0.0418853126,
-0.0437306874,
0.0094669731,
-0.024923021,
-0.0682122409,
-0.0047601126,
0.0099837761,
-0.0201953202,
-0.0187785886,
-0.0024419564,
-0.1006876454,
0.0183057226,
0.0006496824,
0.0046045454,
0.0046353824,
0.0873646736,
-0.0343591869,
-0.0477178767,
-0.0175674297,
0.0220337901,
0.0375601351,
0.0694566965,
0.1035132259,
0.0383654796,
-0.004675054,
0.0040874779,
0.0480260402,
0.0405030139,
0.0584898293,
0.0166968405,
0.107504122,
-0.0049691144,
0.0286417305,
0.0478167497,
0.0297510568,
-0.0151612498,
-0.0666416362,
0.011959319,
0.0133558679,
0.0169762,
0.0075471723,
0.0000906433,
-0.0354872458,
-0.0318125412,
-0.0522431619,
-0.0236494206,
-0.0294954348,
-0.037514057,
0.0457635261,
0.0046826163,
-0.0092597594,
-0.0096668173,
0.0735482648,
-0.0285850093,
-0.0075961617,
-0.0074041192,
-0.0387218408,
0.0092690326,
-0.0092114098,
0.0471332781,
-0.055489365,
-0.0742338672,
0.0111855138,
-0.0015976866,
0.0298011545,
0.0098406952,
0.0407674536,
0.0190758351,
-0.0451636799,
0.0214641914,
-0.0459608547,
0.0352588184,
0.0212657712,
0.0235473365,
0.0444278531,
0.0111897876,
-0.020004008,
0.0721616223,
0.021123521,
-0.0325235054,
-0.0538527481,
-0.0140771568,
0.0113826655,
0.0385538302,
-0.0139061427,
0.0162052382,
-0.0458720364,
-0.019360356,
0.0271366891,
-0.0336288959,
-0.0195769072,
0.0094461646,
2.565e-7,
0.0293673407,
0.0648812354,
0.0065062279,
0.0327895805,
0.0145484069,
-0.0192787629,
-0.0582854785,
-0.0076718591,
0.0200016517,
0.01991437,
-0.0142907137,
0.0248431042,
0.07631246,
0.0405328199,
-0.0435796008,
0.0036233929,
-0.0341245122,
0.0514004156,
-0.0646717027,
0.0216025766,
-0.0273561627,
0.0808352977,
-0.0414887145,
0.002123544,
-0.0130207017,
-0.0192473847,
0.0504722297,
-0.0196380261,
-0.0179747194,
0.0346517973,
0.0068507404,
0.0328292809,
0.026402045,
0.0147109274,
-0.032875903,
0.0116922557,
0.004367651,
0.0787427649,
-0.0024954155,
-0.0189754255,
0.0261525158,
-0.0143957268,
-0.0393256173,
-0.0325132236,
0.0237962082,
-0.0098410957,
-0.0051228157,
0.0209072605,
0.0300613437,
0.0219955482,
0.0373600088,
-0.057535708,
-0.0104901344,
0.0435840115,
0.0563343391,
-0.0206752811,
-0.0201853774,
-0.0058609475,
-0.0190491546,
0.0496680774,
-0.0374245197,
-0.0594409965,
-0.0282433666,
-0.0067300946,
-0.0092490977,
-0.0213725641,
-0.0011235023,
2.375253706e-34,
0.0363848135,
0.0011305377,
0.042891182,
-0.0344703645,
0.0234287195,
-0.0358650386,
-0.011002291,
0.0187271051,
-0.0147981634,
-0.0437073968,
-0.0200260896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12814v1 | Adversarial Attacks on Multimodal Agents | 2024-06-18T17:32:48 | 2024-06-18T17:32:48 | Chen Henry Wu, Jing Yu Koh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Daniel Fried, Aditi Raghunathan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | Vision-enabled language models (VLMs) are now used to build autonomous
multimodal agents capable of taking actions in real environments. In this
paper, we show that multimodal agents raise new safety risks, even though
attacking agents is more challenging than prior attacks due to limited access
to and knowledge about the environment. Our attacks use adversarial text
strings to guide gradient-based perturbation over one trigger image in the
environment: (1) our captioner attack attacks white-box captioners if they are
used to process images into captions as additional inputs to the VLM; (2) our
CLIP attack attacks a set of CLIP models jointly, which can transfer to
proprietary VLMs. To evaluate the attacks, we curated VisualWebArena-Adv, a set
of adversarial tasks based on VisualWebArena, an environment for web-based
multimodal agent tasks. Within an L-infinity norm of $16/256$ on a single
image, the captioner attack can make a captioner-augmented GPT-4V agent execute
the adversarial goals with a 75% success rate. When we remove the captioner or
use GPT-4V to generate its own captions, the CLIP attack can achieve success
rates of 21% and 43%, respectively. Experiments on agents based on other VLMs,
such as Gemini-1.5, Claude-3, and GPT-4o, show interesting differences in their
robustness. Further analysis reveals several key factors contributing to the
attack's success, and we also discuss the implications for defenses as well.
Project page: https://chenwu.io/attack-agent Code and data:
https://github.com/ChenWu98/agent-attack | [
0.038508527,
0.0589229614,
-0.0248771086,
0.0404571258,
-0.0263167657,
-0.0191247556,
0.0399922021,
-0.0161587764,
0.0001616775,
-0.0775403082,
-0.0227690767,
0.0074720653,
-0.0086729787,
0.0658368617,
0.0604863949,
-0.063065432,
0.0329025984,
-0.0455765501,
-0.0289530195,
-0.0141185736,
0.0290093645,
-0.0280098841,
-0.0197840873,
0.0676015913,
-0.0253704656,
-0.0189177431,
-0.0282101482,
0.0076187765,
0.0259712841,
-0.0067121722,
-0.0035054928,
0.0403597504,
0.0382318944,
0.0501452908,
0.0000020416,
0.0026308692,
-0.0071730693,
0.0227399301,
0.0437175222,
-0.0076327007,
0.0192751512,
-0.0583732612,
-0.0247568041,
-0.0015935856,
-0.0340989828,
-0.0131970784,
0.0480295792,
0.0515313223,
0.0922771543,
0.0855139345,
-0.0204096865,
-0.0179217383,
0.039997492,
-0.011567954,
0.0002828069,
-0.0635569766,
0.0103865387,
-0.0063265627,
-0.0065097427,
0.0042703701,
-0.0310070571,
0.038799338,
-0.0015080733,
-0.007256201,
-0.044176992,
0.0426011607,
-0.0415740497,
-0.0509850457,
-0.0237634405,
0.0710904524,
-0.0286522321,
0.0328294449,
-0.0039966251,
0.0308533944,
0.0139459288,
-0.0020945685,
-0.037738055,
0.0447641574,
0.0312976129,
-0.0127579486,
-0.0731434971,
-0.0060079605,
0.0278625842,
-0.0019308206,
0.0071811797,
-0.0159313511,
0.0279061049,
0.0296443403,
-0.0299420245,
-0.0252696443,
-0.0518603809,
-0.0492932387,
-0.0094326315,
0.0102165109,
0.0086837104,
0.0140509401,
-0.1185916141,
-0.0357210264,
0.0073967613,
-0.0224955194,
0.0465797298,
0.0022580617,
-0.0445481203,
0.0501666144,
0.0003642937,
0.0552832521,
-0.0309185293,
0.0662400126,
0.0093144365,
-0.0023595111,
-0.0255099814,
-0.0173626635,
0.014126163,
-0.002695377,
-0.0426061563,
-0.0393308736,
-0.0072667175,
0.033901386,
-0.0560953133,
0.0248713084,
-0.063412264,
0.0076270066,
-0.0055077309,
-0.0015361622,
0.0015640261,
-0.0287952609,
0.0153335789,
0.0030698006,
-0.0068603107,
-0.0997697562,
-0.0246032737,
0.0288116317,
-0.0068766894,
-0.0194548164,
-0.0306067895,
0.1355089694,
-0.0078736991,
-0.0564537458,
-0.0067720586,
-0.0540541112,
-0.0448159948,
-0.0307966638,
0.0177402385,
-0.0376380831,
0.0126776975,
-0.0458179601,
-0.0202219617,
-0.072205171,
0.0386873521,
0.0293291416,
-0.0095788613,
0.134311527,
0.033688806,
-0.0222758073,
0.013609102,
0.0285821985,
-0.0597735345,
0.0492263548,
0.0213925578,
0.0707418993,
0.0474647656,
0.0138704684,
0.0433011353,
0.0387844667,
0.0008033252,
0.026403904,
-0.0182136856,
-0.017146429,
0.0277529173,
0.0046946895,
0.0124448063,
0.0726292878,
-0.0427063927,
-0.0614431277,
0.1387610734,
0.0436819941,
-0.0913649052,
0.0177938584,
0.0022305397,
-0.0010641328,
-0.0004888462,
-0.0123960245,
-0.0666676909,
0.0333209969,
-0.038077306,
-0.0372666679,
-0.0098088346,
0.0319306441,
-0.0216779597,
-0.0110897459,
0.0028446009,
-0.0246625543,
0.0511794202,
-0.0131330956,
0.0426310413,
0.0237144474,
-0.0383386537,
-0.0224267635,
-0.0163485557,
-0.0461834706,
-0.0208433326,
-0.0649178326,
-0.0355906934,
0.0012338938,
0.059108533,
-0.001594135,
-0.0122098709,
-0.0291354042,
0.0050664893,
0.0423511863,
0.0286599323,
0.0149496039,
0.0031485739,
-0.0174389239,
-0.0339115188,
-0.0550088696,
-0.0021246762,
0.033605691,
-0.0163893607,
0.0146537442,
-0.0048815398,
0.0318634883,
-0.0174482316,
0.038710732,
0.0659489259,
-0.0391215831,
-0.0420023911,
0.0199842621,
0.0401230007,
0.0021756375,
-0.0531461276,
0.0268289261,
0.0439253673,
-0.0166079979,
-0.0260851048,
0.0303055719,
0.0252750106,
-0.0221638866,
0.043392688,
-0.0884765238,
-0.0002877252,
0.0710607767,
-0.0390589833,
0.0002129232,
0.0596055612,
-0.0510177948,
-0.0071131364,
-0.0336681269,
-0.014893027,
0.010310919,
0.047443945,
0.0036467451,
0.0390785933,
-0.0208354667,
-0.0691231042,
0.008474187,
0.0400178544,
-0.0030067554,
-0.0223575048,
-0.0577455126,
0.0091069406,
0.0071103396,
0.034452036,
0.0261635594,
-0.0095573068,
0.0051253834,
0.0103767281,
-0.0655923858,
-0.0403713472,
-0.0227147192,
-0.0239844695,
-0.0088691059,
-0.0175033491,
0.004385489,
-0.021726016,
-0.0027790894,
0.0207921751,
-0.0187987108,
0.0495495833,
0.0145795234,
0.0020962991,
-0.0271482952,
-0.0294254906,
-0.0093344301,
0.0061570085,
0.0505245663,
-0.0129937632,
-0.0345840529,
-0.0004815644,
-0.0178342443,
-0.0302232336,
0.0736203343,
-0.0446019955,
-0.0535199605,
0.0439971648,
0.0113131516,
-0.0087344358,
0.0800428838,
0.0174876582,
0.0769962892,
0.0458680466,
0.0103640594,
-0.0125393337,
0.0103400601,
0.0171630513,
-0.040855106,
-0.0191467926,
0.0195238665,
0.030675875,
0.0285151992,
0.0235985946,
0.0132512981,
-0.0491066575,
0.0750336573,
0.0070860237,
-0.0768555254,
-0.0096144984,
0.0013851498,
-0.0470172875,
-0.0067593292,
-0.0100835981,
-0.0423182547,
0.0204111636,
-0.0343642198,
-0.0042527937,
0.0212284736,
-0.0212230645,
0.0305514988,
0.089311026,
0.0564737581,
0.0303145833,
0.0328643508,
0.0202540215,
-0.052292563,
-0.0168428794,
0.0283808745,
-0.0111222416,
0.0455946438,
-0.0499797389,
0.0125437696,
-0.0142523423,
-0.0392508097,
-0.0407900326,
-0.04197146,
-0.023128476,
0.0096802469,
-0.0228724778,
-0.0270722527,
-0.0572001301,
0.0103626987,
0.0512480699,
-0.0073088584,
-0.0199181177,
0.007774089,
-0.0336261466,
0.0239779912,
0.0794132426,
0.00380589,
-0.0314477608,
-0.0287766643,
-0.0140398424,
0.0871763453,
-0.0007200577,
-0.0033796313,
-0.0542333908,
-0.0003373905,
-0.0042532892,
0.0295850597,
0.0060356734,
0.0058987187,
0.0449197218,
-0.0385058299,
0.0264324546,
0.0302747004,
-0.0063046585,
-0.0222625043,
0.0103685753,
0.0163257457,
0.0050036698,
0.006266675,
0.0000135799,
-0.0490975305,
-0.0483881272,
0.0090206647,
0.0041727168,
-0.0088942377,
0.0195109397,
-0.0356102176,
-0.0825597793,
0.0294492971,
-0.0088461135,
-0.0165829901,
-0.0296942648,
0.0285205022,
0.0063288845,
-0.0020715089,
0.026137853,
-0.0002708332,
0.0211812276,
-0.0011993444,
-0.0072364509,
0.0213639066,
-0.0465857163,
-0.0068098307,
-0.0443506986,
0.0372997746,
0.1025343537,
0.0155480774,
-0.0440208428,
-0.0400270447,
0.0200333335,
-0.0013798444,
0.0167376176,
0.0504709892,
0.072898075,
-0.0441269167,
-0.0193233881,
0.0345438123,
0.0454841107,
0.0020002676,
-0.0106666125,
-0.0027047112,
0.0028914625,
0.000199503,
-0.0162863024,
-0.0729594082,
0.0138226049,
0.0078054271,
0.0583856814,
0.0232604686,
-0.0346071683,
-0.0536074638,
-0.0561672561,
-0.002358312,
-0.0391029678,
-0.059002094,
0.0140798679,
0.0115640266,
-0.0443459451,
-0.0824186504,
-0.0540654026,
0.0176656619,
0.0302851424,
-0.0138332974,
-0.0147815524,
-0.0237900056,
0.0695858076,
-0.0212242231,
-0.0022888843,
-0.0174591504,
0.0218188912,
0.0014943897,
0.0266188215,
0.0319610648,
-0.053133402,
-0.019001279,
0.0427207015,
-0.0756077543,
-0.0649437234,
-0.0342829078,
0.076203987,
0.0143236518,
0.0249758959,
-0.0124841146,
-0.0479362793,
0.0482493676,
0.0429042131,
0.03040695,
0.0283491146,
0.0725590289,
-0.0304053947,
-0.0022809592,
0.0518498719,
-0.0514608547,
0.0016161652,
0.006832405,
0.0265181549,
-0.0266630631,
0.0267179776,
0.0012703028,
-0.018406013,
0.0468983725,
-0.0354850441,
0.0257814508,
0.0384644903,
0.0021892276,
-0.0032342793,
0.0111700324,
-0.0471190847,
0.0188606996,
-0.0277620349,
0.0228814762,
0.0263185855,
-0.0072645959,
0.0020566415,
-0.0207810719,
0.005432466,
0.0100471573,
0.0401409753,
-0.0277474001,
-0.0096419267,
0.0351228826,
-0.0141221862,
0.0428330526,
-0.0208034944,
0.0125540979,
-0.0002281809,
0.0428167023,
0.019284822,
-0.0386594757,
-0.0020170098,
0.0529601425,
-0.0656799972,
-0.0169907175,
0.0120656528,
0.0564436838,
0.0530316234,
0.0318004489,
0.0187319722,
-0.0443888307,
-0.0057703229,
-0.0287376884,
-0.0082365992,
0.0234473739,
-0.0313606672,
0.0386079401,
0.0147170238,
0.0071677165,
0.0080821058,
0.0738064274,
0.0184652098,
0.0528633147,
0.0211260859,
-0.0347071029,
-0.0374157205,
-0.0386028253,
0.0321234129,
0.0113585126,
-0.0146577684,
-0.0243344959,
-0.0264215767,
-0.0637456477,
-0.0062876381,
0.0338744409,
0.0107010752,
0.006857106,
0.017780263,
0.0254233871,
0.0192988422,
0.0091023687,
-0.0368543826,
0.0033998364,
-0.0216420945,
-0.0176843293,
0.0457855798,
-6.096683818e-33,
0.0032630335,
-0.003829746,
-0.0003400897,
0.0149998032,
-0.0035419103,
0.0187051557,
-0.0209086817,
0.0027011081,
-0.0064528696,
-0.0050323536,
0.0068411264,
-0.0172866285,
-0.0071756286,
0.0269582197,
-0.0375476219,
-0.0313933417,
0.0044225338,
-0.015192749,
-0.0155501962,
-0.0076074544,
0.0381843336,
-0.0054453663,
0.0225286745,
-0.0471035577,
0.0142745422,
-0.0118849203,
-0.0743308514,
-0.0317839161,
-0.006707483,
0.0663940981,
-0.0199148171,
0.0193816461,
-0.0019094141,
0.0029184585,
-0.0217817612,
0.0330109261,
-0.0079440661,
-0.016889723,
-0.0068511358,
0.0326889716,
-0.0690214783,
-0.0234179012,
0.0215889271,
-0.027869042,
-0.0245657917,
-0.0069958768,
0.0229546055,
-0.015595763,
-0.0014784316,
0.0088045048,
-0.0542457961,
0.0167642478,
0.0078767603,
-0.0388990566,
0.0369199105,
0.008023438,
0.0532736592,
-0.0175693426,
-0.0531857163,
0.0155076012,
-0.0029689395,
-0.0172356442,
0.0816140324,
0.0087623727,
0.0297575537,
0.0990496427,
0.0241668429,
-0.021060802,
-0.026971221,
-0.016820075,
0.0154935857,
0.0671060979,
0.0527723618,
0.0930002481,
0.0287824795,
0.0071074544,
-0.0400003716,
0.0250422899,
-0.0214306917,
0.038367942,
0.066904068,
0.017639935,
-0.0447440222,
0.0395939685,
-0.0140121989,
-0.0414925031,
-0.0346450992,
-0.0459854081,
0.0320418812,
0.0256666541,
-0.0037415652,
0.0067100101,
0.0488097705,
-0.0463743247,
0.007689809,
-0.0062843007,
-0.0282590892,
0.0090095745,
-0.0165801495,
-0.0060801147,
0.0324620157,
0.0223514382,
0.0368791148,
-0.0375858769,
0.0259345155,
0.0120518655,
0.0395253003,
0.0628609061,
-0.0083605591,
-0.0372120552,
-0.029662393,
0.0231093559,
0.004406245,
0.0313306041,
0.0515254475,
-0.0082065314,
-0.0363122784,
-0.0056193853,
0.0163821671,
0.0067901723,
-0.0204482451,
0.0116435923,
-0.0374419466,
-0.0134719079,
-0.0417785272,
0.0014328986,
-0.0375181995,
0.0241389368,
0.0271126553,
-0.0872926712,
-0.0047399458,
-0.0132971136,
2.81e-7,
-0.0311560016,
0.0310446005,
0.0231122728,
0.0197691284,
0.0343074538,
0.0872303545,
-0.0215666536,
0.0823406428,
-0.0523387231,
-0.0546422005,
0.0016808343,
0.0258973725,
0.0300211962,
0.0078928443,
0.0066955113,
0.0026608789,
-0.0245448295,
-0.0246482957,
-0.0366674997,
-0.0222514533,
0.0618254915,
0.0930188522,
0.0254659671,
-0.0355252102,
0.0139383003,
-0.065658845,
0.0485826991,
-0.0137865767,
-0.0049528307,
-0.0444418825,
0.0153046893,
0.0512716286,
-0.0313727222,
0.016933484,
-0.0199560914,
-0.0276728384,
0.0160578489,
0.0466179214,
-0.036744412,
-0.0463222824,
-0.0300083458,
0.0159449764,
-0.0212335531,
-0.0165087208,
0.0876486301,
-0.0211105421,
-0.0410138629,
-0.015920585,
-0.0284982026,
-0.0031351598,
0.0175022539,
-0.0573843047,
-0.0475489832,
-0.0005474569,
0.0090598287,
0.0021214588,
-0.0142618706,
-0.0951312035,
0.0214101505,
-0.0391393267,
-0.0264515486,
-0.0129403332,
-0.0430155694,
0.0144391079,
0.04449898,
-0.0147316577,
-0.0489612035,
2.339998748e-34,
0.0096955169,
-0.0292592682,
-0.0071971901,
-0.0302655958,
0.0340638682,
0.0248429887,
-0.0203559995,
-0.020095896,
0.0032028595,
-0.0319740325,
-0.0522396863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12809v1 | Can Large Language Models Always Solve Easy Problems if They Can Solve Harder Ones? | 2024-06-18T17:25:47 | 2024-06-18T17:25:47 | Zhe Yang, Yichang Zhang, Tianyu Liu, Jian Yang, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities, but
still suffer from inconsistency issues (e.g. LLMs can react differently to
disturbances like rephrasing or inconsequential order change). In addition to
these inconsistencies, we also observe that LLMs, while capable of solving hard
problems, can paradoxically fail at easier ones. To evaluate this hard-to-easy
inconsistency, we develop the ConsisEval benchmark, where each entry comprises
a pair of questions with a strict order of difficulty. Furthermore, we
introduce the concept of consistency score to quantitatively measure this
inconsistency and analyze the potential for improvement in consistency by
relative consistency score. Based on comprehensive experiments across a variety
of existing models, we find: (1) GPT-4 achieves the highest consistency score
of 92.2\% but is still inconsistent to specific questions due to distraction by
redundant information, misinterpretation of questions, etc.; (2) models with
stronger capabilities typically exhibit higher consistency, but exceptions also
exist; (3) hard data enhances consistency for both fine-tuning and in-context
learning. Our data and code will be publicly available on GitHub. | [
0.0380500667,
0.0825218931,
-0.0212137792,
0.0451725349,
-0.0584926084,
0.0326358452,
-0.0193581861,
-0.0103856344,
-0.0191099141,
-0.047630772,
0.0033928885,
-0.0428021327,
0.0108891996,
0.0083644278,
0.031257499,
-0.0409884416,
0.054824993,
-0.0407222807,
-0.0134643493,
-0.0101886708,
0.0089027919,
-0.0125338938,
0.0015177017,
0.0268562902,
0.0232756753,
-0.003397119,
-0.0027766204,
0.0057457066,
0.0098463409,
-0.0019017705,
0.0169216003,
0.0584119037,
0.0013365847,
0.0915673375,
0.0000019428,
-0.0629915521,
-0.0263301171,
-0.0035874674,
-0.0237770732,
0.0449287929,
-0.0168510173,
-0.0596742518,
-0.0228855368,
0.0323981382,
-0.0424186029,
-0.0118181761,
0.0241157301,
0.0131979864,
0.0741489232,
0.0722800344,
0.0116163082,
-0.0121892309,
0.031668447,
-0.0630328581,
0.0149551276,
-0.0875312462,
0.0136802765,
0.0006653686,
-0.0057519958,
0.0098896716,
-0.0317127928,
0.0299259368,
0.0313524827,
0.0334964208,
-0.0579469055,
0.0188655574,
-0.076608032,
-0.0064118709,
-0.0054460559,
0.0889110863,
-0.0329105146,
-0.0074671037,
-0.0145962341,
-0.0285098441,
0.0134630743,
0.0119349193,
-0.0522071198,
0.0222447161,
0.0126728779,
0.0086206067,
0.0128409304,
-0.0368936025,
0.0493375622,
0.0017033617,
-0.0319294035,
0.0684646815,
0.0265262518,
-0.0441121347,
0.0017864821,
-0.0071776467,
-0.0734894052,
-0.0485324785,
-0.014253418,
0.0253615137,
-0.0663801134,
0.0294493549,
-0.0377848931,
0.0018570739,
0.0300285742,
-0.0259515848,
0.0280279405,
0.045024924,
-0.0061090924,
0.060825374,
-0.0056542801,
0.0947852358,
-0.0160378534,
0.0264886841,
-0.0232701171,
-0.0126476288,
-0.0272958912,
-0.0016455253,
-0.0391339362,
0.025687553,
-0.0067761336,
-0.004473527,
-0.0512395948,
0.0252922382,
-0.026344588,
0.0546809323,
-0.0007831503,
-0.0428056382,
-0.0289097913,
-0.0233223159,
-0.0155192884,
0.0435113683,
-0.0326697305,
0.0154416738,
0.0154267931,
-0.048221983,
-0.0005959352,
-0.0186911803,
-0.01919787,
-0.0348741934,
0.0054346016,
0.0443917923,
0.0018533639,
-0.0250904635,
-0.0103165694,
0.0157965124,
-0.0336868949,
-0.095327273,
-0.0272634644,
-0.058789935,
0.0244174488,
0.0491249934,
0.0047730389,
-0.0508678965,
0.006726684,
-0.0094895801,
-0.0215502363,
0.1008189842,
0.0290931091,
0.0079351347,
0.0210944228,
0.0291656908,
-0.0108965198,
0.0510910377,
0.0097896783,
-0.0092153009,
0.0525034219,
-0.0218392499,
0.0217094105,
0.0447056182,
-0.0143516427,
0.0231918544,
-0.0058306218,
0.0199109968,
0.0208571125,
0.0396907665,
-0.0314189307,
0.0822780728,
0.0038596562,
-0.0224413481,
0.0522950776,
-0.0051737404,
0.0025581738,
0.0141658997,
0.0203367062,
0.0011019282,
0.0200046618,
0.0375418738,
-0.0902565047,
-0.0063427333,
-0.0211760793,
0.0136891296,
0.0181176327,
0.0146102412,
-0.0195821058,
-0.0574401282,
-0.0351691023,
-0.0023841774,
-0.0059667341,
0.0130248945,
0.0542295501,
-0.0227303728,
-0.0313938409,
0.0456976332,
0.0075167054,
-0.0292467494,
-0.0275027324,
-0.0460635945,
0.0187528245,
0.0135650737,
0.0495336652,
-0.0467534922,
-0.0591014698,
0.0086153802,
0.0279926751,
0.005460381,
0.0885680988,
0.0023960585,
0.0061383643,
-0.0441091992,
-0.0177416969,
-0.0153803881,
0.0447727591,
-0.0083646728,
0.0385760181,
0.0236232895,
0.0277414378,
-0.0245006159,
-0.01535476,
0.0166341178,
-0.0211586542,
-0.0124139003,
-0.0183355305,
-0.0111167561,
0.0365288891,
-0.0256518349,
-0.0101331137,
0.0106821265,
0.0334957577,
-0.0308438949,
0.0094683934,
-0.0140716229,
-0.0584660247,
-0.0084356116,
0.0526530556,
0.0009369717,
-0.0579407774,
0.0784005895,
-0.0877735689,
-0.0472799204,
0.0179329831,
-0.0274059568,
0.0173006691,
-0.0303531401,
0.0444585234,
-0.0110569242,
0.0101424819,
-0.0500936285,
0.0491920002,
-0.0070067639,
0.0587539226,
0.0005401393,
0.0283812452,
-0.0010023258,
-0.028112432,
-0.043098595,
0.0329417139,
-0.0096735815,
0.0201186575,
0.0222207326,
0.000412683,
-0.0539228544,
-0.0460739695,
-0.0724357814,
0.0118370634,
-0.0334684141,
0.0046872273,
0.0355376005,
0.0015036066,
-0.0068433736,
-0.0058596199,
-0.0298919063,
0.0277665947,
0.0270334706,
0.024685204,
0.0557271466,
0.0315260626,
-0.0367705934,
-0.0481863506,
-0.0265279859,
-0.0200909916,
0.0112758297,
-0.0234210044,
0.0167544745,
-0.0657109097,
0.0157407019,
-0.0549516976,
0.0316178463,
-0.0342423283,
-0.0292578824,
0.0181762949,
-0.0184415057,
0.0496494472,
0.0652436316,
-0.0078043132,
0.0396778286,
0.0573845617,
-0.0260985773,
-0.0348581895,
0.0199042987,
-0.0070084468,
-0.0575576052,
-0.0353716724,
-0.0439585783,
-0.0152089437,
0.0760817155,
-0.0118159112,
-0.0340900831,
-0.0206871051,
0.049855426,
-0.0426035225,
0.0252657179,
-0.0284145735,
0.0162889585,
-0.0231495183,
0.0472914912,
-0.0342812352,
-0.0636590198,
0.0645393133,
-0.0205373596,
0.0022150867,
-0.0455703363,
0.0016180912,
-0.0422931276,
0.0695240647,
0.0259732231,
0.016262494,
0.0090761939,
-0.0178806707,
-0.0915706009,
-0.0195726994,
0.036981836,
-0.0367521644,
0.0801923349,
-0.0675306171,
0.0098255211,
-0.0187427197,
-0.0950427428,
-0.0244985074,
-0.0394855589,
-0.0061311629,
0.0303006358,
0.014170818,
-0.0240058675,
-0.0214971695,
-0.0041610599,
0.0249469057,
0.0429701209,
-0.0274966992,
-0.0087804915,
-0.0304142796,
0.0434424654,
0.0612751991,
0.0344686657,
0.0322040245,
-0.0354359671,
0.0051158192,
0.0405618325,
0.0505644046,
0.0244036801,
-0.0082863094,
0.0090872264,
0.0201848261,
-0.0422910154,
-0.0359610692,
0.019968316,
0.056954518,
-0.0550964363,
-0.0383628011,
0.1253746748,
0.0508979075,
-0.0200962164,
0.0072693052,
-0.0100769736,
0.0375391543,
0.0459959097,
0.0251335558,
-0.0602030531,
-0.0346303992,
0.0293526798,
0.0239473358,
0.0054810666,
-0.0199321415,
0.0024056325,
-0.1160622686,
0.0232975055,
0.0127541525,
-0.0510313101,
-0.0265725031,
-0.0360240713,
-0.0017931677,
-0.0112415124,
0.0586179495,
0.0395464636,
0.0022295231,
-0.0060565979,
0.0089546591,
-0.0082875285,
-0.0531814434,
0.0446037836,
-0.0337025449,
0.0485220626,
0.0452850685,
0.0141858552,
-0.0292036962,
-0.0151172094,
0.0968558788,
0.0024630756,
-0.0447354168,
-0.0086977202,
-0.0166591797,
0.0338727422,
-0.0279624499,
-0.010072316,
0.0237227213,
-0.0082308361,
0.0160594899,
0.0197295733,
0.0674094856,
0.0124537991,
-0.0343813598,
0.0003994008,
-0.049745284,
-0.0271768961,
0.0766654983,
0.0267081391,
-0.0291192178,
-0.0608862489,
-0.0539190881,
0.0149832359,
-0.0103114545,
-0.0119247623,
0.0141345095,
0.0437872969,
0.0170883182,
-0.0436944962,
-0.0480080955,
0.0125506371,
0.0206286088,
-0.0068836957,
0.0186430886,
0.003341414,
-0.0015805305,
-0.0398548245,
0.0195159521,
-0.023442369,
0.0182324201,
-0.0865901038,
0.0020970553,
0.0371924937,
0.012479173,
-0.0293113384,
0.0311463885,
-0.0958289877,
-0.0618567877,
0.0187764186,
0.0404586494,
0.0314146094,
0.036567796,
-0.007845683,
-0.04217574,
-0.0311802235,
0.0131942444,
-0.0202615354,
0.0324339978,
0.0077951574,
-0.0163799841,
0.0037098236,
0.0529378578,
-0.0430853628,
0.0044495161,
0.020100167,
0.0694346875,
-0.0383138396,
-0.0158660002,
0.0303623527,
0.0315456539,
0.0356953405,
0.0097449766,
-0.0162143484,
-0.0022316175,
0.042238567,
-0.0027624969,
-0.0285313353,
-0.0450722836,
-0.0006158447,
0.0408426784,
0.0077401209,
-0.0088148853,
0.0007900744,
0.0286532063,
0.0548478737,
-0.0367636457,
-0.0147462972,
0.0140835177,
0.0128008863,
0.0567266308,
-0.0239854287,
-0.0231388472,
0.0418514535,
0.0060387701,
0.048877947,
-0.0148937739,
0.0435463376,
0.0227359738,
0.003993459,
-0.0172207914,
0.0190616623,
-0.0778514668,
-0.0496238135,
0.0046504238,
0.025044091,
0.0656122416,
-0.0028609075,
0.0361352079,
-0.0307826269,
-0.0298879463,
-0.0466385297,
0.0129592037,
0.0243577641,
-0.0077966447,
0.0445669033,
0.0450544916,
-0.0059984783,
0.0492072776,
0.0669720694,
0.0372769348,
0.0328120552,
0.0299908165,
-0.002080142,
-0.0316133499,
-0.0218363479,
0.0075910809,
0.015227221,
-0.0270344503,
0.0225247219,
-0.0605347268,
-0.0765307173,
0.0001146347,
0.0062027392,
0.0078971209,
-0.0159012321,
0.0032340658,
0.1052078381,
-0.0270642359,
-0.009271808,
-0.0189937241,
-0.0114198532,
-0.0045809001,
-0.0439863987,
-0.0063790842,
-6.388244621e-33,
-0.0222078189,
0.0007745838,
0.0027699065,
-0.0520715378,
0.0035460591,
0.0090810033,
-0.0512998849,
0.0161358248,
-0.0455797464,
-0.0045723007,
-0.0268444438,
0.0199964289,
0.0011216077,
0.0208808817,
0.0077745658,
-0.0227416269,
0.0313008502,
0.0168985818,
-0.043082796,
0.0139149195,
0.0159563497,
0.0097582722,
0.0392037667,
-0.0267499387,
0.0255986843,
-0.0175421797,
-0.0256304108,
0.0432174504,
-0.0525297001,
0.0687324107,
-0.0022455347,
0.0412915908,
0.0237365607,
-0.0448522158,
-0.0039017249,
-0.0422651656,
-0.0509975143,
-0.0393004715,
0.0287169572,
0.0089527201,
-0.0274984464,
-0.0031361466,
0.0643219948,
-0.0167708155,
-0.0179490466,
-0.0159344096,
-0.000829064,
-0.0056400378,
-0.0151044168,
0.024206372,
-0.0369300917,
0.0141256377,
-0.0002554324,
-0.0089940289,
-0.0145715559,
0.0162909552,
0.0000450121,
0.0207995828,
-0.0416147672,
-0.0265477765,
0.0309295617,
0.0595495328,
0.046871461,
-0.0076372689,
-0.0370141864,
0.0292400159,
0.0026933099,
-0.0066251191,
0.0094761327,
-0.0315378867,
0.0133127067,
0.0491240919,
0.0672938451,
0.0385869779,
0.0353773534,
0.0059017772,
-0.0884464309,
-0.0034805816,
0.0046119704,
0.0319170021,
0.0162791591,
0.0145826088,
-0.0584244356,
-0.027913006,
-0.0642855763,
0.0310164336,
-0.0556777865,
0.0003370529,
0.0535146594,
0.0077414406,
0.0064743524,
-0.0081112124,
0.020160079,
-0.0509169027,
-0.0522787645,
0.0157281905,
-0.0239470284,
0.0170869604,
-0.0024101159,
0.0542674176,
-0.0464440323,
-0.0209864248,
-0.0292878561,
0.0048549944,
0.0134997116,
0.0014673888,
0.0311417691,
0.0066237669,
-0.0710888803,
-0.0036143227,
-0.0408077501,
0.0301288944,
-0.0214807186,
0.0078647761,
0.0456599295,
-0.0051330817,
-0.0015171795,
0.0357347317,
0.0219106879,
-0.0350544751,
-0.0359782539,
0.0242577065,
-0.010709851,
0.0230787247,
-0.0078616384,
-0.0179128014,
-0.0195248257,
0.0494518727,
0.0203972999,
-0.0256430116,
-0.0152392089,
-0.0017480956,
2.616e-7,
0.0379345343,
0.0671527386,
-0.0102805234,
0.0316329449,
0.023770595,
0.0342336111,
-0.0692531466,
0.001477614,
-0.0030712916,
0.0130552957,
0.0096203256,
0.0378820598,
0.0565441065,
0.0295687448,
-0.0631529689,
0.0193671454,
-0.0645348206,
-0.0023911907,
-0.0498164743,
0.0231131651,
0.049184788,
0.1262607276,
0.0203029811,
-0.0007220768,
-0.00469153,
-0.0701077804,
0.0493611731,
-0.0384328216,
0.016604919,
0.0279326923,
-0.0050881859,
0.0497604758,
0.0131098256,
0.0061544711,
-0.0037483033,
0.0011920219,
0.0094345342,
0.0649954602,
0.0143865691,
-0.0163487233,
-0.015452751,
-0.0068141343,
0.0003998537,
-0.104448095,
0.0862809941,
-0.0622993782,
-0.0368211344,
0.0127529679,
0.0002436018,
-0.0391239598,
0.0383308642,
-0.0059084138,
-0.0294700433,
0.0056557385,
0.01263161,
-0.0005742831,
-0.0140706738,
-0.0765730888,
-0.0204752572,
0.0247446131,
-0.0177341178,
-0.0580005571,
-0.0520781055,
0.0024793367,
0.0225516781,
-0.0513861477,
-0.0001238816,
2.737248569e-34,
0.0639526695,
-0.017901849,
0.0365257822,
0.0145492014,
0.0371770859,
-0.0128145395,
-0.0057737185,
0.0192299001,
0.0037640228,
-0.062822029,
-0.0142936762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12793v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12793v1 | ChatGLM: A Family of Large Language Models from GLM-130B to GLM-4 All Tools | 2024-06-18T16:58:21 | 2024-06-18T16:58:21 | Team GLM, :, Aohan Zeng, Bin Xu, Bowen Wang, Chenhui Zhang, Da Yin, Diego Rojas, Guanyu Feng, Hanlin Zhao, Hanyu Lai, Hao Yu, Hongning Wang, Jiadai Sun, Jiajie Zhang, Jiale Cheng, Jiayi Gui, Jie Tang, Jing Zhang, Juanzi Li, Lei Zhao, Lindong Wu, Lucen Zhong, Mingdao Liu, Minlie Huang, Peng Zhang, Qinkai Zheng, Rui Lu, Shuaiqi Duan, Shudan Zhang, Shulin Cao, Shuxun Yang, Weng Lam Tam, Wenyi Zhao, Xiao Liu, Xiao Xia, Xiaohan Zhang, Xiaotao Gu, Xin Lv, Xinghan Liu, Xinyi Liu, Xinyue Yang, Xixuan Song, Xunkai Zhang, Yifan An, Yifan Xu, Yilin Niu, Yuantao Yang, Yueyan Li, Yushi Bai, Yuxiao Dong, Zehan Qi, Zhaoyu Wang, Zhen Yang, Zhengxiao Du, Zhenyu Hou, Zihan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce ChatGLM, an evolving family of large language models that we
have been developing over time. This report primarily focuses on the GLM-4
language series, which includes GLM-4, GLM-4-Air, and GLM-4-9B. They represent
our most capable models that are trained with all the insights and lessons
gained from the preceding three generations of ChatGLM. To date, the GLM-4
models are pre-trained on ten trillions of tokens mostly in Chinese and
English, along with a small set of corpus from 24 languages, and aligned
primarily for Chinese and English usage. The high-quality alignment is achieved
via a multi-stage post-training process, which involves supervised fine-tuning
and learning from human feedback. Evaluations show that GLM-4 1) closely rivals
or outperforms GPT-4 in terms of general metrics such as MMLU, GSM8K, MATH,
BBH, GPQA, and HumanEval, 2) gets close to GPT-4-Turbo in instruction following
as measured by IFEval, 3) matches GPT-4 Turbo (128K) and Claude 3 for long
context tasks, and 4) outperforms GPT-4 in Chinese alignments as measured by
AlignBench. The GLM-4 All Tools model is further aligned to understand user
intent and autonomously decide when and which tool(s) touse -- including web
browser, Python interpreter, text-to-image model, and user-defined functions --
to effectively complete complex tasks. In practical applications, it matches
and even surpasses GPT-4 All Tools in tasks like accessing online information
via web browsing and solving math problems using Python interpreter. Over the
course, we have open-sourced a series of models, including ChatGLM-6B (three
generations), GLM-4-9B (128K, 1M), GLM-4V-9B, WebGLM, and CodeGeeX, attracting
over 10 million downloads on Hugging face in the year 2023 alone. The open
models can be accessed through https://github.com/THUDM and
https://huggingface.co/THUDM. | [
0.0138792004,
0.0684158131,
0.0171980541,
0.0292676073,
-0.0628681034,
0.0274200924,
0.0008640026,
-0.0333386064,
-0.0006299375,
-0.0238794703,
-0.0798385814,
-0.0602817573,
0.0194940586,
-0.0008308465,
0.037999969,
-0.0281276274,
0.0770786554,
-0.0185354054,
-0.0216983408,
0.0259351712,
0.0263695512,
0.0398067869,
-0.0088656507,
0.0461130403,
-0.0187046584,
-0.0521112941,
-0.0154445171,
0.0177251045,
0.0300433002,
0.0043321778,
0.015317142,
0.0575300567,
0.0107323155,
0.0771408603,
0.0000020431,
-0.051041346,
-0.0201697201,
-0.012978375,
-0.0338757075,
0.0139222946,
0.0498136058,
-0.0052437182,
-0.0100572146,
0.0384859815,
-0.0503515117,
-0.0169589743,
0.0497958511,
0.022012176,
0.0578407682,
0.1045740843,
-0.0129632624,
-0.0211331677,
0.0275540221,
-0.0320341475,
0.0049206158,
-0.0797894076,
0.0165902469,
0.0184605811,
-0.0156557746,
0.0031527749,
-0.0187808666,
0.0260768905,
0.0064529264,
0.0192273427,
-0.0255814828,
0.0121667664,
-0.0616911948,
-0.01740136,
-0.0044427202,
0.0671029687,
-0.0443445668,
-0.0451443419,
-0.0117353098,
0.0177257266,
0.0046867402,
-0.0340546966,
-0.0454988331,
0.015634302,
0.0033023281,
0.0244848896,
0.0218271203,
-0.0196968224,
0.0231785923,
0.0075284061,
-0.0333948284,
0.0099317785,
0.021972023,
-0.0253578965,
-0.0060986667,
0.0051807058,
-0.0397917442,
-0.0455542095,
-0.0053672572,
0.0168773495,
-0.0587903783,
0.031019656,
-0.0790107995,
0.0108437762,
0.0041544838,
-0.0493896455,
0.0118583506,
0.0795508772,
-0.0100582941,
0.0404749587,
-0.0055946559,
0.0869852453,
-0.0233851448,
-0.0027454381,
-0.0483003892,
-0.0143880723,
-0.0294476394,
-0.0114958175,
-0.0215231571,
-0.0011893499,
-0.0498490818,
-0.0408036821,
-0.0538588502,
0.0538948029,
-0.0008551546,
0.0220025629,
0.0255044643,
-0.0226629842,
-0.0446022488,
-0.0148532661,
-0.0000144315,
0.0363167711,
0.0121595226,
0.0115709575,
0.0097722104,
-0.0651069582,
0.0151135903,
0.0368571766,
0.0011954859,
-0.0491555147,
-0.0123059349,
0.0818543434,
-0.0294435099,
-0.0055795107,
-0.0291320216,
0.004674715,
0.005737077,
-0.0686135665,
-0.0295222551,
-0.0512664951,
0.0259164236,
0.0112736272,
0.003687229,
-0.0249552839,
-0.000861707,
0.0108789764,
0.0275126919,
0.0550204553,
0.0159418508,
0.0024089469,
-0.0028544783,
-0.0261693895,
-0.0250414852,
0.0694612414,
-0.0037708597,
0.0093897423,
0.0325460546,
-0.0314661749,
-0.0044100885,
0.0652017966,
-0.0187110696,
-0.0108985109,
0.000748655,
0.0120420419,
0.0218538959,
0.0347297229,
0.039776843,
0.0490777344,
-0.0142273903,
-0.0068836659,
0.0827418417,
0.0439788178,
0.028455779,
0.0020880129,
0.0161552969,
0.0293754656,
-0.001748981,
0.00444673,
-0.0747232512,
0.0115808723,
-0.0267770588,
0.0337120853,
0.0079821143,
0.0599159822,
-0.0382221565,
-0.0406235084,
-0.0259457026,
-0.002957508,
0.006899246,
0.0024443551,
0.0535969473,
-0.0456830673,
-0.0427595265,
0.0019375216,
0.0117471404,
-0.0329442695,
-0.0035093396,
-0.0504129976,
0.0011734624,
0.0716171339,
0.0178219881,
0.0187493265,
-0.0954400748,
-0.0039665261,
0.0068476466,
0.062782757,
0.0190303605,
0.0117651531,
-0.0068331207,
-0.0656022131,
-0.0274084285,
0.0141454628,
-0.0282684229,
0.0007241179,
0.0379012302,
0.0186531022,
0.0106484834,
-0.0148397842,
-0.017155502,
0.0482412241,
-0.0438053943,
-0.0309045408,
-0.0306050647,
0.0237245765,
0.056808982,
-0.0053496202,
-0.0146762524,
0.0113395257,
0.0143139176,
-0.0017533288,
-0.0049345796,
0.0380094163,
-0.0473424047,
-0.0353633724,
0.0711494908,
-0.0185224526,
-0.0250177719,
0.0668401271,
-0.0534337312,
-0.0626128912,
-0.010886346,
0.003823088,
0.0590116531,
-0.0558579378,
0.0436354503,
0.0126052797,
-0.0117642805,
-0.0350942239,
0.0479575805,
0.0078461142,
-0.0022690061,
-0.002000001,
0.0212466568,
0.0120037813,
-0.0308360532,
-0.0431639142,
-0.0146404374,
-0.0244059395,
0.0509496443,
0.0063015288,
0.0353514217,
-0.0466806665,
0.0173009932,
-0.1252485663,
0.0546705686,
-0.0403996632,
0.0413646922,
0.0513578057,
0.0125779454,
-0.0290731248,
-0.0342880711,
-0.0601041764,
-0.0098907677,
-0.0162046161,
-0.0077864295,
0.0187629648,
-0.0177706145,
0.0017915004,
-0.050706774,
-0.001339672,
-0.0225539673,
0.0012393529,
-0.0057019284,
-0.0315870978,
-0.0360565409,
-0.0027724386,
-0.0226409975,
0.0279619303,
-0.0079362281,
-0.0446392111,
-0.0109086474,
-0.0194420032,
0.0285879187,
0.0603571795,
0.0270626154,
-0.0006193317,
-0.0064716642,
0.0198993012,
-0.0679926053,
0.0210942049,
-0.0224175882,
-0.0555903278,
-0.0195201021,
0.0005590333,
0.0085833892,
0.0920424461,
0.0005800431,
0.0107509764,
-0.0628369972,
-0.0175088625,
-0.0065304721,
-0.0070311823,
-0.0300647467,
0.0375118814,
-0.0538294576,
0.0025957841,
-0.0609467216,
-0.0671678558,
0.0494449064,
-0.024468882,
-0.0200867094,
-0.0675959215,
-0.007568378,
-0.0106729334,
0.0317162164,
0.0010326162,
0.0251728948,
-0.00622909,
-0.0359516628,
-0.0575716384,
0.0425688066,
0.0009488699,
-0.0251394436,
0.0650609136,
-0.0202837754,
0.0389378481,
-0.0260072537,
-0.0427917093,
-0.0407546461,
-0.0216679107,
-0.0112443874,
-0.0029929294,
0.0093044322,
-0.0406810381,
-0.0297471099,
0.0358509943,
-0.0058166273,
0.0438013002,
-0.0236389413,
0.018254526,
-0.0344800092,
0.0133148665,
0.0825478882,
-0.0022554314,
-0.0226703528,
-0.0272012912,
0.0098748505,
0.0466285907,
0.0456709787,
0.0083269151,
-0.0292574037,
-0.0074892961,
0.0352752581,
-0.0405032001,
-0.0285869166,
0.0100674322,
0.0681683868,
-0.045618955,
0.0325335488,
0.1317064315,
0.0077827154,
-0.0366314612,
-0.024428321,
-0.0000483336,
0.0168492645,
0.0108648865,
0.0136448592,
-0.1104488373,
-0.04496089,
0.0108801788,
0.0025080533,
0.0510165095,
0.0225346833,
0.0298898071,
-0.1270643771,
0.0193616897,
0.0316441581,
-0.057576295,
-0.0051441179,
-0.0247184243,
0.0290071145,
-0.0481399819,
0.0444577262,
0.011876327,
-0.0079904804,
0.0035675233,
0.0306197368,
-0.0231752358,
-0.0446204282,
0.0348041169,
-0.0506462008,
0.0259271692,
0.050731305,
0.0229897518,
0.012267191,
-0.0299660172,
0.0698641464,
0.0434483811,
-0.0215681605,
0.0139593836,
0.0152146798,
-0.0361132771,
-0.0167267993,
-0.0085367681,
0.0547954366,
-0.0507899597,
0.0132397413,
0.0253922455,
0.0685792193,
-0.0073915697,
0.0289937295,
0.0042965459,
0.0074102688,
-0.0040809917,
0.0857662782,
0.0057013864,
-0.0567161702,
-0.0522029586,
-0.0156722665,
0.0075870398,
-0.0515652038,
-0.019324623,
0.0277398787,
-0.0280229039,
-0.0238629039,
-0.0678981692,
-0.0426553674,
0.0322694741,
0.033394888,
0.0015358364,
-0.0018733335,
-0.0026557557,
-0.0039791735,
-0.0478786975,
0.0593956262,
-0.0130181257,
0.0286311246,
-0.1001517326,
-0.0142680481,
0.0097298911,
-0.0162562411,
-0.0047463495,
0.0329047479,
-0.0869915187,
-0.0716328099,
-0.0098391827,
0.0360088758,
0.0164290126,
0.0559628196,
-0.0266276188,
0.0255032238,
-0.0000146416,
0.0104937023,
-0.0398874059,
0.025294913,
0.0050437464,
-0.0077568525,
-0.0267888326,
0.0243066959,
-0.0204056632,
-0.0031308208,
-0.0010809113,
0.0490564182,
-0.0162536092,
-0.0141939642,
0.0276012961,
0.0060762144,
0.0275975931,
-0.026996633,
-0.0020521292,
-0.0255123042,
0.0174123272,
0.0088596931,
-0.014582294,
-0.037434347,
-0.0474718884,
0.0513626449,
0.0191309396,
0.0290065724,
-0.013128981,
-0.0016299582,
0.0064225728,
-0.0535629541,
-0.0010324223,
-0.0380860753,
0.0369643308,
0.0186285432,
0.0269496311,
-0.0248634294,
-0.0006381915,
0.0201644041,
0.0362061188,
-0.031553667,
0.0729624331,
0.0062736492,
0.045307558,
0.0106528038,
0.0394036099,
-0.0356469043,
-0.0441158563,
-0.0387364253,
-0.0111776376,
0.0850860178,
-0.0171525963,
0.0568623021,
-0.0211923793,
-0.020506395,
-0.0570249334,
0.0519796908,
-0.0233689435,
0.0003003295,
-0.0079592792,
0.0163469817,
-0.0377736986,
-0.0303764734,
0.0790270045,
0.003496855,
0.0336461291,
0.0271855351,
-0.0054133493,
-0.0413477048,
-0.0288991015,
0.0477826484,
0.0043266076,
-0.0097968364,
-0.0315009765,
-0.0217119996,
-0.0783310086,
-0.0298427269,
0.0153167639,
-0.0416298807,
-0.0061964644,
0.0510531515,
0.0698257685,
-0.029658759,
-0.0074480409,
-0.0235073473,
-0.0191644728,
-0.0120840734,
-0.0027489492,
-0.0236683153,
-6.261362495e-33,
-0.0229962077,
0.0228869282,
0.0442332923,
0.0048091016,
-0.0251876507,
0.0021068403,
0.0045645596,
-0.002762401,
-0.0406055823,
-0.0320455953,
0.0094049117,
-0.0044397074,
0.0256952047,
0.0540417545,
-0.0052762176,
0.0097466344,
0.0259409305,
-0.0165233109,
-0.0066800541,
0.0175582413,
0.0508265607,
0.0369596072,
0.0654357448,
-0.0331913494,
-0.0151943332,
0.013743869,
0.0004135603,
0.0101333996,
-0.0148703186,
0.0840036571,
-0.0191328656,
0.0227004569,
0.0216819681,
-0.0161659718,
-0.0361717194,
0.028792413,
-0.077843599,
-0.0186812598,
0.0445672497,
0.0527783595,
-0.0206839051,
-0.0106943641,
0.0211120192,
-0.0353227854,
-0.0086225793,
-0.0286479834,
0.0311527811,
0.0052841706,
-0.0098377466,
0.0119992616,
-0.0615597107,
0.0167086888,
-0.007659452,
-0.0137986643,
0.008700097,
0.0418505706,
-0.019593481,
0.0077385125,
-0.0406435728,
0.0083096214,
0.0023172095,
0.0578674525,
0.0951767713,
0.0577068701,
0.0273794886,
0.0396710038,
0.0180904027,
-0.0402267613,
-0.0021955448,
0.008875547,
0.037119478,
0.0480921008,
-0.0043745814,
0.0259186625,
0.0212876126,
0.008751872,
-0.0414996147,
0.0382580683,
0.0313178748,
0.0290583782,
0.0098867854,
0.0332929716,
-0.0382658243,
0.0049417852,
-0.0088985572,
0.0228893347,
-0.035209503,
-0.0568477809,
0.0575885363,
-0.0101508945,
0.0162076056,
0.0080789225,
0.0746200308,
-0.0230352618,
0.0141608277,
0.0129182842,
-0.0136172343,
0.0189177692,
-0.022875471,
0.0470987037,
-0.0524159782,
-0.0474562235,
-0.0172484554,
0.0124322427,
0.0055748103,
0.002454268,
0.0298205465,
0.026322199,
-0.048198808,
0.0110753737,
-0.0474718548,
-0.0198405758,
-0.0029521065,
0.0331554897,
0.0735683665,
-0.0052235359,
0.0028816278,
0.0523372479,
-0.0064712218,
-0.013652279,
-0.0354495645,
-0.0752733648,
-0.0360512473,
-0.0082416246,
-0.0096319579,
0.0142818345,
-0.0483153164,
0.0077760201,
0.0142016467,
-0.0637094602,
-0.0041315886,
0.0202422477,
2.698e-7,
0.0648195222,
-0.0073354738,
0.0541388802,
0.0261671524,
-0.0184861477,
0.0092134178,
-0.0261791237,
0.0273647904,
0.0057490007,
0.046049282,
0.0315932818,
0.0184988026,
0.0646598414,
-0.0052292966,
-0.0754100457,
0.004860071,
-0.0658924058,
0.008409516,
-0.05273268,
0.0447716676,
0.0281184632,
0.1279717833,
-0.0164751802,
0.0090260105,
0.0251386762,
-0.036386691,
0.0607151054,
-0.0411140062,
-0.0324417725,
0.0344153754,
-0.0065553463,
0.0238143615,
-0.0235754307,
-0.0074281166,
-0.016078027,
0.0200456828,
0.0142484382,
0.1075438038,
-0.0093208114,
-0.0170895588,
-0.0165715367,
0.0070707607,
-0.0031635086,
-0.075271517,
0.0628810897,
-0.0105121648,
-0.003546237,
-0.0023499448,
-0.044449769,
-0.0253542811,
-0.0193444975,
-0.0276708808,
-0.0156048192,
0.0371491574,
0.0451296791,
-0.0034056329,
-0.0554639362,
-0.0621536635,
-0.0320201702,
0.03012833,
-0.0531337745,
-0.0184952077,
-0.029374199,
0.0169739053,
0.0391650051,
-0.0163909364,
-0.0128481081,
2.514381268e-34,
0.0051629245,
-0.0025401248,
0.0341256373,
0.0464380644,
0.006321826,
-0.0148808975,
-0.0212445036,
0.0498103574,
0.0080434745,
-0.0540217571,
-0.0250541531
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12787v1 | Generating Educational Materials with Different Levels of Readability using LLMs | 2024-06-18T16:55:10 | 2024-06-18T16:55:10 | Chieh-Yang Huang, Jing Wei, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This study introduces the leveled-text generation task, aiming to rewrite
educational materials to specific readability levels while preserving meaning.
We assess the capability of GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2 70B, and Mixtral 8x7B, to generate
content at various readability levels through zero-shot and few-shot prompting.
Evaluating 100 processed educational materials reveals that few-shot prompting
significantly improves performance in readability manipulation and information
preservation. LLaMA-2 70B performs better in achieving the desired difficulty
range, while GPT-3.5 maintains original meaning. However, manual inspection
highlights concerns such as misinformation introduction and inconsistent edit
distribution. These findings emphasize the need for further research to ensure
the quality of generated educational content. | [
0.0085879928,
-0.0655128807,
-0.0153440665,
0.0195491537,
-0.0078620119,
-0.0108557045,
0.0170608833,
0.0373538844,
-0.0230962764,
-0.0524516366,
-0.0249539819,
0.0224223305,
0.0100470688,
-0.0067645637,
0.0025376067,
-0.0752431825,
0.0291389804,
-0.0081119863,
-0.0016255657,
0.0181784648,
-0.0049760421,
-0.0071429978,
-0.0276460629,
-0.027161561,
0.0159670617,
-0.0447884277,
-0.0277910568,
0.0381232239,
0.0354915299,
-0.0279183481,
-0.0146692479,
0.042081587,
0.0105449464,
0.0140340887,
0.0000022653,
-0.0637788698,
-0.0250864346,
-0.0061453017,
-0.0368852802,
0.0662495717,
0.0797040537,
0.0063866987,
-0.0497843623,
-0.00836467,
0.0081904801,
0.0264377091,
0.0076611228,
0.0367474034,
0.0545990504,
0.0449560843,
0.0044491473,
-0.0226754826,
0.0313658752,
0.0164384712,
0.0758393034,
0.0248815697,
-0.0457023606,
0.0352950655,
0.0660084337,
0.0524822436,
0.0075929868,
0.0302640498,
-0.002442749,
-0.0479071103,
0.0122034838,
0.0287080854,
0.0304861162,
-0.0112527702,
-0.0193154775,
0.0436723977,
0.031117525,
0.0055437209,
-0.0118640093,
-0.0527796894,
-0.0100441249,
0.008313898,
-0.0723633543,
0.0244723223,
-0.030924093,
0.021801766,
0.0072508599,
-0.0166992992,
-0.0071013342,
-0.0241475198,
0.0522751585,
-0.0076171686,
0.0171183217,
-0.0501283966,
-0.0123221437,
0.0322369523,
0.0656195879,
-0.0434974208,
0.0104865935,
0.0558665991,
0.0357517824,
0.0211657304,
-0.0696856752,
-0.0620848536,
0.0430405773,
-0.0407669842,
0.0280277915,
0.0549131297,
0.0030413151,
0.0456892587,
-0.0339732058,
0.0444689915,
0.0220038127,
0.0391981378,
-0.021802498,
0.0920433402,
0.0115379561,
-0.0035628958,
-0.0180266947,
0.04959004,
-0.0469950773,
-0.000714346,
-0.0753496066,
0.0098176328,
0.0504672043,
0.0439547114,
0.0029432117,
-0.0326742306,
-0.0626175851,
-0.0127529539,
-0.0144642359,
0.0123167373,
-0.0100660324,
0.0215511192,
0.0085557355,
-0.02476147,
0.0173502397,
0.0374122746,
0.0125131868,
0.0052640298,
-0.0046739103,
0.0869047865,
-0.0518614091,
-0.0047358661,
-0.1056208313,
-0.0299244802,
0.0322125107,
-0.0217351392,
-0.0030424923,
-0.0467567444,
0.0044797435,
-0.0001468211,
0.00268957,
-0.0059048198,
0.0189006422,
0.0369020961,
-0.0024716023,
0.022435002,
-0.0288429484,
-0.0058177589,
0.0760225132,
0.0545377135,
-0.0314944498,
0.0285909716,
0.0492504425,
0.0620303415,
0.0495986827,
-0.0165916998,
0.010429495,
0.0347542129,
-0.0144667057,
-0.0005082279,
0.0214730501,
-0.0492730476,
-0.0207489301,
0.0320570059,
0.0292559639,
0.0335902125,
-0.0248371344,
0.0393207557,
0.0710168481,
0.0199303124,
0.0370270126,
0.0023404155,
0.044420518,
0.0302213561,
0.0425506756,
0.0803785026,
-0.0267089643,
0.0359314419,
-0.0137694674,
0.0367240049,
0.0446452424,
0.0188789573,
0.0214350503,
-0.0659791455,
-0.0222292785,
0.006111755,
-0.0267787948,
-0.0773540959,
0.0027896399,
0.011097,
-0.0801183581,
0.0000941236,
0.0042715389,
-0.0972897932,
0.038644284,
-0.0265751667,
0.0674474537,
0.1092712656,
0.063237071,
-0.0307689831,
-0.0186573863,
0.0006781945,
0.0069811945,
0.0642615706,
-0.0011152274,
-0.0007893335,
0.0143186813,
-0.0849252418,
-0.0280528888,
-0.0502704419,
-0.004384574,
0.0121108592,
0.0018033292,
0.0344801247,
0.0172789656,
-0.0461997762,
-0.0369124599,
0.0537393391,
-0.0361956768,
-0.0841413438,
-0.0319252387,
0.0047621485,
-0.0057008113,
0.0327576138,
-0.0178449862,
-0.0125660487,
0.0165363234,
-0.0023608373,
0.0100723421,
-0.0513010621,
-0.0253646821,
-0.0256168023,
0.0102821663,
-0.0554824509,
0.012243906,
-0.056570705,
-0.0040620952,
-0.0189927723,
-0.0202516466,
-0.0194536224,
0.0277100131,
-0.0109687895,
0.0270871166,
0.0145103689,
-0.0312565602,
-0.0376519486,
0.0448840745,
-0.0080750156,
-0.013953967,
0.0556246638,
-0.0074176011,
0.001545355,
-0.0078162104,
0.0089808954,
0.0081336377,
0.0116759669,
-0.0311576072,
-0.0318929814,
0.0610278621,
-0.0509584174,
-0.0559522547,
-0.0145134879,
-0.0002052805,
0.0056872694,
0.0163288228,
0.0279082824,
-0.0272940639,
-0.0323992483,
0.0081432676,
-0.0255546644,
0.0302537736,
-0.0174509268,
-0.0146445194,
0.0509883761,
0.0116126128,
0.0129204011,
-0.0302141923,
-0.0142867463,
0.010416178,
-0.0007649807,
0.0970552266,
-0.0340546258,
-0.0770415217,
0.0804914534,
-0.0143994531,
-0.0649304986,
0.0238650627,
-0.0085047493,
0.0145205911,
0.018579375,
0.085005559,
0.052871272,
0.0069138566,
0.0460147634,
0.0460287854,
-0.0408750884,
-0.0389589258,
0.0063673737,
0.0031496768,
-0.0167728066,
0.0300197285,
-0.0855884328,
0.0113394503,
0.0416359305,
0.0410949439,
0.0169099625,
-0.0337076075,
0.0204527117,
-0.0323833153,
-0.0256587863,
0.0048129633,
-0.0266728979,
-0.0210971218,
0.0312675759,
-0.0027185697,
-0.0736477375,
0.0441876613,
-0.059714403,
0.00291673,
-0.015232252,
0.0416983999,
-0.0248985738,
-0.0009130427,
-0.0454148613,
0.0152632138,
-0.0004341692,
-0.0295929592,
-0.0615473017,
0.0192446727,
0.0556391254,
-0.0216436014,
0.0174250007,
-0.0728747025,
-0.0376530066,
-0.0516605042,
0.0093077682,
-0.0207847711,
0.0343285352,
0.0565829985,
-0.0418713614,
0.0224039834,
-0.0058636642,
-0.016831981,
-0.0235311575,
0.0573821552,
0.0300923344,
-0.0070450096,
-0.0218318794,
-0.0159967616,
0.0259841345,
-0.0155178858,
-0.019257592,
-0.0007095998,
-0.0497098863,
0.021238558,
0.0314074531,
-0.033076115,
-0.0288451165,
0.038746763,
0.00905417,
0.0231359843,
-0.0458310619,
-0.0340376608,
0.0016463092,
0.0560310036,
-0.0802509859,
0.0133542288,
0.0614952035,
0.0317290649,
-0.0300498176,
-0.027165154,
-0.0569770448,
-0.0264246669,
-0.0222467799,
0.0252648052,
-0.0958353579,
0.0124856113,
0.0195270553,
0.084059082,
-0.022523338,
-0.0018996496,
-0.0071141808,
-0.0539509431,
0.0719646439,
0.0151316505,
0.0223835316,
-0.0012146072,
-0.0126476977,
-0.0121852858,
0.0716082007,
0.0241348147,
0.0047967699,
-0.022181483,
0.0071047684,
0.0082005858,
-0.0108498372,
-0.0319484137,
-0.060589388,
0.0682808384,
0.0585886799,
0.0317017436,
0.0097634066,
-0.0187381078,
-0.0529885255,
0.0297255125,
0.0223840829,
0.0106753893,
-0.0502656773,
0.0249421839,
0.0005302741,
0.0164708141,
-0.0431905985,
0.0416955277,
0.0703614205,
-0.0367022641,
0.0091760717,
0.0263619777,
-0.0102320109,
-0.0367242731,
-0.0399843231,
0.0191527233,
0.0103217494,
0.0448794328,
0.0488059632,
-0.0074083088,
-0.0045489725,
-0.0569723584,
0.0290449243,
-0.0653444976,
0.0044835312,
-0.0073532709,
-0.0837822407,
0.0121390466,
-0.0786724016,
-0.0358852744,
0.0187514797,
-0.0085003758,
0.0364577398,
0.010890482,
-0.0100476248,
-0.0130507154,
-0.0393805429,
-0.0598391593,
-0.0106284497,
-0.0224421956,
-0.1072975844,
-0.0524505079,
-0.0232782308,
-0.0560474209,
-0.0036482133,
0.0114147076,
-0.0059207701,
-0.0562877581,
0.0117704058,
0.0561140254,
0.0242590755,
-0.0219561793,
0.0453198478,
-0.0204534158,
0.0679966658,
0.0176039264,
0.0232430305,
0.0754940063,
-0.0116911596,
0.0379305258,
-0.0003753745,
-0.0122035816,
-0.0337436795,
0.002265173,
0.015755685,
-0.0013388067,
0.0175897684,
-0.0448374748,
-0.0208817367,
0.0538115352,
-0.013933057,
-0.0510509424,
-0.0154051948,
-0.0522154756,
0.0412286855,
-0.0733998492,
0.0229059905,
-0.0231321212,
0.0041399673,
0.0144446762,
-0.0221689716,
0.0003209174,
0.021323679,
-0.0565148965,
0.0256463643,
-0.0132111879,
0.0586463213,
-0.0717777014,
0.0046044667,
0.0237743072,
0.0041145282,
-0.0394610763,
0.0243256446,
-0.039358668,
0.0618907996,
0.0130553003,
0.0895447508,
0.0146059496,
0.0084500154,
0.0143995965,
0.0419255234,
0.0138620799,
0.0124607543,
-0.0478955023,
0.0413372591,
0.0054077148,
0.0362357534,
0.0435925648,
-0.0251655784,
0.0123230126,
-0.0023096038,
0.0385124795,
0.0355216041,
-0.0258617196,
-0.0131411031,
-0.0119383093,
0.029450126,
-0.0161066968,
0.0788149834,
-0.0400636308,
-0.0034214868,
-0.0075607803,
0.0041464954,
-0.0359933525,
-0.0076384903,
0.0315149836,
0.0042520356,
-0.0010474089,
-0.0354534723,
-0.064632751,
-0.0019585069,
0.0152171124,
0.0391753279,
-0.0223815106,
-0.0321452394,
0.0094527239,
0.0222447366,
-0.0215391666,
-0.0079838131,
-0.0058671208,
0.0109141562,
-0.0163954683,
-0.0217849165,
0.0327138193,
-6.175846016e-33,
-0.0628947914,
-0.0449514501,
0.0285033267,
0.0400424935,
-0.0222996566,
0.00745665,
-0.0549126342,
0.0232773386,
0.0420067832,
0.012536359,
-0.0128018977,
-0.0577002689,
0.0219152477,
-0.0055296985,
-0.0166929159,
0.0222368836,
0.0560860634,
-0.0089877062,
-0.0578503162,
0.0257515758,
0.0272740442,
-0.0073169405,
0.063353464,
-0.0411748551,
0.0425207727,
-0.0322279967,
-0.0022517892,
-0.0471938439,
-0.0114054177,
0.0266334135,
-0.0138590699,
0.0235921685,
0.0222942978,
-0.0093930177,
-0.0167029332,
0.0324153565,
-0.0369542204,
-0.0441472903,
0.02126332,
0.0018089901,
-0.0292226803,
-0.0911191404,
0.0506026261,
-0.0290723816,
-0.0295651238,
-0.0202575084,
0.0325017609,
0.0009436929,
0.0037425619,
-0.0251597259,
-0.0832085013,
0.0147852618,
-0.0000265408,
-0.0091058519,
-0.0257577021,
-0.0058083362,
0.0166136622,
-0.0178716276,
-0.0386464708,
0.0294552837,
0.0620246083,
0.0363335386,
0.0587550476,
-0.0237182882,
-0.0293195322,
0.0271249451,
0.0015933793,
0.0284893978,
-0.043490082,
0.0092780376,
0.0113727562,
-0.0200124886,
0.0312699787,
0.0649468154,
0.0243162792,
0.0036256518,
-0.0345835835,
0.08624731,
-0.0056177527,
0.0092190607,
-0.0090943882,
0.0096176816,
-0.0268400293,
-0.0104094539,
-0.0129671674,
0.0301374979,
-0.0131946411,
-0.0635767058,
0.0201688185,
-0.0221499149,
-0.0199013948,
-0.0558651909,
-0.0083574736,
0.0506614633,
0.0125194592,
-0.0329695828,
-0.0149810947,
0.0514247194,
-0.0370545238,
-0.0391849317,
-0.0150059517,
0.012331713,
0.0490707755,
-0.0123846317,
0.0216023121,
0.0266112741,
-0.0108399382,
0.0141742248,
-0.0490858518,
0.0248222519,
-0.0076705241,
0.0222167168,
0.0339470468,
-0.0269534606,
-0.0042335736,
-0.0533404276,
-0.0031291801,
-0.0226027947,
0.0013253972,
-0.0023393782,
-0.0238754768,
-0.0280133765,
-0.0041192062,
0.0142710106,
-0.0561546199,
0.0273686405,
-0.0146729024,
0.0412848853,
0.0050038388,
-0.0397921428,
-0.0158482864,
0.0040672123,
2.879e-7,
0.0406248122,
0.0592348836,
0.0443013906,
0.0011037232,
-0.0059504341,
-0.0104310736,
-0.0050980547,
-0.0024425492,
0.0137320301,
0.0011476963,
0.0391096883,
-0.0121488906,
0.0097219264,
0.0418191329,
-0.0564548261,
-0.0080566835,
0.0245530978,
0.0133432047,
-0.0482209213,
0.0120415455,
0.1183928698,
-0.0461122133,
-0.0238718987,
-0.0343046002,
0.0258755945,
-0.0135731511,
0.0396788828,
-0.0262422487,
0.0185607634,
0.0024131713,
0.0514615513,
-0.0107913166,
-0.0053807553,
-0.0117207402,
-0.0342544541,
-0.0468256846,
0.0085973572,
0.0797734484,
0.015522657,
0.0080688894,
0.0694111511,
-0.0092553953,
-0.0073809782,
-0.0320885144,
0.0254705325,
0.0372291617,
0.0269483104,
0.0725765452,
-0.0560658574,
-0.0179714486,
-0.016788533,
-0.0646963716,
-0.0094122076,
0.0135197621,
-0.0045735715,
0.0067144008,
-0.0238289014,
-0.0092098108,
-0.0077916267,
-0.0443277098,
0.0017714638,
-0.0628697649,
-0.0667768642,
-0.0112579856,
-0.0127959065,
-0.0636027455,
-0.0099148937,
2.643684958e-34,
-0.0071113706,
-0.0462260284,
0.0412393771,
-0.0146663273,
-0.0123610664,
0.0366684943,
0.0016033248,
0.0077375001,
0.0046935896,
-0.0491930284,
-0.0161385126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12784v1 | UBENCH: Benchmarking Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Multiple Choice Questions | 2024-06-18T16:50:38 | 2024-06-18T16:50:38 | Xunzhi Wang, Zhuowei Zhang, Qiongyu Li, Gaonan Chen, Mengting Hu, Zhiyu li, Bitong Luo, Hang Gao, Zhixin Han, Haotian Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has shown promising
practical results. However, their low interpretability often leads to errors in
unforeseen circumstances, limiting their utility. Many works have focused on
creating comprehensive evaluation systems, but previous benchmarks have
primarily assessed problem-solving abilities while neglecting the response's
uncertainty, which may result in unreliability. Recent methods for measuring
LLM reliability are resource-intensive and unable to test black-box models. To
address this, we propose UBENCH, a comprehensive benchmark for evaluating LLM
reliability. UBENCH includes 3,978 multiple-choice questions covering
knowledge, language, understanding, and reasoning abilities. Experimental
results show that UBENCH has achieved state-of-the-art performance, while its
single-sampling method significantly saves computational resources compared to
baseline methods that require multiple samplings. Additionally, based on
UBENCH, we evaluate the reliability of 15 popular LLMs, finding GLM4 to be the
most outstanding, closely followed by GPT-4. We also explore the impact of
Chain-of-Thought prompts, role-playing prompts, option order, and temperature
on LLM reliability, analyzing the varying effects on different LLMs. | [
0.0012211774,
0.0534151196,
-0.0207398646,
0.0372207202,
-0.0674460456,
0.0075624017,
0.0050394274,
-0.009747684,
0.0297665726,
-0.0227447767,
-0.001619463,
-0.067425482,
0.0042514233,
0.0046417792,
0.0242849067,
-0.027745096,
0.0428686067,
-0.0814982876,
0.007317231,
-0.0130890133,
-0.0486173928,
-0.0144269634,
-0.0223342199,
0.0379596017,
0.0406628698,
-0.036983341,
-0.0162824672,
-0.0120005403,
0.0194880888,
-0.0414256938,
-0.0168092754,
0.0746153668,
-0.0034559423,
0.0073387488,
0.0000023908,
-0.0678025186,
0.0106707141,
-0.0244117696,
-0.0477873944,
0.0376451015,
0.0101434886,
0.0571696796,
0.013778246,
0.0364905298,
-0.0172397457,
-0.0119509948,
0.0261087641,
-0.0113097113,
0.0249577053,
0.0195927974,
0.0147876563,
0.0223494768,
0.0152331647,
-0.0105291195,
0.0266509913,
-0.059456978,
0.0188777819,
0.0429328568,
0.0287322477,
0.0202125441,
-0.0472049899,
0.0437560938,
0.0222502202,
0.0126068676,
-0.0524386466,
0.0039916011,
-0.0340823792,
-0.0267765597,
0.008120466,
0.0534116253,
0.0139562031,
0.0018723544,
-0.0542245284,
-0.0053224149,
0.0274813641,
0.0660876408,
-0.0384044796,
0.0288124196,
0.0110406391,
-0.0299669281,
0.0021321881,
-0.006292596,
0.0291074868,
-0.0068885498,
0.0087839346,
0.1157177687,
0.0160777122,
-0.0170315783,
0.0344243236,
0.0043197232,
-0.0435417332,
-0.0599058382,
-0.0180982314,
0.0102709401,
-0.0652840361,
0.0446931832,
-0.0239857547,
0.0266163629,
0.0315413624,
0.0065942686,
0.0549039394,
0.0397791155,
0.0051327683,
0.0458064266,
0.0077951169,
0.0788002461,
0.0186334234,
0.0074135237,
-0.0378102995,
0.0059277043,
-0.0361576788,
-0.0238992292,
-0.0028300625,
0.0024461958,
-0.0199552756,
-0.0084084338,
-0.0663235337,
-0.0004789243,
-0.014627615,
0.0183628872,
-0.0231268816,
-0.0047592535,
0.0279078949,
-0.0065849237,
-0.0562926903,
0.0349385254,
-0.0311227236,
0.0132995313,
0.0246441234,
-0.0571826287,
0.0108581306,
-0.0101070814,
-0.0065522678,
-0.0273562558,
0.0198616944,
0.0524451956,
-0.0014325716,
-0.0313425735,
-0.0099203149,
-0.0187286139,
-0.0434655063,
-0.0890127495,
-0.0126286726,
-0.088098757,
0.0012472508,
0.0319756605,
-0.0048158183,
-0.0258898307,
0.0138164191,
0.0229043067,
-0.0071348334,
0.0458160527,
0.0294504203,
0.0297204461,
0.0200070292,
0.0242172573,
-0.0231933575,
0.0559369251,
0.0252795387,
-0.0020695443,
0.0369212329,
-0.0337455682,
0.0049627037,
0.0406586789,
-0.0186592806,
-0.0081506073,
-0.0102103157,
0.0226176251,
0.0143344142,
0.0409967564,
-0.0230677985,
0.0656360239,
-0.0162385833,
-0.0194280893,
0.0956623852,
0.055757083,
-0.0147181107,
-0.0326668061,
0.0352250114,
0.0171219669,
0.0494115204,
-0.009635034,
-0.0535427928,
0.0169147383,
-0.0259811264,
0.0162250139,
-0.0087088523,
0.0446613133,
-0.0038281616,
-0.0565055609,
-0.0408904813,
0.0076872976,
0.0062373825,
0.0738776922,
0.0432424992,
-0.064075239,
-0.0486172065,
0.0077482644,
-0.0100222044,
-0.0289295278,
-0.0058739986,
-0.050099276,
0.050026603,
0.066160664,
0.0376101919,
0.0015505741,
-0.0749349967,
-0.004646291,
0.0041863085,
0.0200691111,
0.0481203683,
0.00807402,
0.0424216874,
-0.0361536369,
-0.0071855853,
0.0007874044,
0.0073675453,
0.0310001727,
0.0205455944,
0.0010814761,
-0.0165328402,
-0.0329494812,
0.0078849439,
-0.0015044549,
-0.0491764583,
-0.041445531,
-0.0398481488,
-0.0245364327,
0.0301836301,
-0.0125765773,
-0.0062263687,
0.0175957922,
0.0146359941,
0.0003491809,
-0.0189473778,
0.0109483125,
-0.0737790093,
-0.0088061355,
0.0487988219,
-0.0177486949,
-0.0604283586,
0.0512007959,
-0.0021794802,
-0.0422331877,
0.0284394044,
-0.0238459948,
-0.0081139151,
-0.0295272358,
0.031817738,
-0.0467332825,
0.0078248344,
-0.0521493703,
0.0760104358,
-0.0145530598,
0.0549884252,
0.0122053493,
0.0243682452,
0.0208167452,
-0.0450482368,
-0.0507589243,
-0.0085908985,
-0.0300694592,
0.0050352113,
0.0037780521,
0.0147835622,
-0.081478484,
-0.0225112177,
-0.0693766922,
0.0142310318,
-0.0040900041,
0.0097856494,
0.0033089544,
-0.0302595999,
-0.0377045162,
0.0298413299,
-0.0330674797,
-0.0018587683,
0.0164097305,
0.0199768785,
-0.0034642441,
-0.0138516054,
-0.0101949172,
-0.0184392557,
-0.0172280259,
-0.0338590816,
0.0435692631,
-0.0002324735,
0.0494686961,
-0.0195469428,
0.04174795,
-0.0421229042,
-0.0140607283,
-0.0028015431,
-0.0093742665,
0.0423655026,
-0.0046465993,
0.058051981,
0.0533103533,
0.0047764992,
-0.01355772,
0.0666116327,
-0.061776448,
-0.0453420207,
0.0186163429,
-0.0071856151,
-0.0382863283,
-0.0374899432,
-0.0875722095,
-0.0335690975,
0.065366745,
0.0461204275,
-0.0056175292,
-0.0252565667,
0.0422315784,
-0.0414009616,
-0.0403386094,
-0.0654043406,
-0.0084461952,
-0.0142558198,
0.0791325495,
-0.0190885495,
-0.0407329462,
0.0704199672,
-0.0340538286,
0.0059919925,
-0.0221366435,
0.0043119243,
0.0102080712,
0.068191193,
-0.0000723556,
-0.0061870189,
-0.0010735965,
-0.0030111873,
-0.0714444295,
-0.0388627574,
0.0328896269,
-0.0572608784,
0.0621680245,
-0.0788558051,
-0.0297427345,
0.0226909891,
-0.0186612606,
-0.0362966694,
-0.0042547686,
-0.0320097804,
0.0000191648,
0.0299663581,
-0.0240932852,
-0.0067217681,
0.0057066595,
0.0451077037,
-0.0155668985,
-0.0335353091,
-0.0166004766,
-0.0037571706,
0.0362500101,
0.0513397641,
0.0340670161,
0.0679810941,
-0.0345079377,
0.0448131822,
0.0472148173,
0.0316314623,
0.0259982087,
-0.0171711408,
0.0191657525,
0.0220744908,
-0.0003762295,
-0.018619461,
0.0552591234,
0.0856906399,
-0.0494684651,
-0.0244618058,
0.1306557655,
0.0431709588,
0.0080645522,
-0.0011681181,
-0.0553791113,
0.0425640717,
0.0197768454,
0.0308697019,
-0.0585016981,
-0.0379453562,
0.0178757198,
0.0195621327,
-0.0134502696,
-0.0472866073,
0.0197897535,
-0.1155052781,
0.0393670015,
-0.0190461706,
-0.04823827,
0.0042547323,
-0.0491294339,
-0.0002705409,
0.0088981884,
0.0365345739,
0.0329558402,
0.0105419848,
0.0074929581,
0.0052080681,
-0.0531517752,
-0.0415242463,
0.0986254662,
-0.0251873694,
0.0636426881,
0.0339691825,
0.0184043199,
-0.0313098542,
-0.0223400407,
0.021944847,
-0.0225832611,
-0.0313257053,
0.0027815634,
0.020976102,
0.0304510389,
0.0139043499,
-0.0492081083,
0.01420567,
-0.0097481543,
-0.0257551465,
0.0492589213,
0.0887274519,
-0.0053774673,
-0.0416667126,
-0.0059713456,
0.0055369972,
-0.0147260111,
0.0908414498,
0.018464433,
-0.0509433597,
-0.0183121581,
-0.0417654887,
0.0053837351,
-0.0395848565,
-0.0428910367,
0.0265637431,
0.0358480625,
0.0330639035,
-0.0312892124,
-0.036808867,
0.0585302524,
0.0111920461,
-0.0230877623,
0.009131467,
0.0112834964,
0.0198166501,
-0.0264290981,
0.0258450583,
-0.0148721347,
0.0244718529,
-0.050226137,
0.0170079377,
0.0128777176,
-0.0261872858,
-0.0305764917,
0.0514823459,
-0.0726118609,
-0.0522558615,
0.0204206184,
0.0612272881,
0.0331106819,
-0.0215342529,
0.0137789985,
-0.0407964587,
-0.006245119,
-0.0166984424,
0.0073189256,
0.0408045985,
-0.0299203508,
0.0272300243,
0.0041952962,
0.0169428922,
-0.0111971078,
0.0128724463,
-0.0100686317,
0.0513626598,
-0.0114499237,
-0.0553889424,
0.0161646623,
0.0278919637,
0.0070074582,
-0.0050179013,
-0.0011171333,
-0.0098292064,
0.0092417523,
-0.0491275713,
-0.0099662971,
-0.029037822,
-0.0284583475,
0.0575721115,
-0.0402756371,
0.0054028193,
-0.052387502,
-0.0186584331,
0.0248556584,
-0.0160300694,
0.0092257494,
0.0128922528,
0.0153686497,
0.0296423677,
-0.0027545411,
-0.0191205125,
0.0088970009,
-0.0286080223,
0.0642259344,
0.037590567,
0.079857111,
-0.0120091438,
-0.0280193631,
0.0218157303,
-0.0179079175,
-0.0600282177,
-0.0778760687,
0.0254193489,
0.0179635677,
0.0174701549,
0.0004032007,
0.0303902403,
-0.0399746671,
0.0130235776,
-0.0519909225,
0.0019092375,
0.0254357513,
-0.0225600321,
0.0552677289,
0.0459882282,
-0.006348433,
0.0077073835,
0.0504719242,
0.0216092151,
0.0087151583,
0.0179538578,
-0.0385410152,
-0.0388734117,
-0.0338119268,
-0.0403208248,
0.026436789,
-0.0382854231,
0.0204300564,
-0.1025240719,
-0.0841420963,
0.005291068,
0.0438828319,
0.0166469738,
-0.0249462388,
-0.0129570793,
0.064291209,
-0.011076916,
-0.0121653453,
-0.0185205173,
0.0099660773,
-0.0428813361,
-0.0025555168,
-0.0229006112,
-6.822717618e-33,
-0.0279926118,
-0.0536871031,
0.0381968953,
-0.0514155105,
0.0171114728,
-0.0058713229,
-0.0271546859,
0.0606141053,
-0.0408194773,
-0.0011529535,
0.0038937568,
-0.020349808,
0.0133058587,
0.0333529897,
0.0153197451,
-0.0317077674,
-0.0299647357,
0.0245609246,
-0.027161926,
-0.0214920696,
0.0346858092,
-0.0125828302,
0.0452256277,
-0.0439991243,
0.0359549932,
-0.0128657268,
0.0155168679,
0.0152264321,
-0.0543970615,
0.0443115458,
-0.0225322302,
0.0363199636,
0.0161310006,
-0.0390514247,
0.0089734923,
0.0000436958,
-0.0389923193,
-0.0569365844,
0.0454425327,
-0.0175731666,
-0.0362245105,
-0.0082040122,
0.0157932192,
0.028751988,
-0.0404557921,
-0.0402887091,
0.0074798702,
-0.0204436276,
-0.0154121965,
0.0202315804,
-0.0271505211,
0.0156019181,
-0.0235831998,
-0.0184423458,
-0.0468397327,
0.0918116793,
-0.0309417564,
0.0234516673,
-0.0425053276,
0.011797308,
0.0306791328,
0.0170036182,
0.0881710052,
0.0067862235,
0.0142370183,
0.0607858524,
0.0094042281,
-0.0070862048,
-0.0211711731,
-0.0303259175,
0.0471226461,
0.0510939881,
0.0725350007,
0.0681681708,
0.0166334044,
0.0059704995,
-0.0780445933,
0.0259007532,
0.0354528613,
0.0137728862,
0.0419591367,
0.0031098526,
-0.0381554589,
-0.0292013958,
-0.0850421041,
0.0263397023,
-0.0344313867,
-0.0352040902,
0.0704390332,
-0.0565835461,
0.0008445817,
-0.0322490931,
0.059602689,
-0.0117740594,
-0.0147269052,
0.0067998264,
-0.0017482385,
0.0619628914,
0.0049198093,
0.0721568689,
-0.0346368365,
0.0240217578,
-0.0101602497,
0.0010823861,
0.0169012714,
0.0080989292,
-0.0207189396,
0.0075395852,
-0.0519852526,
-0.0125508374,
-0.0313591808,
0.010108104,
-0.0010771406,
-0.0158802439,
0.0373536311,
-0.0067585553,
-0.0090101333,
0.0217073131,
0.00141735,
-0.0234612264,
-0.0175472945,
-0.0111241275,
-0.0356862172,
-0.0176520925,
0.0005210194,
-0.0082793338,
-0.0333885923,
-0.0037470381,
0.0118665481,
-0.0160033479,
0.0071343081,
0.0153266834,
2.988e-7,
0.0714966208,
0.0719408691,
-0.0204283223,
0.0502495468,
-0.0076400992,
0.0335367136,
-0.0246221051,
-0.0395129882,
0.066232495,
0.0009573197,
-0.005155812,
0.035694994,
0.0502990969,
0.0613103621,
-0.0489349402,
-0.0348579399,
-0.0065374137,
0.0115687335,
-0.0318114869,
0.0228132755,
0.0695343018,
0.0594108365,
0.0079009049,
-0.011202164,
-0.0147523303,
-0.0242355131,
0.0368282869,
-0.0812606066,
-0.0305498131,
0.0185540989,
0.0140639683,
-0.0111321416,
0.0362312645,
0.0475134365,
0.0095955366,
-0.0240865275,
-0.0043176431,
0.0498498566,
0.0216263309,
-0.0161426812,
-0.0080215428,
-0.0197110567,
0.0010841218,
-0.0927148461,
0.0692795068,
-0.0617620684,
-0.0438899808,
0.0045724814,
-0.0350495465,
-0.045179382,
0.0501907244,
-0.0254243203,
0.0031694551,
0.0005629409,
-0.0025926868,
-0.0060817036,
-0.0001682789,
-0.0245664679,
-0.0235029459,
0.0234321784,
-0.0209857058,
-0.069000721,
-0.0567642525,
-0.0382744372,
0.0225371849,
-0.079720743,
-0.0070647909,
2.885905442e-34,
0.0366115049,
0.0257345308,
0.0251790583,
0.0208218563,
0.0448782183,
-0.0148879867,
0.0048895138,
0.0279688016,
0.0004429128,
-0.0800610185,
-0.0114315841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12779v1 | Composited-Nested-Learning with Data Augmentation for Nested Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-18T16:46:18 | 2024-06-18T16:46:18 | Xingming Liao, Nankai Lin, Haowen Li, Lianglun Cheng, Zhuowei Wang, Chong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nested Named Entity Recognition (NNER) focuses on addressing overlapped
entity recognition. Compared to Flat Named Entity Recognition (FNER), annotated
resources are scarce in the corpus for NNER. Data augmentation is an effective
approach to address the insufficient annotated corpus. However, there is a
significant lack of exploration in data augmentation methods for NNER. Due to
the presence of nested entities in NNER, existing data augmentation methods
cannot be directly applied to NNER tasks. Therefore, in this work, we focus on
data augmentation for NNER and resort to more expressive structures,
Composited-Nested-Label Classification (CNLC) in which constituents are
combined by nested-word and nested-label, to model nested entities. The dataset
is augmented using the Composited-Nested-Learning (CNL). In addition, we
propose the Confidence Filtering Mechanism (CFM) for a more efficient selection
of generated data. Experimental results demonstrate that this approach results
in improvements in ACE2004 and ACE2005 and alleviates the impact of sample
imbalance. | [
0.0093411682,
0.0598434247,
-0.0106227985,
0.0370712988,
0.0082902592,
0.0697207302,
0.0247021765,
0.0076458887,
0.0317170024,
-0.0752481818,
-0.053150475,
-0.0151933692,
0.0334033705,
-0.0090057887,
0.0085198479,
-0.0293733049,
0.0387063846,
-0.0194591358,
0.0273300018,
0.0096751619,
-0.0395971313,
0.0085682515,
-0.0081615113,
0.010344659,
-0.0034090504,
0.0009604045,
0.0141806854,
0.0006084858,
0.0342198946,
-0.0736178458,
0.0494059101,
0.0388635099,
0.0039858734,
0.0641752481,
0.0000018466,
-0.0284194332,
-0.0176609233,
0.0262127779,
-0.0336840376,
0.0181520507,
0.0546140261,
0.0113610206,
0.0210268535,
0.0019454889,
0.019092245,
-0.0628571883,
0.0203948189,
0.0604390614,
-0.0078389496,
0.0422492959,
0.0053767171,
-0.0534533784,
0.0765311122,
0.0028000376,
-0.0650972575,
-0.0224593878,
0.0675723255,
-0.0076921745,
0.0363107286,
0.0140913669,
0.0002886096,
0.0011280322,
-0.0119339749,
0.0033542863,
0.0595438406,
0.0268304739,
-0.0331052952,
0.0076061799,
0.0060040699,
0.0494247489,
-0.0354370102,
0.026959952,
0.0190885141,
-0.047047548,
-0.0320235752,
-0.0781136826,
-0.0145118618,
0.0021179479,
-0.0380652286,
0.006292881,
0.0255434681,
0.016409399,
0.0116760414,
0.0069777202,
0.008442305,
0.0308857784,
0.0056200139,
-0.0222277828,
0.0082857665,
0.0483865179,
0.0260663852,
-0.0500552505,
0.0348337479,
-0.0007744743,
0.0085258167,
0.0303166155,
-0.0418627821,
-0.0524772517,
-0.0064954641,
-0.0199303273,
0.0039063278,
-0.003890754,
-0.0054670428,
0.0524765141,
-0.0626172945,
-0.0456981845,
-0.0344958007,
-0.0130616743,
0.0284094978,
0.0275620986,
-0.0562175587,
0.0025494476,
-0.0131347673,
0.0535567254,
-0.0083211698,
-0.0177763291,
-0.044848796,
-0.0033793156,
-0.0399615094,
0.0328178331,
-0.0101052541,
-0.0232493114,
0.0036676684,
-0.0048835892,
-0.0214351751,
0.014343855,
0.0079197474,
0.0320994556,
-0.0006005612,
-0.0433628447,
0.005786268,
-0.0152060483,
0.0493750647,
-0.0459083728,
0.0226833764,
0.0316589922,
0.0498785749,
-0.082295768,
-0.0603493825,
0.008956044,
-0.0139022218,
-0.0049360548,
0.0348800831,
-0.0116330171,
0.0567850433,
-0.0376911983,
-0.0002547657,
-0.0359801836,
0.0408922248,
-0.0004823347,
-0.0438288748,
0.0914886594,
-0.0797153413,
-0.0697011203,
-0.0017001024,
-0.0178598389,
0.0256934315,
0.0593231283,
0.0601636209,
0.0164947119,
0.0352097452,
0.017682068,
-0.0248756669,
-0.0095329648,
0.0323005095,
-0.0332964174,
0.0300224461,
-0.0152211934,
-0.0756451562,
-0.0036887184,
-0.0108075328,
0.0080011655,
0.0153869819,
0.0427031182,
0.0284320954,
-0.0044296477,
0.0009681512,
-0.0291452184,
-0.0176655836,
-0.0128012495,
-0.0000044815,
0.0055530309,
-0.0200805012,
0.013790356,
-0.0591605417,
-0.0099111125,
0.0080330269,
0.063971892,
-0.0024194771,
-0.0457867049,
0.006233695,
0.0061254208,
-0.0363085456,
-0.0029632607,
0.0466426462,
-0.0114238542,
-0.0382439494,
-0.0072549442,
0.049271632,
0.0036091178,
0.0330028422,
0.0023921716,
-0.023321541,
0.0265346859,
0.0402233191,
-0.0531988703,
-0.0375764556,
-0.0452026948,
-0.0609865077,
0.0054554408,
-0.0341776833,
0.0007926216,
0.0344270244,
-0.0316529796,
-0.0418433733,
0.0098397639,
0.0174213964,
0.0008863128,
-0.0244751479,
0.0060580033,
0.0083205551,
-0.006729546,
-0.0188971814,
0.0312928408,
0.0126469741,
-0.0112660816,
0.0445181653,
0.0479138531,
0.0292163305,
0.0525707118,
-0.004022419,
-0.015910523,
0.0045372257,
-0.0042900848,
-0.0666539595,
-0.0531838574,
0.0191771444,
-0.075247705,
-0.0023298201,
-0.0129235061,
-0.0463474803,
-0.0410167314,
-0.0371851735,
-0.0215739179,
-0.0541686602,
0.0000961504,
0.0256478861,
-0.0304502286,
0.0520732328,
0.0239103027,
0.0338155031,
-0.0383791737,
0.0928734839,
-0.0200230107,
-0.0066195894,
-0.0135049056,
-0.047717616,
0.0178636443,
-0.0278428514,
-0.0145737529,
-0.0039262744,
-0.0089413114,
-0.0528454594,
0.0058777113,
0.0017637714,
-0.0546946749,
-0.0217189118,
-0.0163766555,
0.0020782852,
0.0105151404,
0.0603708103,
-0.0433848277,
0.0361068659,
-0.0203641392,
-0.0206910558,
-0.0179283489,
0.0099725537,
-0.0600001849,
0.0018470343,
0.0186334159,
0.0166906416,
-0.0385183841,
0.0007445927,
-0.0136982044,
-0.0450363681,
0.0262153912,
0.0252287816,
-0.1030924097,
-0.0350465961,
0.0029064552,
-0.0108175036,
0.0131256627,
0.0359886922,
0.0469095856,
-0.0399700738,
0.0460922383,
-0.0065893321,
0.0487984344,
-0.0148350773,
0.0374310464,
0.0054625096,
-0.0078371121,
-0.0151995355,
0.0417677835,
0.0006710754,
0.0283157267,
0.0138241146,
0.0207677204,
0.0421572402,
0.0532425083,
-0.0307419077,
0.0158233736,
-0.0287040547,
0.0023826121,
-0.0072611431,
-0.019364344,
-0.0260404907,
0.0003155333,
-0.0030605712,
0.0185879096,
-0.0236190297,
-0.0009995862,
0.0772923827,
-0.0436080061,
-0.0006647988,
-0.004951512,
-0.0030722485,
-0.0359277762,
0.0232648402,
0.0174154807,
-0.0039159637,
0.0295472629,
-0.0808390826,
0.0204861537,
0.0464395098,
-0.0019953107,
-0.0462497137,
-0.0162760932,
-0.0021035764,
0.0237349551,
-0.0212811958,
-0.0350361913,
-0.0213706363,
0.0305244662,
-0.0524549969,
0.0064015719,
0.0070905769,
0.0006655225,
-0.0090571437,
0.0234593991,
-0.0186245758,
0.0431317538,
0.0339267217,
-0.0058926004,
-0.0417524464,
0.0496295951,
0.029208092,
-0.0201289244,
0.036875803,
-0.0029701125,
-0.0001086229,
-0.0010548882,
-0.0142204342,
0.0103096785,
0.0118922992,
0.0007885762,
0.0346211791,
-0.0471070372,
-0.0045447224,
-0.0324576572,
0.0025065935,
-0.0357719176,
0.0326080769,
0.0739461705,
0.0107571734,
-0.0250305422,
-0.0093114702,
0.0053274976,
0.00445168,
0.0063039009,
0.0330053754,
-0.0836149231,
0.0049388222,
0.0231387075,
-0.0081992839,
0.0197082032,
-0.0852553323,
0.0073817889,
-0.1391881704,
0.0587931052,
-0.0171389077,
-0.0309717786,
-0.0489290953,
-0.0354836956,
0.0404086001,
-0.0091764703,
0.0024045769,
-0.0473697558,
-0.0235762075,
-0.0157022383,
0.0287950709,
-0.0546889156,
-0.0822910368,
0.0240616947,
-0.0321307741,
0.0407971106,
-0.0312279817,
0.0352412798,
-0.0088141002,
-0.0228413343,
-0.0087566003,
-0.013075253,
-0.0417777151,
-0.0177251659,
0.02399306,
-0.0776699707,
-0.0292157233,
-0.0205078479,
0.0016767931,
-0.0091611128,
-0.0146678416,
0.0327860713,
0.0627188906,
0.0200498886,
0.0148480861,
-0.0225420538,
-0.0185879525,
0.0553022549,
0.0420735665,
0.000928121,
0.0009534133,
0.0078584738,
0.0234844629,
-0.0128058186,
-0.0238496177,
0.0512435809,
0.0886558965,
-0.0543380007,
-0.0010537237,
-0.0631427839,
-0.0347780697,
0.0432359539,
0.0345791727,
0.004797936,
0.0328351595,
0.0438287929,
-0.0051286323,
-0.0494409278,
-0.0123518687,
-0.0326626524,
0.0532858744,
-0.0294239856,
0.0252894051,
-0.0116692819,
0.0024869186,
-0.0684532225,
-0.014033732,
-0.0804338306,
-0.0206924975,
-0.0049995654,
0.013574332,
0.0062479698,
0.039032083,
-0.0156914368,
-0.0453733988,
0.0375910662,
0.0171988625,
-0.0400319286,
-0.0422410667,
0.0361994058,
0.0021559282,
-0.0182039719,
0.0196081456,
-0.0464627184,
0.025194319,
0.027562812,
0.0330061503,
0.0265178587,
-0.0225852598,
-0.0240866765,
0.0156593416,
0.0700727329,
-0.0433930866,
-0.0043296157,
-0.0619938821,
0.0689050555,
-0.0181854237,
-0.0196559727,
-0.0178671367,
-0.038742315,
-0.0063912924,
-0.0289832242,
-0.0245173983,
0.0174411461,
0.0084766708,
0.0224296376,
-0.0022655323,
0.0259927101,
0.0336355269,
0.0243974272,
-0.0161306523,
-0.0130314361,
-0.0254403111,
0.0254218616,
0.0479244776,
0.0479366668,
-0.0302283932,
-0.008483747,
-0.0212009121,
-0.0195012633,
-0.0793266147,
0.0128755122,
-0.0355105028,
0.0626405925,
-0.0289322603,
0.0320789628,
0.0318231732,
-0.0414847843,
-0.0013149205,
-0.0281609558,
-0.0166015439,
-0.0040570772,
0.0337351039,
-0.0076498878,
-0.0282524545,
0.0398360603,
-0.0037093654,
-0.0212466475,
0.0200552866,
0.0836449936,
0.0228713546,
0.0522317849,
-0.0065205479,
0.0084695993,
-0.0373286791,
-0.0179924536,
0.0630346984,
0.0820660368,
-0.0224901326,
0.0368043147,
-0.0240398869,
-0.032822419,
0.0005242794,
-0.0330759361,
-0.0177834406,
0.0100321528,
0.0038142705,
-0.0325832665,
0.0226546284,
-0.0628764927,
-0.0478450134,
0.0224331394,
0.0287226085,
-0.0214401726,
0.0144077018,
-6.191756332e-33,
-0.0572186448,
-0.0199558977,
-0.0230194628,
0.0276841,
-0.0107996576,
0.045008596,
0.0070841741,
-0.0392466709,
-0.0095810127,
-0.0142634744,
-0.0138078062,
-0.0209716056,
0.0421379879,
0.0227575544,
0.0048724138,
-0.0012184327,
0.0519265495,
0.0483689532,
-0.0186965596,
0.0032367713,
0.0091280015,
0.0713530555,
0.0908996537,
-0.1010666117,
0.0292753391,
0.0274269693,
-0.0023095089,
0.0092407577,
0.0637832507,
0.0697929263,
-0.0450736322,
0.0161520634,
0.011054772,
0.0027272615,
0.0293416269,
0.0039931484,
-0.1462355405,
0.0112530859,
-0.0271949749,
0.0507574305,
-0.034416616,
-0.0225045476,
0.003456631,
0.0159499608,
0.0440793559,
-0.060076002,
0.0182167925,
-0.0521395355,
-0.0315317176,
-0.0265822913,
-0.0598843768,
0.0660986006,
0.0099037318,
0.0629002973,
0.0196354669,
-0.009702771,
0.0592241883,
0.0286965705,
-0.0756763518,
-0.0069897161,
0.0182737112,
-0.0279490966,
0.0473699421,
0.0552437976,
-0.0038836366,
0.0718270838,
0.0213571656,
0.0252316035,
-0.0540308207,
0.0157179907,
0.0117603764,
0.0381571203,
-0.0234100502,
0.0689134225,
0.0371901207,
-0.003237963,
-0.0742896944,
0.0316647217,
0.0290752444,
0.0160986092,
-0.0342563726,
0.0061105154,
-0.0794774741,
-0.0116898995,
-0.0122267203,
-0.048558075,
-0.0487101525,
-0.0042387526,
0.0121612391,
0.0312167555,
-0.065374501,
0.0461360328,
0.0082470756,
-0.0243288688,
-0.0684276298,
0.0007324867,
0.0927084088,
0.0243423432,
-0.0058280225,
0.0109010572,
0.002960783,
-0.0361829475,
0.029905675,
0.0222475938,
0.0187970959,
-0.0075335293,
0.0778947622,
0.0047234646,
-0.0726162344,
0.0083916932,
0.0172945336,
-0.0120730493,
0.0047834343,
0.0165501237,
0.0434872955,
0.0022129396,
0.0082534617,
0.040180929,
0.0698184967,
0.0308848713,
0.0009335381,
-0.0196648017,
-0.0073009254,
0.0399896316,
0.0280720405,
-0.0253004413,
0.0071068835,
-0.0206921361,
0.0223170184,
-0.0592882596,
0.005158795,
-0.0278007239,
2.642e-7,
0.0460160412,
0.0292305518,
0.0192802846,
-0.0558884256,
0.0134833166,
-0.0132808397,
0.0442643315,
0.0490339994,
-0.047046151,
0.0256759021,
0.0208466314,
-0.0716869235,
0.0333786346,
0.0205333177,
-0.0239365231,
-0.0680105835,
-0.039202325,
0.0111133866,
-0.0681569949,
-0.0261280127,
0.0933942795,
0.0614351928,
0.0266089793,
-0.0376511514,
-0.0414882414,
-0.0049118139,
0.0296424665,
0.0221130773,
0.000098797,
0.0127950544,
-0.0196373444,
0.1134793013,
0.007010723,
0.0410506353,
-0.0415732563,
0.0535865873,
0.0430504605,
0.0516459309,
0.0002140884,
0.0843713582,
-0.0124943899,
-0.0041630124,
0.0042666839,
-0.0479677692,
0.0731246546,
-0.0689853951,
-0.0099255061,
-0.0442314334,
-0.019821329,
-0.0156720597,
0.0164976139,
0.0196437724,
-0.0213068333,
0.0377103202,
0.011048398,
0.0005099985,
-0.0280175786,
-0.0864559337,
0.0203028619,
0.0172673073,
0.0156406723,
0.0273046196,
0.0161425192,
-0.0109357266,
0.0464012064,
-0.0526476167,
-0.0209696889,
2.309712779e-34,
-0.0079036383,
-0.0283395126,
0.0000083854,
0.0164185371,
0.0202647336,
-0.0115199052,
-0.0106203863,
0.0098748729,
-0.0106062125,
-0.0634179488,
0.0291199163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12775v1 | Hopping Too Late: Exploring the Limitations of Large Language Models on Multi-Hop Queries | 2024-06-18T16:44:13 | 2024-06-18T16:44:13 | Eden Biran, Daniela Gottesman, Sohee Yang, Mor Geva, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can solve complex multi-step problems, but
little is known about how these computations are implemented internally.
Motivated by this, we study how LLMs answer multi-hop queries such as "The
spouse of the performer of Imagine is". These queries require two information
extraction steps: a latent one for resolving the first hop ("the performer of
Imagine") into the bridge entity (John Lennon), and one for resolving the
second hop ("the spouse of John Lennon") into the target entity (Yoko Ono).
Understanding how the latent step is computed internally is key to
understanding the overall computation. By carefully analyzing the internal
computations of transformer-based LLMs, we discover that the bridge entity is
resolved in the early layers of the model. Then, only after this resolution,
the two-hop query is solved in the later layers. Because the second hop
commences in later layers, there could be cases where these layers no longer
encode the necessary knowledge for correctly predicting the answer. Motivated
by this, we propose a novel "back-patching" analysis method whereby a hidden
representation from a later layer is patched back to an earlier layer. We find
that in up to 57% of previously incorrect cases there exists a back-patch that
results in the correct generation of the answer, showing that the later layers
indeed sometimes lack the needed functionality. Overall our methods and
findings open further opportunities for understanding and improving latent
reasoning in transformer-based LLMs. | [
0.0415519699,
0.0873289332,
-0.0329594091,
0.0549304932,
-0.0554919317,
0.0129267545,
0.0057265051,
-0.013595135,
0.009699095,
-0.0337404087,
-0.0032966249,
-0.0497968048,
0.0106487442,
-0.0166912246,
0.0309123173,
0.0045195101,
0.0280096233,
-0.0536898337,
-0.0300940424,
-0.0309677571,
-0.0551019087,
0.0145506524,
0.0076159053,
0.0305186547,
-0.0044415579,
-0.013986825,
-0.0376133695,
-0.0054172827,
0.0032606516,
0.0432853438,
-0.053234119,
0.0470847934,
0.000203382,
0.0423559546,
0.0000021022,
-0.0271766074,
-0.0169871356,
0.0111919018,
-0.033120472,
0.0050960463,
-0.0233941562,
0.0094254073,
-0.0385728814,
0.0263582431,
-0.0172779784,
-0.0022319357,
0.0346036218,
0.0567355789,
0.0418114662,
0.0489305481,
0.0006970243,
-0.0427680574,
0.0331813209,
-0.0094252676,
0.036176607,
-0.0634561181,
0.0594565272,
-0.0161000565,
0.0101480298,
-0.0067485743,
-0.0360472836,
0.0667322353,
0.0265865289,
-0.021417629,
-0.063107565,
0.0389857478,
0.0037422087,
-0.0160569921,
0.0061892737,
0.0241387803,
-0.0068425457,
0.0020350739,
0.0020481299,
0.0148569532,
-0.0089780223,
0.0595462508,
-0.0332801044,
0.0297118481,
0.0007061625,
-0.0052991938,
0.0108292783,
-0.0516368859,
0.062370263,
0.0018193208,
-0.0689833835,
0.0939380154,
0.0242152978,
-0.0302474666,
-0.011608582,
0.004876765,
-0.0021823575,
-0.0750187635,
0.0359996855,
0.0452596061,
-0.0132789109,
0.024692107,
0.0229982473,
0.005031364,
-0.0130933989,
-0.0420187451,
0.0300950836,
0.0565344915,
-0.0175024997,
0.0664871335,
-0.0111598894,
0.0254170187,
-0.0828852281,
-0.0022370149,
-0.0291554648,
-0.0207203012,
-0.0036270453,
-0.0373663493,
-0.0629479215,
0.0623217896,
-0.0325076617,
-0.0220576283,
0.0051667406,
0.0159477498,
-0.011501601,
-0.0247557107,
0.0073700706,
0.012364516,
0.0057602338,
-0.0240926724,
-0.032777939,
0.0586021505,
-0.0084362738,
0.0219053142,
0.0017318135,
-0.0508297831,
-0.015437766,
-0.0110433474,
0.0165802035,
-0.0331124961,
0.0183598679,
0.0509173498,
-0.0138578303,
-0.0099351453,
-0.0284903646,
-0.0526874475,
-0.0183092263,
-0.0788103044,
0.0295661744,
-0.0693568289,
0.0515482426,
0.031071635,
0.0016180126,
-0.0443987362,
0.0108700963,
0.0212306213,
-0.0490986928,
0.0761948302,
0.044417683,
0.0356439725,
0.0179301184,
0.0324067883,
0.0128046228,
0.0751525387,
0.0477531925,
0.0076717865,
0.0241199136,
-0.0137993898,
0.0212549325,
0.0555908456,
0.0181592684,
-0.0041007088,
-0.0052107456,
0.000869676,
0.0028939333,
0.0355954953,
0.0048645316,
0.0631915703,
-0.0235640835,
-0.0159760695,
0.0264373403,
0.0434271246,
0.0584279411,
0.0321798846,
0.0494879559,
-0.0088066459,
0.0051417695,
0.0457933992,
-0.0653024912,
0.0453723148,
-0.0300133806,
-0.0193676595,
0.0114247082,
0.0161188655,
-0.0230255201,
-0.0033664606,
0.0049655559,
0.0251548477,
-0.011010089,
0.0064922264,
0.0354716517,
0.0215860363,
-0.0274587758,
0.1321665645,
0.00729127,
-0.0336976722,
0.0101904068,
-0.0800658092,
-0.0391046405,
0.048946701,
0.0563426353,
0.0073248683,
-0.0072996905,
0.0228014067,
0.0034913688,
0.0096792756,
0.0082343342,
-0.0151312705,
-0.0150959007,
-0.0150689846,
-0.0296828225,
0.0200111996,
0.017570138,
-0.0021768997,
-0.0030222968,
-0.0116738966,
0.0143210404,
-0.0293411575,
0.0623463467,
0.0055430057,
-0.0866066292,
-0.004494058,
-0.0094261141,
0.0116348807,
-0.0012033357,
0.0265436508,
0.0119227655,
0.0374905728,
0.0521967895,
-0.0057430333,
-0.0529039092,
-0.0006554424,
-0.033041589,
-0.0186006483,
0.031520661,
-0.0317575969,
-0.0060487799,
0.0165123921,
0.0042825281,
-0.0514833033,
0.0252540987,
-0.0520658344,
0.0559970625,
-0.0289316606,
0.0406048484,
-0.0147242984,
-0.0152795184,
-0.0066039534,
0.0624308549,
-0.01445005,
0.0134722497,
-0.0086415727,
0.001217033,
-0.0052073766,
-0.01081884,
-0.0390552171,
0.0431215316,
0.026950229,
0.001443197,
-0.0129425703,
-0.0210003816,
-0.0352700651,
-0.0725750476,
-0.0658038482,
-0.00132094,
-0.0264933594,
0.011586586,
0.0024808953,
0.0387731344,
0.0032067744,
0.0080188559,
-0.0166198052,
0.0025524257,
0.0015978578,
0.0318915732,
-0.010407594,
0.0325779356,
-0.0547232591,
-0.0008859037,
-0.0154712684,
-0.0514842644,
0.0575618893,
-0.0255874861,
-0.0287721474,
-0.0701760799,
-0.0103164818,
-0.0330090597,
0.0296302363,
-0.0290304795,
-0.0074892053,
0.0201659799,
-0.0387327522,
0.0536162965,
0.0249641463,
-0.0034197813,
0.0336202048,
0.0596312247,
-0.048761066,
-0.0436894819,
0.0125413975,
-0.061175175,
-0.0239323918,
-0.0621095151,
-0.0315824449,
-0.0401647836,
0.0804787874,
0.0087208757,
-0.0049803378,
-0.0543183051,
0.0195769295,
-0.0017883849,
-0.0218366273,
0.0047865286,
-0.0063651148,
-0.0256058127,
0.0413419046,
-0.000811981,
0.0060236985,
0.0845845938,
-0.0207618047,
0.0061158766,
-0.0164169595,
0.0257947035,
-0.0316292048,
0.0812353417,
-0.0186474118,
0.0194364134,
-0.0161458869,
-0.0562059283,
-0.0711352006,
0.0485430546,
-0.0040060342,
-0.0597033277,
0.0655754358,
-0.0397207402,
0.0128238071,
0.0033489284,
-0.0458877794,
-0.0282247439,
-0.0004023756,
-0.033603549,
0.0266689807,
0.0135979895,
-0.010848769,
-0.0486225225,
-0.0080450336,
0.04074426,
0.0181986298,
-0.0124624921,
-0.009130748,
-0.0363003835,
0.0147683537,
0.0388457328,
0.0131677901,
0.0432099141,
-0.0198805165,
0.0412218645,
0.0562872142,
0.028431423,
-0.0098359836,
0.0239934195,
0.008099135,
0.0690070167,
-0.0188600756,
-0.0253615398,
0.0076131988,
0.0179862678,
-0.0679920465,
-0.0198771264,
0.0919927508,
0.0471231714,
-0.0518691503,
0.0111568384,
-0.0443545952,
-0.0256185345,
0.0132241342,
0.0259829219,
-0.1114699841,
-0.0074916617,
0.0310437903,
-0.0097303148,
2.733e-7,
-0.039170038,
-0.0075769979,
-0.1318513304,
0.0527313761,
-0.0150144938,
-0.0217234958,
-0.0120599456,
-0.0323419236,
0.0061074179,
0.0228214841,
0.033246953,
0.0529910214,
-0.0229084697,
-0.0257106945,
-0.0006867821,
0.0439941846,
-0.0387489609,
0.0329293869,
-0.0322658978,
0.0272858627,
0.0270427,
0.0439980887,
0.0041080411,
-0.0469183251,
0.0408003479,
-0.0300357696,
0.0162366163,
-0.024478117,
0.0248008557,
0.0288035348,
-0.0063051563,
-0.0320310853,
0.0047888313,
-0.0118680568,
-0.0194065478,
-0.0252073929,
0.1003884524,
-0.0367257223,
-0.0343145505,
0.0138388798,
0.0283857174,
-0.0278196335,
0.0761776417,
0.030317381,
-0.0282647908,
-0.0448841155,
-0.0300772842,
0.0114725595,
0.014472913,
-0.0673935115,
0.0297145452,
0.0253221244,
-0.0129993288,
-0.0187999494,
-0.0144550437,
0.0442154482,
0.036812719,
0.0210956931,
0.0262377262,
0.0333335623,
-0.0210671108,
-0.0561121516,
-0.0056039216,
-0.0438415967,
0.031073425,
-0.0213229265,
0.0050538732,
0.0437459089,
-0.0237282086,
-0.021179568,
-0.0416075252,
-0.0860768184,
-0.0533847176,
0.0327251442,
-0.0062228981,
0.0380532928,
0.0352934934,
-0.0279885922,
-0.0777618662,
-0.0001298683,
0.0192894991,
-0.046381671,
0.0202086642,
0.0268118773,
-0.0007025778,
-0.008965835,
0.056129843,
-0.0499408282,
-0.0055188164,
0.019746162,
0.0766766071,
-0.0425563715,
-0.0358524173,
0.0382680632,
0.0190837104,
0.0418615118,
0.008635697,
0.0333976187,
-0.01257734,
0.052373711,
-0.0471708477,
-0.0223303679,
-0.027835425,
-0.0072708474,
0.0253684688,
0.0296477564,
0.0018146978,
-0.002199468,
0.0018879424,
0.0220043752,
-0.037151482,
0.0035139867,
0.0162277855,
-0.0296661127,
0.0644346923,
0.0040599778,
0.0113613391,
0.0096448036,
0.0571137778,
0.0507874824,
-0.0188289266,
0.0470180102,
0.0397465415,
-0.0128613552,
-0.0762564987,
-0.0081032775,
-0.0831391066,
-0.0690825582,
0.0090401266,
0.022364961,
0.0354230963,
0.0193434693,
0.0413034149,
-0.0000576883,
-0.0250242949,
0.0065134461,
0.0004907171,
0.0137106515,
-0.0388757661,
0.0544706844,
0.0416583978,
0.0079340544,
0.0162856225,
0.0595148355,
-0.0126948999,
0.0430597849,
-0.0370654948,
-0.0097687431,
0.008653014,
-0.0501675792,
-0.012758337,
-0.0100276209,
-0.0327299684,
-0.018790856,
-0.0916475952,
-0.0828004554,
-0.0109649627,
-0.0003494487,
-0.0012680301,
-0.0373660624,
0.0022903555,
0.0873623341,
0.0526210219,
-0.0576081388,
-0.0520757586,
-0.0056981752,
0.0071420898,
-0.0028232557,
0.0198655017,
-7.072358088e-33,
-0.0417183861,
-0.0353351422,
0.0578823686,
0.0336598009,
-0.0287964139,
0.0011110426,
-0.0665077642,
0.0147226714,
-0.0140916361,
0.0121418145,
-0.0345193036,
0.0285761319,
0.0217310973,
0.0114311511,
0.0267599728,
-0.0323079489,
0.0385351032,
0.0220773052,
-0.0169272553,
0.0036271962,
0.0392746814,
0.017173741,
0.0348438844,
-0.0315022022,
0.0152458325,
-0.0159924123,
-0.0145938061,
0.0402617194,
-0.0431293212,
0.0475276075,
-0.0190775804,
0.0136801926,
0.0136229536,
-0.0689220726,
-0.006443481,
0.0203885455,
-0.097199358,
-0.0135553684,
0.0381322205,
0.0204799287,
0.0035500135,
-0.0330034345,
0.0330067202,
0.0113828378,
-0.0220798627,
-0.0207046065,
0.0176887922,
-0.0152037749,
0.007879708,
-0.0438495502,
-0.0549302362,
0.0030599833,
0.0201418456,
0.0140527152,
0.0250799693,
0.0223454796,
-0.0036653033,
0.0205856301,
-0.0947452709,
0.0229896698,
0.0144311087,
0.0080473805,
0.0510023832,
0.0231583565,
-0.0005981595,
0.0251379199,
0.0482830219,
-0.0078087421,
-0.0546556078,
0.0170848481,
0.0318351984,
0.0556837954,
0.0201823693,
-0.016572075,
0.0049414411,
0.0112285111,
-0.0491311029,
-0.0080997143,
-0.0035744591,
0.0271493271,
0.029943319,
0.0067580412,
-0.0269414224,
-0.0455552749,
-0.0676056668,
0.0091424566,
-0.0494068712,
-0.0299968086,
-0.0065516713,
0.0139691541,
-0.0301485788,
0.0111055961,
0.0131020453,
-0.0696861148,
-0.0514849871,
-0.0183870606,
-0.0149279563,
0.0088078519,
-0.0084834183,
0.0446177274,
-0.0281750187,
-0.031352628,
0.0319218263,
-0.0177787077,
0.0142960725,
0.0222600736,
-0.0075874804,
0.049693048,
-0.0840312839,
-0.0285841078,
-0.0629807413,
-0.0161772948,
0.0002224487,
-0.0250969753,
0.0347486325,
0.0203453414,
0.0076364605,
-0.0064438586,
0.0419515744,
0.0434568636,
-0.0235217866,
0.0654561296,
-0.004394277,
0.0214629192,
-0.0288009662,
-0.0102728987,
-0.0399968773,
0.0111258905,
0.0651047602,
-0.0626617894,
-0.0400649011,
0.0434981138,
3e-7,
0.0570019819,
0.0260750167,
0.0142661845,
0.047212854,
0.0257177111,
0.0148864007,
-0.0297930371,
0.0033474839,
0.0700599924,
-0.0157469884,
0.0010345799,
0.0226036496,
0.0292291716,
0.0483921655,
-0.0745880827,
-0.0106282244,
-0.0285362452,
-0.0341724008,
-0.0367268063,
-0.0140655441,
0.0066738557,
0.0740706623,
0.0275804289,
-0.0162302088,
-0.0470631309,
-0.0288296062,
0.0581629947,
-0.0113944858,
-0.0110473428,
0.0062041213,
0.0122812409,
-0.0092433495,
0.0371773466,
0.0187549721,
-0.0213288944,
0.0588970594,
0.0048645297,
0.0671138018,
0.0111499578,
-0.0190313179,
-0.0132617699,
-0.0500202477,
-0.0140711125,
-0.0379117914,
0.0878869742,
-0.0642835125,
-0.0679669231,
0.001869558,
-0.0161027443,
-0.018255081,
-0.0093325945,
-0.0017217412,
-0.0062653823,
0.0035658814,
0.0280387662,
0.005530904,
0.0307310093,
-0.084467575,
-0.0086123692,
0.0222147573,
-0.0495015122,
-0.0428147614,
-0.0029654172,
-0.0495212823,
0.0078968573,
-0.0434450433,
-0.0196350906,
2.929288071e-34,
0.0328882746,
0.0054422119,
0.0012013519,
0.0407773778,
0.0413715728,
-0.0263607781,
0.0123625202,
0.027160285,
-0.0027231821,
-0.1019071713,
-0.0485975854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12770v2 | Informatics & dairy industry coalition: AI trends and present challenges | 2024-06-18T16:39:21 | 2024-06-19T11:49:03 | Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, María del Carmen Somoza-López | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI) can potentially transform the industry,
enhancing the production process and minimizing manual, repetitive tasks.
Accordingly, the synergy between high-performance computing and powerful
mathematical models enables the application of sophisticated data analysis
procedures like Machine Learning. However, challenges exist regarding
effective, efficient, and flexible processing to generate valuable knowledge.
Consequently, this work comprehensively describes industrial challenges where
AI can be exploited, focusing on the dairy industry. The conclusions presented
can help researchers apply novel approaches for cattle monitoring and farmers
by proposing advanced technological solutions to their needs. | [
-0.0054952041,
0.0544836894,
-0.0493816324,
-0.0193458721,
-0.0442611203,
0.026148716,
0.020612061,
0.0442254804,
0.0508587845,
-0.005835745,
0.1043945998,
0.0243968386,
-0.0290371496,
0.1098408625,
-0.0090470091,
0.0066471589,
-0.0176029168,
0.048656594,
0.0495393761,
0.0437483452,
-0.0095529892,
0.0048557143,
-0.0299930852,
0.0271971226,
-0.1288350374,
0.0263384487,
0.0052945563,
-0.0395273045,
0.0421054922,
-0.0204771105,
-0.0011938052,
-0.0722416863,
0.0168570988,
0.0270167235,
0.0000020134,
-0.0528157204,
-0.0291938912,
0.0463090986,
-0.0495426394,
0.043493595,
-0.0057074046,
-0.0348101445,
0.0269439947,
0.0129539724,
-0.0076286024,
0.0818948001,
0.0668821409,
-0.0057371906,
-0.0158925653,
0.0203698147,
-0.0250005554,
-0.0403230414,
0.0356006175,
0.0165039543,
-0.0458912961,
0.0169300772,
0.0092424816,
-0.0225408692,
-0.0010561767,
-0.0507890061,
-0.0296921767,
0.080167301,
0.0554596223,
0.0107258391,
0.0069730203,
0.0616461933,
-0.0373451784,
-0.0380557701,
-0.0449187234,
-0.0318685174,
-0.0375867859,
0.0009377086,
-0.0404221304,
-0.0258977972,
-0.0329964086,
-0.0117500434,
-0.0143655008,
0.0189885069,
-0.0315263942,
-0.0014200025,
0.0056208791,
0.0231895316,
-0.0024056172,
-0.0188423879,
-0.0271902308,
0.0980234966,
-0.0128720775,
-0.0156467948,
-0.0008822362,
0.0078010103,
-0.0087527931,
0.0402291566,
0.0180462766,
0.051186692,
-0.0461264327,
-0.0513560139,
0.0121563422,
-0.0868948922,
0.0531364679,
-0.0315221436,
-0.0103505841,
-0.0269294288,
-0.0332972035,
-0.020663565,
0.0200852398,
0.0006197058,
-0.0110259736,
-0.0232233666,
0.0102541363,
0.0353026167,
-0.0419386029,
0.0029318298,
0.0102772657,
0.009572383,
0.0052878833,
-0.0047253435,
0.0115548493,
0.0143962633,
-0.0396667868,
-0.0599932112,
0.0195897259,
0.0188227501,
0.0055091064,
0.0141154751,
-0.0734715238,
0.0292237401,
-0.0782369152,
0.0660335273,
-0.0377025902,
-0.0531678721,
0.0054116594,
-0.0231096223,
-0.0041404963,
0.0506233275,
0.0309666041,
0.0813861117,
0.0090524051,
-0.0378014036,
-0.0648250878,
-0.0174341332,
0.0249967463,
-0.0482941046,
-0.0696452409,
0.0326952785,
0.0579938293,
0.0380417369,
-0.0020343191,
-0.005837183,
0.010170145,
0.0192182753,
-0.0297901593,
0.0133228749,
0.0063645346,
0.0041965907,
0.0254414733,
-0.0263399817,
-0.0076139267,
0.0095551033,
0.0256986469,
0.0169033501,
-0.0417993851,
-0.0048835622,
0.0098787379,
0.0086918678,
-0.0262494795,
-0.0432253703,
-0.0663699731,
-0.0215571113,
-0.0091099385,
0.017258836,
0.0140152024,
0.0435636751,
0.0342576206,
-0.0213800613,
0.0973078609,
0.0627979785,
-0.0053178519,
-0.0296672396,
0.0538089164,
0.0226182658,
0.0001280275,
-0.0383748859,
0.0529887788,
0.010387972,
-0.0824436471,
-0.013437151,
-0.0044775768,
-0.0130645679,
-0.0137171224,
-0.0651808232,
0.0261993054,
-0.0152486656,
0.0439981073,
0.0366064794,
0.0570273064,
-0.0003915129,
0.0132510848,
-0.0696339011,
0.0419337749,
0.0017037197,
-0.0191182178,
-0.0308520924,
0.0615876578,
-0.013158828,
0.0198606029,
-0.0674426928,
-0.0154717285,
-0.0243670922,
0.0096859019,
-0.0120982453,
-0.0136920493,
-0.0281681735,
-0.0104230745,
0.04095532,
0.0152146751,
0.0238415152,
0.0361262672,
-0.0142216263,
-0.0329112858,
0.0351970568,
-0.0569038168,
0.0664822608,
-0.0168809127,
0.0499744862,
-0.0099357497,
-0.0198110826,
-0.0045152949,
0.0244336054,
-0.0100122504,
0.0475441441,
0.0081323143,
0.0071824682,
0.0409140252,
-0.0759073123,
0.0162124075,
-0.0074122916,
0.0886900052,
0.0533156805,
0.0006992848,
-0.0009537044,
-0.0483240485,
-0.052256573,
-0.0355158262,
0.0193063337,
0.0285568293,
-0.0408448316,
-0.0028304716,
0.0009332494,
0.0286131799,
-0.0041271048,
0.0442690067,
-0.0209388416,
0.0063373693,
-0.0154889924,
-0.0167477019,
0.0257129353,
-0.031110866,
-0.0052045439,
-0.009035361,
0.0706833601,
-0.0327786095,
-0.0243203193,
0.0000858866,
0.0295267683,
-0.0036270071,
0.0039904877,
0.0154318297,
0.0441104583,
-0.018595105,
0.0052521699,
0.0064409468,
0.0166799948,
-0.0003457078,
0.0005986933,
-0.0113609629,
-0.0209550671,
0.0759759694,
-0.0442763343,
-0.0328791067,
0.0317479074,
0.050476864,
-0.0501131192,
0.0523944944,
0.0041286657,
-0.0560016558,
0.0463625714,
0.0742232129,
-0.0099536581,
-0.0146495746,
-0.0306840297,
-0.0041976017,
0.0193594825,
-0.0069728717,
0.0301315263,
-0.0331528708,
0.0053443569,
-0.0479712337,
0.05971108,
-0.0078049614,
0.0387018174,
-0.021580549,
0.0239167772,
-0.0096469633,
0.0331885517,
-0.0492259003,
0.0370228253,
-0.0039055811,
0.0091003925,
0.0249731429,
-0.0139948539,
-0.0001890486,
-0.0376544893,
0.0228437241,
0.0968798399,
0.0393454209,
-0.0245968439,
-0.0493243821,
0.0092487056,
0.0380815007,
0.0430650376,
0.0095993159,
-0.0397678502,
0.0199120883,
0.0426377319,
-0.011948131,
0.0242451057,
-0.0396774374,
0.0211715642,
0.0125368433,
0.0239608977,
0.0197028182,
-0.0494728722,
0.0054662414,
0.0359436274,
0.0473902673,
-0.0647052601,
-0.0126572894,
-0.02475035,
-0.0298891813,
-0.0194982551,
0.0199851859,
-0.0170872398,
-0.0595336668,
0.0347378179,
0.0024684402,
-0.0145146046,
0.0498519354,
0.002772744,
-0.0397142619,
0.0339511037,
0.0089139212,
0.0155085437,
0.0409419164,
-0.0027202878,
0.0089647649,
-0.0108415829,
0.0114874989,
-0.0221631769,
0.007857766,
0.0159739926,
0.0369904079,
-0.0059960983,
-0.01331254,
-0.0161047913,
-0.0666938499,
0.0564383902,
-0.0627751723,
-0.037911851,
0.0319225751,
0.0028778759,
-0.0274674874,
-0.0667940229,
-0.0034508633,
0.028982427,
-0.0034186998,
-0.0051624496,
0.0173402373,
0.0371603556,
-0.0610481761,
-0.0165276378,
-0.0036459276,
0.0159180406,
0.0237724036,
0.0126594966,
-0.0241798684,
-0.0770084187,
-0.0620078146,
-0.0155569427,
-0.0474555343,
0.0860465765,
-0.0375396647,
-0.0128826844,
-0.0675004199,
-0.0496683531,
-0.0111946957,
-0.061735481,
0.0183978155,
-0.0234147888,
-0.0162711702,
-0.0298139937,
0.0084472327,
-0.0298438389,
0.0322938412,
0.0037802442,
-0.0443870574,
-0.0148049248,
0.0667552501,
0.0442590192,
-0.025788838,
-0.0635376498,
-0.0302450228,
0.030004425,
0.0187098291,
-0.0304449629,
0.0409234352,
0.0170266852,
-0.0011426405,
0.0019434901,
0.0238518417,
0.0320619084,
0.023550421,
0.0166285988,
0.0461490862,
-0.0382845514,
-0.0165794864,
-0.0200806465,
-0.0341935046,
0.0090514217,
0.01413872,
0.0581085458,
-0.0644789115,
-0.0544702187,
-0.0035266448,
-0.0239218734,
-0.0242894497,
0.010497136,
-0.0028469977,
0.0209331885,
-0.0957055613,
-0.0277032442,
0.0221968573,
0.044873096,
-0.0156557299,
0.0467058644,
0.0523184165,
0.0965419635,
-0.0377421677,
-0.05961309,
0.0095227845,
0.0274191145,
0.0068894476,
-0.005359719,
-0.0167848431,
0.0435888767,
-0.0325022787,
0.0046788896,
0.0415469073,
-0.0212574396,
-0.0240160264,
-0.012520331,
0.0809421316,
0.0058191437,
0.0237434041,
-0.0017654313,
0.0201112684,
0.0050598579,
0.0783012882,
-0.0081362901,
0.0216929205,
-0.0276207533,
-0.0199080575,
0.0093286252,
-0.0396106504,
0.0206343476,
0.0710791051,
-0.0244945101,
-0.0171972178,
-0.0016630274,
-0.0220833961,
0.0252732877,
-0.0089207059,
0.0212480072,
0.0204785019,
-0.0103226006,
-0.0264321603,
0.0039322628,
-0.0016044348,
-0.0199941918,
-0.0159774907,
-0.0237759165,
0.0123994891,
0.0578679368,
-0.0047161528,
-0.0442119204,
0.0383193418,
-0.0450488105,
0.0054711425,
0.0150959622,
0.0098856809,
0.090090692,
-0.0131176086,
0.0237459205,
0.0193611514,
-0.011119009,
0.0065377983,
0.0455347262,
0.0351651013,
0.0234183166,
-0.0144383805,
0.0087060696,
-0.052226387,
0.0345751643,
-0.0165252592,
0.0310458262,
0.0120341312,
-0.0094897673,
0.0052154507,
-0.0545299128,
-0.0036409695,
-0.0266590212,
-0.0431097262,
-0.0245341938,
0.0051209815,
-0.0197080113,
0.0200728346,
-0.0576935373,
0.0048949518,
-0.0270677432,
-0.0313275568,
0.0087457476,
-0.0278448295,
0.0448384508,
-0.0463906303,
-0.0004077384,
0.0061885361,
0.0148104317,
0.0312293842,
-0.0488947369,
0.0175715815,
-0.026459137,
-0.0170352161,
0.0063347043,
0.0181504656,
-0.024199456,
0.0239944849,
0.0150799202,
-0.0063790828,
-0.0359956771,
-0.0053065578,
-0.0642838627,
-0.010299175,
-0.0012475564,
-0.0603783801,
-0.0300448071,
-0.0209515207,
-5.776704705e-33,
0.0106190136,
-0.0528414585,
0.0088559296,
0.0356027633,
0.0071390327,
0.0551782958,
0.0596343428,
-0.0474089682,
0.0429762825,
0.0070085903,
-0.0573381856,
-0.024811592,
-0.0077030477,
0.0428796336,
0.0607924983,
0.0111544486,
0.0315594748,
-0.00395235,
0.0394595601,
-0.0674808994,
-0.0313409865,
0.0214206409,
0.0148958797,
-0.0622454658,
0.0054727211,
-0.0126833525,
-0.0226190668,
-0.0253901836,
-0.0502021164,
0.0040435176,
0.0168221015,
-0.0118781785,
0.0459551886,
-0.0234640036,
-0.0476340503,
0.0903080255,
-0.0561557896,
-0.0209830645,
-0.0916224644,
0.0115863113,
-0.065682061,
-0.0065744258,
0.0556717291,
0.0100822644,
-0.0564657897,
0.0734446943,
0.0439501256,
-0.050652843,
0.0472372659,
-0.0110146543,
0.0010966511,
-0.0334786326,
-0.0108398609,
0.0146955214,
0.0828993917,
0.0347611532,
-0.0155298244,
-0.0336791687,
-0.0661941245,
0.0354487114,
-0.0115849748,
-0.0702318028,
0.0230759494,
-0.0020825742,
0.0138666779,
0.0000387374,
0.0136623941,
-0.0348077454,
0.0011441094,
0.0116063515,
-0.0579669252,
-0.0002678661,
0.0534960851,
-0.0396965556,
0.0179367848,
-0.05592205,
-0.0715889111,
0.0668713897,
-0.0304590929,
-0.0308033731,
-0.0243093856,
-0.0334390253,
-0.0056236587,
0.0006067616,
0.0089072017,
0.0005362886,
-0.0014537242,
0.0216561351,
0.0395540446,
-0.0317501128,
-0.0062863166,
0.0401073582,
-0.0127944015,
0.0032163346,
0.0779191703,
-0.0601757914,
0.0444437265,
-0.0081196856,
0.0504842252,
-0.030525364,
-0.0143580511,
-0.0510091148,
-0.0398129709,
0.0357767493,
0.0163311847,
-0.0369258784,
0.005531311,
0.0338216089,
0.0063815168,
0.0137299923,
0.0334394239,
0.0030708814,
0.0625091344,
0.0031348998,
0.0225872286,
-0.0216482338,
0.0413921624,
0.0444453508,
0.0095094973,
0.0119401924,
-0.0037551976,
0.0034186991,
0.0037836591,
-0.0210984722,
-0.0111768944,
-0.026325006,
0.0002953298,
-0.0526534803,
-0.0249680262,
-0.0260283593,
-0.009586609,
-0.0397814922,
2.658e-7,
0.0778854042,
0.0828389972,
0.0261530988,
-0.0026673619,
0.0023471273,
-0.0187845826,
0.0344836153,
0.0032597338,
-0.0327312201,
0.0203290209,
0.0574132651,
-0.0143073145,
-0.0620035157,
-0.0131310839,
-0.0074940883,
-0.081338577,
0.0062255375,
0.0018437923,
-0.0473828129,
-0.0036570695,
-0.0128490143,
-0.010976132,
0.0227593016,
-0.0202669613,
0.0573084131,
-0.0418296643,
-0.016461147,
-0.0018124204,
0.0893108323,
-0.0151667669,
-0.019225454,
0.0660020709,
0.026637746,
0.0626453757,
0.0266252272,
-0.0117999343,
-0.016040368,
0.0170427114,
-0.0145085715,
-0.0111603197,
0.0446788296,
0.0765038654,
0.027985245,
0.0113134095,
0.027278889,
0.0068631428,
-0.0392260738,
-0.0030179413,
0.0632150769,
0.0168736503,
0.0458662324,
0.001637895,
0.1177279949,
0.0003699919,
-0.0281824376,
0.0044804425,
0.0128231375,
0.0207502451,
-0.0122859115,
-0.0324916765,
-0.0482380651,
-0.0074456357,
0.0069174147,
-0.0043701958,
0.0254509058,
-0.0459283628,
-0.0167077892,
2.348452435e-34,
0.0051878546,
-0.0004184218,
-0.0040350216,
0.0546792708,
-0.0685995966,
0.0152641078,
-0.0242000129,
-0.0224072393,
-0.0223425683,
-0.0143791325,
-0.0170004219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12754v1 | Chumor 1.0: A Truly Funny and Challenging Chinese Humor Understanding Dataset from Ruo Zhi Ba | 2024-06-18T16:22:05 | 2024-06-18T16:22:05 | Ruiqi He, Yushu He, Longju Bai, Jiarui Liu, Zhenjie Sun, Zenghao Tang, He Wang, Hanchen Xia, Naihao Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing humor datasets and evaluations predominantly focus on English,
lacking resources for culturally nuanced humor in non-English languages like
Chinese. To address this gap, we construct Chumor, a dataset sourced from Ruo
Zhi Ba (RZB), a Chinese Reddit-like platform dedicated to sharing
intellectually challenging and culturally specific jokes. We annotate
explanations for each joke and evaluate human explanations against two
state-of-the-art LLMs, GPT-4o and ERNIE Bot, through A/B testing by native
Chinese speakers. Our evaluation shows that Chumor is challenging even for SOTA
LLMs, and the human explanations for Chumor jokes are significantly better than
explanations generated by the LLMs. | [
0.0493853502,
0.0571989864,
-0.0104423771,
0.0669085011,
0.0319419466,
0.0476537757,
0.0125972088,
0.0089385789,
0.0170996357,
0.0230699256,
-0.0431526378,
-0.0088929115,
0.0222260803,
0.0407704972,
0.0204291902,
-0.0497001782,
-0.0099244248,
0.0079054171,
0.0259120073,
-0.0466012992,
0.0351138785,
0.0109065082,
-0.0262832921,
0.0438129902,
0.0164235681,
-0.0059105437,
0.0002523078,
0.0643850192,
0.0003520628,
-0.0444443859,
-0.0017284912,
0.0012999526,
0.0213471148,
0.0019362989,
0.0000019226,
-0.0262543317,
-0.0024409594,
-0.0356509537,
-0.0580593757,
0.0136831729,
0.0423649102,
-0.0160213709,
-0.025698116,
-0.001338982,
-0.0105829546,
0.0078784963,
0.0537424944,
0.0402894616,
0.0694413409,
0.0656144321,
0.0109023619,
-0.0101615665,
-0.0552573577,
-0.0292439386,
0.0379022397,
-0.0262327287,
0.0096873324,
0.0777777061,
0.0078306701,
-0.0357901193,
-0.0782142729,
-0.0278066117,
0.0093581639,
0.0067927465,
-0.0660851672,
0.036448393,
-0.0197571032,
-0.001292305,
0.0108777126,
0.0657577738,
0.0388820805,
0.010789685,
-0.0008503409,
0.0510988869,
-0.031566754,
-0.0208773818,
-0.0789959207,
-0.0002268386,
-0.0120563945,
-0.0098005235,
-0.0032695464,
0.0061023426,
-0.0010313251,
0.0416091755,
0.0401758552,
-0.0118823862,
-0.0146449097,
0.0016667676,
-0.0548614934,
-0.0263149086,
0.015977677,
-0.0269755255,
0.0617766082,
0.0677329972,
0.0144880759,
0.0508322977,
0.0309158564,
0.0392579436,
0.0543808974,
-0.0434404537,
-0.0131028099,
0.0414898805,
-0.063832432,
0.0946492478,
-0.0119693009,
0.0314031616,
-0.0228291005,
0.0105140209,
-0.0174185783,
-0.0010181154,
-0.0249084551,
0.0078053423,
-0.0116591342,
0.0199907012,
0.0241403207,
0.0175523683,
-0.0445218161,
0.0090282373,
0.0103411647,
-0.0063103694,
0.0184609592,
0.0286883246,
-0.0602882989,
-0.0303341709,
-0.0454257354,
0.0595337637,
-0.0799815059,
0.0021159167,
-0.0446712561,
-0.0538594872,
-0.0470614433,
0.0165346731,
0.0275674593,
-0.0347402357,
-0.0108665163,
0.0478709899,
0.0360761881,
-0.0181038789,
-0.0079290457,
-0.0142579693,
-0.0470170602,
-0.039055109,
0.0335794911,
-0.0471408889,
0.0389616042,
-0.0099631362,
0.0136316251,
-0.0281532649,
0.0257809125,
0.00226124,
0.0097339479,
0.0163557902,
-0.0070678098,
-0.0169902332,
0.0201836899,
0.0339168832,
-0.0654229,
0.0523929335,
-0.0155560812,
-0.0052285823,
0.0553732067,
-0.0281426068,
0.0054817158,
-0.0091222357,
-0.0177323725,
-0.0260448903,
0.0097006308,
0.0228524003,
-0.0170828849,
0.0016394847,
0.0732292086,
-0.0191866755,
-0.0428880453,
0.0092797233,
0.0208510738,
0.0531578101,
-0.0264583118,
0.0480695851,
0.0352089591,
-0.0303891022,
-0.0005028719,
0.0504540578,
-0.0028849605,
0.0581473522,
-0.0413016491,
-0.0313980915,
0.0282236766,
0.0513538122,
-0.0382952839,
-0.069396846,
-0.0271070525,
-0.0020139629,
0.033675503,
-0.0139232809,
0.0282556415,
0.0037927658,
0.0103926565,
0.0181021281,
0.0363375098,
-0.0484778695,
-0.0223460048,
-0.0011740958,
0.0227080602,
0.0869138613,
0.0269946158,
-0.034390606,
-0.0080702966,
0.006627494,
0.0535401367,
0.0435936749,
0.0185862575,
0.0276439916,
0.026077373,
-0.0417902432,
0.0033850616,
-0.0235837232,
0.0022615411,
-0.0037734003,
0.047238782,
0.0533857383,
-0.0046279207,
-0.0068488345,
0.0077660866,
0.0052761273,
-0.0909808129,
0.0066167014,
-0.0138157839,
0.0079681808,
0.0395199172,
0.0042953584,
-0.0083805425,
-0.0326354913,
0.0038387771,
-0.0501265749,
-0.0260618571,
0.0907791853,
-0.0489399023,
-0.0883788094,
0.0618179776,
-0.0920492485,
-0.0343386233,
0.018507652,
-0.0423711576,
-0.0095766494,
0.0428807549,
-0.0317227691,
0.0014736578,
-0.0512709729,
-0.0235692002,
-0.0049427138,
0.0425432287,
0.0328703485,
0.063969098,
-0.030618893,
0.0445635505,
0.0071740146,
-0.0163417421,
0.0227727517,
-0.0025164634,
-0.0131589444,
0.0376590267,
-0.0163326506,
0.0022111149,
-0.0180553626,
0.0275085624,
-0.0307237189,
-0.0196462125,
-0.0530884452,
0.0292364843,
-0.0108391065,
0.0068835001,
0.0570911728,
-0.0164927971,
-0.0163468402,
-0.0307720602,
-0.015687298,
-0.0013024098,
-0.0431358106,
-0.0136931241,
0.0340682901,
-0.0469845273,
-0.0258032568,
-0.0072570862,
-0.0060368525,
-0.0154306348,
-0.0071944236,
-0.0033178439,
0.0160194058,
-0.0306022689,
-0.059258908,
-0.0691878572,
-0.0457636639,
-0.0354526378,
-0.0990251154,
-0.0046076407,
-0.0054559796,
-0.0165921766,
0.0302047972,
0.0428753309,
0.0767769068,
0.0035715448,
0.0000185053,
-0.0049634557,
-0.0046782172,
0.0244078264,
0.0325336419,
0.0031573304,
-0.0728548467,
-0.0541700162,
0.052774772,
0.0188208353,
0.0423527025,
-0.0782385096,
0.0160234533,
-0.0054267189,
0.003790701,
0.0062691248,
-0.025817303,
-0.0443975329,
-0.0065411027,
-0.0548205338,
0.0224390551,
0.0924383402,
-0.0332293585,
-0.0490889475,
-0.0292787459,
-0.0211156569,
-0.0475255214,
0.0888477489,
-0.0431727469,
0.0382075682,
-0.0170069113,
-0.0300679561,
0.0063575269,
0.0444135666,
0.0050797323,
-0.0518590435,
0.0009908633,
-0.001164688,
-0.0216298029,
-0.0191955697,
-0.0106865074,
-0.0163651742,
-0.02740217,
-0.0466496311,
-0.0038982448,
-0.004307027,
0.0041603055,
0.026906427,
0.0102910222,
0.0089716334,
-0.0566571131,
-0.0077222595,
0.0118967239,
0.003813999,
-0.0150942849,
0.0131242359,
0.063403897,
0.0105368085,
0.0244068615,
0.0430290587,
0.0430734865,
-0.0366737396,
-0.0258693118,
0.0412292182,
0.0426401608,
0.0200647786,
0.0038974776,
0.0025072559,
-0.0295276698,
0.0770569071,
-0.0365999229,
-0.0099616805,
0.0745893791,
-0.0062639178,
-0.0066746995,
0.0238102246,
-0.0360485353,
-0.0017291055,
0.0346205533,
0.0055293972,
-0.1257791966,
-0.0410885848,
-0.0006364306,
0.0022564903,
0.0019337271,
-0.0218566153,
-0.0247653164,
-0.124500908,
0.0099085011,
0.0004451158,
-0.0221615359,
-0.0160477366,
-0.0421410389,
0.0035107806,
0.0008266509,
0.0065235808,
-0.0073768725,
0.0053359559,
0.0061049568,
0.0233208667,
-0.0148533173,
-0.0268308315,
0.063021794,
0.0089103896,
0.0501348898,
0.0147118289,
0.043149557,
-0.0017049216,
-0.0213544071,
-0.0257203039,
-0.0456544533,
-0.0082464423,
0.0071598864,
0.0469731018,
0.0070717921,
-0.0187074598,
-0.0287065953,
0.029373372,
-0.0307616387,
0.0223926026,
0.0433448702,
0.0426660031,
-0.0021924647,
-0.0275440086,
0.0021606563,
0.0542630441,
-0.0294091403,
0.1110474095,
0.0738074705,
-0.038114164,
0.0145085985,
-0.0526937433,
-0.035456311,
-0.0431013405,
-0.0274014138,
0.0371683128,
-0.025547605,
-0.0230754595,
-0.083049722,
-0.0252883434,
0.0008021609,
0.0099495351,
-0.0126469983,
-0.0283181276,
-0.0773557052,
0.0266879722,
0.0001195268,
-0.0068412749,
-0.0056476779,
-0.009952547,
-0.0428564139,
0.0068615736,
0.0287248325,
-0.0848890767,
0.0031396651,
0.0359908305,
-0.0682430193,
-0.026603004,
0.0365774743,
0.0311042741,
0.0155869285,
-0.0094006583,
-0.0056038969,
-0.0252438392,
0.0036460357,
0.0367382281,
-0.0424638391,
0.002211927,
0.0413818061,
0.0431304201,
0.0274882279,
0.0306392796,
-0.0364603326,
0.0307400078,
-0.0080267182,
0.0414309464,
-0.0467888936,
-0.0133466739,
0.0005869754,
-0.0025737647,
0.0015555988,
-0.0014953065,
-0.0683667138,
0.0123276683,
0.0539590232,
-0.007181251,
-0.0169964954,
-0.0361012332,
-0.0452396385,
0.015141,
-0.0391733833,
-0.0267048869,
-0.0111937802,
-0.0015855768,
-0.0040830132,
-0.0089148032,
0.0341203026,
0.04314119,
0.0004286494,
-0.0458040163,
0.0354774296,
-0.0386440232,
0.0094924076,
0.0077228532,
0.0051367478,
-0.0031312676,
0.0848140493,
0.0008922311,
-0.0013151243,
0.0715086758,
0.0123855816,
-0.0053690667,
-0.0472098887,
0.0404383391,
0.0062219165,
0.0750354528,
-0.0061231782,
0.0809962973,
0.0070970473,
0.0017791254,
0.0077311448,
0.0196715575,
0.0005789938,
-0.0524249934,
0.0269598383,
0.0102125024,
-0.0019688196,
-0.0380278639,
0.1216696203,
-0.0581637397,
0.044663582,
0.0415033177,
0.0057891342,
-0.0117921373,
-0.0153375491,
0.0068763583,
0.0023059177,
0.0379937626,
-0.0034652331,
-0.0418374352,
-0.0746284649,
-0.0415301584,
-0.0084218541,
-0.006378829,
0.0091762841,
-0.0028885154,
0.0300399493,
-0.0002630526,
0.0225168709,
-0.0123724015,
0.0331628248,
-0.0462911129,
0.0204545073,
0.0306112282,
-7.05809126e-33,
-0.0120087471,
-0.049268093,
-0.0298911538,
0.0007276765,
0.0196886305,
-0.004033688,
-0.0809168443,
0.0304459333,
-0.0322219841,
0.004839336,
0.0128894141,
0.0109047573,
0.0032198431,
0.0031637568,
0.0051199012,
-0.0516554825,
0.0193643495,
0.0284077469,
-0.0057868855,
0.0032079883,
0.0477559157,
0.0419871919,
0.0475888923,
-0.0498050675,
0.0259702485,
-0.011764491,
-0.0222372357,
0.031410899,
0.0652814656,
0.0566674583,
-0.0285223331,
0.0665890202,
0.0428574272,
0.0085999733,
-0.0111095905,
-0.0372762941,
-0.0954542458,
-0.0577790551,
0.0215301067,
0.005089819,
-0.0313488357,
-0.0215849075,
0.0467082076,
-0.0154802799,
0.0371917784,
0.0074557099,
0.0489909872,
-0.054145705,
0.0567156598,
0.0078545157,
0.0189753827,
0.0146878883,
-0.0625130162,
-0.0281634834,
0.0089920731,
0.0376827419,
0.0261263475,
0.0148399146,
-0.0405736938,
0.0076930672,
-0.0543100983,
0.0154465334,
-0.0041127652,
-0.071676515,
0.0215455592,
0.0396355502,
0.003819268,
0.03178408,
-0.0242267027,
-0.0439091623,
-0.0215560813,
0.0469556004,
0.0468830131,
0.057224717,
0.0613916256,
-0.0451527759,
-0.0535994135,
0.0389479734,
0.071073398,
0.0113915931,
0.0077154967,
0.0293598473,
-0.0467529893,
0.0185273737,
0.0368594155,
0.0278378613,
-0.0092209689,
-0.1028588712,
-0.0200662017,
0.0200201385,
-0.0452919379,
-0.0253577176,
0.0337903574,
-0.0452424325,
-0.0098046325,
0.0186749529,
0.0086095463,
-0.0237717759,
0.0225383881,
0.0020210173,
-0.0401289426,
-0.0179083738,
0.0034837693,
0.026415946,
0.019669909,
-0.0059653148,
0.0701013207,
0.0072593428,
-0.0210594982,
0.0176297445,
-0.0492000058,
-0.0016622603,
-0.0179847982,
-0.0034956818,
0.0081729777,
0.0356342569,
-0.0385473408,
-0.0353118479,
0.0715498626,
0.0261904895,
-0.0438719764,
-0.0115009444,
-0.024824407,
0.0126190018,
-0.0704336241,
-0.0237582214,
-0.0105636688,
-0.0377551802,
-0.0050090584,
-0.0750916749,
-0.0056953933,
-0.0327668302,
2.725e-7,
0.0441800728,
-0.0018071545,
0.0551030189,
0.0312339235,
0.0491283908,
-0.0045584887,
-0.0337227732,
0.0180518795,
-0.0114118075,
-0.0152488397,
0.0049775722,
0.0518817864,
0.0483204797,
0.0328074358,
-0.0813555643,
0.0286542475,
-0.0656253919,
0.0285985284,
-0.0102369925,
0.0071026897,
0.0184188094,
0.0354246423,
0.0020371028,
0.0073697963,
-0.0147030121,
-0.0374134779,
0.016443789,
-0.0121407006,
0.0566644967,
-0.0038513415,
0.0177977737,
0.0013071886,
-0.0279512834,
-0.047929734,
0.0137233557,
-0.0549157858,
0.0256392304,
0.057974793,
0.0055479081,
-0.0443167053,
0.0170843378,
0.0179734081,
0.0272590276,
-0.0576762408,
0.0590196848,
0.0593540706,
-0.0557067581,
0.030611461,
0.0026701323,
-0.0406373851,
0.0387427546,
0.017346343,
-0.0212947652,
0.0324071646,
0.0046747481,
-0.0211704262,
0.0235647559,
-0.0494409874,
-0.0638548508,
-0.0145727647,
-0.0422148779,
-0.0202010516,
0.0118904738,
-0.0324946009,
-0.0098185576,
-0.0549003296,
-0.0017420895,
2.011682028e-34,
-0.0122833513,
0.0037602086,
-0.0004486265,
0.001328434,
0.0575325824,
-0.0187162105,
0.0157350861,
-0.0283534713,
0.0351214632,
0.0017936779,
-0.0383814126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12753v1 | OlympicArena: Benchmarking Multi-discipline Cognitive Reasoning for Superintelligent AI | 2024-06-18T16:20:53 | 2024-06-18T16:20:53 | Zhen Huang, Zengzhi Wang, Shijie Xia, Xuefeng Li, Haoyang Zou, Ruijie Xu, Run-Ze Fan, Lyumanshan Ye, Ethan Chern, Yixin Ye, Yikai Zhang, Yuqing Yang, Ting Wu, Binjie Wang, Shichao Sun, Yang Xiao, Yiyuan Li, Fan Zhou, Steffi Chern, Yiwei Qin, Yan Ma, Jiadi Su, Yixiu Liu, Yuxiang Zheng, Shaoting Zhang, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been significantly
accelerated by advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large
Multimodal Models (LMMs), gradually showcasing potential cognitive reasoning
abilities in problem-solving and scientific discovery (i.e., AI4Science) once
exclusive to human intellect. To comprehensively evaluate current models'
performance in cognitive reasoning abilities, we introduce OlympicArena, which
includes 11,163 bilingual problems across both text-only and interleaved
text-image modalities. These challenges encompass a wide range of disciplines
spanning seven fields and 62 international Olympic competitions, rigorously
examined for data leakage. We argue that the challenges in Olympic competition
problems are ideal for evaluating AI's cognitive reasoning due to their
complexity and interdisciplinary nature, which are essential for tackling
complex scientific challenges and facilitating discoveries. Beyond evaluating
performance across various disciplines using answer-only criteria, we conduct
detailed experiments and analyses from multiple perspectives. We delve into the
models' cognitive reasoning abilities, their performance across different
modalities, and their outcomes in process-level evaluations, which are vital
for tasks requiring complex reasoning with lengthy solutions. Our extensive
evaluations reveal that even advanced models like GPT-4o only achieve a 39.97%
overall accuracy, illustrating current AI limitations in complex reasoning and
multimodal integration. Through the OlympicArena, we aim to advance AI towards
superintelligence, equipping it to address more complex challenges in science
and beyond. We also provide a comprehensive set of resources to support AI
research, including a benchmark dataset, an open-source annotation platform, a
detailed evaluation tool, and a leaderboard with automatic submission features. | [
-0.0003683718,
0.0685341656,
-0.0325050689,
0.0565647632,
-0.0609712712,
0.0134627689,
0.065351598,
0.0008210313,
0.0388956554,
-0.0272818971,
-0.033801876,
-0.0004341957,
-0.0121597955,
0.0277481787,
0.0227350462,
-0.0286072735,
0.0258642361,
-0.0769078135,
0.0304120183,
-0.034669809,
-0.0346421227,
-0.011987932,
-0.0274982993,
0.0152617944,
-0.0102738608,
-0.028359523,
0.0012877595,
-0.0330198891,
0.0116352001,
-0.0170889311,
-0.0407559089,
0.050396774,
0.0372475684,
0.069122836,
0.0000021384,
-0.0528066941,
-0.0042242599,
0.0065377653,
-0.0182467103,
-0.0008427974,
-0.0124539146,
0.0035107022,
0.0030382597,
-0.0195757728,
-0.0469065011,
0.0634514466,
0.0473915264,
0.034296982,
0.0467712842,
0.0275064446,
-0.0013288716,
-0.0287167039,
0.0488220565,
-0.0049311873,
0.0210618544,
-0.0442108326,
0.0035589128,
0.0330530219,
0.019628806,
0.0157461409,
-0.0009560631,
0.0500843972,
0.0355602652,
0.0060197115,
-0.0572284609,
0.0210603215,
-0.0171178058,
-0.0301661212,
0.0000391535,
0.0593864806,
-0.0127060506,
0.0017229003,
-0.0233623851,
0.0259266961,
-0.0020448649,
0.00356251,
-0.0630642176,
0.0568430386,
0.0084686326,
-0.0148740215,
0.0266266167,
0.0102951266,
0.0139486026,
0.0215498358,
-0.0469424687,
0.115471676,
0.0147263035,
-0.0098971035,
0.0192552935,
-0.0001137533,
-0.0444761291,
-0.0544748604,
0.0210196637,
0.02174991,
-0.0243744291,
-0.0037219496,
-0.0056751342,
-0.0506614298,
0.009088302,
-0.0183631591,
0.0469083376,
0.0322261341,
0.013986934,
0.0728726909,
0.0021699655,
0.0842539743,
-0.0548016913,
0.0402095392,
-0.0157628059,
-0.0412863716,
-0.0585654899,
-0.0247524176,
0.011152002,
0.0177720971,
-0.0212449692,
0.0015112738,
-0.0095004551,
0.0055818078,
-0.0215428378,
0.0109120123,
-0.0247369334,
0.0017770065,
0.001131552,
-0.0341446288,
-0.0522882342,
0.0254849046,
-0.0504585467,
0.0189496689,
-0.0005857514,
-0.007672545,
-0.0082380231,
0.01676156,
-0.0265777893,
-0.050107643,
0.0241061412,
0.1028375626,
-0.0143064847,
-0.0009402967,
0.0090718949,
-0.0475172438,
-0.0028593279,
-0.1260054857,
0.0530129373,
-0.0612908565,
0.0670052618,
0.0153802112,
-0.0232524071,
-0.0686627924,
-0.0030316566,
0.0060420078,
-0.0434857085,
0.0898805335,
-0.0017590218,
-0.0042730076,
0.0426393338,
0.0228606295,
-0.0144549599,
0.0482131578,
0.0322107747,
0.0243120436,
0.0545117781,
0.0051802536,
0.0175694078,
0.0221583638,
0.0116319563,
-0.0077146995,
-0.0068788524,
-0.000954438,
0.0085593462,
0.0519176237,
-0.0058193584,
0.0476655625,
-0.0036779915,
-0.0323667824,
0.0646677539,
0.0724657923,
-0.0555850863,
0.0076190135,
0.0461217836,
-0.0509448126,
0.0245223027,
0.0167092364,
-0.05894069,
0.0776722208,
-0.041377753,
-0.0271933898,
0.0169308744,
0.0291208252,
-0.0131549537,
-0.0583885647,
-0.0100293336,
0.0157906078,
0.0112388991,
0.0245890208,
0.0575643778,
-0.0386707671,
-0.0011184032,
-0.0123659372,
-0.0093371002,
-0.0449951664,
-0.0243430138,
-0.0274114423,
0.0156328622,
0.0497679412,
0.0262488369,
-0.023068672,
-0.0136639131,
0.0163393542,
0.0366434641,
0.0352426171,
0.0401439369,
0.0065062195,
0.0081714997,
-0.026379304,
-0.0044718413,
-0.0428259373,
0.0020615105,
0.0092409467,
-0.0397079736,
0.0155063998,
-0.01770816,
-0.026840087,
0.0014310377,
0.0235978663,
-0.0527580678,
0.0124935387,
-0.0414248817,
0.0014311078,
0.0246698912,
0.0032199051,
-0.0068793753,
0.0205559731,
0.0447637886,
-0.0384284891,
-0.0277493559,
0.0160988588,
0.0036868486,
0.0102056824,
0.0451241508,
-0.0993994772,
-0.0285950247,
0.0143961729,
-0.0235378742,
-0.020459732,
0.0464324355,
-0.0168736018,
-0.0052272859,
-0.0152548924,
0.0166884717,
-0.0259334818,
0.0044125048,
-0.026723681,
0.0804963633,
-0.0134625658,
-0.0006299579,
0.0187917575,
-0.0181339215,
0.0568518639,
-0.0536181889,
-0.0253530741,
0.0440664738,
0.0204705354,
-0.0224935636,
0.0039296439,
-0.0163973998,
-0.0294076875,
-0.0107916892,
-0.1067081094,
0.0091247661,
-0.0021504192,
-0.0003311362,
0.0033277934,
-0.046691414,
0.0058238432,
0.0250042975,
-0.0104020787,
-0.0030964992,
-0.0016945006,
0.0163412262,
0.0404129811,
-0.0101041887,
0.0245806538,
-0.0199828986,
-0.0223251898,
-0.0592276268,
0.0737527311,
0.0371928401,
0.0097244503,
-0.0382624567,
-0.0153968604,
-0.0557566769,
0.0442172885,
-0.0303052478,
-0.040769022,
0.0428872146,
-0.0015114356,
0.018638799,
0.1051832736,
-0.0058982042,
0.0026194793,
0.0670255125,
-0.0302718896,
-0.0273868144,
0.0363649614,
0.0148914438,
-0.0209591296,
-0.0231088512,
-0.0378492847,
-0.02758714,
0.0472420491,
-0.0115946596,
-0.0097508999,
-0.0097150467,
0.0468822308,
-0.0264047161,
-0.0477173291,
-0.0252261702,
-0.0106059276,
0.0222756267,
0.0836854726,
-0.0232807808,
-0.0077513927,
0.0785948709,
-0.0186891779,
0.0269945543,
-0.048382625,
0.015238923,
-0.0216465294,
0.0893780217,
0.0110608572,
0.0408979766,
-0.016994562,
0.0529420823,
-0.0726665184,
0.0100181857,
0.0063418709,
-0.0163924694,
0.0164912399,
-0.0690988004,
-0.0147471456,
0.0051791701,
-0.0705208033,
-0.0186321102,
0.0354752652,
-0.0302621648,
0.0107213696,
0.0109709706,
-0.0437443219,
-0.0664553568,
-0.0055298745,
0.0697076321,
-0.0178713221,
-0.0156734381,
0.0073793642,
-0.0089306487,
0.0101361498,
0.0299816765,
0.0483422913,
0.0370489545,
-0.051892627,
0.0289980471,
0.058465194,
0.0140308263,
0.002383624,
-0.0091153076,
0.0378419198,
0.0020802347,
0.0107411016,
-0.0132490043,
-0.0036704889,
0.0803371742,
-0.0512246639,
0.0182261914,
0.0819551125,
0.0409979895,
-0.0417705365,
0.0021647864,
-0.0047831465,
-0.0348218679,
0.025021147,
0.029976733,
-0.0583928116,
-0.0457654446,
0.0110448198,
-0.0193505455,
-0.0185536146,
-0.0592551343,
-0.0181352105,
-0.0764088184,
0.0416829474,
0.0020719301,
-0.014677098,
-0.0593898892,
-0.0269780979,
-0.0129979895,
-0.0006619437,
-0.0154653843,
-0.0064737834,
0.0473735631,
-0.0112465099,
-0.0285697933,
0.0192797575,
-0.0308294035,
0.0450381897,
-0.0218324084,
0.0114652673,
0.0337330438,
0.0403660648,
-0.0317275152,
-0.0634626523,
0.0356740579,
-0.0059539587,
0.0030379766,
0.0010663056,
0.0559639521,
0.0277776532,
0.0030939849,
-0.0151005425,
0.0423176773,
-0.0254285056,
-0.0389485508,
0.0362969413,
0.1299428493,
-0.0105411382,
-0.0184424818,
-0.0315311477,
-0.0076319901,
-0.0376896411,
0.0693336651,
0.0047229715,
-0.0422625281,
-0.0501268581,
-0.0412242264,
0.001265095,
-0.0672703534,
-0.0398199297,
0.0344576612,
0.0604900755,
-0.0261043962,
-0.0505921505,
-0.0271981359,
0.029251907,
0.0170603245,
0.0188183431,
-0.0242891051,
-0.0193474386,
0.0044067865,
-0.0581548847,
0.0531672314,
-0.0120595824,
0.0294352695,
-0.0295232404,
0.0134354737,
-0.0037977293,
-0.04854903,
-0.023718413,
0.0721056759,
-0.0632708371,
-0.0548053645,
-0.0167974923,
0.0525077134,
0.0286423303,
-0.002723193,
-0.0058532837,
-0.0437791161,
-0.0021403362,
-0.0072762016,
-0.0206164513,
0.0120053887,
0.0070917732,
-0.0000284515,
0.0012721493,
0.0106502809,
-0.0100383423,
0.0156471934,
0.0309282709,
0.0026676324,
-0.0455326736,
0.0011125465,
0.038887389,
0.0244128313,
0.0393801369,
0.0043166601,
-0.0144708669,
-0.0073879343,
-0.0057234322,
-0.0293719023,
-0.0358301736,
-0.0322022997,
-0.0049878694,
-0.0016014775,
0.00771299,
0.0288198646,
0.0066591203,
0.0283098258,
-0.0008961847,
-0.019086929,
0.0262778793,
0.0251949318,
0.0267371219,
-0.0232758913,
0.0194587223,
0.0016447118,
0.0309948623,
-0.037223164,
0.0632538944,
-0.0229399018,
0.0791291073,
0.0303796008,
-0.0073708859,
-0.0158503689,
0.0388822109,
-0.0786548257,
-0.0570143126,
0.0348522812,
0.0476117507,
0.090637289,
0.039573729,
-0.0190273188,
-0.0365910269,
-0.0110414773,
-0.0070031704,
0.0128934756,
0.0347277969,
-0.0170420483,
0.0182823706,
0.028904438,
0.0079832124,
-0.0142488377,
0.0520102046,
-0.0221979152,
0.0227016043,
-0.0113743488,
-0.0065852869,
-0.015853066,
-0.0442349836,
-0.0253399331,
0.0315101817,
0.0059966971,
-0.0101277251,
-0.0542934425,
-0.0740288273,
-0.025273107,
0.0417094417,
-0.0142410267,
0.0282562003,
0.0170335285,
0.0687330738,
-0.0223487336,
-0.05839644,
-0.001582196,
-0.0008264002,
-0.0292596072,
-0.0316283591,
-0.0234092083,
-6.431217755e-33,
0.0001336266,
-0.0647768155,
0.030993674,
-0.0277398024,
0.0027602927,
-0.0066989153,
-0.0388549566,
-0.0015941971,
-0.0568205453,
0.0166007597,
-0.0125349239,
-0.0144438036,
-0.0162784103,
-0.0265938751,
0.0200187229,
0.0033179615,
-0.0083122188,
-0.0077370596,
-0.0370699205,
0.0091071203,
0.0435431674,
-0.028876733,
0.0177396033,
-0.0651879981,
0.0032390647,
0.0125832641,
-0.0249267444,
0.0374060981,
-0.0640921742,
0.0628234297,
-0.0354002267,
0.013688379,
0.0371531285,
-0.0288486611,
0.0059801443,
-0.0119614825,
-0.0327091478,
-0.0378968157,
0.0063245567,
-0.0087566497,
-0.0618668161,
-0.0621878132,
0.0364217646,
-0.022400273,
-0.0243643057,
-0.0390281379,
0.0441523194,
-0.0193178821,
0.04536926,
0.0315364562,
-0.0452886745,
-0.0016674668,
-0.0440572724,
0.0111232987,
0.0216217693,
0.0296198912,
0.0134390909,
0.0326454267,
-0.0735273808,
0.0518749692,
-0.0274385754,
-0.0381822474,
0.0905695483,
-0.0314227082,
0.0190241635,
0.0403179042,
0.0383299775,
-0.0038330881,
-0.0151069006,
-0.0159367919,
0.0093937228,
0.0693522394,
0.1076010019,
0.0420288928,
0.0112061929,
0.006450017,
-0.0613999516,
0.0000881742,
0.0187820289,
0.0156996045,
0.0120456964,
0.0029828933,
-0.0397657603,
0.0037116236,
-0.0317696705,
-0.0157122053,
-0.0441562384,
-0.013434629,
0.0163604263,
-0.0574848354,
0.0129594812,
-0.0059366557,
0.0614339523,
-0.0437246449,
0.0133719295,
0.0211298671,
0.0136455931,
0.0558764674,
0.0209593903,
0.0502973758,
-0.0270872768,
-0.0130390273,
-0.0123955281,
0.0232342221,
0.0576773584,
-0.0000425105,
0.0098040393,
0.0112098046,
0.0181102641,
-0.0149017321,
-0.049222637,
-0.0255148709,
0.0432130024,
-0.0169250239,
0.0167281069,
0.027367752,
-0.0106916996,
-0.0158699043,
0.0259237606,
0.0201197229,
-0.029299723,
-0.0007568317,
-0.0290630981,
0.0163778216,
-0.0217791479,
-0.0263999514,
-0.0509989522,
-0.0005901798,
-0.0154945347,
-0.0652661771,
-0.0137528609,
0.0581985377,
2.888e-7,
0.0499083698,
0.0647766814,
-0.02873661,
-0.0071909348,
0.0332053825,
0.0441113748,
-0.0464840345,
-0.0168736428,
0.0115654701,
0.0127684865,
-0.0174623858,
0.0683375448,
0.0385358036,
0.0584368184,
-0.0420553274,
-0.0213713646,
0.0273375344,
-0.0465373211,
-0.1050622687,
0.0400487445,
0.0828261003,
0.0472594351,
0.0360103324,
-0.0089947488,
0.0119044473,
-0.0523800924,
0.0432257056,
0.0030546326,
0.0131852478,
0.005288031,
-0.0135270087,
0.0234634038,
-0.0162618905,
0.0726721585,
0.0005111531,
-0.0152587928,
0.0217090435,
0.0181500446,
-0.005994197,
-0.0265141316,
-0.0056353854,
-0.0047862059,
-0.0164663065,
-0.0801857188,
0.0975124538,
-0.0440002643,
-0.063110359,
-0.0037086029,
-0.0041066152,
-0.0175125655,
0.0246769357,
-0.0014408749,
-0.0111165913,
0.0216084905,
-0.0020217763,
-0.0047688605,
0.0005243162,
-0.071195215,
0.015800124,
0.0106075238,
-0.0608977266,
-0.0359514244,
-0.0482578874,
-0.0106198657,
0.0667898208,
-0.0520863272,
-0.0064439285,
2.688549583e-34,
-0.0003156509,
-0.0275486596,
0.0208522379,
-0.0287951268,
0.058487393,
-0.0131126335,
-0.0327242948,
-0.0037435251,
0.0089162886,
-0.0747138262,
-0.0107329227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12746v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12746v3 | Rationale-based Ensemble of Multiple QA Strategies for Zero-shot Knowledge-based VQA | 2024-06-18T16:06:38 | 2024-06-23T03:06:42 | Miaoyu Li, Haoxin Li, Zilin Du, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-based Visual Qustion-answering (K-VQA) necessitates the use of
background knowledge beyond what is depicted in the image. Current zero-shot
K-VQA methods usually translate an image to a single type of textual decision
context and use a text-based model to answer the question based on it, which
conflicts with the fact that K-VQA questions often require the combination of
multiple question-answering strategies. In light of this, we propose
Rationale-based Ensemble of Answer Context Tactics (REACT) to achieve a dynamic
ensemble of multiple question-answering tactics, comprising Answer Candidate
Generation (ACG) and Rationale-based Strategy Fusion (RSF). In ACG, we generate
three distinctive decision contexts to provide different strategies for each
question, resulting in the generation of three answer candidates. RSF generates
automatic and mechanistic rationales from decision contexts for each candidate,
allowing the model to select the correct answer from all candidates. We conduct
comprehensive experiments on the OK-VQA and A-OKVQA datasets, and our method
significantly outperforms state-of-the-art LLM-based baselines on all datasets. | [
0.0112538887,
0.0467308275,
0.0042756908,
0.0225906875,
-0.0076705036,
0.0074219238,
0.0262561515,
0.0206460077,
-0.0394847915,
-0.051755622,
-0.0022802157,
-0.0102276532,
-0.0123518109,
0.0233150013,
0.0258914139,
-0.0381043181,
0.0153191863,
-0.019734947,
0.0009811709,
-0.0134862605,
0.0066959714,
0.0129940975,
-0.0222354103,
0.0414880179,
-0.0108219218,
-0.0442673899,
-0.0497523136,
-0.0162103754,
0.0572491214,
-0.030097194,
-0.036708612,
0.0241590198,
0.0417888127,
-0.0181775317,
0.0000020036,
-0.0340589397,
-0.0221725609,
-0.0096323658,
-0.0530019253,
-0.0345960185,
-0.036642991,
0.030009402,
0.0309619326,
0.0346365273,
-0.0513956137,
0.0150904525,
0.0685489774,
0.0438324697,
0.0571058989,
0.0238012206,
-0.0043142196,
-0.0229731873,
-0.0239115842,
-0.0096862158,
0.0248832479,
-0.0468766242,
-0.0062994407,
0.0161487199,
0.0227213334,
-0.000706715,
-0.0181811303,
0.0160428341,
0.0046275049,
-0.0241662227,
-0.0045071915,
0.0441160053,
-0.0117833596,
0.0128888823,
-0.0143733965,
0.107489109,
-0.0009848117,
0.0193178523,
-0.0041643679,
-0.0059418036,
0.0128672877,
0.0092955688,
-0.0679798946,
0.0609703548,
-0.0015212896,
-0.0021998701,
-0.0351284631,
0.0462451801,
-0.01063288,
0.005649359,
-0.0281614009,
0.0148601541,
-0.0094395317,
0.004587383,
-0.0059087151,
0.0195044912,
-0.031592492,
-0.0815766528,
-0.0783847943,
0.0986978933,
-0.0294256117,
0.0277654808,
0.0049971459,
0.0023220237,
0.026641544,
0.0003478267,
0.041902829,
0.0460815281,
0.0040754993,
0.0511960387,
-0.0133998506,
0.0469285361,
-0.0039618309,
-0.0184824523,
-0.0416734032,
-0.014231354,
-0.0661800802,
-0.0212865602,
-0.0075677061,
0.0676168054,
-0.0751953945,
-0.0416504778,
-0.0294725243,
0.0362969339,
-0.0328402296,
0.0055012135,
0.0060979957,
0.089680858,
0.0077123595,
0.0260674581,
-0.0452007651,
0.0435464121,
-0.0525883771,
0.0110738659,
0.0098772123,
-0.0233419277,
-0.003815881,
0.0362585559,
0.0314346589,
-0.0192504376,
-0.0164337121,
0.0569056496,
-0.0577398166,
0.0180885475,
-0.0111320764,
-0.0543906055,
-0.0161669608,
-0.0310665593,
-0.0033109526,
-0.0412885994,
0.0130770411,
-0.0165521,
-0.0241692029,
0.0015603311,
0.0112501225,
0.0377370231,
-0.008265499,
0.0823338777,
0.0110428967,
-0.0134679684,
0.0216093585,
0.026285138,
0.0077092252,
0.0925601721,
-0.0039931661,
0.0242061689,
0.0324520059,
-0.0100963628,
0.0206523538,
0.0074725575,
-0.0007121988,
0.0181739796,
-0.0371294804,
0.0405124538,
-0.014915728,
0.0215759017,
-0.0011490844,
-0.0045230067,
-0.0480757095,
-0.0107388962,
0.0071793948,
0.0421437956,
0.049673304,
-0.0347635336,
0.0051156282,
-0.0030002284,
0.0121697765,
-0.0169022586,
0.0014419263,
0.087476097,
-0.0491582491,
0.0168896113,
-0.0089565935,
0.0442731641,
-0.0356646664,
-0.0374139249,
0.0001767078,
0.0146105057,
-0.0135086952,
0.0322405621,
0.0091339722,
0.0022874125,
-0.0471410491,
-0.0158161316,
-0.0245138891,
-0.0406971686,
-0.0209681652,
-0.0389819257,
0.0964576751,
0.0366316326,
0.0357664265,
-0.0038322299,
-0.0644860342,
-0.0038126749,
-0.0119288787,
0.0119448472,
-0.030984344,
-0.0353661105,
0.0163261928,
-0.0420877412,
-0.0754121616,
-0.0603521764,
-0.0163292307,
0.0004658006,
0.0163930431,
0.0413153172,
-0.0172915887,
-0.0058081425,
0.0629103109,
0.0194403976,
0.0401543342,
-0.0277848858,
0.0368895754,
0.0049587255,
0.0064004143,
0.0202742685,
-0.0035904977,
0.0106161842,
0.012502417,
-0.009803771,
-0.0301417653,
0.0202942602,
-0.0280948523,
-0.0638368428,
0.0283254553,
-0.0232915301,
0.001481718,
-0.0299215168,
-0.0592042543,
-0.0446540825,
0.0032325592,
0.0229974911,
-0.0413883813,
-0.0305925217,
-0.036725577,
0.0238095988,
0.0067839106,
-0.0240354463,
0.0730556399,
-0.0002477037,
-0.0456798859,
0.0289474837,
0.004724714,
0.0381752402,
-0.0279764105,
0.0431046337,
0.0172800273,
-0.0082545616,
0.0097643016,
-0.0166390594,
0.0378751643,
-0.0474996381,
0.0117495479,
-0.0840073973,
-0.0017792203,
-0.0126511892,
-0.0306748226,
0.0166912302,
-0.0103104832,
0.0116911046,
-0.0119579844,
-0.0548176616,
0.0400421061,
0.0059065279,
-0.0003521814,
0.0438337326,
0.0135882506,
0.0524982251,
-0.0038935617,
0.0117289172,
0.0056639933,
0.0845821798,
0.0095971571,
0.0465661511,
-0.0102082947,
0.0007396456,
-0.0642059743,
0.0178546924,
0.0084123909,
-0.0084914984,
0.0420286246,
-0.012366022,
-0.017038919,
0.0541161001,
0.0012798682,
-0.0000313501,
0.0242742635,
-0.0031281929,
-0.0446318686,
0.0252195429,
0.0068966942,
-0.0063456856,
0.0261878818,
-0.0240174253,
-0.0174068362,
0.0007245686,
-0.0277993269,
-0.0065615983,
-0.069632858,
0.0730431154,
0.0478032157,
-0.0288246702,
-0.1108894721,
-0.0115453741,
0.0095863072,
0.072953485,
-0.0102732414,
-0.0048084501,
0.0538369864,
0.0151856607,
0.0106723038,
-0.0031558378,
0.0026436362,
-0.057444185,
0.0498902872,
-0.0479039177,
0.002763046,
0.008066847,
0.0283973906,
-0.0426403955,
-0.0974390134,
0.0128277391,
-0.0213988964,
0.0663268566,
-0.0528489985,
-0.009210852,
-0.0138904313,
-0.0066418909,
-0.0769548938,
-0.0176117923,
-0.0369484276,
0.0248759929,
-0.072102882,
-0.028671518,
-0.0133181158,
0.0244675893,
0.0438851751,
-0.0078053689,
-0.0120355738,
-0.017487321,
0.0109484727,
0.0930811167,
0.1008483768,
0.0567482971,
-0.0005708393,
-0.0018998238,
0.0853435919,
0.0728603974,
0.0222882498,
-0.0012468114,
-0.0101901423,
0.0055359239,
0.0122547057,
0.0003855665,
0.0118308272,
0.027470706,
0.0397680514,
-0.0223791879,
0.0188561864,
0.0629721135,
0.0324403942,
-0.0114815943,
-0.0159538239,
-0.050702747,
0.0281682312,
0.0301670972,
0.0610630661,
-0.1245385855,
-0.04790546,
-0.0372762159,
0.0187915564,
-0.02960453,
-0.0048990576,
-0.0169041585,
-0.1204415932,
0.0494978018,
-0.0103505813,
-0.0521412976,
0.0427557528,
-0.0072228685,
-0.0009404849,
-0.0351865701,
-0.0280431695,
-0.0037197506,
-0.0002859812,
0.0167168546,
0.0003126985,
0.0321564451,
0.0027894862,
0.0322876163,
-0.0167167336,
-0.0164672174,
0.0444667824,
0.0320778526,
0.0002877085,
-0.0785734132,
-0.0416645482,
-0.0893520564,
0.0393254198,
-0.0091997851,
0.036424201,
-0.0047026579,
-0.0094128335,
0.0074779745,
0.0599973276,
0.0000904839,
-0.0335520022,
0.0366244055,
0.0529516377,
-0.0417020358,
-0.0045500016,
-0.0369100943,
0.0133266971,
0.0236574486,
0.0362761728,
0.0174389817,
-0.0186748225,
-0.0471605062,
-0.0090674572,
-0.0108649945,
-0.0969436094,
-0.0175830554,
-0.0276933666,
0.0317748152,
0.0100321937,
-0.0678215399,
-0.0159196984,
0.0719725788,
0.0723770708,
-0.0282872412,
-0.0006913068,
-0.0429356396,
0.0405847877,
-0.024629293,
0.0045823371,
0.0058393162,
0.0289996415,
0.0143575957,
0.0417877212,
0.0106637785,
-0.0630290285,
-0.0174662657,
-0.0348855667,
0.0227748286,
-0.0226492956,
-0.0515037216,
0.0584462583,
0.0150157176,
0.01356347,
0.0246643778,
-0.0269059055,
0.076640591,
0.0398094431,
0.0690135732,
-0.0002575305,
0.0078401044,
0.0205381289,
-0.0167273395,
-0.0097716451,
-0.0324989669,
0.0002313688,
-0.0110497968,
0.0467912257,
-0.0755078346,
-0.0042624855,
0.0090522217,
-0.0372212268,
-0.0320301019,
-0.0193517376,
-0.010646861,
0.0018107364,
0.0273449048,
-0.0078180442,
0.000662362,
-0.0323320441,
0.0030567781,
0.0060980446,
-0.0619523302,
0.0407973789,
-0.0254510958,
-0.0533130504,
0.0145685095,
-0.0178305842,
0.0157692935,
0.0523459204,
0.0252225269,
-0.0230921563,
0.016459832,
0.0103523899,
0.0024908439,
-0.0033330959,
0.0532510132,
0.0141810849,
0.1039036587,
0.0260877609,
-0.0282750409,
-0.0223227981,
0.0338805243,
-0.0433340818,
-0.0532500073,
0.0072943429,
0.0198427588,
0.0502631925,
0.0207490884,
-0.0136088459,
0.0283200294,
-0.0271332059,
0.0302225444,
-0.0188419726,
0.003619066,
-0.0326372832,
0.0724793598,
0.0421951637,
-0.0011798694,
-0.0033470392,
0.0632941201,
-0.0287981555,
0.0049033486,
-0.0285748933,
-0.0010623349,
-0.0260221455,
-0.0044246376,
0.0317980275,
0.0469690599,
0.035435468,
0.0117976302,
-0.0777261779,
-0.0362796076,
0.0128817232,
0.0051637786,
-0.0392250121,
0.0040395604,
0.0371966623,
-0.0067440411,
0.0489113964,
-0.0222239159,
-0.0329679176,
0.0109830406,
-0.0715000704,
-0.0109700812,
0.0001296286,
-6.351882172e-33,
0.0023386751,
-0.0782436356,
0.0492492281,
-0.0657616034,
-0.0161000136,
0.0234703422,
0.0011444662,
-0.0286392812,
-0.0292140469,
-0.0057367817,
-0.01731872,
-0.0303532872,
-0.0069723749,
0.0241144951,
-0.00799172,
-0.0054427898,
-0.007000146,
-0.002451794,
-0.0241779257,
0.0221800879,
0.04175191,
-0.0377295539,
0.000981823,
-0.0156024117,
-0.0149943186,
0.0244910643,
-0.0333764926,
0.0393640846,
-0.0328896977,
0.0778277293,
-0.0162985381,
0.0014592008,
0.0129128359,
-0.0508832969,
0.01823177,
0.0266050752,
-0.0381414369,
-0.06291008,
0.0336388201,
-0.0324191824,
-0.0633612052,
-0.0173003841,
-0.0250034221,
-0.0061739939,
0.026862409,
-0.051721599,
0.0165891219,
-0.0121357189,
-0.0035839877,
-0.0173460394,
-0.0100054657,
0.0023551772,
-0.0461535864,
-0.0242209993,
-0.0076439655,
0.0825216845,
0.0343025699,
0.0306099914,
-0.0690450743,
0.0213897303,
0.0353526026,
-0.0219462849,
0.0928603709,
0.0326720513,
0.0118372152,
0.032684397,
-0.0080661299,
-0.0431344323,
-0.084725596,
-0.0325462818,
-0.067652449,
0.0886267424,
0.087266475,
0.054450158,
0.027973054,
0.0378878862,
-0.0664693192,
0.053764835,
-0.0453213565,
0.0446389839,
-0.0045300755,
-0.0097157471,
0.0131625403,
-0.0062946109,
-0.0539779812,
0.006534846,
-0.0459533595,
-0.0127247805,
0.0291701928,
0.0060788696,
-0.0325150415,
0.0350765362,
0.0343413167,
-0.0338463821,
0.0480856746,
0.0488944575,
-0.0199228022,
0.0648865625,
0.0188179091,
0.0068437266,
-0.0211171005,
0.033445891,
0.0703900456,
-0.0073998957,
-0.0172738172,
0.0154766263,
0.0169962049,
-0.0035094875,
-0.0221160706,
-0.01386071,
-0.026401313,
0.0232260115,
-0.0410086997,
-0.0292168185,
-0.0198393445,
0.0324805193,
-0.0268176012,
-0.0214075334,
0.0053422614,
-0.0120532354,
0.0341216624,
-0.0534236506,
-0.0070293238,
0.0161692239,
-0.0078305099,
0.0319182873,
0.00625969,
-0.0227609836,
-0.0138045233,
-0.0416908264,
-0.0118373213,
0.0661283061,
2.606e-7,
0.0173843652,
-0.024128966,
-0.0144302836,
0.0063027414,
0.0087546846,
0.0618861429,
-0.0058383555,
-0.0086330194,
0.0087954933,
-0.0231296644,
0.0125052426,
0.0670029595,
0.0196792483,
0.0230432004,
-0.0171405524,
0.0013012525,
-0.013624629,
-0.0565545522,
-0.0699875206,
0.0104438001,
0.0920049995,
0.0299853422,
-0.0127818119,
-0.0391180441,
0.0293621849,
0.0005007128,
0.0458920039,
0.036220707,
0.0277773608,
-0.0109750759,
0.0214380976,
-0.0443286635,
-0.0017551474,
0.0065899617,
-0.0014389191,
-0.0071972753,
-0.0231683217,
0.0238591004,
-0.0129974522,
-0.0858583078,
-0.032001283,
0.0002883494,
0.0365725495,
-0.0571455657,
0.1161828935,
-0.0399829634,
-0.0445227809,
-0.0048444653,
-0.0481592715,
0.0206051506,
0.0181978326,
0.0022629178,
-0.0019043761,
0.0026525334,
-0.0044063586,
-0.0112951361,
-0.0180115215,
-0.0574601665,
0.0075115748,
-0.0118507426,
0.0073032528,
0.0085778162,
0.0011224374,
-0.0234157834,
0.0266124755,
-0.0329018086,
-0.0433230884,
1.944566122e-34,
0.0033640079,
0.0038881479,
0.0124590155,
0.0395154767,
0.0230367817,
-0.0027313987,
-0.0299208816,
-0.0305285379,
0.0586145446,
-0.0579534844,
-0.0063840649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12742v1 | Benchmarking Multi-Image Understanding in Vision and Language Models: Perception, Knowledge, Reasoning, and Multi-Hop Reasoning | 2024-06-18T16:02:18 | 2024-06-18T16:02:18 | Bingchen Zhao, Yongshuo Zong, Letian Zhang, Timothy Hospedales | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly broadened
the scope of applications in natural language processing, with multi-modal LLMs
extending these capabilities to integrate and interpret visual data. However,
existing benchmarks for visual language models (VLMs) predominantly focus on
single-image inputs, neglecting the crucial aspect of multi-image
understanding. In this paper, we introduce a Multi-Image Relational Benchmark
MIRB, designed to evaluate VLMs' ability to compare, analyze, and reason across
multiple images. Our benchmark encompasses four categories: perception, visual
world knowledge, reasoning, and multi-hop reasoning. Through a comprehensive
evaluation of a wide range of open-source and closed-source models, we
demonstrate that while open-source VLMs were shown to approach the performance
of GPT-4V in single-image tasks, a significant performance gap remains in
multi-image reasoning tasks. Our findings also reveal that even the
state-of-the-art GPT-4V model struggles with our benchmark, underscoring the
need for further research and development in this area. We believe our
contribution of MIRB could serve as a testbed for developing the
next-generation multi-modal models. | [
0.0236015953,
0.0499432646,
-0.0038926406,
0.0817263722,
-0.0557031669,
0.0230920706,
0.036553748,
-0.0010963274,
0.0249699801,
-0.06411957,
-0.0192818251,
-0.0551337972,
0.0077235731,
0.0242240764,
0.0249111634,
-0.056033127,
0.0438487567,
-0.0433209874,
-0.0030484356,
-0.0017809556,
0.0147718862,
0.0117139919,
-0.0067941276,
0.0337423123,
-0.0394838303,
-0.0183127075,
-0.0099564157,
0.019466931,
0.010123672,
-0.0181587171,
-0.0368455276,
0.0330089405,
0.0778020844,
0.0001280022,
0.0000018544,
-0.0244680345,
0.0033870745,
0.0123027964,
0.0168767646,
-0.0056709661,
0.0166567434,
-0.0518819094,
0.0171466395,
-0.0294642504,
-0.0377786346,
-0.0209751967,
0.0660034642,
0.053887438,
0.0618943386,
0.0469146669,
-0.0288452059,
-0.0642673895,
0.0081773456,
-0.0137616871,
0.0225665253,
-0.051019147,
0.0206952933,
0.0714565814,
0.0143735865,
-0.0244700108,
-0.0427469797,
0.0492613614,
0.0274011679,
-0.0009427693,
-0.0458385199,
0.0481524616,
-0.0140884928,
-0.0425080322,
-0.0162311085,
0.0673821568,
-0.0270070452,
0.0089517096,
-0.0125278309,
0.015334866,
-0.0204149354,
0.0240580887,
-0.0254344754,
0.0398752056,
-0.0238817781,
0.0186930653,
-0.0680168793,
-0.0227337033,
0.0141002191,
0.039276883,
-0.0276147071,
0.0275179613,
0.0251765363,
0.0316243321,
-0.0104465466,
0.0061435318,
-0.0646986589,
-0.035268601,
-0.0376122892,
0.0359917805,
0.0056088618,
0.0213594195,
-0.0203256197,
-0.0033278107,
-0.0122780427,
-0.0132305399,
0.0271938276,
0.0310015511,
-0.0440115482,
0.0947255939,
-0.0430988856,
0.0720338598,
-0.0362868421,
0.0345689133,
-0.0031169418,
-0.0557394624,
-0.0683671981,
-0.0221589878,
-0.0165603366,
-0.0065598236,
-0.0493661016,
-0.0581158884,
-0.005703846,
0.0015333209,
-0.0159954261,
0.0153624453,
0.0189865287,
0.010290808,
-0.0035287605,
-0.0523676127,
-0.0571821071,
0.0429158844,
0.0122005977,
0.0188525412,
-0.0473532379,
-0.057389155,
0.0066215759,
0.0261045005,
0.0061927834,
-0.0394261554,
-0.0087335054,
0.0627173483,
-0.0396037586,
-0.0307898447,
-0.0150737856,
-0.0271037333,
-0.0202416368,
-0.0953444168,
0.0358909369,
-0.0434732139,
0.0161671266,
-0.004908165,
0.0017140228,
-0.0181543063,
0.009003832,
-0.0210801046,
-0.0498377234,
0.1233002767,
0.0032985786,
-0.0053334194,
-0.0088999858,
0.0260698181,
0.0030024464,
0.0787357688,
0.0076263361,
0.0170261916,
0.0052373908,
0.0139636733,
-0.0132458527,
0.0303924736,
-0.0274533164,
-0.0107106809,
-0.0464752838,
0.0133341867,
0.0092675276,
0.0199885406,
0.0015499115,
0.0564051829,
-0.0512041226,
-0.0323030837,
0.0662659556,
0.0209920406,
0.0053126337,
-0.0312112384,
0.0377988927,
-0.0213614758,
0.0000975247,
-0.0085654389,
-0.0941517577,
0.0728988796,
0.0124079632,
-0.0052354294,
-0.017457163,
0.0372009054,
-0.0170399025,
-0.0111260228,
-0.0243364908,
-0.0111332322,
-0.0104237199,
-0.0061251107,
0.0622316524,
-0.034828186,
-0.0307077877,
0.0294215474,
0.0207229462,
-0.0194369555,
-0.0191122424,
-0.0405593701,
0.026506491,
0.0498518422,
0.0231095776,
-0.0019934627,
0.0091450242,
0.0164657589,
0.0084990244,
0.040523205,
0.0014688693,
0.0299733058,
0.0375976376,
-0.0517466404,
-0.045648586,
-0.0283585191,
0.0105647799,
0.0409431197,
0.002591972,
-0.0152208079,
0.0008974427,
-0.0471470803,
0.057250794,
0.0188541617,
0.0332129225,
0.0313909017,
-0.0637038797,
0.0215430148,
-0.0040287906,
-0.0145294433,
-0.0150724249,
-0.0050432612,
0.0008267608,
-0.008717767,
0.0242973901,
0.0269195233,
-0.0320665464,
-0.0431727618,
0.0469092727,
-0.0819435492,
-0.0354974382,
0.0470639355,
-0.0440007225,
-0.027143009,
0.0085953539,
0.0204821266,
0.0221322719,
-0.0688681677,
-0.0209614206,
0.0150014954,
0.01456457,
-0.0122556463,
0.0800394341,
-0.0142206522,
-0.0019252473,
0.013389674,
0.0097530521,
0.0273412783,
-0.006595829,
-0.0247891918,
0.0297242887,
0.0077565368,
0.0078480411,
-0.0349146836,
-0.015668679,
-0.0556926467,
-0.0019326255,
-0.0804939792,
-0.0225955471,
-0.0145417852,
-0.0460084714,
-0.0058162538,
-0.0108769806,
0.017913837,
-0.0335485451,
-0.0196603835,
0.0379234068,
0.0166142918,
0.0214264225,
0.0323725045,
0.0085264137,
0.0040332391,
-0.0121877007,
0.0011603251,
-0.0034403526,
0.0785048977,
0.0161807574,
-0.0112183448,
-0.0145013602,
-0.0183579959,
-0.0641985908,
0.0548712239,
-0.0362578481,
-0.031405244,
0.0135776466,
-0.0466892123,
0.0525461584,
0.0574777238,
0.0017174248,
-0.0084437048,
0.0334424451,
-0.0306732543,
-0.0293620564,
-0.0018053324,
0.0197186023,
-0.0096429782,
-0.0003096828,
-0.0179840792,
-0.0787075162,
0.0200654678,
-0.0142499125,
-0.0139728002,
-0.0705286041,
0.0314195752,
0.0266854726,
-0.0292861108,
-0.0738504976,
-0.0016833985,
0.0241924059,
0.0333957709,
-0.073203817,
-0.0642585009,
0.0421338417,
-0.0456974991,
-0.0084277671,
0.0507773384,
0.0181907676,
-0.017995052,
0.0876905918,
0.0328199714,
0.0356038064,
-0.0062017976,
0.027169995,
-0.0329572111,
-0.0228866208,
0.0391358621,
0.0004584675,
0.0641263425,
-0.0868314803,
0.042361591,
-0.0315967575,
-0.0165455993,
-0.0203714818,
0.0029682321,
-0.0476199947,
0.010795136,
-0.0387356877,
-0.0085158786,
-0.0031091326,
0.0636076406,
0.0123128723,
-0.0031413664,
0.0034915518,
-0.001652861,
-0.012555995,
0.0507730059,
0.0503755957,
0.0042147017,
0.0004820903,
-0.0283409394,
0.0161058716,
0.0476565324,
0.0279236864,
-0.0057053529,
-0.0661373213,
0.0609705113,
-0.0050525041,
0.0671732873,
-0.0156401936,
0.0153857935,
0.0573292971,
-0.0513493307,
0.0116583444,
0.0708905011,
-0.0029345446,
-0.0365837365,
-0.0433327444,
-0.0002010146,
0.0146831209,
0.0481351949,
-0.0043919263,
-0.0758552179,
-0.0706447214,
-0.0104413778,
-0.0593085513,
0.0401573107,
-0.0225107223,
-0.0335480645,
-0.0603384599,
0.058810018,
-0.0114593655,
-0.0108489124,
-0.026915716,
0.0289688483,
0.0019147602,
-0.0149451345,
-0.0263620522,
-0.0117730228,
0.0113772731,
-0.007775526,
-0.0106140198,
0.0377430432,
-0.0160993077,
0.021410156,
-0.0676223263,
0.0065114992,
0.0081748599,
0.0212814715,
0.0130044594,
-0.0790933669,
0.0135688204,
0.0229610149,
0.0196334552,
0.0020922483,
0.0473106019,
-0.0218990743,
-0.0695140287,
-0.0076042665,
-0.0035272108,
-0.015970204,
-0.0127081871,
-0.066152066,
0.0426559933,
0.0010940124,
0.000091377,
-0.0165483411,
0.0010742097,
-0.0222741887,
0.0490120463,
-0.0044889161,
0.0193396099,
-0.0587637126,
0.0004759862,
0.0027903561,
-0.0288654231,
-0.0164093282,
0.0106905969,
0.0016744598,
0.0222045332,
-0.0399289876,
-0.0010834568,
0.0082264747,
0.0437660366,
-0.0361704528,
-0.0120573798,
0.0017978762,
0.0190708004,
-0.0610730387,
0.0711216778,
-0.0335498229,
0.0501296781,
-0.0019357748,
0.0285615344,
0.0455208458,
-0.0492731109,
-0.0200968459,
0.0203482583,
-0.0788422227,
-0.0344178602,
-0.0264664888,
0.0696840808,
0.0186510812,
0.0368515924,
0.0190642886,
-0.0082828365,
-0.0403374769,
-0.0150535777,
0.0267624557,
0.022657413,
0.0118583515,
-0.0144724036,
0.0029167456,
0.0349793993,
-0.0109580858,
0.0274778791,
0.0348910801,
-0.0024129711,
-0.0016750139,
-0.0300659109,
0.0040460117,
0.0115740048,
0.0506390966,
0.00175125,
0.0156281702,
-0.0203137901,
-0.001501023,
-0.0153053449,
-0.0180615336,
-0.0692654029,
0.0074668205,
0.0141068893,
-0.0153913787,
-0.0079467753,
-0.0021207994,
0.0235640854,
0.0104352841,
-0.0117514264,
-0.0108058332,
0.05883516,
-0.0255271345,
-0.0080390098,
-0.0097190058,
-0.0062290304,
0.0034919793,
-0.0322976634,
0.02599518,
-0.0111286966,
0.0782789513,
0.0300603826,
-0.0419310331,
-0.020449562,
0.0336862542,
-0.0470811427,
-0.0346360654,
0.0143131046,
0.0327964537,
0.0814924166,
0.0067208279,
0.0375853144,
-0.0110189505,
-0.0096335737,
0.0049635107,
0.0399576947,
0.0275961272,
-0.0156298093,
0.0874509364,
0.0311547108,
0.016430689,
0.015250111,
0.0459881537,
0.0001163437,
0.0416087583,
-0.0082382131,
-0.0147502935,
-0.0260963701,
-0.0378442295,
0.0357296653,
-0.0025903464,
0.018098563,
0.047279574,
-0.0436560288,
-0.0709250271,
-0.0230000447,
0.0541061088,
-0.0171735324,
0.0343632735,
0.0209730677,
0.0597244911,
0.0322104134,
-0.0329365246,
-0.0034305605,
-0.0500693209,
-0.0229463633,
0.0508190207,
0.021590231,
-6.107406531e-33,
-0.0350186713,
-0.0346748792,
0.0496162772,
-0.0513334423,
-0.0198512338,
0.0163321178,
-0.0113434605,
-0.0114544835,
-0.0522529632,
0.024859203,
0.036767628,
0.0166309271,
0.0022280456,
0.0260484312,
0.0040290626,
-0.0066090939,
0.0232347343,
0.0168347098,
-0.0182112753,
-0.0240498856,
0.0275645703,
-0.0079802759,
0.044894252,
-0.001162656,
-0.0139948167,
0.0280727763,
-0.0368339419,
0.0495129563,
-0.0266354233,
0.0611174218,
-0.0305829905,
-0.0267684162,
0.0361977704,
-0.0064528794,
-0.0314455256,
0.0035689147,
-0.0625081658,
-0.0005364062,
0.0588848889,
0.0080256592,
-0.0718894154,
0.0244731624,
0.023714466,
-0.0277344976,
0.0400497392,
-0.050647635,
0.035850551,
-0.0270180833,
0.0061311913,
0.0153669445,
-0.012362116,
0.0177410841,
-0.0111684119,
-0.0345868133,
0.0561896078,
0.015215857,
0.0195464697,
0.052188985,
-0.0355142169,
0.0100574456,
-0.0326493196,
-0.0125303613,
0.0882596001,
0.0317671485,
0.0004874567,
0.0600158237,
0.0296783019,
-0.0625308901,
-0.0215507708,
-0.0148729822,
0.0144854989,
0.0940797105,
0.0458998494,
0.0792979896,
-0.0052253241,
0.0490599014,
-0.0389492661,
-0.0114953155,
-0.0471684858,
0.0747619867,
0.0223158319,
0.0197989009,
0.0171692539,
0.0150412349,
-0.0542423464,
-0.0278189965,
-0.0552329347,
0.009998397,
0.0467439927,
0.0272349343,
-0.018768752,
0.0627905503,
0.0712683201,
-0.0446034893,
-0.0030809604,
0.0217214637,
-0.0164758619,
0.0299007241,
0.0119616017,
0.0568633415,
-0.0144959949,
0.0023850105,
0.0593873262,
0.0256620683,
-0.013178301,
0.0067170472,
0.0226758476,
0.0059791799,
-0.0392130055,
-0.0167503394,
-0.0693289638,
-0.0223580543,
-0.0428956337,
0.0026551511,
0.0310120676,
0.015162888,
-0.0454989634,
0.0100094117,
-0.0097735478,
-0.0131322322,
-0.0157128889,
-0.0282491762,
-0.0214920677,
0.0477863625,
-0.007996303,
0.0109297652,
-0.0490618087,
-0.0565524623,
0.043304611,
-0.0283407532,
-0.0071606794,
0.0586277284,
2.514e-7,
0.0382669866,
0.0290053729,
0.009303214,
0.0018804171,
0.0275315922,
0.0541877151,
-0.0536255278,
0.0156482682,
-0.0209654495,
-0.0382371172,
-0.0233065635,
0.0677233711,
0.0199574791,
0.0048209,
0.041117087,
0.0229078364,
-0.0253565125,
-0.04519495,
-0.061630141,
0.0200482011,
0.0989478081,
0.0630945042,
-0.0099198408,
-0.0176750552,
0.0229280274,
-0.038835343,
0.0928357393,
-0.0446714461,
-0.004942372,
-0.0295299701,
-0.0099962065,
0.0166530311,
-0.007154352,
0.0403216965,
0.0284055602,
-0.0253669471,
0.0387964696,
0.0464334302,
-0.0355431847,
-0.0173897743,
-0.0248533376,
0.0154255461,
-0.0392000377,
-0.0792845264,
0.1132966131,
-0.0231505148,
-0.0110233109,
-0.0081236809,
-0.0367633328,
-0.0162768401,
0.0134104118,
0.0321141072,
-0.0502123348,
0.0208002534,
0.0088996114,
-0.030936759,
-0.0333884135,
-0.0982063562,
0.0014571535,
-0.0052495184,
-0.0423388854,
0.002929915,
-0.0501932614,
-0.0433257148,
0.0662732422,
-0.0408076495,
-0.0750988051,
1.674421793e-34,
0.0082093244,
-0.0306441952,
0.019815689,
-0.005056737,
0.0408637561,
-0.0214418229,
-0.0600064211,
-0.0037331248,
-0.0329523794,
-0.0854702145,
0.0087804338
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12739v1 | Self-Distillation for Model Stacking Unlocks Cross-Lingual NLU in 200+ Languages | 2024-06-18T16:00:20 | 2024-06-18T16:00:20 | Fabian David Schmidt, Philipp Borchert, Ivan Vulić, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs have become a go-to solution not just for text generation, but also for
natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. Acquiring extensive knowledge
through language modeling on web-scale corpora, they excel on English NLU, yet
struggle to extend their NLU capabilities to underrepresented languages. In
contrast, machine translation models (MT) produce excellent multilingual
representations, resulting in strong translation performance even for
low-resource languages. MT encoders, however, lack the knowledge necessary for
comprehensive NLU that LLMs obtain through language modeling training on
immense corpora. In this work, we get the best both worlds by integrating MT
encoders directly into LLM backbones via sample-efficient self-distillation.
The resulting MT-LLMs preserve the inherent multilingual representational
alignment from the MT encoder, allowing lower-resource languages to tap into
the rich knowledge embedded in English-centric LLMs. Merging the MT encoder and
LLM in a single model, we mitigate the propagation of translation errors and
inference overhead of MT decoding inherent to discrete translation-based
cross-lingual transfer (e.g., translate-test). Evaluation spanning three
prominent NLU tasks and 127 predominantly low-resource languages renders
MT-LLMs highly effective in cross-lingual transfer. MT-LLMs substantially and
consistently outperform translate-test based on the same MT model, showing that
we truly unlock multilingual language understanding for LLMs. | [
-0.0075170859,
0.0505638644,
0.0077439588,
0.0731232241,
-0.0057015694,
0.043409612,
0.0331987888,
-0.0451564081,
-0.0108544063,
-0.0196679831,
-0.0369917713,
-0.0398721211,
0.00114324,
0.005192352,
0.033587791,
-0.0107859578,
0.0279536787,
-0.0502686054,
-0.0500096604,
-0.0211729035,
0.0009730143,
0.0496954136,
0.0004031406,
-0.0033533406,
0.0492373891,
-0.0278966781,
-0.0124674365,
0.0256804172,
0.016656043,
-0.021561062,
-0.0106912069,
0.0127570685,
0.0691881776,
0.0777760148,
0.0000020787,
-0.0156456381,
-0.0353653803,
0.0066848067,
-0.0306688864,
-0.0007898817,
0.0054407241,
-0.0827124864,
0.0068138731,
0.012129847,
-0.0133443242,
0.0250924062,
0.0436505824,
-0.0128727574,
0.0700899884,
0.0552161224,
0.0060759648,
-0.0166928563,
0.0040973104,
-0.0482139736,
-0.0008309747,
-0.0235358402,
-0.0158942509,
0.0142318057,
-0.0536598302,
0.0032481567,
-0.0205402914,
0.0422308147,
0.0292797685,
0.0076292497,
-0.0301923733,
0.0128694577,
0.0094563151,
-0.0588028543,
-0.0233859494,
0.0687201917,
-0.0492091142,
-0.0098668458,
-0.0136144646,
0.0048775729,
-0.0261437874,
-0.0091701392,
-0.0512234569,
0.0474105887,
0.0178331118,
0.0255021285,
0.0321856253,
0.0371683724,
0.0475930199,
0.0283086561,
-0.0430937596,
0.0285307188,
0.0257662088,
0.0013949563,
-0.0032599061,
0.0316568799,
0.0205692835,
-0.0328188203,
0.023034798,
0.0343042985,
-0.006335157,
0.0211593453,
-0.0284466185,
-0.0160966385,
0.0107537853,
-0.027517572,
0.037142083,
0.0785874277,
-0.0164340101,
0.0210130736,
-0.0355913304,
0.0520641543,
-0.0340725295,
0.0084176157,
-0.0629880056,
-0.0357434936,
-0.0193459,
-0.000384119,
-0.006039496,
0.0209198259,
-0.0758620799,
0.0016905955,
-0.0100483727,
0.0281621143,
0.0151361618,
-0.0068579698,
0.0255593117,
-0.0250317156,
-0.0703681037,
-0.0187297463,
0.0070593986,
0.0896161348,
-0.0084008193,
-0.0305094328,
0.0301060025,
-0.0655422956,
-0.0424374081,
0.0254436433,
-0.0143349599,
-0.0465122499,
0.0009636056,
0.0863167346,
-0.042691052,
0.001789391,
-0.0308423322,
-0.0177640151,
-0.0167049058,
-0.0850078315,
0.0259113275,
-0.0668457597,
0.0916102901,
0.0113820788,
0.0127036897,
-0.0651525259,
0.0198620111,
-0.0066746064,
-0.0057145921,
0.0551758967,
-0.0081776325,
-0.0051630372,
0.0293839574,
-0.0110978149,
-0.0048580822,
0.1017926633,
0.0177972745,
0.0399362482,
0.0144746918,
-0.0012486201,
-0.0287287403,
0.0268904809,
0.0271200519,
0.0487931557,
-0.0447825864,
-0.0060358313,
-0.0288615078,
0.0241464805,
0.0860592797,
0.0290663503,
-0.0220494624,
0.0358838998,
0.0536480248,
-0.0007482515,
0.0227883235,
0.0535907894,
0.0683567598,
0.0116681615,
-0.0498197973,
0.0266293548,
-0.0146546047,
0.0534604415,
-0.0089028897,
0.0146774678,
0.0485883318,
0.093949914,
-0.0373325385,
-0.0308988653,
0.0072068386,
-0.0163828451,
-0.0019362825,
0.0178692304,
0.0338744819,
0.0250220299,
-0.0250026528,
0.116112344,
0.0239823274,
-0.0701045692,
0.0571997352,
-0.007489197,
-0.0133043826,
0.0592583232,
0.0153779397,
0.0326662064,
-0.0515495576,
-0.0134992367,
-0.0295142625,
0.0734216049,
0.03305123,
-0.0072280234,
0.0602445565,
-0.0579194985,
-0.0301600602,
-0.0509783588,
-0.0010519648,
0.0295475479,
-0.0351132341,
0.0434984006,
0.0504654981,
-0.0938888267,
-0.016299665,
0.022239469,
-0.0793574899,
-0.0302144717,
0.0140910959,
0.0171526037,
0.00841955,
0.0329654403,
0.007473635,
-0.0060350825,
0.016173495,
-0.0603717491,
-0.0255141743,
0.0173166115,
-0.0578227974,
-0.1113166064,
0.0371420719,
-0.0072587202,
-0.0137244612,
0.0072438121,
-0.0618813112,
-0.0554279163,
-0.0018174171,
-0.0163516048,
-0.0027509329,
-0.0599667802,
0.0242645945,
0.0214896239,
0.0477387942,
0.0018818643,
0.0454186648,
-0.0236113351,
-0.0002071406,
0.0129979113,
-0.0209764745,
0.024459919,
0.0042341603,
-0.0006147057,
0.0254458487,
0.0211895108,
0.0239263233,
0.035744369,
0.0256112088,
-0.0193157848,
-0.0296494868,
-0.057338573,
0.0356303938,
-0.0315667614,
0.0426797234,
0.0414256677,
0.0580519252,
0.0116887586,
-0.0159349032,
-0.0569549277,
-0.0418120362,
0.0292034931,
0.0130423214,
0.0371346101,
-0.0089971768,
0.0157973282,
-0.0055946182,
-0.0012522213,
0.0331541598,
0.0385089666,
-0.03095752,
-0.0319727585,
-0.0558967888,
-0.0069649867,
-0.0673922077,
-0.0220463015,
0.0006597778,
-0.043404188,
-0.0095877796,
-0.0000674646,
0.0202434082,
0.0203133728,
0.0068140263,
0.0107174208,
0.0579205602,
-0.0094346702,
-0.0545503497,
0.0307644438,
-0.00149084,
-0.0187343191,
-0.0242099743,
-0.023655409,
-0.011546622,
0.078616038,
0.0026243129,
-0.0071176719,
-0.0426599532,
-0.0198102836,
0.0201388206,
-0.031333033,
-0.0218434725,
0.0365874395,
0.0082149105,
0.0470627658,
-0.0355415866,
-0.0246473961,
0.0642779917,
-0.0772883222,
-0.0199111812,
-0.0369545706,
-0.0042641223,
-0.0627065897,
0.0339982994,
-0.0156265292,
0.0402885266,
-0.0157851204,
-0.0009132026,
-0.0427633151,
0.0153562324,
0.0077059213,
-0.0251679793,
0.0338684879,
-0.0693470165,
0.0016886643,
-0.0276799183,
-0.032652054,
-0.038578853,
-0.0100317504,
-0.0019952839,
-0.0020125431,
-0.0022499117,
0.0087059662,
-0.04212147,
0.002538976,
0.0400464386,
0.0285918303,
-0.0202731322,
0.0210895073,
-0.0362298265,
0.0507570952,
0.029095659,
0.0349573642,
0.0239152536,
-0.0662606806,
0.05872529,
0.0254865587,
-0.0118168052,
-0.0260449667,
-0.0192668773,
0.0244941544,
0.0556830913,
-0.0102446713,
-0.0129132438,
-0.0118349129,
0.08534275,
-0.0593160354,
-0.0108188167,
0.1119606942,
0.0016661278,
-0.0281160027,
-0.0108267162,
-0.0182154421,
0.0540605634,
0.0318325348,
0.0152978655,
-0.0724186972,
-0.0334361345,
0.0108092474,
0.0053956127,
0.0447459817,
0.0157615487,
-0.0373843238,
-0.1099655032,
0.0182868186,
0.046329122,
-0.0364430994,
-0.0281735789,
-0.0127613526,
-0.023880152,
-0.0208956134,
0.0636055842,
-0.0073993062,
0.0014522034,
0.013948014,
0.0170960017,
0.0063970452,
-0.0644206703,
-0.0075384006,
-0.0258114375,
0.0012766614,
0.041258648,
0.0522145517,
0.0080672102,
-0.0310554076,
0.0151582882,
-0.0402666554,
0.0103816884,
-0.0152567336,
0.0373219736,
-0.0092347087,
-0.0114810178,
0.0271631461,
0.0179764722,
-0.067701757,
0.0189340767,
0.0004130363,
0.0467705876,
-0.0009945065,
0.0103800083,
0.0085413009,
-0.0299900901,
0.0097635631,
0.0729439929,
0.024857549,
-0.0132977273,
-0.0225908943,
-0.0431557968,
-0.01593934,
-0.0499434546,
-0.0045531127,
0.0300763752,
-0.0200584978,
-0.0272068977,
-0.0590499751,
-0.0518517755,
-0.0198020041,
0.0266046226,
-0.0154807772,
0.0228057578,
-0.0094805751,
-0.0098083355,
-0.039824605,
0.0195936989,
-0.036763832,
-0.0130355833,
-0.0251566358,
0.018806532,
0.019691363,
-0.0491967984,
0.0097138919,
0.0093721831,
-0.1030837521,
-0.0834152624,
-0.0588259362,
0.0353799388,
0.0111906175,
0.0838153362,
0.0119000059,
-0.0081748562,
0.0570402667,
0.0079169683,
-0.044170402,
-0.0062163095,
0.0286186803,
0.0158145633,
-0.0207309723,
0.0682421625,
-0.0373517126,
0.0053295125,
-0.0390763283,
0.0719299987,
-0.0110428967,
-0.053918153,
0.0277733169,
0.0097462796,
0.004976518,
-0.0559677631,
0.0252019465,
-0.0257049017,
0.0324263908,
-0.0164476186,
-0.0289083384,
-0.0543469451,
-0.0036371183,
0.0439952798,
-0.0421935059,
0.0134188598,
0.0254749265,
0.0266373865,
-0.0134502221,
-0.0064840419,
0.0087895542,
-0.041261673,
0.0015583402,
-0.0009874027,
0.0043519037,
-0.0146608455,
0.0145225851,
-0.0192853045,
0.0203930475,
-0.0526420437,
0.0505682677,
-0.0061650402,
0.0466466509,
0.0025573943,
0.037940409,
-0.0166689716,
-0.0641949922,
-0.0221010242,
-0.015816763,
0.072305344,
0.0005829969,
0.1294504106,
0.0167428441,
-0.0132457977,
-0.0082777571,
0.045451723,
-0.0140150003,
-0.0072558429,
0.019240303,
-0.0029989551,
-0.0278152004,
0.0005903486,
0.0738966987,
0.0038048539,
0.0006797726,
0.0083315549,
0.0201349352,
-0.0279576778,
-0.0331838131,
0.0028220266,
-0.0226798188,
0.0080525894,
-0.0096805915,
-0.0212182347,
-0.0648264512,
0.0044682315,
-0.0116523542,
-0.0229070503,
-0.0273810849,
0.0177452341,
0.077282466,
-0.0304163583,
0.0091221584,
-0.0531371422,
0.0201104749,
0.0148149794,
-0.0107182376,
0.005059192,
-6.707847576e-33,
-0.0346961282,
0.0048563876,
0.0168906096,
-0.0414240547,
-0.029567346,
-0.0128081162,
-0.042482879,
-0.0357086211,
-0.0067514223,
0.0027688674,
0.015304557,
0.00441967,
0.0163413044,
0.0424830243,
0.0092454832,
0.0141971158,
0.0744104832,
0.0092863031,
-0.0274881739,
0.0263396017,
0.025315566,
0.0432264954,
0.0645472631,
-0.0098807961,
0.0073406058,
-0.0214470811,
-0.0043946831,
0.017219089,
0.0143785365,
0.0194075424,
-0.0258414894,
0.0233054552,
0.0251815151,
-0.0382864848,
-0.0515380241,
-0.0295600425,
-0.0902163759,
-0.0156278629,
0.0139551032,
0.0021889531,
-0.0337246843,
-0.0478200763,
0.0514432341,
-0.0213657524,
0.0316797122,
-0.0396827608,
-0.0079138251,
-0.0281457491,
-0.0030262887,
-0.0229833573,
-0.0406759456,
0.0170544535,
-0.0309868511,
-0.0381241292,
0.0621246621,
0.0330309123,
0.0126813874,
0.0203751568,
-0.0616892129,
-0.0045713936,
-0.048365511,
0.0449520797,
0.1131286249,
-0.0013131114,
-0.0215583481,
0.0304277297,
-0.026650263,
-0.0273662806,
0.0185109787,
0.0321922675,
0.0025940249,
0.0349669643,
0.0035185872,
0.0692921504,
0.0517064892,
0.0086994059,
-0.0670719445,
0.0534906238,
-0.0130286505,
0.0068847248,
0.0133933295,
0.0164545532,
0.0273462608,
-0.0262443013,
-0.0432105623,
-0.0230176747,
-0.0263705961,
-0.0448103175,
0.0076116906,
0.0058079069,
-0.0354327932,
-0.0128689753,
0.062213812,
-0.0256060362,
-0.0281812437,
0.034362182,
-0.0274423826,
-0.0193787348,
0.0127412258,
0.0443824753,
-0.0341234766,
-0.041513633,
-0.0124335662,
0.0060894173,
-0.0029825368,
-0.0025762895,
0.0393590219,
0.0231723431,
-0.0411149524,
0.0168632306,
-0.0829825476,
0.0149671305,
-0.0141126327,
0.0528788194,
0.0255004819,
-0.014885623,
-0.036488682,
0.0340713374,
-0.0035361552,
-0.0243452769,
-0.0349602178,
0.013154651,
0.0101059666,
0.0619985498,
-0.037430279,
0.0044418857,
-0.0253588166,
0.0001435027,
0.0648771301,
-0.0428903326,
-0.0247276295,
0.0029997271,
2.787e-7,
0.0572050922,
0.0228924714,
0.0316930152,
0.005173835,
0.0149105163,
0.029288562,
-0.0379631929,
0.0289613735,
-0.0020665047,
-0.0486207046,
0.0037257378,
0.0645805821,
0.0827466473,
0.0462304316,
-0.038675949,
0.0274507068,
-0.0286886524,
0.0219909605,
-0.0248228051,
-0.0218739863,
0.0164041184,
0.0636765957,
-0.0185864307,
-0.0180251617,
0.0007908418,
-0.0338279381,
0.0946470946,
0.0104643181,
-0.0274826456,
0.0329024941,
-0.0177239086,
0.0269170869,
-0.0308198854,
-0.0313240923,
-0.0275471341,
0.032005053,
0.0089441463,
0.0690548047,
0.0232198276,
-0.0388592482,
0.0250309445,
-0.0107784886,
-0.0007824828,
-0.0444014817,
0.0554675832,
-0.0230896417,
-0.0134809101,
-0.027518047,
-0.0113301035,
0.024514379,
0.0241155904,
-0.0208650641,
-0.0186857227,
0.0667994618,
0.0330297723,
-0.0168329719,
-0.0363080166,
-0.0320371017,
-0.0497931242,
-0.021572182,
-0.0456059575,
-0.0182969309,
-0.0336406678,
-0.0277630482,
0.0031266836,
-0.0589379929,
-0.0193601381,
2.518613048e-34,
0.0202045571,
-0.023365248,
0.0037923185,
0.0098284371,
0.0315834396,
-0.0390090346,
-0.0403218456,
0.0011502192,
-0.0223611593,
-0.0209336467,
-0.0107552493
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12738v1 | Large Language Model as a Universal Clinical Multi-task Decoder | 2024-06-18T15:58:36 | 2024-06-18T15:58:36 | Yujiang Wu, Hongjian Song, Jiawen Zhang, Xumeng Wen, Shun Zheng, Jiang Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The development of effective machine learning methodologies for enhancing the
efficiency and accuracy of clinical systems is crucial. Despite significant
research efforts, managing a plethora of diversified clinical tasks and
adapting to emerging new tasks remain significant challenges. This paper
presents a novel paradigm that employs a pre-trained large language model as a
universal clinical multi-task decoder. This approach leverages the flexibility
and diversity of language expressions to handle task topic variations and
associated arguments. The introduction of a new task simply requires the
addition of a new instruction template. We validate this framework across
hundreds of tasks, demonstrating its robustness in facilitating multi-task
predictions, performing on par with traditional multi-task learning and
single-task learning approaches. Moreover, it shows exceptional adaptability to
new tasks, with impressive zero-shot performance in some instances and superior
data efficiency in few-shot scenarios. This novel approach offers a unified
solution to manage a wide array of new and emerging tasks in clinical
applications. | [
0.0325820334,
0.0262077451,
0.0209195185,
-0.0261007156,
-0.0178821795,
0.0473201834,
0.0135045629,
0.0101036252,
-0.0339080766,
-0.0298062153,
-0.028320197,
-0.0738746598,
-0.0055535971,
0.0457022078,
0.0098922439,
-0.042617064,
0.0267449003,
-0.0078814002,
0.0411370359,
0.0043433644,
-0.0238181055,
0.0283964463,
-0.0441584289,
0.0760018155,
0.0104781622,
-0.0180486534,
-0.0006854812,
-0.0103394669,
-0.0139332497,
-0.0706007481,
-0.0014422466,
0.0469308421,
0.0325959362,
-0.0077985493,
0.0000018627,
-0.0390142389,
-0.017153129,
0.0178674012,
-0.0704298094,
-0.0587888882,
0.0695848987,
-0.0500356629,
0.0149293207,
-0.003351162,
-0.0273673963,
-0.0660161525,
0.0657643825,
0.0654770061,
0.0495937094,
0.0669469163,
-0.0089079123,
0.0158816762,
0.0069188476,
-0.0349082649,
0.0225647818,
-0.0713881403,
0.0285413954,
0.0126074571,
0.0099303704,
0.0029340386,
-0.0053422954,
0.0390218161,
0.0005836509,
0.0468229093,
0.0025905867,
0.0328490846,
-0.018581029,
-0.0360292718,
-0.0436687842,
0.0636076331,
-0.0523328744,
-0.0051201796,
0.0072993306,
-0.0091048097,
-0.0357249826,
-0.023333326,
-0.0551307276,
0.0010277212,
-0.024833912,
0.0117060728,
0.0487521589,
0.0187258851,
0.0272922646,
-0.0112769464,
-0.0274760202,
-0.0072504068,
0.0188189801,
-0.0051461989,
0.0475936607,
0.0336793736,
-0.0237141605,
-0.0145793138,
0.0195031632,
0.0378883034,
-0.0953131989,
0.0144475438,
-0.0405038707,
-0.0696709082,
0.0627177507,
-0.0717016682,
0.0725524276,
0.0036067066,
-0.0180358365,
0.0634331629,
-0.0018650267,
-0.0063071894,
-0.0343070552,
0.0031731208,
-0.0518990755,
-0.0126040177,
-0.0509112515,
0.0036997092,
-0.0158071127,
0.0130094634,
-0.0096952273,
-0.0021671711,
-0.0571872778,
0.0214994065,
0.0027688185,
-0.0079450002,
0.0577307604,
0.0370158404,
-0.0686989054,
-0.0266776495,
0.0271525532,
0.0355564803,
0.0267810579,
0.0457682014,
-0.0267744176,
-0.0318846814,
-0.0157915168,
0.0160234142,
0.0000949814,
-0.0180190727,
0.0243278258,
0.0531384088,
-0.0084064268,
-0.0147378435,
-0.0027903563,
-0.0205614865,
-0.0456708223,
-0.0208935104,
0.0232069623,
-0.0528428182,
0.0549430735,
0.0158543624,
0.0206220392,
-0.0355111025,
0.0048416019,
-0.0132243885,
-0.0529600345,
0.0673710629,
0.0042542885,
-0.0001523489,
0.0246027987,
0.0217024218,
-0.0016837954,
0.0638877228,
-0.0097707808,
-0.0200811271,
-0.0082262866,
-0.0176544748,
-0.0041271793,
0.0313011445,
-0.0029183386,
-0.0551229008,
0.0102232052,
0.00553742,
0.0445144512,
0.0394423902,
-0.0167649761,
0.0572974868,
0.0037873795,
-0.0111179575,
0.0240388662,
0.0432269871,
0.0172108524,
0.0116453003,
0.0609333776,
0.0082852505,
-0.0015956105,
-0.0372582488,
-0.0001926828,
0.0079979943,
0.0223058295,
-0.0226588808,
-0.0232779328,
-0.0039195097,
-0.0491816029,
-0.016291162,
-0.0137932599,
-0.0524855889,
-0.0110202553,
0.0067418991,
0.0827414244,
-0.0009141733,
-0.0793524459,
0.0378552079,
0.058318425,
-0.0071998304,
-0.01054201,
-0.0439933576,
-0.0129750818,
0.0321587287,
0.0278597437,
-0.0446588807,
-0.0401633531,
-0.0317580812,
0.0463876314,
-0.0048632207,
0.0041990504,
-0.004178063,
0.0610682443,
-0.0476081744,
-0.0158625208,
0.0483903252,
0.0263186656,
-0.0242531784,
-0.0035166927,
0.0072967359,
-0.0243294518,
-0.0246551074,
-0.0186739359,
0.045460254,
-0.0409945771,
-0.0278203543,
0.0234197397,
-0.0018790659,
0.0338804685,
-0.0014500212,
-0.0185033306,
0.0216571502,
0.0328050591,
-0.059245944,
0.0000275034,
-0.0165018365,
-0.063396506,
-0.0395444222,
0.0007300314,
0.0042090314,
-0.0172525197,
-0.0048832917,
-0.0338341109,
-0.0106754601,
-0.0298994631,
-0.0266114604,
0.0204087961,
0.0256854817,
-0.0008626601,
0.0245530531,
0.002354526,
-0.0582780354,
0.0192370079,
0.0055171647,
-0.0174846184,
0.0002085464,
-0.0488573834,
-0.0145107443,
-0.0211964212,
-0.0362183005,
0.0104851732,
-0.0239123981,
0.0194037277,
-0.0174433608,
0.0186772533,
0.002660838,
-0.0439996384,
-0.1318072975,
-0.0045875018,
-0.0076714954,
-0.0116306823,
0.0186655782,
0.0103177708,
0.0126404762,
-0.0219434462,
-0.0318848193,
-0.0085218167,
0.0356908478,
0.0222590175,
-0.0151512446,
0.0370955691,
0.014352385,
-0.0006319922,
-0.0136667453,
-0.0212842077,
0.0525204167,
-0.0035480445,
-0.0339835398,
-0.0181582235,
0.0276974123,
0.0168513358,
-0.0178447124,
-0.0004678109,
0.0133557413,
0.0181604698,
-0.0214870144,
0.0228261538,
0.0519743375,
-0.0197274089,
0.0352451839,
0.0411775596,
-0.0224095993,
-0.008936177,
-0.0101081897,
-0.0334848613,
-0.0679766238,
-0.0195680298,
-0.0225354806,
0.0024731264,
0.0954318494,
0.039059937,
0.0108943097,
-0.0659415573,
-0.0314864255,
-0.0455830246,
-0.0025492457,
-0.0427753441,
-0.0029511263,
-0.039289251,
0.0066651846,
-0.0148128131,
-0.0290130638,
0.0927411243,
0.0123781282,
0.0097671598,
-0.0807627141,
-0.0246859808,
-0.0317505859,
0.0220465045,
-0.023495404,
0.015158046,
0.0225666817,
-0.024282556,
0.0034320941,
0.0571202561,
-0.0277619623,
-0.0684630275,
0.0890311003,
-0.0384840965,
-0.0041851662,
0.0063571506,
-0.0291971155,
-0.0288420264,
0.012771355,
-0.0226722565,
-0.001590377,
-0.0049132155,
0.0356628075,
-0.0497931577,
0.0110864267,
-0.0455990918,
0.0372536853,
0.0106827877,
0.002007287,
-0.0182314347,
-0.0115759568,
0.019462496,
0.0130111929,
-0.0520148613,
-0.0437602885,
0.0221712887,
0.0535899885,
0.0274618883,
0.0099291075,
-0.0134964734,
0.0349868163,
0.0242224094,
0.0008864913,
0.0036501249,
0.052083116,
0.0287769418,
-0.0729624778,
0.0051557184,
0.1006494984,
0.0231764093,
-0.100738585,
0.0026629288,
-0.015556599,
-0.0186022557,
-0.0263053775,
0.0187996868,
-0.0607838929,
-0.0557990521,
-0.0190404225,
0.0259225741,
-0.0097080702,
-0.0232932828,
0.0059146797,
-0.0265657455,
0.026973702,
0.0393511765,
-0.0180120431,
-0.014115829,
-0.0480011851,
-0.0102150552,
-0.0466488898,
-0.0037913127,
-0.0102900825,
-0.0121638821,
-0.0120411403,
0.0360413045,
-0.0362081863,
-0.1031320617,
0.0320767798,
-0.0297179669,
0.0744503811,
0.072642006,
0.0036735986,
-0.0308935232,
0.0374566987,
-0.0084162205,
0.0207887664,
-0.0131431706,
0.0020440004,
0.0602868535,
-0.0018375703,
-0.005276185,
-0.0282270778,
0.021183284,
-0.0519453026,
-0.0376737379,
-0.0064645382,
0.1120829359,
-0.0469960049,
-0.0212567076,
-0.0215032194,
0.0005720188,
0.0615450442,
0.0695219114,
-0.0104469033,
-0.0304707326,
-0.0163748898,
-0.0077202097,
0.0224613026,
-0.0287191533,
-0.0219389405,
0.0266522113,
-0.0480742306,
-0.0254781824,
-0.0394426323,
-0.0052647819,
0.0796098486,
-0.0113759413,
0.0262697861,
0.0500968583,
0.0531557873,
-0.0070076054,
-0.0851366818,
0.0332751386,
0.0487264432,
0.0112045966,
-0.0804482996,
-0.069272384,
0.0560898893,
0.0056567513,
-0.0018346256,
0.0552530028,
-0.0654076338,
0.0008183717,
0.030165419,
0.0625603944,
0.0144910393,
0.0046566296,
-0.0055694017,
-0.0255818646,
0.0370719247,
-0.0011817206,
-0.0262698922,
-0.0036293587,
0.0202216618,
-0.0267305952,
-0.0148860589,
0.017778011,
-0.0272252969,
0.0378855914,
0.0111681996,
0.0302531328,
-0.0072273868,
-0.0133068124,
0.0298562422,
0.0054765684,
0.0632681474,
-0.0007922084,
-0.0268918164,
-0.0067049507,
0.0062112086,
-0.0017891069,
0.0420189984,
-0.0377708115,
0.0191852301,
0.0418456197,
-0.0165841095,
-0.0122878067,
0.0384420082,
-0.0331996903,
-0.0308931191,
-0.0435340963,
0.0359425992,
-0.0119357798,
-0.0111502288,
0.0620984472,
0.0165138673,
-0.0241805986,
0.0172895957,
0.0017595099,
-0.0020623673,
-0.0165855624,
0.0610188209,
-0.0106042009,
0.0434493423,
-0.0194323566,
0.0639475062,
-0.0184602086,
-0.0330645181,
-0.0153926779,
-0.0161178112,
0.0235508606,
-0.01603234,
0.0203203633,
-0.0239845607,
0.0260557327,
-0.0505084433,
0.0494454689,
-0.0449177325,
0.0223235507,
0.0293072443,
0.0025137761,
0.0188142546,
-0.0205900855,
0.1005996317,
0.006764797,
0.0378589295,
-0.0014913584,
-0.0279955044,
-0.03617597,
-0.0301107671,
0.0268167891,
-0.0085804593,
-0.0754981041,
0.0165403895,
-0.0255540535,
-0.0215581413,
0.0353711583,
-0.0395277999,
-0.0180765186,
-0.0253131185,
0.0697448105,
0.048155278,
-0.0275340825,
-0.0062684868,
-0.0206118505,
0.0191866904,
0.0115944231,
-0.0034524198,
0.0018071174,
-5.337768135e-33,
0.0210081656,
0.0034439564,
0.0237571895,
-0.0402422734,
0.0102057233,
0.0376963764,
-0.0244154502,
0.0086101936,
0.0152893979,
0.037533842,
-0.0137992874,
-0.0052579269,
0.0182569064,
0.0392722674,
0.0200387686,
-0.0240220502,
0.0330140516,
-0.0184387267,
0.0124476682,
0.0349953361,
0.004085924,
0.0560705699,
0.0499779023,
-0.0705384836,
0.010518319,
0.0257107969,
0.0334806964,
-0.0035754873,
0.0089948038,
0.0687116608,
-0.0323390514,
0.0361987539,
0.0586460792,
-0.0312996507,
-0.0449094214,
0.0267848652,
-0.0577916317,
0.0072977729,
0.0099968081,
-0.0218994692,
-0.0516947769,
-0.0235288534,
0.0264177117,
0.0044164867,
-0.0086725913,
0.0005466604,
0.005478384,
-0.0383731797,
-0.0228718854,
-0.0309391804,
-0.0470234491,
0.0374196209,
0.0113926549,
-0.0304148234,
0.0254862774,
0.0208624937,
-0.0382052697,
0.0156606976,
-0.0176371932,
0.0165061578,
-0.013700461,
0.0092724413,
0.0010979807,
-0.0150381522,
-0.0492891483,
0.0621661544,
0.0012773057,
-0.0092267618,
-0.0524587259,
0.0065645301,
-0.0516944751,
0.0621200837,
0.0409260578,
0.0117387297,
0.0087491153,
-0.0067581497,
-0.0970204398,
0.0317239724,
-0.0239135548,
0.0589357018,
0.0453942902,
-0.0157493837,
-0.0298066083,
-0.0253591239,
-0.0121306516,
0.0349619202,
-0.0153154964,
-0.0274145845,
0.0334077068,
0.0082663419,
0.0089540668,
0.0523350276,
0.0613437817,
-0.0256919824,
0.039662037,
-0.0119899083,
0.0518333949,
0.0174556244,
-0.0347168706,
0.0162341353,
-0.035139408,
-0.0271783452,
0.0645170584,
-0.048783958,
0.0519995689,
-0.0060999119,
-0.0005284678,
-0.0168900527,
-0.0475884639,
-0.0284956172,
0.0053978018,
-0.0283953138,
0.0410236791,
0.0699028522,
0.0632033274,
0.039200563,
-0.0105508864,
0.0605236627,
-0.0220087301,
-0.0560999475,
-0.0427242778,
-0.0439010635,
0.0233555567,
0.0017557768,
-0.0348037034,
-0.0169217959,
-0.0624452829,
0.0090228552,
0.045865126,
-0.0422386043,
-0.0185826793,
0.0100818742,
2.569e-7,
0.084782891,
0.0704981759,
-0.0122154513,
-0.0284034126,
0.026344547,
0.0180685855,
-0.0279731899,
0.0524393395,
-0.0080720671,
-0.0106745018,
0.0165884104,
0.0314316452,
0.0494508855,
0.0270542763,
-0.073074393,
-0.0585750788,
-0.0446447842,
0.0159859266,
-0.0393296108,
-0.0077943988,
0.0424751304,
0.1006012633,
-0.0407380126,
-0.0213330053,
0.0363455378,
0.0103621418,
0.0472611636,
-0.0295951366,
-0.020328844,
0.0480986126,
-0.0142151807,
-0.0236685257,
0.0053021205,
0.0685445368,
-0.0281449594,
-0.0221824907,
0.0205597486,
0.1073405743,
-0.0563145243,
-0.0019229962,
0.015240375,
0.0238912571,
0.0005762901,
-0.0105051184,
0.0403248519,
-0.0994569212,
-0.055614952,
-0.0214019418,
-0.0049880161,
0.0182058811,
0.0474608168,
-0.0229114201,
-0.0089405943,
0.0146027012,
0.0358128771,
0.0212120526,
-0.0417721644,
-0.0729868412,
-0.0128135951,
0.0577501282,
-0.0412756577,
-0.0271574948,
0.0290741213,
-0.0440485477,
0.0276642237,
-0.1026896685,
0.0360508636,
2.242026115e-34,
0.0340673029,
0.0191478971,
0.0154358838,
0.0578362197,
0.0115794968,
-0.0285899527,
-0.0370459259,
0.0426511914,
-0.0021634451,
-0.0704238564,
-0.0158989821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12725v1 | Can Large Language Models Code Like a Linguist?: A Case Study in Low Resource Sound Law Induction | 2024-06-18T15:46:04 | 2024-06-18T15:46:04 | Atharva Naik, Kexun Zhang, Nathaniel Robinson, Aravind Mysore, Clayton Marr, Hong Sng Rebecca Byrnes, Anna Cai, Kalvin Chang, David Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Historical linguists have long written a kind of incompletely formalized
''program'' that converts reconstructed words in an ancestor language into
words in one of its attested descendants that consist of a series of ordered
string rewrite functions (called sound laws). They do this by observing pairs
of words in the reconstructed language (protoforms) and the descendent language
(reflexes) and constructing a program that transforms protoforms into reflexes.
However, writing these programs is error-prone and time-consuming. Prior work
has successfully scaffolded this process computationally, but fewer researchers
have tackled Sound Law Induction (SLI), which we approach in this paper by
casting it as Programming by Examples. We propose a language-agnostic solution
that utilizes the programming ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) by
generating Python sound law programs from sound change examples. We evaluate
the effectiveness of our approach for various LLMs, propose effective methods
to generate additional language-agnostic synthetic data to fine-tune LLMs for
SLI, and compare our method with existing automated SLI methods showing that
while LLMs lag behind them they can complement some of their weaknesses. | [
-0.0037945134,
0.1024897099,
-0.0435347706,
0.0288397875,
-0.0522103868,
-0.0114202714,
-0.0413573273,
0.0107183121,
-0.0229949206,
-0.0390864573,
-0.0141657637,
-0.0101105943,
0.039176397,
0.0129801277,
0.0423836224,
-0.0086344313,
0.0552092753,
-0.0607727133,
0.0081086224,
0.0216461476,
-0.021757409,
0.0074889148,
-0.0041916384,
0.0283945054,
0.0038300306,
0.0037137731,
-0.0121139986,
0.0061134789,
-0.0347888432,
0.0145879658,
-0.0332883932,
0.0084725143,
0.0293696783,
0.0901281759,
0.0000018224,
-0.0594073832,
0.0245749578,
0.0111916671,
-0.019324135,
0.0611697845,
0.0170917995,
-0.0388639458,
-0.0554426908,
-0.003421647,
-0.0154500315,
-0.0045158602,
0.072948046,
-0.1126428172,
0.0397518948,
0.0824207813,
-0.0112735424,
-0.0678275302,
0.0519893244,
-0.0075417445,
0.0219746865,
0.0382155553,
0.0285727512,
0.0139608048,
0.0034477233,
-0.0474085584,
-0.0175386276,
0.0224947426,
-0.0126817226,
-0.0197871123,
-0.0373508744,
-0.0361298025,
-0.0309927613,
-0.0367232412,
-0.0213059317,
0.0296647064,
-0.0061755585,
-0.0817334428,
-0.0288441665,
0.0289853029,
-0.0078940652,
-0.0099202106,
-0.0143232867,
0.0280967001,
0.0188766532,
0.0000416766,
0.0606784113,
-0.0304710567,
0.0497195385,
-0.0220418647,
-0.0308394618,
0.0495332032,
0.0559882782,
-0.0674495623,
-0.0368644372,
-0.0362189077,
0.0301742516,
-0.0293356832,
-0.00490137,
0.0253863074,
-0.0335421413,
0.0474080369,
-0.0072228219,
-0.0089407498,
0.007374411,
0.020822186,
0.0322196558,
0.0246864278,
-0.0057928646,
0.0357388742,
-0.0484442413,
0.0140026174,
-0.0133308908,
-0.0479751192,
-0.0251891688,
0.0114416108,
-0.0340981521,
-0.0264607072,
-0.0662940443,
0.0036746368,
-0.021924099,
0.0292826649,
0.0014155738,
0.0355003029,
-0.0187111069,
0.013979258,
-0.0399870537,
-0.0583809651,
-0.0266112741,
0.0022299376,
-0.0069393734,
-0.0017832208,
0.0297907032,
0.0441754647,
-0.0456718393,
-0.057665661,
0.0102962721,
-0.007058112,
0.0002136996,
0.0228485614,
0.0349939615,
0.0493533835,
-0.0022681113,
-0.0027724071,
-0.0212009083,
-0.017206423,
-0.0233808272,
-0.0129657183,
-0.031241959,
-0.0801708773,
0.0144512821,
-0.0170006584,
-0.007647594,
-0.0482765883,
0.0080088498,
-0.0191853624,
-0.0294444431,
0.0501057096,
-0.0337005518,
0.0519482344,
-0.0300327111,
-0.0181658342,
0.0106911818,
0.0223440081,
0.0743657053,
-0.0752789527,
0.022064086,
-0.0290759895,
0.003833489,
0.0610846356,
-0.0056623844,
0.0147254653,
-0.0552163571,
-0.0266047623,
-0.0022085803,
0.04845367,
0.0154330637,
0.0441761091,
-0.0037333337,
-0.0158158168,
0.0112432381,
0.057308618,
0.011823345,
0.0436129607,
0.095356077,
-0.0395820066,
-0.0023394304,
0.0181317367,
0.0076297391,
-0.0342731401,
-0.0051657255,
0.0331222452,
-0.014275495,
0.0259264782,
0.0130438479,
-0.0141396532,
-0.0036301268,
-0.0161081906,
-0.0234100223,
-0.0062500485,
0.0525128096,
0.073645182,
-0.0369974263,
0.0421223342,
0.0465940125,
-0.0825930834,
-0.0014039774,
-0.0266118012,
0.0598769672,
0.0449435674,
0.0525092892,
-0.0729175881,
0.0444565937,
-0.0029001262,
-0.0211442672,
0.0468946509,
0.0310105383,
-0.0398673639,
-0.0059796423,
-0.0147819156,
0.0184895732,
0.0273285247,
0.0392766483,
0.0552588701,
0.0131732533,
-0.022418797,
0.0026792677,
-0.0409581624,
-0.0262650307,
0.0232159477,
-0.0628968328,
-0.0392760374,
0.0047221109,
0.0071805064,
0.060463544,
0.0233211908,
-0.0375904776,
0.0534443669,
0.0266413167,
-0.0375213027,
0.0205072723,
0.0379964598,
-0.0333474576,
-0.0383989252,
0.0817531422,
-0.006346589,
0.0135372709,
0.0018223017,
0.0076726777,
-0.0203712285,
0.0545873158,
-0.0564009249,
0.0891025066,
-0.0049731517,
0.0325183235,
-0.0256370269,
-0.03216042,
0.0004832815,
0.0077845785,
0.0482055731,
0.0074222251,
0.0156235965,
0.0023237099,
0.0188456904,
-0.0207598694,
-0.0160823204,
0.0108011803,
-0.0238032173,
-0.0011340462,
0.0014641953,
-0.0198291764,
-0.0159391798,
-0.0387364887,
-0.0292979274,
-0.0258709546,
-0.0030231515,
0.0038990784,
-0.0138624795,
0.0137578612,
0.0129469316,
0.0163489077,
-0.0037477063,
-0.0114340251,
-0.0234343782,
0.0352743492,
-0.0063460185,
-0.0421300046,
-0.1138558388,
-0.0380704701,
-0.0127242887,
-0.0089135598,
0.0401230566,
0.0055682831,
0.0120427636,
-0.0773730204,
-0.0027049303,
-0.0395163484,
0.0229571462,
-0.018008925,
-0.041626282,
-0.0025673585,
-0.0303081833,
0.0633634627,
-0.0044053802,
-0.0376251228,
-0.015136457,
0.0508697815,
0.0005942635,
-0.0235541575,
-0.0316855982,
-0.007587174,
-0.0127450293,
-0.0332020596,
-0.013305611,
-0.0037673078,
0.0476113819,
0.0102429492,
-0.0166607667,
-0.0240269098,
0.0268901922,
-0.0052720667,
-0.0166082382,
-0.0059703882,
-0.0817049816,
-0.0338370129,
0.0618338473,
-0.0186289493,
-0.0794020593,
0.0515805222,
-0.038542863,
-0.011429348,
-0.0460911207,
-0.0427851267,
-0.0651156306,
0.0937855244,
0.0025203391,
0.0118243666,
0.0423942395,
-0.012213856,
-0.0253626183,
0.0080716461,
0.061715845,
-0.039377436,
0.0356180891,
-0.0600312613,
0.0384653509,
-0.0001598428,
-0.0391019844,
-0.019064052,
0.0028785721,
-0.0178569723,
0.0379335806,
-0.0073411269,
-0.0352728479,
0.0403344408,
0.0285395719,
0.0254572406,
0.0416390337,
0.0704836026,
0.0059551448,
-0.0246902145,
0.0156496018,
-0.0268976558,
-0.0040745898,
-0.0428268127,
0.0108025027,
0.0243854076,
-0.0340803638,
0.0476269163,
0.0269325357,
-0.0494297929,
0.021043675,
0.0312316231,
-0.0173597187,
0.0015660914,
0.0357332192,
-0.0377316847,
-0.0071773883,
-0.0027655328,
0.0514490157,
0.0330204368,
-0.0062521622,
0.0441728458,
0.0022608209,
0.0487056039,
0.0346691422,
-0.0136795221,
-0.0936739519,
0.0016443732,
0.0308994427,
0.0073038917,
-0.00228544,
0.0098399613,
-0.0106086023,
-0.1360192001,
0.0676078647,
0.0625870228,
-0.0718883425,
-0.0384148955,
-0.0244985875,
0.0042981985,
0.0110708689,
-0.0417178497,
0.0689054579,
-0.0178787131,
0.001190297,
0.0004107125,
-0.0487336516,
-0.0142453797,
0.0020375878,
-0.0252650138,
0.0566058606,
0.0397222638,
0.0462576635,
-0.0464596935,
-0.0273534171,
0.0254388694,
0.0284907091,
0.0007956862,
0.0059933751,
-0.0140460692,
0.1020083129,
0.0023405317,
0.0260511339,
0.0129547771,
-0.042708464,
-0.0294431373,
0.0335078984,
0.0888956264,
0.0186800137,
-0.0152311735,
0.0078167794,
0.0055181812,
-0.0127719212,
0.0408434831,
0.0298327059,
-0.0100391284,
0.002867027,
-0.0340038128,
-0.0558124706,
0.0129634626,
-0.072715506,
-0.0189302266,
0.0157799106,
-0.0558874942,
-0.101468794,
0.0545625538,
-0.0075870468,
0.0454447903,
0.0664381459,
0.0089943921,
0.0382609218,
-0.0102556711,
-0.0797215402,
-0.0119074062,
-0.0522363447,
0.0543774478,
-0.0335339457,
-0.032407064,
0.0431435741,
-0.0243398864,
-0.0104247415,
0.010048083,
0.0028187416,
-0.0797476023,
0.0315691531,
0.0283427108,
0.0247065593,
0.0142728733,
-0.0147934761,
0.0149924271,
0.0182448663,
0.0429873988,
-0.0452538542,
0.0417881869,
0.0551663935,
-0.0050571864,
0.0112542706,
0.0164785963,
-0.0182179473,
0.0013023056,
0.015890006,
0.02573172,
0.0048575825,
-0.0504993014,
0.0559208468,
0.0469837971,
0.0036522236,
-0.0287947878,
-0.0439380147,
-0.0041079251,
0.0063021258,
0.0058195279,
0.012376504,
-0.0468108878,
0.0203690846,
0.0272341426,
0.0251389928,
-0.0035930017,
-0.033929009,
-0.0099854069,
0.029973289,
0.022908438,
0.0516413227,
0.0381282307,
0.0545888208,
0.0714669675,
-0.0198554825,
0.0123835858,
0.067220673,
-0.0677699968,
0.0348431095,
-0.0070550903,
-0.0407317318,
-0.0069203563,
0.0032039639,
-0.0304671545,
-0.0172999874,
-0.0129654426,
-0.0315051861,
0.0035752931,
0.0096096788,
0.0821590573,
0.0140243303,
0.0592852496,
-0.0413966142,
-0.0137133524,
0.0057220748,
0.0381333306,
-0.0175382793,
-0.0170225427,
0.0052288575,
0.0374664292,
-0.0309513789,
0.0429127626,
0.0442445166,
-0.016017152,
0.0680554062,
-0.0026629635,
0.0419193543,
-0.0188387427,
-0.0445579775,
-0.0279864017,
-0.0273906756,
-0.0379496366,
-0.0030775694,
-0.0849498287,
-0.0553042144,
-0.0401980318,
0.0284791347,
0.0189095158,
-0.0131522408,
0.0403129198,
0.0640494451,
-0.0124801993,
0.0598528385,
-0.0119423894,
0.0096543953,
-0.0150082577,
-0.0599875562,
-0.000118432,
-5.058480963e-33,
-0.0218886528,
0.0088490406,
0.0250266958,
0.0242109317,
-0.0002776918,
-0.0009617302,
-0.0501965657,
0.008850391,
0.0128302947,
0.0048156702,
0.027566703,
-0.02592366,
-0.0045174523,
-0.0340787508,
0.0123334127,
0.0321360379,
0.0260681529,
-0.0110942507,
0.0068393205,
-0.0315045975,
0.02169488,
-0.0196212009,
0.0356867574,
-0.0571922995,
-0.0042672856,
0.0334634669,
-0.0215305202,
0.0164953656,
-0.0765035376,
0.0240753088,
0.0053787748,
0.034538243,
-0.0345295779,
-0.0178849548,
-0.0086341128,
0.0108368639,
-0.0506418161,
0.0319629721,
0.0435059443,
-0.0104633356,
0.0299336985,
-0.0166822392,
0.0518988445,
0.016762875,
-0.0216828622,
0.027639186,
-0.0124617629,
-0.0462301783,
-0.0122296596,
-0.0492289402,
-0.1258194149,
0.018327605,
-0.0202889331,
-0.0347515531,
0.0353787765,
-0.0002602254,
-0.0230363254,
-0.0121649923,
-0.0025058244,
0.0637669638,
0.0175076146,
0.0416725911,
0.0086883968,
-0.0234528687,
-0.0227200575,
0.0092478832,
0.078580603,
-0.0222757291,
0.0300911926,
0.0406543948,
0.0358349383,
0.0350539647,
0.0203736313,
0.0439236723,
0.0167384539,
-0.011943521,
-0.0293360557,
-0.0563901849,
0.0643685535,
-0.0370746031,
0.0004462727,
0.0471006744,
-0.0153831299,
-0.0178668238,
-0.0565855056,
-0.0158181228,
-0.0178898554,
0.0048013488,
-0.0029146066,
0.000253118,
0.0364763811,
-0.0277572721,
0.0033545382,
-0.0270855092,
-0.0082774721,
0.0161799323,
-0.0191192664,
0.0251525789,
-0.0263152011,
0.0020366034,
-0.0087072775,
-0.0348493233,
0.0488657169,
0.0028577815,
0.0364279076,
0.0128156105,
-0.0066203433,
0.062239185,
-0.0476486534,
-0.0064270264,
-0.0366372168,
-0.0426422209,
0.0162117779,
0.0046479222,
0.0070558735,
0.0334316827,
0.0142223286,
-0.04185405,
0.0380406268,
-0.0583047383,
-0.0254717208,
0.050418593,
-0.0461672992,
0.0206289664,
-0.0414477326,
-0.026234556,
-0.0019917311,
0.0230620373,
0.0548672713,
0.0059008868,
-0.0186642054,
-0.002230261,
2.794e-7,
0.0146706384,
0.02815051,
0.0539344214,
0.0379450805,
0.0318310373,
0.004012784,
-0.0520435497,
-0.0412479118,
0.0255061723,
-0.0002051787,
0.0283438005,
-0.0253550094,
0.0656120405,
0.0234911032,
-0.114392668,
0.0170258656,
-0.0625999048,
-0.033486601,
-0.0593316592,
-0.0127002671,
-0.0017733224,
0.0895944387,
0.0212470219,
-0.0692534149,
-0.0209541172,
-0.0322396606,
0.0033488583,
-0.0243806299,
0.0010117498,
-0.0158934575,
-0.0233446453,
-0.0301768035,
0.0093093682,
0.0064077936,
-0.0514596105,
0.0203183722,
-0.0171456821,
0.0470067263,
0.0018096303,
0.0573428869,
0.0157930609,
-0.0012840709,
-0.0183081198,
-0.0210914947,
0.0007907343,
0.0345523693,
0.0021508734,
-0.0112236403,
-0.0387419127,
0.028568631,
-0.0315033346,
-0.0009767183,
0.031320937,
-0.0164771639,
0.0297328774,
0.0260614492,
-0.0299862716,
-0.0296013504,
-0.0376998,
0.0414498225,
-0.020491546,
-0.0650007874,
0.0202257819,
-0.0110717444,
-0.0054961224,
-0.0509378798,
-0.0042242901,
2.760471929e-34,
0.0431492515,
-0.0221314635,
0.0519384518,
0.0267174225,
0.0324588344,
-0.012755936,
0.0247381292,
0.0451610908,
0.0304563455,
-0.034473151,
-0.0224177949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12719v1 | On the Robustness of Language Models for Tabular Question Answering | 2024-06-18T15:41:15 | 2024-06-18T15:41:15 | Kushal Raj Bhandari, Sixue Xing, Soham Dan, Jianxi Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), originally shown to ace various text
comprehension tasks have also remarkably been shown to tackle table
comprehension tasks without specific training. While previous research has
explored LLM capabilities with tabular dataset tasks, our study assesses the
influence of $\textit{in-context learning}$,$ \textit{model scale}$,
$\textit{instruction tuning}$, and $\textit{domain biases}$ on Tabular Question
Answering (TQA). We evaluate the robustness of LLMs on Wikipedia-based
$\textbf{WTQ}$ and financial report-based $\textbf{TAT-QA}$ TQA datasets,
focusing on their ability to robustly interpret tabular data under various
augmentations and perturbations. Our findings indicate that instructions
significantly enhance performance, with recent models like Llama3 exhibiting
greater robustness over earlier versions. However, data contamination and
practical reliability issues persist, especially with WTQ. We highlight the
need for improved methodologies, including structure-aware self-attention
mechanisms and better handling of domain-specific tabular data, to develop more
reliable LLMs for table comprehension. | [
0.0217765123,
0.0597989894,
-0.0021375974,
0.008278762,
-0.0057194233,
0.0366231725,
0.0108089307,
-0.0055921711,
0.0131618688,
-0.0282179657,
-0.0604173839,
-0.0426071063,
-0.028881561,
-0.0001851103,
0.0528401397,
0.0193801448,
0.0567714311,
-0.0255102254,
-0.0453693345,
-0.0045542172,
-0.0184236579,
-0.0347611792,
-0.0048847068,
-0.0139481053,
0.0295421686,
-0.0151700964,
-0.0123905474,
-0.0140204979,
-0.0408260114,
0.0171113331,
0.0130073084,
0.082324475,
0.0219879784,
0.042553138,
0.0000021064,
0.0044976096,
-0.0290492829,
-0.0230156779,
-0.026256308,
0.0486097224,
0.0148424208,
-0.0354391076,
0.0082690101,
-0.0146871908,
-0.0289186742,
-0.0057078013,
0.0162261315,
0.0241237581,
0.0684599727,
0.0397487357,
0.023767231,
-0.0293315481,
0.0193958953,
-0.0284416582,
0.0666294321,
-0.0756454691,
0.020611845,
0.0382030308,
-0.0028362658,
-0.0034609269,
-0.0231110454,
0.0601034574,
0.0448666662,
0.0150709748,
0.0135923745,
0.0387601666,
-0.0392961949,
0.0263028052,
-0.0058101234,
0.1070914119,
0.0425226949,
-0.0011071095,
-0.004031966,
0.0184799563,
0.0333603844,
0.0021416522,
-0.0606305785,
0.0056909323,
-0.0025345546,
-0.028513575,
0.0089394068,
-0.0279271062,
0.0180084035,
0.0098181879,
-0.0421464257,
0.0641627908,
-0.0102300998,
-0.0525239892,
0.0146343382,
-0.0036548492,
-0.0303366948,
0.00197866,
0.0185072329,
0.0540185571,
-0.0211203732,
0.041755043,
-0.0083938334,
-0.036266081,
0.0307540353,
-0.0652274936,
0.0333561189,
0.0631606728,
-0.023271786,
0.0384455025,
-0.040155232,
0.0524077564,
-0.030406829,
0.0388067774,
-0.0418455116,
0.0093873544,
-0.0186302625,
-0.0229734108,
-0.0420406833,
0.0416120477,
-0.0485933796,
-0.0068201148,
0.0052464325,
0.0352744721,
0.0086414954,
0.0142782331,
0.0008961033,
0.0116311675,
-0.0282881986,
0.0010974588,
-0.0410636812,
0.0237841252,
-0.0424783044,
0.0059464625,
-0.0204793811,
-0.0538902991,
-0.0329296067,
-0.0181326568,
-0.0257829111,
-0.0494266152,
0.0458351932,
0.0974565148,
-0.0309976023,
-0.0286084712,
-0.0436112769,
-0.0052720415,
-0.0234265812,
-0.0691256598,
0.0208644588,
-0.0408204645,
0.0544762351,
0.0214010701,
-0.0018661499,
-0.0574208014,
0.0068129627,
0.0510008708,
-0.0193024985,
0.079413943,
0.0244125761,
0.0139505286,
0.0104927979,
0.000269134,
-0.0270665959,
0.0770007297,
0.0256336574,
-0.0085905297,
-0.0093732923,
-0.020137623,
-0.0347902142,
0.0340459198,
0.0385680161,
0.0023980839,
0.0085979104,
0.0895327479,
0.0406442583,
0.0216738433,
0.0345852487,
0.0181292538,
-0.0161515139,
-0.0028589931,
0.072622098,
0.0242014267,
0.0008200594,
0.0526173972,
0.0014911394,
-0.004665141,
0.0495836996,
0.0378263742,
-0.0511446297,
0.0368782021,
-0.0093149329,
0.0437226631,
0.0438883267,
-0.0025161989,
-0.0432253741,
-0.0702969134,
0.0035617321,
0.0200948492,
-0.0098996572,
0.0226488113,
0.045877073,
0.0021658619,
-0.0817997381,
0.0190299582,
0.0165968724,
-0.0161836222,
-0.0115185436,
-0.0266051162,
0.0581086539,
0.061633952,
0.0323991068,
-0.0573384427,
-0.0213963706,
-0.0040017115,
0.0466764383,
0.0106247887,
0.0243939906,
-0.0310241468,
-0.0065000281,
-0.0141775003,
0.0070749335,
-0.0169078968,
0.0250469949,
0.0069658579,
0.0093182148,
0.0064251246,
-0.0134550985,
-0.0835472941,
-0.0219569281,
0.0350244269,
0.0006397857,
-0.0588811897,
-0.0237437114,
0.0015237581,
-0.0105770472,
0.0130389612,
0.0060300608,
0.0208012816,
0.0263297409,
-0.0165466815,
0.0305577982,
-0.0365423672,
-0.0386124216,
-0.0220888034,
0.0263470486,
0.0385405086,
-0.0633813441,
0.0089156013,
-0.0234291386,
-0.0169647485,
0.0123834144,
-0.0529859997,
-0.0383760706,
-0.0271555763,
-0.0014088947,
0.0101607759,
0.0452237129,
-0.0287298691,
0.0815881118,
-0.0314671211,
0.027130397,
0.0365446322,
-0.0426402129,
0.0031823814,
-0.0318942778,
0.0157976244,
-0.0253004804,
-0.0136988033,
0.0316210389,
-0.0283861868,
0.0166165177,
-0.0567004867,
-0.0221260022,
-0.0567181781,
0.0374526381,
-0.0598902404,
0.0537288263,
0.0422356762,
-0.0073267287,
-0.0283802189,
-0.0336198546,
-0.0272813514,
-0.0090325009,
-0.0003603558,
0.014216803,
0.0656192899,
0.0179549716,
-0.0089142062,
-0.0406370424,
-0.0465780161,
-0.0307736918,
0.0363906398,
-0.0023226312,
-0.0291083138,
-0.029112421,
-0.0116684651,
0.0029602575,
0.0014368821,
0.0049230536,
-0.006685656,
-0.0054627624,
-0.0009369639,
0.0527237393,
0.1008286849,
-0.0365309119,
0.0374466144,
0.0254284944,
0.0038848626,
-0.0308504179,
0.03237826,
0.0074152318,
-0.0145202773,
-0.011042932,
-0.0589218549,
0.0404501259,
0.0615072213,
-0.0316699222,
0.0071006371,
-0.0449911542,
0.0205834936,
-0.0046353196,
-0.0165490266,
-0.0551916771,
0.0621701665,
-0.007458176,
0.0103514409,
-0.0205024127,
-0.0130632799,
0.0475811809,
-0.0093222642,
-0.001623619,
-0.0461275801,
0.020181736,
-0.0421902686,
0.0469475947,
0.0135112638,
-0.0154241556,
-0.0011846304,
-0.0361774154,
-0.0413746275,
-0.0010348926,
-0.0005198316,
-0.0287972558,
0.0912337825,
-0.0377408452,
0.0224084668,
-0.0141384648,
-0.0126686022,
-0.0194928739,
-0.0269451644,
-0.0039485041,
0.0319310315,
-0.0016156569,
0.0188319534,
-0.0385680273,
0.0021377793,
0.0437302552,
0.0276572425,
-0.0348639749,
-0.0243917797,
-0.0375115313,
0.0621960126,
0.0423912629,
0.0233728345,
0.0084803235,
-0.0379387699,
0.0374384597,
0.0385975875,
0.0261206478,
-0.0241951365,
0.0181861576,
0.0165374558,
0.03024064,
-0.0534155592,
0.0132978642,
0.0289743878,
0.0046884324,
-0.0675939247,
-0.0399329439,
0.0773824453,
0.0219880939,
0.0150091816,
-0.0090364562,
-0.0128764696,
0.0335557908,
0.0180654489,
0.0625802949,
-0.0806523338,
-0.033412829,
-0.0150003852,
0.0231111161,
0.0446904749,
-0.0392524973,
-0.0080696708,
-0.0877686888,
0.0301836319,
-0.0275800209,
-0.0539706722,
-0.0998808965,
-0.0439520217,
-0.0012532617,
-0.0243335571,
0.0772403479,
0.0684991404,
-0.0443426855,
0.023138497,
0.031273514,
-0.0142061878,
-0.0325300135,
0.0153503418,
-0.0286228247,
0.0348975956,
0.0493622497,
-0.0200057887,
-0.0495325848,
-0.0117895063,
0.0144391377,
-0.0088464757,
0.00302855,
0.0185886603,
0.0574872196,
-0.0177174006,
-0.0119521571,
-0.0028375983,
0.0096588517,
-0.0373763815,
0.0261595119,
0.0208483525,
0.0480668321,
-0.0170990918,
-0.0091635128,
0.0147757968,
-0.0093946774,
-0.0259980317,
0.0877375305,
0.0519152135,
-0.0226742383,
-0.0556395948,
-0.0227992535,
-0.0609813966,
-0.0907253772,
0.0109658698,
0.0516260788,
0.0114862407,
0.0106782755,
-0.0512432382,
-0.0647814572,
0.062852405,
0.0267354213,
-0.0176279712,
0.0551654287,
-0.025218524,
-0.0137140499,
-0.0280379262,
0.0079330876,
-0.0632794574,
0.0008540413,
-0.0444442108,
-0.0251778923,
-0.0024951997,
-0.0436559878,
-0.0252925996,
0.020876959,
-0.0915537477,
-0.0249205288,
0.0055926358,
0.0311769675,
0.0187915247,
0.0042051184,
0.0099111293,
-0.0090445243,
-0.0063094762,
0.0026431337,
-0.0808730945,
0.0161323976,
0.0146450624,
-0.0167881437,
0.0052305553,
0.0408236347,
-0.0415785834,
-0.0166708995,
-0.0001063207,
0.0673890859,
-0.0009983747,
0.0336832553,
0.0370226204,
-0.0020780934,
-0.0285304207,
0.0476462618,
-0.0264747124,
-0.0018065382,
0.0372816324,
-0.0223113075,
-0.000226924,
0.0013727358,
-0.0147303743,
0.0164015573,
-0.041283451,
-0.0321107171,
0.0009645104,
-0.0070095086,
0.0472259372,
-0.0657690838,
0.0242002774,
0.015889708,
-0.0206479598,
0.0083201798,
-0.0432538129,
-0.0208603386,
-0.0350396968,
0.0223679431,
0.0430810899,
0.0118424641,
0.0216915216,
0.017898025,
-0.0440948978,
-0.0311249644,
0.0505106635,
-0.0728308633,
-0.0426940173,
-0.0004549172,
0.0310016796,
0.0108250333,
-0.0045523541,
-0.0087627806,
-0.0238066316,
-0.0088033378,
0.010747741,
-0.0369662829,
0.0571066998,
0.0264646597,
0.077624768,
0.0199004021,
0.0041626506,
-0.023271272,
0.0978762358,
0.0779068768,
0.0313648283,
-0.0024723532,
-0.0155703155,
-0.0420377254,
-0.0118252067,
-0.0273450408,
-0.0018421449,
-0.0557475053,
-0.0267913342,
-0.0375749394,
-0.0634660646,
0.0198900551,
0.0209149756,
-0.0377487317,
-0.0201069266,
-0.000212326,
0.0686609522,
0.0524411574,
-0.0152995382,
-0.0320044793,
0.0557502694,
-0.0247976575,
-0.0180703979,
-0.0192035716,
-6.433913311e-33,
-0.0397690237,
-0.00391813,
0.0251809191,
-0.0494525731,
0.0128345545,
-0.0126054082,
-0.0539355874,
-0.0230803862,
-0.0373704769,
-0.0239070505,
-0.0357180461,
0.0428524502,
0.0184375383,
-0.00063307,
-0.0000155071,
-0.0872751921,
0.001808055,
-0.0258228574,
-0.0162198208,
-0.0078443019,
-0.0378910527,
0.0391862914,
0.0384521447,
-0.0066953688,
0.0526934192,
-0.0265300311,
0.0156951379,
-0.0175448526,
0.0089237513,
0.0481811836,
-0.0399558432,
0.0450021997,
0.0300535597,
-0.0763913915,
-0.0338383913,
0.0134804407,
-0.1490563303,
-0.0116614113,
0.0210973509,
0.0299797188,
-0.0192090645,
-0.0308881421,
0.0382096618,
-0.0053874734,
0.0096229771,
-0.0297503285,
0.012863189,
-0.0320010856,
-0.0056210998,
0.0220768768,
-0.0373984277,
0.0080294413,
-0.0322262831,
-0.0017269457,
0.0199524257,
0.0604618117,
0.022864135,
0.0254969243,
-0.0445916392,
-0.0091158105,
0.0103348577,
0.0221390203,
0.0575657114,
-0.019719867,
0.0251932256,
0.0024837605,
0.0225783996,
0.0196790826,
-0.0302434396,
-0.0509766564,
-0.0165596772,
0.0093027251,
0.0430225469,
-0.0015658167,
0.022500271,
0.0110110836,
-0.0823146403,
0.0564000718,
0.0071511827,
0.030867707,
0.0022417116,
-0.0278906636,
-0.0543962643,
-0.001429243,
-0.0325386338,
0.0206925552,
-0.0336961746,
-0.0038578918,
0.0326131806,
-0.030531818,
0.0160186458,
-0.0047560888,
0.0159687735,
-0.0172174815,
-0.0089745708,
0.0512326211,
-0.0123022813,
0.0246272404,
0.0171813965,
0.0243866891,
-0.0311904922,
0.004216081,
-0.0100801401,
0.0068184612,
0.0225473978,
0.0242764447,
0.0242831837,
0.0097767487,
-0.0676204264,
-0.0184450708,
-0.0485149212,
0.0322641172,
0.0160032269,
0.0244262591,
0.0272996519,
0.0154832872,
-0.001555998,
0.0401122794,
0.0234571025,
-0.0067053954,
-0.0237619355,
0.0010707142,
-0.0304122623,
0.0225880649,
0.0037630142,
-0.000150919,
-0.0135805923,
0.0736109242,
-0.0282513853,
-0.0558488481,
0.0028329408,
0.0376611054,
2.672e-7,
0.0796337649,
0.0426133946,
0.0460297801,
0.0380804017,
-0.0123417675,
0.0005232063,
-0.0186928734,
0.0116427885,
-0.0123860203,
-0.0404346362,
0.035954766,
0.031367667,
0.0327485986,
0.007818657,
-0.0470537059,
-0.0368654877,
-0.0611268952,
0.0417423062,
-0.0492621623,
-0.0161947329,
0.0232543964,
0.0814161599,
-0.0661708489,
-0.0122174481,
-0.0111908084,
-0.0528981015,
0.0553879514,
-0.0315225497,
0.0250346828,
0.0275012329,
0.0265013762,
-0.0146988425,
0.0025764145,
0.0532321632,
-0.0154368803,
0.0185060538,
0.0247916579,
0.0671279579,
0.0322970748,
0.0033841433,
-0.0312703922,
-0.0809485912,
0.0343871973,
-0.0761581138,
0.114711225,
-0.0520202667,
-0.0221507642,
0.0700360984,
-0.0246506296,
0.0134006385,
0.0347001329,
0.0070733987,
-0.0084041776,
0.0209551621,
0.0166968461,
-0.0103706587,
0.0147534302,
-0.0458989739,
-0.0132588847,
0.0141150998,
-0.0254384447,
-0.0076951054,
-0.0509484299,
-0.0445175171,
0.0104278587,
-0.0661462247,
-0.0171628091,
2.429343665e-34,
0.0492056534,
-0.0369777381,
0.0426652841,
0.0576198958,
0.0275898278,
-0.0334920138,
0.014329371,
-0.0126066059,
0.0255485084,
-0.111722514,
-0.0065747993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12718v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12718v2 | AGLA: Mitigating Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models with Assembly of Global and Local Attention | 2024-06-18T15:38:41 | 2024-06-21T17:33:21 | Wenbin An, Feng Tian, Sicong Leng, Jiahao Nie, Haonan Lin, QianYing Wang, Guang Dai, Ping Chen, Shijian Lu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite their great success across various multimodal tasks, Large
Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) are facing a prevalent problem with object
hallucinations, where the generated textual responses are inconsistent with
ground-truth objects in the given image. This paper investigates various LVLMs
and pinpoints attention deficiency toward discriminative local image features
as one root cause of object hallucinations. Specifically, LVLMs predominantly
attend to prompt-independent global image features, while failing to capture
prompt-relevant local features, consequently undermining the visual grounding
capacity of LVLMs and leading to hallucinations. To this end, we propose
Assembly of Global and Local Attention (AGLA), a training-free and
plug-and-play approach that mitigates object hallucinations by exploring an
ensemble of global features for response generation and local features for
visual discrimination simultaneously. Our approach exhibits an image-prompt
matching scheme that captures prompt-relevant local features from images,
leading to an augmented view of the input image where prompt-relevant content
is reserved while irrelevant distractions are masked. With the augmented view,
a calibrated decoding distribution can be derived by integrating generative
global features from the original image and discriminative local features from
the augmented image. Extensive experiments show that AGLA consistently
mitigates object hallucinations and enhances general perception capability for
LVLMs across various discriminative and generative benchmarks. Our code will be
released at https://github.com/Lackel/AGLA. | [
0.0087694004,
0.0396049134,
0.018323537,
0.064730376,
0.0090517513,
0.0228288919,
0.0232223254,
-0.0004752616,
0.0348861553,
-0.052168753,
-0.0406308733,
-0.0532267131,
0.0221355055,
0.0115701044,
0.0354329608,
-0.0435887277,
0.029719796,
-0.0419601314,
-0.0618718602,
0.0034896389,
0.0002354527,
-0.0034232282,
0.0093939016,
0.0482868738,
-0.0269260183,
-0.0545152128,
-0.0108753564,
0.0172431152,
0.0216883607,
0.0086218482,
-0.0311984234,
0.0584933236,
-0.0051364205,
0.0038849071,
0.0000021988,
-0.0390965529,
0.0283881556,
-0.0118334321,
0.0218669027,
-0.0270538852,
0.0202104282,
-0.0072921421,
0.0084751435,
-0.0140542733,
-0.0134017691,
-0.0374818295,
0.0937371477,
0.0565956719,
0.0341382958,
0.0309189111,
-0.0137124453,
-0.0231301319,
0.0113262804,
0.0082351072,
0.0506364852,
-0.0208545774,
0.0165335815,
-0.0035932912,
0.0032542155,
-0.0280117802,
-0.0440156683,
0.0251845978,
0.0397529453,
0.0095342482,
0.0620228946,
0.0499319732,
-0.0315234363,
-0.040671207,
-0.0238399878,
0.0681085885,
-0.0711345449,
-0.0611226335,
-0.0284223109,
-0.0032473912,
0.0367842466,
-0.0472930409,
0.0012873866,
0.0553525984,
-0.0350536108,
0.0077737914,
-0.039837718,
0.0006568391,
0.0094480868,
-0.0269753803,
-0.0525493287,
-0.0175527968,
0.0210704673,
-0.022361869,
0.0125864148,
0.0271071065,
-0.0331482589,
-0.0532044061,
0.0370703526,
0.0161848385,
-0.0586239584,
-0.036025133,
-0.0569515936,
-0.0187039301,
-0.0059710201,
-0.0392241888,
0.031883277,
0.0057304171,
-0.1212409809,
0.047421027,
-0.0232381336,
0.0847472548,
-0.062229231,
0.0396779627,
-0.0320565775,
-0.0014812729,
0.0030120979,
0.0167485308,
-0.0247795843,
-0.018928336,
-0.0553285852,
-0.0540367551,
0.0353780501,
0.0046308069,
-0.0353184901,
0.0154814627,
-0.0104197767,
0.0433490425,
-0.0083235335,
-0.0369057283,
0.0016764583,
0.0326537117,
0.0178179275,
-0.0188859981,
-0.0147071574,
-0.1069340557,
-0.0208530389,
0.0439075828,
0.0117156319,
-0.0176475886,
-0.0300808847,
0.0733516216,
-0.0051929899,
-0.0369746275,
-0.0218882356,
0.0204690788,
-0.0323830955,
-0.0180244092,
0.0407005996,
-0.028941432,
0.0200715046,
-0.0240790583,
0.0186395049,
-0.0262921266,
0.0230082124,
0.0104966555,
-0.0084678996,
0.0579439066,
-0.022977544,
-0.0173332989,
0.0016421354,
0.0042536096,
-0.0005798487,
0.037749771,
-0.0099937469,
0.0518699586,
-0.0433753245,
-0.0128309475,
0.0600372516,
0.0389658958,
-0.0132752731,
0.0137331914,
-0.0496722423,
-0.0112783117,
0.022867782,
0.0033415768,
0.0597018488,
0.0554084331,
0.0009331997,
-0.0408571661,
0.0858934522,
0.0054746666,
-0.0531103797,
-0.0243799593,
0.0076419241,
0.0121272318,
-0.0292805191,
0.0050622839,
-0.088955231,
0.0705011562,
-0.015309127,
-0.0147418119,
0.0392631106,
0.0264199879,
-0.0349291377,
-0.0030046736,
-0.0097546047,
-0.0142263845,
0.003783162,
0.065032959,
0.0098601421,
0.0073629948,
-0.050334245,
-0.0022118355,
-0.0021224222,
-0.0240396634,
-0.0025434559,
-0.0249367896,
0.0373733565,
0.0591962561,
0.0320642628,
0.0253524277,
-0.0180546045,
-0.0332227685,
0.0613191947,
0.0901329964,
-0.0356559157,
0.0457742102,
0.0449556075,
-0.0177026,
-0.0470564477,
0.0016911607,
-0.0104689635,
0.0120159276,
-0.0199724976,
-0.0143816592,
-0.0097171813,
0.005627552,
-0.0038727957,
0.0552852713,
0.0491914377,
-0.0276306532,
-0.0382113457,
0.0137398951,
0.0262543708,
-0.0127797136,
-0.0151072275,
0.018367013,
0.0137629071,
-0.0330348611,
0.031694375,
0.0007541782,
-0.0333592296,
0.0025167249,
0.0246172007,
-0.015661953,
-0.0012579393,
-0.0129507557,
0.006827841,
0.0036044351,
-0.0072986367,
-0.0107055102,
0.014433274,
-0.0245886594,
0.0258199815,
0.0314505957,
0.0715796351,
-0.006263495,
0.0631845146,
-0.051903557,
-0.0111267157,
0.0221998487,
0.0400938317,
0.0048809419,
-0.0202337615,
-0.0009851244,
0.0130535262,
0.0017062936,
0.0048863827,
-0.0252400488,
-0.0107776616,
-0.0656152889,
0.0158257727,
-0.0529992208,
-0.0212538503,
-0.0409862064,
-0.0476577394,
0.0046900921,
-0.00692607,
-0.0044180104,
-0.0635757595,
-0.016311245,
0.0287055057,
-0.0177176837,
0.0343766995,
-0.0174771063,
-0.028676074,
-0.0020064488,
-0.0122547681,
0.0131096635,
0.0368181542,
0.0447490811,
-0.0169466808,
-0.0636486784,
-0.0665996969,
0.0466862544,
-0.000007475,
0.0596814528,
0.0091310954,
0.0135391233,
-0.0057634101,
-0.0317574739,
0.0621403828,
0.1338331848,
-0.0120823253,
-0.0101259286,
0.0579886958,
-0.0170890056,
-0.0334394835,
-0.0263659656,
0.0443435088,
-0.0598613434,
0.0032276665,
0.0045369058,
-0.0067339824,
0.0498608723,
-0.0029756355,
0.0172739048,
-0.0831222609,
0.0058188937,
-0.0238743536,
-0.0882519409,
-0.0456402935,
0.0022520397,
-0.0138205783,
0.0269297399,
-0.0570765957,
-0.0559866205,
0.0310635902,
-0.0447172076,
-0.022742033,
0.0224130023,
0.0424712598,
0.0355980434,
0.0292997304,
0.0447448604,
0.0292576291,
-0.0204875693,
-0.0196339432,
-0.0505929552,
0.0052538905,
-0.0677390546,
-0.0124877784,
0.0636299178,
-0.0283295717,
-0.0046063713,
-0.0398831517,
-0.0314015783,
-0.0527093261,
-0.0152564785,
0.0058503444,
-0.0148449028,
-0.0860764235,
0.0103526348,
-0.044045195,
0.0247631278,
0.0208737124,
0.0095389709,
-0.010234178,
-0.0276866965,
-0.0101762526,
0.0059034941,
0.0502235182,
0.0321874954,
0.0233380869,
-0.0356392153,
-0.000302487,
0.079974331,
0.0370156318,
0.0262702703,
-0.0474911891,
0.0373108126,
0.0324186571,
0.0575074852,
-0.0096814632,
0.0493287668,
0.0536487587,
-0.0734681413,
-0.028023947,
0.0583050512,
0.0316431597,
-0.0973425433,
-0.0237120446,
-0.0282981321,
0.0430967771,
0.0101430062,
0.0112137757,
-0.0501388982,
-0.0323750377,
-0.0215662792,
-0.0404237397,
0.0157854054,
0.0206023287,
-0.0095309187,
-0.0897269249,
0.0518322252,
0.0292875301,
-0.0182832088,
-0.0651371703,
0.0513342805,
0.0029621955,
0.0186066329,
0.0224028453,
0.016528869,
0.003271735,
-0.007743401,
0.0224532243,
0.0435304344,
0.0061456873,
0.0236099511,
-0.0274279397,
-0.0142872054,
0.100545451,
-0.0094338404,
0.0456996784,
-0.0988778695,
0.0247636698,
0.0081713209,
0.0122638261,
0.0067717065,
0.012938139,
-0.0221663676,
-0.0374743491,
0.0312902108,
0.0179903787,
-0.0465586223,
-0.0342745446,
-0.0078917621,
0.0160235167,
-0.0128163807,
-0.0226902049,
-0.0349752679,
0.0034001654,
-0.0016136018,
0.0175870154,
0.0430720225,
-0.0392073207,
-0.0321118794,
-0.0052834433,
0.0389544144,
-0.0232149344,
-0.012936648,
0.0563896596,
0.0473542437,
-0.0457385965,
-0.0462673977,
-0.0485951416,
0.025930848,
0.0193890166,
0.0112048639,
-0.0330857337,
-0.0515491739,
0.0097981691,
-0.0308298878,
0.0899365172,
-0.0416406281,
0.0188525859,
-0.0222594868,
0.0336352475,
0.0166998059,
-0.0211030431,
0.0051001711,
0.0615272559,
-0.0827596411,
-0.0225405991,
0.0311809257,
0.0378595144,
0.0095721558,
0.0547995344,
-0.0232757758,
-0.0693913922,
0.0103967395,
0.0249244235,
0.0308775604,
0.0651593283,
-0.02311025,
-0.0251872968,
0.0074792327,
0.0138097731,
-0.0369839072,
0.0288867597,
0.0547030233,
-0.0100310827,
0.0240557194,
0.002769598,
0.0372794867,
-0.0242882334,
0.0313499123,
-0.040902067,
0.0377518684,
-0.0008115024,
0.0062750345,
0.0435307138,
-0.0053422372,
-0.0542849936,
-0.0012568164,
0.0183059759,
-0.0100909229,
0.0408439487,
0.0052021281,
0.0098258927,
0.0062905373,
-0.052491758,
-0.0398757942,
0.0050083706,
-0.0244717877,
0.0182679687,
0.0326862708,
-0.0307367388,
0.0044470178,
-0.0030817438,
0.0559006482,
0.0126061235,
0.0813073143,
-0.000598787,
-0.0479452945,
-0.0457549505,
0.0442579128,
0.0077470182,
-0.0357200168,
-0.0419228822,
0.0504739732,
0.0533370785,
-0.0104819555,
0.0380269215,
0.0035250988,
0.0074064983,
-0.055324737,
0.0053743301,
0.0408885255,
-0.0559840277,
0.0098516196,
0.0051288488,
-0.0144452062,
-0.0354484767,
0.0405745395,
0.0149808731,
-0.0037912843,
0.0063674888,
0.042092368,
-0.0327996239,
-0.04522679,
0.004330656,
0.0051495144,
-0.0131457262,
0.0126271173,
-0.019555239,
-0.05040906,
-0.0418259948,
0.0177191831,
-0.0027035468,
0.0131423948,
0.0333138369,
0.0132298078,
-0.0014302121,
-0.0408352539,
0.0066090301,
-0.0266933907,
0.0488597862,
-0.0019585351,
0.0074498523,
-6.323896591e-33,
-0.0362992734,
-0.0199552458,
0.0256479103,
-0.0510872714,
-0.0099658687,
-0.0135495597,
-0.0015726753,
0.0122526223,
-0.0135361589,
0.0027482223,
-0.0118200667,
0.0316716433,
0.0150191803,
0.0250120163,
-0.0106190853,
-0.0384258255,
0.0268204957,
0.0163760744,
-0.0141614592,
0.027080236,
0.0333988294,
0.0117268097,
0.0487385802,
-0.0520111062,
0.0292593297,
0.0051388447,
-0.0413073748,
-0.021848876,
0.0009947635,
0.0547142997,
-0.0591017753,
0.0386663266,
0.0041832095,
-0.0198745523,
-0.0537581444,
0.0287600234,
-0.0109557686,
0.0181659702,
-0.0280313026,
0.0461971685,
-0.0576309077,
-0.0279770028,
0.0629000142,
0.0091364747,
0.001989841,
-0.0388189964,
0.0429823287,
-0.0409692377,
-0.0483369455,
0.0434860028,
-0.0578704625,
-0.0256040413,
0.0172432233,
-0.0019956762,
0.0574310534,
0.0238909647,
-0.0124870427,
0.041392792,
-0.0388423912,
0.008089372,
-0.0155640272,
0.0051804949,
0.0813471451,
0.057359878,
0.0160589814,
0.0642685816,
0.080082275,
-0.0197791066,
-0.0287715271,
-0.0542895012,
-0.0043600728,
0.0409502573,
0.0232759211,
0.0319322981,
0.0658600926,
0.0163635146,
-0.0246680863,
-0.0182950944,
-0.0819181278,
0.0576868653,
0.0604469813,
-0.0113474904,
-0.0062402342,
-0.0060124793,
-0.0037310119,
0.0322731696,
-0.0681194812,
-0.0105460472,
0.0964868963,
0.0149520794,
-0.0037267527,
0.0122259865,
0.0776654929,
-0.0248001218,
0.0206954833,
0.0136679262,
-0.0064003021,
0.0457215942,
0.014736617,
-0.0062798108,
0.0048225918,
0.005397399,
0.0765149593,
-0.0191860031,
-0.0085349819,
0.034969449,
-0.001499574,
-0.0111476732,
-0.0541572012,
-0.0037884947,
-0.06714461,
0.0084149521,
0.0138216494,
0.0476107933,
0.0584307313,
-0.0167219322,
-0.0243095588,
0.0311422516,
-0.0298167784,
-0.0181603078,
0.0029388957,
0.0278700553,
-0.0155266291,
0.0172175206,
-0.0053180954,
-0.0140932193,
-0.069968462,
-0.0276493002,
0.0526695251,
-0.0439378098,
-0.0079423292,
0.0113924528,
2.903e-7,
-0.0264509376,
0.0117595959,
-0.0087538101,
-0.0135834077,
0.0185833201,
0.0250535179,
0.0249718893,
0.0675587133,
0.0329865776,
-0.0796727166,
-0.0303752273,
0.0522837266,
0.0368206389,
-0.0206606928,
-0.0552723855,
0.015602963,
0.0007073364,
0.0457912162,
-0.0614673123,
-0.0319316648,
0.0018072089,
0.0732699111,
-0.034201473,
-0.0205270294,
0.0920612514,
-0.0529096723,
0.0573314354,
-0.0183485504,
0.0038757559,
-0.037713252,
0.0089178281,
0.0117631992,
0.006486238,
0.0438877642,
-0.000594955,
-0.0389686823,
0.0298880972,
0.0059426711,
-0.0635160729,
-0.0419296548,
-0.0425023772,
0.0261856467,
-0.0133906733,
-0.0618867166,
0.063108094,
-0.0304927435,
0.0032718959,
-0.0144835385,
-0.0394101515,
-0.0223561469,
0.0239616632,
-0.0178814363,
0.0015862978,
-0.0155449044,
0.022145167,
0.0092044976,
-0.0501702651,
-0.0613754168,
-0.04260296,
-0.0053039272,
-0.017976569,
-0.0132661117,
-0.0535003766,
0.0119764879,
0.0280973502,
-0.0232902709,
-0.0289302096,
2.458400416e-34,
-0.012499487,
-0.0078495461,
0.0659063309,
0.0255872458,
-0.0114935162,
-0.0230138861,
0.0085808067,
0.0063239695,
-0.0114335231,
-0.0285171848,
-0.0141357221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12708v1 | AgentReview: Exploring Peer Review Dynamics with LLM Agents | 2024-06-18T15:22:12 | 2024-06-18T15:22:12 | Yiqiao Jin, Qinlin Zhao, Yiyang Wang, Hao Chen, Kaijie Zhu, Yijia Xiao, Jindong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Peer review is fundamental to the integrity and advancement of scientific
publication. Traditional methods of peer review analyses often rely on
exploration and statistics of existing peer review data, which do not
adequately address the multivariate nature of the process, account for the
latent variables, and are further constrained by privacy concerns due to the
sensitive nature of the data. We introduce AgentReview, the first large
language model (LLM) based peer review simulation framework, which effectively
disentangles the impacts of multiple latent factors and addresses the privacy
issue. Our study reveals significant insights, including a notable 37.1%
variation in paper decisions due to reviewers' biases, supported by
sociological theories such as the social influence theory, altruism fatigue,
and authority bias. We believe that this study could offer valuable insights to
improve the design of peer review mechanisms. | [
0.0709777251,
0.0240984876,
-0.0184069835,
-0.0137487333,
-0.0611576848,
-0.040784128,
0.0691580847,
-0.0197751522,
0.0072346581,
0.0031212503,
-0.0480070785,
0.0162660927,
-0.0070913322,
0.0195620991,
0.00076344,
0.0207798071,
0.002230308,
-0.0147306155,
0.1033337563,
-0.0417614207,
0.0006213657,
-0.0263467636,
0.0366400369,
0.0198950786,
0.0918273032,
-0.0106131136,
0.0205792058,
-0.0363843329,
-0.0231142882,
-0.022813404,
0.0006955073,
0.0959384516,
0.0372029766,
0.0647275224,
0.0000020319,
-0.0374689437,
0.0122624552,
0.0591348261,
-0.0152526638,
0.0680567771,
0.0793869719,
0.0063810186,
0.0007614619,
-0.013861767,
-0.0296519026,
-0.0309291817,
-0.0157730877,
-0.0031914981,
-0.0264766272,
-0.0014611973,
0.007055528,
0.0156799909,
-0.0144855333,
-0.0294890143,
0.0013204404,
-0.0406916216,
0.0298701636,
-0.017600216,
0.0346003547,
0.0555308908,
-0.0016716509,
0.004826901,
-0.0221997425,
-0.0586541556,
0.0345348418,
0.0270483419,
0.0299161896,
-0.0165510941,
-0.0147884572,
0.0355271585,
0.0889665261,
-0.0121371662,
0.019142285,
-0.0066647329,
0.0194938965,
0.095798023,
-0.0376357846,
0.0249562822,
0.0172381997,
-0.0200987849,
-0.001710573,
0.0221836455,
0.0172840897,
0.0295476988,
0.0775800422,
0.0157523099,
0.0237889327,
-0.0214381032,
-0.0022901332,
0.0226980802,
0.0767086297,
-0.064515546,
-0.0075929426,
-0.0235099085,
0.0002844842,
0.0009196753,
0.0704630539,
0.0325292051,
0.0535307117,
-0.0458755232,
0.0104347384,
-0.0549580343,
0.0550987758,
0.0712952837,
0.0604183599,
-0.0556452423,
-0.0462039262,
0.0326721072,
0.0405958667,
0.0430985913,
-0.0135134263,
0.0223542191,
0.0504139625,
-0.012406758,
0.0087789698,
-0.0007232409,
-0.0263112504,
-0.0170704126,
-0.0275193062,
-0.0047427365,
0.0257291924,
0.0381747857,
-0.009185276,
0.0150696337,
-0.0298434459,
0.0225907657,
-0.0332505479,
0.0406287834,
-0.0158101376,
0.0502190664,
-0.0079112882,
-0.0159564652,
0.0127121322,
-0.0173428375,
-0.0016583748,
0.0463271439,
0.0293236859,
0.0039219344,
0.033623036,
-0.0273342952,
0.0217817314,
-0.0413242951,
-0.0130144032,
-0.0662375912,
0.0344170257,
-0.0145952441,
-0.0118535059,
-0.0332408436,
-0.0397087187,
-0.0270264503,
-0.0151585722,
0.0362658352,
-0.0440415107,
-0.0067743128,
0.0244325213,
0.0354281329,
-0.0374262929,
-0.0299727116,
-0.0180528332,
-0.0244215485,
0.0414002053,
-0.0203720685,
0.0629584789,
-0.0069930861,
0.0001907678,
0.0736436248,
0.0372292176,
0.0002255953,
-0.0570595153,
-0.0252823811,
-0.0143760145,
-0.0017411035,
-0.0496219732,
-0.0087578418,
0.0729263052,
0.0188201666,
-0.0501164645,
0.0210326891,
-0.0477124043,
0.0510413796,
-0.0077103837,
-0.0283415429,
-0.0017212121,
0.0391964801,
0.0322721861,
-0.0290735401,
0.0020832538,
0.0223806221,
-0.0351976827,
0.004769884,
0.0237162802,
0.0001566387,
0.0095620407,
0.0044172239,
0.038902808,
-0.0238974113,
0.0135148987,
-0.0194708537,
0.0329286493,
0.0041993964,
0.0176987536,
0.0021928987,
0.0527178198,
0.0300184619,
0.0798456222,
0.0001986998,
0.0203722008,
-0.0391074829,
-0.0062867943,
0.0446549319,
-0.0041017584,
-0.0017791027,
-0.0608884729,
-0.0068524936,
-0.0588653795,
0.0021092938,
0.0105456458,
0.023192998,
-0.0034743645,
0.0122038675,
-0.0358122922,
-0.019795876,
-0.0596440658,
0.0089564258,
-0.0329688266,
-0.0205711778,
-0.0167170838,
-0.0312451068,
0.0700355172,
0.0149008352,
-0.0450449809,
0.0172164775,
0.0383886546,
0.0063009053,
-0.0374427028,
0.0312052239,
0.0850398168,
0.0581984445,
-0.0114413183,
-0.0486581847,
0.0142470775,
-0.0229989626,
0.0023391645,
-0.0016319923,
0.0475914292,
0.0525075383,
0.0296870507,
0.0201477651,
-0.0277810674,
-0.0499585941,
-0.0162561648,
-0.012010633,
-0.0184614789,
-0.0191140641,
0.0147275254,
0.029310219,
-0.0022669954,
0.0000320274,
0.0639392734,
-0.0082738604,
0.007351479,
0.0171256382,
0.0048256265,
0.071260266,
-0.0310045369,
0.010507266,
-0.0495073125,
0.0053222231,
-0.0251851864,
0.0293409266,
-0.0165959112,
0.0156734604,
-0.0507327244,
0.0162149966,
0.024164388,
-0.0233871602,
0.0274651684,
-0.0408153422,
0.003185947,
-0.0058482341,
0.0191796198,
-0.0387744084,
-0.0659865886,
-0.0033241059,
-0.0092324717,
0.026701251,
0.0791228339,
0.0225109346,
-0.0344184153,
0.0238736458,
-0.0496540293,
0.0081008887,
-0.0212982707,
-0.0288162902,
0.0206792075,
0.015915202,
-0.0434688292,
0.0004060837,
-0.0167857297,
0.0112530431,
0.0773800835,
-0.0172835141,
-0.055664096,
-0.0279901866,
-0.0073167761,
0.0126872454,
-0.0413362086,
-0.0519992858,
0.0313319936,
0.0166323446,
0.0170956086,
-0.0056955507,
0.005523317,
0.028351957,
0.0000127314,
-0.0408548079,
0.0316710733,
-0.0321905687,
-0.018280169,
0.0410075784,
0.0053369938,
-0.0249323603,
0.031279102,
-0.0280436948,
0.0349315293,
-0.0360045061,
0.0217923764,
-0.0173081476,
0.0322888643,
-0.0004659145,
-0.0125051355,
-0.0203816164,
0.0617059581,
0.008323526,
-0.0034695596,
0.0684083998,
0.009713308,
-0.016144203,
-0.020155061,
0.0132525368,
0.0043630521,
-0.0099942442,
0.0528572351,
-0.096620813,
-0.0019834689,
0.0076347352,
0.0196074881,
-0.0341444239,
-0.0418937169,
0.0030618245,
0.0412582159,
0.0310918465,
-0.0178725459,
-0.0034224803,
-0.0076077031,
-0.001867128,
0.0232000984,
-0.0600900277,
0.0305946562,
-0.0372605957,
0.003758969,
0.0400190875,
0.0192289054,
0.0098635014,
-0.0236494727,
-0.0794024244,
0.0184816718,
-0.0289603546,
-0.0041399696,
-0.0054480527,
0.0055128974,
-0.0358807221,
0.0210109651,
0.0650872737,
0.0078025246,
-0.1543125659,
-0.0151024833,
-0.0197797399,
0.0046550701,
0.0086662062,
0.0152285341,
-0.0450119935,
0.0305826869,
0.0019286454,
-0.0039142394,
-0.0194388516,
-0.0252120607,
0.0113109257,
-0.0228105504,
0.0710030571,
-0.0173530765,
0.0360645615,
0.0398336537,
-0.0482160002,
0.029164996,
-0.0100722499,
-0.0344422683,
-0.0000790122,
0.0526263006,
-0.009704669,
-0.0241813064,
-0.0412081778,
-0.0296602342,
0.09230382,
-0.067705445,
0.09312132,
0.0171984807,
0.0232033152,
-0.0511043072,
-0.0092972387,
0.0156751797,
0.0195360966,
-0.046283491,
0.0203831252,
0.0277714655,
0.0078319078,
0.0405588597,
-0.0351444893,
0.0320404135,
-0.0276823137,
0.0283552352,
0.0250526816,
0.0577730201,
0.0059138639,
-0.0523819439,
-0.04499235,
-0.0166229233,
-0.0084465584,
0.0418942384,
-0.025583202,
-0.05205575,
-0.0338023268,
0.0101860398,
-0.0181575716,
0.0407167524,
-0.0347706713,
-0.0532381162,
-0.0067849141,
-0.0532764867,
-0.0354734547,
-0.0234714821,
-0.0049996194,
-0.013959093,
0.0611102991,
0.0591603294,
0.0678113848,
-0.0420246348,
0.0512621067,
-0.0121736806,
-0.02934484,
0.0102335382,
0.0302821472,
-0.0120328208,
0.0465305708,
0.0318038054,
-0.0031724304,
-0.004755971,
0.0223129988,
-0.0398649424,
-0.0040908814,
0.0517754257,
0.020702647,
0.0367435366,
-0.0403396562,
-0.0375576057,
0.0139474925,
-0.0409197696,
-0.0168115478,
0.0178684331,
0.0087960726,
-0.025228167,
-0.0059120222,
-0.0278521515,
-0.0302059054,
0.0135351587,
0.0418332666,
-0.0441881157,
-0.057173755,
-0.0579432435,
-0.0133052245,
-0.0289832763,
-0.0060685938,
-0.0228332989,
0.0649166033,
-0.0415851772,
-0.027390914,
-0.0491466708,
0.0144558512,
0.0079557169,
-0.0477693193,
0.0268522557,
-0.0130737852,
0.0150532359,
0.0389522836,
-0.0258217789,
0.0208238102,
-0.0445159674,
0.0864659622,
0.0122956932,
0.0203570053,
0.0085242698,
-0.0017825228,
-0.0169264954,
0.00143273,
-0.0583392531,
0.0129263038,
0.0139430501,
0.0392636061,
-0.045046106,
-0.0398987532,
0.0100577464,
0.0146626756,
-0.0893539488,
0.0031167702,
0.023807412,
0.0137646133,
-0.0208626948,
0.0336345434,
0.036743477,
-0.0114230327,
0.0117229149,
-0.031879548,
0.0039282055,
-0.0131263603,
0.0233122688,
0.0388708264,
0.0075838636,
-0.0365566611,
0.0155357746,
0.0551051535,
0.0348193757,
-0.0169907864,
-0.0382297859,
-0.0456199832,
0.0066078017,
-0.0466827005,
-0.0227298513,
0.0143181393,
-0.0149620771,
-0.0335434303,
-0.0599945039,
-0.0080745835,
-0.0175080243,
0.0199657641,
0.017405564,
-0.0443726406,
-0.0426245183,
0.0574638993,
-0.0100572212,
-0.0174473114,
-0.0559045933,
-0.0086140446,
-0.0522257872,
-0.0324259736,
-0.0270363335,
-6.002676596e-33,
0.0183532313,
-0.0314740352,
0.0151042389,
0.0304732043,
-0.0303240027,
0.0200024899,
-0.0527205653,
-0.0107391048,
-0.0051235282,
0.0213613622,
-0.0750263035,
0.0089707691,
0.0017034652,
-0.0282971617,
0.0908650979,
0.0250792075,
0.0471729301,
-0.0447814018,
0.0187591054,
0.0220022351,
-0.0470774099,
-0.0152565418,
-0.0132066198,
-0.0424354784,
0.0913673416,
0.0051096189,
-0.0295464098,
-0.0073434846,
-0.0228526704,
0.0222313236,
-0.0358460397,
0.0064074611,
0.0017167313,
-0.0393453203,
0.0110724391,
-0.0230283942,
-0.0439924523,
0.0150647387,
0.0231665671,
0.0013117827,
0.014914779,
-0.0053901686,
0.0255852565,
0.0123944599,
-0.0874014497,
0.0193824004,
0.045386821,
-0.0090285819,
-0.0233742408,
0.0016424983,
-0.0275954623,
0.0020265945,
-0.0116589982,
0.0504258312,
-0.0190114044,
0.0160881449,
-0.0171775762,
0.0358237885,
-0.0929604843,
0.0140636293,
0.0215128884,
-0.0091298493,
-0.0017367704,
0.013601644,
0.0541688316,
0.0656526312,
0.001909823,
0.0616748482,
-0.0454824492,
-0.0446595885,
0.0158352293,
0.0165516157,
0.0372038446,
0.0951723754,
-0.0155519871,
-0.0406997651,
-0.0368652046,
0.0116839437,
0.0819012895,
0.0128339082,
0.1189405918,
-0.0204837061,
-0.0088965055,
-0.0459059589,
-0.016246818,
-0.0429051928,
0.0095940325,
-0.021544639,
-0.0052398266,
0.0138075035,
-0.0162710696,
-0.0712190419,
0.0285218414,
-0.0350409187,
-0.0437204055,
0.0234583542,
0.0136162601,
0.0605946444,
0.0087595619,
-0.0501813293,
-0.1090773866,
0.008735762,
-0.0690766796,
0.0315877199,
0.000360058,
0.0038761178,
-0.0178679861,
0.0005641677,
-0.0356523171,
-0.0010178643,
-0.0188071821,
0.0079024211,
0.0737512708,
0.0112340869,
-0.0060004829,
-0.003733037,
0.0198397618,
-0.0054893442,
0.029509725,
0.0568097308,
0.0185697488,
0.0881723017,
-0.0244488977,
-0.0146867717,
0.0059265629,
-0.0170928929,
-0.0336996056,
0.014886098,
0.0324909836,
-0.0351407304,
0.0042792447,
-0.0497776344,
2.751e-7,
0.0187626127,
0.0337511264,
-0.0387526974,
-0.024699742,
0.0812431797,
0.0498049334,
-0.0010537452,
0.0470213071,
0.00999719,
-0.0441953354,
0.0369953401,
0.0015325057,
-0.0238225926,
0.0281064659,
-0.0822997019,
-0.0209876709,
-0.0509705842,
0.0127755962,
-0.0201398376,
-0.0477445535,
-0.0646460876,
-0.0207668375,
0.0366862528,
0.0164176263,
-0.064262189,
-0.0273140147,
0.0399406813,
-0.0458537266,
-0.0147589473,
0.0467836522,
-0.0302798748,
-0.021022005,
-0.0252915882,
-0.0011812208,
-0.0022712525,
0.012510322,
-0.0531900898,
0.0445273966,
0.0111491913,
0.0104115102,
0.0475099348,
-0.0447426736,
0.0244922563,
-0.0244342908,
0.0223440379,
-0.0050187199,
-0.0604915731,
-0.0687287152,
-0.02480576,
-0.0406870581,
0.0679753795,
-0.0224795081,
-0.0189608503,
-0.002127565,
-0.0482193008,
-0.0189810991,
0.0146441124,
-0.0107334768,
0.0017546994,
-0.0472027063,
-0.0217224341,
-0.069079496,
0.0222507436,
-0.0077552856,
-0.0354420654,
-0.0022893397,
0.064955622,
2.282016111e-34,
0.0877998248,
-0.0054274439,
-0.0127701852,
0.0115258107,
0.0448980518,
0.0131403729,
-0.0512046888,
-0.0138712684,
0.0330174416,
-0.0637915358,
-0.0230687056
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12707v1 | Talk With Human-like Agents: Empathetic Dialogue Through Perceptible Acoustic Reception and Reaction | 2024-06-18T15:19:51 | 2024-06-18T15:19:51 | Haoqiu Yan, Yongxin Zhu, Kai Zheng, Bing Liu, Haoyu Cao, Deqiang Jiang, Linli Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large Language Model (LLM)-enhanced agents become increasingly prevalent in
Human-AI communication, offering vast potential from entertainment to
professional domains. However, current multi-modal dialogue systems overlook
the acoustic information present in speech, which is crucial for understanding
human communication nuances. This oversight can lead to misinterpretations of
speakers' intentions, resulting in inconsistent or even contradictory responses
within dialogues. To bridge this gap, in this paper, we propose
PerceptiveAgent, an empathetic multi-modal dialogue system designed to discern
deeper or more subtle meanings beyond the literal interpretations of words
through the integration of speech modality perception. Employing LLMs as a
cognitive core, PerceptiveAgent perceives acoustic information from input
speech and generates empathetic responses based on speaking styles described in
natural language. Experimental results indicate that PerceptiveAgent excels in
contextual understanding by accurately discerning the speakers' true intentions
in scenarios where the linguistic meaning is either contrary to or inconsistent
with the speaker's true feelings, producing more nuanced and expressive spoken
dialogues. Code is publicly available at:
\url{https://github.com/Haoqiu-Yan/PerceptiveAgent}. | [
0.0424365662,
0.0381074697,
-0.0308884364,
0.049191419,
-0.0128583666,
-0.0032081078,
0.0054494133,
-0.0322441533,
0.0056369789,
-0.033457078,
-0.0644284338,
0.0137074795,
-0.0063975463,
0.0262234136,
0.0031317058,
-0.0540588275,
0.0298842825,
-0.0218753275,
0.071418494,
-0.0129898852,
0.0311264675,
0.0213872697,
-0.0460706688,
0.0517363511,
-0.0202735066,
-0.0122381113,
-0.0562818125,
0.0403970182,
0.001342171,
-0.0089939898,
-0.0013581541,
-0.0023415103,
0.0564812645,
0.0131770819,
0.0000016922,
-0.0318337642,
0.0354427211,
-0.0285333637,
-0.0231757183,
-0.0197648089,
0.0587555021,
-0.0035941764,
-0.0155074382,
-0.0019428937,
-0.0297880601,
0.0069777141,
0.0160325728,
0.069472909,
0.0859934241,
0.0339428,
-0.0119096469,
-0.0004575884,
-0.0068497541,
0.004484789,
-0.0132373739,
-0.0674798936,
0.0039343047,
-0.011674705,
0.0251099523,
-0.022685295,
-0.0406976566,
-0.0022991309,
-0.015421031,
-0.0120733436,
-0.004683069,
0.0207189173,
0.0237275977,
-0.0559500679,
-0.051813744,
0.112269178,
0.0711573139,
0.0142359724,
0.0111095859,
0.0128478622,
0.0043926355,
-0.0346013941,
-0.0276321247,
0.0037568468,
0.0038092502,
-0.0056929416,
-0.0131133404,
0.0205377694,
-0.0218903534,
0.0281995125,
-0.0028058412,
0.0264498591,
-0.029308822,
-0.006723416,
-0.0174747836,
-0.0342918709,
0.0125577999,
-0.0400956757,
0.0272541232,
0.0459932648,
-0.0580810048,
0.0252629798,
-0.0506274328,
0.0035737352,
0.0068032327,
-0.0317110009,
0.0102384724,
0.0334254317,
-0.0426453575,
0.0504370928,
0.0439478457,
0.0223960355,
-0.0001559194,
-0.0013163008,
-0.01990919,
-0.0010845513,
-0.0088022761,
0.0063217073,
-0.0130813941,
0.0021827053,
-0.0289886594,
-0.0432730541,
-0.0131823383,
0.0342612304,
-0.0335675403,
0.0154584609,
-0.0345241874,
-0.0154855838,
-0.0450956523,
-0.0130775375,
-0.0217330121,
0.0493273139,
-0.0488904528,
0.0686124191,
-0.0138648562,
-0.0493093878,
-0.0101706134,
0.0342185833,
0.0236778092,
0.0108145177,
0.0039883964,
0.0306809414,
-0.0076281568,
-0.0107064815,
-0.0266624317,
-0.0134295942,
-0.0399379171,
-0.0673395172,
-0.054324612,
-0.0028903726,
0.0296621099,
-0.027937321,
-0.0138853574,
-0.0388843566,
0.038568493,
-0.0260438733,
-0.0345110372,
0.0665254816,
0.0018170649,
0.0498461686,
0.0406900942,
0.0391269401,
-0.0146600362,
0.0239631888,
0.0529711135,
-0.0004438589,
0.021309603,
-0.000993478,
0.0071218503,
0.0185682755,
-0.0236965772,
-0.0080998102,
0.0035245037,
-0.024791427,
-0.0455910116,
0.046463944,
0.0723823979,
0.0541107394,
-0.0340097025,
-0.0457334705,
0.0707075521,
0.0692434981,
-0.0067592724,
0.0380771831,
0.0126423398,
0.0701563507,
-0.0039627277,
0.0138792675,
-0.0413599759,
0.0093371877,
-0.0302869361,
-0.0349352323,
0.0030799948,
0.0028012879,
-0.0282899551,
-0.0150734968,
0.0408994295,
-0.0315743312,
0.0456664227,
0.025880374,
0.0424314216,
-0.036717847,
-0.0251328591,
0.0117183626,
0.0063333442,
-0.0596605726,
0.0033566209,
-0.0385505632,
0.0286747664,
0.0802525356,
-0.0090589589,
-0.0392530151,
-0.0163629036,
-0.0014185985,
-0.0325294249,
0.0300235078,
0.0386030823,
-0.0171853937,
0.0693883747,
-0.0434102826,
0.0065181381,
0.012082261,
0.0134740537,
0.0334549583,
-0.0697139427,
0.016860133,
-0.0006198643,
-0.0081143519,
0.0656837672,
0.0153142875,
-0.0218754429,
0.0046634749,
-0.0319167897,
0.0067859651,
0.0181989316,
0.0407856591,
-0.0339604989,
-0.0318551622,
0.0454627164,
-0.0123283137,
0.0163936391,
0.1186481044,
-0.0467090346,
-0.031878531,
0.0445964821,
-0.0129692731,
-0.0076576052,
0.028415449,
0.0112873027,
-0.0496563315,
0.0704662204,
-0.0506194644,
0.0249040574,
-0.0470382944,
0.0027959212,
-0.0340096205,
0.0222056899,
0.0249567125,
0.0105534708,
0.0138910646,
-0.0541313775,
0.0080128387,
0.0244644918,
0.0041383724,
-0.0539109968,
-0.0247254092,
0.0183206704,
0.0271580238,
-0.0034132337,
-0.0186958797,
-0.0226312969,
-0.0711181536,
-0.0363802575,
-0.1274292916,
-0.021254329,
0.0120930914,
-0.0172633212,
-0.0057483944,
0.0159617383,
-0.0174022187,
-0.0174851771,
-0.0197050292,
0.017044181,
0.032495942,
-0.0173661895,
-0.0151175,
-0.0071590724,
-0.0463609658,
-0.0420602262,
0.0398525596,
-0.0247071758,
-0.0087449532,
0.0038680786,
0.0176516231,
-0.0515285656,
0.0154463202,
-0.0240017194,
0.0456891842,
-0.0230553132,
-0.0695444122,
-0.0019316777,
-0.006172244,
-0.0016747634,
0.0976238549,
0.017459657,
0.0585347675,
0.0117684174,
-0.0445986949,
-0.0787315667,
0.0567337908,
0.0294968989,
0.033212509,
-0.0788127333,
-0.0043273736,
-0.0158843733,
0.031257093,
0.0279931072,
0.0321752317,
-0.0401088446,
-0.0023186076,
0.0199575089,
-0.0917437822,
0.0159099158,
-0.0576255806,
-0.0335304551,
0.0248728339,
0.0299737025,
0.0050161737,
0.0773617923,
-0.0204884484,
-0.0437706672,
-0.0359160341,
-0.0407142825,
-0.0146946087,
0.0578156561,
-0.0642437786,
0.0156330299,
0.0008156709,
-0.0264240596,
-0.0221462697,
-0.0185636841,
0.015492958,
-0.0551897511,
0.0291020535,
-0.0542701855,
-0.0180189796,
0.0352960229,
-0.0322036967,
-0.0397453718,
-0.0417991653,
-0.0620661937,
0.0070169503,
-0.0005376998,
-0.0139726019,
-0.0161539949,
0.0208958536,
0.0637940317,
-0.0048412033,
0.0142970085,
0.0102124,
-0.0244768895,
-0.0005703829,
0.0410673954,
0.0556707047,
-0.0002073046,
0.0078439992,
0.1009918675,
0.027167175,
0.0358475521,
0.0075569921,
-0.0186591055,
0.0150061799,
0.0255699102,
0.0251901858,
-0.0055256216,
0.0135684656,
0.0733223855,
-0.0176640414,
0.0089310976,
0.1179376319,
0.0139487144,
-0.0591920912,
0.0249120276,
-0.0159172341,
0.0013821877,
0.002270879,
0.0127158426,
-0.0243374277,
-0.0495727845,
0.0206259061,
0.0000558998,
-0.0323617719,
-0.0174158085,
-0.0027282664,
-0.0568879507,
0.0645803586,
0.0030537695,
0.0240914673,
-0.0326790065,
-0.0112946993,
0.0394258089,
0.0088827219,
0.0077838111,
0.0021982011,
0.0203742515,
-0.0366786048,
-0.0065440261,
-0.0167365726,
-0.0151078505,
0.0391311087,
-0.041311007,
0.0674997717,
0.0461822152,
0.0660136417,
-0.0230850074,
-0.0227591582,
-0.0133995432,
0.0267708767,
-0.0043672621,
0.0078153955,
-0.0225301944,
-0.0152754895,
0.0075936439,
-0.0125890085,
0.0649726316,
-0.0244652163,
0.0081915418,
0.0315049514,
0.0501244627,
-0.0441400371,
0.0333887152,
-0.0023021761,
0.0704120845,
0.0471508913,
0.0613147728,
0.0169585608,
-0.0734394193,
-0.0211439729,
-0.0001322581,
-0.0143605592,
0.0290955547,
-0.0319125615,
0.0250140987,
0.0103713349,
-0.0223641135,
-0.0216477755,
-0.0666637123,
-0.0115399668,
0.024691321,
0.0091145914,
-0.0146898078,
0.0235787332,
0.0356203169,
-0.0027682504,
-0.0008735338,
-0.0069639524,
0.0622677803,
0.0021851494,
-0.0089425333,
0.0687227994,
-0.0611013621,
-0.0167045929,
0.0132222157,
-0.0346743204,
-0.053369157,
0.0067726169,
-0.0074058771,
0.0196775589,
0.0620947629,
-0.0191561803,
-0.0371188708,
-0.0153493444,
-0.0085693514,
-0.0695282072,
0.0490528531,
0.044498764,
0.046964325,
-0.0067810998,
0.0376510173,
-0.0541904792,
0.0329327136,
-0.0149952769,
0.0312388986,
-0.0356462523,
-0.0793690383,
-0.0027589772,
0.0218523294,
0.019677097,
0.0181689262,
-0.0186171345,
-0.004835831,
0.008231014,
-0.0082707461,
0.0153599735,
-0.0559084862,
-0.023166731,
-0.0089366855,
-0.005365713,
0.000435823,
-0.0625296459,
-0.0279090144,
0.006835815,
-0.0060946383,
0.0679165274,
0.019952191,
-0.0318024792,
-0.0230526812,
-0.0028091983,
-0.0126178833,
0.029526582,
-0.0094947638,
0.0137381097,
0.0205250029,
0.0915343538,
-0.0024025703,
-0.0777620673,
0.0019260779,
0.0287443865,
-0.0498568192,
-0.0148047153,
0.0391400307,
0.0490744412,
0.0435995832,
0.0327246934,
0.0215771217,
-0.0331622437,
0.0500826277,
-0.0194705613,
0.0415293463,
-0.0177901424,
-0.0439997278,
0.0438797921,
0.0196883697,
-0.0173932742,
0.0138486978,
0.0144126788,
-0.0544393845,
0.0516417064,
-0.0183476396,
0.0295761153,
-0.058091104,
-0.0156973619,
0.0388343669,
0.0181954987,
-0.029232936,
0.0402032211,
-0.0659036562,
-0.0429548882,
0.0317094028,
0.0055849287,
0.0248235129,
-0.0702453405,
-0.0036234641,
0.0395490527,
-0.0208825376,
-0.0085683074,
-0.0125291226,
-0.0100505687,
-0.064621143,
-0.0090529285,
-0.0202109311,
-5.390889827e-33,
-0.0234692916,
-0.0193198305,
-0.020377636,
-0.00545649,
-0.0616338216,
-0.0133762863,
-0.0253911503,
0.0030646787,
-0.0308956802,
0.0238977727,
-0.0141764758,
0.0410805903,
0.0069935005,
-0.0163977481,
-0.0173303578,
-0.0075202025,
0.0430647247,
-0.0004252844,
0.0172102619,
0.0385816097,
-0.0049114665,
0.0206172578,
-0.0114572467,
-0.102598168,
-0.0056584119,
-0.0052022757,
-0.0402924009,
0.0242502391,
0.0256759226,
0.0581072196,
-0.0099288207,
0.0399362147,
-0.0032558048,
0.0039660321,
0.009465904,
0.0194691718,
-0.0318531543,
0.0158804469,
0.0260824785,
0.0428520255,
-0.0217553936,
-0.0108179376,
0.0064967941,
-0.0033624242,
-0.0304933097,
0.0174027812,
0.0140447244,
-0.0118521629,
0.0307630431,
0.0052902037,
-0.0460817665,
-0.0006433886,
-0.0612806007,
-0.0623709299,
0.0106411166,
0.0367824137,
0.0064644376,
0.0047097765,
-0.0416427255,
0.0486461595,
-0.0225493237,
-0.0553006344,
0.0184749514,
0.0120874709,
0.0211721044,
0.0743680447,
0.0492016412,
-0.0138251362,
-0.0212986041,
-0.0312090944,
0.0277477372,
0.0208090004,
-0.0247297008,
0.0826548412,
-0.0383594818,
-0.0066219452,
-0.0009671901,
-0.00610764,
0.0784232318,
0.0321413018,
0.0498685874,
0.0503905974,
-0.0584271699,
0.0128293727,
-0.0716959313,
-0.0348020941,
-0.0365359858,
-0.0128689958,
0.0331899785,
0.0081433104,
0.006241017,
-0.0455829091,
0.0441358685,
-0.0483371951,
0.0245373398,
0.0090461653,
-0.0168729089,
0.0065332353,
-0.0196251646,
0.0378995053,
-0.0083508939,
-0.0123149836,
0.0537924021,
-0.002970279,
0.0613832101,
-0.004123786,
-0.040293742,
-0.0013240214,
0.0077100587,
-0.0101749329,
0.0021149919,
0.0166121479,
-0.0160054062,
-0.0119756488,
0.0107771652,
-0.0049045128,
-0.0449555591,
0.0004659428,
0.0029358501,
0.0148041509,
-0.0313038118,
-0.0363297462,
-0.0030780726,
0.0315013081,
-0.0847759768,
-0.0181142967,
0.0027138772,
-0.064667128,
0.0082111293,
-0.0330507904,
-0.0119626261,
-0.0038561954,
2.641e-7,
-0.0759357139,
0.0265928525,
-0.0072053941,
-0.0232485216,
0.0470729433,
0.0870443135,
-0.0296845306,
0.0410664529,
0.0252866633,
-0.0317572653,
0.0422436744,
0.0234789196,
0.0804573596,
0.0017325465,
-0.0944857225,
0.0354844294,
-0.0027800105,
-0.0000859592,
-0.0364085771,
0.0233062152,
0.1080141738,
0.0695329756,
0.0212046634,
0.0087028109,
0.0214226358,
-0.0200189184,
0.0177132953,
-0.0541169569,
0.0031583863,
-0.0180714037,
0.0071962168,
-0.0579914749,
0.0009020761,
0.0081638237,
0.0271313116,
0.0369556807,
-0.0127831176,
0.101070866,
-0.037168432,
-0.0767070055,
-0.0098002953,
0.0623988137,
-0.0176902823,
-0.0088257575,
0.0195966382,
-0.016293548,
-0.0603505149,
-0.0219050627,
-0.006964846,
-0.0350960642,
-0.0286360402,
-0.0099068172,
-0.0344573297,
-0.0082293712,
-0.0007208815,
-0.0364397205,
-0.0066043297,
-0.0578065552,
0.0384178571,
0.0009761796,
-0.0775898024,
-0.0570150986,
-0.0118156271,
-0.0243172608,
0.0594872385,
-0.0515760928,
0.0118729472,
1.672134171e-34,
0.0237430986,
-0.008110282,
-0.0144343721,
0.0652879328,
0.0703413486,
0.0161219425,
0.0182072129,
0.0058758534,
0.0706764683,
-0.0865756869,
-0.0079291612
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12702v2 | [WIP] Jailbreak Paradox: The Achilles' Heel of LLMs | 2024-06-18T15:14:35 | 2024-06-21T00:05:35 | Abhinav Rao, Monojit Choudhury, Somak Aditya | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce two paradoxes concerning jailbreak of foundation models: First,
it is impossible to construct a perfect jailbreak classifier, and second, a
weaker model cannot consistently detect whether a stronger (in a
pareto-dominant sense) model is jailbroken or not. We provide formal proofs for
these paradoxes and a short case study on Llama and GPT4-o to demonstrate this.
We discuss broader theoretical and practical repercussions of these results. | [
-0.0118989553,
0.0709407479,
-0.0106052412,
-0.0084673483,
-0.0340503007,
-0.0278982613,
-0.0253018141,
-0.0039705015,
0.0193684902,
-0.0078847017,
-0.00129166,
0.0415943973,
-0.0143606681,
-0.0044878013,
-0.0024053438,
0.0079278862,
0.0391932614,
0.0036553345,
-0.0619662292,
-0.015729202,
-0.0009692077,
-0.0356264822,
0.0516223647,
-0.0112092886,
0.0259202737,
-0.0103177866,
-0.0230302811,
0.0190236866,
-0.0162078869,
-0.0330603272,
-0.0091323536,
0.0093168104,
-0.0180844478,
0.0451720282,
0.0000021879,
-0.0430045612,
-0.0597351938,
0.019382339,
-0.020958988,
0.0423979983,
-0.0421807282,
-0.0185937975,
-0.0212391447,
-0.0008382165,
-0.0114927664,
0.0308170822,
0.009336669,
0.0315181613,
0.044431176,
0.0191485137,
0.0268292464,
-0.0114641627,
0.048675973,
-0.0189934727,
0.0053125625,
-0.043719124,
-0.0075340057,
-0.0078115766,
-0.0023191052,
-0.0163223911,
-0.0019195863,
-0.0091753434,
0.0342210196,
0.0537511632,
-0.015392933,
0.019970322,
0.0144153573,
-0.0143138934,
-0.0410636812,
0.0196001232,
0.0547653474,
-0.0235727597,
0.01164921,
-0.0077805496,
0.0075141969,
0.0268733036,
-0.0246112924,
0.0216543879,
0.0044297487,
0.0443784632,
0.080659695,
-0.0031112819,
0.0791266412,
-0.0173029788,
-0.0222013108,
0.1005664319,
-0.0077272933,
-0.0264302772,
-0.0134261474,
0.027211884,
-0.0015131333,
-0.0115115605,
-0.0328167155,
-0.0077145239,
0.0323943384,
-0.0097600073,
-0.0289953519,
0.0880431682,
0.0220183637,
-0.0383531004,
-0.0447950065,
-0.0196267311,
-0.0160312094,
-0.0096299099,
0.014908961,
-0.0543760844,
-0.06390775,
0.0060283565,
0.0124795334,
0.0442463197,
-0.0140592856,
-0.0074765077,
0.005628183,
0.0903587788,
-0.0235275105,
0.0156263951,
-0.0034937086,
0.0277674813,
-0.034423124,
-0.0015504039,
-0.0429793149,
-0.0230737757,
-0.0080340998,
0.0085398704,
-0.0083200429,
-0.0446733087,
-0.0236881301,
0.0263005737,
0.0177485645,
-0.0726449862,
0.0104414057,
-0.0378081203,
-0.0833986327,
-0.0082331691,
0.0087536694,
0.0650614426,
0.0568821356,
-0.0080605624,
-0.1112675965,
-0.0559942462,
0.0072562229,
-0.042479191,
-0.0285689235,
-0.0638567209,
-0.0473489054,
0.0081844255,
0.0289141741,
-0.002278883,
-0.015234679,
-0.0467533991,
-0.0216681734,
0.0041803177,
-0.0395428091,
-0.0126463519,
-0.0271834116,
0.0739291981,
0.0379975699,
0.0924172923,
0.0002981753,
0.0077947374,
0.0439328328,
0.003181292,
0.017458586,
0.0537546352,
-0.0315543972,
0.0445109829,
0.0099800313,
0.0051814062,
0.0202572756,
-0.0216872059,
-0.0401838683,
-0.0334481299,
0.0126975738,
0.0295230523,
0.0176684,
0.0141694928,
0.0286829416,
0.0468253605,
-0.0697600767,
-0.0538506731,
0.0192449819,
0.0366004147,
-0.0478005745,
-0.0047741346,
-0.0875346661,
0.0130846491,
-0.0896174386,
0.0163985956,
-0.0290200766,
-0.048345957,
0.004880779,
-0.0220411643,
-0.1022386402,
0.0069262292,
0.0225528274,
-0.0215186495,
0.0239966977,
0.1382309198,
0.022714857,
-0.0406468362,
-0.0522446744,
-0.0944811106,
0.0514433756,
-0.0202548429,
0.0146720503,
-0.0498154201,
-0.0249198414,
0.0268598292,
-0.0020460109,
0.0145239495,
0.0116743948,
0.0220698602,
0.0276279356,
0.0138547784,
0.0237506162,
-0.027020162,
0.0572710745,
0.0501655191,
-0.0369402394,
-0.017655177,
-0.0571222194,
-0.045863539,
0.0051947464,
0.0192480348,
0.0253667124,
0.0061965915,
-0.0101426048,
-0.0031672842,
0.004981658,
0.0222939514,
-0.0195170566,
-0.017406188,
0.0751487762,
0.0099117151,
0.0203501098,
0.0286961384,
-0.0221821181,
0.0289472025,
-0.0020178147,
-0.0513452627,
0.0507088974,
0.0290245488,
-0.0394263305,
-0.0234986246,
0.0527522974,
0.0264132209,
0.0760122985,
0.0154130552,
0.0804856643,
-0.0338029042,
-0.0025025553,
-0.0038390877,
0.0121809719,
-0.0512911566,
-0.0018918089,
-0.0253288876,
0.0237202998,
0.0308947414,
0.0156010995,
-0.0209119935,
0.0530643389,
-0.0098738158,
0.018018296,
-0.0167230032,
0.0200699493,
0.0050603761,
-0.0456451774,
-0.0023164423,
0.0161431246,
-0.0004906381,
0.0230832528,
0.030940732,
0.011182718,
-0.0282053649,
0.0228418931,
0.0359385088,
-0.0084101614,
0.0638689101,
0.0072099706,
0.0227098111,
-0.0234820209,
-0.062720567,
0.0053240969,
0.0047462843,
0.0121320216,
0.0210051183,
-0.0334758721,
0.0137232728,
-0.0164644513,
-0.0061750561,
-0.0015560281,
-0.0299827289,
-0.0216854606,
0.0305185486,
0.02829892,
0.0052191652,
-0.0850919113,
0.0271975212,
-0.0555084273,
0.1348065436,
0.0607184209,
-0.0095975203,
0.0031253528,
-0.0366901197,
0.0666967109,
-0.0501581021,
-0.0299281105,
-0.0446156897,
0.0229727179,
0.0453623943,
-0.0213008076,
-0.0132925259,
0.0133983372,
0.0103951469,
0.0191890392,
-0.0102512697,
0.0555634722,
0.0246486012,
-0.0396831371,
0.0295297075,
-0.0078271702,
-0.078512311,
-0.0081574088,
-0.0385662392,
0.0315359607,
-0.016922649,
-0.0593131743,
-0.0967330262,
0.0104717975,
-0.0384799354,
-0.0001577861,
0.0470395908,
-0.006632119,
-0.0063174865,
-0.0115815941,
0.0108426362,
0.0041681188,
0.060302645,
-0.0605140477,
-0.0155887306,
-0.0155603923,
-0.0552991182,
0.0252730921,
0.0117244693,
-0.0194498282,
-0.0003986137,
0.0238578077,
-0.0058464832,
0.0356127135,
-0.0129546514,
-0.0311837811,
-0.0255337823,
0.0150449928,
-0.0210641213,
-0.0269768294,
0.0058211973,
-0.060783606,
-0.0472446829,
0.0424633697,
-0.0287500508,
0.0423307344,
-0.000410947,
0.0716645122,
-0.0052115661,
-0.0306220651,
0.0427844226,
0.0218501538,
0.0008437742,
-0.0534797423,
0.0135824624,
0.0364255868,
-0.0024392351,
-0.0010232812,
0.0364159979,
0.0031454021,
0.0512416027,
0.0432929099,
0.0095385918,
0.0378511325,
0.0501729958,
0.0131675759,
-0.0586329065,
-0.005771528,
0.0050333194,
0.0677857026,
-0.0241450109,
-0.0232202504,
-0.0134405484,
-0.0245738719,
0.0313938856,
0.0439092033,
0.0162275322,
0.0850017592,
-0.02469345,
-0.0508887209,
-0.0295274016,
-0.0367721878,
-0.0066037984,
-0.031060975,
0.0248369835,
0.0207664464,
-0.0493198745,
0.0217718575,
-0.0091008563,
-0.0116727985,
0.0093824044,
0.0401404053,
-0.0344049335,
-0.062962234,
0.0103509258,
0.0486326665,
0.0064557255,
-0.0097966436,
-0.0293470565,
-0.044090949,
0.0518943183,
0.0142153166,
-0.0093326969,
0.003638579,
0.0310511515,
-0.0177265685,
0.042764008,
0.0263394006,
-0.0205505434,
-0.0478558652,
-0.0139892893,
-0.0712495372,
-0.0633115917,
0.0098141693,
-0.0068951305,
0.0088731023,
-0.0885262638,
-0.0536997877,
-0.0691292137,
0.016767595,
0.02266258,
0.0152954329,
0.0173374917,
0.0272542518,
0.0146283256,
0.0158774946,
-0.0716847181,
0.0770746768,
0.0224227328,
0.0161671881,
-0.0613611527,
0.0336590894,
-0.0121106869,
-0.0008997228,
0.0065737134,
0.0105345389,
-0.0654687807,
0.0464119576,
0.0132266795,
-0.0163308326,
-0.0071976911,
-0.0402282774,
-0.0063640503,
-0.0670396835,
0.0171257891,
0.0465666912,
0.0438639373,
-0.0218598768,
0.0059107589,
-0.0005245692,
0.0213429183,
0.1236871183,
-0.0278439801,
0.0701347142,
0.051669661,
-0.0265097842,
-0.0176013149,
-0.0100214351,
-0.029462589,
-0.0245167073,
0.0388165228,
-0.0049307132,
-0.0161652397,
0.0311430283,
-0.0149823744,
0.0405915938,
-0.0007681539,
-0.0020781299,
-0.0317858979,
0.034125302,
0.0288721044,
0.0509098582,
0.0104896389,
-0.01332046,
0.0118273571,
0.0234555155,
-0.0215563737,
0.0175197758,
0.0461671986,
0.0364904292,
0.0228116605,
-0.0073320437,
0.050724078,
0.0104317488,
0.0344957337,
0.0578351766,
-0.001816942,
-0.0183448624,
0.0073429001,
-0.0413631685,
0.0359116569,
0.0104925577,
0.0244464707,
-0.0200623721,
0.026195433,
-0.0131567391,
0.044832956,
-0.0711817965,
-0.0644736961,
-0.0169456881,
0.0879489705,
-0.0238849185,
0.0124205556,
-0.0104832612,
-0.0166234616,
0.0119377403,
-0.038077876,
-0.0073699453,
-0.0322583131,
-0.0455394238,
0.0314740799,
-0.0161141921,
-0.0156777818,
-0.0017715207,
0.0277833026,
0.0841967985,
0.0589801185,
-0.0521139689,
0.0354722403,
-0.0430361815,
-0.0438872837,
0.063437283,
-0.0123961046,
-0.0061486587,
-0.0592969991,
-0.113050282,
-0.0246672519,
0.0057090339,
-0.0038772163,
0.0622849278,
-0.0290145203,
-0.0629279912,
0.0464192033,
0.0161577985,
-0.0218097474,
-0.0212218165,
-0.0505103581,
-0.0198223349,
0.0047723446,
0.0494753905,
-5.981912223e-33,
-0.0099411961,
-0.0161522962,
-0.0154437656,
-0.0071314694,
-0.003089288,
-0.0300665237,
0.021867862,
0.0094161537,
-0.0024483092,
-0.079168871,
-0.0094358614,
-0.0274266899,
0.010421481,
-0.0195242129,
0.0148029299,
0.0074224509,
0.0259944014,
0.0151988054,
-0.0269794837,
0.012168074,
-0.0210113917,
0.020855289,
0.0147896102,
0.0224435981,
0.0584057048,
-0.0508692414,
-0.0077862027,
0.0309329759,
-0.0568925887,
0.0388399847,
0.0095333103,
-0.0248224977,
0.0043455968,
-0.0382139571,
0.0230786223,
-0.0090861991,
-0.0031012327,
0.0071433955,
0.0371374898,
0.0113428337,
0.035821002,
-0.0394568034,
0.026112074,
0.0612729974,
-0.0288716145,
-0.020600168,
0.0033521755,
-0.0412116051,
0.0104227159,
0.0019078808,
0.0224186685,
0.0149578145,
-0.0243499186,
0.0689138547,
-0.0286767557,
-0.0648545399,
-0.0281076878,
-0.0197209138,
0.010650048,
0.0109812804,
0.078260906,
-0.0249669235,
0.0565838031,
0.0103546614,
-0.027188642,
0.0465634018,
-0.0333277024,
-0.01738072,
0.0293075368,
-0.0278964173,
-0.0238162726,
0.0932485312,
0.0412670337,
0.0406028852,
0.037137568,
0.0442395695,
-0.0838330686,
0.0041963165,
0.0303810723,
0.0061340001,
-0.001145036,
-0.0158229712,
-0.0112493811,
-0.0178417582,
-0.0191816296,
-0.0607853532,
0.013143288,
-0.007271972,
0.0272022169,
-0.01765549,
-0.0171908624,
-0.0130920876,
-0.0208782572,
-0.0681964606,
-0.071559608,
-0.0249488465,
0.014196421,
-0.0050196797,
-0.0121666444,
0.0169027187,
-0.0285858922,
-0.0385053158,
-0.0565305948,
0.02593836,
0.0517523363,
-0.00176442,
0.0129909273,
0.0141392993,
-0.0360288359,
0.0120578101,
-0.0198117718,
0.0062635583,
0.0189253539,
-0.0317855924,
0.0179257262,
-0.0724892393,
0.0124063659,
0.0042697694,
0.0143212238,
0.0190314576,
-0.0336108059,
0.0517424978,
-0.0132928621,
0.0427266508,
0.030025484,
0.0029057346,
0.0225714948,
0.0236646663,
0.0420121662,
-0.0556447133,
-0.0247957017,
-0.0061866716,
2.845e-7,
-0.0246351361,
-0.0405779257,
-0.0077446247,
-0.0344181061,
0.0076249093,
0.0562370829,
-0.0766991749,
0.0401388481,
-0.0340734236,
-0.0260372702,
-0.0225754604,
-0.0484789573,
0.0327874124,
0.0069293235,
0.0221635364,
0.0403348319,
-0.0102684414,
-0.0077069649,
-0.0583520271,
-0.0550300814,
0.0067630354,
-0.0095540611,
0.0189518835,
-0.0192573555,
-0.0163675323,
-0.0215276517,
0.0090838987,
-0.010686975,
0.0389650539,
0.0134322308,
0.0156076849,
0.0423939079,
-0.0052398657,
-0.0247716587,
0.0113336714,
0.0019862733,
-0.0440374129,
0.0173611511,
0.0279085543,
0.006728502,
-0.0049478104,
-0.0622244105,
-0.0188197829,
-0.0142787881,
0.1019824743,
0.0312934965,
-0.0201240536,
-0.0269374605,
0.0055787917,
-0.0650371686,
-0.0071411063,
0.0102322185,
0.0500861146,
-0.017561309,
-0.0380330682,
-0.0142144673,
-0.0075774551,
-0.0304362774,
0.0026622817,
0.0463227369,
0.0053553353,
-0.064348571,
-0.0020201681,
0.07865493,
0.02005326,
-0.0419252366,
0.0101921288,
2.898503665e-34,
0.0152069861,
-0.0302154776,
0.0543077439,
0.0647883937,
0.0097938664,
-0.0070723146,
0.0353744365,
0.0186209567,
-0.0045361533,
-0.0397097431,
0.0244621746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12692v1 | MAGIC: Generating Self-Correction Guideline for In-Context Text-to-SQL | 2024-06-18T15:06:06 | 2024-06-18T15:06:06 | Arian Askari, Christian Poelitz, Xinye Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.HC | Self-correction in text-to-SQL is the process of prompting large language
model (LLM) to revise its previously incorrectly generated SQL, and commonly
relies on manually crafted self-correction guidelines by human experts that are
not only labor-intensive to produce but also limited by the human ability in
identifying all potential error patterns in LLM responses. We introduce MAGIC,
a novel multi-agent method that automates the creation of the self-correction
guideline. MAGIC uses three specialized agents: a manager, a correction, and a
feedback agent. These agents collaborate on the failures of an LLM-based method
on the training set to iteratively generate and refine a self-correction
guideline tailored to LLM mistakes, mirroring human processes but without human
involvement. Our extensive experiments show that MAGIC's guideline outperforms
expert human's created ones. We empirically find out that the guideline
produced by MAGIC enhance the interpretability of the corrections made,
providing insights in analyzing the reason behind the failures and successes of
LLMs in self-correction. We make all agent interactions publicly available to
the research community, to foster further research in this area, offering a
synthetic dataset for future explorations into automatic self-correction
guideline generation. | [
0.0521008186,
0.0506934859,
-0.02825718,
0.0018320536,
-0.0276493486,
0.0136108734,
-0.0313773863,
0.0076024812,
0.0208652541,
-0.062267378,
0.0000786922,
0.0209883992,
0.0016124161,
0.0045361388,
0.0353780463,
-0.0282866023,
0.0369204246,
-0.0188890398,
-0.0200636927,
0.0254397467,
0.0034443589,
0.0170498583,
0.0090800822,
0.0065541193,
-0.0239674374,
-0.0300099161,
-0.03462312,
0.0437353402,
-0.0396476649,
-0.0239780974,
0.0058063711,
0.0728732795,
0.0000321757,
0.0228416845,
0.0000019924,
-0.0788922757,
-0.0487605892,
0.011836987,
-0.0379860736,
0.0528798699,
0.029774284,
-0.02817926,
-0.0279601328,
0.0534018278,
-0.0550195165,
0.0307821669,
0.0293598827,
0.0041851476,
0.0757812485,
0.0893558562,
0.0102747753,
0.0139120426,
-0.0099868597,
0.0157137588,
-0.0101614268,
-0.0629816577,
0.032265868,
0.055915419,
-0.0229776017,
-0.0099244667,
0.0046856138,
0.0221947227,
-0.0089947134,
-0.0745021328,
-0.0109194182,
-0.0467016473,
-0.0178192165,
-0.0106846103,
-0.0191964768,
0.0380396619,
0.0317106508,
-0.0365719385,
-0.0032134966,
-0.0007334102,
0.0215532854,
0.0361292548,
0.000487691,
0.0164045822,
0.0122704469,
0.0021650521,
-0.0177681148,
-0.0498985313,
0.0213369448,
-0.0192826856,
-0.0331153907,
0.043650087,
-0.0329941064,
-0.0369339436,
-0.0105346609,
0.0082098683,
0.0229865406,
-0.0590343736,
0.0186685137,
0.048704043,
-0.0781447217,
0.014280729,
-0.0303218123,
-0.0164389759,
0.0501820669,
-0.0672998875,
0.0424679592,
0.0254750121,
-0.006339856,
0.0313683636,
-0.0124223232,
0.004718204,
0.021183826,
0.0379804671,
-0.023163775,
-0.0041369884,
-0.0720400214,
0.0072879884,
-0.0465050489,
0.0029993127,
-0.0110493172,
0.0253927931,
-0.0489797965,
0.0468045138,
-0.0331424847,
0.074129872,
0.008047509,
0.00745701,
-0.0171438009,
-0.0378433168,
-0.0495676063,
0.0132193761,
0.0057938634,
0.001276101,
-0.0091136005,
-0.0546985269,
-0.017256638,
0.0025082557,
0.0001025424,
0.0251243655,
0.0118371956,
0.0685486495,
-0.0126666855,
0.0116118407,
-0.0936737955,
-0.0816426948,
0.0037605104,
-0.0153824473,
-0.0602735616,
-0.0419639125,
0.0048084026,
0.0048269541,
-0.0239900146,
-0.0617664792,
0.0064929738,
0.0051485072,
0.0045380634,
0.0843253508,
-0.0603948124,
0.0590119213,
0.0369841196,
-0.021014588,
-0.0011355839,
0.0611740872,
0.026020186,
-0.0026544153,
0.05045164,
-0.0102609564,
0.0509673357,
0.0186690763,
0.0025790343,
0.0322407521,
-0.0586957037,
0.0454485714,
0.0040679467,
0.0637805387,
0.0164709482,
0.0423184186,
0.0135809463,
0.0212115422,
0.0421183258,
0.0345532931,
0.0374030694,
0.0465063006,
0.0280585717,
0.0009513808,
0.0080884462,
0.0032960242,
-0.0402374454,
0.0151089495,
-0.0274343695,
0.020954499,
0.0179617517,
0.0015290452,
-0.0307447016,
-0.0841030255,
-0.0115645854,
0.0045332857,
0.0094283987,
-0.0116022667,
0.0351451896,
0.0375905447,
-0.033953499,
0.0001938733,
-0.0146636004,
-0.0556926467,
-0.0137291178,
-0.0530591048,
-0.0093330638,
0.1242053062,
0.0671185553,
-0.0496818237,
-0.0059009138,
-0.0123720849,
0.0439171754,
0.0130810216,
0.0565746538,
-0.0376598835,
-0.0635341629,
-0.0309694726,
-0.0275262725,
0.0365451798,
0.0334361494,
-0.0055722748,
0.0329158269,
-0.0246344246,
0.0131571386,
-0.0061095646,
-0.0766304359,
0.0532822572,
-0.0303620808,
-0.046134118,
0.0082006231,
-0.0017257326,
0.0012695364,
0.034880098,
-0.03643829,
0.0336656608,
0.0370262265,
0.0492940731,
-0.0605423264,
-0.0117236655,
-0.0088585671,
0.0105408942,
0.0488220379,
0.0134461736,
-0.0313025005,
-0.0258499719,
-0.0498871692,
-0.0311813764,
0.0186071098,
-0.0089005427,
0.005500637,
-0.041859556,
0.0638652891,
-0.0073073381,
-0.0395549498,
-0.0231695771,
-0.0103439521,
0.01176346,
-0.0354942195,
-0.0182541367,
-0.0259685777,
0.0168928169,
-0.0404477417,
0.0460783914,
0.0019571329,
0.0127690928,
0.0662792921,
-0.0004883189,
0.0120455809,
-0.034008339,
-0.018790381,
-0.0427488498,
-0.0105686942,
-0.0155593576,
0.0136968847,
0.0314786471,
-0.0113316635,
-0.0201557577,
-0.0353916846,
-0.0207307488,
-0.0017773433,
0.0071059419,
0.0200429317,
0.0568368509,
-0.0020742668,
-0.0256057251,
-0.0536305793,
-0.0104515459,
-0.0625275001,
0.0248981956,
0.0140937781,
-0.0054838117,
-0.0883517489,
0.0265974626,
-0.0056971889,
0.0377304293,
0.0135503542,
-0.04220476,
-0.005411902,
-0.0298795961,
-0.0204706881,
0.0476311296,
-0.0028458871,
-0.0075174128,
0.0399986245,
-0.0051616426,
-0.055054076,
-0.0025977644,
0.0131581789,
-0.0429543555,
-0.0109631922,
-0.0283561107,
0.0236160923,
0.0178164057,
-0.0074029798,
-0.0287667122,
-0.0161198322,
-0.0059851184,
0.0149200186,
-0.0130701549,
-0.0234475788,
-0.0384696946,
0.0150730582,
0.0567961931,
0.0049092229,
-0.0432643145,
0.0756579116,
-0.0112253707,
0.0077073826,
-0.0364284106,
-0.0277432222,
-0.0655952916,
0.0631989762,
-0.0092828404,
0.010965243,
-0.0065528303,
-0.0323345251,
-0.0455978513,
-0.0625511333,
0.0660854131,
-0.0110956552,
0.080260314,
-0.089784801,
0.0128523502,
0.0094939098,
-0.0142131271,
-0.0183332358,
0.0010051042,
-0.0532782935,
-0.0166243557,
0.0225670487,
-0.0167178027,
-0.0224251039,
-0.013612886,
-0.003964725,
0.0432168506,
0.0062676584,
-0.0535750501,
0.016662363,
-0.0698460042,
-0.0228693988,
0.0288164336,
0.0014194691,
-0.0341440365,
0.0650437027,
0.0510175675,
0.022724906,
-0.0356592201,
-0.0327284671,
-0.0019785445,
-0.0117115742,
-0.0573382601,
0.0109942127,
0.0286319144,
-0.0074165878,
-0.078795962,
0.0068513914,
0.0975124836,
0.0381332599,
-0.0244878493,
-0.0056601712,
-0.0445985794,
-0.0202992242,
0.0268243849,
0.049541451,
-0.0888750851,
-0.0081827817,
0.0036263203,
0.0534327254,
0.0171712935,
-0.0259217937,
0.0095891515,
-0.1111064255,
0.0561989285,
0.0124586895,
0.0046286741,
-0.027505137,
-0.0160378758,
-0.0153347645,
-0.0342318453,
0.0346880183,
0.0889917985,
-0.0260227583,
-0.0219965857,
0.0203890409,
-0.04309709,
-0.046857994,
0.0071838265,
-0.055753164,
0.0680580214,
0.0999463946,
-0.0057490463,
0.0405431427,
-0.0051328978,
0.0495606028,
0.0218965393,
0.0369895212,
-0.0254343431,
0.080725953,
0.0178810284,
0.0174366888,
0.0298442114,
0.0086275032,
-0.0689028278,
0.0176373925,
0.0433334857,
0.0688305572,
-0.0108780861,
0.0084718307,
0.0122552617,
-0.0075486982,
0.0014810619,
0.0425692946,
0.0069724023,
-0.021758033,
-0.0648561642,
-0.0403372385,
-0.0043886346,
-0.0513545088,
-0.0243996102,
0.0279938914,
-0.0471725129,
-0.0217057131,
-0.0460487641,
-0.0540507734,
0.0661085322,
0.0066937315,
0.0276252683,
0.0107563883,
0.0164533705,
-0.0008148601,
-0.0008018122,
-0.0440842509,
-0.0447146297,
-0.0030280489,
-0.055449158,
-0.0230552722,
-0.0099412529,
0.0053903889,
0.0340779722,
-0.0158691444,
-0.0105145592,
-0.0380195379,
0.0326451063,
0.0408810377,
0.0251379069,
0.0239746459,
0.0102178082,
-0.0835488215,
-0.0265083015,
0.0593760125,
-0.0624484904,
-0.017222384,
0.0107292272,
0.0089305891,
-0.0174582191,
0.0400318615,
-0.0454849862,
-0.0082319845,
-0.0334229544,
0.0106343217,
-0.0568163507,
-0.0562198311,
0.0775767863,
0.0253268331,
-0.0220827069,
0.035570506,
-0.0021682,
-0.0152436588,
0.0397994258,
-0.0422111936,
-0.0486043133,
-0.0143967336,
0.0584647059,
-0.0036598681,
-0.0369477086,
0.0431834683,
-0.0265820455,
-0.0605903342,
0.0077924938,
-0.0054226355,
0.0055628247,
0.0015462568,
0.0320063718,
0.0138028925,
-0.0087612532,
0.0135553768,
0.0365364179,
0.0364861339,
0.0518275946,
0.0080767879,
0.0274976939,
0.0287336949,
0.036465805,
-0.0457704961,
0.0006243648,
-0.0412862413,
-0.0347216986,
-0.0173002798,
0.0324040763,
0.0540290959,
0.0222554542,
0.0521714799,
-0.0285240598,
-0.0170278959,
-0.0145394709,
0.0234472845,
0.0193932503,
0.020078931,
-0.0149776163,
0.0150184147,
-0.0333132483,
-0.0375874937,
0.0481282584,
-0.0019839476,
0.0395128988,
-0.011377221,
-0.0707354918,
-0.0310986619,
-0.0330066048,
0.0169634819,
-0.0307761542,
-0.046533227,
-0.059624508,
-0.0459569097,
-0.0372010991,
0.0060268855,
0.0673304647,
-0.0172442514,
-0.0316061042,
-0.003339956,
0.0866314918,
0.0456918478,
-0.0139417909,
-0.0526653007,
-0.0049201413,
-0.0133392848,
-0.0286849905,
-0.0313259289,
-5.705623664e-33,
-0.0434632599,
-0.053668905,
0.0579335354,
-0.0053178947,
0.0405628942,
-0.0466012396,
-0.0333047323,
0.0134961493,
0.0130919889,
0.0434507318,
-0.0431655049,
0.0374247134,
0.0192856491,
-0.0204562098,
0.0849475786,
0.0045189392,
0.0528022572,
-0.0233092532,
0.0018346929,
-0.0183075685,
0.0103540877,
0.0237723161,
0.0204941668,
-0.0946699977,
0.0422738604,
0.0188202783,
-0.0265438668,
0.0383353718,
-0.0092752054,
0.0406196341,
0.0231845323,
0.0148349749,
0.0054332349,
0.0041369251,
-0.0461855233,
-0.0430281125,
-0.0591750406,
-0.030454522,
-0.0217548516,
0.0148317525,
0.0048748469,
-0.0051309853,
0.0711172894,
-0.0334925726,
-0.0479493998,
0.0244562123,
0.0312599353,
-0.0252135769,
0.0009199661,
0.0229677521,
-0.0464264825,
0.0266212504,
-0.0086523155,
-0.0129125463,
0.0042449823,
0.0073161027,
0.0121944295,
-0.0300244763,
-0.0804877952,
0.0275599454,
0.0614268593,
0.0381741114,
0.0656519532,
0.0082188826,
-0.0065928116,
-0.0004784644,
0.0131388437,
0.058158759,
-0.0218214579,
-0.0001594697,
-0.0053000534,
0.0384838954,
0.0302090328,
0.0797477141,
-0.0105431629,
-0.0362689458,
-0.0430655591,
0.0652661398,
-0.0229478665,
0.0303903408,
0.0025725854,
0.0183883477,
-0.061532516,
-0.0377713591,
-0.01709738,
0.0350575037,
-0.0195414796,
-0.0472187698,
0.0317129418,
0.0081300335,
0.0042035189,
-0.0110410312,
-0.0273341984,
-0.0242565367,
-0.0566568598,
-0.0458080545,
-0.0404347032,
-0.0139480252,
-0.0163976829,
-0.0030189063,
-0.0387705043,
-0.0216967743,
-0.0050516515,
0.0211782977,
0.0373010039,
0.0484408624,
0.005688983,
0.0375001691,
-0.0870310515,
0.0232486892,
-0.0061083408,
0.0235663373,
0.002563538,
-0.0348137394,
-0.0077064722,
-0.0035760875,
0.0118729956,
0.0393756926,
0.0181498881,
-0.0285360701,
-0.0243005864,
0.0190272052,
0.0146069713,
-0.0005055715,
0.0057460386,
0.0006730724,
-0.03772505,
0.0028013275,
0.0672690347,
-0.0099508995,
-0.0038019412,
0.0073554502,
2.648e-7,
0.0824138746,
0.0757090747,
0.0333988592,
0.0523877665,
-0.0005395343,
0.0510879457,
-0.0350588635,
-0.0190637168,
0.020843178,
0.0085312631,
0.068350412,
0.0089287236,
0.0294241887,
0.0403894819,
-0.0243696384,
-0.0295800436,
-0.0257708505,
0.0178467762,
-0.0420267172,
-0.0302649029,
0.0257693827,
0.0361930244,
0.0085134655,
0.0084709805,
0.0074769384,
-0.0640631765,
0.0276816711,
-0.0318324007,
-0.0018798939,
0.0698627234,
0.0542517677,
-0.0034208652,
0.0005828644,
0.0424431078,
-0.0099621592,
-0.0116996169,
-0.046925474,
0.0542942099,
-0.0365811512,
0.0310304612,
0.0006266895,
-0.0519633926,
0.0155220395,
-0.0337332301,
0.0173112024,
-0.0278149731,
0.0078271925,
0.0213927235,
0.001303049,
-0.0341344737,
0.0291536581,
-0.0076671564,
0.0052750022,
0.0274585467,
0.0190686472,
0.045490656,
-0.0142604457,
-0.0388903692,
-0.0226403922,
0.0019588326,
-0.0077755339,
-0.0138401296,
0.0106972037,
0.0257991403,
-0.0301457159,
-0.0356017388,
0.0229273196,
2.518994165e-34,
0.0578001402,
0.0108643593,
0.033596009,
0.0235047285,
0.0794955045,
0.0189803056,
-0.0030952559,
0.044221051,
0.018089503,
-0.0474245921,
-0.0274207853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12687v1 | Using LLMs to Aid Annotation and Collection of Clinically-Enriched Data in Bipolar Disorder and Schizophrenia | 2024-06-18T15:00:24 | 2024-06-18T15:00:24 | Ankit Aich, Avery Quynh, Pamela Osseyi, Amy Pinkham, Philip Harvey, Brenda Curtis, Colin Depp, Natalie Parde | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP in mental health has been primarily social media focused. Real world
practitioners also have high case loads and often domain specific variables, of
which modern LLMs lack context. We take a dataset made by recruiting 644
participants, including individuals diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder (BD),
Schizophrenia (SZ), and Healthy Controls (HC). Participants undertook tasks
derived from a standardized mental health instrument, and the resulting data
were transcribed and annotated by experts across five clinical variables. This
paper demonstrates the application of contemporary language models in
sequence-to-sequence tasks to enhance mental health research. Specifically, we
illustrate how these models can facilitate the deployment of mental health
instruments, data collection, and data annotation with high accuracy and
scalability. We show that small models are capable of annotation for
domain-specific clinical variables, data collection for mental-health
instruments, and perform better then commercial large models. | [
0.0191950444,
0.0366925895,
-0.0145572517,
-0.0101118358,
-0.0133407209,
0.0123634972,
-0.0139796818,
0.0126378043,
0.061880596,
-0.0350832865,
0.0267086122,
-0.0252377633,
0.0051520844,
-0.012684796,
0.0179944653,
-0.068314597,
0.0211949162,
0.0055929092,
0.014237714,
0.0220818911,
0.0056326864,
0.0213912278,
-0.0268551838,
0.037578173,
-0.0069494736,
-0.0011421617,
0.0053872135,
0.0215579011,
0.0165111367,
-0.0832380876,
-0.0306233782,
0.067856282,
0.0079373885,
-0.0398109369,
0.0000016623,
-0.0461057611,
-0.0302285124,
0.0323702283,
-0.004022311,
-0.0569755845,
0.0105748968,
-0.0443754718,
0.0268776715,
0.0179117844,
-0.0363334119,
0.0090343328,
0.0543937571,
0.065703027,
0.0371033102,
0.0307551417,
-0.0175697692,
-0.0245359465,
0.019374257,
-0.0191049576,
0.0348509401,
0.0086184116,
0.0392449759,
0.0103022279,
0.0818058103,
0.0039389688,
0.0177300368,
0.0465980731,
-0.0401780307,
0.0319801271,
-0.0091637122,
0.0037329011,
-0.0166146159,
-0.0093066199,
-0.0016874626,
0.0850529671,
0.033224199,
0.0290041193,
0.0538345538,
-0.015825944,
-0.004075916,
0.0170499776,
-0.0523370244,
0.011607402,
-0.0109144738,
-0.00527192,
0.03442204,
-0.0190872587,
0.032171648,
-0.0453421175,
0.0293030348,
0.0747016072,
-0.0143420845,
-0.0285778865,
-0.001768696,
-0.000482167,
-0.0219421927,
-0.0754096135,
0.0248744078,
0.0487120636,
-0.0356342345,
0.0317930095,
-0.0316212811,
-0.0734896287,
0.0647484511,
-0.0246510543,
0.0475288481,
0.0295702796,
-0.0497970432,
0.0047903396,
0.0368089899,
-0.0019732602,
-0.0035510305,
0.0512819141,
-0.0351021774,
0.0090729194,
-0.0802127123,
0.0091368584,
-0.0111076226,
0.0243812203,
-0.040931087,
-0.0073987679,
-0.0631969795,
0.0296098739,
-0.0005525014,
-0.0008538097,
0.044341132,
-0.0177123807,
-0.0002401303,
0.0393158346,
0.0099578323,
-0.0057765632,
-0.0016602078,
0.0018558074,
0.0277492329,
-0.0645908266,
0.0285959151,
-0.0161318164,
-0.0091339527,
-0.0395102911,
0.0207070671,
0.0932663456,
0.0769857094,
-0.0323177651,
-0.0890650153,
-0.0476911776,
-0.0421124399,
-0.0158770718,
0.0181066561,
-0.0794352591,
0.0619966127,
0.0527311675,
-0.0336322673,
-0.0280478261,
0.0232758019,
0.0163912047,
-0.0722911954,
0.0758021325,
-0.0852506906,
0.011472892,
-0.0059331008,
0.0224350244,
0.0159088224,
0.0461731181,
0.0323532261,
-0.0366969705,
0.0414441973,
-0.030085573,
0.0174585041,
0.0348656885,
0.0111341663,
-0.0446937494,
0.0020590029,
0.0026611127,
-0.0058624852,
0.0453355499,
-0.0126744574,
0.0521703847,
0.0107189622,
0.0257297307,
0.0629457384,
0.0944626406,
0.0354625657,
0.0126026189,
0.0170536451,
-0.0089324387,
-0.0267428346,
-0.0297288969,
-0.0424587913,
0.0548739843,
-0.0109193297,
0.0072191176,
0.0309769679,
-0.0047082915,
-0.0168447345,
-0.0429430008,
-0.0687724575,
-0.0113521293,
-0.0194326025,
0.0216238499,
-0.0406643935,
-0.0244185738,
0.0093179084,
0.1150310263,
0.0184470359,
-0.0218547545,
-0.0150773386,
-0.0256849043,
-0.0164791029,
0.0916037783,
0.013248005,
-0.0536936857,
-0.0279538222,
-0.0415933467,
0.0384720601,
0.0315885544,
0.0136591876,
0.0028205551,
0.0023039456,
-0.0091475416,
0.0028503384,
0.0518972427,
-0.0072770212,
-0.0409474894,
0.0057809716,
-0.0273978394,
-0.0328113623,
-0.0482701398,
-0.0453208946,
0.0552147217,
-0.062182162,
-0.0285310932,
0.0020482063,
-0.0155160362,
0.0580549911,
0.0498609096,
0.013900036,
0.0338511877,
0.0391159765,
-0.0233576298,
-0.057256002,
-0.0069572823,
0.0233830214,
-0.0273898579,
0.0332732759,
0.008540987,
0.0040569324,
0.0056338813,
-0.043094974,
-0.026949754,
0.0061847474,
-0.0577794574,
-0.0034394106,
-0.0108424639,
-0.0107707968,
0.049222298,
0.0292046573,
-0.05790966,
0.003566318,
-0.0434222966,
0.0349527374,
0.0145645225,
-0.0858617425,
-0.0218095183,
-0.0361155719,
-0.025193017,
0.0100810304,
0.0027975431,
0.0329074413,
-0.0294227097,
-0.0114364689,
-0.0059837662,
-0.0153044304,
-0.119367525,
0.0388575234,
0.017046269,
0.0344413966,
0.0096807582,
0.0109273847,
-0.001555057,
0.0072269556,
-0.0379010066,
-0.0120675461,
0.0481536835,
0.0485750139,
0.0417771488,
0.0484537929,
-0.0292560589,
-0.0579065084,
-0.0252028927,
-0.0455251671,
0.0064915824,
-0.0222756285,
-0.0423408151,
-0.0313860923,
-0.0310756378,
-0.0733891055,
-0.0113180913,
-0.0051591387,
0.0141223194,
0.0060770735,
0.0006047282,
0.0549728349,
0.0042114989,
-0.0114630032,
0.024307996,
0.0427738428,
-0.0340820439,
-0.0191693157,
-0.0158555303,
-0.0189224426,
-0.0079364087,
-0.0491858311,
-0.0750990584,
0.0215096287,
0.0630625114,
0.0298005994,
0.0063273478,
-0.02587061,
-0.0389359705,
-0.0042709294,
0.0300775226,
0.0094053997,
-0.0110346451,
-0.0419904403,
0.0382819138,
-0.0062274509,
-0.0209239237,
0.0373727307,
-0.0330091938,
0.0091916537,
-0.0390007347,
-0.0414303094,
-0.0553969182,
0.0262375977,
0.0085569574,
0.0186763033,
-0.0148858968,
-0.0175129678,
0.0150983622,
-0.0309187416,
-0.0319110714,
-0.062875703,
0.0822556242,
-0.0668195933,
0.0351269171,
-0.0192150697,
0.0148208784,
-0.0182035267,
0.0096600987,
-0.0500309691,
0.0112128621,
0.0171973221,
0.0130531667,
-0.0372258686,
-0.0006907261,
0.0298702475,
0.0365020894,
0.0009422158,
-0.0188123174,
-0.0071730493,
0.0418842994,
0.0274469797,
-0.0272061508,
0.0346153267,
-0.0216213483,
-0.0468703397,
0.0386828594,
-0.0371985883,
0.0388223864,
0.0026411272,
-0.0025734035,
0.0130532039,
-0.0561510958,
-0.0313993432,
0.0639094338,
0.0366347134,
-0.0343327858,
0.0118672987,
0.1073159426,
0.0200163852,
-0.0158381425,
0.0228405241,
-0.039057374,
-0.0369006954,
0.0008195704,
0.0027673279,
-0.0474522822,
-0.0194758326,
-0.0040226835,
0.0581874214,
-0.0314472914,
-0.0539995953,
-0.0033812174,
-0.0444408283,
0.0166764017,
-0.0230361093,
-0.0367415287,
-0.0099141272,
-0.0194672719,
0.0145768328,
0.000592773,
0.0125428298,
-0.0198703222,
-0.006494103,
0.0130155729,
0.0349197835,
-0.0906267017,
-0.0585952513,
0.0119233159,
-0.0143451672,
0.1233580559,
0.0506111272,
0.0125736995,
-0.0091407867,
-0.025460925,
0.0168463998,
0.0372345522,
0.0049128407,
-0.0058444776,
0.088700071,
0.0055743763,
0.0201060809,
-0.0549912006,
0.0353539735,
-0.0694073364,
-0.022490399,
-0.0390679538,
0.0911042616,
-0.0143114459,
-0.0142399771,
-0.0363800526,
0.0405592732,
0.0575607158,
0.0479365215,
0.0170012768,
-0.0258201379,
-0.0113097737,
-0.0090951575,
0.0022055248,
-0.0339816995,
-0.0583405308,
0.0202808995,
-0.0192929301,
0.0120092575,
-0.0847191364,
-0.0355610698,
0.0712202117,
-0.0241513029,
0.0244695768,
0.0122760097,
0.0290631931,
-0.0240961593,
-0.081356138,
0.0421129726,
0.0225441027,
0.0309957974,
-0.0478176996,
-0.002839783,
0.0432852767,
0.0183025245,
-0.0101568364,
0.0369801521,
-0.0966493562,
-0.0453730188,
0.0375969186,
0.0340184905,
0.0177393686,
-0.0402258337,
0.0362739302,
-0.035121046,
-0.0332172289,
0.0454518944,
-0.0004571281,
-0.0014613848,
-0.036594823,
0.0638856068,
0.0036453449,
0.0294672865,
-0.0112607945,
0.0228636824,
0.0348072909,
0.0462099724,
-0.0259632301,
-0.0426506624,
0.0051094452,
0.0230997372,
0.0355913192,
-0.0172948558,
-0.024052497,
-0.0007247602,
-0.0317523517,
-0.0341567248,
0.0175470151,
-0.0348014086,
-0.0393388569,
-0.0085404124,
-0.0052356976,
-0.018172117,
0.0035247284,
-0.0826873407,
0.0016364937,
-0.0416739322,
0.0515474454,
-0.0407150313,
-0.0171157457,
-0.0024258289,
-0.0076082395,
-0.0049814582,
0.0345462933,
-0.0038671289,
0.031134503,
-0.0035447022,
0.038190335,
-0.0045433384,
0.0286570229,
0.0440411828,
0.0453403667,
-0.0314960815,
-0.0772519857,
-0.0120065575,
0.0060564172,
0.0314019434,
0.0311694648,
0.0757239684,
-0.0136125153,
0.0006399292,
-0.0320211351,
0.043365024,
-0.0117574269,
-0.0131036844,
0.033067029,
0.0112974988,
-0.0219923481,
-0.0555272587,
0.0561924428,
-0.0068422314,
-0.0086093992,
0.0042496813,
-0.0312880427,
-0.0257715099,
-0.0236084983,
0.000445058,
-0.0010148328,
-0.0574194416,
-0.0320940912,
-0.0565412417,
-0.0550622456,
0.0975227207,
-0.0116477851,
-0.0315687358,
-0.0211089849,
0.0255506672,
-0.0041129244,
0.0172779616,
-0.0259542055,
-0.0298753045,
0.0391995981,
-0.0285524558,
-0.0672640279,
-0.0057413434,
-5.212119911e-33,
-0.0491712131,
-0.048507642,
0.0498565808,
0.0209763292,
-0.0081239436,
-0.0108521702,
-0.0316690244,
0.0447116233,
0.0170328766,
-0.0088649066,
-0.00049065,
0.0394899063,
0.0134986499,
0.0493318737,
0.0430162214,
-0.0316269509,
0.0157534219,
0.0083661648,
0.009157313,
-0.0230458584,
-0.0149416598,
0.0321989842,
0.0663306415,
-0.1046897545,
0.0452087671,
0.0140542947,
0.0424162224,
0.0062457798,
0.0458118692,
0.0228887349,
-0.023436375,
0.031361632,
0.0507942773,
-0.0143965567,
-0.0171518344,
0.0019557618,
-0.0503606126,
-0.0070069036,
0.044224415,
-0.0120006958,
-0.0591526628,
-0.0078031924,
0.0331417881,
-0.0213856064,
-0.0098678358,
-0.0194541197,
0.0423271693,
-0.0698410198,
0.0017497952,
-0.0118225813,
-0.0214346964,
0.0294595473,
0.0086262263,
0.04023562,
-0.0123671945,
0.0129477158,
-0.0426619612,
0.0326599553,
-0.0653100163,
0.006778514,
0.0091438759,
0.0427063219,
0.0273100473,
-0.0278840065,
-0.0054148259,
0.0326817855,
0.0081698941,
-0.0250056088,
-0.0094097396,
0.0304179713,
-0.019260738,
0.0589142106,
0.0484472364,
0.0220679007,
-0.0065490347,
0.0186113473,
-0.0410479642,
0.0247449912,
-0.0300083477,
-0.0132416897,
0.0361102782,
-0.0026607469,
0.0104703559,
-0.0041744933,
-0.0407403149,
0.0182985645,
-0.0018241702,
-0.0441640839,
0.0194728989,
-0.0147173479,
0.0062017888,
0.0213889387,
0.0256264862,
-0.0086713703,
-0.054313127,
-0.0255251937,
0.0414696857,
0.0250323247,
-0.0119657824,
0.0016276954,
-0.0453433804,
0.0101539111,
0.0147248721,
0.012870579,
0.0635633469,
0.0024778259,
0.0417567492,
-0.029828392,
-0.0483614169,
-0.0099750375,
0.0123254051,
0.057487566,
-0.032781411,
0.0577562787,
0.0058638384,
0.0063207792,
0.006398059,
0.0609524362,
-0.0052859746,
-0.0305347126,
-0.0259022582,
-0.0033281764,
-0.0014343907,
-0.0189238153,
-0.0112698479,
0.0045161764,
-0.0245447867,
0.0434674881,
0.0125228046,
-0.0368004255,
0.004363609,
-0.0004011813,
2.442e-7,
0.082643047,
0.0698518828,
0.0043926998,
0.0518894941,
0.0235963073,
-0.0302988905,
-0.0009671424,
0.0242462978,
0.009642249,
-0.0398506448,
0.01009533,
0.0238565281,
0.0439362414,
0.0657209679,
-0.0185660738,
-0.0774009004,
-0.0269777123,
0.0074416613,
-0.0576594919,
-0.0072067981,
0.0677349642,
0.0424519181,
-0.0175888706,
-0.0107879955,
-0.0046341666,
-0.0176910944,
0.0336476415,
-0.0304475129,
0.0062823775,
0.0532575436,
0.0397634916,
0.0120972767,
0.0242728181,
0.0154046286,
-0.0266474877,
-0.0239861179,
-0.0306372978,
0.0767272636,
-0.0438689888,
-0.0545268431,
-0.0031484927,
-0.010427,
0.0119116176,
0.0000934979,
0.0327760875,
-0.0618249737,
-0.040098127,
0.0078808255,
-0.0509657487,
-0.0272936989,
0.0115677128,
-0.0028199663,
-0.0085783368,
0.0347346738,
0.0496780872,
0.0003205794,
-0.0143972095,
-0.0585642681,
-0.0108190095,
0.0504390001,
-0.0419197753,
-0.0218512602,
0.0078101279,
0.0061240508,
-0.034269549,
-0.0528594628,
-0.003355962,
2.326991168e-34,
-0.0009468769,
0.0447159186,
0.0286307745,
0.0237343423,
0.0037402092,
0.0160827693,
-0.0413636044,
0.0042289165,
-0.0281003788,
-0.0850271732,
-0.0189452004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12680v1 | Measuring Psychological Depth in Language Models | 2024-06-18T14:51:54 | 2024-06-18T14:51:54 | Fabrice Harel-Canada, Hanyu Zhou, Sreya Mupalla, Zeynep Yildiz, Amit Sahai, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluations of creative stories generated by large language models (LLMs)
often focus on objective properties of the text, such as its style, coherence,
and toxicity. While these metrics are indispensable, they do not speak to a
story's subjective, psychological impact from a reader's perspective. We
introduce the Psychological Depth Scale (PDS), a novel framework rooted in
literary theory that measures an LLM's ability to produce authentic and
narratively complex stories that provoke emotion, empathy, and engagement. We
empirically validate our framework by showing that humans can consistently
evaluate stories based on PDS (0.72 Krippendorff's alpha). We also explore
techniques for automating the PDS to easily scale future analyses. GPT-4o,
combined with a novel Mixture-of-Personas (MoP) prompting strategy, achieves an
average Spearman correlation of $0.51$ with human judgment while Llama-3-70B
scores as high as 0.68 for empathy. Finally, we compared the depth of stories
authored by both humans and LLMs. Surprisingly, GPT-4 stories either surpassed
or were statistically indistinguishable from highly-rated human-written stories
sourced from Reddit. By shifting the focus from text to reader, the
Psychological Depth Scale is a validated, automated, and systematic means of
measuring the capacity of LLMs to connect with humans through the stories they
tell. | [
0.0565508679,
0.0323271751,
-0.0471634343,
0.0187758487,
-0.0551091023,
0.0225116313,
0.0133998692,
-0.0237037651,
0.0188944191,
-0.0037101095,
-0.0154574681,
-0.0246938486,
0.0203329157,
0.0906203911,
0.0074584163,
-0.0610476956,
-0.0225049537,
0.0008791002,
0.0511914343,
0.0080793332,
-0.0005929422,
0.0544209108,
0.0094799772,
0.0592558905,
0.0194693636,
-0.0249231141,
0.011841367,
0.0297590811,
0.0391604863,
-0.0376326367,
-0.0075908415,
0.0459831245,
0.0197816901,
0.0177503936,
0.0000022872,
-0.0493802428,
0.0275715888,
-0.025776796,
0.0378315225,
-0.005077316,
0.0510156713,
0.0006046348,
-0.0045184442,
-0.0063388436,
0.0073787328,
0.0147009687,
0.0310018882,
0.0521701723,
0.0432331674,
0.0539414249,
-0.0272692852,
-0.0214013588,
0.0285703149,
-0.009258491,
0.0089876652,
0.0278067924,
0.0065779211,
-0.0145902233,
0.0193472672,
-0.0361708514,
-0.0161279924,
0.0111363167,
0.0465154387,
-0.008941385,
0.0154493637,
0.0311608966,
0.0418083444,
-0.0391912535,
0.0183402002,
0.0395061299,
0.0049803643,
0.0074813701,
-0.0141899157,
-0.0134582631,
0.0032398349,
0.0023397314,
-0.0495778359,
0.0125289373,
-0.0011876215,
0.0013591856,
-0.0166024622,
0.0543608516,
0.0058977157,
0.008125023,
0.0427430347,
0.0260952953,
0.0195644107,
-0.0105773108,
0.0045188842,
0.0151641853,
0.0139290961,
-0.0700256974,
0.0148141831,
0.0004040205,
0.0025830131,
0.0173407625,
-0.023504192,
0.0166707337,
0.0235168524,
-0.0687661916,
0.0280951019,
0.0283966884,
-0.0015167436,
0.0327160545,
0.027734777,
0.0319945104,
0.0170741808,
0.00031807,
-0.0219391193,
0.0371586643,
-0.0163013861,
-0.0068005179,
-0.0306144431,
-0.0149673065,
0.0102931578,
-0.0434588529,
-0.0357299447,
0.0067490507,
-0.0037684422,
-0.0295085125,
-0.0398496166,
-0.0000169036,
-0.013170368,
-0.0034138595,
-0.0215665959,
0.0494312346,
-0.0681477338,
0.001961238,
0.0033493522,
-0.0169133581,
0.018448323,
-0.0069943131,
0.0055905487,
-0.0371312015,
0.0281146243,
0.0315367393,
0.0175966974,
-0.0660425946,
-0.0430101342,
-0.0318854041,
0.0122157615,
-0.0425652638,
-0.0384795107,
-0.0648569018,
0.025572842,
0.017981261,
0.0356081612,
-0.0345684662,
0.0072904509,
0.0251034684,
-0.0320918448,
0.005753688,
-0.0159779061,
0.0183504522,
0.0113443816,
0.0353146382,
-0.0107172159,
0.0204313491,
0.0596877858,
0.0842854604,
0.0487543754,
-0.0029254283,
0.0148992753,
-0.004489793,
-0.0758668929,
-0.0054559116,
-0.0106311794,
-0.0364048034,
-0.0465032607,
0.0634170696,
0.0090582436,
0.0529736802,
-0.0315129533,
0.0289266966,
0.1157255992,
0.0914364904,
0.007450378,
0.0526734181,
0.0684871376,
0.0156732183,
0.0331967473,
0.0374311022,
-0.0214483235,
0.0262378659,
0.0129567636,
-0.0197808128,
0.051516939,
0.0460506529,
0.0033757889,
-0.0257693641,
-0.0153340148,
-0.0002071398,
0.023012789,
-0.0245965496,
-0.0170635935,
-0.0012857466,
-0.0388904735,
-0.0621494018,
0.0400574505,
-0.0878144577,
0.0292991325,
0.0022807794,
0.0569966882,
0.110829331,
0.0576883927,
0.0002773774,
0.0403772444,
-0.0153682884,
-0.0003878716,
0.0463776961,
0.0022346904,
0.0147401337,
0.0133462101,
-0.0032562853,
0.0255460721,
-0.0563431531,
0.0164754633,
0.0277624819,
-0.0361407474,
0.0131244054,
-0.0273327604,
-0.0178939514,
-0.0320230834,
0.0177217033,
-0.0700667873,
-0.0110459151,
-0.04988667,
0.0105149196,
-0.0167105887,
0.0217453577,
-0.021816073,
0.0040581156,
0.00639142,
-0.0319399759,
-0.041739732,
0.0474753715,
-0.0270716101,
0.0187698156,
0.0004586199,
-0.0793116391,
0.0082497168,
0.0100774337,
0.0463557765,
0.0007438055,
0.0494116992,
-0.047243651,
0.0380256809,
-0.0113237407,
-0.0018682281,
-0.0446864702,
0.0153183918,
-0.0183311906,
0.0481313132,
0.0070241312,
0.0381896794,
-0.0229225904,
-0.0292076394,
-0.0186899211,
-0.0074071032,
-0.0186196733,
0.0007902171,
0.019647507,
-0.0078447796,
0.0134695517,
-0.017650716,
-0.0637480095,
-0.0639031008,
-0.0931924731,
-0.006909145,
0.0007589695,
-0.0180480517,
0.0304872058,
-0.0180003569,
-0.0465274751,
0.0365603715,
-0.0605464429,
-0.0284871161,
-0.0075480347,
0.0121563682,
-0.001531251,
0.0107642226,
-0.0006102487,
-0.0394953564,
0.0102867186,
-0.0112307025,
0.0595947877,
0.0688295513,
0.0120582376,
-0.012718861,
0.0254005473,
-0.0594637804,
-0.0532372147,
-0.0181067828,
-0.057263948,
0.0194163509,
0.008440692,
0.0632107779,
0.0392032713,
0.03800565,
0.0480988547,
0.0520979874,
-0.027545372,
-0.0098613687,
-0.0105412779,
-0.0026007004,
0.0400739908,
-0.0349478498,
-0.0861127898,
0.0257821716,
0.0646805167,
0.0122234868,
0.0118239345,
-0.0648992732,
0.0518416017,
-0.0117251696,
-0.0370107256,
0.0351388231,
-0.053530816,
-0.0056562065,
0.0381541997,
-0.0089148572,
-0.0534520149,
0.0825832412,
-0.0456536673,
0.0102623096,
-0.0026675884,
-0.0046377028,
-0.0445819311,
0.09568616,
-0.0114319064,
0.0471103899,
-0.0043020649,
0.0062407926,
-0.00139894,
0.0248343386,
0.0141782798,
-0.0242146906,
0.0201129261,
-0.0183583423,
-0.0443129055,
0.037573915,
0.0077571264,
-0.0325652398,
-0.0140808346,
-0.0619274117,
-0.0247340854,
0.0637413934,
-0.0249325112,
-0.0053897318,
-0.0205666907,
0.0472784042,
-0.0146244923,
-0.0110070836,
-0.028809065,
0.0119035402,
-0.0275859684,
0.0561940707,
-0.0148267997,
0.0449907444,
-0.0613849238,
0.0706406012,
0.03149141,
-0.0639597625,
0.0030863667,
0.0202798489,
0.0133804642,
0.0133338952,
0.0070505505,
-0.0296434648,
0.0040197927,
0.0366904549,
-0.0480141528,
-0.0149945728,
0.115109764,
0.0173966996,
-0.0634393394,
0.0259890798,
-0.0466501154,
0.0051326253,
0.0194628835,
0.008034721,
-0.0229754485,
0.0033212933,
0.0059084087,
0.0064514461,
-0.0476162843,
-0.0417892151,
-0.022858534,
-0.0670178309,
0.0240889117,
0.0092656147,
0.0083914334,
0.0077718431,
-0.0362819731,
0.0094338739,
0.0477949083,
-0.0283498168,
0.0041385125,
-0.0103421845,
-0.0032126906,
-0.0497368574,
-0.0266732574,
-0.0321347713,
0.0354050137,
-0.0378515609,
0.0326795764,
0.0337827131,
0.0928835124,
-0.0045382185,
-0.0351310596,
-0.0378683098,
0.0297404248,
0.0036148599,
0.0280214194,
0.0652210414,
-0.0251240805,
0.0297998339,
-0.0728350356,
0.0469876677,
0.0060879341,
-0.0322246253,
-0.0206921659,
0.0484555736,
0.0084954826,
-0.0641595721,
-0.0185975581,
0.0365340784,
-0.0076821209,
0.0719017163,
0.0638233796,
-0.0754084289,
-0.0127297277,
-0.0311252978,
0.0213145837,
-0.033355087,
-0.0674016103,
-0.0108582526,
0.0077747945,
-0.0086276662,
-0.0672804639,
-0.0378537178,
0.0020597279,
0.0071313474,
0.0228990726,
0.0032691318,
-0.0199067276,
-0.0065839924,
-0.0231764503,
0.0324020274,
0.0173187889,
0.0483431518,
-0.0376442671,
0.0244308468,
-0.0226592198,
-0.0652051568,
0.0265870262,
0.0143192755,
-0.0626899675,
-0.0491954684,
0.03755638,
-0.0017076365,
0.0175611973,
-0.0403889827,
-0.0040275771,
-0.1034248397,
0.0365413278,
-0.0046055447,
-0.0534394011,
0.0492179655,
-0.0184701867,
0.0639704987,
0.0143260779,
0.0189146809,
-0.0162398312,
0.0160592217,
0.0100380341,
0.0166972224,
0.0486169457,
-0.05287233,
0.0187920872,
0.024104014,
-0.020823624,
-0.0417849906,
0.0174094122,
-0.060514342,
-0.0439395085,
-0.0616885424,
-0.0089786118,
-0.0509222858,
-0.0147000728,
0.0337537974,
0.0205242746,
-0.031384442,
-0.0462114923,
-0.043231234,
0.0022709442,
-0.0600468926,
0.0031590571,
0.0133199869,
-0.0280369706,
0.0071736728,
0.0015900589,
-0.0351392142,
-0.0141371749,
-0.0667745247,
0.0297158491,
0.0072584297,
0.0340035111,
0.0067482768,
-0.032142058,
0.0031344071,
0.0577447489,
-0.0383071452,
-0.0382885374,
0.0050409087,
-0.0098216599,
0.0513022244,
0.0016285633,
0.0667537823,
-0.0543459766,
0.0205687135,
0.0093218312,
0.0101531222,
-0.010011876,
-0.0584713258,
-0.0613710843,
0.0380764157,
-0.0052883518,
0.0081856987,
0.0435763001,
-0.0252350699,
0.0156034138,
0.0141543886,
-0.019933179,
0.0000901793,
0.0103128133,
0.0231160335,
0.0596571527,
-0.0058617932,
-0.0004515479,
-0.11119093,
-0.0447938927,
0.0215579681,
-0.0068078078,
0.0173651725,
-0.0566290542,
0.0062265992,
0.0333981737,
-0.0108049093,
0.0141469277,
-0.0436483361,
0.0262318011,
-0.0441600867,
0.0043302076,
0.0180354696,
-6.357805929e-33,
0.0026186353,
-0.0319100544,
-0.039915558,
0.0003674141,
-0.0852319673,
0.0076688859,
-0.0650277361,
0.0355289839,
0.0477061458,
0.0641603693,
-0.0041387267,
-0.0106530003,
-0.0118555864,
-0.02460449,
-0.0061082849,
0.0180949215,
0.0340249725,
0.0144964624,
-0.0622477233,
0.0105090821,
0.025119666,
0.0054362998,
-0.0008665649,
-0.0295269862,
0.0261369366,
-0.0324310772,
-0.0231541563,
-0.0195544101,
0.0150813181,
0.0346869454,
-0.0142253404,
0.0515583009,
0.0375731029,
0.010846992,
-0.0014683022,
0.0259642713,
-0.0071177129,
-0.0153951412,
0.0156382937,
-0.0213165544,
-0.0490062162,
-0.0180248879,
0.039852418,
-0.0034687519,
-0.0053865314,
-0.0469471738,
0.0422701575,
-0.0160115361,
0.054450389,
-0.0449492559,
-0.0766163394,
-0.0031799788,
-0.0140537247,
-0.0504463427,
-0.0004494442,
0.0329207219,
0.0096903471,
0.0346148498,
-0.0294114873,
0.0314646438,
-0.0525800623,
0.0096361395,
0.0072660572,
-0.0116063533,
-0.0034087426,
0.0988311321,
-0.0095276348,
0.0626856685,
-0.0650388002,
0.0600113794,
0.0313589536,
0.0368060246,
0.0522282459,
0.0699568093,
-0.0021731572,
-0.0157167688,
-0.0084604137,
0.0410856791,
0.0011617286,
-0.007368173,
0.0648815259,
0.0045443787,
-0.0363705754,
-0.0279733296,
-0.0239825733,
-0.0589687116,
-0.0190604329,
-0.0456514582,
0.0019699603,
-0.0253274273,
-0.0418537669,
-0.0630104989,
-0.0071770232,
-0.0296620317,
0.0194125604,
0.0167451762,
-0.0647169426,
0.0626078397,
0.0018129396,
0.0240210723,
0.0151424771,
0.0215363819,
0.0196789149,
0.0271301512,
0.0652099177,
-0.0062095695,
0.001658593,
0.01880618,
-0.0300810523,
-0.0078262696,
-0.0341792852,
0.0270376038,
0.0347319245,
0.0114986356,
-0.0019355048,
-0.0239707176,
-0.0219393205,
-0.0266897343,
0.0334603749,
0.0023144488,
-0.0525532551,
-0.0251252633,
-0.0510824136,
-0.006057329,
-0.044063516,
-0.00824509,
-0.0221888088,
-0.0417951308,
0.0717918575,
-0.0424393341,
-0.0386215784,
-0.0208612382,
3.065e-7,
-0.0345120355,
0.0530206598,
0.0014693285,
0.0015149642,
0.0359569453,
0.0521434918,
0.0030006052,
0.041229371,
0.0121869221,
-0.0353409499,
0.003480497,
0.009386206,
0.0632825792,
0.0627388582,
-0.0989950746,
0.040156275,
-0.0643183142,
0.0157016795,
-0.067441918,
-0.0341695845,
0.0798169822,
-0.011247959,
0.0630254,
-0.0216071624,
0.0314295217,
-0.0076639582,
0.0136831002,
-0.0301514138,
-0.0062563526,
0.0312549323,
0.0149217285,
-0.0381300822,
-0.0014531034,
-0.0207724981,
-0.0017578033,
0.0156976376,
0.0398271866,
0.0540123209,
0.0026082688,
0.0005065083,
0.0380145088,
-0.0001725142,
-0.0165920556,
-0.0949311927,
0.0380314477,
-0.0130278775,
-0.046614673,
-0.0065381271,
0.0148746157,
-0.0473617092,
0.0466114469,
-0.0254663639,
-0.0434095599,
0.0225801133,
0.0218648985,
-0.0168282222,
0.0276428517,
-0.0354635715,
-0.0184834171,
-0.0230176132,
-0.0335141458,
-0.0309817642,
-0.056091167,
0.0033171093,
-0.029157633,
-0.0782828629,
0.0289529804,
2.758927486e-34,
0.0285709202,
-0.0077737723,
0.005457493,
-0.0323941447,
0.0712343901,
0.0422953293,
0.0125250658,
0.0047344444,
0.037119288,
-0.0698957443,
-0.0164703317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12679v1 | Vernacular? I Barely Know Her: Challenges with Style Control and Stereotyping | 2024-06-18T14:51:30 | 2024-06-18T14:51:30 | Ankit Aich, Tingting Liu, Salvatore Giorgi, Kelsey Isman, Lyle Ungar, Brenda Curtis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in educational and
learning applications. Research has demonstrated that controlling for style, to
fit the needs of the learner, fosters increased understanding, promotes
inclusion, and helps with knowledge distillation. To understand the
capabilities and limitations of contemporary LLMs in style control, we
evaluated five state-of-the-art models: GPT-3.5, GPT-4, GPT-4o, Llama-3, and
Mistral-instruct- 7B across two style control tasks. We observed significant
inconsistencies in the first task, with model performances averaging between
5th and 8th grade reading levels for tasks intended for first-graders, and
standard deviations up to 27.6. For our second task, we observed a
statistically significant improvement in performance from 0.02 to 0.26.
However, we find that even without stereotypes in reference texts, LLMs often
generated culturally insensitive content during their tasks. We provide a
thorough analysis and discussion of the results. | [
0.0428150296,
0.0446307734,
-0.0406675003,
0.0145222703,
-0.009576695,
0.020659091,
0.0345845856,
-0.0395547487,
0.0083318539,
-0.0418892615,
-0.0294774249,
-0.0633473992,
0.0390420556,
0.0088689178,
0.0322886407,
-0.0702546909,
-0.0002479125,
0.0060166819,
0.0398917496,
-0.0267168023,
0.0325261094,
0.043924652,
0.0143179866,
0.0473506376,
-0.0037655798,
-0.0603507645,
0.0417858325,
0.0037192206,
-0.0123509886,
0.0038864382,
0.0734331682,
0.0641544685,
0.0085144313,
0.0045651668,
0.000002634,
-0.0371252298,
0.045731172,
-0.0390441231,
0.055168394,
0.0830040798,
0.0866070613,
-0.0030240505,
-0.0334203318,
0.0072666989,
-0.0199836046,
-0.0194752794,
0.0317831598,
0.0171561241,
0.0062722191,
-0.0291394535,
0.0117791491,
-0.0525356121,
-0.0228822138,
0.0303593203,
0.007397817,
0.0312885642,
0.0119686052,
0.0002027718,
0.0129466271,
-0.0228392277,
-0.0480835326,
0.0611357652,
-0.0062923944,
-0.0159028862,
-0.0123804621,
0.0009227224,
-0.0559366122,
-0.0028188846,
-0.0162246507,
0.0632203668,
0.0604776628,
-0.0496689565,
0.0113033745,
0.022000568,
-0.0171713643,
0.0651676729,
-0.0583538339,
0.0008375663,
-0.0198914316,
0.0081433607,
-0.0439342409,
-0.0269732829,
0.0007578771,
0.0181182493,
0.0071538091,
0.0065703457,
0.0230047386,
-0.0276628342,
-0.0380958878,
0.0334960781,
-0.0124863964,
-0.0268366244,
0.0182279292,
-0.0124865165,
-0.0020360369,
0.0193507299,
-0.0111778062,
-0.0395585336,
0.0056751431,
-0.0455945209,
0.0252045281,
0.0691439137,
0.0034962834,
-0.023511555,
0.0044037113,
0.062751174,
-0.0002888895,
0.0328663513,
-0.0078751137,
0.0264340267,
-0.0257828385,
-0.0401797891,
-0.0090254759,
-0.0159625951,
-0.0026858177,
0.0006168703,
-0.0323236026,
-0.0165293906,
-0.017753534,
0.0022035423,
-0.0162219107,
-0.0235466287,
-0.0088022528,
-0.0178551096,
0.0008996282,
0.0347909704,
-0.0229223091,
0.0244554467,
-0.0310827196,
-0.0644596815,
0.0266828109,
0.0108752474,
-0.0302250385,
-0.0450811759,
-0.0392396934,
0.0044927169,
-0.0549714454,
-0.0153003884,
-0.0537600182,
0.0038486565,
-0.0289040674,
-0.0494204797,
-0.0174480937,
-0.0620186105,
-0.0551863983,
0.0244443342,
0.0416642129,
-0.0586614832,
-0.0272009447,
0.0185352825,
-0.0270237327,
0.0075023551,
0.0505291112,
0.0286639463,
0.0770947561,
0.0361535437,
-0.0014146148,
0.0723250732,
0.0412358567,
-0.0407003053,
0.0116472412,
-0.0530633964,
-0.0249447059,
0.0450782366,
0.0067787096,
0.0329518542,
-0.0722596198,
-0.0358663797,
0.0061550951,
-0.0014766607,
0.0520855859,
0.0622965991,
0.0199692044,
0.0005018126,
0.108289443,
0.0692633316,
-0.0243972074,
0.0371230543,
0.0389703363,
0.0602077842,
0.0652067512,
0.0639206022,
-0.0477198474,
-0.0379002355,
-0.0306601003,
-0.0048433929,
-0.0254137907,
0.0753972903,
-0.0116377734,
-0.0040741018,
-0.0117884632,
0.0503521897,
0.0304334089,
0.0156746414,
0.0001337168,
0.0186520983,
-0.0111400839,
0.0089808675,
0.0163065102,
-0.032360401,
-0.0034447704,
-0.030445205,
0.0205439031,
0.1001938209,
0.0287564993,
0.0039688693,
0.031491369,
-0.0012298506,
0.0232608207,
0.074104473,
0.030156469,
0.0179212168,
0.0000626993,
-0.0492211878,
0.0083334707,
0.0021559834,
0.0261363275,
0.023866199,
0.0066511407,
0.0551590472,
0.0083739059,
-0.0080463216,
-0.056067463,
0.0023810347,
-0.0611688718,
-0.0618763603,
-0.0455308408,
-0.0149348713,
0.00504441,
0.0391048193,
-0.0448775627,
-0.0263357479,
-0.0431398973,
-0.0089913448,
0.0320527293,
0.0457122661,
-0.1070190594,
-0.0051099304,
0.0258806031,
-0.0546321757,
-0.034705095,
-0.0074045402,
0.0301704407,
-0.0520805642,
0.0789932832,
-0.0181693751,
0.0519568287,
-0.0111923041,
-0.0284168329,
-0.0588848628,
-0.012369277,
-0.0432612412,
0.0046861302,
0.0037632261,
-0.0489831753,
0.0293126013,
0.0007541697,
-0.0154561829,
0.0281550754,
-0.0660295188,
0.0263991617,
0.0092020426,
0.0123547791,
-0.0171499643,
0.0131455446,
-0.0275198873,
-0.0243577547,
-0.0713390708,
-0.0445195027,
-0.0096327765,
-0.0084988428,
-0.0146412645,
-0.0303730592,
-0.0644329265,
0.0091272192,
-0.023446871,
-0.0177480243,
-0.0231938995,
0.0257050935,
-0.0178623404,
-0.0103455689,
-0.0446752608,
-0.0420188308,
-0.0361689851,
-0.0196476877,
0.0360746942,
0.0155160679,
-0.0224822015,
-0.0121998005,
-0.0057300581,
-0.0072390316,
-0.0210090913,
0.0024040896,
-0.0524450876,
0.0197181702,
0.0031601747,
0.1445840299,
0.0697198659,
0.0151289226,
-0.011187328,
0.0410910696,
-0.0471867733,
-0.0561129451,
-0.0258129034,
0.0318574011,
-0.0175518319,
-0.0035140731,
-0.0928828493,
-0.0311209969,
0.0689946786,
0.0604316257,
-0.0273121037,
-0.0618328564,
0.0441561081,
-0.0216271095,
-0.039367348,
-0.0049043428,
-0.0545127876,
-0.0293812305,
0.0157200545,
-0.0352913886,
-0.021125447,
0.050665915,
-0.0151128452,
-0.0086539462,
0.0052543236,
0.0089996373,
-0.0077472627,
-0.0235397499,
-0.0202400945,
0.0153685827,
-0.001864596,
-0.034576267,
-0.0243838169,
-0.0306895562,
0.0478737094,
-0.0227191467,
0.0533548407,
-0.064994812,
-0.0041669295,
0.0074974685,
-0.0112095531,
-0.0072674267,
0.0336727947,
-0.005224938,
-0.0137263369,
0.0362577997,
0.01401773,
-0.003941182,
0.0126132304,
0.0335329548,
0.0691766888,
-0.0697403848,
0.0126199881,
-0.0070049041,
-0.0341347158,
-0.0008478889,
-0.0138483765,
0.0132977655,
-0.0533944815,
0.0332755148,
0.0181952454,
-0.0142993359,
-0.0251132455,
0.0205066223,
0.0436429456,
0.0550014898,
0.0007570084,
-0.037788365,
-0.0008533816,
0.1135933399,
-0.0603185035,
0.002141522,
0.0876346529,
0.0063223084,
-0.0568519235,
-0.0354870036,
-0.0517698899,
0.0432475954,
-0.0054459963,
0.0176384393,
-0.055286739,
0.0145894317,
0.001466269,
0.043067079,
-0.002066623,
-0.0386325903,
0.0136677967,
-0.0725176036,
-0.0243140776,
0.0340942591,
-0.0666167587,
0.0063042282,
0.0290482976,
-0.0149125578,
0.050284896,
0.0415191576,
0.0059052329,
-0.0398417562,
0.0014675672,
0.0158099532,
-0.0259788521,
-0.0315398611,
-0.0001273985,
-0.0020350053,
0.0239210632,
-0.0107245333,
0.0073695024,
-0.0202319697,
-0.032648623,
0.0216772445,
-0.0185128376,
-0.0117827328,
-0.0220221505,
-0.0145707531,
0.0255190227,
-0.0051070759,
-0.0489390716,
0.0080919741,
0.0246954728,
0.0277622193,
0.0108115962,
0.0385122485,
0.0445831493,
-0.0081015602,
-0.0519545823,
0.029800972,
-0.0040241499,
0.0550384484,
0.070161052,
-0.0320742354,
-0.0223821886,
-0.0876725763,
0.0219815485,
-0.0072549167,
-0.0789713711,
0.0116592823,
-0.0227587633,
-0.0189869516,
-0.0352889635,
-0.0481474102,
0.0249134898,
0.0167019572,
0.031581156,
-0.028494468,
0.0318011232,
-0.0328202508,
-0.0354533158,
-0.0047457912,
-0.0170977321,
0.0284238122,
-0.0377232507,
-0.033089634,
-0.0016833079,
-0.0290677845,
0.0217974149,
0.0253263954,
-0.0025418419,
-0.0711490065,
0.0550139062,
0.0629819632,
0.0183754954,
-0.001255439,
0.0588623509,
-0.0804428607,
0.0352439992,
0.006674319,
0.0448729359,
0.0366986357,
-0.0154338451,
0.0043614339,
0.0349976458,
0.01457603,
0.0293437745,
0.0567099936,
0.0283735842,
0.0050375867,
-0.010373571,
-0.0001904915,
-0.0061959797,
0.0189430304,
0.0193917286,
-0.0535142347,
0.0058459379,
-0.0438522063,
-0.0312370267,
-0.066494301,
0.0042450018,
-0.0118676964,
-0.0285647549,
0.0297363512,
0.0025171249,
-0.0232459046,
0.0204121005,
-0.0263933036,
0.0700324625,
-0.0422299318,
0.0653053075,
-0.0213248637,
0.0621896498,
0.0118542751,
0.0355663225,
-0.0402655713,
0.0419244058,
-0.0132361157,
0.0580553375,
0.0375318602,
0.0743260905,
0.0114575578,
-0.0097006848,
0.0166255496,
-0.0214051325,
0.0035734479,
-0.0253216717,
0.0046285354,
0.023266932,
0.0119433142,
-0.0350176618,
0.0722062364,
0.0028492848,
0.0142420996,
-0.0197560955,
0.0120345484,
0.0263906419,
-0.015306538,
0.0319213159,
0.0064317915,
0.0303855482,
-0.0360685885,
0.0412802659,
0.0165071543,
0.0120419785,
0.0007679827,
-0.0456736162,
-0.0106342537,
-0.0102559049,
0.0378911719,
0.0351047851,
0.0145548452,
0.0042738477,
-0.0917580202,
-0.0539702773,
-0.0042317631,
0.0076891701,
0.017912969,
-0.0355741307,
-0.0087841777,
0.0325504243,
0.0001292871,
-0.0518281907,
-0.0151464324,
0.0050669662,
-0.0043882197,
-0.0119141005,
0.0242173187,
-7.503830637e-33,
-0.0550610833,
-0.0390867293,
0.0263629481,
0.00895797,
-0.0238908026,
-0.0400499664,
-0.0606283471,
0.0230845492,
-0.0041236617,
0.014352601,
-0.0036890234,
-0.0000722414,
0.0069403313,
0.0138760135,
0.0195762664,
0.0827500448,
0.0502458923,
0.0194330309,
-0.0267692823,
-0.0092409169,
0.0492852926,
-0.0121265464,
0.0674723387,
-0.0542950444,
0.0201292429,
-0.0276731551,
-0.0147725977,
-0.0410046838,
-0.0142793553,
0.0048890617,
-0.0200330932,
0.0757761821,
0.0061661713,
0.0059549552,
-0.0232680794,
0.0562911145,
-0.0271892585,
-0.0564520061,
0.0315401219,
0.0290974956,
0.0663333759,
-0.0452328436,
0.048612792,
-0.0003238263,
-0.0487284772,
-0.0060507427,
0.0517988242,
-0.0298770163,
0.0079805907,
0.022592308,
-0.0938916653,
0.0076812822,
-0.0138470978,
0.0168097019,
0.0077493214,
0.0083218012,
-0.0141306482,
-0.0004972081,
-0.0578631945,
0.0293502025,
0.0188962352,
-0.0054397411,
0.0563162044,
0.0427201577,
0.0213538408,
0.0108247595,
0.0252703372,
0.0700237527,
0.0045824852,
-0.0434034504,
0.0828040466,
-0.0827940553,
-0.0255378354,
0.06214853,
-0.0009851732,
-0.0396134518,
0.0265540928,
-0.0132598374,
0.054562591,
0.0084736301,
0.0057026492,
0.0066122469,
-0.0899930894,
-0.0741497129,
-0.0240715053,
-0.016764624,
0.0077210409,
-0.0159840938,
0.0206738003,
-0.0407931767,
-0.0237142872,
0.0265470836,
0.0168415885,
-0.0187426563,
-0.0451757535,
-0.015878018,
-0.0669429973,
0.0113678947,
-0.005556725,
0.0033251434,
-0.0839259773,
0.0246500354,
0.009615019,
0.0277762506,
-0.0123241795,
0.0467138924,
-0.0016995131,
0.0037279341,
-0.0805791393,
-0.0015967846,
-0.007623144,
0.0117370812,
0.0302217286,
-0.0325816758,
0.0355938934,
0.0185849704,
0.0081280498,
0.0201974344,
0.0512731075,
-0.0553166084,
-0.0320100263,
-0.0409854837,
-0.029115662,
0.0107773086,
-0.0394716449,
-0.0219219662,
-0.0345406085,
-0.0046284185,
0.0219472069,
-0.061684344,
0.0029042386,
-0.0176405404,
3.185e-7,
-0.0275768265,
0.0819529667,
0.0097977119,
0.022308778,
0.0468228161,
-0.0067832568,
0.0012530915,
0.0166609753,
0.0402533412,
-0.0073935208,
-0.0152457142,
0.0512698591,
0.0424839929,
0.0338393301,
-0.0577295497,
0.0193767361,
-0.055122681,
0.0326348357,
-0.0560250431,
-0.0020314474,
0.0244419593,
-0.0123033775,
-0.0027319209,
-0.0087696658,
-0.0242292471,
-0.0196492895,
0.0361734182,
-0.0188914482,
0.0152310459,
0.0173251778,
0.0161980987,
-0.0044387351,
0.0013796262,
0.0112422351,
0.0110069327,
0.0054382719,
-0.0051298635,
0.0705941096,
0.0058481493,
0.0763093829,
0.0284961723,
0.0345578007,
-0.0399329402,
-0.0639128014,
0.0339734666,
0.0282584131,
-0.0115369232,
0.034058135,
-0.0494460054,
-0.0241819061,
0.0196454916,
-0.0180754438,
-0.0466493405,
0.0207246467,
-0.0036821999,
-0.0376435742,
0.0300486013,
-0.0258115269,
-0.0013400714,
0.0156093584,
-0.0160894394,
-0.0244961176,
-0.0372916237,
-0.0084742373,
-0.0391691476,
0.0032852304,
0.0393201523,
2.777255784e-34,
0.0378185846,
-0.0142623605,
0.0759437457,
-0.0061049056,
-0.001032707,
0.0057304767,
0.0152355703,
0.0133920442,
0.0544110611,
-0.0510492809,
0.0039531495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12673v1 | Estimating Knowledge in Large Language Models Without Generating a Single Token | 2024-06-18T14:45:50 | 2024-06-18T14:45:50 | Daniela Gottesman, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | To evaluate knowledge in large language models (LLMs), current methods query
the model and then evaluate its generated responses. In this work, we ask
whether evaluation can be done $\textit{before}$ the model has generated any
text. Concretely, is it possible to estimate how knowledgeable a model is about
a certain entity, only from its internal computation? We study this question
with two tasks: given a subject entity, the goal is to predict (a) the ability
of the model to answer common questions about the entity, and (b) the
factuality of responses generated by the model about the entity. Experiments
with a variety of LLMs show that KEEN, a simple probe trained over internal
subject representations, succeeds at both tasks - strongly correlating with
both the QA accuracy of the model per-subject and FActScore, a recent
factuality metric in open-ended generation. Moreover, KEEN naturally aligns
with the model's hedging behavior and faithfully reflects changes in the
model's knowledge after fine-tuning. Lastly, we show a more interpretable yet
equally performant variant of KEEN, which highlights a small set of tokens that
correlates with the model's lack of knowledge. Being simple and lightweight,
KEEN can be leveraged to identify gaps and clusters of entity knowledge in
LLMs, and guide decisions such as augmenting queries with retrieval. | [
0.0258185118,
0.064018324,
-0.0122979153,
0.0516115129,
-0.0226666126,
0.0142946504,
-0.0120678265,
0.0001383724,
0.0068769599,
-0.0542856455,
-0.002365551,
-0.0602750927,
-0.0253116991,
0.0443181992,
0.0445835963,
0.0335513912,
0.0328500345,
-0.0148594379,
0.0306576584,
-0.0190628227,
-0.0186777283,
0.0030820512,
-0.0062068244,
0.0472402647,
-0.0168034174,
-0.0123381587,
-0.0418716259,
-0.0047427532,
0.0006619561,
-0.0132631874,
0.0082399752,
0.0467563942,
0.0055641774,
0.0462052897,
0.000001878,
-0.0434702747,
-0.0270831287,
-0.0027263786,
-0.0382043347,
-0.0017890612,
0.0112924259,
-0.0123014785,
0.0359057225,
0.0046558273,
-0.0673355311,
-0.0045530214,
0.0289938934,
0.0420309566,
0.0384823158,
0.0709732622,
0.017245898,
0.0201182384,
0.0070423884,
-0.0283737443,
0.0039721001,
-0.0417838208,
0.0198725536,
-0.0351536684,
-0.0322993584,
0.0438089892,
-0.0174690243,
0.0244032983,
0.040820878,
0.0009601201,
0.0261931717,
0.0494094789,
-0.0092485389,
-0.0135750333,
0.0151741439,
0.0516269356,
0.0403702073,
0.0069988333,
0.0255634598,
-0.0027931938,
0.0161142778,
0.0143657047,
-0.0181813836,
0.0284612644,
0.0145713789,
0.010646292,
0.0196099877,
-0.0069334777,
0.0224235803,
0.0082214354,
-0.0257409718,
0.0555062145,
0.0228890963,
-0.0239080135,
-0.0063768895,
0.0297172088,
-0.0059340387,
-0.0864654109,
-0.0346997939,
0.0541996099,
-0.0379634425,
0.0404767171,
-0.0338079743,
0.0019251306,
0.0325757824,
-0.0201407466,
0.0038465804,
0.0434350297,
-0.0125927627,
0.0353435241,
-0.0350331701,
0.0383973904,
0.0080367113,
0.0257561039,
-0.0219737161,
-0.005140916,
-0.019251151,
-0.0325595923,
-0.0091621112,
0.049762439,
-0.0415113382,
-0.0116653312,
-0.037064027,
-0.003683741,
-0.0023086076,
0.0203916747,
-0.0322891846,
0.0363974534,
-0.0443571545,
-0.0002014204,
-0.0778340325,
0.0222723149,
-0.059883222,
0.0089103635,
0.0291917678,
-0.0642975569,
-0.016834883,
-0.0166930389,
0.0016279903,
-0.0295109674,
-0.0019942967,
0.0257704481,
-0.0063424143,
-0.0323845297,
-0.0453196764,
-0.0875903144,
-0.0163891856,
-0.0950238109,
0.0263514053,
-0.0643273145,
0.0253810119,
0.0344157368,
-0.0171059314,
-0.0383594111,
0.0217872802,
0.0177523661,
-0.0110640731,
0.0419357903,
0.0121104755,
0.0107736671,
-0.0117486911,
0.0185192153,
0.03281473,
0.1040950418,
-0.0114020202,
0.0279102344,
0.0439221635,
0.0269170217,
-0.0508931316,
0.0181229711,
0.0730804279,
0.0116918981,
-0.0161715597,
0.0315433927,
0.0078112688,
0.0050954148,
0.0169953555,
0.0378861278,
-0.0282066967,
-0.0331506953,
0.0557334013,
0.0342500806,
0.0152598498,
0.0032899906,
0.0756795704,
0.0177834444,
0.0136706335,
0.0328828767,
-0.0368158966,
0.0394059829,
-0.0291376431,
-0.0069252243,
0.0418322049,
0.0170012042,
-0.02747068,
-0.0449806862,
0.0106750196,
0.0050008586,
-0.0175028741,
0.0195694026,
0.034170758,
0.0195822716,
-0.0094262175,
0.07105425,
0.0313166343,
-0.0455744192,
0.0146488314,
-0.0751528367,
0.0693626553,
0.0201835278,
0.0418136828,
-0.0168830939,
-0.0487461537,
0.0195184983,
-0.0288748257,
0.052495122,
0.0629836917,
-0.0217709467,
0.0200403035,
-0.0079878056,
-0.0073981551,
-0.0297544692,
0.050874427,
-0.006708954,
0.0120893875,
0.0181731991,
0.0345062539,
-0.0725962669,
0.017476337,
0.040815644,
-0.0386183336,
-0.0448491722,
0.0028672218,
0.0207484309,
0.0281398445,
0.0099767148,
0.0239010397,
0.0381200351,
0.0349140801,
-0.0166130979,
-0.0351931974,
-0.0189464949,
0.0031762652,
-0.0370843783,
0.0299098287,
0.0012899628,
-0.0141340895,
0.0039360146,
-0.0163425058,
-0.0394969657,
0.0219087545,
-0.0401513427,
0.0416096672,
-0.0588067509,
-0.0248733815,
0.0090864478,
0.000254898,
-0.0261154119,
0.091337271,
-0.0125460532,
0.0357157663,
0.0176112819,
-0.01468419,
0.0055368231,
-0.0414596237,
-0.0385484397,
-0.0239738431,
0.0116257397,
-0.0026441356,
0.0440204963,
0.001994743,
-0.0609005019,
-0.03079357,
-0.1228828877,
0.0174346343,
-0.0334856547,
0.0161619522,
0.0240328014,
-0.0060033803,
0.005219325,
0.0011663251,
-0.0627964437,
-0.0237240512,
0.0196430236,
0.0316789784,
0.0508297011,
0.0353858098,
0.013050721,
-0.0197439231,
0.0146564813,
-0.0217753164,
0.057489574,
0.0258253943,
0.0366883501,
-0.0395206511,
0.0198388789,
-0.0863610432,
0.0069399835,
-0.0051702787,
-0.0351843946,
0.0291228965,
-0.0130346939,
0.0591439828,
0.0676744357,
0.0345508605,
0.0495860949,
0.0416338556,
-0.024167398,
-0.0600549541,
0.0171465185,
-0.0517227277,
-0.0028300739,
-0.0288623795,
-0.0321251303,
0.012245669,
0.0613406673,
0.0036127602,
-0.0385511592,
-0.0682892725,
0.0719896555,
-0.0250387806,
-0.0622482263,
-0.0517073572,
0.060744565,
0.0091892397,
0.0670512244,
-0.0133757088,
-0.0384868942,
0.0838249996,
-0.0290675573,
0.0052594366,
0.009694377,
0.0106874984,
-0.0366138406,
0.0843287185,
0.0019308284,
0.0230335612,
-0.0081038633,
0.0074399738,
-0.0673374757,
0.0406099148,
-0.0131424721,
-0.0443461835,
0.0323939398,
-0.0412238576,
0.0136577152,
0.0148910265,
-0.0249446947,
-0.0599867441,
-0.0543371513,
-0.0060269102,
-0.0017408993,
-0.0123362793,
-0.0375240333,
-0.0070639951,
-0.0298742726,
0.0278836917,
-0.0227605607,
-0.0400333665,
-0.0090619046,
-0.0255488008,
0.0210470837,
0.0794927999,
0.0224643126,
0.0386469625,
-0.0728344023,
0.0226161182,
0.0619478524,
0.0022233303,
0.0001555168,
-0.0076943273,
-0.0198065266,
0.0103734806,
-0.0063873413,
-0.00653509,
0.0341589339,
0.0701515824,
-0.0519838408,
-0.0484869257,
0.120954521,
0.0292353872,
0.0081953043,
0.0041468395,
-0.0142443366,
0.0329740159,
0.017523868,
0.0332088321,
-0.0640580952,
-0.0060881902,
0.0010711348,
0.0306334551,
-0.0361194238,
-0.0657264367,
-0.0266929623,
-0.1452768594,
0.0393426642,
-0.0424120687,
-0.0365295783,
-0.0344624519,
-0.0024264378,
0.0025993115,
0.0131248208,
0.0102255493,
0.0209326018,
0.0112061733,
0.0308470521,
-0.0037200411,
0.0168219861,
-0.0182666499,
0.038705986,
-0.0263182893,
0.0561953038,
0.0300215371,
0.0543082841,
0.0281403158,
-0.0269547328,
-0.0348716229,
-0.0220998731,
-0.0112066371,
0.0187016111,
0.0728884712,
-0.0087823244,
-0.0235709138,
-0.0164636578,
0.0355328694,
-0.0016135781,
0.0117001282,
0.0003139708,
0.0269442052,
-0.0171721689,
-0.0042874729,
-0.0077003813,
0.0157482717,
0.0067595341,
0.0995689481,
0.070357278,
-0.0317848586,
-0.0191052835,
-0.0278512388,
0.0285391305,
-0.0381872132,
-0.0464957468,
0.0165633578,
0.0137087805,
0.0028455963,
-0.0893061534,
-0.0424574241,
0.027668966,
0.0444420874,
-0.0108104758,
-0.016155934,
0.0414987132,
-0.0399247743,
-0.0524640605,
0.044636324,
-0.054336518,
-0.0057041454,
-0.0444570668,
-0.0143798264,
0.0229192208,
-0.0428223498,
-0.0417216122,
-0.0017213542,
-0.0831354037,
-0.0622627027,
0.0001893664,
0.0433587879,
0.0253744479,
0.0195093136,
-0.0398276933,
-0.0372995362,
0.0279426537,
0.0340775736,
-0.1032421142,
0.0328731015,
-0.0052843797,
0.0058737602,
-0.01506148,
0.0690416843,
-0.0566296615,
0.0081472509,
0.0199686717,
0.0488867201,
-0.0053922548,
-0.047479108,
0.0405544639,
0.0353468731,
0.0383190289,
0.0159868095,
-0.0078864433,
-0.0339756235,
-0.0174297635,
-0.0375531577,
-0.0315419324,
-0.0555394366,
-0.0049149361,
-0.0068794596,
0.0189861301,
-0.0112805776,
-0.0311103929,
-0.0022663381,
0.0766973794,
-0.0235343687,
-0.040379677,
-0.0093853651,
-0.0086416779,
0.0476242527,
-0.0092380438,
-0.0068553737,
0.0215862263,
-0.0118643632,
0.0464687347,
-0.0089902626,
0.0467153303,
0.0275281761,
0.0148279164,
-0.0017913348,
-0.0015493758,
-0.0714594126,
-0.047762394,
0.0058641718,
0.0540989861,
0.0059690871,
-0.0068412325,
0.0224382896,
-0.0370768756,
-0.0043558129,
-0.0065853461,
0.0170529298,
0.00405504,
-0.0533239394,
0.0455922522,
0.0206519011,
-0.0249569844,
-0.0237690955,
0.0881468058,
-0.0030199988,
0.0628748611,
-0.018810736,
-0.0089379558,
-0.0531108044,
-0.0342466272,
0.0179026369,
0.0035532215,
-0.0052173515,
0.0592273846,
-0.1050483063,
-0.0891017169,
0.0018886036,
0.0227694102,
-0.0254698247,
-0.0150535032,
0.0285277236,
0.0650759488,
-0.0044933981,
-0.009553873,
-0.0639453158,
0.0307259262,
-0.0417001322,
-0.005059035,
-0.0100666108,
-6.806902077e-33,
-0.065782696,
-0.0602091774,
0.0297259279,
-0.0376288891,
-0.0114340363,
0.038724333,
-0.0418756232,
0.0117921485,
0.0027135022,
0.0175640583,
-0.0077678319,
0.0218673125,
-0.0007797811,
0.0223585311,
-0.0041098739,
-0.032944236,
0.0406312644,
-0.0249193851,
-0.041358307,
0.0278882757,
0.0650587678,
0.0146814995,
0.0265785754,
-0.0216112081,
0.0555832721,
-0.0108121019,
-0.0006314447,
0.0523368269,
-0.043242,
0.0530682355,
-0.0288318824,
0.0166862421,
0.0134244747,
-0.0341780819,
-0.0072412598,
-0.0066962456,
-0.0454993136,
-0.0481404737,
0.0154244332,
-0.0191667899,
-0.0298734363,
-0.0367794447,
0.0388339087,
-0.0041383347,
0.000925327,
-0.007067726,
0.0283744447,
0.0082541285,
0.0241938997,
-0.0397269838,
-0.0518216267,
0.0174856745,
-0.0049991352,
-0.0185558554,
-0.0177439842,
0.0333608575,
0.0287844129,
-0.0051623848,
-0.0312949717,
0.0210235827,
0.004260398,
0.0288704708,
0.0288954452,
-0.0017098626,
-0.0020808922,
0.0814373866,
0.0014782915,
0.0088582197,
-0.0425603949,
0.0234869141,
0.0460211448,
0.0408668146,
0.0241312198,
0.0680361316,
0.0160010383,
0.0087579414,
-0.0645677,
0.0254497416,
0.0066954605,
0.0124782072,
0.0350197889,
-0.0516660623,
-0.0304452553,
-0.0100684082,
-0.0583844371,
0.0178378858,
-0.0501651987,
-0.0015959778,
0.0431115031,
0.0232411344,
-0.0406475551,
-0.0508722663,
0.0209657606,
-0.0367719643,
0.0148330629,
0.0111563317,
-0.0182052776,
-0.0140766073,
0.0005769145,
0.0403307639,
-0.0572786704,
-0.0106508937,
0.0268437359,
-0.0091625452,
-0.0162138138,
0.009788448,
-0.0068652248,
0.0065677529,
-0.0501526296,
0.0073364,
-0.0356588215,
0.0422042198,
-0.0184284337,
-0.0175719131,
0.0336765647,
-0.0002527004,
-0.0390487984,
0.006976245,
-0.0005385861,
0.0165253673,
-0.0349341296,
-0.0173431858,
0.0273654386,
0.0160921887,
-0.0314333029,
-0.0196930207,
-0.0170885827,
0.0036579648,
0.0273364279,
-0.0131572392,
-0.0038578494,
0.017030526,
2.694e-7,
0.0454267785,
0.0275082923,
0.0018944407,
0.0489612892,
0.0011262973,
0.0498163663,
-0.0209621359,
0.0231670644,
0.0198108032,
-0.0478007346,
-0.0172969829,
0.0462759621,
0.0354932025,
0.0526274629,
-0.0878048465,
0.0148050142,
-0.0438639075,
-0.0169615764,
-0.0332866535,
-0.0360784717,
0.0220329259,
0.065806672,
0.0192099977,
-0.0047587748,
0.0058906386,
-0.0507489815,
0.0913357511,
0.0043234662,
-0.0545523465,
0.016070256,
0.0540151708,
0.0282962266,
0.0345584415,
0.0219118092,
-0.00188968,
0.0362734534,
-0.0029673066,
0.0503971986,
0.0549988635,
-0.0379298925,
-0.0137306806,
-0.018532604,
0.0112745771,
-0.0575139821,
0.0625208467,
-0.0586885028,
-0.0413706414,
-0.029283775,
0.008546168,
-0.0073595112,
0.0060706106,
-0.0170410629,
-0.0266175307,
0.0310681108,
0.0029069558,
-0.0199394114,
0.0317145362,
-0.0607626364,
-0.0379866213,
-0.0319364332,
-0.043637272,
-0.0850639865,
-0.0412892438,
0.0018665765,
-0.0066339443,
-0.0863766149,
0.0089280792,
2.633018495e-34,
0.0381298363,
0.0140281748,
-0.016467426,
0.0036226867,
0.0491851382,
-0.0238213651,
-0.0147701604,
-0.0064877234,
0.0266802348,
-0.074252449,
-0.0215373989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12665v1 | CollabStory: Multi-LLM Collaborative Story Generation and Authorship Analysis | 2024-06-18T14:35:12 | 2024-06-18T14:35:12 | Saranya Venkatraman, Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rise of unifying frameworks that enable seamless interoperability of
Large Language Models (LLMs) has made LLM-LLM collaboration for open-ended
tasks a possibility. Despite this, there have not been efforts to explore such
collaborative writing. We take the next step beyond human-LLM collaboration to
explore this multi-LLM scenario by generating the first exclusively
LLM-generated collaborative stories dataset called CollabStory. We focus on
single-author ($N=1$) to multi-author (up to $N=5$) scenarios, where multiple
LLMs co-author stories. We generate over 32k stories using open-source
instruction-tuned LLMs. Further, we take inspiration from the PAN tasks that
have set the standard for human-human multi-author writing tasks and analysis.
We extend their authorship-related tasks for multi-LLM settings and present
baselines for LLM-LLM collaboration. We find that current baselines are not
able to handle this emerging scenario. Thus, CollabStory is a resource that
could help propel an understanding as well as the development of techniques to
discern the use of multiple LLMs. This is crucial to study in the context of
writing tasks since LLM-LLM collaboration could potentially overwhelm ongoing
challenges related to plagiarism detection, credit assignment, maintaining
academic integrity in educational settings, and addressing copyright
infringement concerns. We make our dataset and code available at
\texttt{\url{https://github.com/saranya-venkatraman/multi_llm_story_writing}}. | [
0.0544124618,
0.0419301018,
-0.0200808719,
0.0416479409,
-0.0860676542,
-0.0088079218,
0.0918099433,
-0.0275818128,
0.0100407479,
-0.0250847619,
-0.0375121534,
-0.0204524845,
-0.0044927122,
0.0306635872,
0.0164125152,
0.0275004897,
-0.0070118965,
-0.004531539,
0.0135528957,
-0.0227790885,
0.007155871,
0.059609957,
0.0194771178,
0.0530572757,
-0.0053646723,
-0.0621404536,
0.0053272685,
0.0093928277,
0.0295471549,
0.0308306552,
0.0274056029,
0.075661391,
0.019246364,
0.0651553571,
0.0000019565,
-0.0577173196,
-0.0245423671,
-0.0083802501,
0.0448938385,
0.0037041793,
0.0372370593,
0.0415972471,
-0.0056285756,
-0.0067623989,
-0.0346494392,
0.0249692947,
0.007222597,
0.0208354611,
0.0581226349,
0.0769266561,
-0.0023130679,
-0.0297619253,
0.016539732,
0.0045599747,
0.0001955852,
0.0266223159,
0.0047556227,
-0.0055888318,
0.0361330546,
0.0004721243,
0.0177318137,
0.0173428673,
0.0215731058,
-0.0388664193,
0.0057235323,
0.0071060536,
-0.0201113056,
0.0116377939,
0.0219446309,
0.0144171296,
0.0169967003,
-0.0419186056,
0.0322447196,
0.0084500546,
-0.0160377547,
0.0360633023,
-0.029967539,
0.07563214,
-0.0430943929,
0.0058213202,
0.0210119616,
-0.0205659401,
0.0018361122,
0.0283518471,
0.0600045398,
0.0425636694,
0.0168864485,
0.0054820841,
-0.0666293576,
0.0139676649,
0.010398021,
-0.0673188716,
0.0516039431,
0.0275996998,
-0.0157751441,
-0.0164790675,
-0.0677632838,
-0.0477538407,
0.0378304161,
-0.0396605134,
0.0864299163,
-0.0095891301,
0.0140412757,
0.0167855583,
-0.0161341634,
0.0444702767,
-0.0064709429,
0.0194110125,
0.0007618158,
0.0031716859,
-0.0619948953,
0.0088922847,
-0.0088650743,
0.0415721573,
-0.0073139896,
0.0154302428,
-0.0307551678,
0.0202491209,
0.0027276711,
0.0282206442,
-0.0106137106,
0.0212237388,
-0.0392857082,
0.0055696913,
0.0322154239,
-0.0139207635,
0.0010700806,
0.012249656,
0.0036264218,
-0.0102320826,
0.0159048382,
0.017591875,
0.0091443928,
-0.0358506888,
0.0258331597,
0.0310972296,
0.0062570334,
-0.0168986768,
-0.000737279,
-0.0985919684,
0.0295688007,
-0.0676651895,
-0.0305453259,
-0.1053904593,
0.0430802181,
0.021769749,
0.0034364911,
-0.0933983624,
-0.0129816979,
0.0241497476,
-0.0247865375,
-0.0037346613,
0.0013825725,
0.0206903275,
0.0494896248,
0.0196476616,
-0.0385368578,
-0.0016120701,
0.0647467002,
0.0322200991,
0.0430678837,
0.0154668707,
0.04099112,
0.0267621111,
-0.0164040923,
0.015540272,
0.0248267557,
-0.0111392085,
0.0306960139,
0.0478499718,
0.0049166167,
0.0773691982,
-0.0102281198,
-0.0168701243,
0.0954640508,
0.0643551052,
0.0260515381,
0.0205649287,
0.0679090619,
0.0090043582,
0.0177675057,
0.0299299583,
-0.0222073141,
0.0227142926,
0.0163449422,
-0.0215103328,
-0.01477932,
0.0515330546,
0.007198099,
0.0093797864,
-0.0055183265,
-0.0019688837,
-0.0725602731,
-0.0231726822,
-0.0052360287,
-0.0106800292,
-0.0208895691,
-0.0003950305,
-0.0099064736,
-0.1233842522,
0.0480716899,
0.0094812913,
0.0698034093,
0.0567801669,
0.0834513456,
0.0100528961,
-0.0058813365,
-0.0500095375,
0.0135732219,
0.0224675573,
0.0076408451,
-0.0277426019,
0.0106297974,
-0.021361975,
-0.0126930978,
-0.0371192843,
-0.0233667828,
0.0139403511,
0.0344850235,
-0.0106347715,
0.0225531999,
-0.0067579611,
-0.0674374029,
0.0376260839,
-0.0900045857,
0.0357976519,
-0.0154268323,
-0.000438882,
0.0166685246,
0.0309964009,
-0.0494697019,
-0.0115788039,
0.0311581735,
-0.0445002206,
-0.0535411164,
0.0366670564,
0.0158180799,
-0.0116316527,
0.0490555689,
-0.057525821,
0.0141136935,
-0.0112844072,
-0.0159822013,
-0.0419078283,
0.0374476165,
0.0037693402,
-0.0136463298,
-0.0425631814,
0.0172831286,
-0.016204631,
-0.0162023213,
-0.018082751,
0.0304805692,
-0.0023919849,
0.0490832888,
0.006308428,
-0.011413008,
0.0198949799,
-0.0044801491,
-0.0143891731,
0.014519576,
0.016737137,
0.0319693908,
0.0009133594,
-0.0126622263,
-0.0260679163,
-0.0651672706,
-0.0601015836,
0.0285228863,
0.0053025233,
0.0300402269,
0.0089177135,
-0.0169243962,
-0.0219877716,
0.0342746638,
-0.0323987752,
-0.0306432247,
0.0065491009,
-0.0120552387,
0.0233403686,
0.0004389379,
-0.0040638531,
-0.0253075454,
0.0149894226,
-0.0036663217,
0.0347758308,
0.0598841533,
-0.0038157974,
-0.0598641187,
0.0405406207,
-0.0278658308,
-0.0244738013,
0.0113828676,
0.013867096,
0.0030619155,
-0.0283543859,
0.043910712,
0.0342359245,
-0.0258375872,
-0.0095980186,
0.0459235571,
-0.0400794595,
-0.0369560085,
0.0037475559,
0.0171083473,
0.0090769939,
0.00137858,
-0.0684072822,
0.0181459263,
0.0424401127,
0.0063505801,
-0.0494286008,
-0.0142818969,
0.0087889414,
0.0037871769,
-0.0048428155,
0.0430481061,
-0.0296463687,
-0.0241532512,
-0.0024438279,
-0.0331287608,
-0.0584790744,
0.070133999,
-0.062228594,
-0.0016307312,
-0.0231462307,
-0.0211404245,
-0.068281576,
0.0933640674,
0.0029133412,
0.028352201,
-0.0143478429,
0.008451513,
-0.0455063395,
0.0237461757,
0.0472835302,
0.0010313559,
0.0134411622,
-0.0544161163,
-0.001916018,
-0.0272862334,
0.0056550535,
-0.0008891157,
-0.0384305827,
-0.0124859624,
0.0215445068,
0.0170367211,
-0.039469,
-0.0244646017,
-0.0533292592,
0.0206703804,
0.0512093492,
-0.0203035921,
0.0054895082,
-0.0394812636,
0.0203797333,
0.014797789,
-0.0247638505,
-0.0731647909,
-0.0505534261,
-0.0061432049,
0.0485752895,
0.0433444493,
0.0086753657,
0.0279911701,
-0.0201986358,
0.0453710631,
-0.0366786271,
-0.0527372174,
-0.0096809231,
0.0749240369,
-0.062604025,
-0.0101600932,
0.1210150421,
0.0152776642,
-0.0733913407,
-0.0240067746,
-0.0218703225,
-0.0020078586,
0.0104459384,
0.0274079796,
-0.0744473189,
0.004072574,
-0.00163888,
0.0059289248,
-0.0294695031,
-0.0693653971,
-0.031101279,
-0.0694321245,
0.027022345,
0.0052660885,
-0.0301413406,
0.0206964258,
-0.0277297534,
-0.0321617499,
0.0167701468,
-0.0202204101,
-0.0013865533,
-0.0174471755,
0.0177570935,
-0.0029831873,
0.0053038215,
-0.0172091592,
-0.0092502283,
-0.0990635306,
0.0536765791,
0.0390262716,
0.040195886,
-0.0082359035,
-0.0073818499,
-0.0353669077,
0.0182639863,
-0.0058674249,
-0.0240907203,
0.0315984488,
-0.0392275378,
0.0180291347,
-0.0119116893,
0.0687255561,
-0.0358695425,
-0.0253360085,
0.0478601381,
0.0687582418,
-0.0164926276,
-0.0263715275,
-0.0084817074,
0.0157821719,
0.0189113934,
0.064684622,
0.0315451771,
-0.0693262145,
-0.0380517356,
-0.022011796,
0.0013047731,
-0.0899075568,
0.0005498769,
-0.0242139176,
-0.0452414565,
0.0195726342,
-0.0599619746,
-0.0453725792,
0.0116564799,
0.0081706131,
0.0593562461,
0.026518032,
-0.0345162526,
-0.0509660654,
-0.0644048974,
-0.0203281567,
-0.0596154705,
0.0659482777,
-0.0507102944,
0.002898887,
0.0075510778,
-0.0120263137,
0.0236102175,
0.0214373469,
-0.1044549048,
-0.0692243427,
-0.0004398851,
0.0162699968,
0.0145679619,
0.0142088206,
0.0170497131,
-0.1007507816,
0.0150017766,
0.0009979139,
-0.0470055975,
0.0610074401,
-0.0001210672,
-0.0283315834,
-0.0280290693,
0.0347535312,
-0.0273861978,
-0.0061023203,
0.0444293022,
0.0089849355,
-0.011342952,
-0.0333583876,
-0.0088991662,
0.0039829509,
-0.005520741,
-0.0478128791,
0.0291571859,
-0.0697631314,
0.0114457887,
-0.0231146365,
-0.0331014469,
-0.0453585684,
0.0028485474,
0.0295471847,
-0.021744553,
0.0019529696,
0.0661995709,
-0.0275943801,
0.0433041938,
-0.0330623239,
0.0574228279,
0.0016926767,
0.047190804,
0.0196484346,
0.0089430315,
-0.0236664321,
0.0068769618,
-0.0451513492,
0.0366066098,
0.0117071848,
0.0344883315,
0.0162567701,
0.0299670454,
0.056348756,
0.0306795593,
-0.0704393759,
0.0043168557,
0.0013595584,
0.011788914,
0.0571716055,
0.0347744003,
0.0993899256,
-0.0299101193,
0.0120639345,
-0.0551261418,
0.0770667717,
-0.0173732545,
-0.0248150621,
-0.0626433045,
-0.0160214677,
-0.020386843,
0.0254817829,
0.1158190072,
0.0172485467,
0.0386137292,
-0.0014380045,
-0.0250548068,
-0.0015497896,
-0.0251791999,
0.0500072651,
-0.0063829916,
0.0119320946,
-0.0432685129,
-0.0679425523,
-0.0262372065,
0.0467362963,
0.0173745714,
0.0045845397,
-0.0436863527,
-0.0110557983,
0.0446375869,
0.0054926886,
0.0223384276,
-0.0700578913,
0.0468349457,
0.0100223096,
-0.0477446876,
0.0098672481,
-5.484495911e-33,
-0.0093000522,
-0.0798092633,
0.0090107974,
0.0598361865,
-0.0215066839,
0.0285489894,
-0.0309996344,
-0.0149232019,
0.0232023355,
0.0061057387,
-0.0241626166,
0.0124085983,
-0.0040480508,
0.0093723368,
0.0465289392,
0.0430297703,
0.0502770059,
-0.002346657,
-0.0345752351,
0.0292416252,
0.0325465314,
0.0382817127,
0.035234794,
-0.060952194,
0.0538499691,
-0.080453746,
-0.0200269129,
-0.0104972143,
-0.0316696018,
0.01062435,
0.0050824052,
0.0278043896,
0.0078179324,
-0.0153601421,
-0.0127384374,
-0.0308596194,
-0.0271801185,
-0.0193437021,
0.0335227549,
0.0116559211,
0.0059273578,
-0.0811995193,
0.0499179848,
-0.0282105468,
-0.0098228268,
-0.0153457224,
0.063521713,
0.0170984659,
-0.0119210044,
-0.0351830162,
-0.0487713814,
0.0055281017,
0.0040732529,
-0.0186319817,
0.0131630832,
0.008969482,
0.0097146109,
-0.0132650035,
-0.0470566414,
0.0419420563,
-0.0446886681,
0.0229731705,
0.0325841233,
0.0086189937,
-0.0174537059,
0.061205443,
0.0124946972,
0.0359227546,
-0.0157975648,
0.0313133188,
-0.0170271397,
0.0657860041,
0.0520285927,
0.0990856364,
-0.0466973931,
0.0110328104,
0.0091913668,
0.0627192929,
0.0501798987,
-0.0345652662,
0.0010701603,
-0.0057115396,
0.0001670572,
-0.0540436842,
-0.0198683385,
-0.0543148145,
-0.0090453485,
-0.0161250848,
0.0085268933,
-0.0260503571,
-0.0053307945,
0.0088484129,
0.0217362177,
-0.0470768884,
-0.0312765315,
0.0229788274,
-0.0314512886,
0.0401896015,
0.0050212438,
0.0307614636,
-0.051612664,
-0.0023390774,
0.0045398558,
-0.0072918483,
0.0420693122,
0.0215457026,
0.072604917,
0.057872586,
-0.0295523368,
-0.0008148644,
-0.0435823016,
0.0050143995,
-0.0010005101,
0.0149908438,
0.0002270967,
-0.0097929463,
0.0163931008,
-0.0024654146,
0.0366159007,
0.0125581222,
-0.0666819587,
-0.0229372196,
-0.0202497002,
-0.0076149106,
-0.0134869535,
0.0182588771,
-0.0206855908,
0.006864999,
0.0371690206,
-0.0206988323,
-0.010685768,
-0.0471959859,
2.652e-7,
0.0190800205,
-0.0075922506,
0.014579176,
-0.020576207,
0.0059114047,
0.0476838462,
-0.0267092716,
0.0616531707,
-0.0030679135,
-0.0058243959,
-0.008580138,
0.0082333675,
0.068320401,
0.0477056801,
-0.0823992565,
0.0127775054,
-0.0456042811,
-0.0023063237,
-0.0812082812,
-0.0082784062,
0.0307331216,
-0.0239312761,
0.0770644248,
-0.0382741727,
-0.0274798553,
-0.0528985038,
0.0443929434,
-0.0231792349,
-0.0349694677,
0.0377589986,
-0.0093324222,
-0.0403918251,
-0.0073785493,
-0.0271465499,
-0.0075839036,
0.0037885692,
-0.0030178921,
0.0574858896,
0.0124292821,
0.0097851241,
0.0339187756,
-0.0556539148,
-0.0379180424,
-0.0426958054,
0.0513702147,
0.0133445868,
-0.0032812939,
0.0001700995,
0.0227751229,
-0.0207205787,
-0.0064968676,
-0.019800039,
0.0120660048,
0.0212899093,
0.000019698,
-0.0175674856,
-0.0103880595,
-0.0205274895,
-0.0509128235,
-0.0039186822,
-0.0513679385,
-0.039006304,
-0.0094566913,
-0.0171663202,
0.0005949264,
-0.0851232335,
0.0375176631,
2.578672315e-34,
0.0116733238,
0.0001225283,
-0.0139644593,
0.0359773003,
0.0368568376,
0.0022558018,
-0.060667567,
0.0224286187,
-0.0290820543,
-0.0113769919,
-0.0332367569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12651v1 | Transforming Surgical Interventions with Embodied Intelligence for Ultrasound Robotics | 2024-06-18T14:22:16 | 2024-06-18T14:22:16 | Huan Xu, Jinlin Wu, Guanglin Cao, Zhen Chen, Zhen Lei, Hongbin Liu | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Ultrasonography has revolutionized non-invasive diagnostic methodologies,
significantly enhancing patient outcomes across various medical domains.
Despite its advancements, integrating ultrasound technology with robotic
systems for automated scans presents challenges, including limited command
understanding and dynamic execution capabilities. To address these challenges,
this paper introduces a novel Ultrasound Embodied Intelligence system that
synergistically combines ultrasound robots with large language models (LLMs)
and domain-specific knowledge augmentation, enhancing ultrasound robots'
intelligence and operational efficiency. Our approach employs a dual strategy:
firstly, integrating LLMs with ultrasound robots to interpret doctors' verbal
instructions into precise motion planning through a comprehensive understanding
of ultrasound domain knowledge, including APIs and operational manuals;
secondly, incorporating a dynamic execution mechanism, allowing for real-time
adjustments to scanning plans based on patient movements or procedural errors.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our system through extensive experiments,
including ablation studies and comparisons across various models, showcasing
significant improvements in executing medical procedures from verbal commands.
Our findings suggest that the proposed system improves the efficiency and
quality of ultrasound scans and paves the way for further advancements in
autonomous medical scanning technologies, with the potential to transform
non-invasive diagnostics and streamline medical workflows. | [
0.0485875383,
0.0712816641,
-0.0316313542,
-0.0488702692,
-0.0158178285,
0.0103322025,
0.0306723565,
0.0270141959,
-0.0505292006,
-0.0028321757,
-0.0348113328,
-0.0480367467,
-0.0056129596,
0.0939571112,
-0.0036974931,
-0.0714466423,
0.0062079276,
-0.0123100448,
-0.0127195409,
0.000441483,
-0.0503484719,
-0.0214552619,
-0.0675774589,
0.066447556,
-0.0395972282,
0.0468162224,
-0.0141495485,
0.0128800767,
0.0257956944,
-0.0628198534,
-0.0274313893,
0.0355359018,
0.0510148853,
0.0497171655,
0.0000019933,
-0.0486175865,
0.0083570769,
0.0222575627,
-0.0286804643,
-0.0281592067,
0.055619888,
-0.0328722298,
-0.0097589539,
0.0065265172,
-0.0211131331,
-0.030754365,
0.0232857335,
0.0203427393,
0.0439079814,
0.015326675,
-0.0146308178,
0.046862565,
0.0171509869,
0.0146952132,
-0.026230311,
-0.0343213156,
0.0122423265,
-0.028410133,
0.0850119442,
0.0056646285,
-0.0106397895,
0.0532839149,
0.0331197344,
-0.0305124298,
-0.0356715173,
0.0502869301,
0.0337482616,
-0.0405063964,
-0.0152553022,
0.0022525934,
0.0349981524,
0.0229523666,
0.0183113497,
0.0211733617,
-0.013796119,
-0.0101029072,
-0.0425882824,
-0.0181873627,
0.0323234983,
-0.0387938246,
-0.0559819825,
0.0010403168,
0.0193455033,
-0.0005108388,
-0.017928848,
0.0047989534,
0.0029808709,
0.0095375199,
0.0095230266,
-0.0299990736,
-0.0231594741,
-0.02013289,
0.0331544504,
0.0872185081,
-0.0505585857,
0.0214605387,
-0.0333782546,
-0.0475309156,
0.0197515078,
-0.0103659425,
-0.0026521517,
0.0023733927,
0.0060234615,
0.0308280326,
0.0009636458,
0.0684818327,
-0.0406813137,
0.0275980774,
-0.0360333212,
0.0269595981,
-0.048941277,
-0.0294382032,
-0.0064011971,
0.0277570412,
-0.0101155723,
-0.0466812737,
-0.0429825857,
-0.0007424026,
-0.0110889981,
0.021506656,
-0.0340411589,
0.0611006357,
0.0026660087,
0.0033216872,
-0.014360318,
-0.0073137633,
0.0150328865,
0.0602821186,
-0.0318274014,
0.0487236381,
0.0083351359,
0.0255334172,
-0.0032019627,
0.0414495803,
-0.0255058631,
0.0789837018,
0.0154010719,
-0.0080576241,
0.0652944669,
-0.0292120259,
-0.0008683222,
-0.0068709925,
0.0683321655,
-0.0526499897,
0.0079840729,
-0.0068427827,
0.0072143874,
-0.028992001,
0.0355449505,
0.0042131823,
0.0089022899,
0.0365933776,
-0.0418548547,
0.0270236135,
0.0094333133,
0.0176274888,
-0.0053817215,
0.0021838974,
0.0172068011,
-0.0496735647,
-0.0228464063,
-0.0044607618,
-0.0033662284,
0.0221316908,
-0.0540325902,
-0.0545356646,
0.0159916263,
-0.0327040888,
0.031441994,
0.0925110132,
-0.0249386448,
0.0646340325,
-0.007253177,
0.012988423,
0.0230954923,
0.0882421881,
-0.0758586079,
-0.0228025243,
0.0411949456,
-0.0497888997,
-0.0128591554,
-0.0278280601,
-0.0429045819,
0.0157014951,
0.0388561338,
-0.0043982835,
-0.0552968085,
-0.011089447,
-0.0256171338,
-0.0474861823,
-0.0575275049,
-0.022896722,
0.0248595811,
0.0025587722,
0.0792432353,
0.0008061693,
-0.0062773786,
0.0194040611,
0.0263463613,
0.0099262046,
-0.0414880216,
-0.0292201638,
-0.0294387545,
0.0474542081,
0.0468094982,
-0.0689186305,
-0.0711483806,
-0.0268531516,
0.0558127835,
0.068129845,
0.001566568,
-0.0252011511,
-0.0360933766,
0.0031765157,
-0.0147938253,
0.0523850992,
0.0239942856,
0.0111006042,
0.0211558044,
0.039008338,
-0.0165916923,
-0.0427801535,
-0.0223581921,
0.0487812646,
-0.0558480695,
-0.0268766154,
-0.0195204299,
0.0104693547,
0.001980192,
0.0306258071,
-0.0386059619,
-0.0131066265,
0.0295566358,
-0.0283042062,
-0.0380924083,
0.0336931422,
-0.0246868972,
0.0486795418,
0.0140693784,
-0.0252902862,
-0.0445724837,
0.0214078035,
-0.009075556,
-0.0267771725,
-0.0335281566,
-0.0370264202,
-0.0005084671,
0.0270360634,
0.0203980263,
0.0417856649,
-0.0491306745,
-0.0070377579,
-0.0338405259,
-0.0193098504,
0.0076485723,
0.0406307317,
0.0002064818,
0.0120881386,
0.0079844557,
-0.0137234358,
0.0555446446,
0.0001919034,
-0.010211057,
0.0123142572,
0.0462946482,
-0.0111656813,
-0.0271927286,
-0.0759986117,
-0.0394301601,
0.0467042029,
-0.0364290178,
0.021580169,
-0.005772383,
0.0044142837,
-0.0222295132,
0.0218537934,
0.0188993756,
0.012497698,
-0.0141364457,
0.0268817414,
0.0155900829,
-0.035743054,
-0.0132428901,
0.0182766747,
-0.039110586,
-0.0431447551,
0.061468225,
0.0359148942,
-0.00665029,
-0.005112207,
-0.0356368572,
0.0332581997,
-0.0032522529,
-0.0530429706,
0.0376057848,
-0.0391909592,
-0.0972326174,
0.0587506704,
-0.0576157719,
-0.0117498562,
0.0581326298,
0.0035139464,
-0.0186435226,
-0.0016368724,
-0.0026131992,
-0.0174181126,
-0.00694553,
-0.008670547,
0.0025897,
0.0670704618,
-0.003120898,
-0.003531877,
-0.0214246884,
-0.0226963032,
-0.050371442,
-0.0426982045,
-0.0438137427,
0.0061777942,
-0.0366766639,
0.0298824105,
-0.0220267046,
-0.0206738543,
0.0937108621,
0.0153471334,
0.0159829259,
-0.0134608289,
-0.0221251231,
-0.0161368642,
0.0629489571,
-0.0060928715,
0.0214848705,
0.0071101701,
-0.0419152826,
-0.0092668319,
0.0508414172,
-0.0548968278,
-0.055262506,
-0.0093509937,
-0.0625228137,
0.0078337053,
0.0292751193,
-0.0649230182,
-0.0498833172,
0.0568189286,
-0.0162228756,
0.0373350605,
-0.0033326505,
-0.0254737679,
-0.057674706,
0.0021352079,
0.0337281562,
0.0484546423,
0.0252209138,
0.0040280684,
-0.05961648,
-0.0088612922,
0.019645635,
0.0374430865,
-0.0682599992,
0.0176017378,
0.0390329622,
0.0249137431,
0.0186372027,
-0.0114935543,
-0.0570450723,
0.0061845384,
-0.0087005002,
-0.0003438604,
0.02047389,
0.0094562806,
0.0229913834,
-0.0095836706,
-0.0245976485,
0.085798718,
0.0292194337,
0.0467339978,
0.008680311,
-0.0047750757,
-0.0438245572,
0.012609113,
0.0179966763,
-0.0055752131,
-0.0193302184,
0.018545378,
0.0373413488,
0.0321992449,
-0.0146651193,
0.0349519849,
-0.0651052743,
0.0440220945,
-0.0067031542,
-0.0577879027,
-0.0991104692,
-0.0120768342,
0.0583389327,
-0.0117193805,
-0.0125679066,
0.0112876836,
0.0087768435,
-0.0278833918,
-0.0034060383,
-0.0227811877,
-0.0227417611,
0.02304429,
-0.0079706674,
-0.0194789674,
0.0929185599,
0.0622735955,
-0.0433198996,
0.0098609664,
-0.0019796465,
0.0484923013,
0.0133942673,
-0.0186734982,
0.0123302545,
0.0144700157,
0.0177481845,
-0.0286599137,
0.0603212602,
-0.0316971429,
-0.0147447959,
0.0002434837,
0.0730490014,
-0.0293579455,
-0.0238794442,
-0.0810044855,
-0.016112702,
0.0100361481,
0.0153659452,
-0.0257091708,
-0.0335787386,
-0.0362383462,
-0.0034978832,
-0.0129659018,
0.0940785483,
-0.0366507694,
-0.0078559555,
-0.0479120649,
-0.0139229316,
-0.0472276658,
-0.0166701246,
0.0628526211,
0.0412625074,
0.0763631314,
0.0197453443,
0.0623440631,
0.0002753019,
-0.0350925773,
-0.0210644267,
0.0118091162,
0.0092140054,
0.0139547465,
-0.0088390801,
0.0819009468,
-0.0106991176,
-0.0027756845,
0.0423341915,
0.0720496699,
-0.0122645963,
0.0178285167,
0.0587817021,
0.0230471417,
-0.004986072,
-0.057126388,
0.0227004234,
0.0761417598,
0.0271637123,
-0.0362777784,
0.0531424507,
0.0400655568,
0.0403366573,
-0.0191958323,
0.0065413392,
-0.0464511178,
0.0108024292,
-0.0102494275,
0.0258328132,
-0.0508348979,
-0.0523066558,
0.0119983694,
0.0540225208,
0.056289956,
-0.0204682238,
-0.0138857402,
-0.0111485375,
0.016235929,
-0.039843224,
0.0217235051,
-0.0207212064,
0.0446378849,
-0.0164746791,
-0.0044385558,
0.0321955867,
0.0022117994,
0.0196570717,
-0.0415738374,
0.0182045735,
0.0437304564,
-0.0012541775,
0.0055621732,
0.0159596223,
0.019268658,
0.023626158,
0.0060023344,
-0.0319854617,
0.0428656973,
0.0240438692,
0.0352690667,
0.0056653717,
-0.0014009427,
-0.0088382978,
0.0287429057,
-0.0449088998,
-0.0827566087,
0.0245163348,
0.0116536031,
0.0284987614,
-0.0065140999,
-0.0207572579,
-0.0870900825,
0.0035961773,
-0.0100957509,
-0.0105047664,
-0.0229672547,
0.0586831085,
0.0298915915,
0.0090490915,
0.0571189001,
0.0091711562,
0.0303345844,
-0.0732967705,
0.0797374919,
-0.0247569531,
-0.0416255891,
-0.0630838275,
-0.0175085273,
0.0402227938,
0.0579175614,
-0.0151272602,
0.0391403958,
-0.0192072224,
-0.0209227819,
-0.008152565,
0.0103683555,
-0.0181975812,
-0.0779796392,
0.1014839709,
-0.0087495977,
0.0011889061,
-0.0204355791,
0.0166222062,
-0.0112145096,
-0.0284346659,
-0.0194020476,
0.0017428286,
-4.993966894e-33,
-0.023824295,
-0.0273024179,
0.0406916477,
-0.0272282157,
-0.0199369118,
0.046845112,
-0.0301919412,
0.0072744754,
0.0077710995,
0.0124328993,
0.0018960008,
-0.0396873429,
-0.0118659819,
0.0194333326,
0.0229989011,
-0.0138901994,
0.0218928084,
-0.009437562,
-0.0029699861,
-0.0087838015,
0.0201670229,
0.019609496,
-0.0022180844,
-0.0819591731,
-0.0421229117,
0.0421488658,
0.0212433375,
0.0068749404,
-0.0172423609,
0.0070774998,
-0.0321237296,
0.0150725348,
-0.0082559129,
-0.0320165642,
-0.0206516273,
0.0294749439,
-0.0719611943,
-0.0396249704,
-0.02456972,
0.0094122263,
-0.0442710631,
-0.0415977389,
0.0612540133,
-0.0174549036,
-0.0329142325,
0.0012321882,
0.0239661224,
-0.0296492521,
0.0226497948,
-0.0311960317,
-0.0413432904,
0.0265388265,
-0.0166320018,
-0.0636895746,
0.0016734751,
0.013288442,
-0.0137744891,
-0.0272010956,
-0.0561173744,
0.0090070637,
0.0247884672,
-0.0091482839,
0.0411448218,
-0.0600412898,
0.039056018,
0.0898339003,
0.0528863072,
-0.0628601983,
-0.0290860571,
0.0383513197,
0.0021895021,
0.038263116,
0.0487237796,
-0.0161155481,
-0.0034615316,
0.0079618394,
-0.036557138,
0.0199517962,
-0.0990219265,
0.1015185639,
0.0599098243,
-0.0283030979,
-0.0775290504,
0.0370065197,
-0.0251251459,
-0.0295328312,
0.0212502182,
-0.039731238,
0.0304189548,
0.0073799733,
0.0229272246,
-0.0500346869,
0.0185724348,
-0.0049611847,
0.0277534947,
-0.0356702581,
0.0321013704,
0.0383821279,
-0.0439009555,
-0.0302640591,
-0.0019573965,
-0.0214209892,
0.0293117054,
-0.0015711973,
0.0624704659,
0.0168916117,
-0.0634561852,
0.0372091383,
-0.0141813522,
0.0146385571,
0.0135820219,
-0.0203250982,
0.0195157565,
-0.0717352331,
0.0817253366,
0.0168546457,
-0.00937194,
0.0079528773,
-0.0146030365,
-0.0209433362,
-0.0483824909,
-0.0221828036,
-0.0479286835,
-0.0095636342,
-0.0890054777,
-0.0636586174,
-0.0284249112,
0.0019931546,
-0.0123667335,
-0.0299488306,
-0.0156144165,
0.0323852785,
2.838e-7,
0.0042077093,
0.0399384908,
0.0258952454,
0.0213855188,
0.0207517855,
0.0203189589,
-0.0386637524,
0.0012017493,
-0.017858997,
-0.0380452387,
0.0374520794,
0.0460618995,
-0.0245884005,
-0.0246752538,
-0.0683681741,
-0.0379612893,
0.0332992673,
-0.0315800868,
-0.0358953178,
-0.006991961,
0.0532668047,
0.0331358016,
0.0094253374,
-0.0258236118,
-0.0131562343,
0.0044049597,
-0.0162478983,
-0.0238273386,
0.0770491883,
-0.0344263837,
0.0020461481,
-0.0044717542,
0.0108753256,
0.0072697611,
0.0175344516,
-0.0034388583,
0.0354915038,
0.0638398901,
-0.0574792512,
0.0229258109,
0.0267070234,
0.0324223265,
0.0007232891,
-0.0228103735,
0.0492628217,
-0.0567265116,
-0.0050853952,
0.0175664313,
0.0183923692,
-0.0218357723,
0.025933411,
-0.0160781555,
0.008858216,
0.0056227958,
-0.0101110525,
0.0184322894,
-0.0172100328,
-0.0444761887,
-0.0074554109,
0.0613746569,
-0.0368857346,
-0.0665941164,
0.0517428964,
0.0080539202,
-0.0485654995,
-0.0678605586,
-0.0082623148,
2.302154029e-34,
0.0317199193,
0.0235882103,
-0.0106355725,
0.0654931292,
0.0245395731,
0.0283537507,
-0.0266568903,
0.0366993248,
0.0782303959,
-0.0505469665,
0.0005818023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12645v1 | Evaluating Transparency of Machine Generated Fact Checking Explanations | 2024-06-18T14:13:13 | 2024-06-18T14:13:13 | Rui Xing, Timothy Baldwin, Jey Han Lau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An important factor when it comes to generating fact-checking explanations is
the selection of evidence: intuitively, high-quality explanations can only be
generated given the right evidence. In this work, we investigate the impact of
human-curated vs. machine-selected evidence for explanation generation using
large language models. To assess the quality of explanations, we focus on
transparency (whether an explanation cites sources properly) and utility
(whether an explanation is helpful in clarifying a claim). Surprisingly, we
found that large language models generate similar or higher quality
explanations using machine-selected evidence, suggesting carefully curated
evidence (by humans) may not be necessary. That said, even with the best model,
the generated explanations are not always faithful to the sources, suggesting
further room for improvement in explanation generation for fact-checking. | [
0.0286101848,
0.0229041148,
-0.0023364038,
0.0100987563,
-0.0394076928,
-0.0106397998,
0.0320878364,
-0.0382319726,
-0.0676044077,
-0.0451031066,
0.0529772192,
0.0121647492,
0.0290549155,
0.0339953192,
0.034804821,
-0.0493699647,
0.0123323454,
-0.0294595771,
0.0651720241,
-0.001625313,
-0.0083732074,
0.028318556,
-0.016276719,
0.0534250252,
0.0065166485,
0.0023406134,
-0.0202815793,
-0.0261238646,
0.0200193971,
-0.0076188897,
-0.0523640215,
0.0219672509,
0.0212400481,
0.0463980064,
0.0000017478,
-0.0100355465,
0.0179373287,
0.0366737656,
-0.0803341717,
0.0550370328,
-0.0138781713,
-0.0170704424,
0.0076181749,
0.0028532874,
0.024355825,
-0.0032706156,
0.0650164858,
0.0268884916,
0.06847395,
0.0487473048,
0.0226594117,
-0.0004985814,
-0.0160142612,
0.0014764493,
-0.0138420379,
-0.0143769318,
0.0296653938,
0.0230604336,
-0.0422169045,
0.047219716,
0.0402620248,
-0.0049814191,
0.0246002935,
-0.0585117526,
-0.0145306895,
0.0381987579,
-0.0279527195,
-0.0213194657,
0.0251743868,
0.0386620797,
0.0509204492,
-0.0319453292,
0.0109051876,
-0.028548982,
0.0031661079,
0.0495013557,
-0.0336261913,
0.0729696676,
-0.0247116704,
-0.0137387281,
0.0346546397,
-0.019560229,
0.0561312847,
0.0649561062,
0.0249967277,
0.0651095361,
-0.0242774822,
0.0016030127,
-0.0269968156,
-0.0005268477,
-0.0064457785,
-0.0964853317,
-0.0297349952,
0.0173421279,
-0.0436181985,
0.0085123247,
0.0018232716,
0.0155436648,
0.0315318815,
-0.0145312464,
0.0035316932,
0.0071609556,
-0.0569797605,
0.0612917319,
-0.0172094256,
0.0174038038,
-0.0262416992,
-0.0138470931,
0.0160163734,
-0.018624397,
-0.0118101463,
0.0093891071,
0.0191524178,
-0.0113380756,
-0.0323544219,
0.0155705484,
-0.0105793085,
-0.0322166942,
-0.0354395099,
0.014970826,
0.0029869403,
0.0069410061,
-0.0137937255,
-0.0313043669,
-0.0776036307,
0.0223620161,
-0.0722378716,
0.0237128083,
0.0388122797,
-0.0469489582,
-0.0324224606,
0.0143159423,
-0.0082091326,
0.0034633284,
-0.017911287,
0.0041066511,
0.0236081742,
0.0502997898,
-0.0285475403,
-0.0409192331,
-0.003582665,
-0.047007136,
-0.0016875925,
-0.0454676338,
0.0114986096,
0.0060324096,
-0.0189751741,
0.0040894393,
-0.003689588,
0.0189262517,
-0.0234206971,
0.0367097892,
-0.0753763914,
0.0270726699,
0.027730329,
-0.0166567117,
-0.0497801863,
0.0568553656,
0.0028778783,
0.0297063068,
0.0472312719,
-0.0021276372,
0.0161778945,
-0.0620270409,
0.0204027891,
0.0236064494,
0.0038093212,
0.00738427,
-0.0536580719,
0.0344099253,
0.038694948,
0.046859622,
-0.0442727543,
-0.0058082808,
0.0663442016,
-0.0096721491,
-0.0045277714,
0.0125844544,
0.0716180429,
0.0015216159,
0.0331294499,
0.0466202237,
-0.0479490049,
0.0483984798,
-0.0047659599,
0.0033817778,
0.019939078,
0.0334813558,
0.0052002342,
-0.0598621219,
-0.0145271448,
0.0122991698,
0.0001806739,
0.0145849157,
0.002709802,
-0.0175672397,
-0.0250662863,
0.0313271806,
0.041166205,
-0.0037991451,
-0.0076009417,
-0.0858451426,
0.0747056305,
0.0491866618,
0.0389412194,
0.0329770967,
0.0303031728,
-0.0333268195,
0.0501584858,
0.0436181873,
0.047660809,
-0.0264633689,
0.0051674875,
-0.0123207085,
-0.0272110403,
-0.0524765179,
0.0675629973,
0.0125331273,
0.0376885757,
-0.0423437469,
0.0205463134,
-0.0363329649,
-0.0468723588,
0.0416968875,
0.015542075,
0.003011323,
-0.0024956029,
-0.0101466672,
0.000607704,
0.0308237448,
-0.015317074,
0.0224266108,
0.0210075155,
0.0100849187,
-0.0112743014,
0.0193964522,
-0.0003530307,
0.0221221838,
0.0038575614,
-0.0325138606,
-0.0398831628,
0.0030513734,
-0.0254641902,
-0.0144628081,
-0.0251604952,
-0.0552391447,
0.014365403,
-0.0261427369,
0.0020994267,
-0.0276634879,
-0.0236250665,
-0.0097302701,
0.0959308743,
-0.007553671,
0.0180306509,
0.0331850834,
-0.0200752411,
0.009000998,
-0.0264526661,
0.0376717262,
0.0404715836,
-0.006367763,
-0.0181649048,
0.0367581137,
-0.0541677698,
-0.0190856177,
0.0268646367,
-0.0224947557,
-0.009724387,
-0.0238900073,
-0.0212577954,
0.0375721902,
-0.0248512402,
0.0250375811,
0.0252140332,
0.0054491893,
-0.0041885935,
-0.0362599231,
0.0263293143,
0.0477187671,
0.014230323,
-0.0322296582,
-0.0419102348,
-0.0026748735,
-0.0163574405,
0.0547766685,
0.0582960993,
0.0132763423,
-0.0978964567,
-0.0060615242,
-0.0426465832,
-0.0273242835,
-0.0312897637,
-0.0231382586,
0.0326782502,
0.0167082828,
-0.0327193178,
0.0689693391,
0.0211103167,
0.0451330505,
0.0646884367,
0.042250216,
-0.0232326668,
-0.029240638,
-0.0090505891,
0.0084152892,
-0.0064010494,
-0.0627562925,
0.0247151516,
0.0315709859,
0.0106926989,
0.012959186,
-0.030289067,
0.0437922031,
-0.0270908568,
-0.0261844303,
-0.0035012583,
-0.0739686862,
0.0005512855,
0.0980289802,
-0.0255861003,
-0.0739942342,
0.0767465606,
-0.0357407928,
0.0449533127,
-0.0100401212,
-0.007375984,
-0.0123961344,
0.0356379934,
-0.0264214184,
0.0260737464,
0.0033835212,
0.0259939656,
-0.0244072545,
-0.0497274995,
0.0925043225,
0.0063379095,
0.0200405363,
-0.0685179457,
-0.0076407562,
0.019826239,
-0.0059779915,
-0.023670109,
-0.0780006349,
-0.0451982543,
0.0122016426,
0.0441045463,
-0.0382169634,
-0.0436920263,
-0.0069645657,
0.1093037575,
0.0019253804,
0.0115745571,
0.006723728,
0.0087320879,
-0.0201607477,
0.0160251688,
0.045121938,
0.0937188491,
-0.0038999864,
0.0118093584,
0.0418480709,
0.0117914062,
0.0264475178,
-0.0229000654,
-0.0563838966,
-0.0361688808,
-0.037722569,
-0.0194923282,
0.0140791107,
0.0527964197,
-0.0644408688,
0.0452090427,
0.0842892751,
0.0167958941,
-0.0234203804,
-0.0089875693,
-0.0140984226,
-0.0175046232,
0.0181582384,
-0.0167079009,
-0.072149694,
-0.0023774698,
0.020299254,
0.0054997699,
-0.0181662887,
-0.0170225129,
-0.0132189011,
-0.0879232138,
0.0359880924,
-0.0063675153,
0.0013501791,
-0.0572018065,
-0.1344848424,
0.0018055205,
-0.0185212698,
-0.0240037665,
0.0473890491,
0.0275931451,
0.0019297386,
0.0029307122,
0.0046583004,
-0.0562352575,
0.0541964509,
-0.0398799889,
0.0313691646,
0.0580773093,
0.0540733896,
-0.0217840094,
-0.0527677163,
-0.0042467061,
-0.0040867086,
0.0001356,
0.0139582362,
0.0755177736,
0.0128221074,
0.0135361496,
-0.0510150716,
0.0223929193,
0.0330523103,
-0.0259875674,
-0.0234362017,
0.0276392177,
0.0077794469,
-0.0547321513,
0.0039694807,
0.0081458576,
0.0182079095,
0.11038661,
0.0415204987,
0.0128956446,
-0.0081086429,
-0.0440261737,
-0.0190116856,
-0.0254715178,
-0.0322759151,
0.0476193912,
0.0108675947,
-0.0456670746,
-0.0477462485,
-0.0264164768,
-0.0010694036,
0.0156116644,
-0.0089794714,
-0.0005204808,
0.0168551579,
-0.0010262589,
0.0107460525,
0.0324180238,
-0.0022942363,
0.0448685959,
0.0177097805,
-0.0318469144,
-0.0067103649,
-0.0202647988,
-0.00269102,
0.0526655056,
0.0178407934,
-0.0309000034,
0.005605462,
0.002318355,
0.0326564275,
0.0585390069,
-0.0034235031,
-0.0352450795,
-0.0263921414,
-0.0082114404,
-0.0417433232,
-0.0099111227,
0.025285583,
-0.0352992527,
0.0226742979,
0.0113849966,
-0.0415316261,
0.0053415364,
-0.0444953479,
0.0254827831,
-0.0271204673,
-0.0186485052,
0.0607406832,
0.0256116837,
0.0450382121,
-0.0358710587,
-0.0185500011,
-0.0074294843,
-0.023523381,
-0.0346681103,
-0.0316192172,
0.0193336233,
0.0465543792,
-0.0118574472,
-0.0453779809,
0.0009093914,
-0.0261582155,
-0.0501588136,
0.0174307153,
0.001166985,
0.0066228174,
-0.0216176882,
0.0188865904,
0.0114137316,
-0.0037323786,
-0.0608316921,
-0.0083515448,
-0.0459370948,
0.0387627482,
0.0021030777,
0.0408436544,
0.0116485674,
-0.019048078,
0.0067051533,
-0.0452015512,
-0.1085970253,
-0.0359507762,
0.0068909354,
-0.0260056909,
0.0261873472,
-0.0131227998,
0.0780875832,
0.0060095899,
-0.049182713,
0.001244917,
0.0367245972,
0.0357682146,
-0.0145315453,
0.0257619005,
0.020496523,
-0.0655396879,
-0.0138650369,
0.0637219846,
0.0192175638,
0.0445379391,
-0.0162315983,
-0.0438231789,
0.0119779799,
-0.0545587242,
-0.0745690539,
0.037664663,
0.0168466698,
-0.0253713019,
-0.064075157,
-0.0507607013,
-0.0331669189,
0.0279807355,
0.0451947302,
-0.0316079929,
-0.0278541073,
0.0831013843,
0.0114287985,
-0.0301509723,
-0.069560349,
0.0537071526,
-0.0243649222,
0.019464545,
-0.0269638374,
-5.991728336e-33,
-0.0053576189,
-0.069866702,
-0.0155219575,
-0.029353613,
0.0008400261,
0.0392128564,
-0.0614833236,
-0.0179408323,
-0.079059273,
0.0841741338,
0.0242406614,
0.0290118307,
0.0183250625,
-0.0373586826,
0.0032601636,
-0.0067919199,
0.0544253178,
0.0221993849,
-0.0433456004,
0.0103839487,
0.0253135022,
-0.0548108928,
0.0144008277,
-0.0645405501,
0.105531849,
-0.0096439226,
-0.0410577767,
0.0063651246,
-0.0173100736,
0.0616138466,
-0.0002072578,
0.02159095,
0.028362181,
-0.0567672774,
0.0035959275,
-0.0064701936,
-0.0624347255,
0.0075883502,
0.0691729411,
-0.0372541547,
-0.0529891923,
-0.0254633706,
0.007606911,
0.0028973499,
-0.0051762848,
-0.0112867979,
0.0191067215,
-0.023619052,
-0.0159005281,
-0.0039839922,
-0.0236147325,
0.0388056114,
-0.018880887,
-0.004477242,
-0.033517018,
0.0369408652,
0.0077090091,
0.0066682287,
-0.0343946442,
0.0342788436,
0.0232988372,
-0.0022162474,
0.0483592562,
-0.036568474,
0.0025550551,
0.0603173636,
0.0073641283,
0.0129994303,
-0.084228307,
0.0005847613,
-0.0551464483,
0.0451584794,
0.0679848045,
0.1010619253,
0.026786752,
-0.0042391336,
-0.063934736,
0.0209968202,
-0.0141519308,
0.0439518914,
0.0346477069,
-0.0104920091,
-0.0335634723,
-0.0152237527,
-0.0698328838,
-0.0295879487,
-0.0307439957,
-0.0085439011,
-0.0076336614,
0.0227735527,
-0.0565749705,
0.0093635395,
0.0004832823,
-0.0221708752,
0.0282140952,
0.0568620637,
-0.0536042973,
-0.0119797178,
0.0115181459,
-0.0243234318,
-0.0500819199,
0.0404230095,
-0.0138280783,
0.0458921567,
0.027304681,
0.0253933761,
0.0328539498,
-0.0195938665,
-0.0053402018,
0.0267681368,
-0.0503777638,
-0.0078154504,
-0.0170836691,
-0.0736483335,
0.0286689028,
0.0288089458,
-0.0267295241,
-0.018194994,
0.007532191,
0.0173687916,
0.0069477642,
0.0066658538,
-0.0095900064,
0.0144901406,
-0.0156085333,
-0.014901517,
-0.0208523329,
-0.0122273993,
0.0590511672,
-0.0396783203,
-0.0181861985,
0.0049372497,
2.364e-7,
0.0273251738,
0.0434833094,
0.0158739816,
0.0229601879,
0.0223930012,
0.0393061973,
0.0359495543,
-0.0359674618,
-0.0031020027,
-0.0723170191,
-0.0491253734,
0.0436722524,
0.0465737022,
0.0461176857,
0.0053308862,
-0.023774365,
-0.0624933243,
-0.0355233699,
-0.0368990786,
-0.0114858262,
0.0106942216,
0.0183349233,
0.0147889936,
0.0092876386,
0.0060906447,
-0.0331722237,
0.0531103797,
-0.0164336208,
-0.0072008129,
0.0117772864,
0.042638395,
-0.0087080365,
0.0131519549,
0.0026442222,
-0.0155623658,
-0.0157888141,
-0.0253670663,
0.0753112808,
0.0081230765,
0.0207076836,
-0.0245352276,
-0.0706253424,
0.0544740744,
-0.0626934692,
0.0474558845,
-0.0223897491,
-0.0342639834,
-0.0661132336,
-0.0310097579,
-0.0067078061,
0.0011895115,
-0.0353594162,
0.0100573292,
0.0265104547,
-0.0654676557,
0.0171001665,
-0.0014672937,
-0.0154201314,
-0.0578702837,
-0.0052134739,
-0.0462229475,
-0.0495181829,
0.0168364607,
-0.0318357348,
0.0439903028,
-0.0371063873,
0.0370510332,
1.790263317e-34,
0.0285932049,
0.00611398,
0.0033940836,
-0.0044703651,
0.0894070044,
0.0406387784,
-0.0030745976,
-0.0328039713,
0.0436881669,
-0.0213623084,
-0.0209642462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12644v2 | Hierarchical Prompting Taxonomy: A Universal Evaluation Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T14:12:27 | 2024-06-27T14:32:07 | Devichand Budagam, Sankalp KJ, Ashutosh Kumar, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Assessing the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) in addressing
diverse tasks is essential for comprehending their strengths and weaknesses.
Conventional evaluation techniques typically apply a single prompting strategy
uniformly across datasets, not considering the varying degrees of task
complexity. We introduce the Hierarchical Prompting Taxonomy (HPT), a taxonomy
that employs a Hierarchical Prompt Framework (HPF) composed of five unique
prompting strategies, arranged from the simplest to the most complex, to assess
LLMs more precisely and to offer a clearer perspective. This taxonomy assigns a
score, called the Hierarchical Prompting Score (HP-Score), to datasets as well
as LLMs based on the rules of the taxonomy, providing a nuanced understanding
of their ability to solve diverse tasks and offering a universal measure of
task complexity. Additionally, we introduce the Adaptive Hierarchical Prompt
framework, which automates the selection of appropriate prompting strategies
for each task. This study compares manual and adaptive hierarchical prompt
frameworks using four instruction-tuned LLMs, namely Llama 3 8B, Phi 3 3.8B,
Mistral 7B, and Gemma 7B, across four datasets: BoolQ, CommonSenseQA (CSQA),
IWSLT-2017 en-fr (IWSLT), and SamSum. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness
of HPT, providing a reliable way to compare different tasks and LLM
capabilities. This paper leads to the development of a universal evaluation
metric that can be used to evaluate both the complexity of the datasets and the
capabilities of LLMs. The implementation of both manual HPF and adaptive HPF is
publicly available. | [
0.0526215732,
0.0047682631,
-0.0222499426,
0.0145325698,
-0.084669888,
0.035327971,
0.034092661,
-0.0116357487,
0.040927507,
-0.0394659564,
-0.0341005772,
-0.0578562096,
0.021206703,
0.039844729,
0.0204386413,
-0.0593658946,
0.0596749224,
-0.0797235295,
-0.0013340857,
-0.009023726,
-0.0242467429,
0.0056050806,
-0.0155774634,
0.0534079,
0.014453142,
-0.0188070983,
-0.0301361643,
0.0084266327,
-0.0003645383,
-0.0334759951,
0.0070541473,
0.086498335,
0.0207933467,
0.0437210463,
0.0000023493,
-0.0790268555,
0.0232506841,
-0.012071114,
-0.0372555666,
0.012683792,
0.0584983155,
0.0094819516,
-0.0136359418,
0.0385951176,
-0.0064016157,
-0.0071959984,
0.0317899436,
0.032909926,
0.0372359641,
0.0377117433,
0.0000974581,
-0.0127327899,
0.0272125471,
-0.0274955425,
-0.0019854824,
-0.0386532359,
0.0236608125,
-0.0070568603,
0.0610333681,
0.0178850386,
0.0039359923,
0.0351003967,
0.0396901593,
-0.0198206678,
-0.0103332913,
0.0082719475,
-0.0071356753,
-0.0345059894,
-0.0471726581,
0.0779852793,
0.010803408,
0.0074401516,
-0.0071646813,
-0.0149289053,
0.0236976594,
0.0199015308,
-0.0387170762,
0.0221839212,
-0.0012406501,
-0.0207485575,
0.0469820723,
0.0182236023,
0.0029862348,
0.0052747782,
-0.0015858631,
0.0686493367,
0.0284853838,
-0.0411763303,
0.026021082,
-0.0244910102,
-0.002980547,
-0.0830444843,
0.0045260051,
0.0263926256,
-0.0901270136,
0.0117121199,
-0.0469075851,
0.0082169389,
0.0557629131,
-0.0235887673,
0.0578625798,
0.048423551,
-0.0302625112,
0.0492931046,
0.0032934824,
0.0923169553,
0.0133867571,
-0.002733008,
-0.0408399925,
0.0176043734,
-0.0660346076,
0.0040668012,
-0.0372154228,
-0.0077906568,
-0.0433641896,
-0.0405308716,
-0.0157858506,
0.0406936482,
0.0136356,
0.0275318958,
0.0571608804,
-0.0180128608,
0.0001982396,
0.0047969162,
-0.0280412361,
0.0089727789,
-0.0504194535,
0.0179609042,
0.0363081135,
-0.0613272563,
0.0160812866,
0.0214694887,
0.0067161,
-0.0175536796,
0.0095451763,
0.0455944836,
-0.0096899709,
-0.0333877616,
-0.0241246335,
-0.0111232828,
0.0101863956,
-0.0797596648,
-0.0201465208,
-0.0739143118,
0.0396610424,
-0.004952854,
-0.0095683839,
0.0280907713,
0.0050209537,
0.0227410309,
-0.0101426914,
0.0445152223,
-0.0182217695,
0.0404883698,
0.0348585211,
0.0061823544,
-0.020884892,
0.0515610017,
-0.0050157295,
0.006798604,
0.0427142717,
0.0003441756,
-0.006121425,
0.052656915,
-0.0374113992,
0.0147679988,
0.0037323053,
0.0156149408,
-0.0094778417,
0.0212999806,
0.0025607012,
0.0670891479,
0.0126979891,
0.0256405156,
0.0536224842,
0.0575691909,
0.0040786914,
-0.0282409303,
0.0538575947,
0.0304901525,
0.0099869464,
0.0091519039,
-0.0718079209,
0.0145785809,
-0.0428586863,
0.0037169463,
-0.0029891294,
0.020288704,
-0.0194316115,
-0.0480993651,
-0.016139552,
0.0148032494,
-0.0014349846,
0.0285808332,
0.0388755947,
0.0003378118,
-0.0650968775,
0.0033293886,
-0.0082977852,
-0.0461769775,
-0.0117768226,
-0.0650154948,
0.0469491147,
0.1005042344,
0.0521944575,
-0.0016752561,
-0.0235944949,
0.0105713084,
0.0304927547,
0.0250445865,
0.0205156282,
-0.0204626471,
-0.0089407945,
-0.0530835316,
-0.0461749397,
0.0083103226,
0.0044505382,
0.0102778235,
0.0044271406,
-0.0272296481,
-0.0014759701,
-0.0036835659,
-0.03201285,
0.0395533703,
-0.0226933975,
-0.0064975736,
-0.0125294793,
0.0139636286,
0.0047858479,
0.0332488082,
-0.0138056474,
0.0232131258,
0.0346783139,
-0.0265665501,
0.0147284269,
-0.0272577144,
-0.0595140681,
-0.0350962952,
0.0181480646,
0.0335965455,
-0.0118917944,
0.0125777209,
-0.0148059316,
-0.0530403219,
-0.0304054525,
-0.0324019343,
0.0036987555,
-0.0412074625,
0.0399684608,
-0.0123993456,
-0.0320681334,
-0.0397777744,
0.0769994482,
-0.0262565631,
0.041063372,
0.0536987521,
0.0374114886,
0.0043664379,
-0.0466538556,
-0.054441452,
0.0173290577,
-0.0385363773,
-0.0022777524,
0.0140059683,
0.0505426265,
-0.0502449758,
-0.0330794193,
-0.0895127058,
0.0072208671,
-0.041028697,
0.0205614045,
0.0108078346,
0.011621817,
-0.0339192487,
-0.0178799257,
-0.0475418642,
-0.0023247718,
0.0291985944,
0.0389688462,
0.0127559984,
-0.0033805373,
-0.0617452376,
-0.020326905,
-0.0259273611,
0.0051798951,
0.0221955571,
0.0041212114,
-0.0091455281,
-0.0424373373,
0.0220251121,
-0.0065754848,
0.0138597209,
-0.0088797947,
-0.01220538,
0.0201533251,
-0.0119751701,
0.0762187764,
0.0493128635,
-0.0012451406,
-0.0077714641,
0.0379821211,
-0.0216212869,
-0.0385359302,
0.0066133677,
-0.0119509408,
-0.0370606296,
-0.002535607,
-0.0438036956,
0.0096670268,
0.0581615455,
0.0102511654,
0.0074451999,
-0.0545290224,
-0.0100136064,
-0.0253596753,
-0.0273849778,
-0.0680113658,
-0.0301623996,
-0.0319237523,
0.0690227523,
-0.0276665278,
-0.0737740397,
0.0617064312,
-0.0549209192,
-0.0120235477,
-0.0478201509,
-0.0125151817,
-0.0214554444,
0.0674458146,
-0.0114721851,
0.0115531674,
0.0396405719,
-0.0496725813,
-0.0348172709,
0.0034033298,
0.0041207448,
-0.0257975366,
0.04120823,
-0.0579816476,
0.0179100819,
-0.0022954247,
-0.0197405182,
-0.0411823094,
-0.0097432695,
-0.0084709441,
0.0330534689,
0.0115411989,
-0.0069500823,
-0.0183416624,
0.017085148,
0.0217571985,
0.0735473484,
-0.0296003539,
0.001541891,
-0.0232443083,
0.0284403116,
0.0357794613,
0.0460160449,
0.0082288077,
-0.013826835,
0.0652341694,
-0.0057853539,
0.0342163444,
-0.0082378006,
0.0123676006,
0.0359751098,
0.0485943668,
-0.0420873277,
-0.0272771232,
0.0624422245,
0.0503016412,
-0.0716024563,
-0.0058980538,
0.1357409954,
0.051317513,
-0.0349128172,
0.0039680726,
-0.0434947982,
0.0215399526,
0.0260538198,
0.0162678473,
-0.0898719877,
-0.0266039725,
0.035802938,
0.0270445421,
-0.0132326186,
-0.0137943709,
0.0108728996,
-0.1144248098,
0.0566348843,
-0.0209256429,
-0.0380279757,
-0.0169511773,
-0.0441143364,
0.0027838745,
0.0183297675,
0.026280297,
0.0307053197,
-0.0222699847,
-0.0262585096,
0.0141392183,
-0.0259592775,
-0.0838181376,
0.0567285754,
-0.0396338366,
0.0763769597,
0.0757429451,
-0.0084960693,
0.0026922172,
-0.0425776206,
0.0056906273,
-0.0243620202,
0.0042897603,
-0.0200877469,
-0.0070575429,
0.0065034716,
-0.00518008,
-0.0564810559,
0.0218600444,
-0.021110395,
-0.0136605483,
0.0274730194,
0.0776624084,
-0.0155609837,
0.0076056854,
-0.0155719016,
-0.0022612954,
0.0357463546,
0.1011614054,
0.0365480892,
-0.0463761501,
-0.0101828054,
-0.0183220692,
-0.0339228362,
-0.0416951478,
0.0094190966,
0.0443419479,
-0.0172637627,
-0.030231731,
-0.0570547953,
-0.027586421,
0.0503361933,
0.0105930744,
0.0120351352,
0.0315593705,
-0.0129948799,
0.0135278292,
-0.0267706495,
0.0328423604,
0.0006046054,
0.0461612307,
-0.113940455,
-0.0159731954,
0.0011846398,
0.0034006222,
-0.0229000729,
0.0167277679,
-0.027279133,
-0.0501013435,
-0.0208909791,
0.0445850641,
0.0233875811,
-0.0145760067,
-0.0215643682,
-0.0814579651,
0.0310297515,
-0.0000459023,
-0.0134921707,
0.0002187658,
0.0052273571,
0.0073396037,
-0.0080497973,
0.0575269312,
-0.0384119973,
0.0175359901,
-0.0364563055,
0.0696029887,
0.0167094357,
-0.0358395241,
0.0185348671,
0.0240822285,
0.0097269202,
-0.0469170809,
-0.0264905933,
-0.0458753593,
0.0073836441,
-0.0212437529,
-0.0407229401,
-0.0550513454,
0.0322754793,
0.017416155,
-0.014781733,
0.0171417985,
-0.0091045955,
-0.0255097654,
0.0254964065,
-0.0506918617,
0.0607519522,
-0.0056565502,
0.0376010276,
0.0255005248,
0.0022359204,
-0.0354101993,
-0.0016873572,
-0.0138053037,
0.0009244699,
-0.0165497418,
0.0916321203,
-0.0069913063,
-0.001002697,
-0.0070618996,
0.0562333949,
-0.0194006991,
-0.0441711657,
0.0182318874,
0.0520992205,
0.0634921491,
0.0177897643,
0.0246256962,
-0.0129704447,
0.0028525852,
-0.0387966894,
0.0133144436,
0.0415645763,
-0.0397823602,
0.0497102924,
0.0358561985,
-0.0179710202,
-0.0000095228,
0.0606733598,
0.0028331913,
0.02052477,
0.0110382205,
0.0229423847,
-0.0459068567,
-0.0217878465,
0.0333545506,
0.0343672186,
-0.0574040413,
0.0103726499,
-0.0605952963,
-0.0471217483,
-0.0219272636,
0.036037948,
-0.022770036,
-0.0083606727,
0.0549333766,
0.0513863042,
-0.0059887511,
-0.0468748175,
-0.0446988828,
-0.0147779034,
-0.0398114137,
-0.0493146516,
-0.0314230733,
-6.850230064e-33,
-0.0332557783,
-0.0195511691,
0.0132155558,
-0.0451414175,
-0.00248018,
0.0115531702,
-0.0476536416,
0.020677587,
-0.0175311398,
-0.0058723567,
-0.030744642,
-0.0380452275,
0.0197806656,
0.004055779,
0.0280935671,
-0.0056404117,
0.0354873613,
-0.0102750203,
-0.0383130498,
0.0215945225,
0.0213879701,
-0.004907534,
0.0343289487,
0.0001047511,
0.0460667089,
-0.0146140195,
-0.0192505177,
0.0294288117,
-0.0187906474,
0.0759164616,
-0.0221656468,
0.0591955669,
0.029948052,
-0.0305176862,
-0.0214506853,
0.1007694378,
-0.0644985735,
-0.033572346,
0.0643632561,
0.0049416209,
-0.040369574,
-0.0423919074,
-0.006790163,
-0.0226044636,
-0.0482632965,
0.0219683219,
0.0001452098,
-0.0097135352,
-0.0238977745,
-0.0242713932,
-0.0613315701,
0.023780169,
0.0042678448,
-0.0700127035,
-0.0037993891,
0.0774821639,
-0.0106482012,
-0.0069506075,
-0.0300762206,
0.0418870524,
0.0438846163,
0.0337430127,
0.0786262453,
0.0267560501,
-0.0041951784,
0.0275568049,
0.0224635378,
0.0046609337,
0.0007322157,
0.0009709982,
0.034543965,
0.0514834076,
0.0443701856,
0.0053273225,
0.0135085266,
0.0157270692,
-0.0366111249,
0.0371469893,
0.031287536,
0.035683874,
0.0255611762,
-0.002569278,
-0.0624302328,
-0.0392070599,
-0.0546687692,
0.0076777809,
-0.0477142371,
-0.0263574962,
0.0734912828,
-0.0127973855,
-0.0019897223,
-0.0171075705,
0.050883878,
-0.0078074378,
-0.0264023282,
0.009887754,
0.0204573814,
0.0474436246,
-0.0050242664,
0.0485854223,
-0.0452012904,
-0.0195583813,
0.0364946984,
-0.0079294462,
0.0120801674,
-0.0064083356,
-0.0091105495,
0.0289617237,
-0.0670534149,
0.0142173357,
-0.0203266349,
0.0389131233,
-0.0010747218,
0.0405204035,
0.0412983745,
-0.0342852138,
-0.0028694032,
0.0495207496,
-0.0215694737,
-0.0511973649,
-0.0502017699,
0.0082936883,
-0.0190894324,
0.0226304606,
-0.0184000935,
0.0295202937,
-0.068289727,
-0.0179498196,
0.0099134045,
0.0099269049,
-0.0034047235,
0.0356408395,
2.966e-7,
0.0064332378,
0.055873055,
0.0071629179,
0.0308377519,
0.001448588,
0.0112496335,
-0.0212223344,
0.0134300888,
-0.0083000781,
-0.0020691934,
-0.0022921376,
0.0035132882,
0.051292561,
-0.000194126,
-0.0995523036,
-0.0236979499,
-0.0669973716,
0.0050555347,
-0.0749974921,
0.0266448818,
0.072955668,
0.0793165192,
-0.0265854858,
0.0004220483,
-0.0254344847,
-0.045751892,
-0.0008571018,
-0.0353331901,
-0.0091578988,
0.0140999202,
0.0147346472,
0.0014238056,
0.0156822577,
0.051583495,
0.0033824388,
0.0276477747,
-0.0054022297,
0.0832778811,
0.0156551432,
-0.0087470692,
0.0099630682,
-0.0179516263,
-0.0044882051,
-0.0898612663,
0.0839006305,
-0.0399450064,
-0.0174286086,
-0.0045847245,
-0.0027285111,
-0.0171114597,
0.0223353039,
-0.0405689664,
-0.0235690828,
0.0339262448,
0.0377334356,
-0.0306511633,
-0.0184598025,
-0.039992366,
0.011069105,
0.016592944,
-0.0250490531,
-0.0728698149,
-0.0578729808,
0.0003806149,
-0.0208693761,
-0.0578638986,
0.0021690072,
3.101789341e-34,
0.0316156968,
-0.0221273471,
0.0247627422,
0.0280535519,
0.0230619516,
0.0020584869,
-0.040853221,
0.0405898541,
0.0076830452,
-0.1154516339,
-0.0149895176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12641v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12641v1 | DetectBench: Can Large Language Model Detect and Piece Together Implicit Evidence? | 2024-06-18T14:08:01 | 2024-06-18T14:08:01 | Zhouhong Gu, Lin Zhang, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Jiangjie Chen, Wenhao Huang, Yikai Zhang, Shusen Wang, Zheyu Ye, Yan Gao, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting evidence within the context is a key step in the process of
reasoning task. Evaluating and enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in evidence
detection will strengthen context-based reasoning performance. This paper
proposes a benchmark called DetectBench for verifying the ability to detect and
piece together implicit evidence within a long context. DetectBench contains
3,928 multiple-choice questions, with an average of 994 tokens per question.
Each question contains an average of 4.55 pieces of implicit evidence, and
solving the problem typically requires 7.62 logical jumps to find the correct
answer. To enhance the performance of LLMs in evidence detection, this paper
proposes Detective Reasoning Prompt and Finetune. Experiments demonstrate that
the existing LLMs' abilities to detect evidence in long contexts are far
inferior to humans. However, the Detective Reasoning Prompt effectively
enhances the capability of powerful LLMs in evidence detection, while the
Finetuning method shows significant effects in enhancing the performance of
weaker LLMs. Moreover, when the abilities of LLMs in evidence detection are
improved, their final reasoning performance is also enhanced accordingly. | [
0.0074959886,
-0.0111313025,
-0.0155485161,
0.0423135944,
-0.0817048848,
0.0089907395,
0.0047670631,
0.0239772797,
-0.0081287576,
-0.0560778901,
0.0018989963,
0.0367331915,
-0.0343438648,
0.0062450101,
0.0480759479,
-0.0216764156,
0.0828325003,
-0.054056894,
0.0593196414,
-0.0086923018,
-0.0219284818,
-0.0253884662,
0.0040281336,
-0.0187316276,
-0.0000194202,
-0.0461532436,
-0.0306456294,
0.0014079259,
0.0135564655,
-0.0292927455,
-0.0390730314,
0.0438208953,
0.0103949849,
0.0338343382,
0.0000019322,
-0.0588346161,
0.0050818748,
-0.0324210711,
-0.0846286863,
0.0093850577,
-0.0418052785,
0.051551681,
-0.0072281165,
0.0239331741,
-0.0492372513,
0.0406915508,
-0.0190496966,
0.0872726813,
0.0335130058,
0.0674808621,
0.0118940463,
-0.0002944608,
0.0176553912,
0.0096873147,
0.0403828882,
-0.0247313995,
0.0165218897,
0.0260258652,
0.0550250709,
0.0367449485,
-0.0036018351,
0.0194134135,
0.0454631634,
-0.0191762578,
-0.0628278181,
0.0355902202,
-0.031476859,
-0.00381165,
0.0097409459,
0.0536138155,
0.0067397594,
-0.021113256,
-0.0333694629,
-0.0196043141,
0.0385645442,
0.0413408801,
-0.0277710576,
0.0387025177,
-0.0476956293,
-0.0327083394,
0.0562667586,
-0.0296980124,
0.0413610972,
0.0373645313,
0.0247466285,
0.1026690304,
-0.0198384374,
-0.0404865555,
0.0327659957,
-0.0272528455,
-0.0250645988,
-0.0750592798,
0.0148654701,
0.0598705448,
-0.0593450107,
0.0107888822,
-0.0071566263,
0.0121201687,
0.0492573455,
-0.0079454351,
-0.0074896496,
0.0261025093,
-0.0410558172,
0.0655070171,
-0.0975784585,
0.0170243736,
-0.0429542065,
0.011085174,
-0.0173182357,
-0.0286443308,
0.0068067601,
-0.021464685,
-0.006696404,
0.0131651675,
-0.0438259318,
-0.0108585618,
0.01180741,
-0.0013640221,
-0.0055643478,
0.0086110802,
-0.0357738249,
-0.003143339,
-0.0047171963,
-0.018091822,
-0.0574656203,
-0.0109324483,
-0.0752461553,
0.0708043501,
0.0564792305,
-0.0416716747,
-0.0206778944,
0.023836121,
0.0257059745,
-0.0297685917,
0.032647606,
0.0186104383,
-0.0127631221,
-0.014790603,
-0.0477845781,
-0.064020887,
-0.0137641542,
-0.0518977009,
-0.0093322964,
-0.0848802105,
-0.0059785736,
-0.0089077922,
-0.0150701962,
0.0138627132,
-0.0175447147,
0.0318335705,
0.0052949786,
0.0595541075,
-0.0303635467,
-0.0206977576,
0.0418902598,
0.0346843265,
-0.0193711463,
0.0386163928,
-0.0123988874,
0.0796733722,
0.0302335769,
0.0145789552,
-0.0370873474,
-0.0198636446,
0.0217732191,
0.0216877107,
-0.0040098233,
0.0310385283,
-0.0193790831,
0.0390768796,
-0.0035139627,
0.0521961339,
-0.0477641821,
-0.0222577509,
0.0369943008,
0.0696702376,
0.0167743098,
-0.0225509405,
0.0381600223,
-0.0320945084,
0.0269512534,
0.0129475584,
-0.0495229885,
0.0270610005,
-0.0441777818,
0.0041102627,
-0.0143067008,
0.0124084586,
-0.0280973595,
-0.0185739752,
-0.0222790651,
0.010470855,
-0.00569933,
0.051340241,
0.0041824197,
-0.0062002721,
-0.0149850957,
0.0104330657,
-0.0098546278,
0.0031302024,
-0.0124318376,
-0.0797610879,
0.1025805473,
0.01178913,
0.0249290057,
-0.0395299196,
-0.0181141477,
-0.0210676007,
0.0341905281,
0.0218403414,
0.0266374778,
-0.0191466101,
-0.0039716852,
-0.0083592637,
-0.0233957041,
-0.0177436452,
0.000993974,
-0.0043249675,
0.0117421076,
0.0043168184,
0.0021141535,
-0.0266297404,
0.0532488413,
0.0339989737,
-0.0473281965,
-0.007695484,
-0.0342327654,
-0.0047153174,
0.0223797001,
0.0154880863,
0.0258293897,
0.0116106179,
0.0252216477,
-0.0185731743,
-0.0411537476,
0.0072806468,
-0.0596543811,
-0.0266022906,
0.0547849163,
-0.0438518748,
-0.0452494919,
-0.0357800871,
-0.0217680838,
-0.0426873304,
-0.0262982473,
-0.0259240009,
0.0038333728,
-0.0449626707,
0.0059261653,
-0.0144450376,
-0.0160882752,
-0.0223572608,
0.1111316979,
-0.0030259332,
-0.0095461933,
0.0322077274,
0.0466338843,
0.033775162,
-0.0536892749,
0.0376586281,
-0.0381214954,
0.0133508909,
-0.0243785363,
0.0107180113,
-0.0170752946,
-0.0704969466,
-0.0168927014,
-0.0538073406,
0.0176040158,
-0.0009206715,
0.0132439621,
-0.0083714696,
-0.0070011229,
-0.0138540277,
-0.0025288395,
-0.0190529618,
0.0329814889,
-0.0013010215,
0.0354013704,
0.0099084796,
0.0124748508,
0.0174443852,
-0.0184409488,
-0.0044648922,
-0.0367033966,
0.0042255195,
-0.0002820649,
0.0027955777,
-0.0660893098,
0.0307906065,
0.0087021561,
-0.0000076885,
-0.0120971752,
-0.0106984703,
0.0418496802,
-0.0080926111,
0.0592906587,
0.1105012819,
-0.0028230494,
-0.029817909,
0.0530456007,
-0.0163694993,
-0.0578964166,
0.0198746305,
0.0222737063,
0.0580835007,
-0.0203602873,
-0.0348867178,
-0.0112353321,
0.013662884,
0.0123059181,
0.0013431398,
0.0123392446,
0.0520733558,
0.0348483734,
-0.0432110056,
-0.0190527793,
-0.0697111189,
-0.0132487454,
0.0601898395,
-0.033636909,
-0.0447221808,
0.0577724203,
-0.0167699922,
0.0600839257,
0.0099674854,
-0.0049147122,
-0.0189747289,
0.0640816316,
-0.024452975,
-0.0035867428,
0.020532513,
-0.037942972,
-0.0236755069,
-0.0490040481,
0.0539898351,
-0.0282575581,
0.0470909923,
-0.0258194543,
0.0137452129,
-0.0114779593,
-0.0280032717,
-0.0508100204,
-0.0732145905,
-0.0505357422,
0.0056123664,
-0.0196171664,
0.0037603173,
-0.0288057774,
-0.0218190197,
0.0442257598,
0.0207380466,
-0.0039546737,
-0.0002914503,
-0.0298265237,
-0.0006589429,
0.0099883182,
0.0345046557,
0.0801766664,
-0.0355852917,
0.0447873026,
0.0803993642,
-0.0229898244,
0.0038172258,
-0.0288941432,
0.0088172862,
-0.0254229661,
-0.0175263043,
-0.0016100352,
0.0233850256,
0.0600966476,
-0.0413481668,
0.0032756438,
0.0993306488,
0.0147428894,
-0.0105884699,
-0.0104483273,
-0.0648579225,
-0.0279226955,
0.0371440649,
0.0112668965,
-0.0753171816,
-0.0573198684,
0.0618380904,
-0.0329411626,
-0.0482435822,
-0.0535988435,
0.0198644307,
-0.1043738425,
0.0262473058,
-0.0191696249,
0.0118579026,
-0.0068363282,
-0.0613419525,
0.026259508,
0.0416582823,
0.023689976,
0.0099748448,
-0.0077321455,
-0.020952221,
-0.0156578682,
0.0242937524,
0.0002127922,
0.0485484824,
-0.0383926108,
0.0461930223,
0.0099755879,
0.0289600268,
-0.0151945455,
-0.0457721651,
0.0549525693,
-0.0086296415,
0.0382419191,
-0.0405653417,
0.026306821,
-0.0050442866,
0.0355222002,
-0.0441508554,
0.0330179818,
-0.0167759545,
-0.0429088548,
0.0452280082,
0.0998806208,
-0.0408475809,
-0.0162156653,
-0.0294947121,
-0.0071128882,
-0.0205449983,
0.0737877786,
0.0168297105,
0.0339996554,
0.000726481,
0.0121364575,
-0.0477176867,
0.0128249917,
-0.0062583759,
0.0185264759,
-0.0017438519,
0.0401701145,
-0.0405413546,
-0.0092235496,
0.0350398459,
0.0613568276,
-0.0292074867,
0.0433764942,
-0.0241021458,
-0.0098925475,
-0.0224283691,
0.0342294984,
-0.0371447355,
0.0521867387,
-0.0337659381,
0.0621127374,
-0.039892748,
-0.0175411403,
0.0065790303,
0.0252144653,
-0.0381463356,
-0.0409515947,
-0.0156235322,
0.0117461029,
0.0216836408,
0.0038052639,
-0.0195528585,
-0.0446541868,
-0.0121779637,
0.0004000572,
-0.0202517491,
0.0079894289,
0.0253290832,
-0.054940138,
0.0023477625,
0.0238492675,
-0.003903171,
0.0406335369,
0.0185058955,
0.0196135603,
-0.0467423722,
-0.0085963383,
0.0364833176,
0.0361823887,
0.0336202495,
0.0086053871,
0.0036123167,
-0.0130172092,
-0.00213684,
-0.0518743247,
-0.0196333528,
0.0492054038,
0.0184921846,
-0.0056395475,
-0.0632905215,
0.0227135941,
-0.0092925783,
-0.0235507879,
0.0191879757,
-0.0273489356,
0.0514003634,
0.0291522332,
0.0272060987,
0.0097182244,
-0.0336613134,
-0.0183336549,
-0.0007960898,
-0.0296294522,
0.0849939659,
-0.0102017876,
0.0790987089,
0.043786414,
-0.0200911555,
-0.0245617852,
-0.0185234677,
-0.0821533427,
-0.0295518599,
0.0422259979,
0.015678728,
0.020633921,
-0.010157736,
-0.0020648532,
-0.0141388783,
-0.0217374228,
0.0097203339,
-0.0088612614,
0.0144755626,
-0.0026124099,
0.0604029633,
0.0432769433,
-0.0216753036,
0.0209943838,
0.0204901099,
-0.0532668643,
0.0089172088,
0.0130272061,
-0.0057220007,
-0.0279194657,
-0.0135990428,
-0.0320735127,
0.0732336938,
-0.0164101664,
0.023679236,
-0.0352171808,
-0.0467841811,
-0.0227927212,
0.060885489,
-0.002210563,
0.0083314311,
-0.0382918306,
0.0645609275,
0.0457459427,
-0.0755636841,
0.0119227022,
0.0699544623,
0.0024461315,
0.004908964,
-0.0025076512,
-6.092633873e-33,
-0.0237516295,
-0.0774954259,
0.0309936814,
0.0065264367,
-0.0005776522,
0.0357649587,
-0.0345184579,
0.0012809187,
-0.0523215905,
0.0455243252,
-0.0344610699,
0.0569753833,
0.0189449843,
-0.0399576984,
-0.0027598413,
0.0066664061,
0.0197866075,
0.0277197175,
-0.0222468916,
-0.0159491785,
0.0247443505,
-0.0314233154,
0.0066847089,
-0.0605400093,
0.021890169,
0.0044101682,
0.000475104,
0.0517485403,
-0.0735572949,
0.0362351313,
-0.0034197164,
-0.0075410432,
0.0259144083,
-0.0238294676,
-0.0073447679,
0.051353123,
-0.0926051438,
-0.0515018068,
0.064386107,
-0.0390189588,
-0.0448502116,
-0.0654453263,
0.0163830854,
0.0204818919,
-0.0007886058,
-0.0018868439,
0.0042985375,
-0.0485992059,
-0.0185167138,
-0.0129606538,
-0.0336741097,
0.0454442538,
0.0021582982,
0.0070432723,
-0.0095608961,
0.0271329489,
-0.0072390204,
-0.0028474687,
-0.0360849835,
0.0064206109,
0.0032296716,
-0.0108473208,
0.0362148248,
-0.0038347705,
-0.0135292225,
0.0660346374,
0.0306514688,
0.0075114239,
-0.0004798026,
-0.0255103968,
0.0030639346,
0.0726587474,
0.0575106032,
0.0501845516,
0.0656703487,
-0.014372102,
-0.0579379089,
-0.0072539174,
0.0799006447,
0.0554220304,
0.0631785765,
0.0004502569,
-0.0436626226,
-0.0128796771,
-0.0524457619,
0.0212521218,
-0.0437454507,
0.0017142104,
0.0256445538,
0.0123533281,
0.0232695043,
-0.025960695,
0.0291598905,
0.0030942177,
0.0514906012,
-0.0106174918,
0.0406649262,
0.0004094231,
-0.0171502531,
0.0366302431,
-0.0749170482,
-0.0212222524,
0.003548804,
0.0027389147,
0.0230651852,
0.0156279821,
0.0341904946,
-0.0011116092,
-0.0440429226,
-0.029637251,
-0.0090462305,
-0.0029073218,
-0.0138841253,
-0.0326161981,
0.0557262748,
0.0320638157,
0.0082135946,
0.0144706164,
-0.0021892095,
-0.0406439938,
-0.0269091446,
-0.026147848,
0.0108283143,
-0.0056140702,
0.0002561613,
-0.0120560722,
-0.0012700831,
-0.0015384749,
0.0021191959,
-0.072587274,
0.005937323,
0.060441643,
2.604e-7,
0.0086033167,
0.0336342342,
0.0269610211,
0.0181414783,
0.0064304657,
0.029685406,
-0.0038359049,
-0.0406788476,
0.0569710098,
-0.0739824995,
-0.0344956927,
0.0502476953,
0.0131294271,
0.0646377951,
-0.0432963632,
0.0028281056,
0.0010102105,
-0.0498941876,
-0.0507633537,
0.0182765666,
0.0495476425,
0.0521890633,
0.0121982675,
-0.0304013155,
0.0029494511,
-0.055270534,
0.0221706647,
-0.0230959058,
0.0047062072,
-0.0143635953,
0.0601173826,
0.0045640105,
0.0348096602,
0.0741519853,
0.0239356197,
0.0279211886,
-0.0385670215,
0.0395143442,
-0.0105263451,
-0.0149538722,
-0.0388037115,
-0.0888358802,
0.0342041813,
-0.0173703097,
0.0886972249,
-0.044578936,
-0.0409949645,
-0.0403212756,
-0.0267136768,
-0.0463416576,
-0.026818905,
0.0162193775,
-0.0033602226,
-0.0084503908,
0.0093662031,
-0.0166918486,
-0.0254877042,
-0.081186384,
-0.015798416,
0.041749604,
-0.0387233421,
-0.0389779285,
-0.0280832071,
-0.0277710762,
0.0522258468,
-0.0738945231,
-0.0005334181,
2.237738545e-34,
0.0285176411,
-0.0067993188,
0.0336615257,
0.0340730511,
0.0520282611,
0.0346962735,
-0.0216970854,
-0.0108382795,
0.0457167998,
-0.0890553147,
-0.0342350043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12639v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12639v1 | Ask-before-Plan: Proactive Language Agents for Real-World Planning | 2024-06-18T14:07:28 | 2024-06-18T14:07:28 | Xuan Zhang, Yang Deng, Zifeng Ren, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of large language models (LLMs) has enhanced the planning
capabilities of language agents in diverse real-world scenarios. Despite these
advancements, the potential of LLM-powered agents to comprehend ambiguous user
instructions for reasoning and decision-making is still under exploration. In
this work, we introduce a new task, Proactive Agent Planning, which requires
language agents to predict clarification needs based on user-agent conversation
and agent-environment interaction, invoke external tools to collect valid
information, and generate a plan to fulfill the user's demands. To study this
practical problem, we establish a new benchmark dataset, Ask-before-Plan. To
tackle the deficiency of LLMs in proactive planning, we propose a novel
multi-agent framework, Clarification-Execution-Planning (\texttt{CEP}), which
consists of three agents specialized in clarification, execution, and planning.
We introduce the trajectory tuning scheme for the clarification agent and
static execution agent, as well as the memory recollection mechanism for the
dynamic execution agent. Extensive evaluations and comprehensive analyses
conducted on the Ask-before-Plan dataset validate the effectiveness of our
proposed framework. | [
0.0781816691,
0.0022368275,
-0.0265275426,
0.0106939813,
-0.0361353792,
-0.0036206287,
-0.0256438404,
-0.0362411328,
-0.006521923,
-0.0137441652,
0.0498518385,
-0.0276909135,
-0.0269751213,
0.0575960577,
-0.0234246626,
-0.070469141,
0.0364533775,
-0.0398202054,
0.0476787426,
-0.0025270088,
0.0117604528,
0.0056402986,
-0.0280558448,
0.0558972806,
-0.0181801356,
0.0070493342,
-0.0664134249,
0.011990292,
0.0126818242,
-0.0198221989,
0.0054374686,
0.0273645725,
0.037413694,
0.0025193177,
0.0000019859,
-0.058911141,
-0.0170771778,
-0.0466004945,
-0.054241959,
-0.0409128182,
0.0019702369,
0.0000499483,
0.0005430094,
0.0164319538,
-0.0587714352,
0.018233316,
0.0127091445,
0.0179319847,
0.0725002289,
0.0690431073,
0.0007430388,
-0.0017157188,
-0.0112227201,
0.0207817722,
0.0082364976,
-0.0705325082,
-0.0004507657,
-0.0026114646,
0.0036494518,
0.0059228241,
0.0257480554,
0.0114002973,
0.0152846267,
-0.0302946754,
-0.070580177,
0.0085922508,
-0.0454676263,
-0.0630324334,
-0.0495948084,
0.0840138346,
0.0144152381,
-0.0011710771,
0.0353569426,
-0.022797998,
-0.0052710557,
0.0011755788,
-0.0219950937,
0.0170879867,
-0.0215808786,
-0.0120987855,
-0.0081834216,
-0.0130659118,
0.02520952,
0.0106503312,
-0.0230461881,
0.1026104316,
-0.0289673489,
-0.0013911022,
0.0160845928,
-0.0319626965,
0.0000216779,
-0.0801961944,
0.0219750535,
0.0909636766,
-0.1056145579,
0.0564155541,
0.0025857983,
0.0017461748,
-0.0053671286,
-0.0283037312,
0.0492769554,
0.0594727844,
0.0190705918,
0.0550043099,
-0.0019392428,
0.0526075624,
0.0021829302,
0.0147210956,
-0.024454616,
-0.0080342712,
-0.0602246262,
0.0124716265,
-0.0642273575,
0.0107414313,
-0.031390436,
0.0143095376,
0.0025704959,
0.0705012381,
-0.0235998817,
0.0715329349,
-0.019297773,
0.0179110821,
-0.0265150405,
-0.0280356538,
-0.0875635743,
-0.0084812967,
-0.0803897232,
0.0060942862,
0.0209484249,
-0.0507080704,
0.0059752143,
0.0239890516,
0.0030073791,
0.0067136833,
-0.0307707656,
0.0721081197,
0.0043632649,
0.0188576244,
-0.0390032418,
-0.0564597435,
0.0392113775,
-0.0787224174,
-0.0130715715,
-0.0420018919,
0.0420863889,
-0.0024009754,
-0.0445294864,
-0.0370458215,
0.0073819133,
0.0086849686,
0.0107385442,
0.0565218143,
-0.00056966,
0.0255920514,
0.0269740783,
0.0080781905,
-0.0408328027,
0.081047602,
0.0503406227,
0.0651695803,
0.0426190309,
0.0429706946,
0.0139621925,
0.0325503089,
0.0098794959,
0.020669736,
-0.0020038127,
0.0442396998,
-0.0259825736,
0.0229412559,
-0.0198435206,
0.0123620378,
-0.0087500624,
-0.0093570529,
0.0140727879,
0.0299213808,
-0.0190404691,
-0.0276434068,
0.0648000464,
0.0451186933,
-0.0311805885,
-0.0328071043,
-0.0418381467,
0.033679828,
-0.0236046314,
-0.0025729849,
-0.0399482623,
-0.0012741821,
-0.0477347858,
-0.0606124885,
0.0143927271,
-0.0239496045,
0.0424296185,
0.0053558452,
0.0139658116,
-0.0033328731,
-0.0682099015,
0.0365400016,
-0.0095655546,
-0.0346978381,
-0.0307572167,
-0.0662924796,
0.031177761,
0.0986821428,
0.0425931178,
-0.0360839143,
-0.0663028806,
0.0164695363,
0.0154297929,
0.0265512615,
0.019532105,
-0.0485194139,
0.0254441574,
-0.047420036,
-0.0514865741,
0.0036529116,
-0.0108415028,
0.0401672535,
0.0392725095,
0.0060519376,
-0.0099026896,
0.017710438,
-0.0115908217,
0.0282844137,
-0.011843387,
0.0025740294,
-0.0357473642,
0.0132678328,
0.0362525731,
0.0097111734,
-0.00607447,
-0.0092669427,
0.0400886424,
0.0087129259,
-0.016856581,
0.0258490685,
-0.0231631584,
-0.0097739734,
0.0504616834,
0.007814859,
-0.0211452749,
-0.0005802911,
-0.0436216369,
-0.0548444726,
0.0155274495,
0.0018177521,
0.0395880677,
-0.0170759745,
0.0138215516,
-0.0058073499,
-0.0337497145,
-0.0021258648,
0.0471745878,
0.0034480034,
-0.0501948819,
0.0489011407,
0.0422507897,
0.0028866965,
0.0017393761,
-0.00456418,
0.0385312214,
0.0419602692,
0.0104080392,
0.0447507277,
0.0353025645,
-0.0464274473,
-0.0123143494,
-0.0730678141,
-0.0129455309,
-0.0412431844,
-0.0327362381,
0.002933041,
-0.0002188954,
-0.0045477361,
-0.0252557565,
-0.02917937,
0.055137299,
0.0023530121,
0.0210369322,
0.0277136974,
0.0519627109,
-0.0352667831,
-0.0403266996,
0.0256244317,
-0.0099421451,
-0.0416124426,
0.0191864967,
-0.0385825671,
-0.0499670543,
0.0323675275,
-0.0627236366,
0.0110221887,
-0.0259559937,
-0.0366833583,
0.0381954126,
-0.0356965363,
-0.0046614041,
0.0277067889,
-0.0101692285,
0.030389566,
0.0599656254,
-0.0324060544,
-0.0780100003,
0.0531203374,
-0.0499639139,
-0.0083101392,
-0.0744680986,
-0.0188506246,
-0.0009712005,
0.0439517573,
-0.0214792471,
0.0325260721,
-0.0684367269,
-0.0295565352,
0.0225139968,
-0.046826683,
-0.0039489875,
-0.0049983561,
-0.030946672,
0.1014591008,
-0.0105117597,
-0.0237957742,
0.0905940458,
0.0148288496,
-0.0295243151,
-0.0109345997,
-0.0098731071,
-0.0224118959,
0.0621366613,
0.0088645052,
0.0169694368,
-0.0345276073,
0.009755969,
-0.0497232713,
-0.054414805,
0.0158533622,
-0.0212465916,
0.0433133356,
-0.0912035033,
-0.0000326623,
0.0018870422,
-0.0291889217,
-0.0545569919,
-0.0304672979,
-0.0432118736,
0.004145592,
-0.0227153692,
-0.0415515006,
-0.0539318174,
-0.0059285704,
0.0073920628,
0.0547975376,
0.0006218214,
-0.033395946,
-0.0318927094,
-0.0613589287,
0.0621918961,
0.0630042404,
-0.0017145386,
-0.0090686651,
0.0585522652,
0.0435371213,
0.0373890288,
-0.058583647,
-0.0243679248,
0.011991905,
0.010453471,
-0.0052561699,
0.0296572112,
0.0666127279,
0.0375578776,
-0.0297643356,
-0.0047675679,
0.0962147489,
0.0380054154,
-0.0324084237,
0.0004154625,
-0.0565649569,
0.0330170505,
0.0335037895,
0.0507663377,
-0.0500554256,
-0.0461780243,
0.0013231423,
0.0041584955,
-0.0194544122,
-0.0523820706,
-0.0298113786,
-0.0772440359,
0.0338453725,
-0.0222128853,
-0.0026544032,
0.0500510931,
-0.0235676728,
-0.0109946812,
0.0047709644,
0.0238521509,
-0.0112023726,
0.0477767624,
-0.0318781435,
0.0045079822,
-0.040527191,
-0.0249818023,
0.0240972806,
-0.0015845855,
0.0533258878,
0.0935178027,
0.0275548659,
0.0207975414,
-0.0109398942,
0.0074145636,
0.0346226841,
0.0302288532,
-0.0269701444,
0.020022044,
-0.0019559204,
0.0176991429,
0.0093766488,
0.0136433849,
-0.0639519021,
-0.0217602886,
0.060933549,
0.0661052763,
-0.0477020741,
0.0140733682,
-0.0303381868,
0.0306016821,
0.03797796,
0.0516757146,
-0.009177533,
-0.0316286422,
-0.0466981344,
-0.0501010939,
-0.041290205,
-0.0657181218,
-0.0064843432,
0.0037024952,
-0.0216899663,
0.024607785,
-0.0362283848,
-0.0786924362,
0.0723693743,
0.0392063856,
0.0258239638,
-0.0196748115,
0.0396492779,
0.0260472763,
-0.0052835485,
-0.0218275506,
-0.0070070503,
0.0152594633,
-0.0306295585,
-0.0467900485,
0.0099506332,
-0.0093496069,
0.0112180198,
0.0193120539,
-0.0539444312,
-0.0669551492,
0.019954538,
0.065656215,
0.0312373973,
0.0542913824,
-0.0157457869,
-0.030040957,
0.0117627205,
-0.018548375,
-0.0396393985,
-0.0242439248,
0.0084325708,
0.0380513072,
0.0030779818,
0.0593743287,
-0.0663953945,
0.0227603763,
-0.0266510621,
0.0195758007,
-0.0846005976,
-0.0247669276,
0.0130054178,
0.0142911412,
-0.0086107384,
-0.0088689346,
-0.011655638,
-0.0044794008,
0.0476635695,
-0.0091912579,
-0.0326859877,
-0.0299637076,
0.0297816992,
-0.0165331289,
-0.0528114252,
0.0576368347,
0.0118686296,
-0.0225302167,
-0.0373432934,
0.0347614996,
-0.0046321247,
0.0184428915,
0.0228968877,
0.0404787734,
0.0230988115,
-0.0070510367,
0.0333038904,
0.0137086306,
0.0691939071,
0.0286918655,
0.0520852543,
0.0257374737,
-0.0015059328,
-0.0277778935,
-0.0042898334,
-0.0468648337,
-0.0840687528,
0.0678554028,
0.038286332,
0.0264596902,
0.0047879103,
0.036067687,
-0.055237662,
0.0372184403,
0.0006571478,
-0.0043662549,
0.0310348254,
-0.0457435511,
0.0463570245,
0.0278998986,
-0.0032249994,
-0.0127215572,
0.0403731167,
-0.0314002261,
0.0625709593,
0.011997208,
-0.0114042722,
-0.0510422476,
-0.0397911519,
-0.0352917723,
0.0240029451,
-0.0185474176,
-0.0069719185,
-0.051542297,
-0.0235946905,
-0.0156256482,
0.0222464986,
-0.0306410771,
-0.0381367356,
0.0275890287,
0.0291677006,
0.0021005031,
-0.0420134068,
-0.0568412505,
-0.0252615567,
-0.0457509495,
-0.0069214012,
-0.0110227522,
-5.793286155e-33,
-0.0253329668,
-0.0362839215,
0.0805284679,
-0.0017673079,
0.0146488799,
-0.0177536346,
-0.0676171929,
-0.0067588333,
-0.0299597196,
0.0165618546,
-0.0427399874,
0.0388862863,
0.0329688862,
-0.0158023611,
0.0021661876,
-0.0303600132,
0.0213721953,
-0.0103915688,
-0.0348770544,
0.0233616102,
0.0593633763,
-0.0043111425,
0.0038578226,
-0.0279890038,
0.0225020703,
-0.0148230037,
-0.0225310624,
0.0598793812,
-0.0065350272,
0.0459501371,
0.0089992573,
0.0335685499,
0.0120207686,
0.0210026111,
-0.0271320399,
0.0046355906,
-0.0202464182,
-0.05703393,
0.0404496007,
0.034446504,
-0.0746696368,
-0.0002051151,
-0.0318350494,
0.0054467958,
-0.0135979624,
0.0390450582,
0.0282017458,
0.0007980833,
-0.0262767617,
0.051084768,
-0.0387613885,
0.0191546716,
-0.0358068831,
-0.0066001476,
0.047912851,
0.0461690277,
0.0186141189,
-0.0219608359,
-0.0478924997,
0.039640408,
0.0002398827,
-0.0164551921,
0.0554785021,
0.019739734,
-0.0114554763,
0.0591792241,
0.0243636072,
0.0400095917,
-0.0212656744,
0.0199879855,
-0.0189032592,
0.0623476505,
-0.0330238268,
0.0622856319,
-0.0251525715,
-0.0007436099,
-0.0214934219,
0.0560891889,
0.0530047007,
0.0632622764,
0.0409847349,
-0.0159171447,
-0.0440624282,
-0.02141615,
-0.0410193391,
0.0606540442,
-0.0122337416,
-0.0539866723,
0.026313493,
0.0278727058,
0.0226290412,
-0.0224254802,
0.0101994975,
-0.0237091351,
-0.0026053763,
0.0236113463,
-0.0346438214,
0.0035230753,
0.0014198025,
0.0621255673,
-0.0364041366,
-0.0194613282,
-0.0062173558,
-0.0219410956,
0.0094232466,
0.0358339511,
-0.0252220463,
0.0518152677,
-0.0209811945,
-0.000104098,
-0.0546189994,
0.0298570357,
-0.0161450058,
-0.0147301722,
0.0183098353,
-0.0108614424,
-0.0380153656,
0.0315411277,
0.0023947377,
-0.0693056881,
0.0005203289,
-0.0045417831,
0.0257578827,
0.0234481934,
-0.0480341725,
-0.0283260811,
-0.0410584211,
-0.0009191266,
0.0299659055,
-0.0429565944,
0.0161478184,
0.0249500871,
2.702e-7,
-0.0147835631,
0.0424476489,
0.0177859496,
0.0333811268,
-0.0013458702,
0.0402473211,
-0.0284295119,
-0.007997456,
-0.0266229995,
-0.0276000928,
0.0583118908,
0.0488359891,
0.0152908843,
0.0460781008,
-0.0772396252,
0.0002498758,
-0.0086036725,
-0.0034304445,
-0.074278295,
0.0114866802,
0.0635608286,
0.0625254437,
0.0097464388,
0.0094082216,
-0.0032344146,
-0.0343769267,
0.0207627229,
-0.0604140721,
0.0037522514,
0.0405740254,
-0.0015109945,
0.0277051851,
0.0094990628,
0.021121949,
0.0088963136,
0.0085040601,
-0.0461161137,
0.0912481621,
-0.0120908637,
-0.0541518927,
-0.0126541136,
-0.0293488968,
0.019058872,
-0.0214086734,
0.0362100452,
-0.0028300723,
-0.032200031,
0.0191667024,
0.0152590536,
-0.0086124968,
-0.0417872444,
-0.0017590877,
-0.0046482179,
-0.001910308,
-0.0101847192,
-0.0221393965,
-0.0031305098,
-0.0909968838,
0.0222963784,
0.0050283228,
-0.0036459798,
-0.0145920953,
-0.0478139184,
-0.0077964566,
0.0056799306,
-0.0252318401,
0.0220346116,
2.094109207e-34,
0.024353819,
0.0346782617,
-0.0043050293,
0.0322468504,
0.0481297635,
0.0221015792,
-0.0220990926,
0.0284094457,
0.033955466,
-0.0392664596,
-0.0431229882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19413v1 | Saliency Attention and Semantic Similarity-Driven Adversarial Perturbation | 2024-06-18T14:07:27 | 2024-06-18T14:07:27 | Hetvi Waghela, Jaydip Sen, Sneha Rakshit | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce an enhanced textual adversarial attack method,
known as Saliency Attention and Semantic Similarity driven adversarial
Perturbation (SASSP). The proposed scheme is designed to improve the
effectiveness of contextual perturbations by integrating saliency, attention,
and semantic similarity. Traditional adversarial attack methods often struggle
to maintain semantic consistency and coherence while effectively deceiving
target models. Our proposed approach addresses these challenges by
incorporating a three-pronged strategy for word selection and perturbation.
First, we utilize a saliency-based word selection to prioritize words for
modification based on their importance to the model's prediction. Second,
attention mechanisms are employed to focus perturbations on contextually
significant words, enhancing the attack's efficacy. Finally, an advanced
semantic similarity-checking method is employed that includes embedding-based
similarity and paraphrase detection. By leveraging models like Sentence-BERT
for embedding similarity and fine-tuned paraphrase detection models from the
Sentence Transformers library, the scheme ensures that the perturbed text
remains contextually appropriate and semantically consistent with the original.
Empirical evaluations demonstrate that SASSP generates adversarial examples
that not only maintain high semantic fidelity but also effectively deceive
state-of-the-art natural language processing models. Moreover, in comparison to
the original scheme of contextual perturbation CLARE, SASSP has yielded a
higher attack success rate and lower word perturbation rate. | [
0.0721185356,
0.049729608,
-0.0122574819,
0.0651201382,
-0.0537119918,
-0.0089459913,
-0.0035800468,
0.000722709,
-0.0317831598,
-0.0567965284,
-0.0240832809,
0.0487610586,
0.0029383455,
-0.0288817771,
0.0571477972,
-0.0414224863,
0.073785305,
0.0254261773,
-0.019671984,
0.0203200839,
0.0327151902,
0.0188459922,
0.0384989642,
0.0276923366,
0.0120881097,
-0.0177626088,
0.0177642535,
0.0478225611,
0.0531778596,
-0.0233952198,
0.0628877804,
0.0464656316,
-0.0058322973,
0.0533857793,
0.0000019425,
-0.021686729,
-0.0404664725,
-0.0051692361,
0.0272329785,
0.0692431778,
0.07295008,
-0.0371569246,
0.0007476052,
-0.0196738075,
-0.0332356356,
0.0302063283,
0.0288481023,
0.0473839939,
0.0683168769,
0.0699675828,
-0.0159055144,
-0.0261887647,
-0.0077270861,
-0.0412633121,
-0.0267768539,
-0.0569185913,
0.0338440835,
-0.0452748276,
-0.0228521023,
0.0374634303,
-0.000112659,
0.0328705236,
-0.0049541476,
0.0249232817,
0.0482180417,
0.0160477441,
-0.0359711088,
0.0130190449,
0.0071469117,
0.0686951652,
-0.0615873747,
-0.0581992269,
0.0061953031,
0.006705184,
-0.0016241727,
0.0385684893,
-0.0114374375,
-0.0311791971,
0.0191220324,
0.0097831627,
0.0090742391,
0.0081168404,
0.0285664406,
0.0491842031,
-0.0095188487,
-0.0226604231,
0.0465695001,
-0.0587590151,
-0.0272505041,
-0.0479648598,
-0.0656761527,
-0.0193463396,
0.0294537265,
-0.0093421778,
-0.0007756238,
0.0103523424,
-0.1198103428,
-0.0649978891,
0.0439602062,
-0.0817583278,
0.0476546846,
-0.0131739369,
-0.0316325575,
0.0458635092,
-0.031077804,
0.0485791266,
-0.0159977376,
0.0602249764,
-0.0498656742,
-0.0022211974,
-0.0088795228,
0.0077861035,
-0.0203785952,
0.0149417054,
-0.0200509802,
-0.034208402,
-0.0180971567,
0.0118744839,
-0.0113043087,
0.0261088908,
-0.0326016285,
0.0431917161,
-0.0410121381,
0.0084929718,
0.0154833971,
-0.0294556748,
-0.0291459281,
0.0050901454,
-0.0479384176,
-0.0424332432,
-0.0477981418,
0.0475858785,
-0.0087256096,
-0.0455909073,
-0.0026395272,
0.0509268232,
0.0089321136,
-0.0623431914,
-0.0502036586,
-0.0173216984,
-0.0383851565,
-0.0211281832,
-0.0216106623,
-0.0314952768,
-0.0045305002,
-0.0371069498,
-0.0282675698,
-0.0488887653,
0.0032708806,
0.0426779948,
-0.0568415038,
0.0803893134,
0.0261164065,
-0.0673801154,
-0.0145532563,
0.0227348432,
0.0053744065,
0.0311140846,
0.0042620176,
0.0695747733,
0.055128213,
0.0193350688,
-0.0118178781,
-0.0008566329,
0.0333044007,
0.0230344087,
-0.0389692597,
0.0055138827,
0.005646111,
-0.0143281966,
0.008799158,
0.0534758233,
-0.0131711764,
-0.0905276537,
0.1021853462,
0.0561719127,
-0.0458512008,
0.0748188421,
0.0084286379,
0.0475175381,
-0.0230570007,
0.0410786457,
-0.0648282617,
0.0132508008,
-0.0601708442,
-0.0018963569,
0.0228303038,
0.0228511654,
0.001136369,
-0.0172108095,
-0.0212698728,
0.0040982813,
0.0167815387,
-0.0012282847,
0.0136317015,
0.0581662245,
-0.058793284,
0.0568964407,
0.0073964535,
-0.0219122712,
-0.0274521317,
-0.0132259633,
-0.0171588846,
0.0552457571,
0.08980719,
-0.0660802573,
0.0175722037,
-0.0186361987,
0.0065531442,
0.0385554209,
0.0382598825,
0.0094025452,
0.0012071158,
-0.0269568395,
-0.0149352755,
-0.0856386721,
0.0189107191,
0.0203061122,
0.0256239474,
-0.0015216285,
0.0382034332,
-0.0164695326,
-0.0046290555,
0.0541851968,
0.0337128267,
-0.0433239527,
-0.0039772652,
0.0140039548,
0.0397278965,
0.0035860594,
-0.0322042815,
0.0381227694,
0.0372793712,
-0.0342878215,
0.0039656945,
0.0120067159,
-0.0125770187,
-0.0513373874,
-0.0137595022,
-0.0406593122,
-0.0144231906,
0.083416082,
-0.0320325941,
0.0314905941,
0.0527786128,
-0.0813054517,
0.045773752,
-0.0369616412,
0.0324376673,
-0.044899933,
0.0487360433,
-0.0443137176,
0.0826193765,
-0.0228937119,
0.0064331088,
0.0039097313,
0.04598758,
0.0209984295,
-0.0283217113,
-0.0259262864,
-0.010577661,
-0.0018416035,
-0.0232960954,
0.0332656763,
-0.0082424702,
-0.0149409231,
-0.0358494967,
-0.0509701446,
-0.0225079544,
-0.0323688872,
0.0056535676,
0.0472845323,
0.0004778981,
0.0097955074,
-0.0141398162,
0.0239995588,
-0.0120947724,
-0.0660514534,
0.0148346126,
0.0430538394,
-0.038317021,
0.0043361834,
-0.0499331616,
0.0052704494,
0.0039615324,
0.0654825643,
0.0107964426,
-0.0002133557,
-0.0295874774,
0.0091094701,
-0.0279014744,
0.0420820862,
-0.0069308765,
-0.0324470699,
-0.0042881286,
0.0248543732,
0.0091364225,
0.0802557915,
0.0453517586,
0.04569076,
0.0196670406,
0.0440971367,
-0.0188938454,
-0.0108528631,
0.0083633577,
0.0318458341,
-0.0085590193,
-0.0291309822,
0.0683110133,
0.0347426385,
0.0292508155,
0.0011384739,
-0.0178779513,
0.0572531,
0.0104794037,
-0.0307449978,
0.0342661999,
0.0101469308,
-0.0312221646,
-0.0491387919,
-0.0452242866,
-0.0525328629,
0.1016041785,
-0.0285709929,
0.0128546627,
-0.0846663788,
-0.0136041855,
0.0193614662,
0.0288674291,
-0.0123291006,
0.0226181615,
-0.0110379281,
0.0050576376,
-0.0307095926,
-0.048250746,
0.0581760071,
-0.0017652581,
0.0494375825,
-0.0059384876,
0.0104560871,
0.0264580436,
-0.0213527512,
-0.0687778145,
-0.0967300311,
-0.0156449452,
0.0009214607,
0.0167589802,
-0.0056671295,
-0.0664652288,
-0.0515145883,
0.0009958687,
0.0250933021,
-0.0108923232,
-0.0004260267,
-0.0392964557,
0.0357706882,
0.0764667094,
-0.0480421223,
0.0333271362,
-0.0015925495,
-0.0018468011,
0.0811577141,
-0.0027778873,
0.0075010057,
-0.0277714562,
-0.026959382,
-0.0009508953,
-0.0360222198,
0.0207701717,
-0.0157639217,
0.0071011004,
-0.0385952704,
-0.0155742653,
0.0718183294,
0.0233387072,
-0.0064542904,
0.0438002199,
0.0022843296,
0.0178889651,
0.0241289828,
0.0064003067,
-0.0381206535,
-0.059721496,
-0.0041114273,
0.0212079603,
-0.0091318246,
-0.0004211481,
-0.0550135076,
-0.0452286787,
-0.0047201216,
0.003133022,
-0.0253144577,
-0.0299475249,
-0.0364956185,
0.0198418982,
0.0013266682,
0.0144247711,
-0.008791999,
0.0036280879,
-0.019458808,
-0.0644372106,
0.0194110461,
-0.0235308502,
-0.0026188821,
-0.0286762919,
-0.0214576907,
0.0994507,
0.0580054559,
-0.0032684514,
-0.0436364301,
0.0179306176,
-0.0343312807,
-0.0087151583,
-0.0026403531,
0.0443968847,
-0.028551979,
0.0008602735,
0.0079081338,
0.0440637358,
0.0121200345,
-0.0222138483,
-0.0020946173,
-0.0017221858,
0.0080924872,
-0.0267816391,
-0.0297330488,
0.0281961542,
0.0199350584,
0.0765331686,
0.0337534212,
-0.0211099293,
-0.053906668,
-0.0254841466,
-0.0087328115,
-0.0483672582,
-0.017304454,
-0.0019894689,
-0.005840471,
-0.0134374285,
-0.0800545514,
-0.0349967591,
-0.0441918746,
-0.021018846,
0.0061566872,
0.020400906,
-0.0139936963,
-0.0117709534,
-0.0245701373,
0.0140075646,
-0.0124348719,
0.0417025462,
0.010813578,
-0.0162112452,
0.0107992683,
-0.0303212907,
-0.0143243466,
-0.0156012373,
-0.0743505508,
-0.0381706208,
-0.0176354721,
0.0326786004,
-0.0042326292,
0.0595024563,
-0.0557223558,
-0.0555505455,
0.0553141423,
0.0229874868,
-0.01210975,
0.0480165854,
0.0514639914,
-0.0112273423,
0.030029824,
0.0603350252,
-0.0221176185,
0.0163744912,
0.0718198046,
0.0059381775,
0.0061204452,
0.0143652717,
0.0113858404,
-0.0144978212,
0.0320530012,
0.0176899098,
0.0204291157,
0.0052088094,
0.0200137701,
0.0188135542,
-0.0226351712,
-0.0280914139,
0.0079042539,
-0.0110729709,
-0.0032907857,
-0.0125423232,
0.0114543429,
-0.0509904101,
-0.0013875053,
-0.0594146214,
0.0174298957,
-0.001691427,
0.0099420622,
-0.0069930963,
0.020237498,
-0.0443886928,
0.0074242256,
-0.0348374136,
0.0373436324,
-0.0113716926,
0.0295573901,
0.0237717964,
-0.0541937798,
-0.0219650567,
0.02748782,
-0.0721954778,
0.0243365932,
-0.0325718671,
0.03354121,
0.0238019805,
-0.0398796163,
0.0261968523,
-0.016191816,
-0.0152004296,
-0.0111350697,
0.0084136864,
0.0117252283,
-0.027166307,
-0.01602556,
0.0103679551,
0.0070143389,
0.0468166545,
0.0563223176,
-0.0129001625,
0.022184914,
0.0357653722,
-0.0409950353,
-0.0504818521,
-0.0433049388,
0.0378129631,
0.0585156716,
-0.0293065663,
0.019866189,
-0.0326600783,
-0.0490327813,
0.0420749821,
-0.0246858262,
-0.0109422849,
0.0120812207,
0.0242610313,
0.0534796827,
-0.0347250886,
0.0027399408,
-0.0372782834,
0.0411274023,
0.0317763761,
-0.0523878299,
-0.0162460506,
-6.126006157e-33,
0.0141599234,
-0.0180942323,
-0.0503788143,
-0.030747043,
0.0145901609,
0.010293941,
-0.0506802201,
-0.0522921793,
-0.0444861725,
0.0141973523,
0.0092012724,
0.0378791131,
-0.018926803,
0.0447531305,
-0.0460174084,
-0.05923656,
0.0530444719,
0.0274391118,
-0.0341458283,
-0.003529985,
0.0322084837,
0.017314123,
0.0594099574,
-0.0567452423,
0.023188781,
-0.004772298,
-0.0111084161,
-0.0170165952,
-0.0114982845,
0.043834541,
0.002492409,
0.0400808081,
0.0064277188,
-0.0008153094,
-0.0157205164,
0.0195057578,
-0.0230011605,
-0.0134906359,
0.0191261116,
-0.0179396328,
-0.0320109911,
-0.0368555784,
0.0393752158,
-0.0190191027,
0.0186254308,
-0.0126715247,
0.0353186503,
-0.0353355147,
-0.0323179588,
0.0189773366,
-0.0784881264,
0.0179986339,
-0.0096899746,
-0.0144025991,
0.0037161929,
0.0509391241,
0.0361248851,
0.0632295609,
-0.0480535291,
0.007255285,
-0.0016951403,
0.0128203649,
0.0240777824,
-0.0089495666,
0.0185016077,
0.073489897,
-0.0026568878,
-0.0170146581,
0.0137390196,
-0.0343705341,
-0.0066505382,
0.0462859981,
0.0794645101,
0.0635000542,
0.0491534621,
-0.0155588817,
-0.0564432591,
-0.0268999692,
0.0265395008,
0.0221086331,
0.0701362565,
0.0148891732,
-0.0563204475,
0.0037894354,
-0.0110347923,
-0.018236693,
-0.0496617332,
-0.007072839,
0.0169617981,
0.0291471444,
-0.0609413683,
0.0693511516,
-0.0233456269,
-0.0362827256,
0.0172400102,
0.0314396955,
-0.0283754021,
-0.0479018614,
0.0216816328,
0.015248714,
-0.0017661956,
0.0199179165,
0.0410973877,
-0.0541278906,
0.0105395252,
0.0020583828,
0.0695943087,
-0.0292630866,
-0.0279765297,
-0.0171527509,
-0.0132799773,
-0.02676454,
-0.0041325362,
-0.0426280797,
0.0298277121,
0.0104896408,
-0.0180961564,
0.0331778489,
0.0381335355,
-0.0024633408,
-0.0145267714,
0.0273939986,
-0.01148206,
0.0211831797,
-0.0168139171,
-0.0284465384,
-0.0080124093,
0.0175572746,
-0.0012845077,
-0.0872111693,
-0.0021249224,
-0.0227982495,
2.795e-7,
0.0161335878,
0.0468802825,
-0.0114049306,
-0.0524737723,
0.0187392645,
0.0425319895,
0.035397917,
0.0855754018,
-0.0470842496,
-0.0149710979,
-0.0146937696,
0.017296508,
0.0583938509,
-0.0223323964,
-0.0793811679,
0.0236102212,
-0.0732033923,
0.0076464224,
-0.0373785831,
-0.0226183776,
0.0403731242,
0.1136602238,
0.0519815758,
0.0004320277,
0.0076987469,
-0.0506727807,
0.0135740303,
-0.0228066053,
0.0067400066,
-0.00931531,
0.0140581112,
-0.0100972317,
-0.0117009925,
0.0047626421,
-0.0453478321,
0.0047278376,
0.0481120124,
0.0432541929,
-0.0158397276,
-0.0435371697,
-0.0550345406,
-0.0261805113,
0.0126920454,
-0.0690979883,
0.086540699,
-0.0369235799,
-0.0141672092,
-0.0215914808,
-0.038461037,
0.0235875677,
0.0325186662,
-0.0252079759,
-0.0581189245,
-0.005923396,
0.0155270034,
0.031152077,
-0.0364082158,
-0.0619662702,
-0.0039968952,
-0.0002239364,
-0.0401656702,
-0.0017100805,
-0.0412733257,
-0.0128655881,
0.0733502135,
-0.0311229136,
0.0200747009,
2.477692529e-34,
0.0349548981,
-0.0191227216,
0.0033312526,
-0.0141854566,
0.017396193,
0.0067084911,
0.039794337,
-0.0099371877,
0.0228708405,
-0.0296625905,
-0.0239965487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12629v1 | SeTAR: Out-of-Distribution Detection with Selective Low-Rank Approximation | 2024-06-18T13:55:13 | 2024-06-18T13:55:13 | Yixia Li, Boya Xiong, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is crucial for the safe deployment of
neural networks. Existing CLIP-based approaches perform OOD detection by
devising novel scoring functions or sophisticated fine-tuning methods. In this
work, we propose SeTAR, a novel, training-free OOD detection method that
leverages selective low-rank approximation of weight matrices in
vision-language and vision-only models. SeTAR enhances OOD detection via
post-hoc modification of the model's weight matrices using a simple greedy
search algorithm. Based on SeTAR, we further propose SeTAR+FT, a fine-tuning
extension optimizing model performance for OOD detection tasks. Extensive
evaluations on ImageNet1K and Pascal-VOC benchmarks show SeTAR's superior
performance, reducing the false positive rate by up to 18.95% and 36.80%
compared to zero-shot and fine-tuning baselines. Ablation studies further
validate our approach's effectiveness, robustness, and generalizability across
different model backbones. Our work offers a scalable, efficient solution for
OOD detection, setting a new state-of-the-art in this area. | [
-0.0319418907,
0.0372277945,
0.0278931726,
0.0785037726,
0.0258162245,
-0.0077962279,
-0.0334985033,
0.0316118672,
-0.0149495788,
0.0177798718,
0.0114506725,
-0.0229418557,
0.0195301566,
0.028752327,
0.0261595435,
0.0524540879,
0.0326122008,
-0.0287489742,
-0.0282242801,
0.0066154823,
-0.0269150194,
-0.0004738487,
-0.0087246215,
0.0285828598,
0.0189623144,
-0.0313995853,
0.0000585617,
0.0526915528,
0.0405804999,
0.0023203713,
-0.001743361,
-0.0146926278,
0.0156003339,
0.0289811045,
0.0000022999,
0.010864513,
-0.0191503558,
0.0288634021,
-0.000434512,
0.0035672782,
-0.0042969869,
-0.0193963535,
-0.0420587584,
0.0329767205,
0.0031781138,
0.0407373272,
0.0866417214,
0.0097347964,
0.0079944516,
0.0753634647,
-0.0020196508,
0.0604714602,
0.0362438299,
-0.0194050167,
-0.0395170227,
-0.0233083311,
-0.0079229465,
-0.0085506244,
-0.0577023327,
-0.0436678603,
-0.0175089203,
0.0329369269,
0.0069546937,
0.0352508388,
-0.0009231558,
0.039522361,
-0.0671429932,
0.0117124366,
-0.0048826532,
0.0620556511,
-0.1398904026,
-0.0173819158,
0.0088713048,
-0.0621928349,
0.0185834002,
-0.0445529819,
0.0056061195,
0.0284827538,
0.0277810004,
0.0402055122,
-0.070830524,
0.0328427516,
0.0317615978,
0.0071921586,
-0.0506709591,
0.0256252922,
-0.0232364479,
0.0227616578,
-0.0080157164,
-0.010678485,
-0.0667805597,
-0.0251696818,
-0.0115888342,
-0.0012683474,
0.0064696162,
-0.0103244297,
-0.0855063275,
-0.0526672043,
-0.0135603622,
-0.0746648312,
0.0941411108,
0.0231523775,
-0.0684403852,
0.0082979156,
-0.0580841526,
0.0399749242,
-0.0467213616,
0.0343104973,
-0.0132254642,
0.0127290701,
0.0127644017,
0.0377284475,
-0.004777872,
0.0226019509,
-0.0269983783,
-0.0588472076,
-0.0142397396,
-0.0191454198,
-0.0287570599,
0.0076540313,
-0.0229995288,
0.0459229797,
-0.0168114305,
-0.0152198318,
0.0295220744,
0.0002137032,
0.0574176461,
-0.016859727,
-0.0273241345,
-0.0426541716,
-0.0492104739,
0.0647853091,
-0.0252575688,
0.0207655896,
0.0160352457,
0.0774279833,
-0.0026397046,
-0.0522281788,
-0.0029652715,
-0.0041946177,
-0.020101808,
-0.0243767966,
0.0417264812,
-0.0645901263,
-0.0567469113,
-0.0294314343,
0.034737289,
-0.056410782,
0.0490596257,
0.0423415937,
-0.0361223295,
0.0186693948,
-0.0369833969,
-0.0153884357,
-0.0394756347,
0.0022585997,
0.0086050872,
0.0922890157,
0.0116551463,
0.0192663148,
0.0130083235,
0.0277990215,
0.0307193752,
0.0632757768,
0.0032486788,
0.022602696,
-0.0673378408,
-0.0114261601,
-0.0001591894,
-0.015644718,
0.0572999828,
0.008972642,
-0.0091934409,
-0.0503121205,
0.02865633,
0.006616591,
-0.0007896213,
-0.0158867557,
-0.0067231711,
0.002969142,
-0.0455273092,
-0.0351001285,
-0.0203664526,
0.0386913531,
-0.0426324159,
-0.0431196317,
-0.0558052398,
0.053089574,
-0.0303018466,
-0.0142702889,
-0.0310745053,
-0.0327148661,
-0.036548052,
0.038693998,
0.0546085835,
-0.0021417013,
-0.0098398458,
0.0385699533,
0.0136500383,
0.0093592973,
-0.0733935535,
-0.0989173055,
-0.0471117273,
-0.0211295374,
0.0469109081,
-0.0308679827,
-0.0062022479,
-0.0053417273,
-0.0031470277,
-0.0042533875,
-0.0461994,
0.0226062965,
0.0699708313,
-0.0483440123,
-0.021986695,
0.0084867841,
0.0160930194,
0.0159042031,
0.0083568608,
0.0254998375,
0.0229215119,
-0.0754883587,
-0.0539745651,
0.0430316739,
0.031859912,
-0.00095231,
0.0393988341,
0.0116825271,
0.0038814768,
0.0066980422,
-0.0270427875,
-0.0152510079,
0.0330797583,
-0.0237732679,
0.0098027596,
-0.0782486498,
-0.027180491,
0.0087335492,
0.037371587,
-0.027483603,
0.0060039368,
0.0669970512,
-0.0343419872,
0.0102583449,
0.0259508193,
-0.0466994978,
-0.0235321615,
-0.0453447811,
0.0031971075,
-0.0315584429,
0.0338194966,
0.0052214749,
0.0763035491,
-0.0425583869,
-0.0410970487,
0.0633445382,
-0.0159934536,
0.0651839152,
-0.0353119038,
-0.0597571917,
0.0072715017,
-0.0573292449,
0.018647857,
-0.025660675,
0.0616515651,
0.0288335029,
0.0064715776,
-0.0368693285,
0.0154003296,
-0.0305221807,
-0.0262623746,
0.0260108151,
-0.015944723,
0.0260092225,
-0.0443332344,
0.0102202604,
0.0466052331,
-0.005976378,
-0.0403749906,
-0.0138110481,
-0.0092896558,
-0.0252841078,
0.0311434306,
-0.0434832573,
0.0155364964,
0.0592769049,
-0.0637633353,
-0.0515475236,
-0.0646998659,
0.0661478341,
-0.0186186433,
0.0731354058,
-0.0135264378,
-0.0258315317,
-0.0124547174,
-0.0167269036,
-0.0292292237,
0.0929472297,
-0.0145125752,
-0.0278116465,
0.0869805142,
0.0567335375,
0.0000608967,
-0.0098524746,
0.0281186234,
-0.0092627294,
0.0279107057,
0.0376707464,
0.0010861653,
-0.0006950693,
-0.0158965625,
-0.0037536535,
-0.0406573936,
-0.008389134,
0.0042795395,
-0.0351921134,
-0.0577313378,
0.0034263462,
-0.0275631733,
0.0187520571,
0.0024900269,
-0.0021021545,
0.0153262047,
-0.0015593446,
0.0080095557,
-0.0037720052,
-0.0265728626,
0.0071073067,
-0.0432117954,
0.0093827536,
0.0297692865,
0.0208228305,
-0.004802682,
-0.0385501422,
-0.0592378713,
-0.0323057771,
-0.0265843961,
0.0416493863,
-0.0099748513,
0.0038779583,
-0.014315444,
-0.0388389714,
-0.0259518512,
-0.0458846651,
0.0170139521,
0.020765705,
-0.0607745424,
-0.0479313284,
0.0000202685,
0.01576625,
-0.0163087454,
0.0911597162,
-0.0374829583,
0.0038912704,
-0.024305189,
0.068940945,
0.043431554,
-0.0269684438,
0.0662962049,
-0.0304765832,
0.0058029979,
0.0587413423,
0.0171064399,
-0.0181045774,
-0.0740180016,
0.008727042,
0.0468083955,
0.0622508787,
-0.0140136974,
0.0704435334,
0.0234995745,
-0.0499296449,
-0.0116105909,
0.0027186435,
-0.0037227601,
-0.0650794879,
-0.0074767596,
-0.0374181308,
0.053154923,
0.0589906313,
0.0184686705,
-0.0554026514,
-0.0241781585,
0.0112531614,
0.0344066694,
-0.0204066634,
-0.0069979522,
0.0293037929,
-0.088905938,
0.0588685535,
0.0056328131,
-0.0386072583,
-0.0677138269,
0.0521825179,
0.0219790544,
-0.0186655726,
-0.0114128049,
0.0174057484,
-0.0093009267,
-0.030423237,
0.0110901706,
0.0018368383,
-0.038608849,
0.002235282,
-0.0412458852,
0.0159621798,
0.0688932538,
-0.0002258329,
-0.0325256027,
-0.0320257209,
0.026549764,
-0.0595874861,
0.0060767541,
0.0303076785,
0.0462568142,
0.019925205,
-0.0158523042,
0.0201664995,
0.0169399213,
-0.0109073846,
-0.0124786487,
-0.0295219142,
0.0430780537,
-0.0249736924,
-0.0137987826,
-0.0382276103,
-0.0020934264,
0.0296350177,
0.0160455257,
0.0082634771,
-0.0214625299,
-0.022889005,
0.0092337262,
0.0210062563,
-0.0268203132,
0.00071709,
0.0355236083,
0.0435771607,
-0.0611256585,
-0.0316049643,
0.0420402475,
-0.0367721617,
0.0410992466,
-0.0063454146,
-0.0567483082,
-0.0285117533,
0.0404020771,
-0.0348049067,
0.0279720109,
-0.0100124367,
0.0020587295,
-0.0188856833,
0.0697167143,
0.0178586449,
-0.0300319772,
-0.0309884045,
0.0698380098,
-0.0540691279,
-0.0261827353,
-0.0014468445,
0.0425468124,
0.021858491,
0.0001455247,
-0.0441204011,
-0.0233038235,
0.0941256508,
0.0544306561,
0.0395600908,
0.0452256948,
0.0398991518,
-0.1242129803,
-0.0204262268,
0.0222899653,
-0.0185186137,
0.0062540481,
0.0560773723,
-0.0217331536,
-0.0115815047,
0.0099037942,
0.0063002873,
-0.0251076594,
0.0575169325,
-0.0193137657,
-0.0180584732,
-0.0266394112,
0.0348502435,
0.0067996006,
0.011782906,
-0.0382737704,
0.067660749,
0.0279286336,
0.0176057462,
0.0058097029,
0.0382669084,
0.0356457755,
0.0156679768,
-0.0106092757,
-0.0182432365,
0.0049849562,
-0.0423303284,
0.0288394652,
0.0080485931,
-0.0192955788,
0.0320568085,
0.0047474932,
0.0167885385,
-0.0228680559,
0.0464652665,
0.0366336331,
0.005982188,
-0.0353640802,
0.0489170551,
0.0022096119,
-0.0523725897,
-0.072634995,
0.0326767117,
0.0371409878,
0.0227282923,
-0.0053141024,
-0.0060735145,
-0.014240684,
-0.0423054136,
0.0103062801,
-0.008915361,
-0.0031358062,
0.0055107847,
0.0171031617,
-0.0014042273,
-0.0081704929,
0.0502502322,
0.040860422,
0.0195957199,
-0.0301226582,
0.0047841016,
-0.0294492971,
0.0016657781,
0.0431493968,
0.0645447746,
-0.0232243203,
0.0179574024,
-0.01919288,
-0.0712122321,
-0.0202025399,
0.0420461707,
0.0105416859,
-0.0037651367,
0.0239966121,
0.0467956774,
0.0062141344,
-0.0111855492,
-0.0146523928,
-0.0818208084,
0.0016147299,
-0.0135877263,
0.0018835857,
-6.212144547e-33,
0.0068111257,
0.004584136,
-0.0220201015,
0.0070751556,
-0.0063557872,
0.0337225869,
0.0016198988,
0.0000795609,
-0.0064501213,
0.0080868034,
-0.0112588294,
0.0474943705,
0.0063134003,
0.0106310239,
-0.0243633296,
0.0109669454,
0.0223863628,
-0.0249644239,
-0.0135843409,
-0.0046355198,
0.0346137285,
-0.0072807092,
0.0059360848,
-0.0312369578,
-0.0751507431,
0.0311383884,
-0.0691885054,
-0.0065209405,
-0.0160899404,
0.0387495682,
-0.0095760245,
0.0318596326,
0.0151138231,
0.0050371736,
-0.0071513881,
-0.0196046717,
-0.0279867761,
-0.001565928,
-0.0304136984,
0.0043987506,
-0.001601974,
0.0078358958,
0.0463572182,
0.0158673096,
-0.0339992084,
-0.0393932797,
0.0425581262,
-0.03588029,
-0.0133643113,
-0.0080254423,
-0.0265625436,
0.0218536612,
0.0125706755,
-0.0452563204,
0.0440701135,
0.0180864744,
-0.0245771669,
0.0042300648,
-0.033746019,
-0.0238749534,
0.021178117,
0.0474566184,
0.0341328159,
0.0661150217,
-0.0324306674,
0.0754311532,
-0.0201167129,
-0.0350282192,
0.0206063781,
-0.0841791704,
0.0581578128,
0.0509502292,
0.0650634915,
0.0469480678,
0.0731176138,
-0.0115563106,
-0.0894715041,
0.0029682482,
-0.0508535728,
0.0140516674,
0.0422306024,
0.0020020311,
-0.0442620628,
-0.019311199,
0.0258127395,
-0.0578720011,
-0.0354282558,
-0.0045493767,
0.0309423115,
0.0471200906,
-0.0309221987,
0.0248424672,
0.0419429466,
-0.0594517067,
0.0969626755,
0.0208012369,
-0.0158979483,
0.0179603882,
0.0110014752,
0.0130339796,
-0.031680584,
-0.006848285,
0.0234117117,
-0.0003247996,
0.0262560099,
-0.0079443641,
0.0555469655,
0.0535043478,
-0.0311195757,
-0.0082286978,
-0.0296077598,
0.0532762669,
0.0022710818,
0.1282931715,
0.0258412492,
-0.0292623546,
0.0037337951,
0.0271515828,
0.0047894446,
-0.0001227261,
-0.0344478376,
0.0141999861,
0.0024023973,
0.0103370948,
-0.0600171648,
0.0055647646,
-0.0210975818,
0.0563881397,
0.0253320448,
-0.065040879,
-0.0350751057,
0.0403118283,
3.057e-7,
0.0084344251,
-0.0137894377,
-0.0398896299,
-0.0133731365,
-0.0115787284,
0.0507953912,
-0.0180838685,
0.0350641832,
-0.0188376438,
-0.0724925175,
0.0260059945,
0.019307863,
0.0358776972,
-0.029702723,
-0.0464287288,
0.0454104133,
-0.0314024501,
0.0110347718,
-0.0193782542,
-0.0508371927,
-0.0247160941,
0.0689145103,
0.0066476595,
-0.0580357499,
0.0251301769,
-0.0102104945,
0.019741958,
0.0166500006,
0.0428601801,
-0.060982056,
0.0159214512,
0.0492629334,
-0.0084258467,
0.0331333913,
0.0019392228,
0.0477100685,
0.0205780566,
0.0196979605,
-0.0248412602,
-0.0078217294,
-0.0074493382,
0.0555985235,
0.0048373016,
-0.0731812119,
0.0570811741,
-0.0131028015,
-0.0215221606,
-0.0554959886,
-0.0065583317,
-0.0080656847,
-0.0119419852,
-0.0526165292,
0.0226803254,
0.0072064279,
0.0200062897,
-0.0142390681,
-0.0208964199,
-0.0655692071,
-0.0271620322,
0.0134549178,
-0.0195135046,
-0.0455866233,
-0.0054331371,
0.0067818868,
0.0368707478,
-0.0408689976,
-0.054667227,
2.936386495e-34,
0.0312746651,
-0.0157009456,
-0.0143926889,
0.0077371048,
0.0056362571,
-0.0057993564,
-0.0294317119,
-0.013251015,
-0.039736174,
-0.0109532559,
-0.0083568692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12624v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12624v2 | Judging the Judges: Evaluating Alignment and Vulnerabilities in LLMs-as-Judges | 2024-06-18T13:49:54 | 2024-07-02T02:57:01 | Aman Singh Thakur, Kartik Choudhary, Venkat Srinik Ramayapally, Sankaran Vaidyanathan, Dieuwke Hupkes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Offering a promising solution to the scalability challenges associated with
human evaluation, the LLM-as-a-judge paradigm is rapidly gaining traction as an
approach to evaluating large language models (LLMs). However, there are still
many open questions about the strengths and weaknesses of this paradigm, and
what potential biases it may hold. In this paper, we present a comprehensive
study of the performance of various LLMs acting as judges. We leverage TriviaQA
as a benchmark for assessing objective knowledge reasoning of LLMs and evaluate
them alongside human annotations which we found to have a high inter-annotator
agreement. Our study includes 9 judge models and 9 exam taker models -- both
base and instruction-tuned. We assess the judge model's alignment across
different model sizes, families, and judge prompts. Among other results, our
research rediscovers the importance of using Cohen's kappa as a metric of
alignment as opposed to simple percent agreement, showing that judges with high
percent agreement can still assign vastly different scores. We find that both
Llama-3 70B and GPT-4 Turbo have an excellent alignment with humans, but in
terms of ranking exam taker models, they are outperformed by both JudgeLM-7B
and the lexical judge Contains, which have up to 34 points lower human
alignment. Through error analysis and various other studies, including the
effects of instruction length and leniency bias, we hope to provide valuable
lessons for using LLMs as judges in the future. | [
0.0702002719,
0.0103222784,
-0.0126964031,
0.0395959392,
-0.0385113731,
0.0141127361,
-0.0012063257,
-0.0012605948,
0.0105323857,
-0.05522158,
-0.0573433116,
-0.014265758,
-0.0100465482,
-0.0287891403,
0.0223574974,
-0.0178134628,
0.0575026907,
-0.0345386155,
0.0427143984,
-0.004102109,
0.0349444039,
-0.0058437441,
-0.0148691088,
0.0175222643,
0.001844096,
-0.0184580702,
-0.0002337034,
-0.0109823504,
0.0096745193,
-0.0240747612,
-0.0099567911,
0.0829627141,
-0.0071335509,
0.044782728,
0.0000019644,
-0.0618800223,
0.0234268904,
-0.0182052292,
-0.0406540446,
0.0488277525,
0.009833198,
0.0430892482,
-0.0203360375,
0.0150041897,
-0.04788642,
0.011960865,
0.0270028785,
-0.0059133801,
0.073322162,
0.0619675741,
0.0170413125,
-0.0137940003,
0.0281862598,
-0.0098277489,
-0.0003980586,
-0.053139329,
0.0002700172,
0.0724218413,
0.022070054,
0.0242335591,
0.0005446017,
0.0387483239,
0.0143374717,
-0.0118001942,
0.0165920742,
-0.0087491684,
-0.0463573448,
-0.0194524955,
-0.0042531025,
0.0747195482,
0.0626967251,
0.0031272506,
-0.0306265466,
0.0067639034,
0.0423141122,
0.0149856973,
-0.0118605038,
0.0324427038,
0.0075042788,
-0.0016296015,
0.0016685891,
0.0091709895,
0.0163490716,
0.0119341454,
0.005416621,
0.0912253112,
0.01766246,
-0.0610690787,
0.0316259488,
0.0242798291,
-0.0009317807,
-0.0644339472,
-0.0129143195,
0.0193997044,
-0.0480351821,
0.0446055904,
-0.0385788195,
0.0274722148,
0.0575940199,
-0.0696013719,
0.0056107189,
0.0516544916,
-0.0039999625,
0.0631248578,
-0.0029381192,
0.0911435932,
0.0239081942,
0.0555097573,
-0.0379821323,
0.0038246703,
-0.0399351977,
-0.0167918708,
0.0251346324,
0.0223306622,
-0.0102000674,
0.0007978659,
-0.0693168864,
0.0152642792,
-0.0210088082,
0.0512372963,
0.0402799919,
-0.0150850005,
0.0277948715,
0.0096207373,
-0.0691862851,
0.0385193825,
-0.0422429591,
0.026435161,
0.0045881984,
-0.0525511503,
0.0140328687,
0.0091247279,
-0.0207012184,
-0.0111292386,
0.012860789,
0.0479082353,
0.0020599384,
-0.0209919736,
0.0125553785,
-0.0324893817,
-0.053614296,
-0.0917468593,
-0.0403917283,
-0.0658921972,
0.0229136106,
0.0129305637,
-0.0123667009,
-0.0460085422,
0.0310318936,
0.042498596,
-0.007145064,
0.0622007698,
-0.0146144554,
0.0266210977,
0.0028435742,
0.0224967711,
-0.0322838239,
0.0466831736,
0.0335140005,
0.0006040293,
0.0309293699,
-0.0291632041,
0.0017055623,
0.0535765067,
-0.0119805168,
-0.007384141,
0.0163198393,
0.0299084298,
-0.003319714,
0.0733855069,
0.0040528779,
0.080014497,
0.0004575652,
0.0000038201,
0.0607378185,
0.0381481908,
0.0035245377,
0.011172547,
0.0090930108,
0.0014036429,
0.0414555557,
0.0218793787,
-0.0744831413,
0.0287338141,
-0.0661844313,
0.0283555109,
0.0243430436,
0.0162973423,
-0.0098140836,
-0.0711908638,
-0.0462172888,
0.0255596433,
-0.0291360188,
0.0177056175,
0.024399424,
-0.0216358714,
-0.0288274586,
0.0489477254,
0.0301364306,
-0.0636935979,
-0.0186486244,
-0.0484277233,
0.029729858,
0.0607734248,
0.0583859123,
0.0058249244,
-0.0541529357,
0.0225128699,
-0.0003443122,
0.0393530354,
0.0741879046,
-0.0036942807,
-0.0635310486,
-0.0571889877,
-0.0293263588,
-0.0171236135,
-0.0014140385,
-0.0015503734,
0.0308332257,
0.0067929481,
0.0070471414,
-0.0723660886,
-0.0438540317,
0.0288347919,
-0.0164119322,
-0.0324870013,
-0.071686767,
0.0072341422,
0.0277825613,
0.0242479891,
-0.00464903,
0.0213760696,
0.024316445,
0.004051853,
0.032454811,
-0.0332898386,
-0.0370738059,
-0.0089691505,
0.0732050538,
-0.0131449299,
-0.0306662284,
0.0326418132,
-0.0126297688,
-0.0392252207,
-0.0264605451,
-0.022300886,
-0.0017255164,
-0.0524024293,
0.0323196985,
-0.0089615453,
-0.0301245544,
-0.046445217,
0.0714086294,
0.0001519007,
0.0163557567,
0.0136213088,
-0.0052518197,
0.0219604634,
-0.0151557,
-0.0779751018,
-0.0034152698,
0.0019824279,
0.0145741748,
0.0168657415,
0.0070400182,
-0.0614391081,
-0.0420019887,
-0.0997205675,
0.0261247195,
-0.0168097895,
0.0197342373,
-0.0084360065,
-0.0213460065,
0.0045062886,
-0.0011440315,
-0.0706494078,
-0.0224013794,
0.0105461031,
0.0124390153,
0.0163772032,
-0.0033461626,
-0.0318500437,
-0.0433517545,
-0.001649495,
-0.0286725573,
0.0246989299,
0.0345266871,
0.0267496537,
-0.0314079225,
0.0637189448,
-0.057852082,
-0.0089898268,
0.0196789075,
-0.0090679945,
0.0406677388,
0.0218592398,
-0.0090423347,
0.0280475207,
0.0033372121,
-0.0013508652,
0.0572376251,
-0.0298867561,
-0.0693251118,
0.0129876966,
0.0509982109,
-0.0476142503,
-0.035208147,
-0.0430746488,
-0.0317009576,
0.0476688035,
-0.0082885502,
-0.0052216738,
-0.0549248345,
0.0250243451,
-0.0398827381,
-0.0191839468,
-0.0510966554,
-0.0220488161,
-0.0300723333,
0.0266849473,
-0.0180459712,
-0.0446971208,
0.086533241,
-0.0480952226,
0.0186171681,
-0.0363399945,
0.0267255194,
-0.0399141833,
0.0616537109,
-0.0295946524,
0.0141166374,
-0.0299486276,
-0.0162747912,
-0.0602126792,
-0.0009957309,
0.0157633536,
-0.0789963529,
0.0485633761,
-0.0591607019,
0.025987776,
-0.0104114795,
-0.038851656,
-0.0507202409,
0.013954171,
-0.0527693443,
0.0237718597,
0.0263323486,
0.0122550661,
-0.0172107723,
0.0130180027,
0.0051460913,
-0.017781755,
-0.0077659707,
0.0018292727,
-0.0139601892,
0.0382326618,
0.0301942062,
0.0300081968,
0.0309138428,
-0.0327271856,
0.0214149598,
0.0523720905,
0.0393842384,
-0.0197126791,
-0.0007050618,
-0.0116854394,
0.060296841,
-0.0517227873,
-0.0270390846,
0.0247765984,
0.0629808232,
-0.0471073836,
0.0131912678,
0.1319550872,
0.0507439077,
-0.0273357928,
-0.0096599041,
-0.007187027,
0.0208258815,
0.0171250515,
0.0203079619,
-0.0999706388,
-0.0434329398,
0.0118740816,
0.0234406441,
-0.002684189,
-0.0107107591,
-0.0055686883,
-0.1144474521,
0.0187708866,
0.0061630015,
-0.0383236334,
-0.0156801976,
0.0024733017,
0.0185378138,
-0.0127108153,
0.04876104,
0.0545237847,
0.0038567667,
0.0143848807,
0.0189968124,
-0.0284248982,
-0.0026991728,
0.0798664764,
-0.0611813366,
0.0940782353,
0.0446101725,
0.0255498905,
0.0030316487,
-0.0853994191,
0.0043373844,
-0.0193909872,
0.0131132537,
0.0151368529,
0.0083832303,
-0.0254116394,
-0.0014368774,
-0.0583233684,
-0.0154523226,
-0.0133659691,
0.0212531649,
0.0341708437,
0.069060795,
-0.01295033,
0.0202868748,
-0.0252244323,
0.0099547077,
-0.0340219215,
0.0986683145,
0.0089177741,
-0.04700673,
-0.0151603324,
-0.0072026248,
-0.0096060038,
-0.0236857329,
-0.052785065,
0.0286628306,
-0.0042376048,
0.0055695781,
-0.0504340753,
-0.0480114631,
0.0256106798,
0.0120472917,
0.0311673973,
0.0011251414,
-0.009996268,
0.02613727,
0.0056598787,
0.0397374257,
-0.0373070017,
0.0199529789,
-0.0506466702,
0.0127893547,
0.0092769954,
-0.0108840428,
-0.0135213388,
0.0238513146,
-0.0403884314,
-0.0535040908,
0.0110931965,
0.0438396446,
0.0273954067,
0.0012236036,
-0.005381464,
-0.037078727,
0.0147667266,
-0.0227216762,
-0.0316795073,
0.0309821051,
-0.0023705792,
-0.0176522583,
0.0006539299,
0.0171362273,
-0.0316500701,
-0.0103524989,
0.0035394938,
0.0528139398,
-0.0335547216,
-0.0690515265,
0.0492532104,
0.0526359826,
0.028752543,
-0.0085312789,
-0.014322632,
-0.0082180789,
0.0117412554,
-0.0419285148,
-0.0331071801,
-0.0238691848,
-0.021627605,
0.016929727,
0.0006189789,
-0.0115261311,
0.0143990042,
-0.0135986833,
0.0398717523,
-0.0321697034,
0.0193578545,
0.0225867573,
-0.0200574286,
-0.0258633588,
-0.0262208283,
-0.0255861562,
0.0223742537,
-0.0134092653,
0.0404004678,
0.008775739,
0.0732669383,
-0.003697433,
-0.0052601988,
0.0255412031,
0.0408530273,
-0.0311811548,
-0.0088709639,
0.0003794555,
0.0387324914,
0.0514274649,
0.0237405859,
0.0103031145,
-0.0019575506,
0.0152073707,
0.0013786193,
-0.0140096107,
-0.007366057,
-0.0155552011,
0.0471171625,
0.0416536853,
-0.0028201975,
-0.0122660128,
0.0518828891,
-0.0202184524,
0.0089137359,
-0.0376806892,
-0.0288863964,
-0.0290693454,
-0.034374319,
-0.0176940188,
0.0086265272,
-0.013524808,
-0.0402201526,
-0.0970832407,
-0.0480754934,
-0.0128014572,
0.0510038584,
-0.0186584927,
-0.011383866,
0.0229075979,
0.0753214508,
-0.0262630917,
-0.0502560027,
-0.0274490733,
-0.0248081516,
-0.0431784056,
0.0062816818,
-0.0007126487,
-6.093054847e-33,
-0.0580401272,
-0.0257884879,
0.056620013,
-0.0183382425,
-0.05292226,
-0.0113055762,
-0.0052317963,
0.0331075042,
-0.0458023436,
-0.0064506405,
-0.0204124488,
0.009233932,
0.000790733,
-0.0177682489,
0.029255528,
-0.0338626616,
0.0062041427,
0.0137353083,
-0.0264261831,
-0.0194502734,
-0.0031620127,
-0.0216885488,
0.0412109718,
-0.0419788174,
0.0882854015,
0.0119170705,
-0.0202398021,
-0.0044272947,
-0.0694037154,
0.0644038618,
-0.0016205978,
0.041590035,
0.0036043439,
-0.0475011468,
0.0169164706,
0.0200442877,
-0.0308808964,
-0.0145499399,
0.0752478391,
0.0216574855,
-0.0089673046,
-0.0546737574,
0.0479078293,
-0.0163452514,
-0.0676688477,
0.0138756437,
0.0306413434,
-0.0311783198,
-0.0077362955,
-0.0170991179,
-0.0369525328,
0.0284940545,
-0.0373707488,
-0.0206908248,
-0.013184757,
0.0177614577,
-0.002318874,
-0.0067858892,
-0.0594985411,
0.0333774015,
0.0155557636,
0.0196491703,
0.0959706828,
0.0034644282,
-0.0315455459,
0.0782823488,
0.0072329473,
-0.0116382865,
-0.0108492281,
-0.0374738239,
0.0072952146,
0.0547733121,
0.0733207837,
0.0415780284,
-0.0064820615,
0.0079161488,
-0.0594204962,
0.0262447596,
0.0063277595,
0.057154011,
0.0165176261,
-0.0000662267,
-0.1103556082,
-0.0070298593,
-0.0434570126,
-0.0066589415,
-0.0503311902,
-0.0411631316,
0.0503062494,
-0.0219237842,
0.0033262002,
-0.0142335668,
0.0074278261,
-0.0343169607,
0.0160970502,
-0.0022068648,
0.0019909593,
0.02367438,
-0.0293939281,
0.0272378828,
-0.0397385471,
0.021176869,
-0.0012287432,
-0.0063144849,
0.019921096,
0.0093776835,
-0.0021570425,
-0.0032261233,
-0.046569258,
-0.0145181706,
-0.0284473207,
-0.0151119661,
-0.0128164282,
-0.023659179,
0.0610899031,
0.0171780176,
-0.0087914709,
0.0143329194,
0.0083962353,
0.0148013076,
-0.0477113426,
-0.0341597423,
0.0072968123,
-0.0281416457,
-0.0082387943,
0.0042107496,
0.0056413184,
0.013552079,
-0.0366975591,
-0.013976045,
0.01077874,
0.0472275838,
2.708e-7,
0.06199627,
0.0674586669,
-0.0192396604,
-0.0033614887,
-0.0199630931,
0.0221310444,
-0.0281172302,
0.0028955417,
0.0506626926,
-0.0302949306,
0.0188066848,
0.0288759694,
0.0464899428,
0.0327446535,
-0.0852306783,
-0.0097212708,
-0.0475206599,
0.0082066152,
-0.0402847454,
0.0393530168,
0.072130166,
0.0614097528,
0.0048809689,
-0.0022293483,
-0.0275178179,
-0.0507867783,
0.0296119172,
-0.0178754982,
-0.0405931622,
0.031059999,
0.104762435,
-0.0198166445,
0.0005859797,
0.0715544075,
0.0213321466,
0.0379950814,
0.0284177493,
0.0677917078,
-0.005002684,
-0.030717697,
-0.0223964378,
-0.0116513651,
0.0010830053,
-0.0603907742,
0.0783112422,
0.0138486465,
-0.0235381704,
-0.0073756538,
-0.0468475185,
-0.0294798464,
0.0093529988,
0.019877471,
-0.0017691822,
0.0055088839,
0.0149950022,
-0.032586094,
-0.0326897725,
-0.0360175706,
-0.0329005234,
0.0116907684,
-0.0088219885,
-0.0968340188,
-0.0261799786,
-0.0332916528,
-0.0091633042,
-0.0948344916,
-0.0144502101,
2.272709732e-34,
0.0264954455,
-0.0264087189,
0.0499594696,
0.0152562642,
0.0225816276,
0.0324219018,
0.0030148046,
-0.009498301,
0.0151465135,
-0.098838903,
0.015237554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12621v1 | Growing Trees on Sounds: Assessing Strategies for End-to-End Dependency Parsing of Speech | 2024-06-18T13:46:10 | 2024-06-18T13:46:10 | Adrien Pupier, Maximin Coavoux, Jérôme Goulian, Benjamin Lecouteux | cs.CL | cs.CL | Direct dependency parsing of the speech signal -- as opposed to parsing
speech transcriptions -- has recently been proposed as a task (Pupier et al.
2022), as a way of incorporating prosodic information in the parsing system and
bypassing the limitations of a pipeline approach that would consist of using
first an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) system and then a syntactic parser.
In this article, we report on a set of experiments aiming at assessing the
performance of two parsing paradigms (graph-based parsing and sequence labeling
based parsing) on speech parsing. We perform this evaluation on a large
treebank of spoken French, featuring realistic spontaneous conversations. Our
findings show that (i) the graph based approach obtain better results across
the board (ii) parsing directly from speech outperforms a pipeline approach,
despite having 30% fewer parameters. | [
0.0158564691,
0.0602586009,
0.0118871788,
0.0462449491,
-0.0701719299,
-0.0236662198,
-0.0076793097,
-0.0412462503,
-0.002569112,
-0.0316622034,
0.0132736703,
0.0015308888,
0.0134689165,
0.060142111,
-0.0052635665,
-0.0652522296,
0.0314210914,
-0.0178084485,
0.0284268297,
0.0119097363,
0.0219744388,
0.0325947367,
-0.0233156197,
0.0134912971,
-0.0680330023,
-0.0162392743,
0.0009716497,
0.0362405255,
-0.017496299,
-0.022466857,
-0.0570417456,
-0.0026072247,
-0.0069837794,
0.0093117943,
0.0000018355,
-0.0345086865,
-0.048741132,
0.0039805071,
-0.0490341522,
-0.038545493,
-0.0006523673,
-0.0160181243,
-0.0211525597,
0.0116657931,
-0.0124936588,
-0.0301248971,
0.0079024835,
-0.0076612672,
0.0174879655,
0.0760452077,
-0.0355530828,
-0.0842080563,
0.0202993155,
-0.008255247,
-0.0280992873,
-0.0287312195,
0.0047640502,
-0.0132376738,
0.0437637717,
-0.0656505972,
-0.0530959256,
0.0227105729,
-0.0048801405,
-0.0429903492,
0.0763832405,
0.03649294,
-0.0245139692,
-0.0437794179,
-0.0201847237,
0.0816784203,
-0.0018601182,
0.0064794482,
0.0244232435,
-0.0300893039,
-0.0441697612,
-0.0208694004,
-0.0247064084,
0.0175533835,
-0.031576965,
0.0111942943,
0.030475527,
-0.0033496567,
0.0065773996,
-0.0875700042,
-0.0150063056,
0.0836083815,
-0.0226033628,
-0.0534173883,
0.0404536203,
0.005814679,
0.0011394001,
-0.0162503067,
0.0187805258,
-0.0657070428,
0.0081447558,
0.0228058323,
0.0205856059,
0.0231377333,
-0.0255708527,
0.019051021,
-0.0538951606,
0.0173263848,
-0.0620317012,
0.0070036147,
0.0469091535,
0.038044326,
-0.0264342614,
-0.0424482636,
-0.0416744687,
0.0378315821,
-0.069180645,
0.0017128915,
-0.0579325408,
0.014493118,
-0.0282087605,
-0.0404479466,
0.0029456755,
-0.0315331221,
0.0165393017,
0.0027418938,
0.0625943765,
0.0041058557,
0.0106391106,
0.0340755619,
0.0527914949,
0.0917399675,
-0.021313671,
0.0379258245,
-0.0349568725,
-0.0796107799,
0.0015025028,
0.0305122957,
0.0616242327,
-0.0092268949,
-0.0057906234,
0.0394639857,
0.0178026166,
-0.0068197669,
0.03534621,
-0.057545606,
-0.0320330672,
-0.0259895381,
-0.0117513351,
-0.0628054664,
0.0199199524,
0.0078020231,
0.0507749282,
-0.0016877542,
-0.002020793,
-0.012926097,
-0.0115762912,
0.0302073397,
0.0029557562,
0.0228376333,
0.0062528653,
-0.0176260676,
-0.0389438644,
0.0345655493,
0.0456208251,
-0.0324981809,
0.0151906284,
-0.0091429465,
-0.0214376673,
0.0308999084,
-0.0364313386,
-0.0389768071,
0.0028294409,
-0.0500946864,
-0.036732886,
0.0070241955,
0.0556980856,
0.0551196262,
-0.0222397689,
-0.0230794903,
0.0019173472,
0.0697781295,
-0.0420550779,
-0.0236308314,
0.0407250933,
0.0362892151,
0.0387231745,
0.0532666519,
-0.0273038875,
-0.057605058,
0.0376356766,
0.021546036,
-0.0575432666,
-0.0385931991,
0.0341094099,
0.0336707011,
-0.0072450712,
-0.0170258284,
0.0146481162,
0.0052686138,
0.0397170894,
0.0289097466,
-0.0275396276,
-0.0244384706,
-0.0167689454,
-0.0445304066,
-0.0233681723,
0.0253462922,
-0.0346482694,
0.0798010975,
0.0225616731,
-0.018135488,
-0.017355103,
-0.0191891138,
-0.0320667438,
0.0343811326,
-0.0367371589,
-0.0302542672,
0.0534548648,
-0.0097768335,
-0.0191266965,
0.0050057601,
-0.0120226191,
0.0357067436,
-0.0856466368,
-0.0246003121,
-0.0174424164,
0.0282527898,
0.0127371317,
0.0029304421,
-0.0002794069,
0.0047184532,
0.0077193882,
-0.0152113494,
0.0349921733,
0.062086165,
-0.0473866984,
0.028503038,
0.0221789163,
-0.0249688514,
0.0516541228,
0.0645049959,
-0.0765253082,
-0.0176162682,
0.0164446943,
-0.0502497181,
-0.0659403354,
-0.0052041104,
0.001947725,
-0.0645130128,
0.0249725319,
-0.0460507236,
0.0656653717,
0.0246967524,
0.0301046073,
0.027815612,
-0.0043991879,
0.0188773125,
0.0404323153,
0.0049656206,
0.0185146462,
-0.034927845,
0.0372015983,
0.0234830379,
-0.0815491751,
0.0060856077,
0.0276070517,
0.0210410971,
-0.0558150299,
0.0216986295,
-0.0241558086,
-0.0403282978,
0.0366615094,
-0.0818195865,
-0.0230376571,
-0.0236506052,
0.0528201908,
0.0082912548,
0.0168841425,
-0.0148083214,
-0.0492901206,
-0.0183002073,
-0.0138979834,
0.0106860334,
-0.0119310226,
-0.020389311,
0.0259112939,
-0.0684724972,
-0.0222479869,
-0.0053991778,
-0.027116999,
0.0136444224,
0.0222209003,
-0.0566703565,
0.0152702043,
0.0153280124,
0.0118197948,
0.044617638,
0.0183403101,
0.0100032296,
0.0185013581,
-0.0365269855,
0.0326370709,
0.0322392918,
-0.045413468,
-0.0138191013,
-0.0162897147,
-0.0369183756,
0.0104399715,
-0.0043231403,
0.0170545466,
0.0615804233,
-0.0650138408,
-0.0213708691,
-0.0359576084,
0.0529067889,
0.0489156842,
0.0360649079,
0.0188174602,
-0.0330954753,
-0.0214891434,
-0.0228982773,
0.0138192056,
-0.0603178032,
-0.0265110675,
0.0140947578,
-0.0437709615,
-0.0048648003,
0.0697823018,
-0.0453650653,
-0.0771261007,
-0.0161634963,
-0.0258863829,
-0.0049286969,
0.0824651793,
0.0669187829,
-0.030829709,
0.0414152071,
-0.1028204635,
0.0169248935,
0.0199203882,
0.0619976968,
-0.0259939376,
0.0041077859,
-0.060822133,
0.0217481796,
0.0107056927,
-0.0418846868,
-0.0093943253,
-0.0165741611,
-0.0447216928,
0.020070482,
0.0020757485,
-0.0274344552,
0.0399433747,
0.0279143341,
-0.0062599154,
0.0711469576,
0.0421985425,
0.0208012108,
-0.0095345872,
0.0718141943,
-0.0325042978,
0.006071548,
-0.0289522428,
0.0179401077,
0.0511644781,
0.0111993589,
0.0695405975,
0.0269930884,
-0.0304937772,
0.0270026848,
-0.0251733977,
0.0028712617,
-0.0781069845,
-0.030200189,
0.007758813,
-0.0515823811,
-0.0171160325,
0.0823235512,
0.0249695536,
0.0190910306,
-0.0007755366,
0.0344965607,
0.0208667833,
0.0414143614,
-0.0101104826,
-0.0592273735,
-0.0108593097,
0.0460674241,
0.0480026193,
-0.0166069176,
-0.0252669323,
0.016354952,
-0.0988712534,
0.0544678979,
-0.0167048182,
-0.0161357392,
0.0154164527,
-0.0558333844,
-0.0278775226,
-0.0358069651,
-0.0290374346,
-0.0002856133,
-0.0352984667,
-0.0186373591,
0.025117496,
-0.096898064,
-0.0415440574,
-0.0193513595,
-0.0125829596,
0.0030644787,
0.0672665909,
0.0223967619,
-0.0133189904,
0.025933383,
0.0470894724,
0.0041400944,
0.0082145454,
-0.0111597227,
0.0033737195,
0.0288117174,
-0.0005173922,
0.0382381789,
-0.0156996883,
0.0110489,
0.0276911017,
0.0321540162,
0.0550335236,
-0.0406296216,
0.0310308151,
0.0560867526,
0.0184506141,
0.0271892827,
0.013180593,
0.0327200815,
0.0243365895,
-0.056833569,
-0.0450970307,
0.0210651532,
-0.0441123694,
-0.0425089374,
0.0583071299,
-0.0014073611,
-0.0479778759,
-0.0587640069,
-0.0183013659,
0.0056604487,
0.0081238532,
-0.0182149019,
0.0258647986,
0.0664205924,
0.0233040284,
-0.0035658814,
0.0081882179,
0.0337447114,
-0.0085730432,
-0.0365542844,
-0.0382904336,
0.0378988087,
0.0063147428,
-0.0347813964,
-0.0011631624,
-0.0344126001,
-0.0422083102,
0.0310969613,
-0.035510093,
0.0193818118,
0.051407177,
-0.0324944183,
0.0059823464,
-0.0383454636,
0.0069938721,
-0.0439729206,
0.0004823726,
0.0311918035,
-0.058190506,
-0.0006642852,
0.0044652307,
0.0034096586,
0.0636458918,
-0.0383738317,
0.040510159,
-0.0387875065,
-0.0298602935,
0.0249339323,
0.0519812293,
0.0477563627,
0.0070442753,
0.0195849277,
-0.0305218957,
0.0360901728,
-0.0678480268,
0.0149661163,
-0.0176958665,
-0.0126689039,
0.0081800623,
0.0312286299,
0.0032378801,
-0.0134742418,
-0.0393464379,
-0.0122749228,
-0.0065582935,
0.0571915321,
0.0568837486,
-0.0240332317,
0.0155420154,
-0.0105297556,
0.0214928016,
0.0109372558,
0.0525031835,
0.0209768564,
0.0045412378,
-0.0060621216,
0.011115578,
-0.0192839615,
-0.0027985021,
-0.0334541053,
-0.0399308614,
-0.0081198355,
0.023904752,
0.0194394439,
0.0405588038,
-0.0243401919,
0.0912248418,
-0.0250244737,
0.0450050049,
-0.0248264726,
0.0192030463,
-0.0082415938,
-0.0471123457,
-0.0172140654,
0.0088717351,
-0.0241041984,
0.0326754041,
0.0511016883,
0.0493994243,
-0.0024257575,
-0.0029131873,
0.0266248155,
-0.0412622094,
-0.0458133817,
-0.034229897,
-0.0036187533,
-0.0344472975,
0.008237699,
-0.0413838141,
-0.0331740864,
0.0215364769,
-0.0213240702,
0.0545704216,
-0.010137137,
0.0513291806,
0.0017177282,
0.0110595981,
-0.0200407095,
0.0125480695,
0.0171306189,
-0.0324553922,
-0.0208338648,
0.0057108384,
-5.680945629e-33,
-0.0224701371,
-0.0233015344,
-0.0215448793,
0.0706565157,
-0.0587206557,
0.0282542147,
-0.0331048965,
0.0018710792,
0.022992786,
0.0153512964,
-0.0132128121,
0.0181200039,
0.0356173515,
0.035534028,
0.0525244139,
-0.0100609446,
0.0626071095,
-0.0451618508,
-0.0062152864,
-0.0037339656,
0.0408261083,
0.0761222169,
0.0057472987,
-0.0556477606,
-0.0007736504,
-0.0384939276,
0.0058236043,
-0.0036913115,
-0.0052194162,
0.0287442207,
0.0107027357,
0.0019417251,
0.0059318352,
-0.0303405765,
-0.0278425552,
0.0413224287,
-0.1312713623,
0.0244650915,
0.0048133065,
0.0709201843,
-0.0152715836,
0.0416978151,
0.0561545454,
0.0111943474,
0.0130622694,
0.0391412415,
0.0153910872,
-0.0296952464,
0.0051704426,
-0.0127445562,
-0.0383070447,
0.0386148877,
-0.0048332005,
0.0351398289,
0.0670210272,
0.058662571,
-0.0091255587,
-0.018560214,
-0.0184522178,
0.0291853379,
-0.0741757303,
0.0428841002,
-0.0134957582,
0.0081203785,
0.011734549,
0.0161338616,
0.0570020899,
-0.0992125943,
0.0161872711,
0.0081241438,
-0.0010892496,
0.0223638471,
0.0041688415,
-0.0348102525,
0.0517942272,
0.0018433849,
-0.0640504137,
-0.0568066724,
0.0696889982,
-0.0021068435,
-0.0561175533,
0.045146957,
-0.0180181209,
-0.0062549971,
0.0035661317,
-0.0298597347,
0.0161151886,
0.0139033785,
-0.0136902872,
-0.0003345832,
0.0269002225,
0.0287805647,
0.0452284999,
0.0163856577,
-0.0001458838,
-0.0039011303,
0.0160231814,
0.0706333891,
-0.0226391945,
0.0195441358,
-0.0536580384,
-0.0299001988,
0.0343351252,
0.0391978323,
0.0754981488,
-0.0438739024,
-0.0203601774,
0.0211805701,
-0.025603205,
0.0177127402,
-0.0151481386,
0.0335774198,
-0.056764435,
0.0544230714,
0.0719398186,
-0.0233434215,
0.0029243859,
0.0342598744,
-0.013874881,
0.0474115387,
-0.0177104156,
-0.0061005289,
-0.0120404782,
0.0261835605,
-0.0507788546,
-0.0154211419,
0.017582221,
-0.011808713,
0.0112564536,
-0.005066779,
-0.0164622217,
0.0289526451,
2.598e-7,
0.0137254922,
-0.0008091027,
0.117367655,
-0.01840166,
0.0623315424,
-0.0348535329,
-0.03854011,
-0.0016863145,
-0.0149651635,
-0.0384218991,
-0.0001918483,
-0.0435505025,
0.0685209557,
0.0299929604,
-0.1535485834,
-0.0179298855,
-0.0573391989,
-0.038748052,
-0.0311911721,
0.0144259334,
0.0149311163,
0.0679148361,
-0.0211497657,
0.0065686335,
-0.01507439,
-0.0023290082,
-0.0210872479,
0.0469451137,
0.0260341913,
-0.0597849749,
-0.0173967425,
-0.0236480106,
-0.0183848068,
0.0535905771,
-0.0096148038,
0.0170474332,
0.0113889584,
0.0296293292,
0.0028406072,
0.0157496389,
-0.0000293169,
0.0249916483,
-0.0188688561,
0.0350368954,
0.0239691269,
-0.0087115867,
0.0180258024,
0.0018355417,
-0.0724797621,
-0.0059422185,
-0.0167662743,
0.0162774064,
0.011681742,
0.0307547189,
0.011609314,
-0.0222897027,
-0.0125165172,
-0.0037703773,
-0.008898654,
0.0414455757,
-0.0352285393,
-0.0308236405,
0.0375003368,
-0.0076259719,
-0.0067323628,
0.0214728191,
-0.0581413731,
2.060711392e-34,
0.0090720681,
-0.0046857973,
0.0079683252,
0.0064300881,
0.0230534635,
-0.0429817475,
-0.0351119936,
0.0392078906,
-0.0080886567,
-0.0289302897,
-0.0201251563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12620v2 | What Makes Two Language Models Think Alike? | 2024-06-18T13:45:50 | 2024-06-24T06:34:35 | Jeanne Salle, Louis Jalouzot, Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Yair Lakretz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do architectural differences significantly affect the way models represent
and process language? We propose a new approach, based on metric-learning
encoding models (MLEMs), as a first step to answer this question. The approach
provides a feature-based comparison of how any two layers of any two models
represent linguistic information. We apply the method to BERT, GPT-2 and Mamba.
Unlike previous methods, MLEMs offer a transparent comparison, by identifying
the specific linguistic features responsible for similarities and differences.
More generally, the method uses formal, symbolic descriptions of a domain, and
use these to compare neural representations. As such, the approach can
straightforwardly be extended to other domains, such as speech and vision, and
to other neural systems, including human brains. | [
-0.0061894008,
0.0417946428,
-0.0548360012,
0.0463394634,
-0.0303450841,
0.0383503102,
-0.0250355657,
0.0361392759,
-0.0108572394,
-0.0431839824,
-0.0561960563,
-0.0280621033,
0.0238116812,
0.0269963387,
0.0645442903,
-0.073601298,
0.0262858439,
0.0030635467,
-0.0103660831,
-0.0070352773,
-0.0105623417,
-0.01915217,
0.0212757029,
0.0529622659,
0.008285488,
-0.0188135635,
-0.0070835054,
-0.0247786995,
-0.0228067078,
-0.0002247538,
-0.0171205439,
0.0194812212,
0.0136601962,
0.0484642275,
0.0000019061,
-0.0210540183,
0.0157105085,
0.0067732865,
0.0011271407,
0.0049745473,
0.012705747,
0.0074918433,
-0.0183937345,
-0.0015239874,
-0.0104019009,
-0.0535840057,
0.0872837231,
0.0316144377,
-0.0016376424,
0.0647199452,
-0.030418938,
-0.0522489361,
0.0438078679,
-0.0067914277,
-0.0346372128,
0.0054043839,
0.0039513437,
0.038809292,
-0.0152261592,
-0.0161862969,
-0.0407291614,
0.0147478869,
-0.0112194857,
0.0558554977,
-0.0107985921,
0.0568247326,
0.030541094,
-0.034241952,
0.0079558138,
0.0311689433,
-0.0343770459,
-0.056128405,
0.0219197106,
0.0324251801,
0.0047609922,
-0.0049956618,
-0.0118678156,
-0.0110048493,
0.0150103103,
0.0654268116,
-0.0242835078,
-0.0246587414,
0.0348602496,
-0.054426726,
-0.0284614582,
0.0383998342,
0.0304098632,
-0.0303999502,
-0.0375812724,
-0.0204628836,
0.0024087334,
-0.0675473139,
-0.0031161283,
0.0116312979,
0.0179581959,
-0.0064124237,
-0.0057013431,
-0.0148165505,
0.0208629426,
-0.0401229709,
0.0430633128,
0.0288789347,
-0.0367444009,
0.0021152631,
-0.0732231662,
0.1274997294,
0.002664333,
0.0704447404,
-0.0342919901,
0.0299632214,
-0.0995833129,
-0.0475340411,
-0.0167219583,
0.0294568464,
0.0252250005,
-0.05009415,
-0.0044148276,
0.0426343828,
-0.01825656,
-0.0071809008,
0.0358612463,
-0.0307530761,
0.0112785976,
0.0237553045,
-0.0358461775,
-0.0066158362,
-0.0341199599,
0.0214145165,
-0.024508521,
-0.045839183,
0.0094502708,
0.0197383128,
-0.0552710481,
-0.0042876108,
-0.0247475319,
0.0854095221,
-0.0094075063,
-0.0042825467,
-0.0179121885,
0.0315003768,
0.0010867768,
-0.0087657906,
0.0173469223,
-0.0498998314,
0.016405236,
0.0039233579,
-0.0007477741,
-0.0411050357,
-0.0146881267,
-0.0216302946,
-0.0115478029,
0.0673565865,
-0.0017198134,
0.0287997276,
0.0465243347,
-0.001861829,
-0.0065985513,
0.0535056144,
0.0542034917,
-0.0326427966,
0.0162227303,
0.0153043726,
-0.048539374,
0.0292445011,
0.0069834599,
-0.0153953899,
-0.0411249176,
-0.016557686,
0.0445211157,
0.0508501604,
0.0434356369,
0.0665650144,
-0.0559359305,
-0.0576930717,
0.0584680066,
0.0733672678,
0.0436606631,
-0.0009499908,
0.0310283508,
-0.0204132702,
0.0045800572,
0.0251164641,
-0.01041371,
-0.0050189984,
0.0242951903,
0.0171792135,
0.0088509424,
0.0271894373,
-0.030731516,
-0.0029468469,
-0.05423766,
-0.0356311463,
-0.0063234009,
-0.0639292374,
0.0366939679,
0.0215269458,
-0.0330342613,
0.0826928169,
-0.0190152302,
-0.0135808112,
-0.0337131582,
-0.0741729289,
0.013505294,
0.0012425752,
0.0184470136,
-0.0278127138,
-0.0010667694,
0.0224078782,
-0.0623408705,
0.0255889315,
0.0437859744,
-0.0173204355,
-0.0015333842,
-0.0452178307,
0.0079665557,
-0.0396149755,
0.0209872816,
0.0264801718,
-0.0018636847,
-0.0024302213,
-0.0060312753,
-0.0640777349,
-0.0186198857,
0.0352561735,
-0.0030465345,
0.0059039057,
-0.0192913562,
0.0204964466,
0.0256749317,
-0.0233310871,
-0.0249838755,
0.0369310789,
-0.016386617,
-0.0216456465,
-0.0256380159,
0.0220681876,
-0.0139170522,
-0.0198052563,
0.0499739349,
-0.0240815636,
0.0307822507,
0.0216853209,
0.0048521878,
-0.015387292,
0.0353146568,
-0.0613918602,
0.1037238836,
-0.0343129523,
0.0428655334,
-0.0534482226,
-0.031795688,
-0.0343062803,
0.081436649,
-0.01207723,
-0.0092167156,
-0.0301220641,
-0.0053502154,
0.0483952761,
-0.0088050431,
-0.0139461467,
0.0360588096,
-0.003632358,
0.0213338509,
-0.0155230621,
-0.048619248,
-0.0155362319,
-0.061902862,
-0.0668893903,
-0.0014959752,
0.0336795934,
0.0310321096,
0.0394001156,
-0.0098887188,
0.0028515942,
0.0037984469,
-0.0462832153,
-0.028286973,
-0.0467391759,
0.0388661139,
0.0378811583,
-0.0303155705,
-0.0262425523,
-0.0459774397,
-0.0254985504,
-0.0529105254,
0.0774853677,
-0.0526656508,
-0.0172482971,
-0.0483039431,
0.0133532323,
-0.0273593217,
0.0230488051,
0.0183615405,
-0.0458668396,
0.0423870087,
-0.0137927197,
0.0340438299,
0.0721392483,
0.0084206276,
0.0661848709,
0.0678550452,
-0.0056835739,
-0.0551581196,
-0.0288673323,
-0.0241995249,
0.0107104899,
-0.0301406067,
-0.0468687676,
0.0048996354,
0.0626133904,
0.0167019963,
-0.0047319583,
-0.0827044919,
0.0374083221,
-0.0115140043,
-0.0102062002,
-0.006105592,
-0.0356779546,
-0.0286082961,
0.031072747,
-0.0395943299,
-0.0475847945,
0.0585200898,
-0.0300895907,
0.014807811,
-0.0301166549,
0.0488870293,
-0.0245569088,
0.0471701995,
-0.0040095313,
0.0476186872,
0.0080176638,
-0.0533073917,
-0.0460183248,
0.0324475281,
0.0283477902,
-0.0240421314,
-0.0071433508,
-0.0169130396,
-0.0203090943,
0.0039999392,
-0.0298032854,
0.000557983,
0.0606593266,
-0.0255639106,
0.047301285,
-0.0402830504,
-0.0329451039,
-0.0370653085,
0.0590965822,
-0.0196235366,
0.0056703044,
-0.007597567,
-0.0042226259,
-0.0293249097,
0.0269632004,
-0.0095458124,
-0.0001134994,
0.0094840815,
-0.042242717,
0.0018588091,
-0.0052043265,
0.0138858901,
0.056183517,
-0.0617931485,
0.0316080227,
0.0324212722,
-0.0053639868,
-0.0487341732,
0.0070161768,
0.0222902857,
0.0167007521,
-0.0217801817,
0.1064494923,
0.0451039709,
-0.0224414524,
0.0421293378,
-0.0372442529,
0.0687410235,
0.0311165396,
0.0131537598,
-0.0319648162,
-0.0325127468,
0.0368395559,
-0.0054797232,
-0.0249726921,
0.0086901812,
0.0285401717,
-0.0971423835,
-0.0327354372,
0.0155120706,
-0.0310703479,
-0.0464889929,
0.0033547517,
0.0028181882,
0.0181078054,
0.0038917102,
0.0184138417,
-0.0024071229,
0.0038751527,
0.0230375212,
-0.0204373077,
-0.069073014,
-0.0048564966,
-0.0281223115,
0.066092141,
0.0966428295,
0.0580609553,
0.010261721,
-0.0495233722,
-0.0204490218,
0.0249300059,
0.0170685183,
0.0019258605,
0.067067571,
0.0403702743,
-0.0414984711,
-0.0072706216,
-0.0062011345,
0.0189956669,
-0.0087967729,
-0.0598360486,
0.054466594,
-0.0094707282,
-0.0458755456,
-0.0070226616,
-0.0299200006,
-0.0331640318,
0.0665454492,
0.0868467465,
-0.0057247682,
-0.0590729713,
0.0027152537,
0.0294606537,
0.0223811828,
-0.0256281123,
0.0108515946,
-0.0128732231,
-0.061496783,
-0.0945726559,
-0.0016354353,
-0.022872854,
0.0194626935,
0.0556084849,
-0.0630989894,
0.0227692518,
-0.0540055223,
-0.0621096194,
-0.0048120772,
0.0108540077,
0.0070212968,
-0.0607241653,
-0.0389145128,
0.0243291967,
0.0094894506,
-0.0472736172,
-0.0239225738,
-0.0449383408,
-0.0628804192,
-0.0244600736,
0.0220251661,
0.0189550109,
-0.0063075521,
-0.0143590719,
-0.0509479232,
0.0450714938,
0.0300459955,
-0.004078113,
0.0216406062,
0.0468102545,
-0.0678720027,
0.0127384253,
0.0402114689,
-0.0249217544,
-0.0006079548,
-0.0148612848,
0.0266200844,
-0.0196607746,
0.0194248948,
0.0238200799,
-0.0019162453,
0.0414150916,
0.0295950789,
-0.0252114721,
-0.0370074734,
-0.0021583994,
-0.0130800391,
0.0193327945,
-0.0392034054,
-0.0112687936,
0.0439914614,
0.0520540513,
0.0025009438,
-0.0106345117,
0.0054712514,
0.0179609079,
0.0095703136,
-0.0070906719,
0.0216816776,
0.0775993317,
-0.0228779409,
-0.0000372991,
-0.0185710862,
-0.002523432,
-0.0062196227,
0.0132472618,
-0.0541774817,
0.0377315283,
0.0448896885,
0.0197314695,
-0.0093455808,
0.0550882183,
-0.0172647592,
-0.077403456,
-0.025463298,
-0.0018371717,
0.0128854299,
-0.0096077938,
0.0726332292,
-0.0361577682,
0.0005281395,
-0.0245513581,
-0.0315615945,
-0.0219433922,
0.0053062658,
0.061234992,
0.0069338931,
0.0070044249,
-0.0350100622,
0.0719157979,
-0.0448823906,
0.0276213065,
-0.0682628229,
-0.0376285836,
-0.0101430314,
-0.0312207062,
0.0744110346,
-0.0100413719,
-0.0012996551,
-0.0252260566,
-0.0430779681,
-0.0638444498,
-0.0140533112,
0.0254732445,
0.036383789,
0.0122530758,
0.0424933061,
0.0424814336,
0.0291970577,
-0.0120890951,
-0.0227660872,
-0.0621510856,
-0.0135395946,
-0.0038560065,
-0.0078456225,
-5.859594689e-33,
-0.0329097621,
0.0169965848,
-0.0093441289,
-0.0171407815,
-0.0264883302,
0.0028023622,
-0.028212823,
-0.0130151389,
-0.0430149846,
0.0244377088,
0.0283931959,
0.0053189285,
-0.0069997311,
-0.0152167957,
0.0157735609,
-0.0097357966,
0.0143474881,
-0.0081350589,
-0.045521453,
0.0002577665,
0.044895824,
-0.0053405245,
0.0327471718,
-0.0481497943,
0.0077503207,
0.0617004335,
0.0166166257,
0.018467363,
0.0105570545,
0.0869122073,
-0.0430571362,
0.0215106811,
0.0141900703,
0.0110271405,
-0.0461285561,
0.0101268571,
-0.022415543,
-0.0491316877,
0.0294069741,
0.0031623067,
0.007378913,
-0.0287351608,
0.0533085056,
-0.0122682694,
-0.0388133079,
-0.025392523,
0.0397750959,
-0.0351166576,
-0.0106544495,
0.0007132253,
-0.0721083954,
-0.0011333504,
-0.012228433,
0.0011589727,
0.0642617494,
0.0252520721,
-0.0254313909,
0.0130424704,
-0.0320901573,
0.038812086,
-0.0055973292,
0.0768088773,
0.0551752858,
0.0418182462,
0.0430436209,
0.0815285295,
0.075278163,
-0.0691959485,
0.0006024791,
-0.0049700388,
0.0787653625,
0.0430784486,
0.0557396449,
-0.0289580561,
0.0077183614,
-0.0198206753,
-0.0331116952,
-0.0089505967,
0.0026586812,
0.006868911,
0.0082334308,
0.0339753926,
-0.0237075333,
-0.0190262515,
-0.0418913364,
-0.0564085357,
-0.0552073121,
-0.0220734123,
0.0358087756,
-0.0510264598,
0.0302991793,
0.0203815009,
0.0033867517,
-0.0324865729,
-0.00322531,
-0.042480506,
-0.0209989958,
0.0319852978,
0.0159047712,
0.0394112691,
-0.001945367,
-0.0699594393,
0.0089065433,
0.0450957194,
0.0637887344,
0.0392417312,
0.0079259779,
0.0084263114,
-0.0389377996,
-0.0008302833,
-0.0309353936,
-0.0956688076,
-0.0177686084,
-0.0319141448,
-0.0081075737,
-0.0141928075,
0.0039249579,
0.0042640739,
0.0343585312,
-0.0144023802,
-0.0365191177,
0.037356358,
0.0112008061,
0.050609082,
-0.0278206822,
-0.0323892199,
-0.0560963526,
0.037030831,
0.0644241348,
-0.0418014452,
-0.0285836589,
0.0432845987,
2.656e-7,
0.0330264233,
0.0535721034,
0.0557364039,
-0.0186273325,
0.0302476324,
0.0580755547,
-0.0328270942,
0.0544105209,
0.0189201273,
0.0136766322,
-0.0122363232,
0.0182506479,
0.032048326,
-0.0013610619,
-0.0513892435,
0.0376410447,
-0.0682783648,
0.0027081869,
-0.0580585226,
0.0056259702,
0.0455868989,
0.0556011014,
0.0333509333,
0.0002584923,
-0.0030667917,
-0.025451107,
0.062552169,
-0.0402448438,
0.0677295551,
0.0422174707,
0.0164798032,
-0.0059345169,
0.0133954929,
0.0334551148,
0.0052189394,
0.0239052754,
0.0366764963,
0.0133560989,
-0.0175775941,
-0.0277942941,
0.0159811415,
0.0019295152,
-0.0236367323,
-0.103465952,
0.0550398417,
-0.0403631628,
-0.0472526476,
-0.0048566703,
-0.0073727057,
0.0234094374,
0.0061650858,
0.0001108495,
-0.0448424481,
0.0343833342,
0.0337397531,
-0.0016684406,
0.0327442065,
-0.0395921916,
-0.0035526231,
-0.0009521052,
-0.0580895916,
-0.0414663255,
-0.0467223935,
0.0221026428,
0.0349571183,
-0.02611221,
0.0072042202,
2.517584491e-34,
-0.004221872,
0.006113294,
0.046562653,
0.0595290288,
0.0181581788,
-0.0283739902,
0.0331596024,
0.0042528217,
-0.0062988936,
-0.0369747132,
-0.0053094383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12618v1 | From Insights to Actions: The Impact of Interpretability and Analysis Research on NLP | 2024-06-18T13:45:07 | 2024-06-18T13:45:07 | Marius Mosbach, Vagrant Gautam, Tomás Vergara-Browne, Dietrich Klakow, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interpretability and analysis (IA) research is a growing subfield within NLP
with the goal of developing a deeper understanding of the behavior or inner
workings of NLP systems and methods. Despite growing interest in the subfield,
a commonly voiced criticism is that it lacks actionable insights and therefore
has little impact on NLP. In this paper, we seek to quantify the impact of IA
research on the broader field of NLP. We approach this with a mixed-methods
analysis of: (1) a citation graph of 185K+ papers built from all papers
published at ACL and EMNLP conferences from 2018 to 2023, and (2) a survey of
138 members of the NLP community. Our quantitative results show that IA work is
well-cited outside of IA, and central in the NLP citation graph. Through
qualitative analysis of survey responses and manual annotation of 556 papers,
we find that NLP researchers build on findings from IA work and perceive it is
important for progress in NLP, multiple subfields, and rely on its findings and
terminology for their own work. Many novel methods are proposed based on IA
findings and highly influenced by them, but highly influential non-IA work
cites IA findings without being driven by them. We end by summarizing what is
missing in IA work today and provide a call to action, to pave the way for a
more impactful future of IA research. | [
0.0593292303,
0.0513093621,
-0.0366769321,
0.0266575571,
-0.0131633198,
-0.0046592243,
-0.0247777794,
0.0046675489,
-0.0058978982,
-0.0754784942,
0.0216897968,
0.0595382191,
0.0107183307,
0.0210197121,
-0.0085974876,
-0.0265899766,
-0.0073331245,
0.0347850919,
0.0236410666,
0.0614150502,
0.0181059204,
-0.0067282831,
-0.0117209814,
0.083203949,
0.0329008624,
-0.0300257131,
-0.0130539276,
-0.0206810217,
0.0009853225,
-0.0527986847,
-0.0420226194,
0.0113846632,
-0.0110322665,
0.0536021553,
0.000002138,
-0.0357868671,
-0.0487623364,
0.0236210823,
-0.042726364,
0.0150666302,
0.0244510006,
-0.0088422056,
0.011399976,
-0.0284903795,
-0.0416690633,
0.0096322866,
0.0716480911,
0.0120985899,
0.0258477163,
-0.0042373468,
-0.0014656979,
-0.0225816779,
0.0066630822,
0.0279972628,
-0.0109742554,
-0.0310997199,
-0.0132009406,
-0.0007619451,
-0.0067670061,
0.04639576,
-0.0261094812,
0.0518312678,
0.0045040031,
-0.026661301,
0.0302925743,
-0.0218758062,
-0.0083603375,
-0.0445397049,
0.032046061,
0.0310887694,
0.0515688248,
-0.003517966,
-0.0061169956,
-0.0408677086,
-0.0190918073,
0.0574571304,
-0.0274587851,
-0.0000766929,
0.017680008,
0.0037448714,
-0.0090522468,
0.0509780422,
0.029578127,
0.0153457895,
0.0099119274,
0.0714851171,
-0.0476554669,
-0.0035263947,
0.0396918468,
0.0260779969,
-0.0042523108,
-0.0037607371,
-0.0103163328,
0.0159162991,
0.0065403064,
0.046838969,
0.0540662929,
0.0022540891,
0.0569399372,
0.0112364693,
0.0581247658,
-0.0188439097,
0.0057930853,
0.001328586,
0.0335591398,
-0.0077815712,
-0.0329706818,
-0.0086179376,
0.0028329967,
0.0194554646,
-0.0867864415,
-0.0278246626,
0.0064926064,
0.0208235681,
-0.0053592306,
0.0001473571,
-0.0189644862,
-0.0319820791,
-0.0688363016,
0.0011585073,
-0.0344849639,
0.0200592894,
-0.025527589,
0.0388184525,
-0.037789233,
0.0389502756,
-0.024881715,
0.0559739769,
-0.0405881144,
-0.036817424,
0.0262165572,
0.004588027,
0.0190972183,
-0.0370282568,
-0.0298724659,
0.0716828331,
0.0534791574,
-0.0217187423,
-0.0391864814,
-0.0849093348,
-0.0037960627,
-0.0252618473,
0.0073120892,
-0.0490363985,
-0.0179342814,
0.0488953069,
0.0314960629,
-0.055328086,
-0.0082332743,
-0.0043006609,
-0.0095970137,
0.0715774149,
-0.0273042992,
-0.0093570556,
-0.0525450669,
0.0161956027,
0.0270747524,
0.0708458796,
0.0079069687,
-0.0024948784,
0.0736288577,
0.0054738675,
0.019934902,
-0.0043119201,
0.0062553203,
-0.0299250167,
0.0298621152,
-0.0297833662,
-0.0961799696,
-0.0202004854,
-0.0126505829,
0.0074587315,
-0.0077447514,
0.0030083135,
0.0029014708,
0.0601838939,
0.0332412273,
0.0083435839,
0.0476545878,
-0.0065356926,
0.0190295801,
0.0001440423,
0.0187445153,
-0.0077544306,
-0.0045075649,
-0.0070842905,
-0.0230185613,
-0.0242944397,
0.0177420229,
-0.0855098665,
-0.0273736715,
0.0291417744,
0.025256319,
-0.0223467741,
0.0382001959,
0.0523967631,
0.0133401463,
0.0382608362,
-0.0057733334,
-0.0470593572,
0.0131560946,
-0.0294457655,
-0.0022752713,
0.0158122201,
0.0309335161,
-0.0269212853,
0.0479680561,
-0.0236646365,
-0.0410693511,
0.008457534,
-0.0271128602,
0.0102257254,
0.0231636651,
0.0106069455,
-0.019950591,
-0.0271982457,
0.0209078714,
0.0019387185,
-0.0076879505,
-0.0171729252,
-0.0409012102,
-0.0486248396,
-0.0830595195,
0.0279125199,
0.0023924799,
-0.0275248401,
-0.034829013,
0.0138637815,
0.0506185219,
0.0851358697,
0.0085194241,
0.0306876972,
0.0342664793,
-0.0153577318,
-0.0132047674,
0.0595571883,
0.0337084904,
0.0223131105,
-0.0051683122,
-0.0927391574,
-0.0382811874,
0.0103429453,
-0.0048695854,
-0.0045015211,
0.0534194671,
-0.041419927,
0.0403618589,
-0.0046679298,
-0.0070191915,
-0.0269732699,
-0.0092650428,
-0.0633200705,
0.0447291099,
-0.0229152311,
0.0401107594,
0.0042678225,
-0.0239353981,
0.0372836702,
0.037521597,
-0.0459750369,
0.0425724164,
0.0044116313,
-0.0021070517,
0.0652290359,
-0.0204910208,
-0.0697711483,
0.0192197394,
-0.0259324014,
-0.0021676659,
0.0089912564,
-0.0082671009,
0.0450241417,
-0.0116830515,
0.0393577293,
0.0279052332,
0.0377280526,
-0.0380589068,
-0.0342834853,
0.0009604229,
0.0555613562,
0.0305032469,
0.0323414691,
-0.0286390409,
-0.0264229085,
-0.0369715951,
0.0904056355,
0.0327990316,
-0.0090157446,
-0.0170753319,
0.0347999409,
-0.0114402222,
-0.0258843768,
-0.0044658892,
0.0053765373,
0.0271947272,
0.0354986638,
-0.0448407233,
0.0142441755,
-0.0381488688,
0.1131784096,
-0.0152742965,
-0.0072300122,
-0.0581293888,
-0.0162459854,
-0.0224894546,
-0.0164970104,
0.0058880299,
-0.0692589134,
0.0482723899,
0.0667711943,
0.0018557569,
-0.01471972,
-0.0349135064,
0.0141804386,
-0.0799408853,
-0.041427277,
-0.0581943877,
-0.0123192631,
-0.0117026856,
0.0714404508,
0.0155330785,
-0.0261338782,
0.0286072586,
-0.0080456845,
0.0013449597,
-0.0550303385,
-0.0129983593,
-0.0715899467,
0.1211815998,
-0.0104760369,
-0.0016961576,
0.0503372364,
-0.0436451584,
0.0103344843,
-0.020989513,
0.0000507546,
-0.011224106,
0.0958869979,
-0.0304437689,
-0.0078883106,
0.0033113668,
0.0239371043,
-0.0091136107,
-0.0005255271,
-0.0427547246,
0.0147064924,
0.0547768101,
-0.0161554851,
-0.0370615423,
-0.0166724455,
0.0474665537,
-0.0383871309,
0.0132536506,
-0.0537385941,
-0.0459102616,
0.0148945954,
0.034608081,
-0.0129262479,
0.0614810139,
0.0337893292,
-0.0218730103,
0.0598462522,
-0.0239644125,
0.0121061886,
-0.0522768758,
0.0361004621,
0.0049461671,
-0.0647316054,
-0.0297225565,
-0.01190376,
0.0491760448,
-0.0629962608,
0.0229811482,
0.0455535837,
0.0346901864,
-0.0274821222,
0.0340725407,
-0.0216096155,
-0.0040893955,
0.010121393,
-0.0106409928,
-0.0470173098,
-0.0058576567,
-0.0327149034,
0.0087065846,
-0.0776960701,
-0.0505993739,
-0.0183711108,
-0.0927725062,
0.0286950041,
-0.0210404377,
0.0052068844,
-0.0161698498,
-0.0504587032,
0.0025100049,
-0.0328767784,
-0.0112661775,
-0.0039075562,
-0.0281436853,
0.0439831242,
0.0424694493,
-0.0693595409,
-0.0322756507,
0.0134190172,
-0.0140204281,
0.0305093862,
0.0032213475,
0.0919410959,
-0.0421518013,
-0.0119432341,
-0.0339919366,
-0.0367586724,
0.0183115993,
-0.0234066714,
0.0398391373,
0.0141579509,
-0.0040069912,
-0.0162224658,
0.0095941639,
-0.0318379179,
-0.0222216621,
0.0005079272,
0.0608840883,
-0.0057725734,
-0.0191438068,
-0.0463363081,
0.0104126204,
-0.0211082492,
0.0572762601,
0.0558650941,
-0.0010507641,
-0.0187566951,
-0.0423898324,
0.043968536,
-0.0296975784,
-0.0849480554,
0.0075349445,
0.0062031751,
-0.0191024654,
-0.001373627,
-0.077594772,
-0.0065454938,
0.0237869043,
0.0101808095,
0.0408225916,
0.0116818715,
-0.0113686332,
-0.0491401367,
0.0224347152,
0.0163030811,
0.0301322881,
0.0534515306,
-0.0569585264,
0.0098108761,
0.0404924899,
-0.0345096216,
0.0250242874,
0.0280371644,
-0.0220893882,
0.0342498757,
0.0087975366,
0.0366830043,
0.0025920172,
-0.0074837063,
-0.0407942906,
-0.0465660393,
0.0426052324,
-0.0057795984,
-0.0169201121,
0.0408301055,
0.0441648401,
0.021533329,
0.0204841457,
-0.0068164505,
0.0026405866,
-0.0040705926,
0.0286115799,
-0.0318699628,
-0.017883705,
0.0028597815,
0.0083844494,
0.0127761848,
-0.0141970841,
-0.0333700515,
-0.008668581,
-0.0589714982,
-0.0079484442,
-0.0179567114,
-0.0420644246,
-0.0167516079,
-0.0321082957,
0.0011757588,
-0.0663006306,
0.0162982903,
-0.0393189192,
0.0224233419,
-0.0248251483,
0.075665988,
0.0348997451,
0.0320860893,
-0.0367197506,
0.0049477047,
-0.0299882367,
0.0007056718,
-0.0189646184,
0.0666740388,
0.0438518226,
0.0375392959,
0.0159683544,
-0.0073293778,
-0.0203687605,
0.0334842019,
-0.0558333844,
-0.0047134412,
0.0562909618,
0.0032840928,
-0.008205683,
-0.0258139428,
0.057774134,
-0.0170170311,
0.0079194242,
0.0310900863,
0.0552476086,
0.0289011877,
-0.0282698758,
0.0136190802,
0.0249973442,
-0.042461697,
-0.0134024601,
0.0527361296,
-0.019107677,
-0.0025774851,
-0.0205821358,
-0.0216308162,
-0.0273411404,
-0.0196618214,
0.0018769965,
0.0456253476,
-0.0059920885,
0.0274987407,
-0.1041228995,
-0.0519294925,
0.0160937328,
-0.0256689359,
0.0278494693,
-0.0344430655,
0.0007596384,
0.0321412086,
0.0567173436,
-0.054338824,
-0.0797948465,
0.0081044836,
-0.0248774197,
0.0124941878,
0.0046254247,
-6.273326824e-33,
-0.0167446751,
-0.0883212015,
-0.0144557171,
-0.0265961196,
-0.0123461476,
0.0531782284,
-0.0491823517,
0.011776479,
-0.0510589145,
0.0301846154,
-0.0181057956,
-0.001975426,
0.0041088425,
0.009323569,
0.061853759,
-0.0070471745,
0.0313224159,
0.0508683547,
0.0017192265,
-0.0033791584,
0.0645942539,
-0.0223857332,
0.0541156977,
-0.1071987823,
0.1137207523,
0.0180481113,
-0.0052424232,
-0.0295289531,
0.0175211262,
0.0608432703,
-0.0153979249,
0.0551776253,
0.0380446203,
-0.0694016442,
-0.006255365,
-0.027372364,
-0.0674457252,
-0.0374829322,
0.0552773178,
0.0367004834,
-0.0559879281,
-0.0189933684,
0.048902791,
-0.0044935415,
-0.0297180135,
-0.0140608419,
0.0679254457,
-0.0301449839,
0.0038358271,
-0.013134921,
-0.0456117019,
0.024503896,
-0.0406345725,
0.0470730588,
0.0334210619,
0.0343348645,
-0.0098315459,
0.0396724083,
-0.1150223017,
-0.0172764361,
0.0187511109,
-0.0188958216,
0.0324716046,
-0.0266313031,
0.0101732081,
0.0602463745,
-0.0249604546,
-0.0180713311,
-0.0140382415,
0.0011042018,
0.0450584665,
0.079425931,
0.0001509771,
0.0144059975,
0.0034115941,
0.0054829386,
-0.0275076479,
0.0096546514,
0.0085680494,
0.0517632067,
0.0418683477,
-0.0001433906,
-0.079424195,
-0.0209736601,
-0.0125278737,
-0.0324451812,
-0.0046619996,
-0.0550316125,
-0.0015154323,
-0.0662486926,
-0.0465842858,
0.0651251748,
0.0143220453,
-0.0537696704,
-0.0487773828,
0.0335697159,
0.009304842,
0.0430132821,
0.0219917316,
0.0013627729,
-0.03974149,
-0.0097340392,
-0.0310091805,
0.0394323766,
0.0528326705,
-0.0250507072,
0.0409716517,
0.0000959947,
-0.0042779027,
-0.0351011716,
-0.0422406718,
0.0053941347,
-0.0234015901,
-0.0357940756,
0.0179872271,
0.0394980535,
-0.020710161,
0.0075424435,
0.0436242558,
0.0515945405,
0.0104002738,
0.046836175,
-0.0290365946,
-0.010859739,
-0.0343965441,
-0.0610077232,
-0.003695935,
0.0320809856,
0.0430884846,
-0.0223458558,
-0.030784633,
-0.0548775047,
2.842e-7,
0.0971149504,
0.0137618706,
-0.0164681263,
0.0042569484,
0.0369905755,
0.0353989899,
0.0048404927,
0.0002899225,
-0.0005477525,
-0.0029392198,
-0.0086680716,
-0.0142387655,
-0.0188593008,
0.0225154012,
-0.0089939488,
-0.0416122004,
-0.0231452454,
0.0128671173,
-0.0372099802,
0.0439823419,
0.0403295048,
0.0245779492,
0.0148751214,
0.0390318446,
-0.0047678575,
-0.0005286704,
-0.002570369,
-0.0449281447,
0.0476873145,
0.0144872526,
0.0434322916,
0.018106645,
0.0569816455,
-0.0083385212,
-0.0016228465,
0.0050599426,
0.0320432745,
0.0094641466,
-0.0117269345,
-0.0129185496,
-0.0122505436,
-0.0318154059,
0.0166923217,
-0.0885278136,
0.0530550592,
-0.0488740169,
-0.0978404507,
-0.0331860371,
-0.0268287305,
-0.0009521964,
0.0097087929,
0.0330110267,
-0.0221391004,
0.0267126318,
-0.0286290534,
-0.0408901684,
-0.0410271287,
-0.0528380498,
-0.0050626243,
-0.0153304525,
0.0338569246,
-0.0128288791,
-0.0064570419,
-0.0216616616,
-0.0022423877,
-0.0618107431,
-0.0149982963,
2.481874947e-34,
0.0130941542,
0.0050997767,
0.0422707535,
0.0623962432,
0.0453557596,
0.0169140417,
-0.0341821574,
0.005789673,
0.0317144841,
-0.0055366498,
-0.0135781225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12614v1 | EUvsDisinfo: a Dataset for Multilingual Detection of Pro-Kremlin Disinformation in News Articles | 2024-06-18T13:43:22 | 2024-06-18T13:43:22 | João A. Leite, Olesya Razuvayevskaya, Kalina Bontcheva, Carolina Scarton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work introduces EUvsDisinfo, a multilingual dataset of trustworthy and
disinformation articles related to pro-Kremlin themes. It is sourced directly
from the debunk articles written by experts leading the EUvsDisinfo project.
Our dataset is the largest to-date resource in terms of the overall number of
articles and distinct languages. It also provides the largest topical and
temporal coverage. Using this dataset, we investigate the dissemination of
pro-Kremlin disinformation across different languages, uncovering
language-specific patterns targeting specific disinformation topics. We further
analyse the evolution of topic distribution over an eight-year period, noting a
significant surge in disinformation content before the full-scale invasion of
Ukraine in 2022. Lastly, we demonstrate the dataset's applicability in training
models to effectively distinguish between disinformation and trustworthy
content in multilingual settings. | [
0.0367625579,
0.0408791043,
-0.0100332266,
0.0270174742,
-0.0316480324,
0.0018120226,
0.0367198288,
-0.0393209197,
0.0029711528,
0.0067228922,
0.008993404,
-0.0230382457,
-0.0117520196,
0.0515436083,
0.0205909014,
-0.006727716,
0.0786839947,
0.0005373437,
0.0241710972,
-0.0464411937,
0.0304743517,
0.0474276319,
-0.0366521403,
-0.0062610027,
-0.010113514,
0.009744809,
0.0145044569,
-0.0054179681,
0.049890697,
-0.0274412744,
-0.0043628374,
0.0141687673,
0.0087188305,
0.07013762,
0.0000015911,
0.0228642486,
-0.0394345932,
-0.0136409001,
-0.003614268,
-0.017488772,
0.064309217,
-0.1027867571,
-0.0180682633,
0.005991857,
-0.0388317928,
-0.0094363969,
0.0363506936,
0.0430358239,
0.0709629953,
0.1288365126,
-0.0196172129,
0.0220515728,
0.0107349642,
-0.0073146056,
-0.0194051545,
0.0236615147,
0.0490115061,
-0.0248170476,
-0.0965725705,
0.0496493094,
0.0460818931,
0.0010139901,
0.0164465643,
0.0061907233,
-0.0575831197,
-0.0058164624,
-0.0122913271,
-0.0482216589,
-0.0061746393,
0.0241253208,
0.0148834167,
-0.0606881976,
0.0291249286,
0.0166670717,
-0.018852409,
0.0405765697,
0.0113612851,
-0.0109273614,
-0.0476124771,
0.0086865639,
0.041673217,
-0.033287745,
0.0231180638,
0.044501178,
0.0020235388,
0.0444277935,
-0.0234695654,
-0.0101675158,
0.0326337665,
-0.0242832191,
0.0015486482,
-0.0406044498,
0.0502586216,
-0.0056129019,
-0.0025840662,
0.0086986264,
-0.0404543504,
-0.0227201879,
0.0395154469,
-0.0667945594,
-0.054801479,
0.0141667342,
0.0052798167,
0.0634579808,
0.0083771311,
-0.022300709,
-0.0098864464,
0.0128947003,
-0.0117800459,
-0.0025310982,
0.0015286042,
0.0389512368,
-0.0155290896,
-0.0356619246,
0.0475101396,
0.0442986749,
-0.0466493368,
-0.0341534764,
-0.0249118879,
0.055139605,
-0.0390113555,
0.0068364455,
-0.0145755913,
0.0032619259,
0.0085223233,
0.0595544688,
-0.0495497659,
0.024217356,
-0.0283011962,
-0.0116949491,
-0.006557473,
0.0082271565,
-0.015099192,
-0.0161045454,
-0.0060281437,
-0.0063818605,
0.0168927684,
0.022322014,
-0.0140061453,
-0.040452607,
-0.0129303243,
-0.0371910669,
0.0499735028,
-0.0560697056,
-0.0181993842,
-0.0219242387,
-0.0214956757,
-0.0559355989,
-0.0044232435,
0.0120908506,
-0.0374527946,
0.068264924,
0.0103202146,
0.0121832471,
0.0635914281,
0.0052409181,
0.0109984372,
0.0889486521,
-0.0463542715,
0.0969676003,
0.0528609976,
0.0040559438,
-0.0018772807,
0.0346955247,
0.0646047443,
0.0696173385,
-0.0133787803,
0.0112159187,
-0.0243938491,
-0.0436200649,
0.0266122054,
0.0043406747,
-0.0067516915,
-0.061633233,
0.0698953494,
-0.0141476747,
-0.0641081631,
-0.0015981075,
-0.0018407046,
0.0268649217,
-0.0234149862,
-0.0062359287,
-0.0403726175,
-0.009523157,
-0.0092798732,
-0.035296768,
-0.0032235107,
0.0468225069,
-0.0291544292,
-0.0093987975,
0.0154808685,
-0.0110796085,
0.0323002413,
-0.0392462537,
0.0307893772,
-0.0087600099,
-0.0233536195,
0.022930203,
0.0508875847,
-0.0112382649,
0.0099733956,
-0.0373218469,
0.0368060917,
0.0077487952,
0.0185404532,
-0.0288332477,
-0.0025325089,
-0.0334416777,
0.0616533123,
0.0368411094,
0.0280233175,
-0.0361104161,
-0.0327190757,
0.0100041917,
-0.0010106361,
-0.028545307,
0.0215692297,
0.0364013352,
0.0298088528,
0.0736280829,
-0.0070760502,
-0.0309347399,
-0.0352186561,
0.026905844,
0.0128008751,
0.017520329,
-0.0075314795,
0.0494407639,
0.005421795,
0.0205434132,
-0.0179074351,
-0.0034786861,
0.0822027028,
0.0196843315,
-0.0059588691,
-0.0168948807,
0.0260318629,
-0.0003422688,
0.0112588601,
-0.0386599898,
-0.0312378705,
0.0137254773,
-0.0380831882,
0.0251776222,
0.0804369599,
-0.0002729126,
-0.0288355723,
-0.0151685262,
-0.0254147481,
-0.0308107976,
0.0065896316,
0.0145587679,
0.0416503213,
-0.040418461,
0.0142236296,
-0.0000665264,
-0.0364634581,
0.0349266082,
0.0147926835,
0.0061464068,
0.0023445755,
-0.0238461327,
-0.0011890403,
0.0309212729,
-0.0421011448,
-0.0083365021,
0.0147180622,
-0.0249810461,
-0.0069401911,
-0.0468131453,
0.0388563871,
0.0613754727,
-0.0144004654,
0.0104160756,
0.0141924536,
-0.052640222,
-0.0237665866,
0.0097837187,
0.0237526447,
-0.0140430219,
-0.0369684473,
0.0171105098,
-0.0127843739,
0.0155574838,
-0.0217954945,
0.0030851678,
0.0082219522,
0.0048281252,
-0.0144453002,
-0.019829914,
-0.0511307903,
0.0155750196,
-0.0722700134,
-0.0636789426,
0.0107745118,
0.0187343974,
-0.0007528319,
0.0312066432,
0.0153517611,
0.0670198426,
0.0680085793,
0.0634117648,
-0.0015577737,
-0.0452624261,
-0.061881166,
0.0381512754,
-0.0316639766,
-0.049765408,
0.0059218793,
0.0156159606,
0.0269668736,
0.0008085616,
-0.0010211227,
0.0331680365,
-0.0300729629,
-0.0224222746,
0.0125819165,
-0.0325797237,
0.0294126906,
0.036977604,
-0.0324935913,
-0.0394226797,
0.0748515055,
-0.0120904297,
0.0567654371,
-0.0145802982,
-0.0605793595,
0.0057036192,
0.0092964191,
-0.0077005541,
-0.0047885804,
-0.0146848829,
0.0427405164,
-0.0321027264,
-0.0374464765,
0.0668342486,
-0.0199246388,
0.0244265907,
-0.0297646038,
0.0093328916,
0.0163585003,
0.0120146889,
-0.034468852,
-0.1024745628,
0.0285431072,
-0.0247295666,
-0.0082075289,
-0.0358697511,
-0.0865089223,
-0.0332553871,
0.0467768684,
0.0328022502,
-0.0190371331,
0.0343793631,
0.0072567631,
0.0362866968,
0.023257263,
-0.0659461692,
0.0542590916,
-0.0248562396,
-0.0158069525,
0.0438841358,
0.0052946811,
0.0311837383,
0.0222821999,
-0.0546385497,
0.01627893,
-0.0001381948,
0.0038793902,
-0.0293581672,
0.0013803963,
-0.038764324,
0.0164170358,
0.0488173403,
0.0095047206,
-0.0193533991,
-0.0075539127,
0.0127264261,
-0.0005383903,
0.0126963295,
0.0025823838,
-0.1012413353,
0.0484208129,
-0.0021743719,
-0.0003537543,
-0.0547081605,
-0.0148749016,
-0.0438275002,
-0.0506971888,
-0.0283097737,
-0.0038702351,
-0.0587664284,
-0.032710366,
-0.1068655327,
-0.004846043,
-0.0144734811,
-0.0219655838,
0.0075398753,
0.025367355,
0.0087026414,
-0.0061378838,
-0.0519063026,
-0.0756243318,
-0.0205502268,
-0.0025198297,
0.0214835908,
0.0164629258,
0.0504001714,
-0.0359489061,
-0.0155952945,
-0.0253205169,
0.0047237454,
-0.0945945606,
0.000790951,
0.0860538036,
-0.0132407043,
-0.0272018518,
0.0095780948,
0.0592304729,
0.0069885487,
0.0026998101,
0.0355399325,
0.016690772,
-0.0098355375,
-0.0288455933,
0.0058994708,
0.0274651498,
0.0609735176,
0.0186124742,
-0.0200638566,
0.039567627,
0.0321937837,
-0.0217362102,
0.0039854227,
-0.0052637784,
-0.0032297389,
0.0503145792,
-0.0474940017,
-0.0883781388,
-0.0628579482,
-0.0325750709,
0.0121408589,
0.0172411818,
-0.0161454249,
0.0199701358,
-0.0161112528,
-0.020573359,
-0.0498198457,
0.0013867297,
0.0280081518,
0.0613409504,
-0.0156802088,
-0.018250132,
-0.0503090918,
-0.0101892035,
-0.0061897896,
0.0377878994,
-0.0598704182,
-0.0539043695,
0.0165781807,
0.004976307,
0.01523061,
0.0366848707,
-0.0043197493,
0.0016312302,
0.0919592381,
0.0066097071,
-0.0329691209,
-0.0189212114,
0.0338745415,
-0.0131758852,
0.0424669981,
0.0272445474,
0.0080043571,
0.0407840647,
0.0319143124,
-0.0945084468,
-0.0676659271,
0.0331011228,
-0.0078735566,
-0.0201298147,
0.0874339566,
-0.0122196069,
0.004881449,
-0.0614129342,
0.0059745014,
-0.015785994,
-0.0332022198,
0.0255678501,
0.0118806548,
0.0336360596,
-0.0255154707,
-0.0094993105,
0.0333479755,
-0.0278046802,
-0.0115596866,
-0.0465558991,
0.0091517484,
0.0117092906,
0.0668369234,
0.0305540729,
-0.0083527183,
-0.0120285461,
0.043069046,
-0.0330959409,
-0.006724603,
-0.0339732096,
-0.0232762005,
0.0071184631,
-0.0349998213,
0.0725854486,
-0.0387340523,
-0.0449147895,
-0.0154104494,
-0.0010320855,
-0.0027300294,
0.01097441,
-0.0027933028,
0.0756150931,
-0.0142526915,
-0.0229916703,
-0.0051525361,
0.0215607788,
0.0091093127,
-0.0245577563,
0.0235294793,
-0.0100710839,
-0.0521361381,
0.0482976735,
0.0281703789,
0.0029114429,
0.0431528948,
0.0511600822,
-0.0647325143,
-0.0018337891,
-0.0220211688,
-0.0102220578,
0.0158612244,
-0.0244403072,
-0.0059243264,
-0.0595125295,
-0.0554884747,
-0.0268236101,
0.0183917675,
-0.0370433107,
0.0069033033,
-0.0040208092,
0.0621673167,
0.0235269908,
0.0710647628,
-0.0719831511,
0.0052746115,
-0.0492294021,
-0.0502503328,
0.0211440995,
-5.617635707e-33,
0.0315180123,
-0.0210772548,
-0.0178146362,
-0.0069740466,
0.0162784513,
0.040583618,
-0.0035461772,
-0.0373057611,
-0.06479197,
0.0363638997,
0.0309117921,
0.0289182235,
-0.0029266635,
-0.0299593471,
-0.0440047085,
0.0103420652,
0.0517250039,
-0.0106964968,
-0.0283334125,
0.0119654322,
0.0974128619,
0.0034166253,
0.0862634853,
-0.0563037358,
0.0758962035,
-0.0120830033,
-0.035544537,
0.0104226237,
0.0301880185,
0.0118576912,
-0.0113145141,
0.0438733287,
0.0198056195,
-0.0381971113,
0.0193468835,
-0.0073555247,
-0.0092918789,
-0.0198928043,
0.0317115113,
-0.0052826186,
-0.0324972533,
0.0257648472,
0.0247551221,
-0.0207617301,
0.0227949228,
0.0356587954,
0.0322328769,
-0.0216552112,
0.0057379231,
0.0077101993,
-0.068918623,
0.0152378073,
-0.0145502677,
0.014204151,
-0.0375601575,
0.0860560238,
0.0542525798,
0.0132580092,
-0.0885193199,
0.0543159433,
-0.0344221815,
0.0290005282,
0.0354382917,
-0.0532034226,
0.006780481,
0.0547195524,
0.0214396808,
0.0354308113,
-0.0141672511,
0.0096325492,
0.002118293,
0.0094191786,
0.0471205339,
0.0924878493,
0.0356900468,
-0.0894435942,
-0.1073935404,
0.0181733146,
0.0546436682,
0.0258054342,
-0.0144148767,
-0.0478094667,
-0.0048606959,
-0.0028178582,
-0.0303635336,
-0.0245166067,
-0.0212750081,
-0.0408593379,
-0.0352018401,
0.0123682367,
-0.0290931277,
0.0308062527,
0.0037101519,
-0.0097970264,
-0.009452628,
0.0732744932,
-0.0367828235,
-0.0109143481,
0.0069351029,
0.066293478,
-0.087061353,
-0.0134396181,
0.0086838575,
-0.0092941495,
0.0180801172,
0.0148102837,
0.0821928009,
0.009915079,
-0.0396185331,
0.0278397314,
-0.0305433385,
0.0456782654,
0.0052091223,
0.0445161052,
0.0297795236,
0.0067572701,
-0.0259260628,
0.0008525513,
0.0225218609,
-0.0139545538,
0.0279711951,
-0.0030997812,
-0.0390310362,
0.0630499795,
-0.0161712393,
-0.0376166701,
-0.0395962708,
0.0186645407,
0.0235315207,
-0.0644751638,
0.0222345013,
-0.0327411368,
2.492e-7,
-0.0011588024,
0.0271535199,
-0.0213757083,
0.0109349201,
0.0273673665,
0.026446227,
-0.0272620432,
0.0218620766,
-0.0729241297,
-0.0804125592,
0.00386297,
0.0344676524,
0.0314266868,
0.051217135,
-0.0230313372,
0.0179503784,
-0.0432941504,
-0.0144388061,
-0.0705813542,
0.0293401219,
-0.0146969641,
0.0605797395,
0.0519511104,
-0.012531681,
-0.02706852,
0.0107303597,
0.0579622798,
0.0201748218,
-0.0313884616,
-0.0127655361,
0.0362349488,
-0.0053216643,
-0.0005347258,
0.0240813009,
-0.0068236496,
-0.0036785987,
-0.0292947944,
0.0006962637,
0.0205207467,
0.0185754336,
0.0073318966,
-0.0485737622,
-0.0246727895,
-0.0825365707,
0.0757167637,
-0.0369530879,
-0.0178402346,
-0.0632176176,
-0.0482538566,
0.0008167478,
0.0529758707,
-0.0132940048,
-0.0226581711,
0.0411395282,
-0.0258543249,
-0.0036534008,
0.0395821519,
-0.0091269081,
-0.0056761019,
0.0150407655,
-0.0259729605,
-0.0381680168,
0.0131702721,
-0.0093535436,
-0.0066851201,
0.0303583145,
0.0399414003,
1.977231548e-34,
0.0566823035,
-0.0348810777,
-0.0472306088,
-0.0515142865,
0.0474058613,
-0.0239414591,
-0.0202232003,
-0.0330987908,
-0.0204923097,
0.015755415,
-0.0093039786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12611v1 | Rapid Language Adaptation for Multilingual E2E Speech Recognition Using Encoder Prompting | 2024-06-18T13:38:58 | 2024-06-18T13:38:58 | Yosuke Kashiwagi, Hayato Futami, Emiru Tsunoo, Siddhant Arora, Shinji Watanabe | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | End-to-end multilingual speech recognition models handle multiple languages
through a single model, often incorporating language identification to
automatically detect the language of incoming speech. Since the common scenario
is where the language is already known, these models can perform as
language-specific by using language information as prompts, which is
particularly beneficial for attention-based encoder-decoder architectures.
However, the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach, which
enhances recognition via joint decoding and multi-task training, does not
normally incorporate language prompts due to its conditionally independent
output tokens. To overcome this, we introduce an encoder prompting technique
within the self-conditioned CTC framework, enabling language-specific
adaptation of the CTC model in a zero-shot manner. Our method has shown to
significantly reduce errors by 28% on average and by 41% on low-resource
languages. | [
-0.0196415782,
0.0608685054,
0.0065660854,
0.0645164922,
0.005266685,
0.0351767838,
0.040596325,
-0.0469618514,
-0.0035555644,
-0.0074974131,
-0.0448644236,
-0.0482404903,
0.0275441967,
0.0333636627,
-0.0085049989,
-0.0247713756,
0.0272835977,
-0.0445745811,
0.0178751759,
-0.0139027797,
-0.0355340801,
0.0143034384,
-0.0117681306,
0.013010852,
0.0091297152,
0.0014219,
-0.0145956371,
0.0189721566,
0.0135509176,
-0.0270174965,
-0.0183572415,
0.038288109,
0.0328348801,
0.0315254591,
0.0000020317,
-0.0256365426,
-0.0079512326,
-0.06351953,
-0.0384846888,
-0.0189162306,
0.0324359424,
-0.0115190875,
-0.0158966538,
0.012935671,
-0.0019447266,
-0.0448189564,
0.0738750845,
0.0148278661,
0.0199581105,
0.0698286146,
-0.0091997311,
-0.0043506338,
0.0041343225,
-0.0234996323,
-0.0142505318,
0.0048392955,
0.0043914416,
-0.0444228612,
-0.0169088449,
-0.0387810506,
-0.0418552235,
0.0357028954,
0.0430330262,
0.0190134477,
0.005749194,
0.0177480169,
-0.0034546519,
-0.0202172101,
-0.0666774511,
0.0375007428,
-0.0217092521,
-0.0216710586,
-0.0303274728,
0.0170721672,
-0.0400084592,
-0.0406497568,
0.0035334616,
-0.0132674817,
0.024317706,
0.0104914298,
0.0487164222,
0.0472309738,
0.0075333174,
-0.0231708307,
-0.0379935205,
0.0327516682,
0.0185704101,
-0.0324956439,
0.0156414695,
0.0050496175,
0.0500701554,
-0.0217037257,
0.0405265056,
0.0195257869,
-0.0092515796,
-0.0098640611,
-0.0271228328,
-0.0566573553,
-0.0490080006,
-0.0352681242,
-0.0030937062,
0.0789797455,
-0.0285831485,
0.0432660133,
-0.05296975,
0.0516730472,
-0.0049138768,
0.0275477692,
-0.0294353738,
-0.038161099,
-0.0028810699,
0.0101739112,
-0.0499998443,
-0.0156688262,
-0.0124094402,
-0.0041850698,
-0.0338761136,
0.0416353382,
-0.0032194268,
-0.0152445734,
-0.0002328043,
-0.0284546148,
-0.0779191703,
-0.0152240228,
0.0236004889,
0.0591884367,
0.0028791502,
0.0075902352,
-0.023843281,
-0.0854420215,
-0.0481460802,
0.0358449519,
0.0481128991,
-0.0180242993,
0.0027317908,
0.0612917505,
-0.0213438831,
-0.0392965898,
-0.0248112753,
0.0397990756,
-0.0232695751,
-0.0149088213,
0.0238883626,
-0.0529049896,
0.0461093523,
0.0031614483,
0.0344486274,
-0.0449586548,
-0.0312987082,
-0.0572517477,
0.0220603105,
0.0648994446,
0.008700572,
-0.0252671633,
0.0788408816,
-0.0237559341,
0.0185140669,
0.0679999813,
0.0356299877,
-0.0371506587,
-0.000858579,
-0.0114728585,
-0.0126916114,
0.076464884,
-0.0171862226,
0.0144986389,
-0.0616879277,
-0.0058957492,
0.0695092902,
-0.0196396951,
0.0671875179,
-0.0009255804,
-0.0214185081,
0.0070443829,
0.0059909159,
0.0244056899,
0.0185520612,
-0.0140907718,
0.0596420243,
0.000497822,
-0.0476995073,
-0.0267614629,
-0.0125179244,
0.0389685072,
0.0157359671,
0.0035183327,
0.0380406789,
0.0328174271,
-0.0589001365,
0.0070696496,
0.0453148484,
-0.0439171679,
0.0317687355,
0.0171017516,
0.0522795804,
-0.0101469755,
-0.0495397113,
0.0235783104,
0.0438743718,
-0.0319794975,
0.0424096733,
-0.0206380133,
0.0088277869,
0.082199052,
-0.0074180248,
0.0155571159,
-0.0229023509,
-0.0195784513,
-0.0056066727,
0.054432448,
0.0264794864,
-0.0108495746,
0.0694323182,
-0.0659659877,
-0.0291117392,
0.0171110947,
-0.0391453691,
0.1057478115,
-0.0516745746,
0.0564796776,
0.0127335684,
0.0173016395,
0.0269343555,
-0.0161761995,
-0.0116268462,
-0.022711467,
0.0816205963,
0.0332790464,
0.0382896401,
0.0414999947,
-0.0106422743,
-0.0393362753,
0.0007388812,
-0.0693244711,
0.0154004674,
0.0682170168,
-0.0760872811,
-0.0911682472,
0.0037839171,
0.0290508159,
0.0031363224,
0.0227793176,
0.0072515025,
-0.0996698663,
0.0380890705,
-0.0051072594,
0.0585587211,
-0.0236094706,
0.0221618395,
0.0094551491,
0.0468377806,
0.0340493843,
0.0172968879,
-0.0029487254,
-0.0281004086,
0.0653364509,
0.0087620653,
-0.0119589148,
-0.0835958794,
-0.0562269911,
0.0495753065,
0.0222718176,
-0.0321771689,
0.0071105254,
0.0491395108,
-0.0061700554,
0.0084696719,
-0.0792455599,
-0.0068320283,
-0.0631508753,
0.0250654239,
-0.0207748599,
0.0288541764,
-0.0149969682,
-0.0668035746,
-0.0277324226,
-0.0109973969,
-0.0195108,
0.0103898915,
-0.0312838592,
-0.013294505,
-0.0175364222,
0.0136958836,
-0.0212014299,
0.0194733869,
0.0470050089,
-0.0273618344,
-0.0527682416,
-0.0737193003,
-0.0100946454,
0.0288279839,
0.0278825946,
0.0064825932,
0.0016042775,
-0.0328637138,
0.0047424766,
0.0254355613,
0.0360735245,
-0.0009446989,
-0.010310025,
0.0384517834,
-0.0105904313,
-0.0491023436,
0.0344955325,
0.0219659768,
0.0233900212,
-0.0006402919,
-0.0105551118,
-0.0137581732,
0.0597218424,
-0.0057542613,
0.0368226916,
-0.09972056,
-0.0306159407,
-0.0178552233,
-0.0309397206,
-0.0218923613,
-0.0045551816,
-0.0296812262,
-0.0000156257,
-0.0149622224,
-0.0175205171,
0.0608326644,
-0.0489786342,
-0.0541910566,
-0.0327507071,
-0.0089740185,
-0.0101943258,
-0.0011129959,
0.0108351726,
0.0157458894,
0.0060284403,
-0.0674759224,
-0.0081776539,
0.01550759,
-0.0100547075,
-0.0014862751,
0.0267718472,
-0.0035048088,
-0.0105231591,
-0.0046058786,
-0.0327250399,
-0.0275351871,
0.0300395004,
-0.0294567458,
0.0142706921,
-0.0146951266,
-0.0152521478,
-0.0012473667,
0.024104815,
0.0164931305,
0.079283081,
-0.0029372119,
0.0131221907,
-0.028089758,
0.0711093917,
0.0134567302,
0.0558459647,
-0.037280295,
-0.0317199789,
0.0496139266,
-0.018637836,
0.0610973798,
0.0182346273,
-0.0598470159,
0.0269513037,
0.0764538422,
0.0123788025,
-0.0022351565,
0.0382316746,
0.0280091744,
-0.0463232808,
0.0144981239,
0.1090003476,
-0.0086078104,
-0.1035201699,
-0.0463109277,
-0.0252478234,
-0.0310794767,
0.0086254254,
-0.0036880553,
-0.0571796373,
-0.0455797836,
0.0064683584,
-0.0017695228,
0.015065263,
0.0335197523,
-0.024850402,
-0.0685217902,
0.0111866333,
0.0351336412,
-0.054763265,
-0.0104625775,
-0.0457552038,
-0.0200645123,
-0.0356470346,
0.021332765,
0.0046460484,
0.0210788324,
-0.0487648956,
0.0281524118,
-0.0085542789,
-0.073073633,
0.0258132797,
-0.0025011653,
0.0724464282,
0.062909849,
-0.0126609867,
-0.0282721985,
-0.0008914632,
0.0301353745,
-0.0201970264,
-0.0247777179,
-0.0407810993,
-0.0055076159,
-0.0215157755,
-0.0118314549,
0.0823849216,
0.0078732846,
-0.0439475738,
0.0291234758,
0.0532268435,
0.0880775228,
-0.0105292173,
0.016832009,
0.0265674368,
-0.0312482603,
0.0343825705,
0.0390472449,
0.0272304043,
-0.0629601032,
-0.0064518265,
-0.0203926787,
-0.0095083956,
-0.0773022771,
0.0121294446,
-0.003768872,
0.018897403,
-0.068675898,
-0.0077951169,
-0.0449516736,
0.011738779,
-0.007422836,
0.0381925963,
-0.0091108037,
-0.002633828,
0.0173730012,
-0.0361690409,
0.0116174808,
-0.0225084703,
0.0046866676,
-0.0867746696,
0.0077664047,
-0.0015938708,
-0.0534225032,
0.0131761581,
0.0093883136,
-0.064938657,
-0.0510929786,
-0.0364767797,
0.0023119852,
-0.0017723321,
0.0987688005,
-0.0360760801,
-0.0307566412,
0.047457803,
-0.0256837029,
-0.0116816657,
0.0017384985,
0.0754609704,
0.0234543867,
-0.0367069617,
0.0203898661,
-0.0607557893,
0.0234215576,
0.0047582402,
0.01549072,
-0.0376430564,
-0.0316973366,
-0.0145806093,
-0.0092413789,
0.0578603037,
-0.028165685,
0.0160389245,
-0.0310188755,
0.0385189652,
-0.0039318278,
0.0430413634,
-0.028003443,
-0.0154004395,
-0.0072625144,
0.0109040905,
0.0123695182,
-0.0009983002,
0.0095136976,
-0.061484877,
-0.0294338465,
0.0645820722,
0.0013661799,
0.0272676796,
0.033540342,
-0.0119305635,
-0.0410670377,
0.0113850739,
0.037456017,
0.0077072904,
-0.0389981158,
0.0533438548,
0.0054737823,
0.0070617991,
-0.010337309,
0.0254979562,
0.0064333421,
-0.0022822062,
0.0068816333,
-0.0012240546,
0.064122729,
-0.0183478221,
0.0745870098,
-0.007070093,
0.0145256668,
-0.0353496298,
-0.0026101419,
0.0073756459,
-0.0409398526,
0.040838208,
-0.0192022268,
0.0043712365,
0.0396507457,
0.0388688296,
-0.0375244506,
-0.0216973945,
0.0090251705,
0.060831245,
-0.036699269,
-0.0107993344,
-0.023069093,
-0.0370586328,
-0.0523136891,
0.0225236025,
0.0308096558,
-0.0350299589,
0.0298829731,
-0.0152159361,
0.0001883746,
0.0050294539,
0.0192286726,
0.0290928688,
-0.0104255052,
-0.0221242495,
0.0032837638,
-0.0261489619,
0.026321074,
-0.0238372348,
-0.0317296796,
-6.28558723e-33,
-0.005873689,
0.0240487922,
0.0067538396,
-0.0196679514,
0.0074075786,
0.0095471293,
-0.0373482257,
-0.0117762554,
-0.0064138006,
-0.0526807085,
-0.0190034006,
-0.0002104033,
0.0312113073,
0.0428674482,
0.0384264328,
0.0057678926,
0.0755088851,
-0.0181974173,
-0.0298131667,
0.0547610931,
0.0416187719,
0.0306570213,
0.0716772825,
-0.0106005138,
0.0088054854,
0.0136113223,
0.0345003121,
0.0046722335,
0.0552102029,
0.0325167701,
-0.0096324645,
0.0472601652,
0.0149562387,
-0.0745572746,
-0.0161359608,
0.0467622466,
-0.1030593514,
-0.0363484286,
-0.0528145097,
0.0468841977,
-0.036600288,
-0.0692563802,
0.0049573067,
0.0353173204,
0.0031686639,
-0.0159824416,
0.0279297978,
-0.0290353037,
-0.0374858342,
-0.0348952152,
0.0096635306,
0.0373900607,
-0.025967814,
0.00099121,
0.0655423626,
0.0994196907,
-0.0168351829,
-0.0132009825,
-0.0879200101,
0.0415915176,
-0.0264681429,
0.0119411619,
0.0669446513,
0.0439535417,
-0.0168035794,
-0.0001366286,
0.0024167225,
-0.0276720729,
0.0451104455,
-0.0075542028,
0.0323384143,
-0.044724036,
-0.0110335518,
-0.0115187215,
0.0354229249,
-0.0296953451,
-0.0280896407,
0.0007464126,
0.0700420961,
0.0132351322,
0.0457671918,
-0.0252458155,
-0.0432130359,
-0.0032459588,
-0.0042704395,
-0.0002959082,
-0.0477835946,
-0.0262606665,
0.0383889712,
-0.0152956359,
0.0194551703,
-0.0421368144,
0.1064096242,
0.0009889288,
0.0451673605,
0.0327447802,
-0.0089197718,
-0.0072372588,
0.001682035,
0.0671976879,
-0.0412361138,
-0.0113017038,
0.0101762023,
-0.034397047,
0.0005425576,
-0.0058594914,
0.0067169159,
0.0460413247,
-0.0558275543,
-0.0130652953,
0.0050828201,
0.0247988384,
0.0047433437,
0.0468832999,
0.0395606719,
-0.0039684656,
0.0030137547,
0.0370071754,
-0.0224923603,
-0.0164065342,
-0.0315460414,
-0.0145409461,
0.0156456102,
0.0467008501,
-0.0300071128,
0.0136834327,
-0.0143399453,
0.0223782659,
-0.0042194142,
-0.0351065584,
-0.0023132982,
0.0235492978,
2.75e-7,
-0.0430106297,
-0.0045313323,
0.0097170919,
0.0111438325,
0.0197783541,
0.0124744102,
-0.0187241621,
0.0218373146,
0.0018484828,
0.0454981178,
0.0279808436,
0.0231111124,
0.0761744455,
0.0050024949,
-0.0851283148,
-0.0190693848,
-0.0262361895,
0.0714264065,
-0.026750451,
0.0183252692,
0.0247953255,
0.0834447369,
-0.0144563243,
0.0120295528,
-0.0372000858,
-0.0180892963,
0.0535246432,
-0.0260474551,
0.0137272151,
-0.0012142699,
-0.0027145157,
0.0147885215,
-0.0431885272,
0.0385677665,
-0.0373323634,
0.053574007,
-0.0341703519,
0.0326166712,
0.0064704139,
-0.0702943504,
0.0215956718,
0.0390699431,
-0.0583321936,
-0.0038139527,
0.0769841149,
-0.0513895191,
-0.0186138712,
0.022783773,
-0.0165794827,
0.0321555473,
0.0270314179,
-0.015021326,
-0.0452503748,
0.0037089961,
0.0340500884,
-0.0287481267,
-0.0297047831,
-0.0470685139,
0.0419633649,
0.0072980039,
-0.0487660058,
-0.0014097994,
-0.013468842,
-0.0386836901,
0.0387618206,
-0.0122777941,
0.0258211438,
1.99058443e-34,
0.0359367952,
-0.0102777164,
0.0250296481,
0.0177889299,
-0.0243184399,
-0.0671373382,
-0.026103694,
-0.0038579337,
0.0252477359,
-0.0648021325,
-0.0466386862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12608v1 | Bridging Local Details and Global Context in Text-Attributed Graphs | 2024-06-18T13:35:25 | 2024-06-18T13:35:25 | Yaoke Wang, Yun Zhu, Wenqiao Zhang, Yueting Zhuang, Yunfei Li, Siliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representation learning on text-attributed graphs (TAGs) is vital for
real-world applications, as they combine semantic textual and contextual
structural information. Research in this field generally consist of two main
perspectives: local-level encoding and global-level aggregating, respectively
refer to textual node information unification (e.g., using Language Models) and
structure-augmented modeling (e.g., using Graph Neural Networks). Most existing
works focus on combining different information levels but overlook the
interconnections, i.e., the contextual textual information among nodes, which
provides semantic insights to bridge local and global levels. In this paper, we
propose GraphBridge, a multi-granularity integration framework that bridges
local and global perspectives by leveraging contextual textual information,
enhancing fine-grained understanding of TAGs. Besides, to tackle scalability
and efficiency challenges, we introduce a graphaware token reduction module.
Extensive experiments across various models and datasets show that our method
achieves state-of-theart performance, while our graph-aware token reduction
module significantly enhances efficiency and solves scalability issues. | [
0.0049381182,
0.0299422257,
0.0012917268,
0.0433430113,
-0.0226886161,
-0.001004669,
0.0268702172,
-0.0070743915,
0.0512061156,
-0.0539933518,
0.016130412,
0.0405664369,
0.0289865918,
0.0609871671,
0.0330025107,
-0.0275274832,
0.0084168538,
0.0179674495,
0.0411517769,
-0.018667521,
0.0155284898,
0.0583644286,
0.0405613109,
0.0376929007,
-0.0674333572,
-0.0096786916,
0.0193463452,
0.0354905911,
0.0225613341,
-0.0257042628,
-0.0331513844,
0.008133539,
0.0136793954,
0.0324384123,
0.0000019596,
-0.0076800212,
-0.0347831734,
0.0086482968,
0.0002449807,
-0.0068156593,
0.0294556096,
0.0113957822,
0.0463718846,
-0.0030199024,
-0.0184210781,
-0.0486187525,
0.0523478761,
0.0549391173,
0.0496280193,
0.0240344945,
-0.0497505926,
-0.0189691819,
-0.0107378513,
-0.0086853104,
-0.0042708544,
-0.0609741136,
0.0289856121,
0.0236155987,
-0.0131068546,
0.0320710987,
-0.064248316,
0.0236176439,
-0.0076877759,
0.0077231512,
0.066155158,
0.0393447392,
-0.0243686046,
0.0416238531,
0.0206811819,
0.1038323864,
-0.0172032434,
-0.041520644,
0.0170231406,
-0.0186229981,
0.0077010626,
0.0012736595,
-0.0328908935,
-0.0573680103,
0.003504704,
0.0708532482,
-0.0272411648,
-0.0273226704,
0.0548766777,
-0.0142606925,
-0.0338257961,
0.0665097088,
-0.0158324093,
0.029243812,
-0.0109422067,
-0.0020881749,
-0.0186429285,
-0.0628361702,
0.0268249493,
0.0313884355,
-0.015015333,
0.0192754734,
-0.0471047796,
-0.0178329162,
-0.0099494848,
0.0145175308,
-0.0041325749,
-0.0224518906,
0.0117912395,
0.0710931346,
-0.0340449922,
0.0365411043,
-0.0129408119,
0.0302774161,
-0.0332826525,
-0.0641397685,
-0.0949307084,
-0.0091379629,
-0.0517623089,
0.0332467631,
-0.033799313,
-0.0339413732,
-0.01760762,
0.0099420249,
-0.0368131064,
0.0231081918,
0.0091585424,
0.0413718075,
0.0312704183,
-0.0005071261,
0.0125897964,
0.0175185427,
-0.0212196875,
0.0040558591,
-0.0180460531,
0.009153042,
-0.0032068752,
0.0025840977,
0.0850439966,
-0.0285232235,
0.0081574181,
0.0263770465,
0.0258718636,
0.0055210581,
0.0039420873,
-0.0403516516,
-0.0052657742,
-0.0238405727,
-0.0010347501,
-0.0842350796,
0.0470988527,
0.0254971199,
0.0071269008,
-0.0404032096,
0.0101260282,
-0.0022550141,
-0.0866487473,
0.0648893192,
-0.0479754284,
-0.0023638029,
0.0205081217,
-0.0264115427,
0.0278122127,
0.0163401682,
0.0377597511,
0.0736806542,
0.0157421324,
-0.0052176537,
-0.0239127558,
0.0065834899,
0.0545700826,
0.0004906203,
0.0108427731,
-0.038579829,
-0.0027810468,
-0.0306136534,
-0.0002164502,
0.0541623868,
-0.0332009271,
-0.0150330393,
0.0520769656,
0.0529928766,
-0.0320434682,
-0.0043164282,
0.0328971371,
0.0452462547,
-0.0216476284,
-0.0174330529,
-0.0358536132,
0.0086467313,
0.0162194762,
0.006632708,
0.0238544792,
0.0157792475,
-0.0297731925,
-0.0027548776,
-0.0032403313,
-0.0144395363,
0.0607751347,
0.0010439418,
0.0578412227,
0.0000441464,
-0.0219770912,
0.0484221242,
0.021442527,
-0.0028779246,
0.0042208568,
0.0083273519,
-0.0365991667,
0.0457664989,
0.0458721146,
-0.0114087462,
-0.0104522174,
0.0178046115,
0.0339488275,
-0.0296161417,
0.0049560587,
-0.0346291102,
0.0307573713,
-0.0331509337,
-0.069615081,
-0.0194489509,
-0.0064897262,
0.0047857044,
-0.0033005648,
0.0110353995,
0.0038457899,
-0.1124777719,
-0.0336363241,
0.0124747045,
0.0368855707,
0.0119560529,
0.0027329191,
0.0148374485,
-0.0412651412,
0.0359403566,
0.0160922259,
-0.0078992993,
0.0227457844,
0.0052637476,
-0.0278632734,
0.0158137679,
-0.0340998285,
-0.0282830168,
0.0440011062,
-0.03662147,
-0.0299655423,
-0.0117122587,
-0.0672020316,
-0.0535453446,
0.0425075665,
-0.0660376176,
0.0353810415,
0.0289717503,
-0.0179285519,
-0.0180979911,
0.0023147366,
-0.0110398876,
0.0621751882,
0.0162385982,
0.0042778207,
-0.0134398388,
0.0320592336,
0.0229706187,
-0.008205778,
0.0097786114,
-0.0255275406,
-0.005336537,
-0.0011292169,
0.0335761011,
-0.0349270627,
-0.0377181396,
0.0343842171,
-0.1023352668,
-0.0051806797,
0.0299448799,
0.0163518004,
-0.0104020499,
0.0289894529,
0.0330105908,
-0.0290167313,
-0.0512243025,
0.0229736231,
-0.0149574326,
0.0037273038,
0.0509060845,
-0.018921379,
-0.0170004368,
-0.0208771974,
-0.0221114587,
-0.031116195,
0.0965387449,
0.0120734982,
-0.0827563256,
0.0035538354,
-0.0366962925,
-0.0522390194,
0.0158065762,
-0.0002416892,
-0.0053817276,
-0.0210300498,
0.0167561397,
0.0444312952,
0.0195710976,
-0.0439406671,
0.0160938948,
0.0073023885,
-0.0143337334,
-0.0557410456,
-0.008328734,
-0.0135737192,
0.0355721451,
-0.0153571181,
-0.0439811945,
-0.0017453966,
0.0321400575,
0.0111834249,
-0.0196841117,
-0.0280884709,
-0.0054514562,
-0.0118230172,
-0.0070501221,
-0.0434813537,
-0.040945217,
0.038585607,
-0.0138246343,
-0.051916644,
-0.0238377601,
0.0765840411,
-0.0222732257,
0.0112658422,
0.0423634872,
-0.0165257528,
-0.0556524843,
0.0741399899,
0.0547894686,
0.0442210175,
0.0011887059,
-0.0339878798,
-0.0062895338,
0.0286868736,
0.0203641877,
-0.016448928,
-0.0155186662,
0.031050086,
0.0275030117,
-0.0070333006,
-0.0220259838,
0.0158520881,
0.0076136873,
-0.0233747009,
0.0420302041,
0.0473941118,
-0.0250634272,
-0.0448250286,
-0.007165486,
-0.0073929229,
0.0130387936,
-0.0131433476,
-0.0080275824,
-0.0253053308,
0.0682921931,
0.0219808966,
-0.0498502851,
0.0004711791,
0.0009015315,
-0.0082292743,
0.0654533431,
0.0328457393,
-0.0497150198,
-0.0329187512,
-0.0011792165,
-0.0046764645,
-0.0026933074,
-0.007639274,
-0.0367816091,
0.0514367707,
-0.0279241223,
-0.0070559168,
0.0636895522,
0.0603944398,
-0.0440123267,
-0.0038459592,
0.015602448,
0.0257283375,
0.0199535452,
-0.0062314519,
-0.0900868624,
-0.0354746133,
-0.0102316886,
-0.002459411,
0.0432995744,
-0.0610384718,
0.0004498731,
-0.0743295476,
-0.0187846944,
0.0246177018,
-0.0342661776,
-0.0189027674,
-0.0619512573,
0.0052812621,
-0.0143391835,
-0.0302622505,
-0.0492580235,
-0.0091321357,
-0.0037256554,
-0.004420659,
-0.0154904043,
0.0257562213,
0.0042567383,
-0.0441069156,
0.0313505679,
-0.0379744917,
0.056832429,
0.0205239058,
0.0106370719,
0.0314768553,
0.0214254372,
-0.00728756,
-0.0182596091,
0.058890257,
-0.0157813169,
0.0048486949,
-0.0294144303,
0.0023423815,
-0.0246800277,
-0.0346591473,
-0.0580565743,
0.1073670685,
0.0418094769,
0.0002695427,
-0.019403059,
-0.0504741259,
0.0003434283,
0.0229005087,
0.0538273789,
0.0035460999,
-0.0739965662,
-0.0487882011,
0.0232611094,
-0.0534077026,
0.017766241,
0.0338226967,
-0.0598500632,
-0.0241717789,
-0.0422135442,
-0.015427324,
0.0562820099,
-0.0026639171,
-0.02926955,
0.0267553758,
0.0261914041,
-0.055867631,
-0.1050775647,
-0.0009749967,
-0.058203999,
0.0355342217,
0.0420845859,
-0.0028679429,
0.0340038389,
-0.0033873483,
-0.0257247109,
0.0342603549,
-0.0363763012,
-0.0769985244,
-0.0208871607,
-0.0213727709,
0.0076526687,
0.0489775874,
-0.041784063,
-0.0573456734,
0.0540918708,
0.0468771644,
-0.0281823259,
-0.0169820376,
-0.0083540017,
-0.0030322699,
-0.0106241433,
0.0343196094,
-0.0713094324,
0.0275112726,
0.0343495756,
0.0152412616,
-0.0240460318,
-0.0187863782,
0.0077477829,
0.0621493906,
0.0019432219,
0.0174538326,
0.0270387772,
-0.04106576,
-0.0212308038,
-0.0055048121,
-0.0288131591,
-0.0016354355,
0.0009303433,
-0.0143688712,
-0.0069164671,
0.0081356373,
-0.0317685306,
0.0503191166,
0.0799652487,
-0.0547254756,
-0.0178952273,
-0.0177121051,
-0.0090327291,
0.0171332713,
0.0200919006,
-0.0076002344,
0.0017811832,
0.0158389118,
-0.0155703556,
-0.0406606793,
-0.0351750888,
0.031308312,
0.0038860932,
-0.0773063824,
0.0382753909,
-0.0440333709,
0.0245391931,
-0.0202699844,
0.0036478378,
0.0437107272,
0.0262736809,
0.0345746204,
0.0164144225,
-0.0159787629,
0.0086746924,
0.0436119325,
0.0041148337,
-0.0521408021,
0.0117778042,
0.022154415,
-0.0154857934,
0.0277484078,
0.0704342797,
0.0363657996,
0.0161593985,
-0.0051458348,
-0.0615437888,
-0.0253308136,
0.001510198,
0.0043280637,
0.0408295058,
-0.0074385963,
-0.0063165743,
-0.0351319127,
-0.0959939659,
0.0193757378,
-0.018493725,
-0.002413397,
0.0289499722,
0.0044318694,
-0.0104553439,
0.0618151538,
-0.0215369165,
-0.0129915299,
0.0332376808,
0.0228887163,
-0.0291601717,
0.0110013885,
-6.075092191e-33,
-0.0137057854,
-0.0899457484,
-0.0100067211,
0.0226460993,
-0.0605273135,
0.0563915707,
-0.039998766,
-0.0427676477,
0.0027094716,
0.0427704118,
-0.0015526443,
0.0259956773,
0.0042050509,
0.0293978173,
-0.029132504,
-0.0222796667,
0.033000607,
0.0400327742,
0.0160842109,
0.0720630586,
0.0670636073,
0.0061529721,
0.0533775315,
-0.0910087228,
0.0279888399,
-0.0093142437,
-0.0041551157,
0.0087141879,
0.1014861315,
0.036880184,
-0.0150724249,
0.044460088,
0.0336656757,
-0.0095279999,
-0.002137043,
0.019659128,
-0.1055986285,
-0.0158038847,
-0.0109688174,
-0.0055026608,
-0.0347949304,
-0.0272919703,
0.0317870118,
-0.0025493575,
0.0367503501,
-0.026513638,
0.0723502859,
0.0254185814,
-0.0425912477,
-0.0506447256,
-0.0352404416,
0.0435974859,
-0.0394813083,
0.0544095114,
0.038072899,
-0.0326268859,
0.031146273,
0.0302594006,
-0.0500777923,
0.0182004962,
-0.0476543456,
-0.0299914908,
0.0166115407,
0.0154439658,
0.0279810466,
0.0476030558,
0.0126687922,
0.0093627702,
-0.0341201499,
0.0328635387,
0.0031915137,
0.0662118793,
0.0387428328,
0.0117017878,
-0.0478006192,
-0.0250281524,
-0.0905277282,
0.0233518481,
0.005796419,
0.017219143,
-0.0218910091,
0.0527230129,
-0.0001326608,
-0.0447809212,
-0.0169751216,
-0.0229411665,
-0.044111155,
-0.015489012,
-0.0272102207,
-0.034505561,
-0.0480772033,
0.07348831,
0.0001358002,
-0.06308835,
-0.0350629203,
0.0752591491,
0.0463235825,
0.0611534081,
-0.0015144631,
0.0142590115,
-0.0211213361,
-0.0355864912,
0.0234476998,
-0.0069605275,
0.0422356501,
0.0062269978,
0.053998705,
0.0013105824,
-0.0465574451,
0.004238857,
-0.0364717059,
-0.0436143875,
-0.0629385412,
-0.0429021753,
0.0562186465,
0.0380185433,
0.0041426388,
0.0270299911,
0.0732775033,
0.0409415103,
0.0084536402,
0.0280992314,
-0.0113315824,
0.0067302459,
-0.017183248,
-0.0260092653,
-0.0300324876,
-0.0215360839,
0.0606716648,
-0.0561803393,
-0.0365531892,
0.0014030186,
2.697e-7,
0.0323328264,
0.0514197163,
0.0509451739,
-0.0126360012,
0.0141872419,
0.0437484011,
-0.0025091581,
0.0575472526,
0.002771613,
0.0012034858,
0.0370495543,
0.0302464049,
-0.0223319214,
0.05121281,
-0.0626180843,
0.0663920492,
-0.0684451386,
-0.0415901728,
-0.0409834981,
0.0418022498,
0.0077485638,
0.0276480261,
0.0392441936,
-0.0097008301,
-0.0188939627,
-0.0534746423,
0.0185710285,
-0.0066064238,
-0.0097987615,
0.0219418965,
-0.0272757038,
-0.00199413,
-0.0103485733,
0.009952547,
-0.0127848871,
0.0327004083,
0.0504995547,
0.0122366603,
-0.0407724455,
0.0049910764,
-0.0124072433,
-0.0802552849,
0.022691438,
-0.0500034727,
0.0664443225,
-0.0473683625,
-0.0298174061,
-0.0132714743,
-0.0392169915,
0.0129209999,
-0.0063938596,
0.0276751462,
-0.0248289853,
0.0522871055,
0.0035236347,
-0.0101340525,
-0.0143067073,
-0.092375651,
-0.0026271476,
-0.0141229061,
-0.0029881343,
-0.0319109149,
0.0007724446,
0.0663107187,
0.0434640199,
-0.0611089021,
0.0154395001,
2.555539872e-34,
0.0158290267,
-0.0107465396,
-0.028045617,
0.0268427804,
0.0317852832,
-0.0564668924,
-0.0742338598,
0.0308558717,
0.0241480488,
-0.0955093279,
-0.0013766433
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12606v1 | Low-Redundant Optimization for Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-18T13:34:40 | 2024-06-18T13:34:40 | Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jingyuan Wang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are still struggling in aligning with human
preference in complex tasks and scenarios. They are prone to overfit into the
unexpected patterns or superficial styles in the training data. We conduct an
empirical study that only selects the top-10\% most updated parameters in LLMs
for alignment training, and see improvements in the convergence process and
final performance. It indicates the existence of redundant neurons in LLMs for
alignment training. To reduce its influence, we propose a low-redundant
alignment method named \textbf{ALLO}, focusing on optimizing the most related
neurons with the most useful supervised signals. Concretely, we first identify
the neurons that are related to the human preference data by a gradient-based
strategy, then identify the alignment-related key tokens by reward models for
computing loss. Besides, we also decompose the alignment process into the
forgetting and learning stages, where we first forget the tokens with unaligned
knowledge and then learn aligned knowledge, by updating different ratios of
neurons, respectively. Experimental results on 10 datasets have shown the
effectiveness of ALLO. Our code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/RUCAIBox/ALLO}. | [
0.0206508338,
0.0761956796,
0.0117687806,
0.050139688,
-0.0261603463,
0.0107341828,
-0.0296685025,
-0.0337354802,
-0.0278825872,
0.0170069654,
-0.0958779678,
-0.0336649343,
0.0406009406,
-0.0427930094,
0.0449664667,
-0.0154560599,
0.0728339627,
0.0024925277,
-0.0027462272,
-0.0152988378,
0.0347807631,
0.0115322266,
-0.0171696469,
0.0125723192,
-0.0163881294,
-0.0306550898,
-0.0157397259,
0.025305273,
0.0431731157,
-0.0071863011,
0.0369030982,
0.0388491377,
0.0032324276,
0.059279453,
0.0000020154,
-0.0418118425,
-0.0112356171,
-0.0288463812,
-0.0396747775,
0.0082340166,
0.0166992731,
0.0081181657,
-0.0206829868,
0.0151646705,
-0.0175616574,
-0.0080942344,
0.0946716741,
0.0449196286,
0.0527543537,
0.1043050438,
0.0143086975,
-0.0323010199,
0.0205664039,
-0.0442349762,
-0.005601224,
-0.0241695661,
0.0390021019,
-0.0341795087,
-0.0453324802,
-0.0360142887,
-0.0134797683,
0.0411643796,
0.0029455826,
0.0251472872,
0.0151660433,
0.0282322746,
-0.0206643995,
-0.0328949764,
-0.0044373279,
0.0825653076,
-0.0560797565,
-0.0382090695,
0.0052786535,
-0.0130464137,
0.0025363241,
-0.0480037667,
-0.0219831243,
-0.006978414,
0.0223988965,
0.0543051027,
0.0236715507,
-0.0282441992,
0.052774094,
0.0197446868,
-0.0211860333,
0.0474322662,
0.0202939995,
-0.0179642104,
0.0077423663,
-0.0039908616,
-0.05617797,
-0.0460636541,
-0.0126155419,
0.0029647597,
-0.0833767429,
0.0413949266,
-0.0608875528,
-0.0437615179,
0.0139463842,
-0.0633996874,
0.0577528477,
0.0596259199,
0.0184504166,
0.0341307707,
-0.0191467218,
0.0874809399,
-0.0508092418,
0.0232503712,
-0.0447047539,
0.0006750092,
-0.01978972,
-0.0299578179,
0.0039106435,
0.0172658209,
0.0125608537,
-0.0397051945,
-0.0260518081,
0.0407869108,
-0.010101648,
0.03846379,
0.0063602892,
0.0081237294,
-0.0448074266,
-0.0256629623,
-0.0187798943,
0.0540400967,
-0.0163049176,
0.01341567,
0.0128734056,
0.0060160528,
-0.0166574288,
0.0449034348,
-0.0011320892,
-0.0473832302,
-0.0007863558,
0.0584621243,
-0.0326308943,
0.0003643306,
-0.0453711636,
0.0320894383,
-0.0247573424,
-0.0607281178,
-0.0156503208,
-0.0471578054,
0.0672967061,
-0.0148791047,
-0.0175297167,
-0.0656083673,
0.0013242735,
0.0026195874,
-0.0149353007,
0.0385495983,
-0.0013052896,
0.0127879232,
0.0515811592,
-0.0442027561,
0.0121552786,
0.0786183402,
0.0321529657,
0.0510138161,
-0.0197310038,
-0.0052949344,
-0.0415928476,
0.0556760989,
0.0259669647,
-0.0098299365,
-0.0374919027,
-0.0092333937,
0.0431368388,
0.0771765709,
0.089681454,
0.0310385805,
-0.0195580665,
-0.0057892385,
0.0877863243,
-0.0050684521,
0.0291819628,
-0.0049449159,
-0.0023428525,
0.0135444906,
0.001332066,
0.0011628938,
-0.0782285035,
0.0357944146,
-0.0094562853,
0.0320902616,
0.0180980992,
0.0294591468,
-0.0312421601,
-0.0227147061,
-0.0071923286,
-0.027118234,
-0.0143161174,
0.0088578966,
0.0438435636,
-0.0161873624,
-0.0550101437,
0.0496026389,
0.0394355431,
-0.0151989814,
-0.0020049943,
-0.0120071117,
0.0222827625,
0.0368683711,
0.0123358611,
-0.0125271436,
-0.0668986216,
0.0227318257,
-0.0181805994,
0.0330064781,
0.0300124791,
0.0051579271,
0.0333657116,
-0.0765479952,
-0.037801303,
0.0207275134,
-0.0038318618,
0.0367265791,
0.0208846852,
-0.0190679431,
0.0033892961,
-0.0061938101,
-0.051784005,
0.0468837917,
-0.025387872,
-0.0154002476,
-0.0100484388,
0.0349236764,
0.0299770348,
-0.0179136544,
0.0047956812,
0.003335441,
0.0263909493,
-0.0209158175,
0.0233949926,
-0.0050804499,
-0.0745029598,
-0.0353274569,
0.0636688694,
0.0100844912,
-0.0401626192,
0.051379025,
-0.0437757671,
-0.0653543398,
-0.0156496894,
-0.0291621052,
0.052807305,
-0.0036972032,
0.0450807959,
-0.012674327,
-0.0144960498,
-0.0660151765,
0.065930672,
0.0156669803,
0.0230631679,
-0.0073292982,
-0.0176320411,
-0.0060809981,
-0.0610799119,
-0.040639095,
0.0038106355,
-0.0206108149,
0.0441574864,
0.0109168151,
-0.018281484,
-0.0502803847,
-0.0205778051,
-0.0732686222,
0.0479266942,
-0.018014906,
0.0407686569,
0.0435504802,
0.0096595082,
-0.0049989307,
-0.02071031,
-0.0469025224,
0.012019515,
-0.0503684059,
-0.0081305886,
0.0424794294,
-0.0138349216,
-0.0327574015,
-0.0665572733,
-0.005537455,
-0.0122915059,
0.0171687286,
-0.0397326872,
-0.0012592606,
-0.0645254925,
0.0359093323,
-0.0264923554,
0.0085505126,
0.0030019521,
-0.0432867073,
-0.0213573668,
0.0136891436,
0.0449393727,
0.0861434489,
0.0113719981,
-0.0092330119,
0.0418969952,
0.0256936345,
-0.0702486485,
-0.0057683606,
-0.0271316357,
-0.0142918797,
-0.0457366444,
0.0023844203,
0.0028294879,
0.0870911404,
0.0115026264,
0.0006549057,
-0.0413512364,
-0.0241140928,
0.0076838634,
0.0042124167,
-0.0210679211,
0.006192816,
-0.0579309389,
0.0165500566,
-0.0617584549,
-0.0508189648,
0.0516113192,
-0.022034619,
-0.0033409554,
-0.0432119481,
-0.0009266086,
-0.022107726,
0.0170078054,
0.0337765887,
0.0479789972,
0.0038903463,
-0.0583074503,
-0.0965961143,
-0.0193552375,
0.0118235359,
-0.021234408,
0.0480783731,
-0.0115508186,
0.0170073323,
-0.0287749991,
-0.0626386255,
-0.0583840013,
-0.0238980427,
-0.006572891,
-0.0157452393,
0.0107163377,
-0.0079926234,
-0.0585393421,
-0.030823322,
0.0186440814,
0.0450279638,
-0.0237313136,
0.0310807619,
-0.027069116,
0.0294482615,
0.0720438808,
0.0218982436,
-0.0124694016,
-0.0386284925,
-0.0238826536,
0.0383319184,
0.0466050953,
0.0353330113,
-0.0470138565,
-0.0244533867,
0.0420649648,
-0.0498077795,
0.0072701476,
-0.0160671584,
0.0302564632,
-0.0307326,
0.0325927362,
0.1185958758,
0.0144838076,
-0.0760392174,
0.0055601979,
0.0022248116,
0.0590782911,
0.0127981855,
0.0307706036,
-0.0451335348,
-0.0294426754,
0.0173807517,
0.0091506252,
0.0409554541,
0.0327600129,
-0.0023204999,
-0.1005081162,
-0.0401250906,
0.0530251004,
-0.0505039059,
-0.0082467319,
-0.0007713275,
0.0118672997,
-0.0514441244,
0.0554378591,
0.0446595028,
0.0255896244,
-0.0175022613,
0.0189712606,
0.0061847069,
-0.0467980616,
-0.0102302888,
-0.0521421172,
0.0669624582,
0.0830084532,
0.0369976014,
0.0029754797,
-0.0407417901,
0.0465553179,
0.0363841169,
-0.0121488972,
0.0268237647,
0.0094962949,
-0.0188555978,
-0.0190091822,
-0.0186076276,
0.0624212623,
-0.0411657244,
0.0083633726,
-0.0131241381,
0.0432522036,
0.0039569247,
0.0310851708,
0.0236441139,
-0.0409242809,
-0.0085066864,
0.0498315059,
0.0067908685,
-0.0661240444,
-0.0062133153,
0.0082759224,
0.0028114128,
-0.034575358,
-0.0035667268,
0.025730921,
-0.041812066,
-0.0263181087,
-0.0662117749,
0.00490251,
0.0072728274,
0.0463925041,
0.0237539336,
-0.0053721196,
-0.0059845462,
-0.0541365445,
-0.0404025987,
0.0469559655,
-0.0259844624,
-0.001971229,
-0.0946092084,
0.0112692779,
0.005406809,
-0.0218414888,
0.0027094665,
-0.0077367793,
-0.0766862333,
-0.0896128044,
-0.0054259989,
0.0214348994,
0.0136961071,
0.0806076676,
-0.0051372405,
-0.0427285768,
0.0221467204,
0.0380746461,
-0.0031755769,
0.0113107692,
-0.0034967614,
-0.0212140363,
0.0000429932,
0.0365847982,
-0.0196755473,
-0.0140607748,
0.0455366708,
0.0416520312,
0.0031455467,
0.0130575346,
0.0413396806,
0.0024374439,
0.0620688722,
-0.0350388847,
0.0192882977,
-0.0362797603,
0.0057893447,
0.0336475298,
-0.0331643745,
-0.0068270015,
-0.015805278,
0.0501330495,
0.0145447701,
0.0187026747,
-0.0302300528,
0.0510350652,
-0.0016517937,
0.0046240683,
-0.0493818149,
-0.0221456494,
0.0008559477,
0.0327065662,
0.0465482995,
-0.0348241255,
0.0318226889,
0.0126495231,
0.0456432886,
-0.0245011002,
0.0173996519,
0.0483256914,
0.0146049475,
-0.0423689112,
0.0312480293,
-0.0063504153,
-0.0512153059,
-0.031412404,
-0.0258687157,
0.0878345743,
-0.0265771598,
0.0781465322,
0.0032143299,
-0.009038995,
-0.0374691226,
0.0306462143,
-0.0491553508,
0.0135279726,
0.0048738206,
0.0215851143,
-0.020685127,
-0.019304486,
0.0664223805,
-0.0072237612,
0.0182547793,
-0.0488380678,
0.0198615715,
-0.0417381823,
0.0160045698,
0.02035366,
0.0148391658,
-0.0746886209,
-0.0351202823,
0.0175824668,
-0.0659909546,
-0.0186589435,
0.0281070508,
-0.0247880593,
-0.0001044192,
0.055931516,
0.0317623243,
-0.0432610251,
0.0152032068,
-0.0109668076,
-0.0222309306,
-0.0115379663,
-0.0313600451,
-0.0150073348,
-6.717516017e-33,
-0.0236853007,
0.0060227136,
0.0186015274,
-0.0214817002,
-0.0637591034,
-0.0077523133,
-0.010867863,
0.0124118021,
-0.0258369166,
-0.0128491111,
0.0024548962,
-0.0163752493,
0.0084538218,
0.0290254634,
0.0223976728,
0.0120974202,
0.0210982487,
0.0008938406,
-0.0379865021,
-0.0273764096,
0.0549764,
0.024990743,
0.0681114867,
-0.0222282223,
0.0026911336,
0.0230977982,
-0.0162474588,
0.0277950838,
-0.0078175087,
0.0511634611,
-0.0009434365,
0.0205209479,
0.0050506778,
-0.0230776481,
-0.0242503285,
0.0106088007,
-0.0578953959,
-0.0237044618,
0.0361308381,
0.0460758954,
-0.0250982102,
-0.0460699238,
0.0747223124,
-0.0166021083,
0.0003768914,
-0.0002598887,
0.0290867873,
-0.0250839684,
-0.0537376255,
0.0363328122,
-0.0648286492,
0.0077314656,
-0.0008763042,
-0.0232549682,
0.0049555129,
0.0106506953,
-0.0051206322,
0.0151692349,
-0.086074166,
0.0061709816,
-0.0263142399,
0.0738996342,
0.0823142603,
0.068091467,
0.0178786106,
0.0535630882,
0.0547981672,
-0.0407956541,
0.028877845,
-0.0093402965,
0.0316696428,
0.0211673211,
0.0119357836,
0.0182442181,
0.0480242707,
-0.0299889166,
-0.0435765125,
0.0197376832,
0.0135691436,
0.023530826,
0.0226584114,
0.0592095442,
-0.0191482883,
-0.0209925398,
-0.0385801792,
-0.0078506572,
-0.0442561135,
-0.0258410275,
0.0086756814,
0.0046278229,
-0.000318315,
-0.017321758,
0.0102274334,
-0.029993698,
0.0034538994,
0.0183278993,
-0.0216492191,
0.0117706507,
-0.0067580012,
0.0183394682,
-0.0673065558,
-0.0326476097,
-0.047559686,
0.0088599008,
0.0270462688,
0.0265465733,
0.0511654243,
0.0237504318,
-0.0499258973,
0.0071891961,
-0.0376271904,
-0.0490712412,
0.0006472138,
0.0008847079,
0.0696914569,
-0.0215633065,
0.0047421791,
0.0561609901,
0.0370119624,
-0.0074271243,
-0.0293712318,
-0.0079549393,
-0.0074285096,
0.0430085026,
-0.0121395113,
0.0198553018,
-0.0156951454,
-0.0062449425,
0.0155790159,
-0.0340492614,
-0.0077457456,
0.0086926958,
2.8e-7,
0.0343990698,
0.0276123267,
0.0355060995,
0.004748879,
-0.0003922873,
0.049879998,
-0.0159996003,
0.0189625062,
-0.0171046928,
0.0171953645,
0.043057058,
0.000202464,
0.0558773465,
-0.0250486154,
-0.109296523,
0.0008963245,
-0.0805280432,
0.0346521623,
-0.0361745246,
0.0105364872,
0.0084093027,
0.1122205257,
0.0381802693,
-0.0144357076,
0.008635045,
0.0040135067,
0.060433954,
-0.0260806866,
-0.0012979636,
0.0228466522,
-0.0028292513,
-0.0251212623,
-0.0494069271,
-0.0100058923,
-0.0001537003,
0.0414877608,
0.0043045157,
0.0562301502,
-0.0242209118,
-0.0253605843,
-0.0024948465,
0.02126454,
-0.0135827241,
-0.0493116193,
0.0434854031,
-0.0564459413,
-0.0493951328,
-0.0476906784,
0.0027767618,
0.0151418289,
0.0457312949,
-0.0239243787,
-0.0139589254,
-0.003526791,
0.0222022384,
0.0002903776,
-0.0553514734,
-0.0668307096,
-0.0421552844,
0.0350085013,
-0.0586741529,
-0.0316927955,
-0.0305782855,
0.02656883,
0.0361425318,
-0.0487981141,
-0.0150027182,
2.163500797e-34,
-0.0165871512,
-0.0202100072,
0.0318092182,
0.0498256572,
0.0061612083,
-0.0148442108,
-0.0216074158,
0.0186966117,
0.0021773858,
-0.0472476557,
-0.0215897746
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12593v1 | PromptDSI: Prompt-based Rehearsal-free Instance-wise Incremental Learning for Document Retrieval | 2024-06-18T13:25:18 | 2024-06-18T13:25:18 | Tuan-Luc Huynh, Thuy-Trang Vu, Weiqing Wang, Yinwei Wei, Trung Le, Dragan Gasevic, Yuan-Fang Li, Thanh-Toan Do | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Differentiable Search Index (DSI) utilizes Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs)
for efficient document retrieval without relying on external indexes. However,
DSIs need full re-training to handle updates in dynamic corpora, causing
significant computational inefficiencies. We introduce PromptDSI, a
rehearsal-free, prompt-based approach for instance-wise incremental learning in
document retrieval. PromptDSI attaches prompts to the frozen PLM's encoder of
DSI, leveraging its powerful representation to efficiently index new corpora
while maintaining a balance between stability and plasticity. We eliminate the
initial forward pass of prompt-based continual learning methods that doubles
training and inference time. Moreover, we propose a topic-aware prompt pool
that employs neural topic embeddings as fixed keys. This strategy ensures
diverse and effective prompt usage, addressing the challenge of parameter
underutilization caused by the collapse of the query-key matching mechanism.
Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that PromptDSI matches IncDSI in managing
forgetting while significantly enhancing recall by over 4% on new corpora. | [
0.0224947128,
0.0550640337,
-0.0036864756,
-0.0160400439,
0.0039009366,
0.0122193806,
0.0204496142,
0.008210971,
0.0180798732,
-0.0050051478,
-0.0262648724,
-0.0233491231,
-0.0550039522,
0.0388276353,
-0.0189015288,
-0.0060633393,
0.074478142,
-0.0122656655,
0.0118152993,
-0.0002818483,
0.0016859518,
-0.0297400206,
-0.0163667444,
0.0055207014,
0.0052728415,
-0.03649747,
-0.0472966805,
-0.0087529542,
-0.0296088886,
-0.0270475671,
0.0391864777,
0.052234821,
0.0879874751,
0.0145524871,
0.0000021267,
-0.0371225514,
-0.0323825926,
-0.0478245392,
-0.0212076902,
-0.0024104996,
0.0463277549,
0.0041060154,
0.0427320376,
-0.0058127576,
-0.011627201,
-0.0661839172,
0.0131256711,
0.0041188886,
0.0491376258,
0.0654869303,
0.0011150236,
0.004508046,
0.0368876457,
-0.0266824085,
0.018104285,
-0.0290791783,
0.0116842389,
-0.0727997497,
0.008943879,
0.0399460457,
0.0262204278,
0.0493484698,
0.0209786296,
-0.0255783591,
0.0486434996,
0.0397695154,
0.0472448841,
-0.0255649723,
-0.016275743,
0.0346425623,
-0.0116910255,
-0.023052454,
-0.0196177289,
-0.0132055795,
-0.0045630704,
0.0350111388,
-0.042281989,
-0.0047801947,
-0.007151267,
-0.0209713615,
0.0036756496,
0.0080633983,
0.0199987087,
0.029187819,
-0.0185687989,
0.0003689618,
0.030927049,
-0.0558311343,
0.0393244103,
-0.0368786976,
-0.0145055791,
0.0255534463,
0.0483080857,
0.040033374,
-0.0404437259,
0.0124999788,
-0.0066595981,
-0.0563353002,
0.0324999951,
-0.026093794,
0.0068730251,
0.0455937758,
-0.0261851419,
0.0557320677,
-0.0153634083,
0.0447004065,
0.0359297618,
0.0267081093,
-0.0573722124,
0.0077321711,
-0.035366483,
-0.0331734978,
-0.0754554942,
0.0527740754,
0.0159565806,
-0.0325378552,
0.0269838404,
0.0716386065,
0.0142583521,
0.0090852128,
-0.0207812842,
-0.0042011845,
-0.0522522144,
0.022828076,
-0.027571043,
0.0342924781,
-0.0357851908,
-0.0041765696,
0.0193776879,
-0.0032671646,
-0.043847993,
-0.007285486,
0.010122274,
-0.0090947701,
0.0046919957,
-0.0296575986,
-0.0409754254,
-0.0796540976,
-0.0115103154,
0.0287019331,
0.0449018441,
0.0105554499,
0.0099368151,
-0.014729579,
0.0295423847,
-0.032116238,
-0.0143679548,
-0.0734719113,
-0.0110631548,
0.0609510019,
-0.0288461465,
0.0522405542,
-0.0016935766,
-0.0036097013,
0.0639680028,
0.0216544066,
0.0282254722,
0.056144651,
-0.0257491339,
0.0234312769,
0.0418232307,
0.020835435,
-0.0001177027,
0.0005407415,
0.0338246748,
0.0290332232,
-0.0369456783,
0.0282234438,
0.0561333895,
0.0375852212,
0.00796354,
-0.0057250722,
-0.0342950299,
-0.0176950768,
0.0146054775,
0.0617791861,
-0.0021903301,
-0.0177532975,
0.0026471238,
0.009968414,
-0.0035124449,
-0.0244330708,
0.004655784,
0.0063861329,
-0.0057744836,
-0.0084254406,
0.0369106047,
-0.0236714929,
-0.0477529205,
-0.0135612637,
0.0305088107,
0.0027984267,
-0.0218227413,
0.0074683186,
0.0235728174,
-0.0018245087,
-0.0229944922,
0.0427445173,
-0.0003148229,
-0.0436636023,
-0.0039564273,
0.0027597442,
0.0271705408,
0.0923145562,
0.0381479673,
-0.0716374815,
-0.0178186446,
-0.0134788686,
0.048312474,
0.034937717,
0.0037526384,
-0.0093071843,
0.0140224947,
-0.0551821478,
-0.021246044,
0.0047438019,
0.008541652,
0.0165811833,
-0.0103853941,
0.040005818,
0.0041704276,
-0.0128935473,
0.0040669348,
0.0354934186,
-0.0607284456,
-0.0464052036,
0.0150467865,
0.0096540367,
-0.0274567548,
-0.0048098224,
-0.0022605672,
0.0185739063,
0.0491458066,
-0.0235011224,
0.0027598552,
-0.0325480551,
-0.0645762682,
-0.0291494504,
0.0087629817,
0.0573139749,
0.0158908851,
-0.0423882492,
-0.0138523057,
-0.0189565346,
-0.009451271,
0.0209319666,
0.0122684184,
-0.0642735064,
-0.0086735161,
-0.0359747782,
0.0004243205,
-0.0444435962,
0.0360515527,
-0.0420996398,
0.0441816226,
0.0170385893,
0.0811799839,
-0.0123055102,
-0.0570388995,
-0.0274469592,
0.0412117988,
0.0132503286,
0.0076131732,
0.0395241119,
0.0245776959,
-0.0302565023,
-0.0239804164,
-0.0833322108,
0.0269785058,
-0.0389654301,
-0.032857392,
-0.0149458796,
0.0295841917,
-0.031711176,
-0.0497938022,
-0.002261688,
-0.0361098982,
-0.0111225303,
0.0452637933,
-0.0022603374,
0.0264712814,
0.0154516948,
-0.0227366351,
-0.0221086964,
0.0269566737,
0.0733621269,
-0.0292632319,
-0.03446218,
-0.0380829424,
0.0459621288,
-0.0167344213,
0.0092633143,
-0.0226564519,
-0.002138501,
0.0104890456,
-0.0549391098,
0.0139271002,
0.0468678586,
0.0441307463,
0.0095089339,
0.022865437,
-0.0297950469,
-0.0908522978,
0.0316296741,
-0.0359351374,
-0.0478945635,
0.0401125588,
0.0188351683,
0.0358014479,
-0.0015206086,
-0.0180207789,
0.004757673,
-0.037346229,
0.0093669491,
-0.012236095,
0.0065422887,
-0.1067840382,
-0.0069865067,
-0.0143911252,
-0.0093776891,
-0.007876873,
-0.0595801622,
0.0650286973,
0.0079411818,
0.0158643834,
-0.0540635623,
-0.0070079858,
-0.003833245,
0.0195942782,
-0.0055777789,
-0.0048656096,
0.0080364989,
-0.0320488252,
-0.0182160344,
0.0305284038,
0.0079989871,
-0.0404346138,
0.0399616733,
-0.0050107837,
0.0434996709,
0.0198231209,
-0.0546668731,
-0.0664472133,
-0.0949909389,
0.0534351319,
0.0052146548,
-0.0264234543,
0.0035261584,
-0.022383716,
0.0007222786,
0.027034631,
0.0884385258,
-0.0249371696,
-0.0164318811,
-0.0071989414,
0.0067176656,
0.0187062193,
0.0054410459,
-0.0338113755,
-0.0154918032,
0.0366704836,
0.0290175918,
0.0505357496,
-0.0619475506,
-0.0083097164,
0.0295031201,
0.0283106193,
-0.0548552684,
0.0037040568,
0.0060035228,
-0.0432852544,
-0.0094062332,
-0.0708955005,
0.0932603404,
0.0274113361,
-0.1259602755,
-0.0445795693,
-0.0102916928,
0.0374961942,
0.0168455075,
0.0550794341,
-0.0529690757,
-0.0069766729,
0.0124489171,
0.0831822902,
0.018966157,
-0.0153456004,
-0.0283748787,
-0.0707761496,
0.0064356378,
0.0058823619,
-0.0019064877,
0.0204955824,
-0.0911630988,
-0.0257683434,
0.046609547,
0.0234910902,
0.0641336516,
-0.0212280359,
0.0080488268,
0.0148903672,
0.0042882808,
-0.0577107742,
-0.0364869498,
-0.0212849807,
-0.0118429828,
0.0269745477,
-0.0209514704,
0.012308782,
-0.0477889143,
0.0239079446,
-0.0457044095,
-0.0115448413,
-0.028836485,
0.0031063068,
-0.0440168828,
0.0212496929,
-0.0061256755,
0.0069351154,
-0.0402547233,
-0.0344422907,
0.0150260953,
0.0393643565,
-0.0342284217,
0.0510469228,
-0.0188488774,
-0.0512249395,
0.0009531017,
0.0545410737,
0.0171815045,
-0.026086228,
0.0202263165,
-0.0081241177,
0.0507113263,
0.0281097386,
0.0534780249,
-0.0147986226,
-0.0285139848,
0.0192254279,
-0.03083634,
-0.0468116105,
-0.0154855363,
0.0473628715,
-0.002839304,
0.0228137635,
-0.0439077467,
-0.0264785085,
-0.0780569389,
0.0323634967,
-0.0166113302,
-0.0389171541,
-0.0650829673,
-0.0186286904,
0.0327571146,
0.0002405231,
-0.0291490722,
-0.0451893806,
-0.0253927354,
-0.0176208038,
0.0165233668,
0.0279368218,
0.0026318145,
0.0456546843,
-0.0158138685,
-0.078706637,
0.0922907442,
0.0335477255,
-0.0302392244,
0.0188573692,
-0.0142197609,
-0.0168006904,
0.0015328792,
-0.0018255201,
-0.0637563542,
0.0013690763,
-0.0005330693,
0.0400172733,
0.0306884144,
-0.0364934169,
0.0054915971,
0.0016016725,
0.074139148,
0.0341378488,
0.0100450702,
-0.0830552429,
0.0459556282,
0.0191499442,
-0.0307137873,
-0.0054130009,
0.0352002867,
0.0236362144,
-0.0231557842,
-0.0247715469,
0.0350860171,
0.0222827848,
0.0277204141,
-0.0067235501,
-0.0370886102,
0.0072586294,
0.0287590604,
0.0018224266,
0.0329508185,
-0.0555215999,
0.0424681418,
-0.0149873486,
0.0354641117,
-0.0629786104,
0.0517804027,
0.0534087829,
-0.0120674474,
-0.0426497273,
0.0369956754,
-0.061143145,
-0.0694918334,
-0.0097827567,
0.0015626127,
0.0509084053,
-0.0061249365,
-0.0210555997,
-0.0111189019,
0.0129214153,
-0.0288276076,
-0.0414536595,
0.0384652019,
-0.0501364544,
-0.0026718327,
0.0257043075,
0.0095025487,
0.0445079543,
0.0619856492,
-0.0309868827,
0.028527258,
-0.0434961952,
0.0009550905,
-0.0363479629,
0.0423355401,
0.0244448837,
0.077767089,
-0.0164286569,
0.0010591922,
0.0130855516,
0.0183556415,
0.0446596555,
-0.01631134,
-0.0415181704,
0.0314926319,
0.0480831675,
0.068637982,
-0.0175053552,
-0.000334565,
-0.0276963525,
0.0455942526,
-0.014116969,
-0.0491502993,
-0.013511518,
-6.891763218e-33,
-0.0347006507,
-0.0025330556,
0.0258781929,
-0.0483924672,
-0.0222885907,
0.0158038754,
-0.0283843558,
-0.0180970076,
0.0194777027,
-0.005664811,
-0.0589528941,
0.0181713738,
0.0091964239,
0.0057646548,
0.0048705931,
-0.0488333441,
0.0538519509,
-0.0022506167,
-0.0160725471,
0.0328928046,
0.0976862535,
0.1005408615,
0.0178028569,
0.0276565868,
0.0267696567,
-0.011824742,
0.0148893632,
0.0384678133,
0.0561800636,
0.0335340388,
-0.0244995728,
0.0361871459,
0.0190054961,
-0.0033753812,
-0.0040537654,
0.0301278848,
-0.1031765193,
-0.0643837601,
-0.044911705,
0.0120763173,
0.0116382847,
-0.0409362987,
0.0176525079,
-0.0289177559,
-0.0189217553,
0.0272052959,
0.0192869157,
-0.0064694057,
-0.0627500713,
-0.0172413643,
0.0083127106,
-0.0054725991,
0.0101317931,
0.0124924928,
0.0035398626,
-0.0057601477,
0.0044354764,
0.0158569589,
-0.0790656209,
0.0017607152,
-0.0246726014,
0.0408854,
-0.0067050904,
0.0295249745,
0.0161028579,
0.0776825473,
0.0406720713,
-0.0155398874,
0.017081188,
-0.0184121393,
0.0814071894,
-0.035963323,
0.001880963,
-0.0152517417,
0.0387210883,
-0.0285135116,
-0.0349063799,
0.0405445062,
0.0645894408,
0.0539858304,
0.0535423458,
0.0357382149,
-0.0332230404,
-0.0452199206,
-0.057671126,
0.0196943078,
-0.0450159982,
-0.0255896002,
0.0547554418,
0.0480324924,
0.0025669243,
-0.0510371141,
0.0646332279,
0.0256957896,
-0.0162433684,
0.0545280091,
0.009806226,
-0.0134143727,
0.0033826842,
0.0251378063,
-0.0263515376,
-0.0237169303,
0.0031178934,
-0.0492767096,
-0.0238375943,
0.0192573536,
-0.0132069252,
0.0316774063,
-0.0589607805,
0.000027459,
0.0013233459,
-0.018762527,
0.001886404,
0.0189478993,
0.0136079388,
0.0124804666,
0.0073672142,
0.0974226892,
0.0239970274,
-0.0088554276,
-0.0460923165,
-0.0267408323,
0.0338608399,
0.0288275611,
0.001377708,
0.0254283641,
-0.0168911461,
0.0518738888,
0.0084243938,
-0.110572733,
0.0503989384,
0.0431993566,
2.96e-7,
0.006058068,
0.0482966602,
-0.0160140544,
-0.0406953581,
0.00060312,
0.0048367148,
-0.042510286,
0.0067604235,
0.0297474936,
0.0216481313,
0.0068964912,
0.0056232163,
-0.0049386197,
-0.0090025179,
-0.1086854115,
-0.0087163812,
-0.0702483431,
0.0234983619,
-0.0568232425,
-0.0255542621,
-0.0118347351,
0.0644746274,
0.0125003895,
0.0139192007,
0.0088567501,
-0.0634327233,
0.0858491287,
-0.0055046906,
-0.0096409703,
-0.0028086109,
0.0633054301,
0.0374461822,
0.0099949706,
0.0028795584,
-0.0194688682,
0.0371723808,
0.0307768695,
0.0298526529,
0.0230436679,
-0.0412912406,
0.0018759613,
0.0003314389,
-0.0144959548,
-0.0354294702,
0.0608453304,
-0.0443556271,
0.0254369881,
0.004846469,
-0.0281698555,
-0.0184129067,
0.0598738492,
-0.004208012,
-0.0664498061,
0.0302972626,
0.0070832954,
0.0516258143,
0.0107384874,
-0.1114191413,
0.0129894344,
0.0010845941,
-0.0484231263,
-0.0196849033,
-0.052053377,
0.0095486809,
0.0063327947,
-0.0230286904,
0.0116265565,
2.685622326e-34,
0.0321791098,
-0.0087079043,
-0.0053708591,
0.0179819539,
-0.00519621,
-0.0273703262,
0.0569385178,
0.03877794,
0.0256140418,
-0.1029521078,
-0.0232101101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12585v1 | Breaking the Ceiling of the LLM Community by Treating Token Generation as a Classification for Ensembling | 2024-06-18T13:17:26 | 2024-06-18T13:17:26 | Yao-Ching Yu, Chun-Chih Kuo, Ziqi Ye, Yu-Cheng Chang, Yueh-Se Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Ensembling multiple models has always been an effective approach to push the
limits of existing performance and is widely used in classification tasks by
simply averaging the classification probability vectors from multiple
classifiers to achieve better accuracy. However, in the thriving open-source
Large Language Model (LLM) community, ensembling methods are rare and typically
limited to ensembling the full-text outputs of LLMs, such as selecting the best
output using a ranker, which leads to underutilization of token-level
probability information. In this paper, we treat the Generation of each token
by LLMs as a Classification (GaC) for ensembling. This approach fully exploits
the probability information at each generation step and better prevents LLMs
from producing early incorrect tokens that lead to snowballing errors. In
experiments, we ensemble state-of-the-art LLMs on several benchmarks, including
exams, mathematics and reasoning, and observe that our method breaks the
existing community performance ceiling. Furthermore, we observed that most of
the tokens in the answer are simple and do not affect the correctness of the
final answer. Therefore, we also experimented with ensembling only key tokens,
and the results showed better performance with lower latency across benchmarks. | [
0.0059660254,
0.0753394738,
0.0001060752,
0.0494455323,
-0.0347018503,
0.0039113718,
-0.0221453998,
-0.0001672754,
-0.002527457,
-0.0747323856,
0.0182977542,
-0.0303414539,
0.0154556166,
0.0144288046,
0.0262259617,
-0.0155510595,
0.0263899919,
-0.0664944425,
-0.0362760574,
-0.0421971157,
-0.036699418,
0.0001726623,
0.0061891978,
0.0507508926,
0.0108589856,
-0.0115248328,
-0.0263190866,
-0.004440574,
-0.004673935,
0.0164695065,
-0.0071479599,
0.0740519986,
-0.033207491,
0.0762438923,
0.000001979,
-0.0677347407,
-0.0282076728,
-0.0007443196,
-0.0474288538,
0.0085220337,
-0.0058616358,
0.0410021096,
0.0022817608,
0.0509293675,
-0.0226667374,
0.0109609179,
0.031381648,
-0.0048695267,
0.046729207,
0.0526765138,
0.0223480687,
-0.0380208343,
0.0333319493,
-0.0038172433,
0.0106895901,
-0.0166934263,
0.0295987837,
-0.0290430523,
0.0055296631,
0.01285455,
-0.0217667185,
0.0008176552,
0.0414839946,
-0.0112727135,
0.0201642439,
0.0360034481,
-0.0454596579,
-0.013480613,
0.000578955,
0.053688921,
-0.0486996099,
-0.0448046289,
-0.0005275387,
-0.0183916837,
0.0266522728,
0.0150340665,
-0.0450163893,
0.0458647646,
-0.022318447,
0.0422737896,
0.0052104066,
-0.0186431166,
0.0435292013,
0.0234997198,
-0.0328680165,
0.1162708402,
0.0318605416,
-0.0014936089,
-0.0371032432,
0.006626565,
-0.0531642102,
-0.0657165498,
-0.0021573955,
0.016682066,
-0.0327530913,
-0.0030144604,
-0.0492250323,
-0.0319779441,
0.0444306321,
-0.0012440138,
0.0005181784,
0.0081608146,
-0.0042467816,
0.0549759939,
-0.04686445,
0.0449856296,
0.00356288,
0.0388818309,
-0.0572657064,
-0.0472368635,
-0.0393212251,
-0.0142990928,
0.0054037203,
0.0777194798,
-0.0468761511,
-0.0105972253,
-0.0717856959,
0.0184148867,
-0.0103360163,
0.0193268191,
0.0117472354,
0.0183008034,
0.0227304976,
-0.0143464413,
-0.0304347314,
0.0014584347,
-0.0201396067,
0.0074338806,
0.0137597481,
-0.0393241011,
-0.0221047457,
0.0374347046,
-0.026470717,
-0.0185349565,
0.0224491898,
0.0387017615,
-0.0064714267,
-0.0251985192,
0.031843476,
-0.0397500098,
-0.0083683245,
-0.0390617326,
-0.0071503916,
-0.1050415263,
0.0300442483,
0.0444397666,
0.003816379,
-0.0408450067,
0.0056154719,
-0.0033621609,
-0.0121464841,
0.0516480505,
-0.0047205663,
0.0185086466,
0.0282070823,
0.0273524933,
-0.0133784693,
0.0612964816,
-0.0037942883,
0.047572419,
0.0368401967,
-0.0239409897,
0.0414426997,
0.0536340997,
0.0285186395,
-0.0143844597,
-0.0093899379,
0.0220721997,
0.062862128,
0.0301931668,
-0.0016528919,
0.055053629,
-0.0357484482,
-0.0207909979,
0.0423068851,
0.0416586176,
-0.0166837182,
-0.0153495967,
-0.0367291868,
-0.0214817915,
0.0044813738,
-0.0131556429,
-0.0433168113,
0.0103552993,
-0.0400265343,
-0.0057450994,
0.1021265611,
0.0439650528,
-0.0008672992,
-0.0513243526,
-0.0267583523,
-0.0283379927,
-0.0727756917,
0.0253273267,
0.0607581288,
-0.032859996,
-0.0365344658,
0.0730914697,
0.017525509,
-0.041660089,
0.0116869221,
-0.0870584026,
0.0149798235,
0.0342758968,
0.0691654459,
-0.018784361,
-0.0148941604,
-0.0076096673,
0.016193619,
0.0195114203,
-0.0056236442,
-0.029805107,
-0.0011987343,
-0.0386738963,
-0.0246890895,
0.0259836093,
0.0171653237,
0.006921662,
0.0529739298,
0.0015648857,
0.0048970897,
-0.0290038791,
0.0186445247,
0.0234780628,
-0.0018107775,
-0.0069074649,
0.0134363174,
-0.0281675179,
0.0471299775,
-0.0092130676,
-0.0188669804,
0.0311605521,
0.0533857197,
-0.0468027517,
-0.076036565,
-0.0333510675,
-0.0125163831,
-0.0272902809,
0.0605900362,
-0.0251121707,
-0.0273263473,
0.0122367321,
-0.0634071454,
-0.0584528483,
0.0046597417,
0.0006336871,
0.0334218703,
-0.0177287515,
0.0299456641,
-0.0172574539,
-0.0143842241,
-0.056576971,
0.0468391813,
-0.0125373546,
0.0551343895,
-0.0042697424,
-0.0148467189,
0.0172158126,
-0.0185200721,
-0.0341729783,
0.0280644279,
-0.0092953574,
0.0126568694,
0.0126631139,
-0.0307047479,
-0.0398244783,
-0.0740233585,
-0.0900499821,
-0.000771017,
0.0026550861,
0.040711958,
-0.0060579279,
-0.0194128901,
-0.0080444599,
-0.0096245091,
-0.0226702821,
-0.0526971146,
0.0203120019,
0.0191360712,
0.0095661394,
-0.0035804238,
-0.0464265272,
-0.0120148361,
-0.0172066819,
-0.0061848569,
0.0579315834,
-0.0082091801,
-0.0022545573,
-0.0639445633,
-0.007947675,
-0.0269474797,
-0.023832934,
-0.0185761526,
-0.0098289102,
0.0007046407,
-0.033264596,
0.0106813246,
0.0412845835,
0.0166733824,
-0.0111230612,
0.0407802835,
0.0091624632,
-0.0590172,
-0.0244574696,
0.0019011553,
-0.0096817976,
-0.0323628709,
-0.0079737986,
-0.0152339395,
0.0436359495,
-0.0217603724,
-0.0428943969,
-0.0324705131,
0.0316381231,
-0.0079951975,
-0.0200597662,
-0.0815418363,
-0.0145038031,
0.0019999328,
0.0290243123,
0.0000812118,
-0.0849223062,
0.051021792,
-0.0190636013,
0.0099995155,
-0.0224636756,
0.0159242358,
-0.0407890715,
0.0593446232,
0.0203242674,
0.0057013165,
-0.0228704158,
-0.0145038757,
-0.0458872728,
-0.0031789737,
0.0066683874,
-0.0551175699,
0.0453875251,
-0.036404077,
0.0138677666,
-0.0209875405,
-0.0646934658,
-0.0187400319,
-0.0283699241,
-0.0186221879,
0.0440678932,
0.0342010967,
-0.0315745808,
-0.0376798995,
-0.0163174812,
-0.0054227794,
-0.0010525516,
-0.0220959894,
-0.0013576602,
-0.0123345684,
0.0471041873,
0.0652025193,
0.0004540962,
0.039958667,
-0.054968942,
0.0051146373,
0.0904069766,
0.0953268558,
0.0239437111,
0.0121979825,
-0.0426713526,
0.0467529297,
-0.0363203101,
-0.0240446497,
0.0259566549,
0.0078925099,
-0.0182039682,
0.0036172559,
0.133172825,
0.0368192866,
-0.0148691526,
-0.0062648538,
-0.0037949716,
0.0544588715,
0.0211998895,
0.0112661961,
-0.0821595192,
-0.0317894667,
0.025867492,
0.0214482248,
0.0101820938,
-0.0257785153,
0.0329916589,
-0.1277599931,
0.0230513141,
0.0209567323,
-0.0471472405,
-0.0337678529,
-0.0635927096,
-0.0256819688,
-0.0122944647,
0.0029096624,
0.0288527831,
0.0147239808,
0.0249889921,
0.0194353703,
-0.0323907882,
-0.0529241078,
0.0297465324,
-0.0402293168,
0.0645830482,
0.0146984644,
-0.0125665516,
-0.004918321,
-0.0448813438,
0.0698457807,
-0.0081056971,
-0.0298424643,
-0.0115622552,
0.0236907434,
0.0028850217,
0.0134864775,
0.0024490214,
0.0344996378,
-0.0453674197,
-0.0287340116,
0.0224154629,
0.0972532481,
-0.0082126437,
-0.0328939669,
-0.0302134361,
-0.0659595504,
-0.0137059204,
0.0825134814,
0.0042138388,
-0.0249768756,
-0.0575591475,
-0.0552191697,
0.0046996432,
-0.0180765092,
0.0231724903,
0.0118042175,
0.0410892554,
0.0173065066,
-0.0296168011,
0.0200871341,
0.0617900752,
0.0388874225,
-0.0151907941,
0.05225306,
-0.0412304364,
0.0040934971,
-0.0314734988,
0.0225760192,
-0.0413961709,
0.0320353583,
-0.0954453498,
0.0071351137,
0.025172323,
0.0106239077,
-0.040874742,
0.0041206665,
-0.0905091465,
-0.0780573785,
0.0180196743,
0.0453593954,
0.0322010703,
0.0131712584,
0.0114656836,
-0.0798156857,
0.0681601167,
0.0825798959,
0.0164761692,
0.0245842766,
-0.0016069713,
-0.0016295488,
-0.0162801798,
0.0145941097,
-0.0472248942,
-0.0152739529,
0.016623361,
0.018511679,
-0.0263825785,
-0.0118263597,
-0.0040480616,
0.0648451969,
0.0158715695,
-0.0196783356,
0.0133149233,
-0.0010242199,
0.0625194609,
0.0020345808,
-0.0225897115,
0.0030917381,
0.0046925787,
0.0352242887,
-0.0329505205,
0.013928975,
0.0225129072,
0.020254964,
0.0377315357,
-0.0143867852,
-0.0090092504,
0.0146774165,
0.032086011,
0.095947735,
-0.0555740781,
0.0123486575,
-0.0318590067,
0.0095382156,
0.0383556709,
-0.0300011132,
-0.0038770393,
0.0285838768,
0.0167586394,
-0.0111532565,
0.0143587226,
-0.0489913411,
-0.0662852749,
-0.0335701369,
0.0727912039,
0.0514253527,
0.0584583245,
0.0342987441,
-0.0095221298,
-0.0361235514,
-0.0380978137,
0.0097437678,
0.0238652211,
-0.028034078,
0.0483283363,
0.0121208662,
-0.0167818349,
-0.0019288248,
0.0899253786,
0.0045600072,
0.0414247923,
0.0029367898,
0.0013790022,
-0.0312154721,
-0.0307228211,
-0.0031007829,
0.0121521158,
-0.0074410732,
0.0168519299,
-0.0457162596,
-0.0453360491,
0.025708653,
0.0475933515,
0.0127452128,
0.0084276749,
0.0236271173,
0.0723655745,
0.0133056855,
-0.0149548166,
-0.0333209001,
0.0056498451,
0.0110402917,
-0.0346210524,
0.0108206645,
-6.179838289e-33,
-0.0164898187,
-0.0529252104,
-0.0040409402,
-0.0015529317,
0.0152177243,
-0.0157830603,
0.0188655797,
-0.000622402,
0.0261339862,
-0.0151069639,
-0.0019051745,
0.0183522422,
0.0092853233,
0.0711105168,
0.0455533303,
-0.0327800997,
0.0318484083,
0.0058399462,
-0.0356990434,
0.0166359991,
0.0379820019,
-0.0054159286,
0.0141214281,
0.0025615776,
0.0019762989,
-0.0025497905,
0.0034646157,
0.0227094758,
-0.0595770068,
0.0580676049,
0.0043627471,
0.0329772569,
0.0155039132,
-0.0197409783,
-0.0105713243,
-0.0079043955,
-0.014815012,
-0.0316290706,
-0.0044036726,
-0.005369972,
0.0008165917,
-0.0387522355,
0.0592577457,
0.0297519453,
-0.0273725521,
-0.020668013,
0.0139417155,
-0.0193526857,
-0.0465309508,
-0.0378945135,
0.014848494,
0.0319292396,
0.0022634955,
0.0104321418,
-0.0146481311,
-0.0020761318,
0.0171071272,
0.0442891791,
-0.0495315902,
0.0151161142,
0.0279270224,
0.0608888604,
0.062035203,
0.0471579134,
-0.0168400723,
0.0702350065,
0.0219199117,
-0.0009215274,
-0.0424794182,
-0.0071168188,
0.0049804994,
0.0232076421,
0.0846008956,
0.0414133966,
0.0529847816,
0.0069064843,
-0.078465566,
0.0457270481,
0.0346830264,
-0.0148853306,
0.0375796594,
0.0118619213,
-0.0219068266,
-0.0327812806,
-0.0630470961,
-0.0003565417,
-0.027462272,
0.004164522,
0.0173694696,
-0.0022186623,
-0.027324263,
-0.0419236645,
0.0257855598,
-0.0418717936,
-0.0733923092,
0.0266550966,
0.0174229853,
0.0032437958,
-0.0028318013,
0.0411076583,
-0.0415343568,
-0.0331312604,
0.0211120378,
-0.0157349613,
0.0244745016,
-0.0056746406,
0.0052188085,
0.0022828253,
-0.0860843509,
0.0141909597,
-0.0219260957,
0.0156042101,
0.0062677767,
-0.0256699678,
0.0468887873,
0.0186909344,
0.0246815868,
-0.00589523,
0.0103847124,
0.0155616254,
-0.009494734,
0.02790487,
-0.0020824403,
-0.0123744179,
0.0225439314,
0.0227679443,
-0.0295856893,
-0.0040131984,
0.0343805365,
-0.0346829593,
-0.0027933002,
0.0100598186,
2.604e-7,
0.07196448,
0.041248098,
-0.0024116924,
-0.0063046147,
0.0318215936,
0.0292190127,
-0.0177649893,
0.0072150752,
0.0440283865,
-0.0119095165,
-0.0453299098,
0.0115545094,
0.0549893379,
0.0553334206,
-0.1103058457,
0.0330696441,
-0.0687941238,
0.0249576829,
-0.0605191253,
0.0016340249,
0.0322083794,
0.1052125096,
0.0133644193,
-0.0277682766,
-0.031099949,
-0.0437498838,
0.0424169973,
-0.0333692096,
-0.0107280053,
0.0302300509,
-0.0050924262,
-0.0307086427,
0.0370462723,
0.0407086685,
0.0035376747,
-0.008627018,
0.0172834918,
0.0358408056,
-0.0052193212,
-0.0109867016,
-0.034735132,
-0.0358311161,
0.0022987588,
-0.0782041848,
0.0780274123,
-0.039442338,
-0.0105009777,
-0.049136728,
-0.0255239829,
-0.0519395769,
0.0571641102,
-0.0013435171,
-0.0176111888,
0.038377434,
-0.0052840011,
-0.0153962336,
0.0282766595,
-0.0844692513,
-0.0393845215,
-0.0080817165,
-0.063932538,
-0.0703262687,
-0.0219672974,
0.0039681201,
0.0222632661,
-0.0536844544,
-0.0139085939,
2.829723929e-34,
0.0608656555,
-0.0057236603,
0.0071010403,
0.0581583418,
0.038324967,
-0.0349852555,
-0.0104487762,
0.0235741697,
-0.0120042162,
-0.0755752921,
-0.0140698841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12572v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12572v2 | Mathador-LM: A Dynamic Benchmark for Mathematical Reasoning on Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T13:02:12 | 2024-06-19T12:28:10 | Eldar Kurtic, Amir Moeini, Dan Alistarh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | We introduce Mathador-LM, a new benchmark for evaluating the mathematical
reasoning on large language models (LLMs), combining ruleset interpretation,
planning, and problem-solving. This benchmark is inspired by the Mathador game,
where the objective is to reach a target number using basic arithmetic
operations on a given set of base numbers, following a simple set of rules. We
show that, across leading LLMs, we obtain stable average performance while
generating benchmark instances dynamically, following a target difficulty
level. Thus, our benchmark alleviates concerns about test-set leakage into
training data, an issue that often undermines popular benchmarks. Additionally,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of both open and closed-source
state-of-the-art LLMs on Mathador-LM. Our findings reveal that contemporary
models struggle with Mathador-LM, scoring significantly lower than average 3rd
graders. This stands in stark contrast to their strong performance on popular
mathematical reasoning benchmarks. | [
-0.0385355987,
0.0837996379,
-0.034811426,
0.0750361085,
-0.0606425814,
0.0053044488,
-0.021815313,
0.0217860229,
-0.0531908982,
0.0162806921,
-0.0025247301,
-0.0017464397,
-0.0231958758,
0.027635647,
0.0065110284,
-0.0166897066,
0.0103936605,
-0.0622595772,
-0.006584222,
-0.0080908826,
-0.0316995196,
-0.0249537751,
-0.0160356387,
0.0096444143,
-0.012885998,
-0.0523751043,
0.014712465,
-0.0272798091,
-0.0114651043,
-0.0448594503,
-0.0196452904,
0.0096769864,
0.0075524151,
0.053024672,
0.0000022447,
-0.0514331199,
-0.0188843533,
-0.0035993191,
-0.0377309024,
0.0302522704,
-0.0208741687,
-0.0053798165,
-0.0048922785,
0.0505492054,
-0.0514815524,
0.0219288506,
0.0085447188,
0.0053485674,
0.0768911168,
0.0616991855,
0.010355426,
-0.0153583232,
0.0323008262,
-0.0120997345,
0.0344898812,
-0.0843347758,
0.0082249949,
0.077767536,
0.0305463243,
-0.0445823148,
-0.0113427136,
0.0126769925,
0.0714851841,
0.0075913407,
-0.0545735173,
0.0207230095,
-0.0291744471,
0.0283677839,
-0.0001524468,
0.0715223178,
-0.0337462164,
-0.0235384945,
-0.010372824,
0.0039932546,
-0.0230977423,
-0.0119271278,
-0.0479181483,
0.0491827652,
0.0077649127,
0.0169368964,
0.0004789082,
0.0080194287,
0.0373553559,
-0.0010828155,
-0.029046949,
0.1194636673,
-0.0076018004,
-0.0146029424,
-0.0222455356,
-0.0094967652,
-0.0527353846,
-0.0495658107,
0.005290864,
0.0403852127,
-0.0085361442,
0.0215450749,
-0.0120651256,
-0.0123868361,
-0.0053843195,
-0.0137360413,
0.0627250224,
0.0760568678,
0.0370521173,
0.0601033308,
-0.0060464097,
0.0529025346,
-0.0043769209,
0.0433067642,
-0.0161583088,
0.0371279418,
-0.0110611133,
0.0099690203,
-0.0234823916,
0.0350706354,
0.0147696594,
0.0259163864,
-0.0260982588,
0.0074544186,
-0.0362427719,
0.0494656079,
-0.0068435417,
-0.0246843249,
0.0175545271,
-0.0393874571,
-0.0236245468,
0.0010498218,
-0.0733321458,
0.0310356021,
-0.0014846246,
-0.0557405837,
-0.0394321978,
-0.0037141696,
-0.0416955166,
-0.0240580421,
0.0415930524,
0.1031690165,
-0.0138348881,
-0.0269146655,
0.0046035275,
-0.0595461279,
0.0448337011,
-0.1149828807,
0.0017580651,
-0.0867783055,
0.0365361646,
0.0118905567,
-0.0080831489,
-0.0161695331,
0.0036546055,
0.0055415388,
0.047118444,
0.0584534332,
0.0543838777,
0.0037666911,
-0.0377278626,
0.0242719334,
-0.0601239838,
0.0898466632,
0.0519210361,
0.0096563641,
0.0061261123,
0.0222469419,
-0.010257435,
0.0861449987,
0.0220206361,
0.0013033199,
-0.0209794752,
0.0355675444,
0.0368035696,
0.0782894641,
-0.0316869505,
0.032314416,
-0.0600404479,
-0.0170705728,
0.0302075874,
0.050611034,
0.0006052827,
-0.0081361728,
0.0179165658,
-0.0328922309,
0.0590285547,
-0.0310870856,
-0.074508898,
-0.0096855983,
-0.0339872204,
0.0007680502,
-0.0332382321,
0.0077545862,
0.0000470742,
-0.0647911951,
-0.0269613992,
-0.0012371344,
-0.0334859937,
0.0096225543,
0.0682486668,
-0.0219892226,
-0.0287549496,
0.0641339719,
-0.0122862449,
-0.01919703,
-0.022788221,
-0.0609236807,
0.0468097553,
0.0018552786,
0.078191556,
-0.0794132724,
-0.0379621349,
0.001616911,
0.028020896,
0.001477531,
0.0020176924,
0.008905055,
0.0142699257,
-0.0361163616,
-0.0188691095,
-0.0303493682,
0.0240247436,
0.0065860306,
0.0508989394,
-0.0075290762,
-0.0259788111,
-0.0636493489,
0.0061588497,
0.0339889117,
-0.0583272986,
-0.0620186329,
-0.013377713,
-0.0189783089,
0.0097002592,
-0.0160936024,
-0.0046603028,
0.0231900569,
0.0319492184,
-0.0172617752,
0.0015651108,
-0.0115319183,
-0.0553564392,
-0.0191991925,
0.0673028156,
-0.0558523834,
-0.0451811589,
0.0307031255,
-0.0525696836,
-0.0064388802,
0.0465607382,
-0.0097043635,
0.0191228334,
-0.0040075621,
0.0367683582,
-0.0276967045,
-0.0088508856,
0.0256798938,
0.0712300539,
-0.0185606554,
0.0052899648,
0.0237977821,
-0.0014347609,
0.0173162036,
-0.0262381658,
0.0220465362,
0.0124426568,
-0.0297918972,
0.0100053661,
-0.0186474212,
0.0254273564,
-0.027925659,
-0.0354017727,
0.0144633446,
0.0235604215,
-0.0164475497,
0.0445437953,
0.0199737456,
-0.0571642704,
-0.0053251972,
0.0112899169,
-0.0093995696,
-0.0085958652,
0.0179081727,
0.0006165412,
0.0110425828,
0.0210482143,
-0.0297450144,
-0.0052479962,
-0.0188237671,
-0.0478219017,
0.0306616854,
0.0053600352,
0.087650612,
-0.0253436025,
0.0094715543,
-0.0539270416,
0.0062190043,
-0.0313044749,
0.0087190121,
0.0368229859,
-0.0088855512,
0.0145338476,
0.0844878778,
-0.0379255004,
0.0303279795,
0.0642655566,
-0.0192696191,
-0.065243043,
0.0105658667,
0.0144231664,
-0.0100270351,
-0.045376353,
-0.0509531274,
-0.03589404,
0.0946831703,
-0.0297532436,
-0.0045734341,
-0.0400405414,
0.056868121,
-0.0137928091,
-0.0027999813,
-0.0478000157,
0.0039868862,
-0.0119450642,
0.0456921495,
-0.0375027321,
-0.034492135,
0.0601893365,
-0.0154533237,
0.0007578252,
-0.0427064151,
0.0386273228,
-0.05867121,
0.0517291874,
0.0214534011,
-0.0163329132,
-0.0354231037,
0.0103652999,
-0.0064226612,
-0.0166875795,
0.058564119,
-0.0514542088,
0.0546386838,
-0.0521505326,
-0.0019083575,
0.0067543341,
-0.0651281998,
-0.0362649336,
0.0338904373,
-0.0434700772,
0.0158330277,
-0.014993621,
-0.0366719067,
-0.0178136807,
-0.0080334432,
0.0188331399,
0.010186418,
-0.0308771394,
-0.008390517,
-0.0120133227,
-0.0075738546,
-0.0076203467,
0.0022769908,
0.063534677,
-0.0479310527,
0.0439326279,
0.0411012918,
0.088285841,
-0.027601881,
-0.0105066467,
0.0304758735,
0.0043423716,
-0.0107241431,
-0.0289580002,
0.0551478676,
0.0285832249,
-0.0885219947,
-0.0080984579,
0.0848258585,
0.0331118107,
0.0219155531,
0.0100287721,
-0.0567708015,
0.0381524898,
0.023573298,
0.0250824355,
-0.076730825,
-0.0306378435,
0.0218412522,
0.0047185076,
0.0059784087,
-0.0539416745,
-0.0070358971,
-0.1260931194,
0.0034919912,
0.0091063948,
-0.0389223434,
0.031880144,
-0.0395258442,
-0.0168048963,
-0.0307292175,
0.0100002829,
0.0294730719,
-0.0053049088,
0.002143462,
0.0091445325,
0.0065674828,
-0.007959269,
0.0589842498,
-0.0094376756,
0.0032671625,
0.0204656962,
0.0197922569,
-0.0260830838,
-0.0672444552,
0.0549716204,
0.0709349215,
-0.0437782332,
-0.0036955513,
-0.0043624882,
0.0013987048,
-0.0041770623,
0.0161712021,
0.0549921542,
-0.0189686678,
-0.0083041918,
0.0404532403,
0.1035583615,
0.0271894597,
-0.0116740037,
0.0032045681,
-0.0131138908,
-0.0318506695,
0.0678863525,
0.0033560393,
0.0129821189,
-0.0362937972,
-0.0587345362,
-0.0386651047,
-0.0406320542,
-0.0520409569,
0.001853405,
0.0363840833,
-0.0119973915,
-0.0310505014,
-0.0123060951,
0.0252923314,
0.0522852689,
-0.0098057669,
-0.0206547137,
0.0161533188,
0.0191479549,
-0.0177946445,
0.0378409326,
-0.0681286156,
0.0309808888,
-0.0461578928,
0.0228433777,
-0.006649801,
-0.0219219923,
-0.0312280338,
0.0196923949,
-0.1025842279,
-0.0313624814,
-0.0216798745,
0.050523486,
0.029156385,
0.0197733473,
0.0014102779,
-0.0146652283,
0.0126321251,
-0.0162179749,
-0.0320341773,
0.021190038,
0.0335529819,
-0.0222892892,
0.0239205062,
0.0275476538,
-0.0134844324,
0.0116293402,
0.0248309951,
0.0537750199,
-0.041502703,
0.0160572175,
0.0177362096,
0.0439300239,
0.0033297385,
0.0235816818,
-0.0046904553,
0.0211277679,
0.0241220649,
-0.0718607455,
0.0068334476,
-0.0377413183,
0.0144049721,
0.0205544066,
-0.0194762629,
-0.0007737781,
-0.0019816973,
0.0111529948,
0.0250960514,
0.0183196459,
0.0421945043,
0.0106769791,
0.0233272798,
0.0462211929,
-0.0369109847,
0.0299968515,
0.0144877592,
-0.0152082657,
0.0626594499,
-0.0073793493,
0.0436122566,
0.0320204198,
0.02389667,
-0.0257712025,
-0.0322508179,
0.0011655528,
-0.0970284194,
0.0162655953,
0.0254084542,
0.0227451958,
0.003852668,
-0.004679394,
-0.0678668544,
0.015821591,
0.0016319837,
-0.0282205027,
0.0042805788,
-0.0381795652,
0.0568067916,
0.0284046661,
0.0340369269,
-0.0112978648,
0.0385887213,
-0.0074525243,
0.0810805708,
0.0144326594,
0.0234080441,
-0.0344817266,
-0.0290734451,
0.0240265559,
0.0167595744,
-0.0033062445,
-0.0145317754,
-0.0752316192,
-0.0615043491,
0.0027575297,
0.0407471731,
-0.0239395574,
0.0057347217,
0.0165435076,
0.0702284947,
-0.0320696905,
-0.028300507,
0.0006706946,
0.0010402222,
-0.0204281099,
-0.0286382996,
-0.0233381875,
-6.132843494e-33,
0.000852629,
-0.0219414942,
0.0772851035,
-0.0163065027,
0.0149232307,
-0.0228605382,
-0.0475025997,
0.0153482836,
-0.0140928011,
0.0003152899,
-0.0241653323,
0.0254491735,
0.0037374774,
0.0040683961,
-0.0077819922,
-0.0192340612,
-0.0004785414,
-0.0285267178,
-0.0750812516,
-0.0177533031,
-0.0086495122,
-0.0222840235,
0.0493788011,
-0.0459777117,
-0.0162305273,
0.0182997491,
-0.0353357382,
0.0672539473,
-0.0694784448,
0.0390997455,
-0.001224346,
0.0055937776,
0.0124338521,
-0.0539019592,
0.0049103284,
-0.02886663,
-0.0442456193,
-0.0486709401,
0.0268147383,
0.0026620876,
-0.021876771,
-0.0471714437,
0.0550064668,
0.0232338086,
-0.0490307361,
-0.0332878493,
-0.0015026622,
-0.0333673619,
-0.0001165423,
0.0294853523,
-0.0162086133,
0.0314566828,
-0.0161460675,
-0.0296413936,
0.0128480485,
-0.0034521278,
-0.0187932234,
-0.0136614162,
-0.023513766,
0.0387087576,
0.0145374434,
0.0106663276,
0.0589677654,
-0.0040740361,
0.0137547012,
0.0416372679,
0.0370134786,
-0.024856763,
0.0009039847,
0.0054050228,
0.0532792136,
0.0607946552,
0.058975663,
0.029917758,
0.0573891029,
0.0356997587,
-0.0743987709,
0.0104892151,
0.018146947,
0.0487978198,
0.0056944867,
-0.0166712552,
-0.0568387434,
0.0225874931,
-0.0591232739,
0.0523749106,
-0.0318751186,
-0.0035107352,
0.0170849897,
0.0004728039,
-0.0193158314,
-0.0266926792,
0.0039317184,
-0.0299279448,
-0.0309637692,
0.0454020277,
0.0006311269,
0.0196538474,
-0.0175768137,
0.0391823836,
-0.0635753796,
-0.0088219857,
-0.0198037121,
-0.019882232,
0.0357810035,
0.0132934554,
0.0157864727,
0.0220327619,
-0.0394142643,
-0.0097002247,
-0.0652289242,
0.0069392645,
0.034610983,
0.0100315511,
0.0500526913,
0.023633698,
0.0142813288,
0.0016623571,
0.0001815008,
-0.0287159365,
-0.0306955818,
0.0237315148,
-0.0040457426,
0.0249944441,
-0.0003066392,
-0.0082451832,
-0.0792209804,
0.0298713949,
0.0210289434,
-0.0458274782,
0.0087815765,
-0.0119835399,
2.879e-7,
0.026888242,
0.0585635304,
0.0075368597,
0.0570721999,
0.0128115071,
0.0352946967,
-0.0727985576,
-0.0316188484,
-0.0050936858,
-0.0174135268,
0.0172992237,
0.0669675767,
0.0224572141,
0.0549988188,
-0.0403781682,
0.0111261066,
-0.0442824773,
-0.0087204538,
-0.0627248064,
0.0074142003,
0.0389372557,
0.0702612549,
0.0398499332,
-0.0001090074,
0.0071760123,
-0.062827833,
0.0367196687,
-0.0168900471,
-0.0067420183,
0.0118418606,
0.016757803,
0.0069197728,
0.0074069779,
-0.016661033,
0.0108648119,
0.0242886562,
-0.0405490585,
0.0629714876,
0.0244126804,
0.0087285545,
-0.0297922716,
-0.0561088733,
-0.0414039418,
-0.0201980062,
0.0876284987,
-0.0189283993,
-0.0475615561,
-0.0024719399,
0.0160731748,
-0.0547746532,
0.0026410574,
0.0088008642,
0.0040749609,
0.0202929396,
0.0003294557,
-0.0320673101,
0.0134999808,
-0.0433405451,
-0.0228926297,
0.000615287,
-0.0453206226,
-0.05556795,
-0.0712715089,
0.0171084758,
0.0070656212,
-0.066232346,
-0.0239768121,
2.782606809e-34,
0.041422829,
-0.0546821728,
0.0328857154,
0.0117152445,
0.0445686355,
-0.0081047034,
-0.0135079138,
0.0175034609,
0.0160118341,
-0.0549097247,
0.0078565814
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15490v1 | Causal Discovery Inspired Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction | 2024-06-18T13:01:30 | 2024-06-18T13:01:30 | Yuncheng Hua, Yujin Huang, Shuo Huang, Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Chris Bain, Richard Bassed, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.4 | This paper tackles the task of emotion-cause pair extraction in the
unsupervised domain adaptation setting. The problem is challenging as the
distributions of the events causing emotions in target domains are dramatically
different than those in source domains, despite the distributions of emotional
expressions between domains are overlapped. Inspired by causal discovery, we
propose a novel deep latent model in the variational autoencoder (VAE)
framework, which not only captures the underlying latent structures of data but
also utilizes the easily transferable knowledge of emotions as the bridge to
link the distributions of events in different domains. To facilitate knowledge
transfer across domains, we also propose a novel variational posterior
regularization technique to disentangle the latent representations of emotions
from those of events in order to mitigate the damage caused by the spurious
correlations related to the events in source domains. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that our model outperforms the strongest baseline
by approximately 11.05% on a Chinese benchmark and 2.45% on a English benchmark
in terms of weighted-average F1 score. The source code will be publicly
available upon acceptance. | [
-0.0121033452,
0.1211762428,
-0.017405076,
0.0589197129,
0.0183592364,
0.0122132804,
0.0106607573,
-0.0027256603,
-0.0101131694,
0.00127078,
-0.0249930732,
-0.004459484,
-0.0719882324,
0.0754873976,
-0.0082522035,
-0.0946420878,
0.0058981078,
0.0566267855,
0.0193565302,
-0.0282350611,
0.008664757,
0.0004725637,
-0.0175601691,
-0.0094492324,
-0.040975932,
0.0040104724,
-0.0167731941,
0.0157077834,
0.065961495,
0.0138233406,
-0.0136021152,
0.0170682613,
0.0501254313,
-0.0330122523,
0.0000024772,
-0.0333421193,
-0.0477146208,
-0.0425623842,
0.0081905928,
-0.0209885035,
0.0164166894,
-0.0167898927,
-0.0139383487,
-0.0152240805,
0.0039999615,
-0.0632870421,
0.0291346051,
0.0652014315,
0.0507315733,
0.0838286132,
-0.0574267209,
-0.0309665538,
-0.007240878,
-0.0496014096,
0.0259329304,
-0.08658351,
0.0631351992,
-0.0124273766,
-0.0213283673,
-0.0765875727,
-0.09287218,
-0.0134401023,
0.0172694959,
-0.0132837519,
-0.0290731322,
-0.0215323381,
0.0194935258,
-0.0205993876,
-0.0012471272,
0.0894150361,
0.0103796581,
0.0097596589,
0.0121289846,
-0.0402811319,
-0.0002723852,
0.076562047,
-0.0246172063,
-0.0129059199,
0.0259780437,
-0.0111281537,
0.0113007603,
0.0217585769,
0.0231794994,
-0.0024350742,
-0.0248005036,
0.0128355836,
0.0175404027,
-0.0077904812,
-0.0049942574,
0.0225343239,
-0.0313068926,
-0.0004037991,
0.0234385841,
-0.0389540866,
-0.0198796354,
0.0024428605,
-0.0335663669,
-0.0522624478,
-0.1089751646,
-0.0134363063,
-0.0259131659,
0.0310455952,
-0.0645218566,
0.044980634,
0.0104365572,
0.012728082,
-0.0496532954,
0.0005494458,
-0.0332912616,
-0.0155196991,
-0.0129152071,
0.0433148257,
0.0146457553,
-0.0143209416,
-0.0495996512,
-0.0282992572,
-0.0303601082,
-0.0039477581,
-0.0427266508,
-0.0267511867,
-0.0352354757,
0.0271039214,
-0.0341654867,
-0.0169102494,
0.0213325452,
0.0192057528,
-0.0898902044,
0.069304131,
0.0176365077,
-0.0091408407,
-0.0143758794,
0.0207649823,
0.0915837139,
-0.025635384,
0.0359465256,
0.0166482776,
0.008444706,
0.0333393738,
-0.0407866463,
0.0027357084,
0.0012144601,
0.0004553134,
0.0299345553,
-0.017521413,
0.0495283939,
-0.0272250138,
0.0206712727,
-0.0758289173,
-0.0135807507,
-0.0887588933,
-0.0611327812,
0.0601610728,
0.0243569762,
-0.0281011537,
0.01045461,
0.0235505663,
0.0323654935,
0.0510838181,
0.0165337976,
0.0386157855,
0.0411974862,
-0.0002310133,
0.013960517,
-0.0003032477,
0.0302834287,
-0.0161792319,
-0.0091099376,
-0.0670554861,
-0.0028453488,
0.0248591658,
0.0669118315,
-0.0315295719,
-0.0290662143,
-0.0013037174,
-0.0194833986,
-0.0086274697,
0.0101548005,
0.0246627908,
0.0252947062,
-0.0060907411,
-0.0347808488,
0.0167728756,
0.0002816821,
0.0513704754,
-0.0133267352,
-0.021965472,
0.0434655435,
-0.0112368045,
-0.0325722657,
-0.0339946151,
0.0282241963,
-0.0172265396,
-0.0266153328,
0.0100875041,
0.064840734,
0.0212424565,
-0.0206733327,
0.0221493989,
0.0553190745,
-0.060213685,
0.0213684179,
0.0246096421,
0.0228240695,
0.0139764342,
0.0255162641,
-0.0442117378,
0.0212876238,
-0.0321501307,
0.0140048452,
0.0171006322,
0.0003960047,
-0.0244800225,
0.0360546857,
-0.0364068523,
-0.0558552854,
0.0020754554,
0.0141024925,
0.0342577472,
-0.0401723161,
0.0185458381,
0.0014227992,
-0.0006552007,
0.0847902298,
0.0198104251,
-0.0550612658,
-0.0095147546,
0.020849904,
0.0493636616,
0.0568435863,
0.0327315181,
-0.0135461455,
-0.0210465379,
0.0169797353,
-0.0585810356,
-0.0572661906,
0.0451261923,
-0.0193586722,
-0.0336005092,
0.0032937627,
-0.0605554767,
0.0039977906,
0.0403424762,
-0.0396450348,
-0.0576089397,
0.0834282711,
0.0363061354,
-0.0326458961,
0.0213324726,
-0.0090371659,
-0.0089975912,
0.0384942777,
0.0372524783,
0.0337355472,
0.0083240904,
-0.034636151,
-0.0134667167,
0.0437915064,
0.023002388,
0.0171240997,
-0.0145543171,
-0.0074837012,
0.0140857147,
-0.0188603383,
0.0496908091,
-0.0489196107,
-0.0393973142,
-0.0273587834,
-0.0243744925,
0.0272127651,
-0.0270111524,
-0.0036766115,
-0.0034498062,
0.0688686222,
-0.0229271799,
0.0074299602,
0.0085711647,
0.0436245911,
-0.0203888789,
-0.0033300943,
-0.0063945954,
0.0046565798,
0.0352752842,
-0.0545470938,
0.0188637208,
-0.0491151735,
0.0309772789,
-0.0034595996,
-0.0164553691,
0.0091526629,
0.0356595963,
-0.0096690161,
0.0169285573,
-0.0283539556,
-0.0535487868,
-0.0320030861,
-0.0193192065,
0.0502185337,
0.0342724025,
-0.0313276276,
0.0767135322,
0.0160461627,
-0.000328399,
-0.0296803899,
0.0478262976,
-0.0494536087,
-0.0006417871,
-0.0274752676,
-0.0049796812,
-0.0463719256,
0.051659815,
0.0092070149,
0.0216071196,
-0.0502502806,
0.0178717114,
0.0202852562,
-0.0532288477,
0.0197503269,
-0.02605219,
-0.0177992526,
0.0297308471,
-0.026521273,
0.0022233948,
0.0344261676,
0.0905543491,
0.0111086397,
-0.0532035977,
0.037878491,
-0.0069671497,
0.0642320514,
-0.0109320935,
0.004958197,
0.015514683,
-0.0207379144,
-0.0287188422,
-0.0133242467,
0.0297707859,
0.0168940518,
0.0161066465,
-0.0275301747,
-0.0163084306,
0.0286831781,
-0.0434464775,
-0.0453747101,
-0.0467068851,
-0.0137284594,
-0.0018122571,
0.0084181493,
0.0065439376,
-0.0374256894,
-0.0554716066,
0.0503362529,
-0.0303664152,
0.0132067269,
0.0074068992,
0.0006267879,
0.0526512899,
0.0722227097,
-0.0190280136,
0.0045733023,
-0.0274713319,
0.0111742979,
-0.0035825402,
0.0258434713,
-0.0244277027,
-0.0071749506,
0.051549904,
-0.0047361651,
0.0311159026,
0.0344742313,
-0.0264290329,
0.0410538912,
0.0000720414,
0.0216922816,
0.081512332,
-0.0195139274,
-0.0507575274,
0.0181913283,
-0.0180144422,
-0.0143828532,
0.0207331441,
0.0190660078,
-0.0465993807,
-0.0333042741,
-0.0104407053,
-0.0193362348,
0.0277604759,
-0.0367924422,
0.0209835898,
-0.0719146878,
0.0093508931,
0.0087606516,
0.0069510555,
-0.0201412234,
-0.0437351502,
0.0358054787,
-0.0514884517,
-0.0177824069,
-0.080048494,
0.0433447771,
-0.0148669621,
0.0385993272,
0.0058409483,
-0.0897418037,
-0.0137065873,
-0.0485571288,
0.0346967466,
0.0604895838,
0.0496690273,
-0.0476740673,
-0.0019049728,
0.00128675,
-0.0039637927,
-0.0126987817,
-0.0081689497,
0.0786888748,
-0.0136840818,
-0.0180004034,
0.0288974382,
0.0662191734,
-0.0598105304,
0.0019368497,
0.0078278463,
0.070579268,
-0.0019133295,
-0.0358396135,
-0.0219155177,
-0.022940835,
0.002650752,
0.0265854709,
0.0171423331,
-0.0491610207,
0.0333105102,
-0.0120011847,
0.0186098833,
-0.0380949676,
-0.0450460725,
-0.0483767986,
-0.0013639806,
-0.0738584623,
-0.0578947179,
-0.0456779078,
0.0024833535,
0.0218521282,
-0.0115035092,
-0.0344974846,
0.0081347106,
-0.0108037172,
-0.0333632268,
0.0326528102,
0.0138209909,
-0.0184420291,
0.0061598211,
-0.0099049127,
0.0155063644,
-0.0219827052,
-0.0196250807,
-0.019281907,
-0.029107267,
-0.0374608487,
0.0159961674,
0.0230773911,
0.0003084225,
0.0675939322,
-0.007914409,
-0.0527927168,
0.0003016481,
0.0074674338,
-0.0032170471,
0.0020452661,
0.0417835526,
-0.0206216592,
-0.029412942,
0.0080319606,
-0.0796380192,
0.0612535216,
0.0265092012,
0.0236684829,
0.0077946498,
-0.0283681676,
0.0046776631,
-0.0237647202,
0.0820187479,
-0.0116795478,
-0.060374476,
-0.0784200504,
-0.0443045795,
-0.0237378199,
0.0087266471,
-0.0413809232,
0.0232742522,
0.019297462,
0.0281448532,
-0.0502523184,
-0.0237044338,
0.0004023344,
-0.0160986502,
-0.0468502566,
0.0707575977,
0.0442730524,
0.0556865185,
-0.035427101,
0.0378360413,
0.0307118967,
-0.0043194131,
0.0627488792,
0.0108615616,
-0.0343859904,
0.048442103,
0.0383785665,
0.0155532015,
0.0324796475,
-0.0107438331,
-0.0445320122,
0.033391688,
-0.0273520574,
-0.0130312378,
0.0509312861,
-0.0593586899,
0.0575533286,
-0.0129794283,
0.016010996,
-0.0180993583,
0.0145189511,
-0.0104487957,
-0.0348354392,
0.0356865376,
0.0129031325,
0.0009712527,
0.009645747,
0.0456876382,
-0.0462281294,
0.0836312771,
-0.0314180925,
0.016714938,
-0.0298209898,
0.0058131833,
0.0644344687,
0.0125033287,
-0.0305185635,
0.0374859981,
-0.0251715351,
-0.0392055176,
0.0099990694,
-0.0613014959,
-0.0245686918,
-0.0058142319,
0.03924115,
0.0614663996,
-0.0404922143,
0.0206718668,
-0.0164048988,
0.0259337835,
-0.0594953634,
-0.0381867252,
0.0202862602,
-6.814447281e-33,
-0.0151277753,
0.0094611477,
-0.0569667406,
0.0008594673,
0.0011687061,
0.0208134279,
-0.0779113248,
-0.0075752125,
-0.0068507288,
0.0777803063,
0.0205313079,
0.0218104795,
0.0085475352,
0.0135126859,
0.0090451809,
-0.0477027223,
0.0612263046,
0.0294284914,
0.0135206562,
0.0365909748,
0.0390598141,
0.0797292888,
0.0498298183,
-0.1693326831,
-0.0036980631,
0.0295650903,
-0.0006955421,
-0.0170954708,
0.0862534717,
0.0417150818,
0.0043123076,
0.0331178345,
-0.0044799098,
-0.0191510934,
0.0063312729,
-0.0313502997,
-0.0391583256,
-0.0392777435,
-0.0300140828,
-0.0024720214,
-0.0303419549,
-0.0650161654,
-0.0063894396,
0.0227997042,
0.0253163595,
-0.0394884944,
0.0518112406,
-0.0249791909,
0.0289027393,
-0.0793192834,
-0.0506342836,
0.0149528095,
-0.0271465275,
-0.0112068262,
0.0355046466,
-0.0156277679,
0.0199755207,
0.0210372005,
-0.0063876403,
0.0046899407,
-0.0365444757,
0.0027268846,
0.0226840135,
0.0003611153,
-0.0038612525,
0.0649237856,
0.0044299359,
-0.0017809562,
-0.0145645663,
0.0232967101,
0.0064103492,
0.0285414252,
0.0106858127,
0.0784860849,
0.0029681132,
-0.0216479395,
-0.0719917789,
0.0539294928,
0.00212692,
-0.0160307921,
-0.0236678571,
0.0516265407,
-0.0091301221,
-0.0122562358,
0.001516878,
0.0047147088,
-0.0176390819,
-0.0207908675,
0.0117153218,
-0.0213399529,
-0.0087294085,
-0.0188595429,
0.021268297,
-0.0279766936,
0.0282923672,
0.0528534651,
-0.0140191391,
0.0262952037,
0.0034182328,
-0.0078692166,
-0.0361624882,
-0.0158735383,
0.0480343401,
0.0140684918,
0.0583352372,
0.016649168,
-0.0077492092,
0.0174217839,
-0.0064647798,
-0.0371008366,
-0.0362711102,
-0.0442095697,
0.0061832047,
0.0016177666,
-0.0278973952,
0.0503791757,
-0.017766254,
0.0317603424,
0.0452522673,
0.0393461771,
0.0145069947,
-0.0244754497,
0.0113982372,
0.0365473963,
-0.0786002278,
-0.0417823903,
0.0045975377,
-0.017700348,
0.0447392054,
-0.0742710754,
-0.0288663898,
-0.0196933039,
3.114e-7,
0.0142237954,
0.0013166802,
0.0494093187,
-0.0408445299,
0.0123321638,
0.0613690019,
-0.0056828647,
0.0323903225,
0.0087392442,
0.0112117445,
0.0614217855,
0.0219659321,
0.0502908155,
-0.0270654634,
-0.0407756343,
0.0165154748,
0.0394273289,
-0.0083910711,
0.0091714971,
0.0021796923,
0.0562801585,
0.074130863,
0.0455593951,
0.0157079231,
0.0387747213,
0.0339161903,
0.0475140326,
-0.0254566595,
-0.0180250648,
0.0220386889,
-0.0685199723,
-0.0332849212,
-0.0245657172,
0.0098077375,
-0.0366754867,
0.0300132297,
0.0383581966,
0.0217772592,
0.0074284771,
-0.026915716,
-0.0328277536,
0.014843272,
0.0296102222,
0.031753432,
0.0460816398,
-0.0454501472,
-0.0641560927,
0.0303688031,
-0.0616930127,
0.0411431156,
-0.012037266,
0.012077854,
-0.0297627505,
0.0022437233,
0.0137100974,
0.0389202386,
-0.0207847208,
-0.0751024261,
0.0336382538,
0.0141630052,
-0.0396810584,
-0.0038650751,
0.004011387,
0.0108077405,
0.0611578301,
-0.0116926376,
-0.0030249746,
2.500197965e-34,
-0.0132010318,
0.036408592,
-0.0255921539,
-0.012983365,
0.0361061208,
-0.0303616039,
-0.0728466809,
-0.0115722744,
0.0285207145,
-0.0252673272,
-0.0149954641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12570v1 | Applying Ensemble Methods to Model-Agnostic Machine-Generated Text Detection | 2024-06-18T12:58:01 | 2024-06-18T12:58:01 | Ivan Ong, Boon King Quek | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we study the problem of detecting machine-generated text when
the large language model (LLM) it is possibly derived from is unknown. We do so
by apply ensembling methods to the outputs from DetectGPT classifiers (Mitchell
et al. 2023), a zero-shot model for machine-generated text detection which is
highly accurate when the generative (or base) language model is the same as the
discriminative (or scoring) language model. We find that simple summary
statistics of DetectGPT sub-model outputs yield an AUROC of 0.73 (relative to
0.61) while retaining its zero-shot nature, and that supervised learning
methods sharply boost the accuracy to an AUROC of 0.94 but require a training
dataset. This suggests the possibility of further generalisation to create a
highly-accurate, model-agnostic machine-generated text detector. | [
-0.0032825398,
0.0536106676,
-0.001666301,
0.0734955743,
-0.0188045874,
0.0594245978,
-0.0100050448,
0.0723093972,
-0.0063287267,
-0.0449521989,
0.0056531555,
-0.0203512628,
-0.0044028116,
0.050346043,
0.008117714,
0.0429317355,
0.0129362606,
-0.0071826354,
-0.006204803,
0.0217329543,
0.0072355373,
0.0045265942,
-0.0126884505,
0.0099657625,
-0.0148004936,
-0.015731452,
-0.0118194679,
0.0324220322,
0.0473624133,
-0.0045685209,
-0.0072786845,
0.0374306329,
-0.0055322116,
0.1398198605,
0.0000017986,
-0.0285298862,
-0.0299968943,
-0.0241971742,
-0.0517994948,
-0.0210807435,
0.0367665701,
-0.0046888907,
-0.03781683,
0.0253638048,
0.0014327643,
-0.005508414,
0.0507506058,
0.0394264758,
-0.030088516,
0.0900459215,
-0.0367481299,
-0.009570268,
0.0463178605,
-0.0009436843,
-0.0039422903,
-0.0058350521,
0.0320928469,
-0.0261311643,
-0.009421913,
0.0094881533,
0.0024432086,
0.0283117928,
0.0095759146,
-0.0389216393,
0.0035423683,
0.0496649183,
-0.0224495735,
-0.0015626221,
-0.0231007989,
0.0067062359,
-0.0666682348,
-0.046410311,
0.0085753817,
-0.0316301361,
0.0075524035,
0.0207347888,
0.0100740679,
0.0372136422,
-0.0483932719,
0.0382985137,
-0.016044084,
-0.0104995156,
0.0281152129,
0.0379549414,
0.014490257,
0.0690344945,
0.0139631182,
-0.029152086,
-0.0166976061,
0.0497880541,
-0.03229573,
-0.0214042496,
0.0149817904,
-0.0018532305,
0.0301526692,
-0.000745522,
-0.0473765545,
-0.0457044728,
0.0149219222,
0.0074023157,
0.0457166992,
0.0081851678,
-0.0136766098,
0.0455347002,
-0.1011566371,
0.070550561,
-0.0434182249,
-0.0131493742,
-0.0268058311,
0.0290048625,
-0.0319897681,
-0.0370194726,
-0.0247764755,
-0.0081498232,
-0.0257382002,
-0.0371768028,
-0.0558227859,
0.0370662138,
0.0484514758,
-0.0093433289,
-0.0211914834,
-0.0360274836,
-0.032463409,
-0.0157350563,
0.0445564426,
0.0051343162,
0.0211656969,
0.0158185009,
-0.0101983668,
-0.082245864,
-0.0451935641,
0.0655248314,
0.0347228386,
0.0148933288,
0.0124455895,
0.0364818014,
-0.020511739,
-0.099000819,
-0.0040290081,
-0.0086039538,
-0.0549080931,
-0.0347112752,
0.0227302089,
-0.0540627614,
-0.0322173722,
0.002736653,
0.0320036635,
-0.0210790858,
-0.0234469566,
0.0001041947,
0.0181022026,
0.0632688627,
-0.0271907877,
-0.0214429181,
0.0335046984,
-0.0004163419,
0.0150973927,
0.0907278061,
0.003389874,
0.1021310017,
0.0185089596,
0.0192264691,
0.0748407692,
0.0646385029,
-0.0009546739,
0.0159649495,
0.0052439272,
-0.0325919688,
0.0005510653,
-0.0268306155,
0.026080545,
-0.0054415166,
-0.0131817823,
-0.0094010048,
0.0723057464,
0.032437183,
0.0042672409,
-0.0062712394,
0.0143377297,
0.01444731,
-0.0289755296,
0.0293650348,
0.0417929962,
-0.0236058738,
-0.1142777875,
-0.015976619,
0.0083558839,
0.0250764415,
-0.0186163504,
-0.0177880283,
-0.0171278864,
-0.0251576565,
-0.0689293519,
-0.0149589591,
0.0942488238,
-0.0106715364,
-0.0528565869,
-0.0520870723,
-0.0133528858,
-0.0358558856,
0.0091794301,
-0.0661977455,
0.0594623536,
0.0136509789,
0.0545487739,
-0.0021945038,
0.0625685155,
-0.0314994417,
-0.0106379157,
0.0781231821,
-0.0551977009,
0.0130682895,
0.0418804735,
-0.0247115716,
-0.0338229425,
0.0221680272,
0.0391489714,
0.0199635699,
0.0118378596,
0.0309278164,
0.0156153142,
-0.0027638879,
0.0024889067,
0.0666396841,
-0.0281375535,
-0.0516953915,
0.0054069725,
-0.010453105,
0.0351346508,
0.0008545822,
-0.0418179967,
-0.00167236,
0.0194578413,
-0.0514531769,
-0.0590057038,
-0.0201976262,
-0.008853402,
-0.0703149736,
-0.0082640741,
-0.0175729338,
-0.008392808,
-0.0101228105,
-0.0247981362,
-0.0329985172,
-0.0191333946,
-0.0473042652,
-0.0238360595,
-0.0805428922,
0.0525879823,
-0.0442446657,
0.0293099973,
-0.0090262201,
0.0547580197,
0.0003357773,
0.0156386402,
-0.0257173758,
-0.0358371325,
0.0664351135,
-0.0392517932,
-0.0353912301,
0.0269372817,
-0.0048281476,
0.0050861221,
0.0179055836,
0.0143079842,
-0.0134559562,
-0.0322674327,
-0.0639908835,
-0.0111675719,
-0.0399801396,
-0.0064956322,
0.0289296228,
-0.0082421778,
-0.0200551115,
-0.025832966,
0.0140374275,
-0.0187452864,
0.0699067265,
-0.0018245021,
0.0128641054,
-0.0257001575,
-0.0088595562,
0.0026492672,
-0.0088390829,
0.0009428186,
0.0429861806,
0.0477976575,
-0.0679864436,
-0.083758764,
0.0360165425,
0.0073951106,
-0.0018536858,
-0.0008634116,
-0.0352305435,
0.0000102739,
-0.0112703377,
-0.0135861319,
0.0920802876,
0.0060463804,
0.0048356936,
0.0104485499,
0.0732477903,
0.0058084526,
-0.0192872062,
-0.0110995257,
0.0115589518,
0.0023245187,
-0.0265396349,
0.0484281257,
0.0847752392,
-0.0206677318,
0.0071690194,
-0.0335964262,
0.0269164015,
-0.0132378507,
-0.0388164856,
-0.0783466846,
-0.0513118915,
-0.0062729958,
0.0436659716,
-0.0217000023,
-0.0902070925,
0.0257443544,
-0.0311888829,
-0.0268783066,
-0.0382043198,
-0.0165661741,
-0.0003639362,
0.0092650773,
0.0768514201,
0.02896671,
0.0257992167,
0.0070481752,
0.0083231106,
0.0137574775,
0.0233323276,
-0.0318261124,
0.0073245158,
-0.0074309111,
0.0535871163,
-0.0089907106,
-0.0257202648,
-0.0463413931,
-0.0173671301,
-0.0077505712,
0.0099726208,
0.0049132584,
-0.052535329,
-0.0415423177,
0.0398785472,
0.0158458389,
0.0603629276,
-0.0185137317,
-0.0218748115,
-0.0234666634,
0.0894548744,
0.0339550003,
-0.0937730223,
-0.004891831,
-0.0537475869,
0.0289141927,
0.0570159666,
0.0013782096,
0.0511666425,
0.0004928377,
-0.0091416016,
0.0287405923,
0.0217766948,
-0.0066171493,
-0.0269134771,
0.0209462196,
-0.0072017871,
-0.022781916,
0.0802042335,
0.0200840998,
-0.0375240073,
-0.0291026011,
0.0148863019,
0.0207400303,
-0.0013546606,
-0.0150574017,
-0.0619117506,
-0.0140573969,
0.0163869541,
-0.0121613909,
-0.0484599136,
0.0041358983,
-0.0003458255,
-0.0986525416,
0.02076957,
0.032159701,
-0.0394902639,
-0.0338659137,
-0.0031120295,
0.0234015957,
-0.0279182158,
-0.041554518,
0.0055075986,
-0.0004628489,
-0.0205753017,
-0.0008962139,
0.0016595911,
-0.0684169978,
-0.0490619875,
-0.0355363823,
0.0017988443,
0.1006235555,
0.0434191413,
-0.0139875719,
-0.0122449351,
0.0242157169,
-0.0282704271,
-0.0077132978,
-0.0105938502,
0.0736895353,
-0.0180982184,
-0.003042008,
0.01233132,
0.0086931316,
-0.0128040314,
0.0118748201,
0.0222925786,
0.0271522254,
-0.001493428,
-0.0602081455,
-0.0218632873,
-0.0469801165,
0.0151427463,
0.0730738416,
0.0095056407,
-0.0188363716,
-0.0473977439,
-0.0333465114,
0.0368928425,
-0.0777457654,
0.0025623634,
0.0193323828,
-0.0051863603,
-0.05530506,
-0.0404613949,
-0.0024661284,
0.0183271375,
0.0320561901,
-0.0146329952,
0.0249563698,
-0.0601145066,
0.0085742278,
-0.0468642637,
-0.0336392447,
-0.0350143239,
0.0045668404,
-0.0595685393,
0.0092032067,
0.001908978,
-0.025802277,
-0.0163070951,
0.0153595312,
-0.0594123527,
-0.0440432653,
-0.0051062321,
0.0020726779,
0.0221232306,
-0.0071791043,
-0.0294830203,
-0.0598019324,
0.1073314399,
0.0385425277,
0.019294668,
0.0133974729,
-0.0075066141,
-0.0512186512,
-0.0453873947,
0.0013326705,
-0.0107798539,
0.0612778366,
0.0488320924,
-0.0428541712,
-0.0444866531,
0.0039713816,
0.0332225524,
-0.0110225948,
0.0374536254,
-0.0440409854,
0.0027178321,
-0.0206255112,
-0.0062330347,
0.0175244901,
0.0296902005,
-0.0518643893,
0.0057584844,
0.0471593626,
-0.0027570915,
-0.0245908573,
0.0503226221,
-0.0374025628,
0.0554632433,
-0.0359593369,
0.0019768435,
0.0083806692,
0.0713286474,
0.0363612361,
-0.0096849948,
0.0124569573,
0.0415431745,
0.0096156439,
0.0024356584,
0.0235932674,
0.0622128323,
0.0359011851,
0.014818334,
0.0203701463,
0.036368195,
-0.0428005978,
0.0309535917,
-0.0855037272,
0.089333117,
0.0697067305,
-0.0209750775,
0.0369845331,
-0.0377907157,
-0.0185674038,
-0.0497379377,
-0.0042899777,
0.0326513723,
-0.022193186,
-0.0002065983,
0.0159577373,
-0.0347321816,
-0.0080482615,
0.0697821453,
0.0461036563,
0.0398758724,
0.0044335895,
-0.024209749,
-0.0441681631,
0.0203481615,
0.0359820798,
-0.0337335803,
-0.0042263577,
0.0692161545,
-0.0062561892,
-0.031076679,
0.0065274164,
-0.0257197283,
0.0417450666,
-0.0029534244,
-0.0182986949,
0.0464943573,
-0.0096837683,
0.0001240076,
-0.0380410776,
-0.0018088723,
-0.0435003452,
0.0103550935,
-0.0175900217,
-5.654503618e-33,
-0.030213587,
-0.0675256252,
-0.0447421484,
-0.0480397679,
0.0234151799,
0.0303021409,
0.0057537453,
-0.0299731549,
0.0082791597,
0.0032486913,
-0.0096930657,
0.0543040261,
0.0150590651,
0.0391591452,
-0.0359278992,
0.0102326637,
0.0565840229,
-0.0266668275,
-0.0574555919,
0.0185750108,
0.02938319,
0.0077898568,
0.0346198715,
-0.0240933243,
-0.0079167988,
-0.0244340543,
-0.0515460894,
0.0014897493,
-0.0094413571,
0.0501581319,
-0.0287688468,
0.0151566947,
0.0571076088,
0.0245263781,
-0.0043306099,
0.0490986593,
-0.0011180845,
0.0147822257,
-0.0426245034,
0.0030207047,
-0.0090825455,
-0.0429201759,
0.0052700588,
-0.0336441174,
-0.0256503541,
0.0046123248,
0.0238255281,
-0.053377904,
-0.0099595236,
-0.0643398762,
-0.0426256731,
0.0390643552,
0.0273648761,
-0.0036858346,
0.0600201376,
0.0409523435,
0.0390905477,
0.0563985258,
-0.0138025219,
0.0153532028,
0.0624907352,
0.058589071,
0.0164085627,
0.084568277,
-0.0061747171,
0.04150014,
0.0144239403,
-0.0017192129,
-0.0401515663,
-0.0515682809,
0.0109131141,
-0.0226510596,
0.065984033,
0.0435155965,
0.0721274614,
-0.0085142069,
-0.0375998653,
0.0188974738,
-0.0024880774,
-0.0204661824,
0.0560970567,
0.0193816982,
-0.062587142,
-0.0008518983,
0.0119184265,
-0.077785939,
-0.0196025893,
-0.0057193078,
0.035891328,
0.0388985313,
-0.0495248325,
-0.0234825909,
0.038724158,
-0.0254268739,
-0.0090795895,
0.0149582755,
-0.01442008,
0.002231406,
0.026042372,
0.0216296893,
-0.0092947045,
-0.0165443681,
0.0476989783,
0.0442659929,
-0.0132894842,
-0.0385671072,
0.0496855229,
0.035925068,
-0.0626499057,
0.0093321418,
-0.0302245244,
0.0226062927,
0.0297642145,
0.0495956503,
0.0081751598,
-0.0235955548,
0.0094294744,
-0.0033608158,
0.0261705592,
-0.0098979017,
-0.0108180577,
-0.0070598181,
-0.0491875447,
0.0336686447,
-0.0240447931,
0.0123604955,
0.0042846366,
0.0176627412,
0.0517887324,
-0.0516641997,
0.0248846076,
-0.0060930145,
2.4e-7,
0.0398712009,
0.0027896108,
0.0119847907,
-0.0256431177,
0.0315794982,
0.0173683558,
-0.0250854995,
-0.0025910863,
0.003545234,
-0.0009194801,
-0.010951139,
0.0116855213,
0.0725190938,
-0.0178182833,
-0.0674359351,
0.0437414646,
-0.0416325331,
0.0368722379,
-0.0582550056,
0.0051151849,
0.0504270233,
0.0623562634,
-0.0130583746,
-0.0387174636,
0.0250209682,
-0.0727080405,
0.0502620265,
-0.0131553374,
0.0341575891,
-0.0033181158,
0.0349747278,
0.0084118098,
-0.0072620637,
0.041012045,
-0.004330134,
0.0083430987,
0.0103607727,
0.0472586602,
-0.0102798771,
0.0644451082,
-0.0034330408,
0.0113695282,
0.0176262837,
-0.0403333008,
0.0560682341,
-0.0264332425,
0.0049697147,
-0.0407988653,
-0.0173334498,
-0.0540901721,
0.0527964495,
-0.0254814811,
-0.0311268307,
0.0217794459,
0.0061148698,
-0.0114023862,
0.0048572011,
-0.0214307569,
-0.0129480502,
-0.0294549037,
-0.0441670604,
-0.014715259,
-0.0536132306,
0.0083172396,
0.0391359329,
-0.0540270731,
0.0066075432,
2.104268968e-34,
0.021252133,
-0.0156536363,
-0.0212959461,
0.0298926365,
-0.0111451047,
-0.0193333812,
-0.0001535841,
-0.0028552059,
-0.0225416236,
-0.0423242152,
0.0431247652
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.